﻿

   Table of Contents
Title Page
About This Book
Introduction
Overview
Chiropractic – A Brief Overview, Part I. Steven Novella
Chiropractic – A Brief Overview, Part II. Steven Novella.
Chiropractic and Deafness: Back to 1895. Harriet Hall
Inside Chiropractic: Yesteryear and Today | S Homola
The Bait and Switch of Unscientific Medicine. Steven Novella
The Swan Song of a Chiropractic Heretic | S Homola
Opposing Chiropractic: Persecution or Justified Criticism? | S Homola
Pushback on Chiropractic | S Novella
A cure for chiropractic | J Bellamy
Chiropractic Abuse: An Insider’s Lament | H Hall
Chiropractic Practice Building: A Doctor’s Confession and the Report of Findings | C Jones
THEORY AND REALITY
Science-based Chiropractic: An Oxymoron? Sam Homola.
Science and Chiropractic. Harriet Hall 
Opposing Chiropractic Vertebral Subluxation Theory | S Homela
Following the Guidelines of Science: A Chiropractic Dilemma | S Homola
The Council on Chiropractic Education Straightens Up? | J Bellamy
The Council on Chiropractic Education reaffirms the subluxation, backs off primary care (sort of) | J Bellamy
Chiropractic: A Summary of Concerns | S Homola
The Enigma of Chiropractic: A Brief Review with a Perspective on Chiropractic as a Specialty | S Homola
Questions and Answers about Chiropractic: The Bottom Line | S Homola
Chiropractic Education for Primary Care | H Hall
A New DC Degree. What the World Needs Now. | M Crislip
Chiropractic Internist: A “specialty” to avoid | J Bellamy
The Image of Chiropractic: Consensus Based on Belief. Sam Homola.
Chiropractic and Spinal Manipulation Red Flags: A Comprehensive Review | S Homola
Spinal Fusion: Chiropractic and Subluxation | J Bellamy
Subluxation Theory: A Belief System That Continues to Define the Practice of Chiropractic | S Homola
Chiropractic Vertebral Subluxations: Science vs. Pseudoscience. Sam Homola.
Chiropractic Subluxation Theory: Science or Gobbledegook? | S. Homola
Brief Note: The Chiropractic Subluxation is Dead. Harriet Hall
Spinal Manipulation, Chiropractic, and Subluxation Theory | S Homola
The Yoke of Chiropractic: Vertebral Subluxation Doctrine | S Homola
The Chiropractic Technique Parade | S Homola
The Problem with Chiropractic NUCCA. Sam Homola
Upper Cervical Chiropractic: NUCCA─The Legacy of HIO | S Homola
The End of Chiropractic. Harriet Hall.
That’s so Chiropractic | M Crislip
Ridiculous Warning from Chiropractors About Alleged Health Effects of Texting | H Hall
Journal of the American Dental Association Falls for Tooth Fairy Science | J Bellamy
"It's Just a Theory" Mark Crislip
PEDIATRICS
Pediatric Chiropractic Care: Scientifically Indefensible? Sam Homola.
Chiropractic, Chiropractic for Kids, and a Few of My Greatest Hits | C Jones
No. “Big Data” Does Not Support Chiropractic Care for Infants | C Jones
Chiropractic Pediatrics: “delayed referral, misdiagnosis, adverse events and ineffective treatments” | J Bellamy
Subluxation Correction: A Chiropractic Treatment for Babies | S Homola
Chiropractor Breaks Baby’s Neck – A Risk vs Benefit Analysis | S Novella
A 2-Month-Old Infant Seriously Injured by Chiropractic Neck Adjustment | C Jones
The Crack Heard Round the World | C Jones
The Saga Continues: Australian Chiropractors Banned from Manipulating Infants…Again? | C Jones
Another Australian Chiropractor is in Hot Water for Manipulating a Newborn | C Jones
Australian Chiropractor Ian Rossborough Promises to Stop Treating Children…for Twenty Days | C Jones
Australia’s Chiropractic Board bans spinal manipulation for children under two pending evidence review | J Bellamy
A Canadian Journalist Calls Out Pediatric Chiropractic Again, and the Canadian Chiropractic Association Responds…Again | C Jones
Recent trends in pediatric chiropractic use: the good, the bad, and the unhelpful | C Jones
The Washington Post Takes on Baby Chiropractic | C Jones
Chiropractic Manipulation Under Anesthesia in Infants with Congenital Torticollis: All Risk and No Benefit | C Jones
Chiropractic for Pediatric Seizures: Marketing in the Form of a Case Report | C Jones
Chiropractic and Sudden Infant Death Syndrome | C Jones
Chiropractic Care of an Infant with Erb’s Palsy: Another Worthless Case Report | C Jones
Neck Adjustment for Newborn Supraventricular Tachycardia: More Chiropractic Manipulation of Reality….. | C Jones
Chiropractic Management of a Newborn with Abnormal Oxygen Levels | C Jones
Separating Fact from Fiction in the Not-So-Normal Newborn Nursery: Chiropractic and Craniosynostosis | C Jones
A Touch to Fear: Chiropractic and the Newborn Baby | Jones
Chiropractic Vs. Conventional: Dueling Perspectives On Infant Colic….. | C Jones
A New Study Finds No Benefit from Chiropractic for Infant Colic, but They’ll Keep Doing it Anyway | C Jones
Chiropractic and the Newborn Baby | C Jones
Separating Fact from Fiction in the Not-So-Normal Newborn Nursery: Chiropractic and Brachial Plexus Injury | C Jones
Newborn Chiropractic, False Balance, and The Doctors | C Jones
More Fear-Based Practice Building: Shaken Baby Syndrome and Chiropractic | C Jones
Chiropractor Treating Concussions for Earlier Return to Play | H Hall
Sports Physicals, Sudden Death, and Chiropractors | H Hall
Osteopathy in the NICU: False Claims and False Dichotomies | J Snyder
Chiropractic “pediatrics” firmly in the anti-vaccination camp | J Bellamy
Anti-vaccination ideology in chiropractic continuing education and conference (again!) | J Bellamy
Anti-Vaccine Chiropractors Threaten Public Health | S Gavura
CLINICAL TRIALS
A Global Summit Conclusion: No Evidence of an Effect of SMT [Spinal Manipulative Therapy] for the Management of Non-Musculoskeletal Disorders | Science-Based Medicine
Low-Back Pain: Causes, Care, and Consequences | S Homola
Chiropractors, Blind Pigs, and Acorns | M Crislip
Between a Rock and a Hard Place: A Case Study Exploring the Battle Lines of Science Based Medicine. Joseph Albietz
Top 10 Chiropractic Studies of 2013 | H Hall
Chiropractors falsely claim they can protect patients from coronavirus | J Bellamy
Chiropractors continue to make claims about chiropractic and COVID-19 | S Gavura
Chiropractic scope of practice includes . . . well, you won’t believe it | J Bellamy
Spinal Manipulation and the JAMA Meta-Analysis: An Analysis of Fuel. | M Crislip
Afterword. Chiropractic and The New York Times. Is the newspaper TRYING to prove Trump right? | M Crislip
Spinal Manipulation for Back and Neck Pain: Does It Work? Annotated. | M Crislip
Cervicogenic Headache and Cervical Spine Manipulation | S Homola
When Headaches Are a Pain in the Neck: Spinal Manipulation vs. Mobilization for Cervicogenic Headache | H Hall
Blind-Spot Mapping, Cortical Function, and Chiropractic Manipulation | H Hall
Studying Chiropractic with Imaging: Another Dead Salmon? | H Hall
The New Chiropractic. And I thought SBM had an uphill battle. | M Crislip
Chiropractic Moves into Transportation | M Crislip
The Time a Pulitzer Prize Winning Journalist Got Manipulated by a Chiropractor | C Jones
A Credible Placebo Control for Chiropractic Research | H Hall
Chiropractic “Research” on Tourette Syndrome: The Trouble with Case Reports….. | C Jones
Not Mine | M Crislip
No-Touch Chiropractic. Harriet Hall 
Chiropractic gimmickry | S Homola
The Graston Technique – Inducing Microtrauma with Instruments. Harriet Hall
Chiropractic Webster Technique: Nonsense Based on Nonsense | S Homola
Functional Disc Rehydration for Chronic Back Pain | H Hall
The American Chiropractic Association Answers Crislip’s Call, Joins the Choosing Wisely Campaign | C Jones
Certification in chiropractic techniques: legitimate care or tomfoolery? | S Homola
“Finally…The Low Back Pain Solution”: A Chiropractor Makes Questionable Claims | H Hall
The Straw Protocol: A Chiropractors Aggressively Promoted Neuropathy Treatment | W London
Chiropractic Neurology | S Novella
Quantum Neurology | S Novella
Chiropractic Nose Balloons | M Crislip
Bias and Spin: Acupuncture and Chiropractic | M Crislip
Maximized Living: “5 Essentials” of Chiropractic Marketing Propaganda | C Jones
The Drugless Doctor’s ADHD Nonsense | B MacBeth
Stem Cells and Chiropractic | H Hall
Chiropractic pediatrics conference features anti-vaccination ideology . . . as usual | J Bellamy
Cranial Osteopathy in Dentistry. Grant Ritchey
Cranial Manipulation and Tooth Fairy Science | H Hall
Osteopathic Medicine – What Is It? | S Novella
Pump it up: osteopathic manipulation and influenza | M Crislip
More Americans turning to complementary approaches to pain control | S. Guavara
An Appraisal of Courses in Veterinary Chiropractic | R&) Kjellin
Veterinary Chiropractic | B McKenzie
Science-Based Satire: Invertebrate Research Reveals Clue to Evolutionary Origins of the Chiropractic Subluxation | C Jones
Science-Based Satire: Australian Fetus First to Undergo Intrauterine Chiropractic Adjustment | C Jpnes
Science-Based Satire: How to Win Patients and Influence Parents as an Infant Chiropractor | C Jones
Science-Based Satire: Implantable Desubluxators Revolutionize Chiropractic Care | C Jones
Science-Based Satire: Were the Dinosaurs Wiped Out by a Mass Subluxation Event? | C Jones
Science-Based Satire: Chiropractors…in Space? | C Jones
Science-Based Satire: More Chiropractors are Using Subluxation Sniffing Dogs | C Jones
Science-Based Satire: Historic Conference Clarifies Vertebral Subluxation Causes | C. Jones
Science-Based Satire: Chiropractors Brace for November Neck Pain Tsunami | C. Jones
WHAT IS THE HARM
Chiropractic- Ignoring the Precautionary Principle Since 1895 | M Crislip
Upper Neck Manipulation: Caveats for Patients and Providers | S Homola
A Statement on Cervical Manipulation and Dissections | S Novella
Update: Chiropractic Neck Manipulation and Stroke | H Hall
Neck Manipulation, Stroke, and the Vertebral Artery Stretch: Views, Opinions, and Options | S Homola
Neck Manipulation: Risk vs. Benefit. Sam Homola
Adverse Effects of Chiropractic. Harriet Hall.
Chiropractic and Stroke: Evaluation of One Paper. Mark Crislip
Whack em hard/Whack em once and Stroke. On chiropractic induced trauma | Science-Based Medicine
Chiropractic Manipulation of the Neck Linked to Stroke in a 6-Year-Old Child… | C Jones
Stroke Death from Chiropractic Neck Manipulation | S Novella
Chiropractic and Stroke: The question is not answered | M Crislip
Chiropractic and Stroke. Harriet Hall
Chiropractic Strokes Again: An Update | H Hall
Chiropractic’s Pathetic Response to Stroke Concerns. Harriet Hall
Not to worry! Chiropractic Board says stroke not a risk of cervical manipulation. Jann Bellamy.
Study: patients should be warned of stroke risk before chiropractic neck manipulation | J Bellamy
Chiropractic and Stroke: No Evidence for Causation But Still Reason for Concern | H Hall
Chiropractic Strokes Again! A Landmark Lawsuit in Canada. Harriet Hall.
Chiropractic Reform: Myth or Reality? | H Hall
Another serious complication from chiropractic cervical manipulation: Vertebral fracture leading to paralysis and death | D Gorski
Vigorous Chiropractic Adjustment Associated with Potentially Serious Eye Injury | C Jones
Did chiropractic neck manipulation kill Katie May? | D Gorski
Chiropractic Neck Manipulations in the News | H Hall
The Good. The Bad. The Ugly. | M Crislip
Beware the Spinal Trap. Steven Novella.
Are Prenatal Ultrasounds Dangerous? Harriet Hall 
Compare and Contrast. Mark Crislip
Edzard Ernst Tackles Chiropractic | H Hall
Chiropractic Gynecologist Offers Dangerous Treatments and Misinformation | H Hall
Chiropractor Disregards the Loss of His License, Continues to Treat Patients with Cervical Dysplasia with Escharotics | H Hall
Chiropractor Lost His License; Patient Lost Her Uterus | H Hall
POLITICS, MEDIA AND LAW
The War Against Chiropractors | H Hall
ACA: Six Key Elements of A Modern Chiropractic Practice Act | J Bellamy
Chiropractic Subluxation Theory: Legal Support for Inappropriate Use of Spinal Manipulation | S Homola
Chiropractic Defense: Tempest in a Teapot | S Homola
A London Chiropractor Gets His Undeserved Fifteen Minutes of Fame | C Jones
The Guardian and the “Cult” of Online Chiropractic | C Jones
Cracking Down on Chiropractic Pseudoscience | S Novella
Canadian authorities warn chiropractors and naturopaths against making false COVID-19 claims | J Bellamy
A Canadian Journalist Calls Out Pediatric Chiropractic, and a Chiropractor Responds | C Jones
Anti-vaccination ideology and COVID misinformation in chiropractic continuing education courses: “Plandemic” edition | J Bellamy
NCCAM manipulates spinal manipulation | J Bellamy
Kaiser Rejects Neck Manipulation. Harriet Hall.
Misleading Ads for Back Pain Treatment. Harriet Hall
Do You Believe in Magic? Oregon Does. Chiropractic and Acupuncture for Pain. | M Crislip
The British Chiropractic Association versus Simon Singh. David Gorski
The British Chiropractic Association Responds to Simon Singh. Steven Novella.
Chiropractic in the News. Harriet Hall.
Those who live in glass houses… Joseph Albietz
Chiropractic clinical training with pediatric patients or complicated cases: slim to none | J Bellamy
October is National Chiropractic Health Month! | J Bellamy
No Education? No Training? No License? No Problem! Jann Bellamy 
Dept. of Education to Council on Chiropractic Education: “Straighten Up!” | J Bellamy
Legislative Alchemy II: Chiropractic. Jann Bellamy
Legislative Alchemy: Chiropractic 2013 | J Bellamy
Legislative Alchemy 2017: Chiropractic | J Bellamy
Legislative Alchemy 2018: Chiropractors rebranding as primary care physicians continues | J Bellamy
Legislative Alchemy 2019: Chiropractors seek scope of practice expansion, including authority to prescribe drugs | J Bellamy
The Exciting Conclusion | J Bellamy
Congress can easily end Medicare waste, fraud and abuse by chiropractors, saving billions | J Bellamy
CAM Docket: Functional Endocrinology Update | J Bellamy
H.R. 2654 forces Medicare to treat chiropractors and MDs as equals | J Bellamy
Chiropractors as Family Doctors? No Way! | H Hall
Turning chiropractors into primary care physicians via Legislative Alchemy | J Bellamy
The DC wants to play PCP on your dime: H.R. 3654 forces Medicare to cover full chiropractic scope of practice | J Bellamy
The DC as PCP? The battle continues | J Bellamy
The DC as PCP? Revisited | J Bellamy
The DC as PCP? Drug Wars Resume | J Bellamy
The DC as PCP? Jann Bellamy
The DC as PCP: the battle resumes | J Bellamy
Chiropractors Lobby for Acceptance by the VA and TRICARE | H Hall
Direct Primary Care Agreements and Chiropractors: A bad deal for patients | J Bellamy
Chiropractors, Naturopaths, Concussions and Senate Bill 1535 | M Crislip
The CAM Docket: Texas MDs v. DCs | J Bellamy
Chiropractor Claims the CDC Is Trying to Get Nazi-like Unfettered Power in Violation of the Nuremburg Code | H Hall
A Very Serious Book Review: The Heroic Adventures of Kid Ki’ro | C Jones
   Title Page
Science-Based Medicine:Chiropractic
A Critical Guide for the Health Practitioner and Consumer 
2024 Edition

Executive Editor Steven Novella MD
Managing Editor David Gorski MD PhD
Series Editor Mark Crislip MD

As of 2025, there are around 5000 essays on the Science Based Medicine website. I do no know about you, but I find it difficult to find any post I wrote, much less one written by another contributor. 

So I have updated the books and include almost all the articles through 2025. The volumes are

CAM Concepts
Chiropractic
COVID 
Critical Thinking
Diet and Nutrition
Ethics and CAM
Herbs, Supplements, and Diet
Homeopathy
Infections and Immunity
Law and CAM
Media and Internet
Medicine, Public Health, Dentistry and Pediatrics
Miscellaneous CAM
Naturopathy
Neurology and Psychiatry
Placebo
Quackademic Medicine
Regulation. FDA and FTC
SBM or EBM
Stem Cells, Genetics, AI and Gender
Supplements, Vitamins and Herbs
Vaccine & Anivax
Vaccines and Autism
Vaccines and Preventable Infections

The articles are roughly organized by publication date and topic. Many articles will be in multiple volumes as an essay of, for example, chiropractic and law will be found in both the chiropractic volume and the law volume.

You may find the organization a bit odd. I do. But 4700 plus articles are difficult to organize and I have more to do in my retirement than work of these volumes.

Still, if you find I have missed a nentry or some glaring error, drop me a note and I will fix it for the next edition.

About the authors
Steven P. Novella, MD – Founder and Executive Editor Science Based Medicine.
Founder and currently Executive Editor of Science-Based Medicine Steven Novella, MD.
David H. Gorski, MD, PhD – Managing Editor. Science Based Medicine.
Mark A. Crislip, MD. Editor, Science Based Medicine Guides. 
He did he editing of all the volumes so is to blame for any mistakes.
As to all the other contributors, if you are interested click on the ‘Link’ at top of each essay to go the SBM site, where further information about each author can be found.
A Note On References

The chapters in this book were originally blog entries at ScienceBasedMedicine.org.
Blog and web pages lend themselves to hyperlinks to sources and references that are tedious to translate into footnotes for this ebook.
Under the title of each essay is a hyperlink, cleverly titled ‘Link’, to the original blog entry with all the hyperlinks and references, as well as the comments to the blogs, which often have interesting and thoughtful insights by our readers, as well as some curious comments by the not so thoughtful.
Graphs, tables and links to videos are not in included these essays due to issues of copyright and permission. However, thanks to the ‘Link’, the graphics are a click away.
Thanks for reading the site.
Mark Crislip 




   Introduction
Steven Novella
The world of health care is becoming an increasingly complex and challenging place. The internet is changing the way we generate and access information, and health information is one of the most popular uses of the internet. It represents an unprecedented democratization of information and opinion. 
While there are many advantages and benefits to such information access, there are also many challenges to health professionals, regulators, academics, and consumers. There is a proliferation of health related products and services, with many provocative health claims. Regulations are generally not keeping up, and often have been watered down, in the face of this onslaught of claims and products. 
The consumer is left with an overwhelming array of health claims, many of which challenge and even directly oppose the traditional experts and institutions. 
The mission of Science-Based Medicine (SBM) is to be a source of reliable information and analysis to help navigate the wild west of health information on the internet and elsewhere. The authors who contribute to this series of e-books are all physicians and other health care professionals who have a great deal of experience educating the public about complex medical issues. We especially take on controversial issues and try to expose pseudoscience and fraud wherever possible.
The Philosophy of Science-Based Medicine
The philosophy of SBM, at its core, is simple: Safe and effective health care is critical to everyone’s quality of life; so much so that it is generally considered a basic human right. Therefore, health care products and services that work and are safe are better than those that do not work or are unsafe. 
The best method for determining which interventions and health products are safe and effective is, without question, good science. Therefore it is in everyone’s best interest for health care to be systematically evaluated by the best science available.
Too often the nature of science itself is misunderstood or misrepresented to the public. Science is not an arcane and privileged discipline. By its very nature it is meant to be transparent and public. Science is nothing more than a systematic and careful use of evidence and logic to evaluate factual claims. And good science possesses certain virtues that are not unique to science but generic to all intellectual endeavors: fairly accounting for all available evidence, using valid and internally consistent logic, using unambiguous concepts and language, proper use of statistics, being quantitatively precise and accurate, and above all being honest.
And yet there are numerous and powerful influences in society that strongly appose the scientific basis of medicine. Driven by some combination of ideology or the desire for profit they wish to eliminate standards of science in health care, or (often under the guise of “health care freedom”) create a double standard in which unscientific methods and products can thrive unchecked. Others simply lack the training or knowledge to achieve minimal standards of quality for scientific medicine. And even the best traditions of scientific medicine can benefit from more critical analysis.
Recognition of the need for careful scientific analysis in medicine partly stems from a recognition that it is very difficult (almost impossible) to reliably assess treatments anecdotally. Human perception, memory, and cognition are prone to a host of flaws, weaknesses, and biases that will tend to mislead us, especially towards conclusions that we wish to be true. Placebo effects, confirmation bias, and simple statistics can make any intervention seem effective, even when they are worthless or harmful. 
Science-Based Medicine vs Evidence-Based Medicine
Within the practice of medicine there is already a recognition of the need to raise the standards of evidence and the availability of the best evidence to the practitioner and the consumer – formalized in the movement known as evidence-based medicine (EBM). 
EBM is a vital and positive influence on the practice of medicine, but it has its limitations. EBM tends to focus on clinical trial results to the exclusion of scientific plausibility. The focus on trial results (which, in the EBM lexicon, is what is meant by “evidence”) has its utility, but fails to properly deal with medical modalities that are highly implausible, or seem to defy well-established findings in science.
All of science describes the same reality, and therefore it must (if it is functioning properly) all be mutually compatible. Collectively, science builds one cumulative model of the natural world. This means we can make rational judgments about what is likely to be true based upon what is already well established. This does not necessarily equate to rejecting new ideas out-of-hand, but rather to adjusting the threshold of evidence required to establish a new claim based upon the prior scientific plausibility of the new claim. Failure to do so leads to conclusions and recommendations that are not reliable, and therefore medical practices that are probably not safe and effective.
The SBM Series
This is why the authors of this series strongly advocate for science based medicine – the use of the best scientific evidence available, in the light of our cumulative scientific knowledge from all relevant disciplines, in evaluating health claims, practices, and products. 
Some of the articles here will analyze individual studies, and explore the strengths and weaknesses of their methods, separating what the study really tells us from how it may be represented in the media. Other articles will summarize what many studies tell us about a specific medical question. 
We will also explore health information on the internet, separating out which information is reliable from that which is misleading, erroneous, or possibly even fraudulent. Likewise we will critique mainstream media coverage of health topics, giving the reader specific tools for to critically analyze health information for themselves.
Other articles will explore topics related to health regulation and academia. Regulations have struggled to keep up with the rapidly changing health care market place, with critical gaps that leave the health care consumer responsible for their own protection. Academic institutions themselves, long the defenders of high standards of scholarship in all fields, including medicine, have been infiltrated by promoters of pseudoscientific belief systems. The result is that there is no longer any single reliable guarantee of scientific integrity. 
The SBM series of e-books is organized by topic, such as acupuncture, chiropractic, homeopathy, and many others. The books are collections of essays, not intended to be a systematic reference, but rather to explore the various scientific issues related to each topic. The goal is to give the reader critical thinking skills and a deeper understanding of, not just the current findings of science, but the process of science, specifically how it relates to health care and the topic of each book. 
Science-based medicine can serve as your pocket guide through the wilderness of health information.

   Overview
Chiropractic was invented by D. D. Palmer on September 18, 1895 when he adjusted the spine of a deaf man and allegedly restored his hearing (a claim that is highly implausible based on what we know of anatomy). Based on this one case, Palmer decided that all disease was due to subluxation: 95% to subluxations of the spine and 5% to subluxations of other bones.
The rationale for chiropractic hinges on three postulates:
Bones are out of place
Bony displacements cause nerve interference
Manipulating the spine replaces the bones, removing the nerve interference and allowing Innate (a vitalistic life force) to restore health.
There is no credible evidence to support any of these claims.
Real subluxations (partial dislocations) show up on x-ray. Chiropractic “subluxations” don’t. In view of the negative x-ray evidence, chiropractic was forced to change its definition of a subluxation from “a bone out of place” to “a complex of functional and/or structural and/or pathological articular changes that compromise neural integrity and may influence organ system and general health.”
Chiropractors are divided into straights and mixers. The straights limit themselves to chiropractic adjustments; the mixers add a variety of other methods ranging from massage to outright quackery like applied kinesiology. Upper cervical chiropractors focus on the atlas, the top cervical vertebra.
In over a century, chiropractic research has produced no evidence to support the postulates of chiropractic theory and little evidence that chiropractic treatments provide objective benefits. Research on spinal manipulation is inherently difficult, because double blind studies are impossible and even single blind studies are problematic; a placebo response is hard to rule out.
There is good evidence that spinal manipulation therapy (SMT) is effective for some patients with low back pain but that it is not superior to other treatments. There is controversial evidence of lesser quality supporting the use of manipulation for neck pain and headaches. SMT is not exclusive to chiropractic: it is also used by physical therapists, doctors of osteopathy, and others. There is no acceptable evidence that chiropractic can improve the many other health problems it claims to benefit, from colic to asthma. There is no evidence to support the practice of adjusting the spines of newborns in the delivery room or providing repeated lifelong adjustments to maintain health or prevent disease.
Up to half of patients report short-term adverse effects from manipulation, such as increased local or radiating pain; and there is a rare but devastating complication of neck manipulation: it can injure the vertebrobasilar arteries and cause stroke, paralysis, and death. Some chiropractors do not accept the germ theory of disease and only about half of them support immunization. Many of them discourage proven treatments with drugs and surgery and many want to take on the role of primary health care provider.
In their book Trick or Treatment, Simon Singh and Edzard Ernst reviewed the evidence for chiropractic and concluded: “Chiropractors… might compete with physiotherapists in terms of treating some back problems, but all their other claims are beyond belief and can carry a range of significant risks.”

   Chiropractic – A Brief Overview, Part I
Steven Novella
Link
When patients ask me if a chiropractor can help them with their problem, I often think to myself, “OK, do I give them the short answer or the long answer?” The difficulty is often in the fact that chiropractic is a diverse profession and it is difficult to even characterize what a “typical” chiropractor is likely to do. As a chiropractor once admitted to me – there are a great many things that happen under the umbrella of “chiropractic.”
In this article I will summarize some of the history and practice of chiropractic, highlighting what I consider to be many of the enduring problems with this profession.
History
Chiropractic was founded in 1895 by Daniel David Palmer, a grocer with an intense interest in metaphysics. Prior to his “discovery” of chiropractic, D.D. Palmer was a magnetic healer. He also had interests in phrenology (diagnosing disease based on the bumps of the skull) and spiritualism. Palmer reported to have discovered the principle of chiropractic when he allegedly cured a janitor of his deafness by manipulating his neck. The fact that the nerve which conveys sound information from the ears to the brain does not pass through the neck did not seem to bother Palmer, if he was even aware of this fact.
Palmer created the term “chiropractic,” which literally means “done by hand,” to refer to his new therapy. He argued that all disease is caused by subluxated bones, which 95% of the time are spinal bones, and which disrupt the flow of innate intelligence. He did not subject his ideas to any form of research, but rather went directly to treating patients and to teaching his principles to the first generation of chiropractors.
Subluxation Theory
Palmer believed in the pre-scientific vitalistic notion that health stems from the flow of a spiritual life force. Although vitalism was rapidly declining within scientific thought by the end of the 19th century, it was the centerpiece of early philosophies of health in most cultures. Palmer borrowed this ancient belief and renamed it “innate intelligence” which he claimed flowed from the brain to the rest of the body through the spinal cord and peripheral nerves. All disease, he argued, results from disruption in the flow of innate intelligence. Disruption in flow is caused by spinal subluxations, which are small misalignments in the spine that compress the spinal nerves.
Therefore, liver disease is caused by a subluxation which compresses the spinal nerve which supplies the liver with life force, depriving it of its vital innate intelligence. Palmer therefore believed he could cure by fixing these misalignments with manipulation.
This idea has remained the cornerstone of chiropractic despite advances in neurobiology and anatomy which have failed to show any evidence for innate intelligence or chiropractic subluxations. Many continue to ascribe all disease to the blockage of innate intelligence despite scientific advances in medicine which have discovered infectious, genetic, autoimmune, degenerative, nutritional, and other causes for many of the diseases which plague mankind.
Chiropractic was also not the only tradition based upon manipulating the bones. Of note, osteopathic doctors also developed an art of bone manipulation in order to heal, but they believed they were unblocking blood flow through arteries. Osteopathy and chiropractic had similar roots, but took very different paths, as we will see.
D.D. Palmer’s son, B.J. Palmer, became involved in the chiropractic movement early on, during the formative years. B.J shared his father’s metaphysical bent (prior to chiropractic, he worked with a mesmerist and worked in the circus), his tendency to make sweeping statements about health without justification, and his ignorance of contemporary scientific knowledge. He was reported to state, for example, “When I saw there was no use for a sympathetic nervous system, I threw it out, and then just had to put something better in its place, so I discovered Direct Mental Impulse.” B.J. also “discovered” a non-existent “Duct of Palmer” connecting the spleen to the stomach. In 1907 B.J. engineered a hostile take over of his father’s school of chiropractic.
B.J. Palmer set the tone that would later dominate the field of chiropractic. He emphasized salesmanship, advertising, and practice building. He was highly critical of medicine, stating that M.D. stands for “more death.” He continuously sought new methods for increasing revenues, such as his neurocalometer, which would pinpoint subluxations by measuring skin temperature and he decreed must be rented from him by other practitioners at exorbitant fees.
From the beginning chiropractors were also politically aggressive. They sought licensure as a protection from the growing scientific medicine with which they were completely at odds. Many legislators were reluctant to license chiropractors for this reason, but as more and more states voted in licensure, it became increasingly difficult to fight. Additionally, many legislators looked upon licensure as way of controlling the scope of chiropractic. By 1925, 32 states had instituted licenses for chiropractors. The struggle ended in 1974 when Louisiana instituted licensing.
Many states then began to pass basic science board requirements for licensure, making chiropractors pass the same tests of basic science knowledge as medical and osteopathic students. This was justified by the fact that chiropractors were presenting themselves as primary practitioners. However, where roughly 86 percent of medical students passed their basic science boards between 1927 and 1953, only 23 percent of chiropractors did. Chiropractors who could not pass the boards either moved to another state without the requirement, or practiced without a license. Between 1967 and 1979 all of the basic science laws for chiropractors were repealed.
Over the years chiropractic has never ceased its tireless struggle for growth and acceptance. Despite the fact that scientific medicine has continued to progress and chiropractic has never shed its pseudoscientific origins, they have been quite successful. After licensure, they gained coverage under Medicare. They have also successfully sued the AMA to stop their antichiropractic campaign. Today they continue to lobby hard for increased coverage and access under health insurance and HMO policies.
Straights, Mixers, and Reformers
Almost since the beginning, chiropractic has been fraught with many internal schisms. Today there is a wide range of differences between individual chiropractors, but most can be placed within one of three basic types.
Straight chiropractors consider themselves the only true or pure chiropractors because they limit their practice to the identification and treatment of spinal subluxations. They adhere strictly to Palmer’s concept of disease and believe that all ailments can be treated through manipulation to restore the flow of innate intelligence. Once freely flowing, they believe innate intelligence has unlimited power to naturally heal the body.
Straight chiropractors are the most extreme in their anti-scientific views. They openly advocate a philosophical rather than a scientific basis for health care, calling mainstream medicine “mechanistic” and “allopathic.” They call physicians “drug pushers” and disparage the use of surgery. They are careful not to give diseases names, but none-the-less they claim to cure disease with their adjustments. They oppose vaccinations. They also openly advocate the replacement of scientific medicine with chiropractic as primary health care. The statements of Dr. Wilson A. Morgan (who just passed away earlier this month), previous Executive Officer of Life College School of Chiropractic, are typical:
“Chiropractic: The health care system whose time as the official guardian of the public’s health is fast approaching!”
“On the other hand, it is equally appropriate for chiropractors to be viewed as generalists in that the far-reaching effects of their highly specific spinal adjustments usually are followed by the decrease and often disappearance of a very broad array of symptoms, disabilities and pathological conditions.”
“Unlike the medical profession, chiropractic has a very strong philosophical basis, which no doubt has contributed to its having been labeled ‘unscientific’ by the more mechanistically-oriented scientific community.”
“It appears that education will prove to be the best strategy in the ‘war on drugs,’ including education about the dangers of drugs available on the street and also those available from the physician as prescriptions.”
Mixers, comprising the largest segment of chiropractors, may at first seem more rational. They accept that some disease is caused by infection or other causes and they do not limit their practice to fixing subluxations. Most chiropractors in this group, however, do not supplement subluxation theory with scientific medicine, but rather with an eclectic array of pseudoscientific alternative practices. Mixers commonly prescribe homeopathic and herbal remedies, practice acupuncture and therapeutic touch, diagnose with iridology, contour analysis, and applied kinesiology, and adhere to the philosophy of naturopathy. This broad use of unproven, unscientific, and fanciful so-called “alternative” practices clearly indicates an antiscience attitude, as well as a lack of scientific knowledge, on the part of those chiropractors who employ them.
The rhetoric of Mixers indicates that they are attempting to become accepted into the scientific mainstream, rather than replace scientifically based medicine with a philosophy based approach. They no longer openly oppose immunization, like straights do, but they do advocate the freedom to choose whether or not to be immunized. Their appeal to freedom is emotionally effective, especially in the United States, but it fails to recognize that immunization is far less effective in eliminating or containing infectious diseases when it is not given to everyone. They also advocate a role for chiropractors as a primary care portal of entry system within HealthCare, despite the fact that they lack adequate training as generalists skilled in medical diagnosis.
A small minority of chiropractors, numbering only about 1,000, or 2% of all chiropractors (these are rough estimates because accurate figures are lacking), have been openly critical of their own field. They have called for absolute rejection of the subluxation theory of illness, disposing of pseudoscientific and unethical practices by chiropractors, and the restriction of chiropractic to treating acute musculoskeletal symptoms. They are attempting to bring their field into the scientific mainstream.
Occasionally chiropractic reformers have attempted to forge a new profession, entirely shedding the pseudoscience attached to the chiropractic brand. About ten years ago one group in Canada renamed themselves “Orthopractors,” and considered the new discipline of orthopractic as distinct from chiropractic. Orthopractic is the use of manipulation to provide symptomatic relief from uncomplicated acute back strain. They do not believe in maintenance therapy, treating medical ailments, or the use of pseudoscientific alternative practices.
Unfortunately, this reform effort died because “orthopractic” did not exist as a legal entity. This also partly explains why the “chiropractic” label persists and covers such a wide range of philosophy and practice – because it exists as a recognized licensed profession. It has a regulatory inertia that is hard to combat.
To further complicate things, spinal manipulation exists outside of the chiropractic profession, and not all manipulation is chiropractic manipulation. Some physiatrists, sports medicine doctors, and osteopaths legitimately employ manipulative therapy to relieve muscle strain, mobilize joints, and improve function. Chiropractors do this as well. But some chiropractors also do chiropractic manipulation designed to realign the spine and reduce imaginary chiropractic subluxations.
The Evidence – Subluxations
In the past 100 years, there has been very little research conducted into the basic principles of straight chiropractic. There is no research that indicates the existence of innate intelligence or that such a force plays any role in health and disease. Further, the evidence strongly suggests that chiropractic subluxations are a figment of the chiropractic imagination. And it also seems that spinal manipulation is not capable of realigning the vertebra of the spine.
A study carried out by Edmund Crelin, Ph.D. investigated the amount of force necessary to displace vertebral bones of the spine in order to cause impingement of a spinal nerve. The study was carried out on six corpses within 8 hours after death. His conclusion was that the amount of force necessary to actually displace the vertebra was great enough to break the spine, arguing strongly that chiropractic manipulation cannot significantly affect spinal alignment, and that misaligned spines do not caused pinched nerves (Crelin, 1973).
Pinched or impinged spinal nerves do occur, but they are caused by herniated discs, fractures, tumors, or overgrowth of the vertebral bones. When spinal nerves are impinged they cause pain, numbness, and tingling and may cause a decrease or loss of deep tendon reflexes and weakness of the muscles supplied by the affected nerve. Impinged nerves are not caused by subluxations nor do they result in diseases of the organs. Believers in subluxation theory must claim, implausibly, that nerve impingement causes only a blockage of innate intelligence without causing any of the known signs and symptoms of such impingement.
Ironically, spinal manipulation is contraindicated in cases of actual nerve impingement and should not be performed. In medical studies of manipulation, such as the RAND study, often cited by chiropractors as evidence for manipulation, spinal nerve impingement was considered a reason not to have manipulation and therefore was a criteria for exclusion from the study.
Another source of evidence that the chiropractic theory of subluxations and innate intelligence is completely false comes from the unfortunate victims of spinal trauma. There are many victims of complete transection, or disruption, of the cervical spinal cord in the neck. Such a complete injury leaves its victim quadraplegic, unable to move the arms or legs. If the injury is high enough in the spinal cord the victim may not even be able to breath on their own. In such victims no impulses from the brain are able to travel below the spinal cord in the neck, and therefore most of the communication between the brain and the body is interrupted. Certainly, this is a much more dramatic and complete interference of nerve flow than that of an impinged spinal nerve.
Yet, in these patients, the organs continue to work without difficulty and diseases do not develop at any higher rate than those without such an injury. Of course, there are some effects from the disruption of the autonomic nervous system, that part of the nervous system which regulates the bladder, the degree of bowel motility, and other functions. But all effects of spinal cord damage are caused by known neurological injury. If subluxation theory were correct, then patients with high spinal cord injuries would be ravaged by every conceivable disease.
So chiropractors cannot realign the spine to fix imaginary subluxations and restore the flow of nonexistent innate intelligence. Subluxation theory is pure pseudoscience, like homeopathy or therapeutic touch, and has no place in a 21st century scientific health care system.
Despite the extreme scientific implausibility of subluxation theory, specific applications have been tested with clinical research – with predictable results. For example, many chiropractors will use manipulation to treat asthma is children. The results of this research are soundly negative – chiropractic does not work on asthma.
Despite this many chiropractors persist in treating asthma. This led Simon Singh to write in the Guardian in 2008 that the British Chiropractic Association, which does advocate chiropractic for childhood asthma, “promotes bogus therapies.” In response to this statement the BCA notably did not provide the evidence that Singh claimed was missing. Rather, they sued him for libel (the case is ongoing).
Next week I will cover the evidence for musculoskeletal uses of chiropractic.
References
N Engl J Med. 1998 Oct 8;339(15):1013-20. A comparison of active and simulated chiropractic manipulation as adjunctive treatment for childhood asthma. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/9761802?dopt=Abstract

   Chiropractic – A Brief Overview, Part II
Steven Novella
Link
Last week I reviewed the history of chiropractic and discussed issues relating to its underlying claims and treatments for non-musculoskeletal indications. Today I will focus on chiropractic for back pain and similar indications.
Manipulative Therapy
There is evidence to support the very narrow indication of spinal manipulation for the symptomatic management of acute uncomplicated lower back strain. The good news for chiropractors is that this is a very common condition and does not respond well to conventional management – actually all treatments: medical management, physical therapy, manipulation, and even just patient education, appear to be equally and quite modestly effective.
There is a body of clinical studies that are relevant to the question of manipulation for lower back strain. A review of this research was published in 1989 by the RAND corporation, an independent research group that put together a panel of both physicians and chiropractors to review the available research on manipulative therapy. They concluded that evidence from 22 studies supported the use of manipulative therapy for acute uncomplicated lower back pain (again – no real pinched nerves). It is important to understand, however, that they were referring to manipulative therapy, not chiropractic. In fact only 4 of the 22 studies mentioned included chiropractors. In the other studies the manipulative therapy was performed by physicians and physical therapists.
The RAND study went on to enumerate a long list of situations in which spinal manipulation should not be performed, including evidence of nerve root compression. Other contraindications include a greater than 6 month duration, X-ray or clinical evidence of malignancy, failure to respond to manipulation or a history of not responding to manipulation, among others. They also concluded that there was insufficient evidence to justify the use of manipulation for most forms of chronic lower back pain. The study in no way supported chiropractic subluxation theory or the scope of chiropractic practice. Nor did it make any comparison between manipulation and other forms of treatment for low back pain.
Because of the popular confusion of chiropractic with manipulative therapy, and the use of manipulation for symptomatic treatment vs the pseudoscientific treatment of subluxations and innate intelligence – some chiropractors were able to exploit this and other positive studies of manipulation to advertise that “chiropractic works” as a way of promoting chiropractic treatments that have nothing to do with manipulation for lower back pain. The number of misrepresentations prompted Paul G. Shekelle, MD, MPH of the RAND corp. who designed the study to write:
“Through RAND’s process of monitoring the popular media, we have become aware of numerous instances where our results have been seriously misrepresented by chiropractors writing for their local paper or writing letters to the editor.”
There have been further studies since the 1989 review. The Meade study, which was published in the British Medical Journal in 1990, concluded that:
“For patients with low back pain in whom manipulation is not contraindicated, chiropractic almost certainly confers worthwhile long-term benefit in comparison with hospital outpatient management.”
There are some serious limitations of this study, however. The two treatment groups were not comparable, because the chiropractic group received 44% more treatment (costing 50% more) over twice as long a period of time and in a private setting. The outpatient physical therapy group was part of the National Health Service, and were noted to have limited resources and could not treat their patients in the same fashion that a private practitioner could.
Second, patients entered into the study were put through a medical screening process including X-rays that were interpreted by hospital radiologists. Between 25 and 50% of patients entering the study were eliminated because they were felt to have contraindications to manipulation. This fact alone makes it impossible to accurately apply the results of this study to the way chiropractic is practiced in the real world, where there is rarely independent radiological review or other medical screening. Of course, practices vary greatly, and some chiropractors do collaborate with physicians for medical screening.
A large 1998 study compared chiropractic to physical therapy to a third group that only received an informational booklet. The study concluded:
For patients with low back pain, the McKenzie method of physical therapy and chiropractic manipulation had similar effects and costs, and patients receiving these treatments had only marginally better outcomes than those receiving the minimal intervention of an educational booklet. Whether the limited benefits of these treatments are worth the additional costs is open to question.
The safety of manipulative therapy has not been adequately established. This 2001 review concludes:
The most valid studies suggest that about half of all patients will experience adverse events after chiropractic SM. These events are usually mild and transient. No reliable data exist about the incidence of serious adverse events. These data indicate that mild and transient adverse events seem to be frequent. Serious adverse events are probably rare but their incidence can only be estimated at present. Further prospective investigations are needed to define their incidence more closely.
A 2004 review of spinal manipulation and mobilizing for acute and chronic back and neck pain concluded:
Our data synthesis suggests that recommendations can be made with some confidence regarding the use of SMT and/or MOB as a viable option for the treatment of both low back pain and NP (neck pain). There have been few high-quality trials distinguishing between acute and chronic patients, and most are limited to shorter-term follow-up. Future trials should examine well-defined subgroups of patients, further address the value of SMT and MOB for acute patients, establish optimal number of treatment visits and consider the cost-effectiveness of care.
The research which has been done into the effectiveness of manipulative therapy can best be summarized as suggesting a role for spinal manipulation in the symptomatic treatment of uncomplicated low back pain, provided adequate medical screening is performed. This includes manipulation by some chiropractors, or by physical therapists, physiatrists and others. Manipulation is no more effective, and is often more expensive than, other forms of treatment – such as best medical management or simple physical therapy with good home back care.
Other Uses of Chiropractic
Many chiropractors also use spinal manipulation for other indications, without evidence to support their safety and effectiveness. For example, neck manipulation for headache is not uncommon, despite a lack of adequate evidence for efficacy. The study most often cited by chiropractors to support manipulation for migraine compared neck manipulation to 25mg of Elavil for 8 weeks vs combined therapy and found no difference in outcome. They conclude from this that neck manipulation works as well as medical management.
However, 25mg of Elavil is too low a dose for most patients to response, and the duration of treatment before a response is typically seen is 6-8 weeks. Often a significant response is only seen after several months, and after increasing the dose to between 50-100mg per day. In other words, they used an inadequate control – a treatment that would not be expected to work. Therefore, the more reasonable conclusion to reach from this study is that chiropractic manipulation does not work for migraine. Also, the lack of any additive effect is consistent with pure placebo response.
A recent Cochrane review from 2004 of physical treatments for headaches, including manipulation, concluded:
The clinical effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of non-invasive physical treatments require further research using scientifically rigorous methods.
“Requires further research” means that there is no currently proven benefit.
With neck manipulation there is also a concern for serious risk. Although the statistical risk is low, there are reported cases of stroke and even death following neck manipulation, resulting from arterial dissection – a tear in an artery in the neck. There is insufficient evidence to conclude firmly what the risk is, but given the soft evidence for a benefit for neck manipulation even a small chance of a serious side effect like stroke is likely not justified.
Many chiropractors also offer “maintenance therapy” – regular visits for manipulation to prevent disease or symptoms. There is no evidence and no biological plausibility to justify maintenance chiropractic manipulation.
This critical summary by Edzard Ernst, in my opinion, is appropriate.
The core concepts of chiropractic, subluxation and spinal manipulation, are not based on sound science. Back and neck pain are the domains of chiropractic but many chiropractors treat conditions other than musculoskeletal problems. With the possible exception of back pain, chiropractic spinal manipulation has not been shown to be effective for any medical condition. Manipulation is associated with frequent mild adverse effects and with serious complications of unknown incidence. Its cost-effectiveness has not been demonstrated beyond reasonable doubt. The concepts of chiropractic are not based on solid science and its therapeutic value has not been demonstrated beyond reasonable doubt.
Conclusion
The chiropractic profession has its roots firmly planted in pure pseudoscience, but despite this there happens to be a plausible role for spinal manipulation for the limited indication of uncomplicated lower back strain. Further research is needed to explore subgroups, cost effectiveness, safety, and whether or not there is any legitimate role for neck manipulation.
Due, it seems, to the personality and personal beliefs of B.J. Palmer, the chiropractic profession has had an ongoing hostile relationship with mainstream scientific medicine. This is unfortunate. Also, the profession has expanded its philosophy and practice to the point that there are now many separate professions all practicing under the banner of chiropractic, leading to much public confusion and poor to nonexistent maintenance of a standard of care within chiropractic.
The chiropractic profession is in need of serious reform. They are unlikely to accept the recommendations of an outsider like myself, but I am going to give them anyway.
First, the profession needs to clean house. Much like the Flexner report did a century ago for medicine – closing most medical school because they were substandard, the chiropractic profession needs to go through a similar purging.
- This means rejecting completely subluxation theory, including the notion of innate intelligence and the existence of mysterious chiropractic subluxations.
- Along with subluxation theory, chiropractors should condemn the use of manipulative therapy to treat medical conditions and diseases, including asthma, ear infections, ulcers, migraines, and other conditions.
- The chiropractic profession should endorse the principles of science-based medicine and dedicate themselves to high standards of science and transparency. This includes subjecting their treatments to more clinical research, changing their practice based upon the evidence, exploring the risks as well as the benefits of their own treatments, and internally policing their practitioners in order to maintain an adequate standard of care across their profession.
- Chiropractors should seek to align themselves with other science-based professions. This includes endorsing science-based public health measures, like immunization. They should not foster hostility toward science-based practitioners, and they should refer patients to other specialists when appropriate.
- Chiropractors should not seek to expand their scope of practice beyond their training and ability. They should not present themselves as primary care providers, nor lobby for regulations to allow them to do so.
- Chiropractors can thrive as a health-care profession as experts in back care and physical medicine. This would provide them with a sufficiently broad scope of practice to be viable, in an area where there is a great need for expertise and symptomatic management. In fact, many science-based chiropractors do just fine within this scope, and provide a best-practice model for their profession.
- The chiropractic profession should purge from their training and practice modalities other than spinal manipulation that are pseudoscientific – including iridology, applied kinesiology, homeopathy, and nutritional pseudoscience. Of course, the medical profession now needs to do this too, as pseudoscience has infiltrated mainstream medicine, but that is a separate article. Also, the percentage of chiropractors using such methods is far greater than within mainstream medicine, and is therefore much more of a problem.
- Chiropractic colleges should change their curriculum so that they are more uniform and more in line with modern scientific concepts and practice.
I harbor no illusions that anything like what I have described above will happen anytime soon, if ever. I hold out a little hope, as there is a small minority of chiropractors who also endorse what I have outlined and are trying to reform their profession from within. I wish them well, and I eagerly await the day that I can feel comfortable with the average chiropractor as an allied science-based health professional.
Until then, in my opinion, public criticism of pseudoscientific claims and practices within chiropractic is the only ethical response.
References
N Engl J Med. 1998 Oct 8;339(15):1021-9.A comparison of physical therapy, chiropractic manipulation, and provision of an educational booklet for the treatment of patients with low back pain. Cherkin DC, Deyo RA, Battié M, Street J, Barlow W.
J Pain Symptom Manage. 2001 Mar;21(3):238-42. Prospective investigations into the safety of spinal manipulation. Ernst E.
J Manipulative Physiol Ther. 1998 Oct;21(8):511-9. The efficacy of spinal manipulation, amitriptyline and the combination of both therapies for the prophylaxis of migraine headache. Nelson CF, Bronfort G, Evans R, Boline P, Goldsmith C, Anderson AV.
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2004;(3):CD001878. Non-invasive physical treatments for chronic/recurrent headache. Bronfort G, Nilsson N, Haas M, Evans R, Goldsmith CH, Assendelft WJ, Bouter LM.
Neurology. 2003 May 13;60(9):1424-8. Spinal manipulative therapy is an independent risk factor for vertebral artery dissection. Smith WS, Johnston SC, Skalabrin EJ, Weaver M, Azari P, Albers GW, Gress DR.
J Pain Symptom Manage. 2008 May;35(5):544-62. Epub 2008 Feb 14. Chiropractic: a critical evaluation. Ernst E.

   Chiropractic and Deafness: Back to 1895
Harriet Hall
Link
Chiropractic originated in 1895 when D.D. Palmer claimed to have restored deaf janitor Harvey Lillard’s hearing by manipulating his spine. This makes no anatomical sense, and few if any chiropractors claim to be able to reverse deafness today. But now a chiropractic website is attempting to vindicate D. D. Palmer. They list deafness among a long (wrong) list of “Conditions That Respond Well to Chiropractic”
They list 6 supporting studies. Three are case reports, two are case series, and one is a review of the literature that is labeled in its title as “A Search to Validate” D.D. Palmer.
Study No. 1
One study is a case report entitled “Hearing Loss, Otalgia and Neck Pain: A Case Report on Long-Term Chiropractic Care That Helped to Improve Quality of Life.” I’ll copy the entire abstract to give a flavor of the quality of evidence these chiropractors find acceptable:
Objective: To describe symptom reports, multiple chiropractic assessments and adjustments over 7 years with a patient experiencing neck pain and complex ear symptoms consistent with Meniere’s syndrome.
Clinical Features: A 43-year-old female, injured years earlier in a motor vehicle collision, suffered recurrent exacerbations of otherwise continuous neck pain. Later she developed aural symptoms of severe otalgia, hearing difficulty, tinnitus and dizziness that increased and decreased in severity with her neck pain.
Intervention and Outcome: The intervention was repeated application of chiropractic adjustments using a modified Pettibon adjusting device. Over 7 years of observation, the subject consistently reported reduction in symptom severity after adjustments, with relief lasting up to 2 months. Consistent with the natural history of Meniere’s syndrome, an overall deterioration was noted during the observation period. Hearing fluctuated in approximate synchrony with changes in angular displacements of upper cervical vertebrae during the treatment period.
Conclusion: Observation over an extended period assists in understanding the progression of chronic disorders. This patient experienced substantially reduced symptoms with chiropractic care during the 7-year observation period. Of note is the repeated exacerbation of neck pain that often precedes exacerbation in ear symptoms, along with the relief of both following adjustment and an association between improved hearing and improved cervical alignment.
Comments: This woman’s deafness was part of her Meniere’s disease and was presumably not related in any way to her auto accident or her neck symptoms. The association of reported increases in neck pain with exacerbation of Meniere’s symptoms could be due to the fact that people in pain and people who are in a depressed mood are more likely to report other physical symptoms. Reduction in symptoms after adjustment is compatible with nonspecific effects of any treatment, with placebo response, or with the natural course of illness. Fluctuating hearing loss is one of the characteristics of Meniere’s disease. The Pettibon system is an upper cervical method that is not supported by any credible evidence. The finding of “angular displacements of upper cervical vertebrae” is an upper chiropractic delusion: actual displacements have not been confirmed by conventional radiologists. “Improved cervical alignment” cannot be scientifically demonstrated.
Study No. 2
This was a case report of a 41-year-old woman who had bilateral ear pain, tinnitus, vertigo, “altered or decreased hearing acuity,” and headaches. She had a history of ear infections treated with antibiotics. She had been diagnosed and treated for temporomandibular joint syndrome (TMJ). The chiropractor diagnosed an atlas subluxation and after 9 treatments her symptoms resolved.
Comments: We don’t know what was wrong with this patient. What does “altered or decreased hearing acuity” mean? Hearing can be temporarily decreased by infections with fluid in the middle ear. TMJ does not cause deafness. Atlas subluxations are mythical. Symptoms like these typically fluctuate and may resolve spontaneously over time.
Study No. 3
A case report of a 75 yr old woman with longstanding vertigo, tinnitus and hearing loss. Her symptoms increased over a 5-week period before she sought chiropractic care. Her symptoms improved during upper cervical chiropractic treatment.
Comments: Symptoms fluctuate over time. The chiropractor saw her when the symptoms were at their worst, and regression to the mean explains why she improved. Did she have Meniere’s disease? A fluctuating hearing loss is characteristic of Meniere’s. Upper cervical chiropractic treatment has never been shown to cure anything. There is no reason to think the treatment had anything to do with her improvement.
Study No. 4
“Improvement in Hearing after Chiropractic Care: A Case Series.” Full text available online The subjects were a “sample of convenience” of 15 patients who presented for chiropractic care and whose chief complaint was not hearing loss. All subjects were found to have hearing loss, more in the left ear than the right, and after a single chiropractic visit 8 patients improved in one ear, 3 improved in both ears, four were unchanged, and 3 were worse. The post-treatment tests continued to show worse hearing in the left ear than the right. The author indulges in wild speculation about possible mechanisms including brain plasticity and the effect of peripheral stimulation on thalamic activity in the brain.
Comments: The discussion section of the report admits that this study can’t prove a cause and effect relationship. To support his speculations, the author references Carrick’s ridiculous blind spot study which I critiqued at length in The Scientific Review of Alternative Medicine and briefly on Chirobase. Just citing Carrick’s article is enough to completely discredit the author in my mind. It is junk science and its conclusions depend on circular reasoning. One thing that particularly bothers me about this study is the finding of more hearing loss on the left side. As far as we know, hearing loss should be evenly distributed. What could account for the discrepancy?
Study No. 5
“Vertebrogenic Hearing Deficit, the Spine, and Spinal Manipulation Therapy: A Search to Validate the D.D. Palmer/Harvey Lillard Experience.” This review of the medical and chiropractic literature
suggests that hearing deficits may be associated with spinal joint motion restriction, spondyloarthrosis, irritation of the sympathetic nervous system, decreased cervico-cerebral circulation and/or decrease in tinnitus…It is proposed that some cases may benefit from SMT. Further research is needed to determine the role of SMT in the treatment of vertebrogenic hearing deficits.
Comments: The very title indicates bias. This author cherry-picked the literature in a vain attempt to validate D.D. Palmer. While the literature may “suggest” the associations he lists, it does not “prove” those associations, much less show that any association represents a causal relationship. He does not provide any evidence that SMT can restore hearing. He calls for research into the treatment of “vertebrogenic hearing deficits” but that would just be Tooth Fairy science, since we have no evidence that hearing deficits can be due to vertebral causes.
Study No. 6
“Cervicogenic Hearing Loss.” The author of this case series starts by admitting “there remains a dispute whether a “vertebragenic hearing disorder” exists. This latter disorder is believed accompanied by tinnitus, a feeling of ear pressure, otalgia and deafness as symptoms of a functional deficit of the upper cervical spine.” It studied 259 patients with “well-defined functional deficits of the upper cervical spine and symptoms of cervical vertigo,” and found subjective hearing disorders in 15% and audiometric threshold shifts in 40%. 62 patients with vertebragenic hearing loss improved during chiropractic management. He concludes that the therapy of choice is chiropractic manipulation of the upper cervical spine.
Comments: He doesn’t have any evidence that the disorder exists, but he diagnoses it in 62 patients (!?) At best, this is a case series of questionable significance; at worst it is Tooth Fairy science, studying something that probably doesn’t exist. There were no controls. How can he conclude that the treatment of choice is chiropractic manipulation when he has not compared that to any other treatment?
Elsewhere chiropractic apologists have hypothesized how problems in the spine might lead to effects in the ear. The vertebrobasilar artery passes through the neck and a branch of it supplies the inner ear. Conceivably a neck injury could damage the artery and reduce blood supply to the ear, but it is inconceivable that manipulating the neck could then reverse the damage. Some have posited effects via the autonomic (sympathetic and parasympathetic) nervous system, but they have not demonstrated that an autonomic problem is present, that it could account for the symptoms, or that autonomic effects could be corrected or compensated for by manipulation. Some argue that sensory stimulation of the body can affect stuff in the brain. Sure, if you hit your toe with a hammer, there will be a change in brain activity. That’s a truism, not an argument for spinal manipulation.
There is a rumor (unconfirmed) that Harvey Lillard’s widow later said he was deaf until the day he died. We will never know enough about his case to understand what really happened. But I think we can reasonably conclude that spinal manipulation is not an effective treatment for hearing loss. And that the authors of this website have no understanding of what constitutes credible scientific evidence.

Inside Chiropractic: Yesteryear and Today
In the 123 years since its inception, the core beliefs of the chiropractic profession have not changed. Chiropractic continues to exist as a form of alternative medicine that embraces a variety of questionable procedures and treatment methods. The chiropractic profession in the United States is still defined by the vertebral subluxation theory that gave it birth and independence as an alternative to conventional medical care. Chiropractors resist changes that would allow development of their profession as a conservative back-care specialty.
Sam Homola on February 16, 2018
Tweet

My father was a chiropractor who graduated from the Palmer School of Chiropractic in Davenport, Iowa, in 1920. Following in my father’s footsteps, I enrolled as a student at Lincoln Chiropractic College in Indianapolis, Indiana, in 1952. Like my father, I believed that chiropractic manipulation or “adjustment” of the spine could be used to treat organic disease by correcting misaligned or “subluxated” vertebrae to remove pressure on spinal nerves. After a few years of mixing basic science study with chiropractic philosophy, however, it became apparent to me that the chiropractic vertebral subluxation theory was a tenuous belief ─ a belief formulated in 1895 by D.D. Palmer, a grocer who was also a magnetic healer. Palmer developed his theory that 95 percent of diseases are caused by displaced vertebrae after claiming that he had cured deafness by “racking” a thoracic vertebra back into place (Wardwell 1992). There is good reason to question Palmer’s claim. The acoustic nerve, with an auditory branch that supplies the function of hearing, is a cranial nerve that connects the brain with the inner ear, following pathways inside the skull, far removed from the 4th thoracic vertebra “racked” by Palmer.
I learned from reading anatomy and physiology books that the body’s organs are innervated by autonomic nerve ganglia and plexuses located outside the spinal column (some of which receive preganglionic autonomic fibers from the thoracic and upper lumbar portion of the spinal cord) and by autonomic cranial and sacral nerves that pass through solid bony openings, unaffected by misalignment of a vertebra. (The 10th cranial vagus nerves pass down from an opening on each side of the base of the skull to supply thoracic and abdominal viscera. Pelvic organs are supplied by autonomic sacral nerves.) Overlapping autonomic nerve supply from multiple sources, along with hormones and other factors, assure involuntary function of the body’s organs independent of spinal nerves that are designed primarily to supply skin and the voluntary function of musculoskeletal structures. This is why the body’s organs continue to function when a spinal cord injury in the neck paralyzes musculoskeletal structures from the neck down. Compression of a spinal nerve results in loss of sensory and motor functions only in the musculoskeletal area supplied by the affected nerve.
Although autonomic nerves are involved in regulating the function of organs, a transplanted organ, supplied by blood flow, can function fairly well without reconnection of severed nerves.
A search for truth
While still a student at Lincoln College, convinced that spinal manipulation (spinal adjustment) was not the panacea portrayed by chiropractors, I visited a nearby medical school library where I found text books written by orthopedic and physical medicine specialists who supported use of spinal manipulation as an option in the treatment of mechanical-type neck and back pain, an option that was not then readily available in departments of physical medicine. Physical therapy was not taught at the chiropractic school I attended, so I studied Bierman and Licht’s Physical Medicine in General Practice, a leading medical text book that described physical treatment methods, including use of spinal manipulation (Bierman 1952). I relied heavily upon the work of James Mennell, M.D., a physical medicine specialist who authored The Science and Art of Joint Manipulation: The Spinal Column (Mennell 1952). I continued this extracurricular study until the day of my graduation from Lincoln College.
When I began my practice as a chiropractor in Panama City, Florida, in 1956, I placed a small ad in the local newspaper announcing that my office offered specialized treatment for back pain, combining spinal manipulation with physical therapy modalities. There was little response to the ad. Although local chiropractors were quite busy treating the gamut of human ailments by adjusting vertebrae, most people thought of chiropractic as a form of quackery. Chiropractic theory that disease could be cured by manipulating the spine to relieve pressure on spinal nerves, however, was appealing to a portion of the population. An advertisement promising cures not provided by the medical profession was sure to attract a number of chronically ill patients.
After a few years of struggle as a “back specialist,” competing with subluxation-based chiropractors, I concluded that chiropractic as a method of treating organic disease was deserving of public suspicion and criticism by mainstream healthcare providers. I could not find any credible evidence to support the theory that a vertebral subluxation can affect general health. While spinal manipulation might temporarily disrupt the signals of receptors responsible for the perception of back pain (nociceptors), there appears to be no reason to believe that the temporary physiological effects of spinal manipulation can have a significant effect on general health. I felt a need to express my views criticizing the controversial aspects of chiropractic care in order to protect public health as well as to promote reform of my profession and to support appropriate use of spinal manipulation.
Opposing subluxation theory
When my book Bonesetting, Chiropractic, and Cultism was published in 1963 (Homola 1963), renouncing chiropractic vertebral subluxation theory and recommending that chiropractic be developed as a specialty in the treatment of mechanical-type back pain, the chiropractic profession refused to acknowledge or review the book. My book was, however, reviewed by the Library Journal, which concluded, in part, that:
A large amount of information from many sources has been brought together. Chiropractic is shown to be a cult without any scientific basis or substance…In view of the absence of any extensive histories of chiropractic, this book has a place in medical collections and reference libraries. (Meyerhoff 1964)
Following publication of my Bonesetting book, the American Chiropractic Association, without explanation, refused to renew my membership and my malpractice insurance:
In regard to your recent application for membership in the American Chiropractic Association and insurance in the National Chiropractic Insurance Company, please be advised that the ACA membership committee has rejected your application. (H.W. Pruitt, D.C., Executive Secretary, American Chiropractic Association, May 17, 1965)
I continued to express my views of chiropractic in articles published in popular magazines and journals, opposing subluxation theory while supporting appropriate use of spinal manipulation (Homola 1992). My published work invariably resulted in negative feedback from members of the chiropractic profession. One of my articles in a 1995 issue of Scholastic Coach and Athletic Director, titled “Sense and Nonsense in Chiropractic Care of the Back” (Homola 1995), resulted in threats to have my license revoked. A “Dear colleague” letter, circulated by a chiropractor, concluded with this appeal:
I believe this chiropractor is more harmful to our profession today than he was 30 years ago. I would personally appreciate any insight that you may have. Please contact me personally at [telephone number] if you feel this is worthy of any concern with respect to the future of the chiropractic profession.
Apparently, there was fear among some of my colleagues that my views could topple the chiropractic profession. My primary concern, however, was to offer support for appropriate use of spinal manipulation apart from chiropractic subluxation theory, hopefully aiding the development of chiropractic as a science-based musculoskeletal specialty.
In my final year of practice, 1998, my article “Finding a Good Chiropractor” was published in Archives of Family Medicine, a journal of the American Medical Association. I had learned from experience that many physicians were receptive to appropriate use of spinal manipulation provided by a properly limited chiropractor who was willing to exchange office notes in caring for patients with mechanical-type back pain. Physicians receiving requests from patients who wanted to see a chiropractor could avoid the questionable care of subluxation-based chiropractors by referring to a carefully vetted “good chiropractor.”
In 1999, my book Inside Chiropractic, edited by Stephen Barrett, M.D., was published by Prometheus Books. The jacket blurb describes the book as useful to physicians and lay persons alike:
Inside Chiropractic makes an important and unique contribution to the literature on chiropractic. Until chiropractic is properly specialized and regulated, consumers will have to learn how to make an informed choice in finding a good practitioner. This book is a must for readers who are considering chiropractic care, and a valuable reference for healthcare professionals who want to know what chiropractic is all about.
In April of 2001, the online edition of Medscape General Medicine published my article “Is the Chiropractic Subluxation Theory a Threat to Public Health?” The article had been previously published in the January 2001 issue of Scientific Review of Alternative Medicine and Aberrant Medical Practices. I received a flood of email and letters. I was praised by mainstream healthcare professionals (and a few chiropractors), but the bulk of my mail came from chiropractors who castigated me for my views. The president of the American Chiropractic Association described my article as “outdated and inaccurate” and asked Medscape to remove the article from their web site.
In September of 2005, Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research, a leading peer-reviewed journal for orthopedic surgeons, published my article “Chiropractic: History and Overview of Theories and Methods“, a review exploring the incongruity underlying the practice of chiropractic based on subluxation theory. Chiropractic was (and is) a profession with the confusing image of a back specialty capable of treating a broad scope of health problems. Despite a plethora of chiropractic publications touting subluxation theory, I could not find any credible evidence supporting claims that a chiropractic subluxation or a joint dysfunction can affect general health.
A 2009 study by three academic chiropractors concluded that chiropractic subluxation theory is unsupported speculation:
No supportive evidence is found for the chiropractic subluxation being associated with any disease process or of creating suboptimal health conditions requiring intervention. Regardless of popular appeal this leaves the subluxation construct in the realm of unsupported speculation. This lack of supportive evidence suggests the subluxation construct has no valid clinical applicability.
A 2014 Position Statement on Clinical and Professional Chiropractic Education issued by the World Federation of Chiropractic (representing nine European, South African, and Australian chiropractic colleges) advised that subluxation theory is unsupported by evidence:
The teaching of vertebral subluxation complex as a vitalistic construct that claims that it is the cause of disease is unsupported by evidence. Its inclusion in a modern chiropractic curriculum in anything other than an historical context is therefore inappropriate and unnecessary.
Appropriate use of spinal manipulation as a treatment for back pain can be helpful in some cases, but spinal manipulation based on subluxation theory, which encompasses a broad scope of health problems, can cause harm by delaying appropriate treatment based on a correct diagnosis. Risk of stroke caused by injury to cervical arteries outweighs any known benefit when upper neck manipulation is used as a treatment to correct a putative chiropractic subluxation.
Perpetuation of chiropractic as a belief system
Today, after 43 years of practice as a chiropractor, 62 years after graduating from a chiropractic college, the definition of chiropractic in the United States, still based on subluxation theory, has changed little. In keeping with the paradigm of the Association of Chiropractic Colleges (in North America) which states that “Chiropractic is concerned with the preservation and restoration of health, and focuses particular attention on the subluxation” (Christensen 2015), the National Board of Chiropractic Examiners defines chiropractic as a practice focused on the subluxation:
The specific focus of chiropractic practice is known as the chiropractic subluxation or joint dysfunction. A subluxation is a health concern that manifests in the skeletal joints, and, through complex anatomical and physiologic relationships, affects the nervous system and may lead to reduced function, disability, or illness. (Christensen 2015)
The American Chiropractic Association (ACA) defines chiropractic as a method of dealing with musculoskeletal and nervous system disorders that affect general health ─ an ambiguous description that seems to leave the door open for chiropractors who use spinal manipulation as a treatment for health problems:
Chiropractic is a health care profession that focuses on disorders of the musculoskeletal system and the nervous system, and the effects of these disorders on general health.
The International Chiropractic Association (ICA), the smaller of the two American-based associations, is clearly dedicated to use of spinal adjustments based on the subluxation theory of chiropractic’s founding father:
The ICA is dedicated to the growth and development of the chiropractic profession based on Dr. Palmer’s fundamental belief in the principles and philosophy of chiropractic as a unique, distinct and drugless health care profession.
Chiropractors are better educated today, and most students enrolling in chiropractic colleges have undergraduate degrees. But despite increasing educational requirements for enrollment in a chiropractic college and for licensure of chiropractors, state laws and most chiropractic colleges continue to embrace subluxation theory. Without representation by a science-based majority, there will be little incentive for development of chiropractic as a properly limited specialty based on the guidelines of science.
Identifying science-based chiropractors
A subluxation-based chiropractor, as opposed to a science-based chiropractor, subscribes to a nonfalsifiable subluxation theory that cannot be verified by the scientific consensus and cannot be supported by the science of anatomy and physiology. Currently, there is no reliable way to distinguish a science-based chiropractor from a subluxation-based chiropractor in the marketplace. Without an academic degree identifying science-based chiropractors, it will continue to be difficult to find a properly limited chiropractor, and medical professionals will continue to avoid referring patients to chiropractors.
It goes without saying that a chiropractic program would not be acceptable in science-based academia until the chiropractic profession is totally divorced from subluxation theory, requiring changes in the mission of chiropractic colleges as well as changes in state laws that define and govern the practice of chiropractic. Such changes would result in programs similar to those already being used to train physical therapists. Increasing use of spinal manipulation by physical therapists and orthopedic manual therapists provides access to appropriate use of spinal manipulation for consumers who are not inclined or able to search for a science-based chiropractor.
When the Florida State Legislature allotted funds to establish a chiropractic college within Florida State University (FSU) in 2003, the proposal was rejected by FSU faculty members and alumni. Chiropractic subluxation theory, as defined by Florida state law and by chiropractic catalogues, was considered to be implausible and unscientific. Florida’s Board of Governors, which oversees state universities, voted against including a college of chiropractic at FSU.
At the present time, there are no U.S. public or state-funded universities that offer a program for a doctorate in chiropractic. The University of Bridgeport, D’Youville College, and Keiser University, all private institutions, have included chiropractic degree programs in their curriculum.
A 2011 review of chiropractic college catalogues revealed that the term “subluxation” is still found within the curriculum of most North American Chiropractic Colleges. All but three of 18 chiropractic colleges mentioned subluxation in their catalogues. Most chiropractic colleges guided by subluxation theory include instruction in adjunctive treatment methods, but a few “straight” schools, adhering to subluxation theory, depend almost entirely upon use of spinal adjustments as a treatment for most ailments. As privately controlled institutions, the mission of chiropractic colleges may vary from one institution to another.
It may not be enough for a chiropractic college to abandon subluxation theory if the college proposes to graduate primary-care physicians who use alternative “natural healing methods” as a treatment for a broad scope of health problems. A chiropractic college that limits instruction to care of musculoskeletal problems would certainly be more acceptable in mainstream health care than a chiropractic college dedicated to subluxation theory or alternative medicine, or a chiropractic college that mixes chiropractic philosophy with manual therapy.
Chiropractic, alternative medicine, and primary care
There are no indications that the chiropractic profession in America has plans to change course and make the changes needed to become a specialty or subspecialty capable of a reciprocal relationship with mainstream healthcare providers. Chiropractors are seeking status as primary care physicians in order to maintain their independence as an alternative to conventional medical care. According to the National University of Health Sciences (formerly the National College of Chiropractic, considered to be one of the best U.S. chiropractic colleges), “National University prepares students to become first-contact, primary care physicians fully qualified to diagnose, treat, and manage a wide range of conditions” (from 2017). As a “leader in the growing field of integrative medicine,” National University offers degree programs in chiropractic medicine, naturopathic medicine, Oriental medicine, acupuncture, and massage. National does not mention subluxations in its chiropractic catalogue.
Evidenced-based natural healing methods such as exercise or nutrition are essential for good health and might occasionally be an effective treatment for some conditions or can be helpful as complementary procedures over a broad scope, but they should not be mixed with subluxation correction and other alternative healing methods that preclude conventional medical care. Inclusion of such practices as homeopathy, naturopathy, acupuncture, or functional medicine in any treatment program, often under the banner of “integrative medicine,” should be viewed with skepticism.
In support of chiropractic care as a form of alternative medicine using natural healing methods, the American Chiropractic Association (ACA) recognizes 11 different chiropractic specialties, in fields including acupuncture, neurology, orthopedics, internal disorders, and pediatrics. A Chiropractic Internist “has training to diagnose a wide spectrum of conditions along with an education to use natural treatment options.” According to the ACA Council on Diagnosis and Internal Disorders, “Every year, more and more patients are choosing DABCIs [Diplomate of the American Board of Chiropractic Internists] as the first doctor they visit when they are sick or are having health problems”.
A diplomate in a chiropractic specialty requires 300 hours of post-graduate classroom work. Such abbreviated classroom instruction cannot compare with a full-time residency program in a hospital setting that lasts 3 to 7 years after graduation from medical school before a physician can be board certified as a specialist. An additional 1 to 3 years of training is required for a highly specialized subspecialty. There are more than 120 specialties and subspecialties that make up the practice of medicine.
Clearly, a chiropractic specialty, subluxation based or not, should not be considered to be a viable alternative to a board-certified medical specialty.
Making an informed career choice
Although there are some good chiropractors who use spinal manipulation appropriately and who do a good job treating mechanical-type neck and back pain, chiropractic in general, defined by subluxation theory, continues to be rejected by the scientific community. Physical therapy, on the other hand, is uncontested as a branch of science-based physical medicine. Since physical therapy is often compared with chiropractic, it is important to understand the difference between the two professions before selecting one or the other as a career.
Aside from aspirations to help the sick and disabled, financial security should be a primary consideration when choosing a profession. The chiropractic profession, identified as a form of alternative medicine, remains outside the mainstream of health care, providing few opportunities for employment outside of private practice. As a result, graduates of chiropractic schools have a much higher student loan default rate than graduates from other schools that train healthcare professionals.
A high student loan debt and the high cost of starting a practice and maintaining an office, coupled with little or no referrals from other health-care professionals, makes it difficult to build a private chiropractic practice from scratch. Many struggling newly-graduated chiropractors resort to self-marketing programs offered by practice-building firms. A 2010 investigation revealed that the 10-year attrition rate for chiropractors licensed in California between 1992 and 1998 was 20-25%.
The high failure rate of chiropractors who enter private practice, facing societal suspicion and rejection by the scientific community, may represent risk that outweighs the security promised by 3 to 4 years of undergraduate study and the 4 years of chiropractic college required to hang out a chiropractic shingle. (Some chiropractic colleges offer a dual-degree program for a bachelor degree and a Doctor of Chiropractic degree to applicants who have completed at least 3 years of undergraduate study for a Bachelor of Science degree in biology; some offer an abbreviated program for a D.C. degree if applicants have a Bachelor of Science degree.)
Most chiropractic colleges require 3 years of undergraduate study for enrollment in a chiropractic program; some require a bachelor’s degree. A few states require a bachelor’s degree along with a chiropractic degree for licensure as a chiropractor.
Persons interested in studying manipulative therapy should consider going for a Doctor of Physical Therapy (DPT) degree that would allow interaction with the scientific community in researching and performing manual therapy without the stigma associated with chiropractic. At the present time, all states, the District of Columbia, and the U.S. Virgin Islands now permit direct access to services provided by physical therapists, allowing private practice that fits in with mainstream health care, with ample opportunity for employment in hospitals and healthcare facilities.
Admission requirements for a physical therapy program may vary but most schools require a 4-year undergraduate degree in such subjects as exercise science, biology, and kinesiology, followed by a 3-year program for a DPT degree. Some physical therapy schools offer a 3+3 curricular format in which 3 years of specific pre-professional courses will allow enrollment for a 3-year DPT program.
Since undergraduate requirements to enter a program for a doctorate in chiropractic or a program for a doctorate in physical therapy are about the same, persons who are contemplating a career in chiropractic should research both professions before making a decision.
The bottom line
A chiropractic spinal adjustment claimed to restore and maintain health by adjusting specific vertebrae to remove nerve interference should not to be equated with generic spinal manipulation used to relieve pain and restore mobility. The former is unproven alternative medicine, the latter a scientifically acceptable modality.
Spinal nerves are commonly affected by disc herniation, osteophytes, and orthopedic subluxations caused by injury or degenerative changes, resulting in neuromusculoskeletal symptoms. But such segmental dysfunctions in the spine have never been associated with organic disease. Vertebral misalignment caused by structural deviations from normal is common and usually harmless. A chiropractic vertebral subluxation alleged to be a cause of health problems, now referred to as a “vertebral subluxation complex,” has not been proven to exist and is not the same as an orthopedic subluxation that causes musculoskeletal symptoms.
Patients and providers who are looking for a good chiropractor should seek out a practitioner who has renounced chiropractic vertebral subluxation theory and who has chosen to limit care to treatment of mechanical-type neck and back pain and related musculoskeletal problems, offering spinal manipulation as a treatment option along with physical therapy modalities. Such services are now being provided by physiatrists and orthopedic manual therapists in departments of physical medicine and rehabilitation ─ much like the service I was providing when I published my Bonesetting book in 1963.
While spinal manipulation is an acceptable option in the armamentarium of physical medicine as a method of relieving pain and restoring mobility, often buying the time needed to allow recovery without use of drugs, injections, or surgery, some studies indicate that spinal manipulation may not be any more effective than other forms of physical treatment. And there is reason to believe that certain upper-neck manipulative techniques can cause stroke by injuring vertebrobasilar arteries. There may be occasions, however, when spinal manipulation would be the treatment of choice in restoring mobility in joints locked by muscle spasm, binding facets, post-traumatic adhesions, impingement of synovial or cartilaginous tissue, or for reasons not yet determined. Many people simply enjoy a hands-on back-cracking back rub.
Unfortunately, appropriate use of spinal manipulation has been shaded by the promotion of such treatment as a method of restoring and maintaining health. Cavitation (a pop produced by slight separation of joint surfaces during manipulation) is often interpreted as evidence that a chiropractic subluxation has been corrected. This perception may have a powerful placebo effect, giving the false impression that spinal manipulation or a “spinal adjustment” is an effective treatment for the ailment being treated.
Surveys indicate that neck pain and back pain are the most common complaints encountered by chiropractors. Back pain and musculoskeletal problems are the first and second most common causes of disability worldwide. Although most people think of chiropractors as “back doctors,” it appears that the chiropractic profession, in its mission to provide primary care in the form of alternative medicine, may have missed the opportunity to make the changes needed to fill a niche in physical medicine as a conservative back-care specialty.

References
    • Bierman W, S Licht. 1952. Physical Medicine in General Practice, 3rd Ed. Paul B. Hoeber, Inc. (Harper & Brothers). New York, NY.
    • Christensen MG, JK Hyland, CM Goertz, et al. 2015. Practice Analysis of Chiropractic 2015. Pages 5, 127. National Board of Chiropractic Examiners. Greeley, CO.
    • Homola S. 1963. Bonesetting, Chiropractic, and Cultism. Critique Books. Panama City, FL.
    • Homola S. 1992. Seeking a common denominator in the use of spinal manipulation. Chiropractic Technique. 4(2):61-63.
    • Homola S. 1995. Sense and Nonsense in Chiropractic Care of the Back. Scholastic Coach and Athletic Director. March; 64(8): 32-34.
    • Homola S., Barrett S. 1999. Inside Chiropractic. Prometheus Books. Amherst, NY.
    • Mennell J. 1952. The Science and Art of Joint Manipulation: Volume 11, The Spinal Column. The Blakiston Company. New York,NY.
    • Meyerhoff E. 1964. Homola, Samuel. Library Journal. Page 643. February 1: 89(8).
    • Wardwell WI. 1992. Chiropractic: History and Evolution of a New Profession. Mosby-Year Book. St. Louis, MO.

   The Bait and Switch of Unscientific Medicine
Steven Novella 
Link
Savvy consumers are familiar with the classic scam of the “bait and switch” – in practice if not the term itself. My wife and I ran across it when we were shopping for our first car. We needed a bargain and so we were attracted to the ads that promised a new Colt for only $9,000 (that’s the bait). Of course when we got to the dealership they were all out of Colts with the configuration advertised, but they had plenty of others that had different options that cost several thousand dollars more (that’s the switch).
It’s a basic and very successful form of deception, and so even though there are laws against such practices it is impossible to eliminate in all its various and more subtle forms. It even permeates scientific, political, and other intellectual endeavors – anytime a more palatable idea or claim is put forward to represent the less acceptable truth.
Science, however, requires transparent honesty to function properly, and therefore scientific practitioners must vigilantly guard against the cognitive bait and switch. Generic intellectual virtues incorporate this vigilance – they include the need to unambiguously define terms, to make claims as specific and operational as possible, and the use of valid logic. Beware of any claims that subtly violate these rules because they are probably setting you up for a bait and switch.
The purveyors of unscientific medical claims have become as expert at this classic deception as the slickest used-car salesman – in fact they have left the hawkers of dubious transportation in the dust.
Practitioners of health fraud, unscientific and sectarian medical practices have learned how to apply the bait and switch at multiple levels – with respect to specific modalities and at higher categorical levels. First I will address some of the more common sectarian practices and show how they apply this deception, whether consciously or out of intellectual sloppiness.
Chiropractic
Chiropractic is perhaps the most common and egregious example of the bait and switch in medicine. The deception begins with the name itself – “chiropractic” fails the basic test of transparency because it is not unambiguously defined. There are in fact numerous professions doing very different things and employing mutually exclusive philosophies under the banner of “chiropractic.”
Therefore someone may go to see a chiropractor and think they will be seeing a medical professional who will treat their musculoskeletal symptoms, but in reality they will see the practitioner of a cult philosophy of energy healing. So-called “straight” chiropractors (who make up an estimated 30% of all chiropractors) still adhere to the original philosophy of chiropractic invented by “magnetic healer” D.D. Palmer, which is based upon the claim that an undetected life energy called “innate intelligence” flows through the spinal cord and nerves and is responsible for health. Such chiropractors will treat any disease or ailment with spinal manipulation.
Most other so called “mixer” chiropractors reject the notion of innate intelligence either partially or entirely, but still incorporate other pseudosciences into their practice. Chiropractors are the primary practitioners of homeopathy, applied kinesiology, and iridology in the US. The bait – claims that chiropractors are medical practitioners with expertise in the musculoskeletal system. The switch – practitioners of discredited pseudosciences that have nothing to do with the musculoskeletal system.
A more subtle form of the bait and switch among chiropractors is the treatment of musculoskeletal symptoms with standard physical therapy or sports medicine practices under the name of chiropractic manipulation. Ironically, the more honest and scientific practitioners among chiropractors are most likely to commit this subtle deception. The problem comes not from the treatment itself but the claim that such treatments are “chiropractic.”
Using techniques like massage, range of motion exercises, strength-building exercises, and mobilization of joints are all legitimate science-based techniques used by physical therapists and physicians with specialties in physiatry, orthopedics, and sports medicine. Some chiropractors also use similar techniques -and with good results. But by doing so and calling it “chiropractic” it legitimizes the pseudoscientific practices that are very common within the profession – like treating non-existent “subluxations” in order to free up the flow of innate intelligence.
Acupuncture
Many studies of acupuncture employ this latter form of bait and switch – studying something that is not really acupuncture but calling it acupuncture and thereby legitimizing pure pseudoscience. Acupuncture refers to a Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) pre-scientific philosophy of health and illness that is based (very similarly to straight chiropractic) on the flow of life energy called “chi”. Fine needles are inserted into special locations on the body called meridians for the purpose of improving, freeing, and balancing the flow chi.
No study has demonstrated that chi exists, or that acupuncture of the meridians has any specific effect. A look at the entirety of the acupuncture literature, in fact, clearly demonstrates that it does not matter where the needles are placed (or how deeply, or if they are manipulated in ways that are designed to manipulate chi). This means that any effects of sticking acupuncture needles into a patient are non-specific – they are not related to the flow of chi. There may be some small non-specific physiological effects – such as counter-irritation reducing pain or inhibiting nausea – but even these claims remain elusive and controversial.
But some studies of “acupuncture” show a larger and more reliable effect, usually on pain. What these studies have in common is that they employ “electrical acupuncture” (for example). Electrical acupuncture, however, is not acupuncture – it’s transdermal electrical stimulation, which is a scientific practice that has proven efficacy in the treatment of pain. Giving transdermal electrical stimulation through acupuncture needles, calling that “electrical acupuncture” and then using positive results to conclude that acupuncture works – is an elaborate bait and switch.
Homeopathy and Herbal Medicine
Homeopathy is another dubious practice based upon pre-scientific notions long discredited. A truly homeopathic remedy is diluted to the point that no active ingredients remain – so a homeopathic remedy is pure solvent, either water or alcohol, sometimes placed on a sugar pill (making a homeopathic pill a literal placebo). But much of the public believes that “homeopathic” simply means “natural” or “herbal”. Few realize that it means that the so-called medicine contains nothing.
But some homeopathic products are not even truly homeopathic – meaning they are not based upon homeopathic principles but rather contain measurable amounts of real drugs. This is now not uncommon for over-the-counters lotions and cold remedies. For example, this pimple cream contains many active ingredients at a “1x” dilution – that’s only 1:10, meaning there is still actual molecules of drugs in the cream. That’s not homeopathic.
A similar and more subtle deception is used in the marketing of herbs. They are sold and regulated as “natural supplements” when in fact they are drugs. Herbs contain chemicals that have pharmacological activity and they are usually taken in doses that are insignificant in terms of their nutritional content, but are significant in terms of their pharmacological activity. The bait is that they are nutritional supplements, the switch is that they are unpurified drugs.
CAM – the Biggest Bait and Switch
All of these modalities fall under an artificial category – so called “complementary and alternative” medicine (CAM) or “integrative” medicine that was created as the ultimate bait and switch.
The deception is largely two-fold. The first is to include modalities within this false category that are legitimate, like nutrition, exercise, physical therapy, relaxation, etc., – and then claim that these legitimize the entire category of CAM, even the far-out stuff like homeopathy. This is just a higher-order version of including physical therapy modalities within the umbrella of chiropractic, for example.
Essentially, at every level terms are used that are vague and poorly defined, and in practice are designed to be all-inclusive so that the purely pseudoscientific can ride on the coattails of the barely plausible or even the legitimate.
This is the opposite of what happens within scientific disciplines – where terminology evolves over time to become more discriminating, unambiguous, and specific. To take an example from my specialty, multiple sclerosis (MS) has been divided into sub-diagnoses: relapsing remitting and chronic progressive. Divisions multiplied and now there are seven subtypes – for example, primary progressive, and progressive remitting.
This increased “splitting” as it is called is not just a pedantic dedication to precision, but a recognition that such divisions may reflect differences in underlying mechanism of the disease. Also, different subtypes of MS respond differently to different treatments. Some drugs work in relapsing remitting but not in primary progressive. Part of the motivation for finer categories is to more accurately predict which MS patients are likely to respond to which treatments.
Contrast this to the maximally broad and imprecise but common marketing slogan “chiropractic works.”
The second kind of deception created by the category of CAM is in the language used itself – “complementary” and “integrative.” What, exactly, are CAM modalities integrating? On close examination it is quite clear – the movement is an effort to mix unscientific, disproved, and dubious modalities into scientific medicine. The bait is that CAM offers legitimate alternatives, the switch is that it primarily promotes treatments that don’t work or are at best untested and highly implausible.
If there were truth in marketing then we would have the Office of Implausible Medicine, the Journal of Bad Medical Science, the Center for Rejected Therapies, and the Institute of Dubious Medical Claims – all under the umbrella of unscientific medicine. It used to be called, even more simply, “health fraud.”
Conclusion
The public would be best served if they were given a reasonable expectation of honesty and clarity in the health marketplace. Instead, increasingly they are being given the old bait and switch, and increasingly the governments and institutions of medicine that should know better are instruments of this deception.
Science and intellectual honesty require that terms mean something specific and definable. Unscientific health modalities have become very savvy at using terminology to confuse rather than inform, to deceive rather than to illuminate.
It is the simplest form of the bait and switch – just call a product or service something that it isn’t.

The Swan Song of a Chiropractic Heretic
After 41 years of private practice as a chiropractor and 60 years of writing books and articles, the age of 94 finds me rethinking my career, wondering if my contributions to the literature justify the path I took.
Sam Homola on Novemner 14, 2023
Link

I began private practice as a chiropractor in 1957. My book Bonesetting, Chiropractic and Cultism, published in 1963, renounced the vertebral subluxation theory that defines the practice of chiropractic as primary care capable of restoring and maintaining health simply by manipulating (“adjusting”) the spine to remove nerve interference. My colleagues called me as a “traitor” and I was denied membership in the American Chiropractic Association. I continued to write articles for journals and magazines, recommending that the chiropractic profession abandon the scientifically indefensible subluxation theory and seek development as a sub-specialty providing conservative care for mechanical-type neck and back pain, a designation not yet filled in physical medicine.
In the years to follow, I was inundated with hostile mail from subluxation-based chiropractors who threatened to have my chiropractic license revoked. Although chiropractic response to my published articles was mostly negative, the support I received from science-based healthcare professionals provided the inspiration I needed to continue writing. My book Inside Chiropractic was published by Prometheus Books in 1999.
Vindication
In 2019, researchers investigating the effects of spinal manipulation reported in a Global Summit that they found no evidence of an effect of spinal manipulative therapy for the management of non-musculoskeletal disorders, verifying what I have been saying since 1963. It is now clear that the all-inclusive vertebral subluxation theory formulated by a magnetic healer in 1895 is a tenuous belief that should be abandoned by the chiropractic profession. An asymptomatic chiropractic “vertebral subluxation complex” alleged to be a cause of disease has never been proven to exist, as opposed to a real orthopedic subluxation that causes musculoskeletal symptoms but has never been associated with organic disease. It is well known that spinal nerves supply skin and musculoskeletal structures while the body’s organs are supplied by a separate autonomic nervous system located outside the spinal column.
Properly defined and limited, chiropractic could fill a niche in mainstream health care by offering appropriate use of generic spinal manipulation in combination with rehab and physical therapy modalities, as I did in my 41 years of practice. Unfortunately, the chiropractic profession continues to define chiropractic as a form of alternative medicine embracing a broad scope of health problems rather than specialize in the care of back pain, despite the fact that back pain and neck pain continue to be the No. 1 and No. 2 cause of disability worldwide.
Acknowledgment
When I was nominated for the John Maddox Prize in 2023 for my stand on the side of science as a whistleblower who endured ostracism and isolation as a “chiropractic heretic,” I was greatly honored. The nomination was timely and comforting recognition at the end of my career as an embattled chiropractor who was dedicated to protecting public health by advocating reform of the chiropractic profession.
I did not win the John Maddox Prize, but the nomination alone is a treasured footnote that enhances my legacy as a “chiropractic heretic,” adding a positive note to the final page of my autobiography, Sam’s Story: The Final Chapter.

Excerpts from Letters to a Chiropractic Heretic, 2012
The Aftermath of Bonesetting, Chiropractic, and Cultism
In view of the absence of any extensive histories of chiropractic, this book has a place in medical collections and reference libraries. –Eric Meyerhoff, Director., The Medical Library Center of New York, N.Y.C., Library Journal February 1, 1964
In regard to your recent application for membership in the American Chiropractic Association and insurance in the National Chiropractic Insurance Company, please be advised that the ACA membership committee has rejected your application. -H.W. Pruitt, D.C., Executive Secretary, American Chiropractic Association, May 17, 1965
I purchased your book some months ago on Bonesetting, Chiropractic, and Cultism. I found it to be a most intriguing and enlightening publication which has been of value to me in some of my own studies in medical anthropology. James G. Roney, M.D., Ph.D., Stanford Research Institute, November 11, 1965
I was more impressed by your criticisms of chiropractic than by those of any other writer, since you are a practicing chiropractor. I think every candidate for chiropractic college should read your book, or at least every student in his first year. –Walter Wardwell, Ph.D., Professor of Sociology, University of Connecticut, August 26, 1976
Thank you for your book Bonesetting, Chiropractic, and Cultism. I found it well-written and most interesting. I have read quite a bit of material on the chiropractic controversy by authors on all sides of the issue. I rank your book among the very best. -William Jarvis, Ph.D., Associate Professor, Loma Linda University, October 22, 1976
I just re-read your chiropractic book and enjoyed it even more than I did five years ago. Your reasoning and predictions have held up remarkably. -Stephen Barrett, M.D., Lehigh Valley Committee Against Health Fraud, July 28, 1979
Unfortunately unknown to most chiropractors, and unavailable at many if not most chiropractic college libraries, Bonesetting, Chiropractic, and Cultism is must reading for chiropractic historians….Perhaps the profession will finally seek out this seer before his most dire predictions come to pass. -Joseph Keating, Ph.D., Professor, Palmer College of Chiropractic-West, Dynamic Chiropractic, January 3, 1990
Fifty years ago, you already expressed some of the things few dare write today! If chiropractic had had more people like you early on, it would be a respectable profession today. -Edzard Ernst, M.D., Ph.D., Professor, Peninsula Medical School, England, January 12, 2010

Opposing Chiropractic: Persecution or Justified Criticism?
Sam Homola on February 1, 2015
Link

The saga of chiropractic began in 1895 when D.D. Palmer, a magnetic healer, announced that “95 percent of all diseases are caused by displaced vertebrae, the remainder by luxations of other joints.” Palmer opened the first chiropractic school in Davenport, Iowa, offering a three-week course of study at the Palmer School and Cure, subsequently renamed the Palmer School of Chiropractic. The school was taken over by B.J. Palmer, the son of D.D. Palmer, in 1906. In 1910, the course of instruction was six months. Kansas and North Dakota were the first states to pass laws legalizing the practice of chiropractic (in 1913 and 1915). By 1921, the Palmer School of Chiropractic, requiring 18 months of study, had 2,000 students, reaching a peak enrollment of 3,600 in 1922. By 1923, 27 states had chiropractic licensing boards. Hundreds of chiropractic schools sprang up, some offering correspondence courses. There were no entrance requirements, anyone could become a chiropractor. H.L. Mencken wrote in the December 11th, 1924, issue of the Baltimore Evening Sun:
Today the backwoods swarm with chiropractors, and in most States they have been able to exert enough pressure on the rural politicians to get themselves licensed. Any lout with strong hands and arms is perfectly equipped to become a chiropractor. No education beyond the elements is necessary.1
Although Palmer’s subluxation theory was contrary to all known laws of anatomy and physiology, the theory was appealing to the general public. Medical science was in its infancy, struggling to find effective and safe remedies for disease and infection. There was no known cure for many common ailments, and many of the medicines used by physicians were ineffective or harmful. In the public marketplace, the door was wide open for snake oil salesmen, entrepreneurs, and opportunists who could mix a concoction or fabricate a new treatment guaranteed to work. With growing numbers of chiropractors treating disease and infection by adjusting the spine to relieve alleged pressure on spinal nerves, offering treatment claimed to be superior to medical care, members of the medical community felt an obligation to oppose what they viewed to be blatant, unbridled quackery.

Morris Fishbein and the American Medical Association
By 1931, 37 states were licensing chiropractors. Chiropractic was gaining ground. In 1932, Dr. Morris Fishbein, the long-time editor of the Journal of the American Medical Association and an outspoken critic of chiropractic, wrote in his book Fads and Quackery in Healing that “…the fundamental dogma of chiropractic, that disease is caused by dislocation or subluxation of the bones of the spinal column, pressing on nerves, is simply a complete misrepresentation of the demonstrated facts.”2
A Report to the Medical Profession titled “Dear Doctor”, distributed by the Louisiana State Medical Society, advised physicians that chiropractors were engaged in the unlawful practice of medicine. “Medical men are opposed to chiropractic because it is baseless and disproved…Scientific medicine has accepted, approved and recommended only a part of what chiropractors do, and did so, in fact, before chiropractic was ‘invented.’ That part is physical therapy.” (The State of Louisiana did not begin to license chiropractors until 1974, the last state to do so, completing licensure of chiropractors in all 50 states.)
In June of 1946, an article in Reader’s Digest (“Can Chiropractic Cure?”) informed millions of Americans that “If you suffer from boils and bronchitis, from dysentery or diphtheria, you can find a chiropractor willing to ‘cure’ you by pressing your backbone and thus ‘adjusting’ an alleged ‘subluxation’ of some vertebra.”3
When it became apparent that medical and journalistic opposition to the practice of chiropractic had had little effect in curtailing public and political support for licensure of chiropractors, the American Medical Association formed a Committee on Quackery with the goal of containing and eliminating chiropractic as a recognized healthcare service. In November of 1966, the AMA House of Delegates adopted a resolution which stated, in part:
Chiropractic is an unscientific cult whose practitioners lack the necessary training and background to diagnose and treat human disease. Chiropractic constitutes a hazard to rational health care in the United States because of the substandard and unscientific education of its practitioners and their rigid adherence to an irrational, unscientific approach to disease causation.4
Chiropractors vs. the A.M.A.
In 1976, a group of chiropractors (Wilk et al.) initiated a law suit charging that the American Medical Association and associated groups had conspired to destroy chiropractic and to illegally deprive chiropractors of access to laboratory, x-ray, and hospital facilities. Most of the defendants settled out of court. On August 27, 1987, a United States District Court judge found the remaining defendants (the American Medical Association, the American College of Surgeons, and the American College of Radiology) guilty of restraint of trade by violating Sherman Antitrust Laws.
Conceding that chiropractic could be effective in treating certain kinds of back injuries and musculoskeletal problems, the court concluded that the American Medical Association had good reason to criticize chiropractic but should not have attempted to contain and eliminate an entire profession without first demonstrating that a less restrictive campaign could not protect the public. “There was evidence that the chiropractic theory of subluxations was unscientific,” the judge noted, “and evidence that some chiropractors engaged in unscientific practices.”5
Although the Federal Court ruled that the AMA was involved in illegal boycott and restraint of trade in its campaign against chiropractors, the ruling was not an endorsement of chiropractic treatment based on subluxation theory.
The yoke of subluxation theory
Clinging to the theory that gave it birth and independence, the chiropractic profession continues to define chiropractic as a method of removing nerve interference or correcting vertebral subluxations to restore and maintain health. State laws using vertebral subluxation theory to define and license chiropractors remain unchallenged. According to the National Board of Chiropractic Examiners in the United States:
The specific focus of chiropractic practice is known as the chiropractic subluxation or joint dysfunction. A subluxation is a health concern that manifests in the skeletal joints, and through complex anatomical and physiological relationships, affects the nervous system and may lead to reduced function, disability, or illness.6
Without mention of the word “subluxation,” the American Chiropractic Association offers this definition of chiropractic:
Chiropractic is a health care profession that focuses on disorders of the musculoskeletal system and the nervous system, and the effects of these disorders on general health.7
Chiropractic care based on an unproven subluxation theory that embraces a broad scope of ailments continues to provide justification for criticisms of chiropractic by the medical and scientific community, a criticism often referred to by chiropractors as “persecution.” A 2011 book written by a prominent chiropractor, The Medical War Against Chiropractors, The Untold Story from Persecution to Vindication, tells how persecution of chiropractors by the medical profession led to vindication for chiropractic when a federal court ruled against the AMA for restraint of trade in the Wilk vs. AMA suit8 ─ a ruling that offered no support for chiropractic subluxation theory.

Subluxation theory: Past, present and future
From the beginning, D.D. Palmer’s 1895 subluxation theory was criticized by medical practitioners who knew enough about the nervous system to know that subluxation of a vertebra or compression of a spinal nerve was not a cause of organic disease. Gray’s Anatomy, first published in 1858, revealed that the body’s organs were governed by the autonomic nervous system and not by spinal nerves, a fact denied by B.J. Palmer, one of the developers of chiropractic:
In the study of chiropractic, there is possibly no one point upon which we so radically differ, from all preceding schools, as in eliminating the so-called sympathetic nervous system. We shall endeavor, by quoting authorities, to show how much they are in the dark as regards the origin of ‘involuntary functions,’ and by so doing supplant it with a superior teaching of Chiropractic.9
Although chiropractic subluxation theory has evolved from a bone-on-a-nerve theory to a more complex description involving a “complex of functional and/or structural and/or pathological articular changes that compromise neural integrity and may influence organ system function and general health,” 10 the theory is no less implausible. Few of the 18 chiropractic colleges in the United States have discarded subluxation theory. “Despite the controversies and paucity of evidence the term subluxation is still found often within the chiropractic curricula of most North American chiropractic programs.”11
Currently, a chiropractic vertebral subluxation is being described as a “vertebral subluxation complex” which involves “changes in nerve, muscle, connective, and vascular tissues which are understood to accompany the kinesiologic aberrations of spinal articulations.”12
It seems likely that subluxation-based chiropractic, now described in many different ways, all alleged to restore and maintain health by removing “nerve interference,” will be perpetuated as a belief system. But I suspect that criticism by the medical and scientific community will eventually force a segment of the chiropractic profession to openly abandon subluxation theory and seek a new direction, as osteopathy did many years ago. Subluxation-based factions in chiropractic will always be around, however, to compete with evidenced-based chiropractors, requiring that each group be separately identified. Some observers feel that it is now too late for the chiropractic profession to seek changes that would allow it to provide services already being provided by mainstream health care, forcing the profession to embrace alternative medicine if it is to maintain its independence without subluxation theory.
Any practice that begins with a false premise and a founding father, such as chiropractic, homeopathy, and osteopathy, can never completely eliminate true believers who are bound together by the tenets of cultism. It will be necessary for health-care professionals and public health officials to participate in a never-ending campaign to inform the public about pseudoscientific practices that might be offered as an alternative to appropriate health care.
The decline of chiropractic
In the late 1950s, the Haynes Foundation in the State of California asked the Stanford Research Institute to conduct a study of chiropractic in California. This study was completed in 1960 and published under the title “Chiropractic in California”. (California, a state with the largest number of licensed chiropractors, has been licensing chiropractors since 1922. In 1989, there were 8,012 chiropractors in California!) “Chiropractors seek to restore health by adjusting body structures, especially the spinal column,” the study reported. Chiropractic was defined as “a system of therapeutics…based on the assumption that disease is caused by interference with ‘nerve force.'” The Stanford report concluded that the most realistic outlook for the future of chiropractic would be “The general continued decline of chiropractic as a profession in its present form.”13
When I published my book Bonesetting, Chiropractic, and Cultism in 1963, I suggested that a logical solution for the survival of chiropractic might be found in chiropractic specialization in the realm of physical treatment, in cooperation with science-based medical practice. I concluded that if the chiropractic profession fails to abandon subluxation theory and specialize in the care of back disorders, “…there will be no justification for the existence of chiropractic when an adequate number of medical specialists and medical technicians make scientific manipulation available in a department of medical practice.”14

It has been 54 years since publication of Chiropractic in California, 51 years since the publication of Bonesetting, Chiropractic, and Cultism. While the chiropractic profession has survived and thrived in the 119 years of its existence, no credible research has been done by chiropractors to validate the chiropractic vertebral subluxation theory. Opponents of subluxation theory maintain that a simple review of anatomy and the autonomic nervous system provides enough evidence to forego serious consideration of the theory.15
Paradoxically, subluxation theory, categorized as a belief system in scientific literature, continues to define chiropractic in all 50 states despite higher educational requirements in chiropractic colleges. (Admission to a 4-year chiropractic college now requires a minimum of 3 years of undergraduate academic study.) It appears that chiropractic associations, representing the majority of chiropractors, might be reluctant to investigate subluxation theory or to seek a change in legislation that supports the licensure and livelihood of thousands of chiropractors.
As predicted by the 1960 Stanford study, support for the chiropractic profession in its “present form” now appears to be declining. Opposition to vertebral subluxation theory is increasing, and enrollment in chiropractic colleges has declined.16 The percentage of U.S. adults utilizing chiropractic services decreased from 9.9% in 1997 to 5.6% in 2006.17
A new approach: Integrative medicine
In what appears to be a survival mode, some chiropractic colleges are offering instruction in a variety of alternative healing methods, seeking shelter under the umbrella of alternative or integrative medicine. Southern California University of Health Sciences (SCUHS), for example, a former chiropractic college, is now offering degree programs in chiropractic, acupuncture, massage, Ayurveda, and oriental medicine.18 Functional Medicine University, sponsored by SCUHS, offers an online course of instruction in “functional medicine” which uses supplements, diet, and “other natural tools for restoring balance in the body’s primary physiological processes.”19 This shift to “integrative medicine” will allow chiropractors to treat a broad scope of non-musculoskeletal ailments as “primary care providers” without necessarily resorting to vertebral subluxation theory.
Mixing alternative medicine with subluxation theory in an “integrated practice,” the chiropractic profession has not renounced vertebral subluxation theory and has not made a concerted effort to specialize in conservative care for musculoskeletal problems. Inappropriate use of manipulation by chiropractors has generated increasing interest in the use of manipulation by physical therapists and orthopedic manual therapists who use manipulation only occasionally and only when appropriate.
There was a time when spinal manipulation was not readily available in departments of physical therapy, despite endorsement of such treatment in physical medicine textbooks. Chiropractors and osteopaths were often the only providers offering spinal manipulation. But this situation is rapidly changing. More physical therapists are being trained in the use of spinal manipulation, offering an alternative to chiropractic manipulation based on subluxation theory. Persons interested in studying or practicing manipulative therapy are being advised to pursue a Doctor of Physical Therapy (DPT) degree in order to avoid societal suspicion and the scientific alienation associated with the practice of chiropractic.
Unjustified criticism of spinal manipulation
Systematic reviews of the literature on the use of manipulation in the treatment of back pain indicate that spinal manipulative therapy may not be any more effective than other recommended therapies.20,21 But I suspect that further research will identify rare and special cases of mechanical-type back pain in which spinal manipulation might be the treatment of choice. Some back-pain patients simply prefer the pleasurable and relaxing effects of a good back-cracking back rub. Patient satisfaction coupled with the “possible” benefits of spinal manipulation is reason enough to support inclusion of spinal manipulative therapy as a treatment option in the armamentarium of any therapist or practitioner who treats back pain. It has been my observation that manipulation can be more effective than most forms of physical treatment in providing dramatic, albeit temporary, relief of mechanical-type back pain. Although acute back pain is usually a self-limiting condition, the symptomatic relief provided by spinal manipulation can be a welcome effect.
In rare cases, spinal manipulation may be a deciding factor in recovery from back pain. In acute back pain, for example, some manual therapists have proposed that a joint locked by muscle spasm caused by entrapment of synovial tissue or a cartilaginous fragment can sometimes be released by a single manipulation. Chronic back pain or stiffness caused by post-traumatic joint adhesions might require a course of high-velocity, low-amplitude thrust-type manipulation that moves spinal joints into the paraphysiologic space (past the normal end range of movement), reducing fixations by forcing slight separation of joint surfaces, often producing a popping sound (cavitation). In such cases, manipulation may be more effective than mobilization that simply moves joints within a normal range.
Needless to say, appropriate care for back pain depends upon a correct diagnosis, which will not always indicate a need for manipulation. Use of manipulation is considered to be inappropriate when based upon a “spinal analysis” done by a subluxation-based chiropractor who routinely “adjusts” the spine to correct “vertebral subluxations.”
Spinal adjustments vs. generic spinal manipulation
It is important to understand that a spinal adjustment used by a subluxation-based chiropractor is not the same as evidence-based generic spinal manipulation. A chiropractic adjustment used to correct a vertebral subluxation is a short-lever “specific” manipulation applied to a transverse or spinous process of a single vertebra in an attempt to move the vertebra and remove nerve interference in order to restore and maintain health. The treatment protocol of subluxation theory requires that all chiropractic patients have a spinal adjustment, whether they are symptomatic or not. Such an adjustment is sometimes done with a handheld instrument that uses a spring-loaded stylus to tap on a selected vertebra. Generic spinal manipulation, on the other hand, whether long lever or short lever, is a hands-on manipulation designed primarily to stretch muscles and loosen vertebrae in order to relieve pain and improve mobility; it is used only when indicated.
Unfortunately, appropriate use of generic spinal manipulation, which can be helpful in treating mechanical-type back pain, has been given a bad name by its association with chiropractic adjustments. Many chiropractors make good use of spinal manipulation when treating back pain, but use of manipulation to correct a chiropractic subluxation is increasingly being viewed as a fraudulent practice. (Remember that an asymptomatic chiropractic subluxation, alleged to be a cause of disease, has never been proven to exist and is not the same as an orthopedic subluxation that causes musculoskeletal symptoms.)

Bottom line
If the chiropractic profession as a whole does not renounce and abandon subluxation theory and make the changes needed to become a properly limited musculoskeletal specialty (possibly filling a niche as a subspecialty in conservative care for mechanical-type neck and back pain), with emphasis on appropriate use of manipulative therapy, justified criticism of subluxation-based chiropractic will continue to reflect upon the entire profession. In the meantime, back-pain patients who do not want to bother searching for a good back-cracking chiropractor who has renounced subluxation theory would probably have no trouble finding a physical therapist who uses manipulation appropriately. (Every state, the District of Columbia, and the US Virgin Islands now allow direct access to physical therapists for evaluation and some form of treatment without a physician referral.22)
References
     1.  Mencken HL. Chapter 29: Chiropractic. Mencken. Vintage Books. New York, 1959.
     2.  Fishbein M. The Basis of Chiropractic. Fads and Quackery in Healing: An Analysis of the Foibles of the Healing Cults with Essays on Various Other Peculiar Notions in the Health Field. Blue Ribbon Books. New York, 1932.
     3.  Maisel AQ. Can Chiropractic Cure? Reader’s Digest. June 1946.
     4.  Statement of Policy on Chiropractic Adopted by AMA House of Delegates. http://chirobase.org/08Legal/AT/amapolicy.html. (Accessed December 14, 2014)
     5.  Getzendanner S. Memorandum opinion and order in Wilk et al. vs. AMA et al, No.76C 3777. U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois, Eastern Division, August 27, 1987.
     6.  Christensen MG, et al. Practice Analysis of Chiropractic. National Board of Chiropractic Examiners. Greeley, Colorado. May 2010.
     7.  American Chiropractic Association. About Chiropractic. http://www.acatoday.org/level1_css.cfm?T1ID=42 (Accessed December 14, 2014)
     8.  Smith JC. The Medical War Against Chiropractors: The Untold Story from Persecution to Vindication. CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform. 2011.
     9.  Maynard JE. Healing Hands (Edited by B.J. Palmer). Jonorm Publishing Company. New York, 1959.
     10.  Association of Chiropractic Colleges. Chiropractic Paradigm. http://www.chirocolleges.org/paradigmscopepractice.html. (Accessed December 14, 2014)
     11.  Mirtz TA, Perle SM. The prevalence of the term subluxation in North American English-Language Doctor of Chiropractic programs. Chiropractic and Manual Therapies. 2011;19:14.
     12.  Rosner A. The Role of Subluxations in Chiropractic. Foundation for Chiropractic Education and Research. Des Moines, Iowa. 1997.
     13.  Stanford Research Institute. Chiropractic in California. The Haynes Foundation. Los Angeles, California. 1960.
     14.  Homola S. Bonesetting, Chiropractic, and Cultism. Critique Books. Panama City, Florida. 1963.
     15.  The College of Physicians and Surgeons of Quebec. The Scientific Brief Against Chiropractic. The New Physician. 1966. http://www.chirobase.org/05RB/CPSQ/00.html(Accessed December 14, 2014)
     16.  Institute for Alternative Futures. The Future of Chiropractic Revisited: 2005 to 2015. Alexandria, Virginia. 2005.
     17.  Davis MA, et al. Utilization and expenditures on chiropractic care in the United States from 1997 to 2006. Health Services Research. 2010;45(3):748-781.
     18.  Southern California University of Health Services. http://www.scuhs.edu. (Accessed December 14, 2014)
     19.  Functional Medicine University. http://www.functionalmedicineuniversity.com. (Accessed December 14, 2014)
     20.  Rubinstein SM, et al. Spinal manipulative therapy for chronic low-back pain: an update of a Cochrane review. Spine. 2011; 36(13):E825-46.
     21.  Rubinstein SM, et al. Spinal manipulative therapy for acute low back pain: an update of the Cochrane review. Spine. 2013; 38(3):E158-77.
     22.  American Physical Therapy Association. FAQ: Direct Access at the State Level. http://www.apta.org/StateIssues/DirectAccess/FAQs/(Accessed December 14, 2014)

Pushback on Chiropractic
Steven Novella on May 25, 2016
Link

From time to time we respond directly to reader comments or e-mails in an article, when it seems that doing so would be a useful teachable moment. One of the strengths of social media is that it is interactive, which can be didactic.
I feel it is very important to respond to what people actual believe and say, because otherwise we may tend to get lost in our own narrative, as legitimate as it might be. That is the essence of ivory tower syndrome, academics talking to themselves without a reasonable sense of what is happening in society. Part of our mission is to interact with society, not just our colleagues, and to engage in a serious conversation about the nature of science and medicine.
To that end, I recently received an e-mail responding to an interview I had done previously about chiropractic. The e-mail is full of pro-chiropractic propaganda and misconceptions, and so it provides an opportunity to address some of these claims.
An appeal to an antiquity that never was
It begins:
Your piece/video that was aired on MSN on Chiropractic / Chiropractors is a disappointment due to your lack of professionalism. I think the offensive parts are your deliberation on where Chiropractic stemmed from, of which you are incorrect on the origin or how it works and the level of skill it takes to be a Dr. of Chiropractic.
The charge of lack of professionalism or something similar is very common for the regular contributors to SBM. Sometimes the ad hominem approach rises to absurd levels (as David Gorski is unfortunately now experiencing), but often those who disagree with our position or feel threatened by it react personally.
There is often the implicit or explicit premise that being critical at all is unprofessional, or that everyone who considers themselves to be a health care professional deserves equal respect and should be treated as a colleague. However, we feel it is necessary to challenge the very legitimacy of certain professions, and to criticize them for not having a science-based standard of care, chiropractic included. If you disagree with our position, then address the facts and logic, crying “unprofessionalism” is just petulant.
It was not some divine intervention or hocus pocus, DD Palmer learned of the art of manipulation and it’s benefits from a form of Chinese medicine with ties to acupuncture that was practiced for centuries in Asia which also has ties to your profession – he was although the first to market it and its benefits in the USA, of which is practiced all over the world today helping people out of pain and in many cases back to not good but great health.
Here comes the standard chiropractic narrative. It is interesting how such narratives, like a religion, can evolve over time, and new generations come to believe the blatant historical revisionism as if it is fact.
In this case, however, we have DD Palmer’s own words to enlighten us – published in his 1910 book (errors in original):
Harvey Lillard, a janitor, in the Ryan Block, where I had my office, had been so deaf for 17 years that he could not hear the racket of a wagon on the street or the ticking of a watch. I made inquiry as to the cause of his deafness and was informed that when he was exerting himself in a cramped, stooping position, he felt something give way in his back and immediately became deaf. An examination showed a vertebra racked from its normal position. I reasoned that if that vertebra was replaced. the man’s hearing should be restored. With this object in view, a half-hour’s talk persuaded Mr. Lillard to allow me to replace it. I racked it into position by using the spinous process as a lever and soon the man could hear as before. There was nothing “accidental” about this, as it was accomplished with an object in view, and the result expected was obtained. There was nothing “crude” about this adjustment; it was specific, so much so that no Chiropractor has equaled it.
And:
I founded Chiropractic on Osteology, Neurology and FunctionsÑbones, nerves and the manifestations of impulses. I originated the art of adjusting vertebrae and the knowledge of every principle which is included in the construction of the science of Chiropractic.
There is no mention of acupuncture, although the subluxation theory of chiropractic is a vitalistic belief, as is the modern formulation of acupuncture. Palmer’s story of fixing the deaf janitor is almost certainly nonsense. If it were accidental, Palmer changed the story over time to fit the narrative he needed as an origin of the pseudoscience he apparently invented.
He does make reference to osteopathy, which was a similar pseudoscience. Subluxation theory states, in short, that disease is caused by the compression of nerves by misalignments in the spine which block the flow of life energy. Osteopathy is similar, but believes the misalignments of bones block the flow of blood.
To say that subluxation theory is based on neurology, however, is like saying that astrology is based in astronomy, only in the most superficial sense, and without any of the actual science.
In fact the science of neurology contradicts all the major premises of subluxation theory. Compression of spinal nerves generally causes pain, numbness, and weakness in some combination. Subluxation theory claims that spinal nerve compression can exist without these symptoms, but block only the mystical life energy whose alleged existence has eluded science to this day.
The history is quite clear. Palmer, by his own account, started out as a “magnetic healer” (in other words, a quack) and then discovered and developed chiropractic almost out of whole cloth, with some inspiration from vitalism and osteopathy. Chiropractic is not based on an ancient Chinese secret, but that is a clear attempt to make an argument from antiquity (a common fallacy used to support dubious treatments).
The modern chiropractic narrative relayed by the e-mailer is nothing but retconning – retroactively fitting the history of chiropractic to the current marketing narrative. “We’ve always been at war with Eastasia“.
An appeal to irrelevance
He continues:
Leander Eckhart scientifically proved the value of manipulation with passive motion controlled traction using video fluoroscopy at the U of W as to correcting spinal fixations, along with his research and work correcting Scoliosis, documenting physiological changes, so you are incorrect there too.
This is a common tactic of pseudoscience also – citing research which does not establish the basic principles of the claim as if it does. Chiropractors, even though they have had over a century to do so, have not demonstrated scientifically that chiropractic subluxations exist, that manipulation can “correct” alleged subluxations, that such subluxations are associated with any specific disease or that “innate intelligence” (their word for the vitalistic life energy) exists, or that chiropractic manipulation improves any disease.
None of their basic premises have been demonstrated scientifically, and in fact their claims are incompatible with modern medical science.
Keep in mind, I am referring here to subluxation theory specifically. Contemporary chiropractors have a broad range of practice, and some practice something closer to physical therapy or sports medicine, without treating disease through subluxation theory.
A little bit of historical denial, and some tu quoque
Being a professional using modern (scientific?) arguments against century old beliefs is a fail on so many levels not to mention a cheap shot with no scientific support or merit. Turnabout would be fair play if one was to look at your profession and there are many skeletons in that closet.
This is a very odd claim. I think the unstated premise here is that chiropractors no longer practice the century-old beliefs of their profession. If this were true, then he might have a point, but it is clearly not true.
To give an analogy, I have written about phrenology, the practice of determining personality through reading the bumps on the outside of the skull. This was practiced by neurologists two centuries ago. There is a tiny fringe that still practice phrenology, but not within the medical or neurological professions. I wrote about it for historical interest only, not as a criticism of modern neurologists.
If subluxation theory had been abandoned entirely by the chiropractic profession the situation would be the same. In fact, I don’t spend time criticizing modern osteopaths for their outdated beliefs (although there appears to still be a fringe who cling to them). Largely osteopaths have rejected the pseudoscience of their past and embraced science-based standards.
As a profession chiropractors have not rejected the pseudoscience of their origin. By some estimates about 30% of chiropractors still practice according to subluxation theory. They are pseudoscientists. And this is not some fringe. The British Chiropractic Association famously fought with Simon Singh over their support of blatantly pseudoscientific current chiropractic practices, and lost spectacularly. They defended manipulation for the treatment of a long list of childhood diseases and disorders, based upon terrible science, which I dutifully deconstructed on SBM.
Subluxation theory is not a skeleton in the closet. It is a living breathing part of modern chiropractic.
And finally, some flat-out propaganda
Would it be too much to ask for you to be professional, most Chiropractors are, they have much more education that most MD’s and Specialists, with a minimum of 2 years pre-med before they can enter into the 4 year program to become a Dr. of Chiropractic and compulsory ongoing annual continuing education to keep their license.
Yes, it is too much. The chiropractic profession, in my opinion, does not deserve professional respect. They tolerate pseudoscience in their ranks, and do not have a reasonable standard of care. They are not science-based as a profession.
The claim that chiropractors have more education than most MD’s is pure propaganda, and is very telling. We have covered the issue of chiropractic education before, so I won’t go into it again in detail. Suffice it to say chiropractic basic science and clinical education is not even close to what MDs receive.
Conclusion: The usual tropes that miss the point
The e-mailer ends with the usual tu quoque logical fallacy – more MDs have killed patients than chiropractors. This misses the risk vs benefit context, and also is not a meaningful comparison because of the relative size of the professions. The claim is just more misleading propaganda.
If chiropractors wish to defend themselves from science-based criticism, they should do proper research and then adjust their practice based upon the results of that research. They should align their profession with modern science.
Instead, they generally attack the messenger, attack the medical profession, demand respect they have not earned, and revise history to suit their marketing needs.

A cure for chiropractic
Jann Bellamy on February 20, 2014
Link
Almost 10 years ago, a thoughtful article, entitled “Chiropractic as spine care: a model for the profession”, appeared in the journal Chiropractic & Osteopathy. The authors were a group of both academic and practicing chiropractors, as well as representatives from a health insurer specializing in coverage of CAM provider services. Another article, under different authorship, appeared the same year deploring some aspects of chiropractic education. In 2008, a third article came out with a similar theme, “How can chiropractic become a respected mainstream profession? The example of podiatry.” All three are open access and worth reading. The authors are to be commended for taking on an extremely contentious subject in their own profession.
The first article is a refreshingly honest look at the current state of chiropractic. The authors note the inability of chiropractors to consistently define who they are and what they do, which results in public confusion (including among those in the healthcare industry) about just what role chiropractors should play in the healthcare system. The authors deplore the continued existence of the “subluxation” in chiropractic and it’s accommodation by no less than the Association of Chiropractic Colleges. And they thoroughly deconstruct any notion that such a thing exists. The idea that chiropractors are capable of acting as primary care physicians is given equally short shrift and debunked as well.
The article points out that, whatever the confusion among chiropractors about who they are and what they do, the public has decided on its own: the public perception of chiropractors is that of back pain specialists. Back-related problems account for over 90% of the reason patients see chiropractors. They also argue that chiropractic must embrace evidence-based healthcare and stop relying on their clinical experience, noting the many reasons (e.g., regression to the mean) that a chiropractor’s observations may be explained by something other than treatment effectiveness. They admit that the chiropractor’s stock-in-trade, spinal manipulation, might not hold up under an evidence-based standard. (A possibility that is becoming a reality.) They even quote Marcia Angell’s observation on “alternative” medicine:
There is only medicine that has been adequately tested and medicine that has not, medicine that works and medicine that may or may not work.
The article on chiropractic education is downright disturbing considering claims by chiropractors that they are qualified to serve as primary care physicians. Especially appalling is the lack of clinical training:
Our cumulative observations suggest that the obvious contrast in numbers of patient encounters in a chiropractic externship, when compared to a medical/osteopathic internship, are sadly disconcerting from the perspective of the volume and variety of patient exposures.
And this alarming observation:
Instruction in evidence based medicine (EBM) in American chiropractic schools also appears to be lacking.
In addition to improvements in chiropractic education, they propose stiffening chiropractic school admission requirements, which they note are the least stringent among all professional degree healthcare disciplines.
The third article holds up podiatry as a template for necessary change to chiropractic: university-based education and training, a commitment to improving podiatry education via honest analysis of its weaknesses (including a Flexner Report-type analysis), collaboration with (not rejection of) medical doctors, commitment to public health (including proven public health measures like vaccination and fluoridation), and acceptance of a niche patient population (people with foot problems).
So why has nothing happened?
Summarizing all three articles, their solution is a professional model of chiropractic as portal-of-entry provider of “spine care,” improvements in chiropractic education, ridding chiropractic of the “subluxation,” acceptance and promotion of evidence-based healthcare, a conservative clinical approach, chiropractic as an integrated part of the healthcare system, and implementation of accepted standards of professional ethics.
As far as I can tell, their suggestions have been ignored by the chiropractic profession. This is due, at least in part, to a fatal flaw in their plan:
[T]he Spine Care model is completely consistent with current state licensing.
I’m afraid not.
As pointed out in an informative article by a physical therapist (also well worth reading) writing about the chiropractors’ incessant attempts to claim (falsely) that chiropractors alone have education and training to perform spinal manipulation:
In effect, the subluxation construct was and remains to this day central to the legal definition of chiropractic, its scope of practice, and reimbursement for chiropractic services, no matter how many factions within the profession decry defining the profession based on this outdated 19th century construct.
My own review of the 50 chiropractic state practice acts agrees with this conclusion.
The physical therapist notes that chiropractors have expanded the subluxation definition (while keeping it equally nonsensical) over the years, thereby automatically expanding the chiropractic scope of practice, as well as opportunity for insurance reimbursement, without ever having to amend the chiropractic practice acts. The subluxation is, quite conveniently, whatever they say it is.
(I’ve even wondered whether the chiropractic practice acts could be challenged in court on the basis that they exceed the state’s police power, that is, the power to regulate for protection of the public health, safety and welfare, reserved to the states via the Tenth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution. Certainly, allowing baseless diagnoses and treatments hardly meets this protective purpose. But we’ll leave that for another day and more research.)
Despite the widespread recognition that chiropractic desperately needs reform, after a search of both PubMed (which indexes a number of chiropractic journals) and the legal literature, I could find only one article discussing the need to amend the chiropractic practice acts to address this pressing problem. (In this journal, although the article, “Note: Adjusting the Role of Chiropractors in the United States: Why Narrowing Chiropractor Scope of Practice Statutes Will Protect Patients,” by Peter Morrison, is not available on online without a subscription service.) To his credit, the author recognized the need to rid chiropractic of the subluxation via reform of the chiropractic practice acts, although he did not make specific suggestions for statutory language.
If there is a movement afoot among chiropractors to limit their practice to the sort of model suggested in the three chiropractic journal articles, it is not evident in their current legislative efforts. Right now, for example, there is a bill pending in Hawaii that would simply default to the faulty chiropractic educational system to determine chiropractic scope of practice. And, as expected, chiropractors in New Mexico are again attempting to expand their scope of practice to include prescribing even more drugs, including dangerous drugs. (You can find out more about these bills and other unfortunate legislative efforts to expand the reach of CAM providers on the Society for Science-Based Medicine website, updated weekly. See how many pro-CAM bills are pending? Discouraging, isn’t it?)
I am not of the opinion that we necessarily need chiropractors at all. (As best I can tell, physical therapists can do everything evidence-based that chiropractors do, and more.) But I am concerned about the continued fleecing of the public with outlandish claims that the detection and correction of subluxations is not only beneficial, but necessary for good health (and so forth), forcing health insurance consumers and taxpayers to pay for unnecessary and, in some cases, frankly quack diagnoses and treatments. And yes, in anticipation of the irrelevant comments that will almost certainly appear, medicine needs reform too but for entirely different reasons. And medicine is paying attention to its problems and offering solutions, not ignoring them. Chiropractors are largely ignoring their problems. In fact, they are actively perpetuating them.
While it is all well and good to make frank assessments of the many deficiencies in chiropractic education, training and practice, the authors are not advocating for the one action that can have the most impact. In fact, they deny the need for a legislative solution. Reformers (some of whom have commented on SBM) must draft a new model chiropractic practice act and lobby for it. (Physical therapists already have a model act; see page 25.) Pick a state and start. I guarantee you will get a legislator’s attention if you, a group of chiropractors, tell him or her that the state’s chiropractic practice act is promoting quackery, not giving patients and third-party payers value for their healthcare dollar, and permitting unsafe practices. And I imagine this is one piece of chiropractic legislation that will find support in other businesses and professions, such as health and worker’s compensation insurers, employers, medical doctors, and doctors of osteopathy.
And we’re going to help you.
Here are my suggestions for the Model Chiropractic Practice Reform Act. (I’ve ventured into this territory before.) They would need to be drafted as a bill, in statutory language, a detail that can be left for later and with the help of experts in bill drafting. Reasons for the provisions follow in parentheses.
     1.  Limit chiropractic scope of practice to diagnosis, treatment and prevention of musculoskeletal conditions related to the spine. (That is what they are educated and trained for, if imperfectly, and that is what their patients see them for.)
     2.  Prohibit the administration, prescription or recommendation of drugs. (They are not sufficiently educated and trained to do this. And when given the privilege, they have employed it irresponsibly.)
     3.  Forbid diagnosis and treatment based on the existence or clinical significance of the subluxation or any putative condition derived from the original subluxation “hypothesis.” (For obvious reasons.)
     4.  Require that chiropractors practice evidence-based healthcare. (Should they be singled out among healthcare professions? Yes, because of their long history of what might be called “abuse of science.”)
     5.  Require chiropractors to make clear to patients the limitations of their scope of practice and to refer all conditions outside their scope of practice to a medical doctor or doctor of osteopathy. Require a referral from an M.D. or D.O. for treatment of pediatric patients. (There is evidence that the public isn’t aware they are not medical doctors. As to pediatric patients, again, the issue is education and training, and the lack of reliable safety and effectiveness evidence.)
     6.  Prohibit the sale of dietary supplements, vitamins, homeopathic products and other remedies by chiropractors to patients. (A terrible conflict of interest.)
     7.  Starting in four years, require that all chiropractors applying for a license to practice have a baccalaureate degree prior to entering chiropractic college and a one-year post-graduation internship. (For the reasons stated in the journal articles.)
     8.  Form a commission consisting of academic and practicing chiropractors, medical doctors, osteopathic physicians, and university-based academics who specialize in spinal anatomy, physiology and neuroscience. Chiropractors should choose their members and M.D.s and D.O.s should choose the rest of the group. This group should meet and in two years have recommendations ready for further amendments, if necessary, to the chiropractic practice act to ensure the health, safety and welfare of the public. This should include the administration of additional testing and post-graduation internship requirements prior to being licensed by the state. There should also be some mechanism for continued monitoring of how the new law is working.
     9.  Require the state chiropractic board to issue regulations in accordance with the chiropractic practice act, as amended, within a specified period of time. (No foot-dragging allowed.)
There is certainly room for improvement in these suggestions. But someone has to start somewhere. Chiropractors who don’t like being lumped in with the subluxation or “DC as PCP” set need to step up to the plate and be proactive about reform. And without legislation chiropractors simply won’t make the sort of dramatic changes needed to bring them into the 21st century.

Chiropractic Abuse: An Insider’s Lament
Harriet Hall on October 29, 2013
Link
There is a new book critical of chiropractic: Chiropractic Abuse: An Insider’s Lament. The author, Preston Long, DC, PhD, is a chiropractor who says he made a big mistake when he chose chiropractic as a career. He has written an intriguing book explaining his mistake and the experiences that resulted from it during 3 decades as a chiropractor and a critic of chiropractic.
Chiropractic encourages self-delusion, and those who break free of delusion have two choices: to fight or run. Preston Long chose to fight, to keep the baby and throw out the bathwater polluted with pseudoscience and quackery, to try to practice rationally and ethically, and to try to reform chiropractic from within. He soon learned that it was next to impossible for a chiropractor to make a living with a science-based, ethical practice. He eventually found his niche and put his knowledge of chiropractic to good use. He evaluates chiropractic cases for disability and fraud, has worked with the FBI, and has testified at over 200 trials. He has written two previous books, The Naked Chiropractor (2002) and The P.R.E.S.T.O.N. Protocol for Back Pain (2006). This new book tells the story of his life and exposes the delusions and misbehaviors of his chiropractic colleagues.
He reveals “20 things most chiropractors won’t tell you”:
     1.  Chiropractic is not based on science
     2.  Chiropractors promise too much
     3.  Their education is vastly inferior to that of medical doctors
     4.  Their legitimate scope is very narrow
     5.  Little of what they do has been studied
     6.  It’s best to get diagnosed elsewhere
     7.  They offer lots of unnecessary services
     8.  “Cracking” the back doesn’t mean much
     9.  If the first few visits don’t help, more treatment probably won’t help
     10.  They take too many x-rays
     11.  Research on spinal manipulation doesn’t reflect what happens in chiropractic offices
     12.  Neck manipulation is potentially dangerous
     13.  Most chiropractors don’t know much about nutrition
     14.  If they sell vitamins, they charge too much for them
     15.  They have no business treating young children
     16.  The fact that patients swear by them doesn’t mean they are actually being helped
     17.  Insurance companies don’t want to pay for chiropractic care
     18.  Lots of chiropractors do really strange things
     19.  Don’t expect chiropractic licensing boards to protect you
     20.  The media rarely look at what they do wrong.
The first time I read this list, there was no number 19. I wondered if 19 was the one thing no chiropractor will tell you, not even Preston Long. Turns out it was just an inadvertent omission that was corrected in subsequent copies.
He started to realize his mistake during his first classes in chiropractic school. He wondered why he hadn’t learned about those displaced bones and all the devastating health problems they cause during his undergraduate studies in anatomy, physiology, and biology. He noticed that his teachers never mentioned how hormones help regulate the human body. Despite glaring doubts about this profession, he stayed, simply because he had no other place to go. He has lots of stories to tell about his first adjustment, the cheating he observed, and the inconsistencies in what he was taught.
He covers the history of chiropractic, the imaginary subluxation, the studies evaluating the efficacy of spinal manipulation, the economic abuse of patients, the reasons you should never sign a contract for chiropractic care, the risk of stroke with neck manipulation (with tragic patient stories), insurance frauds and injury mills, upcoding visits, regulatory abuses, and unethical practices of chiropractic boards.
As a practicing chiropractor, he observed many kinds of misconduct among his peers, from cynical marketing techniques to defrauding insurance companies. I got a kick out of the idiotic behavior of chiropractors in several of the cases of sexual misconduct he encountered during his career. One chiropractor
…did rectal exams on all of his female patients and videotaped them. When women complained, investigators found tapes in and near a VCR in a bedroom in his home. He claimed to have done the taping to document the procedures so that insurance companies would pay for them. But he could not explain why they were in his bedroom.
Another chiropractor
…suckled a woman’s breast while doing a breast exam. The woman ran out of his office in her gown only. She contacted police, who asked her to call the chiropractor and record the call. He admitted to it and even asked her to return later that same day. Somehow the chiropractor got wind of the taped call, walked past his receptionist (his wife), locked the clinic door with her still inside, and flew to Colorado where he remains today.
One chapter covers how to protect yourself and what red flags to look for. Another chapter reproduces the Institute for Science in Medicine’s Chiropractic White Paper, authored by our own Jann Bellamy. A final chapter asks if chiropractic can reform. He is not optimistic:
I believe that in order to survive as a profession, chiropractic must adopt the substance of a scientific health discipline and not merely a veneer. This would require abandoning subluxation theory, adopting ethical standards, and clamping down on the wide range of practices that are unproven and lack a scientifically plausible rationale. Unfortunately, having seen little progress in this direction during the past 25 years, I do not believe chiropractic has the ability to reform from the inside.
This book is a very valuable addition to the literature on chiropractic, combining Long’s personal story with everything you never wanted to know about chiropractic. It’s fun to read and packed with information. Even if you think you’ve heard it all before, there are revelations here that will be new to you, that will elicit surprise, indignation, and laughter.

Chiropractic Practice Building: A Doctor’s Confession and the Report of Findings
Clay Jones on August 30, 2013
Link

“I’ve got to get this off my chest!”
“Dear chiropractic practitioner,
Confessions are tough…Real tough. They are painful, awful things. But, sometimes a confession can set the record straight, and I want to give credit where credit is due. Before I talk about my confession though, let me say a few other things first. You may want to sit down.
You know, when I meet people in town they usually say, “Oh, yeah, I know you, you’re Dr. Jones. I’ve seen your posts with that picture of you and the two cute little girls.” Well, I’m the guy on the left. Aren’t they cute? Now do you feel like you can trust me?
Years ago, something happened to me that changed my life forever. And I would love to tell you all about it, but first I need to give you my report of findings.
I’ve correlated the findings of your examination, and I’ve put it into a package that I’m going to review and send home with you, so you’ll know what we found and what we’re going to do to help you. In the next 10 minutes or so I’m going to review what we found, explain what these findings mean, recommend a course of action and discuss the results you can expect in the future. Feel free to ask any questions as we go along.
First a quick review. You’ve come to our website suffering from an inability to recognize your complete lack of effectiveness in the treatment of headaches, ear infections, asthma, or any other condition, with the possible exception of acute musculoskeletal pain involving the back. You have difficulty accepting that any treatment you offer which is effective is provided by physical therapists, minus all the “baggage”, and that nothing you offer which is unique to chiropractic is effective. You are in denial over how the majority of your profession is woefully ignorant of, or exists in a state of denial of, so many of the advancements in modern medicine, like life-saving vaccines, made since chiropractic was invented by D.D. Palmer in 1895.
Don’t worry, we have had excellent results with these sorts of problems. Well, actually, the proponents of irregular medicine tend to stick their fingers in their ears when faced with criticism and evidence that doesn’t support their world view. In fact, I’m surprised we’ve made it this far. I take that as a good sign.
To locate the specific cause of your problem, we conducted a thorough examination. Here’s what we found:
It’s tough to be a chiropractor
Making it as a chiropractor is hard. The numbers just don’t add up despite how CAM use is portrayed in the media and defended by proponents. Certainly some chiropractors do very well, with the median salary a few years out of training being about seventy thousand dollars a year, but because of low demand and marketplace oversaturation many practices fail. With debt that rivals physicians coming out of medical school, and families to provide for, chiropractors often turn to so-called practice building or management firms to help right the ship. Many of the methods recommended by these companies are quite shady, encouraging manipulation and misrepresentation unbecoming of a group of practitioners with a goal of being regarded as primary care practitioners.
The most recent National Health Interview Survey data on CAM use revealed that 8.6% of people polled underwent some form of manipulation in 2007, which was up from 7.5% in 2002. But these numbers aren’t really comparable. We don’t know what percentage of the patients in the 2007 data were actually seen by a chiropractor rather than an osteopath, because unlike in 2002 they did not differentiate between the two fields. Some osteopaths do continue to provide manipulation-based therapy but most practice or at least incorporate science-based practice. In fact, most osteopaths train with and practice alongside medical doctors.
The number of chiropractors in the United States is somewhere around sixty thousand based on numerous sources. There were 52,000 chiropractors in 2010 according to the Bureau of Labor and Statistics, so I will go with that, and there are currently about 316 million Americans. Based on the NHIS data it appears that about 27 million people get manipulated yearly, which works out to 500 or so people per manipulator. Again, we don’t know how many people are actually visiting a chiropractor but it is probably the majority, and we don’t know what percentage of those are regular visitors. That is not a large patient panel by any stretch of the imagination, and of course it would not be evenly distributed. Some newer practices likely have far fewer patients.
Knowing how the numbers actually break down is interesting considering some of the claims that I have come across researching the chiropractic presence on the internet. A common chiropractic meme (chiromeme) I see is bragging about large patient loads, often with numbers that hint at an ability to interact with space and time in fundamentally new ways. This is a practice-building technique. The bragging, not the manipulation of time.
Claims of seeing hundreds of patients a day, or performing millions of adjustments over a career, are common. Sharon Gormon, for instance, “has cared for thousands of patients and has performed over half a million adjustments in her career.” Over a twenty year career that works out to at least 68 adjustments a day, if she never took a day off. Even taking into account that many patients are diagnosed with multiple subluxations at the same visit it is still a hectic schedule. The ability to claim to have that degree of popularity in order to impress potential patients, while also denigrating physicians for not “treating the whole patient”, is impressive and perhaps unrivaled in the natural world.
Another chiromeme I came across recently, while perhaps not as commonplace, was still repeated word for word on several different chiropractic websites and is considerably more comical:
If you think that chiropractic is a new science, it is. However, you might be surprised to know that spinal manipulation has been utilized for a very long time. The first pictures depicting spinal manipulation were discovered in prehistoric cave paintings in Point le Merd in southwestern France. The historical cave paintings can be dated as far back as 17,500 BC.
A quick search revealed that Point le Merd is not an actual location in France or anywhere else. It is however suspiciously close in spelling to “pointe le merde”, which translates to “the very tip of the shit”. Make of that what you will.
Practice-building techniques
With so few patients at their disposal, I am not surprised that chiropractors are more likely to default on student loans than any other health-related profession. It is also easy to see why so many turn to these practice-building techniques and the seminars run by companies promising to bring more patients in and increase profits. I don’t have a problem with a business trying to succeed and make enough money to feed their family and pay their debts, but I do have a problem with how it is sometimes done. The ends don’t justify the means in this case because they require deceiving patients. The evidence simply does not support the vast majority of the claims being made.
Usually these practice-building techniques come in the form of setting up information booths at local gyms or fairs, ads containing coupons for free spinal exams and pseudo-journalistic press releases run in smaller local publications. The easiest to recognize are the bogus personal testimonials placed on practice websites (1, 2, 3, 4). I’m sure you have seen these “confessions” before, but you may not have realized that they involve the use of a standard template purchased from practice-building firms. Here is a video version which hits all the high points as well. I highly recommend watching all three installments. Here is another one, just for fun.
These seemingly personal stories always follow the same pattern, with many being identical except for the picture of their adorable offspring and specific practice information. The chiropractor always sheepishly admits that he or she has something to confess and then tells the story of how they, or a family member, were injured and could only find relief in the caring hands of a chiropractor, usually after a bad experience with conventional medicine. Thus they are inspired to join the field of chiropractic.
Then comes the confession that they have been taking the credit for healing patients over the years when really it was the chiropractic all along. They simply remove roadblocks to the body’s innate healing ability. They can treat your pain, get you off your meds and save your life naturally. Check out the links above and you’ll see. And trust me there are thousands more, like this one, that are easily accessible online. I can’t help but imagine that they choose from a list of personal tragedy options, and the testimonials typically placed in the ad are likely invented as well. I could be wrong but if not then these are a very accident-prone bunch. They should probably have a special restriction on their driver’s licenses.
Many of these phony personal confessions disparage the medical profession or make questionable claims about the side effects of childhood vaccines. Or they simply complain that medical doctors only know how to push drugs and treat symptoms. Here is one that gives highly questionable medical advice such as bringing your child to the chiropractor if they are injured falling from a high place. It also contains the following gem:
However, have you ever wondered what would happen if you gave a healthy child the same medicine you give a sick child? Don’t parents usually tell their kids “don’t take drugs” if not needed because it’ll make them sick?? So it seems if drugs make healthy people sick, wouldn’t they make sick people even sicker?
Makes sense. I for one would never put a healthy child on a dopamine drip.
Another post on this particular site lists some reasons why chiropractic might not work:
Invalidating Comments: When a patient has a family member (or other close person) who is making them wrong about using chiropractic care, then those people have up-and-down results. The person is better after I treat them, but after coming in contact with that person, they are doing worse again.
I think that Dr. Erica might be on to something. I told a family just today not to speak ill of the gentamicin or it might interfere with its ability to kill bacteria. And if they just had to they should have the decency to not do it in front of the IV. I don’t think this is a chiromeme that will catch on though.
While some rogue chiropractors like Dr. Erica do sometimes go off point on their websites, virtually everything you read on a chiropractic website or in an advertisement for a chiropractic practice is part of a prepackaged practice-building scheme. The wording is carefully chosen to have the biggest impact. Every flyer or handout found in a chiropractor’s waiting room is designed to indoctrinate you so that you not only come back, you go out and spread the word. Here is a nearly ubiquitous example from a chiropractic website’s FAQ section:
Who needs to be evaluated by a chiropractor?
EVERYONE!
Anyone with a spine can benefit. Due to its positive effects on the nervous system, chiropractic can help correct many health problems. Our clinic typically treats patients with fatigue, scoliosis, allergies, asthma, menstrual disorders, headaches, and low immune function.
Another example:
How long will you need chiropractic care?
You’ll need chiropractic care as long as you live in Hanover Park and encounter physical, chemical or emotional stress that you cannot adapt to or accommodate. Ready to get started? Call our office today.
And yet another from a different chiropractic website’s “Story of Chiropractic” page:
Ultimately, the goal of the chiropractic treatment is to restore the body to its natural state of optimal health. In order to accomplish this, I use a variety of treatment methods, including manual adjustments, massage, trigger point therapy, nutrition, exercise rehabilitation, massage, as well as counseling on lifestyle issues that impact your health. Since the body has a remarkable ability to heal itself and to maintain its own health, the primary focus is simply to remove those things which interfere with the body’s normal healing ability.
But these boilerplate “confessions” and FAQ sections are hardly the worst that chiropractic practice building has to offer. That would be the report of findings, or the ROF.
The ROF sounds simple enough as explained to the potential patient on many websites:
After Chiropractor Jones has had time to sit down and thoroughly analyze your exam findings, he will give you a detailed report of all findings and answer any questions including:
     1.  What is causing my problem?
     2.  Can you help me?
     3.  What will my treatment cost?
After reviewing your health history, goals, and examining your spine and X-rays, Chiropractor Jones will discuss recommendations and notify you if your condition requires care with other providers. Chiropractor Jones will provide the best treatment and wellness program for your needs.
Well that sounds lovely, and not much different than when I discuss a treatment plan with the family of a hospitalized child. I go over exam findings and test/imaging results that might have been obtained with the family, I explain my diagnosis and I make treatment recommendations. And I make sure that the family has all of their questions answered.
But there is more to the chiropractic ROF. In the world of chiropractic practice building, the ROF is the sales pitch. It is what all the bells and whistles of the chiropractic office, the x-rays, the neurocalometers, leg length measurements and even simple palpation of the spine are designed to lead up to. It is the chiropractor’s chance to convince the patient of the validity of what B.J. Palmer called the Big Idea. This is the notion that the subluxation is the root of all your health problems and correcting the subluxation will fix all of your health problems. Palmer imagined a world without subluxations. Lennon did not.
The ROF is also the chance to convince the patient that there is more to chiropractic than fixing the acute problem. That pesky subluxation could return at any time. Thus the patient is convinced of the need for transitioning into maintenance care. As insurance does not typically long-term chiropractic care, this tends to require cash. And naturally if you pay up front, they can pass the savings on to you. Many practice-building resources refer to the ROF as a means of achieving the “killer close.” Classy.
I learned how to discuss the nuances of a patient’s diagnosis and management by reading, role play, and observation. There are a number of excellent resources for physicians to improve their ability to communicate. I am still learning after ten years of practice. Recently I’ve focused on learning how to better discuss the management of pain because my wife has transitioned into a career in pediatric palliative care and she made me do it. There is absolutely nothing wrong with the desire to hone these skills. The chiropractic ROF is clearly not the same thing.
There are a number of practice-building programs offer ROF scripts and coaching for purchase, many with claims of superiority in growing a practice, but a great deal of information is available online. There are many different approaches. This particular practice-building consultant, for instance, believes that patient autonomy is a nuisance:
When a chiropractor crosses the line from controlled office procedural and patient management into procedural exceptions and patient management decisions based on patient debate and input, that chiropractor is entering the realm of ineffective practice.
Here is a complete script. I’ve provided some of the highlights:
2. Opening statement with an assertive, We can help you!-Susan, your radiological findings indicate that we can help you. But we have a lot of work to do.-The purpose of your visit today is to first show you how the structural biomechanics of your spine differ from a healthy spine.-The second goal is to give you our recommendations for relief and correction.-Does that sound good?-Patient responds, “Yes”
** Use a model of a spine to show the patient what a healthy spine looks like.-Do you remember the term we use when a bone in your spine is out of alignment?-Patient responds “Subluxation”-If the patient doesn’t respond with, “Subluxation.” Show the patient a poster with the word subluxation on it.-Then make the patient say it, “Subluxation”.
8. Express urgency-If we don’t address this, what do you think will happen?-Patient responds, “It will get worse.”-That’s correct.-You mentioned during the consultation you have been having difficulty working and sleeping. If your subluxations get worse, how do you think that will affect those areas of your life?-Patient responds, “I might not to be able to work at all.”-That is what I am concerned about.
9. Relate subluxations to the organs innervated and associated conditions-You have a subluxation here at C1. These nerves supply your heart, pituitary gland, and lungs.-Subluxations at this level are associated with headaches, migraines, neck pain and stiffness, high blood pressure, anxiety, depression, insomnia and asthma.
(Cardiopituitopulmonary depression is very serious.)
10.How long-I can’t give you an exact date because there are many factors that play a role and impact your body’s ability to heal: what you eat, how you exercise, genetics and how much stress you are under.-However, if we stop at relief care the hole in the roof will not be corrected.-Corrective care for an adult with this severity of subluxations can take between 24 weeks and 24 months.-I know that seems like a longtime, but how long does it take to straighten teeth?-Patient responds, “A couple years.”-That’s correct, it takes time to move bones.
11.Find level of commitment-Are you committed to correcting your subluxations?-Patient responds, “Yes.”-Are you a 100% committed?-Patient responds, “Yes.”
12.How much-You can pay 55 a visit for the 48 visits plus two re-x-rays. That comes to 2838.-You can pay 239 per month for 6 months and that will include three x-rays. That comes to 1434 and saves you 444 dollar-You can also pre-pay for the 24 weeks and receive a 15% discount. That comes to 1219 and saves you 215 dollars over the monthly plan
I’m hard on the practice of chiropractic because it involves lying to patients and parents. I realize that not all chiropractors subscribe to subluxation theories or disparage vaccines, and not all chiropractors make use of slimy practice-building schemes, but there are just not very many out there like Sam Homola. And whether they continue to make claims of effectively treating or preventing non-musculoskeletal conditions despite the reams of negative evidence is because of gullibility or guile, I do not care.
Conclusion: It’s bad when anyone does it
I have no doubt that there are similar tactics put into use by some medical doctors. I cringe every time I see another “health and wellness” medical spa pop up with an MD as a director. It burns me up every time a medical clinic starts offering bogus bio-identical hormone therapy or selling supplements.
I spent a long time trying to see what kind of shady practices go on in the world of pediatrics to drum up business. Outside of some reasonable discussions of website design and establishing a presence in the community, which is also something that chiropractic practice-building techniques cover, my search for the sordid underbelly of pediatrics came up empty. What I did find, using the same search terms minus the word “chiropractic”, were countless examples of pediatricians trying to make a practice better rather than a busier or more profitable.
What does having a better practice entail? Primarily it means providing better care for patients through quality improvement initiatives. It means improving efficiency, limiting the ordering of diagnostic studies like labs and imaging that aren’t supported by good evidence and incorporating more effective educational interventions for families. There is no place in the practice of medicine for the chiropractic model of practice building.

   Theory and Reality

   Science-based Chiropractic: An Oxymoron?
Sam Homola
Link
I spent 43 years in private practice as a “science-based” chiropractor and a critic of the chiropractic vertebral subluxation theory. I am often asked how I justified practicing as a chiropractor while renouncing the basic tenets of chiropractic. My answer has always been: I was able to offer manipulation in combination with physical therapy modalities as a treatment for mechanical-type back pain—a service that was not readily available in physiotherapy or in any other sub-specialty of medicine.
If I had it to do over again, however, I would study physical therapy rather than chiropractic. Considering the controversy that continues to surround the practice of chiropractic, I would not recommend that anyone spend the time, effort, and money required to earn a degree in chiropractic. Physical therapy, which is now beginning to include spinal manipulation in its treatment armamentarium, may offer better opportunity for those interested in manual therapy. Properly-limited, science-based chiropractors are now essentially competing with physical therapists who use manual therapy. Unfortunately, only a few chiropractors have renounced the vertebral subluxation theory, making it difficult to find a “good chiropractor.” I consider physical therapy to be more progressive and more evidence based. For this reason, I generally recommend the manipulative services of a physical therapist rather than a chiropractor.
There are some science-based chiropractors who use manipulation appropriately, but until the chiropractic profession abandons the implausible vertebral subluxation theory and is defined according to standards dictated by anatomy, physiology, and neurology, I would not describe it as a science-based profession.
Heretics and Science-Based Chiropractors
After my second year in chiropractic college, I came to the conclusion that the chiropractic subluxation theory was not a credible construct. In an effort to separate the good from the bad in the use of manipulation by chiropractors, I published my book Bonesetting, Chiropractic, and Cultism in 1963, renouncing the chiropractic vertebral subluxation theory and suggesting that chiropractors should limit their use of spinal manipulation to treatment of back pain. Over the years, I wrote many articles critical of chiropractic, always suggesting that the definition of chiropractic be changed in chiropractic colleges and state laws so that the next generation of chiropractors would be properly limited. Science-based chiropractors could be separated from their subluxation-based counterparts under a new degree, such as a “Doctor of Chiropractic Therapy” (DCT) or a “Chiropractic Manual Therapist” (CMT). I suggested that it would not be necessary for chiropractors to practice as “doctors”—they could practice as therapists offering non-surgical, drug-free treatment for back pain and related musculoskeletal problems, a new specialty combining use of manipulation with physical therapy modalities. Needless to say, this change never occurred and I was labeled a “chiropractic heretic”—or worse—by my colleagues.
Today, the educational requirements for obtaining a degree in chiropractic have improved. Most chiropractic college applicants now have undergraduate degrees. But the basic definition of chiropractic has not changed. As currently defined by the North American Association of Chiropractic Colleges, “Chiropractic is concerned with the preservation and restoration of health, and focuses particular attention on the subluxation,” indicating that the majority of chiropractors may still adhere to a basic version of the subluxation theory. Few chiropractic college graduates may be able or willing to abandon a belief system they must depend upon for an income.
Filling a Need for Manual Therapy
At the present time, spinal manipulation is still not as readily available in medical practice as it should be, leaving an opening for the services of a good─albeit rare─science-based chiropractor who combines manipulation with physical therapy modalities. But it would be necessary for such a chiropractor to openly renounce the chiropractic vertebral subluxation theory (more of a belief than a theory) and publicly state that his or her practice is limited to care of musculoskeletal problems. Unfortunately, as indicated by the paradigm of the North American Association of Chiropractic Colleges, such chiropractors may be in the minority, even among recent graduates─at least in the United States.
High-velocity, low-amplitude (thrust type) spinal manipulation is not yet commonly used by physical therapists. For this reason, orthopedists and neurologists who are familiar with manual medicine are often willing to refer back-pain patients to a good chiropractor for manipulation as well as to steer patients away from subluxation-based chiropractors. Physicians can often locate good chiropractors by reading their office notes and by talking with their patients.
Most cases of back pain are self limiting, and spinal manipulation is not often more effective than other physical treatment modalities in affecting the final outcome. But in many cases, appropriate spinal manipulation may provide more immediate symptomatic relief than other forms of therapy. And in special cases, thrust-type manipulation may be the best way to restore mobility in spines stiffened by post-traumatic adhesions or locked by muscle spasm and binding vertebral joints. For this reason, benefit may outweigh risk when manipulation is used appropriately in the treatment of carefully selected cases of mechanical-type back pain. But there is no evidence to indicate that upper neck manipulation provides more benefit than risk, considering the risk of damage to vertebrobasilar arteries.
Use of manipulation combined with instruction, massage, physical therapy, and rehabilitation may be the best way to relieve mechanical back pain and keep the patient mobile until recovery is complete—provided, of course, that treatment is based on a correct diagnosis. A science-based chiropractor who works in concert with a patient’s physician can often provide such a treatment regimen—as opposed to solo subluxation-based chiropractors whose primary concerns are locating and correcting vertebral subluxations.
Separating the Good from the Bad
Since the vertebral subluxation theory continues to form the foundation of chiropractic, it seems unlikely that the chiropractic profession will ever abandon the belief that adjusting spinal joints will restore and maintain health. Many chiropractors who say that they reject D.D. Palmer’s subluxation theory simply come up with new terminology that identifies some kind of vertebral joint “dysfunction” that allegedly affects the nervous system, thus interfering with the body’s ability to heal itself. Failure of chiropractic colleges to reject such views and make the changes needed to develop chiropractic into a musculoskeletal back-pain specialty (with commensurate changes in state laws) may simply allow chiropractic to continue as an alternative healing method, such as homeopathy or acupuncture, permitting its practitioners to treat the gamut of human ailments as “primary care providers.” It may then be necessary to depend primarily upon physical therapists for appropriate use of manipulation based on credible research. Chiropractors who can no longer tolerate the controversy associated with chiropractic can retrain as physical therapists, making good use of their training in the use of manipulation. Forty-three states now grant physical therapists direct access to patients; that is, referral from a physician is not needed.
Although I am a critic of chiropractic, I would not hesitate to offer support to a good science-based chiropractor who has separated himself or herself from the herd by expressing views that oppose the implausible treatment methods that are so prevalent among chiropractors. When I was in practice as a chiropractor, I felt an obligation to speak out so that friends, patients, and health-care professionals would not assume that my approach represented chiropractic in general. I worried that a patient who was pleased with my services might assume that treatment by any other chiropractor would be the same. Unfortunately, chiropractic treatment based on the implausible vertebral subluxation theory may be so inconsistent that treatment for any condition may range from an atlas adjustment to a sacral adjustment, all purported to be effective in improving health by removing “nerve interference.” So far, apparently reluctant to bite the hand that feeds them, chiropractic associations in the United States have failed to publicly renounce the vertebral subluxation theory or to condemn the multitude of dubious treatment methods based on subluxation theory.
Today, chiropractic treatment in America is like Forrest Gump’s box of chocolates: “You never know what you’re gonna get.”
Why the Chiropractic Vertebral Subluxation Theory Is Implausible
Scientific consensus does not support the theory that nerve interference caused by vertebral misalignment is a cause of organic disease. Spinal nerves primarily supply musculoskeletal structures. Organ function is governed by the autonomic nervous system in concert with psychic, chemical, hormonal, and circulatory factors.
The vagus nerve is an autonomic (parasympathetic) cranial nerve that originates in the brain stem and passes down through the neck and thorax to the abdomen to supply organs along its path. Preganglionic autonomic fibers, which pass through spinal segments from T1 thru L2, terminate in sympathetic trunk and splanchnic ganglia located outside the spinal column. Autonomic cranial and sacral nerves pass through solid bony openings.
The vagus nerve along with autonomic ganglia and nerve plexuses provide overlapping sympathetic and parasympathetic nerve supply from many directions to assure continued function of the body’s organs, independent of spinal nerves. This is why a transverse spinal cord injury at the C4 or C5 level can paralyze musculoskeletal structures from the neck down while involuntary functions of organs continue. With this fail-safe mechanism in place, I don’t know of any reason to believe that slight misalignment of a single vertebra or an undetectable “vertebral subluxation complex” can be a cause of organic disease as suggested by the chiropractic vertebral subluxation theory.
Spinal nerves are commonly compressed by bony spurs and herniated discs. Even the most severe compression of a spinal nerve, which may cripple the supplied musculoskeletal structures, does not cause organic disease. The sphincter muscles involved in voluntary control of bladder and bowel functions are supplied primarily by spinal nerves and sympathetic fibers that are well protected in their passage through the solid bony openings that form the sacral foramina.
When there is disc protrusion into the spinal canal, or when there is a space-occupying mass in the spinal canal compressing cauda equina spinal nerves that travel down (from the conus medullaris at the lower border of the 2nd lumbar vertebra where the spinal cord ends) to exit lumbar and sacral foramina, loss of voluntary control of bladder and bowel muscles (most commonly urinary retention) signals a medical emergency that requires the immediate attention of a neurosurgeon.
Implausible Theory Fosters Implausible Treatment Methods
The implausibility of the chiropractic vertebral subluxation theory does not provide a foundation for a consistent, replicable treatment method. As a result, vertebral subluxation theory has fostered the development of a great variety of antithetical chiropractic treatment methods designed to “remove nerve interference,” many of which do not involve use of hands-on manipulation—such as healing touch or use of a spring-loaded stylus to tap vertebrae into alignment. Such treatment methods are unrelated to legitimate use of manual manipulation in the treatment of back pain and related musculoskeletal problems.
The chiropractic (undetectable) “vertebral subluxation complex” is not the same as a true vertebral misalignment, a true vertebral subluxation, or any one of a number of joint problems that cause mechanical-type symptoms (which can often be relieved by manipulating the spine) but are not alleged to be a cause of visceral disease.
Proper treatment hinges on a proper diagnosis, which, in my opinion, is never a “vertebral subluxation complex.”

   Science and Chiropractic
Harriet Hall 
Link
In the comments to a previous blog entry, a chiropractor made the following statements:
1. Chiropractic is a science.
2. Chiropractic is based on neurology, anatomy and physiology.
3. Chiropractors are doctors of the nervous system.
4. Chiropractic improves health and quality of life.
I offered to write a blog entry on the “science” of chiropractic, and I asked him, both in the comments section and by personal e-mail, to educate me first by providing me whatever evidence he could find to support those claims. I never heard back from him, so I was left to do my own research as best I could. Here’s what I found.
Is chiropractic a science? No.
In 1895, a magnetic healer named D. D. Palmer adjusted a deaf man’s back and allegedly restored his hearing. Generalizing from this one case, he reasoned that “A subluxated vertebra… is the cause of 95 percent of all diseases. …The other five percent is caused by displaced joints other than those of the vertebral column”
He decided that when a bone was out of place, it pressed on a nerve and impaired the flow of Innate (always capitalized), his word for a mythical vitalistic force that allowed the body to heal itself. At one point he talked of establishing chiropractic as a religion.
Once he had decided what he wanted to believe, he never put his beliefs to any kind of a test. He simply proceeded to treat as many patients as possible as quickly as possible. His son B.J. was a marketing genius who established the first chiropractic school and sold chiropractic to the American public. Ironically, chiropractic no longer claims to be able to treat deafness, the condition that got it started.
This describes a cult, not a science. Sciences are not invented in a day by an individual. Sciences are based on research, testing, and verification, not on contemplation, belief, and practice. Sciences progress as new knowledge builds on old and disproven ideas are discarded. Chiropractic keeps adding new techniques (over 200 now) but never discards one. As far as I’ve been able to determine, chiropractic has never discarded anything except “nerve tracing,” the palpation of nerves unknown to anatomy. Chiropractic tries to “do” science, but even its best journals publish articles of poor quality, and in over 100 years it has made precious little progress in understanding what actually happens when they “pop” a back, which techniques are better than others, or how to predict who is likely to benefit.
Is chiropractic based on neurology, anatomy and physiology? No.
It was based on a misunderstanding of those very disciplines. Palmer didn’t understand the germ theory of disease and he didn’t have the advantage of x-rays. He thought bones were actually out of place and thought he was putting them back: x-rays eventually showed this to be false. He thought the spinal nerves controlled every function of the body: he didn’t know about hormones, and he presumed connections that anatomy has never demonstrated. He thought of nerve impulses as flowing like water through a hose, and thought pinching a nerve would impair nerve conduction downstream rather than just at the point of constriction. He got almost all the basics wrong.
Chiropractic was finally forced to admit that the BOOP (bone out of place) theory was wrong. In 1996 the Association of Chiropractic Colleges redefined the subluxation as “…a complex of functional and/or structural and or pathological articular changes that compromise neural integrity and may influence organ system and general health.”
This is not a definition a scientist could grab hold of to do research. It’s a useful fiction that allows chiropractors to treat anything they choose to treat by saying there is a subluxation.
Are chiropractors doctors of the nervous system? No.
A neurologist is a doctor of the nervous system. Chiropractors can’t do most of the things neurologists do, like prescribing anticholinesterase agents for myasthenia gravis, treating seizure disorders, or hospitalizing patients. Chiropractors really don’t have anything much to do with the nervous system: they work on the musculoskeletal system with manual adjustment techniques. If they are “straights” manipulation is all they do. If they are “mixers” they use a variety of other treatments like heat and massage.
Does chiropractic improve health and quality of life? No.
There’s no published evidence to support that idea. In fact, I found one study suggesting that chiropractors don’t live as long as other people. Despite enthusiastic claims, there is no evidence that preventive or maintenance adjustments do anyone any good.
—————–
Chiropractic is not a science, but that doesn’t mean that nothing they do is based on science. There is evidence that spinal manipulation therapy is effective for some kinds of low back pain. It is no more effective than other treatments for low back pain, but is a viable option for patients who prefer it. It is not exclusive to chiropractors, but is also used by physical therapists, physiatrists and doctors of osteopathy. In essence, the one “claim to fame” that chiropractors have is not really anything uniquely chiropractic but is a manual therapy shared with other disciplines.
There are a few chiropractors like Samuel Homola, author of Inside Chiropractic, who limit their practice to short-term treatment of musculoskeletal problems, who reject the subluxation myth, and who try to provide rational, evidence-based care. I respect them, especially the ones who have been attacked by their colleagues for speaking out in favor of science and reason.
Unfortunately the majority of chiropractors still believe the subluxation myth. Many of them aspire to be family doctors, discourage immunizations, and think they can help patients with somatovisceral problems – everything from ear infections to stomach ulcers. Some of them want to adjust your baby’s spine in the delivery room and sign you up for lifetime care. A large percentage of them practice applied kinesiology, a bogus muscle testing technique relying on the ideomotor illusion. If a new quackery comes along, you can be sure chiropractors will be among the first to jump on the bandwagon. And once in a while a patient dies of a stroke after a chiropractor applies a rapid twisting thrust to his neck and tears his vertebral artery.
Click on this link for an excellent article by a chiropractor describing what a rational chiropractor can do for you and offering tips on how to choose a chiropractor. There is also a wealth of information on the Chirobase website.

Opposing Chiropractic Vertebral Subluxation Theory
There is no credible evidence to support use of spinal manipulation to correct vertebral subluxations as a treatment for non-musculoskeletal disorders

Sam Homola on October 23, 2025
Link

My father was a chiropractor who graduated from the Palmer School of Chiropractic in Davenport, Iowa, in 1920. In 1952, I enrolled as a student at Lincoln Chiropractic College in Indianapolis, Indiana. Chiropractic was based on a theory formulated in 1895 by D.D. Palmer, a magnetic healer who claimed that 95 percent of diseases were caused by vertebral subluxations, treated by manipulating the spine. After a few semesters of mixing basic science study with chiropractic philosophy, it became apparent to me that Palmer’s subluxation theory was a tenuous belief, not supported by the laws of anatomy and physiology.
In 1963, I renounced the chiropractic subluxation theory with the publication of my book Bonesetting, Chiropractic and Cultism. In the years to follow, unable to find any credible evidence to support subluxation theory, I limited my practice to treatment of musculoskeletal problems, primarily back pain, combining use of spinal manipulation with physical therapy modalities. I continued to express my views as a critic of vertebral subluxation theory in order to protect public health and to promote development of chiropractic as a conservative musculoskeletal specialty. I stood alone in the chiropractic community, labeled as an enemy of the chiropractic profession. In fear of ad hominem attacks from subluxation-based chiropractors, who were in the majority, few chiropractors would express concern about the validity of chiropractic subluxation theory.
Subluxation Theory: A Global Consensus
On September 14-15, 2019, in Toronto, Canada, 50 researchers from 8 countries and 28 observers from 18 chiropractic organizations met in a Global Summit to determine the efficacy and effectiveness of spinal manipulative therapy for the primary, secondary, and tertiary prevention of non-musculoskeletal disorders. The conclusion of their systematic review of the literature did not support the vertebral subluxation theory:
We found no evidence of an effect of SMT [Spinal Manipulative Therapy] for management of non-musculoskeletal disorders, including infantile colic, childhood asthma, hypertension, primary dysmenorrheal, or migraine. This finding challenges the validity of the theory that treating spinal dysfunctions with SMT has a physiological effect on organs and their function. Governments, payers, regulators, educators, and clinicians should consider this evidence when developing policies about the use and reimbursement of SMT for non-musculoskeletal disorders. (Chiropractic and Manual Therapies, February 17, 2021)
Where have we heard this before?
This conclusion echoes the 2009 groundbreaking review “An epidemiological examination of the subluxation construct using Hill’s criteria of causation“. The treatise, authored by Timothy Mirtz, DC, PhD, et al, concluded:
There is a significant lack of evidence in the literature to fulfill Hill’s Criteria of Causation with regards to the chiropractic subluxation being associated with any disease process or creating sub-optimal health conditions requiring intervention. Regardless of popular appeal this leaves the subluxation constrict in the realm of unsupportable speculation. This lack of supportable evidence suggests that the subluxation construct has no valid applicability. (Chiropractic and Osteopathy, December 2009)
Samuel Homola visiting with Timothy Mirtz, DC, PhD
Vindication
These reports provide support for views I have been expressing since 1963.
In 2023, I was nominated for the international John Maddox Prize for my stand on the side of science as an embattled critic of the scientifically indefensible vertebral subluxation theory. I did not win the prize, but my nomination was an acknowledgement of my published work as a worthwhile contribution to the literature.
The profession today
Today, the chiropractic profession is divided internally by subluxation believers and subluxation deniers. Although some chiropractic colleges have backed away from subluxation theory, few have openly renounced the theory. Most state laws continue to define chiropractic as a subluxation-based profession. Properly limited chiropractors who treat musculoskeletal problems must continue to compete with subluxation-based chiropractors who embrace a broad scope of practice as a form of alternative medicine.
Like homeopathy, osteopathy, and other disciplines given birth by a belief system, factions of subluxation believers in chiropractic will persist since true believers are not subject to critical thinking or scientific analysis.


Following the Guidelines of Science: A Chiropractic Dilemma
Sam Homola on October 26, 2012
Link
Preamble: When my book Bonesetting, Chiropractic, and Cultism [full text] was published in 1963, renouncing chiropractic vertebral subluxation theory and recommending that chiropractic be developed as a subspecialty of medicine in the treatment of mechanical-type back pain, the chiropractic profession refused to acknowledge or review the book. I was labeled “an enemy of chiropractic.” If it had not been for the support I received from the science-based community, I might have had doubts about my mind set and my motives. Favorable reviews by members of the science-based community sustained me over the years; for that, I am deeply grateful. Today, still unheard by the chiropractic profession, the message of my Bonesetting book remains relevant in describing the problems of chiropractic. Although out of print, the entire book can be read online on Chirobase.org.
The Aftermath of Bonesetting, Chiropractic, and Cultism, 1963
In view of the absence of any extensive histories of chiropractic, this book has a place in medical collections and reference libraries. ─ Eric Meyerhoff, Director, The Medical Library Center of New York, N.Y.C., Library Journal, February 1, 1964
In regard to your recent application for membership in the American Chiropractic Association and insurance in the National Chiropractic Insurance Company, please be advised that the ACA membership committee has rejected your application. ─ H.W. Pruitt, D.C., Executive Secretary, American Chiropractic Association, May 17, 1965
I purchased your book some months ago on Bonesetting, Chiropractic, and Cultism. I found it to be a most intriguing and enlightening publication which has been of value to me in some of my own studies in medical anthropology. ─ James G. Roney, M.D., Ph.D., Stanford Research Institute, November 11, 1965
I was more impressed by your criticisms of chiropractic than by those of any other writer, since you are a practicing chiropractor. I think every candidate for chiropractic college should read your book, or at least every student in his first year. ─ Walter Wardwell, Ph.D., Professor of Sociology, University of Connecticut, August 26, 1976
Thank you for your book Bonesetting, Chiropractic, and Cultism. I found it well-written and most interesting. I have read quite a bit of material on the chiropractic controversy by authors on all sides of the issue. I rank your book among the very best. ─ William Jarvis, Ph.D., Associate Professor, Loma Linda University, October 22, 1976
I just re-read your chiropractic book and enjoyed it even more than I did five years ago. Your reasoning and predictions have held up remarkably. ─ Stephen Barrett, M.D., Lehigh Valley Committee Against Health Fraud, July 28, 1979
Unfortunately unknown to most chiropractors, and unavailable at many if not most chiropractic college libraries, Bonesetting, Chiropractic, and Cultism is must reading for chiropractic historians….Perhaps the profession will finally seek out this seer before his most dire predictions come to pass. ─ Joseph Keating, Ph.D., Professor, Palmer College of Chiropractic-West, Dynamic Chiropractic, January 3, 1990
Fifty years ago, you already expressed some of the things few dare write today! If chiropractic had had more people like you early on, it would be a respectable profession today. ─ Edzard Ernst, M.D., Ph.D., Professor, Peninsula Medical School, England, January 12, 2010
“…the Main Trouble with Chiropractic Is Chiropractic Itself.”(Bonesetting, Chiropractic, and Cultism, 1963)
This morning, I saw an advertisement by a chiropractor who claims that he has had “great success” treating patients suffering from chronic illnesses and neuropathy. He treats patients by adjusting misaligned vertebrae to “relieve pressure on nerves and restore whole body wellness.”
Unfortunately, such advertisements are common and unchallenged, reflecting a theme typical of a pseudoscientific alternative healing method.
I don’t know of any reason to believe that adjusting a misaligned or “subluxated” vertebra to remove nerve interference will improve health or cure an organic ailment. If you follow the guidelines of science, the chiropractic vertebral subluxation theory appears to be a tenuous belief system, far removed from a legitimate theory based on accepted knowledge that can be studied or explained. When I was being taught subluxation theory in chiropractic college, the anatomy and physiology textbooks I studied led me to question subluxation theory. It quickly became apparent to me that the body’s organs are innervated primarily by autonomic nerve ganglia and plexuses located outside the spinal column, supplied largely by autonomic cranial and sacral nerves that pass through solid bony openings and by preganglionic spinal cord fibers. The very important vagus nerves traverse openings in the base of the skull and travel down to supply thoracic and abdominal organs. Overlapping autonomic nerve supply from many directions and sources, along with chemical, hormonal, and circulatory factors, assures function of the body’s organs, unaffected by a segmental dysfunction (subluxation) and independent of spinal nerves that are designed primarily to supply musculoskeletal structures. Spinal nerves are commonly compressed by disc herniation and osteophyte formation, affecting the peripheral and musculoskeletal structures they supply, but such “pinched nerves” have never been associated with ill health or organic disease.
Despite increasing educational requirements for enrollment in a chiropractic college and inclusion of adjunctive treatment methods in chiropractic care, the basic principles of chiropractic have not changed much, persisting largely because of their simplicity in attracting and educating patients. Locating a “subluxation” in the spine and then pointing to a nerve chart linking the subluxation to an organ or a disease process rarely fails to impress a prospective patient. Adjusting the spine to produce a pop that signals correction of an alleged subluxation, or simply telling the patient that a subluxation has been corrected, is a powerful form of suggestion that produces a placebo effect.
Clinging to the theory that gave the chiropractic profession birth and independence, chiropractic associations and state laws continue to define chiropractic as a method of adjusting vertebral subluxations to restore and maintain health, guided by a modified version of vertebral subluxation theory (“vertebral subluxation complex”) to justify a broad scope of practice. A 2010 publication of the National Board of Chiropractic Examiners (NBCE), Practice Analysis of Chiropractic, states that “The specific focus of chiropractic practice is known as the chiropractic subluxation or joint dysfunction. A subluxation is a health concern that manifests in the skeletal joints, and, through complex anatomical and physiologic relationships, affects the nervous system and may lead to reduced function, disability, or illness.” This definition of chiropractic is in keeping with a paradigm formulated by the Association of Chiropractic Colleges (ACC) in 1996, signed by 16 North American chiropractic college presidents: “Chiropractic is concerned with the preservation and restoration of health, and focuses particular attention on the subluxation.”
Such subluxations have never been proven to exist. A review of web sites and advertisements sponsored by recent graduates of chiropractic colleges, however, reveals that subluxation-based chiropractic care is still very much in vogue. A 2011 study reported that “Despite the controversies and paucity of evidence the term subluxation is still found often within the chiropractic curricula of most North American chiropractic programs.” (Mirtz & Perle. The prevalence of the term subluxation in North American English-Language Doctor of Chiropractic programs. Chiropractic and Manual Therapies. 2011;19:14)
Many students enrolling in chiropractic colleges today have undergraduate degrees. How can a chiropractor with a bachelor’s or master’s degree in science subscribe to what appears to be a scientifically indefensible subluxation theory?
Critical Thinking vs. Pseudoscience
Many people with a good education profess support for views based on a belief system, especially in the areas of healing and religion. I suspect that some advocates of pseudoscience are not capable of critical thinking and are simply products of the most persuasive voice they hear. An inherent ability to reason and think independently may be more important than an academic degree in the makeup of a science-based skeptic. In my own profession as a chiropractor, I was often amazed to see chiropractors with advanced academic degrees touting vertebral subluxation theory. While some of these practitioners were undoubtedly marketing a belief system for economic reasons, fully aware of the impropriety of their actions, it appeared to me that some of them were well-meaning but misinformed or simply did not understand what they had been taught.
In 1998, the year of my retirement, the January issue of the American Medical Association’s Archives of Family Medicine published my article, “Finding a Good Chiropractor,” designed to help family physicians distinguish between the good and the bad in the use of manipulation by chiropractors. My book Inside Chiropractic, A Patient’s Guide, was published by Prometheus Books in 1999. I explained why I thought the chiropractic subluxation theory was false. I supported use of generic spinal manipulation as a modality in the treatment of some types of back pain. Unlike homeopathy and some other dubious healing methods that have no value whatsoever beyond a placebo effect, spinal manipulation as a form of manual therapy has some plausible basis for relieving back pain and restoring mobility.
Speaking Out Against Nonsense
I wrote many articles critical of chiropractic and subluxation theory. The biggest splash of all came when the April 2001 online edition of Medscape General Medicine published my article “Is the Chiropractic Subluxation Theory a Threat to Public Health?” previously published in the winter 2001 issue of Scientific Review of Alternative Medicine. I was inundated with hate mail. A spokesperson for the American Chiropractic Association described my article as “outdated and inaccurate” and asked Medscape to remove the article from their website. In September of 2005, Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research, a leading peer-reviewed journal for orthopedic surgeons, published my article “Chiropractic: History and Overview of Theories and Methods,” a review that took a critical look at chiropractic based on subluxation theory.
Apparently reflecting the views of the majority, chiropractic associations have not renounced subluxation theory. Failure of the chiropractic profession to make the changes needed in the curriculum of chiropractic colleges to define the practice of chiropractic as a properly-limited specialty has kept the profession marginalized and mired in pseudoscience. Development of chiropractic as a physical-treatment method sans subluxation theory would lead to appropriate legal definitions of chiropractic. But the simplicity of chiropractic subluxation theory and its public appeal may make it difficult to change state laws in order to eliminate judiciary support for “adjusting vertebral subluxations to restore and maintain health.” If subluxation theory is not rejected by a chiropractic majority that is supported by public opinion, subluxation-based chiropractic will be perpetuated along with homeopathy, acupuncture, naturopathy, naprapathy, and other questionable but legally licensed alternative healing methods.
(Three states allow licensing of an MD or a DO as a homeopathic physician, but many states allow licensed health-care providers such as chiropractors and naturopaths to use homeopathic remedies. Forty-four states and the District of Columbia license practitioners of acupuncture and oriental medicine, all of which is considered to be within the scope of practice of most health-care providers, especially chiropractors. Naturopathic physicians are licensed in 16 states, the District of Columbia, and the U.S. territories of Puerto Rico and the Virgin Islands. Naprapathy, founded in the early 1900s by a chiropractor, advocates manipulation of joints and muscles to correct problems alleged to be caused by connective tissue disorders. Naprapathic physicians are licensed only in Illinois and New Mexico. There appears to be no shortage of practitioners who practice “alternative medicine,” which seems to be gaining public acceptance under the label of “complementary” or “integrative” medicine, reflecting public demand for nonsensical care along with conventional medical care.)
It has been estimated that “Chiropractors perform about 90 percent of manipulation in the United States” (The Appropriateness of Manipulation and Mobilization of the Cervical Spine, RAND, 1996). With the public equating use of manipulation with chiropractic care, manipulation in general has been stigmatized by its association with chiropractic subluxation theory. Increasing use of spinal manipulation by physical therapists and orthopedic manual therapists, however, offers opportunity to bypass questionable chiropractic care when seeking appropriate treatment with spinal manipulation. Credible research, most often conducted by physical therapists, offers support for use of manipulation as part of the treatment armamentarium of physical medicine.
Critics of chiropractic should take care not to include appropriate use of generic spinal manipulation in their criticism of chiropractic manipulation based on subluxation theory. As I have said many times, manipulation used to relieve pain and restore mobility is not the same as a chiropractic adjustment used to “restore and maintain health.” An asymptomatic and undetectable chiropractic subluxation alleged to affect general health is not the same as an orthopedic subluxation, a partial dislocation that can cause musculoskeletal symptoms. Generic spinal manipulation as a form of manual therapy (and the word “subluxation”) existed long before the development of chiropractic in 1895. Hippocrates, in describing methods of reducing “dislocations” in the spine (On the Articulations), noted that “luxations and subluxations take place in different degrees.”
Choosing between Chiropractic School and Physical Therapy School
While there are undoubtedly some chiropractors who use spinal manipulation appropriately and do a good job treating mechanical-type neck and back pain, I would not recommend that anyone enroll in a chiropractic school where there might be indoctrination in a belief system that is rejected by the scientific community and shaded by societal suspicion. Some chiropractic colleges are less subluxation-centered than others but may embrace controversial alternative healing methods. A properly limited chiropractor who might be a graduate of one of the better chiropractic schools, and who is aware of his or her limitations, would be forced to endure the nonsense and the competition of licensed unscientific alternative healers and subluxation-based chiropractors who set the standards, ostracizing nonbelievers and alienating the cooperation of mainstream health-care professionals.
Persons interested in studying manipulative therapy would be best served by going for a Doctor of Physical Therapy (DPT) degree that would allow interaction with the scientific community in researching and performing manual therapy without the stigma associated with chiropractic. At the present time, 47 states and the District of Columbia permit direct access to services provided by physical therapists, allowing private practice that fits in with mainstream health care.
All things considered, with the status and the future of chiropractic in doubt, I would not think that any well informed person following the guidelines of science today would choose to be a Doctor of Chiropractic rather than a Doctor of Physical Therapy.
When confronted with two courses of action I jot down on a piece of paper all the arguments in favor of each one─then on the opposite aside I write all the arguments against each one. Then by weighing the arguments pro and con and canceling them out, one against the other, I take the course indicated by what remains.
    • ─ Benjamin Franklin, circa 1732

The Council on Chiropractic Education Straightens Up?
Jann Bellamy on December 12, 2013
Link
Three years ago, we reported that the Council on Chiropractic Education (CCE) was deeply embroiled in a heated dispute among various chiropractic factions over its new accreditation standards for chiropractic colleges. In a June, 2012 update of that post, we found the CCE still deeply embroiled in a heated dispute among various chiropractic factions over new accreditation standards for chiropractic colleges. Current events, however, require that we now report that the CCE remains deeply embroiled in a heated dispute among various chiropractic factions over new accreditation standards for chiropractic colleges. And it has come to this:
Ostensibly, the debate is about whether chiropractic students should be taught to detect and correct the putative subluxation and CCE’s commitment to chiropractic’s remaining a drug and surgery-free practice. As we have discussed several times here at SBM, a faction of chiropractors fancy themselves as primary care physicians who are competent to diagnose and treat patients with a wide variety of diseases and conditions, such as diabetes and cardiovascular disease, with various methods, such as “Functional Endocrinology.” This is, in fact, the position of the largest and most mainstream of the chiropractic trade associations, the American Chiropractic Association (ACA). (The ACA is actively promoting reimbursement of chiropractors for required primary care benefits under the Affordable Care Act.)
At the other end of the spectrum, the chiropractic purists (or “straights”) believe chiropractors should limit themselves to the detection and correction of the (non-existent) chiropractic subluxation. And they are adamant about chiropractic remaining “without drugs or surgery.”
Protestations to the contrary notwithstanding, chiropractic belief in the subluxation is widespread among chiropractors in North America and in Australia. And as far as I can tell, chiropractors who eschew belief in the subluxation have merely renamed it and redefined it in terms so vague as to be meaningless. Those who want to expand chiropractic to include a broader range of treatments do not exclude the subluxation as a relevant clinical entity. They’ve simply tarted it up in an attempt to obscure its lack of scientific viability. 
The CCE on probation
The Council on Chiropractic Education, which accredits all 15 U.S. chiropractic colleges, has become a surrogate battlefield on which these skirmishes are fought. Usually chiropractors manage to stay on group message in their public persona. This unified front is facilitated by their isolation – their schools operate outside the mainstream American higher education system and their practices generally operate outside the mainstream healthcare system. No one really knows what they are up to. But because the CCE must renew its recognition as an accrediting agency with the U.S. Department of Education (Education) every three years, the public gets a peek inside.
The National Advisory Committee on Institutional Quality and Integrity (NACIQI) conducts the recognition process for Education. Its staff looks into whether an accrediting agency under review is meeting Education’s standards. The staff issues a report to the NACIQI, which, after a public hearing, makes a recommendation to Education. The straight chiropractic faction perennially uses CCE’s re-recognition by Education as an opportunity to harp on the CCE’s move (as seen by the straights) away from traditional chiropractic toward the “medicalization” of the practice. Because, in the straight’s view, the more liberal end of the chiropractic spectrum controls the CCE for its own purposes, the CCE is unrepresentative of the entire profession and the schools teaching traditional chiropractic philosophy. And this view has received some sympathy from at least one NACIQI member, who said in a 2006 hearing on the CCE’s continued recognition:
[S]ome of this, maybe most of it, is a consequence of, at least as I see it, a monopoly control of a profession which has led to the establishment of a virtual cartel.”
This led the dissidents henceforth to refer to the chiropractic powers that be as “The Cartel.” When CCE came up for recognition renewal again, in 2011, battle lines were drawn.
NACIQI received about 4,000 letters on the subject, only 30 of which were positive. At a December, 2011, hearing, in addition to staff and CCE representatives, 25 others who represented the broad range of chiropractic practice testified (e.g., the ICA, ACA and Association of Chiropractic Colleges). Of these, representatives of 2 spoke in favor of the CCE and 23 against.
The staff report was unflattering too. It found over 40 deficiencies in applicable standards for re-recognition, which garnered CCE the dubious distinction of being in the top tier of accrediting agencies in violation of Education’s standards. According to The Chronicle of Chiropractic (“The Source for News on Traditional, Conservative Chiropractic”):
Arthur J. Rothkopf, president emeritus of Lafayette College and vice chairman of NACIQI told CCE, “You’ve hit the jackpot on deficiencies,” noting that the problems enumerated by the department suggest a “sloppiness” in CCEs actions as an accreditor.
(To give you an idea of where The Chronicle is coming from, it carries an ad seeking support for the “National Vaccine Information [Mis] Information Center.” So, if you ever need proof that chiropractors are anti-vaccination, here’s your citation.)
The NACIQI recommended a one-year extension of the CCE’s recognition so they could clean up their act. In addition, the NACIQI imposed a requirement that the CCE become more representative of the entire profession. This delighted the protesters. While the Undersecretary of Education agreed with NACIQI on all other points, it said the Department had no authority to impose this additional requirement. The CCE was to issue a full report in one year, at which time there would be another staff evaluation and hearing. The Undersecretary warned the CCE that further extensions were rare and that it could lose accreditation if CCE didn’t straighten up. Later, another hearing before the NACIQI was set for December 12-13, 2013. (That is, starting today.)
The dissenters circle their prey
The CCE thus weakened in the eyes of the straights, they set to work. They formed their own coalition of organizations named the “Da Vinci Group,” ironic in light of Leonardo Da Vinci’s meticulous study of anatomy. According to one member, the International Chiropractic Pediatrics Association (ICPA), the Group is a coalition of “at least” 70 chiropractic organizations. The most robust of these is the International Chiropractors Association (ICA), the official trade association for the straight faction, which provided funding to form the Group and emerged as a natural leader for the organization, an involvement that led to later disappointments, as we shall see.
The Group is now circulating a petition:
To be meaningful, CCE reform must include, but not be limited to the following elements:
1) Vertebral subluxation detection and reduction, stated in unambiguous terms, in both symptomatic and asymptomatic patients must be included in the CCE Standards as the essential element in a curriculum leading to the Doctor of Chiropractic degree.
2) Chiropractic must be defined as “without drugs and surgery” in the Standards. [“Drugs” means OTC as well as prescription drugs.]
3) Governance reform of the CCE including: [briefly, reforms in elections and an expansion of site teams which inspect schools for the CCE].
Note the “in both symptomatic and asymptomatic patients” language. In other words, the Group is demanding that students be taught “maintenance care,” sometimes referred to as “wellness care.” This is based on the chiropractic philosophy that all patients, including newborns, suffer from subluxations throughout their lives. If not reduced by adjustments (or manipulation, a term they use interchangeably with adjustment) these subluxations interfere with the nervous system’s regulation of the body, resulting in health problems, including heart disease, sudden infant death syndrome, allergies, asthma – you name it.
While the Da Vinci Group didn’t want to see the CCE killed as the recognized accrediting agency, it did want to put it on life support for one more year while Education decided whether to pull the plug for good. The Da Vinci Group members would argue to the NACIQI that if CCE were re-accredited, it should only be for another year, either by extension of its probation or a shortened recognition time. During that time, the Group could use CCE’s tenuous grip on life to leverage its own position.
A defection to the Cartel
Things were going along swimmingly when, in November of this year, ICA broke ranks as a result of an offer during the November meeting of yet another chiropractic group, The Summit. The Summit apparently consists of some groups (the CCE, the ACA, etc.) the dissidents would refer to as the Cartel, but the ICA is also a member. (Other professions have subgroups based on specialty, e.g., the American Academy of Pediatrics, the America Bar Association Section of Anti-Trust Law. Chiropractic apparently groups itself according to factions.)
At that meeting, the Summit decided it would endorse continued recognition of the CCE and issued a statement saying so. In what appears to be an attempt to soothe, or at least quiet, the dissenters, the statement said:
After multiple focus groups, the following marketing language was passed: The Summit acknowledges the concepts of spinal health and well-being as credible marketing messages and we encourage further efforts to refine and test such efforts.
Which is an interesting thing to say smack dab in the middle of a document explaining a group’s position on the governance of the chiropractic educational system. Perhaps it inadvertently reveals something about the focus of chiropractic education.
Relevant to charges that the CCE and other chiropractic organizations were being wishy-washy about drugs:
no chiropractic organization in the Summit promotes the inclusion of prescription drug rights and all chiropractic organizations in the Summit support the drug-free approach to health care.
So now we have yet another subdivision of chiropractic. A sub-faction of the mixers, the DC as PCP group, wants the privilege of prescribing drugs, although they are not generally the type of drugs any medical doctor would ever think about using on patients. They’ve achieved some success in New Mexico but were rebuffed in Colorado. And now they’ve been rejected by the Summit, although maybe “multiple focus groups” could change the Summit’s mind if prescription drugs become a “credible marketing message.”
The CCE, in front of all the other Summit members at the meeting, offered to engage in good-faith discussions addressing the ICA’s (as well as some other Summit member’s) concerns about CCE’s governance. The ICA president also “spoke with” the CCE leadership about including the Da Vinci Group in these conversations. In exchange, the ICA would temper its testimony against CCE at the December NACIQI hearing, not oppose re-recognition, and not limit its support of recognition to one year.
The Group regroups
The rest of the DaVinci Group was not amused. (One headline in the chiropractic press read: “ICA Endorses CCE . . . Move Shocks DaVinci.”) Accusations went flying. Chiropractic had managed to split into yet another set of factions. The Group viewed ICA’s action as joining The Cartel for sure. Claims and counter-claims were made about the effect of the CCE’s loss of accreditation status on federal student loans (a big cash cow for chiropractic colleges) and state licensing (many states defer to the CCE accreditation in deciding whether to accept a degree from a particular chiropractic college in determining eligibility to practice).
The ICPA sent out a urgent “Call to Action” e-mail to members bemoaning the CCE Standards’ “ambiguous” language on the subluxation and lack of a clear stance against drugs and surgery. It asks, rhetorically:
Do you want the freedom to effectively care for your patients, to proficiently adjust spines of all ages and offer the best possible chiropractic care too all: symptomatic or not? Do you desire research that substantiates the role of the adjustment in wellness and improved quality of life?
Yes, after all, what is the goal of research other than to tell you you’re doing everything exactly right?
In the midst of all this, the DaVinci Group suffered another blow when the NACIQI staff report was released in advance of the current hearing. Staff found that CCE had indeed straightened up. Staff recommends renewal of CCE’s recognition for a period of three years. All parties appear to be in agreement that NACIQI will adopt the recommendation and CCE’s recognition is assured.
If you are looking for some insight into chiropractic education from this 45-page report, forget it. To me, it reaffirms the notion that schools teaching black magic could form the Council on Black Magic Education accrediting agency and get that agency approved by the U.S. Department of Education as long it complied with financial, conflict of interest and like standards. It doesn’t matter WHAT you teach. Once again, the staff blew off complaints about the subluxation’s supposedly dwindling role and the “medicalization” of chiropractic education. But the dissidents remain undeterred.
So what? Who cares?
If you want to judge chiropractic education, look at chiropractic practice. As noted at the beginning of this post, practice is still mired in the subluxation, whether the original or new, murkier, multi-name version. Best I can tell, what has been added to practice in the name of “progress” are silly tests for “nutritional deficiencies,” homeopathy, claims that chiropractors are primary care physicians, acupuncture, and other treatments which lack a grounding in science. Frankly, I don’t care who wins this fight, or all the sub-fights within the main event. For me, their value is in providing a rare public glimpse into what transpires in the world of chiropractic.
What I do care about is the fact that millions of patients are spending millions of dollars on worthless diagnoses and treatments at the hands of chiropractors. The federal government’s approval of the CCE only serves to facilitate this unconscionable state of affairs. And it makes the taxpayer foot part of the bill, in the form of student loans. All in all, a terrible waste of money that could be going to improve healthcare in a meaningful way.

The Council on Chiropractic Education reaffirms the subluxation, backs off primary care (sort of)
The subluxation lives on in new chiropractic education standards.
Jann Bellamy on August 4, 2026
Link

The U.S. Council on Chiropractic Education (CCE) has been at the center of a years-long battle among various factions of chiropractors who have competing ideas of just what chiropractic is and what chiropractors should, and should not, do. This ranges from straight, subluxation-based chiropractic practitioners all the way to the equally absurd chiropractor-as-primary-care-physician clique.
Because the CCE must establish common educational requirements for all U.S. chiropractic schools, it has been forced to try to accommodate these competing factions. Today, we take a look at the CCE’s 2026 Accreditation Standards and see how it tries to thread the needle this time.
But first, we’ll review a bit of the history of this battle for the soul of chiropractic and CCE’s role in it.
As explained in my last post (on the crisis in “naturopathic medicine”), the U.S. Department of Education farms out accreditation of higher education institutions to private organizations which, by law, are supposed to ensure that those institutions meet “acceptable levels of quality”.
Unfortunately, as we shall see, the Department does not require a science-based education to meet its “quality” benchmark, even for purported health care professions. Hence, the CCE is free to include pseudoscience in its standards. (And, as we shall also see, it does.)
To become a licensed chiropractor, states require graduation from a CCE-accredited chiropractic school. Thus, whatever the CCE decides is a “quality” chiropractic education gets foisted upon the rest of us, via the magic of Legislative Alchemy. Some state practice acts even more fully embrace the CCE’s dictates, incorporating whatever chiropractic schools teach into their legal scope of practice. (More on this in a moment.)
The War
With that, let’s go to war.
We begin way back in 2010, in a post titled The DC as PCP?:
The long-simmering internecine wars among various factions of chiropractic recently reached a full boil when the . . . (CCE) had the audacity to eliminate the word ‘subluxation‘ from its draft 2012 ‘Standards for Doctor of Chiropractic Programs.’
In an update, I reported:
As you may recall, the CCE . . . stood accused of removing the subluxation from its standards for accreditation, so that chiropractic students would no longer be required to learn how to ‘detect’ and ‘correct’ the putative vertebral subluxation. . . . This brouhaha was raised by the more traditional wing of the chiropractic community, called ‘straights,’ whose practice (and livelihood) is based on convincing patients that their spines need ‘adjustments’ to remove these subluxations under the threat of ill health should they be left unattended. The straights were also upset at the move by another faction of chiropractic seeking to rebrand chiropractors as primary care physicians who diagnose and treat a wide variety of diseases and conditions.
The “straights” went so far as to register their complaints with the Department of Education during its review of CCE, which gave the Department an opportunity to officially announce its apathy towards science. Removal of the term “subluxation” from CCE standards, it said, was
a professional issue within the chiropractic community. Staff concludes that it is beyond the purview of the Department to dictate to any [accrediting] agency what its curriculum requirements and accreditation standards should be.
Subsumed in the argument over retaining the subluxation were skirmishes over what to call it and how to “correct” it.
One CCE draft proposed “subluxation/neuro-biomechanical dysfunction”, which, a mere two years later, it changed to “subluxations/segmental dysfunction”. A sect whose motto is “Vertebral Subluxation . . . Nothing More . . . Nothing Less . . . Nothing Else” didn’t like either one.
And then there was the controversy over exactly how to remove these non-existent subluxations. Regarding a draft of CCE standards proposed for 2013:
For the first time, apparently, the CCE has included what they call a ‘meta-competency’ requirement in adjusting/manipulation, which pleases the ICA [the International Chiropractors Association, an organization of ‘straight’ chiropractors.] The fly in this ointment is that the skill required is not just ‘adjustment’ but ‘adjustment/manipulation.’ According to the ICA, they are not the same thing. The ICA is correct. ‘Adjustment’ has always referred to a method of ‘correcting’ the phantom subluxation. Other professions perform manipulation, or, as the ICA would prefer to call it, ‘other forms of manual care,’ but, as the ICA says, ‘only doctors of chiropractic administer chiropractic adjustments.’ The reason is that no other profession believes the chiropractic subluxation exists or, obviously, that it can be ‘adjusted,’ but they don’t bring this up.
And so the battle raged, for years, with groups and sub-groups within groups, coming together in common cause when convenient to their mission, then splitting and reconstituting their alliances as their special interests dictated. Along with the ICA, the American Chiropractic Association, the International Federation of Chiropractors and Organizations, the International Chiropractic Pediatrics Organization, the Association of Chiropractic Colleges, state chiropractic associations, the incongruously-named DaVinci Group (“a coalition of ‘at least’ 70 chiropractic organizations”), The Summit (another multi-group coalition), the Cartel (a derogatory name bestowed by one group on another), and so on, all duked it out.
And all this over what to call, and how to treat, a condition that doesn’t exist, and whether to teach this phantom phenomenon to students.
Primary care
As hard as the “straights” have pushed to preserve the subluxation, another faction of chiropractors has dedicated itself to the ridiculous notion that chiropractors are “primary care physicians”, which, as noted above, infuriated the straight chiropractors. The American Chiropractic Association (ACA), the lobbying and PR arm of the chiropractic industry, has been at the forefront of this effort.
Along the way, the “primary care” proponents have used a variety of tactics to push their agenda.
The ACA created an ersatz “board certification” for “diplomates” in “chiropractic internal medicine”, calling practitioners “chiropractic internists”. To become a “diplomate”, a chiropractor attends 300 hours of weekend courses, mostly online, taught by faculty ridiculously unqualified to teach the offered subject matter, like cardiovascular disease, gastroenterology, endocrinology, and dermatology.
In addition, chiropractors have pushed for expansion of state scope of practice laws beyond manual manipulation of the spine to correct “subluxations”, to include diagnostic testing and health (including nutrition) advice, which can be parlayed into a “functional medicine” practice.
Another tactic is to amend their scope of practice to include anything chiropractors are taught in chiropractic school, a pet project of the ACA, which at one time was vigorously lobbying to include prescription privileges in practice acts as well.
Some schools are fully on board. The National University of Health Sciences (NUHS) chiropractic program claims, for example, that it
prepares students to become first-contact, primary care physicians fully qualified to diagnose, treat and manage a wide range of conditions.
NUHS offers “specialty” concentrations in “Functional Medicine” and “Women’s Health”.
Let’s pause for a moment and state the obvious here: the notion that chiropractors are appropriately educated and trained to practice as primary care physicians is ludicrous. The late, great Dr. Harriet Hall, an actual primary care physician herself (family practice), demolished that notion back in 2012 in the aptly-titled Chiropractors as Family Doctors? No Way! and again the next year in her review of Chiropractic Education for Primary Care.
Yet by 2012, the “DC as PCP” model had won out. According to the CCE:
An accredited DCP [Doctor of Chiropractic degree Program] prepares its graduates to practice as primary care chiropractic physicians . . .
The CCE further defined “primary health care” as:
Care that is provided by a health care professional in the patient’s first contact within a health care system that includes an examination and evaluation, diagnosis and health management. A Doctor of Chiropractic practicing primary health care is competent and qualified to provide independent, quality, patient-focused care to individuals of all ages and genders . . .
But just 6 years later, in the 2018 standards, the term “primary care” disappeared from the accreditation standards, although its ghost lingered in language used to describe what chiropractic students must be prepared to do in practice, and “meta-competencies” that must be taught.
Accreditation requirements . . . prepare DCP graduates to serve as competent, caring, patient-centered and ethical doctors of chiropractic/chiropractic physicians qualified to provide independent, quality, patient-focused care to individuals of all ages and genders . . . managing the patient’s health care and integrating health care services including treatment, recommendations for self-care, referral and/or co-management.
So, without limitation to the musculoskeletal system in general or the spine in particular, the chiropractic student must be able to compile a patient history, examine “body regions and organ systems”, and perform and utilize diagnostic studies, all “for the purpose of constructing a differential diagnosis” and “develop a management plan appropriate to the diagnosis/es”.
To be sure, examination and evaluation of “any subluxation/segmental dysfunction” (as it is called at this point) and delivery of “appropriate chiropractic adjustments/manipulations” is included, but nothing limits the chiropractic student to those tasks.
Thus, the CCE gave chiropractic programs plenty of wiggle room to teach some ersatz version of primary care, or at least venture well beyond the musculoskeletal system, without actually using the term “primary care”.
And today?
In January, the CCE released yet another version of its accreditation standards (there was also a new version in 2021).
Note: Before we get to the matter at hand, and although not the subject of this post, interestingly, in 2026 the CCE dropped its GPA minimum from 3.0 to 2.75 if the applicant has 24 science credits among the 90 credit hours required for admission without an undergraduate degree. Alternatively, a bachelor’s degree (in no particular subject) is acceptable without any minimum GPA. And, for the first time, a hard number – 1,000 hours – was added for clinical training.
The standards retain the slippery language of former iterations, permitting non-musculoskeletal differential diagnoses (including diagnostic testing) and treatment for “all individuals of all ages and genders” and “managing the patient’s health care”, but with no mention of “primary care”. In sum, the CCE-accredited NUHS and like-minded schools have nothing to fear in promoting chiropractors as PCPs.
And the subluxation lives on! As with previous standards, an entire “meta-competency” requirement is devoted to “CHIROPRACTIC ADJUSTMENT/MANIPULATION” because “Doctors of chiropractic employ the adjustment/manipulation to address joint and neurophysiologic dysfunction”, so they must be able to “identify subluxations/segmental dysfunction of the spine and/or other articulations”, one of two mentions of the subluxation in the entire document. Yep, let’s educate like it’s 1895!
The CCE, again as with previous versions, signals that it doesn’t care if a school chooses to teach straight-up, Palmerian, subluxation nonsense:
The CCE values educational freedom and institutional autonomy. The CCE does not define or support any specific philosophy regarding the principles and practice of chiropractic, nor do the CCE Standards support or accommodate any specific philosophical or political position. The Standards do not establish the scope of chiropractic practice.
So, basically, something for everyone. More of the same. And nothing good for the public.
s

Chiropractic: A Summary of Concerns
Sam HomolaonApril 2, 2014
Link

Although obscured by controversy, there is evidence to indicate that spinal manipulation can be as effective as conventional treatment methods in relieving low-back pain.1,2,3,4 This grain of truth mixed with chiropractic vertebral subluxation theory that encompasses a broad scope of ailments makes it difficult for the average person to distinguish between appropriate and inappropriate use of manipulation by chiropractors. A person who is satisfied with chiropractic manipulative treatment for back pain might be led to believe that the same treatment can be used to treat a variety of organic ailments by correcting “vertebral subluxations.” Such treatment is usually described as a “chiropractic adjustment.”
A manual chiropractic adjustment
Although chiropractic care based on subluxation theory has been rejected by the scientific community, spinal manipulation used in the treatment of mechanical-type back pain has a plausible basis that makes it acceptable in mainstream healthcare. A good back-cracking back rub provided by a chiropractor or some other manual therapist can be a pleasurable, pain-relieving experience, and this can be a preferred method of treatment for some types of back pain. But you should be well-informed enough to know where to draw the line in separating subluxation-based chiropractic adjustments from appropriate use of generic spinal manipulation if you should consider treatment by a chiropractor. Otherwise, you might become the victim of the bait-and-switch tactics of chiropractors who offer you treatment for back pain and then attempt to indoctrinate you in subluxation theory.
Much of what follows in this article has been said before in other articles of mine posted on this site. An up-to-date summary of basic concerns about chiropractic care, however, might be useful for new readers and others, including professionals, who want a brief overview for quick reference in seeking answers to questions about the problematic aspects of chiropractic use of spinal manipulation.
Subluxations do not affect general health
The vertebral subluxation theory that gave birth to the chiropractic profession proposed that 95 per cent of diseases are caused by displaced vertebrae that place pressure on spinal nerves.5 Today, chiropractic is defined as a method of adjusting a “vertebral subluxation complex,” an asymptomatic and undetectable “joint dysfunction” (involving nerves, muscles, connective tissues, blood vessels, and other factors) alleged to influence organ system function and general health.6 There is no credible evidence to support the chiropractic theory that joint dysfunction or a vertebral subluxation in any form can affect general health or cause internal organs to become diseased. Spinal nerves are commonly compressed by bony spurs and herniated discs. Even the most severe compression of a spinal nerve, which may cripple the supplied musculoskeletal structures, does not cause organic disease. In the absence of fracture or pathology such as disc herniation or osteophyte formation, vertebral misalignments rarely affect spinal nerves.
Spinal nerves supply the sensory and motor (voluntary) functions of musculoskeletal structures. Involuntary function of the body’s organs is regulated by autonomic nerve ganglia and plexuses located outside the spinal column and by autonomic cranial and sacral nerves that pass through solid bony openings. The vagus nerves are autonomic (parasympathetic) cranial nerves that originate in the brain stem, traversing openings in the base of the skull to pass down through the neck, thorax, and abdomen to supply organs along their path. Preganglionic autonomic fibers, which emerge from the spinal cord and pass through spinal segments from the first thoracic vertebra to the second lumbar vertebra, terminate in sympathetic trunk and splanchnic ganglia located outside the spinal column. The vagus nerves along with autonomic ganglia and nerve plexuses provide overlapping sympathetic and parasympathetic nerve supply from many directions and sources (in concert with chemical, hormonal, and circulatory factors) to assure continued function of the body’s organs, independent of spinal nerves.7 This is why severance of the spinal cord in the neck area, shutting off brain impulses to spinal nerves, can cause paralysis of muscles from the neck down while the body’s organs continue to function. Transplanted organs function without reconnection of severed nerves.
A serious transverse spinal cord lesion above C5 (upper neck) can cause respiratory paralysis and often death. Since the spinal cord ends at the level of the 2nd lumbar vertebra, spinal nerves pass down from the spinal cord (like the hair on a horse’s tail) to exit openings between the lumbar vertebrae and from openings in the sacrum. The spinal nerves supplying bladder and bowel sphincter muscles pass through the solid bony openings of the sacrum (a pelvic bone at the bottom of the spine) and are not subject to compression by a subluxation. But they can be compressed by protrusion of a lower lumbar disc into the spinal canal, affecting voluntary control of sphincter muscles (cauda equina syndrome).
A chiropractic vertebral subluxation or “joint dysfunction” alleged to cause disease by interfering with nerve supply to organs cannot be demonstrated and cannot be equated with a real orthopedic subluxation, a partial dislocation that causes musculoskeletal symptoms. Spinal manipulation, massage, and other forms of manual therapy can have some temporary neurological and physiological effects that might be beneficial in relieving back pain symptoms. But there is no evidence to indicate that such effects have a significant affect on general health.
“One of the key ‘selling points’ for chiropractic care is the anatomically impossible premise that your spinal nerve roots are important to your general health.”8 An excellent, reader-friendly discussion of this subject can be found on PainScience.com via the reference for this quotation.
Despite the implausibility of chiropractic subluxation theory, which is more a belief than a theory, state laws and chiropractic publications in the United States continue to define chiropractic as a method of correcting vertebral subluxations to restore and maintain health.9
Alternative chiropractic care
Although the public generally thinks of chiropractors as back specialists, few chiropractors limit their care to treatment of back pain. The vague and all-inclusive chiropractic subluxation theory generates a hodgepodge of entrepreneurial techniques and treatment methods for a variety of ailments. Treatment methods vary from one chiropractor to another, and are often incompatible with interchange in mainstream health care. According to the Association of Chiropractic Colleges, chiropractic is associated with the field of complementary and alternative medicine as a method of improving and preserving health.10 The profession has chosen not to seek development as a scientifically acceptable musculoskeletal specialty, despite the fact that back pain and musculoskeletal conditions are the No. 1 and No. 2 causes of disability worldwide.11 Some chiropractic colleges offer decent instruction in the care of musculoskeletal problems but are tainted by subluxation theory that encompasses a broad scope of ailments. Physicians who refer patients to chiropractors for spinal manipulative therapy must be cautious in selection of a chiropractor, and they must take responsibility for the diagnosis, lest inappropriate treatment makes them vulnerable to liability for damages. Care must also be taken to make it clear that referral to a selected chiropractor who uses manipulation appropriately is not an endorsement of subluxation-based chiropractic.
Subluxation theory perpetuated as a belief system
There are no indications that subluxation theory, the foundation of chiropractic, will ever be discarded by all chiropractors. With no plausible or scientific rationale to support it, subluxation theory will be perpetuated as a belief system. Putative chiropractic subluxations that are not detectable by conventional methods are allegedly being located by such dubious procedures as thermography, applied kinesiology, and leg-length checks. Dozens of different techniques are used to correct such subluxations. Some chiropractors use a spring-loaded stylus in an attempt to tap vertebrae into alignment in order to “restore the integrity of the nervous system.” Upper cervical chiropractors believe that aligning the atlas (the vertebra at the top of the spine) will “influence the central nervous system and brain stem function” as well as realign vertebrae from the neck down.12
While there are some good chiropractors who offer a service of value in the care of back pain, combining appropriate use of spinal manipulation with other physical treatment methods, it would certainly seem advisable to avoid the services of any chiropractor who proposes to treat a health problem by adjusting vertebral subluxations. Physical therapists who use mobilization or generic spinal manipulation to relieve pain and restore mobility in an injured area of the spine are more likely to use manipulation appropriately than a chiropractor who adjusts every patient to remove “nerve interference” caused by an asymptomatic “vertebral subluxation complex.” A subluxation-based chiropractor may even manipulate the neck as a treatment for low-back pain.12 Since upper cervical manipulation has been associated with stroke caused by injury to vertebral arteries, neck manipulation should be reserved for a carefully selected, albeit rare, neck problem for which there is no other viable treatment option. Manipulative techniques that involve rotating the head to force rotation of upper cervical structures should not be used. Risk certainly outweighs benefit when neck manipulation is used routinely to correct chiropractic subluxations.13
Note: Mobilization moves joints through normal ranges of movement. Manipulation forces movement of a joint beyond a normal range, often into a paraphysiologic space where there may be slight separation of joint surfaces (cavitation) to produce a popping sound. Manipulation can produce popping sounds in normal joints. Such popping is not considered to be significant, but it can have a powerful placebo effect among those who believe that the popping sound signals correction of a disease-causing subluxation. Unfortunately, some chiropractors allow their patients to believe that a popping sound means that vertebral subluxations are present, producing a nocebo effect that lures chiropractic patients into a program of regular spinal adjustments in an attempt to maintain health by keeping their vertebrae aligned.
The bottom line
There is no credible evidence to support use of spinal manipulation for anything other than uncomplicated mechanical-type back pain and related neuromusculoskeletal problems. There is no evidence at all to support chiropractic subluxation theory. It has never been demonstrated that a real orthopedic subluxation or a pinched spinal nerve can affect general health or that an undetectable “vertebral subluxation complex” can cause organic problems.14 If you are looking for a chiropractor who offers spinal manipulation as an option in the treatment of back pain, look for one who does not subscribe to subluxation theory ─ one who is willing to exchange office notes with your family physician. Remember that most of the time, acute low-back pain is a self-limiting condition that will resolve in four to six weeks, with or without treatment. Appropriate treatment can, however, relieve symptoms and speed recovery. When back pain grows progressively worse, persists unrelieved for longer than a week, or is worsened by rest, there may be cause for alarm. Chiropractic care should not be continued for longer than two to four weeks if there is no measured improvement. A correct diagnosis is essential when considering treatment options. Treatment based on correction of an alleged chiropractic vertebral subluxation complex may result in unnecessary chiropractic adjustments for nonexistent or unrelated problems, delaying appropriate treatment based on a correct diagnosis. I don’t know of any reason to manipulate the immature, cartilaginous spine of a neonate or an infant as some pediatric chiropractors are doing.15
References
     1.  Rubinstein, Sidney M., Marienke van Middelkoop, Willem J.J. Assendelft, et al. 2011. Spinal manipulative therapy for chronic low-back pain: an update of a Cochrane review. Spine. 36(13):E825-46. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21593658 Accessed February 17, 2014.
     2.  Rubinstein, Sidney M., Caroline B. Terwee, Willem J.J. Assendelft, et al. 2013. Spinal manipulative therapy for acute low-back pain: an update of the Cochrane review. Spine. 38(3):E158-77. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23169072 Accessed February 17, 2014.
     3.  National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine. 2012. Spinal manipulation for low-back pain: What the science says. NCCAM Clinical Digest. May. http://nccam.nih.gov/health/providers/digest/chronic-low-back-pain-science Accessed February 6, 2014.
     4.  Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. 2010. Complementary and Alternative Therapies for Back Pain. http://www.ahrq.gov/research/findings/evidence-based-reports/backcam2tp.html Accessed February 6, 2014.
     5.  Palmer, Daniel David. 1910. The Chiropractor’s Adjuster: A Textbook of the Science, Art, and Philosophy of Chiropractic for Students and Practitioners. Portland, Oregon. Portland Printing House.
     6.  Association of Chiropractic Colleges. Chiropractic Paradigm. http://www.chirocolleges.org/paradigm_scope_practice.html Accessed February 6, 2014.
     7.  Homola, Samuel. 2006. Chiropractic: History and Overview of Theories and Methods. Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research. 444:236-242. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/16446588 Accessed April 2, 2014.
     8.  Ingraham, Paul. 2014. Spinal Nerve Roots Do Not Hook Up to Organs! https://www.painscience.com/articles/spinal-nerves-and-organs.php Accessed November 26, 2014.
     9.  Bellamy, J.J. 2010. Legislative alchemy: The U.S. state chiropractic practice acts. Focus on Complementary and Alternative Therapies. 15(3):214-222. http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.2042-7166.2010.01032.x/abstract Accessed April 2, 2014.
     10.  CCE. An open letter to the profession from the Council on Chiropractic Education. November 22, 2011. http://www.acatoday.org/pdf/CCE_Letter.pdf Accessed February 6, 2014.
     11.  Vos, Theo, Abraham D. Flaxman, Mohsen Naghavi, et al. 2012. Years lived with disability (YLDs) for 1160 sequelae of 289 diseases and injuries 1990-2010: a systematic analysis of the Global Burden of Disease Study 2010. The Lancet. 380(9859):2163-2196. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23245607 Accessed April 2, 2014.
     12.  Homola, Samuel. 2009. The problem with chiropractic NUCCA. Science-Based Medicine. August 7. https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/index.php/the-problem-with-chiropractic-nucca/ Accessed February 6, 2014.
     13.  Homola, Samuel. 2009. Neck Manipulation: Risk vs. Benefit. Science-Based Medicine. August 27. https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/neck-manipulation-risk-vs-benefit/ Accessed February 6, 2014.
     14.  Mirtz, Timothy A., Lon Morgan, Lawrence H. Wyatt, et al. 2009. An epidemiological examination of the subluxation construct using Hill’s criteria of causation. Chiropractic and Manual Therapies. 17:13. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19954544 Accessed April 2, 2014.
     15.  Homola, Samuel. 2010. Pediatric Chiropractic Care: Scientifically Indefensible? Science-Based Medicine. https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/pediatric-chiropractic-care-scientifically-indefensible/ Accessed February 6, 2014.

The Enigma of Chiropractic: A Brief Review with a Perspective on Chiropractic as a Specialty
Sam Homola on September 27, 2015
Link


Much of what is discussed in this article has been said before in previous articles I have written for Science-Based Medicine. But since the audience for SBM has greatly increased over the past few years, some subject matter should be repeated for the new readers and researchers coming to this site for reliable information on health care.
Many consumers now search SBM for articles dealing with controversial alternative treatment methods that have been shown to be ineffective or to be loaded with fraud and quackery. Chiropractic in particular continues to be problematic for its failure to renounce the scientifically indefensible, nonfalsifiable subluxation theory that defines the profession as a whole. A review of chiropractic web sites reveals that many chiropractors continue to base their treatment methods on subluxation theory, encompassing a broad scope of health problems. Some chiropractors are now including use of “functional medicine” which uses “natural tools” to treat diabetes, thyroid disease, neuropathy, and other diseases best treated by conventional medical care. Most alarming of all is the treatment of infants and children by “pediatric chiropractors.” Chiropractors are being certified in 10 different specialties, including a diplomate in Diagnosis and Internal Disorders.
As long as chiropractic is licensed as a health-care profession based on subluxation theory or some other unscientific approach, it will continue to be subjected to scrutiny and criticism by the science-based community. It is, in fact, the moral and ethical responsibility of science-based practitioners to oppose any form of unscientific health care, wherever it might exist, separating sense from nonsense without being influenced by politics, special interest, pseudoscience, or belief systems.
Legal recognition vs. science
The vertebral subluxation theory that defines the chiropractic profession has been rejected by the scientific community. Yet, chiropractic has gained public acceptance and licensure as a profession capable of treating both physical and organic ailments. Some chiropractors claim to be primary care providers, despite use of a limited treatment method. Chiropractic’s primary treatment, the spinal adjustment, is described as a modality used to improve health by correcting vertebral subluxations that are interfering with nerve supply to the body’s organs. While spinal manipulation might have value as a complementary procedure or as a treatment option in the care of mechanical-type neck and back problems, a distinction should be made between appropriate use of generic spinal manipulation and the questionable use of chiropractic adjustments to restore and maintain health.
Legal recognition of chiropractic as a health-care profession has generated considerable confusion in the public’s perception of the role of manual therapy in health care. Subluxation theory defining use of manipulation by chiropractors has allowed the proliferation of practitioners who promote a variety of nonsensical treatment methods that are the antithesis of generally accepted medical care. Separated from the mainstream of health care, chiropractic is being presented as a form of alternative medicine, competing with primary care physicians as well as with physical therapists who offer manual therapy for musculoskeletal problems. In the absence of any apparent movement by the chiropractic profession to police its ranks, it is important that the general public be made aware of the controversy surrounding subluxation-based chiropractic care.
The implausibility of subluxation theory
There is no credible evidence to support the contention that a vertebral subluxation, a joint dysfunction, or compression of a spinal nerve can cause nerve interference that will affect general health or cause organic disease.1,2 A simple review of anatomy and the nervous system seems to provide enough evidence to refute subluxation theory.
Spinal nerves are commonly compressed by bony spurs and herniated discs. Compression of a spinal nerve can cripple supplied musculoskeletal structures but does not cause organic disease. In the absence of pathology such as disc herniation or osteophyte formation, vertebral misalignments rarely affect spinal nerves. The body’s organs are supplied primarily by autonomic nerve ganglia and plexuses located outside the spinal column and by autonomic cranial and sacral nerves that pass through solid bony openings,3 providing overlapping nerve supply that is unaffected by slight misalignment of a vertebra or by a dysfunctional spinal segment.
Defining chiropractic
The chiropractic profession continues to cling to the theory that gave it birth and independence. State laws defining chiropractic as a method of restoring and maintaining health by adjusting vertebral subluxations to remove nerve interference remain unchallenged.4
According to a 2015 publication by the National Board of Chiropractic Examiners in the United States:
The specific focus of chiropractic practice is known as the chiropractic subluxation or joint dysfunction. A subluxation is a health concern that manifests in the skeletal joints, and through complex anatomical and physiological relationships, affects the nervous system and may lead to reduced function, disability, or illness.5
Some definitions of chiropractic avoid use of the word “subluxation,” referring instead to nerve interference as a cause of disease. Such interference is often attributed to a “vertebral subluxation complex” involving changes in nerve, muscle, connective tissue, and vascular tissues without actual displacement of a vertebra.6 Although chiropractic subluxation theory has evolved from a bone-on-a-nerve theory to a more complex description involving “a complex of functional and/or structural and/or pathological articular changes that compromise neural integrity and may influence organ system function and general health,” 7 the theory is no less implausible. An asymptomatic chiropractic subluxation alleged to be a cause of disease (not to be confused with a real orthopedic subluxation that causes musculoskeletal symptoms) is generally considered to be an imaginary lesion.
It is important to remember that subluxation-based chiropractors often genuinely believe that they can restore and maintain health by adjusting the spine and will often advise their back-pain patients that every member of the family needs regular spinal adjustments to stay healthy. For this reason, physicians and science-based chiropractors should openly advise against subluxation-based chiropractic care, especially when recommending chiropractic care for back pain. Unfortunately, chiropractic associations might be reluctant to renounce the nerve interference aspect of subluxation theory, which would require a change in legislation that supports the licensure and livelihood of thousands of chiropractors.
If the mission of chiropractic colleges is not changed sufficiently to produce a chiropractic majority that opposes subluxation theory, laws and the belief system defining the practice of chiropractic will not change.
Appropriate use of spinal manipulation
Systematic reviews of the literature on the use of manipulation in the treatment of back pain indicate that spinal manipulative therapy may not be any more effective than other recommended therapies.8,9 A 2012 systematic review of the effectiveness of spinal manipulation provided by physical therapists in the treatment of low back pain concluded: “Based on the findings of this systematic review there is evidence to support the use of spinal manipulation by physical therapists in clinical practice. Physical therapy spinal manipulation appears to be a safe intervention that improves clinical outcomes for patients with low back pain.”10
I suspect that future research will identify specific mechanical-type back problems for which judicious use of spinal manipulation might be the treatment of choice in relieving pain and restoring mobility. Some back-pain patients simply prefer the pleasurable, relaxing effects of hands-on manipulation and massage. Patient satisfaction coupled with the immediate, albeit temporary, effects of spinal manipulation is reason enough to support inclusion of spinal manipulative therapy as complementary care or as a treatment option in the physical treatment armamentarium of any therapist or practitioner who treats back pain — without subluxation theory, of course.
Unfortunately, the Chiropractic Paradigm of the Association of Chiropractic Colleges, which “focuses particular attention on the subluxation,”7 is echoed in a 2015 survey of North American chiropractic students, “a majority of whom would like to see an emphasis on correction of vertebral subluxations.”11 Regardless of scientific developments in the use of spinal manipulation, it appears that subluxation-based chiropractic will be perpetuated as a belief system.
Back-care specialty, an opportunity missed
While opinions describing chiropractic range from “quackery” to “miracle healing,” many people think of chiropractors as back doctors since they manipulate the spine for what is commonly believed to be a vertebra out of place. A 2015 Gallup poll (“Americans’ Perceptions of Chiropractic“) reported that the majority (61%) of American adults agree that chiropractors are effective at treating neck and back pain.
“When given a choice of five different healthcare providers they might see about neck and back pain, regardless of cost, slightly more than half of adults (54%) say a medical doctor would be their first choice, followed by 29% saying they would most like to see a chiropractor. Less than 10% would prefer to see a physical therapist, massage therapist or acupuncturist for neck or back pain.”12 Although a majority agreed that chiropractic is an effective treatment for neck and back pain, only 29% of polled respondents would choose chiropractic for such care, perhaps reflecting low confidence in treatment provided by chiropractors.
Despite the public’s perception that chiropractors treat neck and back pain, and the fact that back pain and musculoskeletal problems are the No. 1 and No. 2 causes of disability worldwide,13 chiropractic has failed to fill a niche as a specialty providing conservative care for mechanical-type back pain. There are some good chiropractors who use generic manipulation appropriately in a practice limited to care of back pain and related musculoskeletal problems, and they can offer a service of value. It appears, however, that the chiropractic profession as a whole may have missed an opportunity to abandon subluxation theory and make the changes needed to become a legitimate mainstream musculoskeletal back-care specialty based on science, the common denominator that unites mainstream health-care professionals. An increasing number of physical therapists are now being trained in the use of science-based spinal manipulation, offering an alternative to subluxation-based chiropractic manipulation.
Some chiropractors identify themselves as spine specialists, a designation often used by orthopedists who have the facilities and the means to handle any kind of spine problem. Since chiropractors cannot offer medication to relieve acute back pain and do not have access to the hospital facilities needed to treat a serious, incapacitating back injury or to diagnose back pain of unknown origin, chiropractic care cannot always be appropriate for back pain or a spine problem. A science-based chiropractor who offers conservative care for uncomplicated back pain would be compelled to refer certain acute back-pain patients to medical providers for pain relief, for hospitalization, or for a hospital-based diagnostic procedure. A correct diagnosis indicating disease, infection, or neurological complications would require immediate referral to a medical specialist.
A chiropractic “spine specialist,” subluxation-based or not, is obviously not capable of independently handling back pain across the board. No specialty can function in the best interest of the patient without the cooperation of mainstream health-care professionals, a position unattainable by chiropractic in its present form.
Chiropractic specialties vs. medical specialties
Despite the limitations of chiropractic treatment methods and the isolation of chiropractic from mainstream health care, the American Chiropractic Association (ACA) endorses 10 post-graduate programs offering diplomate certification in specialties for chiropractors:
    • Chiropractic Pediatrics
    • Chiropractic Physical and Therapeutic Rehabilitation
    • Chiropractic Acupuncture
    • Diagnosis and Internal Disorders
    • Diagnostic Imaging
    • Neurology
    • Nutrition
    • Occupational Health
    • Sports Physician
    • Orthopedics
With the exception of Diagnostic Imaging, which requires a full-time 3-year residency in a chiropractic college, certification in these specialties is obtained by attending 300 to 400 hours of classroom instruction in 26 sessions of 12-hour weekends over a period of 3 years.14 Such part-time classroom instruction cannot begin to compare with a full-time residency program in a hospital setting that lasts 3 to 7 years after graduation from medical school, depending upon the specialty. An additional 1 to 3 years of training is required for a subspecialty.15
Resisting what the chiropractic profession considers to be a demeaning identification as a back specialty, it appears that the profession has taken the untenable position of competing with medical specialties, using spinal adjustments as the primary treatment method. According to an executive of the ACA’s Council on Diagnosis and Internal Disorders, a chiropractic internist with a DABCI certification (Diplomate American Board of Chiropractic Internists) can treat everything from allergies to thyroid problems to fatigue as a primary care physician:
We do laboratory workups, blood chemistries, adrenal and hormone testing, GI function studies, EKGs. We treat everything from allergies to thyroid problems to fatigue. It makes us more of a family doctor, not in the sense that we always take care of the whole family, but we can take care of all that ails them….If I’m adjusting somebody and not getting them better, [my training] gives me a broader range of things to look at as to what it might be.14
While post-graduate study offered to chiropractors is commendable for its value in expanding the knowledge base of the individual practitioner, specialty certification in a chiropractic classroom cannot compare or compete with a board-certified hospital-based medical specialty that requires thousands of hours of training. A chiropractic specialty certainly does not justify or excuse use of chiropractic adjustments based on vertebral subluxation theory, and it is no less questionable under the label of alternative medicine or integrative medicine.
State laws defining chiropractic as a method of adjusting vertebral subluxations do not permit chiropractors to use many of the tests and procedures implied to be part of a chiropractic specialty. Medicare coverage of chiropractic services, defined by federal law, is specifically limited to manual manipulation of the spine to correct a subluxation (demonstrated to exist) causing a related neuromusculoskeletal problem; no other diagnostic or therapeutic service furnished by a chiropractor or under the chiropractor’s order is covered.

As we men of medicine grow in learning we more justly appreciate our dependence upon each other. It has become necessary to develop medicine as a cooperative science, the clinician, the specialist and the laboratory workers uniting for the good of the patient. The people will demand, the medical profession must supply, adequate means for the proper care of patients, which means that individualism in medicine can no longer exist.16
Dr. Will Mayo (1861-1939)
References
     1.  The College of Physicians and Surgeons of Quebec. The Scientific Brief Against Chiropractic. The New Physician. 1966. http://www.chirobase.org/05RB/CPSQ/00.html. (Accessed August 19, 2015)
     2.  Mirtz, TA, Morgan L, Wyatt LH, Greene L. 2009. An epidemiological examination of the subluxation construct using Hill s criteria of causation. Chiropr Man Therap. 17:13. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19954544 (Accessed August 30, 2015)
     3.  Homola S. Chiropractic: History and Overview of Theories and Methods. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2006. 444:236-242.
     4.  Bellamy JJ. Legislative alchemy: The U.S. state chiropractic practice acts. Focus Alternat Complement Ther. 2010 Sept;15(3):214-222.
     5.  Christensen MG, Hyland JK, Goertz CM, Kollasch MW, Shotts BL, Blumlein NL, et al. Practice Analysis of Chiropractic 2015. National Board of Chiropractic Examiners. Greeley, Colorado. May 2015. p5. http://www.nbce.org/practiceanalysis/ (Accessed September 21, 2015)
     6.  Rosner AL. The Role of Subluxation in Chiropractic. 1997. Foundation for Chiropractic Education and Research. p2
     7.  Association of Chiropractic Colleges. Chiropractic Paradigm. http://www.chirocolleges.org/paradigmscopepractice.html. (Accessed August 30, 2015)
     8.  Rubinstein SM, van Middelkoop M, Assendelft WJ, de Boer MR, van Tulder MW. Spinal manipulative therapy for chronic low-back pain: an update of a Cochrane review. Spine. 2011; 36(13):E825-46. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21593658 (Accessed September 21, 2015)
     9.  Rubinstein SM, Terwee CB, Assendelft WJ, de Boer MR, van Tulder MW. Spinal manipulative therapy for acute low back pain: an update of the Cochrane review. Spine. 2013; 38(3):E158-77.
     10.  Kuczynski JJ, Schwieterman B, Columber K, Knupp D, Shaub L, Cook CE. Effectiveness of physical therapist administered spinal manipulation for the treatment of low back pain: a systematic review of the literature. Int J Sports Ther. 2012;7(6):647-662. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3537457/ (Accessed September 21, 2015)
     11.  Gliedt JA, Hawk C, Anderson M, Ahmad K, Bunn D, Cambron J, et al. Chiropractic identity, role and future: a survey of North American chiropractic students. Chiropr Man Therap. 2015;23.4. http://www.chiromt.com/content/23/1/4 (Accessed August 30, 2015).
     12.  English C, Keating E. Majority in U.S. say chiropractic works for neck, back pain. Gallup. September 8, 2016. http://www.gallup.com/poll/184910/majority-say-chiropractic-works-neck-back-pain.aspx? (Accessed September 8, 2015).
     13.  Vos T, Flaxman AD, Naghavi M, Lozano R, Michaud C, Ezzati M, et al. Years lived with disability (YLDs) for 1160 sequelae of 289 diseases and injuries 1990-2010: a systematic analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study 2010. Lancet. 2012; 15;380(9859):2163-96.
     14.  American Chiropractic Association. Chiropractic Specialties on the Rise. https://www.acatoday.org/content_css.cfm?CID=2323 (Accessed August 28, 2015).
     15.  American Medical Association. Requirements for Becoming a Physician. http://www.ama-assn.org/ama/pub/education-careers/becoming-physician.page? (Accessed August 30, 2015).
     16.  Clapesattle, Helen. The Doctors Mayo. Garden City Publishing Company. Garden City, New York, 1943.

Questions and Answers about Chiropractic: The Bottom Line
Sam Homola on October 19, 2014
Link

I am often asked, “What do chiropractors do?” That’s not an easy question to answer. The answer is usually expected to be, “They treat back trouble.” But as alternative medicine practitioners, chiropractors do a lot of things, and they treat a variety of ailments, based largely on a scientifically-invalid vertebral subluxation theory which proposes that nerve interference resulting from a misaligned vertebra or a dysfunctional spinal segment can affect general health.
As a co-host of the Chirobase web site, I frequently answer questions about chiropractic, some of which are published in a section titled “Consumer Strategy/Consumer Protection.” In this post, I’ll focus on these:
    • Are Subluxations Causing My Health Problems?
    • Is a Misaligned Atlas Causing My Back Pain?
    • What is that “Thumper” My Chiropractor Uses on My Back?
    • How Does a Chiropractor Locate Subluxations?
    • Should I Let a Chiropractor Adjust My Baby?
    • Why Is Every Chiropractor’s Treatment Different?
    • Can Neck Manipulation Cause a Stroke?
    • Should I Go to a Chiropractic College?
    • Are There Any Good Chiropractors?
    • Is It Possible to Reform the Chiropractic Profession?
By far, most of the questions I receive express concern about questionable methods and advice offered in the offices of chiropractors. Many questions are generated by the suspicions of patients who initially visited a chiropractor for treatment of back pain and who were then offered spinal adjustments as a treatment for health problems unrelated to the spine. Patients are often concerned about the expense involved in such care, usually extended over a long period of time, followed by “maintenance care” to correct or prevent “vertebral subluxations” after symptoms have resolved. I generally advise patients to refuse chiropractic care for anything other than a musculoskeletal problem, to seek treatment only when symptoms are present, never pay for treatment in advance, and to discontinue treatment and see an orthopedic specialist if symptoms worsen after a few days or have not subsided after a week or so.
Are subluxations causing my health problems?
No. Unfortunately, the chiropractic vertebral subluxation theory sounds plausible to medically untrained persons. When a chiropractor explains the subluxation theory, holding up a real spine and then pointing to a nerve chart showing spinal nerves connecting with all the body’s organs, along with a list of diseases caused by “nerve interference,” few lay persons are knowledgeable enough to question the theory. The truth is that spinal nerves supply musculoskeletal structures. The body’s organs are supplied by ganglia (some of which receive preganglionic fibers from the thoracolumbar portion of the spine) and plexuses in a separate autonomic nervous system located outside the spinal column and by the all-important vagus (cranial) nerves which pass down from openings in the base of the skull to supply thoracic and abdominal organs. Hearing, sight, and other functions involving structures in the head are supplied by cranial nerves which pass through openings in the skull. Autonomic fibers supplying pelvic viscera pass through solid bony openings in the sacrum at the bottom of the spine. Obviously, the well-protected autonomic nervous system, so essential to life, is not threatened by a vertebral subluxation.
A spinal nerve is rarely compressed by a misaligned vertebra. When a spinal nerve is compressed, usually by disc herniation or osteophyte formation, symptoms occur in the musculoskeletal structures supplied by the affected nerve but the body’s organs are not affected. Severance of the spinal cord at or above the 4th cervical vertebra, shutting off brain impulses to spinal nerves, can cause paralysis of muscles from the neck down while the body’s organs continue to function.
Although the original theory of chiropractic defines a subluxation as a vertebral misalignment that places pressure on a spinal nerve, more recent theories define a subluxation as a “vertebral subluxation complex” that affects nerve, blood vessel, and connective tissue structures in a spinal segment, causing nerve interference without misalignment of a vertebra. Both types of subluxations are alleged to affect general health; neither has been proven to exist. Nevertheless, it is common practice among chiropractors to treat a health problem by adjusting the spine to “realign the vertebrae” or to “remove nerve interference.”

This is a portion of an old Meric System chart that assigns certain vertebrae to certain organs and diseases; it ignores the cranial nerves which pass through openings in the skull. Some subluxation-based chiropractors still use this chart to determine which vertebrae to adjust when treating an organic problem. “Up-to-date” chiropractic upper cervical specialists, however, claim that simply adjusting the atlas to remove pressure on the brain stem will “restore perfect health” (www.nucca.org).
Is a misaligned atlas causing my back pain?
One of the most common and exasperating questions I receive comes from chiropractic patients who have been told that misalignment of the atlas, the uppermost neck vertebra, is the cause of a great variety of ailments from the neck down, including low-back pain. Frightened by scare tactics that predict dire consequences from atlas misalignment that allegedly presses on the brain stem, patients are often reluctant to discontinue treatment they have been led to believe will prevent the development of illness.
When the atlas is not locked or fixated by injury or disease and is freely movable, its resting place is dictated by the anatomical configuration of joint surfaces and cannot be changed. When the atlas is moved by manipulation, it always returns to its normal resting place. Atlas “subluxations” found in the necks of persons who are not having a neck problem are usually the result of measuring structural asymmetry and are not significant.
Patients are always relieved to hear that their atlas is not out of place and that they do not need atlas adjustments to restore or maintain their health. An atlas misalignment is certainly not a cause of low-back pain.
What is that “thumper” my chiropractor uses on my back?

Once a patient has been convinced that his or her spine harbors vertebral subluxations that can cause disease or affect general health, any one of dozens of chiropractic adjustive techniques might be used to correct and prevent recurrence of such subluxations. One of the most bizarre methods of adjusting the spine uses a handheld instrument with a spring-loaded or electrically powered mallet or stylus to tap on selected vertebrae. A dubious leg-length check might be used to determine if correct alignment has been restored, a procedure so implausible that it is the subject of many of the letters I have received from chiropractic patients.
Some computerized adjusting instruments use a piezoelectric sensor that will allegedly locate and correct a vertebral subluxation by analyzing the echo of an oscillating force applied to a vertebra. Such an instrument has proved to be an effective way to sell chiropractic care and is often advertised as “advanced chiropractic technology.” While some chiropractors genuinely believe that the vertebral subluxation theory is valid, subluxation-based “chiropractic technologies” have more to do with marketing than with health care.
How does a chiropractor locate subluxations?
Chiropractors generally locate subluxations by measuring x-ray images of vertebral misalignment caused by degenerative changes or structural abnormality, such as disc degeneration or spinal curvature. Such “subluxations” are usually asymptomatic and not significant. Subluxation-based chiropractors might use such “advanced technology” as computerized surface electromyography (not the same as needle electromyography used by neurologists) that prints out brightly colored charts measuring electrical activity in muscles, alleged to indicate the presence of vertebral subluxations. Some use thermography that measures an elevation in skin temperature believed to be associated with vertebral subluxations. Applied kinesiology (not the same as the science of kinesiology) is a nonsensical way of locating subluxations by testing arm strength before and after a spinal adjustment; it is also used to detect the presence of disease and vitamin deficiency. Many chiropractors claim to be able to find vertebral subluxations by palpating the spine, that is, by using fingertips to feel vertebrae.
All such subluxation-detection devices and procedures are as dubious as the subluxation theory that prompts their use.
Remember that a real orthopedic subluxation, a partial dislocation, causes musculoskeletal symptoms and is not the same as an asymptomatic chiropractic vertebral misalignment (subluxation) or an undetectable “vertebral subluxation complex” alleged to be a cause of bad health.
Should I let a chiropractor adjust my baby?
No! When I see a chiropractor palpate the spine of an infant or a neonate in a search for subluxations, I suspect either fraud or woeful ignorance. There is no way that a chiropractor can find a subluxation by palpating the fat-padded cartilaginous spine of a newborn baby. Following up such an examination with an attempt to correct vertebral alignment by manipulating the baby’s spine is unnecessary and dangerous.
There has been some speculation that manipulating the immature spine of an infant or a small child might damage the soft, cartilaginous growth centers in the vertebrae, resulting in the development of pre-adolescent spinal deformity, such as scoliosis or Scheuermann’s kyphosis (O’Neal 2003) — a speculation worth considering since there is no reason to believe that manipulating the spine of a small child is ever helpful or indicated.
Why is every chiropractor’s treatment different?
The techniques of manual generic spinal manipulation performed by science-based practitioners are pretty much the same, no matter who does the manipulation, whether done by a chiropractor, a physical therapist, an osteopath, or a physiatrist. Spinal manipulation, called a “spinal adjustment,” performed by subluxation-based chiropractors, however, may involve dozens of different techniques, each one different from the other, some of which do not require manual manipulation of the spine, none of which are compatible with conventional manual therapy.
Chiropractic: An Illustrated History, published in 1995 by Mosby-Year Book, listed 97 different chiropractic techniques, ranging from Activator Technique to Zindler Reflex Technique. When a patient goes from one chiropractor to another, each using a different technique that is claimed to be superior to the other, an apparent lack of standards would suggest that it might be best to bypass the chiropractor and seek manipulative care from a physical therapist or an orthopedic manual therapist.
Can neck manipulation cause a stroke?
Questions often arise about the safety of neck manipulation and the possibility of such treatment causing a stroke. With an increasing number of case reports associating neck manipulation with stroke caused by injury to vertebral and internal carotid arteries, there is good reason to question the use of neck manipulation, no matter who does it. When the neck is forcefully rotated in passive manipulation, the greatest amount of rotation takes place in the atlantoaxial joints in the upper cervical portion of the spine. There is reason to believe that extreme rotation of these joints during thrust manipulation can overstretch or injure the vertebral arteries and cause stroke, affecting the posterior portion of the brain.
Since there is little or no evidence that benefit outweighs risk when manipulating upper cervical structures, it is generally best to avoid such treatment. Unfortunately, many chiropractors, especially “upper cervical specialists,” manipulate the neck of every patient they treat in a misguided effort to correct alleged vertebral subluxations.
Should I go to a chiropractic college?
I occasionally receive letters from undergraduate students who are considering enrolling in a chiropractic college, asking which college is best. I also receive letters from chiropractic students who are beginning to doubt what they are being taught in chiropractic class rooms. There are a number of reasons why I generally advise against attending a chiropractic college, the first and foremost of which is the scientifically indefensible chiropractic subluxation theory that isolates the chiropractic profession from mainstream health care, keeping it marginal and controversial. Rejection by healthcare professionals in the scientific community, combined with the aggressive competition of subluxation-based chiropractors, makes it difficult to succeed in practice as an ethical, properly-limited chiropractor. Failure in private practice leads to unpaid student loans and very little opportunity for employment outside of private practice.
In January of 2012, the Health Resources and Services Administration (HRSA) reported that chiropractic schools had a much higher default rate on student loans than other health professional schools. More than half of the individuals on HRSA’s default list attended chiropractic school. Societal suspicion, refusal of accredited academic institutions to recognize chiropractic, the competition of physical therapists who now use manipulative therapy, and uniform criticism by the scientific community has had an adverse effect on chiropractic colleges and the income of chiropractors in private practice (who treat less than 10 percent of the population annually). A November 2012 Gallop Poll reported that only 38% of respondents rated the honesty and ethical standards of chiropractors as high, with a 70% rating for medical doctors.
According to the U.S. Department of Commerce, the average gross income per chiropractic office between January1992 and December 2007 rose at less than half the rate of inflation. This loss of purchasing power makes it difficult to justify the high cost of opening an office today if such an operation does not yield adequate income.
Enrollment in chiropractic colleges in the United States dropped precipitously─35 percent─between 1995 and 2002 and has since flat lined. As a result of a decline in the enrollment of students in chiropractic schools and a reduced demand for chiropractic services, a few chiropractic schools have labeled their institutions as a “University of Health Sciences,” including programs offering degrees or certificates in such subjects as acupuncture, Ayurvedic medicine, naturopathic medicine, oriental medicine, and massage, all of which, with the exception of massage, are questionable practices sheltered under the umbrella of alternative medicine.
My heart goes out to those ethical and well-meaning chiropractors who discover too late that they must suffer embarrassment and financial strain in years of struggle that may or may not lead to a successful practice. If I could have advised them beforehand, I would have suggested that they pursue a doctor of physical therapy degree, which would provide opportunity to use manipulative therapy along with other physical treatment methods, without dogma, societal suspicion, or rejection by the scientific community.
Are there any good chiropractors?
I am often asked why I am always badmouthing chiropractors and if I think that there are any good chiropractors. I always respond by saying, “Yes, but they are hard to find.” A chiropractor who limits care to musculoskeletal problems, with emphasis on the care of mechanical-type neck and back pain and related problems, can offer a service of value if he or she does not subscribe to chiropractic vertebral subluxation theory.
Believing that chiropractors are back specialists, patients sometimes request referral to a chiropractor. It has been my observation that physicians are often receptive to referral of a back-pain patient to a properly-limited chiropractor who offers appropriate manipulative therapy that is not readily available in local physical therapy establishments. The availability of a good chiropractor can provide physicians with a way to steer their patients away from the nonsensical, pseudoscientific services of subluxation-based chiropractors.
A physician can sometimes identify a competent chiropractor by personal correspondence that includes an exchange of office notes. Unfortunately, it seems that few chiropractors will publicly renounce the anti-medical subluxation theory that places chiropractors in competition with physicians, making it necessary to generally advise against chiropractic care.

Is it possible to reform the chiropractic profession?
I gave up trying to reform the chiropractic profession many years ago. My primary concern has long been to separate appropriate use of generic spinal manipulation from subluxation-based chiropractic. It will continue to be necessary for good chiropractors to publicly identify themselves as opponents of chiropractic subluxation theory if they are to receive any support from the scientific community. If chiropractic is ever to be developed as a properly limited musculoskeletal specialty, it must discard subluxation theory and alternative medicine practices that embrace a broad scope of ailments and then make the changes needed to specialize in conservative care for mechanical-type neck and back problems, offering a physical treatment armamentarium that includes use of spinal manipulative therapy as a treatment option.
At the present time, with state laws defining chiropractic as a method of correcting vertebral subluxations to restore and maintain health, change for the better does not seem likely anytime soon. Chiropractors who back away from subluxation theory might use alternative medicine procedures along with spinal adjustments in order to expand their scope of practice. According to National University of Health Sciences, a leading chiropractic college, “National University is a leader in the growing field of integrative medicine. We set the standard in training for careers in health care and prepare students to become first-contact, primary care physicians who are fully qualified to diagnose, treat and manage a wide range of conditions.”
It appears that chiropractors generally prefer to use spinal adjustments or a combination of spinal adjustments and alternative healing methods to treat non-musculoskeletal conditions as well as musculoskeletal problems as primary care providers rather than specialize in the care for back pain and related musculoskeletal problems, despite the fact that back pain and musculoskeletal problems are the No. 1 and No. 2 causes of disability worldwide (Vos et al. 2012).
The bottom line
When the National Board of Chiropractic Examiners published its updated version of Practice Analysis of Chiropractic in 2010, a pre-publication bulletin stated that “…the 2009 survey questionnaire did not ask about the use of applied kinesiology or any of the subluxation-based ‘adjustive procedures’ that place chiropractic in an unfavorable light.” The updated report, describing chiropractic as “the nation’s third largest primary health care profession,” stated, however, that “The specific focus of chiropractic practice is known as the chiropractic subluxation or joint dysfunction. A subluxation is a health concern that manifests in the skeletal joints, and, through complex anatomical and physiological relationships, affects the nervous system and may lead to reduced function, disability, or illness.”
Chiropractic continues to be based primarily on subluxation theory, with increasing use of a variety of alternative healing methods. The question “What do chiropractors do?” continues to be difficult to answer. Persons who are not familiar with the controversial aspects of chiropractic care might simply assume that chiropractors are back specialists since they work on the back. A visit to a chiropractic office for back-pain treatment, however, where spinal adjustments or some other alternative medicine procedure might be offered as a treatment for “a wide range of problems” would suggest that chiropractic is certainly not properly limited and is not a specialty or subspecialty in the care of back pain.

Chiropractic Education for Primary Care
Harriet Hall on October 15, 2013
Link
Chiropractors would like to reinvent themselves as family doctors. I’ve written about that before and Jann Bellamy has written about it here, here, here, and here. A new study in The Journal of Chiropractic Education alleges that the National University of Health Sciences is nearing its institutional goal of training chiropractic students as primary care practitioners. The data they collected don’t even begin to support that assertion. The study is not only meaningless, it demonstrates a gross misunderstanding of the education required to practice competent primary care.
Traditional education of MDs
The 4 years of medical school are very different from those of a chiropractic school. When I was a student, the first two years were spent in classrooms and labs studying gross anatomy, physiology, pharmacology, pathology, biochemistry, histology, neuroanatomy, microbiology, immunology, embryology, and other meaty science subjects. In the 3rd year, students moved into the hospital wards, rotating through internal medicine, surgery, pediatrics, OB/GYN, psychiatry, neurology, radiology, emergency medicine, etc. 4th year clinical rotations involve a higher level of responsibility and include electives. Most of the clinical experience is with seriously ill hospitalized patients, but students also get some outpatient clinic experience.
The real training begins after graduation, when students get to put their learning into practice. They assume primary responsibility for patients, under supervision. I did what was called a “Rotating 0” internship, designed to provide a broad foundation before entering a specialty. I rotated through internal medicine, surgery, OB/GYN, pediatrics, and electives (neurology and ENT). Most of my time was spent on the hospital wards, but I also worked in outpatient clinics and in the ER. The experience was intensive, with call every 3rd night. This meant working all day, all night, and the following day for a total of 32+ hours straight, followed by a day when we worked 9-10 hours and got to go home in the evening. In my case, my training was interrupted by an Air Force assignment as a General Medical Officer, and after that I spent 2 years in a 3-year residency in Family Practice (my internship counted for year 1). Residencies are where doctors get their training in a specialty, with graduated responsibilities as the program proceeds. At 3 years, the family practice residency is one of the shortest; a surgery residency typically lasts 5 years, a neurosurgery residency 7 years. In some cases, a residency is followed by a fellowship in a subspecialty, such as gastroenterology or child psychiatry. Rigorous exams are required at various stages of training and for board certification in a specialty.
Changes in recent years
Since I graduated, there have been new developments. There are limits to the number of consecutive hours a resident can work; medical schools are integrating classroom training with clinical experiences in various ways; there is a new designation of “hospitalists” who care for inpatients admitted by other doctors. Some primary care and even some specialty care is carried out by nurse clinicians and physician assistants with lesser levels of training than MDs, training more focused on what they will actually be doing in practice. PA training typically involves 2-3 years of postgraduate study, and most PA students have previous health care experience.
Chiropractic education
Chiropractic education is much less rigorous. Class time is taken up by many hours of training in manipulation technique like “toggle,” and “cervical technique,” palpation, and “subluxation” analysis; and for subjects like financial management and practice management. They don’t get any experience caring for seriously ill hospitalized patients. There is no internship or residency. The NUHS calls students in its student clinic “interns,” but that bears no resemblance to what “intern” means in medical training. The training it offers is in line with the purpose of the Council on Chiropractic Education, and they state “students at NUHS are educated and clinically trained to become primary care physicians. To become an effective primary care provider, a student intern must be prepared to identify, manage, and refer successfully when necessary a broad scope of conditions that include musculoskeletal and nonmusculoskeletal problems.”
The NHUS study
The study’s purpose was to quantify the number of musculoskeletal and nonmusculoskeletal cases NUHS interns treat during the clinic component of their education and to compare the results to data available for chiropractic and “allopathic” providers. The method was a retrospective chart review based on diagnostic codes. Of a potential 173 patients scheduled to be seen in the specified time frame (one trimester), 8 were no-shows, 27 denied consent, and 25 patients had no treated diagnoses, leaving only 113 patient files to be analyzed.
The results: 297 coded diagnoses, 76% of these musculoskeletal. Treated diagnoses: 52.2% musculoskeletal only, 12.4% nonmusculoskeletal only, and 35.4% both musculoskeletal and nonmusculoskeletal. This compared to 83% musculoskeletal and 17% nonmusculoskeletal diagnoses for practicing chiropractors, and 10% musculoskeletal and 90% nonmusculoskeletal diagnoses for “allopaths.”
Diagnoses not represented: neoplasms, blood disorders, diseases of the circulatory system, complications of pregnancy, childbirth and puerperium, and perinatal conditions. Out of 113 patients, only one was under the age of 20, and none were under the age of 11. Here is the list of diagnostic categories:
Note that the list of categories includes only 1 infection, 2 endocrine, nutritional and metabolic diseases, 4 diseases of the respiratory system, 4 diseases of the respiratory system, 3 diseases of the genitourinary system, 2 diseases of the skin, and there are several categories with no patients at all. These are just categories, they don’t tell us the actual diagnoses, whether they amounted to what has been called “snotology” (minor complaints like colds) or more serious disorders.
They don’t say how many students were involved, but elsewhere I found that 84 students are enrolled in the program. Surely no one student could have seen more than a few patients or seen a full spectrum of these diagnoses.
The authors point out another serious problem: diagnoses like hypertension or diabetes mellitus were not treated by students, but were “monitored or appropriately referred.”
Comparison to primary care
Contrast that to the 25 most common diagnoses seen in primary care: hypertension, hyperlipidemia, and diabetes lead the list, followed by back pain, anxiety, obesity, allergic rhinitis, reflux esophagitis, respiratory problems, hypothyroidism, visual refractive errors, osteoarthritis, fibromyalgia/myositis/neuritis, malaise and fatigue, joint pain, acute laryngopharyngitis, acute maxillary sinusitis, major depressive disorder, acute bronchitis, and asthma.
The chiropractic students all put together saw a total of only 2 patients who fell into one of the categories of the top 3 conditions presenting to primary care providers. As defined by the CCE, primary health care is:
Care that is provided by a health care professional in the patient’s first contact within a health care system that includes an examination and evaluation, diagnosis and health management. A Doctor of Chiropractic practicing primary health care is competent and qualified to provide independent, quality, patient-focused health care to individuals of all ages and genders by: (1) providing direct access, portal of entry care that does not require a referral from another source; (2) establishing a partnership relationship with continuity of care for each individual patient; (3) evaluating a patient and independently establishing a diagnosis or diagnoses; (4) managing the patients [sic] health care and integrating health care services including treatment, recommendations for self-care, referral and/or co-management.
Conclusion
How could anyone possibly imagine that the findings of this study show that the school is approaching the goal of “training students to become primary health care providers”? You would have to be delusional to think that. They saw no children and no patients with the top 3 conditions presenting to a primary care office. The numbers tabulated were for the entire group of students, with no indication of the numbers seen by any individual student.
It’s just plain stupid to think that simply listing diagnostic categories could establish the adequacy of training.
Apart from the inadequacies of clinic training, there is a glaring defect: chiropractors don’t have inpatient hospital experience with responsibility for the care of seriously ill patients. Without that experience, how could they be expected to develop good judgment about when to refer and when hospitalization is necessary?
Chiropractors are not qualified to provide primary care. This study only reinforces that fact.

A New DC Degree. What the World Needs Now.
Perhaps the neck manipulation was a bit too aggressive.
Mark Crislip on November 19, 2024
Link
Last month the following showed up in my feeds: In a First, Academic Center Offers Chiropractic Program. Sigh. Well, at least it is not associated with the Medical School. Yet.
I suppose I could clutch my pearls and cry, baby, but no point in that. In The Demon-Haunted World: Science as a Candle in the Dark, Carl Sagan noted
The candle flame gutters. Its little pool of light trembles. Darkness gathers. The demons begin to stir.
To judge from the widespread offering of SCAMs in major medical centers, in health care the candle is out. All that is left is the red coal, producing smoke but little light or heat. And soon that too, is likely to be extinguished.
But, to use contradictory metaphors, while medicine burns, I have my proto-guitar to occupy my time.
As the old saying notes, when life hands you lemons, make an army-navy and forget your troubles.
I thought it would be interesting to look over the first of its kind Chiropractic degree in a
research-intensive public university, providing an educational experience unmatched by any other program. Based on its strong reputation in the health sciences, Pitt is uniquely positioned to train a new generation of chiropractors who will be at the leading edge of science for spine and musculoskeletal disorders.
and see what they offer and how it compares to reality. If the program is part of a research-intensive public university, and they are offering a DC doctorate, I have to wonder just how much research Pitt did into the realities of chiropractic. But perhaps I am cynical. Or skeptical. Or both.
Get It While You Can
First, cost.
$15,398 per term ($123,185 total for 8 terms) for in-state students
$18,400 per term ($147,202 total for 8 terms) for out-of-state students
Holy Cannelloni. Cost for a DC degree vary widely, but this appears to be a bit more than the average, especially for out-of-state students. Still, they will acquire the patina of fool’s gold legitimacy, getting a quack degree from a University, albeit one that has likely abandoned scientific standards, instead of a quack degree from a quack institution. That patina must be worth a bit more for the graduates. With 40 students in the first year, that is at minimum a cool $4,927,400. Not bad. Now I know why they are offering the program.
And chiropractic students may be a susceptible group to price gouge:
These chiropractic students demonstrated inadequate financial literacy and did not engage in many recommended financial habits.
Such as spending money on a Doctor of Chiropractic degree, I suppose.
Student Body
Who will these 40 students be? They need to have an average GPA of 3.0. A ‘B”. 2.75 is enough for some schools I looked at. It is safe to say that best and brightest do not become chiropractors. It is a career choice that suggests a surfeit of magical thinking or a deficiency of critical thinking skills. Or both. I mean, did you do any research on what it means to be a chiropractor? And if so, you were not dissuaded from that career path?
And I had to laugh when I saw that under technical skills, they expect
Intellectual Abilities: Chiropractors are required to think critically and solve problem.
As this blog routinely demonstrates, critical thinking is not a must in the field; if critical thinking were applied we would see
“Oh dear,” says a chiropractor “I hadn’t thought of that,” and the field promptly vanishes in a puff of logic.
The Curriculum
Starting a new school is a good opportunity to discard the problematic baggage of the past and start afresh. The chance to reinvent oneself and leave the old you in the dustbin of history is tempting and should not be passed up. Especially if the old you is reality avoidant.
The front page of the website says
From day one, students will receive a combination of rigorous, evidence-based education and clinical experiences within an interprofessional academic environment.
Rigorous. Evidence-based. Chiropractic. Elmo might have something to say.
Makes an old SBM skeptic like myself wonder just what parts of chiropractic will be taught.
Now I am going to define terms here. SCAMs tend to be very Humptydumptian in their use of language. Precision of language is not their strong suit. And you learn in medicine that precise speaking is a manifestation of precise thinking. God forbid you should call a patient dehydrated on rounds. Although it is done humorously, that is EXACTLY what happens.
So moving forward, for the sake of precision, when I say chiropractic I am referring to the straight chiropractic approach pulled out of the ass of its founder, D.D. Palmer. Disease is caused by subluxations of the spine that interfere with the movement of inane, er I mean innate intelligence and that by manipulating the spine, the subluxations are removed to allow the flow of innate intelligence and resolution of illness.
That is the defining characteristic of chiropractic, its sine qua non, and as this blog has demonstrated over and over, is all a load of fetid dingoes kidneys. All sound and fury, signifying nothing. A fiction from start to finish. It is Oakland. You get my drift.
But here is the odd thing. The fundamental fiction that uniquely determines what is a chiropractor is not mentioned anywhere on the site. Are they embarrassed? Or are they abandoning the core idea that makes a chiropractor and turning out a tarted-up physical therapist? I don’t know. In the FAQ under what is a chiropractor, they say
Doctors of Chiropractic (DCs) are first contact providers (i.e. there is no need for a referral) licensed to practice chiropractic in all 50 states, the District of Columbia, the U.S. Virgin Islands and Puerto Rico. DCs perform the diagnosis, treatment and prevention of spine and musculoskeletal problems with a focus on back and neck pain. As part of their practice, DCs conduct physical exams, order and interpret radiological imaging and laboratory tests, diagnose and treat musculoskeletal dysfunction, counsel patients on health and wellness, and co-manage or refer to other health care providers when appropriate. DCs exercise autonomy in clinical decision-making and provide a broad range of diagnostic and therapeutic services focused mainly on spine-related and other musculoskeletal disorders. The use of manipulation, manual therapy, therapeutic exercises and lifestyle modifications are the cornerstones of chiropractic practice.
Sound good. Nice and non-specific. The DC is in the details, and the details are not mentioned on the site.
There are useless adjunctive diagnostics and therapies used by chiropractors such as applied kinesology or actuators but they are not unique to chiropractic practice.
And there are useful adjunctive therapies used by chiropractors such as massage, heat, stretching, and exercise but they are also not unique to chiropractic.
As has been noted about many a SCAM, what is unique is not helpful and what is helpful is not unique. And so it is with chiropractic.
But if they are going to offer a rigorous, evidence-based education, then no part of chiropractic, as defined above, needs be taught. And the only thing that chiropractic has benefit for is early improvement of low back pain. And even for that, I am skeptical, as when you look at the details of these studies spinal manipulation is used with other, actually useful, adjunctive therapies making it difficult to determine just what chiropractic adds to the care. I bet nothing. So why not avoid the fiction-based chiropractic and go for a physical therapy degree? Probably because you don’t get to be called doctor.
Looking at the outline of the curriculum it looks be a cursory review of medicine but, since the first class is not until Aug 2025, is understandably short on specifics. But it does raise questions.
What is taught is woefully inadequate for the DC to be a primary care provider, as is encouraged by some DCs, although not in Pennsylvania. Hell, a real medical school education does not prepare you to take care of patients. That only occurs after internship, residency and fellowships, 3 to 7 years of training post-medical school depending on specialty. But they do mention that what is taught will be at a level useful for chiropractors. I am Joe’s Body level I would suppose. That dates me. And I really do not think much of chiropractors, do I?
The Director of the program is evidently a proponent of the primary spine practitioner, akin to a podiatrist. Not a bad idea, I always appreciated the expertise of the podiatrists I worked with. But I would not want my primary spine practitioner to be trained as a chiropractor. I want my health care providers to be grounded in reality.
The program will offer Chiropractic Science. Hm. As you know, I am not a fan of adjectives preceding the word science. But I suppose there is biologic science. And medical science. And social science. But chiropractic science? Now there are two words I never thought I would see together; very humptydumptian. How does one have a science based on a fiction? It usually doesn’t end up well, as Lysenko horrifically demonstrated. Perhaps, and I have always been both skeptical and a optimistic pessimist, they will actually change the profession and make it reality based. I can hope.
They have a public health section. I wonder how they are going to cover vaccines, as anti-vaccination sentiments are common in chiropractors and start in school:
we found in both colleges that anti-vaccination attitudes were more prevalent in the later years of the programs.
And the chiropractic profession was not a shining beacon of science during COVID. Although, if they are abandoning the whole subluxation fiction, there may be hope yet.
Musculoskeletal spine-care chiropractors were more adaptive to certain COVID-19 public health changes within their practice setting than subluxation-based chiropractors.
I see they have a section on cervical mobilization and manipulation. I note that the head of the program appears skeptical of the chiropractic hanging, er, I mean neck manipulation leading to vertebral artery dissection. He prefers to go with the Cassidy study calling it a
landmark study by Cassidy et al., considering that it is arguably the best epidemiological evidence published on this topic to date.
I would argue the paper is the chiropractic equivalent of inconceivable and I have. it is a study where, if you read the paper, you will find that the body contradicts the assertion in the abstract that cervical manipulation does not cause strokes. But, that takes careful critical thinking to determine.
So more questions than answers on just how evidence-based this DC degree will be. Perhaps this will be the start of something new, like DOs, who have mostly moved on from their quasi-chiropractic beginnings. Fiction-free chiropractic?
To crack, or not to crack; that is the question;
Whether ‘tis nobler in the mind to suffer
The slings and arrows of chiropractic manipulation,
Or to take arms against a sea of pseudo-science,
And by opposing end them. Science. Evidence.
Critical Thought; applied to end
The heart-ache and the thousand natural shocks
That subluxation is heir to; ‘tis a consummation
Devoutly to be wished.
Well shall see.
Post Graduation
There are 60,000 unneeded chiropractors in the US, with 2500 added to the workforce every year. Three years from now, they will add 40 more. Are they going to have jobs, since they can only legitimately care for acute low back pain. Income? They will start out at $50,000 a year and reach a top pay of $90,000 a year. I found a variety of numbers on the web. Can you actually reach those numbers as a rigorous, evidence-based ie chiropractic-free DC? Or will the graduates go down the rat holes of subluxations, spinal maintenance, anti-vaccination, and other SCAMs that permeate the profession today?
We can hope that these DOs are going to be different.
But you can probably guess where I would put my money.

Chiropractic Internist: A “specialty” to avoid
The “chiropractic internist” is the creation of an industry association which promotes chiropractors as “primary care physicians.” After 300 hours of instruction in a hotel conference room, they claim they can treat “anything that a medical doctor can.”
Jann Bellamy on January 5, 2017
Link

Chiropractors have created a “board certified” specialty called “chiropractic internist.” We’ve met the “chiropractic internist” before on SBM, as one iteration of the “DC as PCP,” an attempt by one faction within the chiropractic industry to refashion themselves as primary care physicians. For the sordid history of that effort, you can read the posts listed here, which covers the internecine battles between various groups of chiropractors over education, prescription privileges, scope of practice, and various other public hangings-out of chiropractic’s huge pile of dirty laundry.
While the chiropractic internist is not new, the American Chiropractic Association (ACA), chiropractic’s largest industry association, has created a shiny new website to promote it. This effort is bolstered by recent attempts to expand the chiropractic scope of practice beyond back cracking and the ACA’s ongoing attempt to get what is essentially the chiropractic practice of medicine covered by Medicare. So, today we take a closer look at “chiropractic internists” and their PR campaign to fool the public into thinking they are real internists who can effectively diagnose and treat real diseases.
The ACA’s new “chiropractic internist” website is headlined with a shot across the naturopathic bow:
“Natural primary care.” Sound familiar? Naturopathic “medicine,” is, according to one of its proselytizers,
a distinct system of primary health care that emphasizes prevention and the self-healing process through the use of natural therapies.
In other (unsaid, but certainly implied) words, naturopathic “doctors” are licensed or regulated in only a handful of states, but “doctors of chiropractic” and “chiropractic physicians” who practice “natural primary care” are licensed in all 50 states. Take that, naturopaths!
But that’s nothing compared to the way they take on medical doctors. If that was a shot across the bow, this is a direct aim at the medical profession:
Such as?
They seem particularly concerned that you might think they don’t know enough about testing to diagnose “this vast amount of other diseases” [sic], hence:
And, of course, they feel compelled to repeat that famous CAM canard and “vile, false accusation” that, while medical doctors treat only symptoms, chiropractors get to the “root cause” of your problem.
Actually, as we shall see, that’s not exactly how “treatments provided by Chiropractic Internists differ from standard medical care.”
Who’s behind all of this?
The “chiropractic internist” is the creation of the American Chiropractic Association (ACA), the largest of the chiropractic trade associations. The “Council on Diagnosis and Internal Disorders,” (CDID) is one of the ACA’s “specialty councils.” (Others include neurology and pediatrics.) According to its bylaws, the CDID “functions as a subordinate arm of the ACA” and “must act pursuant to and in conformity with ACA policy.” To help the ACA keep tabs on what it’s doing, the CDID must submit “activity reports” and its budget to the ACA.
“Board certification” as a “chiropractic internist” is bestowed by the American Board of Chiropractic Internists (ABCI), and being “board certified” permits one to call oneself a “diplomate” of the ABCI and use the initials “DABCI” after one’s name. However, ABCI is not a separate entity (as the term “Board” would imply); rather, it was established by and operates under the auspices of the CDID, and therefore the ACA. The Board consists of four chiropractors selected by the CDIC and it, too, must submit regular reports to the ACA. The Board recommends education and training courses for “diplomate” status as a “chiropractic internist.” The CDIC’s bylaws prohibit the Board’s decisions from conflicting with the ACA’s “Master Plan” and the ACA “administers and coordinates the activity of the DABCI post-doctoral specialty.” In sum, the whole operation is firmly in the control of the ACA.
With that in mind, let’s look at this “education and training.”
A company called ProHealth Seminars is the only ABCI-authorized course provider. According to public records, ProHealth Seminars is a Missouri limited liability company registered under the names of Jack Kessinger, a chiropractor, and Virginia Kessinger, presumably a relative. These two are also registered as the managing members of another company, Clint Publications, which publishes a journal of sorts for the “chiropractic internist,” called “The Original Internist.” (There is also a Florida outfit listed as a provider, but its website is down and it does not appear to be active.)
ProHealth’s DABCI seminars are taught in five U.S. cities, two of them in Missouri, where Jack Kessinger practiced. (He passed away in 2011.) The 300-hour seminars take place on 26 weekends, one seminar per month, 9 AM to 6 AM on Saturdays and 9 AM to Noon on Sundays, for a little over 2 years. (There’s also a 100-hour “certificate of completion” course.) Each costs $395 if you register early. With two exceptions, all classes are held in either an Embassy Suites Hotel, an Airport Sheraton, Airport Hilton, or Hilton Garden Inn. The 100-hour “certificate” course and a “Pelvic Workshop” ($750 in advance), which is required of all seminar participants, are held at the National University of Health Sciences, which grants degrees in chiropractic, naturopathy, acupuncture and massage. The “Pelvic Workshop” (“The Natural Approach to Family Practice”) is advertised as “24 Hours and Hands On,” although the flyer doesn’t say whether that means actual live patients or some sort of medical mannequin. Why the DABCI feels only pelvic exams warrant clinical education is a mystery. In any event, to become a “diplomate” you’ll have to shell out over $10,000 for these courses, not including meals and lodging.
All seminars are identical in topic and faculty, each registration handout changing only the location and the dates. Whether they are live or video presentations, or a combination, is not clear. Whatever their format, each 12-hour weekend covers a topic (or topics) that would ordinarily consume weeks of education and training in a real internal medicine residency. For example, “Infectious Diseases and Emergency Disorders” is covered one weekend, as is “Geriatrics and Mental Health.” Cardiovascular Disease? 12 hours. Pulmonary Disease and Lung Function? 12 hours. Dermatology? 12 hours. And so on. References to dubious diagnostics and treatments are sprinkled throughout the course titles (again, 12 hours each): “Allergies, Sensitivities and Autoimmune Response,” “Detoxification and Diagnosis of Hepatic and Renal Systems,” and “Pharmacognosy – Utilizing Botanicals in a Functional Practice,” or, as we know it, Functional Medicine.
[By way of comparison, you can see what a real, three-year internal medicine residency looks like here. In contrast to the DABCI’s 300-hour course, here’s an internal medicine resident’s account of her first year, during which she worked 3,000 hours.]
Almost half of these courses (11 of 26) are taught by Robert Kessinger, Jack’s grandson, and, along with his father, Jack’s former chiropractic practice partner in Rolla, Missouri. Robert is either a medical genius or way out of his depth. He teaches “Foundations of Chiropractic Family Practice,” along with “Natural Strategies in Laboratory Testing,” as well as the courses covering allergies, endocrinology, blood tests (including tumor markers), infectious diseases, emergency medicine, diseases of the arterial system, geriatrics, mental health, neoplastic diseases and cancer and review of systems, history and physical exam.
Robert’s breadth of medical knowledge, or lack thereof, is closely matched by Darren Kirchner, a Kahoka, Missouri chiropractor, who teaches eight of the courses, including “Gastrointestinal Health and Protocols for a Healthy Gut,” cardiovascular disease, “detoxification,” differential diagnosis, and neoplastic disease and cancer (second course). ProHealth Seminars thankfully devotes 24 hours to the important topic of cancer, the only topic besides pelvic health for which the company offers more than one weekend of instruction.
Robert practices “upper cervical chiropractic care,” which is a variant of straight subluxation-based chiropractic. He refers readers of his blog posts to the National Vaccine Information Center, the notorious anti-vaccination website. A PubMed search reveals that he has published all of two case studies, both in a chiropractic journal and both claiming to have diagnosed upper cervical subluxations, with repeated x-rays and a thermocouple, in one patient with vertigo, hearing loss and tinnitus, and another with trauma-induced kyphosis (22 office visits). Needless to say, he claims treatment was successful. He’s also published in pseudoscientific fluff like the Journal of Vertebral Subluxation Research and says he’s “active in multiple Upper Cervical Research projects in conjunction with multiple clinics.”
I couldn’t find anything Kirchner had published. Nor could I find that either holds a faculty post at any educational institution. Just what might qualify either of them to teach such a breathtaking range of medical topics is another mystery I assume only the ABCI and the ACA could explain.
If you manage to finance, and find the time for, the ProHealth Seminar courses, you are eligible to sit for the ABCI exam, administered by the National Board of Chiropractic Examiners. It consists of 200 multiple choice questions and lasts 3 ½ hours. If you get 75% right, you pass. There is also a practical exam consisting of “several stations, including but not limited to male examinations, female examinations [and] Regional physical exam . . .” (Again, the creepy emphasis on examining females.) Finally, there is a (yes, one) case presentation.
And it shows
This skimpy education and training shows in their practices. Judging from the websites of “board certified chiropractic internists,” their practice looks a lot like the practice of a naturopathic “doctor”: dubious diagnostic testing and plenty of dietary supplements, all “proven” with a big dose of testimonials. Here are some examples:
    • Infrared sauna for “detoxification” (“detoxification” is a bogus concept)
    • Treatment of “leaky gut” (a real thing, but not the way CAM practitioners think)
    • ALCAT “food sensitivity” testing (no predictive value in the diagnosis of allergy or intolerances)
    • Homeopathy (“the one quackery to rule them all“)
    • Treatment of “chronic candidiasis” (not a real disease)
    • Breast thermography for cancer screening (not evidence-based and not recommended by experts)
    • “Functional” lab testing (a part of Functional Medicine)
    • Functional medicine
    • Hair analysis (bogus)
    • Selling dietary supplements to patients (huge conflict of interest)
    • Substandard treatments for hypothyroidism (pseudoscience)
    • IgG food allergy testing (not predictive)
    • Salivary tests for hormones (not reliable)
    • MTHFR genetic testing (a real thing but not the way quacks use it)
    • IV nutrient injections (e.g., Vitamin C) (not evidence-based)
    • Hyperbaric Oxygen (CAM practitioners go beyond limited evidence-based uses)
    • Lab tests for heavy metals and “toxins” (quackery)
    • Stress-Adrenal “Burnout” (not a real thing)
    • “Wellness Blood Testing” (another way of saying “functional medicine” testing)
How is this even legal?
If you are wondering how chiropractors can deceive patients with unvalidated testing, quack diagnoses and worthless treatments, look no further than your state legislators. To legally pull off this make-believe internal medicine practice, chiropractors need certain elements in their practice act: the right to use diagnostic testing and to offer “clinical nutritional” advice in the form of recommending (and, better yet, selling) dietary supplements and homeopathic remedies. Dietary supplements include not only vitamins and minerals, but also herbal remedies (that is, unpurified and unproven drugs) and glandulars (desiccated animal organs). These seemingly innocuous rights to perform diagnostic testing and give clinical nutrition advice can be parlayed into a perfectly legal “chiropractic internist” practice, even if one doesn’t go to the trouble of getting board certified. Even better is a provision allowing them to use all diagnostic and treatment procedures “taught by chiropractic colleges.”
Ohio is a recent example of how chiropractors are expanding their scope of practice to include an ersatz form of primary care. Ohio defines the practice of chiropractic as
utilization of the relationship between the musculo-skeletal structures of the body, the spinal column, and the nervous system in the restoration and maintenance of health, in connection with which patient care is conducted with due regard for first aid, hygienic, nutritional, and rehabilitative procedures and the specific vertebral adjustment and manipulation of the articulations and adjacent tissues of the body.
Sounds like traditional, subluxation-based chiropractic, right? But the Legislature gave jurisdiction over chiropractors to a State Board of Chiropractic, including the authority to enact rules governing chiropractic practice. The Board, which is made up of four chiropractors and one public member (a lawyer), by enacting a regulation, magnanimously interpreted the chiropractic scope of practice to include
the use of such diagnostic and treatment procedures as are taught by board approved chiropractic colleges except as prohibited by law and/or the rules of this board.
As long as a chiropractic college teaches a particular diagnostic or treatment procedure, and the Legislature or the Board hasn’t prohibited it, it’s legal. And what has the Council on Chiropractic Education said that all schools must teach students?
[to] practice primary health care as a portal-of-entry provider for patients of all ages and genders focusing on the inherent ability of the body to heal and enhance function without unnecessary drugs or surgery.
The State Board of Chiropractic, in its approved continuing education courses, supports this view that chiropractic practice extends far beyond musculoskeletal conditions. Courses include:
Endocrine System: “Overview of all hormones with special focus on estrogen dominance, metabolic syndrome, adrenal fatigue.” (Adrenal fatigue is a fake disease invented by naturopaths.)
Nutritional Support for Chronic Fatigue Syndrome
Chiropractic and Pregnancy, including how to recommend homeopathic remedies and herbs for pregnant patients.
In 2016, just to make sure, chiropractors got the Ohio Legislature to pass a bill authorizing chiropractors to administer, sell and provide advice regarding dietary supplements, homeopathic remedies and non-prescription drugs “to restore and maintain health.” Gov. Kasich signed the bill into law on Jan. 4.
So, in bits and pieces of legislation and regulations, Ohio chiropractors have cobbled together a legal framework that takes them far beyond detecting and correcting subluxations into what is essentially primary care practice, just “without drugs or surgery.” This strategy is repeated in other states.
The ACA, for its part, is heavily lobbying Congress to expand Medicare coverage of chiropractic so it will, as the ACA cryptically says,
allow doctors of chiropractic (DC) to perform to the fullest scope of their license in Medicare. . . seniors are being denied the full range of chiropractic services that could help them lead healthier and happier lives.
The ACA doesn’t explain what the “fullest scope of their license” or what the “full range of chiropractic services” might be, but you can bet their “Chiropractic Internists” want a part of the publicly-funded pie.
The average state legislator probably has little idea what seemingly innocuous bills allowing chiropractors to give “clinical nutrition” advice to “support and maintain health” or practice diagnostic methods and treatments “taught in chiropractic colleges” really mean. They likely think of chiropractors as “back doctors,” along with the rest of the public. That ignorance results in poorly educated and trained “chiropractic internists” who prey on the sick and worried well with their quack diagnoses and dubious treatments.

   The Image of Chiropractic: Consensus Based on Belief
Sam Homola
Link
As a chiropractor, I am often asked why the image of chiropractic is so bad. “Why is chiropractic so often ignored by the media and ridiculed by physicians?” Journalists and health professionals tend to judge chiropractic by the worst of what they see, and what they see is often bad. This March 15, 2011, post from a chiropractic group asking for money to provide chiropractic services for earthquake and tsunami victims in Japan is a good example of why chiropractic has a bad image:
Please consider donating whatever you can to the SOTO-I/PAAC [Sacro Occipital Teaching Organization International-Pacific Asian Association of Chiropractic] Japan Relief Fund. 100% of your donation will go directly to helping the needy Japanese people through SOT Chiropractic treatments and services.
Please consider this avenue of donation rather than the Red Cross etc. While they are worthy organizations, we have ZERO overhead to administration and the funds will provide CHIROPRACTIC services to the needy. Please recommend this avenue of aid to your patients and friends also. Any and everything will help!
Practitioners of Sacro Occipital Technic (SOT) and SOT Craniopathy claim to restore innate healing capacity by removing neurological interference and improving the flow of cerebrospinal fluid (“craniosacral respiration”). Vertebral subluxations affecting certain organs are found by palpating tendon insertions at the base of the skull. Craniosacral respiration is improved by adjusting the bones of the skull and the sacroiliac joint.
There are dozens of such nonsensical chiropractic treatment methods foisted on the public through “press releases” and junk-science journals. NUCCA (upper cervical technique), which identifies slight misalignment of the atlas as a major cause of human ailments, is a commonly-promoted technique based on chiropractic vertebral subluxation theory.
This press release further illustrates the reason for chiropractic’s bad image:
A revolutionary neuro relief technique is being used by chiropractors across the United States and Canada to treat a wide-array of Symptoms and Chronic Disorders they were never before able to handle. This technique, when applied correctly performs absolute miracles for patients who have been suffering for an extensive period in their lives. Thus patients are happier and chiropractors are increasing their visibility and incomes!
Online PR News – 12-March-2011 
An article titled “Second Opinion: Of Chiropractors & Christians,” published in a Baptist news magazine, describes an “inherently unbelievable” chiropractic message:
My back hurt, so I went to a chiropractor. He is helping my back pain. That’s a good thing.
But that is not what this article is about.
My chiropractor is an evangelist for his particular brand of chiropractic. Literally, he and his staff are religious about it. They preach the word. They offer written materials. They make promises of a greater life. I am unmoved. I just want him to make my back feel better.
I have a better understanding now of how nonbelievers may react to Christian witness. My reactions to the “message” I get at my chiropractor’s office could also be the reactions of someone you know to church, Christianity or the gospel message of Christ:
These folks are extremely nice, and I appreciate that, but that does not mean I am going to believe what they believe or what they tell me to believe.
They sincerely believe what they say. I do not doubt that. Their sincerity does not persuade me to change my mind.
They walk the walk. They cleanse their toxins, go to burst training, take supplements and get regular adjustments. As far as I can tell, they are not hypocrites. But I am not moved.
They go out of their way to educate me. They offer written information. They invite me to seminars, dinners and meetings. I do not have the excuse that “I don’t understand.”
These folks care about me. I believe that.
So, why am I not fully sold? Why won’t I buy into the full program instead of just “settling” with having them make my back feel better?
Their message is inherently unbelievable.
Their message runs counter to what I know and to what I read and hear everywhere else.
Their message is too demanding of my time, energies and commitments.
Sound familiar? Those are reasons why people routinely reject our Christian witness…
Published: March 11, 2011 (The Baptist Standard)
Sorting out a Few Good Apples
As illustrated by the above clips, it’s not hard to understand why chiropractic has such a bad image. If the chiropractic profession does not take steps to eliminate the nonsense in chiropractic, it may be difficult for ethical, science-based chiropractors to separate themselves from questionable treatment methods that have been traditionally supported by chiropractic subluxation theory. The practice-centered approach of chiropractors who disseminate misinformation, whether they are true believers or not, hurts the public as well as the profession. It is unlikely that unethical chiropractors will voluntarily give-up a faith-based or money-based approach they are using to make a living. Ethical chiropractors, many of whom are well-meaning but misinformed, struggle while pitch masters thrive. Guardians of public health feel compelled to issue warnings about chiropractic. Science-based chiropractors, as individuals, are forced to distance themselves from misguided colleagues and from purveyors of bogus methods based on the tenets of chiropractic. My heart goes out to those well-meaning chiropractors whose education left them totally dependent upon belief-based self-employment. Few of them have the faculties or the means needed to take a different path.
While it would be painful for chiropractors to point out and renounce obviously worthless diagnostic and treatment methods used by some of their colleagues, it might be prudent for chiropractic associations to do so to establish credibility in the eyes of the public. No other health profession has such a negative image. Good chiropractors are mixed in with bad chiropractors, like a crate of partially spoiled fruit that still contains a few good apples but is often discarded.
The chiropractic profession has to face the reality that chiropractic as a method of treating human ailments by adjusting vertebral subluxations is not acceptable in the scientific community and is unrelated to the generic spinal manipulation now being used by physical therapists and science-based chiropractors. A look at chiropractic journals, advertisements, and office procedures, however, reveals that a large number of chiropractors still cling to Palmer’s subluxation theory, some combining science with pseudoscience. I suspect that chiropractic has survived primarily because its use of manipulation in the treatment of back pain has provided a service not readily available in medical care, that is, symptomatic relief for mechanical-type neck and back pain or a good back-cracking back rub for providing pleasure and relieving tension. I believe the chiropractic profession today would be better off if it renounced the subluxation theory that gave it birth and concentrated on caring for back pain. So far, there is no indication that this will happen any time soon. Until the chiropractic profession does discard the vertebral subluxation theory, it will be difficult for the profession to condemn a multitude of popular, wacky chiropractic techniques based on a theory that defines the profession.
Entrenched Subluxation Theory
When the Council on Chiropractic Education (CCE) proposed new accreditation standards for chiropractic colleges, subject to take effect in January of 2012, all reference to “subluxation” was omitted. (“The CCE does not define or support any specific philosophy regarding the principles and practice of chiropractic, nor do the CCE Standards support or accommodate any specific or political position. The Standards do not establish the scope of chiropractic practice. They specify core educational requirements but do not otherwise limit the educational process, program curricular content, or topics of study.”) The American Chiropractic Association (ACA), the largest association in America representing the chiropractic profession, responded, in part, with this comment regarding the subluxation:
The document removes all references to the term “subluxation” – a core element of the practice of chiropractic that has been integral since the profession’s beginnings over 100 years ago. While the term “subluxation” and its role in the practice of chiropractic is sometimes misunderstood or not fully appreciated by all parties involved in medical related research and the delivery of health care, the term is one which is explicitly recognized in federal law (Section 1861(r) of the Social Security Act) and has been widely recognized by the courts, state legislative bodies and licensing authorities. The elimination of any reference to this term in the proposed standards will be viewed by many within the profession as a counter-productive action that will, in the long-term, likely weaken the profession’s collaborative strength and historic identity. We would propose placing “subluxation theory” back into Section 2, H. Educational Program for the Doctor of Chiropractic Degree and Vertebral Subluxation Complex into Section 3 Initial assessment and diagnosis as a required component.
As a chiropractor and a critic of chiropractic, I often found common ground with other health-care professionals by noting the value of generic spinal manipulation while providing guidelines to separate science-based chiropractors from subluxation-based chiropractors. Failure to point out obvious chiropractic nonsense may simply allow a believing public to assume that all chiropractors are the same, most of whom do not deserve to feed off the positive image projected by a few ethical, science-based chiropractors. Subluxation-based chiropractors peddle dubious services without opposition from their colleagues or from their associations, alienating chiropractic from the scientific community.
When I published my book Bonesetting, Chiropractic and Cultism in 1963, I renounced the vertebral subluxation theory and recommended that chiropractic be developed as a back specialty. It has always been my hope that chiropractic would become a form of physical medicine, a sub-specialty of medicine offering physical treatment methods for mechanical-type neck and back problems. If chiropractic aspires to become an independent, primary non-surgical specialty capable of accepting full responsibility for treating neck and back pain and related problems, it would have to have access to certain prescription medications and all available rehabilitative and physical treatment methods as well as access to hospital facilities, requiring changes in state laws and chiropractic college curriculum. As a back-pain specialty or sub-specialty, the chiropractic profession could be sustained by referrals from other health-care professionals.
Back Specialists?
In 2005, the World Federation of Chiropractic defined chiropractors as “…spinal health care experts in the health care system…with emphasis on the relationship between the spine and the nervous system…” This ambiguous definition fails to place proper limitations on the practice of chiropractic, leaving the door open for subluxation-based chiropractors who use spinal adjustments to treat general health problems. Such chiropractors, with only a hammer in their tool box, cannot qualify as a legitimate “back specialist” or “spine specialist.”
According to the Agency for Healthcare Policy and Research, low-back trouble is the second most common reason for office visits to primary care physicians and the most common reason for office visits to orthopedic surgeons, neurosurgeons, and occupational medicine physicians. Back problems are the most common cause of disability among persons under the age of 45 (Acute Low Back Problems in Adults, 1994). Despite the fact that back pain is one of this nation’s most common ailments, the niche for a back-pain specialty remains unfilled. With changes, chiropractic could have filled this niche (specializing like optometry or chiropody), but instead chose to be defined as a form of alternative medicine with a limited treatment method and an unlimited scope of practice .
Most people think of a chiropractor as a “back doctor.” And most people who go to a chiropractor go for treatment of a neck or back problem. It is certainly ironic that many chiropractors consider it demeaning to be called a “back specialist,” preferring to “treat human ailments without use of drugs and surgery.” Unfortunately, most state laws define chiropractic in this way, resulting in scientific and societal suspicion that hinders change and keeps utilization of chiropractic low.
Today, 48 years after publication of my Bonesetting book, I am still of the opinion that the chiropractic profession is not properly defined and limited. Chiropractic associations continue to tolerate implausible theories that provide an umbrella for inappropriate use of spinal manipulation and a variety of proprietary treatment methods applied to the gamut of human ailments. Many subluxation-based chiropractors seek support in the camp of alternative medicine where they are more readily accepted and where quackery is rampant. They are not representative of chiropractors who follow the guidelines of science in limiting their scope of practice. The uncontested proclamations of chiropractors who make vague and all-inclusive claims continue to drag the profession down, as indicated by figures showing that the percentage of the population seeing chiropractors annually decreased from 9.9% in 1997 to 7.4% in 2002 (Altern Ther Health Med. 2005;11:42-49), despite increasing popularity of alternative medicine.
Scientific presentations will not eliminate a belief system such as homeopathy or subluxation-based chiropractic, nor will the actions of a few science-based chiropractors. It seems likely that there will always be subluxation-based chiropractors. Until the majority of chiropractors make a clean break from what has traditionally been known as chiropractic (adjusting the spine to restore and maintain health), changes for the better in the profession as a whole will be problematic. Chiropractic associations will tend to represent the views of the majority, even if these views are scientifically indefensible. And the definition of chiropractic will continue to be based upon consensus rather than upon science.
Since physical therapy as a sub-specialty of medicine is now incorporating use of science-based manipulation in an armamentarium designed for treatment of neck and back pain and other musculoskeletal problems, it might be too late for the chiropractic profession to establish itself as a preferred back-pain specialty or sub-specialty. Forty-six states now allow direct access to the services of a physical therapist without physician referral. According to the American Physical Therapy Association, physical therapy, by the year 2020, will be provided by physical therapists who are doctors of physical therapy and who may be board-certified specialists.
The Majority Rules
Chiropractors who use manipulation appropriately may be in the minority, making it necessary for them to seek refuge and camaraderie in small groups of like-minded chiropractors who voluntarily follow the guidelines of science in offering patient-centered care. It would certainly be nice if these chiropractors could be separated from the herd with a special degree in a separate camp until they become a majority and the national associations are forced to follow suit.
Until then, I hope that good chiropractors will offer their patients (and the public) tips on how to recognize questionable claims so that good judgment can be exercised in selecting a chiropractor. It may be necessary for chiropractors themselves to openly criticize esoteric techniques used to locate and correct the mysterious, asymptomatic, and undetectable chiropractic vertebral subluxations alleged to be a cause of disease. Scientifically indefensible theories and treatment methods must be labeled as such to discourage use by the public as well as by chiropractors. As the undesirable aspects of chiropractic (e.g., “killer subluxations”) become less acceptable in the eyes of the public, fewer chiropractors will tout such nonsense. When science-based chiropractors are in the majority, if that ever happens, chiropractic associations might then define chiropractic properly and make appropriate changes in state laws.
Finding a Good Chiropractor
Here are the guidelines I offer patients who might want chiropractic treatment for back pain:
    • While a good chiropractor can do a good job treating back pain, not all chiropractors are the same; some follow the guidelines of science, some do not.
    • Look for a chiropractor who limits his/her practice to care of musculoskeletal problems and who uses hands-on generic spinal manipulation in combination with physical therapy modalities. Such a chiropractor can often be found working in a multi-disciplinary back-pain clinic.
    • Avoid chiropractors who propose to locate and adjust “vertebral subluxations” as a treatment for disease or to “restore and maintain health.”
    • Avoid chiropractors who ask for payment in advance for a long course of treatment. As a general rule, treatment should be discontinued if symptoms worsen after one week or have not improved after two weeks.
    • Avoid chiropractors who routinely x-ray new patients or who do full-spine x-rays on every patient. Remember that simple back strain will usually resolve on its own in a few weeks and does not require an x-ray exam.
    • Do not accept the services of a chiropractor who refuses to share his/her records with your family physician or a medical specialist. An orthopedist who has exchanged office notes with chiropractors can often offer guidance in selecting a chiropractor.
    • Persons who want manipulative therapy for a back problem but are reluctant to see a chiropractor should ask for a referral to a physiatrist, a physical therapist, or an orthopedic manual therapist who has been trained in the use of spinal manipulation.

Chiropractic and Spinal Manipulation Red Flags: A Comprehensive Review
Many people visit chiropractors’ offices seeking relief from back pain. Appropriate use of spinal manipulation provided by a chiropractor can be helpful in treating mechanical-type back pain, but there are good reasons to avoid chiropractic manipulation based on correction of “vertebral subluxations,” and there are red flags to look for before undergoing any kind of manipulative treatment for neck or back pain.
Sam Homola on July 7, 2017
Link


While generic spinal manipulation is an acceptable physical medicine modality, spinal manipulation based on chiropractic vertebral subluxation theory is scientifically unacceptable. Since a significant number of chiropractors base their practice on subluxation theory which supports use of spinal manipulation as a primary treatment for a broad scope of health problems, it continues to be necessary to inform the public about the controversial aspects of chiropractic care and the role of spinal manipulation as a form of manual therapy.
This updated fully-referenced review of chiropractic past and present will be helpful in connecting the dots for persons who have questions about chiropractic or who might be concerned about the practice of chiropractic as an alternative healing method. This review also offers useful tips and warnings dealing with spinal manipulative treatment for neck and back pain, including specific reasons why infants and small children should never be subjected to spinal manipulation, especially “spinal adjustments” provided by subluxation-based chiropractors.
Chiropractic subluxation theory: still no evidence
The vertebral subluxation theory that gave birth to the chiropractic profession in 1895 proposed that 95 per cent of diseases are caused by displaced vertebrae that place pressure on spinal nerves. Today, chiropractic is defined as a method of removing nerve interference to restore and maintain health by adjusting a “vertebral subluxation complex,” which has been described as “changes in nerve, muscle, connective, and vascular tissues which are understood to accompany the kinesiologic aberrations of spinal articulations”.
There is no credible evidence to support the theory that a vertebral subluxation can affect general health or cause internal organs to become diseased. Spinal nerves are commonly compressed by osteophyte formation or by a herniated disc. Even the most severe compression of a spinal nerve, which may cripple the supplied musculoskeletal structures, does not cause organic disease. In the absence of fracture or pathology, vertebral misalignments rarely affect spinal nerves.
Organs are not supplied by spinal nerves
Spinal nerves supply the sensory and motor (voluntary) functions of musculoskeletal structures. Involuntary function of the body’s organs is regulated by autonomic nerve ganglia and plexuses located outside the spinal column and by autonomic cranial and sacral parasympathetic nerves that pass through solid bony openings (where subluxations do not occur). The all-important vagus nerves (cranial nerves that originate in the brain stem) pass through openings in the base of the skull and travel down through the neck, thorax, and abdomen to supply organs along their path. Preganglionic autonomic (sympathetic) fibers, which emerge from the spinal cord and pass through spinal segments from the first thoracic vertebra to the second lumbar vertebra, terminate in sympathetic trunk and splanchnic ganglia located outside the spinal column.
The vagus nerves along with autonomic ganglia and nerve plexuses provide overlapping sympathetic and parasympathetic nerve supply from many directions and sources (in concert with chemical, hormonal, and circulatory factors) to assure continued function of the body’s organs, independent of spinal nerves. This is why severance of the spinal cord in the neck area, shutting off brain impulses to spinal nerves, can cause paralysis of muscles from the neck down while the body’s organs continue to function. (A serious transverse spinal cord lesion above C5 in the upper neck can cause respiratory paralysis and often death.) Transplanted organs, relying upon hormones supplied by blood flow, can function without reconnection of severed nerves.
Since the spinal cord ends at the level of the 2nd lumbar vertebra, spinal nerves travel down from the spinal cord (like the hair on a horse’s tail) to pass out through openings (foramina) between the lumbar vertebrae and through solid bony openings in the sacrum to supply bladder and bowel sphincter muscles. Except in severe cases of lower lumbar spondylolisthesis (sliding forward of a vertebra as a result of a fracture or a congenital defect in the bony bridges that connect the vertebra with the spinal joints), sacral spinal nerves are not affected by vertebral misalignment but can be compressed by protrusion of a lower lumbar disc into the spinal canal, affecting voluntary control of sphincter muscles (cauda equina syndrome), a medical emergency requiring the attention of a neurosurgeon.
The effect of spinal manipulation on joint mechanoreceptors and nociceptors might temporarily relieve back pain, and mobility might be improved by releasing adhesions and stretching connective tissues. But there is no evidence to indicate that such effects have a significant effect on the body’s organs.
A chiropractic vertebral subluxation or “joint dysfunction” alleged to cause disease by interfering with nerve supply to organs has never been proven to exist and cannot be equated with an orthopedic subluxation, a partial dislocation that causes musculoskeletal symptoms.
Tenuous subluxation theory
Generic spinal manipulation designed to relieve pain and restore mobility is not the same as a chiropractic adjustment that is claimed to improve health. While some chiropractors use spinal manipulation appropriately in a practice limited to treatment of musculoskeletal problems, many “adjust” the spine to correct “subluxations” in an attempt to restore and maintain health by removing “nerve interference.” The theory underlying such treatment is so tenuous that it cannot be explained or tested, resulting in a number of vague and implausible definitions that are supported only by placebo effects and anecdotal case reports.

Resting on the principles of its founding father, chiropractic in the United States continues to be defined as a method of correcting vertebral subluxations to restore and maintain health. A 2015 publication of the National Board of Chiropractic Examiners (NBCE), Practice Analysis of Chiropractic 2015, states that “The specific focus of chiropractic practice is known as the chiropractic subluxation or joint dysfunction. A subluxation is a health concern that manifests in the skeletal joints, and, through complex anatomical and physiologic relationships, affects the nervous system and may lead to reduced function, disability, or illness”. This definition of chiropractic is in keeping with a paradigm formulated by the Association of Chiropractic Colleges (ACC) in 1996, signed by 16 North American chiropractic college presidents:
Chiropractic is concerned with the preservation and restoration of health, and focuses particular attention on the subluxation…a complex of functional and/or structural and/or pathological articular changes that compromise neural integrity and may influence organ system function and general health.
A new definition of the chiropractic subluxation, formulated by The Rubicon Group, an international consortium of seven chiropractic colleges which includes three subluxation-based chiropractic colleges in the United States (Life Chiropractic College West, Life University, and Sherman College of Chiropractic), describes a “neurologically-centered model of subluxation”:
We currently define a chiropractic subluxation as a self-perpetuating, central segmental motor control problem that involves a joint, such as a vertebral motion segment, that is not moving appropriately, resulting in ongoing maladaptive neural plastic changes that interfere with the central nervous system’s ability to self-regulate, self-organize, adapt, repair and heal.
The International Federation of Chiropractors and Organizations (IFCO), disagreeing with the Rubicon definition of a chiropractic subluxation, responded with this statement:
The IFCO asserts strongly that any attempt to define chiropractic subluxation without emphasizing the importance of vertebral subluxation is a diminution of the profession.
The IFCO offered this definition of a chiropractic subluxation:
A vertebral subluxation is an alteration of the intervertebral relationships of one or more articulations of the spinal column or the immediate weight bearing components of the axial skeleton; accompanied by a change in the morphology of the tissue occupying the neural canal and/or intervertebral foramina; as well as an alteration of neural function sufficient to interfere with the transmission of organizing information, considered to be homologous to the mental impulse.
A 2015 Position Statement on Clinical and Professional Chiropractic Education, representing seven European chiropractic colleges, does not support chiropractic subluxation theory:
The teaching of vertebral subluxation complex as a vitalistic construct that claims that it is the cause of disease is unsupported by evidence. Its inclusion in a modern chiropractic curriculum in anything other than an historical context is therefore inappropriate and unnecessary.
Despite the obvious implausibility of chiropractic subluxation theory, explained in the scientifically incomprehensible language of pseudoscience, studies done by chiropractors rarely dispute the basic tenets of subluxation theory. One exceptional landmark study by a team of academic chiropractors, however, concluded that:
No supportive evidence is found for the chiropractic subluxation being associated with any disease process or of creating suboptimal health conditions requiring intervention.
But belief in subluxation theory persists. An independent study by chiropractic researchers revealed that:
Despite the controversies and paucity of evidence the term subluxation is still found often within the chiropractic curricula of most North American chiropractic programs
A survey of North American chiropractic students published in 2015 reported that a majority “would like to see an emphasis on correction of vertebral subluxations”.
The American Chiropractic Association (ACA), the leading association representing chiropractors, says that:
Chiropractic is a health care profession that focuses on disorders of the musculoskeletal system and the nervous system, and the effects of these disorders on general health.
With no mention of the word “subluxation,” the ACA advises prospective patients that “Doctors of Chiropractic (DCs) care for patients of all ages, with a variety of health conditions”. Embracing a broad scope of practice based on the effect of musculoskeletal problems on the nervous system (a position that leaves the door open for advocates of subluxation theory), it appears that the ACA might be refraining from renouncing subluxation theory in order to preserve its membership – a dilemma that compromises the association’s credibility in representing chiropractic as a science-based profession.
The International Chiropractic Association (ICA), the smaller of the two American chiropractic associations, clearly defends subluxation theory:
The basic premise of chiropractic science is that abnormalities and misalignments of the spine, defined as subluxations(s) in chiropractic science, can and do disrupt the normal function of the nervous system and may create negative health consequences. The correction and/or reduction of subluxation(s) through the adjustment of spinal structures can remove nervous system interference and restore the optimal function of the body.
Subluxation deniers vs. subluxation believers
Controversy surrounding the validity of subluxation theory has divided chiropractors into camps of “subluxation deniers” and “subluxation believers.” Chiropractors often deny that subluxation believers are in the majority, even though state laws and the National Board of Chiropractic Examiners in the United States define chiropractic as a profession “focused on the chiropractic subluxation”. It certainly appears that subluxation deniers in the chiropractic profession may be in the minority, making it difficult to find a chiropractor who does not subscribe to subluxation theory or who does not offer spinal manipulation as a treatment for anything other than a musculoskeletal problem.
Making an effort to separate themselves from the stigma associated with chiropractic subluxation theory, some subluxation believers no longer use the “subluxation” word, instead substituting vague descriptions of a spinal problem, such as a “joint dysfunction” or a “neuro-biomechanical lesion.” Some of these descriptions do not involve displacement of a vertebra, but all are alleged to have an adverse effect on the nervous system and general health. You cannot rely upon the care of a chiropractor who claims to have abandoned the vertebral subluxation theory but who continues to manipulate the spine in an attempt to restore and maintain health by removing nerve interference – care that is no different from that of a subluxation believer.
Consumers should be wary of the rhetoric of chiropractors who say “I do not treat disease. I simply remove nerve interference so that the body can heal itself.” Such chiropractors assume that for every disease there is a corresponding vertebral subluxation, requiring life-long treatment to correct or prevent subluxations.
Spinal manipulation as a treatment option for back pain
Although there is considerable literature dealing with the use of spinal manipulation as a treatment for neck and back pain, there are few reliable studies providing adequate proof supporting such treatment. A 2015 Cochrane review, for example, dealing with manipulation for neck pain, reported that “No high-quality evidence was found, so uncertainty about the effectiveness of mobilization or manipulation for neck pain remains”.
Low-back pain is most often the subject of credible reviews and studies that examine the effects of spinal manipulation, a treatment now being provided by physical therapists, osteopaths, physiatrists, orthopedists, and chiropractors. Scientifically-oriented reviews dealing with use of generic spinal manipulation as a treatment for back pain, however, do not offer strong support for such treatment:
    • A 2011 Cochrane Systematic Review of spinal manipulative therapy for chronic low-back pain reported that “High-quality evidence suggests that there is no clinically relevant difference between SMT [spinal manipulative therapy] and other interventions for reducing pain and improving function in patients with chronic back pain”.
    • A 2013 Cochrane review of spinal manipulative therapy for acute low-back pain concluded that “SMT is no more effective for acute low back pain than inert interventions, sham SMT or as an adjunct therapy. SMT also seems to be no better than other recommended therapies. Our evaluation is limited by the few numbers of studies; therefore, future research is likely to have an important impact on these estimates.”
    • A 2012 National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine review of back-pain studies reported that “Overall, studies have shown that spinal manipulation is one of several options─including exercise, massage, and physical therapy─that can provide mild-to-moderate relief from low-back pain. Spinal manipulation also appears to work as well as conventional treatments such as applying heat, using a firm mattress, and taking pain-relieving medications.”
    • A systematic review and meta-analysis of the use of spinal manipulative therapy in the treatment of acute low-back pain published in The Journal of the American Medical Association in 2017 concluded that such treatment resulted in “modest improvements in pain and function at up to 6 weeks.
Some chiropractic colleges offer decent instruction in the care of musculoskeletal problems, including skillful use of spinal manipulation as a treatment for back pain. But such treatment is tainted by subluxation theory that encompasses a broad scope of ailments. For this reason, physicians who refer back-pain patients to chiropractors for spinal manipulative therapy must be cautious in selection of a chiropractor, and they must take responsibility for the diagnosis, lest inappropriate treatment makes them vulnerable to liability for damages. Care must also be taken to make it clear that referral to a selected chiropractor who uses manipulation appropriately is not an endorsement of chiropractic subluxation theory.
Unfortunately, manipulative techniques used by chiropractors may vary from one practitioner to another. While some chiropractors may use generic spinal manipulation in an appropriate manner, many of their colleagues use subluxation-based proprietary manipulative techniques that have no known value and no reciprocal compatibility in working with other health-care professionals. The techniques and goals of mobilization or generic spinal manipulation, however, when properly performed and based on the science of anatomy, are always basically the same, no matter who the provider might be.
Although evidence supporting use of spinal manipulation as a treatment for back pain may be weak, and the benefits of such treatment modest or temporary, it is important to understand that while chiropractic manipulation based on subluxation theory has been rejected by the scientific community, generic spinal manipulation is a plausible and acceptable treatment option that can be beneficial in the care of carefully selected mechanical-type back problems.
Manipulation/mobilization/adjustment
Mobilization of joints has been traditionally identified as a physical therapy procedure. Most physical therapists who use manual therapy use manipulation as well as mobilization. Chiropractors, on the other hand, are identified primarily by their use of a “spinal adjustment,” a procedure that is used for a reason that differs from the principles supporting use of standard manipulation or mobilization.
On the physical therapy side, mobilization and manipulation are used to improve range of motion in any joint that does not function normally. Grade I through Grade IV mobilization, for example, moves joints through normal ranges of movement, while Grade V mobilization (thrust-type manipulation) forces movement of joints beyond their normal end-range of motion. A chiropractic adjustment based on subluxation theory is a thrust-type manipulation directed at a specific vertebra to remove “nerve interference.”
Manipulation that forces slight separation of joint surfaces can produce cavitation (popping sounds). Although cavitation or “gapping” of joints during spinal manipulation may temporarily increase range of movement or signal release of joint adhesions, the sound associated with such treatment (which can occur in normal joints) is generally not considered to be significant. In the case of a chiropractic adjustment, however, in which the stated goal is to correct a subluxation causing nerve interference, the popping sound can have a powerful placebo effect. Taking advantage of the power of suggestion, some chiropractors lead their patients to believe that the popping sound heard during a spinal adjustment means that vertebral subluxations are always present, requiring regular adjustments to keep selected vertebrae properly aligned. The nocebo effect (fear of illness) that occurs as a result of not getting regular adjustments further perpetuates unnecessary treatment.
Spinal manipulation as a treatment for neck and back problems has been used for thousands of years. A specific chiropractic adjustment, a thrust-type manipulation directed at selected vertebrae in an effort to restore and maintain health by removing nerve interference, is a fairly recent development, invented by D.D. Palmer in 1895. Subluxation-based chiropractors are quick to explain that long-lever spinal manipulation or mobilization is not the same as a specific short-lever chiropractic adjustment applied to a vertebral subluxation, thus clinging to a belief system that continues to define the practice of chiropractic.
A physical therapist who uses mobilization or manipulation (Grade V mobilization) to relieve pain and restore mobility in a compromised area of the spine is more likely to use manipulation appropriately than a subluxation-based chiropractor who uses “specific adjustments” up and down the spine to correct asymptomatic “subluxations” or to remove “nerve interference.”
Complementary vs. alternative
In observing the web sites and promotional materials of newly graduated chiropractors, it appears that many of these chiropractors are combining science-friendly treatment methods with the pseudoscience of subluxation theory in order to “remove nerve interference and improve health.” Some are claiming to be primary care providers, combining “spine care” with “health-and-wellness care” in a holistic approach that entails treatment and prevention of the gamut of human ailments, often including “functional medicine” and other questionable healing methods under the banner of “alternative medicine” or “integrative medicine.”
Although the public generally thinks of chiropractors as back specialists, few chiropractors limit their care to treatment of back pain. According to the Association of Chiropractic Colleges, “chiropractic is associated with the field of complementary and alternative medicine as a method of improving and preserving health.” Apparently, the chiropractic profession at its core has chosen the complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) route rather than seeking to develop as a scientifically acceptable back-care musculoskeletal specialty, despite the fact that back pain and musculoskeletal conditions are the No. 1 and No. 2 causes of disability worldwide.
Substituting an unproven spinal adjustment for a variety of proven or reasonably effective treatment methods for a variety of health problems places subluxation-based chiropractic care squarely in the camp of alternative medicine where bogus and unproven treatment methods gather for undeserved recognition.
It is important not to confuse a nonsensical unproven alternative treatment method (such as homeopathy or subluxation-based chiropractic) with scientifically acceptable massage or generic spinal manipulation that can be described as a primary or complementary form of treatment for some musculoskeletal problems. As said by Marcia Angell and Jerome Kassirer in 1998:
It is time for the scientific community to stop giving alternative medicine a free ride….There cannot be two kinds of medicine─conventional and alternative. There is only medicine that has been adequately tested and medicine that has not, medicine that works and medicine that may or may not work. Once a treatment has been tested rigorously, it no longer matters whether it was considered alternative at the outset. If it is found to be reasonably safe and effective, it will be accepted.
Back care vs. spine care

While a good chiropractor can offer a service of value in conservative care for uncomplicated mechanical-type back pain, a chiropractor is not a “spine specialist” capable of providing care for complicated conditions affecting the spine. Isolated from the mainstream of healthcare, solo chiropractors do not have access to the multiple medical facilities and the pharmaceuticals needed to diagnose and treat spinal problems involving severe injury, disease, infection, or pain of unknown origin – a service now being provided by some orthopedic surgeons who identify themselves as a spine specialist.
I have always believed that the chiropractic profession would be more acceptable socially and scientifically as a conservative back-care specialty or as a subspecialty of medicine – contingent, of course, upon changes in state laws and the curriculum of chiropractic colleges. Low back pain, the fifth most common reason for all physician visits in the United States, is difficult to diagnose and treat – a time-consuming responsibility that few physicians are qualified to handle or willing to accept and who would probably welcome a back-care specialty.
Physical therapy offers care and rehabilitation for a broad scope of neuromusculoskeletal problems – care that includes use of manual therapy. But there is not yet a certified physical-medicine specialty or subspecialty limited to conservative care for neck and back pain.
The path of chiropractic
At the present time, there are no indications that chiropractic colleges in the United States will seek specialization in conservative care for back problems, retreating from the definition of chiropractic as a form of alternative medicine. The National University of Health Sciences, for example, formerly the National College of Chiropractic (a leading chiropractic college), offers programs in naturopathic medicine, acupuncture, and oriental medicine as well as a degree in chiropractic medicine. Such dubious alternative healing methods are gaining acceptance as a form of “integrative medicine,” a designation that bends the rules of science in order to meet public demand for questionable care that can be financially lucrative when combined with conventional care.
There is no reason to believe that the subluxation theory will ever be discarded by all chiropractors. Adjustment of chiropractic vertebral subluxations, a belief system perpetuated by pseudoscience and monetary returns, will continue to be guided by whimsical thinking and misinformation. Chiropractic subluxations that are not detectable by conventional diagnostic procedures, for example, are allegedly being located by such dubious procedures as thermography, surface electromyography, applied kinesiology, and leg-length checks. Dozens of different antithetical manipulative techniques are used to correct such subluxations.
A 1995 publication endorsed by the Association for the History of Chiropractic listed 97 “named chiropractic techniques” used by chiropractors, most of which are too implausible to warrant consideration. For example, some chiropractors use a spring-loaded stylus in an attempt to tap vertebrae into alignment in order to “help the body heal itself”. A few use “reflex” techniques to realign vertebrae without manipulating the spine. Upper cervical chiropractors believe that aligning the atlas (the vertebra at the top of the spine) will “influence the central nervous system and brain stem function” as well as realign vertebrae from the neck down. And so on.

While the chiropractic profession continues to be mired in the pseudoscience of vertebral subluxation theory, use of spinal manipulation is gaining greater acceptance as a physical treatment option in the armamentarium of physical medicine, providing competition for chiropractic treatment of back pain. On a path of no return as a form of alternative medicine competing with conventional medical care, the chiropractic profession is becoming increasingly dependent upon its spinal nerve-interference theory to justify its existence and its independence as a healing art.
Red flags and back-pain symptoms that warn against use of spinal manipulation
The next time you have back pain and you want to try using spinal manipulation to relieve your symptoms, there are some red flags you should know about in order to avoid inappropriate use of such treatment, no matter who does it. You cannot always depend upon a chiropractor or a manual therapist to inquire about subjective symptoms that might be helpful in planning treatment. It is always a good idea to be as well informed as possible when submitting to any form of treatment, especially spinal manipulation or a spinal adjustment that might be potentially harmful.
It goes without saying that spinal manipulation for acute back pain should not be done immediately following injury or without a definitive diagnosis.
    • If you are on a treatment program requiring prolonged ingestion of a corticosteroid or a thyroid hormone, especially if you are past middle age, sudden appearance of back pain that restricts movement might be an indication that an osteoporotic vertebra has collapsed. Manipulation should not be considered.
    • If you have a history of lung, breast, or prostate cancer and you develop a gradual onset of back pain, or if you have persistent back pain for no apparent reason, you should be tested for bone disease. Some forms of malignancy commonly metastasize to the ribs or the vertebrae, making them vulnerable to fracture during manipulation.
    • Backaches can be caused by a kidney infection that may go undetected until an elevation in temperature is discovered. Always take your temperature when you have a backache. If you have a fever, you should always see your family physician, regardless of what you think might be causing your backache.
    • Mechanical-type back pain that originates in musculoskeletal structures is relieved by rest and aggravated by movement. Back pain that has an internal origin is unaffected by movement. If you develop constant back pain that is not affected by movement of your body, you should see your family physician to rule out such things as organic disease, infection, or an aortic aneurysm.
    • Persistent backache that defies diagnosis should undergo testing and observation in a search for such elusive diseases as ankylosing spondylitis or rheumatoid arthritis, which could be aggravated by manipulation.
    • Kidney stones can cause acute back pain. Unlike mechanical-type back pain that restricts movement, the referred pain of a kidney stone produces pain that will not allow you to rest or sit still. If you have the misfortune of experiencing back pain that causes you to squirm about or roll around on the floor, you should go to a hospital emergency room as soon as possible.
    • Pain, numbness, and other symptoms radiating down one or both legs, or weakness in one leg or foot may be an indication of encroachment upon spinal nerves in the lower portion of the spine. Such symptoms can be caused by disk herniation, osteophyte formation, or some other pathological process. When a spinal disc is herniated or when a spinal nerve is pinched, spinal manipulation is not indicated. (A pinched spinal nerve in the thoracic area of the spine can refer pain into musculoskeletal structures in thoracic and abdominal areas, often mimicking angina or an organic disease. Pain anywhere in the torso should be brought to the attention of a physician.)
    • Loss of bladder or bowel control with numbness in the perineal (saddle area) of your pelvis is a medical emergency (cauda equina syndrome) requiring the immediate attention of a neurosurgeon. Such symptoms can be caused by a lumbar disk protrusion that has entered the spinal canal.
The clear and hidden dangers of neck manipulation
Numerous reports have associated upper cervical manipulative therapy with stroke involving injury to vertebral or internal carotid arteries. Such strokes have occurred in young, healthy persons, some of which have been confirmed by imaging studies that show dissection of healthy vertebral arteries due to trauma. Although strokes believed to be caused by neck manipulation are rare, there is good reason to warn against use of neck manipulation that involves rotation of head and upper cervical (occiput-atlas and atlanto-axial) structures beyond normal ranges of movement.
The vertebral arteries in particular are vulnerable to injury when mobilization and manipulation techniques involve a rotatory component greater than 45 degrees at the atlanto-axial level. Risk always outweighs benefit when neck manipulation of any kind is used to correct alleged chiropractic subluxations.

The normal anatomical configuration of the top two cervical vertebrae that provide a bony pathway for the vertebral arteries places these arteries at risk when there is extreme head or upper neck rotation. In addition to possible disease or malformation in the network of vertebrobasilar and internal carotid arteries in the base of the skull, there are some rare, often undetected, structural abnormalities that threaten the vertebral arteries when the head and neck are rotated.
Obvious contraindications for cervical spine manipulation include atlas instability in rheumatoid arthritis, nerve root impingement or disc herniation, osteoporosis, use of blood thinners, carotid bruits, atherosclerosis, symptoms of vascular insufficiency (such as fainting) on active and passive head rotation within a normal range of movement, the short neck of basilar invagination (congenital migration of the upper cervical spine into the base of the skull), and so on.
Often undetected structural contraindications for upper neck manipulation include these cervical spine abnormalities:
    • A retrolenticular vertebral artery ring, an abnormal bony bridge that encompasses the vertebral artery where it passes over the posterior arch of the atlas, can severely compress a vertebral artery during rotatory upper cervical manipulation.
    • Chiari malformation, a structural defect that allows a portion of the cerebellum to pass down through the foramen magnum and enter the spinal canal, can cause headache that begins on the back of the head and neck, resembling a cervicogenic headache or a muscle-contraction headache. Upper cervical manipulation in such a case would be dangerous.
    • Bow hunter’s syndrome, a rare vertebral artery insufficiency caused by an abnormal fibrous band or an osseous prominence that compresses the vertebral artery at the atlantoaxial level during active or passive head rotation in a certain direction, often within a normal range of movement. Such symptoms detected during range of motion testing in the cervical spine are an obvious contraindication for cervical spine manipulation. Any symptom of circulatory insufficiency, such as dizziness or drop attack, caused by rotation of the head or by extension of the cervical spine warns against use of cervical spine manipulation or any form of manual therapy applied to the neck.
    • Os odontoideum is a congenital absence or lack of fusion of the odontoid process, a dowel-like projection of bone from the axis that serves as a pivoting point for rotation of the atlas. Since there is no intervertebral disc between the atlas and the axis, a defective odontoid process would allow dislocation of the atlas when the upper cervical spine is forcefully manipulated, with or without rotation.
Bottom line: There is no credible evidence to support use of spinal manipulation for anything other than uncomplicated mechanical-type neck or back pain and related neuromusculoskeletal problems. Upper neck manipulation, however, is so risky (with little evidence of benefit) that I usually advise against submitting to such treatment.
If you are looking for a chiropractor who treats back pain, look for one who does not subscribe to subluxation theory and who limits care to musculoskeletal problems – one who is willing to exchange office notes with your family physician. Remember that most of the time, acute low-back pain is a self-limiting condition that will resolve in four to six weeks, with or without treatment. Appropriate manipulative treatment may, however, relieve symptoms and reduce need for medication.
If acute back pain grows progressively worse or persists unrelieved for longer than a week, or if there is no measured improvement after two to four weeks, manipulation should be discontinued. Uncomplicated back pain that lasts longer than three months may be classified as chronic, requiring use of self-help measures (such as exercise and postural ergonomics) and occasional treatment for symptomatic relief as needed.
Chiropractic and children
According to the International Chiropractic Association’s Council on Chiropractic Pediatrics, “Chiropractic care can never start too early.” Patient education provided by the council advises that:
A 1992 survey showed that the most common conditions for which children visit a chiropractor are: earaches, neck pain, check-up, headache, upper respiratory, low back pain, allergies, asthma, enuresis, and thoracic pain. Other reasons are ADD and ADHD, colic, torticollis, insomnia, growing pains, and persistent crying in infants.
I do not know of any medically acceptable diagnosis that would warrant manipulating the spine of a pre-adolescent child. The cartilaginous, immature spine of an infant or a small child should never be manipulated, as some chiropractors are doing to correct alleged “subluxations”.
When British author Simon Singh stated in an April 19, 2008, issue of the Guardian that the British Chiropractic Association’s (BCA) claims that chiropractors can help treat children with “colic, sleeping and feeding problems, frequent ear infections, asthma and prolonged crying” were bogus, he was sued for libel by the BCA. The BCA was unable to present adequate scientific evidence to support chiropractic treatment for children. The suit was withdrawn in 2010 when the court ruled that Singh’s comments were legally permissible as “fair comment”.
There has also been some speculation that manipulating the spine of a child younger than 6 to 8 years of age might fracture or damage cartilaginous epiphyseal growth centers, an occult injury that could result in development of pre-adolescent spinal deformity such as scoliosis or Scheuermann’s kyphosis.

In general, “Potential complications and unknown benefits indicate that SMT should not be used in the pediatric population.”
The above statement was made by a neurosurgeon. I have not seen any credible medical publications that recommend use of spinal manipulation for children. When the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services published Acute Low Back Problems in Adults [PDF], suggesting that spinal manipulation might be helpful for patients with acute low back problems without radiculopathy, it excluded children younger than 18 years of age, “since diagnostic and treatment considerations for this group are often different than for adults.”

Spinal Fusion: Chiropractic and Subluxation
Jann Bellamy on November 3, 2011
Link
A spirited exchange about chiropractic arose in response to a recent post proposing “The Cure” for the legalization of implausible and unproven diagnostic methods and treatments. Some comments pointed to the implausibility of the chiropractic “subluxation” and the lack of robust evidence of efficacy/effectiveness for spinal manipulation, as well as the difficulty of understanding what exactly “chiropractic” is, or does, that distinguishes it from other manual therapists.  In response, other comments were posted positing that the Science-Based Medicine blog “is not informed  on contemporary chiropractic practice,” that “the profession does not support [the chiropractic] subluxation as a cause of disease,” that chiropractors who treat the chiropractic subluxation are “on the fringe,”  and that the chiropractic “subluxation” is no longer taught in chiropractic colleges as a clinically relevant concept, but merely as an artifact of chiropractic history.
However, a review of recent chiropractic literature does not appear to support the latter opinions.  The same concerns as raised on SBM are shared by chiropractors themselves and are discussed in articles appearing in peer-reviewed chiropractic journals. Nor is the chiropractic literature as sanguine on the demise of the chiropractic “subluxation” as a clinically relevant condition which is both diagnosable and treatable.
Despite the concerns expressed by chiropractors themselves, the chiropractic literature continues to discuss the chiropractic “subulxation” as if it were a clinically relevant condition subject to diagnosis and amenable to treatment for both non-musculoskeletal and musculoskeletal conditions.  This same view of the “subluxation” is taught in chiropractic colleges in North America and Australia.
Chiropractic 101: the subluxation
A June, 2011, article in the journal Chiropractic and Manual Therapies explored, as the title explains, The prevalence of the term subluxation in North American English-language Doctor of Chiropractic Programs.  The authors, one from the School of Education at the Indiana Institute of  Technology and the other a D.C. on the faculty of Bridgeport College of Chiropractic in Connecticut and the School of Chiropractic and Sports Science at Murdoch University in Australia, studied the academic catalogs of 16 North American chiropractic colleges for use of the term “subluxation.”  The authors chose these catalogs as an indication of “what domains of knowledge are taught in the  classroom and what domains are evaluated in assuring student competence.”
Their conclusion?
The concept of the subluxation in chiropractic is a controversial subject with a paucity of evidence. With the exception of three schools, all English-language DCPs [Doctor of Chiropractic Programs] in North America mention the concept of the subluxation either in course titles or descriptions and/or their respective missions. Despite the lack of evidence for the subluxation construct, it appears to be very much a key part of chiropractic education.
Some schools may state that they are not subluxation-focused or heavily engaged in the teaching of subluxation. Nonetheless, most schools continue to teach about the subluxation in what seems to be more than just a historical context. We believe that this puts the profession in an awkward position because the skeptic and/or critic of subluxation can point to chiropractic education as outdated and unscientific. Chiropractic education will have to address this issue if the chiropractic education enterprise wishes to become scientifically competitive with other healthcare sciences and produce graduates who are critical thinkers prepared as the evidence changes to change their practice and throughout their careers.
The authors specifically rejected the notion that the subluxation was taught simply as an historical concept:
One might argue that a historical presentation of the subluxation may be all we are finding references to in our research of the DCP curricula. This would be a reasonable argument if the subluxation was mentioned in only one course in a DCP program or if it was only in what was described as a philosophy course. This, in fact, only occurred at two colleges (Texas Chiropractic College and the University of Bridgeport College of Chiropractic), however, with an aggregate average of 13.5 appearances [in the catalogs] and many of those in technique classes it seems unlikely that this is purely to explain the history of [the] term in the chiropractic profession.
In support of their conclusions, the authors referenced other research finding:
    • Over 88% of chiropractors surveyed favored retaining the term vertebral subluxation complex.
    • Over 70% of chiropractors reported that subluxation is important to their clinical decisions and guides their clinical care of patients.
    • A strong majority (over 75%) believed that subluxation was a significant contributing factor 50% or more of visceral disorders.
The article concluded with a prediction that just the sort of examination of current statutory scope of practice for chiropractors I’ve been advocating could occur: “Future research should determine if changes in regulation and research change the prevalence of the use of the term subluxation in chiropractic curricula.” [Emphasis added.]
A closer look at Canadian Memorial Chiropractic College
Despite the fact that the study found “no mention of the term subluxation” at Canadian Memorial Chiropractic College [CCMC] another article in the chiropractic literature,  Attitudes of clinicians at the Canadian Memorial Chiropractic College towards the chiropractic management of non-musculoskeletal conditions, revealed that “although the concept of chiropractic treatment for non-MSK conditions is controversial, students at the Canadian Memorial Chiropractic College . . . are exposed to a variety of opinions on the subject.”  In a survey of clinicians supervising interns at one of six clinics in the Toronto area, all of whom had been educated at CMCC, 50% either “agreed” or “strongly agreed”  that chiropractic could be effective for the treatment of asthma, chronic pelvic pain, constipation, dysmennorhea, infantile  colic and vertigo.”
This study was published in the Journal of the Canadian Chiropractic Association, which describes itself as “the official, peer reviewed, quarterly research publication of the Canadian Chiropractic Association.”
To understand the significance of 50% figure, one must realize that the referenced treatment of non-MSK conditions by chiropractors is subluxation-based:  the detection of spinal “misalignments” and their “correction” through adjustments.”   Without ever using the term “subluxation,” this is evident in the article’s explanations for treatment of various non-MSK conditions.  [Note also the improper use of “case studies” as “evidence.”]
Asthma:
Chiropractic treatment [that is, adjustments] has been thought to be beneficial in the treatment of this condition as it posited that it may modify the autonomic system and elicit viscerosomatic reactions to it. Additionally, it has been hypothesized that misalignments at the levels of the upper C-spine create spinal reflexes that can induce asthma and correcting the misalignments could potentially alleviate the symptoms.
Constipation:
In a study conducted by Alcantara and Mayer on three pediatric patients, they found successful resolution of the condition after a regiment [sic] of spinal manipulative therapy by observing an increased frequency in bowel movements, with less straining and pain. Similarly, a case study done of a 64 year old Caucasian female demonstrated a positive resolution to chronic constipation after ten treatments of spinal manipulativetherapy.
Infantile colic:
Since an‘adjustment’ theoretically causes sympathetic stimulation which, based on physiology, in turn relaxes the smooth muscle of the gastrointestinal tract, reduces peristalsis, and inhibits bowel function, infantile colic could be  effectively treated through manual therapy.
Vertigo:
A retrospective study conducted by Elster showed 100% positive response with either symptoms having improved or completely reversed within one to six months of care using a treatment plan of upper cervical adjustments.
In sum, while the CCMC does not openly mention the chiropractic subluxation in its academic catalog, its students are trained by chiropractors who accept the existence and clinical significance of the subluxation and the utility of detecting and correct it for a variety of conditions, as described in an article which wholly fails to question the concept.
National University of Health Sciences
Another institution which, according to the study of academic catalogs, did not mention the subluxation is the National University of Health Sciences (NUHS), which educates naturopaths and acupuncturists as well as chiropractors.    However, had the authors examined a broader range of the school’s literature in divining support for the chiropractic subluxation and its putative effect on human health they would have found it in the form of the Journal of Chiropractic Medicine, published by NUHS and described on the school’s website thus:
Published quarterly, this peer-reviewed indexed journal meets the modern-day chiropractic physician’s need for practical and cutting-edge information with concrete clinical applications.
A review of the first 25 articles, published  during 2010-2011 (a full fifteen of which were case reports) appearing in aPubMed search for the Journal of Chiropractic Medicine, turned up the  following:
Applied  kinesiology methods for a 10-year-old child with headaches, neck pain, asthma,  and reading disabilities:
According to  Quackwatch, “applied kinesiology is a pseudoscience based on the anatomically  and physiologically impossible notion that muscle-testing enables the  practitioner to determine ‘weaknesses’ of organs throughout the body that  ‘correspond’ to nutrients placed under the tongue.” Application of various  applied kinesiology diagnostic methods and treatments is described in this  Journal of Chiropractic Medicine article, including:
Insalvation refers to the fact that the taste buds on the tongue can detect extremely small concentrations of substances within a fraction of a second of stimulation. Oral nutrient evaluations are used in AK because they are clinically useful in the assessment process. Exposure to taste elicits a variety of neurologic, muscular, digestive, endocrine, cardiovascular, thermogenic, and renal responses . . . [T]here is considerable evidence in the literature of extensive efferent function throughout the body from stimulation of the gustatory and olfactory receptors with actual insalivation . . . Insalivation of choline (a component of the neurotransmitter acetylcholine) corrected this finding.” [It is unclear what “finding” was “corrected.”]
In a swipe at the  patient’s pediatrician, the article adds:
The previous treatments did not deal directly with the craniosacral system, nor did they appear to evaluate adequately the sensory input into the nervous system from the musculoskeletal and viscerosomatic system (adrenal glands and lungs). Applied kinesiology theory suggests that to resolve biomechanical, biochemical, psychosocial, and sensory problems, many areas of the body must be examined and corrected to achieve long-lasting symptomatic relief.
Cessation of  cyclic vomiting in a 7-year-old girl after upper cervical chiropractic care: a  case report.  The lead author is an  Assistant Professor at Palmer College of Chiropractic.  From the abstract:
A 7-year-old girl had a history of cyclic vomiting episodes for the past 4 ½ years. She also had a 2-month history of headaches and stomachache. . . The patient received low-force chiropractic spinal manipulation to her upper cervicalspine. [As described in the article, “The directional misalignment was determined as an anterior-right misalignment by using pediatric Duff analysis on her upper cervical radiographs.”] There was improvement in her symptoms within an hour after the chiropractic manipulation. . . This case study suggests that there may be a role for the use of chiropractic spinal manipulative therapy for treating cyclic vomiting syndrome.
Use of multimodal  conservative management protocol for the treatment of a patient with cervical  radiculopathy.  The author is an  Assistant Professor in the Department of Chiropractic at D’Youville College,  Buffalo, NY.  The article describes  chiropractic treatment following “Gonstead chiropractic protocols”  of a patient with a disk protrusion at C5-C6.  Here’s a description of the Gonstead  System from the Gonstead Clinical Studies  Society, quoted in Keating JC, Charlton KH,  Subluxation: Dogma or Science?  Chiropractic & Osteopathy. Vol. 13, August 10, 2005:
Minor displacements of the spinal bones, known as vertebral subluxations, can cause endangering stress to the spinal cord which acts as the main line of intelligence for the whole body. These displacements, or subluxations, are the cause of many of the unwanted health conditions that people suffer from every day. Although there have been many valuable techniques that have been developed in the chiropractic profession, the Gonstead System is considered a ‘gold standard’ for chiropractic techniques because of its record of safety and effectiveness in correcting vertebral subluxation . . .
In addition to  the articles describing “subluxation”-based treatment, of these 25 most recent  articles in the Journal of Chiropractic Medicine, three discussed diagnostic  techniques for the detection of chiropractic “subluxations.”
Standard  deviation analysis of the mastoid fossa temperature differential reading: a  potential model for objective chiropractic assessment.  The author is an Assistant Director of  Research at Sherman College of Chiropractic:
The mastoid fossa  temperature differential (MFTD) reading is described as having been used in  chiropractic since the 1950s.  A  temperature is obtained, without making contact, in the mastoid fossa area on  both sides.  An MFTD “is calculated by  subtracting the mastoid fossa temperature on one side from the other  side.”  While “the clinical significance  of the MFTD readings has yet to be determined,” nevertheless “one method for  interpreting MFTD readings is with pattern analysis, where an abnormal set of  baseline readings are identified and thought to be related to the condition  known as vertebral subluxation.”
Computer modeling  of selected projectional factors of the 84-in focal film distance  anteroposterior full spine radiograph compared with the 40-in film distance  sectional views.  Two of the authors are  chiropractors in private practice and also involved in research at the Gonstead  Clinical Studies Society:
While  acknowledging that the role of the full-spine anteroposterior full spine  radiograph is “controversial,” the authors conclude that “working knowledge of  the A-P full spine view is important . . . [as it] may be used for scoliosisevaluation; and additionally, there are doctors of chiropractic who use the A-P  full spine as part of their assessment when viewing of the full spine.”  And what might they be “assessing” in the  “full spine?”  Although not specificallyadmitted in the article,  full-spine  radiographs are used by chiropractors for the “detection” of   “subluxations.”  Peterson DH, Bergmann TF, Chiropractic  Technique, Principles and Procedures,  2nd ed. (Mosby 2002), 75-79.
Geometry of  colplanar stereoscopic radiographic pairs for analysis of the lateral cervical radiograph: a study using mathematical models.  The author is a Research Assistant Professor at Sherman Chiropractic  College.  The article is of interest only  to those who use X-rays to detect the presence of cervical “subluxations.”
In sum, a review  of the most recent 25 articles in the NUHS- published Journal of Chiropractic  Medicine reveals that NUHS has hardly rejected the chiropractic subluxation,  even though its academic catalogue does not mention the term.
Life University College of Chiropractic
A recent article  about chiropractic education shows how instruction in the detection and  correction of subluxations is part and parcel of the core training of  chiropractic students at Life University College of Chiropractic.  The article, Self-Perceived Skills  Confidence:  An Investigative Study of  Chiropractic Students in the Early Phases of a College’s Clinic Program, was  written by an Associate Professor at this chiropractic school.   Categories of student self-assessment  surveyed for the article
. . . were those used in the early clinical curriculum. They included radiograph interpretation of the pelvis, occiput, atlas, and vertebral spine, using full-spine listings (Gonstead type) with the spinious process as a reference, and descriptive listings (fixation, malposition, misalignment, restriction) with the vertebral body as a reference, and motion palpation assessment of the corresponding anatomical areas.
Spinal manipulation categories were those used in the clinical curriculum. They included basic manual intersegmental full-spine (Gonstead-type) and diversified procedures . . .
This description  is, quite literally, a textbook example of student training in the detection  and correction of the chiropractic “subluxation.” Scaringe JG, Gaye, LJ,  Palpation: The Art of manual Assessment (Chapter 10), Scaringe JG, Cooperstein  R, “Chiropractic Manual Procedures (Chapter 12) in  Redwood D, Cleveland CS, eds., Fundamentalsof Chiropractic (Mosby 2003).   It was  accepted for publication in a peer-reviewed chiropractic journal, the Journalof Manipulative and Physiological Therapeutics (May/June 2010), and won a  chiropractic research reward.
More  “subluxation” in recent chiropractic literature
The chiropractic journal articles  summarized above demonstrate that the chiropractic “subulxation” is still  taught in North American chiropractic colleges as a clinically relevant  condition capable of “detection” and “correction.”  They also show that the putative  “subluxation” is uncritically presented as such in current peer-reviewed chiropractic  literature.
Even those chiropractic  journals which appear to be more oriented toward an evidence-based assessment  of manual therapies have recently published articles which uncritically accept  subluxation-based chiropractic diagnostic techniques and therapies. In addition  to the articles noted above, we find:
From the Journal  of Manipulative and Physiological Therapeutics:
Interexaminer  reliability of supine leg checks for discriminating leg-length inequality  (2011):  Discusses “functional leg-length  inequality,” a bogus diagnostic method used to determine “subluxations.”
A retrospective  study of chiropractic treatment of 276 Danish Infants with infantile colic  (2010):  Without ever describing the  proposed mechanism of action by which “chiropractic manipulation” is purported  to affect infantile colic, reaches the conclusion that “the findings of this  study do not support the assumption that effect of chiropractic treatment of  infantile colic is a reflection of the normal cessation of this disorder.”
Running posture  and step length changes immediately after chiropractic treatment in a patient  with xeroderma pigmentosum (2009): “A 5-year-old female patient with XP (type  A) volunteered to participate in the experiment with the consent of her parents  . . . [T]he patient was assessed for spinal dysfunction and adjusted (full  spine) using diversified techniques . . .  Adjustments were delivered in an attempt to correct any or all of the  spinal dysfunctions that the clinician [a chiropractor] found at the time of  the experiment.”
Journal of the  Canadian Chiropractic Association:
Chiropractic care  for patients with asthma: A systematic review of the literature (2010):  States, without criticism of the lack of  scientific plausibility underlying the concept, that “in treating asthmatic  patients, the objective of chiropractic spinal manipulative therapy (high  amplitude, low velocity thrusts) is  . . . to affect nervous system activity.”
Chiropractic care  of a pediatric patient with symptoms associated with gastroesophageal reflux  disease, fuss-cry-irritability with sleep disorder syndrome and irritable  infant syndrome of musculoskeletal origin (2008):  “it was determined that the patient had  spinal segmental dysfunctions of the atlas and the 4th thoracic vertebrae.  The atlas was determined to have a right  posterior rotation and right laterally malposition with respect to the C2  vertebral body (VB).  The 4th thoracic VB  had a posterior malposition with respect to C3VB.  Following craniosacral technique procedures,  cranial distortions of the right parietal and temporal bones were determined as  well as aberrant motion of the mandible at the right temporomandibular joint  (TMJ).” And so on.
More criticism of  chiropractic, by chiropractors
Admirable for  their criticism of the “subluxation,” other recent articles in the literature  critical of chiropractic reveal the “subluxation’s” continued presence in the  current practice of chiropractic in North America and in Australia.   As well, they demonstrate that some of the  same criticisms of chiropractic posted on SBM have been expressed bychiropractors themselves.
An article  published in Chiropractic and Manual Therapies this year, authored by 3  chiropractic academics, found that “patients searching the Internet for  chiropractic wellness information will often find a lot of poorly done, uselessinformation that will not help them maintain health or become well.”  Significant to our discussion here, of thesample studied:
    • 77% of sites  contained information on chiropractic “subluxation”
    • 60% had  information on “innate”
    • 34% contained  obvious anti-vaccination information
    • 34% had  information that was anti-drug (prescription or medical use of drugs)
The authors  concluded that “the depth of information on the sites analyzed was poor and wasrarely evidence-based.”
Another article,  published in Chiropractic and Osteopathy (as the journal Chiropractic and  Manual Therapies was formerly named) in 2010 surveyed a sample of  non-practicing chiropractors and their reasons for leaving chiropractic practice.  Due to the small sample size  and low rate of response, the authors state that “generalizations to broader populations should be made with caution.”  Yet, the results reveal a notable congruence between the negative opinions about chiropractic expressed on SBM and those who had actually left  the practice of chiropractic:
    • 80% agreed that  business ethics in chiropractic were perceived as questionable.
    • 62% disagreed  with the statement that chiropractic education is an asset when pursuing  another career.
    • 60% agreed that  dogma and philosophy of chiropractic were reasons to abandon active practice.
    • 71% believed that  associates in a chiropractic practice are often encouraged to prolong the careof patients.
    • 74% believed that  the chiropractic profession lacked cultural authority.
    • 58% agreed that  the political problems in chiropractic were factors in being perceived as aquality clinician.
This frustration  with chiropractic was shared in another recent article in the same journal  authored by an Australian chiropractor and based on a lectured delivered at the  Annual Conference of the Chiropractic & Osteopathic College of Australasia,  in 2010.  The author bemoans the fact  that
    • The Chiropractors  Association of Australia (CCA) “actively promotes subluxation based  chiropractic.”
    • “Chiropractic  trade publications and so-called educational seminar promotion material often  abound with advertisements of how practitioners can effectively sell the VSC  [vertebral subluxation complex] to an ignorant ublic.”
    • The CCA and the  Australian Spine Research Foundation (ASRF) “are promoting ‘wellness care,’  which involves the detection and adjustment of VSC’s,” noting a recent  statement in the ASRF’s newsletter  that  “. . .  it is not possible to be well if  vertebral subluxation complex is present as a vertebral subluxation complex  represents a non-homeostatic state . . . . which makes a state of wellness  impossible.”
    • Of the three  chiropractic teaching institutions in Australia, the program at RMIT Universitypromotes what the author calls “the subluxation myth.”
Conclusion
Criticisms of  chiropractic on Science-Based Medicine are not the reflection of  misunderstanding of contemporary chiropractic  practice in that, according to chiropractic literature:
Subluxation dogma  continues to be a part the education and training of chiropractors in North American and Australia.
Subluxation-based  chiropractic remains an integral part of chiropractic practice in North America  and Australia, as demonstrated by the uncritical acceptance of articles  discussing its implausible diagnostic methods and treatments in peer-reviewed  chiropractic journals, its presence in surveys of chiropractic practice in  peer-reviewed chiropractic literature, as well as the aforementioned inclusion  in chiropractic education.

Subluxation Theory: A Belief System That Continues to Define the Practice of Chiropractic
Chiropractic as a profession is defined by the subluxation theory, the unfalsifiable belief that disease is caused by impaired nerve flow. No proof exists for this theory, and likely never will.
Sam Homola on December 30, 2011
Link
When I graduated from Lincoln Chiropractic College in 1956, I had come to the conclusion that chiropractic’s subluxation theory, that misaligned vertebrae can cause organic disease, was not true. When I began my practice in Panama City, Florida, I limited my practice to care of mechanical-type back pain and related problems. Back then, that was not too much of a stretch, since manipulative services were not readily available in medical practices and there were a number of orthopedic and physical medicine texts recommending use of manipulation in the treatment of back pain.
In 1963, I published my book Bonesetting, Chiropractic, and Cultism, renouncing subluxation theory and recommending that chiropractic be developed as physical treatment specialty in the care of back pain. The book was reviewed by the Library Journal (February 1, 1964) and recommended for inclusion in medical and reference libraries. In 1965, I received a letter from the American Chiropractic Association (ACA) informing me that my application for membership in the ACA had been rejected. In the years to follow, I published many articles in an attempt to initiate an effort to change chiropractic from a subluxation-based practice to a legitimate physical treatment method that would fit in with mainstream health care. My suggestions were ignored and I was called a “chiropractic heretic.” Today, I find myself still saying some of the things I said in my 1963 Bonesetting book, still being rejected by most of my colleagues and still voicing opposition to subluxation theory.
There are now some chiropractors who do not subscribe to the theory that some kind of segmental dysfunction in the spine can cause organic disease, but they are overshadowed by subluxation-based chiropractors who publish their own journals, using scientific-sounding jargon to defend implausible theories and dubious treatment methods. Some of these chiropractors do not use the “subluxation” word, instead substituting some other vague description of a spinal lesion, such as “joint dysfunction,” alleged to have the same affect on the nervous system and general health as a “vertebral subluxation.”
The status of chiropractic vertebral subluxation
In the United States, state laws and chiropractic publications define chiropractic as a method of correcting vertebral subluxations to restore and maintain health. A 2010 publication of the National Board of Chiropractic Examiners (NBCE), Practice Analysis of Chiropractic, states that “The specific focus of chiropractic practice is known as the chiropractic subluxation or joint dysfunction. A subluxation is a health concern that manifests in the skeletal joints, and, through complex anatomical and physiologic relationships, affects the nervous system and may lead to reduced function, disability, or illness.” This definition of chiropractic is in keeping with a paradigm formulated by the Association of Chiropractic Colleges (ACC) in 1996, signed by 16 North American chiropractic college presidents: “Chiropractic is concerned with the preservation and restoration of health, and focuses particular attention on the subluxation.”
When the Council on Chiropractic Education (CCE) published its proposed 2012 Accreditation Standards for chiropractic colleges, reference to the word “subluxation” was omitted. The American Chiropractic Association (ACA) responded, in part, arguing that “The elimination of any reference to this term in the proposed standards will be viewed by many within the profession as a counter productive action that will, in the long-term, likely weaken the profession’s collaborative strength and historical identity.“ The CCE compromised by using the nebulous phrase “subluxation/neuro-biomechanical dysfunction” in the final 2012 Standards in order to satisfy advocates of the vertebral subluxation theory. (An open letter to the profession from CCE, Nov 22-11) Obviously, the factory of the chiropractic profession has not discarded subluxation theory. Chiropractic associations continue to reflect the views of the majority, even if such views are based on a belief system.
At least one recent study by individual academic chiropractors has concluded that “No supportive evidence is found for the chiropractic subluxation being associated with any disease process or of creating suboptimal health conditions requiring intervention.” (Mirtz, et al. An epidemiological examination of the subluxation construct using Hill’s criteria of causation. Chiropractic and Manual Therapies. 2009;17:13)
Another independent study by academic chiropractors revealed that “Despite the controversies and paucity of evidence the term subluxation is still found often within the chiropractic curricula of most North American chiropractic programs.” (Mirtz & Perle. The prevalence of the term subluxation in North American English-Language Doctor of Chiropractic programs. Chiropractic and Manual Therapies. 2011;19:14)
It will not be enough for chiropractors and chiropractic colleges to substitute such words and phrases as “joint dysfunction,” “vertebral subluxation complex,” and “subluxation/neuro-biomechanical dysfunction” for the word “subluxation” if they continue to imply that such disturbances can affect the nervous system to cause illness. A chiropractic subluxation by any other name is still a chiropractic subluxation.
Real and imaginary benefits of spinal manipulation
Recent reviews of the literature indicate that manipulation may not be any more effective than other treatment methods in affecting the ultimate outcome in recovery from back pain. For symptomatic relief of uncomplicated mechanical-type back pain, however, use of hands-on manipulation may provide more immediate and dramatic relief by stretching tight muscles and mobilizing the spine. Apart from the misinformation provided by chiropractors who keep asymptomatic patients coming back for correction of “subluxations” alleged to cause a myriad of health problems, many back-pain patients return for manipulative treatment for the symptomatic relief they experience. A competent chiropractor would release the patient when back-pain symptoms have resolved, as opposed to subluxation-based chiropractors who lock their patients into lifetime “subluxation correction” as a preventive measure. Endorsement of the use of manipulation in the treatment of mechanical-type back pain is not an endorsement of chiropractic adjustments used to correct subluxations or some other “joint disturbance” alleged to cause illness or poor health.
In rare cases involving articular adhesions, actual locking of a vertebral joint, or post-traumatic loss of mobility in spinal joints, there is no substitute for appropriate manipulation. Recognizing this, physical therapists and orthopedic manual therapists are now including use of manipulation in their treatment armamentarium.
In addition to the effect of mobilization and manipulation in relieving uncomplicated mechanical-type back pain and restoring mobility in spinal joints, there are additional effects produced by “popping” the vertebrae.
When vertebrae are manipulated to produce a popping sound, there is a slight separation of joint (facet) surfaces, producing a vacuum that pulls in nitrogen gas from joint or synovial fluids to fill the space. This is called “cavitation,” an effect that temporarily increases mobility and range of motion. Such an effect may produce a sense of well being, which seems compelling for some people. There might also be some slight temporary increase in height as a result of cavitation and decompression of disc cartilage.
Persons who believe that they have subluxations or vertebrae out of place causing a health problem may be subject to a powerful placebo effect when the spine is popped, leading them to believe that their condition is being helped or cured by replacement of a vertebra. Such popping does not mean that a vertebra was out of place. Normal vertebrae can be popped when thrust-type manipulation forces movement of spinal joints into the paraphysiologic space (beyond the normal range of movement).
After vertebrae have been manipulated to produce cavitation, it may take three or four hours for the joint surfaces to settle back together so that the vertebrae can be popped again. This popping sound may produce fear that failure to get regular adjustments to pop or align the vertebrae will result in development of illness─a nocebo effect often exploited by chiropractors who have asymptomatic patients coming back on a regular basis for “preventive maintenance.”
Alternative medicine: A refuge for chiropractic
In view of increasing opposition to subluxation theory, some chiropractic colleges have read the handwriting on the wall and moved into the camp of alternative medicine. The National University of Health Sciences (NUHS), for example, often referred to as the foremost American chiropractic college, offers Doctor of Chiropractic, Doctor of Naturopathic Medicine, Master of Science in Acupuncture, and Master of Science in Oriental Medicine degrees. NUHS recently announced a new cooperative arrangement with the Graduate Program in Complementary and Alternative Medicine at Georgetown University Medical Center in Washington D.C. Faculty at the two schools will work together to help students seeking advanced degrees in health care by advising students of the benefits of each other’s programs and providing preferential seating and advanced standing in each other’s programs when appropriate.
The web site of the Association of Chiropractic Colleges, in its “What Is Chiropractic?” section, states: “Because of the emphasis on holistic health care, chiropractic is associated with the field of complementary and alternative medicine.” (Accessed December, 13, 2011) Most health-care professionals consider “alternative medicine” to be a haven for unproven and implausible treatment methods.
Few consumers are aware of the great diversity in chiropractic, and few know what questions to ask when looking for a science-based chiropractor. Until all chiropractic colleges uniformly renounce the vertebral subluxation theory and are upgraded to training musculoskeletal specialists, treatment methods will vary from one chiropractor to another, incompatible with exchange in mainstream health care. With increasing numbers of physical therapists using high velocity, low amplitude thrust-type manipulation, physicians and other health-care providers can refer a patient to physical therapy for spinal manipulation, thus avoiding the problems associated with finding a chiropractor who uses manipulation appropriately.
In observing the web sites and promotional materials of newly graduated chiropractors, it appears that many of these chiropractors are combining science and pseudoscience to support treatment methods based on the basic tenets of traditional chiropractic, that is, manipulating the spine for some unverifiable neurological effect that will affect general health or organ function. Some, claiming to be primary care providers, combine “spine care” with “health care” and “wellness care” in a holistic approach that entails treatment and prevention over a broad scope of ailments, using a variety of alternative healing methods. Legislation to allow chiropractors with an “advanced practice” certification to prescribe drugs from a limited formulary has been proposed in New Mexico, South Carolina, and Alabama. Chiropractors would be required to have 90 hours of additional training in pharmacology. So far, such legislation, opposed by chiropractors who feel that chiropractic should remain a drugless healing profession defined by the basic principles of chiropractic, has failed.
Chiropractic and physical therapy are not the same
The only thing unique about chiropractic is its basic definition as a method of adjusting vertebral subluxations to restore and maintain health. Any other physical treatment method, including generic spinal manipulation, is physical medicine. The subluxation theory has been the chiropractic profession’s only reason for existence since its inception in 1895. Failure of the profession to establish itself as a legitimate physical-treatment specialty with an armamentarium that includes use of generic spinal manipulation continues to leave the profession dependent upon the basic tenets of chiropractic. Many chiropractors feel that if the chiropractic profession discards the subluxation theory and specializes in the care of back pain and related musculoskeletal problems, it will not be able to compete with physical therapists and other musculoskeletal practitioners who use manual therapy.
With a foundation based on an implausible theory that nurtures a hodgepodge of dubious chiropractic techniques, the chiropractic profession is splintered by philosophies that go in many different directions. The approach of chiropractic colleges may range from “straight chiropractic,” which proposes that most ailments can be treated by adjusting vertebral subluxations, to “alternative medicine,” which permits use of unproven treatment methods to treat a broad scope of ailments without resorting to subluxation theory.
It’s important to understand that manipulation used in the context of chiropractic subluxation theory is not done for the same reasons guiding the use of manipulation by physical therapists. With the exception of a few science-based chiropractors who use manipulation appropriately, it appears that most chiropractors manipulate or adjust putative vertebral subluxations in a misguided effort to restore and maintain health. Physical therapists use manipulation-mobilization primarily to restore mobility in the spine. When chiropractors accuse physical therapists of stealing their treatment method, nothing could be further from the truth. Generic spinal manipulation has long been a part of physical medicine and is unrelated to subluxation-based chiropractic. Chiropractors often say that the difference between physical therapists and chiropractors is that chiropractors adjust vertebrae while physical therapists manipulate the spine.
Entrenched subluxation theory
There is no reason to believe that the subluxation theory will ever be discarded by all chiropractors. Unable to demonstrate that real orthopedic subluxations can cause organic disease, some chiropractors refer to a “vertebral subluxation complex,” another name for a chiropractic subluxation that is asymptomatic and undetectable. Belief systems cannot be eradicated by scientific presentations, especially subluxation-based chiropractic which finds support in the pseudoscience of alternative medicine. It seems unlikely that chiropractic, tainted by subluxation theory, will ever be absorbed by physical therapy, become a subspecialty of medicine, or be welcomed by academia. It may already be too late for the chiropractic profession to make the changes needed to train chiropractors to do what physical therapists, physiatrists, and orthopedic manual therapists are already doing. It certainly does not seem likely that the chiropractic profession, as it stands today, could take the path chosen by osteopathy in 1929 when the federal government gave the osteopathic practitioner the same privileges granted to medical doctors.
In the final analysis, we see only what we are ready to see, what we have been taught to see. We eliminate everything that is not part of our prejudices.
— Jean-Martin Charcot, 1825-1893

   Chiropractic Vertebral Subluxations: Science vs. Pseudoscience
Sam Homola
Link
A 1997 publication by the Foundation for Chiropractic Education and Research, supporting the vertebral subluxation theory, noted that “…we [chiropractors] have successfully distanced the concept of a chiropractic subluxation from that of an orthopedic subluxation.”1 When discussing “subluxations” or misaligned vertebrae, however, chiropractors often fail to point out the difference between an orthopedic subluxation and a chiropractic subluxation. Reference to subluxations in medical literature is often presented as support for the practice of chiropractic as a method of adjusting vertebral subluxations to “restore and maintain health.”
In the eyes of the public, the chiropractic vertebral subluxation theory has confused the definition of the word “subluxation,” a common medical term. Unlike the mysterious, undetectable and asymptomatic chiropractic “vertebral subluxation complex” alleged to be a cause of disease, a real vertebral subluxation, that is, an orthopedic subluxation, can be a cause of mechanical and neuromusculoskeletal symptoms but has never been associated with organic disease.
Subluxations: Real and Imaginary
An orthopedic subluxation, recognized and named as such since the days of Hippocrates, is a painful partial dislocation. Simple misalignment of a vertebra, also referred to as a “subluxation,” is commonly caused by disc degeneration, curvatures, spondylolysis, and structural abnormalities. Such a subluxation may or may not be mechanically symptomatic and can be seen on a plain x-ray image. In the absence of pathology such as disc herniation or osteophyte formation, these common vertebral subluxations or misalignments rarely affect spinal nerves and have never been associated with organic disease. Spinal nerves supply musculoskeletal structures. The body’s organs are supplied primarily by autonomic nerve ganglia and plexuses located outside the spinal column and by cranial and sacral nerves that pass through solid bony openings, providing overlapping nerve supply independent of any one spinal nerve that passes between two vertebrae.
An orthopedic subluxation, a true vertebral misalignment, or a mechanical joint dysfunction that affects mobility in the spine is not the same as a “chiropractic subluxation” that is alleged to cause disease by interfering with nerve supply to organs. Such a subluxation has never been proven to exist. There is no plausible theory and no credible evidence to support the contention that “nerve interference” originating in a single spinal segment can cause an organic disease.
Unable to provide evidence that commonly occurring vertebral misalignment can cause organic disease, advocates of the subluxation theory have reasoned that there must be some other type of joint dysfunction that can affect general health. They have chosen, by consensus, to call this undetectable lesion a “vertebral subluxation complex,” which “embraces the holistic nature of the human body, including health, well-being, and the doctor/patient relationship as well as the changes in nerve, muscle, connective, and vascular tissues which are understood to accompany the kinesiologic aberrations of spinal articulations.”1
Some chiropractors claim to be able to locate these elusive subluxations by using surface electromyography, thermography, vibratory instruments, leg length checks, or by palpating the spine.
A largely ignored landmark review of the literature by a Ph.D. and a chiropractor (Nansel and Szlazak), published in 1995, concluded that there is not a single appropriately controlled study to indicate that any dysfunction in structures of the spinal column is a cause of organic disease.2 The review noted that pain and other symptoms referred from a spinal segment can “create overt signs and symptoms that can mimic, or simulate (rather than cause), internal organ disease,” lending no support to the vertebral subluxation theory. Spinal nerves are commonly irritated or compressed, causing pain and other symptoms in the musculoskeletal structures supplied by the affected nerve. But even the most severe compression of a spinal nerve does not cause organic disease.
A review of the current evidence on the epidemiology of the subluxation construct (Mirtz, et al, 2009) also failed to find any credible evidence supporting the chiropractic vertebral subluxation theory. This paper, authored by three chiropractors and a Ph.D., concluded that “No supportive evidence is found for the chiropractic subluxation being associated with any disease process or of creating suboptimal health conditions requiring intervention. Regardless of popular appeal this leaves the subluxation construct in the realm of unsupported speculation. This lack of supportive evidence suggests the subluxation construct has no valid clinical applicability.”3
While there is justification for use of the word “subluxation” when referring to a mechanical-type spinal problem, there appears to be no justification whatsoever for suggesting that a “chiropractic subluxation” can affect general health.
A Chiropractic Subluxation by Any Other Name…
If the chiropractic profession dumped the subluxation theory and took the steps needed to become a physical-treatment specialty in the care of mechanical-type neck and back problems, it could remain open to future research that might reveal evidence that spinal manipulation benefits general health─a finding that would be a bonus for use of manual therapy. Until then, the theory that adjusting a “vertebral subluxation complex” will restore and maintain health is too implausible to warrant support by the scientific community.
Unfortunately, the chiropractic profession in the United States continues to be defined by subluxation theory. Too few chiropractors are willing to “step out of line” and announce that the theory (more accurately defined as a belief) is scientifically indefensible and should be dumped. Failure of chiropractic associations to publicly disagree with subluxationists who identify chiropractic as a method of adjusting the vertebral subluxation complex keeps chiropractic marginalized and subject to ridicule by the scientific community. Without some identifying label or degree that distinguishes science-based chiropractors from subluxation-based chiropractors, medical physicians will continue to be reluctant to refer a patient to a chiropractor, lest they deliver a patient into the hands of a pseudoscientific practitioner whose philosophy embraces an anti-medical approach and endangers the patient. Science-based chiropractors who are properly specialized should openly announce their limitations if they are to earn the recognition and trust of medical professionals who can provide the referrals needed to sustain a specialized practice. 
In May of 2010, the British General Chiropractic Council (GCC) advised members of the British Chiropractic Association (BCA) that “The chiropractic Vertebral Subluxation Complex…is not supported by any clinical research evidence that would allow claims to be made that it is the cause of disease or health concerns.”4 Chiropractors were advised to provide evidence-based care that “incorporates the best available evidence from research, the preferences of the patient and the expertise of practitioners including the individual chiropractor her/himself.”4 In response, the British Chiropractic Association advised its members to “refrain from making any reference to Vertebral Subluxation Complex in media to which their patients or the general public may have access,” adding that “this advice has no bearing on scope of practice.”4
While the action of the GCC and the BCA in avoiding reference to the Vertebral Subluxation Complex is an important and unprecedented move in the right direction, it appears that the door was left open for British chiropractors to continue treating a broad scope of health problems. Such leniency would not restrict use of a variety of unproven treatment methods (originally based on the vertebral subluxation theory) promoted by individual chiropractors and preferred by indoctrinated patients.
Although many chiropractors are now backing away from the chiropractic vertebral subluxation theory, many continue to use the theory to justify treating a broad scope of health problems by “adjusting” the spine. They simply point to legal and dictionary definitions of chiropractic to support their claims. Some who do not use the word “subluxation” simply substitute another word or words, such as “joint dysfunction,” in support of their belief that some kind of segmental spinal “lesion” can affect overall health.
Spinal Manipulation Stigmatized by Subluxation Theory
The basic definition of chiropractic provides opportunity for pseudoscientific spinal manipulators who treat a broad scope of health problems with a myriad of implausible and unproven treatment methods, alienating an informed public along with the scientific community.
According to a study published in 2005, the percentage of the US population seeing chiropractors annually for various reasons decreased from 9.9% in 1997 to 7.4% in 2002.5 Using data from a 2002 National Health Interview Survey, a study published in a 2010 issue of The Journal of the American Board of Family Medicine reported that about 6% of the US population used complementary alternative medicine (CAM) to treat their back pain. About 74% of this 6% (about 4.4% of the population) went to chiropractors; 22% went to massage therapists.6 Since conventional medical practitioners traditionally refer back-pain patients to physical therapists, physiatrists, or orthopedic surgeons, physician referral to CAM practitioners remains low.
The chiropractic profession would be well advised to make the changes needed for recognition as specialists in the care of mechanical-type back pain, “the second leading reason for ambulatory office visits” and the most common reason for use of CAM in the United States.6
Science-based chiropractors who do not subscribe to the chiropractic vertebral subluxation theory, who specialize in the use of manipulation and other physical treatment methods in the care of mechanical-type neck and back problems, will use manipulation more appropriately. Unfortunately, there is no recognized label, degree, or association that distinguishes such chiropractors from subluxation-based chiropractors. Without a clear choice in selecting a good chiropractor, few physicians will risk referring their patients to a chiropractor, making survival difficult for properly specialized chiropractors.
As Sir James Frazer wrote in 1922, “The ablest man is dragged down by the weakest and dullest, who necessarily sets the standard, since he cannot rise, while the other can fall.”7
Belief System Perpetuates Status Quo
Since my graduation from a chiropractic college in 1956, arguments and opinions about chiropractic have changed very little. No one seems to know what chiropractic is or what it does. No two chiropractors can agree on how to treat a specific ailment or which vertebrae to adjust. There are at least 97 named antithetical adjustive techniques,8 all based on a nonsensical, nonfalsifiable chiropractic vertebral subluxation theory. The chiropractic profession as a whole has yet to be properly defined and specialized so that diagnosis and treatment methods are uniformly consistent and interchangeable among chiropractors. Subluxation-based chiropractic continues to be at odds with mainstream health care.
Although the public generally thinks of a chiropractor as a “back doctor,” societal suspicion keeps utilization of chiropractic low. In a cycle perpetuated by the definition of chiropractic, science takes a back seat to standards that allow some chiropractors to follow a 19th century philosophy formulated by a magnetic healer 115 years ago. So far, the chiropractic profession has failed to take a stand and draw a line that separates sense from nonsense in chiropractic care, keeping the profession on the fringe of health care and in the realm of alternative medicine. The Chiropractic Paradigm formulated by the Association of Chiropractic Colleges (ACC), representing North American Chiropractic Colleges, proposes that “Chiropractic is concerned with the preservation and restoration of health and focuses particular attention on the subluxation.”9,10 The purpose of chiropractic is to “optimize health.” This vague and untestable ACC paradigm has been endorsed by the American Chiropractic Association, the International Chiropractic Association, and the World Federation of Chiropractic. The ACC notes that “Because of the emphasis on holistic health care, chiropractic is associated with the field of complementary and alternative medicine.”11
Until chiropractic schools and associations draw a line (with the fanfare of a clarion call) and take a stand on the side of science as a properly limited specialty, uniformly defining and limiting chiropractic in state laws, the credibility and the status of chiropractors will remain low. Physicians will continue to refer their patients to physical therapists, physiatrists, and orthopedic surgeons rather than risk a bad outcome with inappropriate treatment provided by a chiropractor. With an increasing number of physical therapists and orthopedic manual therapists now including spinal manipulation in their treatment armamentarium, it may eventually become unnecessary to search for the manipulative services of individual science-based chiropractors who are “not like the other chiropractors.”
It seems likely that subluxation-based chiropractic, like homeopathy and other belief systems, will be perpetuated to some degree by true believers. It remains to be seen whether chiropractic will eventually split into two camps─one for science-based chiropractors and one for subluxation-based chiropractors. Hopefully, the science-based camp will eventually prevail as a majority in defining chiropractic in state laws, forcing subluxation-based chiropractors to practice surreptitiously. This may never happen. But in the archives of science, the “chiropractic subluxation” will be filed away under the label of dogma.
Nonfalsifiable Subluxation Theory Still Alive
Despite the general consensus of scientific and academic groups that the chiropractic vertebral subluxation theory is not a viable construct, the National Board of Chiropractic Examiners continues to define chiropractic as subluxation-based: “The specific focus of chiropractic practice is known as the chiropractic subluxation or joint dysfunction. A subluxation is a health concern that manifests in the skeletal joints, and, through complex anatomical and physiological relationships, affects the nervous system and may lead to reduced function, disability, or illness.”9
Such a definition continues to allow routine manipulation of vertebrae anywhere in the spine to “restore and maintain health” by correcting “subluxations” or “joint dysfunction.” This approach allows frequent manipulation of the cervical spine, a treatment that has been associated with stroke caused by dissection of vertebrobasilar arteries. It’s important to remember that the chances of injury are multiplied when chiropractic neck manipulation is routinely used many times on every patient in a misguided attempt to improve health, as opposed to occasional use of neck manipulation by physical therapists and other manual therapists who are concerned only about restoring mobility in a stiff spine.
In June of 2010, the Connecticut Chiropractic Board, denying that neck manipulation can be a cause of stroke, issued this statement: “After a careful and thorough review of all the testimony and documentary evidence admitted at the hearing [January 2010], the Board concludes that there is sufficient evidence to establish that a stroke or a cervical arterial dissection is not a risk or side effect of joint mobilization, manipulation or adjustment of the cervical spine.”12 It seems unlikely that any group or organization outside of chiropractic will agree with this observation.
Because of apparent concerns that chiropractic neck manipulation based on subluxation theory involves more risk than benefit, the Kaiser Permanente Mid Atlantic States and Mid-Atlantic Permanente Medical Group recently revised their Chiropractic Manipulation Medical Coverage Policy to exclude cervical Chiropractic Manipulative Treatment (CMT). The revised policy states: “Given the paucity of data related to beneficial effects of chiropractic manipulation of the cervical spine and the real potential for catastrophic adverse effects, it was decided to exclude chiropractic manipulation of the cervical spine from coverage.”13 In response, the American Chiropractic Association “…sent a letter to Kaiser outlining the extensive data that supports cervical spine manipulation as both beneficial and safe.”14
Until the schools and associations of the chiropractic profession totally abandon the vertebral subluxation theory, and state and federal laws defining chiropractic are changed, it is not difficult to understand why there might be some justification for blanket condemnation of chiropractic, despite evidence that spinal manipulation can be useful in the treatment of uncomplicated mechanical-type back problems. It does not appear, however, that the chiropractic profession might be willing to voluntarily reduce its scope of practice by renouncing the vertebral subluxation theory. At the present time, “…the 50 state chiropractic practice acts essentially define chiropractic as the detection and correction of subluxations and assume their significance to human health, allowing a broad scope of practice. Because the chiropractic profession seems unwilling to abandon these discredited concepts, reform of the state chiropractic practice acts to eliminate subluxation-based chiropractic practice may be the only viable solution to the perpetration of unscientific and unproved healthcare practices.”15
The subluxation is the yoke of the chiropractic profession. The “chiropractic subluxation,” under one name or another, continues to find shelter under the umbrella of chiropractic. Good science-based chiropractors who do not subscribe to the vertebral subluxation theory and who use manipulation appropriately can offer a service of value. Unfortunately, such chiropractors are not easy to find.
References
     1.  Rosner A. The Role of Subluxation in Chiropractic. Des Moines, IA: Foundation for Chiropractic Education and Research; 1997.
     2.  Nansel D, Szlazak M. Somatic dysfunction and the phenomenon of visceral disease simulation: a probable explanation for the apparent effectiveness of somatic therapy in patients presumed to be suffering from true visceral disease. J Manipulative Physiol Ther. 1995;18:379-397.
     3.  Mirtz TA, Morgan L, Wyatt LH, Greene L. An epidemiological examination of the subluxation construct using Hill’s criteria of causation. Chiropractic & Osteopathy. 2009;17:13. http://www.chiroandosteo.com/content/17/1/13 (Accessed August 24, 2010).
     4.  Brown R. President, British Chiropractic Association. BCA Statement on Vertebral Subluxation Complex. May 24, 2010. General Chiropractic Council Guidance on Claims Made for the Chiropractic Vertebral Subluxation Complex. http://www.gcc-uk.org/files/page_file/guidance_on_claims_for_VSC_May_2010.pdf (Accessed August 24, 2010.)
     5.  Tindle HA, Davis RB, Phillips RS, Eisenberg DM. Trends in use of complementary and alternative medicine by US adults: 1997-2002. Altern Ther Health Med. 2005;11:42-49.
     6.  Kanodia AK, Legedza AT, Davis RB, Eisenberg DM, Phillips RS. Perceived benefit of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) for back pain: a national survey. The Journal of the American Board of Family Medicine. 2010;23(3):354-362.
     7.  Frazer J. The Golden Bough. New York, NY: The Macmillan Company; 1956.
     8.  Peterson D, Wiese G. Chiropractic: An Illustrated History. St. Louis, MO: Mosby; 1995:260-261.
     9.  Christensen M, et al. Practice Analysis of Chiropractic. Greeley, CO: National Board of Chiropractic Examiners; 2010.
     10.  Chiropractic Paradigm. Association of Chiropractic Colleges, 2010. http://www.chirocolleges.org/paradigm_scope_practice.html (Accessed August 24, 2010.)
     11.  What Is Chiropractic? Association of Chiropractic Colleges. 2010 http://www.chirocolleges.org/whatis.html (Accessed August 24, 2010.)
     12.  Connecticut Chiropractors’ Informed Consent Standard Upheld. American Chiropractic Association. June 11, 2010. http://www.acatoday.org/content_css.cfm?CID=3978. (Accessed August 28, 2010.)
     13.  No Evidence of Benefits, Health Insurer Excludes Neck Manipulations. PR Web. August 28, 2010. http://www.prweb.com/pdfdownload/4432714.pdf (Accessed Aug 28, 2010.)
     14.  American Chiropractic Association responds to new Kaiser policy excluding cervical manipulation. Chiropractic Economics. August 20, 2010. http://www.chiroeco.com/news/print-this.php?id=10075. (Accessed August 28, 2010.)
     15.  Bellamy JJ. Legislative alchemy: the US state chiropractic practice acts. FACT. 2010;15(3):214-222.

Chiropractic Subluxation Theory: Science or Gobbledegook?
Many chiropractors continue to claim that vertebral subluxations can affect organ function by interfering with nerve flow in spinal nerves, a view that is scientifically indefensible.
Sam Homola on January 23, 2024
Link

A 4th thoracic adjustment
When D.D. Palmer, a magnetic healer, claimed that he had cured deafness by thrusting on a displaced 4th thoracic vertebra, there was good reason to question the claim since the nerves responsible for hearing are contained in the skull. Some chiropractic historians have suggested that the cure was fabricated in a move to follow the approach of osteopathy, a new method of healing. Today, many chiropractors continue to claim that vertebral subluxations can affect organ function by interfering with nerve flow in spinal nerves, a view that is scientifically indefensible since spinal nerves supply musculoskeletal structures apart from the autonomic nervous system that supplies the body’s organs.
There Is No Evidence to Indicate that Vertebral Subluxations Affect Organ Function
In 1895, D.D. Palmer, the founder of chiropractic, announced that 95 per cent of diseases are caused by displaced vertebrae that place pressure on spinal nerves,1 giving birth to the subluxation theory that serves as the foundation of chiropractic. Today, chiropractic is defined as a method of adjusting a “vertebral subluxation complex,” an asymptomatic and undetectable “joint dysfunction” (involving nerves, muscles, connective tissues, blood vessels, and other factors) alleged to affect organ system function and general health. There is no credible evidence to support such a speculation as a foundation for a health-care profession.
Spinal nerves are commonly compressed by bony spurs and by herniated discs. Even the most severe compression of a spinal nerve, which may cripple the supplied musculoskeletal structures, does not cause organic disease. Vertebral misalignments, which are common in structural deviations from normal, rarely affect spinal nerves. A real orthopedic subluxation which causes musculoskeletal symptoms has never been associated with organic disease and is not the same as an elusive chiropractic vertebral subluxation complex.
Spinal nerves supply the sensory and motor (voluntary) functions of musculoskeletal structures. Involuntary function of the body’s organs is regulated by a chain of autonomic nerve ganglia and plexuses located outside the spinal column and by autonomic cranial and sacral nerves that pass through solid bony openings, unaffected by vertebral subluxations. The all-important vagus nerves are autonomic cranial nerves that originate in the brain stem, traversing openings on each side of the base of the skull to pass down through the neck, thorax, and abdomen to supply the body’s organs. Preganglionic autonomic fibers, which emerge from the spinal cord and pass through spinal segments from the first thoracic vertebra to the second lumbar vertebra, terminate in para-vertebral trunk and splanchnic ganglia.
The vagus nerves along with autonomic ganglia and nerve plexuses provide overlapping sympathetic and parasympathetic nerve supply from many directions and sources (in concert with chemical, hormonal, and circulatory factors) to assure continued function of the body’s organs, independent of spinal nerves.2 This is why severance of the spinal cord in the neck area (at or above C4 to C5), shutting off brain impulses to spinal nerves, can cause paralysis of muscles from the neck down while the body’s organs continue to function. (Severance of the spinal cord above C5 can cause fatal respiratory paralysis.) Transplanted organs, reconnected with blood supply, function without reconnection of severed nerves.
Since the spinal cord ends at the level of the 2nd lumbar vertebra, spinal nerves pass down from the spinal cord (like the hair on a horse’s tail) to exit openings between the lumbar vertebrae and the solid bony openings (foramina) in the sacrum, supplying bladder and bowel sphincter muscles. These nerves, like vagus nerves, are not subject to compression by a vertebral misalignment. Sacral nerves, however, can be compressed by protrusion of a lower lumbar disc into the spinal canal, affecting voluntary control of bladder and anal sphincter muscles (cauda equina syndrome), a medical emergency that requires the immediate attention of a neurosurgeon. Spinal manipulation should not be done as a treatment for a herniated disc anywhere in the spine, especially in the lumbar spine where massive disc protrusions can occur.
Subluxation Theory Continues to Define Chiropractic
Spinal manipulation, massage, and other forms of manual therapy may have some neurological and physiological effects that might be beneficial in temporarily relieving back pain symptoms. But there is no evidence to indicate that such effects have a significant effect on organ function or general health.
A recent study by academic chiropractors concluded that “No supportive evidence is found for the chiropractic subluxation being associated with any disease process or of creating suboptimal health conditions requiring intervention.”3 Another independent study by academic chiropractors revealed that “Despite the controversies and paucity of evidence the term subluxation is still found often within the chiropractic curricula of most North American chiropractic programs.”4
Despite the implausibility of chiropractic subluxation theory, state laws and chiropractic publications in the United States continue to define chiropractic as a method of correcting vertebral subluxations to restore and maintain health.5 A 2015 publication of the National Board of Chiropractic Examiners (NBCE), Practice Analysis of Chiropractic 2015, states that “The specific focus of chiropractic practice is known as the chiropractic subluxation or joint dysfunction. A subluxation is a health concern that manifests in the skeletal joints, and, through complex anatomical and physiologic relationships, affects the nervous system and may lead to reduced function, disability, or illness.”6 This definition of chiropractic is in keeping with a paradigm formulated by the Association of Chiropractic Colleges (ACC) in 1996, signed by 16 North American chiropractic college presidents:“Chiropractic is concerned with the preservation and restoration of health, and focuses particular attention on the subluxation…a complex of functional and/or structural and/or pathological articular changes that compromise neural integrity and may influence organ system function and general health.”6
Spinal Manipulation as a Treatment Option
It’s important to understand that while a chiropractic adjustment based on subluxation theory has been rejected by the scientific community, generic spinal manipulation used in the treatment of mechanical-type back pain has a plausible basis that makes it acceptable in mainstream healthcare.
A 2011 Cochrane Systematic Review of spinal manipulative therapy for chronic low-back pain reported that “High-quality evidence suggests that there is no clinically relevant difference between SMT [spinal manipulative therapy] and other interventions for reducing pain and improving function in patients with chronic back pain.”7 A 2012 Cochrane review of spinal manipulative therapy for acute low-back pain concluded that “SMT…appears to be no more effective than other recommended therapies.”8 A 2012 National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine review of back-pain studies reported that “Overall, studies have shown that spinal manipulation is one of several options─including exercise, massage, and physical therapy─that can provide mild-to-moderate relief from low-back pain. Spinal manipulation also appears to work as well as conventional treatments such as applying heat, using a firm mattress, and taking pain-relieving medications.”9
Although some studies have indicated that spinal manipulation may not be more effective than a variety of other treatment methods for relieving back pain, many manual therapists know from experience that spinal manipulation can, on rare occasions, provide dramatic and permanent relief when manipulation restores mobility by breaking down adhesions or by unlocking binding vertebral facets. In my own practice as a chiropractor, I had many patients who simply loved a back-cracking back rub. Despite the controversy surrounding the use and effects of spinal manipulation, generic spinal manipulation deserves a place as an option in the armamentarium of physical medicine.
Aside from physical effects, spinal manipulation based on subluxation theory has powerful placebo and nocebo effects that perpetuate such treatment beyond reasonable use. Manipulation can produce popping sounds caused by separation of joint surfaces (cavitation) in normal joints. Such popping is not considered to be significant, but it can have a powerful placebo effect among those who believe that the popping sound signals correction of a dangerous subluxation. Unfortunately, some chiropractors allow their patients to believe that a popping sound means that vertebral subluxations are always present, producing a nocebo effect that lures fearful chiropractic patients and their families into a program of regular spinal adjustments in order to maintain health by keeping their vertebrae aligned.
According to WebMD, 22 million Americans visit chiropractors annually. Of these, about 7.7 million are seeking relief from back pain.10 While spinal manipulation and physical therapy modalities may be helpful in the treatment of musculoskeletal problems, it is important to be on guard to avoid spinal manipulation or any treatment method based on subluxation theory.
Subluxation Theory Perpetuated as a Belief System
There are no indications that the nonfalsifiable subluxation theory, the foundation of chiropractic, will ever be discarded by all chiropractors. With no plausible or scientific rationale to support it, subluxation theory based on the tenets of a founding father will continue to be perpetuated as a belief system by subluxation-based factions in chiropractic, as in the case of homeopathy and traditional osteopathy. Chiropractic subluxations that are not detectable by conventional methods will continue to be “located” by such dubious chiropractic procedures as thermography, applied kinesiology, and leg-length check.
A Global Summit Conclusion
In September of 2019, 50 researchers from 28 countries met in a Global Summit to announce that there is no evidence that there is an effect of SMT (Spinal Manipulative Therapy) for the management of non-musculoskeletal disorders. “This finding challenges the validity of the theory that treating spinal disorders with SMT has a physiological effect on organs and their function.11
Until chiropractors quit hanging up wall charts to indoctrinate patients in subluxation theory, it will continue to be necessary to voice opposition to vertebral subluxation theory on the behalf of consumers and evidence-based chiropractors in order to facilitate informed choice.
References
1. Palmer, Daniel David. 1910. The Chiropractor’s Adjuster: A Textbook of the Science, Art, and Philosophy of Chiropractic for Students and Practitioners. Portland, Oregon. Portland Printing House.
2. Homola, Samuel. 2006. Chiropractic: History and Overview of Theories and Methods. Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research. 444:236-242.
3. Mirtz, Timothy A., Lon Morgan, Lawrence H. Wyatt, et al. 2009. An epidemiological examination of the subluxation construct using Hill’s criteria of causation. Chiropractic and Manual Therapies. 17:13.
4. Mirtz, Timothy A., Stephen M. Perle. 2011. The prevalence of the term subluxation in North American English-Language Doctor of Chiropractic programs. Chiropractic and Manual Therapies. 19:14.
5. Bellamy, J.J. 2010. Legislative alchemy: The U.S. state chiropractic practice acts. Focus on Complementary and Alternative Therapies. 15(3):214-222.
6. Christensen, M G, Martin W. Kollasach, John K. Hyland, et al. 2015. Practice Analysis of Chiropractic 2015.Greeley, Colorado; National Board of Chiropractic Examiners.
7. Rubinstein, Sidney M., Marienke van Middelkoop, Willem J.J. Assendelft, et al. 2011. Spinal manipulative therapy for chronic low-back pain. Cochrane Database Systematic Review. February 16. (2):CD0081123.
8. Rubinstein, Sidney M. Caroline B. Terwee, Willem J.J. Assendelft, et al. 2012. Spinal manipulative therapy for acute low-back pain. The Cochrane Library. September 12. (2):CD008880.
9. National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine. 2012. Spinal manipulation for low-back pain: What the science says. NCCAM Clinical Digest. May.http://nccam.nih.gov/health/providers/digest/backpain-science?nav=cd.
10. Skarnulis, Leona. 2022. Chiropractic Care for Back Pain. WebMD. https://www.webmd.com/back-pain/guide/chiropractic-pain-relief/
11. Cote P, Hartvigsen J, Axen I, et al. The Global Summit on the efficacy and effectiveness of spinal manipulative therapy for the prevention and treatment of non-musculoskeletal disorders. A systematic review of the literature. Chiropractic and Manual Therapies. February 17, 2021.
Samuel Homola is a retired chiropractor who has been expressing his views about the benefits of appropriate use of spinal manipulation (as opposed to use of such treatment based on chiropractic subluxation theory) since publication of his book Bonesetting, Chiropractic, and Cultism in 1963. He retired from private practice in 1998. His 15 published books include Inside Chiropractic, published by Prometheus Books in 1999.

   Brief Note: The Chiropractic Subluxation is Dead
Harriet Hall 
Link
The General Chiropractic Council, a UK-wide statutory body with regulatory powers, has just published a new position statement on the chiropractic subluxation complex:
The chiropractic vertebral subluxation complex is an historical concept but it remains a theoretical model. It is not supported by any clinical research evidence that would allow claims to be made that it is the cause of disease or health concerns.
They remind chiropractors that they must make sure their own beliefs and values do not prejudice the patient’s care, and that they must provide evidence-based care. Unfortunately, they define evidence-based care as
clinical practice that incorporates the best available evidence from research, the preferences of the patient and the expertise of practitioners, including the individual chiropractor her/himself. [emphasis added]
This effectively allows “in my experience” and “the patient likes it” to be considered along with evidence, effectively negating the whole point of evidence-based medicine.

Spinal Manipulation, Chiropractic, and Subluxation Theory
While generic spinal manipulation can be helpful in treating mechanical-type back pain, there are good reasons to be skeptical about chiropractic manipulation based on subluxation theory which dictates that health can be restored and maintained by adjusting vertebral subluxations. A grain of truth mixed with subluxation theory makes it difficult for many of us to distinguish between appropriate and inappropriate use of manipulation by chiropractors.
Sam Homola on February 21, 2023
Link
Vertebral Subluxations Do Not Affect General Health
The vertebral subluxation theory that gave birth to the chiropractic profession proposed that 95 per cent of diseases are caused by displaced vertebrae that place pressure on spinal nerves.1 Today, chiropractic is defined as a method of adjusting a “vertebral subluxation complex,” an asymptomatic and undetectable “joint dysfunction” (involving nerves, muscles, connective tissues, blood vessels, and other factors) alleged to influence organ system function and general health.2 There is no credible evidence to support the theory that joint dysfunction or a vertebral subluxation in any form can affect general health or cause internal organs to become diseased.
Spinal nerves are commonly compressed by bony spurs and herniated discs. Even the most severe compression of a spinal nerve, which may cripple the supplied musculoskeletal structures, does not cause organic disease. In the absence of fracture or pathology such as disc herniation or osteophyte formation, vertebral misalignments rarely affect spinal nerves.
Spinal nerves supply the sensory and motor (voluntary) functions of musculoskeletal structures. Involuntary function of the body’s organs is regulated by autonomic nerve ganglia and plexuses located outside the spinal column and by autonomic cranial and sacral nerves that pass through solid bony openings. The vagus nerves are autonomic (parasympathetic) cranial nerves that originate in the brain stem, traversing openings in the base of the skull to pass down through the neck, thorax, and abdomen to supply organs along their path. Preganglionic autonomic fibers, which emerge from the spinal cord and pass through spinal segments from the first thoracic vertebra to the second lumbar vertebra, terminate in sympathetic trunk and splanchnic ganglia located outside the spinal column. The vagus nerves along with autonomic ganglia and nerve plexuses provide overlapping sympathetic and parasympathetic nerve supply from many directions and sources (in concert with chemical, hormonal, and circulatory factors) to assure continued function of the body’s organs, independent of spinal nerves.3 This is why severance of the spinal cord in the neck area (at or above C4 to C5), shutting off brain impulses to spinal nerves, can cause paralysis of muscles from the neck down while the body’s organs continue to function. (Severance of the spinal cord above C5 can cause fatal respiratory paralysis.) Transplanted organs, reconnected with blood supply, function without reconnection of severed nerves.
Since the spinal cord ends at the level of the 2nd lumbar vertebra, spinal nerves pass down from the spinal cord (like the hair on a horse’s tail) to exit openings between the lumbar vertebrae and from openings (foramina) in the sacrum. Spinal nerves supplying bladder and bowel sphincter muscles pass through the solid bony openings of the sacrum (a pelvic bone at the bottom of the spine) and are not subject to compression by a subluxation. But they can be compressed by protrusion of a lower lumbar disc into the spinal canal, affecting voluntary control of bladder and anal sphincter muscles (cauda equina syndrome). This is a medical emergency that requires the immediate attention of a neurosurgeon. Spinal manipulation should not be done as a treatment for a herniated disc anywhere in the spine, especially in the lumbar spine where massive protrusions can occur.
Subluxation Theory Scientifically Indefensible but Still Going Strong
Spinal manipulation, massage, and other forms of manual therapy may have some neurological and physiological effects that might be beneficial in temporarily relieving back pain symptoms. But there is no evidence to indicate that such effects have a significant effect on general health.
A recent study by academic chiropractors concluded that “No supportive evidence is found for the chiropractic subluxation being associated with any disease process or of creating suboptimal health conditions requiring intervention.”4 Another independent study by academic chiropractors revealed that “Despite the controversies and paucity of evidence the term subluxation is still found often within the chiropractic curricula of most North American chiropractic programs.”5
Despite the implausibility of chiropractic subluxation theory, state laws and chiropractic publications in the United States continue to define chiropractic as a method of correcting vertebral subluxations to restore and maintain health.7 A 2015 publication of the National Board of Chiropractic Examiners (NBCE), Practice Analysis of Chiropractic, states that “The specific focus of chiropractic practice is known as the chiropractic subluxation or joint dysfunction. A subluxation is a health concern that manifests in the skeletal joints, and, through complex anatomical and physiologic relationships, affects the nervous system and may lead to reduced function, disability, or illness.”7 This definition of chiropractic is in keeping with a paradigm formulated by the Association of Chiropractic Colleges (ACC) in 1996, signed by 16 North American chiropractic college presidents: “Chiropractic is concerned with the preservation and restoration of health, and focuses particular attention on the subluxation…a complex of functional and/or structural and/or pathological articular changes that compromise neural integrity and may influence organ system function and general health.”8
Manipulation as a Treatment Option
It’s important to understand that while a chiropractic adjustment based on subluxation theory has been rejected by the scientific community, spinal manipulation used in the treatment of mechanical-type back pain has a plausible basis that makes it acceptable in mainstream healthcare.
A 2011 Cochrane Systematic Review of spinal manipulative therapy for chronic low-back pain reported that “High-quality evidence suggests that there is no clinically relevant difference between SMT [spinal manipulative therapy] and other interventions for reducing pain and improving function in patients with chronic back pain.”9 A 2012 Cochrane review of spinal manipulative therapy for acute low-back pain concluded that “SMT…appears to be no more effective than other recommended therapies.”10 A 2012 National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine review of back-pain studies reported that “Overall, studies have shown that spinal manipulation is one of several options─including exercise, massage, and physical therapy─that can provide mild-to-moderate relief from low-back pain. Spinal manipulation also appears to work as well as conventional treatments such as applying heat, using a firm mattress, and taking pain-relieving medications.”11
Although some studies have indicated that spinal manipulation may not be more effective than a variety of other treatment methods for relieving back pain, many manual therapists know from experience that spinal manipulation can, on rare occasions, provide dramatic and permanent relief when manipulation restores mobility by breaking down adhesions or by unlocking binding vertebral facets. In my own practice as a chiropractor, I had many patients who simply loved a back-cracking back rub. Despite the controversy surrounding the use and effects of spinal manipulation, generic spinal manipulation deserves a place as an option in the armamentarium of physical medicine.
Aside from physical effects, spinal manipulation has powerful placebo and nocebo effects that perpetuate such treatment beyond reasonable use. Manipulation can produce popping sounds (cavitation) in normal joints. Such popping is not considered to be significant, but it can have a powerful placebo effect among those who believe that the popping sound signals correction of a dangerous subluxation. Unfortunately, some chiropractors allow their patients to believe that a popping sound means that vertebral subluxations are always present, producing a nocebo effect that lures fearful chiropractic patients and their families into a program of regular spinal adjustments in order to maintain health by keeping their vertebrae aligned.
It goes without saying that the cartilaginous, immature spine of an infant or a preadolescent child should never be “adjusted,” as some chiropractors are doing in a misguided effort to correct “subluxations,” risking injury to vertebral growth centers.12,13
Chiropractic Has the Confusing Image of a Back Specialty Capable of Treating a Broad Scope of Ailments
Although the public generally thinks of chiropractors as back specialists, few chiropractors limit their care to treatment of back pain. The vague and all-inclusive chiropractic subluxation theory generates a hodgepodge of entrepreneurial techniques and treatment methods for a variety of ailments. Few consumers are aware of the great diversity in chiropractic, and few know that it is important to seek a chiropractor who has rejected subluxation theory. Unfortunately, such chiropractors are hard to find. Treatment techniques vary from one chiropractor to another among subluxation-based chiropractors. Some chiropractors use a spring-loaded mallet to tap vertebrae in place in order to “restore the integrity of the nervous system.” Upper cervical chiropractors believe that aligning the atlas (the vertebra at the top of the spine) will “influence the central nervous system and brain stem function,” curing disease as well as relieving back pain.14
Note: Upper cervical manipulation has been associated with stroke caused by injury to vertebral and carotid arteries. Neck manipulation should not be done except in the case of a carefully selected mechanical-type neck problem in which use of manipulation, like mobilization, does not involve rotating the head to force rotation of upper cervical structures beyond normal ranges of movement (into the paraphysiologic joint space), stretching vertebral arteries in the atlanto-axial area. Risk certainly outweighs benefit when any neck manipulation is based on correction of a putative chiropractic subluxation.15,16
Web promotions by recent graduates of chiropractic colleges, parroting subluxation verbiage, emphasize “spine care” in combination with a variety of subluxation-based treatment methods. These chiropractors may claim to be primary care providers with a holistic approach that entails treatment and prevention of the gamut of human ailments, using a variety of unproven and implausible alternative healing methods.
Note: The University of Pittsburg offers a program that certifies chiropractors and physical therapists as Primary Spine Practitioners (PSP) who specialize in the treatment or the need for referral of spine-related disorders, sans subluxation theory.17
According to the Association of Chiropractic Colleges, “Doctors of chiropractic are primary care professionals for spinal health and well being …who are concerned with the diagnosis, treatment and prevention of disorders of the musculoskeletal system and effects of such disorders on the nervous system and overall health.”18 With a vague definition suggesting that musculoskeletal problems (not ruling out vertebral subluxations) can affect the nervous system to cause a health problem, the chiropractic profession has not chosen to seek development as a scientifically acceptable musculoskeletal specialty, despite the fact that back pain and musculoskeletal conditions are the No. 1 and No. 2 causes of disability worldwide.19
Some chiropractic colleges offer decent instruction in the care of musculoskeletal problems but may be tainted by subluxation theory or by alternative medicine methods (such as functional medicine or acupuncture) that encompass a broad scope of ailments. A few chiropractic colleges that have backed away from subluxation theory remain on shaky ground by including the subject of alternative medicine in their curriculum. Without uniform licensure of chiropractors, with standardization of treatment methods as a musculoskeletal specialty, a science-based, properly-limited chiropractor who openly renounces subluxation theory will continue to be an anomaly, and appropriate use of spinal manipulation will remain in the domain of physical therapy and physical medicine.
Without changes in state laws and the curriculum of chiropractic colleges, the chiropractic profession will remain dependent upon subluxation theory for its existence.
Subluxation Theory Perpetuated as a Belief System
There are no indications that the nonfalsifiable subluxation theory, the foundation of chiropractic, will ever be discarded by all chiropractors. With no plausible or scientific rationale to support it, subluxation theory, based on the tenets of a founding father, will be perpetuated as a belief system, as in the case of homeopathy and traditional osteopathy. Chiropractic subluxations that are not detectable by conventional methods are allegedly being located (only by chiropractors) by such dubious procedures as thermography, applied kinesiology, and leg-length checks.
Consumers should be advised to avoid subluxation-based chiropractors who say “I do not diagnose or treat disease. I simply remove nerve interference so that the body can heal itself.”
The Bottom Line
According to WebMD, 22 million Americans visit chiropractors annually. Of these, about 7.7 million are seeking relief from back pain.20 While spinal manipulation and physical therapy modalities may be helpful in the treatment of musculoskeletal problems, it is important to be on guard to avoid spinal manipulation or any treatment method based on subluxation theory.
There is no credible evidence to support use of spinal manipulation for anything other than uncomplicated mechanical-type back pain and related problems. It has never been demonstrated that a real orthopedic subluxation or a pinched spinal nerve can affect general health. An undetectable “vertebral subluxation complex” alleged to cause organic problems simply does not exist.
If you are looking for a chiropractor who treats back pain or a musculoskeletal problem, look for one who does not subscribe to subluxation theory and who combines use of generic spinal manipulation with physical therapy modaliities. A good science-based chiropractor is always willing to exchange office notes with your family physician. Remember that acute low-back pain, when it is mechanical in nature and not accompanied by fever or radiation down one leg, is often a self-limiting condition that will resolve in four to six weeks, with or without treatment. Appropriate treatment, however, can relieve symptoms, which may provide temporary but welcome relief that may reduce need for medication.
A correct diagnosis is essential when considering treatment options. When treatment for back pain or a health problem is based on a “subluxation complex” diagnosis, unnecessary chiropractic adjustments will delaying appropriate treatment based on a correct diagnosis and may lock the patient into ongoing preventive-maintenance spinal manipulation. Remember that a “subluxation complex” alleged to cause health problems is asymptomatic and undetectable, thus nonexistent, as opposed to an orthopedic subluxation which causes musculoskeletal symptoms and is detectable on physical and x-ray examination.
References
1. Palmer, Daniel David. 1910. <em>The Chiropractor’s Adjuster: A Textbook of the Science, Art, and Philosophy of Chiropractic for Students and Practitioners</em>. Portland, Oregon. Portland Printing House.
2. Association of Chiropractic Colleges. Chiropractic Paradigm. http://www.chirocolleges.org/paradigm_scope_practice.html
3. Homola, Samuel. 2006. Chiropractic: History and Overview of Theories and Methods. <em>Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research</em>. 444:236-242.
4. Mirtz, Timothy A., Lon Morgan, Lawrence H. Wyatt, et al. 2009. An epidemiological examination of the subluxation construct using Hill’s criteria of causation. <em>Chiropractic and Manual Therapies</em>. 17:13.
5. Mirtz, Timothy A., Stephen M. Perle. 2011. The prevalence of the term subluxation in North American English-Language Doctor of Chiropractic programs. Chiropractic and Manual Therapies. 19:14.
6. Bellamy, J.J. 2010. Legislative alchemy: The U.S. state chiropractic practice acts. <em>Focus on Complementary and Alternative Therapies</em>. 15(3):214-222.
7. Christensen, Mark G, Martin W. Kollasach, John K. Hyland, et al. 2015. <em>Practice Analysis of Chiropractic 2015</em>. Greeley, Colorado; National Board of Chiropractic Examiners.
8. CCE. An open letter to the profession from the Council on Chiropractic Education. November 22, 2011. http://www.acatoday.org/pdf/CCE_Letter.pdf
9. Rubinstein, Sidney M., Marienke van Middelkoop, Willem J.J. Assendelft, et al. 2011. Spinal manipulative therapy for chronic low-back pain. <em>Cochrane Database Systematic Review</em>. February 16. (2):CD0081123.
10. Rubinstein, Sidney M., Caroline B. Terwee, Willem J.J. Assendelft, Michiel R. de Boer, et al. 2012. Spinal manipulative therapy for acute low-back pain. <em>The Cochrane Library</em>. September 12. (2):CD008880.
11. National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine. 2012. Spinal manipulation for low-back pain: What the science says. NCCAM Clinical Digest. May. http://nccam.nih.gov/health/providers/digest/backpain-science.
12. Homola, Samuel. 2010. Should Chiropractors Treat Children? <em>Skeptical Inquirer</em>. 34(5):50-53
13. Homla, Samuel. 2016. Pediatric Chiropractic Care: The Subluxation Question and Referral Risk. <em>Bioethics</em>. 2016; 30(2): pp63-68.
14. Homola, Samuel. 2009. The problem with chiropractic NUCCA. Science-Based Medicine. August 7. http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/index.php/the-problem-with-chiropractic-nucca/
15. Homola, Samuel. 2009. Neck Manipulation: Risk vs. Benefit. Science-Based Medicine. August 27. http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/neck-manipulation-risk-vs-benefit/
16. Homola, Samuel. 2014. Neck manipulation, stroke and the precautionary principle. <em>Focus on Alternative and Complementary Therapies</em>. 19(4):208-211.
17. Primary Spine Practitioner Certification Program. University of Pittsburg. www.psp.pitt.edu
18. Association of Chiropractic Colleges. What is Chiropractic? http://www.chirocolleges.org/about-chiropractic/2023
19. Vos, Theo, Abraham D. Flaxman, Mohsen Naghavi, et al. 2012. Years lived with disability (YLDs) for 1160 sequelae of 289 diseases and injuries 1990-2010: a systematic analysis of the Global Burden of Disease Study 2010. The Lancet. 380(9859):2163-2196.
20. Skarnulis, Leona. 2022. Chiropractic Care for Back Pain. WebMD. https://www.webmd.com/back-pain/guide/chiropractic-pain-relief/

The Yoke of Chiropractic: Vertebral Subluxation Doctrine
The mysterious, asymptomatic chiropractic “vertebral subluxation complex” alleged to be a cause of disease has never been proven to exist. A real orthopedic vertebral subluxation, which can be identified by imaging and by physical signs, has never been demonstrated to be a cause of organic disease. Chiropractic subluxation theory has been perpetuated largely by misinformation, fear, and a powerful placebo effect, produced, in part, by insignificant cavitation (popping) that occurs during manipulation of normal joints.
Sam Homola on May 27, 2019
Link

One day, many years ago, when I was in private practice as a chiropractor, a local neurologist who often referred patients to me asked me how and why the chiropractor down the street from my office always had a parking lot filled with cars. The neurologist knew from experience that it was not possible for one practitioner to provide appropriate examination and treatment for so many patients in one day. I explained to him that this chiropractor was spending only a few minutes with each patient, treating imaginary vertebral subluxations that he located by feeling the patient’s spine with his fingertips. As a subluxation-based chiropractor, this chiropractor believed (or pretended to believe) that a vertebral subluxation was the only diagnosis needed and that the only treatment needed was a spinal adjustment. Regular adjustments were required to “keep the spine in line”. With such an approach, and with good salesmanship, this chiropractor could see dozens of patients daily. This practice-building approach, which now includes treatment of infants and children, is still being used by some chiropractors.
Although many subluxation-based chiropractors might sincerely believe that they are helping their patients by adjusting vertebral subluxations, I suspect that some are knowingly misleading their patients for monetary gain. When I see chiropractors palpating a baby’s spine searching for subluxations, or arbitrarily tapping on a patient’s spine with a spring-loaded mallet to correct alleged subluxations, I find it difficult to believe that such chiropractors really believe that they are providing appropriate care.
Real vs. imaginary vertebral subluxations
Subluxations do exist, but a true orthopedic subluxation is not the same as a chiropractic subluxation alleged to be a cause of organic disease. A subluxation was recognized and named as such in the writings of Hippocrates (circa 400 B.C.) who said that “luxations and subluxations take place in different degrees.” Hippocrates used traction and manipulation in an attempt to treat curvatures and “displacements” in the spine.
Combining extension (traction) with manipulation in an attempt to correct a “hump” in the spine, Hippocrates advised that “The physician, or some person who is strong, and not uninstructed, should apply the palm of one hand to the hump, and then, having laid the other hand upon the former, he should make pressure, attending whether this force should be applied directly downward, or toward the head, or towards the hips”.

Simple or slight misalignment of a vertebra, often referred to by chiropractors as a “subluxation,” can be caused by disc degeneration, curvatures, and structural abnormalities. Such a subluxation is common and cannot be corrected; it may or may not be mechanically symptomatic and can be seen on a plain x-ray image. In the absence of pathology such as disc herniation or osteophyte formation, vertebral subluxations or misalignments rarely affect spinal nerves and have never been associated with organic disease, even when a spinal nerve has been severely compressed. The reason for this is that spinal nerves supply skin and musculoskeletal structures while the body’s organs are supplied by autonomic ganglia and nerve plexuses located outside the spinal column and by autonomic cranial and sacral nerves that pass through solid bony openings. The involuntary function of organs can be sustained by hormones and other factors supplied by the flow of blood when nerve supply has been severed, as shown in the case of a transplanted organ. The body’s organs continue to function (supplied by blood flow and autonomic nerves) when a spinal cord injury in the neck paralyzes musculoskeletal structures from the neck down by shutting off brain impulses to spinal nerves.
An orthopedic vertebral subluxation that causes pain and loss of mobility in the spine (often as a result of injury) or a compressed spinal nerve that causes pain and other symptoms in musculoskeletal structures cannot be equated with a chiropractic subluxation or an asymptomatic “vertebral subluxation complex” that is alleged to cause disease by interfering with nerve supply to organs. Such a subluxation, with or without nerve root compression, has never been proven to exist. There is no plausible theory and no credible evidence to support the contention that “nerve interference” originating in a single spinal segment can cause an organic disease. There is no reason to believe that the temporary physiological effects of spinal manipulation can affect the cause of an organic disease.

Many subluxation-based chiropractors routinely x-ray every patient’s spine in order to measure a harmless vertebral misalignment or a structural asymmetry that may be labeled as the cause of a health problem. A “vertebral subluxation complex”, which is not detectable by physical examination or by imaging procedures, is located by using such dubious methods as surface electromyography, thermography, applied kinesiology, leg length checks, and so on. Manufactured fear of a “killer subluxation”, whether a vertebral misalignment or a subluxation complex, locks patients into a lifetime of inappropriate treatment that may circumvent appropriate care. A subluxation-based chiropractor, and his patients, may falsely attribute natural recovery from illness to correction of subluxations, encouraging unnecessary, ongoing treatment until an emergency forces the patient to seek medical care.
Enter subluxation deniers
A published review of the evidence on the epidemiology of the subluxation construct failed to find any credible evidence supporting the chiropractic vertebral subluxation theory. The review, conducted and reported by three chiropractors and a Ph.D., concluded:
No supportive evidence is found for the chiropractic subluxation being associated with any disease process or of creating suboptimal health conditions requiring intervention. Regardless of popular appeal this leaves the subluxation construct in the realm of unsupported speculation. This lack of supportive evidence suggests the subluxation construct has no valid clinical applicability.
Although many chiropractors and a few chiropractic colleges are now backing away from the chiropractic vertebral subluxation theory, subluxation-based chiropractors continue to use the theory to justify treating a broad scope of health problems by adjusting the spine. They simply point to case reports, state laws, and dictionary definitions of chiropractic to support their claims. Some chiropractors who do not use the word “subluxation” simply substitute another word or words, such as “joint dysfunction”, in support of their belief that some kind of segmental spinal “lesion” can affect general health.
It appears that most chiropractors continue to be guided by the Chiropractic Paradigm formulated by the Association of Chiropractic Colleges (ACC), representing North American Chiropractic Colleges, which proposes that “Chiropractic is concerned with the preservation and restoration of health and focuses particular attention on the subluxation”. The Canadian Memorial Chiropractic College, parting ways with the ACC paradigm, recently announced that it has joined 12 other chiropractic institutions around the world that have renounced vertebral subluxation theory. The World Federation of Chiropractic, representing anti-subluxation colleges, has stated:
The teaching of vertebral subluxation complex as a vitalistic construct that claims that it is the cause of disease is unsupported by evidence. Its inclusion in a modern chiropractic curriculum in anything other than an historical context is therefore inappropriate and unnecessary.
The chiropractic profession has long been divided by the views of “straight chiropractors” (whose treatment is limited to use of spinal adjustments to correct vertebral subluxations) and the views of “mixer chiropractors” (who use other forms of treatment along with spinal adjustments to correct vertebral subluxations). Today, with increasing numbers of chiropractors and chiropractic colleges rejecting subluxation theory, the profession is being divided by “subluxation believers” and “subluxation deniers”.
Subluxation theory vs. treatment based on a correct diagnosis
With an increasing number of physical therapists and orthopedic manual therapists now including use of spinal manipulation as an option in their treatment armamentarium, it might eventually become apparent that generic spinal manipulation provided by physical therapists is preferable to chiropractic manipulation (adjustments) that might be tainted by subluxation theory. A specific chiropractic adjustment to correct an alleged vertebral subluxation complex is not the same as generic long-lever manipulation used to improve mobility. A chiropractic “adjustment”, sometimes done with a mallet, can hardly be characterized as manipulation.
A program associated with the Department of Physical Therapy at the University of Pittsburgh (Pennsylvania) is now training and certifying chiropractors and physical therapists as Primary Spine Practitioners (PSP) capable of providing conservative care that includes use of manipulation in the treatment of mechanical-type neck and back problems ─ sans subluxation theory.
Appropriate treatment for back pain does not always require use of manipulation. A correct diagnosis may contraindicate use of manipulation, or it might indicate a need for manipulation to restore mobility. Most cases of acute mechanical-type back pain will resolve with time, but spinal manipulation, massage, thermal applications, and other physical therapy modalities might be useful as options in providing relief from pain, buying the time needed for recovery and reducing the need for pain medication.
Most back-pain patients will need instruction in self-help measures to aid recovery or to prevent injury, tailored to the needs and the structure of the individual. Much of what must be done to prevent back pain, such as exercise and ergonomics, must be done by the patient. So there is more to treating back pain than simply manipulating the spine. But a correct diagnosis is essential for appropriate care ─ care that may not be provided by subluxation-based chiropractors who adjust the spine of every patient they treat to correct alleged vertebral subluxations, relying heavily upon a popping sound to signal a successful treatment.
Some subluxation believers do not diagnose; they simply “analyze the spine” and adjust subluxations to “remove nerve interference” so that the body can heal itself, whatever the problem might be. Although some chiropractors commonly report that a “pinched nerve” is the cause of a health problem, a spinal nerve that is truly pinched, usually by a herniated disc or a bony spur, is a painful condition that could be aggravated by spinal manipulation.

The majority rules
Hopefully, science-based chiropractors will eventually prevail as a majority in defining chiropractic in state laws as a properly limited musculoskeletal specialty, forcing subluxation-based chiropractors to practice surreptitiously. With back pain and musculoskeletal conditions rated as the No. 1 and No. 2 cause of disability worldwide, there should be incentive for chiropractors to fill a niche as conservative musculoskeletal back specialists. A review of chiropractic web sites and chiropractic college catalogues, however, most of which embrace subluxation theory, suggests that this may never happen. There appears to be a subluxation-based majority in North America that will continue defining chiropractic as a form of broad-scope alternative medicine.
The mindset that allows allegiance to vertebral subluxation theory breeds susceptibility to such pseudoscientific nonsense as applied kinesiology, homeopathy, and functional medicine, further expanding the practice of chiropractors as “natural primary care providers”, despite public perception that chiropractors are back specialists.

The vertebral subluxation theory that gave birth to chiropractic as an independent alternative to conventional medical care is a yoke that can never be totally discarded. As a belief system that is not subject to critical thinking, subluxation-based chiropractic care will continue to hinder the development of chiropractic as a science-based specialty. Legally licensed “subluxation believers” will continue to compete with “subluxation deniers”.



The Chiropractic Technique Parade
Failure of the chiropractic establishment to renounce the scientifically indefensible vertebral subluxation theory assures an unending parade of questionable chiropractic diagnostic and treatment methods for correction of putative vertebral subluxations.
Sam Homola on September 14, 2018
Link

When I published my book Bonesetting, Chiropractic, and Cultism in 1963, one chapter was devoted to “Chiropractic Technique Wars.” Dozens of different chiropractic techniques were being used by chiropractors who claimed that their method of adjusting vertebral subluxations to relieve pressure on spinal nerves was the most effective way to cure disease. Most techniques were based on a Meric system which associated certain vertebrae with certain organs. The Palmer School of Chiropractic, however, was teaching the H.I.O. (hole-in-one) technique, which limited treatment to adjustment of the atlas, the uppermost neck vertebra. The Palmer School had initially taught that subluxations anywhere in the spine could cause disease, as “proven” by use of Palmer’s Neurocalometer, a hand-held paraspinal scanning device that used a thermocouple to measure heat claimed to be associated with a vertebral subluxation. B.J. Palmer, the developer of chiropractic, eventually theorized that only the atlas vertebra could be subluxated and that it was only necessary to adjust the atlas to relieve pressure on the brain stem to cure disease ─ a departure from the revelations of D.D. Palmer, the founder of chiropractic, who claimed that he had cured deafness and heart disease by adjusting a thoracic vertebra.
Going from one extreme to another, the Logan Basic College of Chiropractic was teaching that adjustment of the sacrum was the key to successful treatment of disease. Sacral realignment was done by pressing a thumb into a gluteal sacrotuberous ligament.
Combining two extremes, the Sacro-Occipital Technique, “based on the provable fact that every human who is sick or in pain has a distortion and a subluxation responsible for that sickness or pain,” required manipulation of both the occiput and the sacrum to restore nerve function by removing interference with the circulation of cerebrospinal fluid.
The Parker System, developed by a practice-building expert, taught full-spine adjusting based on a full-spine x-ray exam in order to increase the income of chiropractors. Displacement of vertebrae was measured in millimeters which were added up to determine the number of adjustments that would be needed to cure the patient’s condition.
Taking advantage of the frustration generated by antithetical chiropractic techniques, the Electrotactic theory of chiropractic, introduced in the January 1959 issue of the Journal of the National Chiropractic Association, offered chiropractors a treatment that would replace every other chiropractic treatment method. This new method, too nonsensical to explain, included the perennial leg-length check.
As time passed, the parade of chiropractic techniques grew longer. When the Association for the History of Chiropractic published Chiropractic: An Illustrated History in 1995 (Peterson 1995), it listed 97 entrepreneurial chiropractic techniques. The National Board of Chiropractic Examiners reported in Job Analysis of Chiropractic 2005 that individual chiropractors, on average, used six separate techniques in their practices. Of 15 listed techniques, the Meric System was still being used by 15% of chiropractors, 25.7% were using Palmer’s H.I.O. technique, 26% were using Logan Basic Technique, and 49.6% were using the Sacro-Occipital Technique ─ all based on subluxation theory.

Subluxation theory still prevails
Other than sophistication in the promotion of chiropractic, the basic tenets of chiropractic have changed little since publication of my Bonesetting book in 1963. Most chiropractic treatment methods continue to be based on chiropractic vertebral subluxation theory, which is supported by state laws and taught in most chiropractic colleges. The word “subluxation” can be found in all but three of 18 North American chiropractic college catalogues.
COREscore, which uses handheld paraspinal surface electromyography and thermography scanning devices claimed to be effective (only by chiropractors) in locating and measuring the effects of a vertebral subluxation, is currently popular among subluxation-based chiropractors. This approach, with a new twist, includes a heart rate variability testing device applied to the patient’s hand to determine the effect of stress on the nervous system ─ along with an ear clip for use in pediatric applications.
With COREscore, “You can now become focused on what really matters ─ reporting on the presence of subluxations and the impact that nerve tension and spinal reactions have on human health and potential.” COREscore is designed to “Generate more referrals, increase potential retention, and turn your practice into a profit center”.

Why are there so many chiropractic techniques?
The techniques of generic spinal manipulation, based on the laws of anatomy and physiology, are all similar when used appropriately in the treatment of musculoskeletal problems, no matter who provides such treatment. Chiropractic manipulation based on vertebral subluxation theory, however, is so contrary to what is known about anatomy and physiology that it has no factual basis and no testable substance. The subluxation construct is more an implausible, nonfalsifiable belief than a theory, making it easy to be exploited by chiropractic entrepreneurs who fabricate scientifically indefensible vertebral subluxation theories and treatment methods, taking advantage of struggling chiropractors who have been indoctrinated in subluxation theory.
Unfortunately, many chiropractors sincerely believe in subluxation-based chiropractic ─ conforming to a belief that makes them susceptible to technique peddlers who offer a new and effective technique that “really works” or which will, at least, provide a source of revenue.
Defining elusive chiropractic subluxations
There has been no evidence to indicate that a real orthopedic vertebral subluxation (a partial dislocation that causes musculoskeletal symptoms) can affect general health. Spinal nerves affected by vertebral misalignment, subluxation, osteophyte formation, or disc herniation affect only skin and the voluntary function of musculoskeletal structures. The body’s organs are regulated by autonomic cranial and sacral nerves that pass through solid bony openings and by ganglia and plexuses located outside the spinal column, unaffected by a vertebral misalignment or a segmental dysfunction. Hormones and other factors supplied by blood flow sustain the function of organs. There is no credible evidence to suggest that manipulating the spine for any reason will restore and maintain health as postulated by subluxation-based chiropractors.
Unable to clearly identify or define a chiropractic vertebral subluxation, subluxation-based chiropractors have used many different names to define a subluxation, such as a vertebra out of place, a neuro-biomechanical lesion, joint dysfunction, a spinal distortion, a rotational malposition, and so on. When it became apparent that commonly detected vertebral misalignment or a compressed spinal nerve had no effect on general health, subluxation theory was reworded to suggest that health problems could be caused by nerve interference resulting from a “vertebral subluxation complex” which affects joint-related nerve, muscle, connective, and vascular tissues. Since such subluxations are asymptomatic and not detectable by conventional imaging methods, many chiropractic treatment methods depend upon thermography, surface electromyography, and leg-length checks to detect the presence of subluxations. Such procedures can be influenced by bias and can be easily manipulated by the examiner to provide “proof” that subluxations are present.
Surface electromyography for subluxation detection
Surface electromyography (sEMG), paraspinal scanning with a hand-held device to detect electrical activity in muscles allegedly affected by vertebral subluxations, is a popular method of locating chiropractic subluxations. The American Academy of Neurology has concluded that surface electromyography, while useful for evaluating muscle movement disorders, was unacceptable as a clinical tool for diagnosing low back pain or neuromuscular disease
There is no reason to believe that surface electromyography can detect a real orthopedic subluxation, much less an asymptomatic “vertebral subluxation complex”.
According to Aetna’s Clinical Policy Bulletin No. 0112:
Aetna considers high-density surface electromyography (HG-sEMG), surface scanning EMG, paraspinal surface EMG, or macro EMG experimental and investigational as a diagnostic test for evaluating low back pain or other thoracolumbar segmental abnormalities such as soft tissue injury, intervertebral disc disease, nerve root irritation and scoliosis, and for all other indications because the reliability and validity of these tests have not been established. [emphasis added]
Like most major insurance carriers, Blue Cross Blue Shield reports that:
There are no data on the impact of SEMG on patient management of health outcomes. The evidence is insufficient to determine the effects of the technology on health outcomes. [emphasis added]

Paraspinal thermography for locating vertebral subluxations
Thermography used to record skin temperature up and down the spine is often used along with sEMG to produce colorful printouts indicating the presence of vertebral subluxations. Extraneous factors that influence the flow of blood to the skin, or a little more pressure applied with a hand-held scanning tool, will produce indications of an abundance of subluxations in areas of the spine where a particular chiropractor might prefer to work. NUCCA practitioners, for example, following H.I.O. principles, concentrate on upper cervical manipulation.
A number of medical authorities have concluded that thermography has no proven medical value, including the American Medical Association, the Office of Health Technology Assessment (OHTA), and the American Academy of Neurology.
There are no published studies that demonstrate how the results of thermography can be used to improve patient health outcome.
Use of thermography or surface electromyography to locate subluxations may be used by subluxation-based chiropractors who might falsify evidence of vertebral subluxations in order to treat every patient they see for a variety of health problems.
Leg length checks
Many subluxation-based chiropractic techniques include use of a Derifield leg-length check to determine the need for an adjustment to correct a subluxation or to evaluate the results of an adjustment. Supposedly, a functional leg-length discrepancy is a temporary non-structural imbalance caused by the effect a vertebral subluxation has on musculoskeletal structures. Leg lengths, determined by bringing the feet together for visual inspection, return to normal when the subluxation has been corrected.
The Activator Method, which uses a spring-loaded stylus to tap a vertebra into alignment or to promote healing by removing the interference of a “vertebral subluxation complex,” includes use of nonsensical leg checks. Activator is used by 70% of the world’s chiropractors.
Correcting vertebral subluxations
Appropriate use of generic spinal manipulation that stretches muscles and produces cavitation (slight separation of joint surfaces) to loosen vertebrae can occasionally be helpful in relieving pain and restoring mobility when there is mechanical-type back pain, but the need for specific manipulation to correct a vertebral subluxation is rare. A true orthopedic subluxation may be a painful, partial dislocation that cannot be corrected by manipulation and should not be manipulated. Vertebral misalignments due to degenerative changes, such as disc degeneration, or structural deviations from normal, such as scoliosis, cannot be changed by manipulation. Acute mechanical-type back pain is most often the result of ligamentous, muscle, or joint injury that does not involve vertebral subluxation.
There is no credible evidence to suggest that vertebral subluxations can be detected by such dubious methods as thermography, surface electromyography, or leg-length checks. Yet, “subluxation stations” that utilize such methods are commonly found in the offices of chiropractors, some of whom are true believers and some of whom are concerned only about patient retention and profit.
A word to the wise
Not all chiropractic manipulative techniques are based on subluxation theory; some can be helpful as an option in a physical treatment armamentarium. It goes without saying, however, that any chiropractor who offers to treat non-musculoskeletal problems by adjusting vertebral subluxations, or who resorts to use of such alternative medicine measures as functional medicine or homeopathy, should be viewed askance.
In a promising new development that will assure appropriate use of spinal manipulation, a program associated with the Department of Physical Therapy at the University of Pittsburgh (Pennsylvania) is being developed to train and certify chiropractors and physical therapists as Primary Spine Practitioners (PSP) who work in a team environment caring for spine-related disorders.
References
Peterson D, G Weise. 1995. Chiropractic: An Illustrated History. Mosby-Year Book. St. Louis, MO.

   The Problem with Chiropractic NUCCA
Sam Homola
Link
In 1895, Daniel David Palmer, a magnetic healer, announced that “95 percent of diseases are caused by displaced vertebrae; the remainder by luxations of other joints.” He opened the first chiropractic school in Davenport, Iowa—the Palmer Infirmary, which offered a three-week course of instruction.
In 1906, D.D. Palmer’s son, Bartlett Joshua Palmer, a 1902 graduate of the Palmer Infirmary, took over his father’s school. In 1924, claiming that “subluxation” of any vertebra would cause disease by compressing nerves in the intervertebral foramina, B.J. Palmer introduced the “Neurocalometer,” a thermocouple device guaranteed to locate nerve-pinching vertebral subluxations. Chiropractors were told that if they did not use this “infallible” device to measure heat differentials on the skin over the spine, they could not competently locate and adjust a subluxation. But the Neurocalometer was not for sale. Chiropractors were forced to lease the instrument and then pay a monthly rent. 
In the early 1930s, after nearly three decades of teaching that subluxations anywhere in the spine can cause disease, B.J. Palmer announced that he had found the one and only cause of disease: subluxation of the atlas. Palmer concluded that subluxation of a spinal vertebra below the axis was not possible because vertebrae below that level were bound together by intervertebral discs and interlocking joints. Students at the Palmer School of Chiropractic were not permitted to adjust the spine below the axis until 1949 when full-spine techniques were once again included in the course of instruction. 
B.J. Palmer’s “hole-in-one” (HIO) technique for adjusting the atlas and the axis remained popular among certain factions of the chiropractic profession. According to the 2005 edition of Job Analysis of Chiropractic, published by the National Board of Chiropractic Examines, 25.7% of practicing chiropractors include the “Palmer upper cervical/HIO” technique in their adjustive procedures. 
The NUCCA Club
Members of the National Upper Cervical Chiropractic Association (NUCCA) specialize in adjustment of the atlas, using the procedure as an exclusive treatment for a great variety of ailments. “The focus of the NUCCA work is the relationship between the upper cervical spine (neck) and its influence on the central nervous system and brain stem function. It is this relationship that affects every aspect of human function from the feeling sensations in your fingers to regulating hormones, controlling movement, and providing the ability to hear, see, think, and breathe.” The mission of NUCCA is defined as “Maximizing the human health potential as associated with the reduction of the Atlas Subluxation Complex (ASC).” (nucca.org)
With such a broad and inclusive definition, NUCCA practitioners adjust the atlas as a treatment for ailments ranging from allergies and ear infections to multiple sclerosis and epilepsy. (See http://www.ucc-ny.com for a list of conditions treated by NUCCA practitioners.)
NUCCA Procedures
In an effort to locate “minor and pain-free atlas subluxations” that allegedly cause “brainstem ischaemia” and compromise brainstem neural pathways, NUCCA practitioners commonly use these dubious procedures:
    • A supine leg-length check that reveals disparities in leg length when the head is turned left or right.
    • Use of thermography or infrared thermocouple devices to measure skin temperature over the cervical spine.
    • A postural analysis using the “NUCCA Anatometer” that requires standing on a platform apparatus that measures postural imbalance, pelvic distortion, head tilt, and unequal right and left leg weight bearing.
    • Three x-ray views of the atlas-axis area.
    • Use of a protractor to measure atlas alignment.
    • The patient is then placed in a side-posture position so that the heel of the hand (pisiform bone) or a machine stylus can be used to adjust the “misaligned” atlas.
NUCCA Treatment of High Blood Pressure
The NUCCA approach to treating human ailments received unexpected support recently when a pilot study published in a legitimate medical journal suggested that correcting atlas misalignment would reduce early high blood pressure. A larger clinical study of the effect of upper cervical manipulation on Stage 1 hypertension will soon be done at the Palmer College of Chiropractic under a grant awarded by the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine. “This project will replicate and expand upon a recent study published in the Journal of Human Hypertension, which found that a specific chiropractic technique known as National Upper Cervical Chiropractic Association (NUCCA) is effective in lowering high blood pressure within a small group of hypertensive patients. The study will involve eight weeks of chiropractic care in 155 patients. The clinical site for patient care will be at Palmer’s Davenport Campus.” (Chiropractic Economics, Chiropractic News, May 2008)
Views and Opinions of a Skeptic
I have never been convinced that manual therapy of any kind can produce a permanent reduction in blood pressure. Some forms of manual therapy can temporarily lower blood pressure while others may temporarily raise blood pressure. Tension relief or relaxation that occurs as a result of manual therapy may temporarily lower some forms of high blood pressure, but I don’t know of any way that neck manipulation can permanently reduce high blood pressure, which has many causes unrelated to the neck. Except in cases involving gross anatomical abnormality or injury to the upper cervical area, affecting vascular structures, there is no reason to believe that slight misalignment of the atlas would affect blood pressure, especially the minor, painless “subluxations” routinely adjusted by NUCCA upper cervical chiropractors
When I was in chiropractic school back in the early 1950s, I learned from Best & Taylor’s Physiological Basis of Medical Practice that compression of the carotid sinus at its bifurcation in the upper cervical area would cause a fall in blood pressure and heart rate by raising the pressure in the sinus, while pressure on the common carotid artery in the lower cervical area would raise arterial pressure and heart rate by reducing pressure within the carotid sinus. Such effects resulting from manual stimulation are, of course, temporary, and not a cure for essential hypertension or for high blood pressure caused by bad kidneys, diseased arteries, and other organic problems.
Whatever effect neck manipulation might have on blood pressure, the claim by chiropractic NUCCA “upper cervical specialists” that they can lower blood pressure by correcting minor misalignments of the atlas to relieve “brain stem ischaemia” and to normalize brainstem neural pathways is too implausible to be taken seriously. When the atlas is freely movable and is not locked by painful disease or injury, its resting place, which is determined by the anatomical structure of the articulating surfaces of the occiput, the atlas, and the axis, cannot be changed. NUCCA chiropractors may simply measure structural asymmetry to determine if the atlas is misaligned. Since there are no intervertebral discs and no interlocking joints in the articulation of the atlas with the occiput and the axis, the atlas will move when manipulated, as it does in everyday head movement, but the atlas always returns to its anatomically dictated resting place, as determined by ligamentous constraints and the contours of joint surfaces. Even when there is atlanto-occipital fixation or atlanto-axial fixation, there is no reason to believe that the brain stem would be affected if injury has not occurred and there is no anatomical deformity.
In my 43 years of practice as a chiropractor, I was never able to determine that manipulation of the spine ever permanently changed the position of the atlas or any other vertebra that is freely movable.
The NUCCA chiropractor who examined and treated the patients who participated in the study published in the Journal of Human Hypertension (Atlas vertebra realignment and achievement of arterial pressure goal in hypertensive patients: a pilot study. Vol. 21, No. 5, 2007) determined alone that he had located and corrected “atlas misalignment” in otherwise healthy patients who had misalignment as indicated by imbalances detected in a supine leg length check and by other questionable operator-dependent assessments such as measuring pelvic distortion and cervical skin temperature. A “NUCCA Anatometer” was used to measure “postural asymmetries.” The treating chiropractor, who has been using the NUCCA technique for 50 years, provided both sham procedure and real treatment in this “double blind placebo-controlled” study. He believes that the atlas vertebra is the “fuse box to the body,” and that when the atlas is misaligned as little as half a millimeter bad things happen to the body. (WebMD Medical News, March 16, 2007)
Obviously, it would be difficult or impossible for a dedicated non-blinded NUCCA practitioner to provide sham intervention to one group and real treatment to another group without transmitting his belief to the patient, possibly triggering a placebo effect in the treatment group. X-ray measurements performed by one person might be influenced by patient positioning and by the prejudice of the investigator. An attempt to replicate the findings of such a flawed pilot study with another study done in a chiropractic college using similar procedures would certainly raise questions. Short term treatment for fluctuating blood pressures in patients with Stage 1 hypertension (pressures less than 159/99 mm of Hg, with no known cause) would be difficult to evaluate. The conclusion that “restoration of Atlas alignment is associated with marked and sustained reductions in BP” after eight weeks of weekly upper neck manipulation begs for another explanation.
Examining claims that chiropractic manipulation can lower blood pressure, a study published in a 2002 issue of Journal of Hypertension (Treatment of Hypertension with Alternative Therapies Study: a randomized clinical trial. Vol. 29, No. 10) concluded that “For patients with high normal blood pressure or Stage 1 hypertension, chiropractic spinal manipulation in conjunction with a dietary modification program offered no advantage in lowering either diastolic or systolic blood pressure compared to diet alone.”
The minor atlas subluxations routinely found by NUCCA chiropractors have not been proven to be significant. I would be surprised if a legitimate properly controlled study offered proof that upper neck manipulation would permanently lower blood pressure that has an organic origin. The claim by NUCCA practitioners that a painless slightly misaligned atlas is a cause of high blood pressure does not have enough supporting evidence to warrant the risk of manipulating the necks of patients suffering from high blood pressure, risking injury to vertebrobasilar arteries.
The findings of the questionable and controversial study in the Journal of Human Hypertension, offering support for contentions that correcting a minor atlas misalignment will lower blood pressure, are being extrapolated by NUCCA chiropractors to prove that upper cervical chiropractic is an effective treatment for organic ailments. According to the chiropractor who participated in the blood pressure study, “…high blood pressure is far from the only thing an Atlas misalignment causes.” (WebMD Medical News, March 16, 2007)
Although the NUCCA blood pressure study did note that “The mechanism as to why this improvement in BP occurs is unknown and cannot be determined by this study,” the study itself reads like a chiropractic promotional piece. For example, the study states that “What is clear is that misalignment of the Atlas vertebra can be determined by assessment of the alignment of the pelvic crests,” adding that “…pain was not present in any of the patients randomized in this study.” Such statements may be used by chiropractors to support treatment of a variety of human ailments, based on measurement of common but insignificant vertebral misalignment or on harmless structural deviations from normal.

Upper Cervical Chiropractic: NUCCA─The Legacy of HIO
Upper cervical chiropractors continue to offer an atlas adjustment to treat a variety of health problems, despite lack of credible evidence to support such treatment.
Sam Homola on November 22, 2019
Link
Preamble: My first article published on Science-Based Medicine, on August 7, 2009, “The Problem with Chiropractic NUCCA“, examined an adjustive technique used by chiropractors who believe that subluxation or misalignment of the atlas (1st cervical vertebra) is a major cause of disease. As a chiropractor who answers questions about chiropractic on the Chirobase web site, I often receive letters from patients who have doubts about the validity of a treatment which requires that every patient have an atlas adjustment for whatever problem the patient might have, including low-back pain.
In 2007, a medical journal published a pilot blood pressure study which concluded that NUCCA (National Upper Cervical Chiropractic Association) upper cervical adjustments to realign the atlas would lower blood pressure in persons with Stage 1 hypertension. The article was widely quoted by chiropractors as proof that upper cervical manipulation was an effective treatment for high blood pressure. In 2016, however, a duplication of the NUCCA study, done at the Palmer College of Chiropractic, concluded that upper cervical manipulation did not lower systolic or diastolic blood pressure. The study was largely ignored by subluxation-based chiropractors who continue to quote the findings of the 2007 study to support use of upper cervical manipulation as a treatment for high blood pressure and a variety of other health problems.
Following is an update of my 2009 NUCCA article.
From HIO to NUCCA
In the early 1930s, after nearly three decades of teaching that subluxations anywhere in the spine can cause disease, B.J. Palmer, the developer of chiropractic, announced that he had found the one and only cause of disease: subluxation of the atlas, the vertebra at the top of the spine (C1). Palmer concluded that subluxation of a vertebra below the axis (C2) was not possible because vertebrae below that level were bound together by intervertebral discs and interlocking joints. Students at the Palmer School of Chiropractic, the “Fountain Head of Chiropractic”, were not permitted to adjust the spine below the axis until 1949 when full-spine techniques were once again included in the course of instruction.
B.J. Palmer’s “hole-in-one” (HIO) technique for adjusting the atlas and the axis is still being used by some chiropractors, many of whom are members of the National Upper Cervical Chiropractic Association (NUCCA). According to the 2005 edition of Job Analysis of Chiropractic, published by the National Board of Chiropractic Examines (NBCE), 25.7% of practicing chiropractors include the “Palmer upper cervical/HIO” technique in their adjustive procedures. The 2010 edition and the 2015 edition of Practice Analysis of Chiropractic excluded mention of upper cervical chiropractic and other subluxation-based adjustive procedures that “place chiropractic in an unfavorable light.” But the NBCE continues to report that “The specific function of chiropractic practice is known as the chiropractic subluxation or joint dysfunction”.
The National Upper Cervical NUCCA Club
As noted above, in 2005, 25.7% of practicing chiropractors included use of upper cervical techniques in their treatment of patients. The National Upper Cervical Chiropractic Association Directory currently lists about 243 NUCCA chiropractors, 21 of whom are “board certified”.
Members of the National Upper Cervical Chiropractic Association specialize in adjustment of the atlas vertebra, using the procedure as a primary treatment for a great variety of ailments:
The focus of the NUCCA work is the relationship between the upper cervical spine (neck) and its influence on the central nervous system and brain stem function. It is this relationship that affects every aspect of human function from the feeling sensations in your fingers to regulating hormones, controlling movement, and providing the ability to hear, see, think, and breathe.
The mission of NUCCA is defined as “Maximizing the human health potential as associated with the reduction of the Atlas Subluxation Complex (ASC)”.
With such a broad and inclusive definition, a NUCCA practitioner may adjust the atlas as a treatment for ailments ranging from bed wetting and attention deficit disorder to multiple sclerosis and cerebral palsy.
NUCCA procedures
In an effort to locate “minor pain-free atlas subluxations” that allegedly cause brainstem ischemia and compromise brainstem neural pathways, NUCCA practitioners commonly use these procedures:
    • A supine leg-length check that reveals disparities in leg length when the head is turned left or right.
    • Use of thermography or infrared thermocouple devices to measure skin temperature over the cervical spine.
    • A postural analysis using the “NUCCA Anatometer” that requires standing on a platform apparatus that measures postural imbalance, pelvic distortion, head tilt, and unequal right and left leg weight bearing.
    • Three x-ray views of the atlas-axis area.
    • Use of a protractor to measure atlas alignment.
The patient is then placed in a side-posture position (lying down) so that the heel of the hand (pisiform bone) or a machine stylus can be used to adjust the “misaligned” atlas.

A follow-up of the NUCCA blood pressure study
In 2007, the Journal of Human Hypertension, a Nature Publishing Group medical journal, published an 8-week pilot study which concluded that early high blood pressure could be reduced by using a NUCCA adjustment to correct a minor pain-free atlas misalignment that can “potentially injure, impair, compress and/or compromise brain stem neural pathways”. The study was widely distributed by NUCCA chiropractors who promoted use of upper cervical manipulation as a treatment to reduce high blood pressure and to “maximize the human health potential”. A multi-disciplinary follow-up study of the effect of upper cervical manipulation on Stage 1 hypertension, published in 2016, was done at the Palmer College of Chiropractic under a grant awarded by the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine. The study concluded that:
Six weeks of toggle recoil spinal manipulation did not lower systolic or diastolic blood pressure when compared with a sham approach.
Participants in the NUCCA study received no hypertensive medication whereas participants in the Palmer study remained on their antihypertensive medications.A toggle recoil adjustment to realign the atlas, similar to that used in the NUCCA study, was used in the Palmer study. The adjustment is done by using the pisiform bone of one hand to apply a speedy thrust (with equally speedy withdrawal) to one side of the neck (atlas) while the patient is in a side posture.

Views and opinions of a skeptic
Pre-hypertension or Stage 1 hypertension, determined by systolic blood pressures between 130 and 139 mm Hg and diastolic pressures between 80 and 89 mm Hg, is usually treated with lifestyle modifications. Pre-hypertension blood pressures may fluctuate, depending largely upon whether the cause of the hypertension is secondary or primary, making it difficult to evaluate the effect of treatment.
Investigating claims that chiropractic manipulation can lower blood pressure, a study examining the effect of diversified spinal manipulation, published in a 2002 issue of Journal of Hypertension, concluded:
For patients with high normal blood pressure or Stage 1 hypertension, chiropractic spinal manipulation in conjunction with a dietary modification program offered no advantage in lowering either diastolic or systolic blood pressure compared to diet alone.
I have never been convinced that manual therapy of any kind can produce a permanent reduction in blood pressure. Relaxation or muscle-tension relief that occurs as a result of manual therapy may temporarily lower some secondary forms of pre-hypertension, but there is no reason to believe that an upper cervical adjustment ─ or any spinal adjustment ─ can permanently reduce high blood pressure, which has many primary causes unrelated to the neck or the spine.
When I was in chiropractic school back in the early 1950s, I learned from Best & Taylor’s Physiological Basis of Medical Practice that compression of the carotid sinus at its bifurcation in the upper cervical area would cause a fall in blood pressure and heart rate by raising the pressure in the sinus, while pressure on the common carotid artery in the lower cervical area would raise arterial pressure and heart rate by reducing pressure within the carotid sinus. Such effects resulting from manual stimulation of the neck are temporary and have not been shown to be a cure for essential hypertension or for high blood pressure caused by bad kidneys, diseased arteries, and other primary causes.
Whatever effect neck manipulation might have on blood pressure, the claim by chiropractic upper cervical specialists that they can lower blood pressure by correcting minor misalignments of the atlas to relieve “brain stem ischemia” and to normalize brain stem neural pathways is physiologically implausible. Without serious injury to upper cervical ligaments, an atlas misalignment would not move far enough to affect the brain stem or compromise blood flow in the vertebral arteries.
It is well known that the vertebral arteries can be stretched and possibly injured when manipulation forces passive rotation of the atlas past 45 or 50 degrees. A NUCCA adjustment does not involve rotation of the upper cervical spine, but thrusting on the atlas might fracture the styloid process (a slender projection of bone on each side of the base of the skull) and threaten an internal carotid artery where it enters the carotid canal in the base of the skull.

Atlas alignment
When the atlas is freely movable and is not locked by disease or injury, its resting place is determined by the anatomical configuration of the articulating surfaces of the occiput, the atlas, and the axis and cannot be changed. The atlas might appear to be misaligned on x-ray measurements simply because of structural deviations from normal. No matter how many times a painless freely movable “misaligned” atlas is adjusted, it always returns to its anatomically dictated resting place. I have heard many stories of patients who keep going back to their chiropractor for repeated adjustments to realign the atlas when symptoms persisted, requiring another adjustment because the last adjustment “did not hold.” And despite repeated adjustment of the atlas, the atlas is always “out of alignment” when symptoms are present or when a new health problem develops. Fear that an atlas misalignment might be a cause of disease has a powerful nocebo effect that keeps patients coming back for “maintenance therapy”.
Even when there is atlanto-occipital fixation or atlanto-axial fixation (a rare occurrence which might benefit from manipulation), there is no evidence to suggest that the brain stem would be affected if serious injury has not occurred or if there is no upper cervical disease or anatomical deformity. In a NUCCA case, a freely movable atlas might be repeatedly manipulated to correct an “atlas subluxation complex” as determined simply by checking pelvic imbalance and leg-length disparity. According to the 2007 NUCCA blood pressure study, “What is clear is that misalignment of the Atlas vertebra can be determined by assessment of the alignment of the pelvic crests”.
Atlas displacement that occurs as the result of a real orthopedic subluxation (a partial dislocation) is a painful and serious problem that may truly threaten the brain stem and should not be subjected to chiropractic manipulation. If slight misalignment of the atlas could compress the brain stem, thrusting on the side of the neck with an upper cervical adjustment, forcing excessive movement of the atlas, would be a dangerous practice.
In my 43 years of practice as a chiropractor, I was never able to determine that manipulation of the spine ever permanently changed the position of the atlas or any other vertebra that is freely movable or that restoration of mobility in a fixated vertebral joint had an effect on general health.
Scientific objectivity vs. indoctrinated bias
In view of the fact that the 2016 Palmer blood pressure study did not support the findings of the 2007 NUCCA study, the question arises about the reliability of the findings of the NUCCA practitioner who examined the patients and then provided sham intervention to one group and real treatment to another group. He alone examined and treated the patients who participated in the study. Atlas misalignment was determined by using such operator-dependent assessments as measuring leg length. A NUCCA “Anatometer” was used to measure “postural asymmetries”. X-ray measurements of the atlas, guided by the beliefs of the subluxation-based chiropractic examiner, might have been influenced by structural irregularity or by patient positioning.
The chiropractor who participated in the NUCCA study has stated that the atlas vertebra is the “fuse box to the body”, and that if the atlas gets locked in a position as little as half a millimeter (half of .03937 inch) out of line, it can “pinch the base of the brain”.
With about 50% of cervical rotation normally occurring in the atlantoaxial joints, it is unlikely that a slightly misaligned atlas would affect the brain stem. If the brain stem and its associated structures were that vulnerable, the human species would not have survived the evolutionary process. Injury of the medulla (lower) portion of the brain stem (at the atlas level), usually the result of fracture or dislocation of the atlas, can result in respiratory failure and possible death. A spinal cord injury at or above the 4th cervical vertebra, shutting down brain impulses to spinal nerves, can result in quadriplegia, but the body’s organs continue to function, supplied by autonomic nerve ganglia and plexuses located outside the spinal column.
A slight asymptomatic atlas misalignment (often a measured structural asymmetry), commonly identified by subluxation-based chiropractors as a subluxation, has not been proven to be significant. The claim by NUCCA practitioners that a slightly misaligned atlas is a cause of high blood pressure does not have enough supporting evidence to warrant the risk of manipulating the upper neck of patients suffering from high blood pressure, risking stroke caused by injury to vertebrobasilar arteries.
Although the NUCCA blood pressure study did note that “The mechanism as to why this improvement in BP occurs is unknown and cannot be determined by this study,” the methods used in the study are used by upper cervical chiropractors to locate and correct atlas misalignment claimed to be a major cause of disease.
Upper cervical chiropractic is only one of many unstandardized chiropractic techniques used by subluxation-based chiropractors to remove nerve interference by correcting vertebral subluxations so that the body can “heal itself.” Most chiropractic techniques are based on the Meric system, which assigns certain vertebrae to certain organs, despite the fact that spinal nerves supply musculoskeletal structures, not organs. The NUCCA technique is unique in that it focuses on one vertebra ─ the atlas. There is no credible evidence to suggest that an asymptomatic chiropractic subluxation complex, a vertebral misalignment, a real orthopedic subluxation, or a segmental dysfunction anywhere in the spine is a cause of organic disease.
Generic spinal manipulation can be helpful in treating mechanical-type neck and back pain and related problems. But such treatment is not the same as subluxation-based chiropractic adjustments used to treat a broad scope of health problems.

   The End of Chiropractic
Harriet Hall
Link
An article written by 3 chiropractors and a PhD in physical education and published on December 2, 2009 in the journal Chiropractic and Osteopathy may have sounded the death knell for chiropractic.
The chiropractic subluxation is the essential basis of chiropractic theory. A true subluxation is a partial dislocation: chiropractors originally believed bones were actually out of place. When x-rays proved this was not true, they were forced to re-define the chiropractic subluxation as “a complex of functional and/or structural and/or pathological articular changes that compromise neural integrity and may influence organ system function and general health.” Yet most chiropractors are still telling patients their spine is out of alignment and they are going to fix it. Early chiropractors believed that 100% of disease was caused by subluxation. Today most chiropractors still claim that subluxations cause interference with the nervous system, leading to suboptimal health and causing disease.
What’s the evidence? In the 114 years since chiropractic began, the existence of chiropractic subluxations has never been objectively demonstrated. They have never been shown to cause interference with the nervous system. They have never been shown to cause disease. Critics of chiropractic have been pointing this out for decades, but now chiropractors themselves have come to the same conclusion.
In “An epidemiological examination of the subluxation construct using Hill’s criteria of causation” Timothy A. Mirtz, Lon Morgan, Lawrence H. Wyatt, and Leon Greene analyze the peer-reviewed chiropractic literature in the light of Hill’s criteria, the most commonly used model for evaluating whether a suspected cause is a real cause. They ask whether the evidence shows that chiropractic subluxations cause interference with the nervous system and whether they cause disease. The evidence fails to fulfill even a single one of Hill’s nine criteria of causation. They conclude:
There is a significant lack of evidence in the literature to fulfill Hill’s criteria of causation as regards chiropractic subluxation. No supportive evidence is found for the chiropractic subluxation being associated with any disease process or of creating suboptimal health conditions requiring intervention. Regardless of popular appeal this leaves the subluxation construct in the realm of unsupported speculation. This lack of supportive evidence suggests the subluxation construct has no valid clinical applicability. [emphasis added]
While some chiropractors have rejected the subluxation paradigm, it is supported by the major chiropractic organizations and schools and is considered essential by the great majority of practicing chiropractors. In two recent studies cited in the Mirtz et al. article, 98% of chiropractors believed that “most” or “many” diseases were caused by spinal misalignments and over 75% of chiropractors believed that subluxation was a significant contributing factor to 50% or more of visceral disorders (such as asthma and colic), an implausible idea that is not supported by any evidence whatsoever. Simon Singh was sued for saying so when he correctly referred to “wacky ideas” and “bogus treatments.”
When chiropractors use spinal manipulation therapy for symptomatic relief of mechanical low back pain, they are employing an evidence-based method also used by physical therapists, doctors of osteopathy, and others. When they do “chiropractic adjustments” to correct a “subluxation” for other conditions, especially for non-musculoskeletal conditions or “health maintenance,” they are employing a non-scientific belief system that is no longer viable.
As the authors of this paper indicate, the subluxation construct must go. And without the subluxation, the whole rationale for chiropractic collapses, leaving chiropractors no justifiable place in modern medical care except as competitors of physical therapists in providing treatment of certain musculoskeletal conditions.
The absence of publicity is astounding. This study has not even been noticed by the media. Where are the sensationalist journalists who usually exaggerate the news and make up provocative headlines? They could be trumpeting “Chiropractic Is Dead!” “Chiropractors Admit They Were Deluded by False Beliefs” “Simon Singh Vindicated: Chiropractic Really Is Bogus” and so on. Chiropractors demolishing the basis for chiropractic ought to be big news.
When the news finally gets out, I predict contorted efforts at damage control. Chiropractors will claim that it is not appropriate to apply the Hill criteria in this way, and that the criteria are not a valid test of causality. That’s a straw man: not even Hill suggested that the criteria were a definitive test. They are more of a guide to thinking about causality. Edzard Ernst, the world’s first professor of complementary and alternative medicine, finds them useful. He has recently applied Hill’s criteria to neck manipulation as a cause of stroke: he found that it fulfilled all but one of the criteria for causation. (Article pending publication). Chiropractors won’t like that either.
I predict the authors of this paper will be attacked as traitors by their colleagues. And I predict my own comments will be misinterpreted as some kind of personal vendetta and I will be called ugly names. I also predict that no one will dispassionately offer acceptable scientific evidence to contradict the findings of the paper (They can’t, because there isn’t any!). The first comment (and so far the only comment) on the Chiropractic and Osteopathy website offers no counter-evidence but rather calls for not letting evidence-based protocols overshadow clinical experience.(!) The Weekly Waluation of the Weasel Words of Woo could have a lot of fun translating that statement.
If chiropractors reject the conclusions of the Mirtz et al. paper, the burden of proof falls on them to show
     1.  that the subluxation can be objectively demonstrated,
     2.  that it does cause interference with the nervous system, and
     3.  that it does cause disease.
They have failed to do so for 114 years.
Most chiropractic research falls under the category of Tooth Fairy Science. Instead of doing good basic research to examine the subluxation construct as a falsifiable hypothesis, they blindly forged ahead, implemented it for diagnosis and treatment, and studied various aspects of its clinical use.
The chiropractic emperor has no clothes, and now even some chiropractors have realized that. This study should mark the beginning of the end for chiropractic, but it won’t. Superstition never dies, particularly when it is essential to livelihood.

That’s so Chiropractic
Mark Crislip on August 22, 2014
Tweet 

Old bad studies: Fantastical autopsy results
I found the following quote at “Chiropractic care can treat more than just bad backs” (FYI. Chiropractic can’t):
Luse references a study published in The Medical Times authored by Dr. Henry Windsor [sic], M.D. that showcases the correlation of spinal health to overall wellness. Windsor dissected 75 human cadavers to investigate their causes of death. The study showed that 138 of the 139 diseases of the internal organs that were present were in connection to the misalignments of the vertebrae.
But I was intrigued. So I went to the video tape. Well, the PDF.
It is an interesting read by a physician who was looking for an association between curvature of the spine and visceral pathology.
He had 50 corpses, age unknown, that he dissected, looked at the spine for curvature and then looked for pathology in organs in the same distribution of sympathetic nervous system as the level of the spine curvature.
It would be important to know the age and co-morbidities of the patients, since curvature of the spine is a natural result of aging and can be found in normal people and those with nutritional and other metabolic problems.
More importantly, there is no description of the definition of what constitutes a curvature of the spine beyond the obscenity definition: He knows it when he sees it. In fact he finds curvatures where:
such a curve would have been considered normal by many.
He found the curves then found internal pathology then lined up the diseases with the curvature and found associations. 50 cadavers, 105 curvatures of which 100 were ‘minor’ and of these 105 curvatures, 96:
showed evidence of disorders in some of the structures supplied by that portion of the sympathetic system coming from the vertebral segments of the curvature.
Why only some? What was minor? Why are not all the organs in the sympathetic distribution diseased? Um. Because it is an imaginary association?
Or reversing the process of thought, 221 structures other than the spine were found diseased. Of these, 212 were observed to belong to the same sympathetic segment as the vertebrae in curvature
And when there wasn’t an association, it was due to the levels one vertebrae up or down; close enough, right?
Without knowing how abnormal curvature is defined and how the spines were examined, as far as I can tell this is a massive example of confirmation bias. He saw what he wanted to see.
There were a hodgepodge of problems discovered: infections, tumors and cirrhosis, that, as he philosophically notes, are:
the ordinary diseases of adult life
It is curious that diseases with radically different pathophysiologies were thought to be perhaps due to spine curvature and involvement of the sympathetic nervous system. I can think of no reality-based physiology that would result in cancer and infection from interference with the sympathetic nervous system, and we have no way of knowing if the sympathetic nervous system was even impaired in these cadavers. It is a hypothesis, not a conclusion, from his studies, and an awful one at that.
Some of the processes do not seem to be diseases at all: one small bladder, one unduly large bladder, eight large and seven small red kidneys, one degenerated pancreas, whatever that is, one groin wound, four dilated stomachs, seven large and five atrophic spleens. So many subjective findings. It seemed as if when there was no pathology he found some anyway.
This is as curious an example of presuming causation from association as I have ever seen.
It is fun to read old studies (this study was from 1921), in part due to the style of speech used and in part to see the complete lack of rigor in how information was measured and reported. By modern standards this was a truly awful study. This report would be a nice example for students on how not to do a study for if a mistake could be made, it was.
He concludes that children and dogs like to curl up to sleep because it:
[relaxes] the sympathetic nervous system, induces contraction of the great vessels [and empties] the cerebral vessels.
A unique explanation of sleep: depriving the brain of blood by curling up. The report was from the 1920’s so I suppose we can cut the author a little slack for his unique hypothesis of sleep physiology.
And how this fanciful study applies to the equally fanciful adjustments of subluxations of the spine performed by chiropractors is uncertain as:
All curvatures and deformities of the spine were ridged, apparently of long duration: irreducible by ordinary manual force: extension, counter-extension, rotation, even strong lateral movement failed to remove them or even cause them to change their relative positions.
Nothing there a chiropractor could alter, unless they used a hammer. Or perhaps a spring-loaded rod.
Modern bad studies: Frightening autistic children
“Hope for Autism” reads the title. From a chiropractor. I thought, I’m skeptical. I can’t see how the manipulation of the spine to correct fanciful subluxations could do anything for autism . So I went looking for the original paper, which is in a journal so obscure, J. Vertebral Subluxation Res., it is not on PubMed. But the original, “Clinical Efficacy of Upper Cervical Versus Full Spine Chiropractic Care on Children with Autism: A Randomized Clinical Trial,” is available for download.
Their introduction is humorous, although I suspect not deliberately:
Since the primary problem in autistic children is neurological, it is prudent to research the efficacy of chiropractic care in these children.
Since at its heart chiropractic has nothing to do with neurology, or reality.
They decide to answer the question as to:
which is the recommended chiropractic technique in these cases of autism?
I would wager none.
It is every bit as methodologically horrible as you could predict: 14 patients, no randomization or blinding, no control, short follow-up and outcomes based on parents observations and the Autism Treatment Evaluation Checklist. Any results, given the zero prior plausibility of chiropractic, are going to be due to bias. The study, and its results, are best described as garbage.
If the study was approved by an IRB it is not mentioned in the methods nor is there any mention of informed consent. The study mentions how stressful it was for these autistic children, and all for no valid reason.
A few of the children displayed aggressive behavior such as pushing, falling, flaying arms in the air, and kicking. These actions were usually momentary. Chiropractic care was resumed when he child was able to continue… X-ray examination proved to be the most difficult procedure for autistic children…Light from the collimator bulb either scared or fascinated the children.
They used the percussion adjustment instrument of the Atlas Orthogonal technique on these poor children:
The patient is placed on his side with head support at four inches below the mastoid. A metal stylus is placed between the mastoid and the ramus of the mandible. An adjustment, an impulse imparted to the stylus by a plunger that excites a compressional wave in the stylus, is then delivered to the patient. At the patient-stylus interface, a portion of the wave energy is transmitted to the patient and a portion is reflected back to the plunger. The former portion of energy is enough to direct the atlas vertebra to move to its normal orthogonal position.
No wonder they thrashed about in terror, being held down so a rod could thump them behind the ear like a mob execution. There is zero literature on the PubMeds to support the use of Atlas Orthogonal technique and the patter used to justify its use sounds science-y, but, as one chiropractor recognizes, it:
is an outdated, unproven, unsubstantiated technique system.
The kids also received an unhealthy dose of useless radiation:
To attain this, the technique recommends four pre-adjustment cervical x-rays and two post-adjustment x-rays be taken immediately after the first adjustment in the cervical area.
X-rays are not a benign diagnostic modality (although the data is from CT scans, ionizing radiation should not be given as part of tooth fairy science without IRB approval and informed consent):
Risk estimates are derived for paediatric head computed tomographies (CTs) as well as for brain tumours in adults. On the basis of estimates for Germany about the number of head scans, the annual rate of radiation-induced diseases is calculated. About 1000 annual paediatric CT investigations of the skull will lead to about three excess neoplasms in the head region, i.e. the probability of an induced late effect must be suspected in the range of some thousands.
The scant literature on the topic of autism and chiropractic summarized by the “Hope for Autism” authors is also horrible:
Our systematic review of the literature revealed a total of five articles consisting of three case reports, one cohort study and one randomized comparison trial. The literature is lacking on documenting the chiropractic care of children with ASD…However, given the ineffectiveness of pharmaceutical agents, a trial of chiropractic care for sufferers of autism is prudent and warranted.
The ‘since airplane design has flaws, flying carpets should be used’ argument.
A worthless study that only served to scare and irradiate autistic children and proved nothing about the efficacy of chiropractic for autism. If it had been approved by an IRB, they ought to be ashamed for allowing autistic children to be frightened and irradiated without good reason.
Chiropractors, primary Care and vaccines
Some chiropractors want to become primary care providers. Jann Bellamy and Harriet Hall have written about this fantasy. There are several issues with having chiropractors function as if there were knowledgeable and competent physicians.
The first is that their education in school is woefully inadequate to diagnose and treat common medical problems.
The second is that their practical training is even less adequate. I have yet to meet a new medical school graduate who is even barely competent to take care of patients. It is why they have a residency. Most of the real meat of medical training occurs during the 3 to 7 years after medical school. Chiropractors do not have any meaningful post graduate training.
And third, they do not want to participate in the key concepts that make up primary care. Part of primary care is to diagnosis and treat acute and chronic medical problems and they have no training for this. But another part is health maintenance: doing the testing and treatments for the prevention of diseases such as colonoscopy, mammograms and vaccines.
Vaccines are a key part of health maintenance and arguably the most important intervention to improve human health. Maybe fresh water and flush toilets were more important. Part of health maintenance is making sure your patients are up to date in their vaccines.
And chiropractors are often loudly and proudly against vaccines: Immunizations by Colorado DCs: Really?
Are You Prepared to Vaccinate?
Did no one in Colorado get the memo? Based on the feedback I’ve received from previous columns, not many doctors of chiropractic support prescriptive injectables2 and precious few would be willing to give immunizations to infants.
and
In my opinion, providing risky immunizations to Colorado babies for the purpose of accomplishing a pro-drug agenda is much like a betrayal of those infants for “30 pieces of silver.”
Chiropractors do not subscribe to the reality that vaccines have been and are one of the key tools in the prevention of infections.
A greater than 92% decline in cases and a 99% or greater decline in deaths due to diseases prevented by vaccines recommended before 1980 were shown for diphtheria, mumps, pertussis, and tetanus. Endemic transmission of poliovirus and measles and rubella viruses has been eliminated in the United States; smallpox has been eradicated worldwide. Declines were 80% or greater for cases and deaths of most vaccine-preventable diseases targeted since 1980 including hepatitis A, acute hepatitis B, Hib, and varicella. Declines in cases and deaths of invasive S pneumoniae were 34% and 25%, respectively.
Chiropractors ‘heck no’ antagonism is further evidence against them being responsible for primary care.
Are you willing to administer all of those vaccinations to your infant, adolescent and adult patients so you can meet the accepted standard of a primary care physician? I suspect the majority of you will not just say, “No,” but will say, “Heck no!” So, if we are not willing to do that, then maybe it’s time for us to stop trying to be something we don’t want to be and trying to obtain authority to do things we don’t want to do…However, I do not think the majority of the chiropractic profession believes that primary care – when it includes the medical “Holy Grail” of vaccinations – is the right course to follow.
It is not an isolated opinion but part of the chiropractic world view.
Anti-vaccination attitudes till abound within the chiropractic profession. Despite a growing body of evidence about the safety and efficacy of vaccination, many chiropractors do not believe in vaccination, will not recommend it to their patients, and place emphasis on risk rather than benefit… But this puts the chiropractic profession outside the greater healthcare community and may contribute to its continued marginalization and small market impact.
And it disqualifies them as primary care providers. One would think that to practice primary care people would need to understand the concepts behind primary care and this chiropractor has the correct conclusion for his field. They have no business being in primary care.
Chiropractic, stroke and patient safety
I learned early in my career that even simple interactions can lead to harm. I had a patient as an intern who had an out-of-hospital cardiac arrest. In the field they placed an IV for resuscitation. The IV site became infected, she became bacteremic, the infection went to her aortic valve, which blew out acutely and she died.
It is why I roll my eyes when people say the first rule of medicine is to do no harm. Everything you do in medicine has the potential for harm, including doing nothing. All actions and all inactions can have bad consequences.
The real rule of medicine is that the odds of providing benefit should be greater than the odds of doing harm. There is also a fudge factor for the disease being treated. I once took care of a patient who died of acute liver failure due to medication she was taking for toenail fungus. I always mention this to patients when they ask for terbinafine. There is a low likelihood of death to treat a trivial problem but most people find the risk/benefit unacceptable when I mention my case. And there are other, less toxic, therapies for nail fungus.
If the disease, like leukemia, offers certain death, patients are more likely to accept the risk of serious complications from chemotherapy or a bone marrow transplant since the potential payoff, life, is worth the risks for the treatment. Risks and benefits are variable and deciding what to do is complex calculus filtered through patients’ expectations and values that is not done justice by the simplistic phrase ‘Do no harm.’
The issue with most of the pseudo-medicines is they do nothing, they alter no physiologic process, and so any side effect is not acceptable. If the benefit is zero, the risk should also be zero.
Cervical manipulative therapy has little real proven indication, especially if being used to fix mythical subluxations. Chiropractors are remarkably adamant that their adjustments are safe and do not cause stroke from vertebral artery dissection (VAD). They love to point to “Risk of Vertebrobasilar Stroke and Chiropractic Care Results of a Population-Based Case-Control and Case-Crossover Study” as evidence that chiropractic is safe and suggest patients are seeking chiropractic care for their prior VAD. In point of fact the study confirms the risk of stoke following CMA.
I noted at SBM:
A passive hanging (no drop) gives about 686 Newton’s of force around the neck for a 70 kg human. In chiropractic, “the mean force of all manual applications [is] 264 Newton’s and the mean force duration [is] 145 milliseconds”. So a chiropractic neck manipulation, for a short period of time, can provide 38% the force of a hanging. And a bad hanging at that.
Neck injuries are not that frequent because the muscles of the neck prevent injury by preventing sudden, disastrous, movement. If you want to increase the chance of injury from relatively minor trauma, have the person relax. If the muscles are relaxed because the person is not expecting the trauma, the chance of injury goes up. It is why whiplash can occur after minor injuries. Chiropractors often have their patients relax just before the coup de grace, I mean manipulation, helping to maximize the chance of injury despite having less force applied to the neck than a noose and gravity.
Given the above, to claim that the [vertebrobasilar artery stroke] occurred before the patient had chiropractic neck manipulation is like saying the hanging victim had a broken neck, but it occurred on the steps up to the scaffold.
There is now a position paper “Cervical Arterial Dissections and Association With Cervical Manipulative Therapy” from the American Heart Association/American Stroke Association and discussed by Dr. Novella.
They review the literature and anatomy/physiology of stroke and CMA. The money quote:
Although current biomechanical evidence is insufficient to establish the claim that CMT causes CD [Cervical artery dissections], clinical reports suggest that mechanical forces play a role in a considerable number of CDs and most population controlled studies have found an association between CMT [cervical manipulative therapy] and VAD [vertebral artery dissection] stroke in young patients. Although the incidence of CMT-associated CD in patients who have previously received CMT is not well established, and probably low, practitioners should strongly consider the possibility of CD as a presenting symptom, and patients should be informed of the statistical association between CD and CMT prior to undergoing manipulation of the cervical spine.
In epidemiology, Hill’s Criteria provides a framework for considering whether association is causation and is helpful when there are no definitive studies. We will never have a prospective trial of cervical manipulation to see if it can induce a stroke and given the rarity of the event will have to rely on less definitive data. Hills Criteria are:
    • Strength: A small association does not mean that there is not a causal effect, though the larger the association, the more likely that it is causal.
    • Consistency: Consistent findings observed by different persons in different places with different samples strengthens the likelihood of an effect.
    • Specificity: Causation is likely if a very specific population at a specific site and disease with no other likely explanation. The more specific an association between a factor and an effect is, the bigger the probability of a causal relationship.
    • Temporality: The effect has to occur after the cause (and if there is an expected delay between the cause and expected effect, then the effect must occur after that delay).
    • Biological gradient: Greater exposure should generally lead to greater incidence of the effect. However, in some cases, the mere presence of the factor can trigger the effect. In other cases, an inverse proportion is observed: greater exposure leads to lower incidence.
    • Plausibility: A plausible mechanism between cause and effect is helpful (but Hill noted that knowledge of the mechanism is limited by current knowledge).
    • Coherence: Coherence between epidemiological and laboratory findings increases the likelihood of an effect. However, Hill noted that “… lack of such [laboratory] evidence cannot nullify the epidemiological effect on associations”.
    • Experiment: “Occasionally it is possible to appeal to experimental evidence”.
    • Analogy: The effect of similar factors may be considered.
Hill’s Criteria has been applied to the concept of Chiropractic subluxation and the reality of subluxation was found wanting.
There is a significant lack of evidence to fulfill the basic criteria of causation. This lack of crucial supportive epidemiologic evidence prohibits the accurate promulgation of the chiropractic subluxation.
For stroke causation, Hill’s criteria are modestly met. The preponderance of information points to CMT as a risk for dissection and stroke and there is certainly plausibility for what is fortunately a rare event. The case reports of stoke immediately after CMT give one pause; they may reach the level of parachute evidence.
I have spent a significant part of my career in infection control and quality, where we strive apply the literature to maximize patient safety and to good effect.
To date the only pseudo-medical quality initiative that led to an increase in patient safety of which I am aware is the use of sterile disposable acupuncture needles, an intervention they work hard to subvert by ignoring all other infection control interventions like gloves. A hallmark of pseudo-medicines is they do no change because of data.
In real medicine we recognize the potential for harm and strive to reduce it. In my institutions we try to always put patient safety first. The question is the response by the chiropractic community to the position paper. I predict denial rather than changes in practice to increase the safety of their clients.
Well what do you know? From the American Chiropractic Association
The largest and most credible study, Cassidy et al., found that a patient is as likely to have seen a primary care medical doctor as a doctor of chiropractic prior to experiencing a cervical arterial dissection (CD).
Neck manipulation is a safe, conservative treatment option for neck pain and headache. The evidence presented in the AHA paper fails to show that neck manipulation is a significant risk factor in CD. In addition, the paper fails to put into context risks associated with other neck pain treatments such as neck surgery, steroid injections and prescription drugs.
And leading scientist Christine Goertz DC
In an Aug. 8 speech, Christine Goertz, DC, PhD, vice chancellor for research and health policy at Palmer College of Chiropractic, explained that medical doctors and doctors of chiropractic need to be vigilant in assessing patients who may be in the early stages of vertebral arterial dissection (VAD). It’s also extremely important that the data regarding the risk of VAD is presented to patients in an accurate manner.
“The facts are that VADs are very, very rare events, and there’s absolutely no research that shows a cause-and-effect relationship between chiropractic care and stroke,” Goertz said.
We have very rare events in real medicine as well. We used to use the antibiotic trovafloxacin at the rate of 300,000 prescriptions a month, but there were 6 deaths and handful of severe liver failures from the medication.
And now? We no longer use it because we have safer therapies with equal efficacy. And unlike cervical manipulation for neck pain, an intervention that has no benefit, trovafloxacin was an effective antibiotic.
To use massive understatement, the pharmaceutical industry has not always been forthcoming about the risks of their products. But when they are discovered by physicians, we respond in a way to maximize patient safety. The President of the Infectious Disease Society of America doesn’t give a speech release saying
The facts are that liver failure are very, very rare events, and there’s absolutely no research that shows a cause-and-effect relationship between trovafloxacin and liver failure
or
trovafloxacin is a safe, conservative treatment option for infection. The evidence presented fails to show that trovafloxacin is a significant risk factor in liver failure.
In medicine we balance the risk and the benefit of an intervention and try to do what is in the best interest of the patient by changing practice. When in doubt we try and maximize patient safety
Chiropractic is more interested in keeping their business model active than changing to decrease patient risk. But that is the case for all pseudo-medicines.
Lets increase the chance of more strokes
A while back I mentioned a study that wasn’t a study by the British Chiropractor Association that suggested that texting could kill you.
Their completely unsubstantiated theory is that texting, by causing the head to lean forward, would lead to hyper-kyphosis, restrictive lung disease and death. This idea has no basis in the medical literature I can find.
However, the English need some entrepreneurial sprint because it took
Dr. Dean Fishman, a chiropractor (to) create and trademark the phrase “text neck.”
Hereby referred to as TN.
He has an Android app ($2.99 and free version) to let you know if you are using your phone at a dangerous angle. Why might you do this? Because TN, according to the Text-Neck Institute:
… IS A GLOBAL EPIDEMIC! ‘Text Neck’ is a world-wide health concern, affecting millions of all ages and from all walks of life. Widespread overuse of handheld mobile technology is resulting in a harmful and dangerous physical condition on the human body, which is known as Text Neck.
that will lead to:
Flattening of the Spinal Curve, Onset of Early Arthritis, Spinal Degeneration, Spinal Misalignment, Disc Herniation, Disc Compression, Muscle Damage, Nerve Damage, Loss of Lung Volume Capacity, (and) Gastrointestinal Problems.
TN is based on almost no data and/or wild extrapolation as the search term “text neck” has no hits on PubMed.
I do not doubt a stiff neck and tension headache may occur from prolonged use of a mobile device in an awkward position. I certainly get a sore neck at the computer, especially as the screen is not at bifocal level.
But disc herniation? Loss of lung volume? Gastrointestinal problems? Color me skeptical.
He quotes “Roentgenographic findings of the cervical spine in asymptomatic people” as:
FHP has been shown to flatten the normal neck curve, resulting in disc compression, damage, and early arthritis.
The abstract from 1986, long before cell phones and texting, concerns normal changes in the neck with aging:
The purpose of this study was to determine the incidence and severity of degenerative changes seen on lateral roentgenograms in 200 asymptomatic men and women in five age groups with an age range of 20-65 years and to determine the normal values of cervical lordosis and spinal canal sagittal diameters and their relationship to degenerative changes. It was found that by age 60-65, 95% of the men and 70% of the women had at least one degenerative change on their roentgenograms. A small sagittal diameter correlated with the presence of degenerative changes at the same disc level, and the strongest correlation was with the size of the posterior osteophytes at C5-6 (r = 0.52). Cervical lordosis measurements did not relate to degenerative changes except for subjects over age 50 with moderate or severe intervertebral narrowing. It is important to realize that although roentgenographic abnormalities represent structural changes in the spine, they do not necessarily cause symptoms.
He conveniently ignores the association between cervical spine curvature and neck pain which suggests:
In conclusion, we suggest that when so-called “abnormalities” of the sagittal profile are observed in the older patient with neck pain they must be considered coincidental, i.e. not necessarily indicative of the cause of pain. This should be given due consideration in the differential diagnosis of patients with non-specific neck pain.
In the Cephalalgiaarticle, used as a reference,
the study demonstrated a strong association between an increased forward head posture and decreased respiratory muscle strength in neck patients.
Was in a whopping 24 patients.
Not the most robust of literature to support the concept of TN.
But the biggest concern with making TN a worry to people is the ‘solution’ to the problem. Somehow I suspect the treatment will be chiropractic manipulation of the neck.
And that could lead to an increase in strokes. Great.

Ridiculous Warning from Chiropractors About Alleged Health Effects of Texting
Harriet Hall on April 8, 2014
Link

The United Chiropractic Association has warned that using mobile phones for texting could cause poor posture that could shorten your life. They claim that poor posture is as big a health risk as obesity and that it increases the risk of an early death, especially in elderly people. Chiropractors have said a lot of silly things, but this ranks right up there among the silliest. They are just making stuff up and using scaremongering as a practice-building technique.
They say these claims are based on research studies. They aren’t. They are fanciful imaginings built around a tiny grain of truth that is just large enough to confuse a medically naive public. When people text, they usually bend their head forward; and if you hunch over for long periods, your back is likely to hurt. I have to keep reminding myself not to sit at the computer too long in one position.
But these chiropractors are not talking about temporary muscle discomfort. They say the posture assumed in texting will lead to hyperkyphosis. Kyphosis is an exaggeration of the natural curvature of the upper back. It can be a flexible increase in curvature (= a habit of slouching, the postural kyphosis that is common in teenage girls but that doesn’t impact their adult health) or it can be an inflexible bony deformity. When the curvature exceeds 45 degrees it is classified as hyperkyphosis. The Hunchback of Notre Dame had hyperkyphosis, but I don’t think he even owned a cellphone. Hyperkyphosis can be the result of vertebral fractures, congenital defects, infections like tuberculosis, or nutritional deficiencies like rickets. The “dowager’s hump” deformity in elderly women is usually due to “wedging,” a partial collapse of the anterior side of the spinal vertebrae from osteoporosis. They may be so bent over that they face the ground and can look ahead only with great difficulty. Not surprisingly, severe kyphosis scrunches the chest cavity. It can reduce breathing capacity; can lead to cardiac, neurologic, or digestive complications; and can reduce life expectancy.
Remember when Mom told you not to cross your eyes because they might get stuck and stay that way permanently? Of course that can’t really happen; and no amount of hunching over a cell phone is going to produce a permanent hyperkyphosis either. Chiropractors claim to know more about the musculoskeletal system than MDs; how can they not know this?
The United Chiropractic Association is based in the UK and has members in the US, Canada, and ten other countries. A perusal of its website rings alarm bells.
It includes a lot of informative (sarcasm intended) articles like “Detox with a Smoothie,” “Kids’ Spines Not Coping,” and “Usain Bolt Utilizes Chiropractic.” An article titled “Studies Prove Chiropractic Can Prevent Heart Disease” tells us that “adjustments of the atlas, or first cervical vertebra, may stop some heart attacks while they are occurring” – a ridiculous and dangerous claim based not on any study but merely on one chiropractor’s opinion. The article “Vaccine” informs us that “After receiving data regarding febrile seizure risk after MMRV [the measles/mumps/rubella vaccine], few physicians report they would recommend MMRV to a healthy 12-15-month-old child.” By the time I got to “Why Women in China Do Not Get Breast Cancer” my patience had run out. I couldn’t bring myself to read that one or any more of the articles.
On a webpage about “Why get adjusted?” they claim adjustments can improve vision, reading ability, memory, alertness, and energy; keep joints young and well-lubricated; improve overall health and reduce the incidence of disease; make muscles stronger; remove scar tissue and joint adhesions; improve eye-hand coordination; cure colic in babies; and make your teeth whiter. (OK, I made that last one up, but why not include it? There is just as much evidence for white teeth as for those other claims: exactly zero.)
They fully subscribe to chiropractic’s foundational myth, the subluxation, defining it as “a complex of functional and/or structural and/or pathological articular changes that compromise neural integrity and may influence organ system function and general health.” That means whatever they want it to mean, and means exactly nothing to non-chiropractors.
Notice how they use the word “adjustment” as if they were doing something special and uniquely chiropractic, instead of the term “spinal manipulation therapy” that is used by physical therapists and others who perform the same maneuvers without imagining they are correcting subluxations.
They say chiropractic adjustments remove disruptions of the nervous system, the system that “controls and regulates every single function in your body.” Apparently they have never heard of hormones or autonomously beating heart muscle cells. Apparently they don’t know that cranial nerves, vision, hearing, the firing of brain neurons, and many other bodily functions are anatomically out of the reach of spinal adjustments. Apparently they don’t know that transplanted organs continue to function quite well when their nerve supply has been not just “disrupted” by a subluxation but completely severed. Apparently they have never heard about the useful bacteria that reside in the gut. Why weren’t they taught about such details of anatomy and physiology in chiropractic school?
They sell merchandise, too. You can buy Christmas cards, stickers with a whimsical pig and the slogan “Oink If You Love Chiropractic,” or a children’s book titled Bennie Gets Adjusted (With an accompanying activity book to reinforce the propaganda). They’re not selling Melanie’s Marvelous Measles, but that book would have felt right at home there.
Science and philosophy have moved beyond the outdated concept of vitalism, but it remains alive and well in the UCA:
We ascribe to the idea that all living organisms are sustained by an innate intelligence, which is both different from and greater than physical and chemical forces. Further, we believe innate intelligence is an expression of universal intelligence.
Where are the reformers we keep hearing about? The ones who are no longer taught the old chiropractic subluxation concept in their schools and who are only treating musculoskeletal problems with evidence-based methods? THIS appears to be the real face of modern chiropractic, at least in the UK, since “The UCA is the youngest chiropractic association in the UK with membership growing steadily since 2000.” The president’s name is Kevin Proudman. The man shouldn’t be proud of leading such an anachronistic, pseudoscientific organization.
Conclusion
Texting can definitely be hazardous to your health if you pay more attention to your phone than to traffic, but you needn’t worry about these inane warnings from time-travelling chiropractors who are still living in the 19th century world of chiropractic’s inventor D.D. Palmer. Palmer lived at a time when the germ theory of disease was not yet accepted and x-ray machines hadn’t been invented yet, and he had never studied medicine; yet he invented chiropractic all by himself (on a single day, September 18, 1895 – it says so on his monument). He based the whole edifice of chiropractic on his naïve misinterpretation of a single case. I guess the UCA chiropractors think he was some kind of infallible genius. He wasn’t; his thinking was obviously misguided. And the UCA’s warnings about texting are equally misguided. They would do well to learn some science and join the modern world.

Journal of the American Dental Association Falls for Tooth Fairy Science
Jann Bellamy on November 14, 2013
Link

Another venerable scientific journal has fallen prey to “alternative” medicine research. The Journal of the American Dental Association (JADA) has joined the New England Journal of Medicine and Annals of Internal Medicine, among others, with its publication of “A pilot study of a chiropractic intervention for management of chronic myofascial temporomandibular disorder,” in the October, 2013, issue.
And what “chiropractic intervention” is this? The Activator Method Chiropractic Technique (AMCT) as taught by Activators Methods International (AMI), which also conveniently sells its own line of Activator Instruments. (Practice-building seminar DVDs sold separately.)
What is this Activator Method? In short, it is a method of detecting and correcting subluxations (the chiropractic version, not the medical one). Thus, the underlying premise of this study was that subluxations could cause myofascial temporomandibular disorder (TMD) pain and that finding and vanquishing these subluxations could bring about pain relief.
Now, as regular readers of this blog know, vertebral subluxations are a figment of the chiropractic imagination. They do not exist, as we have pointed out many, many, many times. And here is where alternative medicine has it all over conventional medicine and dentistry. In alternative medicine, once you invent a non-existent condition you can proceed to invent all sorts of diagnostic techniques and remedies to treat patients with this condition. The AMCT is a perfect example of this. Conventional medicine and dentistry, on the other hand, are saddled with the scientific method, biological plausibility, having to discard therapies when studies no longer support their use, and all sorts of other persnickety limitations.
The Activator Method Chiropractic Technique is a complete diagnostic and treatment package. The diagnostic method is laughably nonsensical. Here, we turn for an explanation to SBM contributor and chiropractor Sam Homola, writing for Chirobase:
The AM system is based on a concept of “pelvic deficiency (P.D.)”—also called “functional short leg”—which proponents define as an “apparent” difference in length, not an anatomical difference. To determine where the alleged problem is located, the practitioner holds the patient’s feet in various prescribed ways while the patient lies facedown on an examining table. Other parts of the body may be tested in various other ways.
AMI sells these shoes for patients to wear during their leg length analysis to “ensure accuracy.”

Now, to the treatment itself, which is equally nonsensical “chiropractic gimmickry,” again quoting from Chirobase:
If any inequality or “imbalance” is found, the practitioner taps various points along the spine, pelvis, and/or elsewhere with a handheld, spring-loaded mallet [called an Activator] until the legs appear to be equal in length . . . Slight variations of hip position or normal spinal muscle tension are probably responsible for the “imbalances.”
Ironically, the Activator design was derived from a dental impactor. Here’s the Activator IV, used in the JADA study:

I’ve used a similar Activator, to great comic effect, in my talks to medical students on complementary and alternative medicine. They seem to enjoy passing it around and thumping each other.
Here’s the latest model, described on the website as “revolutionary not evolutionary.”

Climbing the stairway to FDA approval
Yet, the FDA has issued a 510(k) medical device clearance for the Activator Adjusting Instrument for “chiropractic adjustment of the spine and extremities.” How could that happen?
According to FDA records, Activator I (still for sale on the AMI website) was in use prior to the effective date of the federal law requiring pre-market approval. Such devices were grandfathered in under the law. After the law’s enactment, AMI applied for pre-market approval of its newer model, Activator II. It did so on the basis that II was “substantially equivalent” to I, as permitted by law. However, applicants must show that the device submitted for approval is similar in safety and effectiveness to the device already on the market. The required 510(k) summary submitted to the FDA cited a 1986 study published in the Journal of Manipulative and Physiological Therapeutics (JMPT): “Accuracy of Piezoelectric Accelerometers measuring Displacement of a Spinal Adjusting Instrument.” Unfortunately, I cannot access the full article or provide you with a link to this abstract, from which this quote is taken:
The impedance-head-equipped spring-loaded Activator chiropractic adjusting instrument had a low velocity when used on the patient and appeared to cause bone movement and a measurable EMG response.
According to the summary, this “demonstrate[s] the effectiveness of the instruments to cause vertebral movement for chiropractic adjustment at very low energy.” Note that there is no statement in the abstract about whether this “bone movement” actually did anything for the patient or even that its putative effect was measured at all.
But progress marches on, and eventually the Activator III appeared. Its premarket approval was based on substantial equivalency to Activator I and II, with no citation of additional studies of clinical effectiveness in the 510(k) summary. Activator IV apparently did not require FDA approval, or at least I didn’t find any evidence that AMI got it. That brings us to Activator V. This application was based on similarity to III and to two similar devices (FDA approved here and here) manufactured by other companies. Like the III application, the V didn’t cite any studies of clinical effectiveness, nor could it piggyback onto studies cited by the manufacturers of the two other devices, as they don’t cite any in their applications. There is now an Activator V-E, also approved, but unfortunately its summary does not appear on the FDA’s website. (V-E is not sold on AMI’s website.)
Thus, it appears that the evidence of clinical effectiveness of the Activators submitted by AMI to the FDA is less than convincing, even though the FDA requires it for approval. (21 CFR Sec. 807.92) Interestingly, by the time V was submitted for approval in 2007, there was a 2005 article in the JMPT reviewing the studies of clinical effectiveness of the Activator Method and validity of leg-length analysis. The authors concluded that studies of AMCT diagnostic measures “did not permit assertions concerning the validity of AMCT assessment procedures for the detection of supposed joint lesions [one of the many names chiropractors have invented for the invented subluxation] or targets for adjustive intervention.” Clinical trials of the Activator method itself led them to the conclusion that it “may be a clinically useful tool” although they admit that the handful of studies they rely on have insufficient controls (e.g., lack of a placebo, not blinded) and not enough participants to demonstrate much of anything. And the funny thing is one of the authors of this article is Arlen W. Fuhr, D.C., co-creator of the Activator Method, President of Activator Methods International and the contact person on each of the pre-market approval applications filed with the FDA. Why wasn’t his article cited to the FDA?
The Tooth Fairy visits the Journal of the American Dental Association
Of course, all of this is simply Tooth Fairy Science in the first place, that wonderful term coined by SBM’s own Harriet Hall. “Tooth Fairy science seeks explanations for things before establishing that those things actually exist,” according to the Skeptic’s Dictionary. Dr. Hall offers this example:
You could measure how much money the Tooth Fairy leaves under the pillow, whether she leaves more cash for the first or last tooth, whether the payoff is greater if you leave the tooth in a plastic baggie versus wrapped in Kleenex. You can get all kinds of good data that is reproducible and statistically significant. Yes, you have learned something. But you haven’t learned what you think you’ve learned, because you haven’t bothered to establish whether the Tooth Fairy really exists.
Speaking of tooth fairy science, let’s turn to the JADA article. The rationale for the study will sound familiar:
TMD can become a chronic problem lasting several years, and patients receive little help from traditional forms of treatment. Consequently, some patients may seek complementary and alternative (CAM) approaches to manage their TMD-related pain.
So, what to do? Should we expose chiropractors for ripping people off by telling them they have subluxations which may be causing their TMD pain and proceeding to “correct” those subluxations with little spring-loaded mallets? No, we study it because CAM is popular. (Actually, it isn’t.) And we study it with taxpayer money, in this case provided by NCCAM. No surprise there.
Do the authors cite any evidence that the Activator method is nevertheless effective for TMD in an attempt to justify this study, despite the lack of plausibility (which they never admit, of course)? Well, they cite a single case report and a prospective case series of 8 patients who were assessed at 6 weeks with no further follow-up. There was no blinding and no placebo control. I don’t know if this would normally justify a “prospective randomized controlled pilot trial” (as this study is described) of a medical or dental intervention, but perhaps some of you could comment.
Fifty-two (out of an original 80) completed the JADA study. Participants were divided into 4 groups which numbered between 11 and 14 in each group. They compared self-care and self-care plus either AMCT, sham AMCT or reversible interocclusal splint therapy (RIST). Self-care consisted of someone talking to the patient about TMD and suggesting such things as using OTC pain medications, jaw relaxation stretches, and reducing their stress levels.
Before I get into how AMCT was described, let me repeat Sam Homola’s explanation, because it should be fresh in your mind when you read what follows:
The AM system is based on a concept of “pelvic deficiency (P.D.)”—also called “functional short leg”—which proponents define as an “apparent” difference in length, not an anatomical difference. To determine where the alleged problem is located, the practitioner holds the patient’s feet [perhaps shod in AMI shoes] in various prescribed ways while the patient lies facedown on an examining table. Other parts of the body may be tested in various other ways. . . . If any inequality or “imbalance” is found, the practitioner taps various points along the spine, pelvis, and/or elsewhere with a handheld, spring-loaded mallet until the legs appear to be equal in length . . .
Of course, anyone with a background in medicine or dentistry would have his or her suspicions instantly aroused by such an explanation and likely seek further information. Or perhaps even toss the proposed article into the wastebasket. But let’s look at how the authors describe AMCT:
The AMCT protocol is a structured method of chiropractic treatment that involves the use of a series of biomechanical tests in determining how, where and when (or when not) to perform a mechanically assisted manipulation. These biomechanical tests involve well-defined joint or joint complex (motor unit) movements involving the area of examination. Each specific manipulation—called an “adjustment”— is given with a hand-held, springloaded instrument (Activator IV, Activator Methods International) that delivers a quick, shallow thrust. The AMCT protocol can include the entire spine and extremities, as well as the temporomandibular joint. The entire AMCT protocol has been described in detail elsewhere.
A “series of biomechanical tests?” Where is the description of functional leg-length analysis? Or the subluxations it supposedly uncovers? How about an explanation of the subluxations’ putative effect on TMD? Or what it is that this “quick, shallow thrust” is supposed to do?
And that description “in detail elsewhere?” The authors cite a chiropractic textbook written by the aforementioned Arlen W. Fuhr, a text which I expect resides exclusively in chiropractic school libraries and practitioner offices. A less obfuscatory explanation of ACMT can in fact be found in a source more readily available via medical libraries – the same 2005 article in the Journal of Manipulative and Physiological Therapeutics not cited to the FDA by AMI. (JMPT is indexed in PubMed.) Also not cited was a 2012 systematic review in the Journal of the Canadian Chiropractic Association (also indexed in PubMed), which found no difference in results between the Activator Method and manual therapy. Since none of the 8 studies were randomized clinical trials, all lacked a no-treatment or sham treatment group and were unblinded, no results could reliably be attributed to either treatment.
Had the JMPT article been cited, the peer reviewers would not only have discovered the obvious: the lack of validity, not to mention the underlying pseudoscience, of functional leg length analysis and lack of evidence of effectiveness (and, again, the pseudoscience) of the Activator Method. They would also have found a refreshingly honest admission by its authors: there is no evidence that the chiropractic subluxation exists in the first place.
Let’s imagine two scenarios here. First, the peer reviewers were misled by what was made to sound like a fairly innocuous procedure by using vague terms like “structured method of chiropractic treatment” and “biomechanical tests.” Part of me hopes this is the case, although I do think someone should have asked for more detail. And part of me doesn’t want to contemplate a second scenario: that more information was requested by the reviewers and a more straightforward explanation provided by the authors and that it informed them exactly what AMPT is.
And the results of the JADA study?
After going through an impressive amount of verbiage about subject selection, control groups, confidence intervals, baseline characteristics, and all the other accoutrements typical of Tooth Fairy Science, we learn there was no statistically significant difference between results in each group. But that’s ok because the study was simply looking at the “feasibility of conducting a full-scale RCT to evaluate the effectiveness of AMCT” although the next study, according to the authors, should be a comparative effectiveness study. An odd suggestion, as such studies are generally done to compare treatments that are effective. Otherwise, why would you do it?
However, I can’t say nothing useful was learned, although likely not what the researchers intended. First, for all of the hoopla we hear about patients preferring CAM practitioners for their more “holistic” approach, mean satisfaction with care was actually greater for the RIST and self-care-only groups than with the AMCT and sham-AMCT groups. Second, they report “subtle differences” between the chiropractor’s interaction with participants in the AMCT and sham AMCT groups. Actually, some of the differences (more fully explicated in a poster presentation by the authors) weren’t so subtle. The chiropractor talked more to one group than another, but which was which is not reported. And in the active AMCT group the median number of Activator device “clicks” was almost twice as many as in the sham group (42 clicks v. 22 clicks).
But what about the idea that CAM practices must be studied because, as the authors suggest, “some people may seek complementary and alternative approaches to manage their TMD-related pain.” True enough, “some people” do exactly that. “Some people” may seek crystal therapies or use biomats, or tape magnets to their jaws. Should we study those too? After all, they have no less plausibility than AMCT. Must we study every treatment anyone makes up? And does it matter why “some people” try these therapies? Does it matter that they seek them out because chiropractors are misleading them about AMCT’s effectiveness and taking their good money for a worthless treatment? Wouldn’t it be more useful to tell them this rather than spending money on implausible treatments that we know can’t possibly work? Do we think for one second that chiropractors will stop using AMCT because the studies don’t support its use? (Answer: they won’t.)
Which brings me to other troubling aspects of this study.
Why was this study approved by the University of Iowa’s Institutional Review Board (IRB)? I am certainly not an expert in bioethics, but it is my understanding that no trial should be approved that does not conform to the “World Medical Association Declaration of Helsinki – Ethical Principles for Medical Research Involving Human Subjects,” which states:
21. Medical research involving human subjects must conform to generally accepted scientific principles, be based on a thorough knowledge of the scientific literature, other relevant sources of information, and adequate laboratory and, as appropriate, animal experimentation.
As well, ethical and legal principals require informed consent before a human subject agrees to participate in a trial. As Steve Novella said yesterday in his post on informed consent:
This principle is, in turn, based largely upon the principle of autonomy – people have the right to control their own lives, and one cannot have control without information.
The same is true for informed consent in the legal context, which is based historically on the tort of battery: no one can intentionally touch you without your consent. And to consent you have to know what you are consenting to.
So let’s review what we know about AMCT.
It is based on the “theory” that subluxations (chiropractic version) of the spine affect human functioning and can cause ill health. As chiropractors themselves admit, there is no real support for this “theory.” And whatever chiropractors think, as any responsible scientist will tell you (and as one neuroscientist in fact told me) the whole idea is nonsense.
These subluxations can be discovered by something called “functional leg length analysis,” which even a casual observer can see makes no sense (anatomical or otherwise) whatsoever.
That thumping the vertebrae or other articulation with a small, spring-loaded mallet will reduce the subluxation by moving it back into its proper location, an obviously dubious concept.
This “correction” of the subluxation will have a beneficial effect on the patient’s condition.
And how do we know this? Through information readily available via a search of literature indexed on PubMed. There are plenty of other journal articles with similar information, but articles on AMCT alone will tell you everything you need to know. As will Science-Based Medicine, for that matter.
Did the University of Iowa IRB have this information? I don’t know, but it was certainly easily available. Would this information be relevant to a person making a decision on whether to participate? Of course. Were the subjects told this? I doubt it. (And if anyone out there has the informed consent documents used in this trial, I would certainly love to see them.)
If I can figure all of this out with my 10th grade biology science education and an internet connection, why couldn’t the editors of JADA? Why couldn’t the University of Iowa IRB? Good questions.

   ““It’s just a theory”
Mark Crislip
Link
I am afraid that the experiments you quote, M. Pasteur, will turn against you. The world into which you wish to take us is really too fantastic.
La Presse, 1860
It’s just a theory. Not evolution. Germ theory. Just a theory, one of many that account for the etiology of diseases.
I should mention my bias up front. I am, as some of you are aware, an Infectious Disease doctor. My job is simple: me find germ, me kill germ, me go home. I think there are three causes of disease: wear and tear, genetic, and germs. Perhaps a bit of an exaggeration, but not much. My professional life for the last 22 years has been spent preventing, diagnosing, and treating the multitudinous germs that a continually trying to kill or injure us. It is a fundamentally futile job, as in the end I will be consumed by the organisms I have spend a lifetime trying to kill.
I would have though that the germ theory of disease was a concept that was so grounded in history, science and reality that there would be little opposition to the idea that germs (a broad term for viruses, bacteremia, fungi, parasite etc) cause infections and some other diseases.
Wrong. There are people who deny the validity of germ theory. Add there are people who deny gravity. And evolution.
Opponents of germ theory come in two flavors:
Germ theory deniers.
Those who propose alternative mechanisms of disease.
There is great overlap between the two categories, and the division serves more as a literary device for the sake of exposition than a true description of reality.
Germ Deniers
The germ deniers put forth as their patron Saint Antoine Bechamp, a contemporary of Louis Pasteur. Bechamp lived from 1816 to 1908, the dawn of modern medicine and the beginning of microbiology. No one had a clue in the 1800′s as to the cause and treatment of diseases and there were many speculations and experiments performed in an attempt to understand and treat diseases. Most people had a life expectancy less than 50 years and the predominant cause of morbidity and morality was infectious. Since we do not die young of infections and we get to live long enough to die of cancer, heart and vascular disease. Before the 1900′s, if you could understand what caused infections, you could understand most diseases.
The foundations of microbiology and infectious diseases are based on the work of Pasteur and Robert Koch. Like Darwin, the insights of Pasteur and Koch are not the end of understanding of infectious diseases, but the beginning. The world is far more complicated and subtle than Pasteur and Koch could appreciate with the scientific tools of the time.
Pasteur, of course, performed the experiments that proved that germs existed and were a cause of some diseases. His name is well known and lives on in pasteurization, the heating of milk to kill microorganisms and prevent the spread of disease, one of many contributions he made to medical sciences. His insights, which lead to antibiotics, hygiene, and vaccines have undoubtedly prevented more morbidity and mortality than any human in history.
Another contemporary of Pasteur was Robert Koch, who, among many accomplishments formulated Koch’s postulates, conditions that were to be met to prove the infectious cause of disease:
The organism has to found in all cases of the disease
The organism has to prepared and maintained in a pure culture
The organism had to be capable of producing the original infection, even after several generations in culture
The organism retrievable from an inoculated animal and cultured again.
Modern biochemistry and molecular techniques have refined Kochs postulates. We can’t always grow the organism but we can isolated its DNA. Given the species specificity of some germs, we cannot always infect animals to prove causation. I doubt anyone would want to prove the cause of Ebola by re-inoculating a human with cultured virus. Also, there is great variability in the ability of many germ strains to cause disease and great variability in the hosts immune system to combat diseases. Some germs are more virulent than others. Some people are some or less susceptible to disease, and the last 10 years have seen an explosion in understanding of the variability in the human immune system (polymorphism’s) that explain why some people get ill from a given pathogen and others do not.
The combination of germ theory and Koch’s postulates, improved and refined by biotechnology, are still the cornerstones of infectious diseases. Pasteur, Koch and their contemporaries began the science of infectious diseases and microbiology, a field that has lead to more benefits to mankind than perhaps any other.
What do the germ deniers offer as a alternative to Pasteur et. al.? The theory of Antoine Bechamp and others called pleomorphism (1).
CELLULAR THEORY (BECHAMP)
Disease arises from micro-organisms within the cells of the body.
These intracellular microorganisms normally function to build and assist in the metabolic processes of the body.
The function of these organisms changes to assist in the catabolic (disintegration) processes of the host organism when that organism dies or is injured, which may be chemical as well as mechanical.
Microorganisms change their shapes and colours to reflect the medium
Every disease is associated with a particular condition.
Microorganisms become “pathogenic” as the health of the host organism deteriorates. Hence, the condition of the host organism is the primary causal agent.
Disease is built by unhealthy conditions.
To prevent disease we have to create health.
Bechamp’s hypothesis was, at the time, no more or no less reasonable than other ideas. Unfortunately for him, a century and a half of research has demonstrated that there he was wrong on all the particulars of his ideas, except for 7 and 8. Postulates 1, 2, 3, 4, and 6 are all flat out false. From 1950 to November 2nd 2008 at 9:50 am PST, there were 909, 599 citations on Pubmed relating to infections. How many papers and experiments were done in the 100 years prior to 1950 I do not know, but it is a safe bet that germ theory is supported by over a million studies and experiments. A Pubmed for terms to support pleomorphism finds zero references. Germ theory is as confirmed a concept as science can offer. Cellular theory lost the battle to experiment. Reality and science supports the ideas of Pasteur, not Bechamp.
Alternative practitioners are drawn to the concepts of Bechamp because the reason for disease is that the body fails. Alternative providers are all about supporting health to allow the body to heal itself. Bechamp lends credibility to many alternative practices.
Here is where it gets weird.
Rather than look at the mountains of evidence to support germ theory and the complete lack of evidence to support pleomorphism as the reason for the dominance of germ theory, they resort to paranoid sounding conspiracy theories.
The Whale is a good source for this kind of thinking and is representative of what you will find if you browse the web:
How did Pasteur’s ideas become the foundation of organized medicine? Politics. Pharmaceutical economics.
Early in his career, Pasteur was decorated by the Emperor Napoleon. His position as a scientist was thereby secured, even though he was only a chemist and had no credentials at all in medicine or physiology…..
For the first time in history, things were coming into focus. Discoveries were being made about fundamental issues, but in a piecemeal fashion. It was perfect timing for an opportunist to take advantage of the general uncertainty and lack of understanding and to claim that he understood all the issues involved, and furthermore had thought of them first. Pasteur was noted for his habit of playing both sides of the fence on issues he didn’t understand, and then later, to quote the parts of his earlier writing that supported the later finding, always with the claim that he had been there first. Only the scientists understood the complexities of these emerging ideas. The royal court and the press just knew that something was going on, and though they didn’t know what, were going to act as though they did. And for them, a chameleon like Pasteur was the perfect frontman.
Politics never changes. The same type of thinking that imprisoned Galileo long ago for discovering that the earth went around the sun, the rulers’ eternal attempt to control the minds of their subjects, these are the forces that cast Pasteur, an ambitious opportunist, into a position he may not have deserved – the supposed Trailblazer in the science of modern biomedicine.
Funny how things often don’t really get “discovered” until the commercial aspects of that discovery have been worked out.
or
Béchamp’s research revealed that the inner condition of a person’s cellular terrain determined whether disease would manifest or spread in the body. He proved through rigorous scientific method that disease was not due to germs attacking the body from the outside as Louis Pasteur later convinced the world. What you eat, breathe, drink, and bathe in are the primary factors that determine your body’s inner condition.
Instead of incorporating Béchamp’s discoveries to bring about a health revolution in the world and save countless lives, greedy, power hungry industrialists decided to ostracize his work and put their dollars behind Louis Pasteur’s “Germ Theory of Disease” because it was a way for them to build a colossal pharmaceutical/medical empire for profit. No pharmaceutical company in the world today cares one iota about curing disease. They want to control disease and focus on symptom suppression so they can make huge profits by getting you to become a lifelong user until you die from their poison. That’s why they go to war against disease with all their “anti” this and “anti” that medications instead of addressing the inner condition of a patient and re-establishing homeostasis in the body. (2)
This is weird not only because it denies over a million interrelated studies that confirm germ theory, but Pasteur’s fundamental ideas were confirmed about 60 years before the discovery of penicillin. That is just how subtle and clever big Pharma is: they suppressed a theory because they knew that 60 years in the future they would make a fortune selling antibiotics. Someone needs to send Big Pharma the JREF million dollar prize.
Then there are HIV deniers, who live in a bizarro world of their own. My medical career started with the onset of the HIV epidemic. I have seen HIV go from zero understanding about the disease and a 9 month life expectancy to amazing detail about the biochemistry and pathophysiology of HIV and an almost normal life expectancy for many AIDS patients. There are 191,000 plus articles on Pubmed concerning HIV research. The astounding accumulation of data to support HIV as a cause of AIDS and the benefits of applying that understanding to the treatment of AIDS is triumph of the modern medical-industrial complex. It is why I have one AIDS patient die this century after a decade of AIDS deaths. Application of germ theory saves lives. Millions and millions of lives.
Of course, that is just what they told me to say.
Alternative mechanisms of disease
There are a multitude of alternative mechanisms of disease: blocked chi in acupuncture, blocked innate intelligence in chiropractic, toxin build up in the colon, etc etc. What these alternative therapies share is a lack of appreciation or understanding of germ theory. Since germs cannot be seen, and since it is not germs but their alternative theory that causes disease, why would you expect alternative providers to behave as if germs exist? The result of believing that germs do not exist is infections. The germs will always win.
Acupuncture and Infections
Acupuncture is unique compared to most alternative practices in that it is invasive and because acupuncturists actually do something to accomplish nothing. Stick needles into people and you can drag in all kinds of germs. I have a healthy respect for needles and the damage they can cause by practitioners who understand germ theory. A review of adverse events associated with acupuncture demonstrated that “Infection accounted for 204 primary reports and 91 secondary reports. Over 60% of these cases were hepatitis B. The next most common infection was of the external ear, as a complication of auricular acupuncture (3).”
Cellulitis, bacteremia, endocarditis, empyema, osteomyelitis, endophthalmitis, abdominal abscesses, epidural abscesses and infected joints are well described complications of acupuncture. Blood borne pathogens such as HIV, hepatitis C and hepatitis B are associated with acupuncture. Mycobacterium abscesses and Mycobacterium chelonae outbreaks have occurred due to acupuncture. Needles are dangerous, and while the body has good defenses against infectious complications of minor trauma, the defenses fail on occasion.
One would think acupuncturists would clean the skin before needle insertion, but a review of skin disinfection for acupuncture states: “Disinfection of clean skin before injection is not generally considered necessary and observations of lack of infection following injections without prior skin disinfection support this (4).” Another review suggests that “none the less, good infection control is essential” but that assumes the practitioner understands and appreciates germ theory as a cause of infectious diseases. Infection after penetrating trauma is uncommon, a rare event under most circumstances. I would guess that many reading this have evidence of minor skin trauma right now and are not infected. It is what the immune system is for.
One of the lessons you learn in medicine is there is a difference between what one can get away and what is the best practice for all patients. Most of the time you do not need to wash your hands or prep the skin or do any of the procedures that decrease the risk of infections. Most of the time you can get away with being sloppy. But the more you practice infection control procedures, the greater the odds that the patient will avoid infection. Of course, there is the underlying assumption that you think germs cause disease. If not, why bother? There are a smattering of infections treated with acupuncture (UTI, skin infections, arthritis) in the medical literature; one can only wonder why. I suppose the acupuncture will support immune health a foster the innate healing process. I would rather kill bacteria. But then, I would.
Chiropractic and Infections
Two studies have cultured chiropractic exam tables and found pathogens, including methicillin resistant staphylococcus. Apparently chiropractors are not particularly fastidious at disinfecting their exam tables. Why would they? Germs are not necessarily the cause of disease in their world view.
I am particularly drawn to one of the conclusions: “Rudimentary behavioral changes to improve chiropractic clinic infection control are needed.” Rudimentary. Not an enthusiastic vote that the education chiropractors received in school was in infection control. I note chiropractic schools offer microbiology, and again I wonder why. It would not appear to be for the purpose of learning rudimentary infection control. But why should they feel inclined towards good infection control practices? The cause of disease is not germs, it is due to blocked innate intelligence.
It maybe less of an issue currently, but chiropractors long opposed germ theory and a google using chiropractor and germ theory as search terms finds no shortage of chiropractors who oppose the concept of germs causing disease. Given the huge variability in chiropractic practice, it is difficult to know if such lack of understanding of germ theory is typical of the field or not.
Other practices
There was an outbreak of colonic amoebiasis associated with colonic irrigation. Thirty six people developed the disease and 10 required colectomy. “Tests of the colonic-irrigation machine after routine cleaning showed heavy contamination with fecal coliform bacteria. The severity of disease in this outbreak may have been related to the route of inoculation.” Colonic irrigation is done to cleanse the colon of toxin build up that causes disease. It is an idea for the cause of diseases that has no bearing on reality and colonic irrigation is useless for removing toxins or curing diseases. Why concern yourself with germs and their transmission to others, since they are not a cause of disease. It is no surprise that the cleaning was not optimal
Moxibustion has been associated (and yes I know association is not causation) with a spinal epidural abscess and with a Pasturella abscess. The other complication of moxibustion is burn injury, which is fertile soil for infections. It is no surprise that this procedure would be associated with infection.
Naturopathic care is associated with a case of prosthetic valve endocarditis with P. acnes after unnecessary vitamin injections.
Other alternative modalities have fewer or no reported infections associated with them probably because they do not do anything. The recent 50 facts about homeopathy suggested “The chances of contracting MRSA or C. Difficile at a Homeopathic Hospital are extremely rare.” Of course it is. An intervention that does nothing cannot have an infectious complication. Doing nothing results in nothing.
What unites many alternative practitioners is their opposition to vaccines. Germs don’t cause disease, so why prevent infections with vaccines? Like many practices with alternative medicine practitioners, it is difficult to know how pervasive anti-vaccine sentiments are.
CAM also lends support to the “anti-vaccination movement. In particular, sections of the chiropractors, the (non-medically trained) homoeopaths and naturopaths tend to advise their clients against immunization. The reasons for this attitude are complex and lie, at least in part in the early philosophies which form the basis of these professions (5).” In other words belief in magic prevents understanding of infectious diseases and germ theory.
Chiropractors often advise against vaccination and do not vaccinate their own children. There is a contingent chiropractors of who are against vaccines, but to what degree they represent chiropractors as a whole I cannot say. Since Chiropractors are not required to use evidence to base their practice, there appears to be fewer standards and greater variability as to what what constitutes chiropractic practice. Attitude by health care professionals can influence decisions to vaccinate, and 27% of chiropractors in one survey advised against childhood vaccination (7). In another series where a fictitious patient asked for vaccination advice on the internet, of 93 homeopaths and chiropractors, “no homeopath and only one chiropractor advised in favor of the MMR vaccination (8).”
Advice from chiropractors, homeopaths, naturopaths and other alternative practitioners against vaccinations abounds on the web, it is difficult to tell from the published studies if this dangerous advice is the norm for these practitioners or the deviant recommendations of the more extreme of the already irrational. The studies are few and small in number, but disturbing in their implications. Chiropractors and naturopaths are pro childhood infection.
Anti-vaccination is often spun as an issue of choice “Concerning immunization information, a much higher proportion of faculty (91%) and students (80%) than practitioners (62%) felt chiropractors should provide both pro and con information to patients (6).”
It may be that the biggest source of infections from alternative medicine practitioners is not what they do but what they do not do. The only studies I can find on vaccine refusal concerns religious exemptions. I wonder how many who refuse vaccinations do so because of information obtained from chiropractors, homeopaths, naturopaths and other alternative practitioners.
I looked for, and could not find, studies that examined how compliant various alternative providers are with rudimentary hand hygiene and other infection control recommendations. In science based medicine, where germs are an accepted etiology of disease, compliance with hand hygiene has historically been poor. Rates for hand washing have typically been less than 50% in a group of people who allegedly think germs exist. Thanks to intensive education and focus this century, hand hygiene rates have gone up at all my hospitals. It has been gratifying to see as the compliance with infection control has increased, the rates of hospital acquired infections have dropped. The last 19 years that I have been the Chair of our Infection Control committee has seen the continuous and relentless decline in infections at all my hospitals. That is one of the side effects of applying evidence based medicine and germ theory to the hospital: infections decrease.
Any useless anecdotes from readers? Did your chiropractor wash her hands? Your naturopath? Your primary care doc? If not, you should perhaps seek care elsewhere.
All of the infections associated with alternative medicine modalities are unusual. I also suspect that the infectious complications associated with alternative medicine are under reported because it takes time and effort to report cases. I have seen a handful of infections (and other complications) associated with alternative therapies and have neither the time nor inclination to report them formally to a journal.
I am certain someone will mention in the comments all the morbidity and mortality us real doctors cause on a regular basis. Health care is not, unfortunately, risk free, and I know all too well the improvements that could be done to improve patient safety. I also know the enormous strides we have made in preventing hospital acquired infections during my career. I used to be able to make a living off hospital acquired infections and the last 19 years have shown a steady decrease in nosocomial infections at my hospitals to the point where some have not had a nosocomial pneumonia in over a year.
In medicine we have to weigh the risks of what we do with the benefits we hope to gain. In the world of alternative medicine, there is all risk with no benefit. See http://whatstheharm.net/ for more anecdotes (not data).
Beliefs in disease causation have consequences. Believing that germs do not cause disease doesn’t affect the germs. They are out there waiting for the opportunity to invade and try and kill you. Job security.
References
(1) http://whale.to/p/bechamp.html
(2) http://www.healthtruthrevealed.com/full-page.php?page=article&&id=11421316206
http://whale.to/v/bechamp1.html
Acupuncture references:
(3) Acupunct Med. 2004 Sep;22(3):122-33. A cumulative review of the range and incidence of significant adverse events associated with acupuncture.
(4) Acupunct Med. 2001 Dec;19(2):112-6. Skin disinfection and acupuncture.
Outbreak of invasive methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus infection associated with acupuncture and joint injection. Infect Control Hosp Epidemiol. 2008 Sep;29(9):859-65. PMID: 18684094.
Acupuncture-associated Listeria monocytogenes arthritis in a patient with rheumatoid arthritis. Joint Bone Spine. 2008 Jul;75(4):502-3. Epub 2008 May 2. PMID: 18455948
Outbreak of acupuncture-associated cutaneous Mycobacterium abscessus infections.J Cutan Med Surg. 2006 Jul-Aug;10(4):166-9.PMID: 17234114
[Risk of hepatitis C related to traditional medicine: a case control study in Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam] Rev Epidemiol Sante Publique. 2007 Apr;55(2):107-12. French. PMID: 17 442516
Paraplegia caused by spinal infection after acupuncture.Spinal Cord. 2006 Apr;44(4):258-9.PMID: 16151454
Multiloculated pleural empyema following acupuncture.Infection. 2005 Aug;33(4):297-8. PMID: 16091905
HIV infection after Chinese traditional acupuncture treatment.Complement Ther Med. 2003 Dec;11(4):272. PMID: 1496979
Soft tissue abscess and osteomyelitis secondary to acupuncture.ANZ J Surg. 2003 Sep;73(9):770. PMID: 12956798
Group B Streptococcus endogenous endophthalmitis : case reports and review of the literature.Ophthalmology. 2002 Oct;109(10):1879-86. Review. PMID: 12359609
Chiropractic References
Chiropr Osteopat. 2007 Jun 7;15:8. Assessment and risk reduction of infectious pathogens on chiropractic treatment tables.
Am J Infect Control. 2006 Apr;34(3):155-7. The role of chiropractic adjusting tables as reservoirs for microbial diseases.
Chiropr Hist. 1996 Jun;16(1):72-87 Chiropractic’s tension with the germ theory of disease.
Other Practices
N Engl J Med. 1982 Aug 5;307(6):339-42.Links An outbreak of amebiasis spread by colonic irrigation at a chiropractic clinic.
Spinal epidural abscess associated with moxibustion-related infection of the finger. J Spinal Cord Med. 2008;31(3):319-23. PMID: 18795486
Pasteurella multocida infection of the calf in a patient who had moxa cautery treatment for degenerative arthritis. Yonsei Med J. 1982;23(1):65-70
Tidsskr Nor Laegeforen. 1991 Sep 20;111(22):2741-2. [Bacterial endocarditis after treatment by a natural healer]
Vaccines and alt med
(5) Vaccine. 2001 Oct 15;20 Suppl 1:S90-3; discussion S89. Rise in popularity of complementary and alternative medicine: reasons and consequences for vaccination.
(6) J Manipulative Physiol Ther. 2004 Jun;27(5):287-98. A survey of US chiropractors on clinical preventive services.
http://www.chirobase.org/06DD/chiroimmu.html
(7) Vaccine. 2004 Dec 2;23(3):372-9. here to read Beliefs and behaviours: understanding chiropractors and immunization; Association between Health Care Providers’ Influence on Parents Who Have Concerns about Vaccine Safety and Vaccination Coverage.: Smith PJ, Kennedy AM, Wooten K, Gust DA, Pickering LK.Pediatrics, November 2006; 118(5):e1287-e1292
(8) Vaccine. 2003 Mar 7;21(11-12):1044-7. MMR vaccination advice over the Internet.

Pediatics

   Pediatric Chiropractic Care: Scientifically Indefensible?
Sam Homola
Link
In a paper published in 2008, two academic chiropractors offered this observation: “The health claims made by chiropractors with respect to the application of manipulation as a health care intervention for pediatric health conditions continue to be supported by only low levels of scientific evidence. Chiropractors continue to treat a wide variety of pediatric health conditions.”1
Despite lack of support by the medical and scientific community, chiropractic treatment of children is growing in popularity, and more chiropractors are specializing in “chiropractic pediatrics.”
The International Chiropractic Association offers a post-graduate “Diplomate in Clinical Chiropractic Pediatrics” (DICCP) and publishes a “peer reviewed” Journal of Clinical Chiropractic Pediatrics. The diplomate syllabus is a 30-module, 360+ hours classroom course during weekends over a three-year period. There is no hospital training and no contact with diseased or injured children — only a “mandatory observational/training weekend at a chiropractic center for special needs children under multi-disciplinary care.”2 A post-graduate certification in chiropractic pediatrics (CICCP) can be earned after 180 hours of classroom instruction.
In a June 2008 joint press release, the American Chiropractic Association’s (ACA) Council on Chiropractic Pediatrics and the Council on Chiropractic Pediatrics of the International Chiropractors Association (ICA) announced that the ICA’s Diplomate in Clinical Chiropractic Pediatrics (DICCP) is now recognized by the ACA and its council as the official credential for specialization in chiropractic pediatrics.3
Noting increasing public support for chiropractic treatment of children, a January 2009 press release from the American Chiropractic Association made this announcement: “Survey data indicates that the percentage of chiropractic patients under 17 years of age has increased at least 8.5 percent since 1991.…Studies are beginning to show that chiropractic can help children not only with typical back and neck pain complaints, but also with issues as varied as asthma, chronic ear infections, nursing difficulties, colic and bedwetting.”4
A trend toward greater utilization of chiropractic by children has not gone unnoticed by the medical profession. An article in the January 2007 issue of Pediatrics (the official journal of the American Academy of Pediatrics) described chiropractic as the most common complementary and alternative medicine practice used by children, who made an estimated 30 million visits to US chiropractors in 1997.5 In 1998, children and adolescents constituted 11% of patient visits to chiropractors.6
Promoting a broad scope of practice for pediatric chiropractors, the ICA Council on Chiropractic Pediatrics offers links to abstracts from chiropractic journals that support chiropractic treatment for a great variety of a childhood ailments.7 Chiropractors commonly claim to have an effective treatment for otitis media, asthma, allergies, infantile colic, and enuresis. While many of the pediatric conditions treated by chiropractors are self limiting, treatment is offered for such serious conditions as cerebral palsy, epilepsy, myasthenia gravis, ADHD, and Tourette syndrome. For the most part, treatment for all these conditions is based upon detection and correction of “vertebral subluxations.” An article titled “The Child Patient: A Matrix for Chiropractic Care” in a 2005 edition of the Journal of Clinical Chiropractic Pediatrics, for example, stated: “Any alteration in form or function in the child may signal the presence of subluxation, and the subluxation may in turn alter the physiology of the child.”8 For wellness and prevention reasons, parents are advised that children should visit a chiropractor 6 to12 times a year to be checked for subluxations.8
A 2009 survey of chiropractors and parents of chiropractic pediatric patients, conducted by the International Chiropractic Pediatric Association, revealed that “The indicated primary reason for chiropractic care of children was ‘wellness care’.”9 Such care would require manipulating the spines of healthy children for “subluxation correction.”
There is no credible evidence to support the contention that “subluxation correction” will restore or maintain health or that such subluxations even exist.10,11,12 There are hundreds of subluxation-based studies published in chiropractic journals supporting chiropractic treatment for children but only a few studies disputing such treatment. I suspect that most medical researchers feel that claims based on the chiropractic vertebral subluxation theory are too implausible to warrant investigation. But such claims should not go unchallenged, especially when they involve treatment of children.
Evidence Fails to Support Chiropractic Treatment of Childhood Ailments
To date, legitimate properly-controlled studies have failed to support the claims of chiropractors who treat children for organic ailments. In the case of asthma, for example, a randomized, controlled trial of chiropractic spinal manipulation for children with mild or moderate asthma, published in a 1998 issue of The New England Journal of Medicine, revealed that “the addition of chiropractic spinal manipulation to usual medical care provided no benefit.”13 A randomized, controlled trial of infantile colic treated with chiropractic spinal manipulation, published in a 2001 issue of Archives of Diseases in Childhood, concluded that “Chiropractic spinal manipulation is no more effective than placebo in the treatment of infantile colic.”14 A recent systematic review of randomized clinical trials offered this conclusion: “There is no good evidence to show that spinal manipulation is effective for infant colic.”15
It has been suggested that use of osteopathic manipulative techniques as an adjuvant therapy in routine pediatric care of recurrent acute otitis media might have potential benefit by affecting the patency of the auditory tube.16 Chiropractors who manipulate a child’s neck in a misguided attempt to correct “subluxations” might provide some symptomatic relief for secretory otitis media by inadvertently stretching the Eustachian tube, facilitating drainage of fluids from the middle ear. But the risk of such treatment outweighs any possible benefit. (Although otitis media is normally self limiting, it should be kept under observation by a pediatrician who can prescribe antibiotics, if needed, when there is acute otitis media with bacterial infection. Otitis media commonly occurs in children under 3 years of age. As the child grows older, changes in the length and angle of the Eustachian tube reduce chances of bacteria or virus traveling from the throat to the middle ear.)
Considering the implausibility of the chiropractic vertebral subluxation theory and the training chiropractors receive, there is good reason to question the ability of chiropractors to diagnose and treat childhood ailments. A correct diagnosis notwithstanding, there is no evidence to support the belief that manipulating the spine of a child to correct “vertebral subluxations” would be appropriate treatment for anything. A 1993 risk/benefit analysis of spinal manipulative therapy for relief of lumbar or cervical pain, published in Online Neurosurgery, advised neurosurgeons that “Potential complications and unknown benefits indicate that SMT [spinal manipulative therapy] should not be used in the pediatric population.”17
Because of the damage that manipulation might do to cartilaginous growth centers, there is no known justification for using spinal manipulation on an infant or a pre-adolescent child. Yet, some chiropractors recommend that the spine of a newborn baby be adjusted at birth to correct “subluxations.” According to the ICA (International Chiropractic Association) Council on Chiropractic Pediatrics, “Chiropractic care can never start too early.”18
Generally, pediatricians think of a child as being under 18 years of age — before vertebral end plate growth is completed. In a child under the age of 8 to 10 years, the cartilaginous growth centers are too immature and too vulnerable to injury to be subjected to spinal manipulation. There is some speculation that injury to growth plates might result in spinal deformity (such as scoliosis or Scheuermann’s kyphosis) as growth progresses.19 Such injury may not be detectable. “The incidence of subtle growth plate fractures following high-velocity [manipulation] techniques in children is surely under-appreciated because of the occult nature of these injuries.”19
Under normal circumstances, it seems unlikely that the cartilaginous, flexible spine of a healthy child would be as easily injured as an adult spine that has been weakened by degenerative changes. Referred pain caused by organic disease is not commonly experienced by children. When back pain in a child does occur, it is potentially more serious than back pain in an adult and should always be brought to the attention of a board-certified pediatrician.
Spinal manipulation has the potential to injure the spine of a child. A systematic review of 13 studies published up to June 2004 uncovered 14 significant manipulation-related injuries in children up to18 years of age, 9 of which were serious (e.g., subarachnoidal hemorrhage, paraplegia) and 2 of which were fatal (one child died from a brain hemorrhage and another from dislocation of the atlas following neck manipulation). Ten of the injuries were attributed to manipulation done by chiropractors, 1 to manipulation by a physiotherapist, and 1 to manipulation by a medical doctor; 2 injuries were caused by unspecified providers of manipulation. In 20 cases of harm caused by delayed diagnosis as a result of using manipulation, 7 involved a delayed diagnosis of cancer; 2 children died because of delayed treatment for meningitis.5 The incidence of spinal injuries in children is reported to be 2 to 5% of all spine injuries.21
Dubious Methods Used to “Detect and Correct” Pediatric “Subluxations”
High velocity, low amplitude thrusting, commonly used by chiropractors, is usually the type of manipulation that injures a child’s spine. Most chiropractors who manipulate an infant’s spine may simply use light thumb pressure to “adjust” an allegedly misaligned vertebra, thus reducing possibility of injury. Gentle touch may have a calming affect on an infant. But any manipulative technique applied to the neck of an infant is unnecessary and potentially dangerous. Some chiropractors may use a spring-loaded stylus or an electrically-powered mallet in an attempt to tap vertebrae into alignment. Chiropractors who adjust newborn babies to correct “subluxations” may concentrate on the upper cervical (neck) area of the spine. The upper neck is more likely to be injured by delivery during birth and is most vulnerable to injury caused by manipulation. Pediatricians have observed that “The most common traumatically injured region of the immature spine is the first and second cervical vertebrae.”19
There is no credible evidence that chiropractors are able to find “subluxations” in the spine of an infant. It seems unlikely that a chiropractor could detect vertebral misalignment by palpating the flexible, cartilaginous spine of an infant through a thick layer of baby fat. I have always suspected that chiropractors who say they can use their fingertips to feel subluxations in a baby’s spine are either deceiving themselves or misinterpreting what they are feeling.
Some chiropractors use surface electromyography, thermography, leg-length checks, or some other questionable device or approach to locate subluxations. It goes without saying that chiropractors should not expose a child to unnecessary radiation by x-raying his or her spine in a search for elusive or nonexistent “subluxations.” In Canada, the Alberta Society of Radiology has recommended that radiologists refuse requests from chiropractors who ask for diagnostic imaging of any type involving children aged 18 years or younger.21
Of all the claims made by chiropractors, I regard the claims made by those who treat children to be the most problematic. I have always advised against manipulating the spine of a small child or a newborn baby for any reason. Manipulation of the spine of an adolescent child under the age of 18, no matter who does it, should be done in concert with an evaluation and a diagnosis provided by an orthopedist, preferably a pediatric orthopedic specialist. Caring for children is very different from caring for adults and requires a special expertise. Board-certified medical and osteopathic pediatricians are best qualified to provide or recommend appropriate care based on a correct diagnosis.
Drawing the Line on Chiropractic Treatment of Children
Although spinal manipulation is often recommended as a treatment for back pain, this recommendation does not often apply to children. When the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services published a Clinical Practice Guideline suggesting that spinal manipulation can be helpful for patients with acute low-back problems without radiculopathy (sciatic pain) when used within the first month of symptoms, the report included this statement: “The recommendations included in the guideline may not apply to persons younger than 18 years since diagnostic and treatment considerations for this group are often different than for adults.”22 An adolescent child might benefit from appropriate manipulation designed to relieve symptoms caused by uncomplicated, mechanical-type back problems. But use of chiropractic “spinal adjustments” for “subluxation correction” may delay appropriate treatment based on a correct diagnosis — and the younger the child the greater the chances of misdiagnosis or injury.
Some chiropractors believe that adjusting a child’s spine will stimulate the immune system and help prevent infection. On September 8, 2009, for example, the Journal of Pediatric, Maternal and Family Health — Chiropractic issued a press release titled “Chiropractic Part of Swine Flu Prevention Program in Children.” The editor of the journal recommended that all children should be checked for vertebral subluxations before and during the flu season. “Since the nervous system has a direct effect on the immune system and because the spine houses and protects so much of the nerve system it is important to have your child’s spine checked for any interference.”23
Such alarming and unscientific views find support in the basic definition of chiropractic and in official chiropractic publications. The National Board of Chiropractic Examiners (NBCE), for example, advises that “Psychoneuroimmunology has revealed an interrelationship between the central nervous system and immunity (consistent with chiropractic philosophy)….By manually manipulating vertebrae into their normal physiological relationship, chiropractic practitioners relieve interference with the nervous system along with accompanying symptoms.” Regarding treatment of children, the NBCE advises that “Chiropractic management of childhood disorders primarily consists of adjusting concomitant spinal subluxations and providing specific nutritional advice and/or support and other palliative measures.”24
All things considered, it is an understatement to say that “Pediatric chiropractic care is often inconsistent with recommended medical guidelines.”6 Recommendation of any complementary alternative medicine therapy that has a risk/benefit ratio that is not acceptable and is not supported in medical literature may make a referring physician liable for negligence if the referral causes harm by delaying necessary conventional treatment.25
I don’t know of any reason to believe that it might be necessary to refer a child to a pediatric chiropractor or to use spinal manipulation on a child prior to onset of adolescence. “Wellness care” in the form of “subluxation correction” is unnecessary and scientifically indefensible, and it places children at risk. 
References
Gotlib A, Rupert R. Chiropractic manipulation in pediatric health conditions — an updated systematic review. Chiropractic & Osteopathy. 2008;16:11 http://www.chiroandosteo.com/16/1/11 Accessed April 17, 2010.
ICA Council. Diplomate in Chiropractic Pediatrics. http://www.icapediatrics.com/members-postgrad.php Accessed April 10, 2010.
ACA Council on Chiropractic Pediatrics. Pediatric diplomate certification recognized by both ICA and ACA. 2007. http://www.acapedscouncil.org/pressrelease.html Accessed April 10, 2010.
ACA. Increasing numbers of children receive pediatric chiropractic care. January, 2009. http://www.acatoday.org/press_css.cfm?CID=3247 Accessed April 10, 2010.
Vohra S, et al. Adverse events associated with pediatric spinal manipulation: A systematic review. Pediatrics.2007; 119(1):e275-e283.
Lee A, Li D, Kemper K. Chiropractic care for children. Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine. 2000; 154:401-407.
ICA Pediatrics. Journal Abstracts. http://www.icapediatrics.com/reference-journals.php Accessed April 10, 2010.
Fallon J. The child patient: A matrix for chiropractic care. Journal of Clinical Chiropractic Pediatrics (Supplement). 2005; 6(3).
Alcantara J, Ohm J, Kunz D. The safety and effectiveness of pediatric chiropractic: A survey of chiropractors and parents in a practice-based research network. Explore: The Journal of Science and Healing.2009; 5(5):290-295.
College of Physicians and Surgeons of the Province of Quebec. A scientific brief against chiropractic. New Physician.1996. http://www.chirobase.org/05RB/CPSQ/00.html Accessed April 10, 2010.
Mirtz TA, Morgan L, Wyatt LH, Greene L. An epidemiological examination of the subluxation construct using Hill’s criteria of causation. Chiropractic & Osteopathy. 2009; 17:13. http://www.chiroandosteo.com/content/17/1/13 Accessed April 10, 2010.
Nelson C. The subluxation question. Journal of Chiropractic Humanities. 1997; 7(1):46-55.
Balon J, et al. A comparison of active and simulated chiropractic manipulation as adjunctive treatment for childhood asthma. The New England Journal of Medicine.1998; 339(15):1013-1020.
Olafdottir E, et al. Randomised controlled trial of infantile colic treated with chiropractic spinal manipulation. Archives of Disease in Childhood. 2001; 84(2):138-141.
Ernst E. Chiropractic spinal manipulation for infant colic: A systematic review of randomized clinical trials. International Journal of Clinical Practice. September, 2009; 63(9):1351-1353.
Mills V, et al. The use of osteopathic manipulative treatment as adjuvant therapy in children with recurrent acute otitis media. Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine.2003; 157(9):861-866.
Powell FC, et al. A risk/benefit analysis of spinal manipulation therapy for relief of lumbar or cervical pain. Neurosurgery Online.1993; 33(1):73.
ICA Home. Council on Chiropractic Pediatrics. http://www.icapediatrics.com Accessed April 10, 2010.
O’Neal ML. The pediatric spine: Anatomical and Dynamic considerations preceding manipulation. Comprehensive Therapy.2003; 29(2):124-129.
Hayes J, Arriola T. Pediatric spinal injuries. Pediatric Nursing. 2005; 31(6):464-467.
Editorial. Alberta radiologists target chiropractors. Canadian Medical Association Journal. 1998; 159(10):1237.
Bigos SJ, et al. Acute Low Back Problems in Adults.1994; Rockville, Maryland: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. AHCPR Publication No. 95-0642.
McCoy M. Chiropractic part of swine flu prevention program in children. McCoy Press Research Update. September 8, 2009. http://researchupdate.mccoypress.net/2009/09/08/chiropractic-part-of-swine-flu-prevention-program-in-children.aspx Accessed April 10, 2010.
Christensen M, et al. Job Analysis of Chiropractic.2005. Greeley, CO; National Board of Chiropractic Examiners.
Cohen MH, Kemper KJ. Complementary therapies in pediatrics: A legal perspective. Pediatrics. 2005; 115(3):774-780.

Chiropractic, Chiropractic for Kids, and a Few of My Greatest Hits
A few thoughts on chiropractic and the evolution of my feelings on the subject. Also, a bit of a walk down memory lane with highlights of my most memorable posts on pediatric chiropractic quackery.
Clay Jones on October 30, 2020
Link

A bit of an editorial today, and a walk down memory lane. A few thoughts on chiropractic, if you’ll indulge me, starting with the origin story of my animus towards the profession and a bit on how my thinking has evolved over time. I’ll finish up with a few of the most egregious examples of how absurd and dangerous members of the profession can be when they attempt to manage pediatric patients.
I recently took care of a young child with constipation severe enough to require admission to the hospital for treatment. I’ve written about constipation in the past here on SBM. This was the kind of constipation that is far too common in children and can result in fecal impaction, severe acute pain that mimics surgical emergencies like appendicitis, chronic pain that can reduce a child’s quality of life, urinary tract infections, bedwetting, stool accidents, and social upheaval. Unfortunately, my patient had been undergoing “treatment” by a local chiropractor. Needless to say, it wasn’t working.
I couldn’t help but recall my first exposure to so-called pediatric chiropractic during my residency training at Vanderbilt Children’s Hospital in Nashville. At the time, I was familiar with chiropractic as a profession but didn’t know much more than that they were back and neck pain specialists in the same way that podiatrists focus on the feet. This erroneous assumption came mostly from commercials that I was exposed to in my youth. I can still remember the commercials for a chiropractor in Baton Rouge that played during the 1980s and promoted something called the “NOOPE Plan” (no out of pocket expense). Now I recognize this as an illegal marketing bait used to reel in more patients.
On that day in 2007, while on a pulmonary medicine rotation as a 2nd year resident, I encountered a child with a severe asthma exacerbation that had been under the care of a local chiropractor. As she developed increasingly severe respiratory distress, gasping for air with lungs already dangerously hyperexpanded and using every available muscle of respiration (retractions), her parents finally sought proper medical attention. The father, a famous musician, explained that he was told repeatedly by the chiropractor not to worry, that he had things under control. Luckily, the child responded to treatment quickly and did not require intensive care.
I remember being so angry back then. Of course, it didn’t help that at about that same time I also took care of a child with a life threatening infection in the deep tissue of the neck that was being treated with acupuncture. These experiences, and a fortuitous viewing of an interview of James Randi, set me on my current path. My initial stance on the subject of chiropractic, once my eyes had been opened to its potential for outright quackery, was firm and unyielding: all chiropractors were charlatans seeking to deceive the public, placing their patients at risk of severe injury or delayed medical care just to get more referrals and the chance to convince them of the benefits of long term contracts.
I have learned a lot since then, and developed a much more nuanced understanding on the subject of chiropractic and medical pseudoscience in general. Now I know that mine was a simplistic view, emotionally satisfying but clumsy and unfair. I’m not arguing that there isn’t an unfortunate amount of blind faith, arrogance of ignorance, and even intentional deception within the profession. Far from it. But as is so often the case, it’s complicated.
Over the past 13 years, I’ve read a great deal about the training and clinical activities of chiropractors. I’ve shadowed a pediatric chiropractor for a day. I’ve silently observed their message boards and have occasionally been unable to resist chiming in only to be banned. I’ve watched hundreds, if not thousands, of online marketing videos demonstrating a wide variety of pure and unadulterated pseudomedical buffoonery. (Just google “ring dinger” or “Y-Strap” to get a small taste.) I’ve read the research on strokes from vertebral artery injuries. I’ve seen several more pediatric patients whose care was inappropriately delayed. The bottom line is that if all anyone was ever exposed to was this, the correct stance would be that the profession deserves our contempt.
I’ve also conversed, both online and in person, with chiropractors who disagree with and even push back against the worst of these practices, publicly disavowing such nonsense as the chiropractic subluxation and the management of all but a short list of musculoskeletal complaints. There are evidence-minded chiropractors who promote quality medical information, work with physicians, and function essentially as physical therapists. There is legitimate chiropractic research. It can help some patients.
Does this absolve the entire profession of guilt? Of course not. Although I’m now much more cognizant of the chiropractors who don’t fit into my initial understanding, it is not clear to me how successful they have been in their efforts to reform chiropractic from within. I’d argue that it hasn’t been very successful at all if you take into account the overall quality of the online outreach from most chiropractic practices. And the bulk of the chiropractic literature isn’t much better, particularly when it involves children.
I have had several chiropractors tell me that the “good ones” far outnumber the practitioners treating asthma or promoting anti-vaccine propaganda, to name just a couple examples. But I’m not convinced by the surveys that I’ve seen. I think that it remains incredibly challenging for the public to weed out the charlatans and to find their way into the offices of a Samuel Homola or a Mark Croucher. So I still find myself wondering, if a science-based chiropractor is equivalent to a good physical therapist, why not just go to a physical therapist instead of rolling the dice in a rigged game?
But the question of just how generous to be when evaluating the chiropractic profession is entirely moot when we double back to the issue of pediatric chiropractic, particularly the nauseating concept of newborn/infant care. Any claim of chiropractic involving the evaluation and management of infants is indefensible nonsense based on magical thinking and pseudomedical garbage. All of it.
It boggles the mind that this is something that is even allowed in this country or any other. It serves as a prime example of how the regulation of quackery fails when the very people who promote and practice it are given oversight authority rather than those who would evaluate safety and effectiveness using rigorous scientific standards. The lack of basic scientific plausibility and the overall poor quality of clinical studies do not support any indication for bringing an infant to a chiropractor. But when the fox is guarding the hen house, I guess it makes sense that they would go for the most vulnerable first: the scared, the sick, and the young.
Here are a few examples of the pediatric chiropractic topics I’ve discussed over the years:
In my very first post for SBM, I discussed the limitations of chiropractic research that heavily relies on case reports, and claims of success in treating Tourette syndrome. I can’t believe it has been 8 years since I joined the team. I did a quick search and yes, nothing has changed in that time.
My 2013 post on the claims by some chiropractors that they can prevent the sudden unexpected death of an infant during sleep is still the one that makes me the most angry. Again, it’s like none of these people even read my posts. Sheesh!
In the past 8 years, I’ve also covered chiropractors managing newborns requiring resuscitation after delivery (yes, you read that right), claiming to prevent abusive head trauma (formerly known as shaken baby syndrome), managing dangerous abnormal heart rhythms, and manipulating infants under anesthesia. As with TS and SIDS, nothing has changed because there is apparently no political will for it to do so. That ship sadly sailed a long time ago and I don’t see a future where there are regulations put into place by the government. I am left hoping that those chiropractors fighting from within will gain a foothold, but I’m not holding my breath.

No. “Big Data” Does Not Support Chiropractic Care for Infants
A new study claims to have used “big data” to help answer the question of infant chiropractic effectiveness, but it’s just another collection of anecdotes that adds nothing to our understanding of infant medicine.
Clay Jones on June 28, 2019
Link

I have never hid the fact that I am not a fan of so-called infant chiropractic. There is no condition for which there is a shred of plausibility that chiropractic manipulation or adjustment of the infant skull or spine would provide specific benefit. Not colic. Not reflux. Not ear infections. Not craniosynostosis. And not SIDS. Yes, you read that right.
So-called clinical placebo effects do, however, give parent and practitioner alike the false perception of benefit. This is unavoidable when the majority of infant conditions that are claimed to be amenable to chiropractic care are self-resolving over time. Or when a caregiver’s perception of the severity of subjective symptoms, such as fussiness, is altered by an expectation of improvement.
This hasn’t prevented chiropractors from marketing their services to caregivers of young children, a group that is particularly vulnerable in my opinion. Thousands of infants are brought to chiropractors every year, in large part because of credulous reporting like this, complete with the standard opening anecdote, token skepticism (it’s me), and false balance. And thousands of individual chiropractic websites that a curious parent might stumble upon present worthless testimonials and case reports as proof of effectiveness.
With all this in mind, as it almost always is, I recently read a paper published in the Journal of Manipulative and Physiological Therapeutics that claims to have used the power of “big data” to show that maybe there is something to this infant chiropractic thing after all. In fact, according to the authors, it is the “first large prospective study reporting parental report of effectiveness of routine chiropractic care for infants”. Manipulative indeed.
Maternal report of outcomes of chiropractic care for infants
I’m confident that you already know where this is heading. But before I get to just what this study involved, there were a few interesting comments in the introduction:
An important development in health care in the past decade has been the increasing interest in patient-centered care emphasizing the patient’s own perspective on their illness and treatment. Patient-reported outcome measures are designed to assess a patient’s subjective impressions of their health with respect to symptoms, function, and health-related constructs such as health-related quality of life. The WHO points out that involvement of the patient in their own health care is a social, economic, and technical necessity.
This is true. We have come a long way in the practice of real medicine in regards to leaving our paternalistic past behind, though we are far from perfect. An increased focus on patient autonomy, or parental authority in pediatrics, and in shared decision making is incredibly important. The authors, however, are setting up an implication that downplaying or appearing to outright disregard the perception of parents whose infants have undergone chiropractic care is poor form.
It gets worse:
Routine collection of patient-reported outcomes has been suggested as a method of collecting large amounts of data to capture information about what occurs in routine clinical practice. These large amounts of data may be used to measure quality of care and evaluate comparative effectiveness of treatments.
They then segue into collecting “big data” for infants undergoing chiropractic care, which they see as crucial for determining treatment effects, safety, and parental satisfaction. They even acknowledge that chiropractic has been criticized for a lack of “high-quality evidence to support the care of this population”, and position studies such as this as an improvement. While there is certainly some truth to this, that patient-reported outcomes are an important aspect of clinical research and care, they are leaving out some very important caveats.
There can be significant problems with focusing too much on certain patient-reported outcomes in certain clinical situations. In the case of conditions that are highly subjective, uncontrolled data can be very misleading if you are looking for evidence that a treatment truly works. The same can be said for developing an understanding of potential adverse outcomes. In regards to satisfaction, using this as a metric has been shown to actually result in lower quality and more expensive care with worse outcomes.
I’ll cut to the chase now. This was an observational study involving prospectively collected data using the United Kingdom Infant Questionnaire (UKIQ) from mothers who sought chiropractic care for their infant. So right off the bat, there is risk of selection bias. Mothers reported their child’s age, sex, complaint at presentation, type of birth, and referral source. The UKIQ also allowed the mothers to grade their child’s feeding, sleep, and crying on a scale from 0 to 10, with 10 representing a “serious problem”. Also included were questions on infant sleep position and general pain or discomfort as well as maternal anxiety and quality of life.
The treatment each child underwent was not standardized but left up to the individual chiropractor, of which there were many at several different clinics. Follow up questionnaires were filled out at the fourth or final visit, whichever came first. At that time, mother’s rated their overall satisfaction with their child’s care from 0 to 10, with 10 representing “very satisfied”, as well as their perception of “global impression of change” in their child’s condition. This response could range from “much worse” to “completely better, made a huge difference, like a different baby”.
A subset of mothers, although how this was determined was not explained, were asked about the development of adverse events or side effects. The authors state that a question about cost effectiveness “was added later when it was discovered that this type of research had particular utility in asking such a research question.” This sounds like one of those researcher degrees of freedom that Steve is always talking about.
2,001 mothers completed the intake questions. Unfortunately, only half gave follow-up information, with even some of those responses being incomplete. This is a pretty glaring problem and certainly calls their results into questions. And speaking of results, to absolutely nobody’s surprise they were all positive and statistically significant.
They found that the mothers who completed the second questionnaire reported significant improvements in infant feeding, sleeping, crying, supine sleeping, pain, neck movement and tummy time, as well as in maternal anxiety, depression, and satisfaction with motherhood. Virtually all responding mothers rated their children as being improved with over 80% rating them as much or completely better. Over 80% of responding mothers also rated their satisfaction with chiropractic care as a 9 or 10. It all sounds amazing, doesn’t it?
None of this really means anything when you take into account the limitations of the study and the extreme lack of plausibility that gently prodding a baby’s spine would play a role in any of these conditions. In the discussion, the authors admit as much. Well not the part about the lack of plausibility. These results tell us that studies designed to have positive results…have positive results.
The authors admit that this type of study can’t determine if chiropractic actually is effective. But they weasel out of this by claiming that proper studies might not be able to tell if a treatment is truly clinically effective anyway. For this, they ponder, perhaps asking the parents really is the best means of answering the question.
Perhaps the most grandiose claim made by the authors of the study involve postpartum depression. They claim that because there were apparent reductions in maternal anxiety and improvements in quality of life, chiropractic treatment of infants might prevent postpartum depression. They even slip in an apparent dig at conventional doctors who fail to help mothers when they merely reassure them that their child’s condition is not life-threatening rather than providing “specific contextualized help”. In other words, by telling a mother that their child is crying because of a fictional subluxation and then providing a bogus remedy.
Conclusion: Just another worthless collection of anecdotes
This study adds nothing of value to our understanding of infant medicine. It took a highly selective population of mothers likely already sold on the benefit of chiropractic care of infants and asked for subjective perceptions of subjective symptoms. All of the complaints involved in the questionnaires are likely to resolve over time without intervention, and are very likely to seem improved when non-specific placebo effects are involved. And I have to wonder how statistically significant would these results have been if the 1,000 mothers lost to follow-up had completed their surveys.
By questioning this data, I’m not attacking mothers or ignoring caregiver assessments of their children. I rely on parental perception every day to provide care for infants. It’s a team effort. But these reports have to be evaluated in context. I’ve lost count of how many times I’ve been told by a parent that their child is subjectively improving only to find objective evidence that shows the opposite. Medicine, and I mean real medicine rather than the make believe cargo cult pretend medicine that some chiropractors play at, is rarely as simple as they would have us believe.

Chiropractic Pediatrics: “delayed referral, misdiagnosis, adverse events and ineffective treatments”
A study finds “delayed referral, misdiagnosis, adverse events and ineffective treatments” in chiropractic management of pediatric orthopedic conditions. States should act to prevent this harm to children.
Jann Bellamy on June 7, 2018
Link


Chiropractic education and training in pediatrics is inadequate and chiropractic treatments for pediatric patients lack evidence of safety and effectiveness, not to mention basic biological plausibility. Yet, all U.S. chiropractors can legally treat pediatric patients, from neonates to teenagers, for practically any disease or condition. This appears to be true in Canada as well. In the U.S., it is because politicians have given chiropractors a scope of practice commensurate their self-proclaimed competency without ever having examined whether that competency exists. A newly-published study adds to the body of evidence that this gap between legislatively-prescribed expertise and their actual capabilities causes patient harm.
The premise of this study was simple: Review medical records to see how chiropractors actually diagnose and treat pediatric patients with orthopedic pathology. After all, chiropractors claim they are experts in musculoskeletal conditions.
Medical records of patients under age 19 presenting at the Pediatric Bone and Joint Institute at Penn State over a 4.5-year period were reviewed for use of chiropractic services for orthopedic pathology, resulting in 23 cases with an average patient age of 12 years, with the youngest being 21 months old. Twelve of the 23 patients went to a chiropractor first, but only five were referred to a pediatric orthopedic surgeon by the chiropractor. The remaining 18 were referred by a pediatrician or another orthopedic physician. Why so few patients who had seen a chiropractor were discovered in this search is unclear, although we do know that patients, or their parents, often do not reveal CAM use to physicians.
The results were reported recently in the Journal of Surgical Orthopedic Advances as well as published in Pediatrics as a Meeting Abstract. (Because the authors understandably use medical terms, I’ve added explanations and links from the American Academy of Orthopedic Surgeons, the Pediatric Orthopedic Society of North America, and a medical dictionary.)
Adverse outcomes were documented when one or more of the following issues were encountered: misdiagnosis, delay to diagnosis or treatment, and contraindication to manipulative therapy. Contraindications were determined on the basis of the current orthopaedic literature and consisted of hip manipulation in children with DDH [developmental dysplasia of the hip, in which the hip socket is shallow, meaning the ball of the thighbone cannot firmly fit into the socket], Perthes disease [blood supply to the rounded head of the thighbone is disrupted, causing bone cell death], and SCFE [slipped capital femoral epiphysis; for reasons that are not well understood, the ball at the head of the thighbone, slips off the neck of the bone in a backwards direction], as well as displacement of a proximal phalanx [finger bone] fracture. Misdiagnosis was recorded in four cases, with delay to diagnosis or delay to treatment observed in an additional seven cases. Of the 23 patients studied, 11 cases (48%) were found to have a to least one adverse outcome.
In addition to adverse outcomes, the authors discovered that, despite the lack of evidence of safety and efficacy of manipulative therapy for pediatric patients, 19 received just that, some seeing the chiropractor for as many as one to two visits per month. This included manipulation of the spine, hip, wrist, and shoulder for a chiropractic diagnosis (some of which, again, were misdiagnoses) of developmental dysplasia of the hip, leg length discrepancy (whether real or the imaginary discrepancies found by chiropractors, we don’t know in all cases), scoliosis, hip pain, hip dislocation, knee pain, muscular dystrophy, cerebral palsy (for three years in one case!), and wrist deformity. Other treatments included kinesiotaping, electrical stimulation, and acupuncture.
The many ways chiropractic pediatrics can go wrong
With that overview in mind, let’s look more closely at some specific cases.
Five patients with scoliosis received spinal manipulation and none reported improvement. As noted by the authors, although evidence is lacking, there is “continued intention among chiropractors to treat idiopathic scoliosis with manipulation.”
In one of these cases, an 18-year-old’s long-standing back deformity had been managed by a chiropractor since age two. The chiropractor recommended that he avoid surgery until he reached skeletal maturity, but he was finally referred to an orthopedic surgeon when his back pain worsened and he had difficulty in breathing on exertion. Orthopedic exam revealed significant congenital scoliosis, which is almost universally treated with surgery at an early age. He ended up having a two-stage T2 to L3 spinal fusion.
As the authors note, from a medical standpoint, manual therapy is often contraindicated in pediatric hip conditions. Yet, in reviewing the chiropractic literature, including chiropractic pediatric textbooks and American Chiropractic Association and International Chiropractic Association publications, the authors found that manipulation has not even been investigated as a therapy for hip conditions, nor were hip conditions uniformly identified as contraindications to manipulation. But to chiropractors, hip manipulation of children with symptoms of pediatric hip conditions is just what the doctor ordered.
In all, there were five cases where a direct contraindication to manipulation was present and, of these, subsequent orthopedic treatment in four cases required stabilization techniques such as casting and pinning. All five were also subject to misdiagnosis, delay to diagnosis, or delay to treatment.
One 4-year-old girl had a limp favoring her left leg, worsening over two years, which raised the possibility of a hip condition. Yet, she was treated by her chiropractor with manipulation of the hip, pelvis, spine, and gluteal muscles in seven visits over three months, but no x-rays were taken. The chiropractor then incorrectly diagnosed her with developmental dysplasia of the hip (DDH) and leg length discrepancy and referred her to an orthopedic surgeon. Her orthopedic diagnosis was avascular necrosis of the left hip (the blood supply to the femoral head is disrupted, bone cells die and the area becomes intensely inflamed and irritated) and a large femoral head consistent with Perthes disease.
In another case, a chiropractor diagnosed a two-year-old girl with leg length discrepancy and treated her with hip manipulation. When she didn’t improve, he referred her to an orthopedic surgeon. An x-ray revealed complete dislocation of the left hip, almost certainly congenital. (That this was not discovered earlier raises the possibility that she had never been seen by a pediatrician or family doctor.) She was diagnosed with DDH and underwent surgery. Despite the delayed diagnosis caused by her chiropractor and inappropriate treatment with manipulation, her parents continued to take her to a chiropractor for what she described as her left hip “popping,” which her chiropractor “popped” back into place, although further x-rays showed no evidence of dislocation.
In other cases:
    • A 14-year-old boy with dwarfism and bowed legs received hip and spinal manipulation for hip and knee pain, one to two times a month, from his chiropractor. On referral to an orthopedic surgeon, he was diagnosed with a defect of the growth plate in the legs which required surgery to straighten them.
    • A 16-year-old ballet dancer with back pain was treated with spinal manipulation, massage and laser therapy; on referral to an orthopedic surgeon she was diagnosed with scoliosis.
    • An 11-year-old runner with hip pain was treated with hip manipulation by his chiropractor; he was actually suffering from chondrolysis of the hip (rapid progressive damage to the articular cartilage of the hip) and early Perthes disease.
    • After a fall, an 8-year-old’s putative finger dislocation was supposedly put back into place by his chiropractor; it was actually a fracture, worsened by the chiropractor’s inappropriate treatment, and treated with six weeks of taping by an orthopedic surgeon.
    • An 11-year-old cheerleader’s “right hip dislocation” was treated with hip manipulation (3 visits in one week); she was subsequently diagnosed by the orthopedic surgeon with leg length discrepancy.
    • A 16-year-old ballet dancer’s low back pain was treated by her chiropractor with spinal manipulation; the orthopedic surgeon’s diagnosis was spondylolysis, a crack or stress fracture of the vertebrae.
    • A 15-year-old with cerebral palsy was treated with spine and hip manipulation; an orthopedic surgeon diagnosed left hip dysplasia and chronic left hip subluxation (the real kind, a partial dislocation, not the mythical chiropractic subluxation). Surgery is normally necessary and was offered.
    • A 14-year-old was treated with hip manipulation for hip pain; his orthopedic surgeon diagnosed SCFE, which required surgical pinning of the left hip. According to the American Academy of Orthopedic Surgeons it is important to diagnose SCFE as quickly as possible because, without early detection and treatment, SCFE can lead to serious complications like painful arthritis of the hip joint.
In only one of the 23 cases did the chiropractor directly refer the patient to her primary care physician with a correct diagnosis (a dislocated right hip) without first instituting a course of inappropriate joint manipulation, as happened in most cases, or some other unproven treatment, like acupuncture.
Yet, despite the fact that:
chiropractic intervention for the conditions encountered in this case series . . . was either insufficiently studied, contraindicated, or found to be of no measurable benefit,
and the authors discovered
missed or delayed diagnosis [and] more invasive surgery needed because of a delay to treatment,
nine patients (or, more likely, their parents) opted to continue chiropractic management after a diagnosis was made by their orthopedic surgeon and their perception toward chiropractic was positive in every case.
In other words, some patients will continue choosing chiropractic care even in the face of its ineffectiveness and adverse outcomes.
States should act to protect children
We’ve discussed chiropractors’ incompetent management of pediatric cases (not to mention anti-vaccination ideology) many times here on SBM. We’ve also covered their lack of education and training in pediatrics, to the point that some of them have never even encountered a pediatric patient before they go into practice. In fact, although the response rate was small, in surveys chiropractors themselves have owned up to the fact that, although they see pediatric patients for a variety of conditions, their pediatric training is lacking. Their post-graduate courses in pediatrics, another topic we’ve covered on SBM, are wholly inadequate to remedy these deficiencies. This is on top of the fact that many chiropractors who self-identify as practicing “pediatric chiropractic” are of the straight variety, believing that the mythical chiropractic subluxation must be “adjusted” in everyone from neonates on, at the risk of poor health.
Given that chiropractors will continue putting young patients in harm’s way, the only reasonable solution is that they be prohibited from seeing infants and children until they can satisfactorily demonstrate they can competently diagnose and treat them, a fact that has been, to date, simply presumed, without proof, by the state legislatures who grant them that authority.

Subluxation Correction: A Chiropractic Treatment for Babies
Sam Homola on February 26, 2016
Link
My article “Pediatric Chiropractic Care: The Subluxation Question and Referral Risk” was published in the 2016 February issue of the journal Bioethics. The abstract summarizes the message of the article:
Chiropractors commonly treat children for a variety of ailments by manipulating the spine to correct a “vertebral subluxation” or a “vertebral subluxation complex” alleged to be a cause of disease. Such treatment might begin soon after a child is born. Both major American chiropractic associations─the International Chiropractic Association and the American Chiropractic Association─support chiropractic care for children, care that includes subluxation correction as a treatment or preventive measure. I do not know of any credible evidence to support chiropractic subluxation theory. Any attempt to manipulate the immature, cartilaginous spine of a neonate or a small child to correct a putative chiropractic subluxation should be regarded as dangerous and unnecessary. Referral of a child to a chiropractor for such treatment should not be considered lest a bad outcome harms the child or leads to a charge of negligence or malpractice.1
The first objection to my article came in a January 30 Facebook posting by Milehighchiro, a subluxation-based group: 
Subluxation Denier Sam Homola DC just had a paper published in the journal Bioethics where he contends that children should not undergo chiropractic care and that subluxations do not exist.
Thankfully, because of the work of the ICPA [International Chiropractic Pediatric Association] there is a rich literature base supporting chiropractic care for children that can be used to respond to this garbage…. If we lose the ability to adjust people of all ages because subluxations in and of themselves are detriment to health. Period. We completely lose our profession.
Babies and subluxation-based chiropractors
Evidence-based chiropractors who do not subscribe to the vitalistic dogma of chiropractic subluxation theory often attempt to defend the image of the chiropractic profession by saying that subluxation-based chiropractors are in the minority. The response of chiropractors to criticism of subluxation-based chiropractic care, however, and a review of chiropractic web sites indicate that a significant number of chiropractors still cling to the belief that a vertebral subluxation or a “joint dysfunction” can affect general health (Clay Jones has also previously discussed chiropractic and subluxation-based treatments of pediatric issues like ear infections, shaken baby syndrome, and colic here on Science-Based Medicine).
Endorsing subluxation theory, the International Chiropractic Pediatric Association offers a Diplomate in Clinical Chiropractic Pediatrics to chiropractors who complete 360+ hours of weekend classroom study.2 Such didactic training cannot possibly qualify chiropractors to diagnose and treat pediatric health problems, nor does it justify manipulating the immature spine of an infant. Most, if not all, subluxation-based chiropractors treat pediatric ailments by manipulating the spine to correct subluxations, whether they are certified in chiropractic pediatrics or not.
The web site of the International Chiropractic Association’s Council on Chiropractic Pediatrics provides links to chiropractic journal abstracts that support subluxation-based chiropractic treatment for a great variety of a childhood ailments, such as otitis media, asthma, allergies, infantile colic, and enuresis.3 A 2015 survey of North American chiropractic students revealed that the majority of students would like to see an emphasis on correction of vertebral subluxations.4 Such commonly-accessed sites as YouTube are replete with disturbing videos of chiropractors manipulating the spine of a baby to correct alleged subluxations, either as a preventive measure or as a treatment for an aliment of some sort.
Subluxation-based chiropractors maintain that chiropractic research supports pediatric chiropractic spinal manipulation for children of all ages.
Is chiropractic research credible?
Health-care professionals outside of chiropractic generally think of the chiropractic vertebral subluxation theory as a pseudoscientific fabrication. There is no credible evidence that a vertebral subluxation, real or putative, can affect general health or that such subluxations even exist.5 Articles in chiropractic journals, however, offer “proof” that subluxation correction can play a role in the treatment and prevention of disease. I am not aware of any satisfactory evidence that supports such nonfalsifiable claims, many of which are based on anecdotal case reports.
When British author Simon Singh stated in an April 19, 2008, issue of the Guardian that the British Chiropractic Association’s (BCA) claims that chiropractors can help treat children with “colic, sleeping and feeding problems, frequent ear infections, asthma and prolonged crying” were bogus, he was sued for libel by the BCA. The BCA was unable to present adequate scientific evidence to support chiropractic treatment for children. Nineteen citations presented by the BCA as scientific evidence supporting chiropractic treatment for children were analyzed in a 2009 article in the British Medical Journal and found to be deficient in proof that chiropractic is an effective treatment for children.6 The suit was withdrawn in 2010 when the court ruled that Singh’s comments were legally permissible as “fair comment.”7
Research findings by subluxation-based chiropractors who describe a mysterious and undetectable “vertebral subluxation complex” alleged to be a cause of disease have little credibility and do not have enough testable substance to be replicated by properly controlled studies. (Without factual support, chiropractic subluxation theory is considered to be more a belief than a testable hypothesis.) The bias of chiropractic researchers who assume that the vertebral subluxation theory is valid does not lend to production of a scientifically accurate study. For this reason, research published by subluxation-based chiropractors is generally ignored by mainstream health-care professionals.
Guided by what appears to be slanted research designed to support rather than question subluxation theory, subluxation-based pediatric chiropractors offer unproven care as an alternative to care provided by board-certified pediatricians, unchallenged by the chiropractic establishment. According to the American Chiropractic Association’s ACA Council on Chiropractic Pediatrics, “Our goals are to support our members who take care of children in their chiropractic practices, and to promote the acceptance and advancement of pediatric chiropractic care.”8
Pediatric chiropractors versus pediatricians
It is, of course, ludicrous to claim that an ICPA-certified “pediatric chiropractic physician” can compete with a medically-trained, board-certified pediatrician who spends thousands of hours in classrooms and hospitals preparing to provide primary care for children. Pediatric medicine has been divided into 19 subspecialties, requiring additional training in the diagnosis and treatment of health problems that are different from those of an adult. A solo chiropractor, subluxation-based or not, cannot offer any pediatric treatment of value that is not better provided by a pediatrician.
Spinal manipulation dangers

Spinal manipulation or subluxation correction has not been demonstrated to be an effective treatment for any pediatric ailment, and there is reason to believe that manipulating the immature spine of a child might result in occult injury or fracture of synchondrosial ossification centers.9 Such injuries could conceivably result in the development of a pre-adolescent spinal deformity such as scoliosis or Scheuermann’s kyphosis, speculations that are certainly worth considering. The possibility of epiphyseal injury coupled with the absence of any known benefit is reason enough to advise against the use of spinal manipulation in the pediatric (preadolescent) population.
A real subluxation (a partial dislocation), which sometimes occurs in the fragile upper cervical spine of a baby or an infant, should be treated by an orthopedic specialist, not by a chiropractor. The anatomy of the developing cervical spine of a small child predisposes the child to injury that can be caused by manipulation as well as by accidental trauma.
My impression from reading the literature is that most spinal injuries in children under 8 years of age occur in the cervical spine, most often involving the top two cervical vertebrae.9 Chiropractors who treat babies often manipulate a baby’s atlas, the uppermost vertebra, which they believe is commonly subluxated by the birthing process.
Manipulating imaginary subluxations
When I was in chiropractic school, it became apparent to me that the asymptomatic vertebral subluxations I recorded during patient exams were simply harmless structural deviations such as bony asymmetry. An orthopedic subluxation, which causes musculoskeletal symptoms, is not the same as a chiropractic subluxation, which is defined as a “health concern” by the National Board of Chiropractic Examiners in the United States:
The specific focus of chiropractic practice is known as the chiropractic subluxation or joint dysfunction. A subluxation is a health concern that manifests in the skeletal joints, and, through complex anatomical and physiological relationships, affects the nervous system and may lead to reduced function, disability, or illness. (Practice Analysis of Chiropractic 2015)10
When I see a chiropractor palpate the fat-padded, cartilaginous spine of a baby and then proceed to adjust a subluxation, I suspect that the chiropractor is pretending to have found a subluxation and then pretends to manipulate the spine. If the chiropractor is convinced that a subluxation has been found in the baby’s spine, use of a thrust-type manipulative technique dictated by subluxation theory may result in injury that is not detectable, such as a fracture in a radiolucent ossification center. Pediatric chiropractors who simply use finger-tip pressure or a spring-loaded stylus in a misguided attempt to tap a vertebra into alignment may not injure the baby, but such pretentious care can certainly delay appropriate treatment by misinforming the parents of the child.
Ethical considerations
Despite lack of scientific support for subluxation theory, the chiropractic profession continues to endorse subluxation correction as a valid method of treating a variety of childhood ailments. According to the National Board of Chiropractic Examiners, “Chiropractic management of childhood disorders primarily consists of adjusting concomitant spinal subluxations and providing specific nutritional advice and/or support and other palliative measures.” (Practice Analysis of Chiropractic, 2015)10
It is apparent that chiropractic treatment of children, including babies, is a common practice based on the well-entrenched, scientifically indefensible chiropractic subluxation theory. The International Chiropractic Association’s Council on Chiropractic Pediatrics advises that “Chiropractic care can never start too early.”11
It does not appear that chiropractic care for children is opposed by legislation or by chiropractic academia. For this reason, science-based health-care professionals, including chiropractors, have a moral and ethical responsibility to question the practice of chiropractors who manipulate the spine of a baby or a preadolescent child for any reason, especially those chiropractors who advocate subluxation correction as method of treating and preventing childhood ailments.
Note: Unreferenced statements represent my own views and opinions. While I advise against manipulating the spine of a neonate or a preadolescent child, I have no problem with appropriate use of spinal manipulation as an option in the treatment of uncomplicated mechanical-type back pain in adolescents and adults.
References
     1.  Homola S. “Pediatric Care: The Subluxation Question and Referral Risk.” Bioethics. 2016;30(2):pp63-68.
     2.  ICA Council. Diplomate in Chiropractic Pediatrics. [Accessed 23 February 2016].
     3.  ICA Pediatrics. Journal Abstracts. [Accessed 23 February 2016].
     4.  Gliedt JA, Hawk C, Anderson M, Ahmad K, Bunn D, Cambron J, et al. “Chiropractic identity, role and future: a survey of North American chiropractic students.” Chiropr Man Therap. 2015;23.4. [Accessed 23 February 2016].
     5.  Mirtz TA, Morgan L, Wyatt LH, Greene L. “An epidemiological examination of the subluxation construct using Hill’s criteria of causation.” Chiropr Man Therap. 2009; 17:13. [Accessed 23 February 2016].
     6.  Ernst E. “Chiropractic for paediatric conditions: substantial evidence?” BMJ. 2009;339:b2766 .
     7.  BCA v. Singh. Wikipedia. [Accessed 19 February 2016].
     8.  ACA Council on Chiropractic Pediatrics. [Accessed 23 February 2016].
     9.  O’Neal ML. “The pediatric spine: Anatomical and dynamic considerations preceding manipulation.” Compr Ther. 2003;29(2):124-129.
     10.  Christensen MG, Hyland JK, Goertz CM, Kollasch MW, Shotts BL, Blumlein NL, et al. Practice Analysis of Chiropractic 2015. Greeley, CO; National Board of Chiropractic Examiners. January 2015. pp. 103, 106.
        ◦ ICA Council on Chiropractic Pediatrics. [Accessed 23 February 2016].

Chiropractor Breaks Baby’s Neck – A Risk vs Benefit Analysis
Steven Novella on October 2, 2013
Link

It is unfortunately that individual dramatic cases are often required to garner public and regulatory attention toward a clear problem. The Australian press is reporting:
Melbourne paediatrician Chris Pappas cared for a four-month-old baby last year after one of her vertebrae was fractured during a chiropractic treatment for torticollis – an abnormal neck position that is usually harmless. He said the infant was lucky to make a full recovery.
Medicine is a game of risk vs benefit – everything we do, or don’t do, should be evaluated on the potential benefit vs the potential risk, using the best available evidence and scientific rationale. This case is important, not because it is a case of harm, which can happen with any intervention, but because it highlights the risk vs benefit question. Are there any indications for chiropractic care of children, for neck manipulation at any age, and what are the risks?
For an overview of chiropractic see my prior summaries here and here. Overall the evidence suggests some benefit for manipulative therapy for acute uncomplicated lower back strain, but probably no better than physical therapy or even minimal intervention. The risks of chiropractic are not sufficiently studied, and other indications have not been established by adequate evidence.
Chiropractic for children
The chiropractic profession generally has been aggressive in expanding its scope of practice, including treating children and infants, despite a lack of evidence or even plausible scientific rationale. The chiropractic treatment of childhood disorders was the focus of the British Chiropractic Association’s (BCA) libel suit against Simon Singh. During that suit the BCA put out a statement attempting to justify the chiropractic treatment of childhood illness, but the result merely showcased the lack of evidence, and their own poor standards of science.
The BCA was claiming evidence for the chiropractic treatment of asthma, colic, otitis media, and nocturnal enuresis (bedwetting). In each case the evidence actually showed a lack of effectiveness for these indications.
The current case involved the treatment of infantile torticollis, which is a dystonic disorder, an involuntary contraction of a muscle, in the case of torticollis involving the neck. This is generally a benign disorder. A review of 624 cases found that 97% resolved with conservative management, including stretching and active stimulation, most in less than 6 months. The other 3% had an underlying anatomical defect and required surgery.
Another prospective study of 821 patients treated with manual stretching found:
subsequent surgical treatment was required by 8% (thirty-four) of the 452 patients in the sternomastoid tumor group compared with 3% (eight) of the 276 patients in the muscular torticollis group and 0% (none) of the ninety-three patients in the postural torticollis group.
There does not seem to be a role or need for chiropractic neck manipulation for this condition.
I could only find two references in PubMed presenting evidence for chiropractic manipulation of torticollis, both single case reports, one in a 6-year old, and one in a 7-month old infant. That’s it – two cases. In the case of the 7-month old, the intervention included:
chiropractic manipulation, trigger point therapy, specific stretches, pillow positioning and exercises.
We already know that stretching works, so there is no reason to conclude that the chiropractic manipulation added anything to the patient’s recovery in this case.
I also found one case report from 1992 of quadraplegia in an infant following spinal manipulation for torticollis. The child had a spinal tumor, and the manipulation caused it to bleed, resulting in the damage. There is also another report of a spinal astrocytoma presenting as torticollis. The authors conclude that such tumors should be ruled out in infantile torticollis.
Risk vs benefit
As with chiropractic care in general, there is insufficient evidence to make firm statements about the risk vs benefit of chiropractic intervention in children for any indication, including torticollis. This is due, in my opinion, to a cultural and historical lack of science-based practice within the profession of chiropractic. This represents a failure of the entire profession that is in dire need of correction.
In the case of infantile torticollis, this is a benign condition in most patients, who quickly recover with conservative and safe management. The single case report discussed above is worthless as scientific evidence because it is anecdotal, and usual care was combined with manipulation, and the patient was overwhelmingly likely to recover from the usual care alone.
Given a benign condition with an established safe and effective treatment, the standard of care dictates that any new intervention should at least demonstrate equivalency to the established therapy. If the new therapy is more expensive or has higher risk than the established therapy, it should demonstrate sufficient superiority to justify the added risk or expense.
Chiropractors have not established equivalency let alone superiority for manipulation in infantile torticollis, and therefore there is no justification for treatment.
In a risk vs benefit analysis, therefore, any incremental risk is not justified. Chiropractors, however, are not in the habit of reporting or systematically studying the risks of their interventions, so we often have to rely upon case reports from non-chiropractors who receive the results of their interventions. With regard to infantile torticollis we have the 1992 report of quadriplegia, and now we have an additional report of a fractured cervical spine.
Chiropractic response
The response of the chiropractic profession to these cases is unsatisfactory, to say the least. Dr. Pappas, the pediatrician who treated the infant with the broken neck, reported the case to the health authorities in Australia. They turned the case over to the chiropractic board.
That is the first problem – chiropractors are in the position of self-regulating. But if the profession itself has a problem with science and evidence, self-regulation will not provide the solution. Predictably, the chiropractic board closed the case with the judgement that the chiropractor can continue practicing if he obtains further education in pediatric chiropractic care.
That is a paltry slap on the wrist. The decision also implies endorsement of pediatric chiropractic, which has never been established as a legitimate practice. Training is irrelevant when you don’t have a science-based practice in the first place.
The response of the Chiropractic Association of Australia was outrage – not that one of their members committed malpractice, but at the suggestion that it was chiropractic manipulation that caused the child’s neck fracture.
The CAA is outraged that rather than clearing the chiropractor’s name, as appropriate, the newspapers have smeared the chiropractor and the profession with such an allegation
It seems clear from their response that they are more concerned with the reputation of chiropractors than the safety of their patients. Perhaps they will try the same gambit as the BCA and put out a statement reviewing the scientific evidence for the chiropractic treatment of infantile torticollis, hoping that no one actually reads the evidence and is simply impressed by the list of references.
Conclusion: Chiropractors should not adjust babies
The chiropractic profession continues to have a serious problem of being insufficiently based upon science and evidence (to put it mildly). There are a great deal of practices that occur under the banner of “chiropractic” from blatant pseudoscience, such as energy medicine, to somewhat plausible musculoskeletal management. In the latter case chiropractors are little more than physical therapists.
Chiropractors continue to use and promote chiropractic treatment for a long list of indications that are not supported by basic scientific plausibility or clinical evidence. They cannot justify their interventions on an evidence-based risk vs benefit assessment.
Rather, they seem to employ a strategy of not reporting or studying the risks of their interventions, then citing the lack of evidence for risk as evidence that their treatments are safe. Lack of evidence is not sufficient in the practice of medicine, however.
What evidence we do have suggests that there is not a single legitimate indication for chiropractic manipulation of children or infants, which is sufficient to condemn the practice. There is also evidence of potential harm, and even if rare, any harm resulting from a worthless intervention results in an unfavorable risk vs benefit.

A 2-Month-Old Infant Seriously Injured by Chiropractic Neck Adjustment
A young infant was severely injured by unnecessary chiropractic neck adjustments for a benign condition.
Clay Jones on November 12, 2021
Link

Hold on to your butts.
– Ray Arnold, Chief-Engineer at Jurassic Park
As regular readers will know, I have written extensively on the absurdities of pediatric chiropractic. In particular, I have focused on newborn and infant chiropractic. One aspect of this practice that is almost a defining feature, despite a few infuriating examples to the contrary, such as the “crack heard round the world” I discussed back in 2016, is that chiropractic management of infants tends to be almost comically gentle. As I frequently say, parents might be fooled by medical misinformation but they will usually bristle at interventions that clearly hurt their babies.
Though all but a few seconds of my recent interview by Inside Edition ended up on the cutting room floor, I even reassured the producers that I have never been particularly worried about direct injury to babies from chiropractors, though I did say it was possible. I’ve always been much more concerned about potential indirect harm, such as might occur from delaying appropriate care or from anti-vaccine propaganda. I was wrong to downplay the risk of direct injury.
While still a rare event, after reading a recent case report published by the American Academy of Pediatrics in the September 2021 issue of Pediatrics in Review, the official AAP source for continuing education, I will handle the discussion of risk a bit differently.
“Abnormal Behavior in a 2-Month-Old Boy”
In the report, pediatricians and a radiologist at University of Nebraska’s Children’s Hospital and Medical Center describe the case of a previously healthy 2-month-old who was brought to the emergency department after four days of increased fussiness when awake, less time where he was awake and interactive, and episodes of unusual movements of his arms and legs. The only finding on history was mild torticollis, a common and generally benign problem with turning the head easily from side to side. Torticollis almost always resolves with simple physical therapy that can be performed by caregivers at home. Unfortunately, the family had been bringing him to a chiropractor for treatment that involved neck adjustments.
When examined by the pediatric medical professionals in the emergency department, he was witnessed having a tonic-clonic seizure with stiffening and then rhythmic jerking of his arms and legs and fixed eye deviation to the right. This seizures lasted about 90 seconds before self-resolving. The team appropriately ordered a number of labs, obtained IV access, and initiated treatment for a presumed life-threatening bacterial infection while carefully considering other possible causes of infant seizures, such as abusive head trauma, electrolyte abnormalities, and stroke.
Imaging of the child’s brain was swiftly obtained, which revealed large areas of infarction involving the posterior parietal, posterior temporal, and occipital lobes of both cerebral hemispheres that consistent with ischemic stroke. Something had happened which appeared to have compromised bilateral posterior cerebral arterial blood flow to those regions of the brain. As seen on this child’s CT scan, without enough oxygen to meet metabolic demand the involved brain tissue quickly begins to die.
The finding of infarct was also seen on a follow-up MRI of the brain. A CT angiogram of the neck was obtained, which involves the injection of a special dye that allows mapping of the blood vessels, which demonstrated absent flow in the left vertebral artery. Finally an MRA (MRI + angiogram) confirmed poor blood flow through the posterior cerebral arteries on both sides of the brain. A diagnosis of vertebral artery dissection was confirmed.
The child was started on anti-seizure medication and aspirin, and he was eventually discharged home with close neurology follow-up. At 6 months of age, he continued to have an abnormal EEG but no further clinical seizure activity was reported. At 9 months of age, he was found to have some difficulty with eye tracking but had an otherwise normal exam with no developmental concerns. But because of the widespread nature of his brain injury, it is highly likely that developmental difficulties will become apparent as he ages and more is expected from him. Only time will tell what his ultimate outcome will be.
Conclusion: Risk from infant chiropractic always outweighs potential benefit
        ◦ Vertebral artery dissection, where the inner lining of a vital blood vessel is torn and then predisposed to the development of a blood clot that obstructs flow to the brain, is rare in any population. It is extremely rare in infants and it does not just happen in this population without some kind of trauma or underlying disorder. The child in this case report was severely injured by an unproven and implausible chiropractic intervention for a condition that has a proven safe and effective medical treatment. Add this report to the large and growing pile of evidence supporting calls to remove the right of chiropractors to treat young children.

The Crack Heard Round the World
Clay Jones on May 6, 2016
Link

In January, Melbourne chiropractor Ian Rossborough uploaded a video to YouTube of himself treating a 4-day-old premature infant. The video, one of many that can be found on his “Chiropractic Excellence” channel, is for educational purposes only, intended to teach the world about the miraculous benefits of chiropractic care for a wide variety of conditions. Although the cynical among us may proclaim that his videos are just more examples of chiropractic practice building shenanigans, Rossborough claims that he simply wants to “enable natural healthy living, without resorting to drugs or surgery.”
Australian physicians respond
Well, there are apparently a lot of angry and cynical Australians, particularly journalists and physicians. In late April, the video, which features Rossborough manipulating the newborn’s thoracic spine hard enough to cause a loud cracking sound and a cry of pain went viral after it was featured in a story on Australian Broadcasting Corporation Radio National. Rossborough, and the treatment of children by chiropractors, has since come under intense scrutiny.
According to the Australian press, “doctors have declared war on chiropractors” in response to the realization that newborns and young infants are undergoing unnecessary spinal manipulation for problems such as colic, acid reflux, and excessive crying as well as for nebulous benefits like boosting the immune system and improved growth and development. The Royal Australian College of General Practitioners, the largest medical college in Australia with a membership of over 30,000 rural and urban primary care physicians, has even requested that members refrain from referring patients to chiropractors. They want the federal government and private insurers to stop paying for nonsense such as infant chiropractic.
Frank Jones MD, president of the RACGP, has made the media rounds, describing infant and toddler adjustments as “seemingly almost cruel” and lacking any supporting evidence. He has also called for the Chiropractic Board of Australia to shape up in order to have any chance of being accepted as a legitimate scientific discipline. Jones thinks that chiropractors like Rossborough and his ilk don’t know what they are doing and are putting patients at risk. He reminds the public that a physician’s job is to advocate for patients and to try to reduce exposure to practices where the risk far exceeds any potential benefit. I like this guy.
History repeats itself
There are two interesting historical tidbits that are worth mentioning. Back in September of 2013, infant chiropractic in Australia was front and center after Melbourne pediatrician Chris Pappas reported a concerning case to the Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency (AHPRA), who handed the case over to the Chiropractic Board of Australia. Dr. Pappas had personally cared for a 4-month-old infant whose neck was allegedly broken by a chiropractor attempting to treat torticollis. Steven Novella wrote about the case at the time and, as usual, provided an excellent risk versus benefit analysis.
At the time, the President of the Australian Medical Association spoke out, calling for the chiropractic board to “either produce evidence supporting chiropractic treatments for children or rule out pediatric care.” He stressed, and nothing has changed since, that there is no available evidence to suggest that spinal manipulation helps infants in any way. As Steve discussed in his post, the initial response from chiropractic leadership was an attempt at damage control. They were simply beside themselves that a chiropractor’s good name was being sullied.
The plot thickened after Steve’s post, with reports that the chiropractor had been cleared by an investigation. The president of the Chiropractor’s Association of Australia claimed that the child had been found to have a congenital abnormality that only mimicked a “hangman’s fracture” of the second cervical vertebra. Dr. Pappas stood by his report. I like this guy too.
Soon after, doubts about the claims being made by the CAA were raised when the investigation’s report was leaked. There was evidence of a fracture as well as a congenital abnormality. And although it is true that certainty of a causal relationship is hard to prove, it strains credulity to hand wave the chiropractor’s role in injuring the child. The truly despicable aspect of this is the implication from the chiropractic community that the family must have caused the fracture themselves.
The chiropractic board’s toothless gesture
The second interesting historical tidbit is much more recent, occurring just one month prior to the Rossborough video going viral. In March of this year, the Chiropractic Board of Australia issued a statement on advertising that includes the following guffaw-inducing introduction:
The Board is very concerned about any chiropractors with advertising (including websites) that may not meet the required standards despite repeated guidance being provided by the Board.
In order to provide further clarity to both practitioners and the public, the Board provides the following clear advice on advertising matters.
So in an attempt to reign in blatantly false marketing by chiropractors, the board “strongly encourages practitioners to review their advertising and ensure it complies with the requirements of the National Law or they risk prosecution and/or disciplinary action.” Their response to the chiropractic community’s utter disregard for prior requests to stop lying to patients or their caregivers is to issue another request. As if anyone is listening, they reveal exactly what isn’t allowed:
Claims suggesting that manual therapy for spinal problems can assist with general wellness and/or benefit a variety of pediatric syndromes and organic conditions are not supported by satisfactory evidence. This includes claims relating to developmental and behavioral disorders, ADHD, autistic spectrum disorders, asthma, infantile colic, bedwetting, ear infections and digestive problems.
The National Law mentioned above specifies that advertising of health services that is “false, misleading or deceptive or is likely to be so” is prohibited. Testimonials aren’t allowed. Neither is advertising that “creates an unreasonable expectation of beneficial treatment, and/or encourages the indiscriminate or unnecessary use of health services.” Violations are a criminal offence punishable by fines of thousands of dollars per offence.Despite rampant false advertising, the Rossborough video being just one of countless examples easily encountered online, nobody at the AHPRA is enforcing this law. Why? As we saw with the 2013 case, concerns are simply passed along to the chiropractic board. They might talk the talk, but their own president recently refused to condemn advertising in a Chiropractic Association of Australia’s newsletter for treating colic, fussiness, and tongue-tie.
More concern from experts and politicians in Australia
Adding to the response from the RACGP are concerns from the AMA Victoria as well as the Victorian Department of Health and Human Services. AMA Victoria’s president, Dr. Tony Bartone, pointed out that no evidence supports spinal manipulation for treating infant colic and that babies might be injured by chiropractic care. The Health Minister herself has written to the chiropractic board and AHPRA “demanding they take tougher action.” She also raised concerns about chiropractors who “pedal anti-vaccination myths outside their scope of practice.”
Rossborough responds
The disgraced chiropractor at the heart of this issue has not backed down. Soon after the backlash began he uploaded another video to YouTube in an attempt to respond to concerns voiced by the medical community and disgusted public. He also appeared live on Studio 10 in what can only be described as a painfully awkward defense of his methods.
His excuses actually make for excellent examples of the kind of thinking that we encounter from proponents of pseudoscience in medicine. They are full of logical missteps, false assumptions, and blatant rationalizations. I’ll discuss a few examples here but will be going into greater detail in my upcoming talk at NECSS next week.
1. “The reason why we adjust the babies is because the parents bring them to us…They come to us in desperation.”
I’ve been there both as a pediatrician and as a parent with an extremely fussy infant. There were weeks of what seemed like non-stop crying and many sleepless nights for my wife and I with our first child. And I’ve cared for many children whose parents were haggard with exhaustion and stress. I can understand how some parents feel desperate. But desperation is not an excuse to give false promises and charge money for taking advantage of the self-limited nature of infant colic.
2. “The birth process can be very traumatic for many babies so it is logical to check a newborn child to ensure their spine is functioning properly…”
Birth can be a traumatic process. Just today I diagnosed a broken clavicle in a 3-day-old infant. Babies can suffer bruised and swollen heads, broken bones, and even injured spinal nerves during difficult deliveries. This reality in no way supports the benefit of a chiropractic evaluation.
The kind of trauma they are talking about is the chiropractic subluxation, and it does not exist. There is no subtle birth trauma resulting in myriad widespread health concerns that can be detected by palpation of the skull and spine. There is no birth trauma that can be corrected by spinal manipulations.
3. “We do NOT twist, rotate, manipulate or randomly crack the spine.”
Except when you do. The video linked to at the onset of this post, several others by Rossborough, and countless others from other chiropractors reveal twisting, rotating, manipulation AND cracking. And it is random. Just because these practitioners have convinced themselves that they feel specific areas of decreased joint movement, increased heat, paraspinal edema, or unbalanced energy doesn’t mean it exists.
4. “There is a divide between some parts of the medical profession and chiropractic and I think it’s largely based on misunderstanding.”
No, it’s largely based on an understanding of human anatomy and physiology, and of infant behavior, and the many ways that we can fool ourselves into believing that a useless intervention works.
5. “We don’t treat colic as such. It’s not like in medicine where a symptom plus a symptom equals colic and then you get a medication for colic. There is no colic bone or part of the spine associated with colic.”
Rossborough is simply spouting classic “straight” chiropractic rhetoric. They say that they don’t treat specific illness or symptoms, they simply remove interference that prevents the body from healing. In the days of Daniel David Palmer, this vitalistic healing power was known as the Innate. It came down from God and coursed through the body to keep us healthy. With this in mind, it shouldn’t come as a surprise that Palmer and his son B.J. once considered making chiropractic into a religion.
These days there are still believers in the Innate, but most chiropractors simply give credit to the nervous system. The claims they make are equally outrageous however. But if you watch the video that started this whole mess, Rossborough clearly tells the parents that he is treating their child’s acid reflux disease. He knows what he is going to “find” before he examines the baby’s spine. Oh, and the medical treatment for colic is reassurance and counseling on methods to calm a fussy infant and to help deal with the stress associated with frequent crying spells.
What really happened in the Rossborough video?
The funny thing is, the child in the video doesn’t have acid reflux or colic. Neither of those are conditions we diagnose in 4-day-old infant. The kid was hungry.
What the parents describe, and taking into account the mild prematurity of the infant, is consistent with a hungry, cluster-feeding baby whose mother’s milk hadn’t come in yet. The reason the child was less fussy one week later was because by that time it had. She didn’t need chiropractic, she needed a weight check and an evaluation of her obvious jaundice. Her parents needed reassurance and breastfeeding support. They all just needed a good primary care doctor.
Conclusion: It’s bad down-under, is it worse up-over?
The Australian medical community, and even some high ranking government officials, are going on the offensive against blatant quackery thanks to a Melbourne chiropractor’s particularly unsettling marketing video. But it seems a bit like deja vu as similar concerns were raised two years ago when a young infant was likely severely injured by unnecessary manipulation of the neck. And while I’m happy that the Australian medical community is once again focusing on the most egregious example of chiropractic nonsense, the treatment of infants, I have to worry if this will actually result in any increased regulation or enforcement of truth in advertising laws already on the books.
Chiropractic in America is no different than in Australia*. There are also plenty of practitioners here who see newborns and children of all ages for a variety of medical conditions that have absolutely nothing to do with the spine. Where is the outrage of doctors and medical organizations here? The notoriously CAM-friendly American Academy of Pediatrics remains silent as usual.
*With the exception that Australian chiropractors perform spinal adjustments in a clockwise fashion rather than counterclockwise, because of the Coriolis force.

The Saga Continues: Australian Chiropractors Banned from Manipulating Infants…Again?
Those silly Australian chiropractors are at it again, what with all their high jinks and shenanigans and what not. This time they have reinstated a ban on treating babies that they had just gotten rid of.
Clay Jones on July 5, 2024
Link

Australia has a chiropractor problem no different than here in the United States. All manner of chiropractic nonsense, including claims of treating infants and toddlers with a range of conditions both real and imagined, has been a reality in the land down under for over a century. There is, however, one very important regulatory difference between our two countries.
Back in 2016, I wrote about Australian chiropractor Ian Rossborough, who at the time was facing harsh criticism after posting a marketing video featuring his aggressive and clearly painful adjustment of a very young infant. He ended up with a temporary suspension of his ability to treat pediatric patients, but that ended sometime in 2018. In 2019, however, a second controversy arose after a different chiropractor promoted his practice using a video demonstrating a pile of pseudoscientific garbage while treating another baby that ticked off the healthcare regulators.
Because of Andrew Arnold’s video, or more accurately because of the public outrage and calls for action by actual medical professionals, the Chiropractic Board of Australia (CBA) issued an interim policy that prohibited spinal manipulation of children under two years of age pending expert review. Again, because I want to be very clear, the CBA fully supported infant chiropractic care, even when it included craniosacral therapy for colic or the use of an “activator” to treat torticollis, they just caved in to pressure from national health authorities. That 2019 policy was updated in November of last year, once more giving chiropractors clearance for treating kids under 2 years, in response to two systematic reviews performed by Cochrane Australia in 2019 and 2022 that they claimed demonstrated the safety and effectiveness of spinal manipulation in this younger age group.
Not so fast.
You will likely not be shocked to learn that the 2019 review by Cochrane Australia, and the 2022 update that did not differ in any substantial way, do not justify claims of safety or effectiveness in the treatment of young children. At best, they cannot be used to show that there are large numbers of children who have been directly harmed by chiropractic adjustments, although this ignores the possibility of indirect harms from delayed care or antimedicine/antivaccine misinformation, for example. In the report, the authors discuss reasons why strong evidence of harm may not have been discovered:
There are two principle reasons why the search did not find strong evidence of harm in Australia. First, it is unlikely that spinal manipulation, as defined with the scope of the review, is a technique that is being routinely applied in Australia to young children or those with an immature spine. Second, skilled chiropractic care requires the practitioner to modify the force applied based on the age and developmental stage of the child. This means that children, particularly very young children, under the care of an Australian chiropractor are not likely to be receiving high impact manipulations.
Nonetheless, it is clear that spinal manipulation in children is not wholly without risk. Any risk associated with care, no matter how uncommon or minor, must be considered in light of any potential or likely benefits. This is particularly important in younger children, especially those under the age of 2 years in whom minor adverse events may be more common.
https://www.safercare.vic.gov.au/sites/default/files/2019-10/20191024-Final%20Chiropractic%20Spinal%20Manipulation.pdf
The two sentences I emphasized are important. I often point out that risk of direct harm, though possible and it has certainly occurred, is very low, though this has nothing to do with how skilled the chiropractor is in their craft. It has everything to do with marketing. Parents are not very likely to appreciate their baby being forcefully adjusted and crying out in pain, which is why the vast majority chiropractors who treat infants use silly devices like the activator and often go to great lengths to explain how their adjustments are equivalent to checking a tomato for ripeness. I discuss this in detail in a previous post.
In regards to the second emphasized sentence, the reviews found no good evidence to support claims of any benefit:
Specifically, the comprehensive review of the literature failed to identify any strong evidence for the effectiveness of spinal manipulation for a variety of conditions for which children are widely offered chiropractic manipulations. These conditions included colic, enuresis, back/neck pain, headache, asthma, otitis media, cerebral palsy, hyperactivity and torticollis.
There was low certainty (weak) evidence that spinal manipulation may be beneficial for modestly reducing crying time in children with colic, or for reducing the number of wet nights in children with enuresis. For both conditions the evidence was also consistent with either no or worsening effects.
For other conditions – headache, asthma, otitis media, cerebral palsy, hyperactivity, and torticollis – there was no evidence that spinal manipulation was effective.
Based on this review of effectiveness, spinal manipulation of children cannot be recommended for:
    • headache
    • asthma
    • otitis media
    • cerebral palsy
    • hyperactivity disorders
    • torticollis
The possible, but unlikely, benefits of spinal manipulation in the management of colic or enuresis should be balanced by the possibility, albeit rare, of minor harm.
https://www.safercare.vic.gov.au/sites/default/files/2019-10/20191024-Final%20Chiropractic%20Spinal%20Manipulation.pdf
It was more than a bit of a stretch to hold up these findings as impetus to return to manipulating infants and toddlers. Apparently the real Australian heath authorities, such as Australian Health Minister Mark Butler, thought so as well. He has also pointed out that the decision was contradicted by the systematic reviews.
In addition to Butler, Victorian Health Minister Mary-Anne Thomas and Australian Medical Association’ Victorian president Dr. Jill Tomlinson have spoken out. And the return to manipulating children under age two was called both “reckless” and “deeply disturbing” by the Chair of child and young person health at the Royal Australian College of General Practitioners. In light of the renewed criticism, the CBA has issued a policy update that reinstated the ban until further consultation with the Health Ministers.
I’m obviously hoping that this will become a permanent ban, and there is chatter regarding this as a potential outcome. I can’t imagine something like that ever happening in the United States, however. We continue to provide no real protection for children when it comes to abject quackery and I just don’t see that changing.
Here is a response to the reinstated ban from some “conservative, traditional” chiropractors that I just don’t have the strength to get into right now. You’ll never guess what they think about the pandemic. Enjoy!

Another Australian Chiropractor is in Hot Water for Manipulating a Newborn
Yet another Australian chiropractor is under fire for treating young infants. Will anything be done about it?
Clay Jones on February 22, 2019
Link

As we speak, an Australian chiropractor named Andrew Arnold is outraging people all over the world after a marketing video of him performing spinal adjustments on a young infant went viral. Healthcare regulators and heads of medical organizations are calling for bans and the chiropractor has agreed to stop treating children as an investigation commences. It’s a whole thing.
If this all seems very familiar, it’s because it has all happened before down to the smallest detail. Back in 2016, Australian Chiropractor Ian Rossborough was under fire for the exact same issue.
Rossborough took all of his videos down, and his personal and practice YouTube sites remain barren, but there is now no official record of his being banned from treating young children or of the requirement for supervision (by another chiropractor) when treating older children. None. He has a clean record without restrictions on the Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency website. In July of last year, however, a fan started a gofundme page for Rossborough with a goal of a $250,000 and let’s just say that they aren’t quite there yet.
In the latest controversy, Arnold is shown doing the exact same shtick that I have seen in hundreds of these marketing videos. It’s actually fairly tame as these things go. Rossborough’s video, which involved the forceful manipulation of a 4-day-old’s spine, complete with a loud crack and an immediate shriek of pain in response, was considerably more stomach churning.
What has people bent out of shape is that Arnold briefly holds the baby upside down by his feet, the rationale of which isn’t made clear in the video. I’ll explain what he’s doing, not that it matters. It’s ridiculous no matter how you slice it.
When explaining this “test” to parents, the reason given typically involves the “fencing reflex“, a primitive reflex where the arm and leg flex when a young infant’s head is turned to that side. Holding a baby upside down by one leg to see if a baby turn’s their head a certain way is an incredibly stupid means of testing for the presence of this reflex, but here we are. The chiropractor will claim that if the baby doesn’t turn correctly then there must be some kind of nervous system “interference” that only they can fix.
Sometimes this reflex isn’t mentioned at all and they just make the claim that the baby should keep their head straight. If the head turns, it must be because of some kind of spinal misalignment that only they can fix. Whatever the explanation, the chiropractor can literally use any response from the baby as a reason for treatment because it is all just made up. It’s all just a performance. The individual chiropractor may believe what they are saying, but that doesn’t mean that they aren’t fooling themselves by reading into random baby behavior.
The rest of the video involves a lot of typical baby chiropractic nonsense. He uses an Activator, one of those spring-loaded handheld mallet devices that make a weak thump against the skin. It’s completely harmless, and Arnold follows the standard parental reassurance script, although I was impressed that he didn’t compare his adjustments to the pressure used to check the ripeness of a tomato.
He also does some craniosacral work on the spine and skull, and even mentions pushing spinal fluid around. It’s all nonsense, but it doesn’t look like he’s hurting the baby. There is crying throughout the video, but I don’t read it as pain.
So here we are again. Victoria’s Health Minister has condemned Arnold and area physicians are upset and calling for legislation to stop chiropractors from treating children. If history tells us anything, he will receive a slap on the wrist and return to business as usual. We are facing similar issues here in the United States, where pediatric chiropractic care is an increasing marketing approach.
I do hope that I will be proven wrong, of course.

Australian Chiropractor Ian Rossborough Promises to Stop Treating Children…for Twenty Days
Clay Jones on May 20, 2016
Link

Before I begin this brief update to my recent post on Australian baby chiropractor Ian Rossborough’s “crack heard round the world,” I want to give a quick thanks to Jann Bellamy for organizing our day of Science-Based Medicine at NECSS last week. It was an amazing experience sharing the stage with the SBM crew for my first public presentation, and finally getting to meet Scott, John, and Saul. I’ve given hundreds of lectures to residents and students, and even a grand rounds or two, but this was orders of magnitude more exciting and stressful. I may be biased, but I think we nailed it.
With NECSS prep taking up a significant percentage of my time and a rough current work week making up for days off, my post today is a little shorter than usual. My overall average word count still gives Gorski a run for his money however. Well, that’s not actually true. Gorski is in another league.
Rossborough provides an undertaking?
Chiropractor Ian Rossborough, who I recently discussed in a post on the backlash against pediatric chiropractic in Australia, has received the slap on the wrist I sadly expected. According to the Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency website, which has jurisdiction over the Chiropractic Board of Australia when it comes to “professional conduct, performance or health of registered health practitioners,” Rossborough has promised to leave them kids alone:
Dr Ian Rossborough provides the following undertaking to the Chiropractic Board of Australia (the Board):
1. The practitioner undertakes not to perform any chiropractic treatment of patients up to the age of 18 years from the end of today [being 13 May 2016] until and including 2 June 2016.
2. For the purposes of this undertaking, chiropractic treatment of patients up to the age of 18 years includes assessment, undertaking a diagnosis/clinical impression, formulating and implementing a management plan, the provision of any manual therapy (including manipulation of the spine), monitoring or reviewing care and facilitating coordination or continuity of care.
I didn’t even need a calculator to figure out that this promise to behave is for 20 days. That’s it. 20 days for blatantly ignoring advertising laws by engaging in “false, deceptive or misleading advertising” and giving parents the expectation that his manipulations of the spine will provide benefit for their child.
The chiropractic board will be investigating the claims made against Rossborough and at some point between now and June 2nd a hearing will be held. He may suffer the indignity of a reprimand or, unlikely as it would be, even more significant penalties. My prediction is that he will be tasked with “educational requirements” in order to continue treating children and nothing will change.
Rossborough may stop advertising the treatment of children for a bit, but nothing is likely going to keep him and his ilk from performing spinal adjustments on newborns in the future unless there is a major change to the current regulations. He certainly hasn’t demonstrated one iota of understanding or remorse for hurting the infant in this video. I hope I’m wrong.
Not that you need another example of chiropractors breaking the rules
Although not a new phenomenon, the recent focus on chiropractic care of young children in Australia has led to more reports such as this, which demonstrate the fact that some chiropractors feel that they are not obligated to play by anyone’s rules. Chiropractors have been sneaking into Australian hospitals despite this being forbidden by the facilities, in order to adjust the spines of newborn infants. The most recent incident provided this gem of a justification:
It was an awesome experience checking [the baby’s] spine for the first time. As I gently laid my hands on his spine, without even waking, he did his first poo!
I have seen roughly 30 newborn infants so far this week and probably a third of them urinated or passed meconium while I was examining them. But I’m not attributing this to my stethoscope’s aura or my powers of colonic reiki. And I won’t be posting any pictures on Facebook or YouTube videos of my taking credit for random bodily functions.
Of course not all baby poo is random. Sometimes it is a sign from God.
Conclusion: Make that crack a crack down
The AHPRA is charged with numerous objectives, most importantly to protect the Australian public from potentially dangerous nonsense. Allowing the continued chiropractic “treatment” of children fails that objective. Although I won’t be holding my breath, I’m really hoping that a true crack down takes place that can serve as an inspiration for policy makers in other parts of the world.

Australia’s Chiropractic Board bans spinal manipulation for children under two pending evidence review
Chiropractic Board of Australia interim policy prohibits spinal manipulation of children under two years old pending expert review of evidence by health authorities. Given the lack of evidence supporting chiropractic treatment of children, it should be banned.
Jann Bellamy on March 28, 2019
Link

The Chiropractic Board of Australia (CBA) has advised chiropractors not to use spinal manipulation to treat children under two years of age pending an independent expert review of the evidence and development of a final policy. Despite public outrage and calls for regulation brought on by recent viral videos of Australian chiropractors treating infants, the Board took action only after national health authorities forced their hand.
Prior to the CBA’s ban, Victorian Minister for Health Jenny Mikakos asked Safer Care Victoria, the state’s healthcare quality and safety improvement agency, to lead an independent review of the practice of spinal manipulation on children under 12 years (not just children two and under) and for the findings of that review to be reported to the Council of Australian Governments (COAG) Health Council, including any need for changes to the national law governing chiropractic practice. At its March, 2019, meeting, the COAG Health Council, comprised of federal, state, and territory Health Ministers,
noted community concerns about the unsafe spinal manipulation on children performed by chiropractors and agreed that public protection was paramount in resolving this issue.
The Health Council welcomed the Victorian Health Minister’s proposal for an independent review with the findings reported to the Council.
Health Minister Mikakos took action after seeing a video of Melbourne chiropractor Andrew Arnold manipulating an infant’s spine, hips and collarbone, which she called “deeply disturbing”. Arnold uses an “activator”, a spring-loaded chiropractic device, on the baby, which elicits cries from the child as it is applied to his neck, tailbone and spine.
It’s appalling that young children and infants are being exposed to potential harm . . . Newborn babies are extremely fragile and it’s important to be aware that the damage done to an infant may not be obvious immediately and may not manifest until years later.
While Mikakos focused on manipulation of the baby’s spine, SBM’s resident pediatrician, Dr. Clay Jones, also exposed the quack diagnostic method used by Arnold in justifying his treatment, chiropractic shtick he’s seen in hundreds of chiropractic marketing videos.
What has people bent out of shape is that Arnold briefly holds the baby upside down by his feet, the rationale of which isn’t made clear in the video. I’ll explain what he’s doing, not that it matters. It’s ridiculous no matter how you slice it.
When explaining this “test” to parents, the reason given typically involves the “fencing reflex“, a primitive reflex where the arm and leg flex when a young infant’s head is turned to that side. Holding a baby upside down by one leg to see if a baby turns their head a certain way is an incredibly stupid means of testing for the presence of this reflex, but here we are. The chiropractor will claim that if the baby doesn’t turn correctly then there must be some kind of nervous system “interference” that only they can fix.
Sometimes this reflex isn’t mentioned at all and they just make the claim that the baby should keep their head straight. If the head turns, it must be because of some kind of spinal misalignment that only they can fix. Whatever the explanation, the chiropractor can literally use any response from the baby as a reason for treatment because it is all just made up. It’s all just a performance. The individual chiropractor may believe what they are saying, but that doesn’t mean that they aren’t fooling themselves by reading into random baby behavior.
It was Mikakos herself who referred Arnold to the Chiropractic Board and the Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency (AHPRA). Arnold has agreed not to treat children up to 12 years of age pending the results of an investigation by health authorities.
Yet, despite public outrage over the Arnold video, the CBA’s initial reaction was the same as ever — simply reiterating policies that were obviously being widely ignored by chiropractors:
The board has made a strong statement about the care of children and has written to every chiropractor in Australia to warn them to comply with their professional and ethical obligations, which are clearly outlined in the board’s code of conduct,” a [CBA] spokeswoman said.
It was only after the independent expert review train had left the station that CBA issued the “Interim policy on spinal manipulation for infants and young children“, banning, for now, manipulation of children under two. This action follows a 2017 CBA position statement on chiropractic pediatric care, itself an apparent response to public outcry following publication of several reported incidents of dubious chiropractic treatment of children. In the 2017 statement, the Board announced
an expectation that chiropractors ensure their clinical practice is consistent with current evidence and/or best-practice approaches.
But – OOPS! – the Board has now belatedly realized that
there is no current clinical guideline, or peer-reviewed publication to guide chiropractors with respect to the care of infants and young children, and the use of spinal manipulation in particular.
Thus, the CBA claims to “look forward to the outcomes of the independent review” which effectively wrests the pediatric spinal manipulation issue out of the CBA’s grip and into the hands of Safer Care Victoria, whose no-nonsense approach is evident from its plan to tackle the matter.
Safer Care Victoria will convene a panel of experts in healthcare evidence, governance, pediatrics, and musculoskeletal care, as well as consumer representatives, all of whom will be required to declare any conflicts of interest. Starting in June of this year, the panel will conduct a systematic review of the literature and review written submissions from the public. A final report and recommendations is expected within six months.
Repeatedly ignoring the CBA’s rules
The video Victoria’s Health Minister found so appalling was just one of several recent incidents of chiropractic malfeasance in Australia and the CBA’s anemic response, all ably covered by SBM’s Drs. Jones and Novella.
In 2013, a Melbourne pediatrician cared for a four-month-old infant whose neck was allegedly broken by a chiropractor attempting to treat torticollis. The CBA closed that case by allowing the chiropractor to continue practicing as long as he obtained further education in pediatric chiropractic care. As Dr. Novella noted at the time, “training is irrelevant when you don’t have a science-based practice in the first place.” Dr. Jones later reported that the Chiropractic Association of Australia tried to obfuscate the chiropractor’s role in the infant’s injury.
Then, in 2015, the media reported that chiropractors who had not been credentialed to practice in hospitals were nevertheless sneaking in to “adjust” newborns, further evidence that chiropractors were simply ignoring the rules. The chiropractors were ordered to undertake ethics and professional development training.
Next, in “the crack heard round the world“, Melbourne chiropractor Ian Rossborough’s promotional YouTube video (since removed) of himself manipulating a four-day-old premature infant’s thoracic spine hard enough to cause a loud cracking sound, and a cry of pain from the baby, went viral after being featured in an April, 2016, Australian Broadcasting Corporation Radio National story. Rossborough claimed the treatment was for acid reflux and/or colic, conditions, which as Dr. Jones pointed out, aren’t diagnosed in infants of that age.
The CBA did impose sanctions on Rossborough but, according to NewsGP,
despite these conditions, as well as restrictions related to testimonials and advertising, dozens of videos of Mr Rossborough appeared online in 2017 that show the controversial chiropractor performing a range of treatments on children – some as young as three weeks’ old.
Sanctions were lifted in July, 2018, and he is now free to treat patients of any age. His registration shows no disciplinary action.
Just a month prior to Rossborough’s video going viral, as Dr. Jones noted, the CBA had, once again, admonished chiropractors:
Claims suggesting that manual therapy for spinal problems can assist with general wellness and/or benefit a variety of pediatric syndromes and organic conditions are not supported by satisfactory evidence. This includes claims relating to developmental and behavioral disorders, ADHD, autistic spectrum disorders, asthma, infantile colic, bedwetting, ear infections and digestive problems.
But CBA’s repeated warnings did absolutely nothing to stop either Rossborough or Arnold.
“Plenty of science” say American chiropractors
The Royal Australian College of General Practitioners welcomed the evidence review, although the RACGP believes the inquiry should be more wide-ranging, broader than just the use of spinal manipulation in children.
Not surprisingly, the response from fellow chiropractors in America has been less enthusiastic. According to The Chronicle of Chiropractic, the CBA’s admission that there are no current clinical guidelines or peer-reviewed publications to guide to using spinal manipulation in the care of young children is false:
nothing could be farther [sic] from the truth. There is a robust base of evidence for the chiropractic management of children including practice guidelines by the Council on Chiropractic Practice and the International Chiropractors Association. Further, studies on safety and efficacy have been carried out by the International Chiropractic Pediatric Association among others.
The Foundation for Vertebral Subluxation chimed in, saying there is “plenty of science” supporting vertebral subluxation management.
Sherman College of Chiropractic also issued a statement supporting chiropractic care of children:
Misalignments in the spine may result from the birth process, falls, tumbles, and stresses of childhood, resulting in interference with proper function of the nerve system. These are called vertebral subluxations. Doctors of Chiropractic recognize the importance of locating and gently correcting vertebral subluxations so that the body may function at its best.
The International Chiropractors Association is “offering any and all assistance, information and available resources” to the Australian Chiropractors Association, while advocating “the earliest possible evaluation, detection and correction of chiropractic subluxations in children, especially infants, to maximize the potential for normal growth and development”.
To borrow Dr. Jones’s term, this is typical “straight” chiropractic shtick, and it’s nonsense. Yet it is the foundation upon which subluxation-based chiropractors, including the Australian video stars, base treatment of all manner of childhood conditions via “adjustments” to restore “proper nerve function” thereby allowing “the body to heal itself”. This is scaremongering to convince parents that the normal birth process (hence the chiropractors sneaking into hospitals) and everyday childhood activities are a dire threat to their children’s health and require immediate chiropractic treatment.
One of the supporters did make an interesting point, though. The CBA’s Interim Policy defines “spinal manipulation” as “moving the joints of the spine beyond the child’s usual physiological range of motion using a high velocity, low amplitude thrust”. But, as the author notes, “much of chiropractic care of infants does not involve cavitating joints.” This is, in fact, a chiropractic selling point: that their “adjustments” of a child’s “vertebral subluxations” is gentle or, as they like to say, comparable to the pressure used to check the ripeness of a tomato. Whether the ban will fall on this semantic nicety remains to be seen.
In any event, it is perfectly legal here in the U.S. to make these claims and no one seems to be doing a thing about it. Notably, Sweden has legislated that no child under eight can be treated by chiropractors.
Based on a recent systematic review of the evidence evaluating the use of manual therapy for clinical conditions in the pediatric population, assessing the methodological quality of the studies, and synthesizing findings based on health condition, it looks like Safer Care Victoria’s independent expert review cannot possibly support chiropractic manipulation for children. Put another way, actually there is not “plenty of science”.
Fifty studies investigated the clinical effects of manual therapies for a wide variety of pediatric conditions. Moderate-positive overall assessment was found for 3 conditions: low back pain, pulled elbow, and premature infants. Inconclusive unfavorable outcomes were found for 2 conditions: scoliosis (OMT) and torticollis (MT). All other condition’s overall assessments were either inconclusive favorable or unclear. Adverse events were uncommonly reported. More robust clinical trials in this area of healthcare are needed.
And that was the conclusion of researchers from three chiropractic colleges and a private chiropractic practice. Edzard Ernst, MD, was even less impressed with the evidence. His review of their review concluded
there is no good evidence for chiropractic, osteopathic or other manual treatments for children suffering from any condition.
And, as he pointed out, even if you accept the authors’ take,
Only three conditions are, according to the authors, based on evidence. This is hardly enough to sustain an entire speciality of paediatric chiropractors.
I hope Australia’s Health Ministers will come to the same conclusion and, more importantly, do something about it.

A Canadian Journalist Calls Out Pediatric Chiropractic Again, and the Canadian Chiropractic Association Responds…Again
The National Post has published another quality article pointing out the absurdity of infant chiropractic care. The Canadian Chiropractic Association’s attempt at a rebuttal falls flat.
Clay Jones on July 12, 2019
Link

Sigh. I’ve got déjà vu…all over again.
In May of 2018, I discussed an excellent article in The National Post by Sharon Kirkey that effectively showed infant chiropractic for the absurd and potentially dangerous nonsense that it is. I also evaluated the Canadian Chiropractic Association (CCA) president’s meager rebuttal. But Ka, as the old one’s say, is like a wheel, and its one purpose is to turn, and in the end it always comes back to the place where it had started.
Last week, Kirkey published another piece on the subject of infant chiropractic, with a rather memorable title: “This. Hurts. Babies: Doctors Alarmed at Weekend Courses Teaching Chiropractors How to Adjust Newborn Spines“. In the article, she points out the sad fact that while Australia is protecting young infants from unnecessary chiropractic adjustments, and associated exposure to all manner of anti-medical propaganda, Canadian babies are increasingly becoming targets of practitioners taking comically short training courses run by the International Chiropractic Pediatric Association:
Attendees will be practicing on baby dolls. “Any type of baby doll, other than Barbie (too small) or Cabbage Patch Kid (no neck) is acceptable,” according to the conference website. Mon Bébé is the preferred choice.
Several experts are quoted in the article, with each helping to further reveal that infant chiropractic has no legitimate evidence to support it as an intervention for any complaint, and that the claimed underlying pathology supposedly being treated is pure fantasy. As I have said many times in the past, it is at best a misguided treatment based on a true belief in chiropractic philosophy and a profound ignorance of infant medicine, and at worst a manipulative and fear-based marketing strategy designed to drum up business. And it does hurt kids, sometimes a lot.
The Canadian Chiropractic Association responds…again
Three days after The National Post article was published, the CCA issued a public statement meant to counter the claims made by Kirkey and the quoted experts. It raises more questions than it answers, and fails to provide any reasonable rationale for parents to bring their children to a chiropractor. It is very misleading and full of weasel words. Here are some highlights:
Millions of Canadians of all ages visit a chiropractor each year and there is a growing body of scientific evidence showing the value of chiropractic in the treatment of conditions and disorders related to the muscular, skeletal and nervous systems. Chiropractic treatments can effectively relieve pain, restore function and mobility and improve health outcomes for all Canadians, including children.
The first claim is undoubtedly true, although the percentage of those visits that involve infants is still, thankfully, fairly small. There is also a growing body of evidence involving chiropractic care, it just isn’t of a very high quality and it doesn’t support treatments that are specific to chiropractic for much more than some forms of mild back and neck pain, and even that is underwhelming. Chiropractic plays no role in treatment of the nervous system, and it is a huge leap to make claims regarding general health outcomes.
All of this is especially problematic when focusing on children, particularly infants. And if there was evidence to back up their claims, they would have cited it. What they do cite is a study on pediatric chiropractic care best practices, which is just a collection practices that they mostly agree on but they are thoroughly untrained for, such as assessing children for red flags concerning for serious illness. It contains no actual evidence that their treatment interventions are effective. In fact, it contains the following:
However, the scientific evidence for the effectiveness and efficacy of chiropractic care and spinal manipulation for treatment of children is not plentiful or definitive.
And if the evidence base for treatment of children is lacking, just imaging what infant chiropractic care might draw upon for guidance. Again, this was the study that the CCA cited in a rebuttal to Kirkey’s article, the primary point of which is to point out that infant chiropractic is not science-based. They’ve got nothing.
The only other citation is a study on reports of adverse events occurring during pediatric chiropractic interventions. They are congratulating themselves for being unable to causally link chiropractic care to any pediatric deaths with certainty. There were deaths and serious injuries, however. And of course, no pseudoscientific intervention is ever risk free. Even a small risk of minor injury outweighs the complete absence of benefit in the case of infant chiropractic care.
While Daniel David Palmer is considered the founder of chiropractic, the profession — like other mainstream healthcare fields — has evolved, growing more reliant on evidence-based, patient-centered care.
Yes, there are chiropractors that have denounced the fictional subluxation and provide what is essentially physical therapy without any of the philosophical nonsense. But any chiropractor who is treating infants has not evolved. There is no evidence to support it, and it is almost exclusively based on the false claim that birth trauma results in subluxations that interfere with the function of the nervous system.
We’ll give Ms. Kirkey the benefit of the doubt and assume she’s unaware of the extent of the curriculum taught at Canada’s two chiropractic colleges.
This is irrelevant to the concerns Kirkey and the quoted experts are expressing. There is no curriculum at any chiropractic college in Canada or throughout the world that prepares them to appropriately care for infant patients.
We’ll also acknowledge that a 12-hour continuing education course does not give one sufficient education or training to make a claim of expertise – in the field of pediatric chiropractic or any other field. As we have no affiliation with the course provider, we cannot comment on course quality or its teachings. And the claim that “most newborns need a spinal adjustment to unblock nervous system interference caused by the trauma of passing through the birth canal”, referenced in the article, is not supported by current scientific evidence.
Then why aren’t they doing something about it, considering that almost all Canadian chiropractors are members of the CCA?
Continuing education courses are common in all health professions. They afford practitioners the opportunity to learn about the latest evidence, guidelines and best practices and are intended to improve patient outcomes and care. However, in the case of chiropractors, continuing education courses aren’t their first introduction to pediatrics.
No chiropractic trainee has access to enough pediatric patients to gain anything remotely approximating expertise, and they have absolutely no exposure to ill children. They may learn about pediatric medicine from books and lectures, but they are not trained to provide competent pediatric care or to recognize true illness.
While there is no recognized pediatric specialization in chiropractic in Canada, pediatrics and pre- and ante-natal care are an integral component of the four-year chiropractic curriculum and include relevant topics such as embryology, genetics, congenital and developmental defects, maturation of the skeletal system, etc. Students also complete over 50 hours of coursework in pediatric diagnosis and management and antenatal care, followed by a mandatory one-year internship during which they care for patients of all ages under the supervision of an experienced chiropractor.
Pediatric residents are capped at an average of 80 hours a week, for three years. Even then it takes almost constant review to maintain diagnostic and management skills. To think that 50 hours is something to brag about reveals just how clueless these people are. I also highly doubt that these year-long internships improve their pediatric fund of knowledge very much. I guarantee that any 3rd year medication student having completed the typical 3-month pediatric rotation would blow any chiropractor out of the water.
Chiropractic is not simply the technique of adjustments or manipulations, although this is a common misconception. Chiropractors use a range of techniques, supplementary procedures and advice in the provision of comprehensive patient care. As allied health professionals, chiropractors also work collaboratively with a range of other healthcare providers using a collaborative care approach to co-manage and provide advice and referrals in the best interests of the patient.
Yes, they often do this despite a complete lack of evidence to support it. And their comprehensive patient care far too often involves promoting anti-vaccine propaganda.
Chiropractors put patient safety first. This is especially true with pediatric patients. When treating infants and children, chiropractors follow best practices. This includes modifying techniques and the application of force to support the needs and comfort of the child.
These are the best practices referenced above. None of them involves a treatment approach supported by actual evidence. If 80% of survey respondents agree on a certain treatment approach, it doesn’t mean that it works. It just means that they were exposed to the same propaganda and have fallen prey to the same biases.
Chiropractic expertise in the musculoskeletal system comes not only from seven years of intensive post-secondary education and practical hours, but also from a growing body of rigorous research. Since 1976, the Canadian Chiropractic Research Foundation (CCRF) has been funding chiropractic research to discover the best, evidence-informed treatments for patients living with pain and disability caused by spinal dysfunction and disease.
None of it in infants.
The body of knowledge that comes from research allows chiropractors to provide safe, scientifically-sound treatments in their practice – bringing the most advanced methods to patient care. Chiropractic research also informs other health professionals who partner with chiropractors to deliver quality MSK treatment to their patients.
None of this applies to infants.
Existing evidence related to pediatric chiropractic treatment draws heavily on inter-professional and international research studies. Available evidence suggests moderately positive or favourable outcomes in pediatric populations.
The study they cited, which I referenced above, says the exact opposite.
While the evidence for pediatric conditions is limited, research in this area is ongoing and growing. Like other healthcare professions the processes and challenges of translating an ever-increasing evidence base into practise is a healthcare wide issue not a chiropractic-specific one, but one that the chiropractic profession and educators take seriously.
So is there evidence or not? Perhaps aggressive marketing aimed at recruiting pediatric patients should stop until they have figured this out. Just a thought.
Same as it ever was: Infant chiropractic is pseudoscience
The article written by Sharon Kirkey is accurate across the board. There is no quality evidence that supports the treatment of infants by chiropractors for any reason. They should not be allowed to do it. The response from the CCA is hollow propaganda. If they had any integrity at all, they would join the call to end this pseudoscientific and risky practice.

Recent trends in pediatric chiropractic use: the good, the bad, and the unhelpful
A new study looks into the numbers behind pediatric chiropractic in the United States. There isn’t much new here, but it adds a bit of nuance to the discussion. Still, it’s clear that we need better data.
Clay Jones on July 8, 2022
Link

I have had a strong feeling that pediatric chiropractic is becoming increasingly popular for a while now. Unfortunately, there hasn’t been much legitimate scientific data available to help confirm or assuage my fears. A few years ago there was a National Center for Health Statistics (NCHS) survey that involved questions on the use of chiropractic by kids, as well as yoga and meditation, that were in part developed by the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health* and gave some insight:
Among U.S. children, there was no significant difference in the use of chiropractic care between 2012 and 2017 (3.5 percent versus 3.4 percent). There were no significant differences between boys and girls in the use of chiropractic care. Non-Hispanic white children were more likely to have used chiropractic care than non-Hispanic black children or Hispanic children.
This survey further revealed that of the roughly 2 million children that were seen by a chiropractor at least once in 2017, those aged 12 to 17 years were more than twice as likely (5%) to have done so as children aged 4 to 11 years (2%).
So at least based on this data set, use of chiropractic by kids aged 4 to 17 years hadn’t been increasing, but that was 5 years ago and much of my gut feeling has been about patients younger than 4 years anyway, especially newborn infants that are being exposed to unscientific and potentially dangerous chiropractic care. This is largely based on the massive increase in the number of online marketing videos using them as props. I regularly see new YouTube videos from chiropractors discussing pediatric chiropractic, and I know that there are many more on the Instagrams, Ticktocks, and whatever else the kids are into these days.
Last month, a paper from the Journal of Manipulative and Physiological Therapeutics was published online that helps to shine a bit more light on this issue, though not much. And as you’ll soon see, we are left with a lot more questions than answers. Many thanks to Edzard Ernst for bringing this paper to my attention.
National trends in the expenditure and utilization of chiropractic care in U.S. children and adolescents
The authors set out to examine a representative sample of children and adolescents in order to determine how many were seeing a chiropractor, how often they were doing so, and how much money was being spent. They used yearly serial cross-sectional data provided by the Medical Expenditure Panel Survey from 2007 to 2016. The MEPS does involve self-reported data from individuals and families, just like the above referenced NCHS survey, but it is also verified by their medical providers and insurers. And, importantly, it looked at kids of all ages.
The lead author of the study, and perhaps the lot of them, appear to have some significant bias. In the introduction, they praise chiropractic as “one of the most utilized complementary and integrative health options in the U.S. population, with demonstrated clinical effectiveness for back and neck pain in both adults and adolescents”. They springboard off of this claim into a another that is equally dubious:
Therefore, chiropractic care is uniquely positioned to address the public health burden associated with musculoskeletal pain, and its utilization should be explored in depth.
The only problem with those statements is that they aren’t particularly accurate, or at least they are highly misleading. Chiropractic may be more popular as a treatment approach for musculoskeletal complaints than other irregular therapies, but it does not have demonstrated benefit for adults or adolescents. Nothing unique to chiropractic is effective. When helpful, chiropractors are making use of standard physical therapy and science-based recommendations such as exercise, improved sleep, and avoidance of activities that might aggravate an injury.
Furthermore, evidence in support of pediatric chiropractic for any indication is particularly lacking. This 2019 systematic review and meta-analysis came to a very different conclusion than the authors of the current study:
Based on GRADE methodology, we found the evidence was of very low quality; this prevented us from drawing conclusions about the effectiveness of specific SMT techniques in infants, children and adolescents. Outcomes in the included studies were mostly parent or patient-reported; studies did not report on intermediate outcomes to assess the effectiveness of SMT techniques in relation to the hypothesized spinal dysfunction. Severe harms were relatively scarce, poorly described and likely to be associated with underlying missed pathology.
So while severe harms may have been uncommon, they happened just as we have often predicted that they would here at SBM, by delaying appropriate care. Any risk of harm is too much when evidence of benefit is essentially non-existent. Furthermore, the proposed mechanism of potential benefit from unique chiropractic interventions for most of the reasons that they treat young children is implausible to the point of near impossibility.
What did the study find?
First off, just as in the NCHS survey, older white kids (14-17 years) were much more likely to go to a chiropractor than any other group. And boys were only slightly more likely to do so than girls. Though most had private insurance, roughly a third of children who saw a chiropractor relied on SCHIP. Of course, most of these visits were likely paid for out of pocket regardless.
There were some significant ups ($946 million in 2012) and downs ($317 million in 2008), likely related to the Great Recession of the late 2000s, when looking at expenditures. From 2007 to 2016 there was a yearly increase of about $22 million spent on chiropractic care for children, but this result wasn’t statistically significant enough to claim with confidence that there has been true growth. Regardless, people are spending a lot of money on nonsense even if expenditures for pediatric chiropractic only make up about 3-4% of the total.
When looking at how many kids were seen by chiropractors over this time period, there was a lot of variation from year to year, with a difference of roughly 600,000 children between the peak (1.48 million in 2015) and the valley (864,000 in 2011). Analysis found that there was a statistically significant yearly increase of about 50,000 children, however. The total number of pediatric visits ranged from 4.32 million in 2008 to 12.44 million in 2012, with the year-to-year growth using linear regression analysis being essentially stagnant.
The final bit of statistical analysis I’ll mention is percent utilization. The authors found that the percent of U.S. children that saw a chiropractor during this 10-year period ranged from 1.17% in 2011 to 1.99% in 2015, and that there was a statistically significant increase of .064% each year. Again, this was found using a linear regression model. The total percent utilization was lower than what was found in the NCHS data I mentioned earlier, but that is because this MEPS data goes down to birth. Younger children (.37% to 1.12%) are much less likely than older children (1.3% to 2.3%) to see a chiropractor, so the utilization is diluted.
The elephant in the room
There is a huge limitation when it comes to the conclusions of this study. Unfortunately, it focuses only on pediatric visits to a chiropractor, and expenditures for their services, in the setting of musculoskeletal complaints. In fact, each visit was linked to a specific but partial ICD-9 code, which allowed the study authors to lump them each into one of 6 broad categories, such as “head and neck” or “curvature of the spine”.
While it is true that most chiropractic visits for older children likely involve problems like neck and back pain, virtually all infants and very young children do not. Infants in particular are often seen for complaints such as fussiness, reflux, feeding problems, sleep problems, or for a desire to boost a babies’ immune system. Toddlers and school aged children are also commonly seen for non-musculoskeletal complaints, such as bedwetting, ear infections, or concerns about overall health and development. It’s possible that some or many of these visits were coded as a musculoskeletal problem, but some visits might have slipped through the cracks. This study doesn’t add any helpful insight when it comes to this issue.
Conclusion: we need better and more current data
Unfortunately, this new study doesn’t add much to our understanding of the utilization of pediatric chiropractic, though I don’t believe there has been anything else published on the pediatric chiropractic-specific expenditures. The data is essentially in line with the earlier published NCHS survey results and doesn’t support any claims by chiropractors that parents are beating down their clinic doors. There may have been some modest increase in the total number of kids going to a chiropractor from 2007 to 2016, but the total number of visits and total amount of money spent on them doesn’t appear to be on the rise.
Still, there were thousands of kids and millions of visits every year during this period. And millions were spent, even if was a fairly small percent of the total expenditure for chiropractic care. And this new batch of numbers doesn’t address my concern that social media is both a cause of, and a window into, increasing numbers of very young children, even newborn babies, finding themselves being poked and prodded by a fool with delusions of expertise and considerably more confidence than good sense. I’m sure it’s not a huge number by any stretch, though of course one is too many in my opinion. But it’s a number that should be tracked.

*Previously known as the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine. Before that it was the Office of Alternative Medicine, which began as Senator Tom Harkins’ bee pollen-inspired pet project.

The Washington Post Takes on Baby Chiropractic
A recent Washington Post article takes on baby chiropractic and…it isn’t terrible! In fact, I’ve seen many that are a lot worse. Still, sadly, there is an unfortunate and undeserved false balance that should have been cut from the first draft.
Clay Jones on December 9, 2022
Link
This certainly won’t be the first time we point out that journalists don’t always do a great job covering medical topics, and I’m confident that it won’t be the last either. The risk is increased, of course, when they aren’t a dedicated science or medicine reporter, but even that isn’t a fully reliable indicator of a quality piece. In my post today, I’ll discuss a recent article from a “general assignment reporter” working for The Washington Post that takes a look at the world of baby chiropractic and is a bit of a mixed bag.
The article is titled “Is it safe to bring a baby to a chiropractor? Here’s what experts say“. Overall the article isn’t bad. There is some good information for parents, and a few excellent points made by the involved experts, but it provides the false balance that we so often call out here at Science-Based Medicine. I will say, however, that I appreciate the fact that it doesn’t open with the standard emotional story of a baby getting adjusted and a happy parent’s glowing testimonial.
In fact, the opening paragraph actually contains the important nugget of truth that chiropractic treatments being promoted for infants are all unproven. This is followed by the example of a chiropractor (Judd) going viral on TikTok with a video where he uses a vibrating tool to massage a newborn. The video, like many over the past several months, has millions of views:
The baby “got his 1st adjustment and LOVED IT,” reads the caption. The video has been viewed more than 1.2 million times. (Judd later told The Washington Post he used the device, called a vibracussor, to soothe the colicky baby.)
Right off the bat, this demonstrates a fundamental lack of pediatric knowledge. Newborns certainly cry, and are often labelled as fussy at times, but they don’t have colic. Colic is a label that has meaning, even if we don’t know exactly what it is. (Narrator: We pretty much known what it is.) Maybe he is just using it as a general term for crying, but it’s imprecise and an “expert” should be more careful. Regardless, babies often can be consoled by holding and rocking them and there is no evidence that vibration or massage reduces overall crying beyond that through any specific mechanism.
In response to criticism in the comments to his video, the chiropractor responds with a classic bit of fallacious logic:
“It’s very dogmatic,” Judd said. “You get all kinds of hate from one way or another. But, I’m on a mission. I’ve seen what it does.”
Criticism can be hateful at times, but labeling all of it as such is a cheap means of deflection. It reduces arguments to emotional outbursts based on belief, which I find more than a bit ironic considering his use of “mission” and apparent reliance on his own anecdotal experience. Who is actually being dogmatic here? I and many others in the medical community have raised numerous questions regarding pediatric chiropractic over the years, particularly when it involves infants, and at no point have our objections relied on personal beliefs or experiences.
Again, the author of the article makes an important distinction:
More than five-dozen videos of infant and toddler chiropractic care have been posted in the past year by TikTok accounts advertising clinics across the country.
These videos are produced and posted as marketing ploys. They are not educating the public on important medical topics. They are not promoting public health measures. They are advertisements.
Historically, many of these videos were encouraged by practice management services designed to increase profits. There are thousands online that are just pre-packaged templates that are paid for. The rise of social media sites like TikTok has resulted in an explosion of more amateurish videos like the one focused on in the Washington Post piece, but the purpose remains the same.
The evidence that chiropractic care can soothe babies is scant. But clinicians on TikTok claim chiropractic care can offer relief to fussy babies suffering from a variety of ailments, including colic, constipation, reflux, musculoskeletal problems and even, some say, trauma babies experience in childbirth.
Not only scant, but there is also the issue of extremely low plausibility that the unique chiropractic interventions they promote could soothe babies. Fussiness, colic, constipation, and reflux are, in almost all instances when talking about young infants, the name given for a caregiver’s subjective perception of normal infant behaviors rather than discrete medical conditions. If a baby truly is constipated, has a medical condition that is causing pain, or a musculoskeletal problem like congenital muscular torticollis, no evidence supports chiropractic care.
Trauma occurring during childbirth does happen, and as a newborn hospitalist I have seen a number of swollen heads and broken clavicles, but this isn’t what chiropractors mean when they use the term. They are talking about subluxations or functional impairments of the spine that they blame for pain and a wide variety of specific and general health concerns. As you well know, unless very new to SBM, subluxations in the chiropractic rather than orthopedic sense are fictional and there is no real concern from pediatricians that parents need to worry about their baby’s spine after delivery.
The article then describes a few examples of chiropractors treating infants: leg exercises for constipation, cervical spine adjustments for reflux, and full spine adjustment using an ArthroStim device along with that nonsense where they hold babies upside down for improved nervous system function. In that video, the chiropractor demonstrates some classic chirobabble about resetting the nerves and tells dad that babies usually have a blow out poop on the way home and sleep better too, but not always. And, if you can hear over the child’s crying, he establishes justification for multiple future visits to keep the child’s spine healthy.
Up next is the standard defensive posturing used by infant chiropractors:
Chiropractors say treatments for infants and toddlers are safe and gentle — far from the explosive cracks and contortions generally associated with adult chiropractic care.
This is largely true, though there have been many exceptions that I have found online and that have made the news in recent years. They know that not many parents are going to tolerate aggressive adjustments that look, and can be, painful. So chiropractors have adopted the “tomato checker’s defense” strategy.
The tomato checker’s defense involves pointing out, and I have seen this in hundreds of their marketing videos, that chiropractic adjustments on infants only use the amount of pressure you might use to check for the ripeness of a tomato. Rarely, oddly enough, they will instead claim that they only use an amount of pressure that wouldn’t cause pain when pushing on your eyeball. This is actually used later in the piece by a quoted baby chiropractor. It is comical to imagine how pressure that would barely indent the skin is somehow moving spinal bones around in the human body, but this is also the profession that in some cases believes that it can move the spinal bones of elephants by hand.*
Now come the safety concerns from real experts:
“Ultimately, there is no way you’re going to get an improvement in a newborn from a manipulation,” Tabaie said. “The only thing that you might possibly cause is harm.”
Tabaie is a pediatric orthopedic surgeon and, like many others, he worries that an infant’s bones and joints are less developed and prone to overstretching and injury. Here is where I diverge a bit from Tabaie and the other quoted experts. Though I agree that there is no potential for specific benefit from spinal manipulation, and I fully acknowledge that harm is possible, has happened, and the risk to benefit ratio is decidedly unfavorable here, I don’t think that a heavy-handed focus on the risk of direct harm is the right approach.
Actual injury caused by a chiropractor treating an infant is exceedingly rare. Chiropractors can, and often do, attempt to make opponents out to be alarmist as they demonstrate how gentle their adjustments are. Parents can see that what is being done to their child is not any more harsh than burping a baby or giving a tummy massage in most cases, and they may be more likely to ignore other warnings.
We should be focusing instead on the indirect harm that comes from the potential for delays in appropriate care when a potentially ill or injured infant is brought to a practitioner that lacks adequate pediatric training and expertise, and on the anti-vaccine and general anti-medicine beliefs that are so common in infant chiropractic circles. When we talk about the potential for direct harm, we should be clear that we are talking specifically about high velocity adjustments and stretching beyond the normal range of motion. We should provide education, and attempt to guide parents away from choosing chiropractic care for their infant, but empower those who do to ask up front that these aggressive techniques not be used on their child.
The author gives one reason why some parents seek out chiropractic care for their babies:
Parents say part of the reason they are attracted to chiropractic care is that practitioners promise relief for problems traditional medicine often cannot solve, particularly colic, one of the most distressing and little understood conditions that affect newborns.
There is some truth to this statement. Chiropractors who treat infants do often validate parental concerns or even fears while offering a solution. The mystery, and inability of us conventional doctors to solve it, is frequently emphasized during evaluations. But rather than having problems that can’t be fixed, most infants in these situations have self-limited and non-specific issues that go away with time. So there can unfortunately be a false perception of benefit and the development of an entrenched narrative that parents then share with others.
The author is very misinformed when it comes to colic, however. While caring for a baby that either cries a lot, simply because they sit on the wrong end of a spectrum of normal development, or is merely perceived as crying a lot because of caregiver stress, anxiety, depression, sleep deprivation, or sensitivity, it can certainly be distressing. It can even play a role in neglect and physical abuse of infants. But colic is well understood by pediatricians, as demonstrated later in the article by a primary care pediatrician in Colorado:
“Colic is a developmental phase in a normal kid,” Milobsky said. “But it’s been sold as something that can be treated or solved, as opposed to being understood that this is just a developmental period that has a wide spectrum of presentations.”
The key to managing colic is ruling out an injury or medical condition requiring treatment, such as a milk protein allergy, followed by education on soothing techniques and an assessment for any red flags signalling severe caregiver stress or mental health concerns. Focusing on ways to reduce sensitivity to crying, or on how to safely get some space from a baby that is hard to console, can literally be lifesaving. Though there is no plausible reason to connect spine problems and colic, there have been a number of studies assessing chiropractic as a treatment that are of varying degrees of design quality, and overall are not convincing.
There are some solid examples of motivated reasoning from baby chiropractic proponents in this article. The lead author of a randomized and controlled colic study that failed to show benefit and who is a professor at the University of South Denmark still recommends chiropractic:
“You owe it to the baby to try,” she said.
The director of pediatric integrative medicine at the Andrew Weil Center for Integrative Medicine chalks up the lack of supporting evidence to how difficult it is to measure relief from discomfort in babies when studying manual therapies, but points out that ultimately it’s our fault:
“Conventional medicine has to evolve to understand what chiropractic is all about,” Weydert said.
The chiropractor that posted the viral video discussed in the opening to the article points out that insurance doesn’t cover his services so parents pay out of pocket, demonstrating some classic fallacious reasoning along the way:
If his treatments weren’t working, he said, people wouldn’t spend the money.
Finally, the president of the American Chiropractic Association’s Council on Pediatric Chiropractic claims that infant chiropractic is safe and effective, though she admits that more research is needed to prove that it works. This truly is a science and reason free zone we have entered into:
“We can’t really say for sure what’s happening,” she said. “It’s sort of like a black box. But, what we do know is that, clinically, what we’re doing is effective because we see a change in the symptoms of the child.”
Unfortunately the article, which overall was better than most I’ve read from the mainstream press on alternative medicine, ends with a believer in abject nonsense, who can present no legitimate evidence to support their belief in such a thoroughly implausible notion as baby chiropractic, getting the last word. She knows it works, therefore they can keep doing it until, one day, the evidence proves it. I mean, it has only been 127 years since a superstitious magnet healing middle-school drop out who believed in ghosts, but not vaccines, and wanted to start a new religion based on the ideas he stole from the founder of osteopathy, just made it all up one day. Maybe 2023 will be their year!

*For a more satirical take on exotic large animal chiropractic, please check out this article from my buddy Zoo Knudsen.

Chiropractic Manipulation Under Anesthesia in Infants with Congenital Torticollis: All Risk and No Benefit
It may sound too unethical to be true, but some chiropractors and their conventional medical conspirators are placing infants under general anesthesia for treatment of congenital muscular torticollis
Clay Jones on April 5, 2019
Link

The title of this post isn’t an exaggeration. I will be discussing a paper published late last year in the Journal of Chiropractic Medicine that retrospectively analyzed the outcome after six infants with a common musculoskeletal condition were placed under general anesthesia, with a breathing tube and everything, in order for a chiropractor to manipulate their neck.
This isn’t satire.
A pediatric anesthesiologist was involved, as was a pediatric radiologist. Nurses were there and a pediatric surgeon was present in one case. This happened at a children’s hospital in Switzerland, I assume with the approval of the institutional review board, and was written up by a member of the faculty at the University of Zurich. Again, this isn’t satire. This isn’t a joke. This is an egregious breach of medical ethics. It is medical child abuse.
What were they thinking?
This question has been rattling around my head for a couple weeks now, and I’m still at a bit of a loss. It’s easy to chalk it up to the numerous cognitive errors that plague mankind, and the way that the unconscious need to avoid cognitive dissonance serves as a powerful motivation to rationalize even the most horrific beliefs and behaviors. That’s ultimately how this study came to be conceived and implemented, of course, but it isn’t the whole picture.
For this study to happen, for these six children to be so fundamentally failed by the Swiss healthcare system, it required more than just a reckless chiropractor with delusions of legitimate research methodology and a seemingly preternatural ability to fool herself. She needed access to a medical facility and the necessary personnel to pull it off. She also needed parents to consent to it, although I try to not blame the victims. They were lied to.
The faculty member mentioned above as the author of the study, Inga Parvicini, is also the deluded chiropractor. She selected the six victims featured in this paper from the infants treated by an unnamed Swiss chiropractor with manipulation under anesthesia (MUA) over the past 25 years. In each case, she had assisted in the procedure.
Paravicini is also the curriculum director for the UZH master’s course in chiropractic medicine. So in Switzerland, it would seem abject quackery has been fully integrated into pediatric medical practice. Some of these kids were actually even referred for this treatment by their pediatrician.
What is torticollis?
Also known as wry neck, torticollis is a common condition with many causes that result in twisting of the neck to one side because of pain, stiffness, or neurological defects. In older children and adults, it is frequently caused by a self-limited soreness of the muscles of the neck and shoulder, the classic crick in the neck. By far the most common form, however, occurs in young infants and is known as congenital torticollis. We have discussed torticollis before, including that time a chiropractor broke a baby’s neck in a vain and unnecessary attempt to fix torticollis.
Congenital torticollis is diagnosed when a newborn or young infant presents with difficulty turning their head, with a classic resting position where the head is tilted to one side but turned to the opposite. The most common subset of congenital torticollis is congenital muscular torticollis (CMT), which occurs in as many as 15% of newborns, most of which simply have a positional preference based on their position in the womb that quickly resolves without intervention. More than 80% of torticollis cases fall into this category.
Roughly 1 to 4% of newborns will develop a more severe version of CMT, which is caused by an injury to one of the sternocleidomastoid (SCM) muscles on either side of the neck. These muscles run from the sternum and clavicle to the bony protuberance just behind the ear and are used to turn the head up and to the opposite side, or, when acting in unison, to look straight up or down. The most likely cause of tightness in one of these muscles is injury while still in the womb, which is why it tends to present in the first few weeks of life. Later presentations are more likely to have an acquired cause such as an infection or traumatic injury.
CMT is something that newborn healthcare providers are always on the lookout for because earlier treatment tends to result in faster resolution. It is a primarily clinical diagnosis based on positioning of the head at rest, reduced range of passive movement, presence of tightness or a mass in the SCM, and a lack of concerning signs of a non-muscular cause. Radiographic imaging is rarely necessary in babies that have a typical presentation, although sometimes ultrasound of the SCM muscle can be helpful in confirming injury and an X-ray or CT scan can rule out bony abnormalities when a child presents in an unusual way.
Infants with congenital torticollis do sometimes have a non-muscular etiology, one of which is an abnormality in the cervical spine, though this kind of anomaly is quite rare. These vertebrae need to be able to move freely for the neck to turn appropriately with a normal range of motion.
One of these cervical spine abnormalities is a true subluxation of the first and second vertebra, which is different from the chiropractic subluxation that we have written about many times on SBM in that it exists. Also known as an atlantoaxial rotary subluxation, it involves a displacement of the normal alignment of the first and second vertebra caused by swelling and inflammation from an infection, trauma, or recent surgery in the area. It typically occurs in older children and in most cases is treated with pain control, rest, and a soft cervical collar. In severe cases, immobilization and surgery may be necessary.
A chiropractic understanding of congenital torticollis
According to the author of the study, there is another category of newborn torticollis known as the arthrogenic type. Try looking this term up and you won’t find any legitimate discussion of it. You will find the study we are discussing and that’s about it. It appears to be completely fictional. According to the author, however, it has German origins:
In Germany, this condition sometimes is called kopf-gelenk indurzierte symmetrie storung…this type of torticollis indicates a joint dysfunction caused by capsular adhesion at the atlantoaxial joint.
In other words, it is just another nebulous description based on a functional defect with a cause that can’t be tested or disproved. Paravicini goes into horrific detail regarding treatment of this fictional entity:
Because the fixation of the atlantoaxial joint is not due to a neuromuscular reflex mechanism but rather due to capsular adhesions, the specific mobilization is without impulse and the sound that is heard during the mobilization is not a cavitation but rather the breaking up of adhesions.
Remember that she is talking about the treatment of infants and describing manipulation of a child’s neck vigorous enough to make a cracking sound. Most chiropractors these days will admit that the sound being made is simply the escape of gas from the joint space, so-called cavitation, and that it is not meaningful. Paravicini has invented an alternate explanation in order to give a false impression that her preferred approach is fixing a problem. That tingling sensation means it’s working!
She claims that 2.5% of children with “arthrogenic torticollis” will not respond to standard chiropractic interventions and may be candidates for manipulation under anesthesia. Where does she get this estimate from? Keep in mind that we are talking about exposing infants to general anesthesia and a breathing tube while reading her answer:
These numbers are anecdotal data originating from 1 specialized chiropractor in Switzerland who treats approximately 400 infants per year with arthrogenic newborn torticollis. From these 400 infants, 10 will end up needing MUA due to the reasons mentioned above.
There have been no studies looking into the safety and efficacy of MUA in infants. Nobody with a shred of ethical integrity would have even considered this as an intervention. The “reasons mentioned above” are not worth your time because they are manufactured rationalizations conjured up in an attempt to force the variation of congenital muscular torticollis outcomes, assuming that this is even a reliably given diagnosis in every case seen by the mysterious unnamed chiropractor, into a convenient pattern. Arthrogenic torticollis does not exist. Infant MUA is an abomination.
And now the study
Paravicini essentially looked at the files of a bunch of infants who had undergone MUA for torticollis, and whose treatment she had assisted in for the unnamed Swiss chiropractor with, and picked six of them to write up. She doesn’t explain why she chose these six cases. She does explain that the indication for MUA in each was arthrogenic newborn torticollis verified by x-ray, which the pediatric radiologist I spoke with laughed at. She also claims that each patient had failed to improve despite several weeks of standard treatment, which might have included chiropractic, osteopathy, or craniosacral therapy in addition to physical therapy or home-based interventions. I do not have confidence in her claim that conventional treatment was appropriately performed.
The six cases included male infants aged 4, 4.5, 5.5, 8.5, 9, and 10 months who each had descriptions consistent with classic congenital muscular torticollis without any need to invoke the arthrogenic label. Each had X-rays done to rule out a rare bony abnormality that would make neck manipulation dangerous, though three of them required CT scans for added reassurance. All of this radiation was likely completely unnecessary.
The infants were put to sleep using an IV agent and a breathing tube was placed under the care of a pediatric anesthesiologist. The author assisted the unnamed Swiss chiropractor in providing “mobilization” of each child’s first two cervical vertebrae “with minimal force and with no impulse”. This essentially means that they didn’t do a high-velocity low-amplitude adjustment but simply moved the neck around a bit while gently pushing on the neck. Although the noise claimed to be caused by breaking up adhesions was again mentioned, she did not actually say if it occurred in these cases.
The primary outcome that they looked at was active (patient moves on their own) and passive (the patient is moved by an examiner) range of motion of the neck. They documented this before and after MUA at visits 2 and 6 weeks later. Unsurprisingly, they found improvements. This is a problematic assessment, however, because this obviously was not blinded. It is easy to provide a little more or less force when assessing passive range of motion. Also, assessing active range of motion in infants, one of which had severe developmental delays, is very unreliable and subjective.
The secondary outcome was parental feedback at the 2 and 6 week visits and then by phone interview anywhere from 6 to 72 months later depending on their availability. This again is challenging to interpret because of the random timing of the follow-up but mostly the lack of blinding. The parents knew that their child had undergone MUA and they had to have known that this was an unusual intervention. It likely was not cheap and some of them had to drive for hours to seek out care from this chiropractor. So there was ample motivation to both perceive their child as being subjectively better and to perhaps become more adherent to more conventional treatment approaches.
The author concludes that MUA is safe and may be effective in the treatment of infants. Neither claim is justified by her case series. She points out that this was the first study of its kind and suggests that there are likely infants out there who have suffered harm because MUA wasn’t performed on them. She downplays the potential risk from radiation and general anesthesia.
The potential risk from radiation and general anesthesia
Important in any discussion of medical interventions is an assessment of the risks and benefits of both doing and not doing that intervention. In an infant, there is a small but real risk associated with exposure to radiation. The younger the patient, the more time there is for cellular damage from ionizing radiation to result in cancer. One CT scan using pediatric protocols is unlikely to cause lymphoma down the road, but we don’t know what the future holds for thess children regarding a potential need for additional studies for different indications.
More worrisome is the effect of general anesthesia on the developing brain. There have long been concerns based on a lot of animal data showing neurocognitive harm that exposure to anesthesia in young children may result in problems with learning and development later in life. The FDA and the International Anesthesia Research Society started SmartTots to help address these concerns.
What we have learned is that a single, brief (less than 1-2 hours) exposure is unlikely to cause any major issues, but we can’t say that it is completely safe in this regard. There may be minor delays or dips in a child’s eventual IQ that haven’t been picked up. The AAP recommends that general sedation be avoided in infants and toddlers under age 3 years unless it is deemed to be truly necessary. It often is, but a rational assessment of risk and benefit is necessary. As with radiation exposure, we don’t know if these children will need additional unrelated procedures that may require sedation in the near future.
In the case of MUA for infant torticollis, risk is far greater than potential benefit
CMT sometimes resolves on its own without intervention, although that is uncommon. Untreated CMT often results in permanent craniofacial asymmetry that is of cosmetic concern. So for most infants, treatment is strongly indicated.
More than 90% of cases will respond to simple interventions such as changes in positioning and handling, environment adaptations, and physical therapy at home if started before 12 months of age. Sometimes professional physical therapy is indicated, which almost always works in that subset of patients. The longer it takes for treatment to be initiated, the longer treatment takes to work, but it almost always works. Surgery is typically only required when treatment is initiated late but results in full function and resolution of craniofacial asymmetry that has developed in almost 90% of cases.
So essentially it is unlikely that conventional treatment failed the 6 infants described in the Paravicini paper. And I am extremely skeptical of claims that MUA truly hastened resolution. I am even more skeptical of the existence of arthrogenic torticollis in anything other than the minds of certain chiropractors.
This paper is useless as a means of answering the question of MUA. It’s a collection of a small number of self-selected anecdotes after the fact. There was no control group. The collection of outcome data was highly suspect. And again I want to be clear in my condemnation of the author, the University of Zurich, and the actual medical professionals that let this happen on their watch.

Chiropractic for Pediatric Seizures: Marketing in the Form of a Case Report
Here we are again with yet another case report full of limitations but making bold claims regarding chiropractic care of children with real medical conditions.
Clay Jones on August 19, 2022
Link

Here we are again with yet more chiropractic nonsense coated with a patina of science and published in a journal that was essentially created to serve the purpose of marketing bogus treatments for pediatric patients. Yes, I’ve taken you down this road before and I promise it’s as annoying to me as it likely is to you. And the sad truth is that I am confident this won’t be the last time.
The offending journal linked to above is the Journal of Pediatric, Maternal & Family Health – Chiropractic. Like the foundation that launched it, this particular waste of electrons and paper is dedicated to promoting the vertebral subluxation, a fictional entity often blamed for causing musculoskeletal complaints like neck and back pain as well as all manner of general health concerns. Barbara Loe Fisher, founder and president of the anti-vaccine National Vaccine Information Center, sits on the journal’s editorial board, as does my long time nemesis Joel Alcantara.
Alcantara is the research director for the International Pediatric Chiropractic Association. The ICPA is an organization that is similarly focused on the vertebral subluxation, believing that it is the nexus of the chiropractic multiverse. Alcantara has been promoting pediatric chiropractic care for decades by developing educational degree programs for chiropractors seeking ways to better fool parents through undeserved recognition as an expert in pediatric care. He has also done this by packing the chiropractic literature with scores of worthless case reports that are then used to promote pediatric chiropractic on practice websites around the world.
What’s the deal with case reports?
Case reports aren’t inherently bad things. At least they don’t have to be. They can serve a useful purpose despite their low rank on the hierarchy of scientific evidence used to support medical practice. They can challenge assumptions, generate hypotheses, and inform plans for future research. And when it comes to conditions that only effect a very small number of people, they might serve as the only available guide for clinical management.
Proper evaluation of any case report requires an understanding of their limitations. Even the most meticulously documented report is still an anecdote at heart, and thus can never be relied upon to establish whether an intervention truly is safe and effective. In the legitimate medical literature, case reports usually, but certainly not always, involve a treatment that has a reasonable degree of plausibility based on basic science. Still there are far too many variables that can’t be accounted for in this context, and over-reliance on case reports can result in false tracking.
When written to support a belief system, case reports are ultimately no more helpful than that time your mom told you that her friend from college treated her gout with a poultice of activated charcoal and ground flaxseed. Maybe she did. And maybe she thought it helped. Stories like that don’t tend to provide information such as what other medical treatments a person is using, what lifestyle factors might have changed, what the natural course of a condition looks like, and how symptoms might be impacted by the myriad non-specific factors we simplistically lump together as the “placebo effect”.
A high quality case report should discuss its own weaknesses. A high quality case report should make efforts to point out factors that might give the false impression that an intervention helped. And when a high quality case report is written up by a non-expert in the condition it focuses on, it would ideally include input from a relevant expert. Finally, a high quality case report should be built on a foundation of basic science and add something to our understanding of a particular condition or treatment approach.
A low quality case report: Resolution of Chronic Seizures in an Infant Undergoing Chiropractic Care for Vertebral Subluxation
The sole author of the case report I’m focusing on today is a fundamentalist private practice chiropractor in Missouri who epitomizes the manipulative use of a bogus ICPA certification for marketing purposes:
Dr. Nicole McCauley who is the only chiropractor within 250 miles of Springfield, MO who is a registered Pediatric Diplomate. This means she holds the highest level of education a chiropractor can receive in pediatric and perinatal care
Of even greater concern is how her practice website guides parents of acutely ill children to visit the website of a medical doctor in New York who promotes a wide variety of unscientific treatment modalities and is aggressively anti-vaccine, as discussed by Orac, who I believe is a sentient moisture vaporator from Tatooine, in this 2020 post. This is a prime example of two of the most serious concerns I have regarding pediatric chiropractic. Promoters are almost always vocally anti-vaccine and their patients face the risk of delays in appropriate care should they have a serious illness.
In the report, McCauley begins by briefly explaining seizures in the most simplistic and unhelpful way:
Seizures occur due to a disruption in the mechanisms responsible for balancing excitation and inhibition. Disrupting the mechanisms responsible for inhibition of firing or promotion of the mechanisms needed to facilitate excitation may both lead to seizures. Conversely, the opposite will usually bring about prevention of seizure activity.
This isn’t wrong, but it certainly leaves a lot out. I’m not arguing that the intro to a case report should be able to substitute for a review article on a condition, but she doesn’t even mention that it is an electrical disturbance or identify what these mechanisms might involve. It is in her best interest to keep it vague, however, because unscientific beliefs thrive in the gaps in our understanding. It doesn’t take much of an understanding of seizures and their numerous potential causes to grasp that there is zero plausibility behind claims that chiropractic subluxations or their treatment play a role.
The patient in this report is a 15-month-old child who supposedly began having seizures at the age of 6 months. McCauley claims that the child’s birth was traumatic, though the description of the delivery is rather benign:
The delivery was via C-Section at 37 weeks with an epidural administered. There was no fetal distress or meconium staining present. The infant cried strongly immediately, was pink all over, with arms and legs actively moving.
Not mentioned is why his mother had a c-section when she went into labor a bit early at 37 weeks. It is possible that the indication was some sign of fetal distress, which is perhaps why McCauley referred to the delivery as traumatic, but the baby clearly did fine. Meconium is the term used for the material built up in the fetal intestines while in the womb. Passage of meconium prior to delivery can be a sign that a baby is in distress, and its highly viscous nature makes it quite harmful if aspirated into the lungs. But again, nothing was stated that gives any impression of distress.
When fundamentalist chiropractors talk about birth trauma, they are typically referring to the forces applied to the head and neck during delivery that result in chiropractic subluxations. In their estimation, it doesn’t even have to be a forceps or vacuum-assisted delivery, or a particularly challenging extraction at all, to be traumatic. This is why many chiropractors promote chiropractic evaluation of all newborns, which always find subluxations, as a way to prevent a wide variety of future health problems.
Trauma is essentially meaningless as they define it, and there is no evidence whatsoever that pulling on the head during delivery can lead to seizures or any future health concern for that matter. Again, subluxations as imagined by chiropractors do not exist. This doesn’t mean that complications around delivery don’t sometimes result in injury to the brain and increase the risk of a child having seizures. But this occurs in the setting of decreased oxygen delivery to the brain, an entity know as hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy.
After an uneventful newborn course, it is implied that the child had no problems until he had some number of “seizure-like episodes” six months later. These were not described in any way, and we aren’t told when they stopped occurring. Eight months later, however, he began to have additional concerning episodes:
The mother reported events of unresponsiveness with associated limpness occurring upon waking from naps when diaper is changed after patient has had a bowel movement. He would also sometimes experience episodes consistent withbowel movements every other day. Each episode lasted approximately 1-2 minutes and happened 2-3x/week but there was no loss of consciousness.
He would suddenly become unreactive and unable to move parts of his body including all four limbs – though sometimes just the lower extremities or one side of the body. His otherwise strong neck muscle tone diminished, and he had adifficult time keeping his head up during an episode. His lips would become cyanotic during some of the episodes, but he did not appear to have any difficulty breathing.
He did not have any tonic-clonic movements or any other involuntary movements of his body with these episodes. Mother reported having checked his heart during an episode with no noticeable abnormalities. She noted his lips would occasionally turn blue with episodes.
A brief tangent on scary and unexplained events in infants
One of the most frustrating clinical scenarios faced by pediatricians, particularly those working in hospitals, is something known as the Brief Resolved Unexplained Event (BRUE). In my roughly 20 years of practicing pediatric medicine, I have lost count of how many infants I’ve admitted to the hospital after a parent witnessed a concerning change in their child’s breathing, color, mental status, or muscle tone and then urgently sought medical care. Most came into the emergency department via ambulance, surrounded by tearful caregivers.
There are many reasons why these cases are so challenging. First off, they sometimes involve a truly dangerous condition with a list of potential offenders that is extremely long. Second, the child’s caregiver is almost always terrified because they have the perception that their child almost died. Many believe that some intervention done at home, such as blowing in a child’s face or even performing what they think was effective rescue breaths or chest compression, is what prevented death. They are often understandably worried that their child will die unexpectedly in the near future. Third, and the evidence is quite clear on this, these children are almost always completely fine, nothing dangerous actually happened, and their risk of unexpected death is no higher than in any other healthy child.
Here is where it gets really complicated. By definition, a BRUE doesn’t have any obvious red flags for serious pathology, such as when a child required (or is still requiring) high quality CPR performed by paramedics/emergency department personnel, or the description of the event by caregivers is classic for a generalized tonic-clonic seizure. Also by definition, the child has to look fine in the ED and can’t have any historical risk factors such as prematurity or known medical conditions that put them at risk for sudden death. So at a minimum, these kids all need a thorough physical exam and review of the child’s personal and family medical history. If something comes up, it isn’t a BRUE.
Sometimes if there is a very clear story from a caregiver that reveals a benign event, such as a bit of gagging during a feed, most of us feel comfortable providing reassurance, education, and discharge papers. But despite the fact that labs, imaging, and extended observation as an inpatient almost never end up revealing something to worry about, many babies still undergo a significant work up and get admitted to be watched on monitors for a day. As a hospitalist, this can be quite frustrating because in many cases this unnecessary evaluation doesn’t even provide reassurance for caregivers. Sometimes it has the opposite effect and increases the likelihood that a healthy child will be perceived as vulnerable. This increases anxiety in the home and the risk that the child will face more unnecessary medical interventions in the future.
So what is going on with these babies that scares their caregivers so much? Ultimately we don’t know, in part because we are relying on the observations of witnesses who were understandably not focused on taking meticulous notes. I’m confident that had I been at the bedside during the event, I probably wouldn’t have been concerned. But they happen at the child’s home, usually in the middle of the night and in a dark or dimly lit room. It is often the caregiver’s first baby. Essentially what I’m getting at is that most of these are probably misinterpretations of normal infant behaviors or a perception of reality altered by psychosocial factors.
When it comes to BRUE evaluations, we have to consider a host of frightening possibilities, like sepsis, meningitis, seizures, cardiac arrhythmias, metabolic diseases, ingestions, and even child abuse. But again, these are rarely to blame. We then have to communicate effectively with caregivers and hopefully guide them towards comfort with some amount of uncertainty while still counseling them on what red flags to watch out for. But we have avoid planting any seeds of anxiety or the believe that their child is at high risk of some bad outcome. We are also sometimes compelled to admit these babies after extensive evaluations that weren’t needed for observation that isn’t likely to be helpful. All of this adds to the moral fatigue that many of us experience on a daily basis.
But I digress.
What do BRUEs have to do with this case report?
The description of the events provided in the case report I was supposed to be focusing on in this post fits that of a BRUE quite perfectly, at least initially. The BRUE diagnosis doesn’t apply once multiple events have been witnessed or if a child is older than a year of age. In general, it’s just easier for parents to mistake normal behaviors for pathology in babies than it is in a toddler.
This doesn’t mean that toddlers always have a dangerous condition when a caregiver believes that they were about to die. If they look good in the emergency department, they also usually don’t have any serious pathology to worry about. And the same concerns regarding psychosocial influences on caregiver perception can still apply. But this is always a diagnosis of exclusion. Assumptions can lead to missed diagnoses and bad outcomes.
Though the case report assumes that the events in question are seizures, as described by McCauley they do not really fit well into any known seizure category. They are labelled as atonic seizures, which are also commonly referred to as “drop attacks”, but we don’t know by who. The diagnosis is likely based entirely on the caregiver’s understanding of the situation, which may not be accurate. It would be very helpful to know what the actual medical professionals involved in this child’s care thought about these recurrent events of clinical concern, particularly any neurologist that evaluated him.
The report is clear that there were no classic tonic-clonic episodes witnessed by caregivers. These seizures involve the stiffening and rhythmic jerking of muscles that most people are familiar with and used to be known as grand mal seizures. The description is also inconsistent with all other seizure types as well, though I get why someone at some point might have mentioned atonic seizures, as they involve loss of muscle tone and are the closest to what is described. This label could have been something that the patient’s caregivers, or perhaps even McCauley herself, applied after a clumsy internet search. Supporting this is the description of the child’s medical evaluation prior to being brought to see McCauley:
He had a number of medical tests performed including two EEG’s that were interpreted as normal. An MRI and ECG were also done and noted to be normal. He was examined for heart murmur, abnormal biventricular size and function,abnormal valvular structure and function, and large intracardiac shunting due to an Aortic Arch Obstruction. All results were negative. There was no definitive medical diagnosis given.
A EEG that is obtained when there is no apparent seizure activity at the time is often normal. This is because EEGs are often ordered because of the suspicion that a seizure occurred and the movements of concern are often not true seizures. But even patients who ultimately end up being diagnosed with a seizure disorder can have a normal EEG between seizures. But it is unlikely that a child at that age and having events that frequently would have a normal EEG if they truly had epilepsy.
Atonic seizures do involve a sudden loss of muscle tone, so there is that, and they do typically start in childhood. But they represent less than 1% of seizures, almost always occur along with other types of seizures, and usually occur in the context of Lennox-Gastaut or Dravet syndrome, which are severe, very difficulty to treat, and associated with development delays and numerous other health problems. So while I can’t say with certainty that this never had any seizures, I would put it in the very unlikely category. The pediatric neurologist I consulted with, after reading the report, agreed.
When evaluated by McCauley, the child was found to have a few retained primitive reflexes (bogus but beyond the scope of this post) and, you’ll be shocked to learn, subluxations involving the “right S/I joint, T9, C1 and right Coronal Suture”. After eight months and 17 adjustments of his spine and skull, as well as parent driven home therapy involving stimulation of his feet and cheeks to fix those retained primitive reflexes, the supposed seizures gradually decreased in frequency until they were gone for good. His parents were also advised to restrict sugar, wheat, and dairy in his diet. This of course raises another concern with pediatric chiropractic, which is the potential for unproven or even harmful dietary recommendations, but also with case reports like this. When there are multiple interventions, how do we know what might have helped?
After a discussion including the description of a few earlier case reports involving chiropractic and seizures, each similarly worthless, McCauley does briefly get into potential limitations:
The author was unable to find cases in the scientific literature specifically describing the patient’s symptomatology. Further limitations included the use of a single case study design which cannot be generalized to the population, in addition to not having a control group to rule out maturation as a factor in improvement of chronic seizures. Moreover, further research is necessary to determine the effectiveness of chiropractic care in resolving chronic seizures in infants.
I would have added a bit to this section. But she does include what is most likely at play in this child’s apparent improvement. They got older. If I had to guess, there were a few scary, BRUE type events when he was an infant. This primed his caregiver to potentially perceive normal infant and then toddler behavior, such as breath holding spells for example, as seizure activity. He had an extensive evaluation out of an abundance of cation that was reassuring, but not reassuring enough. Enter the chiropractor and their nonsense. Over the next 8 months he outgrew the behaviors and chiropractic care had nothing at all to do with it. Just time.
McCauley came to a different conclusion:
The results of this case study and relevant research pertaining to chiropractic’s role in reduction and resolution of chronic seizures support the hypothesis thatsubluxation reduction may have a positive impact on the symptoms associated with epilepsy.
Conclusion: This is why we can’t have nice things!
Case reports aren’t completely useless, unlike chiropractic care of pediatric patients. You just have to take them with a grain of pink Himalayan salt and understand their limitations. But if they involve an intervention so thoroughly lacking in basic science support and prior plausibility as adjusting subluxations to treat epilepsy, they are probably just trying to sell you something.

Chiropractic and Sudden Infant Death Syndrome
Clay Jones on March 1, 2013
Link

As a pediatrician caring for hospitalized children, I deal with fear on a daily basis. My day is saturated with it. I encounter fear in a variety of presentations, with parental fear the most obvious but probably least impactful on my management decisions. I do spend a lot of time and mental energy calming the fears of others but more managing my own, both struggling to prevent it from biasing my thought process and harnessing it as a productive motivational force. I devote a significant amount of effort towards teaching residents and students the practice of inpatient pediatric medicine and fear can be a valuable teaching tool when used appropriately.
So I admit that I take advantage of fear to a certain extent in my practice. Most pediatricians do. Maybe we all do. Proper informed consent, for instance, must include potential poor health outcomes related to medical intervention or the refusal of them. I accept that fear is an impetus for seeking medical care. Parents should be afraid of poor health outcomes from vaccine-preventable illnesses, for example. They should be made aware of the repercussions of poor adherence to home asthma management or of not placing their child in a proper car seat every time they put them in a car. Fear can serve the greater good.
But there is a difference between these unavoidable aspects of science-based medical care and the abuse of fear by practitioners of irregular medicine.
Robert T. Carroll, in his excellent book on critical thinking, Unnatural Acts: Critical Thinking, Skepticism, and Science Exposed, discusses the role of fear in decision making:
Nothing can motivate people like fear. Manipulators of beliefs and actions have known this for millennia…Advertisers and phony healers use fear to sell us worthless products. Politicians play on our fears to manipulate us. For some, fear is the weapon of first resort.
In the absence of a plausible mechanism of action and any compelling evidence, what does an alternative medicine practitioner have in his armamentarium? I have little doubt that most readers of this website could competently rattle off a number of reasons why a patient might seek out the care of a chiropractor for a variety of conditions, for example, and why the patient might believe the treatments were effective. Any treatment after all, even the most outlandish, might appear to work when used for conditions that wax and wane in severity, are impacted by subjective variables such as stress and anxiety, or that can spontaneously resolve.
But what about when the condition isn’t self limited and doesn’t wax and wane in severity? How does a bogus alternative practice approach something which isn’t significantly impacted by the many recognized placebo effects? What about terminal cancer or ALS where with even the best science-based care there is no hope of a cure? What about a condition where death is a prerequisite for diagnosis?
The answer is that chiropractors, homeopaths and their ilk don’t simply focus on the diagnosis and treatment of illnesses, some of which only exist in their own fantasies. A very consistent and seemingly across the board claim is that of success in the prevention of illness. It is one of their most widespread selling points, in fact, and often spouted in the same breath as claims that conventional medical practitioners only focus on symptom management in their Western and overly materialistic approach to healthcare. Unless, of course, the tools of our materialistic approach appear to lend support to their personal belief system. Then science is tops.
Naturally readers of this blog will easily recognize straw man arguments such as that. All practitioners of science-based medicine understand the pivotal role of prevention in caring for their patients. There is a wealth of solid scientific data to support general lifestyle recommendations on such things as smoking cessation, healthy diets and daily exercise. A homeopath may give some of the same advice but they are only repeating bits and pieces of what they learned from medical research. They are broken clocks that feel no shame in taking credit for the results of decades of good science.
There are also a wide variety of well-supported disease-specific recommendations that are vital in preventing complications, such as daily penicillin prophylaxis against bacterial sepsis in patients with sickle cell disease. We also are big supporters of vaccines, a science-based intervention that has saved millions of lives. Thinking of this aspect of preventative care only serves to make me more infuriated when reading posts on the naturopathic and chiropractic communities’ attempts to gain primary care practitioner status. What they don’t know might just kill you.
But nothing frustrates me more than chiropractic claims regarding SIDS prevention.
What is SIDS?
When it comes to inducing fear in parents, both new and experienced, few entities are as effective as sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS). SIDS is the leading cause of death in children aged one month to one year in the United States, affecting roughly 2,000 infants annually, and is about as bad as it comes in the world of pediatrics. Although there are risk factors, even some modifiable ones, there is no way to effectively predict which infants are at high risk. There is no screening test for SIDS and we simply do not have a firm grasp of why it occurs in some children and not others, or of the underlying pathophysiology.
To meet the strict diagnostic criteria of SIDS, an autopsy, death scene investigation and review of the clinical history must be performed. These are all very important steps in the process because there are a number of medical conditions, such as abuse, accidental suffocation, and a variety of underlying disease processes, which can mimic SIDS. As our diagnostic capabilities have improved over the past few decades, a large number of deaths that would have been classified as SIDS are now attributed to one of these other conditions. That and the success of science-based public health campaigns like the “Back to Sleep” initiative have led to a dramatic decrease in the incidence of SIDS since the early 90’s.
The fact that SIDS occurs about half as frequently than it did in 1992, however, is no consolation to the parents of a deceased child. The unexpected death of a young child without a satisfactory explanation is a tragedy that is hard for those who have not experienced it to wrap their heads around. Having to tell a family that there is no explanation, leaving them to potentially blame themselves despite our best efforts to educate them otherwise, is one of the most challenging and painful aspects of pediatric medicine.
Not surprisingly, SIDS is an outcome commonly cited by both parents and medical professionals as a significant source of anxiety. I personally have encountered hundreds of parents that have expressed significant fear of their young infant passing away while they sleep, many of which engaged in potentially harmful practices such as foregoing sleep to watch their child for signs of breathing cessation or bed sharing in the hopes of preventing SIDS. Equally unsurprising are the plethora of unscientific concepts and practices invented to both deal with that anxiety and, despicably, to profit from it.
Why does SIDS happen?
The short and frustrating answer to the question of why SIDS happens is that we don’t know. But this doesn’t mean we don’t know anything or that our knowledge isn’t advancing. We actually have learned a great deal about the pathophysiology of SIDS over the past several years.
The long and perhaps equally frustrating answer to the above question is that SIDS is a polygenic, multifactorial condition, with genetic, environmental, and behavioral/sociocultural contributing factors. Some make use of a “triple-risk” model, meaning SIDS occurs in infants with an underlying vulnerability that experience a trigger event at a vulnerable developmental stage of the central nervous or immune system. Most SIDS occurs between the 2nd and 4th months of life, a period of time during which significant developmental changes in the infant brain take place.
Malfunctioning of the infant’s ability to arouse is almost certainly a critical part of the process and researchers are homing in on underlying defects in receptors for the neurotransmitter serotonin in areas of the brainstem that impact arousal and cardiorespiratory responses. There appears to be a deficiency in serotonin and its primary biosynthetic enzyme, particularly in the medulla, an area of the brainstem involved in a wide range of autonomic processes. The autonomic nervous system works without conscious control to regulate functions like respiration, heart rate and digestion to name just a few.
The role of genetics is less clear as there is evidence to support and refute involvement. Siblings of SIDS patients are not significantly more likely to be affected and there is a lack of concordance in twins. But a number of gene polymorphisms have been discovered in SIDS victims that may increase susceptibility by negatively impacting myocardial conduction, serotonergic transmission, or some other vital process. Thus while genetics may not play a large role overall, some infants may have a genetic predisposition and succumb when exposed to certain environmental triggers.
SIDS risk factors and environmental triggers
From decades of epidemiological data, we have become aware of a number of risk factors, both positive and negative, and possible inciting events that play a role in SIDS. Some of these risk factors can even be avoided, the most well-known being the prone sleeping position (on the tummy). When pediatricians in the United States began recommending that all infants be put to sleep on their backs, the incidence of SIDS was cut in half. Other modifiable risk factors include maternal smoking during and after pregnancy (all smoke exposure is bad, not just from mothers), maternal drug/alcohol abuse, loose or excessive blankets/pillows, bed-sharing and overheating.
Not every risk factor is completely avoidable, such as young maternal age and preterm and/or low weight birth. Actions that may actually protect against SIDS include room-sharing, pacifier use, breastfeeding, fan use and immunizations. Possible environmental triggers include prone positioning during sleep, cardiac dysfunction and infection.
Again, we don’t know exactly why SIDS occurs. Its mysterious nature and the severe emotional impact of the possibility of it occurring on parents is a perfect set up for the false promises and bogus claims made by the alt med community. Chiropractors in particular like to claim SIDS as falling under their purview.
Why does SIDS happen according to chiropractors?
Not surprisingly, the chiropractic community has come up with their very own hypothesis regarding the etiology of SIDS. And they think that children at high risk of SIDS can be identified, if only they were brought in for examination as soon as possible after birth. Naturally this hypothesis revolves around a vague notion of dysfunction of the vertebral column, in this specific case the relationship between the base of the skull and first cervical vertebra, or atlas. The fictional chiropractic subluxation is invoked as a causal factor, as well as brainstem “microtrauma” that is reminiscent of N-Rays and Ocsillococcus. When all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail as the old saying goes.
The internet is overflowing with the chiropractic viewpoint on pediatric conditions such as SIDS, both on individual practice websites and the pages of large organizations such as the ICA’s Council on Chiropractic Pediatrics. The ICA likes to claim expertise in pediatric care, even offering training to chiropractors wishing to become a Diplomate of Chiropractic Pediatrics. According to their online information:
The subject areas covered in the syllabus include all aspects of pediatrics —from pregnancy, birth, infancy to adolescence. Each stage of pregnancy and of a child’s development are covered in-depth so the practicing doctor of chiropractic acquires greater skills and competencies in a wide range of evaluative, diagnostic and assessment procedures, as well as corrective and adjustment skills for different stages of pre-natal care, neonatal and at different ages to adolescence. Also included are expanded modules on radiology, nutrition, functional medicine and immunology, sports injuries, orthopedics, neurology, and special needs. A unique feature of the curriculum is a mandatory observational/training weekend at a chiropractic center for special needs children under multi-disciplinary care.
Yes, there apparently is a chiropractic center for special needs children. The ICA considers enough training to achieve “the expertise to understand and apply appropriate clinical protocols in all situations and provides care that is safe, appropriate and always of a high professional standard”, to be roughly 360 hours spread out over three years. What they call a three year course I call the first four weeks of my residency in pediatrics. Add to that the fact that many of their modules are focused on manipulation techniques such as craniosacral therapy, and that none are taught by an actual pediatrician (they do have a doctor of naturopathy teaching nutrition), and it should be obvious that anyone holding this distinction should be considered dangerous in the presence of ill children.
How do chiropractors know what causes SIDS?
In researching the chiropractic take on SIDS, I found that several studies were discussed but one study was most consistently held up as evidence to support their claims. Published in 2002 by L.E. Koch in Forensic Science International, the study involved documenting what happens when some infants are poked in the neck. I truly wish that I was kidding or exaggerating.
Koch, based on a smaller 1998 study also published by him in the same journal, developed the hypothesis that mechanical irritation of the high-cervical spine might play a role in SIDS. He had observed that infants undergoing atlanto-occipital chiropractic adjustments developed “vegetative reactions” involving flushing, sweating, hyperextension and even apnea (cessation of breathing). The 2002 study looked at 695 infants between 1 and 12 months of age also being submitted to manipulation of the high cervical spinal column for chiropractic diagnoses. What did they find?
They reported that nearly half of the subjects experienced a significant change in heart rate, with 40% of those subjects experiencing a decrease by 15-83%. According to the authors, younger infants (less than three months) were more likely to have more extreme drops in heart rate. They found that 12% of the subjects experienced apnea (despite an earlier caveat that their data on respiratory rate was unreliable). This all sounds very concerning, right?
The authors state that pronounced drops in heart rate are known to precede occurrences of SIDS. This is true in the sense that dead kids don’t tend to have heart beats, but it isn’t established that severe bradycardia (abnormally low heart rate) is causally associated with SIDS. These infants may stop breathing first, which then leads to physiologic changes that injure the brain and stop the heart. They may have sudden cessation of breathing and heartbeat. Or perhaps their heart slows down first. We just don’t know, and neither do chiropractors.
They state that bradycardia precedes apnea (again, we don’t know that), which is followed by gasping for air which, they claim, fails to evoke an arousal response. As previously mentioned in this post, arousal mechanism dysfunction likely does play a key role in SIDS, but there is no evidence that their described pattern is what really happens. Infants who die of SIDS are notoriously quiet. Several documented cases of SIDS have occurred while being watched in daycare centers and there have been cases described of SIDS occurring in hospitals while on monitors, just not enough to reliably know what happens to them.
According to the authors, “the atlanto-occipital region controls crawling, movement during the night, vagal autonomic nerve function, phrenic nerve function and vertebral artery blood flow.” There is some truth to this but it is still classic chiropractic nonsense. Injury to the spinal cord/brainstem at that level could result in paralysis, fatal inability to breath and stroke, but chiropractors aren’t talking about actual injury, they are talking about the chiropractic subluxation. This is a fictional entity without validity or a reliable means of diagnosis. Chiropractors often base their determination of the presence of a subluxation on how the muscles feel, skin temperature differences, leg length discrepancies, and x-ray imaging of which ten different chiropractors might give ten different interpretations. This study only in a roundabout way might support these claims. We are supposed to make the connection that when someone, in this case a chiropractor, irritates the high cervical spine it is essentially mimicking what happens when a child has a subluxation in that area or when they are in a prone sleeping position.
The upper cervical manipulation in this study took the form of a brief “impulse” to the side of the neck just under the base of the skull using the edge of a finger. The amount of force applied is described as ranging from 30 to 70 Newtons (roughly 6 to 15 pounds of force) and sounds like a fairly low velocity push over about half a second. This would have no lasting impact whatsoever on the alignment of the spine or skull. The authors do not describe the state of the subjects after the application of the impulse outside of heart rate (kind of), respiratory rate (not really), and the presence or absence of flushing. We don’t know if the subjects were irritated and crying, awake, asleep, alert and interactive or demonstrating evidence of pain such as facial grimace to just give a few examples.
There was no control group in this observational study. It is worthless. I believe they have done a mediocre job documenting random noise. A comparison to infants undergoing ICA-endorsed chiropractic tummy tickles would have been more interesting. But I will forge ahead. Resting heart rate in infants under a year of age can range from 80 to 150 beats per minute with the higher values typically seen in those less than 3 months of age. There is significant heart rate variability in infants. There is heart rate variability in everyone, particularly associated with breathing cycles (up with inhalation and down with exhalation), but it is more pronounced in infants.
The authors compared each subject’s resting heart rate with the heart rate during (not sure how they measured heart rate over 600 milliseconds) and after the impulse. The average change in heart rate documented was an increase of 14%. That would be an increase of 16 beats per minute for a baseline of 120 beats per minute. Some children had significant drops by as much as 40% to 83%. That would take the same child with a baseline of 120 beats per minute down to 20. That is severe and life-threatening bradycardia. But that isn’t what happened in this study.
These drops in heart rate were noticed over a few seconds and then quickly corrected over a few seconds or less. Any nursing or medical student should be able to tell you what a big mistake that is. I am generally not pleased (that is how we describe being furious in pediatrics) when I catch someone taking a pulse for six seconds and multiplying by ten. You will often mistakenly diagnose abnormally low or high heart rate doing so in a child. They noticed more of this in the subjects less than three months of age. Of course they did because the heart rate is faster at that age and more prone to a random error because of increased variability.
The authors note the occurrence of apnea in 12% of the subjects, making their conclusions sound all the more impressive. They note that apnea usually occurred with a delay of several seconds after the impulse. The authors note that because of “ethical reasons” they did not actually wait to see if the infant would resume breathing on their own so they “restored normal breathing immediately after the onset of the apnea by blowing air into the baby’s face.” But they defined apnea as cessation of respiratory effort that exceeded the time it took for the infant to go through one normal breathing cycle.
The breathing or respiratory cycle is the act of taking a breath in and letting it out. The average time it takes for a single cycle is easy to determine. A healthy young infant may breathe anywhere from 30 up to 50-60 times each minute, thus a respiratory cycle typically lasts 1-2 seconds. Pediatricians define apnea in an infant as cessation of respiration longer than 20 seconds or shorter if associated with bradycardia (the real kind), cyanosis (turning blue), or marked hypotonia (floppy). They have made up their own definition of apnea, which if followed would mean that every single young infant has repeated daily occurrences because pauses in breathing are normal.
This study is being used by chiropractors all over the country, including state chiropractic organizations, to scare parents into having their newborn infants “screened” for subluxations to prevent SIDS. Parents are warned that their child may have a life threatening subluxation and immediate correction is necessary to prevent the death of their child. These recommendations are not based on good science but cherry-picked poorly designed research and anecdotal observations. Once in the chiropractor’s office, parents are often exposed to a variety of anti-medicine or anti-vaccine propaganda, and they may be less likely to seek out medical care when there truly is something wrong with their child. There is more harm than merely the loss of money.
I found one chiropractor discussing the topic of SIDS in an online video. In it he describes how birth trauma leads to subluxations. He also describes treating a 4-hour-old infant with temperature instability, which is truly terrifying to a former neonatal hospitalist who has cared for many septic newborns whose only early manifestation was the inability to maintain a normal temperature. Luckily most instances of this occur secondary to the baby being left unwrapped and/or wet and not to illness. His video is a classic example of how someone we can be fooled into thinking a treatment has a true effect.
Trauma experienced at birth is often blamed for the development of the subluxations, which seems plausible at first glance. I have cared for many children with injuries related to the birthing process. Broken clavicles, injured nerves, and complications from bleeding are all known risks. But there is no evidence that birth trauma is related to chiropractic subluxations, because they don’t exist, or to the subsequent development of SIDS. In rare cases some children do die from complications of birth, but that is not SIDS. And the type of birth, C-section versus vaginal, does not appear to be related to SIDS.
And now a dose of reality
So what can be done to decrease the risk of SIDS? The following list comes from the most recent AAP Policy Statement:
     1.  Back to sleep for every sleep
     2.  Use a firm sleep surface
     3.  Share a room but not a bed
     4.  Keep soft objects and loose bedding out of the crib
     5.  Get prenatal care
     6.  Avoid any smoke exposure during pregnancy and after birth
     7.  Avoid alcohol and illicit drug use during pregnancy and after birth
     8.  Breastfeed
     9.  Offer a pacifier at onset of sleep (you don’t need to put it back in if it falls out while asleep)
     10.  Avoid overheating
     11.  Immunize your babies
     12.  Avoid commercial devices marketed to reduce the risk of SIDS
     13.  Avoid use of home cardiorespiratory monitors as a strategy to reduce the risk of SIDS
     14.  Supervised awake tummy time
SIDS is not common. Many pediatricians and family practice doctors will go their entire career without encountering it. Chiropractors don’t see a fraction of the number of pediatric patients that physicians do, so it would be extremely unlikely for them to have a patient die from it either. This can lead to a false impression that an intervention is effective at preventing SIDS. I worry that parents receiving false reassurance that their child is protected might feel less inclined to follow evidence-based recommendations.

Chiropractic Care of an Infant with Erb’s Palsy: Another Worthless Case Report
A recently published case report claims that chiropractic care helped heal an infant’s paralyzed arm. In reality, the chiropractor took credit for the natural course of a well-known medical condition and luckily didn’t make things worse for the patient.
Clay Jones on August 6, 2021
Link

At the risk of sounding like a bit of a broken record, chiropractic management of any infant is at best unhelpful. Unfortunately, it can expose these children to the indirect risk of delayed appropriate medical evaluation and treatment as well as their caregivers to anti-vaccine propaganda. At worst, there is the risk of direct injury. The case I am going to discuss today veers perilously close to a worst case scenario.
I was planning to write a post about the myriad ways in which the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic has harmed children, and perhaps even resulted in some benefits in a few unique (but still not worth it) ways. This is a fascinating issue and the more I looked into it the more I found to potentially discuss. I was just at the point of making the decision to put a pin in the topic in order to allow more time for reflection when some new “research” from the word of infant chiropractic was brought to my attention. As usual, I couldn’t resist.
A follower/followee of mine on twitter alerted me to an article from the Australian Spinal Research Foundation, a fundamentalist chiropractic organization devoted to the worship of the chiropractic subluxation:
At ASRF, we’re developing a clear understanding of vertebral subluxation and its effects, by funding scientifically testable research drawing on the philosophical tenets of chiropractic. We lead our profession by facilitating global research in the areas of vertebral subluxation science and the clinical benefits of chiropractic care for the human population.
The article in question is the press release for a case report published in the Asia-Pacific Chiropractic Journal, a new open access journal designed specifically for mobile platforms, and it is exactly what you would expect it to be. But before I get into it, here is an interesting video describing the journal that does not exactly inspire confidence.
In the ASRF press release, the author starts out with a comment on infant birth trauma and then briefly describes an anatomical region known as the brachial plexus. It quickly goes off course:
If you’ve ever suffered from pain in your arms and hands after a long day hunched over a computer, or suffered from chronic pain in your arms and hands at all, it could be due to this thing called the brachial plexus. Up in your neck, where the C5 and C6 Vertebra unite (at Erb’s point), a rich bunch of nerve fibres slip through a small gap and then out to your arms and hands. When we slump forward into a posture where our head is forward and our shoulders are rounded forward, we can make this gap even smaller causing pain.
The brachial plexus, a complex network of nerves which also contains branches originating at C7, C8, and T1, is unfortunately placed and injury with subsequent pain/weakness/loss of sensation are fairly common. But they don’t occur because of bad posture. Bad posture as a cause of pain or health problems is largely a myth propagated by chiropractors and other so-called “posturologists”. Friend of SBM Paul Ingraham did an excellent deep dive analysis of the role of posture in neck and back pain at his website that is worth checking out.
Brachial plexus injuries typically occur because of trauma, usually in the setting of participation in contact sports or involvement in a car or bicycle accident. The mechanism of injury is an impact that pushes the head away from the shoulder and stretches the neck forcefully. They can be mild and quickly resolve (stingers and burners) or cause long term weakness or even paralysis of the involved arm and hand (brachial plexus palsy).
Neonatal brachial plexus palsy (NBPP) is a form of brachial plexus injury diagnosed around the time of birth. And while a minority of cases can result from intrauterine injury, and some occur during easy deliveries, the biggest risk factor for NBPP is a difficult extraction requiring forceful lateral flexion of the neck when a baby’s shoulders are stuck in the pelvis during delivery, something called shoulder dystocia. It’s also not uncommon for NBPP to be accompanied by fracture of the clavicle or humerus on the involved side. As the author of the press release points out, the common term for most cases of NBPP is Erb palsy, although there are other types that go by different names.
A classic Erb’s palsy presentation occurs when the affected shoulder is held in internal rotation, with extension and pronation of the elbow and the wrist in flexion. It can result in some paralysis of some arm muscles, specifically biceps, deltoid, supraspinatus, and brachioradialis muscles which all sit around the upper arm and shoulder area. The degree of injury can vary, with mild cases resolving independently within a few weeks while severe cases may struggle to completely resolve. In more recent years it is understood that there may be residual defects, such as muscle weakness, shoulder and elbow contractures, bony deformity and shortening of the involved arm.
This explanation is good enough for our purposes, although it isn’t entirely accurate. Only about a third of infants with NBPP have a complete Erb palsy, known as Erb palsy plus, with injury to exiting spinal nerves at C5, C6, and C7 and a classic “waiter’s tip” phenomenon where the hand and fingers are flexed. The classic Erb palsy, where hand and finger extension is spared, is more common and is diagnosed in about half of cases. NBPP in its most severe form can involve the entirety of the arm and hand, and even present with paralysis of the diaphragm in rare cases.
But what does this have to do with chiropractic? Nothing, of course, but the press release claims that NBPP is a reason for having an infant checked after birth. Such a bold claim requires compelling evidence, however, and they’ve got just what the chiropractor ordered!
A recent case study looked at the instance of a 9-week-old girl that presented with right Erb’s palsy which had been diagnosed 2 days post-birth. Since birth, she had no movement in her right arm, and after consulting with a specialist it was decided they would wait and see if it resolved spontaneously (independent of treatment). It wasn’t expected this would happen and the infant’s mother sought chiropractic care as a final hope, but without much expectation.
That is unfortunate, but not terribly surprising. There is so much bogus chiropractic marketing to be found online, and I’ve written about a lot of it over the years. Of course some caregivers are going to fall for it. Claiming that the patient’s mother sought chiropractic care as a final hope is also unfortunate. It’s likely just manipulative language used by the author to promote chiropractic, but it could have been how the mother actually felt. If so, that’s potentially a failure of communication between her and the child’s pediatrician or neurosurgeon.
The gold standard approach to NBPP is to allow a considerable amount of time to pass, typically 3 to 9 months, before considering surgery. This is because the condition improves on its own in most cases and surgery is not at all guaranteed to benefit the patient. That doesn’t mean nothing is done to help the patient, of course. Physical and occupational therapies to prevent muscle contractures and promote muscle strengthening are standard components of care. Obviously we are relying on a biased interpretation of the facts of the case, so who knows what really went down, but the patient’s mother should not have felt hopeless at only 9 weeks out from the injury.
The press release goes on to give some unhelpful details on the patient’s injury and then reveals that the “Gonstead chiropractor” evaluating the child found a subluxation. Who saw that coming? Only the subluxation that they found was in the sacrum at the other end of the spine! But don’t worry, I just know that they will have a clever explanation for how that is supposed to be causing injury to nerves in the neck. And the child miraculously improved after only one treatment, which is, and trust me on this, quite literally impossible. The author points out that generalizations can’t be made based on one case report, but clearly believes that this specific child was cured with chiropractic and able to avoid an almost certain surgical fate.
It is possible that the child’s neurosurgeon had told the mother that surgery would likely be necessary. In order to hazard a guess regarding that possibility, however, we would need to know more details about just how severe the injury was. In other words, does “no movement in her right arm” really mean no movement at all in the entire arm, including the hand and fingers? I’m curious if there will be a more detailed explanation of the child’s diagnosis and prognosis in the case report, and we’ll get to it soon…I promise.
But first, a bit on the Gonstead system.
What makes the Gonstead System so special?
There are hundreds of chiropractic techniques, each with its own name and sometimes religious-like adherents. But there is a lot of overlap between them, and many have only very minor differences. They essentially boil down to a marketing scheme, with believers in specific techniques often promoting their preferred flavor of nonsense as the one true technique. It’s like Highlander without the beheadings, although not always for lack of trying.
The Gonstead System is very special, according to the people who practice it. It’s so special in fact that not just any chiropractor can handle its specialness. How special.
Gonstead procedures are the result of extensive clinical research by Clarence S. Gonstead, founder of the world famous Gonstead Clinic of Chiropractic in Mount Horeb, Wisconsin and his associates. Doctor Gonstead’s fifty-five years of continuous practice and over four million chiropractic adjustments resulted in the most complete method of biomechanical analysis available for use by today’s doctors of chiropractic. So why don’t all chiropractors use this technique? Because the analysis takes more time and mastering the art of delivering a specific adjustment takes a LOT of practice and dedication.
I always get a kick out of the absurd numbers of adjustments claimed to have been performed by some chiropractors in their marketing efforts. Let’s break this one down. Four million adjustments over 55 years comes out to almost 73 thousand every year. That’s about 200 adjustments every day if he didn’t take any days off. Even taking into account that he very likely “found” more than one subluxation to adjust in many if not most of his patients, that is still a ridiculous claim.
Gonstead’s extensive clinical research helped him establish 5 criteria to detect vertebral subluxations:
     1.  Visualizing subtle changes in posture and movement. This of course allows the chiropractor to see something that indicates a problem in every patient.
     2.  Using a Nervoscope to detect uneven heat distribution across spinal bones with subluxations. They claim that this represents inflammation or nerve pressure. In reality, it represents how hard the device is pressed against the skin and allows for a subluxation to always be found.
     3.  Palpation of the spine while the patient is still in order to feel swelling, tenderness, or tight muscles. These findings are extremely nebulous and allow a practitioner to feel whatever they expect to feel. Let’s just say that what I would consider swelling is very different than what they would.
     4.  Palpation of the spine while the patient is moving or bending in order to feel how easily each spinal segment moves in various directions. Same problems as number 3.
     5.  X-rays. Because of course. And full spine films too. Line up ten blinded chiropractors and you will likely get ten difference interpretations of these films. They are a Horshack test, only with more ionizing radiation.
Finally…the case of the 9-week-old with the self-limited condition
Now for the case report itself. It’s bad. It’s read bad. It’s full of boilerplate Gonstead System scripture, it makes outlandish claims regarding the mechanism of action for chiropractic adjustments benefiting the patient, and it mentions but then completely disregards the significant limitations inherent in relying solely on an anecdote to support a conclusion that chiropractic helped this baby…(checks notes)…regenerate spinal nerves.
As described in the press release, the patient (Isabelle) was brought in for chiropractic evaluation at 9 weeks of age for NBPP diagnosed on the second day after delivery. Isabelle had apparently been evaluated by a surgeon who was unable to determine the severity of the nerve damage, but reportedly suspected an avulsion. This is when the spinal nerve is ripped out of the cord and it is the most severe cause of brachial plexus injuries.
An avulsion of a spinal nerve root will not heal without surgery. Even with surgery, many patients don’t regain full function of the involved arm. But, as the author even discusses at one point in the paper, it is impossible to reliably diagnose an avulsion clinically because mild to severe NBPP can present in the same way initially, with just a baby who isn’t moving an arm. MRI of the cervical spine isn’t even that helpful. Time is required to determine severity, with more significant injuries taking longer to improve or not improving at all.
Nine weeks is much too early to confidently determine that there has been an avulsion. It’s likely, however, that the surgeon discussed all the possible outcomes and management options with the child’s parents, but very unlikely that they would have said with any confidence that a nerve transplant would be required. As I mentioned earlier, surgeons typically allow several months to pass before going that route if there is no substantial improvement.
The patient’s mother, an occupational therapist, had learned of chiropractic as a potential treatment for NBPP from a Facebook group. The paper describes her as interested in seeing if chiropractic might help and feeling as if she had nothing to lose by trying, but it doesn’t paint the picture of hopelessness described in the press release. It reads more like she just got some bad information and perhaps didn’t run this by her daughter’s pediatrician and surgeon.
The author and Gonstead chiropractor, Karen Forsyth, describes the child’s neurological exam:
When observing Isabelle her right arm hung loosely by her side, she was unable to abduct or flex the right shoulder and there was no movement in the right elbow.
She does not mention anything about the hand or finger movement. It would be helpful to know if the entire arm, including the hand and fingers, was immobilized. The general rule in these cases is that the presence of any early improvement, particularly in the first 2-3 months, is a good sign that the patient will have meaningful recovery of function and will be very unlikely to ultimately require surgery. I’ll also point out here that Isabelle’s mother, an occupational therapist, was performing daily physical therapy exercises as instructed by the surgeon.
Forsyth’s chiropractic examination revealed a “sacral S1 segment posterior dyskinesia”, which is jargon for subluxation. And yes, that’s at the complete other end of the spine. She didn’t use a nervoscope to confirm her findings on visualization and palpation, however, because the patient was too small. So take her diagnosis with a grain of pink Himalayan sea salt.
During her exam ritual, she noted decreased lateral flexion in the cervical spine in both directions, which means that she stretched and could have further injured the involved nerves depending on how much force she used. I’m hopeful that she didn’t yank on the kid’s neck very hard, but would you trust your baby to an infant chiropractor in this situation? I wouldn’t.
After the first adjustment of the S1 vertebrae, Isabelle’s mother noted immediate and significant improvement in the movement of her arm. As I mentioned earlier, this is impossible. That’s just not how this works at all. Nerves don’t just up and start conducting like that. I mean, I realize that some chiropractors act like what they do is magic, but it’s not real magic. That would be impossible because they don’t have wands. Wait…never mind.
Her mother is an occupational therapist, so one might argue that she should be capable of assessing a patient’s ability to move their arm. But Isabelle is her daughter, not her patient, and the stress, fatigue, and worry of coping with a chronically ill infant can alter perception of reality. I’ve seen in many times. We are also only hearing one side of this story.
What happens next is portrayed in the paper as a miraculous and unexpected recovery. After several visits for adjustments of the S1 subluxation over many weeks, and then continued follow-up visits for many months, Isabelle’s arm improved dramatically. In fact, by her last visit prior to writing up this paper, when Isabelle was nearly 2 years old, her only noticeable deficit was some difficulty with bringing a spoon to her mouth. Forsyth noted that Isabelle’s surgeon has seen her several times during her course of chiropractic treatment and had declared that a procedure would not be necessary. Again, this is indistinguishable from the natural course of NBPP for the majority of patients.
In the discussion of the paper, Forsyth points out that spontaneous resolution has been observed in as many as 96% of patients in some studies and that the natural history of NBPP is hard to predict. She also notes correctly that a decent percentage, perhaps as many as a third, will have some degree of residual impairment. She leaves out that this residual impairment is usually not clinically meaningful.
She discusses the limitations of her report:
Limitations to this study include a possibility that this may have been the natural history of the Erb’s palsy. However, it would be very coincidental and rather ironic that movement would spontaneously begin the day following chiropractic treatment. Isabelle’s mum was near certain that she would require surgery at some point and when I was first consulted there was a high suspicion that the nerve was ruptured, and recovery would be minimal. Other biases and limitations include the lack of a control in this study, it is a small sample with only 1 case being presented and some may even argue the patient may have expected clinical resolution. This latter point is irrelevant as Isabelle was a baby when she received treatment and mum really had little expectations but more hope.
Ironic? Not really. I am sure that Isabelle’s mother believed that her improvement began suddenly and unexpectedly within hours of her first adjustment, but that just isn’t physiologically possible. Much more likely, despite Forsyth’s commentary on expectation and hope, is that she noticed minor changes that had been going on for some time and evaluated them in a more optimistic light, which is one of several possible placebo effects. I addressed the difficulty with determining nerve rupture and a need for surgery earlier. Also nobody would claim that a 9-week-old infant had expectation of benefit.
Before wrapping up, I wanted to briefly discuss Forsyth’s explanation for how adjusting a subluxation near the tailbone might improve function of nerves in the neck:
The proposed mechanism to describe how a subluxation as low as the sacrum can affect the 5th and 6th cervical nerve roots is, an S1 biomechanical misalignment may create a longitudinal tension in the dura and result in dural tension.
The dura is the covering that surrounds the brain and spinal cord, and it is continuous. She is essentially saying that if something tugs on the dura at any location, it can somehow pinch exiting spinal nerves at another location. This is silly. You are bending your neck and back, adding tension to the dura, nearly constantly without causing impingement of nerves. Simply bending over to pick something up off of the ground would result in significantly more tension than a so-called chiropractic subluxation that can only be appreciated with magic fingers and a bogus diagnostic device. Even if stretching the neck it takes significant force to actually stretch the nerves of the brachial plexus in a way that causes injury.
Okay, one last thing. You don’t often see an airing of grievances in the medical literature. That’s what blogs are for. I’m actually surprised that what I’m about to share made it through, but I’m not confident that the peer review process for this journal is all that robust. Forsyth, a subluxation-worshiping Gonstead devotee, does not take to kindly to those who would question the core tenets of her belief system:
This case provides interesting contrast to those in the Chiropractic profession who are ‘subluxation deniers’, such as Guillame Gonclaves, Christine Le Scanff and Charlotte Leboeuf-Yde, Chiropractic Researchers…They argue that vitalistic concepts such as ‘the body can heal itself and the nervous system controls and coordinates all body functions’ are false and chiropractic should be only for musculoskeletal problems…If we listened to people like Gonclaves, Le Scanff and Leboeuf-Yde, Isabelle may have been denied chiropractic care which would have been devastating for her and her family.
Conclusion: Chiropractic management of brachial plexus injury is a sham
No surprise there. I believe that I built my case effectively. With rock bottom plausibility as an intervention for injured spinal nerves, and nothing to support claims of benefit except for a few case reports, this is the only rational conclusion. Thankfully Isabelle did not suffer any apparent harm during her chiropractic evaluations, but unnecessary lateral stretching of her neck could have worsened her outcome. I’m happy that she did not end up requiring surgical intervention, and confident that chiropractic played no role whatsoever in her improvement..

Neck Adjustment for Newborn Supraventricular Tachycardia: More Chiropractic Manipulation of Reality…..
Clay Jones on July 31, 2015
Link

[Editor’s note: Not enough Clay for one day? Check out this post on homeopathy over at The Scientific Parent!]
It was recently brought to my attention that a chiropractor was promoting his profession on Facebook by claiming to have treated and cured a potentially life-threatening cardiac arrhythmia. The condition in question, supraventricular tachycardia (SVT), can be very serious and even deadly in patients of all ages. Needless to say, the thought of anyone but a well-trained medical professional with access to appropriate medication and equipment to control the heart rate if necessary was unsettling to say the least.
After a deep breath, I followed the link and was sadly not surprised to find that it was true. In fact, after taking a minute for the rage to subside, and a few more to delve deeper into the case, I found that it was in reality much worse that I had initially imagined. The intervention, a stealthy adjustment of the child’s first cervical vertebrae, was performed by her father while she was being treated in a neonatal intensive care unit just hours after being born.
The events in question were posted by the chiropractor on a public account for his practice. Still, I feel hesitant to link to them directly as they reveal not only the name of the child but the identity of the cardiologist and intensive care doctor involved in her care (who naturally cannot respond because of privacy laws). If readers want to go to the trouble of locating the source of my outrage, they certainly can.
I will provide details of the child’s care as described by her father, but first a brief primer on SVT to set the stage a bit.
What is supraventricular tachycardia?
SVT is the fancy medical name for an excessively fast heart beat that has an origin above the heart’s lower chambers, also known as the ventricles, which pump blood out of the heart into either the lungs or the rest of the body. SVT, which is the most common abnormal cardiac rhythm diagnosed in children, typically occurs in patients with a normally-formed heart and no other medical problems, but is more likely to occur in the presence of congenital heart defects. Regardless of whether the heart is structurally normal or not, the problem stems from an abnormality in the conduction pathway that defines the electrical communication between the upper and lower chambers.
In a neonate, the most common form of SVT is known as atrioventricular reentrant tachycardia (AVRT). The electrical activity within the muscle of the heart under normal circumstances is initiated in the upper chambers and passes into the lower via the AV node, a specialized collection of cells between the chambers that slows conduction just a bit in order for the ventricles to fill with blood prior to their contraction. AVRT becomes possible only when an accessory pathway for electrical activation of ventricular contraction exists that bypasses the normal route.
Electrical signals can pass through the accessory pathway from the atria to the ventricle or vice versa. Anterograde conduction results in a signal that bypasses the AV node and avoids that important slight delay. This “preexcitation” can be seen on an EKG as the infamous “delta wave” that medical students and residents learn about several hundred times during their training, despite it being relatively uncommon. Patients who develop SVT in the setting of preexcitation are diagnosed with Wolff-Parkinson White syndrome (WPW). Retrograde conduction absent SVT, where the accessory pathway allows electrical activity to pass from the ventricles back into the atria, cannot be seen on ECG.
The process that results in abnormally increased heart rate in SVT, which can be as fast as 300 beats per minute in young infants (normal is less than half of that) and 220 to 240 in older children, is when a reentrant circuit forms. The most common form of this, seen in roughly 95% of cases, is when electrical conduction goes through the AV node and then quickly moves retrograde through the accessory pathway where it can go right back through the AV node. This results in the impressively fast heart beat associated with SVT and can lead to a variety of clinical presentations.
How does SVT affect children?
Despite heart rates that seem too fast to believe, most episodes of SVT occur suddenly, stop without any intervention within 10-15 minutes, and are clinically silent. Some episodes resolve spontaneously within a couple of minutes while others, less commonly, last much longer. When they do cause symptoms, older patients will often describe heart palpitations (the sensation of their heart beating in an abnormal way), chest pain, and feeling tired or lightheaded. Infants and toddlers, who obviously can’t express what they are feeling, may just act fussy or funny.
Some patients will actually lose consciousness because of associated dips in blood pressure and poor perfusion of the brain with oxygenated blood. In general, the longer that an episode lasts, the more likely it is to result in more serious complications, and Wolff-Parkinson White syndrome in particular is associated with sudden death. Neonates and older infants, because persistent or frequent episodes are less likely to be recognized in a timely fashion, are much more likely to present in heart failure with excessive fussiness, poor sleep, feeding difficulty, bluish skin because of low oxygen levels, and abnormally fast and difficult breathing.
How is SVT diagnosed?
There are additional causes of SVT other than AVRT, although it is the most common of the vast majority of cases in kids under 2 years, and even in older children. Other potential etiologies can be associated with worse prognoses so it is extremely important for the right diagnosis to be made. This requires the involvement of a pediatric cardiologist and appropriate testing modalities, most importantly an ECG, but also an echocardiogram to rule out any structural abnormalities. Ambulatory monitoring of the heart at home is often necessary because of the sporadic and brief nature of most SVT episodes.
How is SVT treated?
In many cases of acute SVT, no treatment is required at all because it stops spontaneously without any intervention. The parent or patient may even be completely unaware it happened. When a child with SVT does come to the attention of medical professionals, whether in the office, emergency department, or inpatient unit, the first step is always an assessment of their hemodynamic stability. An ECG with continuous monitoring of the child’s heart rhythm is of course important as well, but assessing for evidence of low blood pressure, heart failure, and shock is critical.
Stable patients, which make up the majority of cases, are typically managed conservatively at first, but still with urgency. The goal is always to convert the rhythm back to normal – we don’t wait to see if it will stop on its own. The initial approach is usually trying one of several vagal maneuvers, which can be done while appropriate resources and personnel are gathered for additional treatments if necessary. A vagal maneuver is one of several techniques employed in an effort to increase the activity of the vagus nerve, which can slow conduction through the AV node and convert SVT to a normal rhythm.
Vagal maneuvers can involve having an older and cooperative patient bear down as if trying to have a bowel movement or blow through an occluded straw. In younger patients and infants, a common vagal maneuver involves covering the face with a bag filled with ice water for up to 30 seconds in order to stimulate the “diving reflex” and slow AV nodal conduction. Massaging the carotid arteries or pressing down on the eyes have been tried historically but are currently not recommended in children because they are less effective and can cause harm.
Another key component of any vagal maneuver is close observation of the patient and their cardiac rhythm during the attempt. The particular pattern seen if successful can help diagnose the etiology of the SVT. And although rare, vagal maneuvers can potentially result in different and more concerning abnormal rhythms or even prolonged asystole, which is when the heart fails to contract at all. Sometimes parents of older patients are counseled to evaluate their child at home and perform or assist in vagal maneuvers. To perform an unsupervised vagal maneuver on a newborn having their first episode of SVT is, well, I’m getting a little ahead of myself. Let’s put a pin in that for the moment.
If vagal maneuvers were to fail, and the child remains stable, the next step in treatment is almost always big pharmaceutical. The drug of choice is adenosine, which acts on cardiac cell surface receptors leading to an increase in the normal AV node delay in conduction. This can interrupt the reentrant circuit that is usually causing all the fuss in the first place.
Adenosine is an IV medication that acts extremely rapidly, usually within seconds. Continuous ECG monitoring is a must in order to document what happens and help make the diagnosis. It has an extremely high rate of successful conversion to normal rhythm in most cases of pediatric SVT, but should be avoided in some circumstances. It can worsen the situation if used in a patient with WPW, for example. Adenosine should never be given without the team being ready to provide emergency resuscitation if needed.
Patients who are unstable at presentation are treated very differently. Time is never wasted on vagal maneuvers or even medications. Instead, the child is given appropriate sedation and electrode paddles are used to cardiovert (i.e. shock) the rhythm into a normal pattern.
What are the long term implications of SVT?
SVT can recur in many children. Depending on the etiology, the risk of recurrence can be higher or, as in the case of WPW, associated with more concerning acute events, even sudden death. I won’t get into too much detail on this because it is complex and there is much less of a clear evidence base to go on. Essentially, some children can be observed without any preventative medications, just counseling on recognition, use of vagal maneuvers, and when to seek medical attention. Some children may be placed on medications or even undergo procedures to remove the abnormal accessory pathway. Luckily, many young children who are diagnosed will stop having episodes as they age.
Chiropractic management of SVT in a newborn infant?
Now back to the case in question, which to refresh your memory involved the patient’s father, a chiropractor, claiming to have successfully treated his child’s SVT while in the NICU (emphasis added by me for future reference):
…Within an hour (of being born), things became very serious as her heart rate went to 300+ BPM and was taken to the special care nursery. Nobody knew what was going on and they had called care flight to take her to another hospital. As the nurses stepped out of the room to make arrangements to move my daughter to another hospital, I decided to step in and check her out while all the nurses were out of the room. As I walked closer I began to pray and cry, I thought my girl was dying. With one adjustment to her atlas (C1), her heart rate fell to zero and then quickly back to up to 140. The nurses all rushed in to see what was going on. To their astonishment, Gemma’s heart rate was normal. They had no clue what had just happened and so I told them I adjusted her…By removing the interference, her parasympathetic nervous system took back over and did what it was suppose to [sic] do.
From another post in which he throws the obstetrician under the bus (emphasis added by me for future reference):
…Our bodies are self-healing and self-regulating and our nervous system is the master system and master controller of our body. Without interference it functions correctly. So what happened to Gemma? Her ability to self heal and self regulate was taken away. She was healthy before birth, her delivery was quick and the doctor pulled too hard on her neck. Her atlas was subluxated causing interference of her parasympathetic nervous system, specifically the Vagus nerve, which slows heart rate. Without the inhibition of the parasympathetic nervous system, the stress of being born caused her sympathetic nervous system to speed up her heart rate. The adjustment allowed her brain to function correctly and self regulate her heart rate. Without an adjustment, Gemma could have possibly died, been injured, or have been on harmful medications the rest of her life. How many kids are medicated because their nervous system isn’t functioning properly? EVERY kid needs to get checked by a ChiropracTOR. [sic] Their health and well-being depends on it. You may just be saving their lives! Feel free to share.
There is a lot to unpack here but I’ll do my best. From the information provided, if accurate, it is very likely that this child did in fact have an episode of SVT. It’s possible, but very unlikely, that something else such as pain or illness caused the heart rate to increase to that degree. Usually that can be differentiated fairly easily. Fast but normal rhythm is usually variable with swings up and down, while with SVT it appears to be stuck at one rate. Also this child, from what I can tell, was otherwise perfectly healthy.
Twice he mentions that nobody knew what was going on. This seems odd as SVT is a pretty well recognized phenomenon in both pediatric and adult medicine. This child was born at around 11PM and the increased heart rate wasn’t noticed until an hour after birth. In most nurseries, this means that the pediatrician would not see the baby until the morning. Even if the facility, like my own, has an in-house pediatrician 24 hours a day, healthy babies aren’t typically seen right away unless there are problems.
This facility apparently has a special care nursery, which is usually considered the equivalent of a level 2 NICU. Babies of moderate prematurity (32 weeks gestational age and up) and/or illness can be managed in a special care nursery without needing to be transferred to a higher level of care. I would have thought that routine SVT would not require transfer.
There is no mention of a neonatologist or pediatrician being involved with the initial care of the baby, which leads me to think that this hospital doesn’t have one in-house. The father did provide a photo of a rather unhelpful consultation note from a pediatric cardiologist the following day, which also names a neonatologist, however. Any neonatologist or pediatric hospitalist would have recognized SVT and treated appropriately. Of course the provided narrative might be missing important details for dramatic effect or because of simple frailty of human memory.
Sneaking into a child’s room, even your own, in order to avoid awareness of the hospital staff is shady to say the least. I have no idea what kind of neck adjustment this father performed, but I imagine that it involved some kind of high velocity technique that would have been concerning to nursing. If he was simply going to break out his Activator, why hide it?
The father’s understanding of the pathophysiology of SVT is completely wrong. SVT isn’t caused by a malfunction in the nervous system or brain, it is almost always caused by an accessory pathway for electrical conduction in the heart. The problem isn’t an overactive sympathetic nervous system (think fight or flight), or even suboptimal parasympathetic activity (think rest and digest). Vagal maneuvers are an attempt to hyperstimulate the nerve and increase parasympathetic action above normal in order to convert the rhythm.
The father also demonstrates a lack of understanding of basic neuroanatomy despite all of that focus on it in chiropractic colleges. Manipulating the spine in any way is not going to have an effect on the origin of the vagus nerve, also known as the tenth cranial nerve, which lies in the brain stem’s medulla oblongata within the base of the skull. Even a complete injury to the spine at the level of the first cervical vertebra, which is where the father claims his child had a subluxation, would not result in changes in the heart rate let alone SVT because the vagus nerve doesn’t live there.
The roots of the vagus nerve exit the skull via bilateral jugular foramen and travel with the jugular and carotid vessels on each side of the neck. This is why carotid massage can sometimes stimulate it and convert SVT. In fact, all vagal maneuvers attempt to stimulate the nerve at the point where it runs though the neck. So it is entirely possible that a chiropractic adjustment might “work” in the sense that somebody is potentially pressing down on the side of the neck for several seconds. The more likely reason that this child’s SVT converted is because SVT tends to just stops on its own.
As a pediatrician who often cares for very ill children, and a parent myself, I can certainly relate to the feelings of panic and fear expressed by the child’s father. He may have actually thought his baby was going to die, suffer injury, or go on to require harmful medications for the rest of her life. Apparently the possibility of life flight was even on the table and there doesn’t seem to have been anyone there to talk the family through the situation. In reality, the child needed appropriate medical care but was actually at fairly low risk of any of those concerns.
Chiropractic fear-based marketing
I probably wouldn’t have written about this if the father hadn’t turned the events into a marketing gimmick on his chiropractic practice’s public social media page. It’s a practice building scheme I’ve written about before several times and it’s as cheap as it gets. What better way to sell a product, particularly if it provides no demonstrable benefit, than to make people afraid of life without it? Even more powerful is the fear that your child may suffer horrible illness, even death, if you don’t do what they recommend.
Chiropractors certainly aren’t alone in the use of this marketing tactic, but I think that they might be the best at it. Despite any evidence to support their claims, they want parents to think that hidden subluxations are a risk for a variety of problems, even SIDS and “shaken baby syndrome.” And these hidden subluxations can occur during routine delivery or even regular care and play. Here is a chiropractor demonstrating how to avoid injuring the spine while changing your baby’s diaper. If a diaper change can injure the spine, imagine what falling down while learning to walk must do!

Chiropractic Management of a Newborn with Abnormal Oxygen Levels
A recently published case report documents chiropractic management of a newborn with low oxygen levels and yes, it’s as terrible as you imagine.
Clay Jones on November 13, 2020
Link

Last time out I caught readers up to speed regarding my thoughts on chiropractic care, particularly when it involves the pediatric population. As I stated in that post, the most egregious example of chiropractors practicing far outside of what would be considered an appropriate scope of practice by any rational outside observer is newborn chiropractic. I linked to several posts that I have written tackling this subject. This will be another one and it should make you angry.
In the October issue of the Journal of Pediatric, Maternal & Family Health – Chiropractic, a vertebral subluxation-focused repository for all manner of pseudoscience, there is an article with a gorge-elevating title: “Resolution of Abnormal Pulse Oximetry Measured in Real-Time in a Neonate with Vertebral Subluxation: A Case Report”. To give a little perspective on the quality of this journal before I delve into this train wreck of a case report, Barbara Loe Fisher is on the editorial board. So is Christopher Kent, president of the Foundation for Vertebral Subluxation.
The case, such as it is
The report in question is bad. It paints a clear picture of a “certified” midwife (certified how?) and a chiropractor with a poor grasp of newborn physiology fumbling their way through the care of a baby immediately after delivery. In the report, the authors, one of which I assume is also the chiropractor involved in the child’s care, focus on one very serious potential cause of low oxygen levels in a newborn, congenital heart disease, completely ignoring other possible etiologies. What they describe is reckless and they are extremely lucky that the baby ended up doing well despite the chiropractic intervention rather than because of it. This report serves as further evidence that chiropractors should not be allowed to treat children.
The report begins with the “natural” home birth (another topic for another time) of a full-term 8-pound baby girl after an uncomplicated pregnancy. For an unexplained reason, the midwife placed a pulse oximeter probe on the child’s foot and at 3 minutes she saw that it was reading 73%. According to the authors of the paper, the normal value should be 95-100% and they were seeing continued fluctuations between 80% and 90%. I’ll point out here that it is not the standard of care to start continuous monitoring with oximetry after the uneventful delivery of a term baby, so something may have worried the midwife or it may be something she does with every home delivery. It isn’t entirely clear, but I think I might know the answer.
What is an APGAR score?
The midwife assigned APGAR scores of 7 at both one and four minutes after delivery. APGAR scoring is a fast and simple assessment of a baby’s health during the first several minutes of transition from fetal to newborn physiology, a process that is very complex where a lot can potentially go wrong. It’s a backronym based on the name of Dr. Virginia Apgar, a pioneer in neonatal medicine who developed the scoring system in 1952. It stands for appearance, pulse, grimace, activity, and respiration. Scoring is typically done at 1 and 5 minutes, not 1 and 4 minutes as described in the case report, and then additionally at 5 minute intervals until a baby is stabilized, they require resuscitation, or 20 minutes have passed.
While its utility has its limits because components of the scoring are subjective, there are issues with inter-rater reliability, and it doesn’t predict long-term outcomes, it is a not terrible way to standardize how we decide which babies need intervention and which can go straight to mom. I’m sorry if it sounds like I’m not a fan, but I’m not a fan. I frequently joke with learners that it is the most useless thing we do in medicine. Also whenever I see scores of 10, I know it’s either somebody’s first day in labor and delivery or it’s the baby of a VIP. All babies have blue hands and feet at 1 minute and lose a point for it. And 99.999% of babies have blue hands and feet at 5 minutes. Accept it and move on.
Back to the case…wait, more about APGAR scores
So the baby is found to have low oxygen levels (just play along for now), as determined by pulse oximetry, at 3 minutes. And the APGAR score is 7 at 1 and 4 minutes. They don’t break the scores down, but it’s most likely 2 off for color (central and acrocyanosis) and 1 off for tone (a bit floppy) at 1 minute. I don’t for one second trust the ability of the midwife to determine normal tone in a newborn, however. But in general, an APGAR of 7 at 1 minute is pretty normal. The 5 minute APGAR is where the money is, but it’s bitcoins.
It’s hard to say what they took off for the 4 minute APGAR, which again isn’t when we would typically do the second assessment. The second score is thought of as a snapshot of how well we did our job resuscitating a newborn and it is usually higher or at least the same as at the initial assessment. Typically a baby pinks up centrally and would have better tone, heart rate, and reactivity after some good stimulation or help expanding the lungs a few times with positive pressure ventilation using a bag and mask. But in general, a 7 at 5 minutes is still reassuring.
The authors don’t describe central cyanosis in the report, which would be concerning at this point and unlikely to be left out if it had been present. They also don’t mention anything about the respiratory effort or the heart rate. I have to think that if the baby wasn’t breathing or didn’t have an adequate pulse, they would have commented on it. So maybe they took off a point for color, a point for poor tone, and a point for decreased response to stimulation. If the baby had been blue all over it would at least explain why the midwife broke out the pulse oximeter, but the report implies that it was put on immediately after birth and not in response to concerning exam findings. Honestly, it’s almost as if the people writing this case report don’t know what is important to pay attention to and to document. Weird.
Okay, now back to the case
The midwife then puts the baby on oxygen “intermittently”, but the authors do not explain how this is accomplished. Most likely it was “blow-by“, when an oxygen source is placed near a baby’s face rather than delivering it with a mask, nasal cannula, or endotracheal tube. This method does often seem to do the trick with the little ones, but it doesn’t actually do much to increase the fraction of inspired oxygen above the room air value of 21% unless done in a particular way. Often the blow-by is just somewhere around the baby’s head or chest (or feet), which is useless.
The authors go on to state that after starting the intermittent oxygen therapy, the baby’s pulse oximetry readings increased to 93% to 95% but would sometimes still dip down to 85%. They attributed these dips to when the baby wasn’t getting oxygen, but I’m not confident that the baby was getting any appreciable amount of extra oxygen at any point. They do not provide any additional details on how much time has passed, but they do write that the parents of the child were told that she might need to be transported to a local emergency room because of possible congenital heart disease.
Imagine how scared the family must have been. Now imagine how this family had put their trust in the midwife and expected a competent professional trained to treat the mother and also manage complications with the baby…at home. And then further imagine that someone had the idea to call in a chiropractor. Finally, if you have any remaining neurons not taken over by rage, imagine that the chiropractor, after being told that there is a baby that might have a life threatening heart defect, thought it was within their scope of practice and headed on over.
Enter the chiropractor
I’ll just quote directly from the paper here:
After an in-depth consultation with the parents and the attending midwife, a pediatric chiropractor evaluated the newborn for the presence of vertebral subluxations. Special attention was placed on the upper cervical spine as it is a common area of trauma during the birth process. It is important to understand that even when pediatric cervical injuries in general are a rare occurrence, birth related neck trauma is many times unpublicized and therefore not treated accordingly.
Taking a step back for a minute, let’s look at this rationally. Assuming that they are correct in their use and interpretation of newborn pulse oximetry (be patient, I’ll get there), we have a baby with low oxygen levels requiring oxygen support during the first few minutes after delivery. And the midwife is worried enough about the possibility of congenital heart disease, which in some forms can result in rapid decompensation, shock, and death without immediate intervention, that she is discussing emergency transport.
I’ve personally seen a baby go from well-appearing to critically ill in a matter of minutes as their heart lost the ability to provide oxygenated blood to the body and it is very scary. It’s one of many reasons why home births are a bad idea. How much time was wasted while waiting for the chiropractor to arrive and provide an “in-depth consultation”? The authors go on to describe the chiropractor’s nonsense evaluation of the newborn, which consisted of the standard palpation and leg length checks used by NUCCA practitioners who focus on the upper cervical spine. How long did this take? Again, every second counts if congenital heart disease is a possibility.
To absolutely nobody’s surprise, a vertebral subluxation of the left atlas transverse process was discovered and then “treated” with a “gentle sustained-contact type of force with the middle finger”. The argument being that the amount of pressure one would use to check for the ripeness of a tomato, a very popular description used by baby chiropractors, is enough to move spinal bones around. To their amazement, the chiropractor/author witnessed a real time increase in the baby’s pulse oximeter reading to 95%, and it remained there. Correction was achieved and the baby did not need to be moved to a hospital. Hallelujah!
Let’s break all this down.
Newborn transition and the role of pulse oximetry
I’ll just stick to the cardiorespiratory system of term healthy newborns for this discussion, which is complicated enough without getting into how it is impacted by prematurity. Plus the baby in the report was term. As I mentioned above, a lot of complex physiology is happening just before, and in the immediate period after, a baby is born. This will just be a shallow dive though.
Fetal lungs, which are collapsed and fluid filled, do not receive much blood flow because of high pulmonary vascular pressures, so a fetus receives oxygen from its mother via the placenta. The oxygenated blood coming from the placenta is routed through the inferior vena cava and into the heart’s right atrium where at least half of it shunted away from the right ventricle. The blood instead passes into the left atrium through a hole in the wall between the two chambers (the foramen ovale) because the higher pulmonary pressures make it the path of least resistance.
From the left atrium, the oxygenated blood moves into the left ventricle and then is pumped into systemic circulation via the aorta. In addition to forcing blood across the foramen ovale, the high pulmonary pressures also force about 90% of the blood that did manage to make its way into the right ventricle and pulmonary artery into the aorta through a connection called the ductus arteriosis. So ultimately there is only just enough blood entering into the pulmonary circulation to oxygenate that tissue and the rest goes through the aorta to deliver oxygen to the rest of the body. This is if everything is hooked up correctly.
As labor begins, there is a surge of hormones that signal the lungs to prepare to absorb the fluid within the airways. Within seconds of birth as a baby takes their first breaths, the lungs expand and rapidly clear themselves of the bulk of the residual fluid so that normal ventilation and respiration can occur. This, and the clamping of the umbilical cord, reduces the high pressures within the pulmonary circulation and increases blood pressure in the systemic circulation respectively. As a result, blood flow to the lungs begins to increase because less of it is shunted across the foramen ovale or through the ductus arteriosis, and the lungs replace the placenta as the sole source of oxygen.
The transition that I’ve just described is a gradual process that takes several minutes to occur, thus oxygen levels do not reach “normal” adult values for at least 10 minutes after delivery. And again, this is if everything goes right. Although not needed for normal postnatal circulation in a healthy newborn, these accessory pathways continue to exist for weeks (for the ductus) to months (for the foramen ovale). Sometimes their persistence can cause problems, particularly the ductus arteriosis in premature infants, which may need to be closed with medications or a procedure. Sometimes their persistence is the only thing keeping a baby alive in the case of certain congenital heart defects where the only way a baby is able to get oxygen to the systemic circulation is through these shunts. We sometimes give a medication to keep the ductus from closing until surgery can be performed.

Pulse oximetry is a very helpful tool in our approach to managing newborns at the time of delivery, and not just for the detection of congenital heart disease. It is based on the absorption of specific wavelengths of light (red 640 nm and infrared 940 nm) by hemoglobin molecules that do or do not have attached oxygen. A probe attached to the skin at strategic locations will measure these values and the device uses the power of math to determine the oxygen saturation. This gives us a much more sensitive means of determining low oxygen levels since we don’t have to rely on the visual assessment of cyanosis, and it is much faster than sending blood to the lab for analysis.
Regarding congenital heart disease, it is now standard to check oxygen saturation percentages in all newborns prior to discharge, typically at around 24 hours of life. There are, however, other potential causes of abnormally low values, such as pneumonia, retained fetal lung fluid, persistent pulmonary hypertension, aspiration of stool passed prior to delivery, and anatomical abnormalities, to name just a few. Many newborns have low values that gradually improve over the first several minutes to few hours that are, with hindsight and often a few reassuring tests, attributed to ultimately benign delays in the normal transition that I described above.
Pulse oximetry is far from perfect, however, and I see false alarms all the time. You can’t just slap it on a baby and expect reliable results. You have to do it right. It can be misleading even when everything is done correctly because the value on the monitor tends to jump around…a lot, leading to frequent false alarms and unnecessary interventions. The probe often loses the signal and many medical professionals don’t realize that oxygen saturation displayed on the monitor is an average over the previous 8 to 16 seconds, so it can take time to represent the actual physiological state of the patient. You really have to know what you are doing when interpreting pulse oximetry in any patient, especially a newborn.
Conclusion: What really happened
As I mentioned earlier, and this is demonstrated in the above table, a healthy newborn’s oxygen saturation starts low and gradually increases during the first ten minutes after delivery. So the oxygen saturation of 73% at 3 minutes described in the case report was very likely completely normal and not representative of an underlying congenital heart defect. And with the reassuring APGAR scores and lack of any mention of red flags such as labored breathing or persistent central cyanosis, this baby was probably perfectly fine.
All the jumping around of oxygen saturation values they described was likely just pulse oximetry doing what pulse oximetry does and they didn’t know how to interpret it. If the baby truly did have abnormal oxygen levels caused by serious pathology such as congenital heart disease, the delay in seeking appropriate care could have resulted in a very bad outcome. It is beyond irresponsible to attempt a trial of chiropractic before calling an ambulance when you are managing a potentially very sick newborn, which is something you would think would go without saying. But here we are.
We use our understanding of human physiology to avoid overzealous use of oxygen when caring for newborns because it can actually be harmful, particularly for premature infants. Before we developed this understanding, this seemingly benign intervention injured the brain, eyes, and lungs of countless newborns. We now know that most newborns can be resuscitated using room air. When we use oxygen, we typically start low and increase the amount to only what is needed to maintain normal oxygen saturation. Only for the small percentage of babies that don’t respond to lower amounts of oxygen, or who require interventions such as chest compression and the placement of an endotracheal tube, do we use 100% oxygen.
In the conclusion of the case report, the authors state that obstetric healthcare providers should know about cases such as this. I agree. I think more people should definitely be made aware of how dangerous the chiropractic profession can be when their delusions of bogus spinal abnormalities put children at risk of very real harm.
One more thing…
Anyone who reads SBM regularly knows how obnoxiously vague and nonsensical the attempts by quacks to science up their belief system can be. My favorite has always been this chiropractic definition of a subluxation:
A complex of functional and/or structural and/or pathological articular changes that compromise neural integrity and may influence organ system function and general health.
You may wonder, after reading my post, how the authors of the case report connected subluxations of the cervical spine to low oxygen levels in this newborn. I’ll just leave this here for your reading pleasure:
Sympathetic dominance, due to a reduced parasympathetic function or an increased sympathetic function can affect the autonomic nervous system creating a reduction in dynamic flexibility of the system, as a consequence of poor adaptation to an increase in external and internal demands. This in turn could create an imbalance in the autonomic nervous system which can have negative effects with regard to pathological conditions.
Now that is a mighty fine pseudomedical word salad, the likes of which we may not see again for many years. It’s a masterpiece of malarkey. If there were a hall of fame for this kind of thing, it definitely has my vote.

Separating Fact from Fiction in the Not-So-Normal Newborn Nursery: Chiropractic and Craniosynostosis
Clay Jones on March 27, 2015
Link

Pediatricians, particularly those who spend a significant amount of time caring for newborns, see a lot of babies with unusually-shaped heads. Although to be fair, the fact that the overwhelming majority of vaginally-delivered babies, and quite a few born via Caesarean section, will have a transient and abnormal shape to their heads makes it, well, not unusual. In fact, I rarely make it out of the room without some discussion and reassurance regarding the lumps and bumps of a new arrival’s head.
The potentially lumpy and misshapen head of the newborn occurs for a variety of reasons, some common and some extremely rare. It often is related to the development of the bones of the skull but can also involve the surrounding tissues of the scalp. A vaginal delivery, and some difficult Caesarean births, subject a baby’s head to a lot of pressure. This pressure frequently results in swelling of the scalp that can be quite impressive, but tends to resolve in a day or two.
This same pressure can also cause bleeding, perhaps because of an insufficient amount of vitamin K available to optimally activate clotting, that collects under the top layer of one or more of the bones of the skull. These cephalohematomas can also be impressive and may take weeks to completely resolve. Rarely the trapped blood becomes calcified and requires surgical correction to remove the otherwise-permanent lump and restore a normal contour to the head.
Newborns very frequently have a molded skull. Depending on the timing and severity of the pressure experienced during delivery, the shape and size of the uterus and positioning of the baby in the womb, the newborn can emerge with a variety of head shapes. The most common one that I see is a cone. If you’re thinking of a classic Saturday Night Live sketch right now, you’ve got the correct mental image.
Babies who are breech also have a distinct pattern of molding which involves a flattened and elongated top of the head because of pressure against the uterine wall. Abnormal positioning in the womb can also result in asymmetric molding of the head and facial structures like the jaw, nose and ear. Fortunately these pressure-induced and positional deformities usually resolve without intervention, often within a few days, but some are serious enough to require intervention and even surgical correction.
Why are the cranial bones of newborns so easily molded by the pressure of birth? This is a question I answer frequently for new parents and inexperienced medical students. The answer will segue us into the primary topic of this post, but before I discuss craniosynostosis, and the sadly unsurprising claims of some in the chiropractic community, a review of normal cranial anatomy is in order.
Why are newborn skulls so easily molded?
The skull of a typical healthy newborn is not just one large bone but is actually comprised of several bony plates, each joined by fibrous joints called sutures. These sutures, the major ones running mid-line down the top (sagittal) and diagonally and bilateral at the front (coronal) and back (lambdoid) of the skull, are made of strong connective tissue similar to the attachments of the teeth to the bony sockets. When fused, they allow minimal but usually clinically-insignificant movement.
But sutures in the newborn, the most well-known being the “soft spots” at the front and back of the skull, are not normally fused. The ability to shift freely with significant pressure allows for molding, so the skull doesn’t fracture or become stuck as it makes its way through the pelvis, and for the safe growth of the brain over the first two decades of life. The most rapid period of brain growth, the first two years of life, results in a brain that is four times larger than at birth. Without the ability to accommodate the expansion of the brain, a variety of problems can arise.
What is the normal pattern of cranial growth and fusion?
As the brain grows, it exerts outward pressure which pushes the bones of the skull apart. In response, new bone is formed along the edges of the cranial bones at the sutures. So appropriate growth, and this is important for later discussion of abnormal early fusion, occurs perpendicular to the suture line.
Normal fusion of the bones of the skull occurs in a reproducible pattern. At roughly two months of age, the posterior fontanel should be closed. At around two years, the anterior fontanel should no longer be palpable. The linear sutures fuse more slowly, with completion not occurring until well after full growth is achieved, but the ability of the bones to move relative to themselves to any meaningful degree is gone by two to three years of age. And prior to that it would still require significant amounts of pressure that would risk pain and injury to the skull and underlying brain.
What happens when fusion of cranial bones occurs too early?
Abnormal early fusion of one or more of the cranial sutures, known as craniosynostosis, is diagnosed in roughly 1 out of every 2000 to 2500 babies around the world. In a bit over half of cases, early fusion affects the sagittal suture that runs down the top of the head and separates the parietal bones of the skull. The second most common location is the coronal suture which runs from ear to ear separating the frontal and parietal bones.
Most of the time, craniosynostosis is an isolated abnormality with only partial fusion of one suture. But multiple sutures are prematurely fused in about 10% of cases, and this generally occurs due to a genetic syndrome with other dysmorphic features, such as cleft palate and fusion of the finger bones. Several specific gene defects resulting in craniosynostosis syndromes have been identified, typically in the fibroblast growth factor receptor family, the most well-known examples being Apert, Crouzon and Pfeiffer syndrome.
When a suture is fused too early, it restricts the growth of the skull in a predictable way. Remember earlier when I pointed out that normal growth occurs perpendicular to the suture line? If a suture is fused, normal perpendicular growth can’t occur, which accentuates growth at the sutures that aren’t fused because of increased pressure. So growth of the head will only occur parallel to the fused sutures.
For example, in the case of sagittal suture fusion the head tends to become strikingly long and narrow, a shape known as scaphocephaly. This translates to “boat skull.” When the coronal suture is fused prematurely on both sides of the forehead, the resulting shape is known as brachycephaly or “short skull.” The skull will be shortened from front to back but abnormally wide, and if untreated will begin to preferentially grow upward as well. So depending on which sutures are fused before their time, and if the fusion occurs on one or both sides of the head, there are a variety of recognized pathognomonic shapes ranging from mild to extreme.
How is craniosynostosis diagnosed and treated?
The diagnosis of abnormal early fusion of one or more sutures should be suspected when the shape of the head is abnormal. In the case of genetic syndromes, when multiple sutures are involved and associated dysmorphic features are present, it can be fairly easy to recognize. When the sagittal suture is involved, as it is in about half of cases, the classic head shape is an extremely helpful clue. But in the case of isolated non-syndromic premature fusion of other sutures, it isn’t always clear because abnormal head shape related to positioning of the infant’s head during sleep can mimic craniosynostosis.
Pediatricians see a lot of what is known as positional plagiocephaly (“twisted skull”), a phenomenon which increased significantly after universal recommendations that young infants sleep only on their backs in order to reduce the risk of SIDS. When children sleep on their backs, and especially when they have a persistent side preference, there can be significant flattening to one side of the skull. This is also more common in babies with difficulty turning the head from side to side, as occurs in a condition known as torticollis, or when they have neurological injury or disease resulting in difficulty moving at all.
It is important to consider conditions that mimic craniosynostosis because they can often be managed successfully without surgery. Positional plagiocephaly often responds to lifestyle changes, such as increased time off the back and repositioning of the head during sleep, and to physical therapy in the case of torticollis. Often suspected mild craniosynostosis resolves spontaneously before any significant diagnostic work-up is initiated. When it is severe, or doesn’t improve after a few weeks of conservative measures, the appropriate means of confirming the diagnosis is CT imaging of the skull.
Timely diagnosis and treatment of craniosynostosis is very important in order to prevent the development of complications. The most concerning potential complication is increased intracranial pressure and impaired growth of the brain. Untreated craniosynostosis can result in cognitive deficits and neurodevelopmental delays in feeding, vision, hearing and speech. It can also be a cosmetic concern that shouldn’t be taken lightly as it is linked with difficulty in social development that can have lifelong repercussions.
Except in very mild cases that are not associated with risk of increased intracranial pressure or problems with socialization, surgery is required. The complexity of management is naturally determined by the severity of the presentation and the presence of other dysmorphic features such as a cleft palate. Optimal outcomes depend on a multi-disciplinary approach that involves surgeons, pediatricians, dentists, a variety of other medical subspecialists, and various therapists. Many pediatric facilities have craniofacial teams set up for just such situations.
What does chiropractic have to do with craniosynostosis?
Unfortunately, there are practitioners of so-called complementary and alternative (or integrative) medicine out there claiming to be able to correct abnormally-shaped infant skulls. Long time readers of SBM are probably familiar with the pseudoscience known as craniosacral therapy. Drs. Hall, Crislip, and Ritchey have discussed this topic in detail in the past, although not in the setting of treating craniosynostosis. Of note, Dr. Hall links to the report of a 2-day-old child who died from injury to the brain caused by craniosacral therapy at the hands of a rogue dentist.
As I have discussed in prior posts, there are few things that chiropractors love more than a good anecdote trumped up as a case report and published in one of their low-quality journals. In fact, my first post for SBM looked at one such example of chiropractic “research” as it applies to the treatment of Tourette syndrome. Case reports when properly utilized, and their inherent weaknesses taken into account, can be a meaningful component of science-based medicine. But in the world of chiropractic they are frequently used to make inappropriate claims of treatment efficacy and as part of practice-building efforts.
One such case report exists for the use of chiropractic to correct potential craniosynostosis, the low plausibility of which rivals even homeopathy. Authored by chiropractor Joel Alcantara, the Director of Research for the International Chiropractic Pediatric Association, and published in their Journal of Pediatric, Maternal & Family Health – Chiropractic, the report discusses a 3-week-old infant supposedly diagnosed with craniosynostosis by her obstetrician and pediatrician.
The mother of the infant is described as having sought out chiropractic care during a period of recommended observation. If at that point the problem had not resolved, imaging and surgery would be arranged. The report describes the child as having a fused posterior fontanel, something that can’t be diagnosed by simple palpation, and an open but small anterior fontanel. It then describes the discovery of subluxations at multiple locations along the spine as well as the right temporomandibular joint. There were apparently also “cranial distortions of the right frontal/parietal and left parietal/occipital bones.”
The patient underwent “specific, gentle high velocity, low-amplitude type thrust” to the subluxations, as well as craniosacral therapy. After six visits, her “skull diameter” increased by roughly 5 cm from 34.5 to 39.2 cm. This is odd considering that skull diameter is not a routine measurement. I assume that they mean head circumference, which is on average 34.5 cm at birth in a term infant. If accurate, this demonstrates normal growth of the child’s head.
After her series of 13 chiropractic adjustments and “craniosacral therapy”, she was evaluated by appropriate medical professionals at almost 4 months of age who determined that surgery was not indicated. This is wonderful news of course, but it had absolutely nothing to do with subluxations or cranial distortions. From what I can piece together using the abstract, accompanying press release and some online discussion of the case by a chiropractor on her practice website, the child likely never had craniosynostosis.
Craniosynostosis is often only suspected by pediatricians. In the case of a nonsyndromic child with potential isolated early fusion, a period of observation prior to exposing them to the ionizing radiation of a CT scan can be very appropriate. These children are seen regularly to monitor for worsening of the shape of the head despite conservative measures, and signs or symptoms of increased intracranial pressure, and in many cases imaging and surgery are not needed. A false alarm is orders of magnitude more likely than chiropractic intervention reversing a fused suture, something which would require more force than pulling out a healthy tooth.
Alcantra, the author of the case report, was considerably more optimistic about the findings:
In this case we have a defect in the infant’s skull that did not require a planned surgery following a trial of chiropractic care of the spine and skull.
And:
While this is only a single case study, it shows what can happen when chiropractic to correct spinal and cranial distortions is included as a health care option for children.
In the press release, the journal’s editor Mathew McCoy also seems to conclude that the case proves efficacy:
Chiropractors work with the alignment and movement of the bones that make up the spine and many chiropractors also work on the bones of the skull, especially in children where its normal development is so crucial. So it is not so surprising that you’d see this type of outcome.
I agree that it isn’t surprising, but not that chiropractic had anything to do with it.
Unfortunately, it isn’t just that chiropractors are touting their ability to manipulate the positioning of the bones of the skull and unlock fused sutures. I easily found the blogs of clearly well-meaning but misinformed parents discussing their use of chiropractic for craniosynostosis. This post, which is found very high on Google when searching “chiropractic AND craniosynostosis” implies that it has benefit. If curious families don’t read the future posts, they won’t see that when imaging was eventually performed there was no improvement and successful surgery took place.
Conclusion
Abnormal head shape in the newborn period is extremely common and has varied causes. Premature fusion of the cranial bones, while less common, is a very serious condition that generally requires surgical correction because fused sutures are extremely strong. Improperly managed, craniosynostosis can lead to lifelong developmental delays, cognitive impairment and psychosocial difficulties.
Chiropractors who claim to be able to shift the bones of the skull, especially in children with craniosynostosis, are deluded. There is no evidence that chiropractic subluxations exist let alone play a role in the shape of the head. And it would take extreme pressure to move unfused skull bones, which would risk harming or even killing a young infant. Luckily, craniosacral therapy typically involves nothing more than a head massage and most chiropractors use gentle adjusting techniques.
Taking money from families without providing any actual benefit is wrong, but it isn’t my main concern. Abnormal head shapes do often correct on their own if related to birth pressure, which can give the appearance of chiropractic success, but many babies require true intervention. Education on proper positioning, physical therapy and even fitted helmets are common non-surgical treatments. If parents are delaying science-based medical care, it risks poor cosmetic and psychosocial outcomes. And if a child has actual craniosynostosis, improper management can also be dangerous.

A Touch to Fear: Chiropractic and the Newborn Baby
Clay Jones on August 29, 2014
Link

A significant part of my job as a pediatric hospitalist involves caring for newborns. It is arguably the best thing that I get to do as a physician, even if I do at times prefer the increased intellectual stimulation of the ill hospitalized child. While seeing newborns, I am almost always surrounded by happy and appreciative parents, grandparents and whoever else is invited to meet and greet the new arrival because the babies are almost always healthy. In fact, and not that I really care (sniff, sniff), the parents of newborns are with rare exception the only caregivers that ever thank me at discharge.
Unfortunately, sometimes I am called upon to assist babies that are having difficulty transitioning into the outside world for a variety of reasons. These reasons can range from the fairly minor and transient to the catastrophic. And despite our advances in the understanding of neonatal pathophysiology and in medical technology, there remain newborn infants that cannot be saved or who have severe lifelong deficits caused by their illness or injury. This will likely always be the case, especially if unqualified professionals continue to involve themselves in either the delivery or the care of babies.
Over the course of 11 years of practice, and after having seen thousands of both perfectly healthy and severely ill newborns, I have acquired a skill set which allows for the recognition of a baby in trouble and the ability to respond appropriately. All pediatricians and family doctors strive to develop this, particularly if they see patients in the newborn nursery, although I imagine none, including myself, would claim to have perfected this “art”. Newborn medicine can be very challenging for many reasons, not the least of which is the significant overlap of the presenting signs and symptoms of many serious conditions, with even normal baby behavior sometimes mimicking potentially life-threatening pathology.
Take a fussy or jittery baby for example. These are common symptoms often experienced as part of normal newborn behavior or related to environmental insults such as hunger, overstimulation, or a wet diaper. Frequently babies are fussy for no apparent reason at all, and normal newborn findings like the Moro reflex and startle can be exaggerated but within the wide range of what is normal. But fussiness or jitteriness can be the presenting symptoms for hypothermia, hypoglycemia, hypocalcemia, opioid withdrawal, meningitis, pneumonia, sepsis, necrotizing enterocolitis, a collapsed lung, a broken clavicle, hemorrhaging into the brain, a twisted testicle and much more.
While it is true that there are often historical clues or additional exam findings that can help differentiate the many possible causes of a newborn’s signs or symptoms, it isn’t always the case. Sometimes helpful clues develop over time, but time isn’t always a luxury we have. Waiting for a blood culture to become positive or for a baby to develop hypothermia and seizures before starting antibiotics would result in some very poor outcomes.
Healthcare professionals who care for newborns are trained to deal with most of the complications that can arise in the immediate period after a baby is born. We are qualified in neonatal resuscitation and regularly maintain our skills by attending classes and taking part in simulated cases. And again, we see actual sick babies. Some of us, particularly neonatologists, see a lot of them.
I tell you all this to provide some insight into my utter revulsion at the concept of chiropractors taking part in the care of any newborn infant, let alone one that might require medical intervention to save their life or prevent long-term complications. I realize that readers of Science-Based Medicine are almost certainly aware of the push by many practitioners of so-called alternative medicine to be accepted as a primary care provider or PCP. There are a number of posts that discuss their legal tactics by Jan Bellamy, for instance. And several that point out the absurdity of it all considering the lack of a fund of knowledge and appropriate training that could even remotely qualify them to successfully prevent or treat real medical problems, as opposed to their litany of fictitious ailments.
For this post, which is coming out on the 14th consecutive day that I will spend caring for newborns and hospitalized children, I wanted to provide readers with an example of why the chiropractor as a PCP, specifically one that involves themselves with newborns, is such a dangerous concept. And while I haven’t spent as many years exposing myself to the world of chiropractic foolishness as some of my fellow SBM contributors, in my opinion this one is up there with the worst of the worst.
(If new to the site, check out my prior posts on the chiropractic approach to SIDS and colic for additional background information)
A pathway to disaster
Pathways to Family Wellness is a magazine published quarterly by the International Chiropractic Pediatric Association, who according to their website is essentially the American Academy of Pediatrics for chiropractors:
The ICPA is a nonprofit organization whose mission is to advance chiropractic by establishing evidenced informed practice, supporting excellence in professional skills and delivering educational resources to the public. It fulfills this mission by engaging and serving family chiropractors worldwide through research, training and public education.
In reality they do none of this. Their evidence base almost exclusively consists of case reports and the education they provide is largely self-serving. They provide resources which help chiropractors expand their panel of customers by recruiting children as patients. Their biggest claim to fame is that they offer certification (certifiction?) and diplomate programs in pediatric chiropractic.
Pathways is mostly just a magazine to put in the waiting room, hand out at health fairs, or leave in piles at local grocery stores with a flier for your practice tucked inside. It’s propaganda. The article in the Summer 2014 issue that I want to focus on, “A Touch to Heal: A Chiropractor Helps Direct an At-Risk Newborn Toward Wellness “, is an abomination that perfectly illustrates everything that is wrong with both chiropractic in general and their nonsensical goal of being taken seriously in the role of primary care for children. I’ll be honest and say that I think, like the chiropractic subluxation itself, this article is fiction. I think it’s almost certainly either extremely exaggerated or completely made up as part of a practice building scheme for an individual practice. In fact, here is strikingly similar anecdote from an earlier issue of Pathways.
A touch to fear
Written by chiropractor Ryan Dopps, “A Touch to Heal” takes us through a night in the life of an apparently always on-call chiropractor:
The text came through at 10:41 p.m. on a Friday night. It was from our midwife, Michelle Ruebke, C.P.M.: “I just delivered a baby and think he needs to see one of you guys. He’s too fussy (not crying) and won’t nurse.” Instantly I turned to my wife, who is also a chiropractor, and with little discussion I was out the door. On my 40-minute drive north to Michelle’s rural home, my thoughts were already fixated on this little person, preparing my heart and mind for what was to come.
Just to clarify this introduction, a baby was delivered at the home of a midwife apparently nowhere near a proper medical facility. And the worried midwife called a chiropractor who lives almost an hour away for help. This is truly the blind leading the blind. An irritable or extremely fussy baby could be very ill (see earlier differential for the fussy baby). Also, I’m a bit confused regarding just what it means when a baby is excessively fussy but not crying. Is the baby not crying because of respiratory depression? Is their airway partially obstructed? Do they have ischemic encephalopathy? Instead of preparing his heart and mind, he should be reviewing his PALS and NRP algorithms.
Michelle was an experienced midwife who had delivered over 600 babies. She even had delivered the children of chiropractor Dopps. Despite this experience, and the confidence to deliver babies at her home in the country, she was apparently very worried about something. Of course, with 10% of babies requiring a little help to start breathing but less than 1% needing significant resuscitation, it isn’t impossible that she could have delivered 600 babies without incident, especially if she only took care of very low risk mothers.
Chiropractor Dopps surveys the scene:
A baby boy, only hours hold, was swaddled tightly and very agitated, struggling to get out a cry. He would not nurse and was having spasms in his arms. Asking questions about his birth and the time since then, I dove right in. His respiration was fast and his head was misshapen, more so than in most newborns. “He only shows his whimper if we place our hands on his head,” Michelle said.
There is a lot to unpack here. Again, an “agitated” baby could be very ill, but then again I don’t trust that they have the ability to differentiate normal crying/fussiness from irritability/agitation. And describing his arm movements as spasms is very unhelpful. Was the baby having normal or exaggerated intermittent reflex motor activity, benign sleep related myoclonic jerking, or actual seizure activity? What questions about the birth did he ask, I have to wonder. Certainly chiropractic education doesn’t teach about prenatal, delivery and postnatal complications that can lead to difficulties, or at least they can’t get into too much detail during the weekend learning about newborns as part of the ICPA diplomate program.
Also, how does he know what most newborns heads look like? I routinely see significant, even scary, molding of the scalp. This occurs because the bones of the skull are not fused together and can move around because of the pressure of a vaginal delivery, often forming a cone shape. It has no clinical significance when this occurs and resolves within several hours to a couple of days with no intervention. The baby could have had swelling of the scalp, called caput, or a collection of blood under the thin but tough outside layer of one or more of the skull bones. Cephalohematomas, as they are called, unless huge are almost always of no clinical concern and resolve over the first few weeks of life. All newborns breathe fast compared to older kids and adults, with the upper limit of normal being 60 breaths per minute. Did this kid have true tachypnea (faster than normal breathing rate)?
The plot thickens:
When I checked the newborn I found a right lateral atlas subluxation, as well as a misaligned right mastoid fontanel. The parietal and occipital bones were overlapping each other to the accord of a half inch. With a gentle but purposeful touch, I adjusted the cranials and the atlas. The right lateral atlas set into place with a profound thud. I’ve never experienced a newborn’s atlas moving the way this child’s did. I knew innate was being unleashed to express vitality through his body.
It’s getting real now. It is very likely that the only thing Dopps felt was the power of his own imagination. He expected there to be a vertebral misalignment, so there was one. And again, baby skulls are made to move around. If not, they would be at significant risk of becoming stuck when moving through the mother’s pelvis. It isn’t a design flaw, it’s a safety feature necessary because of our big brains.
A misaligned fontanel is a meaningless term that has no clinical significance. A fontanel or “soft spot” is one of a few of the larger sutures, or spaces between the largely unfused skull bones. As stated earlier, their presence allows for a malleable and more easily-delivered skull but also the ability of the cranium to expand as our big brains get bigger. They also allow for ultrasound of the brain to be a viable imaging modality in young infants and for a possible clue that a baby is dehydrated (sunken fontanel) or has meningitis or some other cause of increased intracranial pressure (bulging fontanel).
It takes a lot of pressure to move the skull bones around. To actually believe that a gentle touch “adjusted” anything, let alone the “cranials” or the first cervical vertebra (the atlas), is as plausible as water memory or transferring healing human energy fields by email. Also extremely unlikely is the possibility that this child had displacement of the atlas in the first place. A true subluxation of C1 or an actual fracture usually occurs only with major trauma, such as after diving into unexpectedly shallow water or with extreme rotation of the neck, but can result because of a variety of congenital or chronic inflammatory conditions over time.
Depending on the direction and severity, this can be a fatal injury if the vertebra compresses or transects the spinal cord traveling through it. It doesn’t happen often during delivery, but it can, and it is a medical emergency with an overall mortality rate of 16%. The description of this child’s problems actually does overlap a little with a possible C1 injury (difficulty moving arms, abnormal breathing, apparent pain). It’s a bit of a stretch, but any manipulation of a neck with a C1 injury can result in complete paralysis and an inability to breathe. I doubt that Ruebke and Dopps (worst premise for a TV show ever) would have been prepared to intubate and bag this kid until an ambulance or Life Flight arrived.
During the rest of the encounter, chiropractor Dopps ends up adjusting the child’s neck two additional times until the atlas “held” but also finds subluxations in both the ilium (one of the hip bones) and sacrum that need correcting. Thankfully his adjustment of the mastoid fontanel held strong. Eventually the baby is crying normally, feeding like a champ at the breast and no longer having “uncontrolled arm movements.” At one point the baby is described as having “inflammation on the vertex”, a phrase that when put into Google can only be found in this particular article. I guess now there will be two occurrences. I think what he is talking about is the common finding of some skin discoloration, often somewhat reddened, at the point of maximal pressure during a vaginal delivery, usually the top of the head which is called the cranial vertex. He refers to it as if it’s a problem and that his adjustments helped it “settle down”.
Sprinkled throughout the anecdote are phrases that really stand out as examples of how chiropractic, like many systems of alternative medicine, share more in common with religion than science or medicine. “I knew innate was being unleashed to express vitality through his body.” Innate being the “straight” chiropractor’s raison d’être. It is the healing force of nature/God that flows into our bodies and through a healthy spine into every nook and cranny. The chiropractic adjustment removes impediments to this otherwise all-powerful entity in the same way that acupuncture needles treat stagnant chi by unblocking meridians, which is to say that they work via theatrical placebo.
The most egregious examples of the arrogance of ignorance inherent in being a chiropractor that is comfortable caring for an “at-risk newborn” comes when Dopps, in awe of his own healing abilities, writes “That is the truth; the newborn was at peace when my hands were working” and “Your baby is in my hands now, and he’s going to be just fine.”
Dopps finishes up with a not-unexpected dig at conventional medicine and yet another example of the vitalistic religiosity of chiropractic philosophy:
On my drive home early Saturday morning, I was humbled by the chiropractic principles that I live for. That there was no bag of medicine, no needle full of whatever, no brain-function monitor that I could have brought in a little black doctor bag that had more intelligence than what was inside that brand-new baby boy. It is good work that we do. With these hands, innate can be the doctor.
Conclusion
I feel compelled to again mention the fact that I think that this particular anecdote is likely greatly exaggerated by Dopps for the effect of coming across as a knowledgeable savior for a newborn baby in serious trouble. He did heal with the gentle touch of his hands, after all. Although everyone knows that Jesus was really just a Reiki Master. It may simply be completely made up. Either way, it demonstrates his poor understanding of how babies work and the potential dangers of what might happen should he or any other chiropractor find themselves in the position of caring for a truly ill or injured newborn.
The story also illustrates how risky an at home delivery is. The midwife in question was clearly terribly unprepared and this child could have easily suffered severe neurologic sequelae or even died considering how many really bad things can present like he supposedly did. So if you weren’t already incensed at the thought of the chiropractic profession achieving their goals of serving as the PCP for children, I truly hope that you are now.
Here is a video demonstrating a chiropractic exam and spinal adjustment of a baby that is supposedly 5 hours old. I will go ahead and let you know that there is absolutely, under no circumstances, any indication to hold a baby up in the air by one leg to see which way their head turns. He just keeps doing it until the kid happens to look the other way and then claims to have successfully corrected the pressure on the baby’s brainstem. This is what we are dealing with. This is what we must deal with.

Chiropractic Vs. Conventional: Dueling Perspectives On Infant Colic…..
Clay Jones on September 13, 2013
Link
Infant colic, while not a deadly disease by any stretch of the imagination, is an extremely troubling entity. Not only can it be quite distressing to caregivers, it is also a well-established risk factor for neglect and abuse of the child. Excessive crying in general, whether diagnosed as infant colic or not, is a frequent impetus for seeking advice from medical professionals. How science-based providers approach the evaluation of babies with excessive crying, and the management of infant colic if diagnosed, can have a powerful impact on how families perceive the health of their child and on future interactions with the healthcare system.
Infant crying is about as bread and butter as it gets in pediatrics. It is a problem which we are constantly exposed to during our training. We discuss it with families in our continuity clinics, where we learn how to truly be primary care providers. We address it on the inpatient wards, where children often cry because of illness or pain, and during our months of service in the newborn nursery. We frequently are called upon to talk anxious parents through it while taking overnight phone calls, and we learn over time with variable success the seemingly preternatural ability to understand what babies are trying to tell us with their cry.
Crying happens for a variety of reasons in young infants, ranging from the benign and expected to the life threatening. Discussing excessive crying, regardless of why it occurs, requires effective communication skills. And the evaluation of unexplained excessive crying often tests the limits of our ability to practice non-defensive medicine, avoiding unnecessary laboratory testing and imaging. Because of all this, I believe that infant crying, and in particular the entity known as infant colic, serves as a useful entry point into a discussion of the differences between a science-based approach to medicine and one based on pseudoscience like chiropractic.
Readers of this blog should be well aware of the push by alternative medical practitioners for recognition as primary care providers, with the chiropractic community leading the charge. In this post I will compare and contrast the common understanding of the etiology and treatment of infant colic held by conventional medical doctors and doctors of chiropractic. You will see that in some ways they do not differ as much as we might expect, but have little in common where it truly matters.
What is colic?
With rare exceptions, all babies cry. Infant crying is typically an intermittent phenomenon related to hunger or an environmental insult like cold air or a dirty diaper. Many babies cry only when really bothered by something while some seem to cry all the time. In general, babies get most of their crying out of the way during the first three months of life, with estimates of the average total duration in the range of two hours a day during the first six weeks. Crying trends down after that. But how much a baby should be allowed to cry before a parent should worry, or before giving them a diagnosis, is very hard to peg down and risks ignoring the infant’s environment and the caregiver concerns when a baby falls short of diagnostic criteria.
So what is infant colic? In many instances, it is simply regular crying that crosses what is essentially an arbitrary threshold while in others it may appear more consistent with actual underlying pathology. And to further confuse our understanding of the concept, the designation of an infant as “colicky” has been rendered nearly meaningless by its widespread use as a nebulous word for any young baby who is fussy for unclear reasons. The obvious linchpin of the diagnosis is the perception by caretakers that the crying is excessive and requires intervention beyond normal soothing techniques, feeding or changing. Naturally, this is a highly subjective determination that is influenced by environment, experience and culture.
Despite these difficulties, there is a classic definition that is at least generally agreed upon by most pediatricians if not actually put into practice. The Wessel criteria, or “rule of three”, states that colic is an appropriate designation when an otherwise healthy infant cries for more than three hours per day, more than three days a week, and it lasts longer than three weeks. But when the parents of a young infant who has had long and intense bouts of crying but doesn’t meet these criteria come in for help, they tend to want an answer. So there is motivation to diagnose something when a baby that is less than about three months old cries a lot. Colic is an all-too-convenient something.
Though we lack truly evidence-based diagnostic criteria, based on piles of anecdotes involving young babies that cry a lot and aren’t sick there are certain signs that most pediatricians would describe as consistent with infant colic. Crying spells with colic tend to have an equally abrupt beginning and end, with no obvious relationship to the events surrounding the spell. They often seem to cluster in the evening (“the witching hour“) and are often felt to be qualitatively different than “normal” crying in that they are more intense and turbulent in nature. For example, the cry is often described as more painful, urgent and irritating by caregivers. Colic spells are often associated with stiffness, arching the back, flushing and a tense abdomen. Finally, young infants who are having what is thought to be a colic “attack” are very hard to calm.
These particular signs are common in infants with certain medical conditions, such as gastroesophageal reflux and intolerance to various components of formula or breast milk, leading some experts to link these phenomena with colic. A number of interventions aimed at treating those underlying conditions have been studied in babies that were diagnosed with colic or felt to have excessive crying by parents. Not much has panned out but there are some promising leads. But the subjectivity of the diagnosis is such that it is extremely difficult to study, and there is a great deal of plausibility to claims that many infants are diagnosed with colic because parental perception of the crying has been warped by psychosocial factors. So is colic a disease, or is it simply one end of a spectrum of infant temperament? Or does reality lie somewhere in between? Should it even exist as a stand-alone diagnosis, where it might potentially serve as a convenient foot in the door for those who would take advantage of weary parents?
Which babies “get” colic?
Which infants actually have colic, if it even truly exists, is a very difficult question to answer. What do we base this determination on? Do we follow strict criteria, which is problematic because it relies on subjective reports from caregivers, or do we use a more relaxed approach where if the parents are worried about it, it is probably colic? Pediatric lore tells us that colic affects about a third of infants, but the literature reveals anywhere from 8 to almost 50 percent. We know that most children who are considered to have colic by the primary caregiver do not fit the strict criteria.
Unfortunately, there are no well-established clues to what infant colic might actually be buried in the numbers. There does not appear to be any variable that reliably influences the likelihood of an infant being diagnosed with colic. Researchers have looked at a number of possible factors, including birth order, gender, feeding practices, and gestational age at birth and the data has not fit well with any possible association. Even breast feeding versus formula feeding, which I would have put good money on, does not appear to matter.
Probably the closest we have to a solid association are psychosocial factors such as parental stress and a lack of parental self-confidence. It is very difficult to entertain any claims of causality though. Does stress somehow impact parental interactions with the infant, leading to more crying? Does it alter the intrauterine environment? Is it all just epigenetics/magic (that’s for you DG) at play? Or does stress and parental insecurity alter the caregiver’s perception of reality? I have absolutely experienced many discussions at the bedside where I wondered if a parent was looking at the same child that I was.
So what causes a condition composed of nothing but non-specific signs like crying, and that can be diagnosed in virtually any healthy baby on the planet? Not to mention that the diagnosis is subjective almost to the point of rendering it meaningless as a concept? And once diagnosed, what is the best approach to decreasing the amount of crying, or in some cases the caregiver perception of the crying? How do we help these families? There are no easy answers here, but let see who inspires the most confidence.
The science-based approach
What causes colic?
We don’t know what causes colic. We don’t really know for certain if it is real to begin with. Perhaps it is merely a wastebasket or a useful framing device to aid in discussions with families about parenting and psychosocial risk factors. But absolutely any discussion of etiology has to involve a possible parental role. Infant colic probably does exist as a unique entity with an underlying pathology in a small subset of kids that have been diagnosed, and some that haven’t, but many with the label are probably completely normal kids with hypersensitive parents that are set up to focus on crying.
There isn’t great evidence to support any of the proposed etiologies. That doesn’t mean that there isn’t any evidence, just nothing to support a confident claim that would help us to narrow things down a bit and focus treatment approaches. Proposed causes can be broken down into three categories: Gut specific, biologic and psychosocial. Here is the best of what we have so far:
Gut – while not implausible to think that colic stems from issues in the GI tract, I would like to point out that there is a general bias towards blaming gas every time a baby cries. I have lost count of how many times a very ill or injured infant’s pain, many times caused by a broken bone, was passed off as gas by a caregiver or medical professional. There should be a special term for anchoring related to gas. It should probably be German. They have the best words.
1. Allergy to cow milk protein – Some young infants develop inflammation of the intestines when exposed to casein or whey. They are often quite fussy and most, but not all, develop bloody stools. If the largely clinical diagnosis is correct, within a week or two of changing to a specialized formula, the symptoms completely resolve. This is a fairly common condition and it would be silly to think that there aren’t at least some children diagnosed as having colic who actually have a mild case of milk protein allergy causing excessive crying but no grossly bloody stool or failure to thrive.
2. Fruit juice intolerance – Based on some small studies, fruit juices that contain sorbitol and a high fructose to glucose ratio might actually play a role in some infants with colic. This has decent plausibility as a possible etiology of some children diagnosed with colic. You shouldn’t give infants fruit juice anyway.
3. Differences in intestinal microflora – There are small studies showing that kids with colic have bad bugs and higher markers of gut inflammation. There are even small studies showing that providing good bugs might help some kids with colic. They may have been funded by Jamie Lee Curtis.
4. Gas
Biologic – Some of these make more sense than others (migraines, I’m looking in your direction).
1. Migraines – Yeah, probably not. This is based on asking if kids with migraines had colic as a baby.
2. Underfeeding, overfeeding, poor feeding technique, etc. – Hungry baby cry more than full baby. Vomiting baby cry more than not vomiting baby. Baby fed upside down or with a straw cry more than…well, you get the point. Makes sense to me. Of course many babies diagnosed with colic are fed just fine.
3. Immaturity – The brain, the gut, the gutbrain, etc. It is certainly plausible that some infants diagnosed with colic are more sensitive to external stimuli because of a general immaturity. Pediatrician to the stars and Jenny McCarthy punching bag Harvey Karp is a vocal proponent of this hypothesis. Immaturity of the gut, specifically gut motility, has also been proposed as a potential contributing factor.
4. Exposure to nicotine and/or tobacco smoke – This is very plausible and has some decent data in support of it. Both prenatal and postnatal exposure are implicated. What do you say to that Stephen Dorff!
Psychosocial – Who says that regular doctors don’t practice holistic medicine?
1. Temperament – Some babies just cry a lot. That makes sense. A lot of babies diagnosed with colic are helped by teaching parents how to better handle crying babies.
2. Hypersensitivity – Perhaps some babies are just stressed out after a long day and take some time to vent. Seriously, that’s a thing.
3. Parents – If there is anything we have learned in pediatrics, or during a trip to the Walmart, be very careful when you imply that any child’s behavior is the fault of their parents. But … maybe … based on some okay evidence … and I am really not judging here, but parental stress and parent-baby interactions almost certainly play a role in the diagnosis of colic in some babies.
How do we treat colic?
When a caregiver comes to a pediatrician or family doctor with concerns about their infant’s excessive crying, the most important initial step is to evaluate for any condition or environment that puts the child at risk of harm. This is regardless of whether or not the parent’s description meets any potential diagnostic criteria for infant colic. Even if the baby only cries for 30 minutes a week, it is vital to take any parent asking for help seriously.
To make sure that a baby is safe, and does not suffer from a serious illness or live in a home where caregiver stress is a possible risk factor for neglect or abuse, there are important questions to ask. Naturally these involve ascertaining the nature of the crying. What does it sound like, when does it happen, and for how long? It is vital to determine what soothing techniques the parents have been putting into use. Many young first time parents don’t know any, or what they do know might actually be making things worse.
Once while taking diaper duty in the middle of the night, I secured my screaming 1-month-old daughter’s pacifier in her mouth with Scotch tape during a particularly rough crying spell. I stood there, nearly delirious with fatigue, for about ten seconds before I took the tape off even though it was actually working. I was a 2nd year pediatric resident and luckily knew enough to realize that I was probably increasing her chance of dying from SIDS despite my foggy brain. Stress, fatigue and excessive infant crying can be dangerous combination. Even two pediatric residents needed help. What we learned from our daughter’s pediatrician and our own research improved our lives dramatically over the next few months.
How is the baby fed? How do the parents feel about the crying and about being a parent in general? How is the family unit as a whole reacting to the crying? What are any beliefs that the family has about why the child is crying? Answers to these questions might give insight into the possible cause of the child’s crying and greatly assist in determining what the next step should be.
After discussing the problem, a thorough exam is necessary. How is the child growing? Are there any concerning physical finding that could be a clue to illness or abuse? Are there any signs of pain that might not be related to possible colic? I once took a direct admission from a local pediatrician who was unable to determine the cause of a young infant’s persistent crying. After a thorough history and exam, she wasn’t convinced that infant colic was the right call. She didn’t anchor on the suggestion of it and asked for me to watch the child closely in the hospital after a reasonable work-up. The only reason I caught the clavicle fracture and she didn’t, luckily before labs were drawn, was that I had the benefit of time and multiple examinations. Infant colic is a diagnosis of exclusion.
There is no one-size-fits-all treatment approach to infant colic. But if after a thorough evaluation and assessment of the need for parental support infant colic is the diagnosis, a reasonable approach in many cases is to do exactly nothing. Infant colic will stop on its own, often by 3 months of age, and nearly all infants have significantly improved by 4 months. This is why infant colic is such a perfect condition for practitioners of irregular medicine. Colic will get better, and whatever is being done when it does will get the credit.
So what is the appropriate approach when a pediatrician and family decide together that an intervention is necessary? I do not think anyone would describe any of the proposed treatments as well-supported in the pediatric literature, but some have a better evidence base than others. First and foremost is addressing and managing parental stress. This may lead to a new perspective on the crying and remove the desire to intervene medically. Teaching simple soothing techniques can be an instant cure in many cases.
Based on the available evidence, which isn’t great, the additional intervention that has the best chance of helping decrease the duration and intensity of crying episodes is a trial of specialized formula which contains no intact cow milk protein or having a breast feeding mother observe a hypoallergenic diet. After that it goes downhill fast and any interventions likely work via parental placebo. These include feeding techniques to reduce swallowed air, probiotics, and distracting techniques. Distracting techniques involve things like pacifiers, baby swings and massage.
No medication is both effective and safe for use in the treatment of infant colic and drugs are rarely prescribed. Still, I wish all pediatricians and family doctors would have the concept of a pharmaceutical intervention for infant colic wiped from their minds, including even the ever-present simethicone (Mylicon). Though an uncommon practice now, I have seen anticholinergics, antihistamines, barbituates and opiates all used for healthy babies with infant colic. Herbal remedies, as they often do, show some promise in small and poorly designed studies but are poorly regulated. There are many examples of them being contaminated and/or adulterated.
What about other alternative approaches? The big ones when it comes to colic are homeopathy and chiropractic, which I lump together with cranial osteopathy as “manipulative techniques”. Homeopathy has no effect beyond parental placebo. Bet you didn’t see that coming. The manipulative techniques don’t hold up to scrutiny either. They follow the expected pattern of small and poorly-designed studies showing equivocal to weakly positive effects, while larger and better-controlled studies show no benefit.
The study that I found to be most commonly touted by chiropractors involved the unblinded use of spinal manipulation on roughly 300 infants diagnosed, using strict criteria, with infant colic. Based on maternal diaries and interviews, 94% of the infants showed significant improvement in crying after an average of 2 weeks of treatment, which persisted until the end of the study (at least 3 months post-treatment). None of this is surprising. It is merely another in a long line of examples of pragmatic pediatric studies that rely on parental placebo to achieve positive results. Add to that the fact that at 6 weeks most infants with colic are at the peak of their crying. Remember it typically starts at 3 weeks and is usually gone by 12 weeks.
Interestingly, some well-known traditional approaches that are still frequently recommended haven’t stood up to randomized study. Going for a drive doesn’t work, for instance. And speaking of things that don’t work…
The chiropractic approach
What causes colic and how do they treat it?
Most coverage of colic in the chiropractic literature or on individual practice websites will state much of what I just covered, although not in such detail and with considerably less accuracy. They keep it simple, speaking more in absolutes. None of the information discussed so far comes from chiropractic researchers of course. As with chiropatter about almost any topic, the first half to two-thirds is comprised of information derived from scientific investigation and the last bit consists of bashing conventional medicine while offering up a chiropractic solution. The most glaring difference is the lack of any discussion of the nuance and complexity of the diagnosis of infant colic.
As you might guess, the primary purpose of any article on colic placed on a chiropractic website is to convince parents to seek out chiropractic care for their children. There are many blatant factual errors and misleading statements employed to do just that.
One website uses the following definition of colic:
Colic is defined as severe, often fluctuating pain in the abdomen caused by intestinal gas or obstruction in the intestines and suffered especially by babies.
This is the textbook medical definition of colic in general, rather than infant colic. While they do share a name, they are not the same. One is a descriptive term for pain localized to the abdomen and one is what I have been writing about. Any healthcare professional desiring to be a primary care practitioner who sees children should be aware of the difference.
There are two extremely common chiromemes evident when researching the chiropractic approach to infant colic. The following quotes are prime examples of the measures taken to paint physicians in a negative light and make chiropractors out to be caring and competent healers:
Chiropractors address the underlying cause of your baby’s colic; they don’t just treat symptoms.
Medical doctors haven’t discovered the cause or solution to this common problem. The medical solution is not promising. Medical recommendations include drug therapy that is not very effective.
Treatment within mainstream medicine often includes drug therapy or simply waiting for your baby to outgrow this condition.
This doesn’t exactly do justice to the science-based approach and it does a disservice to parents. It simply isn’t true. Chiropractors haven’t discovered the cause of infant colic either and clearly have no understanding of it. They pay homage to some of the possible causes of excessive crying in some kids, like milk protein allergy, but they mindlessly recommend many of the treatments discussed above that have been disproven or have no good evidence to support them. They believe that the primary cause of infant colic is the vertebral subluxation and resulting nerve irritation or dysfunction. They see science-based discussion of immaturity of the nervous system as a possible but unproven etiology of colic in some infants and twist it to their advantage:
From a chiropractor’s perspective many of the resulting symptoms of colic may be due to nerve dysfunction, which results in poor communication between the brain and digestive organs.
The one true treatment according to chiropractors is of course the spinal adjustment:
Chiropractic adjustments for the correction of vertebral subluxations (nerve dysfunction) have long been acknowledged as an excellent therapeutic tool for infantile colic. In fact Chiropractic has been shown to have a 94% success rate with Colic.
I have yet to see a rational discussion of the role of psychosocial factors in the diagnosis of infant colic in anything written by a chiropractor. Many websites provide tips on how to soothe a crying infant which are borrowed from conventional medical recommendations. There is also a very good chance that the parent of a child with excessive crying will be offered herbal or homeopathic remedies.
Conclusion
Infant colic is a complicated clinical entity. It has the potential for negatively impacting an infant’s environment, thus indirectly causing harm, but in many cases is likely nothing more than a wastebasket diagnosis. The scientific consensus is that while some infants diagnosed with colic may have an underlying organic condition like an allergy to cow milk protein, or are manifesting symptoms of general immaturity of the brain and/or intestines, most are probably responding to their specific environment in a way that simply does not fit well with their caregiver. There is likely a spectrum of normal infant crying and some just fall on one end of it. And some infants may have what the majority of parents would consider normal crying but their caregivers have an altered perception of the duration and intensity because of psychosocial factors.
Most of the treatments aimed at improving infant colic are not supported in the literature but can appear to work because infant colic is self-limiting and does not last longer than two to three months. The best intervention is parental support and education in the hopes of improving skills to soothe a crying infant, and the development of a contingency plan when those skills fail. Changing parental expectations about infant crying in a positive way and reducing family stress as much as possible is also a vital aspect of management.
In contrast, the chiropractic community displays an overly simplistic understanding of infant colic that makes use of scientific knowledge which fits into its world view while ignoring the rest. Treatment recommendations unique to chiropractic are unsupported by well-designed studies. I believe that using infant colic as a litmus test for the readiness of chiropractors to act as primary care providers for children is a reasonable thought experiment, and one that reveals serious inadequacies in their knowledge base and ability to interpret the medical literature.

A New Study Finds No Benefit from Chiropractic for Infant Colic, but They’ll Keep Doing it Anyway
A new study attempted to answer the question of chiropractic’s potential benefit for infant colic. It was successful, but I don’t think it turned out the way the authors’ hoped. Sadly, I don’t think that this will change the mind of any chiropractor who treats babies.
Clay Jones on July 23, 2021
Link

In 2013, and then again in 2017, I wrote about infant colic in the context of bogus claims by believers in chiropractic and acupuncture respectively. At the time, although considerably more hopeful and optimistic than the tired shell of a skeptic that I have become, I never imagined that the application of pseudomedical nonsense to colic would end because of my insightful analysis and commentary. And, as that younger me would have surely predicted, here we go again.
I went into extreme detail regarding the definitions, epidemiology, and pathophysiology of infant colic in my 2013 post, and then again in the 2017 post on acupuncture not working as a treatment. I invite readers to check those posts out if interested in more detail. I will briefly discuss infant colic in this post before delving into a recently published “single-blind randomized controlled trial” that serves as a prime example of how bias muddies the interpretation of study results and of the classic “more research is needed” tactic used so often in the world of irregular medicine.
What and why is infant colic?
(Going forward I will just call this mysterious entity colic, dropping the qualifier, because I’m confident that readers will not think that I’m writing about horses.)
Colic is, essentially, a reified concept forged into existence by our attempts to measure infant crying. All babies cry to some extent, with some crying more than others, and they always have. Modern humans in the past few decades have arbitrarily established a cutoff, a certain amount occurring for a certain number of days each week for a certain number of weeks, and labelled crying in excess of that cutoff as colic. This is of course almost entirely based on the subjective assessment of caregivers.
The entire endeavor, as well as our approach to colic in the medical community and in society at large, is more than a bit ridiculous. Thinking of colic as a real condition, and communicating that thought process to caregivers, engenders an environment where a treatment must exist and should be sought out. These assumptions often result in overdiagnosis of things like reflux disease, the treatments for which are rarely helpful and can be harmful in infants, and can increase caregiver anxiety when no specific explanation or treatment is offered.
I am of course not saying that infants who cry a lot, or seem to, never have an underlying medical condition. They absolutely sometimes do. I encourage caregivers to talk to their child’s primary care provider about their concerns, and those providers should perform a thoughtful evaluation. As I discussed in my previous posts, it is not unreasonable to sometimes recommend a structured trial of dairy avoidance or a specialized formula to rule out a milk protein allergy.
With the possible exception of milk protein allergy, babies labelled as colicky rarely have a problem that requires a medical or surgical intervention and the unexplained crying will almost always improve dramatically by 3-4 months of age, lending credence to the hypothesis that colic is a manifestation of a normal developmental process in the infant brain. I think that most colic ends up being diagnosed because of an imbalance in the child-caregiver dyad, a mismatch of infant temperament and caregiver tolerance of crying.
But the amount or nature of an infant’s crying is not really the metric that should be focused on. What matters most is how a caregiver, or caregivers, respond to any crying and how pediatric professionals counsel them. Whether or not the crying is objectively excessive is irrelevant because perception is reality, and if a caregiver is at risk of harming their child something needs to be done to address their concerns. That’s why the best educational campaigns focus on coping skills. One great example is the Period of Purple Crying.
Chiropractic for colic?
Because this is science-based medicine, we can’t evaluate the potential role of chiropractic in the treatment of colic without devoting some space to the plausibility of such an intervention. Don’t worry, this will be brief. There is none.
The only purported mechanism of action involves fundamentalist chiropractic beliefs regarding subluxations and their potential role in the function of specific organ systems or general health. These beliefs are not based on any legitimate science. Specific chiropractic interventions would be implausible if the excessive crying was objectively present and caused by an underlying medical condition and it would be implausible if colic was, as I believe, a combination of normal development and parental perception. It is possible that a caregiver might perceive chiropractic to “work”, however, because of various non-specific placebo effects, in particular not taking into account the natural course of colic.
So, in my opinion, any claims of effectiveness for chiropractic would need to be based on an extremely robust evidence base in order to counteract the plausibility problem. But when it comes to pediatric research, the chiropractic literature is generally full of anecdotes and case reports. You will, in fact, very frequently find these stories of treatment success on the websites of individual chiropractic practices or even touted by mainstream chiropractic organizations. And while anecdotal observations can serve an important function in medicine by generating hypothesis, revealing potential pitfalls in our management recommendations, or giving insight into our patient’s lived experiences, they are not particularly helpful when it comes to determining if an intervention is safe and effective.
In today’s post, however, I get to discuss a bit of chiropractic research that isn’t simply a collection of anecdotes. It’s an actual study…with blinding! Recently published in Chiropractic and Manual Therapies, the official journal of the Chiropractic and Osteopathic College of Australia (no website available), this study investigated the potential effect of chiropractic care on infant colic and was designed as a single-blind randomized controlled trial conducted at four Danish chiropractic clinics.
After a not terrible discussion of colic and a nod to the lack of quality research on chiropractic for colic, the authors describe subject recruitment:
Children were recruited at the age of 2 to 14 weeks with symptoms of infantile colic defined as episodes of excessive crying and fussing that lasted at least 3 h a day, for at least 3 days a week in the previous 2 weeks. The children were otherwise healthy and thriving with appropriate weight gain. The children were ineligible if they had received chiropractic treatment before. Concomitant treatment for colic (e.g. reflexology) was not permitted during the project period.
Caregivers learned of the study from the media, maternal and child health nurses, and the participating chiropractic clinics. If interested, they then contacted the primary investigator themselves. After a phone interview screening, a home visit was arranged if appropriate and the potential subject was evaluated for any potential medical concerns and baseline information on the baby’s crying was obtained. So right off the bat there is a potential for selection bias where these caregivers might already be convinced that chiropractic is an effective treatment modality for infants. Blinding would need to be really well done.
Caregivers were also instructed on how to keep a detailed diary of their infant’s behavior:
These were filled out with a variety of symbols representing different aspects of the child’s behavior, including the amount of inconsolable crying (crying without an obvious reason that could not be comforted by the parents), the time the child needed to be held and rocked to limit crying (crying without any obvious reason that was only partly and briefly limited if the child was constantly held and rocked), the time the child was awake and content, the time spent sleeping, feeding patterns and bowel movements. Consolable crying with an obvious reason where the child was easily comforted e.g. hunger, or a soiled diaper was recorded as ‘awake and content’. To limit recall bias and make the recording of information as precise as possible, the parents were advised to fill in the diary several times a day, e.g. every time the baby was fed.
It’s good that they were attempting to make this as objective as possible, but including numerous secondary outcomes unrelated to crying (spitting up, burping, stooling patterns, etc.) comes across like a fishing expedition in order to have some random noise to pad their conclusion with. But maybe I’m just being cynical.
Parents obtained 3 days’ worth of baseline data and then met with the primary investigator at a chiropractic clinic in order to iron out any problems:
Here, any difficulties filling out the diary were identified, and the parent’s assessment of the crying pattern was evaluated in a second interview-based questionnaire
This is another point where so-called researcher degrees of freedom, whether manipulated intentionally or not, could lead to a false positive result. I don’t like that the primary investigator had so much face time with caregivers when the outcomes being measured are this subjective. Again, perhaps I’m being overly cynical, but it would be easy to unintentionally coach them to be assess their infants as fussier at baseline than they might have otherwise, which could make an intervention for colic seem more helpful than it really is. It is an unfortunate reality that we have to be aware of these potential issues.
Subjects were then randomized to either the treatment or control groups. Caregivers were blinded to the allocation but not the treating chiropractor. Fortunately, the research team and statistician were also blinded until after analysis was completed. It’s entirely possible that the blinding of the caregiver broke down at the individual practice clinics, but only 60% correctly guessed which group their child was in. As would be expected, caregivers were more likely to guess that their child was in the treatment group when their child’s crying seemed to improve more substantially.
In the end, 185 infants were included in the study and randomized into either the control or treatment group and were seen at a participating clinic twice a week for two weeks. Those in the control group would simply be entertained for 5 minutes behind a closed door and then returned to their caregiver. Infants in the treatment group underwent the standard infant chiropractic nonsense:
For children in the intervention group a full examination, including movement palpation of the joints was carried out, and the manual therapy applied was individualized according to any biomechanical dysfunction found. Thus, the chiropractors were informed that manual therapy could include manipulation or mobilization of the spine and/or the extremities as they found indicated by the child’s potential biomechanical dysfunctions, including movement restriction, tenderness or an obvious asymmetry in the muscles or joints. The treatment technique for restricted joint movements in this age group is, in general, very light short-term pressure with fingertips and gentle massage in case of hypertonic muscles.
Naturally there were problems unique to chiropractic “discovered” in every single subject in the treatment group. In the history of baby chiropractic, a patient being evaluated for the first time has never been told that they don’t have a problem that can only be fixed by some kind of adjustment or manipulation. But no evidence exists to support these biomechanical dysfunctions, movement restrictions, or asymmetries in infants.
After the 4th visit, caregivers continued keeping a daily behavior diary for a few more days and then received a coupon for 4 free chiropractic treatments. So yes, this whole thing was just marketing for the participating clinics. There I go again.
So did it work?
No. It didn’t. The primary outcome measured was the change in daily hours of inconsolable crying requiring soothing techniques such as holding and rocking. There was a small difference when looking at the percent of each group that had a reduction in crying by at least one hour, with 63% of babies in the treatment group compared to 47% in the control group. But when controlling for potential confounding variables such as age and baseline hours of crying, they did not find a statistical difference between the treatment and control groups when looking at mean reduction in hours of crying. There were also no meaningful differences between the groups for any of the secondary outcomes either, most importantly the caregiver’s assessment of the severity of their child’s colic.
The study authors did some light spinning of the results:
The results of this randomized, controlled trial suggested an overall small positive effect of chiropractic care on infantile colic, but the clinical significance is debatable. We found a reduction in crying time of half an hour in favor of the treatment group, which was not statistically significant. However, a larger proportion of participants in the treatment group achieved a predefined clinically relevant reduction in crying time of 1 h at a statistically significant level; in short, more children improved in the treatment group, but the difference was small.
Honestly, that could have been worse. They admit that there is a difference between statistical and clinical significance. They don’t admit, however, that it is likely that the small difference found wasn’t even real and would likely disappear in a larger study. And then this happened:
From a clinical perspective, the mean difference between the groups was small, but there were large individual differences, which emphasizes the need to investigate if subgroups of children, e.g. those with musculoskeletal problems, benefit more than others from chiropractic care.
The authors apparently fully planned to use the same data in an attempt to find a more substantial benefit through secondary statistical analysis/data massaging as a plan B:
We proposed this when planning the study, and investigations into potential treatment modifying factors will be the next step in the analyses of the study and will be reported in a separate article.
Here is the separate article, which found no treatment modifying factors of any use. It really is a mess of a study that involved several made up indicators of “musculoskeletal problems” such as “Does the child resist dressing” and “Is the child tense during meals?” They concluded that “None of the preselected items or predefined indices were valuable for identification of infants with potentially larger gain from manual therapy than others”. This did not stop them from calling for research into some other random findings suggested by the data. It really never will end, will it?
And don’t think I didn’t notice that the chiropractors providing treatment in the initial study diagnosed every subject in the treatment group with musculoskeletal problems. So it makes absolutely no sense whatsoever that they then act like this wasn’t the case in the second study’s reanalysis of the initial data. It really is all just a house of cards.
Conclusion: Chiropractic is not an effective treatment for unexplained infant crying
I applaud the effort by these researchers to design a study involving some degree of blinding and control, rather than just putting out a call for anecdotes. But these two studies are negative and do not change my assessment of the plausibility of chiropractic as a treatment for unexplained infant crying, or if you must give it a name, colic. Caregivers would be better served talking to a qualified medical professional about ways to cope with crying until it naturally decreases over time.

Chiropractic and the Newborn Baby
Clay Jones on February 27, 2016
Link

I had the pleasure of speaking on the topic of chiropractic and the newborn baby earlier this week at a meeting of the Boston Skeptics. There is a video of the talk online for anyone interested in learning more. And if you haven’t yet, please read yesterday’s post on chiropractic and babies by Sam Homola.
My introduction to pediatric chiropractic
Although I was aware of the existence of chiropractic well before beginning my medical training, I was blissfully ignorant of the full scope of what many chiropractors actually do on a daily basis. My belief that they practiced solely as “doctors of the back” was shattered early in my pediatric training at Vanderbilt while on a pulmonary medicine rotation when I was asked to consult on the child of a well-known musician who lived in the area. The patient, perhaps only hours from respiratory failure, had been brought to our emergency department only after chiropractic treatments had failed to manage a severe asthma exacerbation.
That encounter, as well as another around the same time involving a child with a throat abscess being treated with acupuncture, inspired me to dig deeper into the general concept of alternative medicine. I even went so far as to approach a local chiropractor who had set up a table at a Nashville YMCA to promote chiropractic prevention and treatment of the flu. Dr. Fakename happily allowed me to spend a day in his office, and even brought in his own child to demonstrate his approach pediatric care.
Needless to say, Dr. Fakename failed to convince me of the benefits or need for chiropractic involvement in pediatric healthcare. When the discussion turned to routine childhood vaccines, I heard the party line on the subject for the first of many times. Dr. Fakename was not against vaccines, he was in favor of giving families all of the facts. He gave me some reading material, and a book suggestion or two, which provided nothing but potential and unproven risks with no mention of the well-established benefits and proven safety of immunizations. I’ll never forget what his wife, who had brought their child in for the demonstration, whispered to me during a moment of distraction: “Don’t worry, we vaccinate our kids. I make sure.”
By the end of my residency I was a full blown skeptic of a variety of alternative medical modalities in addition to chiropractic, and had built a reputation as someone interested in and knowledgeable on the subject of quackery. I even gave a grand rounds on pediatric CAM with a focus on chiropractic which I’m proud to say drew a standing room only crowd that included folks from the community interested in alternative medicine as well as from the brand new integrative medicine center at Vanderbilt. I had even been asked to serve as a resident representative, however that invitation was quickly rescinded after my skeptical talk.
My particular interest in the chiropractic approach to newborn medicine came about by chance. While I still do care for hospitalized children of all ages, the primary focus of the majority of my career so far has been taking care of well newborns. The discovery of newborn chiropractic as an entity, while not as shocking as my initial exposure to pediatric chiropractic in general back in residency, was still surprising. And I continue to be occasionally surprised as I research this area of irregular medicine over a decade later. I always think I’ve found the worst example of their irresponsible and potentially dangerous interactions with children, only to be proven wrong time and time again.
Why do some chiropractors focus on newborns?
There are many explanations, ranging from the overly generous to the rather cynical, for why I believe that many in the chiropractic community target the newborn population. Probably the majority of those who see babies truly believe in the nonsense they are telling parents, putting on their websites, or uploading to YouTube. Perhaps they really do accept the existence of subluxations and that they are the root cause of myriad health problems in young infants, problems as diverse as difficulty breastfeeding, colic, and even sudden infant death syndrome. People are generally the heroes of their own narrative, so it is quite likely in fact that the vast majority of practitioners go to sleep at night feeling like they are helping parents and improving the lives of children.
Because of a history riddled with counter-examples and the widespread availability of solid evidence disproving the totality of chiropractic claims when it comes to newborn care, I can certainly understand why some might approach this question a bit less charitably. Practice building is a notorious aspect of chiropractic training and the running of their clinics after all. It is extremely easy to find examples of this relating to pediatric care, where the focus on children is treated more as a business opportunity than a calling. Convincing a parent who goes to a chiropractor to bring in the kids next time is a great way to increase patient rolls and profits.
How is chiropractic for newborns presented to parents?
Regardless of their intention, a chiropractor’s decision to treat newborns is particularly upsetting to me for obvious reasons. Parents are an especially vulnerable population in my opinion, and chiropractors are hardly alone in their attempts to convince them of questionable claims. A walk through your local Babies”R”Us should convince anyone of that sad fact. The primary tactic, whether trying to sell “The Big Idea” of chiropractic or a useless home monitor that won’t actually prevent SIDS, is always fear.
As discussed by Sam Homola in his post yesterday, the subluxation remains the fictional boogeyman used to convince parents of the need for chiropractic evaluation and treatment. Newborn and very young infants, they claim, acquire subluxations of the spine during the arduous birth process or during routine care such as changing a diaper. Even proven safety interventions such as the use of an infant car seat are potentially to blame!
But birth is the clear favorite when it comes to explaining why a baby is at risk for having a subluxation. Whether born via c-section or vaginal delivery, emergence into the world generally requires pulling on a child’s head, which can require a fair amount of force. As I explained in my discussion with the Boston Skeptics group, babies can acquire traumatic injury during delivery, such as clavicle fractures and injury to the nerves that supply the arm or diaphragm. And even without injury the significant pressure involved can transiently move the bones of the skull into a variety of odd shapes. This nugget of truth is well known to most parents and it is easy to understand why some caregivers are convinced that even seemingly uneventful deliveries might cause problems in a child’s spine.
Once the possibility, or more typically the extreme likelihood of a subluxation being present is accepted, parents are then made aware of what might come to pass if the condition is allowed to go untreated. Which pediatric conditions are claimed to be amenable to chiropractic care depends on the chiropractor, and can range from everything (even cancer) to a limited list that most commonly includes problems such as ear infections, bed wetting, constipation, sleep problems, asthma, weak immune function, and of course musculoskeletal complaints. In the newborn population, problems such as fussiness/colic, difficulty breastfeeding, torticollis, reflux, and sleep difficulties are common.
Some chiropractors go much further, even claiming to be able to prevent life-threatening outcomes by detecting and correcting so-called silent spinal subluxations. I’ve written in the past about such examples: SIDS and “shaken baby syndrome” caused by routine care or play. SIDS and abusive head trauma (what we now call shaken baby syndrome) are two of the very worst issues that pediatricians and parents face and the thought of families living in fear that their perfectly healthy child is at increased risk of death or permanent neurological injury unless they have regular chiropractic adjustments makes me very angry.
Of course not all parents actually need convincing. Probably the majority of newborns seen by chiropractors are born into families who already see a chiropractor themselves and have bought into the concept of subluxation and “spinal health.” Many mother’s of infant patients underwent chiropractic care during the pregnancy. A common theme used by chiropractors is to compare themselves to a dentist, pointing out how dental visits take place regularly even in the absence of symptoms in order to prevent cavities or to catch problems before they become significant. It’s a convincing tactic.
What happens during a newborn’s visit to the chiropractor?
Whether in the hospital (it happens!), at home (another one), or in the office, newborn chiropractic visits tend to involve a similar format. The most powerful part of the process, much more so than the actual adjustment to be honest, involves the laying on of hands. The chiropractor palpates the spine and checks movement of the neck and various joints. They may compare leg lengths or even hold the baby upside down (another one) in order to see how they turn their head. As they go they talk through what they are doing, usually commenting on findings such as tightness or restrictions and always explaining what problems a baby might experience because of subluxations. It can involve a fair amount of absolute nonsense.
There is a lot of cold reading that goes on during these visits which can give the impression that the chiropractor’s examination uncovered problems like constipation or colic. Most of the time the parent has told the chiropractor what the problem is and naturally the cause, a subluxation, is discovered at just the right spot to explain it. Some do a better job than others. Often the chiropractor reacts to random non-purposeful movements, yawns, crying, etc. by working it into the narrative. If a baby begins to cry during palpation, they found a bothersome area. If the baby happens to stop crying, the adjustment did the trick. There are countless examples of this evident on the hundreds of encounters I’ve see online and the few I’ve witnessed in person.
If you watch only one of these videos, make it this one. The chiropractor has an amazing bedside manner while discussing his evaluation. He really does do it all. Cold reading. The laying on of hands. Confidently describing complete nonsense. It’s truly a thing of beauty. He is all about the long game as he appears to say that the baby won’t need any adjustments at that visit, although as the video ends he seems to back track a bit. Here he is again explaining a specific newborn chiropractic technique and some underlying pathophysiology that it is almost complete baloney.
What is the chiropractor feeling during the assessment? They certainly aren’t feeling subluxations, as there is no good evidence to support that they exist in the chiropractic sense. They also aren’t feeling actual restrictions in movement with perhaps the exception of congenital torticollis, where a baby has difficulty fully turning the head. But this problem has nothing to do with the spine but rather unilateral injury to a muscle in the neck. In my opinion, and assuming that they aren’t knowingly deceiving the caregiver, they are simply feeling what they want and expect to find.
The adjustments performed on newborns and young infants are, in most circumstances, very gentle. This makes sense considering that many parents would be likely to bristle at vigorous high velocity adjustments to their baby’s neck or to loud popping sounds coming from their back. In fact, most chiropractic websites and videos that discuss newborn or pediatric chiropractic in general go to great lengths to separate it from the typical adult adjustment.
Chiropractors tend to use almost imperceptible adjusting force in babies, usually with their fingertips. They often claim to use an amount of pressure equivalent to checking for ripeness in a tomato, for example. Many use an adjusting tool like the Activator, a handheld spring-loaded thumping device. The latest model, a cordless electric version, costs a little over $1,500.
Sadly, the gentler approach so common in pediatric chiropractic isn’t ubiquitous. This video demonstrates a clearly painful adjustment of a 2-week-old infant using more substantial pressure. Here is another, which at the 2:00 mark shows a painful jerking adjustment of the neck of a different 14-day-old baby.
Is there evidence for newborn chiropractic care?
As with most indications for chiropractic intervention touted by practitioners, there is very little actual science to support their claims. If the basis of a treatment is finding and correcting the fictional chiropractic subluxation, then there is a lack of plausibility such that efforts to investigate the treatments have been and continue to be a waste of time and money. Treatment provided by chiropractors that is not subluxation-based often consist of other forms of alternative medicine such as acupuncture and herbal or homeopathic remedies that are equally unsound.
In the case of newborn care specifically, there is very little literature to evaluate. What does exist consists mostly of case reports, uncontrolled studies, and systematic reviews published in questionable journals. Thousands of anecdotes and testimonials are available on the websites of individual chiropractic practices however. I very recently stumbled on this study, which revealed to me that chiropractors are diagnosing “benign infant headache” in 2-day-old babies. It is a perfect example of how woefully inadequate their training in pediatric medicine is.
What’s the harm in bringing a baby to the chiropractor?
The ultimate problem with newborn chiropractic care isn’t that these babies are at high risk of direct injury to their developing backbone and spinal cord from aggressive manipulations, although it is a risk and it does happen. Steve Novella has written about such a case before. Here is another scary example where a child likely had their ribs fractured by an adjustment. So it does happen.
The more concerning issue is the indirect risk of missing a serious diagnosis or trying to treat a known life or limb threatening condition, both of which would delay access to appropriate medical care. The above cited headache study is a prime example. Their description of “benign infant headache,” a diagnosis which exists only in the minds and literature of chiropractors, is a prime example of this. Chiropractors, even when they go through post-graduate training in pediatrics in order to claim special designation, obtain a small fraction of the exposure to children, let alone ill children, that pediatricians and family doctors receive. There is simply no comparison whatsoever.
Another issue is that chiropractors who see children are often either overtly anti-vaccine or sneaky about it. They provide “education” that consists only of the risks. Were they to achieve primary care practitioner status I worry that vaccine rates among the subset of infants seen by chiropractors would drop even further. Disparaging conventional medical advice is also common. More babies being seen by chiropractors would likely lead to more families questioning other standard pediatric medicine recommendations because of unwarranted fears.
Conclusion: Chiropractors have no role in newborn care
The bottom line when it comes to newborn chiropractic care is that there is no role for it under any circumstances. There is, despite the claims of many in the chiropractic community, no evidence to support any indication in children that young. And although the risk of serious traumatic injury is low overall, it is not zero. And it will increase as more infants are brought in for evaluation and treatment of phony problems like the subluxation.
Their sometimes impressive demonstrations to families are packed with misinformation and are often designed specifically to bring in customers. Once a regular patient, any child who is truly ill is at risk of delayed care from a provider actually trained in pediatric medicine. And as more families are influenced by chiropractic vaccine misinformation, more children will be at risk for preventable and sometimes deadly diseases. Your child’s spine will most certainly be just fine without chiropractic care.

Separating Fact from Fiction in the Not-So-Normal Newborn Nursery: Chiropractic and Brachial Plexus Injury
Clay Jones on April 22, 2016
Link


Thanks to a hot tip from a follower on Twitter, I’ve once again found myself neck deep in chiropractic propaganda involving the care of a pediatric patient. The case as presented involves, among numerous specious assumptions, claims of successfully treating an infant’s paralyzed arm using chiropractic philosophy and spinal adjustment techniques. As I will explain in detail, this “miracle” is just another in a seemingly endless stream of emotional but worthless anecdotes being used for marketing purposes.
I’ll be discussing two videos, uploaded to YouTube by a father who wants to tell the world about the miracle of chiropractic. He uses that word a lot, in fact, assigning the label to no less than four outcomes and clearly setting the bar lower than my own personal threshold. The videos are a few years old, but have over 150,000 views and can still be found linked to on numerous websites and discussed in interviews. If you’re feeling generous, they serve as excellent examples of how the mind of the believer works when facing uncertainty regarding the health of a loved one.
I will provide a general synopsis of the events in question, but I do recommend watching the videos despite the fact that you will never get those 18 minutes back. They contain the details of the case and, particularly in the second video, some great examples of typical chiropractic tactics and buzzwords.
A Chiropractic Miracle, Part 1A Chiropractic Miracle, Part 2
The case of the baby with the paralyzed arm
In the introduction to video #1, a common scenario that I see frequently as a newborn hospitalist is described. After a lengthy trial of labor, a pregnant woman is taken to the operating room for a C-section because fetal monitoring has revealed the possibility that the baby is in trouble. In addition to the baby’s unstable heart rate, the mother has developed a fever and is at high risk of infection herself, which might also adversely affect the child.
These situations can be difficult. Obstetricians often must recommend surgical intervention in scenarios such as this based on imperfect monitoring technology and without certainty of benefit. They don’t have a crystal ball that reveals whether or not a baby will suffer serious injury or die if an attempt to deliver vaginally is continued, and C-section delivery can increase the risk of a bad outcome for mother even while it reduces the risk for the child.
Mothers frequently have to make a very brave choice. C-sections are scary and they can significantly complicate the recovery process, lengthen the hospital stay by 2 or more days, interfere with successful breastfeeding, and in uncommon circumstances result in unexpected maternal injury and even death, although the likelihood of that is extremely low. Choosing to shoulder this greater burden of risk in order to protect their unborn child is, in my humble opinion, heroic. Unfortunately, the current push for so-called “natural” birth has made this decision even more challenging because of increasing societal pressure for mothers to deliver vaginally and preserve a desired experience. There are also articles like this, written by an acupuncturist and “ancestral health specialist”, that may seem reasonable to a lay audience but grossly exaggerate the risks.
In this particular case, the C-section was complicated by a difficult extraction when the baby was found to be impacted in the pelvis. This isn’t uncommon. Sometimes the incision must be made bigger, which is not called “a double c-section” by the way, and sometimes obstetricians must use a vacuum device in order to help pull the baby from the abdomen. I recently learned from Jen Gunter that nitrous oxide can also be administered to relax the muscles of the uterus. But never is a delivery table “inverted to use the forces of gravity.”
With such a difficult labor and delivery, I’m not at all surprised that the baby was a bit stunned and required some assistance with respiration initially. 10% of babies in general need intervention from trained (ideally) professionals to begin breathing and 1% need significant medical intervention to establish breathing and an adequate heart rate. The father states that it took two minutes and forty one seconds to resuscitate his baby, but no further detail is provided.
I doubt that the baby actually required more than standard resuscitation, at most a brief application of positive pressure ventilation with a bag and mask. He shows a picture of himself holding his swaddled newborn in the delivery room and I don’t see a breathing tube or any umbilical lines. What he refers to in the video as “the first of four miracles,” that his child began to breathe, I call human physiology and basic NRP training.
She does have a right hand peripheral IV, which also isn’t surprising considering she was observed in the NICU for a bit. Brief observation in the NICU is often done as a precaution after difficult deliveries, and PIVs are quickly removed once the baby feeds and demonstrates normal breathing patterns. I bet she was watched for a few hours and then deemed ready to go to the newborn nursery.
The father goes on to describe the birth injuries that resulted from the difficult extraction of his daughter. She had some bruising and evidence of injury to the right side of her neck, which would eventually be diagnosed as congenital muscular torticollis (“wry neck”), and what appears to be a very mild left positional foot deformity. She also demonstrated a lack of movement of her right arm, likely caused by forceful stretching of her neck during delivery, but I doubt that the father was told that his baby’s right arm was “completely paralyzed” with the implication that it was permanent.
In the second video, which was published a year and a half after the first, additional details are given that involve him being told by hospital doctors that she would likely need surgical correction of her torticollis. I find this odd considering that most patients recover with gentle stretching, physical therapy is highly successful in more significant cases, and surgery is required in less than 5% of patients, generally for the most severe presentations or when the condition is diagnosed after a year of age.
Parkland Memorial hospital in Dallas delivers more babies than anywhere else in the United States, something like 35-40 babies every day. They have seen everything a thousand times. I do not think that anyone there would outright state or even imply something as inaccurate and anxiety provoking as “torticollis surgery would result in a straight neck but the inability to turn her head to the right for the rest of her life.” Human memory is such that I take recollections of stressful events that took place three years (2nd video) or even twenty months (1st video) ago with a huge grain of salt.
What is a newborn brachial plexus injury?
Brachial plexus palsy is primarily a clinical diagnosis. Even MRI is unreliable in differentiating the type and severity of injury in newborns, so giving parents a specific prognosis can be challenging. In general, decreased or absent movement is the result of stretching of the nerves and subsequent diminution or failure of conduction. This can occur with transient loss of the fatty insulation around otherwise intact axons or, in the most severe cases, when entire nerves are ripped out of the spinal cord.
Newborn brachial plexus injury isn’t common, occurring in only 0.15% of deliveries overall but in up to 17% of vaginal deliveries where the baby is stuck at the shoulders. I’ve seen a handful of cases over the past 13 years, with most being on the milder end of the spectrum. I’ve never personally discharged a newborn home with a completely paralyzed extremity.
Roughly half of presentations of newborn brachial plexus injury involve a characteristic pattern known as Erb’s palsy. In these cases, the baby’s arm is internally rotated, straightened out, and held against the body because of weakness in the shoulder and upper arm. In another 35% of cases, the Erb’s palsy is accompanied by additional injury that affects the wrist and hand, which is known as “waiter’s tip” positioning.
Involvement down to the fingers is uncommon but it does happen. Not surprisingly, fractures of the clavicle and humerus are occasionally associated with brachial plexus injuries, as are injuries to the shoulder and cervical spine, even true (non-chiropractic) subluxations. These injuries can mimic or exacerbate brachial plexus injury.
Spontaneous and complete resolution of newborn brachial plexus injury is the rule rather than the exception. Even when babies initially have little to no movement of the involved arm, the prognosis is good. Although imperfect, the general consensus is that any improvement seen in the first few post-natal weeks, even just wiggling the fingers, is seen as a predictor of eventual recovery.
Some children, even when early improvement is documented, do go on to have permanent deficits however. Treatment in more severe or persistent cases typically involves physical therapy to prevent muscle tightening, and to maximize strength and function, and sometimes surgery to reconnect nerves. Surgery can help but often does not result in the recovery of full function.
What is congenital muscular torticollis?

Torticollis or “wry neck” occurs when a patient has difficulty maintaining the head and neck in a neutral position, which results in a typical appearance of having the head persistently turned to one side. There are a number of potential causes at varying ages, but the most common is direct injury to the sternocleidomastoid muscle that occurs prenatally or during a traumatic delivery. The injured muscle tissue is replaced with scar tissue that makes it shorter and tighter, and may result in a palpable lump.
If the right muscle is injured, for example, the head is usually bent towards the affected side but turned to the opposite. Conservative treatment is almost always effective, resulting in complete recovery of neck movement, especially if started within the first several weeks of life. Stretching exercises can be done at home by caregivers and techniques can be implemented to encourage infants to move their head to the both sides on their own. Sometimes more intensive physical therapy is required and very rarely surgery, which treats rather than results in the inability to turn the head. Prognosis is excellent even in the most severe cases, and full recovery usually occurs within 6 to 12 months.
Now back to our case.
A chiropractic miracle story or a tall tale?
The father describes calling a chiropractor friend and business partner, who came to the hospital to treat his daughter that day. Within only three hours of an Activator adjustment, they saw the first movements of the right arm, and there was “complete resolution” on day 2 after additional adjustment. He relates how the hospital staff was in disbelief, and once again I doubt that his daughter’s doctors would really say the words that are being put into their mouths. This “second of four miracles” is more reasonably explained by the natural course of this kind of injury and some exaggeration of the severity by dad.
The “third of four miracles” was the treatment and resolution of his daughter’s torticollis within a year of birth. He naturally gives credit to a “highly recommended area chiropractor,” likely because of her DICCP certification and the four entire days she spent learning birth and post-partum pediatrics, who adjusted his daughter weekly for a full year for $5,000. They saw improvement by 8 months and resolution by the end of her first of year of life, which is the expected course for most cases when treated with gentle stretching regimens.
Finally, his “last of four miracles” is the resolution of his daughter’s mild positional foot deformity, which appears to be a calcaneovalgus foot. I’ve seen hundreds of these and they almost always resolve within a month or two without any intervention. He doesn’t outright claim that chiropractic played any role in the improved positioning of the left foot, but I think it’s implied. See what you think. There are plenty of chiropractors that will adjust subluxated feet, however.
What really happened?
Many babies with brachial plexus injuries, and I suspect that the child in this case is one of them, show signs of significant improvement in the first few days of life. That is the natural course of milder injury as nerve swelling and slowed conduction begins to improve. The time to full recovery is variable, but I have seen babies have significant improvement and apparent return to full movement of the arm prior to discharge.
I don’t doubt that most of the facts given in the two videos are accurate. An emergency section was called for which was traumatic and resulted in some injury to the baby. She likely had a mild brachial plexus injury that resolved on its own. She was eventually diagnosed with congenital muscular torticollis, which also resolved on its own or with simple stretching that was recommended by the chiropractor or the child’s medical doctor. Nothing specific to chiropractic played a role in the child’s recovery.
Of course we don’t have access to medical records, so we are relying on the potentially biased recollections of the father that may have become warped or exaggerated over time. It is entirely possible that the child never really had a complete absence of movement in the right arm. One clue that this may have not been as severe as dad is recalling is that peripheral IV. It’s in the baby’s right hand. Generally we don’t do any manipulation of the extremity when severe brachial plexus injury is suspected.
Even assuming that dad’s memory is accurate, the pathophysiology of brachial plexus injury is fairly well worked out in newborns. Stretching is by far the most likely etiology, not the dislocation of multiple cervical and thoracic vertebrae pinching the spinal nerves as they exit their respective spinal canals. That would be an extremely rare and severe injury, clearly evident on plain x-ray, which would not resolve in a couple of days by lightly thumping on the side of the neck. It has near-homeopathy level plausibility.
We also know the pathophysiology of congenital muscular torticollis. It is caused by injury to a specific muscle in the neck and subsequent fibrosis. It is not related to the position of the spine and, again, light thumping on the neck with an Activator could not possibly play a role in its resolution.
Finally, and I thought long and hard about whether or not to include this, the father in these videos is Chris Burfield who, is not a chiropractor but is a chiropractic strategic marketer who builds self-described “Propaganda Marketing Machines.” Here he is discussing how to case medical doctors’ offices for clues about their personalities and other “sneaky ninja” tactics to trick them into setting up appointments to discuss patient referrals. Here is one of Burfield’s websites where he discusses making and selling viral videos to spread the word about chiropractic. In this 2015 podcast interview, he discusses his daughter’s case and then how to use YouTube videos as marketing.
His career, and even examples of him discussing the use of YouTube viral videos to promote chiropractic, do not mean that he is intentionally misleading the public. It does seems shady, but I mention this more as an example of how one’s personal biases can mold our interpretation of events and even our memories over time. I found Burfield in a discussion on a Facebook marketing page stating that chiropractic brought his daughter’s paralyzed arm “back to life.”
Conclusion: The propaganda machine keeps on spinning
We will never know exactly how Burfield’s daughter presented after her traumatic delivery. Without access to the medical record, we will never know exactly how her condition was discussed by the treating physicians. Ultimately, as a pediatrician, a father, and a human being, I’m very happy that she recovered seemingly without incident.
Not every patient is so lucky. Putting faith in pseudoscience such as chiropractic philosophy can be dangerous. Depending on the technique used, a brachial plexus injury could be worsened and even made permanent if the nerves are further stretched. And injury to the neck, although uncommon, has been documented when chiropractors attempt to treat torticollis.
Finally, and I realize I’m adjusting a dead horse here, chiropractic marketing tactics are manipulative and shameless. I honestly don’t understand how they look patients in the face when using their memorized scripts or sleep at night after a day of pestering medical doctors in their offices or people at health fairs or shopping malls. Don’t fall for the hype.

Newborn Chiropractic, False Balance, and The Doctors
The vacuous TV docs on The Doctors have demonstrated once again why the show is a highly unreliable source for medical information of any sort.
Clay Jones on December 30, 2016
Link


On the December 14th episode of the Emmy Award winning “talk show-informative” spin off of a spin off (Oprah begat Dr. Phil, who in turn begat) The Doctors, the segment “Is It Safe for Babies to Go to the Chiropractor?” was aired. The Doctors, which debuted in 2008, is a program that aims to provide accurate and trustworthy information on a variety of medical topics but fails to do so roughly half of the time. It tends to be more accurate than friend of SBM Dr. Oz, but still generally adds to our societal burden of medical misinformation. In this particular segment, a skeptical viewpoint is presented but it is overpowered by false balance and an amateurish, though clearly well-meaning, attempt to counter common claims of so-called pediatric chiropractors.
A little shock and awe
As the segment opens, host Dr. Travis Stork, who I knew while in residency at Vanderbilt and have always thought was a nice and well-meaning puppet on the string of ignorant writers and producers, introduces the concept of newborn chiropractic with a brief video of a chiropractor adjusting a 12-day-old infant. To his credit, he comes across as skeptical and the clip is met with what appears to be shocked silence interrupted by a few gasps and one loud exclamation of “What?” This is exactly how I responded when I first learned that this was something that many chiropractors recommend.
Stork then points out that newborn visits to chiropractors are becoming more common but I’m not sure how he knows this. There is no data to my knowledge that specifically addresses this question. I imagine that he is basing this assessment on the biased information producers obtained from the chiropractors involved in the segment. What I do know is that claims of treating newborns, often in numbers that are hard to believe (just wait), are very common on individual practice websites and that there are many fumbling news articles (check out the token skeptic in this one!) and online parenting resources that discuss the subject haphazardly in such a way as to legitimize the practice and make is seem more prevalent than it likely is.
It is easy to come to the conclusion that increasing numbers of parents are bringing their newborns to see chiropractors based on what can be found online. Sadly I wouldn’t be surprised if the numbers are increasing a bit, but I am skeptical that it is significant considering that data from NHIS reports over the past 14 years hasn’t revealed an increase in overall pediatric visits. Another reason to be skeptical is that claims of treating impressively large numbers of patients is a common tactic taught in chiropractic practice-building programs. It is also easy to find individual chiropractors and even major chiropractic organizations like the International Chiropractic Pediatric Association claiming to treat “shaken-baby syndrome” or to prevent sudden infant death syndrome, all in an effort to drum up business.
Chiropractors are desperate for business. Despite the claims of chiropractic colleges and practice-building firms, they have high rates of failure and difficulty repaying student loans. Competition is fierce and America’s strip malls are practically littered with former chiropractic offices. Recruiting younger patients and focusing on wellness care and prevention (“You don’t wait until you have a cavity to see the dentist, do you?”) are a huge aspect of practice-building firm recommendations on how to ensure a steady and reliable cash flow.
A skeptic emerges from the audience
Dr. Stork follows up the video of a baby (and his or her caregivers) being manipulated by a chiropractor by introducing a representative of “the world of pediatrics,” pediatrician Dr. Dafna Ahdoot. As is common on the show, Adhoot was placed in the audience rather than on stage. It’s awkward, it undermines her authority, and I’ve never understood why they do this.
She is given the opportunity to speak first, to anticipate the claims certain to be made by the chiropractic proponents waiting to speak and pull the rug out from under them. Unfortunately she undermines her own authority on the subject by revealing that she doesn’t actually know anything about the subject and refers to it as “pediatric chiropracty.” While not unheard of, use of “chiropracty” as a noun is odd. It may have just been nerves though.
Adhoot then mentions how the video is disturbing to her as a mother, which I also find a bit unfortunate. As a father, I’m also disturbed by this practice but I don’t see how that is relevant. Setting the stage with an emotional statement like that further weakens her position of authority on pediatric care in my opinion.
She then appeals to her pediatric expertise and understanding of why some parents may turn to alternative therapies when their children are ill. Many caregivers do feel helpless when their loved one isn’t recovering from an illness or injury, and medical doctors sometimes have no available curative treatment at their disposal. Sometimes the phony validations and false promises found in the offices of irregular medical practitioners can lead a parent or caregiver to believe that they are doing the right thing. But Adhoot misses an opportunity to point out that most newborns seen by chiropractors are perfectly healthy and are being adjusted to treat common, benign, and self-limited complaints such as general fussiness, colic, breastfeeding difficulty, and reflux. She could have told the audience that any treatment would appear to be effective in these circumstances.
Adhoot then attacks what is largely a strawman argument when it comes to newborn chiropractic, although there are exceptions. She describes how “forceful sudden movements” applied to the body of a young infant puts them at risk of muscle spasms, fractures, and neurological damage. While certainly possible, infant chiropractic rarely involves the high-velocity, low-amplitude adjustments often associated with chiropractic care.
The overwhelming majority of chiropractors who treat babies employ very gentle adjustment techniques, often using handheld spring loaded devices called Activators that impart barely enough force to briefly indent the skin let alone break a skull or spinal bone. Chiropractors who see kids frequently work the gentle nature of the treatments into their sales pitch, usually comparing the amount of force used to checking a tomato for ripeness. One of Stork’s co-hosts, a plastic surgeon, even points out that it looked like all the chiropractor was doing was infant massage. Unfortunately this ends up making Adhoot potentially come across as alarmist and allows the defenders of chiropractic to reassure the audience.
This could have been an opportunity for Adhoot to point out that while direct harm is extremely rare (although not unheard of) this isn’t why bringing a baby to the chiropractor is problematic. Chiropractic training is woefully inadequate when it comes to pediatric care. They are simply not trained to recognize serious pathology, which can be subtle in young infants. To give just one of countless examples, an infant with a life-threatening intestinal obstruction called intussusception may presents as simply more fussy or sleepy than usual. As a chiropractor searches for non-existent subluxations, a child’s bowel may be dying. To be fair, Adhoot later implies this concern but it is a weak argument thrown in too late.
In addition to this form of indirect harm, chiropractic involvement in pediatric care tends to undermine the recommendations from science-based medical providers. Anti-vaccine sentiment, for example, is rampant in the chiropractic community. And although even indirect harm such as this remains uncommon, thanks to a still-decent herd immunity in most regions and the fact that most parents are unlikely to, when push comes to shove, bring an obviously ill young infant to the chiropractor instead of the pediatrician, family doctor, or emergency department, any risk whatsoever is far too high when compared with the utter lack of proven benefit from chiropractic in this patient population.
Two defenders of baby chiropractic join us on Skype
Dr. Stork then introduces a husband and wife chiropractic team, Stuart and Theresa Warner, who in addition to running a practice that reportedly consists of 75% children and pregnant women, also run a practice-building company that teaches other chiropractors how to convince parents of the importance of pediatric chiropractic in order to bring in more patients. Their tactics, in addition to a bit of insurance fraud, has gotten them into trouble in the past. So rather than two ambassadors for pediatric chiropractic care looking to educate the audience, The Doctors has provided a forum for a couple of shady salesmen to advertise themselves as a product.
Stork opens by revealing that he loves chiropractic and is, in fact, heading to one as soon as the show is done taping. Despite this, he admits concern regarding infant care. The Warners respond by claiming that “chiropractors have been adjusting kids for over a hundred years and that tens of millions of adjustments are safely and effectively given to children each and every year.”
Chiropractic was invented in 1895 by Daniel David Palmer, not exactly out of whole cloth but essentially as a clone of osteopathy that focused primarily on the spine. I have no doubt that some practitioners began treating children in the early days. Some also claim to be able to adjust the spines of elephants and horses with their bare hands, an accomplishment that has near homeopathy level implausibility. But those numbers I find hard to believe and consider it to be typical marketing hyperbole. Every chiropractor in America would need to perform hundreds of pediatric adjustments per year.
Stuart Warner then repeats a common canard that goes unchallenged. He asks the audience to consider that “chiropractic malpractice rates are a fraction of what other doctors pay because what we do is safe.” This may be accurate, but it says nothing about whether or not what they do is effective. Also they don’t take care of ill patients. He says this to counter Adhoot’s exaggerated warnings about potential harms and no doubt scores a few points with uninitiated viewers.
He follows this with another easily countered and extremely common claim, that the delivery process puts a newborn’s neck through extreme degrees of torsion and traction and is much more harsh than chiropractic adjustments. This implies that babies develop spine problems that must be diagnosed and treated by chiropractors. Adhoot could have headed this off at the pass by pointing out that while some babies do suffer birth trauma, there is no evidence that injury to the spine is common or, in rare cases where it occurs, subtle enough to be missed by medical practitioners in the newborn nursery. She could have told the audience that millions of babies are born every year who develop normally and have no major medical problems without ever setting foot in a chiropractic office.
Warner claims that “parents today are understanding and recognizing the important role that the spine and nervous system plays in their child’s health and well-being.” Statements like this are pure marketing boilerplate used on hundreds if not thousands of individual practice websites. Of course the spine and nervous system are vital to our health at any age, but this begs the question that chiropractors can do anything to recognize and treat problems with them.
Outside of some evidence of benefit, primarily when doing things also done by physical therapists, for a very small number of musculoskeletal complaints in adults, there is no reason to believe that chiropractors play any role in any patient’s health, especially a pediatric patient. This claim is also commonly used to imply that chiropractic subluxations can result in general health concerns, weakened immune systems, and impaired development. They do not because they don’t exist. They would not even if they did.
Where is the evidence?
One of the co-hosts of the show, a gynecologist who also earlier questioned the chiropractors’ claims regarding birth trauma, asked about actual evidence of safety and benefit for infants. Theresa Warner, who looks an awful lot like Bridget Fonda, responds by claiming that “there are more and more studies being done all the time and that data shows the efficacy of chiropractic care for children.” This is true but extremely misleading. Yes, more publications on chiropractic care of children appear at a steady rate, but they are of the poorest methodological quality, almost exclusively found in journals with clear editing bias, and mostly consist of unblinded case reports and pragmatic studies practically designed to give positive results.
The master marketers know that scientific evidence isn’t really what prospective patients and patient parents tend to respond to however. So it came as no surprise to me whatsoever when Theresa Warner followed her praise of the chiropractic literature by stating that “the truth is in the patients. There are millions and millions of moms and dads who will testify as to the life changing benefits that chiropractic has had for their family and their children. In 24 years of practice, we’ve seen nothing but children really benefiting.” Again, these numbers are highly suspect. Also sketchy are claims of 100% success in any form of healthcare. That just isn’t how the body, or the real world, works. This claim, which is just another marketing sound bite carefully constructed by this dynamic duo of pseudomedical nonsense, only reveals the degree to which confirmation bias can warp our perception of reality.
More fear mongering…from the pediatrician!
Sadly, Dr. Adhoot only appears to have prepared one line of argument to counter the claims made by infant chiropractors. When asked again about potential risks associated with the practice, she mentions atlanto-axial instability and spina bifida. The former, an extremely rare condition except in children with Down syndrome, would put a patient at risk of spinal cord injury should they undergo neck manipulation. The latter, a much more common condition, primarily involves the lower spine and is clinically silent in most patients. It would be very unlikely for a child with the most common form of spina bifida, which goes undiagnosed in the vast majority of patients, to be harmed by chiropractic adjustment. And infants with the uncommon but considerably more clinically obvious form would be extremely unlikely to be seen by a chiropractor.
Her worries have merit, but as I previously discussed they aren’t the main reason why infant chiropractic is of concern. And once again they are easily countered because she focuses on the rarely used high-velocity, low-amplitude adjustment techniques. Theresa Warner responds by stating that these conditions would be picked up during their initial history taking and exam, which is not true, but also that these patients would have already been evaluated by medical professionals and diagnosed prior to coming in for chiropractic care. This is also sadly not always true. Specifically in the case of atlanto-axial instability in a child with Down syndrome, 15% of patients would be at risk of severe injury and even death if their necks were jerked around and most go undiagnosed.
Final thoughts from Dr. Stork and friends
It’s clear that the co-hosts of The Doctors, who aren’t shy about endorsing medicals nonsense, are skeptical of chiropractic for young infants. Stork, a believer in chiropractic care for himself, straight up says he doesn’t buy what they are selling. They close the segment by pointing out the importance of having newborns evaluated by a pediatric professional. They also point out the need for good communication between families and their child’s doctor. So great job team. Wait….
Conclusion: A train wreck disguised as marketing
Despite the obvious skeptical stance taken by the hosts of The Doctors, the segment was a train wreck. The pediatrician invited to serve as a medical authority, though clearly well-intentioned, was inadequately prepared and none of the bogus claims made by the two chiropractors were effectively challenged. The Doctors followed the same format so often used in the media, offering equal time to two opposing viewpoints. Sometimes that is acceptable, but not in situations such as this where the weight of the evidence is so clearly on one side.
There is no real debate over the safety and efficacy of newborn chiropractic. Their claims, some of which may have a thin patina of legitimacy, are easily revealed to be total nonsense with minimal skeptical investigation. Sadly, the segment gave an undeserved opportunity for two chiropractors to promote themselves and their practice. it is likely that many viewers will come away from the segment confused about the subject or even more accepting of bringing newborn infants to a chiropractor.

More Fear-Based Practice Building: Shaken Baby Syndrome and Chiropractic
Clay Jones on November 7, 2014
Link

During my first clinical rotation in medical school, I found myself at the pediatric nurse station one afternoon waiting for a patient to arrive from the emergency department. An adorable older infant was there sitting in a bouncy chair, smiling and drooling as babies tend to do, and looking rather well for an inpatient. The nurse watching her explained that she had come a long way since first being transported to the facility by ambulance after being admittedly shaken (and almost certainly also beaten) by her mother’s new boyfriend one evening when she wouldn’t stop crying.
Now, cortically blind and facing a lifetime of disability, the child was awaiting placement by social services. I had experienced my first exposure to child abuse, a scourge of pediatric medicine that I hadn’t thought of at that point despite having decided on a career in pediatrics well before being accepted into medical school. I’ve since had many more opportunities to care for abused children, some of which involved considerably more visually disturbing findings and a couple that resulted in a child’s death. But I will never forget her and the feeling of utter revulsion I felt that day.
Child abuse is common and it comes in many forms that can involve physical abuse as well as neglect. Children under the age of 4 years are the most frequently affected, but children under a year tend to suffer the most severe manifestations. Head injuries make up the bulk of physical abuse in this age group, and they are often fatal. Roughly 40% of child abuse-related deaths occur in the first year of life and there is frequently both a history of abuse prior to the fatal event as well as missed opportunities for medical professionals to have intervened.
The head injuries that children suffer at the hands of abusive caregivers, if not fatal, are frequently still devastating. It is not uncommon for these children to suffer permanent neurologic injury which can include persistently altered mental status, cognitive impairment, cerebral palsy, blindness and recurring seizures. In addition to the child’s injuries, the psychosocial impact on the family can also be quite severe. I’ve seen families torn apart because of guilt and anger. 
Now if you’ve read more than two of my posts on Science-Based Medicine, then you are probably well aware of my feelings on the shady marketing tactics of the overwhelming majority of practicing chiropractors. According to thousands of websites, commercials and print ads, the average chiropractor has the ability to prevent SIDS, resuscitate distressed newborns and treat a variety of common (and not so common) ailments usually managed by actual medical professionals. They make these claims despite a lack of appropriate education and training, and a blatant disregard for even our most successful medical interventions.
Until very recently, if asked what I thought was the most vile example of the chiropractic community taking advantage of parental fear in order to put more patients on the adjusting table I would have gone with their claims to prevent sudden infant death syndrome. I still would probably choose that but I may at least have discovered a close runner-up. It has come to my attention, thanks to yet another self-inflicted descent, with nose pinched and breath held of course, into the miasmic internet sewers of subluxation-based make-believe, that many chiropractors are using the terms and imagery of severe child abuse, specifically the infamous shaken baby syndrome, to encourage parents to have their infants and toddlers evaluated for injuries to the spine.
Child abuse, especially involving injury to the head and the precious contents within, deserves to be taken seriously by our society. And if the chiropractic community joined legitimate pediatric healthcare professionals in providing science-based education on ways to recognize and modify risk factors in order to potentially prevent abuse, or discussed ways of recognizing abuse after it has occurred and how to access appropriate resources, I would give them the credit they would deserve. Instead, and to be honest this didn’t surprise me in the slightest, they have decided seemingly en masse to provide blatant misinformation. But before I delve more into this inexcusable chiropractic practice-building technique, first a brief primer on shaken baby syndrome.
What is shaken baby syndrome, and what it isn’t?
First described by pediatric radiologist John Caffey in a 1972 paper, “On the theory and practice of shaking infants”, what is popularly called shaken baby syndrome is actually a somewhat outdated term that continues to be used publicly because of its utility in parental education and awareness campaigns. But it is too narrow in scope for clinical utility. The more accurate and preferred diagnosis is abusive head trauma (AHT). Children suffer injury to the skull, brain and spine via a variety of mechanisms, one of which might involve the extreme translational and rotational acceleration-deceleration forces seen during a shaking event.
The other major component of abusive head trauma in children is the force applied to the head via blunt impact. Historically, there has been controversy regarding the roles of shaking and impact forces, and the literature is a bit unclear. There are biomechanical models that have led some to question shaking alone as a cause of the physical manifestations of AHT. Or perhaps severe shaking causes injuries to the spinal cord that are difficult to discover on autopsy, without injuring the brain directly.
There are clear cases of blunt trauma causing severe injury, where the physical findings can be agreed upon by all and seen from across the room. But there are also many cases where there are minimal or no obvious findings consistent with an impact to the head and a caregiver who readily admits to shaking the child aggressively and with significant force. Of course it is entirely possible that they were lying or that they didn’t realize that one or more impacts occurred while the child was being shaken. The likely reality is that shaking plays some role, although perhaps a much smaller role than initially theorized, and only in some cases of AHT.
What are the effects of abusive head trauma?
It appears that infants are more likely than older children and adults to develop “shaken baby syndrome”, whether from actual shaking or from blunt impacts, because of their unique anatomy and physiology. The infant brain not only has a bit more room to move around within the skull, thus increasing the opportunity for injury as it sloshes around during acceleration and deceleration, it is encased in a thin and less-rigid skull that does not provide the same degree of protection as in older kids and adults. The large head of a baby is also poorly stabilized by their weak neck muscles, leaving them less able to counteract forces occurring during vigorous shaking. Their brains are also generally less dense and their nerves largely lacking a protective myelin sheath.
The pathophysiology of AHT involves both primary and secondary sources of neurologic injury. Primary injury occurs when the child’s head is rotated or moves in a straight line (translational) quickly and forcibly followed by sudden deceleration. This can occur either during shaking back and forth and side to side or when the head is impacted by a blunt object like a table or caregiver’s hand. Although again there is some controversy over the exact mechanism of primary injury, the most widely accepted belief is that these forces injure nerve fibers and lead to bleeding within the retina and between the brain and the thick membrane that covers it.
As if this wasn’t enough, the related secondary injury can play an even larger role in the development of acute and chronic neurologic manifestations of AHT. This occurs when the brain is starved of oxygen for a long enough period of time for cell injury and ultimately death to occur. Acute primary injury can result in periods of breathing cessation and prolonged seizure activity, to name just two of the possible mechanisms of secondary injury.
There are more injuries seen in the setting of AHT than simply the classic triad of subdural hemorrhages, retinal hemorrhages and diffuse injury to the brain. Bleeding is often seen in other areas such as between the skull and dura, and within the brain itself. Fractures of the skull, although common, aren’t always present, even in the setting of severe intracranial injury. Fractures involving other bones also frequently accompany AHT, with posterior rib, femur, humerus and metaphyseal fractures associated with abuse more so than accidental injury.
How is abusive head trauma in children diagnosed?
AHT can be challenging to diagnose with certainty in some cases. Severe brain injury frequently occurs absent a history of trauma, although it should not come as a shock to hear that an alleged child abuse perpetrator might not be too keen on ‘fessing up to healthcare professionals or the authorities. More importantly there are also frequently no or only minimal external findings on physical examination. Adding to the complexity of AHT in children is the fact that accidental head injury, as well as a few medical conditions, can potentially result in overlapping presentations.
So if the mechanism of AHT is somewhat murky, and we can’t always count on the presence of overt findings of blunt trauma to the child’s head, how is it diagnosed? Very carefully considering the possible repercussions to the family and involved medical professionals if the wrong call is made. Children are often removed from their home and people go to jail. It keeps some of us up at night with worry, and unfortunately I have no doubt that the system doesn’t always get it right. But if the appropriate steps are taken, the likelihood that a medical condition or incidental injury would truly present in the same fashion as AHT is very low.
Diagnosis typically involves an expert combination of forensic interviewing, physical examination, radiologic imaging and laboratory analysis in order to rule out potentially confounding medical conditions that can result in a similar pattern of findings. The assistance of pediatricians specially trained in child abuse, when available, as well as experts in pediatric radiology, ophthalmology and neurosurgery, are often called for. And when there is suspicion of abuse, child protective services and/or law enforcement are notified. The role of the pediatrician in these situations isn’t to assist in a criminal investigation or to assign blame but to care for an injured child, although we are often asked to interpret medical information.
AAP recommendations for pediatricians regarding abusive head trauma
The American Academy of Pediatrics has released guidelines regarding the diagnosis and discussion of AHT:
     1.  Pediatricians should be alert to the signs, symptoms and head injury patterns associated with AHT.
     2.  Pediatricians should know how to begin a thorough and objective medical evaluation of infants and children who present for medical care with signs and symptoms of potential AHT. Consultants in radiology, ophthalmology, neurosurgery and other areas are important partners in medical evaluation and can assist in interpreting data and reaching a diagnosis.
     3.  Pediatricians should consider consulting a subspecialist in the field of child abuse pediatrics to ensure that the medical evaluation of the patient has been complete and that the diagnosis is accurate.
     4.  Pediatricians should use the term “abusive head trauma” rather than a term that implies a single injury mechanism, such as shaken baby syndrome, in their diagnosis and medical communications.
     5.  Pediatricians should continue to educate parents and caregivers about safe approaches to calming and coping with crying infants and the dangers of shaking, striking, or impacting an infant’s head.
What is the chiropractic approach to abusive head trauma?
Now that I’ve provided a decent, although far from complete, review of abusive head trauma from the standpoint of science-based medicine, let’s look into how the chiropractic community tackles this complicated subject. Keep in mind their push in many states to gain primary care practitioner status. A search of the American Chiropractic Association yielded no discussion of child abuse in general, let alone AHT. The International Chiropractic Pediatric Association mentions the concept of shaken baby syndrome in an issue of their Pathways to Family Wellness magazine:
Shaken Baby Syndrome was originally referred to as a “whiplash” injury. Shaken Baby Syndrome occurs when a child is shaken violently in a to-andfro [sic] fashion. Such violence can cause hematomas (bruising) in the area between the skull and the brain, retinal hemorrhaging (bleeding in the eyes), and, less commonly, fractures to the skull.
Though most people feel that Shaken Baby Syndrome occurs only as an act of violence, it can also occur during play activities that were never meant to harm. These activities include:
    • Repeated and vigorous tossing of a child into the air. This allows a “whipping” motion of the head and neck.
    • Jogging with infant on back or shoulders. Just because the infant is in a carrying restraint does not mean that head is supported in a neutral position.
    • Bouncing the child on knee or swaying the leg back and forth, creating a to-and-fro motion and a “whipping” motion of the head and neck.
    • Swinging child around by ankles. The child will attempt to move head against force of motion. This can cause “whipping” of the head and neck.
    • Spinning child around in circles. The child’s head will feel very heavy and will often fall backwards, causing the “whipping” motion.
Signs and/or symptoms of brain stem swelling (e.g. Shaken Baby Syndrome) include: constant crying, stiffness, inability to wake up or sleeping more than usual, and vomiting. If you see any of these symptoms in your infant or child after any play or injury, take them to their doctor immediately. Please use caution at all times in order to best protect your infant or child from such injuries.
Many individual chiropractic practice websites express even more blatant misinformation:
This damage has been known to occur after playfully throwing the child up in the air and catching him/her. The damage caused is called Shaken Baby Syndrome. Not only being shaken or thrown but being spanked can also cause spinal or neurological damage to a child. Any child who has been subjected to this rough behavior desperately needs a chiropractic checkup to prevent possible nerve damage.
Another:
An infant’s spine is very susceptible to injury. “Shaken Baby Syndrome”, which occurs when a baby is severely shaken, can cause eye and brain damage, blindness, paralysis, convulsions, and even death. It is a cause of post-natal brain damage that most medical doctors don’t even recognize. Chiropractors have been dealing with the effects of SBS for over a century.
Childhood is a very “physical” time for all of us. Although they are all part of normal childhood, running, jumping, falls, and accidents can all cause VSC [verterbral subluxation complex] and nerve damage, with serious consequences.
It only makes sense for parents to have their children’s spines checked regularly throughout the growing years.
“When Playtime Can Be Unsafe“:
As parents and caregivers it is important to be aware of how fragile our children and their delicate bodies can be. As chiropractors, when adjusting newborns and children, our mission is to remove all nerve interference that prevents a child from reaching their optimum potential. This happens through our adjustments of course, but educating our patients about preventing activities that cause injury and nerve interference in the first place is also a big part of our mission.
Mention of shaken baby syndrome most frequently comes up on chiropractic websites when touting their ability to cure colic. They rightfully state that babies perceived as having colic are at increased risk of being abused. Tired and stressed caregivers are more likely to both interpret their infant as being fussy and to have poor coping skills, sometimes resulting in “losing it.” But chiropractors are begging the question that they can do anything about infant crying. I’ve covered chiropractors and colic in a prior post.
It is abundantly clear, and hardly a shock, that chiropractors have an extremely limited understanding of abusive head trauma in children. And their use of “shaken baby syndrome” is a marketing ploy that preys on parental fear rather than informs caregivers how to reduce the incidence of abuse. Their claim that a child might suffer brain damage during normal activity and play is absurd and abhorrent. There may be controversy over the exact mechanism of injury in AHT, but it is well accepted that the force applied must be violent in nature. Even incidental falls involving impact to the head rarely result in the patterns and severity of injuries seen with AHT.
Finally, some chiropractors even attribute shaken baby syndrome to injury from vaccinations. This topic has been well covered by others, so I’ll leave it at that.
Conclusion
Abusive head trauma is a tragic event associated with high rates of mortality and severe morbidity in the most vulnerable among the pediatric population. Although imperfect, over the past several decades our understanding of the risk factors and underlying mechanism of injury has steadily improved, and pediatric medical professionals at every level of care strive to prevent abuse or at least recognize it as soon as possible. We are aware of our limitations and even our failures in this endeavor via the process of scientific endeavor, but remain steadfast in our goal of saving lives and preserving families.
The chiropractic community, a substantial percentage of which would like to serve as primary care practitioners for young children, appears to take a different approach. Taking advantage of the mental imagery attached to severe child abuse, primarily the entity known as shaken baby syndrome, they seek to increase their income by telling parents of healthy children that routine activity and play might lead to a similar outcome. And naturally they claim the ability to detect and correct injury before it results in serious problems.
To be fair, I don’t really know what is in the hearts of the chiropractors that do this. It’s entirely possible if not likely that the majority of them truly believe it. Yet no evidence exists to support the claim that neurologic injury remotely as severe as that associated with shaken baby syndrome or abusive head trauma can occur with routine activity and play. Similarly the evidence that chiropractic training, even their own version of advanced training in pediatrics, provides insight into childhood illness or injury management is also lacking. But ignorant or evil, the end result is the same.

Chiropractor Treating Concussions for Earlier Return to Play
A chiropractor is using questionable diagnostic and therapeutic measures to return athletes to play sooner after a concussion. Not a good idea.
Harriet Hall on April 23, 2019
Link

A science teacher contacted me with concerns about a story he saw on his local TV news. It featured a chiropractor in his area who is treating athletes with concussions. He claims that with dynamic compression therapy and the BrainTap device, these athletes can return to their sport weeks early. Are other chiropractors doing this? Are any medical doctors doing it? Is there any evidence that these treatments work? Are patients being endangered by a premature return to play? Should chiropractors be treating concussions?
Concussions
Concussion is the most common type of traumatic brain injury (TBI). It is usually caused by a blow to the head, but there may be no external signs of head trauma, and it may or may not involve a loss of consciousness. There is a temporary loss of normal brain function, often with loss of memory, confusion, and other deficits. There can be microscopic damage that doesn’t show up on a CT scan. A post-concussive syndrome with symptoms like headache, dizziness, and difficulty concentrating can persist, sometimes for months or even years.
Concussions are common in football, soccer, and other contact sports. 34% of college football players have had one concussion; 20% have had multiple concussions. After a first concussion, athletes are four to six times more likely to suffer a second concussion. In second-impact syndrome, when a second concussion occurs before the patient has completely recovered from the first, acute brain swelling and increased intracranial pressure can occur and may be fatal.
Effects are cumulative, and with repeated concussions there is an increased risk of depression, Alzheimer’s, memory deficits, and the “punch drunk” syndrome first noted in boxers.
In recognition of the potentially serious consequences, guidelines for return to play after a concussion have been developed by numerous organizations. There is no treatment that will speed recovery. Rest is the first step, followed by a graded return to activity and clearance for sports only after full recovery.
Chiropractors want to be team doctors. There is even an American Chiropractic Board of Sports Physicians. Chiropractic is not a science. It is more like a cult. The majority of chiropractors still accept the subluxation myth, and a large percentage of them discourage immunizations and practice applied kinesiology (bogus muscle testing) and ineffective treatments. In my opinion, patients (especially patients with concussion) would be better served by science-based medical doctors.
Dynamic compression therapy
While I found some information ondynamic compression therapy, I couldn’t find anything on its use for concussion. Dynamic compression therapy is used to speed recovery after exercise by providing “peristaltic” pulsed pressures to the lower extremities, basically a form of mechanical leg massage. It seems to be offered mainly by chiropractors. It is said to “flush out toxins”. The toxins are not specified. I looked for supporting scientific studies and didn’t find any.
BrainTap
BrainTap is a gimmick that allegedly “turns your brainwaves into a symphony,” entraining your brain waves witha proprietary neuro-algorithm using sound and light, with binaural beats, guided visualization, 10-cycle holographic music, isochronic tones, and pulsing lights that “travel through the retina and ear meridians.” The company website has a tab for “The Science Behind BrainTap” but it consists of pseudoscientific gobbledygook rather than scientific studies.
Canary concussion test
The same chiropractor is using the Canary concussion test in his role as team chiropractor for a high school. It asks the usual questions but uses new technology to analyze the patient’s voice before and after an injury and supposedly can tell if it has changed due to a concussion. He thinks it can also be used to determine when recovery is complete. The same voice recognition technology is being used to test for everything from Parkinson’s to dementia. I couldn’t find any supporting scientific studies. The test doesn’t seem to have been validated in any way.
Conclusion: not a better way to treat concussions
There is very little information available, and what there is smacks of a non-science-based chiropractor’s typical enthusiasm for jumping on the bandwagon for anything new. There is certainly no evidence that he has found a better way to diagnose concussions or speed athletes’ return to play. Medical doctors have established guidelines to protect patients, and it seems to me it would be foolish to replace mainstream practices without having any evidence that the new practices are better or even equivalent. I hope this silliness will not catch on. Patients could be harmed.

Sports Physicals, Sudden Death, and Chiropractors
Sports physicals could prevent cases of sudden cardiac death in children, but could be improved even more. What won’t improve things is letting a chiropractor do it.
Harriet Hall on October 16, 2012
Link
A correspondent sent me a link to an article about the decision of the Wichita Falls (Texas) Independent School District to recommend that chiropractors be allowed to give sports physicals to junior high and high school students. Current policy limits examiners to physicians, physician assistants, and nurse practitioners. Adding chiropractors to this list would bring the district in line with policies in the rest of Texas, as well as in some other states. And it would “give parents more options.”
I’ve written about the attempts of some chiropractors to assume the role of family doctors and why I think it is a terrible idea. The idea of allowing them to do sports physicals impresses me as somewhat less terrible, but not by very much.
The reasons for requiring sports physicals
The goals of the Pre-participation Athletic Exam (PAE) include:
    • To identify athletes who should not participate because of high risk of injury or death
    • To identify those who require further evaluation or treatment so they can participate safely
    • To identify conditions that do not affect athletic participation but that should be treated
    • To possibly identify those at risk for substance abuse, depression, violence, etc.
    • To provide preventive health advice
    • To satisfy legal requirements.
According to a review article in American Family Physician
Specific conditions that would exclude or limit athletic participation include hypertrophic cardiomyopathy, long QT interval syndrome, concussion, significant knee injury, sickle cell disease and uncontrolled seizures. Overall, about 1 percent of athletes who are screened are completely disqualified from sports participation.
The greatest concern is the risk of sudden death.
Sudden cardiac death
In the fifth century BC, Phidippides ran 25 miles to bring the news of victory in the battle of Marathon to Athens. After delivering his message to the archons, he collapsed and died. Sudden death during or immediately after athletic exertion continues to be a problem. Estimates of incidence range from one young athlete in 200,000 every year to 1 in 43,770 NCAA athletes and 1 in 3100 NCAA Division I male basketball players per year. A Minneapolis Heart Institute Foundation study of sudden deaths in trained athletes identified 158 deaths, 85% due to cardiovascular causes. Hypertrophic cardiomyopathy was the most common cause. Physical exams are not very good at preventing these deaths. 115 of these athletes who died suddenly had had a standard preparticipation medical evaluation, and only 4 of them had been suspected of having cardiovascular disease. Of those 4, the abnormality responsible for sudden death was correctly identified in only one.
An article in the Journal of Athletic Training characterized current screening methods as “ineffective and inefficient.” The standard history and physical exam result in an extremely small number of significant cardiac findings. Screening ECGs have been proposed but are generally considered to be ineffective because of the high false positive rate. In a study of 501 college athletes, 75 had abnormal ECGs requiring further examination, but none of them led to restrictions from participation.
Italy has an aggressive screening program that disqualifies 1.8% of athletes for
    • physical features of Marfan syndrome;
    • delayed femoral arterial pulses;
    • single, wide or fixed splits in the second heart sound;
    • systolic or diastolic murmurs of grade 2/6 or greater;
    • irregular rhythms; or
    • blood pressures greater than 145/90 mm Hg
This screening reduced the mortality of young competitive athletes by approximately 90%. But other sources show that the overall SCD incidence in Italy remains similar to that in the US.
Screening all athletes with echocardiography would identify many athletes at risk for sudden death, but it would cost an average of $857 per patient. False positive findings may lead to expensive further evaluations, and there are emotional costs (worry, stress, persistent fear of death even after reassurance of normality). There are also false negatives.
The American Heart Association has a list of recommended screening items including family history of sudden death and cardiovascular disease, personal history of 6 specific symptoms, 4 physical exam items, and parental verification. In one review, only 17 of 43 state forms met AHA recommendations.
Non-cardiac problems
Blood pressure, weight and vision are tested. The PAE can identify patients with post-concussive sequelae to help prevent second-impact syndrome. Patients with a single eye, sports injuries. Patients with seizure disorders can be dissuaded from high risk sports like high diving. Exercise induced asthma can be treated. Patients with sickle cell trait can be counseled about hydration and acclimatization. Old injuries can be assessed for complete healing. Tests like duck-walking (walking in a deep squat) can detect a torn meniscus. Eating disorders may be identified. Contagious skin infections may be spotted.
There are other benefits. The exam offers an opportunity to address prevention issues (smoking, seatbelt use, etc.). It can identify health concerns that don’t directly affect participation but that need further evaluation and treatment.
How are sports physicals done?
There is a standard form for these exams that is recommended by several medical organizations. Not all schools use this form, but all have some kind of history form to be completed by student and parents, and a checklist for things to be looked at in the physical exam.
The history is the most important part of the process, identifying up to 78% of pertinent conditions. Unfortunately, as Dr. House says on the TV series, “patients lie.” Children and parents are motivated to get clearance to play a sport and may intentionally omit or minimize symptoms or past illnesses/injuries that they think might disqualify them. The ideal examiner is the child’s personal physician who already knows the health history and family history in depth. A family physician or pediatrician has the broad training to pick up potential problems in all areas.
Other than the cardiovascular exam recommendations from the AHA, there is little guidance about which physical exam components are worthwhile. Should we have every patient duck-walk to test for meniscal tears in the knee? Is measuring every child’s height really important? How often does a cursory exam for enlarged lymph nodes lead to a significant diagnosis? When the form calls for musculoskeletal exam of the wrist/hand/fingers, should we just look to see if all the fingers are there, or should we test strength, flexibility, and range of motion? What criteria define a significant finding in this context, and what actions are indicated for positive findings? We simply have no evidence to guide us.
There are two ways to get these exams. Students can be seen by their personal physician; but this involves cost and inconvenience, and timely appointments may not be available. Some schools offer mass screening exams with an assembly line of stations where individual tasks are accomplished, like vision testing and BP measurement, ending with a station where a physician reviews the results and examines the patient. This method is cost-effective and time-effective, but it may decrease quality.
I have participated in those mass screenings, and I hated them. They were a chore to be endured, with limited time for interactions with the patient and with little sense of purpose. Back when I was doing them we had no guidance and little understanding of what we should be looking for; and it easily degenerated into a perfunctory task of checking items off on a list with the feeling that it wasn’t going to make any difference to anybody anyway. Only around one percent of patients have a disqualifying condition, and it can be very tedious to wade through the other 99. I’ve always disliked doing routine physicals of any kind, because they are largely unproductive, as I explained in another post. Doing a physical in pursuit of a diagnostic problem is fun, stimulating, and rewarding. Listening to the normal hearts of 99 often shy and embarrassed teen and pre-teen strangers is not. I’d much rather see a regular patient in my office and fill out the form based on a long-term relationship and a limited, directed physical exam.
Who can do these exams?
    • 5 states have no specific recommendations
    • 21 states allow PAs and NPs to perform these exams
    • 10 states allow chiropractors
    • 1 state allows naturopaths
    • Colorado allows chiropractors to do school physicals but requires special training and certification.
Some PAs and NPs have enough training and experience to detect cardiovascular disease, but few chiropractors do. Specific training might bring selected chiropractors up to an acceptable level, but there are other considerations. They might miss things because they still would not have the broad experience of all kinds and severities of illness that physicians get with in-hospital training, and they might be influenced by belief systems that are outside the scientific paradigm. Less than half of chiropractors support immunization, many of them use bogus muscle testing (applied kinesiology), and many of them still imagine they are correcting mythical subluxations: those at least would have to be excluded. And they would have to be prevented from soliciting customers for chiropractic adjustments and from spreading misinformation. The whole thing is just too problematic.
Questions and answers
Q: How effective is the sports physical for identifying health problems?
A: Not nearly as effective as it could be.
Q: Which health problems should preclude athletic participation or defer it pending further testing?
A: Controversies exist; there are few absolutes, and the degree of risk varies with the magnitude of the problem.
Q: Does the requirement for sports physicals reduce the rates of injury or death?
A: There’s some evidence that it does, but it’s not entirely conclusive, and the reduction is likely small in magnitude. And even if barred from athletic programs a young person may choose to ignore advice and risk injury or sudden death by strenuous recreational exertions.
Conclusion (AKA my humble opinion)
Sports physicals have the potential to significantly reduce the risk of injury and death, but in actual practice they are often inadequate. They could be improved by standardization and more rigor, including uniform application of AHA recommendations. Ideally, they would be done by the child’s family physician. Ideally, examiners would have specific training in what to look for and which exam procedures to use, training that will be problematic until we can support specific recommendations with better evidence. Physicians and properly trained, experienced PAs and NPs are qualified to do these exams. Chiropractors and other alternative providers are not, even with special certification and training.

Osteopathy in the NICU: False Claims and False Dichotomies
John Snyder on January 31, 2014
Link
I would like to preface this post by stating that I have worked with many DOs (Doctors of Osteopathy), and I have helped train many pediatric residents with DO degrees. I have found no difference in the overall quality of the training these students have received, and some of the very best clinicians I have ever worked with have been DOs. I would never prejudice my assessment or opinion of a physician based on whether they have an MD or a DO after their name.
Now, on to the discussion at hand.
I recently stumbled upon an article entitled, “Effect of osteopathic manipulative treatment on length of stay in a population of preterm infants: a randomized controlled trial”. There is nothing particularly exciting or interesting about this study, as there have been many published on the use of osteopathic manipulative therapy (OMT) in children. There aren’t that many RCTs, however, and this particular one, although published in the open-access BioMed Central Pediatrics (impact factor 1.98), was chosen to be included in AAP Grand Rounds. AAP Grand Rounds is a publication put out by the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) to help pediatricians “Stay current and save time with monthly critical, evidence-based summaries of clinical content from nearly 100 journals.” Because the AAP found this important enough for mention in this widely read publication, with a distribution of 19,000 (source: AAP, 2014), I thought it would be interesting to take a closer look at it. I am also interested in the very odd existence of the two, distinct paths to becoming a physician in this country, osteopathic and traditional medical school training. The distinction between the two is rarely discussed, even within the halls of academia or in our health care centers. That’s not to say that the topic isn’t discussed at all (in fact it was highlighted very recently right here on SBM), it has just remained a somewhat politically incorrect subject, sliding mostly under the radar. Having worked with and trained pediatricians with osteopathic degrees, I can tell you that discussions about this are considered taboo. This is primarily because osteopathic physicians have become mainstreamed over time (see below), and discussing the validity of the existence of their “specialness” is an awkward proposition. After taking a look at the paper in question, I’ll address this issue some more as I think it deserves additional attention.
Effect of osteopathic manipulative treatment on length of stay in a population of preterm infants: a randomized controlled trial.
This was a single-blinded RCT conducted at Santo Spirito Hospital in Pescara, Italy to explore whether OMT could shorten the length of stay among premature infants in their neonatal ICU (NICU). Secondary outcomes studied were the differences in daily weight gain and total cost of the NICU stay.
I’ll discuss the methods in a moment, but first let’s review the results.
Results
Infants who received OMT in addition to an osteopathic evaluation were found to have a significantly shorter NICU length of stay (LOS) than those in the control group who received only an osteopathic evaluation, without OMT. The mean average LOS was 26.1±16.4 days for the study group and 31.3±20.2 days for the control group (p<0.03). This was found to be true even after accounting for likely confounders using linear regression analysis. In terms of the secondary outcomes measures, there was no significant difference in daily weight gain between the two groups, but the authors found an almost 3 000€ (~$4 100) savings in hospital costs for the study group, related to the shortened LOS.
Methods
Now let’s look at how this study was conducted. A total of 101 preterm infants were included in the study. Infants were randomly assigned to one of two groups:
     1.  Osteopathic evaluation only
     2.  Osteopathic evaluation and OMT
Here’s where it gets silly, and I’d like to briefly step away from the article to review the fundamentals of osteopathy before moving on.
Osteopathy is a pseudoscientific belief system developed in 1874 by the physician Andrew Still. The fundamental premise of osteopathy is the inter-relatedness of mind, body, and spirit. Still believed that this tripartite system had intrinsic, self-healing and self-correcting capabilities. He believed that disease states were caused by misalignments or obstructions of various structural elements of the body (bones, muscles, fascia, nerves, blood vessels, lymphatics), and that specific corrective manipulations could facilitate the body’s innate ability to heal. Like many wacky medical belief systems of this era, osteopathy was not any worse than much of the prevailing thought and practice of the day. Today, the practice of osteopathy varies considerably within the profession, as does the degree of adherence to the fundamentals of the original dogma preached by Dr. Still. I will revisit this at the end of the post and discuss how it pertains to the current training and practice of osteopathic physicians in this country. Now, let’s return to the study.
The authors of the study define osteopathic practice much the way AT Still described it in the 1800s:
Osteopathic practitioners use a wide variety of therapeutic manual techniques to improve physiological function and restore homeostasis that has been altered by somatic (body framework) dysfunction…Osteopathic practitioners use their understanding of the relationship between structure and function to optimize the body’s self-regulation and self-healing capabilities. This holistic approach to patient care and healing is based on the concept that a human being is a dynamic functional unit, in which all parts are interrelated and possesses its own self-regulatory and self-healing mechanisms.
This definition is so rife with fantasy and meaninglessness that it is difficult to discuss rationally or with a straight face. But we shall try. First, it assumes there is some specific physiologic function that needs to be restored. Now, we can go along with this since pretty much every pathologic state, by definition, has some physiologic basis. But osteopathy then assumes that a detectable structural dysfunction lies at the center of this physiological “imbalance”, much the way many chiropractors claim that fictional spinal “subluxations” are the cause of myriad disorders. We know this is whole-cloth fantasy, since not one shred of evidence supports this claim. However, the entire concept of osteopathy is predicated on this fantasy. But the definition gets even stranger. It then claims that osteopaths use their understanding of this relationship between a specific structural disequilibrium/obstruction/misalignment/lack of homeostasis (pick and choose) and a specific, corresponding physiologic dysfunction to design an effective manipulative fix. These manipulations then allow the body to resume its innate, self-healing magic to restore the body to health. I still can’t figure out why, if the body has innate self-healing abilities, these manipulations are required, and what they are supposed to be doing.
Now, recall the two groups of infants in the study, Group A (the control group) and Group B (the study group). All infants received 10-minute osteopathic evaluations by one of four Group A osteopaths. The study group infants additionally received a 10-minute evaluation and a 10-minute OMT session from one of four Group B osteopaths who visited the infants at a different time. After the group A osteopaths performed their evaluations, they remained standing at the bedside for an additional 10 minutes, supposedly as a form of “blinding”. Let me repeat this in table form for clarification:
	Group A (control)	Group B (intervention)
Group A osteopaths	10 minute evaluation +10 minutes of standing by the bedside	10 minute evaluation +10 minutes of standing by the bedside
Group B osteopaths		10 minute evaluation +10 minutes of OMT
Total time at bedside	20 minutes	40 minutes
	Group A and B osteopaths entered the NICU at different times of the day.
The authors explained blinding as follows:
NICU staff was blinded to patients allocations, since all infants were at least touched by osteopaths from group A and B and osteopaths spent the same amount of time in front of incubators and/or beds. Moreover osteopaths were unaware of study design and outcomes.
I read the methods over and over again and this explanation is either untrue or there is an error somewhere. Infants were not at least touched by osteopaths from each group. The control subjects were touched only by group A osteopaths, who then stood by the bedside (doing what, we don’t know) for an additional 10 minutes. Study subjects had this same evaluation and bizarre “standing” gimmick, and then at another time had an additional evaluation by group B osteopaths followed by an OMT session. I don’t see how group A osteopaths standing by the bedside for ten additional minutes after their evaluation accomplishes anything, since the study infants will again be visited by a second osteopath. NICU staff would certainly see that two different osteopaths were visiting the study infants. There is no blinding here as far as I can tell. The authors describe further “blinding” as follows:
Osteopaths from group A and B entered to the NICU in different hours of the schedule days, to provide blinding and to avoid possible confounding.
Even if there were different NICU staff working at these times, they could easily discuss their observations with one another. Again, this is not blinding. Of course, the treating osteopaths could not have been blinded.
So we know the methods are flawed and prone to producing biased and confounded results, but let’s discuss the intervention, which itself defies all Bayesian rules of logic. For those of you not familiar with the precepts of osteopathy, the fantasy is rich:
The aim of the structural examination is to locate the somatic disfunction [sic]. In newborns the structural exam is usually performed with the infant lying down on the table. Diagnostic criteria for somatic disfunction [sic] are focused on tissue texture abnormalities and tone. Areas of asymmetry and misalignment of bony landmarks are evaluated. The quality of motion, its balance and organization are noted.
If this sounds to you like hocus-pocus, you are not alone. Structural, anatomic assessment is obviously important for detecting a wide array of newborn problems and is, of course, performed every time an infant is examined. But the osteopathic evaluations described above purport to detect subtle findings reflecting complex, systemic, physiologic processes. They claim to detect vague alterations of texture, tone, and alignment indicative of the overall physiologic state of these premature infants – a tidy package of physiologic dysfunction that is somehow contributing to their need to remain hospitalized. As with other forms of CAM, there is a drastic oversimplification at play here, of phenomena that are very complex. To claim that a premature infant’s hospital stay may be prolonged by physiological “imbalances” that can be predictably detected by an osteopath’s trained, hands-on assessment, and which can then be treated with simple manipulations, is not just fantastical and wishful thinking, it is a massive simplification of a very complex physiological reality. A reality over which no “traditional” practitioner would ever claim such mastery and control. Because these telltale stigmata do not actually exist, inter-rater reliability for osteopathic evaluations would be expected to be poor or non-existent, as has been shown in the few studies that have looked at it (Giles, 2011, Wirth-Pittullo et al., 1994, Pattyn et al., 2013). The “dysfunctions” identified by the evaluators in this study are not stated but are presumed to be related to significant and complex issues keeping these infants in the NICU, since the manipulations concocted to relieve them resulted in an improved LOS. Several hypotheses for how OMT may be working here are put forth in the discussion section of the paper. These include possible anti-inflammatory effects, and bringing “balance to the sympathetic and para-sympathetic inputs, creating an improvement of newborns clinical condition.” I will not be discussing the evidence for the benefits of touch and massage on newborns in the NICU (there is some interesting data on this), but this has nothing to do with the imaginary structure-function claims of osteopathy. Even if the hands-on interventions of the osteopaths in this study did truly improve the LOS for these infants (and this cannot be assumed from the evidence in this study), it in no way validates the mechanistic claims of osteopathy. If there is benefit to hands-on touch and massage in neonates, that’s one thing, and that is an interesting and potentially valuable thing to study. But it says nothing about and does not require the existence of osteopathy, which is based on non-existent relationships and false assumptions about anatomy and physiology.
Osteopathy today
There are large regional and individual differences in the ways in which osteopathic providers practice OMT. Different countries have their own regulations and even definitions of osteopathy. Though individuals trained as osteopaths in the 19th and first half of the 20th century practiced in a fashion closely aligned with Still’s original dogma, osteopathic training and practice in the US over the last half century has changed dramatically, coming to resemble traditional modern medical training and practice in nearly every respect. In the United States, there are two types of medical schools that confer degrees bestowing equivalent privileges to practice medicine and surgery. The DO curriculum in the US is now indistinguishable from that of the MD curriculum of traditional medical schools, with one glaring distinction. A vestigial, non-trivial remnant of osteopathic teaching has been retained and remains, at least for the sake of appearances, at the heart of the mission of these schools. While osteopathic schools also claim distinction by focusing on a “holistic” approach to health and on disease prevention, this is a false distinction as traditional medical schools place this approach at the core of their missions as well. Despite the one true distinction between traditional and osteopathic medical school (the focus on osteopathic manipulative therapy), a minority of DOs continues to practice OMT once they finish their training (Johnson et al., 2001). My experience working with many DO students and graduates is that most do not choose this path to a medical degree because of the DO component of the training, but because of the less competitive nature of the admissions requirements. The traditional DO student body has tended to be older and have lower GPA and MCAT scores than that of traditional medical schools. Probably a plus, it has also tended to be comprised of students with more diverse, non-traditional backgrounds. These distinctions, however, have grown smaller as traditional medical schools have broadened their perspective about what characterizes a good candidate. More and more, medical schools are seeking individuals with broader, more well-rounded backgrounds, often looking toward the liberal arts for their prospective students. So other than a lower admissions standard and the focus on a pseudoscientific belief system, there is no difference between the two educational systems. So why should this two-tiered system even exist? It is time to rid ourselves of this pre-scientific, dual system of medical education. It is time to acknowledge that there is no such thing as osteopathy, and focus our efforts on improving our science-based approach to medicine.

Chiropractic “pediatrics” firmly in the anti-vaccination camp
Jann Bellamy on September 4, 2014
Link


Who would you invite to speak at your conference if you wanted to show the world you are firmly in the anti-vaccination camp? Barbara Loe Fisher, head of the National Vaccine (Mis) Information Center (NVIC)? How about Andrew Wakefield, the thoroughly disgraced British physician who, having been stripped of his medical license, continues his despicable anti-vaccination campaign? How about both?
The International Chiropractic Pediatric Association sprang for both. Fisher and Wakefield will be keynote speakers at the ICPA’s upcoming conference, “Celebrating the Shift to Conscious Choice.” The conference offers the mutually exclusive opportunities of participating “in the discussion of the latest evidence-based holistic research” while at the same time exploring “the vitalistic perspectives of conception, pregnancy and birth through family wellness.” I hate to be the bearer of bad news, but you can embrace evidence-based research or you can embrace vitalism, but not both at the same time. There will also be an opportunity for the requisite bashing of “conventional” medicine.
It’s hard to decide who’s slumming whom here. On the one hand, the ICPA is a small group (3,000 members). They are straight, subluxation-based chiropractors and they don’t need convincing that vaccination is “bad.” Fisher and Wakefield will be preaching to the choir. Wakefield, with his medical education and training, is most certainly aware that their subluxation-based “theory” is nonsense and they are incompetent to diagnose and treat pediatric patients. And this is a far cry from Fisher’s former gigs as an advisor to the government.
On the other hand, Wakefield and Fisher are not exactly in-demand conference speakers. I can imagine it’s not too hard to get on their calendars.
In the heyday of the media’s penchant for reporting “both sides” of the vaccination manufactroversy, Fisher was the go-to gal for reliable fear-mongering about vaccines. She was, after all, a founder of the NVIC, a source of vaccine “information” that claims to be neither for nor against vaccination, only for “safe” vaccinations and informed consent. By continuously moving the goalposts, the NVIC ensures that vaccination is never safe and that there is always a fresh supply of misinformation with which to scare parents away from vaccinating their children. The NVIC is a sponsor of the ICPA conference.
However, since being excoriated by investigative journalist Seth Mnookin in his excellent book The Panic Virus (2011), the media, suitably chastised, seems to have learned its lesson and appears less likely to ring up Fisher, Jenny McCarthy or other science-deficient sources for their views on vaccination.
In addition to taking the media to task, Mnookin took on Fisher herself. (Wakefield and the NVIC don’t fare too well in the book either.) Here’s how he described Fisher’s talk at a 2009 Autism One conference:
Barbara Loe Fisher, the grande dame of the American anti-vaccine movement, explained how vaccines are a “de facto selection of the genetically vulnerable for sacrifice” and said that doctors who administer vaccines are the moral equivalent of “the doctors at Nuremberg.” (That parallel, she said, had been pointed out to her by Andrew Wakefield . . .)
While Fisher normally seems more than happy to talk to reporters, she clammed up when Mnookin wanted to interview her. Mnookin says he tried several times, but she refused, ostensibly because of an article about vaccines and the anti-vaccine movement that appeared in Wired in 2009. It was in this article that Paul Offit, M.D., famously said Fisher lies and she famously sued Offit. The case was tossed out by the court. Her refusal was based on the fact that Mnookin was a contributing editor at Vanity Fair, which has the same corporate parent as Wired. Sounds a bit thin to me.
The double punch of shaming the media for its credulous reporting and exposing Fisher’s off-the-rails positions seems to have had some effect. Fisher briefly surfaced in a couple of years ago with a few publicity stunts (her background is in PR), such as a “public service” announcement from the NVIC shown on Delta Airlines in which she conveniently excludes vaccination as a means of flu prevention. A few news outlets continue, irresponsibly, to give voice to her views from time to time, even while at the same time reporting (finally) that vaccines are safe and effective. A couple of sources picked up Fisher’s and the NVIC’s attempt to milk the non-event of the CDC non-whistleblower non-exposé, simply parroting their press release calling for removal of vaccine oversight from HHS.
Andrew Wakefield, who is described as an “academic gastroenterologist” in the conference materials, has been discussed a number of times on this blog, most recently in David Gorski’s series of posts in which we find Wakefield attempting to become relevant again with the CDC “whistleblower” kerfuffle. (Last post and references to others here.) Briefly, he is the British physician whose fraudulent “study” suggested a link between the MMR vaccine and autism, thereby igniting an unnecessary fear and consequent increase in vaccine-preventable disease. He was later stripped of his medical license and his article reporting the study withdrawn. He now lives in the U.S., unfortunately.
Diplomates in pediatric chiropractic
The ICPA has its own certification and “diplomate” programs in chiropractic pediatrics. Cleveland Chiropractic College, Northwestern Health Sciences University, Parker College of Chiropractic and Life University all co-sponsor the ICPA’s curriculum and classes. The certification consists of 200 hours of classroom instruction, apparently with no actual patient care involved. An additional 200 hours will make you a diplomate, again with no real clinical component. Its website is chock full of terrible “wellness research,” mainly case reports in which a few patients allegedly benefit from chiropractic treatment for such conditions as ADHD, eczema, stuttering, scoliosis – you name it. They are big on something called “birth trauma,” which is the idea that babies need adjustments after the stress of birth to correct immediate problems caused by this “trauma” and to improve long term health. It appears the chiropractor who’s incompetence in diagnosing and treating a newborn was examined in Clay Jones’s chilling post last Friday subscribes to this notion. If you ever needed evidence that chiropractic education is not up to snuff and that chiropractors are deficient in research skills, this is the place.
Of course, no one would be surprised to learn the ICPA is anti-vaccination. Many chiropractors are anti-vaccination, an attitude that becomes more prevalent as they move through chiropractic school. (Although some do recommend removal of the non-existent subluxation as a means of flu prevention.) But considering the fact that the vast majority of patients see chiropractors for back pain, those visits seem less likely to pose the threat of a chiropractor misinforming his patients about childhood immunizations. Why would someone going to a chiropractor for back pain ask the chiropractor about vaccination of their children? Now, however, by re-defining “primary care physician” to suit their needs, chiropractors are taking up the position that they can serve as PCPs, a subject both Harriet Hall and I have addressed before.
And while chiropractors have always maintained that they can treat children, the movement toward a “specialty” in pediatrics appears to be a fairly recent one. It is hard to find dates but, for one, the ICPA’s Journal of Clinical Chiropractic Pediatrics started publication only in 2009. The ICPA was started by Larry Webster, D.C., in 1986. Webster was the inventor of the Webster Technique, a system of spinal adjustments chiropractors claim are effective in turning breech babies. (And, I might add, yet another example of how poor their education and training must be.) Apparently, it was something of a one-man operation until his death in 1997, when a board of directors took over. The American Chiropractic Association’s Pediatrics Council, which we’ll get to in a minute, was established on 2005.
If chiropractors are anti-vaccination, and are actively seeking to attract pediatric patients via their presumed expertise in pediatric chiropractic care, it is worth looking deeper into what the chiropractic “pediatrician’s” position is given their ability in that role to spread anti-vaccination ideology even further.
ICA and ACA
The International Chiropractors Association has its own “Council on Chiropractic Pediatrics” and its own “Board Certified Diplomate in Chiropractic Pediatrics,” although you need only 360 hours of classroom instruction to become an ICA dipolmate. It too is having a conference this fall, although apparently without the added attraction of virulently anti-vaccination speakers.
A search of the ICA CCP website soon turns up some smoking guns, in the form of recommended books and articles. One is a book by Viera Scheibner, whose dive off the deep end is documented on Wikipedia. Scheibner claims, for example, there is a connection between SIDS and vaccines, that shaken-baby syndrome is misdiagnosed and is actually caused by vaccination, and that polio, measles, whooping cough and rubella pose no danger. Another book on vaccination on the list is praised by Richard Blalock, M.D., an “all-purpose medical crank,” and conspiracy minded anti-vaccinationist, who, among other things, recommends cold showers and a multitude of dietary supplements to counteract the effects of vaccinations.
And there is this chiropractic journal article, from Robin Hyman, D.C., “The Vaccination Myth: An Exercise in Logic:”
The author suggests that the Outside-In, Below-Up approach of the vaccination theory is in direct philosophical contradiction to chiropractic’s Above-Down, Inside-Out healing veracity. [Whatever a “healing veracity” might be.] He provides logical arguments aimed at disproving five basic vaccination myths regarding their safety and effectiveness.
But how about the more mainstream American Chiropractic Association? It too has a pediatric component, the ACA Pediatrics Council. And it too is having a fall conference. (Is there some sort of competition going on here?) In this video, we see the Council’s President, Elise Hewitt, DC, DICCP (from the ICA’s pediatric diplomate program), selling a new mother on the ridiculous “birth trauma” idea, although you will note she is awfully vague as to exactly what it is she is doing, why she is doing it or how it might help this infant.
Oddly, the only article on vaccination I could find on this website was one from the Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine (2000), which, based on a survey, found, among other things:
For pediatric care, 30% [of chiropractors] reported actively recommending childhood immunizations; presented with a hypothetical 2-week-old neonate with a fever, 17% would treat the patient themselves rather than immediately refer the patient to a doctor of medicine, doctor of osteopathy, or an emergency facility.
Thus concluding,
Pediatric chiropractic care is often inconsistent with recommended medical guidelines.
Maybe they are bragging?
The ACA itself believes immunization is a topic (scroll down to “Wellness Model”) chiropractors are competent to address as an element of primary prevention. The ACA also believes chiropractors should treat both neuromusculoskeltal and non-neuromusculoskeletal conditions in pediatric patients. (See “Pediatric Chiropractic Care”) The ACA’s official policy on vaccination seems to have taken a page from the NVIC’s playbook:
Since the scientific community acknowledges that the use of vaccines is not without risk, the American Chiropractic Association supports each individual’s right to freedom of choice in his/her own health care based on an informed awareness of the benefits and possible adverse effects of vaccination. The ACA is supportive of a conscience clause or waiver in compulsory vaccination laws thereby maintaining an individual’s right to freedom of choice in health care matters and providing an alternative elective course of action regarding vaccination. (Ratified by the House of Delegates, July 1993, Revised and Ratified June 1998).
(Apparently, this attitude toward the individual’s right to “informed awareness” does not extend to neck manipulation.)
American Public Health Association Chiropractic Section
Finally, although it’s not related specifically to pediatric patients, we’ll close with a look at one organization within chiropractic that one would certainly hope supports childhood immunization: the Chiropractic Section of the American Public Health Association. That’s right, there is one, established after great resistance from the APHA. Of course, chiropractors don’t seem to be all that fond of the APHA either. Here’s what Cheryl Hawk. D.C., VP of Research at Cleveland Chiropractic College has to say on the matter in a Q &A session, when asked “what are some issues that prevent chiropractors from becoming involved in public health issues?”
Public health is too “medical,” especially because of its emphasis on immunizations. Although public health does emphasize immunizations, it also emphasizes other types of prevention, such as treating tobacco dependence and encouraging mothers to breast-feed. Why don’t we focus on the areas where our interests overlap rather than on where they differ?
In other words, chiropractors can cherry-pick the public health measures they like and leave off the rest.
The Section is part of the APHA, but the ACA also has a “APHA/Wellness & Health Promotion Committee,” thereby giving their committee the supposed imprimatur of the APHA.
The American Chiropractic Association’s APHA/Wellness & Health Promotion Committee has assembled the following links and information to help doctors of chiropractic educate their patients about health promotion and injury prevention strategies.
Curiously (actually not) although there is a link to the CDC’s information on smoking cessation, there is none to the extensive information on vaccination available on the CDC’s website. Likewise, in the links for patients, there is no link to the CDC’s vaccination information. This from a group that refers to chiropractors as “primary care physicians” and sees providing information on immunization as part of the chiropractor’s preventive health care role.
The official APHA Chiropractic Section maintains an “Immunization Information Resource Website,” which receives no funding from chiropractic institutions and is run by volunteers. It has not been updated since 2011. The website is a curious mixture of accurate information about immunizations and cherry-picking the studies. While it does link to the CDC and other reputable vaccination information sources, it also contains an odd list of journal articles which do not accurately represent the status of vaccination research, even in 2011. The HPV vaccine is not mentioned at all. Links to abstracts are given but it is doubtful that many chiropractors have access to the full journal articles. There is no mention of the APHA’s own Policy Statement concerning immunizations, which “reaffirms its support for immunization as one of the most cost-effective means of preventing infectious diseases.”
For example, under “Rotavirus,” we find only one link: “Intussusception among recipients of rotovirus vaccine–United States, 1998-1999,” when there have been a number of studies since 1999 on the safety and effectiveness of rotavirus vaccines. Why wasn’t this article from 2009 cited? “Comm. on Infectious Diseases, AAP, Prevention of Rotavirus Disease: Updated Guidelines for Use of Rotavirus Vaccine.”
With more than 14 million doses of RV5 distributed in the United States since 2006, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) Immunization Safety Office summary of postlicensure safety monitoring of RV5 does not indicate that immunization with RV5 is associated with intussusception. Further monitoring is ongoing. Rigorous postlicensure monitoring for safety end points has also been initiated for RV1.
The citations for varicella suffer from the same incompleteness. For example, the list includes “Prevention of Varicella: Recommendations of the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP), Centers for Disease Control and Prevention” from 1996 but not 2007 (which has itself been updated).
And, unfortunately, the lack of updates means these two excellent resources are not available on the website, although one wonders if they would have been cited even then: “Safety of Vaccines Used for Routine Immunization of US Children: A Systematic Review” and the Institute of Medicine’s “The Childhood Immunization Schedule and Safety,” which concluded,
This report is the most comprehensive examination of the immunization schedule to date. The IOM committee uncovered no evidence of major safety concerns associated with adherence to the childhood immunization schedule. Should signals arise that there may be need for investigation, however, the report offers a framework for conducting safety research using existing or new data collection systems.
All in all, while the Chiropractic Section should be commended for providing links to the CDC and other reliable sources, a fair review of the entire site evidences a “pull the punches” approach to immunization that mixes in outdated and incomplete advice over-emphasizing risks with good information.
The chiropractic position on pediatric immunizations appears to range from virulently anti-vaccination to, at best, tepid support from a small group. Yet many within chiropractic view themselves as capable of acting as primary care physicians in general and pediatricians in particular. Their lack of education and training belies those beliefs, as does a look at their actual practices. And their lack of support for childhood immunization makes the proposition downright scary.

Anti-vaccination ideology in chiropractic continuing education and conference (again!)
Yet another chiropractic pediatrics conference features anti-vaccination ideology. Chiropractic institutions approve anti-vaccination CE course content. To protect public health, if chiropractic regulators won’t stop this, the states should do it for them.
Jann Bellamy on August 1, 2019
Link
If there were a contest for the most shamelessly anti-vaccination group of health care practitioners, the bastardized specialty known as “chiropractic pediatrics” would win hands down. Naturopaths are anti-vaxxers but, as far as I know, don’t shout it out it by featuring marquee figures of the anti-vaccination movement at their conferences. There are anti-vaxx physicians too, but they are spurned by their colleagues and they sometimes get disciplined.
Not chiropractic pediatrics! They crank it up to 11! As we’ve documented here on SBM, chiropractic pediatrics conferences regularly feature anti-vaccination royalty like Barbara Loe Fisher, grande dame of the anti-vaccination movement, Andrew Wakefield, the pediatric research fraudster, Del Bigtree, maker of the widely disparaged “documentary” VAXXED, and Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., who is so embarrassingly wrong on vaccines that he got called out by his own family in Politico.
This year is no different. In October, Kennedy will be a featured speaker at Genesis PedCon, (“The Pediatric and Family Conference of the Year!”), held at the Hilton in East Brunswick, NJ, advertised as being only “30 minutes from Manhattan.” (Maybe in the Batmobile.) Kennedy’s notorious anti-vaccination campaign has earned him a number of posts on SBM (e.g., here, here, and here) and over on Respectful Insolence (e.g., here, here, and here). He has, among his many outrageous attacks on science, compared “vaccine-induced autism” to the Holocaust and said that pediatric infectious diseases expert Paul Offit, MD, should be in jail.
In Kennedy’s fevered mind, there is a huge conspiracy afoot in which scientists, government and Pharma employees, and their minions, who must number in the hundreds, are secretly acting in concert to intentionally harm millions of children. The crux of it is nicely summed up by Slate‘s Laura Helmuth:
The short version of the vaccine conspiracy theory (if you are stuck on the phone with RFK Jr., you will be subjected to the long version) is that a vaccine preservative called thimerosal causes autism when injected into children. Government epidemiologists and other scientists, conspiring with the vaccine industry, have covered up data and lied about vaccine ingredients to hide this fact. Journalists are dupes of this powerful cabal that is intentionally poisoning children.
Of course, a roomful of chiropractors who believe in the phantom subluxation and fabricate its deleterious effects on health are obviously lacking in critical thinking skills and therefore the perfect audience for Kennedy.
Also speaking will be anti-vaccine “paleo” doctor Jack Wolfson, who, once asked if he would feel bad if a sick child with a medical exemption caught measles from his child and died, he replied:
I could live with myself easily. It’s an unfortunate thing that people die, but people die. And I’m not going to put my child at risk to save another child.
Wolfson also spoke at last year’s Genesis PedCon, as did none other than anti-vaxx propagandist Del Bigtree, who has himself trampled on the memory of the Holocaust by likening the horrific killing of millions of Jews and other groups persecuted by the Nazis to school vaccine mandates.
One of the conference’s sponsors is the National Vaccine Information Council, the vitriolic anti-vaccine misinformation machine founded by Barbara Loe Fisher, who has indulged in her own Nazi-themed hyperbole by calling doctors who administer vaccines are the moral equivalent of “the doctors at Nuremberg”. (Orac recently did a nice takedown of her latest rant.)
Genesis PedCon is being run by the irrepressible Teri and Stu Warner, both subluxation-based chiropractors and author of strategies on how to undermine parents’ faith in their child’s pediatrician. Sample:
When performing a skin temperature measurement, ask . . . “Did your pediatrician do this test.” Respond, “Interesting” then move on.
As Chirobase points out, skin-temperature measurement is an invalid diagnostic test used by chiropractors to find “subluxations” that they claim need treatment.
In 2008, the New Jersey Board of Chiropractic Examiners disciplined the Warners for billing parents and insurers multiple times for the same services, for which they paid several thousand dollars in penalties and costs. Stu’s agreement also required him to stop “engaging in unprofessional dialog with parents of minor patients that is intended to undermine the relationships they have with other health care providers”.
In other words, PedCon has picked the cream of the chiropractic crop.
In addition to anti-vaccination ideology and courses in “adjusting” (including Upper Cervical Technique) infants, children, and pregnant women, there will be a hefty helping of practice building, which will, according to Teri and Stu’s promotional video, allow attendees to position themselves as the “go-to kids’ health authority in your community.” And speaking of kids, bring yours! Let them play, again according to Teri and Stu, with “other unsubluxated kids”. There are up to 21 hours of continuing education credit “approved throughout North America”.
While we could spend several more paragraphs on PedCon, we must move on to other means of learning anti-vaccination ideology for chiropractors, but not before turning to one final claim from Teri and Stu’s promotional video, selected especially for my SBM colleagues Drs. Steve Novella and Harriet Hall. The Warners promise “the number one brain and nervous system chiropractor”, will be at PedCon, Ted Carrick. Drs. Novella and Hall (who was once called “bizarre, rude, and offensive” by Carrick) expertly shredded Carrick and his “chiropractic neurology” here, here, and here.
“Chiropractic pediatrics” CE courses
This brings us to “Pediatrics 115” a CE course offered by ChiroCredit, which says it’s mission is to “provide high quality, clinically relevant” and “accurate” programs “to maintain clinical excellence” and “meet state license requirements”.
ChiroCredit is approved as a CE provider by PACE (Providers of Approved Continuing Education), a service of the Federation of Chiropractic Licensing Boards, an organization of state chiropractic regulatory boards. PACE vets CE course providers and approves those that meet its standards. Some boards automatically accept PACE-approved courses; others do not.
According to PACE, its mission includes “protecting the public through advancements in chiropractic education”. PACE standards cover issues like facilities for CE courses, the allocation of credit hours and, as might be expected, the qualifications of instructors and the rigor of the course content. Thus,
The provider shall ensure that each instructor in its continuing education program is qualified to teach the subject matter assigned to him or her.
Interestingly, though, courses need not be science- or evidence-based:
Subject matter shall be evidence-based, authority-based or tradition-based and shall be credible, academically rigorous and presented in a balanced manner.
(Emphasis added.)
ChiroCredit is also a “strategic partner” with the University of Bridgeport’s College of Chiropractic, which offers CE via ChiroCredit. In Colorado, for example, Pediatrics 115 is “automatically accepted as facilitated by the University of Bridgeport, Health Sciences Postgraduate Education Department”. What standards, if any, Bridgeport requires for ChiroCredit’s courses is not revealed.
In short, Pediatrics 115 bears the imprimatur of both the Federation of Chiropractic Licensing Boards and an accredited chiropractic college.
The course content of Pediatrics 115, an on-demand video course listed in the PACE catalog of courses, is:
Examine the current allopathic approach to vaccinations, including recommended schedules
Assess potential side-effects seen in patients, both pediatric and adult, in your clinic daily
Uncover the pharmaceutical industrys [sic] interest in creating more vaccinations
Analyze political maneuvers behind many vaccination mandates
Explore varying philosophical viewpoints on vaccinations, including Religious beliefs, Ethical viewpoints, Schools desires, and alternative/healthier lifestyle approaches
Educate your patient on their choices for vaccination
Create alternative vaccination schedules
Discover ways to identify and treat the common side effects of vaccinated children
Identify useful Homeopathic Nosodes and Remedies proven to be effective alternatives to vaccinations
(Quotation reformatted for easier reading.)
Let’s unpack this and see how many anti-vaccination tropes we can find:
    • The presumed ubiquity of side effects (“seen in your practice daily”), real or imagined, and the implication that these side effects require treatment. [If they appear at all, most vaccine side effects are minor, go away in a few days, and do not require treatment. Side effects that do require treatment are not amenable to chiropractic care and are outside the scope of chiropractic practice.]
    • The implication that there are nefarious motives behind creation of new vaccines.
    • The assumption that “politics,” and not protection of public health, is behind vaccine mandates.
    • Promotion of the notion that there are effective alternatives to vaccination, such as “alternative/healthier lifestyle approaches” and homeopathic nosodes. [Neither is an evidence-based recommendation; homeopathic nosodes aren’t even scientifically plausible, much less effective.]
    • What appears to be an attempt to promote vaccine resistance in parents (“educate your patients on their choices”).
    • Teaching that “alternative” vaccination schedules are valid. [In fact, they are not evidence-based.]
The instructor for Pediatrics 115 is Robin Mayfield, a Texas chiropractor and “functional nutritionist” who offers pseudoscience-based alternative medicine standards like adrenal fatigue and heavy metal testing, candida and “leaky gut” treatment, detox, homeopathy, applied kinesiology, and a “medical intuitive.” I could not find any mention of education or training in pediatrics or infectious diseases on her website or any indication that she practices in those areas; indeed, her practice seems to focus on adult females.
Tropes aside, both the content of Pediatrics 115 and its approval by major chiropractic organizations serve as evidence of the appalling condition of chiropractic education and state regulation of the practice of chiropractic. The course is not only anti-vaccination, it is not evidence- or science-based (nor is it required to be, according to PACE) and I can find nothing to indicate that Mayfield is qualified to teach a course on pediatrics or infectious diseases. The subject matter of the course is obviously beyond the scope of chiropractic practice as well as beyond chiropractic education and training.
Another PACE-approved ChiroCredit course, also offered through Bridgeport, contains content curiously focused on the thoroughly debunked MMR-autism connection, the equally thoroughly debunked thimerosal-autism connection, and “vaccine injury:”
Describe the categories of autism and their symptoms
Comprehend the importance of the 1998 Wakefield paper in Lancet connecting autism to the MMR vaccine
Develop awareness of the vaccine injury court, thimersol [sic] and the vaccine autism link
Discuss vaccine exemptions and analyze chiropractic attitudes toward immunization
Apply strategies to manage autistic patients in your practice
(Quotation reformatted for easier reading.)
This course is taught by Brett Kinsler, DC, who, according to his LinkedIn profile, is no longer in chiropractic practice but has switched to healthcare IT. I could not find any evidence of his qualifications to teach a course on pediatrics, autism, or infectious diseases, the latter of which are beyond the scope of chiropractic practice.
In sum, chiropractors are vectors for vaccine-preventable diseases via indoctrination of patients and parents with their anti-vaccination ideology. As such, they must bear some responsibility for vaccine hesitancy and its attendant consequences. Chiropractic regulatory boards should make it clear that advising patients and parents on vaccination is outside of the chiropractic scope of practice, other than to direct them to their primary care physician (who should not be a chiropractor). The boards must stop granting CE credit for anti-vaccination courses and ensure that anti-vaccination ideology is not taught in chiropractic colleges. If the regulatory boards cannot be trusted with this most basic protection of public health, the states should strip them of their authority and do it for them.

Anti-Vaccine Chiropractors Threaten Public Health
The Canadian Broadcasting Corporation (CBC)’s investigation of Manitoba chiropractors reveals widespread antivaccine sentiment. These statement are at odds with medical facts, and critics are questioning why chiropractic remains publicly funded.
Scott Gavura on March 23, 2017
Link

Medicine today is delivered by a team of health professionals. Whether it’s a primary care clinic or a large hospital, different professions work side-by-side, sharing responsibility for patient care. Teamwork is essential, and that’s only possible because health professionals share common roots. Whether you’re a physician, a pharmacist, a nurse, a dentist, a registered dietitian, or a physiotherapist, you work from the same core set of rules: scientific principles. Biochemistry, pharmacology, physiology, anatomy – all health professions accept the same basic “facts” of medicine.
Integrative medicine is a tactic of embedding complementary and alternative medical practices and providers into conventional medical care. While this is touted as giving the “best of both worlds” to patients, it’s not difficult to imagine how this can be problematic in practice. Integrative medicine explicitly seeks to “integrate” providers that may not accept the scientific basis of medicine, and who may offer treatments that can be antagonistic to established and accepted medical practices. Many alternative medicine practices have nonscientific roots, grounded in belief systems such as the idea of “vitalism“. While vitalism was discarded by science-based medical practitioners long ago, it lives on in the philosophies of practices like homeopathy, naturopathy, and chiropractic. It is these vitalistic roots that lead many alternative medicine providers to be antivaccine.
Chiropractic is an alternative medicine practice with deep anti-vaccine roots, which persist to this day. As discussed yesterday by Steven Novella, this week the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation (CBC) published a story illustrating concerning statements and advertisements made by chiropractors in the province of Manitoba. These statements are at odds with medical facts, and critics are questioning why chiropractic remains publicly funded in the province. Importantly, the story illustrates that many Manitoba chiropractors are routinely promoting opinions that contradict important public health goals. It also illustrates that considerable change is needed in the profession of chiropractic in order for it become a true allied health profession.
Chiropractic’s antivaccine roots
I won’t repeat the numerous scientific and evidentiary concerns with chiropractic, as they’ve been well documented before. Even in an area where chiropractic manipulations could more plausibly help, low back pain, the evidence for chiropratic manipulations is weak and unconvincing. However, as a physical therapy, there is the potential (and some support by chiroprators) for chiropractic to move towards a more science-based, evidence-based practice, as Steve discussed in yesterday’s post. But this will require a major shift in the basis of chiropractic itself, and a rejection of much of the dogma in the profession. Anti-vaccination is one of the most obvious examples of the vitalistic thinking in chiropractic that persists to this day. Anti-vaccination sentiment in chiropractic goes as far back as the first chiropractor. D.D. Palmer, the “inventor” of chiropractic, described vaccination as a “medical delusion” in 1889. Chirowatch itemizes the evidence, collected over decades, that antivaccination sentiment has been a part of chiropractic since that time. One of the most interesting studies was back in 2002 that found that students at Canadian Memorial Chiropractic College in Toronto appeared to be developing progressively more anti-vaccine sentiment, year-over-year of their education.
While many primarily think of chiropractic for back and neck pain issues, few chiropractors limit their practice to this area. Given there’s no scientific basis to the chiropractic “subluxation”, the business of chiropractic has expanded into treatments for many conditions which have never been shown to benefit from spinal manipulation therapies, and for which there is no credible evidence to support. And it’s clear that evidence is no real barrier to the marketing of chiropractic, as the CBC showed:
A CBC News analysis of company websites and Facebook pages of every registered chiropractor in Manitoba found several dozen examples of statements, claims and social media content at odds with many public health policies or medical research.
Examples include:
    • Offers of treatments for autism, Tourette’s syndrome, Alzheimer’s disease, colic, infections and cancer.
    • Anti-vaccination literature and recently published letters to the editor from chiropractors that discourage vaccination.
    • An article claiming vaccines have caused a 200 to 600 per cent increase in autism rates.
    • A statement that claims the education and training of a chiropractor is “virtually identical” to that of a medical doctor.
    • Discouraging people from getting diagnostic tests such as CT scans, colonoscopies and mammograms.
    • An informational video discouraging the use of sunscreen.
It seems anti-vaccine, vitalism-believing chiropractors aren’t hard to find:
The Manitoba Chiropractors Association (MCA) is responsible for regulating chiropractors in Manitoba. Its website makes no public mention of vaccination. Unlike the Ontario Chiropractic Association the MCA’s website provides no public guidance to chiropractors, nor does it endorse the Canadian Chiropractic Association’s unambiguous statement on public health vaccination:
The Canadian Chiropractic Association recognizes that vaccination and immunization are established public health practices in the prevention of infectious diseases. Vaccination is not within the scope of chiropractic practice. The appropriate sources for patient consultation and education regarding vaccination and immunization are public health authorities and health professionals with a scope of practice that includes vaccination.
While the MCA states that they have addressed vaccination issues with “internal communication“, it is notable that none of this communication appeared to have had any meaningful effects on marketing claims made by Manitoba chiropractors.
This is not only a Manitoba issue. Anti-vaccination sentiment is well-document in chiropractors around the world. The Sydney Morning Herald has described chiropractors’ waiting rooms as “recruiting grounds for the anti-vaccination cause“. No less than (former Doctor) antivaccinationist Andrew Wakefield was the keynote speaker at the recent International Chiropractors Association’s Annual Conference on Chiropractic and Pediatrics, speaking, not surprisingly, on the (nonexistent) relationship between vaccines and autism.
The numerous instances where antivaccine sentiment has been noted among chiropractors was also reviewed by chiropractor Dana J Lawrence in 2012. She noted in her conclusion:
Anti-vaccination attitudes till [sic] abound within the chiropractic profession. Despite a growing body of evidence about the safety and efficacy of vaccination, many chiropractors do not believe in vaccination, will not recommend it to their patients, and place emphasis on risk rather than benefit. This is positioned within a context privileging individual autonomy, which by many is seen as core ethical value. But this puts the chiropractic profession outside the greater healthcare community and may contribute to its continued marginalization and small market impact.
Conclusion: The antivaccine roots run deep
Anti-vaccine views have been a part of chiropractic since inception. The facts of vaccination are untenable to those in the profession that prioritize its vitalistic roots over acceptance of scientific evidence. While not all chiropractors are antivaccine, it’s unclear whether the profession of chiropractic is ready or capable of accepting a scientific worldview and basis for its practice. And without this, chiropractors cannot be considered to be appropriate and capable of working alongside, and in partnership, with health professionals in the delivery of science-based health care. It seems clear that there is a long way for the profession of chiropractic to go.



A Global Summit Conclusion: No Evidence of an Effect of SMT [Spinal Manipulative Therapy] for the Management of Non-Musculoskeletal Disorders
A new systematic review places one more nail in the coffin of chiropractic vertebral subluxation theory and the use of spinal manipulation as a treatment for non-musculoskeletal disorders.
Sam Homola on March 2, 2023
Link

Preamble: The chiropractic subluxation theory (belief) that a vertebral subluxation can cause organic disease by affecting spinal nerves is scientifically indefensible since spinal nerves supply musculoskeletal structures and not organs which are supplied by a separate autonomic system. There is now conclusive evidence that the temporary neurological (autonomic) and physiological effects of spinal manipulation have no significant effect as a treatment for non-musculoskeletal disorders.
Vindication for Subluxation Deniers
When I published my book Bonesetting, Chiropractic, and Cultism in 1963, I stood alone as a chiropractor in my conclusion that the chiropractic vertebral subluxation theory was false and that spinal manipulation was not an effective treatment for organic disease. Over the years, I published many articles expressing my view that there is no credible evidence supporting subluxation theory. Today, in the United States, chiropractic continues to be defined in state laws as a method of adjusting a “vertebral subluxation complex” to restore and maintain health.1 The chiropractic profession continues to oppose limiting chiropractic to care of musculoskeletal disorders.
On September 14-15, 2019, in Toronto, Canada, 50 researchers from 8 countries and 28 observers from 18 chiropractic organizations met in a Global Summit to determine the efficacy and effectiveness of spinal manipulative therapy for the primary, secondary and tertiary prevention of non-musculoskeletal disorders. Here is their conclusion:
Our systematic review included six randomized clinical trials (534 participants) of acceptable or high quality investigating the efficacy or effectiveness of SMT [Spinal Manipulative Therapy] for the treatment of non-musculoskeletal disorders. We found no evidence of an effect of SMT for the management of non-musculoskeletal disorders including infantile colic, childhood asthma, hypertension, primary dysmenorrheal, and migraine. This finding challenges the validity of the theory that treating spinal dysfunctions with SMT has a physiological effect on organs and their function. Governments, payers, regulators, educators and clinicians should consider this evidence when developing policies about the use and reimbursement of SMT for non-musculoskeletal disorders.2
Six of 50 participants (12%) in the Global Summit did not approve the final report.

Belief in Subluxation Theory Will Not Disappear
Although there is increasing opposition to chiropractic vertebral subluxation theory or the use of spinal manipulation as a method of restoring and maintaining health, there is no reason to believe that subluxation-based chiropractic care will disappear. In a belief system alienated by science, true believers will continue to adhere to the simple fundamental definition that gave birth to the chiropractic profession. It is important that consumers be informed about the pros and cons of chiropractic care so that they can recognize the signs and the jargon of subluxation-based chiropractors who propose to treat a variety of ailments by adjusting vertebral subluxations. A wall chart associating spinal nerves with diseased organs in the office of a chiropractor is reason enough to exit the office.
References
     1.  Bellamy J. Legislative Alchemy: The U.S. state chiropractic Practice Acts. Focus on Complementary and Alternative Therapies. 15(3):214-222.2010
Cote P, Hartvigsen J, Axen I, et al. The global summit on the efficacy and effectiveness of spinal manipulative therapy for the prevention and treatment of non-musculoskeletal disorders: a systematic review of the literature. Chiropractic and Manual Therapies. February 17, 2021.

Low-Back Pain: Causes, Care, and Consequences
Sam Homola on April 13, 2012
Link
Low-back problems are one of the most common reasons for visits to doctors’ offices and the most common cause of disability among persons under the age of forty five. Most of the time, acute low-back pain is the result of simple strain and is a self-limiting condition that will resolve in four to six weeks, with or without treatment. But since back pain can be a forerunner of disability or a symptom reflecting serious pathology, every effort should be made to seek appropriate care that is based on a definitive diagnosis. Failure of physicians to ease the concerns of back-pain patients by explaining their problem and advising them in the care of back pain often results in dissatisfied patients who may be attracted by the approach of alternative medicine practitioners who tout a spurious quick-cure treatment based on a dubious diagnosis. Misinformation provided by such practitioners may contribute to disability by allowing progression of disease or by exaggerating the seriousness of the problem in the mind of the patient. Thus, while back pain is rarely serious, it should always be carefully evaluated to reach an accurate diagnosis and to determine if specialized care is needed. Care should be taken to inform the patient in a positive manner─to avoid unnecessary surgery as well as inappropriate or unnecessary treatment.
Something to Consider When You have Back Pain
Almost everyone will experience acute low back pain at least once during a lifetime. Much of what must be done to care for a bad back must be done by you. It would certainly help to be well informed about the causes of back pain when seeking appropriate treatment.
It goes without saying that when incapacitating back pain occurs as a result of a serious accident or injury, you should seek emergency medical care. When back pain grows progressively worse, persists unrelieved for longer than a week, or is worsened by rest, you may need the services of a specialist. Back pain that occurs for no apparent reason and does not affect movement may be a symptom referred from an internal organ. Once a diagnosis has ruled out a serious problem and it has been established that you have nonspecific or uncomplicated mechanical-type back pain, self-help measures designed to relieve your symptoms and to protect and strengthen your back may be the only treatment needed. If there is no active pathological process and your back pain lasts three months or longer, you may have a “chronic” back problem that can lead to recurring back pain, requiring ongoing vigilance and self help.
Time is the most important part of treatment for uncomplicated back pain caused by injury. It’simportant, however, to be aware of red flags indicating that back pain might be the result of something more serious that a simple strain. In the absence of red flags, imaging studies or special testing might not be indicated during the first four weeks of low back symptoms. When a red flag is present, you should not delay in reporting your symptoms to your family physician.
Back Pain Red Flags
Here are some red flags that should be considered when back pain is severe, persistent, or associated with other symptoms.
    • If you are on a treatment program requiring prolonged ingestion of a corticosteroid or a thyroid hormone, especially if you are past middle age, sudden appearance of back pain that restricts movement might be an indication that an osteoporotic vertebra has collapsed. The location of a vertebral crush fracture can often be determined by applying percussion over a prominent spinous process.
    • If you have a history of lung, breast, or prostate cancer and you develop a gradual onset of back pain, or if you have persistent back pain for no apparent reason, you should be tested for bone disease. Some forms of malignancy commonly metastasize to the ribs or the vertebrae, requiring a bone scan or some other special imaging procedure to detect the disease in an early stage.
    • Backache can be caused by a kidney infection that may go undetected until an elevation in temperature is discovered. Always take your temperature when you have a backache. If you have a fever, you should always see your family physician, regardless of what you think might be causing your backache. Any persistent backache that defies diagnosis should undergo testing and observation in a search for such elusive diseases as ankylosing spondylitis or rheumatoid arthritis.
    • Kidney stones can cause acute back pain. Unlike mechanical-type back pain that is relieved by rest and intensified by movement, the referred pain of a kidney stone produces pain that will not allow you to rest or sit still. If you have the misfortune of experiencing back pain that causes you to squirm about or roll around on the floor, you should go to a hospital emergency room as soon as possible.
    • Pain, numbness, and other symptoms radiating down one or both legs, or weakness in one leg or foot, especially when associated with back pain, would be a red flag indicating possible encroachment upon spinal nerves. Such symptoms could be caused by disk herniation, osteophyte formation, or some other pathological process.
    • Sudden appearance of constant and severe leg pain that is not associated with back pain, or cramping leg pain that occurs only when you walk and is relieved by rest (intermittent claudication), might be an indication of diseased arteries. Your family physician might want to refer you to a vascular specialist in order to differentiate vascular claudication from neurogenic claudication caused by spinal stenosis.
    • Loss of bladder or bowel control (especially urinary retention) that is associated with back pain or numbness in the perineal or saddle area of your pelvis is a medical emergency (cauda equina syndrome) requiring the immediate attention of a neurosurgeon. Such symptoms can be caused by a lumbar disk protrusion that has entered the spinal canal.
Diagnosing Back Pain
Although an x-ray exam is not often indicated (depending upon your medical history) when acute back pain occurs, your doctor might order an imaging study if symptoms persist longer than a month. A plain x-ray image can be helpful in finding a structural problem, such as spondylolisthesis, that might be causing back pain; it might also detect bone disease, an abdominal aneurysm, or some other problem that might be causing non-musculoskeletal back pain. When there is a red flag involving spinal nerves, an MRI study might be needed to look for nerve root impingement or disc herniation. CT-myelography might be ordered in the case of spinal stenosis or cauda equina syndrome, and so on. An appropriate specialist will order an appropriate testing procedure. In most cases, a good physical exam and a detailed case history by an astute clinician will provide a diagnosis that will often be confirmed by special studies.
Generally, non-musculoskeletal back pain referred from an internal organ is characterized by pain that is not affected by movement, percussion, and other mechanical testing procedures. Back pain complicated by neurological symptoms, such as loss of reflexes, localized muscle weakness, muscle atrophy, and other signs of progressive nerve damage, may be an indication of massive herniation of an intervertebral disk.
Barring the medical emergency of a cauda equina syndrome, any recommendation for surgical excision of a herniated disk would warrant taking time for a second and third opinion. Surgery can often be avoided when time is combined with periodic evaluation by a physician who can watch for progressive neurological signs that indicate an unquestionable need for surgery.
Basic Self-Help Measures
When the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services published Acute Low Back Problems in Adults in 1994, it advised that “The use of physical agents and modalities in the treatment of acute low back problems is of insufficiently proven benefit to justify their cost. As an option, patients may be taught self-application of heat or cold to the back at home.”
Here are some basic self-help measures that anyone can use safely and effectively to relieve symptoms and to buy the time needed for recovery.
Cold and heat: As a general rule, it’s best to use cold applications during the first 24 to 48 hours after an injury─about 20 minutes at a time several times during the day. Cold constricts blood vessels and reduces swelling. When an injury is severe enough to cause swelling in deep tissues, early application of heat might increase pain and swelling by dilating blood vessels and drawing blood into the injured tissues. While it’s unlikely that significant capillary bleeding occurs in simple, uncomplicated back strains, many physicians routinely recommend cold applications during the first 24 hours as a safety measure and to relieve pain by numbing the tissues.
When back pain is not severe, it probably makes little difference whether you use heat or cold; you may try using brief applications of each and then use whichever feels best. Heat applied for 20 or 30 minutes will often provide soothing relief by relaxing spastic muscles. If heat seems to increase pain or cause a throbbing sensation, you should discontinue use of heat and use cold applications for at least two days before trying heat again.
A gel pack that can be cooled in a freezer or heated in a microwave oven can provide a convenient source of heat or cold. Such packs can be strapped to the back to permit movement around the house; they should always be wrapped in fabric to prevent tissue damage caused by excessive temperature.
Rest: When acute back pain occurs as a result of injury, you may have no choice other than to rest in bed the first day or two. But the sooner you begin moving around, the better. Unless you have sustained a spinal fracture or a herniated disk, it’s never a good idea to stay in bed longer than a couple of days. Prolonged bed rest─longer than four days─can lead to weakness and debilitation.
When you are resting in bed, placing a pillow under your knees will relieve strain on your lower back by taking tension off hip flexors (psoas muscles) that tug on the lumbar spine. You can relieve tension on hip flexors and get the added effect of traction by lying on the floor and draping your legs over the arm of a sofa. If you don’t have leg pain caused by nerve root impingement, don’t be afraid to move around the house, even if you have to grunt and groan to do so. Even though movement may be painful, the pain you feel will prevent excessive movement and will not worsen your injury. Use a walker or a pair of crutches if necessary. A simple wrap-around velcro back support might help when standing or walking. A behind-the-back cushion to maintain the normal lumbar curve while sitting might also be helpful.
Medication: When you have uncomplicated musculoskeletal back pain (without sciatic nerve root compression), you won’t often need prescription medication to relieve your pain. Over-the-counter medication such as Tylenol (acetaminophen) will usually provide adequate pain relief. But do not continue use of such medication for longer than about a week at a time. In most cases, the acute pain of a nonspecific back problem will subside after a few days. If pain persists unrelieved, see your doctor. Prolonged or excessive use of acetaminophen, aspirin, or any of the nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory medications (NSAIDs) can have serious side effects. Use medication only as needed if a cold pack or a hot pack does not relieve the pain enough to allow you to lie down and sleep at night.
Exercise: Avoiding bed rest that lasts for longer than a day or two will help reduce the weakness and stiffness caused by back injury. But after two to four weeks of restricting normal activities to relieve mechanical-type back pain, you should begin doing a little exercise to help regain lost strength and mobility─without placing compression or leverages s Ho0mo on the lumbar spine and without contraction of hip flexor muscles that tug on lumbar vertebrae. Care must also be taken to avoid forced or excessive flexion or extension of the lumbar spine. Here are two starting exercises that can be done safely and comfortably by anyone.
     1.  Get down on your hands and knees. Arch your back up and down several times with slow, deliberate movement. This alternate contraction of abdominal and back muscles with flexion and extension of your spine will loosen spinal joints and tone muscles supporting your spine.
     2.  Lie on your back with your knees bent, your feet flat on the floor, and your arms at your sides. Lift your body from the floor so that your weight is supported by your feet and your shoulders to form a bridge. Work up to 12 to 15 repetitions. You can increase the resistance of the exercise in a progressive manner by placing a little weight over your lower abdomen and holding it in place with your hands.
Healing is a matter of time, but it is sometimes also a matter of opportunity.
— Hippocrates, 400 B.C.

Chiropractors, Blind Pigs, and Acorns
Mark Crislip on April 29, 2016
Link


When people are at the end of their life they like to pass on their life lessons. One thing I have never had a patient say is “Doc, I sure wish I had spent more time at work.”
I try and keep that in mind, but then there are those work commitments that are hard to avoid. I need to have a talk with Drs. Gorski and Novella. No one should have write a blog entry any week their team is in the play-offs. The Blazers were not meant to win more than 25 games, much less be the 5th seed in the West with a chance to make the conference finals. I know. Trailblazers fans are not always grounded in reality. But we are up on the Clippers 3–2 and heading home to close out the series tonight. For the record I wrote the preceding sentence during the game 5 tip-off. I really should not have to do any work this week. Basketball is simply more important.
Take this case report. Anywhere else.
Case reports are a tradition in medicine. Usually they are unique or unusual cases, diseases you are likely to see but once in a career, if that. There are all sorts of medical curiosities that need to be reported. I have a blog over at Medscape devoted to Infectious Disease case reports.
Some case reports, however, inspire eye rolls and sniggers. Why are these even reported?
Take “Cellulitis of the Knee in a 16-Month-Old Boy: A Case Report.”
Somehow it is worth killing a tree to discuss a child with cellulitis, a common a disease, in a chiropractic journal.
A diagnosis of cellulitis was rendered based on the presentation of the rapidly spreading erythema and radiographically confirmed findings.
Sorry. Anyone who knows anything about cellulitis would not get an x-ray to confirm a diagnosis of cellulitis. I’ll take water is wet, fire is hot for 500 Alex:
This case demonstrated that for this young patient with cellulitis of the knee, timely recognition and referral, together with patient or parent education and immediate treatment, were essential to a successful outcome.
Really. My god. Who would have thought of using proper medical care for the treatment of an acute infection? For chiropractic, the most mundane of medical cases is considered worthy of publication. It shows that chiropractors either have zero experience of cellulitis or no publishing standards, not that the two are mutually exclusive.
You learn early in medicine that patients never read the textbook. Actual disease presentation is often very different from the typical case you learn about in lectures and books.
Angina, for example, is classically heavy, substernal chest pain radiating to the neck and down the left arm brought on by exertion. Angina, by the way, means neck pain in Latin. I once had a patient who had exertional left wrist pain as the only manifestation of angina, quite the language/anatomy disconnect. Everyone knows the presentation of angina, and of all diseases, is as often atypical as typical. It is part of what makes medicine difficult.
Except for “Presentation of Coronary Artery Disease in a Chiropractic Clinic: A Report of 2 Cases” by Captain Obvious.
Patients may present for chiropractic care with what appears to be musculoskeletal chest pain when the pain may be generating from coronary artery disease necessitating medical and possibly emergency care.
It does make one worry how many coronary artery patients have been missed if chiropractors need to be reminded of information learned in the 4th year of medical school.
Unfortunately chiropractors are 4 years of medical school and residency short of medical training, which is why they need to be reminded to consider imaging for patients with unexplained focal neurologic symptoms.
Examination showed slow gait with a lack of arm swing, bilateral hip flexors and knee extensors were all graded as 4/5 on muscle testing, and cranial nerve examination was unremarkable with the exception of 2 beats of nystagmus on left lateral eye movement. Because of these findings and a family history of multiple sclerosis, the patient was referred for a brain magnetic resonance imaging scan… Imaging showed a craniocervical junction mass centered at the floor of the fourth ventricle with obstruction of foramina and marked impingement on the medulla.
It is the purpose of medical case reports to make other clinicians aware of unusual manifestations of diseases. Or in the case of these reports, remind the oblivious chiropractor of the medically obvious.
Or the patient who has a “”crunch-like” sound” and sudden onset of 7/10 neck pain. Crunching sounds from bone should make one cautious. That would be an impressive presentation of a subluxation. Let’s try:
Axial compression of 2–3 lbs of pressure did not contribute to or alleviate his symptoms. Cervical traction was painful.
Mucking about on a crunchy neck with no diagnosis. Gives me the willies. Nothing bad happened to the patient, which is lucky since the patient had a burst fracture of C4 from myeloma without the typical findings. They conclude:
This case should serve as a reminder that in some circumstances, orthopaedic tests may be of limited clinical value. Practitioners need to be diligent in their clinical assessment of patients to be aware of subtle signs of disease processes.
Which is difficult when you have no real training in medicine.
Or:
A tall thin 25-year-old male anxiously presented to a chiropractic clinic with six days of sudden unexplained left thorax pain. His breathing was laboured and his dry cough aggravating.
Is it worth presenting a classic case of spontaneous pneumothorax for chiropractors? I suppose they are so short for real medical knowledge anything would help.
And now the kickers
One case report was published only because it supports the contention that chiropractors do not cause stroke, but they can recognize it. As providers who allege they are expert in the nervous system, one would think they would recognize a stroke in progress. I guess not, since it was worth publishing “Vertebral artery dissection in evolution found during chiropractic examination.”
Or be wary of metastatic breast cancer.
The aim of this case is to heighten awareness of the presentation of metastasis to the brain and the spine in a chiropractic patient.
What an insight. Cancer metastasis can show up late? Who knew? I mean besides everyone with an MD/DO/NP/RN but not DC after their name.
Not all case reports are diagnostic triumphs worthy of a medical student on their first clinical rotation. One chiropractor sat on a case of acute appendicitis for two weeks, the patient “was treated with soft tissue therapy (?)” and eventually diagnosed with:
phlegmonous appendicitis. After a failed trial of conservative care (antibiotics and fluids), he required an emergency hemicolonectomy due to the massive inflammation that encased and adhered the ruptured appendix and ileum, to the abdominal wall.
Diagnosing an acute appendix can be difficult for trained physicians, much less chiropractors with no experience because:
physical tests taught in the chiropractic curriculum may be antiquated. As such, it is pertinent that chiropractors co-manage patients who present with complaints that may be visceral in origin.
Co-manage? Why on earth would you need a chiropractor for an abdominal complaint of any origin? Chiropractors would add nothing. The correct phrase should be “it is pertinent that chiropractors have no business managing patients who present with complaints that may be visceral in origin.”
These reports never seem to mention specifically whether spinal manipulation was done. It makes me wonder if manipulation was not done or not reported due to embarrassment.
These are all be interesting cases. If you were teaching 4th year medical students with zero clinical experience.
But these cases are directed towards practicing chiropractors to make them aware of diseases that are bread and butter for real medicine. The editors of the journals felt that such papers would be of value to their readers. Maybe they should start with I Am Joe’s Body for supplemental information. It would be age appropriate for those that found these case reports valuable.
And remember, chiropractors are agitating to be primary care providers.
Conclusion: Maybe an extra weekend course will be enough?
These case reports confirm chiropractor’s understanding of basic medicine is every bit as lacking as you would expect from their education and training, just what you want in a PCP. At least in Oregon.
Over the years I have had casual conversations with chiropractors as patients or at social events, situations where I try to be less snarky. It is not uncommon for them to mention the one medical case they diagnosed, demonstrating their medical competence. Color me unimpressed.
Even a blind chiropractor gets a diagnosis once in a while.
By the way. I had a patient years ago who was literally a blind chiropractor. He assured me he could still read the spine x-rays, that he could sense the energy signature of the subluxation. True story. And one of the few times in my life I was speechless.

   Between a Rock and a Hard Place: A Case Study Exploring the Battle Lines of Science Based Medicine
Joseph Albietz
Link
“Primum non nocere.” First, do no harm. It is a guiding principle of medicine, and one which is next to impossible to achieve in practice. It is difficult for the general public to hear, but any intervention a physician makes, and indeed the decision to make no intervention, carries a risk of harm with it. Given enough time, every physician will make a decision which results in unintended harm to a patient, even death, and it haunts us every day of our careers. Faced with this horrible certainty, what is one to do? The only responsible, ethical position to take is to ensure that each patient receives the care most likely to generate a positive outcome, in other words, to stack the deck as steeply in favor of the patient as is possible. Diligent application of the scientific method to every therapy, novel and new, old and venerated, is the only way we as physicians can be certain we are doing the greatest good and the least harm to those who seek our help; it is the only way to assuage our conscience if things end badly.
Our professional organizations and academic institutions have been vital in formulating, propagating, and enforcing the practice of evidence based medicine (EBM). They have stood, to borrow the phrase from Carl Sagan, as “a candle in the dark,” promoting the best practices and protecting patients from those that are ineffective, fraudulent, harmful, or even simply sub-standard. It is a heartening environment in which to work.
With increasing distress, I and others have watched, and I fear have been complicit in, the assisted suicide of EBM at the very moment it is reaching maturity. While our academic centers have supported EBM, they have simultaneously allowed its antithesis to take root within their very halls under the misnomer of Complimentary and Alternative Medicine (CAM). As CAM is almost by definition non-evidence based, EBM and CAM are guaranteed to come into conflict in practice.
This conflict is one I was certain I would confront in due time, but not on my very first day as a newly minted faculty member. Few things are as stressful to a family as an acute, severe illness. The disruption of normal life, reminder of mortality, financial burden imposed, and in particular the loss of control are trying to everyone who finds themselves in the intensive care unit. These factors are magnified when the victim is a child. When faced with the critical illness of their child, parents will seek help from any source they feel may hold the slightest glimmer of hope. Frequently this will lead them to some form of pseudoscience. It is not uncommon, then, for me to be faced with questions about homeopathic treatment for a child with a severe infection, herbal supplementations for a metabolic disorder, or chiropractic after a car accident.
In most situations, such questions are a request for more detailed discussion about their child, for reassurance, or for insight into what I and the other physicians are actually thinking about. Sometimes a rational explanation of why any given pseudoscience is unhelpful and may put their child at risk is enough to explain why my preferred needle is an IV and not acupuncture. Even in the situation where families are staunch believers in a pseudoscience, most recognize that the intensive care unit is not the place for its application. Such was not the case on my first day.
Among the children in my care was a 6 month old child with a new onset of seizures. He had appeared to be previously healthy, but now was on a breathing machine, heavily sedated, and would seize again whenever his medicine was lightened. Frustrating to his family and his caregivers was the lack of a clear diagnosis, a reason for his aggressive seizures. My team and I took a great deal of time every day to explain what we knew and what the plan, both short and long term was for their child, and even went so far as to involve the family in our daily rounds. In spite of these efforts, their dissatisfaction grew, and their relationship with me and the care team became increasingly antagonistic.
While I worked with many sub-specialists and pursued causes both likely and less so, his family pursued its own investigation. The child’s uncle was a chiropractor, and told them of another chiropractor who claimed to specialize in neurological problems. The family asked on several occasions to have the neuro-chiropractor brought in to the hospital and officially consulted by my team.
Here then, is the crux, the conflict. EBM or CAM? Shall I refuse to involve the chiropractor, as there is no reason to suspect he has anything of value to add, and significant risk to the child can be incurred with manipulations? In refusing the family’s explicit request, I would almost certainly undermine their trust, making it more difficult to provide the care this child will continue to require. In protecting this child from the chiropractor and preserving my academic integrity, I would sacrifice any hope for a healthy collaborative relationship with the family. On the other hand, I could grant the family’s desire to have the chiropractor become a functioning member of the medical team, which would bolster their confidence while exposing the child to risk without benefit, and sacrificing both my and my institution’s academic integrity.
As though this situation were not already difficult, there is precedent within my hospital to allow temporary privileges for chiropractors to see children while they are inpatient when families have requested it. Furthermore, the university we are affiliated with is one of dozens of major institutions which now teach elements of CAM in medical school and who have a section of CAM within the university. Put bluntly, this means that if I as the attending physician were to make a stand at this child’s bedside against the involvement of chiropractic within my ICU, I would not have been supported by my own administration.
In this child’s case, I opted for a compromise between the two polar alternatives I described. I allowed the chiropractor a one time visit to see the child, under the stipulation that his visit be supervised by me while he examined the child, and that no manipulations of any kind would be done before consultation with both myself and the involved neurologist. I would gladly speak to him and the parents together regarding our thoughts on the case, and take his recommendations under advisement, but would be under no obligation to act upon them.
The chiropractor’s recommendations were a bit surprising. He had no interest in spinal manipulations of any kind. The philosophy under which he labored was that he needed to encourage “normal neuronal pathways.” This amounted to gentle tactile stimulation, passive range of motion exercises, having the parents talk to the child, and playing music he claimed was specially designed to stimulate different parts of the brain. He also made dietary and nutritional recommendations, which included continuing to use breast milk (he was stunned and impressed I would “allow” such a thing to happen), and supplementing his mother’s diet with fish oil. Further herbal recommendations were made directly for the child; these I flatly refused to entertain without knowing the exact contents and pharmacologic interactions. In the end, the family was pleased by the visit, we enhanced our relationship with them, and prevented the child from coming to harm.
In this episode, I don’t feel that it was in the child’s best interest to fight the battle between EBM and CAM at his bedside (though I acknowledge that such a fight may be required under different circumstances). In hindsight, though, I feel it could have been handled slightly differently. We frequently have priests, imams, prayer sessions, rabbis, etc visit children within the PICU and make no special arrangements. We will speak to these people about their thoughts on the patient and the family’s condition, if they so desire. We do not, however, seek to give them privileges within the hospital. I think that I should have allowed the family to have the chiropractor visit as they would any other family friend, and if they wanted me to speak with him, I would agree to do so. This would have allowed the family to be heard and to have their needs sated without giving the mistaken impression of treating a chiropractor as an equal.
What are we to make, however, of the situation within our academic institutions? As long as CAM is supported, EBM will remain difficult to practice. The public will become more confused as to what constitutes safe and effective medicine, funds will be wasted on futile projects, and medical progress will be retarded. Most concerning, the next generation of physicians, immersed in the mutually exclusive principles of CAM and EBM will be poorly prepared to provide the best possible care to their patients.
The current political, commercial, and academic powers have been ineffective at preventing the corrosion of the principles of EBM. We have a professional and ethical obligation to strengthen and reform the intellectual infrastructure of medicine. If, however, it is no longer sufficient for physicians to align themselves with existing organizations in order to stand clearly in support of EBM, it may be time to develop a way for physicians and health care professionals who practice science based, evidence based medicine to publicly stand up and be counted.
Primum non nocere. An unattainable goal it may be, but a relentless commitment to EBM is the only way for us to honor our duty to our patients and our profession. To compromise for anything less is unacceptable.

Top 10 Chiropractic Studies of 2013
Harriet Hall on January 21, 2014
Link
ChiroNexus recently listed the top 10 chiropractic studies of 2013. In my experience, chiropractic studies tend to be of poor quality. A media report says “study shows chiropractic works for X,” and when I look for the study it turns out to be a single case report or an uncontrolled study. When Simon Singh was sued by the British Chiropractic Association for saying chiropractic treatment for certain childhood ailments was bogus, the BCA responded with a list of 29 studies they said provided evidence for their claims. Steven Novella showed that out of 29 studies on the list, only 17 actually constituted evidence for 4 clinical claims, and those 17 were poor quality, cherry-picked, and too weak to support the claims. I have a copy of a chiropractic textbook entitled Somatovisceral Aspects of Chiropractic: An Evidence-Based Approach and there is nothing in it that would qualify as credible evidence to a science-based thinker. Chiropractic commenters on SBM have told us that modern chiropractic rejects the “subluxation” paradigm and relies on evidence, and I am always willing to look at new evidence and give chiropractors another chance to convince me that a reform movement is really underway, so I looked up the top 10 studies and read them. I was not impressed.
Note: This is a long article with mind-numbing details that will not be of interest to most readers. Feel free to scroll down to the Summary section. You can just read the bold-faced headings describing the claims of each study on the way down.
Also note: For those who want more detail, the “Study #” headings are links to the full text when available online, or to the PubMed citation.
Study #1: Immediate Benefits of Chiropractic Visible on MRI
The full title is “Magnetic Resonance Imaging Zygapophyseal Joint Space Changes (Gapping) in Low Back Pain Patients Following Spinal Manipulation and Side-Posture Positioning: A Randomized Controlled Mechanisms Trial With Blinding.” It was published in the major chiropractic journal, the Journal of Manipulative and Physiological Therapies (JMPT). The authors are from the National University of Health Sciences, a school noted for integrating quackery with medicine. A school that accepts students who don’t even meet their admission requirements and that remedies the lack by teaching them everything they think chiropractors need to know about science in two 8-week sessions of evening classes. Funding was from the NCCAM (in other words, our tax dollars paid for it).
Underlying hypothesis: If the motion of zygapophyseal joints is decreased for any reason (inactivity, repetitive motion, injury), it is hypothesized that they develop adhesions and that both spinal manipulation therapy (SMT) and side-posture positioning (SPP) break the adhesions by “gapping” the joints (separating the articular surfaces, the same process that happens when you crack your knuckles).
Methods: 112 patients with low back pain were randomized to four treatment groups: SMT, SPP, SMT control, SPP control.
First MRI appointment: Patients were placed in a neutral position prior to treatment; the most painful side was always the up side for treatment. An MRI was taken in the neutral position before treatment, then treatment was given followed by a post-treatment MRI.
     1.  SPP Group: SPP, remaining in SPP for 2nd MRI
     2.  SMT control group: Side-posture SMT, followed by neutral positioning for 2nd MRI
     3.  SMT group: side-posture SMT, remaining in side-posture for 2nd MRI
     4.  SPP control: brief SPP followed by neutral positioning for 2nd MRI
Groups 2 and 4 served as control groups because previous studies had shown that returning to the neutral position after treatment resulted in no Z joint gapping difference between the 1st and 2nd MRIs.
Treatment phase: All patients received chiropractic care for 2 weeks, including SMT and other modalities.
Second MRI appointment: After 2 weeks of chiropractic treatment, the second MRI appointment was identical to the first with the exception that the groups were switched (1 with 2 and 3 with 4) so that all subjects were in both an intervention and control group and all subjects were in an SPP and an SMT group during the study.
Results: At the first MRI appointment, the SPP group had greater gapping than the other three groups. (SPP .66 +/- .48 mm, SMT .23 +/-.86 mm, controls .18 +/- .71 mm). At the second MRI appointment, SMT followed by SPP was the only group that showed significantly higher increases in gapping from the first MRI appointment. On pain questionnaires, SMT followed by SPP was the only group that showed significant improvement in pain between the first and second MRI appointments.
Conclusion: They speculated that paraspinal muscles may have relaxed more with SPP at the first MRI appointment, whereas SMT might have resulted in transient increased muscle tightness, and that the reversal of findings at the second MRI appointment may have been because the muscles were more relaxed after 2 weeks of SMT. They conclude that SMT is effective in decreasing pain and increasing gapping and that keeping the patient in the side-posture position for several minutes following SMT may have therapeutic benefit.
My thoughts: The research design was complicated, and trying to figure it out gave me a headache. After reading the report several times, I’m still not entirely sure exactly what they did, why they did it, or what the results mean. We already knew that SMT was effective for low back pain, but we didn’t understand the mechanism. This study attempted to show that the improvement is related to increased gapping of the zygoapophyseal joints, but the authors suggest that muscle relaxation may be the mechanism for both increased gapping and decreased pain, raising the question of whether SMT actually accomplishes anything that other muscle relaxing treatments might not do just as well. Basically, before chiropractic treatment, a single SPP treatment increased gapping more than SMT, and after 2 weeks of SMT treatment, a single SMT treatment increased gapping compared to a single SPP treatment. The suggestion of keeping the patient in a side position following SMT is interesting, but this study was not designed to show whether that would improve clinical outcomes. Since the increased gapping disappears as soon as the neutral position is assumed, its clinical importance is questionable. It would be nice to find out if the hypothesized adhesions are real, but the study didn’t address that.
Study # 2: AMA Recommends Chiropractic Before Resorting to Surgery
This is not a study at all. It is a patient information page from the Journal of the American Medical Association. Under the “Treatment” heading it says:
Many treatments are available for low back pain. Often exercises and physical therapy can help. Some people benefit from chiropractic therapy or acupuncture. Sometimes medications are needed, including analgesics (painkillers) or medications that reduce inflammation. Surgery is not usually needed but may be considered if other therapies have failed.
I don’t think this constitutes a recommendation to try chiropractic before resorting to surgery. It mentions acupuncture in the same breath, and specialty organizations like the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons and the American Academy of Family Physicians do not include either chiropractic or acupuncture in their list of treatment options. As a matter of fact, the WHO guidelines for chiropractic specify that disc herniation with progressive neurological deficits is an absolute contraindication to spinal manipulation treatments. It is really a stretch to claim that the AMA recommends chiropractic.
Study # 3: Chiropractic as Effective as Epidural Injections for Lumbar Disc Herniation
This study by Swiss chiropractors, published in the JMPT, was a comparative effectiveness observational study using data from two databases, one of patients who received nerve root injections (NRIs) and the other of patients who received spinal manipulation therapy (SMT) at a single chiropractic practice. Subjects were 51 matched cases of patients who all had MRI-confirmed lumbar disc herniation. (Note: 28% of asymptomatic people also have these same MRI findings.) Two kinds of SMT were given: intraforaminal disk herniation was treated with modified push adjustment with a kick; paramedian disk herniation was treated with pull adjustment with a kick. They did not explain the rationale for when to push and when to pull.
They found no difference in favorable outcomes between the two treatments.
Other studies have found NRI and SMT effective, but the quality of evidence is poor and many studies fail to differentiate between disc herniation and other causes of low back pain. As mentioned under Study #1, chiropractic manipulation is not widely accepted as a treatment option for lumbar disc disease.
They admit some limitations of their study: it was not a randomized clinical trial, so they themselves point out that
the outcomes of these patients cannot be directly attributed to the specific treatments.
(And yet they go right ahead and attribute.) They did not have sufficient demographic information to assess possible confounders. The sample size was small. Outcome data were collected by telephone interview, a method that tends to produce more positive responses than questionnaires. Outcomes were subjective patient reports, not objective measurements. The groups were not comparable: the NRI group had higher pretreatment pain levels. There was an obvious source of bias: patients or referring physicians had chosen which treatment they wanted to try. Also, the NRI was done at a single appointment, while chiropractic patients were seen for multiple treatments. The time spent with the provider is a probable confounder.
They said SMT was slightly less expensive than NRI, but they admitted that they were only looking at direct procedure costs and could not determine overall cost-effectiveness.
This study was not even randomized. It would have made a lot more sense to have done a prospective randomized study and to have ruled out as many confounders as possible. Because of the flaws in this study, no conclusions can be drawn from it.
Study # 4: Chiropractic Lowers Blood Pressure
This was a study from Sherman College of Chiropractic published in the Journal of Chiropractic Medicine entitled “Blood pressure changes in African American patients receiving chiropractic care in a teaching clinic: a preliminary study.” There were only 24 subjects, all black patients diagnosed with pre-hypertension (120-139/80-89) or hypertension stage 1 (140-159/90-99), with or without medication. There was no control group, and the subjects were not a random or characteristic group of hypertensive patients, but a sample of convenience. Chiropractic did NOT lower blood pressure. The results were negative! BP did not change significantly after chiropractic care. They weren’t happy with that result, so they tried throwing out 4 data points from patients with “outlier” high BMIs, and lo and behold! The remaining data yielded a statistically significant reduction in BP (diastolic pressure only). I don’t think throwing out the outliers was justified; I think it constituted illegitimate data mining. And even for the tweaked dataset, the difference was not clinically significant. The diastolic pressure only dropped from 81.5 to 77.1 and the systolic pressure was unchanged.
Study # 5: Chiropractic Best Option for SI Joint Pain
“Treatment of the sacroiliac joint in patients with leg pain: a randomized-controlled trial” was a single-blinded randomized trial from the Netherlands, published in the European Spine Journal. It was a small trial: a total of 51 patients with leg pain attributed to the SI joint were randomized to one of three treatment groups: physiotherapy (exercise), manual therapy (manipulation with high-velocity thrust technique), and intra-articular steroid injections. They set simple criteria for success and failure: success was complete relief or improved VAS (visual analog scale) pain score; failure was dropping out because of worsening complaints or a VAS score that did not improve. The PT group had 12 failures and 3 successes, the manual therapy group had 5 failures and 13 successes, and the injection group had 9 failures and 9 successes. The magnitude of the improvement was small. On the 10-point VAS of pain, PT improved the score by an average of 0.4 points, manual therapy by 1.9 points, and injection by 0.7 points. In their opinion, a clinically meaningful difference was 1.3-2 points. I’m not sure I agree.
They concluded that manual therapy was the treatment of choice for this select group of patients with SI-related leg pain, but cautioned that the findings may not apply to patients not meeting the specific criteria for inclusion in this study and that because of the small sample size, their results need to be confirmed by a larger study.
The patients were referred by general practitioners with the question whether they had a radiculopathy due to a herniated lumbar disc. It can be difficult to differentiate disc pain from SI pain, and some of the tests have questionable inter-observer reliability.
They mention that they had difficulty recruiting patients willing to be randomized. 23% had an overt favorite. 10 wanted an injection, 5 did not want an injection, 1 wanted manual therapy, and 3 wanted PT.
There is no mention of chiropractors in the study. They did not specify who provided the manual therapy.
The findings of this study contradicted other studies. A 2012 study showed that lumbar manipulation was more effective than SI manipulation. Other studies have shown a greater response to intra-articular injections (67%) than the 50% that this study found. And previous studies have found PT to be effective.
Study # 6: Neck Adjustments Immediately Improve Joint Position Sense
A study from Korea published in the Journal of Physical Therapy Science evaluated 30 normal adults who were divided into two groups (no mention of randomization): the test group was given cervical joint manipulation and massage and the control group got massage only. Reduction in cervical range of motion (ROM) is thought to reduce joint position sense and possibly to be related to dizziness; this study investigated whether increasing ROM in normal volunteers by neck manipulation would improve joint position sense (JPS). Researchers showed patients how to adopt six exact neck positions and then were tested with an inclinometer to see if they could adopt the same positions without instruction. The test group improved significantly on all six tests; the control group didn’t. In a comparison of the test group to the control group, two tests showed a significant difference; the other four didn’t. Errors declined from 2.5 to 3 degrees pre-treatment to 1-1.2 degrees post-treatment. The authors recommend that:
when treating patients with reduced JPS due to decreased ROM, persistent neck pain, or whiplash injuries, the combined application of cervical joint manipulation and massage [be] used.
That conclusion is not supported by the data. A study of JPS on normal volunteers with a normal ROM can’t be used to make clinical recommendations for patients with neck pain and decreased ROM. They didn’t even measure ROM; they just measured people’s ability to assume a previously taught position. The clinical significance of improved JPS is unknown. If they think it is the mechanism by which manipulation works, they need to study JPS in patients with neck pain.
Of concern: neck manipulation carries a small but serious risk of stroke. Question: would gentle mobilization and massage get the same results with less risk?
Study # 7: Chiropractic Better than Medical Care Alone for Back Pain
A randomized controlled trial by American chiropractors entitled “Adding Chiropractic Manipulative Therapy to Standard Medical Care for Patients With Acute Low Back Pain: Results of a Pragmatic Randomized Comparative Effectiveness Study.” Subjects were 91 military men and women between 18 and 35 years of age with acute low back pain (LBP). All patients got standard medical care and 45 were randomly assigned to also get chiropractic treatment. Standard medical care (SMC) was a single visit that might include any or all of the following: a focused history and physical exam, diagnostic imaging as indicated, education about self-management including maintaining activity levels as tolerated, pharmacological management with the use of analgesics and anti-inflammatory agents, and physical therapy and modalities such as heat/ice and referral to a pain clinic. Chiropractic treatment (CMT) consisted of 5 visits for high velocity/low amplitude (HVLA) manipulation plus whatever else the chiropractor chose to do (education, exercise, mobilization, etc).
Results: 73% of the SMC + CMT group reported improvement compared to 17% in the SMC-only group. Satisfaction on a 10-point scale was 8.9 and 5.4 respectively. There were two adverse events after chiropractic treatment.
Problems:
    • Followup rates were 85% for the standard care group and 63% for the combined care group.
    • Participants had higher expectation of helpfulness for the combined medical/chiropractic treatment than for standard care alone. This is a clear source of bias.
    • Pain, functional status, and patient satisfaction were measured by subjective answers to questionnaire; no objective measurements were done. They did not even track use of pain medication during the trial or speed of return to full duty.
    • Care was not standardized. Improvement could have been due to some other component of treatment.
    • Multiple visits to chiropractor were compared with a single visit for standard care.
    • This was a select group of healthy young patients; results might not apply to the general patient population.
The design of this trial practically guaranteed that it would favor chiropractic. Pragmatic comparative effectiveness trials of CAM treatments are inherently biased to favor CAM. They allow the nonspecific effects of provider/patient interactions to shine. They are not designed to test whether a CAM treatment is superior to placebo; they are a way of bypassing that essential step.
Study # 8: Spinal Adjustments Relieve Muscle Pain Instantly
From the JMPT. 33 healthy young adults with myofascial trigger points in the gluteus medius and infraspinatus muscles were randomized and treated with SMT targeted to the C5-6 spinal segment or with sham SMT. The pressure pain threshold increased in the treatment group. Chiropractic theory says that SMT relieves pain by improving nerve function. Does increased pressure pain threshold mean the nerves in the infraspinatus muscle are functioning better? We don’t know; the study didn’t address that. Does the finding have any clinical importance for patients with muscle pain? The study didn’t address that either. (Our assistant editor Paul Ingraham has written much about the idea of myofascial trigger points, skeptically.)
Study #9: Cervical Disc Herniation Eased by Chiropractic
A study by Swiss chiropractors published in the JMPT entitled “Outcomes from Magnetic Resonance Imaging-Confirmed Symptomatic Cervical Disk Herniation Patients Treated with High-Velocity, Low-Amplitude Spinal Manipulative Therapy: A Prospective Cohort Study with 3-Month Follow-Up.” This was an uncontrolled study of 50 patients. 55% were “improved” at 2 weeks, 69% at 1 month and 86% at 3 months, according to the patients’ own global impressions; there were no objective measurements. Improvement was greater in patients with acute pain than in those with chronic pain. The treatment is exactly the kind of neck manipulation that has been associated with strokes.
How many of these patients would have improved with no treatment at all, due to the natural course of the disease? The authors say it is virtually impossible to extract reliable figures on the natural history of this condition, so a control group is crucial to interpreting the significance of their findings, and it’s hard to understand why they failed to use one. While double blinding with a credible placebo control would be difficult, they might at least have compared HVLA manipulation to gentle mobilization with exercise and physical therapy modalities like heat.
Study # 10: Chiropractic Thaws Frozen Shoulder Syndrome
From the Journal of Chiropractic Medicine. This was a case series of 50 consecutive patients diagnosed with frozen shoulder syndrome (FSS) and treated with a series of chiropractic manipulation treatments of the cervical and thoracic spine, plus a novel chiropractic method, the OTZ Tension Adjustment, which involves a “skull glide” and an HVLA thrust to correct occipito-atlantal subluxation. There was no control group. The findings:
Many of these patients’ complaints seemed to improve or resolve within 1 month of presentation, whereas, in general, it is thought that FSS symptoms can persist for 2 years or more.
This is junk science.
    • There is no credible mechanism by which anything in the spine could cause FSS.
    • There is no such thing as a chiropractic subluxation.
    • Treating problems elsewhere in the body by adjusting the 1st cervical vertebra doesn’t work and is rejected even by most chiropractors.
    • “Skull glide” is not defined and I couldn’t find anything about it on the Internet. Probably a bogus untested maneuver.
    • The OTZ adjustment has never been tested and there is no reason to think it should work for anything, especially in the shoulder. The founder of the system claims it works for frozen shoulder, migraine, vertigo, insomnia, Bell’s palsy, ADHD, posture, and other conditions.
    • The lead author is the owner and founder of the OTZ system.
    • All patients had been treated by the lead author.
    • No control group.
    • Frozen shoulder usually resolves in a matter of months with physical therapy; even without treatment, it resolves within 24 months.
    • Manual manipulative treatment of the shoulder itself has been tested and found helpful for FSS, but manipulation of the spine has not.
It would have been so simple to use a control group, even if it were only to compare chiropractic treatment with and without OTZ. The lead author invented OTZ and proceeded to treat thousands of patients without bothering to test whether it worked.
This amounts to Tooth Fairy Science squared: it is a study about treating an imaginary subluxation with an imaginary treatment.
Summary
To recap, my evaluation of these “10 best studies” showed:
Study 1. Bewilderingly complicated design, clinical relevance of findings not established.
Study 2. Not a study
Study 3. Small study with numerous limitations and evidence of bias; the authors themselves said outcomes could not be attributed to treatment.
Study 4. Negative study misrepresented as positive
Study 5. Small study with evidence of bias; results incompatible with previous studies
Study 6. Small study of joint position sense in normal people, with questionable clinical relevance. Data do not support conclusions.
Study 7. Pragmatic comparative effectiveness trial designed to guarantee it would favor chiropractic
Study 8. Small study with questionable clinical relevance
Study 9. Uncontrolled study
Study 10. Uncontrolled case series; junk science intended to promote the OTZ System, whose owner and founder is the lead author and treating chiropractor.
Questions remain
Is chiropractic effective? Numerous studies have established that SMT is:
    • Effective for certain kinds of low back pain but not more effective than other treatments.
    • Effective for certain types of neck pain but only when accompanied by exercise, and not more effective than mobilization.
    • Not effective for any other condition.
None of these 10 studies would change those conclusions.
How does chiropractic work? 1,6,and 8 addressed possible mechanisms for effects of SMT. Chiropractic was founded in 1895 and we still don’t know how it works. None of these studies provides a credible answer.
Why aren’t they doing better studies?
How do these studies measure up on Bausell’s 4-point checklist? Not very well:
     1.  Subjects randomly assigned to a CAM therapy or a credible placebo control? At best, 1 out of 10 studies.
     2.  At least 50 subjects per group? 0 out of 10 studies.
     3.  Less than 25% dropout rate? 9 out of 10 studies.
     4.  Publication in a high-quality, prestigious, peer-reviewed journal? 0 out of 10 studies.
Standards for conducting well-designed clinical trials are common knowledge today. Why is anyone still doing uncontrolled studies or using inadequate controls? Why is so little research on chiropractic of sufficient quality to merit publication in high quality journals?
Conclusion
If these 10 studies are the best chiropractic research from 2013, that means the quality of chiropractic research is appallingly poor.

Chiropractors falsely claim they can protect patients from coronavirus
Chiropractors are falsely claiming that their spinal “adjustments” can protect people from coronavirus infection, as well as giving other dubious health advice on COVID-19. As they have with other bogus remedies, the media and government authorities should take action.
Jann Bellamy on March 12, 2020
Link

Some chiropractors are falsely claiming that spinal “adjustments” will do everything from “boosting the immune system” (which you can’t do), helping ward off the novel coronavirus, to actually preventing patients from contracting the virus. They also advise other dubious measures for keeping the virus at bay.
These bogus assertions are based on their misrepresentation of the human nervous system as susceptible to interruptions of “nerve flow” or “nerve energy” between the brain and the rest of the body. According to chiropractors, these putative interruptions are caused by “subluxations”, or “misalignments”, of the spinal vertebrae, creating deleterious effects such as a compromised immune system. Chiropractors can “correct” these “subluxations” with spinal “adjustments”, thereby restoring “nerve flow”. As one chiropractic website “explains”:
Spinal adjustments have been shown to boost immune function because they serve to correct the spinal misalignments that cause neural dysfunction. Neural dysfunction stresses a body out, which may lead to a weakened immune system and lowered response to a foreign body, such as the cold virus.
Organs that have a strong relationship with the immune system, such as the lymph nodes and the spleen, communicate with your brain and nerves, and if your nervous system isn’t functioning at an optimal level, a communication breakdown can occur. You can imagine what may happen next. Getting a chiropractic adjustment is a great place to start so you can get any spinal misalignment you may have corrected. Even one adjustment can bring about an immediate immune boost.
No, it won’t. Actually, what the “adjustment” (in the form of spinal manipulation) may do is cause anything from mild to moderate adverse events, such as pain, to vertebral artery dissection and consequent stroke following cervical manipulation. At the least, the patient will have wasted money on a worthless treatment.
Unfortunately, neither the uselessness of, nor risks associated with, their treatments are keeping chiropractors from exploiting the coronavirus epidemic. There’s even a new poster and patient handout offered by one company warning that skipping your chiropractic “adjustments” will put you at greater risk for contracting the coronavirus.
As is often the case in the service of pseudoscience, a good, old-fashioned anecdote is employed as evidence of the “adjustment’s” effectiveness. In a post titled “Coronavirus”, this chiropractic practice claims that
a patient [was seen] last week suffering from cold and flu symptoms for two weeks with no change after 2 rounds of prescribed medications and a variety of over the counter medications all to no avail. One adjustment and 2 days later the patient was 80% better. That is the power of an adjustment. Safe and effective. No side effects. That’s protection. Have you had an adjustment lately?
[Emphasis in original.]
A Texas chiropractor is, more creatively, window dressing his false claims with science-based advice, while at the same time adding adjunct pseudoscience and a touch of historical negationism which casts chiropractors as the saviors of Spanish flu victims. Under the title “7 Ways to Protect Yourself from Coronavirus” we find:
Standard recommendations to prevent infection spread include regular hand washing, covering mouth and nose when coughing and sneezing . . .
This comes with a warning against two perennial CAM bugaboos, sugar and dairy, because
too much sugar weakens our immune system, and voilà! Sickness isn’t an if, it becomes a when.
But that’s nothing compared to what milk will do to you: milk increases antibiotic resistance, making us more susceptible to “superbugs” like coronavirus; contains high levels of estrogen and progesterone, which leads to abnormal early puberty and increases the risk of uterine, breast and prostate cancers; contains casein, which facilitates the growth of cancer cells; increases the risk of Type I diabetes and multiple sclerosis; disrupts the body’s Vitamin D production and negatively affects bone growth; and, because of sulfurous amino acids, leaches the calcium out of our bones, thereby “leading to a vastly higher risk of osteoporosis at an earlier age”.
While there may be reasons one would not want to consume milk, this is a vast overstatement of the risks.
In any event, chiropractic “adjustments” are essential:
Of course I have to include this. Everyone who comes into my office for their first visit has a misalignment of their C1 vertebra, also known as a vertebral subluxation. This is significant because just about every nerve in the entire body passes through the C1 as the spinal cord. When there is a subluxation of the C1, this adds stress, tension, and/or pressure to some aspect of some nerve that travels to somewhere in the body. When this happens, people experience symptoms either immediately or eventually. Removing the subluxation and restoring proper positioning of the C1 allows the nervous system to properly communicate with the body and vice versa. Since the nervous system is the master system, it happens to control all other systems, including the immune system.
Everyone?
To “boost” his case, the website cites this unpublished 4-page paper from 1978, full of uncredited statistics and anecdotes, for the claim that:
[P]eople infected with influenza [during the 1917-18 epidemic] who received chiropractic care as their primary means of treatment died at such a lower rate than those treated by medicine that it was staggering.
While some chiropractors may depend on the patient’s making the connection between an immune system “boost” and protection against the coronavirus, others are not so subtle. From a Charlotte, NC, chiropractor’s website:
[W]hat I want to talk to you about is how to strengthen your immune system, how to make yourself coronavirus proof, so that you don’t have to worry about it, your family doesn’t have to worry about it. . . .
So, in order to make you coronavirus free and may make you independent and not have to worry, make your body strong enough to know, that regardless, if somebody walks in and sneezes on you or shakes your hand or kisses you, you’re not going to wind up getting sick because you got to make sure your immune system is kicking on all cylinders. Which means, your nervous system has to be kicking on all cylinders. . . .
Now, the best way to do that is to find an upper cervical chiropractor. To check this area, we have objective tools [one of these, perhaps] that we can actually scan your neck and see if there’s any interference anywhere between your brain and your body. If there is, then we can figure out what’s causing that interference. We can remove that interference. Make sure the brain’s talking at 100%, and that way it keeps your immune system kicking at 100%, so then you can fight off anything, anything that comes in and tries to hurt you.
[Emphasis added.]
This is not only patently false, it is dangerous. Anyone who believes he is immune from the coronavirus is unlikely to take precautions for himself or others, increasing the risk of contracting COVID-19.
If an “adjustment” isn’t enough to nip your coronavirus in the bud, you can, according to this California chiropractor, pop some dietary supplements, which he conveniently sells to his patients. After incorrectly saying that the coronavirus is “the latest version” of the flu, he says:
In my office we have some amazing supplements in the area of immunity. One of these is Echinacea Premium from Mediherb. It is fabulously potent. . . Echinacea is an immune booster and balancer. . . We use the Standard Process supplement Immuplex to rebuild the immune system. [Caution: non sequitur ahead.] Dig that people used to live much shorter lives than we live today. So all these supplements rebuild a tired, depleted system. . .
Acute infections can be addressed with Congaplex and sometimes Andrographis Complex which contains echinacea premium. Garlic can be helpful for many people too. We sell garlic capsules. The trick to acute infections is to jump all over them with supplements within a few hours of the moment you get an inkling you might be coming down with something. Why? There is a good chance if you address the infection quickly enough it never takes hold.
“Immuplex” is basically a multi-vitamin/mineral supplement to which a “proprietary blend” of bovine liver, spleen, and thymus extracts, veal bone extract, and other ingredients have been added. Even the maker of “Congaplex” (which also contains animal organ extracts) admits it doesn’t know if it works in humans. There is no evidence that either echinacea or garlic will prevent, or reduce the severity of, COVID-19. In fact, federal law prohibits the sale of dietary supplements to treat infectious diseases.
Fortunately, the promotion of bogus preventatives and remedies for coronavirus infection is getting media, blogosphere, and government attention. On Monday, the Washington Post reported that the FDA and FTC sent warning letters to seven companies touting various products, including teas, essential oils, and colloidal silver. The Post also ran a column by a registered dietician several days ago noting that claims one could “boost” one’s immune system were proliferating and explaining why this is nonsense, although it did not mention chiropractors. Televangelist Jim Bakker’s shilling for “Silver Solution” was widely reported. Even the CAM-friendly National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health is warning against alternative remedies being promoted for coronavirus infections.
Unfortunately, no one has alerted the public to the dangers of chiropractors promoting their “immune boosting” powers. In fact, the standard recommendation to “check with your health care provider” could lead some patients to rely on their chiropractors for advice about the coronavirus. After all, they promote themselves as “primary care providers”. Newspapers and other media should do a better job of warning the public away from unreliable health care advice given by those who are, regrettably, licensed by the states to practice pseudoscience.

Chiropractors continue to make claims about chiropractic and COVID-19
Chirorpractors continue to make unsubstantiated claims about COVID-19.
Scott Gavura on April 2, 2020
Link

Never let a good crisis go to waste
– attributed to Rahm Emanuel but also Winston Churchill
Perhaps not surprisingly, as the COVID-19 pandemic has upended and disrupted society, there are those that are leveraging legitimate fears to sell dubious products and services. Jann Bellamy blogged last week about naturopathy, chiropractic, and COVID-19. Two days ago, CBC News profiled action being taken in Ontario:
There’s no scientific evidence that chiropractic care can boost your immune system, but that hasn’t stopped some chiropractors from touting the practice as a tool to prevent infection from the novel coronavirus that has caused the COVID-19 pandemic.
The problem is so widespread that one Ontario man has filed at least 34 complaints against chiropractic clinics in the province alone in the past few weeks.
“As soon as there is public fear to exploit, these practitioners are really quick to get on message and promote this type of misinformation for their own profit,” said Ryan Armstrong, who runs an independent non-profit called Bad Science Watch.
Multiple organization have made statements regarding inappropriate marketing, the CBC reports:
Across the country, provincial governing bodies have issued warnings to their members not to spread misinformation about chiropractic care and COVID-19.
The College of Chiropractors of B.C., the Alberta College and Association of Chiropractors, the Manitoba Chiropractors Association and L’Ordre des chiropraticiens du Quebec have all put out statements in the last week or so.
Nationally, the Canadian Chiropractic Association has also warned members about making unsubstantiated claims.
Provincial governments are curtailing access to chiropractic. The Alberta government has ordered chiropractors to not provide services unless it is felt to be emergency or critical. Alberta’s chiropractic regulator has stated the following:
The Alberta government ordered chiropractors to cease normal operations and limit care to urgent, critical and emergency cases only. Chiropractors are not permitted to provide any service that does not constitute urgent, critical or emergency care.
The ACAC was asked by some members to clarify what urgent, critical and emergency chiropractic care means.
This is defined for all chiropractors as follows:
Urgent neurological chiropractic care:
This is defined as a pathology that could reasonably lead to a neurological deficit. The patient must be a demonstratable candidate for response to manual treatment, as delivered by a chiropractor; and if left untreated would result in the patient seeking urgent or emergency care at a medical facility. This must be established with a complete neuro/ortho/biomechanical assessment. No other form of assessment may be used to establish the need for care. Subluxation, wellness or functional care does not meet the criteria for urgent neurological chiropractic care in the context of what has been communicated by Alberta Health.
Urgent musculoskeletal chiropractic care:
This is defined as a pathology that could reasonably be a musculoskeletal condition for the patient that does, or would incapacitate the patient’s ability to function in performing daily activities without immediate intervention; and if left untreated would result in the patient seeking urgent or emergency care at a medical facility. This must be established with a complete neuro/ortho/biomechanical assessment. No other form of assessment may be used to establish the need for care. Subluxation, wellness or functional care does not meet the criteria for urgent musculoskeletal chiropractic care in the context of what has been communicated by Alberta Health.
Relying on patient preference to receive chiropractic care is not currently acceptable in establishing the need for urgent, critical or emergency care. Any consideration for in-person care should begin with the assumption that in-person care is not necessary.
While many will argue that all chiropractic is unnecessary, given this is coming from the chiropractic regulator, it leave only a very small number of patients eligible for treatment, if this order is followed. If chiropractors are following orders to offer noting but the most urgent/critical cases, then touting unproven benefits related to coronavirus should, hopefully, cease. We will keep monitoring.

Chiropractic scope of practice includes . . . well, you won’t believe it
Jann Bellamy on August 7, 2014
Link

Ladies, how would you like a chiropractor to deliver your baby? How about perform your annual well-woman exams, such as breast exam, bi-manual pelvic exam, speculum exam, recto-vaginal exam and Pap smear?
Sound out of their league? I thought so too. Way out. But, in some parts of the U.S., the law allows chiropractors to do all of these things and a great deal more. Including “adjusting” your basset hound.
A 2011 survey asked chiropractic regulatory officials whether their jurisdictions (all states, plus D.C., Virgin Islands and Puerto Rico, but I’ll refer to them collectively as the “states”) allowed 97 different diagnostic, evaluation, and management procedures. The results were recently reported and interpreted in the Journal of Manipulative and Physiological Therapeutics, in an article authored by Mabel Chang, DC, MPH, who was primarily responsible for the survey. Missouri allows the most procedures (92) and Texas, the fewest (30). A handful of states did not respond or did not respond to all questions, but the overall response rate was 96%. Results from a survey of Canada, Australia and New Zealand will be reported in a separate article.
One wonders whether there was some stagecraft at work in deciding which procedures to include. Although the survey was willing to ask about homeopathic products and colonic irrigation, other quackery is nowhere to be seen. For example, diagnostic techniques such as applied kinesiology, contact reflex analysis and various EAV devices are not mentioned. And although “subluxations” were mentioned, the fact that their detection and correction is the centerpiece of all chiropractic state practice acts was not. For example: “In Michigan, procedures . . . are permitted if they relate to the subluxation complex.” (This would include “glandular supplementation” in that state, according to the survey.)
Chiropractic OB/GYN?
So, how many states allow chiropractors to perform much, perhaps all, of your well-woman exam or deliver your baby? (We’ll get to the rest of surveyed procedures in a minute.) Here are the results:
    • Obstetrics: 9 states (2 require additional training); can order an obstetrical exam in 2 states. Chiropractors can sign birth certificates in 10 states.
    • Breast exam: 29 states (2 with additional training); can order in 3. Mammography was not included in the survey, but thermography, which is used (but shouldn’t be) for diagnostic breast imaging, can be performed by chiropractors in 32 states (6 with additional training) and can be ordered in 9.
    • Bi-manual pelvic exam: 24 states (1 with additional training); can order in 5.
    • Speculum exam: 24 states (2 with additional training); can order in 6.
    • Recto-vaginal exam: 23 states (2 with additional training); can order in 5.
    • Pap smear: 17 states; can order in 10.
I mention these procedures not to be titillating, but because they are extremely invasive and can be embarrassing and painful for women. They should never be performed by anyone without proper medical training. Yet chiropractic schools offer, at most, only the most cursory classroom instruction in these subjects. I would hazard a guess that chiropractic in-school clinics, where the vast majority of their clinical training takes place, do not include any OB/GYN training. Chiropractic post-graduate training generally consists of weekend lectures in hotel conference room settings. They do not do residencies before going into practice.
Regulators in a few states themselves seem to question the inclusion of these services in chiropractic scope of practice. Some recommended referral to “a more appropriate professional.” Others said “documentation of appropriate setting and clinical rationale” is recommended, adding that a chiropractor could be subject to investigation and sanctions without same. Which makes me wonder: why don’t these regulators ask their legislatures to remove these procedures from chiropractic scope of practice by statute?
Survey results
The survey provides a list of all 97 procedures and tells us, state by state, whether a chiropractor can perform it, can perform with additional training/certification, can order it, or cannot order/perform. The survey also calculates what percentage of the states consider each procedure within the scope of practice, whether it be performing (with additional training or not) or ordering. The article divides these procedures into 3 groups, presented in three tables:
     1.  Diagnostic and examination certifications
     2.  Physical examination, gender-specific services, physiotherapeutics, and specialty training techniques
     3.  Adjunctive and specialty service
While overall this information is valuable, how the author groups them is not. As is true of chiropractic scope of practice, these groupings don’t necessarily make any logical sense, and most certainly do not conform to any medical taxonomy. I’ve discarded in them in my analysis, because how a chiropractor would group them doesn’t matter. What matters is whether they should or should not be included in their scope of practice. I include the percentage of states allowing chiropractors to perform or order procedure, in parentheses. Here is my determination. Your results may vary.
Appropriate for chiropractic scope of practice, if limited to musculoskeletal conditions and evidence-based:Impairment ratings (100), extremity exam (100), orthopedic exam (100), neurological exam (100), hydrocolation (hot packs, etc.) (100), cryotherapy (cold packs, etc.) (100), massage (98), traction (100), orthotic supports (100), spinal supports (100), lifestyle counseling (100), rehabilitation (98), recommendation of OTC (63)
May be appropriate to order, with adequate clinical rationale, but not perform:Full spine X-rays (100), skull x-rays (98), soft tissue X-rays (98), tomography (85, most order only), CT scan (100, most order only), MRI (100, most order only), diagnostic ultrasound (95, most order only), surface scanning EMG (100), needle EMG/NCV (93, many order only)
Appropriate with limitations to insure against overuse or use in inappropriate circumstances:TENS (100), electrical stimulation (100), shortwave therapy (95), vitamin supplementation (100), diet formulation (100), botanical therapy (100), intrarectal manipulation of coccyx (83)
Not appropriate for chiropractic practice:Barium studies (74), cholecystography (X-ray visualization of gallbladder after administration of radiopaque substance) (80), thermography (95), electrocardiography (88), venipuncture (98), blood analysis (100), urinalysis (98), sputum analysis (95), fecal analysis (95), semen analysis (84), throat swab (92), skin scrape (92), school physicals (86), US DOT physicals (98), pre-employment physicals (95), pre-marital physicals (77), sign birth certificates (38), sign death certificates (50), EENT exam (90), abdominal exam (95), stethoscopic exam (98), sphygmomanometry (blood pressure) (95), bi-manual pelvic exam (73), speculum exam (72), recto-vaginal exam (72), Pap smears (79), female breast exam (80), rectal exam (85), male genital exam (85), prostatic exam (digital) (85), hernia exam (85), ultrasound (treatment) (100), IFC (interferential therapy) (100), microcurrent therapy (100), iontophoresis (not with prescription medication) (100), Russian stimulation (100), non-ablative laser therapy, nonadjustive treatment of female pelvic conditions (72), ear irrigation (83), TMJ (100), oral chelation therapy (76), IV chelation therapy (39), vitamin injection (43), limited prescription privileges (7), oxygen therapy (57), dry needling of trigger points (64), minor surgery (9), obstetrics (22), extremity casting sprains (71), extremity casting uncomplicated fractures (58), hypnosis (66), electrolysis (44), hyperbaric chamber (62), manipulation under anesthesia (71)
Pseudoscience/quackery:Hair analysis (93), magnetic therapy (90), extremity adjusting (assuming “adjusting” is related to “subluxations”) (98), soft tissue manipulation of the abdominal viscera (95), craniopathy (98), glandular supplementation (desiccated animal glands) (98), homeopathic preparations (95), colonic irrigation (74), endonasal technique (84), nasal specifics (75), needle acupuncture (70), electro-acupuncture (75), veterinary chiropractic (63)
What should the scope of practice be?
If you are startled, as I was, by the breadth of the procedures allowed, keep in mind that the opinion of chiropractic regulators is not the last word. Many of the procedures surveyed are not explicitly included in the state chiropractic practice acts. Some are permitted by regulations, which are usually enacted by the chiropractic boards. Others are included in policy memos or other informal guidance issued by the boards. Yet others are not specifically mentioned at all in state statutes, regulations or policies. When asked, some regulators included them because they were not explicitly prohibited yet thought to be consistent with the statutory scope of practice.
State statutes are the ultimate authority on what chiropractors can and can’t do and all regulations and policy statements are subject to challenge on the ground that they are outside the authority granted by the legislature. This occurred recently in the Texas Medical Board’s court challenge to the Texas Chiropractic Board’s rule allowing chiropractors to perform vestibular-ocular-nystagmus testing, manipulation under anesthesia, and needle electromyography. The Medical Board won. Nor does the fact that a chiropractic board says a procedure is within chiropractic scope of practice prevent a chiropractor from prosecution by the authorities or another board which feels the practice poaches on their territory, a scenario that played itself out when two chiropractors practiced “functional endocrinology.”
The author, to her credit, cautions that interpretations are subject to the ever-changing regulatory authority members (such as chiropractic boards). She also cautions that where a statute does not address a particular procedure, “upon challenge there may be a possibility of sanctions depending on interpretation.” There also were several comments by regulators that, even though “DCs are qualified in the procedures, the procedures must be related to a spinal condition as stated in the statutes.” For the life of me, I can’t see how many of these could possibly be “related to a spinal condition” unless one takes the extreme view of the straight chiropractors that everything is related to the spine.
In an understatement one can only agree with, the author concludes that “chiropractic practice in the United States can vary widely between jurisdictions.” She also advises “studies to assess whether quality or safety of health care is jeopardized in states with broader scopes.” I agree, although the time to research the possible implications for safety would be before enacting statutory practice expansion or liberal interpretation of scope of practice, which never seems to occur to state legislators or chiropractic regulatory authorities. I would add that research into whether the proposed practice is quackery, unsupported by evidence of effectiveness, or is the subject of adequate education and training in chiropractic schools is also appropriate, another area of inquiry which seems to regularly escape the notice of legislators and regulators.
Unfortunately, citing the presumed physician shortage, the author makes an argument for greater use of chiropractors:
to accommodate the demands for health care, especially in states that are already experiencing health care workforce shortages. Using all health care providers to the fullest extent of their training is one solution that will provide timely relief to these problems.
This comment appears to be based on the same deeply flawed premise as Section 2706 of the Affordable Care Act: state practice acts are based on a reasoned determination that adequate education and training underlies scope of practice. In fact, the author seems to believe that the practice acts underrepresent what chiropractors are actually educated and trained to do.
Education and training of limited scope health care providers is broader than what state practice laws allow. For instance, as part of The Council of Chiropractic Education [CCE] accreditation process, chiropractic schools are to educate and train students to become a “competent doctor of chiropractic who will provide quality patient care and serve as a primary care physician,” yet the variances in practice regulation do not allow this to occur.
Some states have bought into the idea that the CCE should have the final word in what the legal scope of chiropractic practice should be. As the article notes:
Kentucky and Montana affirm that DCs may perform procedures as long as they were taught them at an accredited chiropractic school.
Chiropractic scope of practice should never be conflated with adequacy of education and training. Nor should the CCE be allowed to determine scope of practice. But as long as warring chiropractic factions, overreaching chiropractic regulators, and credulous legislators are allowed to form a three-ring circus whose main event is deciding what chiropractors should and should not be allowed to do, we’ll likely be stuck with the current system.

Spinal Manipulation and the JAMA Meta-Analysis: An Analysis of Fuel.
Association of Spinal Manipulative Therapy With Clinical Benefit and Harm for Acute Low Back Pain: Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. It is even worse than I thought it would be.
Mark Crislip on April 28, 2017
Link


I never meta analysis I liked
I have a love-hate relationship with meta-analyses (here after called metas). I have never understood why metas are always put on the top of the evidence pyramid as they are only as good, or as bad, as the studies that go into the analysis. Metas don’t belongs on the evidence pyramid any more than spam hash belongs on the food pyramid, but that’s me.
Metas do have their uses. As a specialist, I like metas in my field as they give a nice overview of a topic and offer the opportunity to see if my understanding of a topic matches the metas. I usually know most, but never all, the primary literature and metas allow me fill in gaps in my knowledge and, if I was in disagreement with the meta, to assess my understanding.
For medicine outside of infectious diseases metas give me an understanding of current thinking of a literature I will never read.
For pseudo-medicines? The theory behind pseudo-medical metas is that if you take all cow pies and place them in one big pile, you get gold. The reality is you get a huge cow pie. For metas of homeopathy or acupuncture, it is usually garbage in garbage out; meta-analysis of fiction can only lead to fictional results. Acupuncture metas are particularly annoying as it is rare that any of the compared interventions are the same: different acupuncture styles (ear or Chinese or electro etc), different points used, different frequency and duration of treatment. And most pseudo-medical metas have the same conclusion: maybe some effect, but poor quality studies, so more studies need be done.
A meta for SMT?
But what about spinal manipulation therapy (SMT) for low back pain? There is no prior plausibility that suggests SMT would not have effects on low back pain. We are apes, and apes find hands-on care beneficial. And SMT is not necessarily synonymous with chiropractic, although chiropractors are the main purveyors of SMT. So while there is the urge to judge a therapy by the company it keeps, it may be that SMT has efficacy independent of the pseudo-science of innate intelligence, subluxations, and chiropractic manipulations.
JAMA had a meta-analysis of SMT for low back pain suggesting to a superficial reading that SMT was minimally beneficial: “Association of Spinal Manipulative Therapy With Clinical Benefit and Harm for Acute Low Back Pain: Systematic Review and Meta-analysis.”
I would like to know the primary literature that went into the construction of this meta. Metas are not laws or sausage; you really need to know what they are made of. Is it made of high quality studies? Or cow pie?
There are the usual summary tables, one for pain:And one for short term function. Let’s go with the pain references, shall we, and see what we can discover.
There were two references in the meta-analysis that were “Comparison group, sham” and both were considered to favor manipulation. There were only two sham controlled trials in the whole meta. And if the studies are not sham/placebo controlled they are likely useless.
This was the best study ?!?
There was “Assessment of diclofenac or spinal manipulative therapy, or both, in addition to recommended first-line treatment for acute low back pain: a randomised controlled trial.” In this study the sham was a detuned pulse ultrasound applied to the patient as long as the manipulation. Not really a manipulation sham controlled trial. And the SMT? We have no idea what the patients received:
Consistent with contemporary best clinical practice, the physiotherapist will adjust the treatment to the clinical presentation of the patient rather than apply the same treatment to all patients.
These physiotherapists used:
the application of manually applied postero-anteriorly directed forces to all levels of the lumbar spine.
Whatever that might be. And the results?
Neither diclofenac nor spinal manipulative therapy had a statistically significant effect on the secondary outcomes of pain, disability, function, or global perceived effect at any time point.
It is odd that an essentially negative original study is analyzed as being suggestive of SMT efficacy in the meta-analysis. I can see no explanation for this except the magic of metas.
And this was considered to be the best study in the group with a rating of 8. Completely negative. And they say:
high-quality studies tended to report larger benefits.
Hmmm. The highest rated had no benefit I can find.
Failed blinding with extra pseudo-science
The other sham study, rated a mere 3, was “A randomized clinical trial comparing chiropractic adjustments to muscle relaxants for subacute low back pain.”
In this trial they compared:
chiropractic adjustments with placebo medicine, muscle relaxants with sham adjustments, or placebo medicine with sham adjustments.
In this study patients received cervical, lumbar and/or pelvic adjustment by the DC’s best judgement (snort). In the cervical spine they used an activator for an extra bit of worthless pseudo-medicine. A completely different intervention than the first, best, study.
So again, we really don’t know what SMT the patients received and if it was comparable to the first trial. Maybe all the benefit was from the activator, he says in a voice filled with sarcasm.
The sham was a laying on of the hands with light pressure but no thrust. Obviously not a chiropractic adjustment since it would not have snap crackle pop of a ‘real’ adjustment. As a result blinding failed big time, 87% in the chiropractic group thought they received the real deal, 40% in the medical group and 20% in the control.
When you look at the graphs and error bars, even the small benefit from the unsuccessfully blinded chiropractic overlaps with the comparators.
This is a negative study, and rating it a three is overly optimistic. Still, the meta says it favors spinal manipulation.
Sham studies of the other kind of sham
The rest of the studies were “Comparison group, all other therapies”.
What were the other therapies? Let’s go through them best to worst, which is more than the editors and writers did as the footnotes are off. The table has Grunnesjö et al, as reference 35, but it is reference 37. Oops. Hyperlinks and footnotes are tough. And I know I am setting myself up for a fall here.
Reference 37 would be “A randomized controlled clinical trial of stay-active care versus manual therapy in addition to stay-active care: functional variables and pain.”
SMT compared to standard treatment. A worthless methodology. As Dr. Edzard Ernst notes:
We have been over this so many times… that I am almost a little embarrassed to explain it again: it is fairly easy to design an RCT such that it can only produce a positive result. The currently most popular way to achieve this aim in alternative medicine research is to do a ‘A B versus B’ study, where A = the experimental treatment, and B = routine care…
As I stated above, it is fairly easy to design an RCT such that it can only produce a positive result. Yet, it is arguably also unethical, perhaps even fraudulent, to do this. In my view, such RCTs amount to pseudoscience and scientific misconduct.
In this study what was the SMT? Similar to the others? Of course not. Cochrane forbid they are comparing equivalent interventions. In Grunnesjö et al they used some sort of:
Swedish manual therapy with “locking techniques”, mobilization for pelvic dysfunctions according to Kubis, with the addition of an Evjent and Hamberg locking technique and a strictly applied MET procedure.
Whatever the hell that is. Kubis appears to be the craniosacral therapy of the sacroiliac joint. What Evjent and Hamberg are doing is beyond my google skills; some sort of muscle stretching. And MET (Muscular Energy Technique) is where the patient rather than the provider, causes the muscle to contract. Also:
All patients were treated with specific mobilization or lumbar thrust techniques (manipulation) or both by the 2 physicians. In addition, the physiotherapists treated 67% of the experimental patients with specific mobilization or manipulation. According to the factorial study design, steroid injections, in case of specific findings, were allowed in half of the patients. Steroids were often given in combination with “needling” and local anesthetics. After parasacrococcygeal injections, the soft tissues were also stretched per rectum.
Steroids. Local anesthetics. Needling. Soft tissue stretching per rectum. Treatment or abuse?
They decreased significancy over time in both groups but there were not significant differences between groups.
After aggressive ‘p-hacking‘ (there were dozens of variables evaluated) they did come up with a barely significant difference: a faster decrease in pain at the last week of intervention.
This was another negative study. It was rated a 7! And again favored spinal manipulation?!? Given all those interventions that is concluded how? You and I both know it was the soft tissue stretching per rectum and not the spinal manipulation.
I am only three into the original papers. If you thought knowing what went into the production of hot dogs makes one queasy, just imagine the offal we will find in the next study.
Hot dogs have better ingredients
Bloomberg, the next 7-rated study, had five references. The first reference (32) in the table is a study that compares 101 patients:
One group was given standardized conventional and optimised activating treatment by primary health care teams. The other group received, according to a pragmatic approach, another treatment programme including manipulation, specific mobilisation, muscle stretching, autotraction and cortisone injections.
You know, the kind of methodology that will give a positive result. But given the hodgepodge of interventions in the experimental group, I think it would be impossible to credit the guaranteed positive results as “favors spinal manipulation”.
The second reference is 34. Again it points to the wrong footnote, I suspect they mean 36, but the study is more of the same, but with fewer patients, 53 instead of 101. But why it is referenced in the table since as best I can tell it was not included in the calculations. The final three references are all the same 101 patients. Four papers from one horrible study. Not bad. But my library doesn’t have access to all the Bloomberg papers so further evaluation is not forthcoming.
Pragmatic hodgepodge
The next? “Adding chiropractic manipulative therapy to standard medical care for patients with acute low back pain: results of a pragmatic randomized comparative effectiveness study.” Definition of Pragmatic: A study methodology for researchers who want their bias confirmed rather than to understand.
And the SMT intervention this time (emphasis added)?
Participants in the group receiving CMT in addition to SMC were scheduled for up to 2 visits weekly with a doctor of chiropractic (DC) for a period of 4 weeks. The initial visit with the DC included a focused history and physical examination and diagnostic imaging as indicated. Treatments consisted of HVLA manipulation as the primary approach in all cases, with ancillary treatments at the doctor’s discretion, including brief massage, the use of ice or heat in the lumbar area, stretching exercises, McKenzie exercises, advice on activities of daily living, postural/ergonomic advice; and mobilization. HVLA manipulation involves a single load or impulse “thrust” to body tissues. Patients were placed in a lateral recumbent or side-lying position with the superior or free hip and knee flexed and adducted across the midline. The chiropractor stabilized the patient’s free leg with his own leg while holding the patient’s superior shoulder. The manipulative load was applied by using a pisiform contact on the patient’s lumbar spine or sacroiliac joint while preventing motion of the patient through stabilizing holds on the shoulder and hip. The single impulse load, or thrust, was delivered by a quick, short controlled movement of the shoulder, arm, and hand combined with a slight body drop.
This 7 (?!?!?!) rated study with a hodgepodge of interventions, again different from the prior studies, ‘favors spinal manipulation?!?!?!? Seriously? This is just getting sad.
The last 7-rated study was “A randomized, controlled trial of osteopathic manipulative treatment for acute low back pain in active duty military personnel.” This time it as osteopathic manipulative treatment added to usual care. See a pattern here? And this was considered a good study by the meta, not pseudoscience and scientific misconduct. I lean towards the latter.
They used a hodgepodge of techniques (see the link) that differed, again, from the other interventions.
The next, rated a 6, “A comparison of physical therapy, chiropractic manipulation, and provision of an educational booklet for the treatment of patients with low back pain“:
For patients with low back pain, the McKenzie method of physical therapy and chiropractic manipulation had similar effects and costs, and patients receiving these treatments had only marginally better outcomes than those receiving the minimal intervention of an educational booklet.
What did they do for this marginal benefit?
a short-lever, high-velocity thrust directed specifically at a “manipulable lesion.” This procedure is typically performed with the patient lying on his or her side on a segmental table. No other physical treatments were permitted. Chiropractors evaluated patients according to their usual procedures and were allowed to make the same recommendations about exercise and activity restrictions that they usually did.
Again, more than just lousy methodology, there was more than manual therapy done. Yet, somehow, it too ‘favors spinal manipulation’ as one would expect.
Threes
The last 3’s were:
“Manipulation in the Treatment of Acute Low Back Pain “, another A vs. A + B study using orthopedic manipulation; I can’t get the original to see just what orthopedic manipulation was and how if differed from other interventions.
And:
“Acute low back pain. Comparison of two conservative treatment approaches.” They looked at:
The conservative treatments compared were passive mobilisation and manipulation of the lumbar spine and a regimen of microwave diathermy, isometric abdominal exercises and ergonomic instructions.
Another hodgepodge of interventions compared. Studies that ‘favor spinal manipulation.’ Eye roll.
The wurst
Finally the wurst, rated a 2, was “One-year follow-up comparison of the cost and effectiveness of chiropractic and physiotherapy as primary management for back pain. Subgroup analysis, recurrence, and additional health care utilization” showed no difference compared to physiotherapy although:
More patients in the chiropractic group (59%) than in the physiotherapy group (41%) sought additional health care
Favor manipulation? Of course. But it is not the spine that is being manipulated in this meta.
Conclusion: I’d rather watch sausage being made
What went into this meta-analysis?
A hodgepodge of different interventions from either negative or useless studies. In other words cow pie.
And that is what came out.
Cow pie.
Their conclusion?
Among patients with acute low back pain, spinal manipulation therapy was associated with modest improvements in pain and function at up to 6 weeks, with transient minor musculoskeletal harms.
Nonsense. Drawing any conclusions about any form of spinal manipulation for low back pain is impossible given how awful the primary literature is.
My conclusion from this Frankenstein’s Monster of a meta, where more than the brain was abby normal, a meta-analysis constructed from nonfunctioning, putrid parts?
Does SMT help for low back pain? Who knows. I have zero idea. Not that I could tell from the primary literature. Any effect of SMT is impossible to dissect out from all the other interventions in the studies. What little beneficial effect that is reported is small and likely from placebo and/or bias. And with a hodgepodge of interventions, it would appear to be a nonspecific effect, like one ape grooming another.
Do I even know what SMT is so it could be applied? Nope. I just know I do not want my muscles stretched per rectum based on this meta.
Did the lightening bolt of the meta-analytic methodolatry transform negative and/or useless studies into life? Nope.
Will this study be used to promote chiropractic SMT with all the additional pseudo-science that makes up chiropractic, setting the monster loose on the village? You bet.
The accompanying editorial, by a Professor of Evidence Based-Medicine, is the usual cautious, namby-pamby analysis that shows how EBM fails when applied to pseudo-science. A little bit of the appeal to popularity here, bit on the issues with the standard treatments there, with downplaying of the risks and underlying fiction of chiropractic. And nothing that suggests a critical review of the sausages that made up this monster. And no, I am not mixing metaphors, beer with me here.
The editorial also suggests that SMT is equal to NSAIDs. I would note that a recent BMJ meta suggests NSAIDs do not work, as noted in the confused conclusions:
NSAIDs are effective for spinal pain, but the magnitude of the difference in outcomes between the intervention and placebo groups is not clinically important.
Effective but no different than placebo? You would think this was an acupuncture meta.
And the Danish guidelines have advised against NSAIDs for the treatment acute low back pain. So yeah, I agree. SMT is likely as beneficial as NSAIDs.
I suspect the author does not spend much time in the world of pseudo-medicine as it contains the following howler:
Chiropractic therapy is not widely accepted by some traditional health care practitioners. This may be, at least in part, because some early practitioners of chiropractic care rejected the germ theory, immunizations, and other scientific advances.
Dude. That defines chiropractic today every bit as much as then. Or maybe he is referring to those who start work at 6 am.
And that is the problem with SMT. Even if SMT was effective low back pain, you would likely send your patient off to a chiropractor, with all the additional pseudo-science that entails. It would be like finding your diabetic patient is iron deficient and suggesting they replete it by doing all their dining at McDonalds.
Hardly worth it.

Afterword. Chiropractic and The New York Times. Is the newspaper TRYING to prove Trump right?
The New York Times had to go an publish “For Bad Backs, It May Be Time to Rethink Biases About Chiropractors” right after my Friday extravaganza, “Spinal Manipulation and the JAMA Meta-Analysis: An Analysis of Fuel. Sigh. Doody [sic] Calls.
Mark Crislip on May 2, 2017
Link


I meant this to be a relaxing week. I am meeting my wife in Vegas for a long weekend of desert hikes, food, drink and shows. I was not going to write any blog posts, record podcasts or in any manner work on my multi-media empire. I was actually planning on reading Thunderbird on the flight, which I have been saving like a fine whiskey for an extended quiet time.
Nope. The New York Times had to go an publish “For Bad Backs, It May Be Time to Rethink Biases About Chiropractors” right after my Friday extravaganza, “Spinal Manipulation and the JAMA Meta-Analysis: An Analysis of Fuel.” Sigh. Doody [sic] Calls.
I will be brief. And a warning: I am smug skeptic, and as such I am armed with “copious amounts of mockery.”
As an ID consultant I am used to seeing people screw up ID cases. ID is more than picking an antibiotic off the culture and sensitivity report. Others often do not understand the significance of the S. aureus in the blood, or why ciprofloxacillin [sic] is a poor choice to treat the infection. No one would treat cancer without an oncologist or MS without a neurologist, but some will flail about treating infections as if they know what they are doing. They don’t.
It is often because the physicians have not taken the time and effort, or do not have the time, to look it up, because in the era of Google, Pubmed, and UpToDate looking something up is just so hard. They assume a superficial knowledge gleaned from an electronic guide is a substitute for knowledge and real expertise. There is a lot background to ID, or any other medical field, that needs to be known to really understand disease. It is no surprise ID consultation leads to decreases in mortality and morbidity for a variety of infections. Gee, having someone who actually knows what they are doing makes a difference in patient outcome. Who da thunk it?
It is ‘nice’ to see a similar approach applied to the pseudo-medicine in The New York Times, sort of a metaphorical project Alpha researchers approach to spinal manipulation.
Let’s see what the author, a pediatrician and professor, has to say:
Spinal manipulation — along with other less traditional therapies like heat, meditation and acupuncture — seems to be as effective as many other more medical therapies we prescribe, and as safe, if not safer.
I will focus on spinal manipulation component. As I noted on Friday, efficacy is more than suspect. It is risible.
But safe? Reviews of spinal manipulation from:
two prospective reports suggested that relatively mild adverse effects occur in 30% to 61% of all patients.
How about stroke? As if chiropractors are going to limit their pseudo-science to the low back? The entire spine is their alleged purview and it must be aligned from top to bottom and from birth to death. Tell Nicole Rhodes, the most recent victim of chiropractic pseudo-science, that chiropractic is safe:
it was neck manipulation by chiropractor that triggered her stroke.
No treatment of a self-limited illness should have as its potential complication a stroke, no matter how rare the complication.
Most back pain resolves over time, so interventions that focus on relief of symptoms and allow the body to heal are ideal.
One of the classic pseudo-medical concepts with no real content. Back pain gets better. So how do you know these interventions are the reason the symptoms improve?
And I thought that chiropractors were getting at the root cause of the problem, a subluxed spine blocking innate intelligence, and not treating just symptoms.
So just how does spinal manipulation “allow the body to heal”? The body is healing anyway, with or without the spinal manipulation. And I would point out that pain is the body’s way to say “stop it’ and not adding to the trauma. If you block symptoms you stop protecting the damaged area and probably delay healing. Tell Bill Walton relieving the symptoms of foot pain was helpful.
Physicians are traditionally wary of spinal manipulation (applying pressure on bones and joints), in part because the practitioners are often not doctors and also because a few chiropractors have claimed they can address conditions that have little to do with the spine.
Well, I would argue with a fictional understanding of the spine, chiropractors cannot really address conditions of the spine either.
And few? Been to Mantioba recently?
Based on the Manitoba Chiropractors Association membership listing, there are approximately 275 licensed practitioners working out of 215 offices. CBC News found questionable online content linked to more than 30 chiropractic offices.
Pseudo-science is intrinsic to chiropractic.
He continues:
Almost a decade later, a Cochrane review assessed the literature once more, and found 12 new trials had been conducted. This review was more damning. It found that spinal manipulation was no better than sham interventions.
When a procedure is no better than sham, it means no efficacy. But then…
But since then, data have accumulated, as more higher-quality studies have been performed.
Ohhhhh. Higher quality studies. These I have to see. And just where were those higher quality studies to be found?
Recently, in The Journal of the American Medical Association, researchers looked for new studies since 2011, as well as those that had been performed before.
Yes, the same heap of cow pies I reviewed last week. I suspect, like I so often see in how others practice ID, the author did not do the due diligence of actually looking at the primary literature contained in the meta. Because there are no high quality studies in that article. Anyone who reads more than the Cliff Notes version of the meta and actually dug into the literature would never conclude:
The evidence from 12 randomized controlled trials — which overlapped, but not completely with the other trials — of almost 1,400 patients showed that spinal manipulation also resulted in improvements in function.
The author then points to “Noninvasive Treatments for Acute, Subacute, and Chronic Low Back Pain: A Clinical Practice Guideline From the American College of Physicians” as supportive of spinal manipulation.
That guideline contains that great mystery of all the guidelines: how they can make strong recommendations based on low-quality evidence? Got me. It is the alchemy of guidelines, turning digested straw into spun gold.
Here is the text. The effect of spinal manipulation is unimpressive:
Low-quality evidence showed that spinal manipulation was associated with a small effect on function compared with sham manipulation; evidence was insufficient to determine the effect on pain. Low-quality evidence showed no difference in pain relief at 1 week between spinal manipulation and inert treatment (educational booklet, detuned ultrasound, detuned or actual short-wave diathermy, antiedema gel, or bed rest), although 1 trial showed better longer-term pain relief (3 months) with spinal manipulation. Function did not differ between spinal manipulation and inert treatment at 1 week or 3 months. Moderate-quality evidence showed no difference between spinal manipulation and other active interventions for pain relief at 1 week through 1 year or function (analyses included exercise, physical therapy, or back school as the comparator). Low-quality evidence showed that a combination of spinal manipulation plus exercise or advice slightly improved function at 1 week compared with exercise or advice alone, but these differences were not present at 1 or 3 months
Anyone impressed? Not me. It is the usual pseudo-medical analysis, a hodgepodge of weak studies show marginal aka placebo effect.
The only things that might detract from the use of spinal manipulation in this situation would be its cost and potential harms.
Medicine is about cost and benefit. With no good benefit, it should have no cost and no harm. But chiropractic offers only harm and cost. And suggesting a patient waste time and money based on this kind of data is not my idea of good medical advice.
Medication and surgery can also lead to harms. We shouldn’t forget that prescription pain medications, like opioids, can lead to huge costs, especially when they’re misused.
Medicine can be dangerous, but medicine and surgery actually have real effects. The argument is because medicine has issues we should instead use pseudo-medicine? Great idea. Where would we be without the old, “There are problems with airplanes, so let’s rely on magic carpets” argument.
And:
Some physicians are uncomfortable that we don’t have a clear picture of how spinal manipulation actually works to reduce pain. It’s also possible that some chiropractors do it “better” than others, and we can’t tell. This concern should be tempered by the fact that we don’t have a great understanding of why many other therapies work either. Some of the more traditional things we recommend don’t even work consistently.
A careful reading of the spinal manipulation literature and an understanding of the pitfalls of research in pseudo-science like chiropractic gives a clear picture of how chiropractic works. It doesn’t. It is placebo and it is considered unethical to offer placebo.
This is what comes from applying the standards of science to pseudo-science. His idea that treating:
infantile colic, painful periods, asthma, gastrointestinal problems, and more.
With chiropractic is not a good idea is not that chiropractic is pseudo-science not grounded in reality. Nope. It is because:
the therapy lacks a good evidence base.
Give up a ‘bias’ against a medical fiction? Might as well say we should give up our bias against Ai Sedai healing. And while we are at it, abandon bias and add astrologers to NASA. We don’t have a clear understanding how astrology works, but a large and growing number of Americans think it is valid and its proponents and adherents say it works.
That is modern medicine: promoting all the variations of the curse removal scam disguised as science. The researcher wears no lab coat.
And he finishes with the same empty pseudo-science mantra:
But given the natural course of back pain — that most of it goes away no matter what you do — the ideal approach is to treat the symptoms and let the body heal. Noninvasive therapies seem to do that well enough.
For spinal manipulation there is no compelling symptom relief and it does nothing to let the body heal. Healing happens on its own, with the exception that a wallet relieved of its cash has less pull on the lower back.
So when I see a headline like “Feds reach $1 million settlement with Kansas City area chiropractor” because:
procedures that the government contended were not medically necessary.
I suggest that ‘not medically necessary’ defines chiropractic.
While searching the web looking for the author’s other writhttp://www.404errorpages.com/ings on chiropractic and spinal manipulation I did find that he is also the author of “Labels Like ‘Alternative Medicine’ Don’t Matter. The Science Does“, which is true, but…
No irony there. No siree Bob
Time to put my seat back in the locked and upright position. I hope to be gone until Monday.
Later.

Spinal Manipulation for Back and Neck Pain: Does It Work? Annotated.
Spinal Manipulation for Back and Neck Pain: Does It Work? You would think it does if you read the article but not if you actually read the literature.
Mark Crislip on February 17, 2017
Link

I was getting ready to write about health care workers and influenza vaccination when “Spinal Manipulation for Back and Neck Pain: Does It Work?” popped up in my feeds. I read it. Ugh. Duty calls, so perhaps influenza vaccination next time. For sake of openness, I am a paid Medscape blogger, but my tax returns will not be released until after the audit is complete.
The article starts with:
In her office at McMaster University in Toronto, Anita Gross, MSc, has logged paper after paper showing that spinal manipulation can help control neck pain. “The evidence keeps growing and growing,” she says.
I have a eponymous law on RationalWiki. Another law of pseudo-medicine, eponymous 2, states that when a pseudo-medical intervention says there is growing evidence, there isn’t. It is a corollary to Betteridge’s law of headlines.
Well, perhaps the growing evidence is more of a Kellyanne Conway statement, an alternative fact, because while it is true that there is growing evidence, it is usually terrible evidence.
Remember that when any intervention is compared to usual care, the intervention always results in improvement in subjective symptoms. As Dr. Ernst points out, it is ‘A trial design that generates only ”positive” results.’
We conclude that the ‘A + B versus B’ design is prone to false positive results
Where A is an intervention (acupuncture, chiropractic, reiki, homeopathy) and B is standard care,

There are too-numerous-to-count pseudo-medical studies that use this methodology and all are useless for evaluating efficacy. The ‘A + B versus B’ study only demonstrates that the researchers either did not know what they are doing for study design or have no interest in anything beyond generating propaganda.
And if you apply a flawed study design to an intervention with a prior plausibility of zero, false positives are guaranteed.
The question is whether an intervention is better than a sham or placebo intervention. To really know if an intervention is effective, especially an intervention that is not based in the known reality of anatomy, physiology, and biochemistry, you want to do placebo/sham controlled studies, preferably blind.
Let’s check out the ‘growing’ literature of chiropractic manipulation compared with sham chiropractic for neck pain. And if you think there is no valid sham chiropractic manipulation, think again.
There is “Short-term usual chiropractic care for spinal pain: a randomized controlled trial” from 2013:
Short-term chiropractic treatment was superior to sham; however, treatment effects were not clinically important.
And it was those who knew they were getting treatment who had the most improvement. A classic placebo effect.
That’s it for manipulation vs. sham manipulation for neck pain. But that is growth. From zero to one.
Manipulation vs. sham manipulation for back pain? There is “Spinal Manipulation A Systematic Review of Sham-Controlled, Double-Blind, Randomized Clinical Trials” which included two studies of back pain. They found:
The most rigorous of these studies suggest that spinal manipulation is not associated with clinically-relevant specific therapeutic effects.
Or the recent review “The effectiveness of complementary manual therapies for pregnancy-related back and pelvic pain: A systematic review with meta-analysis” where:
Meta-analyses found positive effects for manual therapy on pain intensity when compared to usual care and relaxation but not when compared to sham interventions.
Here is the classic interpretation: When an intervention is equal to sham/placebo, it is not effective; the intervention does not work. It is why, for example, we no longer do mammary artery ligation for angina.
Or “Spinal Manipulative Therapy for Chronic Lower Back Pain in Older Veterans: A Prospective, Randomized, Placebo-Controlled Trial.”
The SMT did not result in greater improvement in pain when compared to our sham intervention; however, SMT did demonstrate a slightly greater improvement in disability at 12 weeks. The fact that patients in both groups showed improvements suggests the presence of a nonspecific therapeutic effect.
Again. Not better than sham equals no efficacy. And “nonspecific therapeutic effect” is code for placebo effect.
That’s it for the growing literature of clinical trials with meaningful methodologies, sham controlled studies, that I found on Pubmed. There are numerous ‘A + B versus B’ studies, but they tell you nothing.
So the literature that is growing and growing is less than impressive in numbers or outcomes.
On to the second paragraph:
Gross, a physiotherapist and associate professor of rehabilitation science, helped write a 2015 Cochrane review of the literature and is already at work on updating that paper.
It implies, and maybe this is just me, that the Cochrane review is favorable for manipulation, since it follows the growing and growing quote. Just what does that review say?
No high-quality evidence was found, so uncertainty about the effectiveness of mobilisation or manipulation for neck pain remains.
Color me unimpressed.
The third paragraph?
Mounting evidence also supports spinal manipulation for low back pain, says Roger Chou, MD, professor of medicine at Oregon Health & Science University in Portland, Oregon, who led a similar review for the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality last year.
And that similar review?
These include exercise, yoga, and tai chi; various psychological therapies; multidisciplinary rehabilitation; acupuncture; spinal manipulation (vs. an inert treatment); and low-level laser therapy. Effects were small to moderate in magnitude.
And they point to a table.
In that table there is spinal manipulation vs. inert treatment (7 trials) which had “small” effects BUT spinal manipulation vs. sham manipulation (1 SR (3 RCTs) 1 RCT), the gold standard for showing efficacy, had…
*…pause for dramatic effect while we decide which baker has to leave the tent…*
No effect.
Let me repeat: manipulation and sham manipulation are equal. That means it doesn’t work.
And that begs the question. You have back pain. I am going to send you for manipulation, but how do I order the manipulation that is vs an inert treatment and avoid the manipulation that is vs sham because it is the former works and the latter that does not. I can do that how? Puh-lease.
Kellyanne, Kellyanne, did it rain at the inauguration? Were the crowds yuuuuge? Was it the greatest Electoral College victory ever? Does chiropractic work better than sham? Is supportive literature growing and growing? Do these:
findings counter decades of accusations of quackery mounted against healers who massage or manipulate patients’ muscles or joints[?]
No. It is, at least in its chiropractic form, still quackery. But more on that later. But it does support the accusations that manipulation does nothing.
Paragraph 4.
But other therapies, particularly exercise, may work just as well.
And the other therapies lack the risk of stroke and other complications, oddly not mentioned in this article. There has been the American Heart Association/American Stroke Association Scientific Statement, on the positive association between neck manipulation and subsequent stroke. That warning is always ignored by those who manipulate necks; patient safety has never been a strong suit of pseudo-medical providers. And last month there was “Adverse events associated with the use of cervical spine manipulation or mobilization and patient characteristics: A systematic review” which found
Most patients were treated by chiropractors (66%). Manipulation was reported in 95% of the cases, and neck pain was the most frequent indication. Cervical arterial dissection (CAD) was reported in 57% (P = 0.21) of the cases and 45.8% had immediate onset symptoms.
I’ll quickly help with the rest of the paragraph 4
And the research so far leaves big questions unanswered. For example, does one technique for spinal manipulation work better than another?
You mean is one form of theatrical placebo superior? Probably not.
What is the mechanism of these techniques?
Placebo. And in the US deliberately giving placebo outside of clinical trials is often unethical, relying, as it does, on deception.
Are patients better off being treated by physical therapists, chiropractors, osteopathic physicians, massage therapists, or some other category of practitioner?
None of the above. Manipulation has only serious, if rare, risk for a mild placebo effect.
How long should a patient keep trying spinal manipulation before deciding that no more benefits are likely?
Until they have a cervical artery tear? Not a good endpoint. I suggest don’t even try it.
See how easy that was? For those interested in more details concerning the answers to these questions, they can be found on this site.
There are some incomplete statements:
Daniel David Palmer, a practitioner of magnet healing (a pseudoscientific alternative medicine practice), founded chiropractic.
Forgetting the (a pseudoscientific alternative medicine practice) after ‘chiropractic’.
They continue with:
Some focus entirely on manual therapy, whereas many others incorporate other modes of alternative medicine into their practices, such as herbal medicine or acupuncture. Some chiropractors confine themselves to musculoskeletal and neuromuscular disorders, especially for back pain, but others treat a broader range of disorders.
Which is part of the danger of sending patients to chiropractor: the wide range of useless pseudo-medicines that are often incorporated into the chiropractic practice along with a propensity for anti-vaccine rhetoric.
And no, chiropractic has no efficacy for any process and chiropractors have no education and training that would allow then to ‘treat’ a broad range of disorders. They offer worthless, dangerous, and expensive interventions often combined with the unethical sales of supplements in the office.
No one knows for sure why spinal manipulation works.
That is certainly true for those who do not read the literature, but as noted above, based on gold standard evaluations, spinal manipulation doesn’t work beyond a weak placebo. I call it beer goggles.
Palmer said chiropractic manipulation corrects subluxations—misalignments of vertebrae that impinge nerves.
That’s the pseudo-scientific alternative medicine practice I was referring to. There is no chiropractic subluxation complex. And Palmer did not think it impinged nerves so much as the subluxation blocked a mystical innate intelligence, a form of non-existent energy, concepts divorced from good sound clinical reasoning and biology (these words were chosen as a form of foreshadowing) and still held as true by the majority of DC’s and taught in their schools.
Even though the chiropractic subluxation and its correction are, at its core, rank pseudo-medicine.
Contemporary theories on the mechanism of spinal manipulation include the disruption of articular or periarticular adhesions; release of entrapped synovial folds; unbuckling of motion segments that have undergone disproportionate displacements; relaxation of hypertonic muscle; alteration of mechanoreceptors in the spinal apophyseal joints; and release of endorphins.
Just like the mechanism of acupunctures, it sounds all science-y with little to support for a mechanism for what is a poor placebo effect. More tooth fairy science.
And the coupe de grace:
However spinal manipulation works, it’s at least better than nothing when it comes to chronic low back pain, says Dr Chou.
No, it doesn’t work and everything, and anything, is always better than nothing. See that whole ‘A + B versus B’ thing above. I think you need to have more responsibility for patients’ health, wealth and lives than to use such a lame reason to send patients off for expensive and dangerous placebos.
And after all that Kellyanne-ish spin the best they can say is:
The effects of spinal manipulation appeared to be not only modest but also short in duration.
Just like a placebo. All that build-up for such a tepid conclusion?
And then they say the same about neck pain:
Gross and her colleagues reached similar conclusions about improving pain, function, and quality of life related to neck complaints.
After all that, I would quote the Bard:
spinal manipulation efficacy is a tale told by an chiropractor, full of sound and fury, signifying nothing
Then they say
Spinal manipulation is difficult to study because patients and practitioners can’t be effectively blinded to the treatment.
Yes they can.
Most effects are subjective.
And so very sensitive to biased reporting, all the more reason to evaluate efficacy using strict methodologies rather than those that generate false positives.
And it’s hard to standardize treatments from one practitioner to another.
In other words, like acupuncturists, chiropractors make it up as they go along. Another suggestion that the effects of manipulation are all placebo, you get the same outcome from a wide variety of dissimilar interventions. It is no wonder why:
…researchers couldn’t find much evidence for the superiority of any particular spinal manipulation technique or any category of practitioner. Nor could they determine the optimum frequency or duration.
Just what would be expected from a pseudo-medical placebo.
But the main reason to avoid high quality randomized, double blind sham controlled studies is that the study will be negative.
When he does refer patients for spinal manipulation, Dr Chou tries to make sure the practitioner is not going to apply additional therapies that are unproven.
LOL. As constructed the sentence reads like chiropractic is also unproven. Which it is. Paging Dr Freud. Despite that:
He advises patients to try spinal manipulation for 3-4 weeks, then move on to something else if it isn’t helping.
In my opinion that is unethical: wasting patients’ time and money on a worthless and dangerous pseudo-medical placebo.
she adds that no literature review or evidence-based algorithm can provide all of the guidance a practitioner needs to treat a patient’s back or neck pain.
Yes, but the literature can guide you to know when a therapy is useless. And understanding basic science would let a practitioner know when an intervention is almost certainly fanciful.
That is true of all of medicine, but a lousy excuse to sending patients off for what I would consider a form of fraud. The special pleading of all pseudo-medicine; that there is something in their particular intervention that makes it immune to reality-based evaluations and data.
The decision to use spinal manipulation “always has to be based on more than just research evidence”
Especially when the research evidence is negative? I wish I could get away with that in my practice, but infections have a nasty habit of progressing and killing my patients if I were to give ineffective therapy.
Gross insists. “It has to be based on good sound clinical reasoning [not present for chiropractic manipulation], biology [not present for chiropractic manipulation], the psychosocial elements around you, and the individual you are helping.”
So chiropractic manipulation has no foundation in basic science, its placebo effects are minimal and transient at best, it is dangerous, costly, and time consuming for the patient, but if one tries hard enough you can rationalize an excuse to give it a try.
Sigh.
Just the solution for the chronic pain problem in the US.
I wonder if I can get Kate McKinnon to read this for the Quackcast?

Cervicogenic Headache and Cervical Spine Manipulation
Sam Homola on April 12, 2016
Link
NOTE: Today we offer a double feature on the treatment of cervicogenic headache: this post and Dr. Harriet Hall’s post, “When Headaches Are a Pain in the Neck: Spinal Manipulation vs. Mobilization for Cervicogenic Headache.” They complement each other, as well as Dr. Hall’s post from last week on the possible risk of stroke with neck manipulation.
A cervicogenic headache has been defined as a secondary headache (beginning in the suboccipital area) caused by nerve pain referred from a source in the upper cervical spine. According to the American Migraine Foundation, “To confirm the diagnosis of cervicogenic headache, the headache must be relieved by nerve blocks….Treatment includes nerve blocks, physical therapy, exercise, Botox injections, and medication. Physical therapy and an ongoing exercise regime often produce the best outcomes.”1
There are a number of published studies advocating use of upper cervical manipulation as a treatment for cervicogenic headache,2 often without adequate consideration of the danger of such treatment. While upper neck manipulation might sometimes be an effective treatment for a cervicogenic headache, care must be taken to avoid upper cervical manipulative techniques that may pose risk of stroke by damaging vertebral and internal carotid arteries.
Most headaches are of the tension-type variety, often originating in the myofascial structures of the head and neck. There are many other types of headache, some of which can be life-threatening or unbearably painful, none of which are neck related. Headache caused by a leaking brain aneurysm may portend possible rupture of a swollen blood vessel. A migraine or a cluster headache is less serious but can cause agonizing pain. Sudden appearance of neck pain with headache can be a symptom of spontaneous vertebral artery dissection, which can result in a full-blown stroke if aggravated by neck manipulation. When a headache is sudden, severe, or persistent, it is important to have a medical evaluation before concluding that you have a neck-related headache or before submitting to neck manipulation, especially upper cervical manipulation that involves rotation of the atlas on the axis.
Rotation in atlanto-axial joints
The greatest amount of rotation in the cervical spine occurs in the atlanto-axial (C1-2) joints in the upper cervical spine where vertebral arteries are most often injured. There are no interlocking joint surfaces and no intervertebral disc to limit rotation of the atlas on the axis, which is restrained primarily by ligaments. When rotation of the atlas exceeds 45 or 50 degrees, vertebral arteries threading through transverse processes on each side of the axis and atlas (to enter an opening in the base of the skull) are stretched, risking stroke caused by vertebral artery dissection or clot formation. Vertebral arteries that are diseased and have lost some of their elasticity are more susceptible to injury caused by neck manipulation.
The prevailing view of neck manipulation, based on scientific consensus, suggests that rotatory upper cervical manipulation is unsafe and that there is no known benefit that outweighs the risk of such treatment. Unless a specific upper cervical problem has been identified that can benefit from manipulation that does not involve more than 50 degrees of atlanto-axial rotation, there may be no justification for use of upper neck manipulation.

Effects of cervical spine manipulation
Manipulative treatment such as massage, mobilization, or spinal manipulation applied to neck and upper back structures would probably be beneficial in relieving tightness and tension that triggers or contributes to a neck-related headache. Manipulating the cervical spine may have some neurophysiological effects in relieving head and neck pain as well as a mechanical effect in restoring mobility in cervical joints. There is reason to believe that spinal manipulation can temporarily relieve pain and muscle spasm by influencing pain (nociceptive) receptors and mechanoreceptors in muscles and joints. Noxious stimuli of any kind, such as acupuncture or a thrust-type manipulation, might relieve pain to some extent by stimulating the body’s production of endorphins (chemicals that interact with opiate receptors in the brain to reduce perception of pain). The popping sound of cavitation produced by spinal manipulation can have a powerful placebo effect, producing a psychological perception that the treatment is effective. Although such effects may provide temporary relief of pain, no permanent effect would occur unless the manipulation relieves muscle spasm or restores mobility in spinal joints.
The precautionary principle
There may be no positive proof that upper cervical manipulation can cause stroke by damaging the vertebrobasilar arteries3 (as is often said, “association is not causation”), but there are numerous case reports associating neck manipulation with stroke caused by injury to vertebrobasilar arteries, some occurring in young, healthy persons (most under the age of 45) immediately following a neck manipulation. Some of these injuries have been confirmed by imaging studies that show dissection of healthy arteries due to trauma.4,5 Considering the totality of evidence, it is logical to assume that reports associating neck manipulation with vertebral artery dissection in healthy persons strongly suggest a cause-and-effect relationship, providing reason enough to avoid upper neck manipulation.
The American Heart Association and the American Stroke Association offer this precautionary advice to practitioners who manipulate the cervical spine:
CD [cervical artery dissection] is an important cause of ischemic stroke in young and middle-aged patients. CD is most prevalent in the upper cervical spine and can involve the internal carotid artery or vertebral artery…. Although the incidence of CMT [cervical manipulative therapy]-associated CD in patients who have previously received CMT is not well established, and probably low, practitioners should strongly consider the possibility of CD as a presenting symptom, and patients should be informed of the statistical association between CD and CMT prior to undergoing manipulation of the cervical spine.6
Cavitation and rotatory manipulative techniques
Rotatory upper cervical manipulation is the technique most often associated with post-manipulative stroke. Extreme rotation of the top two cervical vertebrae ─ usually producing cavitation ─ is believed to be a cause of traumatic dissection of a vertebral artery. It is the extreme range of motion (uniquely upper cervical), not the cavitation, that injures a vertebral artery. While extreme rotation of the atlanto-axial joints should be avoided, with or without cavitation, cavitation is not always a bad thing.
The amount of rotation that takes place in high-velocity low-amplitude cervical spine manipulation depends upon the technique used. There are some techniques, such as lateral thrusting with a thumb contact, which can result in cavitation with little rotation. Cavitation in the cervical spine can also occur when pulling on the head at the end range of distraction (after taking up the slack) to stretch the spine with high-velocity low-amplitude traction while the patient is in a supine (face-up) position.
Note: Cavitation occurs when two contiguous joint surfaces are forcefully separated, creating a vacuum that pulls in gasses from synovial fluid, causing a pop. Joint surfaces are held together by a fluidic attraction that allows the joint surfaces to slide upon each other. When there is forceful movement of a joint, exceeding the normal range of movement (into the paraphysiologic space), the cavitation that occurs may temporarily increase range of motion or result in restoration of mobility if there is binding or fixation in the joint. The popping sound heard during manipulation can occur in normal joints and does not mean that a subluxation, an adhesion, or a misalignment was present. A joint that is freely movable is not subluxated or out of place and will always return to its anatomically dictated resting place after manipulation or cavitation. The alignment of freely movable joints cannot be changed.
Head rotation vs. neck rotation
When the head is actively rotated (a voluntary action), a little rotation takes place in all the cervical joints, including the atlanto-axial joints which rotate a little more than lower cervical joints but well within a safe range, allowing about 70 degrees of head rotation right and left. When the head is used to rotate the cervical spine with a long-lever technique, usually while the patient is in a supine position, a maximum amount of rotation occurs in the atlanto-axial joints, reaching ligamentous constraints where the vertebral arteries are most stressed. Extreme rotation in the atlanto-axial joints also occurs when a specific short-lever contact is used to rotate the atlas vertebra.
Needless to say, any manipulative technique that forces extreme rotation of the atlas on the axis should not be done.

When I had occasion to use neck manipulation in my practice as a chiropractor, I usually sat the patient on a stool, using a four-finger contact on the side of the neck so that I could rotate the cervical spine as a whole. When the atlanto-axial joints are included in a full cervical contact for full cervical rotation, rotation in the atlanto-axial joints is not likely to be excessive. When the atlanto-axial joints are not included in a full-cervical rotation (below the C1 level), head rotation is considerably less, with little or no rotation of the atlas on the axis.
Cervical spine problems such as loss of mobility due to post-traumatic adhesions or entrapment of a cartilaginous fragment might benefit from full cervical rotation that does not force extreme rotation in the atlanto-axial joints, but such problems are questionable or not common and have not been adequately investigated.

Undetected contraindications for neck manipulation
There are many apparent contraindications for use of cervical spine manipulation, such as atlas instability in rheumatoid arthritis, nerve root impingement or disc herniation, osteoporosis, fever and other symptoms indicating disease or infection, use of blood thinners, carotid bruits, atherosclerosis, and so on. There are also some contraindications that may not be apparent in healthy, asymptomatic persons.
In addition to the danger of vertebral artery injury posed by excessive rotation of upper cervical vertebrae, undetected structural abnormalities in the cervical spine compound the danger of such treatment. A “retrolenticular vertebral artery ring,” for example, an abnormal bony bridge that encompasses the vertebral artery where it passes over the posterior arch of the atlas, can severely compress a vertebral artery during rotatory upper cervical manipulation.7 A Chiari malformation, a structural defect that allows a portion of the cerebellum to pass down through the foramen magnum and enter the spinal canal, can cause headache that begins on the back of the head and neck, resembling a cervicogenic headache or a muscle-contraction headache. Upper cervical manipulation in such a case would be dangerous.
Suffice it to say that no one should submit to neck manipulation as a treatment for headache without a careful history, a thorough exam, and a definitive diagnosis, and only with informed consent after first trying such physical treatment methods as massage and manual traction.
Note: The most common contraindication for upper cervical manipulation is a diagnosis of “subluxations” by some chiropractors who manipulate the neck of every patient they treat.
The bottom line
Because of the danger associated with upper cervical manipulation and the difficulty establishing a need for use of cervical spine manipulation, plus the difficulty finding a practitioner who uses cervical spine manipulation in a safe, conservative, and appropriate manner, I usually advise against submitting to neck manipulation when I am asked about such treatment. In most cases, time combined with use of such measures as exercise, postural ergonomics, sub-occipital massage, and manual axial (longitudinal) traction will be sufficient treatment for mechanical-type neck pain or a headache related to a neck problem ─ provided an orthopedic evaluation has ruled out complicating factors.
References
     1.  Robert T. Cervicogenic Headache – The Basics. American Migraine Foundation. 2012. Return to text
     2.  Dunning JR, Butts R, Mourad F, et al. Upper cervical and upper thoracic manipulation versus mobilization and exercise in patients with cervicogenic headache: a multi-center randomized clinical trail. BMC Musculoskelet Disord. 2016; 17:64. Return to text
     3.  Church EW, Sieg EP, Zalatimo O, et al. Systematic review and meta-analysis of chiropractic care and cervical artery dissection: no evidence for causation. Cureus. 2016; 8(2):e498. Return to text
     4.  Jatuzis D, Valaikiene J. Migraine-like presentation of vertebral artery dissection after cervical manipulative therapy. Perspectives in Medicine. 2012; 1(1-12):452-454. Return to text
     5.  Jones J, Jones C, Nugent K. Vertebral artery dissection after a chiropractic neck manipulation. Proc (Bayl Univ Med Cent). 2015; 28(1):88-90. Return to text
     6.  Biller J, Sacco RL, Albuquerque FC, et al. Cervical arterial dissections and association with cervical manipulative therapy. Stroke 2014; 45: 3155–74. Return to text
     7.  Rao SR, Swamy G, Vasudha TK, Rao TR. Unusual foramen on the posterior arch of atlas. Journal of Science. 2015; 5(12):1165-1167. Return to text

When Headaches Are a Pain in the Neck: Spinal Manipulation vs. Mobilization for Cervicogenic Headache
Harriet Hall on April 12, 2016
Link
NOTE: Today we offer a double feature on the treatment of cervicogenic headache. My article is about a study that compared manipulation to mobilization; it is followed by retired chiropractor Sam Homola’s guest article on manipulation for cervicogenic headache. The two posts complement each other and also complement my post from last week on the possible risk of stroke with neck manipulation.


Cervicogenic headache (CGH) refers to headaches that are caused by problems in the neck, as opposed to headaches of non-neck etiology that may be accompanied by neck pain. There is controversy over whether CGH is even a valid diagnosis. Diagnostic criteria usually include unilateral headache triggered by head/neck movement or by pressure on the neck, headache that spreads to the neck, shoulder or arm; and often limited range of motion in the neck. If a nerve block in the neck relieves the headache, that would confirm that the pain originates in the neck, but nerve blocks are not routinely done and are not required for diagnosis.
Is manipulation effective for CGH?
There is controversy over whether spinal manipulation is an effective treatment for CGH. A 2005 systematic review concluded that “A greater number of well-designed, randomized, controlled trials are required to confirm or refute the effectiveness of spinal manipulation.”
A 2011 systematic review of RCTs said:
The results of 6 RCTs suggested that SM is effective for treating CGH compared to physical therapy, light massage, drug therapy, or no intervention. Three RCTs showed no differences in pain, headache duration and frequency compared to placebo manipulation, physical therapy, massage, or wait list controls. Most trials had major methodological flaws.
They concluded:
…the evidence that SM is effective for CGH is not conclusive. Further rigorous research in this area is needed. Until conclusive data are available, SM cannot be regarded as an evidence-based approach in the treatment of CGH.
Comparison of manipulation and mobilization
Cochrane reviews in 2010 and 2015 compared manipulation and mobilization for neck pain and found that the evidence was poor quality; they concluded that manipulation offered no clear advantage over mobilization.
A new study published in February 2016 in the journal BMC Musculoskeletal Disorders is the first to compare the effectiveness of high velocity low amplitude (HVLA) cervical and thoracic manipulation to mobilization and exercise for CGH. It found that manipulation was more effective than mobilization. How convincing is that study?
Methods
The study was a multicenter randomized trial with 110 carefully selected subjects, with 6-8 treatments over a four-week period and a follow-up evaluation at 3 months. The treatments were performed by physical therapists with an average of 10 years’ experience and with special additional training to ensure standardization of treatments. The patients were randomized into two groups.
The manipulation group got manipulations with the patient supine (lying face up). The right and left C1-2 articulations and bilateral T1-2 articulations were manipulated on at least one of the 6–8 treatment sessions. On other treatment sessions, therapists either repeated the C1-2 and/or T1-2 manipulations or targeted other spinal articulations (i.e., C0-1, C2-3, C3-7, T2-9, ribs 1–9) using manipulation. The selection of the spinal segments to target was left to the discretion of the treating therapist and it was based on the combination of patient reports and manual examination. For both the upper cervical and upper thoracic manipulations, if no popping or cracking sound was heard on the first attempt, the therapist repositioned the patient and performed a second manipulation.
The mobilization/exercise group got mobilization in the prone (lying face down) position targeting C1-C2 and T1-2 on at least one session. On other treatment sessions, therapists either repeated the C1-2 and/or T1-2 mobilizations or targeted other spinal articulations (i.e., C0-1, C2/3, C3-7, T2-9, ribs 1–9) using mobilization. The selection of the spinal segments to target was left to the discretion of the treating therapist. Staged craniocervical flexion exercises were performed with the subject supine.
Results
All subjects improved over the course of the study. The manipulation group had greater improvements in headache intensity, disability, headache frequency, headache duration, and medication intake than those who got mobilization combined with exercises. They estimated a number needed to treat (NNT) of four patients treated with manipulation for one additional patient to achieve clinically important pain reduction at 3 months follow-up. No patients had either of the two major potential adverse events that they specifically asked about, but ‘We did not collect any data on the occurrence of “minor” adverse events (transient neurological symptoms, increased stiffness, radiating pain, fatigue or other).’
Questions remain
     1.  How many subjects would have improved with no treatment or with other treatments like massage?
     2.  How can we know which treatments worked when so many different articulations were treated and individual patients were treated differently?
     3.  How do these treatments compare to what the average patient with CGH would get from visiting the average chiropractor or physical therapist?
     4.  Why did they not collect data on minor adverse events? I would think radiating pain and transient neurological symptoms would be very worrisome.
     5.  Might these subjects have been biased by previous experience with manipulation or mobilization? Were they biased by hearing the popping or cracking sound?
     6.  Did the supine vs. prone position make a difference? Would it have been as effective and possibly safer to do manipulations with the patient seated?
     7.  Could therapist preference have biased the results?
     8.  Could the authors’ competing interests have influenced the results in some way? Four of them are instructors who provide postgraduate training in manipulation and mobilization.
     9.  If these treatments work, what is the mechanism?
     10.  Why were they intent on producing a popping or cracking sound? Is it of any benefit or might it possibly increase the incidence of adverse effects?
     11.  Do the benefits of treatment justify the small risk of stroke or death from neck manipulation? The authors cited the Cassidy study as evidence that patients receiving spinal manipulations were no more likely to have a stroke than patients treated by a medical physician. That is not at all what that study showed. It provided no data on whether patients got manipulation. And it showed that if you are under the age of 45 and visit a chiropractor, there is a strong association between that visit and a stroke in the next 24 hours. See Mark Crislip’s evaluation of the Cassidy study.
Conclusion: Still not enough to justify cervical manipulation
In my opinion, considering the evidence from previous studies, the possible risk of stroke, and the unanswered questions, this one study is not enough to justify adopting manipulation for CGH. Samuel Homola, a science-based chiropractor, advises against neck manipulation for cervicogenic headache in a post following this one and explains why.

Blind-Spot Mapping, Cortical Function, and Chiropractic Manipulation
Harriet Hall on November 29, 2011
Link

Steven Novella recently wrote about so-called “chiropractic neurology” and its most outspoken proponent, Ted Carrick. In 2005 I published an article in The Scientific Review of Alternative Medicine (Vol 9, No 1, p. 11-15) entitled “Blind-Spot Mapping, Cortical Function, and Chiropractic Manipulation.” It was an analysis of a study Carrick had published.
Carrick read a shorter, popularized version of my critique in Skeptical Inquirer and responded with a diatribe that was inaccurate, distorted what I had said, and accused me of fraud, deception, and mis-representation. He failed to offer a credible rebuttal of my specific criticisms; and, in my opinion, showed that he failed to understand some of my points. He referred to me as “Ms. Hall” and suggested that I was psychotic. He characterized my e-mail correspondence with him as “bizarre, rude, and offensive.” It was none of those, and I have copies of the e-mails to prove it. Carrick says he “forwarded it to the legal council for the American Chiropractic Association for review.” Now that strikes me as bizarre.
I am re-publishing the entire text of my article here as an instructive example of what passes for science in the chiropractic neurology community. Readers can judge for themselves whether my critique amounts to fraud and whether I am showing signs of psychosis, whether Carrick is a good scientist and whether his reply to my critique was appropriate.
Title: Blind-Spot Mapping, Cortical Function, and Chiropractic Manipulation
ABSTRACT:
Background: A technique of blind-spot mapping is being used by chiropractors to determine hemispheric dominance and to map cortical function; the findings are being used clinically to guide unilateral cervical spine manipulations.
Objective: The objective of this paper is to evaluate the evidence for the assertions that (1) large numbers of normal people have an enlarged blind spot on one side; (2) mapping the blind spot is equivalent to mapping brain function, and (3) spinal manipulation alters the size of the blind spot by altering brain function.
Design: A review of the literature found only 1 pertinent study; this study was analyzed for flaws and for quality of evidence.
Results: Serious methodological and logical flawswere found that invalidate the conclusions of the study.
Conclusion: The evidence for a high incidence of enlarged blind spots is unconvincing. There is no evidence that blind-spot mapping reflects cortical function or that manipulation can affect the size of the blind spot by altering brain function.
BACKGROUND
The blind spot is the area of the retina where the optic nerve enters the eye, where there are no photoreceptors. In monocular vision, it represents a small area of the visual field, about halfway between the midpoint and the lateral edge, where no visual input is received. In binocular vision, that area is visible to the opposite eye. The brain fills in the missing information to create the illusion of an uninterrupted visual field. Ophthalmologists routinely map the blind spots when testing visual fields for clinical diagnosis and follow-up. Until 1997, no one had observed any significant difference in blind-spot size between the left and right eyes in the absence of retinal disease. In that year, a study by Frederick Carrick, DC, PhD, titled “Changes in Brain Function after Manipulation of the Cervical Spine,” was published in the Journal of Manipulative and Physiological Therapeutics. (1) Studying 500 volunteers, he reported that all had a significant enlargement of 1 blind spot and that it returned to normal size following selective unilateral manipulation of the cervical spine.
The blind-spot-mapping technique described by Dr. Carrick is now being widely used by chiropractors and others. The technique is being taught at postgraduate chiropractic neurology seminars. Proponents claim to be mapping brain function, and to be able to affect brain function by manipulating the spine. A sample newspaper ad reads:
DO YOU HAVE A GOOD BRAIN OR A BAD BRAIN? ONE SIMPLE TEST MAY TELL YOu. Balance Problem? Learning Disability? Pain? Eye Problems? You name it. It could all be in your head. Researchers concluded: “Accurate reproducible maps of cortical (i.e. brain) responses can be used to measure the neurological consequences of spinal joint manipulation. Cervical manipulation activates specific neurological pathways. Manipulation of the cervical spine may be associated with an increase or a decrease in brain function depending upon the side of the manipulation and the cortical hemisphericity (i.e., side of decreased brain function) of a patient. Call Today for a FREE Brain Function Exam. (2)
Chiropractic originally claimed that all disease resulted from the effect of bone displacements (subluxations) on the nervous system. (3) Some chiropractors now limit their practice to the musculoskeletal system; others still claim to be able to treat other systems of the body. Ear infections, asthma, and constipation are among the conditions treated by chiropractors. (4) Neuroanatomy, as it is presently understood, tells us that spinal manipulation should not affect the brain or other structures within the skull; chiropractors believe it does, and they have been seeking scientific proof of that belief for over a century. The 1997 study by Dr. Carrick is considered by some to constitute that proof. The issue is an important one: if manipulation is proven to have an effect on brain function, there will be reason to accept chiropractic as a part of mainstream medicine and to teach it in medical schools.
OBJECTIVE
The evidence for blind-spot mapping was evaluated to determine if it supported claims that
     1.  large numbers of normal people have an enlarged blind spot on one side;
     2.  mapping the blind spot is equivalent to mapping brain function;
     3.  spinal manipulation affects the size of the blind spot by altering brain function.
DESIGN
The medical literature and the Internet were searched and the author of the original 1997 study was contacted in an attempt to locate all published literature on the subject. Ten letters to the editor followed the original study in the Journal of Manipulative and Physiological Therapeutics, each answered by the author; no other studies were found. The author of the 1997 article knew of no other published studies since that date, although he has other studies in progress.(5)
Information on the Internet was sparse. One Web site (6) was found that mentioned the test and the results of a clinical series: “We have tested thousands of people in the past five years and have found less than 1% have normal sized blind spot maps.” No further details or documentation were provided. This Web site advertised a device for chiropractic manipulation (an activator) and was riddled with errors (such as confusing the blind spot in the eye with a driver’s blind spot). On a second Web site, (7) a chiropractor criticized Dr. Carrick for dogmatism and failing to respond to criticism about the 1997 study and criticized a third, now-defunct Web site on which a chiropractor had made statements about the blind spot not supported by anything in Dr. Carrick’s study or in the rest of the chiropractic literature. Anecdotal evidence was found indicating that a number of clinicians have also found enlarged blind spots with the test, and that the information has been clinically useful.
In the absence of any other information suitable for analysis, this analysis is based solely on the one published article.
RESULTS
Summary of the Study
The objective was “to ascertain whether manipulation of the cervical spine is associated with changes in brain function.” The subjects were 500 volunteers enrolled in postdoctoral neurology programs. Their blind spots were mapped with a simple paper-and-pencil test by 2 “blinded” examiners, and the 2 maps were judged for reproducibility by 2 “blinded” examiners who superimposed the 2 maps over a bright light. Four hundred seventy-three pairs of maps were judged reproducible; all had an enlarged blind spot on one side, with an average circumference of approximately 1.5 times the circumference of the smaller spot. In 330 subjects, the right blind spot was larger; in 143 subjects, the left one was larger. In 20 subjects with enlarged blind spots on the right, the second cervical motion segment was reduced on the right in 10 and on the left in 10. Retesting showed that after manipulation on the right side, the right blind spot was significantly smaller and the left blind spot was unchanged; after manipulation on the left side, the right blind spot was unchanged and the left blind spot was significantly larger. The remaining 453 patients were all manipulated on the same side as the enlarged blind spot; after manipulation, the enlarged blind spot was significantly smaller, while the blind spot in the other eye did not change. The study concluded:
Accurate reproducible maps of cortical (i.e. brain) responses can be used to measure the neurological consequences of spinal joint manipulation. Cervical manipulation activates specific neurological pathways. Manipulation of the cervical spine may be associated with an increase or a decrease in brain function depending upon the side of the manipulation and the cortical hemisphericity (i.e., side of decreased brain function) of a patient.
The study refers to the blind spot maps as “physiological cortical maps” and “an integer of brain activity.”
Description of the Blind-spot Test
Ophthalmologists have a variety of standardized methods for testing visual fields. The test in this study is a simple paper-and-pencil variant of the tangent-screen method:
     1.  A piece of paper with a dot in the center is placed at eye level 28 cm from the subject’s forehead.
     2.  The subject covers one eye and fixates on the dot with the other eye.
     3.  The examiner moves a small target laterally from the dot to the edge of the paper; pencil marks are made where the target seems to disappear and where it seems to reappear.
     4.  The target is placed in the area where it was invisible and moved up, down, and at 45° angles until a total of 8 dots have been mapped to delineate the borders of the blind spot.
     5.  The 8 pencil marks are connected with straight lines and the circumference of the blind spot is measured.
Possible Methodological Flaws
     1.  The test as described is imprecise and would be expected to vary with many factors such as degree of cooperation, speed of target movement, slight tilting of the head, reliability of fixation, judgment as to where to draw the dots, etc.
     2.  The measurements of this new blind-spot mapping method were reproducible within the study but were not shown to be valid; there was no comparison with measurements by other, older methods.
     3.  Reproducibility was determined by superimposing 2 drawings over a bright light; this was a subjective judgment. The maximum difference allowed between 2 “reproducible” maps was not quantified.
     4.  The investigators may have been biased, as suggested by the objective of the study. (They were trying to study the effect of manipulation on brain function, not simply to establish a blind-spot-mapping test.)
     5.  There were no controls who were not manipulated or who received sham manipulation or manipulation of levels below the second cervical vertebra.
     6.  The subjects were postgraduate chiropractic neurology students. They were presumably biased in favor of chiropractic and may have been biased towards finding expected results. They knew which side of their spine had been manipulated and therefore understood which eye would be expected to show a change.
     7.  Although the examiners were taught to monitor the subject’s eye movements, it seems unlikely that they could watch the subject’s eyes and draw dots on the paper at the same time. The subject may have been able to glance surreptitiously at how the map was developing. The subject may have been able to compare the left map to the right.
     8.  All 500 subjects had enlarged blind spots, but the study does not mention whether anyone had equal blind spots on initial testing and was not included in the study.
References Cited in the Study
The 47 references listed are mostly irrelevant or misinterpreted and do not support the findings and conclusions of the study. Reference 1 describes how the brain chooses what illusion to put in the blind spot when adjacent signals are ambiguous, i.e., where 2 color zones abut. Reference 2 is cited to support the statement, “Cortical receptive field size varies in different individuals.” It actually says there is a rapid variation in cortical receptive-field size in response to stabilized images in the same individual. Reference 3 says: “Ocular dominance stripes … are absent from the cortical representations of the blind spot and the monocular crescent” in the Cebus monkey. Reference 4 concerns possible mediation of contour interaction phenomenon by long-range connections within the striate cortex. From this, Dr. Carrick hypothesizes that “the frequency of firing of these cortical connections affects visual perception and enlargement of the blind spot might be attributable to any mechanism that decreases the firing rate of horizontal cortical connections, hence decreasing the probability of neuronal summation.” (1, p. 537) References 5-9 all describe retinal diseases (central-retinal vein occlusion, multiple evanescent white-dot syndrome, etc.) that may cause an apparent enlargement of the blind spot as well as other areas of loss of vision. References 10-12 refer to conditions that Dr. Carrick interprets as unexplained blind-spot enlargement but actually are known to be due to retinal disease, such as acute zonal occult outer retinopathy (AZOOR). Reference 13 shows that microwave radiation can alter the size of the blind spot (by damaging tissue). Reference 14 shows that treatment of glaucoma can reduce an enlarged blind spot caused by local pressure due to glaucoma. Reference 15 shows that glaucoma can damage the retina near the blind spot. Reference 16 states that multiple events affecting vision are often related. (It reports a case of chorioretinopathy complicated by occipital lobe infarction and sinusitis in a drug abuser.)
After citing these 16 references, Dr. Carrick concludes, “It is clear that the size and shape of the blind spot is a product of neuronal activity and that this activity can be affected by a variety of processes. It was therefore chosen as a sensitive integer of brain activity that could be used to measure changes in cortical activity if other integers were manipulated.” (1, p. 539) This conclusion is not justified.
References 17-23 refer to various methods of recording blind spots (such as computerized static perimetry and multifixation campimetry), pointing out that they are more expensive than the pencil-and-paper method.
The abstract of one of these references actually states: “Statistically there was no evident difference of the size and depth of the defects of the blind spot either between the right and left visual field or among the individual age groups” (8) — in direct antithesis to the findings of Dr. Carrick’s study.
References 24-43 consist of various studies relating to the thalamus, the optic nerve and its connections, the plasticity of the visual cortex, etc. These studies say nothing about any cortical effect on the size of the blind spot or about any cortical effect of neck manipulation. Dr. Carrick uses them as departure points for imaginative speculation about how nerve signals from the neck might possibly interact with optic-nerve signals through some mechanism which has never been recognized. For example, reference 27 is titled “In Vivo Demonstration of Altered Benzodiazepine Receptor Density in Patients with Generalized Epilepsy.” He cites this to support this statement: “The amplitude of somatosensory receptor potentials will influence the frequency of firing of cerebello-thalamocortical loops that have been shown to maintain a central integrative state of cortex.” He then speculates: “Changes in the amplitude of muscle stretch receptors and joint mechanoreceptors that dictate the frequency of firing of primary afferents that contribute to cerebellothalmocortical loops should also affect the integrative cortical state, which might affect the size of the blind spot when visual afferents are maintained in a steady state.” (1, p. 540) (Emphasis added.)
References 44-47 are Dr. Carrick’s own publications describing his manipulative techniques.
Logical Flaws
     1.  Nothing in the paper or the references it cites justifies calling a blind-spot map “a physiological cortical map” or “an integer of brain activity.” The blind spot is a fixed anatomical feature. The brain functions to fill in the blind spot but has no effect on its size.
     2.  When a new test contradicts the findings of all previous tests, its accuracy must be suspect. Either the blind spots are the same size or they are not. Either this study is wrong or all previous observers are wrong. The test cannot be used as a measurement tool in further experiments until this dilemma is resolved.
     3.  Carrick’s argument boils down to this: spinal manipulation must affect cortical activity because it changes the size of the blind spot, and the blind spot must represent a map of cortical activity because its size changes with spinal manipulation. Demonstrating that the size of the blind spot changes following manipulation does not prove that manipulation changes the brain or that the brain changes the blind spot, even if no other explanation is apparent. The fact that A is followed by C does not prove that A causes B and B causes C. That amounts to what has been called a logical “sillygism.”
Other Observations
In Figure 8 of the paper, a heading reads: “Blind Spots Are the Consequence of Global Brain Activity and Representative of the Anatomical Size of the Optic Disc.” This is a false statement not justified by anything in the paper.
The language of the paper is often confused and unclear. It is difficult to understand what the author means by statements such as “A constant type of environmental stimulation (vision) was used in this research to stimulate the brain through specific known neuronal pathways. The effects of this environmental stimulation were used to affect human perceptual activity and demonstrate the effectiveness of cortical mapping through comparison.” (1, p. 531)
Neuroanatomists have mapped the nervous system in great detail, and pathways that might allow spinal manipulation to affect the brain are not known to exist.
The study describes detailed statistical analysis of manipulation experiments based on a blind-spot test that has not been shown to be valid. Statistical significance is meaningless if it is based on invalid data.
CONCLUSION
Evidence supporting the use of the blind-spot-mapping test is limited to one fatally flawed study. The evidence of this study that one blind spot is larger than the other is unconvincing and contradicts all previous findings. The assertion that the size of the blind spot can change is opposed to all present anatomical and physiological knowledge. There is no evidence that blind-spot mapping reflects cortical function or that manipulation can affect the size of the blind spot by stimulating cortical function. The study fails to meet its stated objective of ascertaining whether manipulation of the cervical spine is associated with changes in brain function. The conclusions it reaches are unjustified and illogical. The paper-and-pencil blind-spot-mapping test has not been validated, and there is no reason to think that it has any clinical usefulness.
REFERENCES
     1.  Carrick F. 1997. Changes in brain function after manipulation of the cervical spine. J Manipulative Physiol Ther. 20(8): 529-545.
     2.  Tacoma (Washington) News Tribune, December 31,2002.
     3.  Palmer D. The Chiropractor: Whitefish, MT: Kessinger Publishing; 1997.
     4.  Sportelli L. 2000. Introduction to Chiropractic. 10th ed. Norwalk, IA: Practicemakers Products.
     5.  Author? 2002. Personal communication. December 26.
     6.  Biokinetics Health Systems. Frequently Asked Questions. Available at: http://www.biokineticshealth.com/faqs. html. Accessed December 31,2002.
     7.  Seaman D. Philosophy and science versus dogmatism in the practice of chiropractic. The Chiropractic Resource Organization. Available at: http://www.chiro.org/LINKS/ ABSTRACTS/Science _ vs_ dogmatism.shtml. Accessed December 31, 2002.
     8.  Lest’ak J. 1993. [Marriotte’s spot]. Cesk Oftalmol 49(6):394-398.

Studying Chiropractic with Imaging: Another Dead Salmon?
Harriet Hall on September 27, 2016
Link


Researchers in Japan have done a study evaluating the effects of chiropractic treatment using MRI and PET scans. It was published in the 2009 report of the Cyclotron and Radioisotope Center (CYRIC) of Tokohu University.
Their rationale for doing the study
Ray Hyman‘s categorical imperative is “Do not try to explain something until you are sure there is something to be explained.” These researchers believe there is something to be explained. They think chiropractic has proven clinical benefits and they are trying to find the underlying physiological mechanisms. They think they have found something with their advanced imaging procedures, but the dead salmon study and Satel and Lilienfeld’s book Brainwashed have taught us that neuroimaging studies can be misleading and must be interpreted with great caution.
They say chiropractic is “one of the manipulative therapies initiated by Daniel David Palmer.” I didn’t know he initiated any other manipulative therapies; I wonder what they were. They argue that chiropractic is widely used and is legislated in the U.S. and in over 20 other countries. So what? That’s not evidence that it works. They say chiropractic spinal manipulation is “considered one of the main treatment techniques for neuro-muscular-skeletal problems.” Considered by whom? Which neuro-muscular-skeletal problems, exactly?
Experimental design
Subjects were volunteers who responded to a poster on a university campus. 20 patients with low back pain were divided into three groups (normal, sacral base anterior and sacral base posterior) by pressure testing in Activator Methods. 9 were classified into the SB anterior group, 11 into the SB posterior group, and none into the normal group. Subjects received chiropractic spinal manipulation (CSM) depending on the results of pressure testing. They don’t describe what the chiropractic treatment was, but they state that all treatments were performed by the same chiropractor who was “an advanced proficiency rated doctor of Activator Methods,” so I think we can assume the treatments were activator treatments. Activators are spring-loaded instruments that provide a variable impulse to a localized area. They provide a “kinder, gentler” chiropractic for patients who are wary of the traditional “back-cracking” manipulations. Activator methods have not been scientifically validated, and they are not the most characteristic chiropractic treatment; the very name chiropractic is derived from “hands-on,” not gadgets-on. Only 70% of chiropractors use activators, and only 24% of patients get that treatment.
The description of what they did is confusing, to say the least. They start out talking about 20 subjects with low back pain, then they say subjects had cervical pain and shoulder stiffness. 20 patients with low back pain somehow morphed into 15 with neck pain who were “first assigned for MRI examination of the cervical region” (the neck), then 3 were excluded because they had disc problems. So they ended up with only 12 subjects. Although the first mention of MRIs refers to the neck, the images shown in the study write-up are MRIs of the low back.
The experimental design was a crossover study comparing scan results in the same patient with and without CSM.
Results
They found that chiropractic treatment produced:
    • Apparent angle changes on MRI in most but not all subjects
    • Increased glucose metabolism in certain areas of the brain and decreased metabolism in other areas
    • Subjective improvement with lower visual analog scores (VAS)
    • Changes in cervical muscle tone
    • Reduced salivary amylase values
    • Deactivation of the cerebellar vermis, which is considered to be playing a role in pain perception and is thought to be involved with the autonomic nervous system.
    • Activation of the cingulate cortex and inferior prefrontal cortex, which are known to be involved in the generation of autonomic responses.
They say the observed angle changes “clearly demonstrated that this phenomenon is caused by balancing effect of CSM on the alignment of the lumbar spine and the sacrum.” Sorry, but I don’t think it clearly demonstrates anything of the sort.
They think they have demonstrated effects of CSM both in peripheral structures and in the central nervous system, providing a mechanism that would explain the efficacy of CSM. I don’t.
Problems
There are a lot of things that bother me about this study:
    • They are trying to show “how” CSM works without first showing “that” it works.
    • The method they chose to represent chiropractic, activator method, is not representative and has not been validated.
    • There were only 12 subjects.
    • They didn’t use another treatment as a control.
    • The write-up is hopelessly confused, with low back pain morphing into neck pain and shoulder stiffness.
    • CSM procedures are not described. We don’t know what was actually done.
    • They give no rationale for measuring salivary amylase and no explanation of what they think reduced levels might mean.
    • There is no way to know what the changes on MRI and PET imaging really mean. MRIs are only pictures that require careful interpretation and clinical correlation: an abnormal MRI can indicate spine disease but MRIs are also abnormal in a significant percentage of people who don’t have back pain. PET scans are only an indirect indication of what is happening in the brain, highlighting variable areas that could represent either activation or repression of some function. This may not be another dead salmon study, but it may be just as meaningless.
Conclusion: Junk science and bad fishing
In my opinion, this study amounts to junk science and a fishing expedition. They have used sophisticated new toys to produce questionable findings and they have over-interpreted the meaning of the data.
The last sentence in the report was “Further neuroimaging studies are needed on effects of CSM.” I disagree. I think they would be a waste of time, just like this study. 

The New Chiropractic. And I thought SBM had an uphill battle.
Mark Crislip on July 8, 2016
Link


Over at the Society for Science-Based Medicine we have Sisyphus as the logo on the website. Sisyphus, as you may know, is the Greek who had to push a boulder up a hill every day, the archetypal metaphor for futile labor. It was meant to be a bit tongue in cheek, but only a bit. As quackademia proudly expands I sometime feel we were overly optimistic. Perhaps it should have been Prometheus…
But if SBM has it tough, it pales next to the work of Bruce Walker DC, an Australian chiropractor who is calling for The new chiropractic.
His goal is to remake chiropractic, turning it into an evidence-based spine specialty, abandoning all the pseudo-scientific baggage.
I wish him luck. He will need it.
Follow the bouncing ball…er boulder
First, he believes in the benefits of chiropractic.
The “good” can be summed by recognising over a century of improvement to public health by improving pain and disability in countries where chiropractic is practised. It can be asserted that this has provided significant economic savings and improved productivity.
I wonder if this is true. It is of interest that he is the author of a reasonably well done study that demonstrated the worthlessness of spinal manipulative therapy for thoracic pain:
no difference in outcome at any time point for pain or disability when comparing SMT, Graston Technique® or sham therapy for thoracic spine pain, however all groups improved with time.
A result mirrored in a Cochrane review:
Combined chiropractic interventions slightly improved pain and disability in the short term and pain in the medium term for acute/subacute LBP. However, there is currently no evidence that supports or refutes that these interventions provide a clinically meaningful difference for pain or disability in people with LBP when compared to other interventions.
Although like much of the medical literature Newton’s third law applies, for every meta-analysis there is an equal and opposite meta-analysis. If chiropractic manipulation has any unique and reliable effects on pain and disability, it is lost in a sea of poorly done studies. SMT is certainly not at the level of, say penicillin for Streptococcal endocarditis.
He can assert the benefits of chiropractic, but not prove it, and medicine ought not be the same geometric assumptions. His assertion is the one unreferenced statement in the paper and for good reason. That there has been ‘good’ from chiropractic is in the eye of the beholder; I would need a much better lens prescription from my ophthalmologist before I could see it.
Then he lists the “Aberrant practices that cause significant reputational damage to the profession”, which he appears to ascribe to a minority of the field.
    • Adherence to a flawed chiropractic ideology centring on innate intelligence and vitalism
    • Claims of cures for visceral and other non-musculo-skeletal conditions
    • Anti-vaccination propaganda
    • Anti-drug and anti-medicine propaganda
    • Anti-physiotherapy sentiments
    • Misleading and deceptive advertising
    • Open plan clinics where multiple people are treated in the same room fully dressed
    • Unscrupulous contracts of care
    • Over-servicing
    • Obligatory full spine x-rays
    • Use of the term “subluxation” as a valid diagnosis
    • Unnecessary treatment of babies
    • Biologically implausible diagnostic tests and therapies
    • Unfounded claims of decreased immunity from “subluxation” and increased immunity from chiropractic treatment
    • Life time chiropractic care in the name of “wellness”
    • An unhealthy disregard of clinical research, evidence based practice, and non-specific treatment effects including natural history and the placebo effect.
And I would add an
    • unhealthy disregard for patient safety and the potential complications of SMT.
The above list is why this site has so many articles on chiropractic. I can find no information to suggest these are the aberrant practices of a minority. The first three hits on google? One, two, three aberrant practices. The whole profession is a cluster-something-or-other. Cluster-jam. Yeah. That’s the word I was looking for. I think these aberrant practices define chiropractic practice as well as chiropractic educational and professional organizations.
The author would like to make chiropractic a legitimate healthcare partner, making chiropractors musculoskeletal practitioners with an emphasis on skeletal pain. Doing what exactly for patients, since their bread and butter, SMT, has little, if any, meaningful effect on skeletal pain. Or anything else. To paraphrase someone, the good things about chiropractic practice are not unique, the unique things about chiropractic are not good. Once the aberrant practices (I love that term; it would make a great punk band name) are removed what is left? One might as well have a physical therapist, at least one that doesn’t use dry needling.
He does have a 10 point plan for improving the field. All his ideas are excellent until you realize how they have to be applied. Silk purse, sows ear and all that.
Bruce Walker’s ten-point plan
1) He wants a better pre DC education. Not a bad idea. The GPA for chiropractic school in the US is 2.5. C+. The best and the brightest are not becoming DC’s. And what bright student would want to be a chiropractor, new or otherwise? Might as well become a real healthcare provider.
He also thinks that chiropractic colleges should not be accredited if they teach subluxation. Whoa. Good luck with that. It would be like asking Christian Scientists to give up prayer.
2) Become “solely musculoskeletal practitioners with a special emphasis on spinal pain.” Nice in theory. Kind of like podiatrists of the spine, and I value podiatrists.
But do the math. There are 44,000 DCs in the US (and a little over 7,000 infectious disease physicians). Let’s say about 65,000,000 people have back pain at any given time (one of many estimates I found on the interwebs). That’s about 1,400 back pain patients per chiropractor at any given time. If they all go to a DC, that’s about 6 patients a day, about a third needed to support a full time practice. The only option is to get rid of about 2/3 of the chiropractors in the US and most of the chiropractic schools as well since they are pumping 2,900 new graduates a year into the economy (as compared to 218 new ID docs a year). It would be a good start.
With supply vastly outstripping demand, I suspect there are compelling financial reasons for chiropractors to continue income-generating aberrant practices.
3) Chiropractic needs to develop a specialized knowledge outside of chiropractic, a “special interest that sets us apart as experts in a distinctive area.”Perhaps. But first they need to do the same within their field, which is sadly lacking in any specialized knowledge once subluxations and their correction are removed.
My warning. Swallow any milk or coffee before proceeding; laughter with a mouthful of liquid can damage your computer.
4) Marginalization of the nonsensical elements within the profession. As professionals chiropractors should not tolerate colleagues or leadership in the profession who demonstrate aberrant ideas.
Good luck with that. Aberrant ideas are what define the profession. The majority of chiropractic schools, for example, endorse aberrant ideas as their raison d’être.
More than half of the chiropractic colleges in Canada and the United States make unsubstantiated claims for clinical theories or methods on their Web sites. This behavior likely reflects what is taught in the schools. Chiropractors’ quest for greater legitimacy and cultural authority is retarded by this tendency.
5) Be pro-public health: as in pro-vaccination and stop diagnosing babies.
Like the American Chiropractic Association?
The ACA is supportive of a conscience clause or waiver in compulsory vaccination laws thereby maintaining an individual’s right to freedom of choice in health care matters and providing an alternative elective course of action regarding vaccination
6) Support chiropractic organizations that espouse these principals. Such organizations do exist. Much like, I suppose, Latinos for Trump. I suspect they are not representative.
7 & 8 & 9) Are the variations on applying evidence-based practice to improve the profession at all levels.
The problem, of course, is that to apply the evidence for chiropractic, from basic principles to clinical practice would lead to the death of the profession.
And last is the call for chiropractors to grab the bull by the horns and apply these ideas in their own lives.
Sound principles, unlikely in practice
An admirable list of goals. Good luck as their application will be close to impossible. DO schools in the US are now no different than MD schools in the physicians they produce and osteopathic manipulative therapy is fading into the used needle container of history. So I suppose it is possible to make a new chiropractor, much like the New Soviet man. We know how well that worked.
There may be the odd chiropractic gadfly and reformer, but as a connoisseur of pseudo-medicine I just do not see that the field as a whole has what it takes to change for the better.
And it is not like science-based medicine has a snowball’s chance in hell of altering the course of the current quackademic tsunami. Aberrant practices bring in the bucks from Stanford to Harvard and points in between. Medicine doesn’t marginalize the nonsensical elements within the profession and tolerates colleagues or leadership who demonstrate aberrant ideas. In medicine aberrant practices get academic appointments in the division of Integrative Medicine. Pot? Meet kettle.
“Oho!” said the pot to the kettle;“You are aberrant, unscientific and quack!Sure no one would think you were rational metal,Except when you’re given a crack.”
“Not so! not so!” kettle said to the pot;“‘Tis your own aberrant image you see;For I am so scientific – without blemish or blot –That your quackery is mirrored in me.
If reality-based medicine is embracing aberrant practices, can chiropractic ever make the same shift, much less in a generation? I hope so, but I just do not see even the hint of a suggestion of a possibility that in the US chiropractors are adhering to the wisdom of 1 Corinthians 13:11
When I was a chiropractor, I spoke as a chiropractor, I understood as a chiropractor, I thought as a chiropractor; but when I became an evidence-based practitioner, I put away chiropractic things.

Chiropractic Moves into Transportation
Mark Crislip on June 10, 2016
Link
I debated which of two topics to blog about this week that appeared in my feeds.
The first was “Graduate slams CQU for offering ‘pseudoscience degree’,” where an Australian is upset that her University is offering an undergraduate Bachelor of Science in Chiropractic and a postgraduate Master of Clinical Chiropractic degree because chiropractic is “complete pseudoscience”.
And the second was:“Foundation for Chiropractic Progress Publishes Landmark White Paper : Non-Pharmaceutical Pain Management is a Safer Strategy than Opioids.”
Why choose? Just keep in mind that chiropractic is “complete pseudoscience” as we look at the landmark white paper.
First some chiropractic PR
The Foundation for Chiropractic Progress is a not for profit organization that:
…educates the public about chiropractic care through positive press.
It is an interesting site since as best I can tell the word subluxation is nowhere to be found. They are supported by several chiropractic colleges, including the Palmer College of Chiropractic, whose philosophy statement includes:
Chiropractic posits that subluxation of the spinal column and other articulations can affect nervous system function and the expression of health, which may result in symptoms, infirmity and disease.
So I suspect the nonsense that is subluxation is part of their world view.
They are curiously vague as to just what chiropractic is and what chiropractors do, but they do suggest that chiropractic is safe and effective. In fact, in a colorful and glossy pdf (can pdf’s be glossy?) they suggest chiropractic is a safer strategy than opioids for back pain.
This appears to be the current push of chiropractic: to position the profession as the best provider of treatment for acute and chronic back pain. And I fear it is going to work.
They start out with the issues that modern medicine has with chronic pain and opiate use and abuse. No real argument there.
There is a nice patina of conspiracy mongering in the white paper:
When combined with the relentless pursuit of financial gain, these circumstances are magnified many times over by the nation’s drug manufacturers
And the evil of the pain-profit nexus, where:
we are facing a situation where the good intention of pain relief was upended by special interests.
There are those who find these conspiracy arguments compelling, but is always hard to take the aluminum hat crowd seriously, especially when they are shills of big supplement to the tune of over a million dollars, and over a million dollars from big shoe inserts.
The supplement-insert-chiropractic-profit nexus looks like they are getting ready to give the pain-profit nexus a run for, well, their money.
Cherry Pickin’ Daddies
I love their song, Subluxation Riot.
What is the solution for the problem of chronic pain and opiate abuse? Go to Midas, get a muffler. The supplement-insert-chiropractic-profit nexus suggests?
Chiropractic, the aforementioned pseudoscience.
Chiropractic care is a hands on, non-invasive approach documented to be effective in the acute and chronic neuro-musculoskeletal pain environment, yielding improved clinical outcomes, reduced costs and high levels of patient satisfaction. Chiropractic patients may receive spinal adjustments and/or alternative drugless therapies that assist the innate capabilities of the body to relieve pain, restore health and prevent disease. Chiropractic adjustments may aid in musculoskeletal mobilization to reduce pain and improve function.
I love the weaselly ‘may’; at least they have the courage of their convictions. Even the white paper channels the quack Miranda.
Effective? The most recent Cochrane reviews suggests:
High quality evidence suggests that there is no clinically relevant difference between SMT and other interventions for reducing pain and improving function in patients with chronic low-back pain. Determining cost-effectiveness of care has high priority. Further research is likely to have an important impact on our confidence in the estimate of effect in relation to inert interventions and sham SMT, and data related to recovery.
And:
Combined chiropractic interventions slightly improved pain and disability in the short-term and pain in the medium-term for acute and subacute LBP. However, there is currently no evidence that supports or refutes that these interventions provide a clinically meaningful difference for pain or disability in people with LBP when compared to other interventions.
The supplement-insert-chiropractic-profit nexus somehow fails to mention just how thin the gruel of their data is. Which comes as no surprise given that chiropractic is based on fantasy.
The ‘other interventions’ also do not have the potential for complications of chiropractic like stroke, that chiropractors work so hard to deny.
They do note:
The peer-reviewed scientific literature evaluating the effectiveness of U.S. chiropractic treatment for patients with back and neck pain suggests that these treatments are at least as effective as other widely used treatments.
“Suggests”. “At least as effective”. “May”. That is one strong foundation upon which to build the care of chronic pain.
I’ll take the other therapies: they are not based in magic, they do not have the risks of adverse reactions, and are not often linked with other wackaloon modalities and ideas promulgated by many in the supplement-insert-chiropractic-profit nexus like applied kinesiology, supplements, and anti-vaccination.
Like philosophers at a computer, they finish with a series of demands which I will ignore, such that reality based physicians should
begin prescribing safer alternatives such as chiropractic care for chronic pain management.
I’ll pass. Safer? Sure. But the supplement-insert-chiropractic-profit nexus? I’ll pass. I’ll stick with reality-based interventions.
And who puts profits before patients?
The white paper suggests:
The time has come for putting patient safety and health above self-interest and profits.
As if the supplement-insert-chiropractic-profit nexus has ever had any interest in safety. The supplement-insert-chiropractic-profit nexus is a topic in my feeds dominated by links for practice building aka self-interest and profits. Safety and efficacy? Not so much.The white paper reminds me of Ben Goldacre’s immortal phrase: FLAWS IN AIRCRAFT DESIGN DO NOT PROVE THE EXISTENCE OF MAGIC CARPETS.

The Time a Pulitzer Prize Winning Journalist Got Manipulated by a Chiropractor
Clay Jones on October 23, 2015
Link


Katherine Ellison won a Pulitzer Prize in 1985, not for science journalism but for coverage of the monetary mayhem perpetrated by Ferdinand and Imelda Marcos on the people of the Philippines. I was nine at the time and have little recollection of the impact of her work, but I will assume that it was meaningful in light of the award. And she went on to win numerous additional accolades for her writing on politics, economics, and human rights.
Her most recent work, “Chiropractic Care Grows, and Gains Acceptance“, will likely not be considered for any journalism awards. The article, published on the New York Times Health and Wellness blog, reveals a terribly flawed understanding of chiropractic practice and philosophy and a preternatural ability to interpret fleecing at the hands of an obvious quack as a positive experience. She displays few if any signs of an ability to think critically when it comes to medicine and gives no indication of having done more than cursory research on the subject of chiropractic.
Sometimes the apple does fall far from the tree
The inspiration for Ellison’s article was a trip to the chiropractor after having injured her tail bone during a spin class. She does this despite having grown up with a surgeon father who apparently did not think highly of “alternative healers,” particularly chiropractors. Right off the bat she brings up the history of the AMA’s stance on the chiropractic profession:
Of course, this was in the 1960s, when the American Medical Association was still waging war on the profession via its Committee on Quackery, which labeled chiropractors as an “unscientific cult.”
And:
The A.M.A.’s Committee on Quackery is long defunct, having gone out of existence after a lawsuit by chiropractors led to a 1987 federal district judge’s ruling that the medical association had tried to destroy the chiropractic profession.
Well, not exactly. The AMA absolutely was vehemently opposed to chiropractic and its practitioners and, as Dr. Harriet Hall describes, they are far from beyond reproach in the methods they used. In fact, I think you would be hard pressed to find anyone that would defend their tactics today. But the Committee on Quackery actually disbanded in 1974, two years prior to the filing of the infamous Wilk v. AMA antitrust lawsuit and at a time when all 50 states were licensing chiropractors. Louisiana, as backwards as my home state can be when it comes to science and medicine, was the last to give in that same year.
Ellison seems to imply, as countless chiropractors have outright claimed, that the final verdict supported the validity of the chiropractic profession and that the goal of the AMA anti-chiropractic efforts was to limit competition for financial reasons. In reality, Judge Getzendanner found that the AMA violated Section 1 of the Sherman Antitrust Act, but not Section 2. Essentially what the AMA did was illegal, but they met the burden of proof for their defense that “the dominant factor was patient care and the AMA’s subjective belief that chiropractic was not in the best interests of patients.” She also clearly stated that the ruling should not be interpreted as an endorsement of chiropractic as a science-based modality.
Ellison continues:
Since then, the number of chiropractors has steadily grown. Today it seems as if everyone I know is seeing one — and not just for the standard hands-on treatment of lower-back pain, but for an expanding range of interventions falling under the rubric of “integrative wellness.”
According to the most recent data on the use of various forms of irregular medicine in the United States, which Jann Bellamy discussed back in February, 8.4% of Americans underwent “chiropractic or osteopathic manipulation” during the previous 12 months. This is actually down a bit from the 2007 data, but it’s close enough to say no growth in my opinion. Even assuming that the vast majority represented visits to the chiropractor rather than a Doctor of Osteopathy, that’s not a huge number. I imagine that confirmation bias is playing a large role in her perception, or perhaps there is some selection bias to acceptance into the Ellison circle of trust.
Chiropractic tries to reach more than the spine
It is absolutely correct that many chiropractic patients are subjected to spinal manipulation geared towards treating or preventing a wide variety of complaints and conditions, not simply lower-back pain. We have documented myriad examples on Science-Based Medicine. But the most common reason overall remains musculoskeletal symptoms, primarily lower back pain.
Claiming to manage non-musculoskeletal conditions is not a new phenomenon. The first condition ever cured by Daniel David Palmer, according to him, was deafness. Today many chiropractors also employ non-manipulative treatments such as vitamins and supplements, conveniently sold at the front desk of course, as well as acupuncture, homeopathy, and reflexology. You can even get an Iridology Analysis Scan from Dr. Nick (not that you should). I wonder if he also treats Bonus Eruptus.
The more recent development is the use of terms like “integrative wellness.” The concept of integrating unscientific testing and treatments with science-based medicine, like mixing cow pie into your apple pie in the hope of improving the flavor, is primarily a marketing strategy cleverly designed to serve as a spoonful of sugar to help quackery go down the gullets of as many people as possible. It has worked spectacularly, even convincing leading academic medical facilities of the miracles of chiropractic. David Gorski’s recent post on the evolution of the NCCIH covers this in detail. But to be clear, the “expanding range of interventions” of which she speaks are those which have not been shown safe or effective, and are thus not part of the consensus standard of medical care.
Argument from Employment Opportunity: A new fallacy
Ellison digs her hole a little deeper:
The American Chiropractic Association estimates that there will be 80,000 chiropractors in the United States by 2020, up from 58,000 in 2010, with chiropractic colleges graduating about 3,000 new practitioners each year.
Even if true, so what? An Argument from Employment Opportunity doesn’t support safety or efficacy, but it does help put paying students in the chiropractic colleges. I’m sure that their practice building firms wouldn’t disagree considering that more chiropractors means more need for their services.
A 2007 study found that more than 18 million Americans had been treated with spinal manipulation, the core of chiropractic practice, during the previous year, a number that has likely increased since then.
No need to guess. It hasn’t. I already linked to the updated NHIS survey released several months ago which showed no increase in chiropractic care since 2007. I guess her “research” missed that. And don’t forget, some of those manipulations were provided by an osteopathic doctor rather than a chiropractor.Increasingly, spinal manipulation is being offered by physical therapists without all the baggage. Spinal manipulation, primarily for acute lower back pain of less than 6 weeks duration, does have an evidence base. But what chiropractors do that might provide benefit isn’t unique to chiropractic, and what is unique provides no benefit beyond the illusion of placebo.
The “experts” weight in
Ellison quotes a few believers in chiropractic, but after a nebulous assertion of efficacy (“It’s mainstream because it works”) by the former team chiropractor for the Golden State Warriors, the others are hardly ringing endorsements. A spokesman for the American Academy of Orthopedic Surgeons admits that chiropractic is fairly low risk if used for low-back pain, and implies it might help decrease the need for opioids. This is probably true in some situations as some chiropractic techniques are about as good as doing physical therapy or taking ibuprofen.
Dr. Richard Deyo, a professor of evidence-based medicine at Oregon Health and Science University describes chiropractic as “a reasonable alternative” to conventional medical care for back pain because it “may be approximately as effective.” He cites this and successful lobbying as reasons for increasing referrals from medical doctors. Deyo’s explanation for how chiropractic might help back pain primarily involves relaxation and placebo effects, including simple regression to the mean and the self-limited nature of back problems.
Deyo, who is clearly the only voice of reason involved in the piece, does comment on chiropractic management of conditions other than back pain, including diabetes and thyroid disease. He’s skeptical. But Ellison, even after confirming that “some chiropractors claimed to offer such therapies as pendulum divination, biological terrain assessment and herbal crystallization analysis,” doesn’t appear to be.
After handwaving the risk of vertebral artery dissection and stroke associated with manipulation of the cervical spine, Ellison quotes the president of a chiropractic college on their educational standards:
The standard is four to five years of postgraduate study at a chiropractic college and at least one year of supervised patient care. Before chiropractors can practice, they must also pass a national exam and be licensed by their state. The American Chiropractic Association says the training is similar to that at medical school.
The subject of chiropractic education has come up numerous times on Science-Based Medicine because of claims such as this that are often made to support the treatment of non-musculoskeletal conditions. Or even in defense of chiropractors’ attempts to become primary care practitioners, something which truly frightens me. Chiropractic education’s only similarity with that of medical education is the total number of hours and the names of a few classes. And the “national exam” is designed within the profession. It isn’t as if the American Academy of Pediatrics signed off on their competence in pediatric care.
The manipulation begins
Ellison’s trip to the chiropractor, encouraged by one of her aforementioned friends, is a complete disaster from beginning to end. She admits to being surprised by the fact that she has to pay cash, because many chiropractors don’t want the hassle of dealing with insurance companies, and then to “stunned acquiescence” when put through a “three-hour wellness exam, with more than $300 in extra charges.” In a classic bait-and-switch scam, she had been told by the receptionist that the visit would only cost $125.
The chiropractor evaluated Ellison with “various instruments,” discovering a litany of classic bogus diagnoses including chronic Lyme disease and candida infection. If she really does have thrush, she has a lot more to worry about than her tail bone. He apparently also practices iridology as he was worried about a “brown spot” on her right eye. Also among the possible conditions she was suffering from was a loss of bone density. Remember that one.
Ellison jokes about the tail bone, where her actual symptoms are, being connected to the “smile bone” because she was told that she had an asymmetrical smile. It’s almost as if on some level she gets how utterly ridiculous her encounter is. She then botches a brief summation of the origin of chiropractic, simply describing it as the theory that “everything is connected,” and that impairment of the nervous system can cause a variety of health problems. She clearly did a very shallow dive into these murky waters and I don’t think she can even swim.
Here is where I kind of feel sorry for her, where it becomes truly clear how she is a victim in all of this. She describes having identified as a generally healthy older woman prior to the encounter, but left the visit feeling vulnerable, like “a walking time bomb” with a host of newly discovered health problems to worry over. This anxiety played a role in her agreeing to expensive and almost certainly unnecessary x-rays, although she found the resolve to turn down a selection of his exclusive vitamin supplements. After all of this she undergoes a brief manipulation of the tail bone, and probably unnecessary ultrasound therapy which added $70 dollars to her bill without her knowledge.
The verdict is in
Ellison, despite leaving the unnamed chiropractor’s office having been misled, robbed of hundreds of dollars, and still suffering from her coccydynia, draws no firm conclusions. She believes that the jury is still out. After weeks pass and her pain finally subsides, as is the natural course in many cases with conservative management, she wonders if “that 15 minutes of touch and heat” may have played a role in her recovery.
She bends over backwards to find something positive to attribute directly to the chiropractor, giving him credit for discovering her decreased bone density. But did he? Roughly a third of post-menopausal women have decreased bone density, and if she happens to have a family history of osteoporosis, and mentioned that, his odds of guessing correctly would be even higher.
Ellison describes being tested with “various instruments” that also raised concerns for candida infection in her mouth and muscle atrophy in her extremities. Only extremely dubious diagnostic devices are used to make such diagnoses. It is possible, if not extremely likely, that he simply mixed in a high probability guess along with the usual bogus maladies.
She was urged to have her bone density tested at a specialist lab, whatever that means, and was found to have osteoporosis. Someone, likely a qualified medical professional, prescribed an actual medication for the condition. I don’t believe that any credit should go to the chiropractor for discovering her osteoporosis, and certainly not for the eventual resolution of her initial complaint of tail bone pain. Ellison on the other hand, citing her research on the subject of “integrative wellness,” would use the services of a chiropractor for future occurrences of serious low back pain. And she plans to encourage her primary care physician to perform “periodic, thorough checkups.”
Ellison claims to have expertise in neuroscience, and has written a book on ADHD that will be on shelves next month. Her current New York Times blog post does not inspire confidence in her ability to communicate such a complex condition to the public. ADHD is a common focus of practitioners of medical pseudoscience and I can’t help but wonder what her research on the subject will uncover. I also can’t help but wonder about the quality control at the New York Times.

A Credible Placebo Control for Chiropractic Research
Harriet Hall on October 11, 2016
Link


The research on chiropractic has been far from rigorous. One of the problems is that studies of spinal manipulation therapy (SMT) can’t be double blinded, and it is very difficult to even do single blinding. So most studies resort to non-manipulation control groups like “usual care” or “wait list” or “pain medication.” Those studies are practically guaranteed to lead to false positive conclusions: they make SMT look more effective than it would look if you could provide a control that patients couldn’t distinguish from real SMT.
In a study just published in the European Journal of Neurology, Chaibi et al. successfully used a credible placebo manipulation on patients with migraine. It showed that SMT doesn’t work for migraine, but that’s not news. The news is that it showed how to improve the methodology of SMT studies to get more reliable results.
The study design
It was a prospective three-armed, single-blinded randomized controlled trial (RCT) conducted at a university hospital in Norway. 104 patients who had at least one migraine attack per month were studied over a period of 17 months. The control group continued with their usual pharmacological management, the active treatment group got SMT, and the placebo group got “a sham push maneuver of the lateral edge of the scapula and/or the gluteal region.” I would have thought patients could tell the difference, but they couldn’t. The blinding was successful. They did an “exit poll” after each intervention session, and more than 80% of subjects in both the active treatment and the placebo treatment groups believed they had received SMT.
The results
The number of days with migraine were significantly reduced in all three groups. This is not surprising, because doing anything, even just enrolling patients in a study, usually results in improvement; that’s why we have to use control groups. Initially there was no difference between the three groups. The effect continued in the SMT and placebo groups during follow-up, while it returned to baseline in the usual-care control group. They looked at several secondary outcomes and found some small differences, but they didn’t draw any conclusions from that data. They concluded that the effects in both the SMT and the placebo manipulation groups were “probably a placebo response.”
Adverse effects
Adverse effects were significantly more frequent in the SMT group than in the placebo manipulation group. The most commonly reported ones were local tenderness and tiredness. Fewer than 1% of patients reported other effects including lower back pain, face numbness, nausea, provoked migraine attack, and fatigue in arms. No severe or serious adverse effects were reported. If the patients got neck manipulations, face numbness and nausea might have been worrisome red flags indicating possible vertebral artery dissection and impending stroke.
Why the Gonstead method?
The SMT group was treated with the Gonstead method, with high-velocity, low-amplitude thrusts “directed to spinal biomechanical dysfunction (full spine approach) as diagnosed by standard chiropractic tests at each individual treatment session.” They did not say what those standard chiropractic tests were. According to skeptical chiropractor Sam Homola, those “standard chiropractic tests” are not reliable, and they are meant to diagnose mythical “subluxations.” Why Gonstead? Homola commented, “I cannot imagine why a scientific study would rely upon an entrepreneurial chiropractic treatment method rather than upon generic spinal manipulation.”
The authors did not reveal what parts of the spine were manipulated. Gonstead includes adjustments of the cervical spine, and any benefits of neck manipulation (placebo or otherwise) must be balanced against possible risk of a rare but catastrophic complication: stroke or death.
Can chiropractors relieve migraine?
The authors of this study call it “chiropractic” spinal manipulation therapy (CSMT), and Gonstead is indeed a chiropractic technique. But generic spinal manipulation is not specifically chiropractic; it is also used by DOs and physical therapists. The evidence for the effectiveness of “chiropractic” or SMT for migraine is mixed. Considering the flaws of the positive studies (notably the absence of a credible placebo control group) and the results of this new study, I think it is reasonable to conclude that chiropractic and/or SMT have little or no role to play in the treatment of migraine.
I asked Sam Homola, and here’s what he said:
In my own experience as a chiropractor, I felt that a patient in the throes of a migraine headache got more immediate relief from medication than from any kind of physical treatment. Although spinal manipulation can have some neurophysiological effects, I was never able to determine that manipulating the spine or correcting a subluxation was an effective treatment for a migraine that might be caused by an imbalance in brain chemicals.
Conclusion: a valuable study with two lessons
Lessons learned: (1) don’t use SMT for migraine (2) do use proper placebo controls for research.
The authors state that to their knowledge, this is the first manual-therapy RCT with a documented successful blinding. It’s about time! Any future research on manual therapies should incorporate the kind of sham manipulations, blinding, and verification of successful blinding that these researchers used.
The chiropractic subluxation is a myth. It’s appalling that many chiropractors still endorse D. D. Palmer’s obsolete belief system in the 21st century.

Chiropractic “Research” on Tourette Syndrome: The Trouble with Case Reports…..
Clay Jones on November 23, 2012
Link
I can think of few conditions with clinical features more ideal for establishing a pattern of abuse at the hands of practitioners of so-called alternative medicine than Tourette syndrome. Tourette syndrome (TS), which first manifests itself in early childhood in the overwhelming majority of patients, is a neurological disorder with infamous motor and vocal manifestations and a troubled past. Historically the condition was blamed on everything from emotional disturbances to outright faking to demon possession. But over the past few decades it has increasingly been recognized as a primarily organic disorder caused by negative genetic and environmental influences on areas in the brain which control movement and behavior.
I have a particular interest in Tourette syndrome, not just because I am a pediatrician but because I was diagnosed with the disorder at the age of seven. I have been lucky in that my symptoms, after a few rocky years in middle school and early high school, have been fairly mild. It is obvious to most people that I have a movement disorder, but it has never impacted my ability to function in society and succeed in my chosen profession of pediatric medicine. In fact, I often think of my Tourette’s as a positive aspect of my life, believing that it helped shape who I am as a person. I feel that it has helped instill in me positive personality attributes that are beneficial in the practice of medicine, such as empathy and compassion.
Patients that would have been institutionalized a hundred years ago, or worse as you go farther back in time, are now treated based on scientific advances in neuroscience and pharmacology, typically very successfully — that is if they manage to avoid involvement with quacks and charlatans. A 2009 survey of TS patients, or parents of patients with TS, revealed that nearly two thirds partake in alternative therapies with no proven benefit.
Until fairly recently, TS was considered by experts to be inherited in an autosomal dominant pattern. That is, there would be a 50% chance that the child of an individual with TS would inherit the gene or genes involved. The present and more nuanced consensus is that the condition is significantly more complex, with variable expression and incomplete penetrance. In other words, far less than 50% of children at risk of inheriting the condition show any symptoms at all, and the symptom severity in those that do does not correlate well with symptom severity of the parent. A father with very mild TS may have a child with symptoms severe enough to impact function and quality of life dramatically, or one that is similarly affected. While candidates do exist (SLITRK1 gene on chromosome 13q31.1), the genetic basis has not been hammered out by researchers in any clinically meaningful way.
The Tourette syndrome tic
The most recognizable feature of TS is the tic. These are sudden, short-lived and seemingly random movements or vocalizations which exist in the grey area between voluntary and involuntary. By that I mean that although they are generally considered involuntary, and they certainly can take patients by surprise, tics can typically be suppressed voluntarily and patients can learn to use purposeful and less socially awkward movements to dissipate the premonitory urge universally described by patients with the condition. Think of it as a sort of internal itch, maddening at times, that only certain movements or vocalizations can scratch. It is a near constant source of frustration and annoyance in many patients with TS.
Tics can be simple movements, such as eye blinking, grimacing, or jerking of the head and neck, or surprisingly complex behaviors, even ritualistic. They can be violent or subtle, easy to conceal or extremely disruptive. Vocalizations follow a similar pattern of simple and more complex noises. Grunting, throat clearing, and sniffing are extremely common but the most widely known form, thanks to a number of misleading characterizations of TS in movies and on television for comic effect, is that of coprolalia. This symptom of TS, which occurs in ten to forty percent of cases, involves the involuntary utterance of obscene words. Of note copropraxia, when complex motor tics take the form of obscene gestures, is also not uncommon.
Motor tics and vocalizations (which are really just motor tics as well if you think about it) are unfortunately not the only manifestations of TS. ADHD and OCD are quite common comorbid conditions, along with anxiety and mood disorders, migraines, sleep disorders, and even cervical artery dissection from forceful jerking of the neck. Botulinum toxin (Botox) is actually a science based treatment successfully used in a number of TS patients with severe motor tics. It can even help with vocal tics when lower decibel vocalizations are desired. How’s that for an all-natural remedy? In some patients, the comorbid conditions are considered worse than the tics, which can help guide treatment. A patient with severe ADHD, for instance, may benefit from stimulant medication, which may indirectly improve tic severity.
Once felt to be quite rare, we now know that TS is a common cause of tics, although most children with tics don’t have it. Transient tic disorders that last less than one year and do not meet diagnostic criteria for TS are far more common. TS is believed to occur in about 8 children out of every 1000, and is considerably more common in boys. Diagnosis typically occurs around age 7 years but tics can appear up to age 18 (some say 21). A small percentage of those diagnosed actually require any form of treatment, although some are debilitated by the tics and comorbidities.
Alternative medicine and Tourette syndrome
Many patients with TS, even milder forms, seek guidance, reassurance and treatment from medical professionals. Unfortunately, as noted above, some seek out care from practitioners of what I like to call irregular medicine, but is more commonly known as complementary and alternative (CAM) or integrative (IM) medicine. Why they do this is actually easy to understand considering how pervasive CAM has become, even infiltrating our top-tier academic medical centers and boasting well-funded government agencies like the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM). The media credulously reports findings published in questionable journals or simply regurgitates press releases. And skeptics are often portrayed as foolish, or worse, closed-minded.
Alternative medicine, however, is championed by well-known celebrity practitioners and supporters able to reach millions with a seemingly ubiquitous presence on television and in print media. Silver-tongued gurus and their snake-oil spouting minions take full advantage of the large percentage of “shruggies” in the practice of medicine. Reality takes a backseat to belief and patients suffer the consequences. But despite the success they have had without it, proponents of alternative medicine still crave the legitimacy of science and publication in peer reviewed journals.
The most common incursion of alternative medicine into published journals, most of which have impact factors only appreciable with the aid of a high-powered magnification device, is in the form of the case study. A rigorously documented case study can be a valuable thing, even if its place in the hierarchy of evidence is above only the undocumented anecdote or testimonial. They can be particularly useful in determining that an all-inclusive assumption is in error, the classic example being that the existence of even one black swan disproves the statement that all swans are white. Case reports can also be helpful, especially in series, in guiding future research. And in instances of rare conditions, case reports may be all that is available to guide therapy. But a case report, regardless of how well it is documented or of how good a journal it is published in, is incapable of answering the question of cause and effect. They can lead a researcher to come up with a dandy hypothesis or, as occurs with much higher frequency, to waste time and money on a wild goose chase. A physician simply can’t say that a treatment works with anything resembling confidence based on case reports. Prior plausibility as well as the totality of the medical literature must be taken into account.
I have never needed treatment of any kind for my Tourette’s, but I have tried to keep up with the literature on various therapies, pharmaceutical or otherwise, for the condition. I usually stick to reputable sources but every now and then I like to go “slumming” in the world of chiropractic research. During my last trip across the border between science and pseudoscience, I discovered a gem which perfectly illustrates the trouble with case reports and with chiropractic (well, alternative medicine in general). I stumbled on a press release for a case report published in late 2009 in the Journal of Pediatric, Maternal & Family Health — Chiropractic involving the year-long treatment of TS in a 20-year-old female. (Barbara Loe Fisher, founder of the rabidly antivaccine National Vaccine Information Center sits on the editorial board of this journal.) Not unexpectedly, the results were reported as positive.
A Google search using “chiropractic for Tourette’s” reveals over 300,000 results, with many (I stopped counting at 100) individual chiropractors referencing this particular case report when calling for patients with TS to come in for treatment. They were not equivocal on the subject either but then again practitioners of alternative medicine don’t tend to care much for nuance and subtlety. Warning bells should go off whenever a proposed abnormality, be it the chiropractic subluxation, stagnant chi, or liver fluke infection, causes every problem and has a quick and easy, though often pricey, solution. So chiropractors are claiming to be able to cure or significantly impact the symptoms of TS, and this is the proof. Or is it?
The answer is of course no, but I’ll explain.
Tourette syndrome: perfect for fooling patients and practitioners
Once again, TS is a condition perfectly suited for fooling patients and practitioners into thinking their intervention helped, primarily via a number of placebo effects. It waxes and wanes in severity, with many sufferers experiencing periods of time during which their tics aren’t as forceful or frequent. TS is generally at its peak in early adolescence, or about ten years after diagnosis for most patients. But, and I hope this clearly shows why using this case report as anything other than lining your child’s hamster cage overestimates its worth, two-thirds of TS patients experience remission or significant amelioration of their tics in late adolescence or early adulthood. The patient described in this case report was 20-years-old and the treatment took place over an entire year. It is very possible, if not highly likely, that the patient’s symptoms would have improved regardless of the therapy she sought out. Not taking into account the natural course of a condition tends to occur when you lack experience in diagnosing and caring for patients with that condition, and when your background in pediatric pathophysiology involves a weekend course held at the airport Howard Johnson. I’d say it’s a rookie mistake, but chiropractic was invented in 1895.
The tics, whether motor or vocal, simple or complex, experienced by TS patients are unique. They can be suppressed, for a time, only to come back with a vengeance eventually (car rides home after job interviews for instance). They are suggestible. They are affected by stress and fatigue. And, like pain, there is a considerable subjective component to each individual patient’s ability to cope with these movements and outbursts. One patient’s suffering with the condition may be much greater than another’s despite having the same tics at the same frequency in the same location.
The potential factors at play are too numerous to list but to give one example, my most obvious tic, where I forcefully jerk my left arm outward and vigorously flex and extend my arm several times until it “feels right” doesn’t bother me when I’m sitting in bed reading a good book, my bedside lamp safely out of reach and loving wife on my “good side”. But ask me how I feel when sitting in a crowded movie theater with a stranger on my left who I really don’t want to elbow in the face. Now what if I had a stressful job that required long shifts in close quarters? Life could be pretty miserable. Life might suddenly become much less miserable if I was moved to a different location that allowed for more breathing room and less chance of injuring a co-worker or losing an arm. I might report a definite improvement in my quality of life, decreased stress, and subsequent decrease in severity of tics simply because my boss took my condition into account.
We don’t know what else was going on in the life of the patient in this case report. We don’t know about changes in her life that might have decreased (or even increased) her anxiety. Perhaps simply receiving hands on treatment from a perceived authority figure adamantly claiming a high rate of success resulted in less stress and fewer tics. We don’t know if her improvement was simply a regression to the mean. All we know is that she reported an improvement after a year of chiropractic care. Correlation does not necessarily equal causation as the old saying goes.
Another aspect of placebo effects involves reporting bias. Patients who are emotionally invested in a therapy are more likely to report positive results. Patients who like their physician or other practitioner, such as a chiropractor for instance, are more likely to report positive results. Patients in a study, or who are going to be written about in a case report, are more likely to report positive results. This may stem from a Hawthorne effect or from simply not wanting to feel like they let somebody down who stands to gain from positive results. There are other well established psychological entities, such as cognitive dissonance theory, that motivate positive reporting. Nobody wants to feel foolish, for instance, wasting a year of their life and the money required to do it on a failed therapy. None of these effects can be accounted for in case reports such as this.
But is this case report even useful as a hypothesis generator? Does it support the authors’ calls for more research into the chiropractic subluxation as the etiology of TS and chiropractic spinal manipulation as treatment? Once again, the answer is no. While the exact cause of TS is not established, there is expert consensus that it has a genetic origin and involves connections between the cortex and subcortex leading to abnormal synaptic neurotransmission. Some experts have raised the possibility of an autoimmune etiology, particularly related to infection with Group A Strep, but this is highly controversial. There is absolutely no legitimate concern that impairment of spinal nerves, as is claimed to occur in the presence of chiropractic subluxation, is a factor. Sure there have been instances where experts have been wrong, and as a skeptic I always leave room for surprising discoveries, but the evidence required to overturn the current consensus would need to be extraordinary.
Conclusion
Testimonials, anecdotes and case reports are frequently used as evidence to support a variety of alternative therapies, not just chiropractic. Acupuncture, for example, has also achieved wide acceptance by the public and many in the medical field despite negative outcomes in large and well-designed prospective studies. Anecdotes and a number of logical fallacies such as arguments from antiquity and popularity, and successful appeals to magical thinking are more powerful than any placebo-controlled double blinded machination of “western” science, it seems. The conditions necessary to achieve a positive result, or at least positive reporting, in patients with self-limited and subjective complaints are all too easily set up. And negative case reports don’t tend to be accepted for publication. With a foot in the door, a host of even less plausible therapies, like homeopathy and energy healing, continue to slip through the ever widening crack.
It seems at times that we are fighting a losing battle. I’m not sure what it will take to wake up the sleeping giant — the legion of mistakenly disinterested shruggies whose silence plays such a large role in fostering the current CAM friendly environment. Perhaps economics will force their hand, perhaps patient suffering. I hope that won’t be the case. Perhaps reason will one day prevail.
There is cause for hope. The Tourette Syndrome Association, a highly respected organization which has done a great deal for patients with the condition, addresses the issue of unproven alternative therapies for TS in a policy statement. It is well reasoned and calls for proponents of unproven therapies to apply for research money and prove it. They clearly get it. For more in depth analysis of the use of CAM modalities in TS, check out the discussion by Dr. Katie Kompoliti, an Associate Professor of Neurological Sciences at Rush University Medical Center, provided by the TSA.

Not Mine
Any medicine that is not science-based is not mine, nor is it SBM’s
Mark Crislip on April 28, 2026
Link

“Chiropractors are my kind of people.”
RFK Jr. to Chiropractors
Not certain who was more insulted, although it appears both sides considered it a compliment. He went on to say,
The people who are drawn to this field are people who do critical thinking, who are willing to question orthodoxies and have the courage to stand up against these orthodoxies.
Well, critical thinking and chiropractic go together like the proverbial water and oil. It appears from this article that RFK Jr.’s ascent has been a huge opportunity for the cult of chiropractic.
It makes me miss the old days of SBM, when SCAMs were the fringe, not the establishment.
But I thought it would be fun. Yes, fun. I actually enjoy this sort of thing: review the medical literature from the last year, the first RFK Jr. year, and see what these courageous critical thinking orthodoxy questioners have come up with in their pursuit of making America healthy again. Here’s a hint: ain’t vaccines.
A couple of things. First, I am going to focus on clinical trials and some reviews, as there are 441 plus hits in the last year for references on the Pubmeds using ‘chiropractic’. So I will choose articles that I find relevant or amusing.
Second, in interpreting the articles, keep in mind that being hands-on, chiropractic has the potential for both a massive placebo effect and a real physical effect. And when I say chiropractic, he says in his best Humpty Dumpty voice, I am specifically mean fixing mythical subluxations to improve the flow of the equally mythical inane, er I mean innate intelligence. Neither more nor less.
Third, chiropractic practice is variable, from the reasonable and thoughtful Sam Homola to subluxation-adjusting wackaloons. So one often never knows from the literature where a chiropractor lands on the spectrum.
Fourth, I would suppose that the medical literature tilts towards the more reasonable end of the spectrum. For example, there are no papers on chiropractic and vaccines, despite the cult’s usual opposition to vaccines. It is most likely that the more respectable factions of the cult will be represented in the Pubmeds. But not always.
Time to take a trip down old school SBM.

Reviews
As of April 2026, the song remains the same. For issues a spine surgeon might see:
Variability in practice standards, inconsistent informed consent, and poor adverse event reporting limit clarity on Chiropractic lacks an outcomes registry true effectiveness and safety.
Which, given the basics of chiropractic, is how it will always be. Which is why they really need to stop repeating versions of
More robust clinical trials in this area of healthcare are needed.
Efficacy and safety of musculoskeletal manipulations in elderly population with musculoskeletal disorders: a systematic review looked at
trials evaluating the efficacy and safety of MM such as osteopathic manipulation, chiropractic manipulation, myofascial release, craniosacral therapy, as monotherapy or adjunctive therapies in older people (age ≥65 years) with musculoskeletal disorders.
You know the authors are not particularly interested in reality, as there are few SCAMs as wackaloon as craniosacral therapy. And they didn’t find much:
This review provides limited and inconclusive evidence about MM to improve quality of life, pain management and functional status in older adults with musculoskeletal disorders. However, MM appears to be generally safe and well-tolerated.
Limited, meaning most of the time for most issues, no effect.
Exploring Manual Interventions for Infantile Colic: A Scoping Review of the Evidence suggested that
Low-force manual therapies may offer modest short-term relief for colicky infants and improve parental experience
And what were these therapies?
abdominal massage, paediatric Tuina, craniosacral therapy, chiropractic manipulation, osteopathic light touch, reflexology, and acupressure
Really? All different in their treatment and underlying pseudoscience. Suggests colic just gets better with time:
self-limiting nature of the illness as most of the babies grow out of it by the age of 3 to 4 months.
Back in 2024, a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized clinical trials of SMT for migraines showed no benefit and only harms, demonstrating
The effectiveness of SMT for the treatment of migraines remains unproven.
Now there are over 500 hits on PubMed on how evidence needs to guide chiropractic practice. At least until the evidence is against chiropractic. In Critical limitations compromise the conclusions of a recent meta-analysis regarding spinal manipulation and migraine: a commentary, the authors concluded
Given these concerns, patients, clinicians, and stakeholders should be cautious when interpreting the study and determining whether SMT is effective or safe for migraines.
Although for virtually any illness, there is no reason to think SMT would help, so I would expect the river in Egypt to get wider as the evidence flows in.
Clinical Trials
Chiropractic lacks an outcomes registry, making it difficult to evaluate the efficacy of chiropractic. There was one, Spine IQ, that failed. Hm. Probably don’t want to really know outcomes. Handling of truth and all that.
Chiropractic has tried to get on the treatment alternative to opioid bandwagon. Is it effective? Hard to be definitive since interventions are never just chiropractic (see definition above). For example, in Impact of chiropractic care on opioid use for noncancer spine pain: systematic review and meta-analysis, chiropractic care was
receipt of chiropractic care, defined as care provided by a chiropractor, including, but not limited to, spinal manipulation, soft-tissue therapy, education, reassurance, and self-care advice (eg, icing, stretching, and strengthening exercises).
Making it impossible to know if their raison d’etre, spinal manipulation to fix subluxations, does anything. They unimpressively concluded
Our systematic review found very low certainty evidence that receipt of chiropractic care may be associated with lower odds of receiving prescription opioids or initiating long-term opioid use among adults with noncancer spine pain, particularly when chiropractic care is provided earlier vs later. Low certainty evidence shows that receipt of chiropractic care may increase the risk of nonserious adverse events, such as transient stiffness or muscle soreness; however, very low certainty evidence suggests the likelihood of serious opioid-related harms may be reduced.
For headache guidelines
recommendation to use of spinal manipulation for CGH, and for TTH only within multimodal care.
Within multimodal care. Huh. So by itself, chiropractic does nothing? And the multimodal?
Certainty of evidence and strength of recommendations for other nonpharmacological interventions (e.g., acupuncture and exercise) varied. Limitations in evidence precluded strong recommendations for acupuncture, education, meditation/mindfulness, and modalities used in isolation for CGH and electroacupuncture for TTH.
So when chiropractors treat headaches, only use their useless intervention when combined with other equally useless interventions. So much lipstick on a pig.
Remember how chiropractors want to be primary care providers? Taking care of common medical problems like otitis media? There is Misinformation in YouTube Videos About Chiropractic Treatment for Otitis Media to suggest not such a good idea:
Twenty-five videos claimed that chiropractic manipulation could “fix” the Eustachian tube, and 14 videos (28%) asserted nerve correction; none mentioned antibiotics or tympanostomy tubes. Upper‑cervical adjustments (32 videos, 64%) and ear‑massage maneuvers (25 videos, 50%) were the most frequently promoted techniques, despite limited or low‑quality supporting evidence in published literature.
Some studies just leave me unsatisfied. For example, Diagnostic and management concordance between chiropractors and neurosurgeons for patients with low back pain. They made the ever so humorous contention that “chiropractors, known as musculoskeletal experts”, forgetting that the descriptor is self-styled. The omission was whether or not the chiropractors included any of their pseudoscience, like subluxations and leg length discrepancy in the diagnosis. Not mentioned anywhere I could find.
Safety
Safety is important, so it was nice to see Patient safety culture research within the chiropractic profession: a scoping review. The big safety issue we have discussed at SBM is the relationship between neck manipulation and stroke, which chiropractors love to deny, going so far as to suggest a paper that shows an association demonstrates it doesn’t. Ah, that famous chiropractic critical thinking. Instead, they have focused on the rare patient presenting to chiropractors with stroke symptoms. Chiropractors like to brag they have the diagnostic acumen of interns.
But the investigations continue.
Cervical Artery Dissection Diagnosed Following Chiropractic Cervical Manipulation: A STOP-CAD Subanalysis
About 1 in 20 CeAD cases in this registry reported antecedent cervical manipulation. In multivariable binary logistic regression, compared with patients without prior manipulation, those with prior manipulation were younger (OR per year 0.98, 95% CI: 0.97-0.99, P =0.014), more often female (OR: 1.64, 95% CI: 1.21-2.23, P =0.001), less often diabetic (OR: 0.24, 95% CI: 0.08-0.78, P =0.018), presented with neck pain (OR: 2.80, 95% CI: 2.08-3.77, P <0.001), and had higher odds of isolated vertebral artery dissection (OR: 2.15, 95% CI: 1.57-2.94, P <0.001). Recurrent ischemic stroke rates were similar between groups.
Conclusions: Given the very high number of manipulations performed annually, the absolute risk of secondary CeAD is extremely low. Manipulation-associated cases have distinct clinical features, occurring more often in younger women with vertebral dissections. Whether manipulation acts as a precipitating trigger or patients with early CeAD symptoms seek manipulation remains unresolved.
And there was A retrospective search of postmortem examination reports that indicated that death following chiropractic neck manipulation in Australia appears to be a rare event. They found two cases:
This revealed only one case in which chiropractic treatment was considered to have contributed to death. The case was that of an adult male who died from a dissected left vertebral artery following chiropractic manipulation for neck pain. In addition, postmortem records at Forensic Science SA (FSSA) were searched for similar cases over the same time period (approximately 30,000 cases). No cases definitely attributable to chiropractic manipulation of the neck were found, but a case with thrombus in the left vertebral artery would not be entirely excluded as being related to chiropractic treatment. Deaths associated with chiropractic manipulation in Australia therefore appear rare.
I agree it is rare. But death from a useless therapy unhinged from reality seems like a poor way to go.
Serious adverse events associated with conservative physical procedures directed towards the cervical spine: A systematic review
The results confirmed findings of past reviews with most events being vascular (58%) and mainly arterial dissection or vertebral artery related and the majority involving manipulation (75%). However lesser-known SAES ie neurological (25%), combined vascular/neurological (12%) and others (5%) which included cases such as cerebrospinal fluid leaks, phrenic nerve palsies and retinal detachments were identified. Further, some followed procedures such as vestibular testing, gentle mobilization, exercises, acupuncture or even massage.
Which is interesting, Years ago we had a case where the vertebral artery dissection occurred from hyperextension of the neck during yoga. I forget the underlying collagen issues she had.
Me? I would never let a chiropractor near my neck.
Case Reports
Pediatric vertebral artery dissection and ischemic stroke following chiropractic manipulation
The patient encountered in our institution was a 20-month-old male who presented nonspecifically with acute onset of lethargy, vomiting, cyanosis, and respiratory distress. Cerebrovascular imaging revealed a luminal irregularity in the V4 segment of the right vertebral artery, consistent with dissection. The patient’s guardian later provided history of taking the child for cervical chiropractic corrections immediately prior to the patient’s presentation to the emergency department. The patient was managed non operatively and was later discharged without neurological deficit.
Doubt it was the manipulation. More likely the underlying morbidities like smoking and hypertension. Yeah, that’s the ticket.
Acute Spinal Epidural Hematoma: A Serious Complication of Chiropractic Therapy-A Case Report
This case report presents a 48-year-old female patient with a medical history of systemic lupus erythematosus, renal transplantation, and hypertension who developed spinal epidural hematoma after chiropractic manipulation, leading to acute quadriplegia
Nuff said on that one.
Bilateral Thalamic Infarction Due to Artery of Percheron Occlusion in a Young Patient With Hyperhomocysteinemia and Vertebral Artery Dissection
We report the case of a 20-year-old male who was admitted with altered consciousness and nonspecific neurological symptoms. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) demonstrated a characteristic bilateral thalamic infarction consistent with AOP occlusion. Etiological workup revealed hyperhomocysteinemia and a right vertebral artery dissection, the latter suspected to be secondary to chiropractic cervical manipulation. Despite medical treatment and rehabilitation, the patient experienced significant cognitive and motor sequelae.
Complications of Chiropractic Manipulation in a Patient With Von Willebrand Disease: A Clinical Case Report and Literature Review
After chiropractic manipulation, the patient developed severe lumbar and inguinal pain, followed by progressive weakness and sensory impairment of the left lower limb. Imaging revealed a large left iliopsoas hematoma measuring approximately 896 cc, causing femoral nerve compression.
Spontaneous Multiple Cervical Artery Dissections Detected with High-Resolution MRI: A Prospective, Case-Series Study
A history of trauma or chiropractic manipulations, intense physical exercise prior to symptom onset, recent influenza-like illness, and recent childbirth in a young female patient were reported as predisposing risk factors.
Vertebral Artery Dissection Following High Velocity Low Amplitude Cervical Manipulation: A Case Report
We present the case of a 70-year-old female who developed acute expressive aphasia following chiropractic neck manipulation. Imaging revealed a proximal right vertebral artery occlusion with findings suggestive of dissection in the setting of vascular hypoplasia.
See a pattern? So many in the world of SCAM are not fond of the precautionary principle.
My practice dealt with a lot of unusual infections. I was always impressed with all the odd ways people could get sick. Add this one to the list: Delayed Cardiac Perforation Caused by Pacemaker Lead Dislodgement During Chiropractic Therapy
Lead dislodgement was suspected to be caused by prior chiropractic therapy for shoulder rehabilitation.
Chiropractors do love their case reports to show alleged efficacy of their interventions. Well, not always.
We describe the multimodal management of a PSPS-2 patient with a CIS implant presenting to a chiropractic clinic. While no clinically meaningful improvement was observed.
Chiropractic management of L5-S1 disc protrusion in an elite speed skater: a case report would appear to be a success. The management was the usual multimodal; a hodgepodge of interventions, although nothing specifically chiropractic. Case reports being unimpressive, especially given the natural history of disc herniation:
The majority of patients suffering from a radiculopathy caused by a herniated nucleus pulposus (HNP) heal spontaneously without surgery or chemonucleolysis. The clinical course of the radiculopathy varies as well as the efficacy of conservative treatment. In some patients the symptoms decline after a week or two; in others the pain may continue for many months or years. Despite an abundant literature there is still a controversy concerning the treatment of radiculopathies related to ruptured lumbar intervertebral discs.
It’s the title that made me snort: Improvement in Chronic Low Back and Intermittent Chronic Neck Pain, Disability, and Improved Spine Parameters Using Chiropractic BioPhysics® Rehabilitation After 5 Years of Failed Chiropractic Manipulation: A Case Report and 1-Year Follow-Up. He kept seeing the chiropractor on and off for 5 years of failure. That is a whole different kind of manipulation. As is so often the case, when a hodgepodge of exercises was added to therapy, he got better.
Oddities
A review of Chiropractic conspiracy theories and how they are foundational to the cult. I particularly like the
chiropractic’s steadfast commitment to the margins of standardised medical care.
Easy to see why RFK Jr. considers chiropractors his kind of people.
Sometimes the papers make me laugh. An example is Chiropractic evaluation in newborn foals: A preliminary study, where they did chiropractic assessments and tried to find a relationship between foal disease and their imaginary findings. And they couldn’t!
A relationship between joint hypomobility and sickness was found, but the reasons cannot be determined
I wonder why.
Some papers flabbered my gaster. There is a grade school in Wisconsin that has an on-site chiropractic clinic where they hunt down subluxations to treat:
headaches, postural issues, nocturnal enuresis, neurodevelopmental disorders, and back pain.
This paper is amazing, but not in a good way.
Sometimes you run across a paper where you have to giggle, as the author has it right for all the wrong reasons. Case in point was The bi-directional adjustment? where the author did not use the quotes as I would have:
I was pleased to eventually be given a title of “doctor” indicating my “expertise” and “authority”.
I always think of those terms in scare quotes. Glad to see I am not the only one.
Prevalence of imposter phenomenon among chiropractic students at a South African university: A cross-sectional survey. I was surprised it was not 100%. Perhaps more self-reflection?
This showed up in my search, although none of the authors are chiropractors: Effectiveness of epidural amniotic fluid injection for low back pain. Just mull that over.
I’ll end with In Defense of Metaphysics: A Kantian Approach to the Philosophy of Chiropractic, which I found to be gibberish. But I long realized that I lack whatever part of the brain is required for metaphysics or spirituality. Perhaps someone can explain this paper to me in the comments.
Ah. That felt good.

   No-Touch Chiropractic
Harriet Hall
Link
Some time ago, I learned that a Seattle chiropractor, Johanna Hoeller, had been featured on a local TV newsmagazine show. She was so proud of the segment that she had it posted on her web page for all to see. Unfortunately it is no longer there, so I’ll have to tell you what it showed.
She demonstrated her techniques on-camera. She put one wrist on top of the other, held them about an inch away from the patient’s neck and proceeded to produce a cracking sound in her own wrists without touching the patient in any way. The patient claimed to have felt something and to have experienced relief of pain.
The funniest part was when the news crew showed her their video of her performance and pointed out that she had not touched the patient. She appeared to be surprised and responded, “My whole thing is that I’m touching.”
Hoeller practices a form of chiropractic called NUCCA (National Upper Cervical Chiropractic Association). It’s a variant of the hole-in-one idea first proposed by B.J. Palmer, the son of the inventor of chiropractic, D.D. Palmer. Supposedly if you adjust the top cervical vertebra, that will correct any problems in the entire spinal column. Fix one and you fix them all. There is no credible evidence for any of NUCCA’s claims.
So here’s a woman “pretending” to do something that doesn’t work even if you actually “do” it. A little knowledge of psychology easily explains why she has so many satisfied patients. It’s even easy to understand how her experiences may have genuinely convinced her she is doing something effective. What I have trouble imagining is how she first got the idea to try treating without touching in the first place!
I thought this was something the Washington State Chiropractic Quality Assurance Commission should know about, so I reported it to them. I pointed out that state law lists specific techniques approved for use by chiropractors: NUCCA is approved, but no-touch methods are not. If she claims to be treating with NUCCA, she is charging patients for a treatment she did not provide. If she claims to be treating with her own new method, she is using an unapproved method which is not allowed by state law. More importantly, she says she thinks she is touching when she isn’t, indicating that either (1) she is lying, or (2) she is delusional and should have a psychiatric evaluation.
The QAC evaluated my complaint by holding a telephone conference call and deciding not to investigate. They interpreted the video as a dry-run demonstration of what she would do by actually touching the patient.
I filed a second complaint, asking them to reopen the case, and they did. I asked them to view the video again because it clearly showed that she was demonstrating her actual technique, and that she said she thought she was touching when she clearly wasn’t. They still refused to act, because she hadn’t harmed any patients and they apparently thought what she was doing was OK.
I wrote some angry letters to state officials. I asked, if she can pretend to do chiropractic without touching, can I pretend to take out an appendix without touching? If so, there might be a lucrative career in my future. No one answered.
I contacted a professor of chiropractic who claims to be spearheading a reform movement within chiropractic. He was appalled, and brought the case to the attention of a national chiropractic QA organization, hoping they might put pressure on the Washington QAC. Nothing happened.
In September 2007, the Washington QAC finally took action against Hoeller for unprofessional conduct. Allegations include failing to keep adequate treatment and diagnostic records of patients, failing to re-examine a patient after treatment and failing to document a care plan for a patient. They said nothing about her no-touch techniques.
In other words, they didn’t care whether she deceived patients with imaginary hocus pocus as long as she followed them up and kept records of her deceptions.
I wonder… if I had a patient with abdominal pain and I pretended to fix something inside by waving my hands over him, followed him up to document that his pain resolved, and kept meticulous records, could I get away with it? I hope not, but now I’m beginning to wonder. It seems the state of Washington approves of voodoo medicine. 

Chiropractic gimmickry
Sam Homola on August 17, 2012
Link
[Editor’s Note: Today, we have a guest post from Sam Homola, who, as you recall, practiced as a chiropractor until he ultimately realized that there is no evidence that subluxations exist. Since then, he’s discussed in various places, including, we are pleased to say, SBM, his skepticism regarding chiropractic. Enjoy!]
Much has been written (and published on this site) about the implausibility of chiropractic vertebral subluxation theory which proposes that a vertebral subluxation complex or a spinal joint dysfunction “may affect organ system function and general health.” Associated chiropractic gimmickry that might be harmful as well as a waste of time and money should be also be brought to the attention of concerned consumers. As a chiropractor (retired) who has renounced subluxation theory, it might be helpful to share my concerns about some dubious chiropractic methods that are foisted upon an unsuspecting public, unchallenged in the market place.
The Neck Curve Pitch
I often receive mail expressing concern about treatment or services provided by a chiropractor. One of the most common concerns comes from chiropractic patients who have been told that they have a flattened or reversed cervical curve that portends dire consequences if the normal cervical curve is not restored. The patients are informed that failure to undergo a treatment program to realign the cervical vertebrae will allow degenerative changes to occur, progressing to “Stage 4 degeneration” that will trigger the development of life-threatening illness. Frightened by such scare tactics, these patients are usually persuaded to undergo a long course of neck treatment, which may involve use of a special traction harness to force hyper extension of the cervical spine.
It is not unusual for some individuals to have a straight cervical spine or some reversal of the normal cervical curve and have no symptoms at all. Such deviations from normal may be structural in nature, usually cannot be changed, and are not often significant. A cervical curve can be temporarily altered when neck muscles are in spasm, but the curve (or lack of curve) that is normal for the individual returns when the spasm subsides. When there is no pain or loss of mobility in the neck or cervical spine, no treatment is needed. Any attempt to “restore the normal cervical curve” by using manipulation or forced cervical extension is unnecessary and may subject the patient to risk of injury to vertebral arteries.
Stretching the Truth
One of the most popular forms of treatment currently being offered by chiropractors is a form of motorized computer-controlled traction called “decompression therapy.” It is an expensive form of axial or longitudinal traction provided by machines that cost up to $125,000. While any form of traction might be helpful in relieving some types of back pain, promoters of decompression therapy claim that using a computer-driven table to control the level of disc decompression will rehydrate and restore a disc structure by pulling nutrients into ruptured or degenerated disc cartilage. Advertisements promoting decompression therapy often suggest that surgery for a herniated disc can be avoided by using decompression therapy to “restore the disc.” There is no credible evidence to support this contention.
Expensive decompression therapy is unlikely to be any more effective that simple mechanical or manual manipulative traction in the treatment of back pain or disc herniation. According to a current Aetna Bulletin (No. 0180) dealing with vertebral axial decompression therapy, “…there is no adequate scientific evidence that proves that vertebral axial decompression is an effective adjunct to conservative therapy for back pain. In addition, vertebral axial decompression devices have not been adequately studied as alternatives to back surgery.”
Consumers should beware of testimonials extolling the miracle cures of decompression therapy, and they should refuse to pay for a course of traction treatments that may cost several thousand dollars. Patients are often enticed into paying for such treatment in advance in order to reduce the cost of the treatment.
When there is no progressive neurological damage caused by disc herniation, disc surgery is rarely needed or indicated. With time, the disc protrusion will be absorbed and the ruptured disc cartilage will degenerate, with or without treatment, as it would normally do after disc surgery. While a degenerated disc can cause some chronic or recurring back pain, nerve root encroachment rarely occurs unless there is spur formation or bony overgrowth near the intervertebral foramen (where a spinal nerve passes between two vertebrae).
Locating Imaginary Subluxations
Many chiropractors maintain that they can use fingertip palpation to locate vertebral subluxations. Some use computerized instruments that combine thermography with surface electromyography to measure skin temperature differentials and electrical activity in muscles claimed to be associated with vertebral subluxations. A hand-held scanning device is moved up and down the spine, in contact with the skin, measuring electrical activity or skin temperature on each side of the spine. The results appear on a screen that displays graphic bar colors alleged to indicate the location of subluxated vertebrae. Even when there are no physical or neurological symptoms, such testing may be used to persuade a patient to undergo treatment for correction of multiple vertebral subluxations in order to prevent the development of symptoms.
While surface electromyography (not to be confused with needle electromyography) testing might be helpful in evaluating the function of muscles, and thermography might be helpful in detecting the symptoms of such things as reflex sympathetic dystrophy (an autonomic disturbance affecting blood flow to the skin), it is an oxymoron to suggest that either of these tests can locate a chiropractic subluxation that has never been proven to exist. Thermography and surface electromyography are considered to be experimental and investigational with no established validity as diagnostic techniques.
Needless to say, computerized instruments used to locate subluxations that “cannot be detected any other way” can be an effective gimmick for selling chiropractic adjustments to asymptomatic patients who have imaginary vertebral subluxations.
Space-Age Subluxation Correction
Once “subluxations” have been located, an attempt is usually made to correct them by manually adjusting the spine. In many cases, however, instruments may be used to “tap the vertebrae into alignment.” The most common instrument used is a hand-held spring-loaded rubber-tipped stylus that delivers a tap to the offending vertebra. Other variations, some electrically powered, deliver a rapid succession of taps, or a tap with a torque. A special table-top machine designed exclusively to deliver a stylus tap to the atlas, the uppermost cervical vertebra, is sometimes used by chiropractic “upper cervical specialists” who maintain that a misaligned atlas is the primary subluxation causing most ailments.
One “NASA-inspired” instrument uses a piezoelectric sensor to locate and correct vertebral subluxations. A hand-held device shaped like a tuning fork is placed on the spine (straddling the spinous processes). The instrument delivers a vibratory force that measures movement in a spinal segment, which is graphically displayed on a computer screen to indicate the degree of movement or fixation of a vertebra. It is claimed that correction of the subluxation or fixation can be made by using the same hand-held instrument to deliver an oscillating force to restore normal movement, as determined by the piezoelectric sensor. This instrument is used as both a diagnostic instrument and a therapeutic instrument.
If there were any scientific evidence to support the contention that use of adjusting instruments to realign the vertebrae would improve health, such “space-age” instruments would be used in hospitals around the world; at the present time, they are used almost exclusively by chiropractors. FDA approval of the use of instruments for chiropractic adjustment of the spine does not mean that the instruments have been proven to be effective.
Patients who are fearful of back-cracking spinal manipulation (especially the elderly who may have fragile bones) are often subjected to instrument adjusting to correct imaginary subluxations that are alleged to be the cause of back pain and a multitude of other ailments. Some subluxation-based chiropractors treat all of their patients with adjusting instruments.
Paying in Advance for Unnecessary Treatment
One of the most disturbing complaints I hear comes from chiropractic patients who have paid thousands of dollars in advance for a course of treatment lasting several months─after succumbing to a high-pressure sales pitch involving scare tactics. These patients have usually opted to discontinue treatment because symptoms have either worsened or disappeared. Most have signed a contract, however, that does not allow a refund, even if the treatment regimen was not completed. Some have used a chiropractic “health care credit card” to borrow the advance payment from a loan company, leaving the patient legally bound to repay the loan.
It’s never a good idea to pay for chiropractic services in advance. Treatment should be discontinued if symptoms have worsened after one week of treatment or have not improved after two to four weeks of treatment. In many cases of neck or back pain, symptoms will often resolve after a few weeks, eliminating the need for further treatment. Patients who have signed a contract for discounted long-term treatment that involves correction of vertebral subluxations, however, may be told that subluxation-detection instruments indicate that they still have subluxations that need to be corrected to prevent a recurrence of symptoms. Treatment may then be continued as a preventive-maintenance measure, even in the absence of symptoms─all in keeping with subluxation theory which proposes that correction of vertebral subluxations will “restore and maintain health.” Such unnecessary treatment is a needless expense, and it poses a risk that outweighs benefit, especially in the case of neck manipulation which is potentially dangerous.
It is generally considered to be unethical to ask for contracted payment in advance for long-term treatment of a health problem, since such an agreement is tantamount to a guarantee that the treatment will be effective. There is no way to determine if chiropractic treatment might be effective or how many treatments might be needed. I generally advise chiropractic patients to pay for treatment per visit on an as-needed basis and only for treatment of mechanical-type back pain and related problems. A “free exam” or a request for payment in advance should raise a red flag. Few consumers are aware that a diagnosis of “subluxations” in a chiropractor’s office is in itself a red flag.
To smite all humbug, however big; to give nobler tone to science; to set an example to abstinence from petty personal controversies; and of toleration of everything but lying; to be indifferent as to whether the work is recognized as mine or not, so long as it is done.
Thomas Henry Huxley, 1856
(A personal note: Science-Based Medicine has evolved to become one of this nation’s most respected blog sites. Journalists, lay persons, and health professionals who are seeking reliable information about health-related subjects are visiting this site on a daily basis. A new post, published daily by health-care professionals who are authorities in their fields, covers a different subject each day, ranging from quackery to controversial issues in science-based medical care. These blogs are written in a reader-friendly fashion that allows readers at every level to understand and benefit from what they have read. An occasional argumentative response to critical analysis of a pseudoscientific healing method often provides a good example of how someone can be adversely influenced by indoctrination into a belief system, further illustrating the need for an informative site like Science-Based Medicine where there is no reluctance to “smite all humbug, however big.”)

   The Graston Technique – Inducing Microtrauma with Instruments
Harriet Hall
Link
The Graston Technique® is a modification of traditional hands-on soft tissue mobilization that uses specifically designed instruments to allow the therapist to introduce a controlled amount of microtrauma into an area of excessive scar and/or soft tissue fibrosis, hoping that this will invoke an inflammatory response that will augment the healing process. It is also intended to reduce the stress on the therapist’s hands.
Microtrauma? Hurting people to make them better? I know sometimes an improperly healed bone must be re-broken so it can re-heal in proper alignment, but this is different. It bothers me that they are further injuring already damaged soft tissues and hoping (1) that the new injury will heal, (2) that that will help the older injury heal, and (3) that it can somehow avoid stimulating the deposition of just that much more scar tissue and fibrosis. It seems to violate the “primum non nocere” principle. It is unpalatable. Of course that wouldn’t matter if the evidence showed it was effective. Does it?
Soft tissue mobilization is widely used in physical therapy, although the evidence is sparse. According to one PT website,
Soft tissue mobilization breaks up inelastic or fibrous muscle tissue such as scar tissue, move tissue fluids, and relax muscle tension. This procedure consists of rhythmic stretching and deep pressure.
A related modality is Active Release Techniques® (ART) a patented hands-on treatment. The Graston Technique appears to be just another technique in this family of techniques: one that adds a special instrument to the procedure.
The Graston Technique website tells us it is used by more than 6,500 clinicians worldwide—including athletic trainers, chiropractors, hand therapists, occupational and physical therapists. It tells us the Graston Technique® instruments, much like a tuning fork, resonate in the clinician’s hands allowing the clinician to isolate adhesions and restrictions, and treat them very precisely. It tells us the treatment is clinically proven and it has resolved 87% or more of all conditions treated. (This claim is supported only by this “outcome data” chart with no explanation of what the data mean or where they come from.)
You must pay $495 for 12 hours of training to become qualified to treat and to purchase the set of instruments. The price of the instruments is $2755 — for six curved pieces of steel.
Research listed on Graston Technique Website:
The website lists articles in the popular press, poster presentations, and testimonials, but only 3 citations that appear to be acceptable evidence from peer-reviewed journals. I will call them (1) (2) and (3). A closer look reveals that they are not what they seem.
(1) and (2) are listed as having been published in the “Journal of the American College of Sports Medicine.” There is no such journal. They obviously meant the journal Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise which is the official journal of the American College of Sports Medicine. Study (2), by Sevier et al., was not listed in the table of contents of that journal for the issue cited (Vol 27, No. 5, 1995) and was not found by searching the journal’s entire website. It was also not listed on PubMed. If such an article exists, it apparently was not published in a peer-reviewed journal, and certainly not in the journal they say it was published in.
(1) is listed as having been published in the “Journal of the American College of Sports Medicine” in 1995. It was indeed published in the journal Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, but it was not published in 1995 as the citation indicates, but in 1997. It is, in fact, the same study as (3). The citation for (3) is the only correct one.
So the company’s own website offers us only one scientific article from a 12-year-old peer-reviewed study, and it turns out to be a controlled study of 20 rats. They gave half of them an Achilles tendon “injury” by injecting collagenase and treated half of those with Graston Technique. They found microscopic evidence of increased fibroblast proliferation in those treated with the Graston Technique instruments, and there was also an improvement in the animals’ gait. They killed the rats to do the microscopic studies, so there was no data about long-term outcomes. The authors ended the abstract with this disclaimer:
Although healing in rats may not translate directly to healing in humans, the findings of this study suggest that ASTM [augmented soft tissue mobilization] may promote healing via increased fibroblast recruitment.
Research Found in PubMed
A PubMed search for “Graston” brought up 7 articles. 5 were case reports, one was a description of the design of a proposed trial, and the only one that was a clinical study was a pilot study that was not very informative.
1. A case report of treatment of a tibialis posterior strain in an athlete. I thought this one was really funny. In addition to the Graston technique, the patient received acupuncture, electrical stimulation, Active Release Technique((R)), ultrasound therapy with Traumeel (a mixture of 14 homeopathic remedies), and rehabilitation. So in addition to wondering if the patient would have recovered just as fast with no treatment, we are left wondering which of these modalities or which combination of them was helpful, if any.
2. A report of three case studies.
3. Not a trial, but a description of the design of a proposed trial.
4. Case report of treating trigger thumb with both Graston and ART (active release techniques).
5. Case report of a volleyball player with costochondritis that concluded “This athlete seemed to respond positively to manipulation, soft tissue mobilization, and taping.”
6. This pilot study in patients with carpal tunnel syndrome compared soft tissue mobilization by manual techniques to STM by the Graston Technique and found no difference in clinical improvements. Instead of concluding that the Graston Technique offered no advantage over the other treatment, it concluded that it had substantiated the clinical efficacy of both. The abstract doesn’t mention the number of subjects.
7. Another case report.
There was one other study that my search failed to bring up because the abstract did not mention Graston Technique but it did use GT instruments and has been cited by GT therapists as supporting evidence (that’s how I found out about it). It was a mouse study that instead of showing that GT is clinically effective seems to show the opposite. It found favorable effects on early collagen formation and organization, but minimal to no effect on the final outcome of healing.
Summary of the Evidence
It really all boils down to a handful of mice pro, a handful of mice con, one human pilot study showing no advantage over manual mobilization, and a lot of testimonials. Would you be willing to try a new pharmaceutical treatment on the basis of nothing but one favorable mouse study out of two, and one pilot study? Would you agree to let someone deliberately injure you on such flimsy evidence? I would be very happy if the Graston Technique proves useful, but for the time being it must be considered experimental.
A Media Story that Wasn’t
And now for the rest of the story. A physical therapist approached the editor of her local newspaper asking him to do a story featuring her and this wonderful new treatment. The editor had never heard of it, but amazingly he had heard of me, and he contacted me with questions. I had never heard of it either, but I did some quick research and told him I couldn’t find much in the way of evidence. He told the physical therapist that before he could agree to write about it he needed to see some evidence. She submitted 8 items as supporting evidence. The editor forwarded them to me for comment. I commented, rather impolitely:
This isn’t supporting evidence. It’s bullshit.
1. The cover letter consists of nothing but a protracted logical fallacy: the argument from popularity. The fact that lots of people use it and think it works does not constitute evidence that it actually works. Lots of people used bloodletting and thought it worked. Lots of people believe in astrology.
2. The rat study I referred to, by Loghmani and Warden. The last sentence says “Careful interpretation of this controlled animal study is warranted until its findings are confirmed by clinical studies.” Not even the authors are claiming it is an effective treatment for humans!
3. A testimonial from Golf Digest? Come on!
4. A description of how the Graston Technique is applied.
5. Another copy of the same Loghmani/Warden rat study. Didn’t she even realize she had already provided a copy? Did she hope you wouldn’t notice and would just be impressed by the sheer number of documents?
6. A meaningless table of “outcomes” with no explanation of where the numbers came from and no controls.
7. Something they label a “case report” which does not at all fit the definition of a case report. It is a journalistic report of the preliminary phase of an unfinished 3 part study by the same author, Loghmani, in rats. It does not provide the kind of information one would expect from a scientific paper and does not follow the accepted format. It was not published in a peer-reviewed journal, but in an in-house quarterly publication by Graston Technique. It is 4 years old — by now that study should have been finished and published in a peer-reviewed journal. Why wasn’t it?
8. A description of the technique with a testimonial, published in a popular health magazine. It quotes the same researcher, Loghmani. He says “The approach SEEMS to be effective.” It offers nothing in the way of evidence.
To put this into perspective, the only actual evidence the physical therapist has offered is one study in rats. Would you want to take a pharmaceutical that had only been tested in one rat study?
In summary, there is nothing here that could be considered evidence for clinical benefits to humans. As the Aetna insurance company says, this technique must be considered “experimental and investigational, because there is inadequate evidence in the peer-reviewed published medical literature of… effectiveness.”
In my opinion, experimental treatments like this should be limited to controlled research studies. That way we could learn once and for all if it was effective and safe. To forge ahead beyond the evidence and just treat people as she is doing amounts to using people as guinea pigs in an uncontrolled experiment without informed consent.
If you run an article, you will be giving her free advertising for an unproven treatment that she is misrepresenting as proven and effective.
The editor responded,
Thank you so much. Your assessment is exactly what I needed to keep this story out of the paper.

Chiropractic Webster Technique: Nonsense Based on Nonsense
The Chiropractic Webster Technique is a nonsensical method of adjusting the sacrum in a misguided effort to enhance pregnancy and to facilitate childbirth. The technique, unopposed in the United States, is under fire by a Canadian chiropractic regulatory body.
Sam Homola on February 11, 2020
Link
The chiropractic Webster Technique, one of the most nonsensical chiropractic techniques based on the scientifically indefensible chiropractic vertebral subluxation theory, is a method of adjusting alleged sacral subluxations in order to prevent breech birth and to assure a normal delivery by facilitating “neuro-biomechanical function in the pelvis.”
Whatever effect sacral manipulation might have on the body, there is no reason to believe that a sacral adjustment will improve nerve flow to the uterus or affect sacral nerves which pass through solid bony openings. A sacroiliac joint is an amphiarthrodial synovial-plane joint (one on each side of the pelvis) with irregular interlocking joint surfaces bound together with strong, dense ligaments. While there is slight movement in a sacroiliac joint, subluxation or dislocation is rare, usually caused by painful injury. Most often, sacroiliac pain is the result of ligamentous strain or joint inflammation. The asymptomatic “vertebral subluxation complex” routinely adjusted by subluxation-based chiropractors simply does not exist.
Movement in the sacroiliac joints is greatest during pregnancy when the hormone relaxin loosens sacroiliac and pubic ligaments to allow widening of the pelvis during birth. Manipulating sacroiliac joints during the final months of pregnancy may strain relaxed sacroiliac ligaments, contributing to the development of low-back pain.
While most adjustive techniques may involve manual manipulation of the sacrum, some are far removed from what might be identified as manipulation. An Activator technique, for example, uses a spring-loaded stylus to tap on the sacrum in what appears to be a useless, arbitrary procedure. A Logan Basic Technique might be used to place thumb pressure on a gluteal sacrotuberous ligament in order to “realign the sacrum”. An upper cervical (NUCCA) specialist will invariably manipulate the atlas to realign vertebrae from the neck down. Such non-standardized adjustive techniques, all based on subluxation theory, may vary from one chiropractic office to another. The first clue that such techniques may have no value is provided by the subluxation paradigms that define the techniques and profession.
The dangers of the Webster Technique
Use of the Webster Technique to realign the sacrum in order to facilitate childbirth by reversing a breech presentation can endanger both the mother and the fetus by delaying appropriate care. Breech presentation commonly occurs during pregnancy, but most breeches rotate into a head-down (vertex) position by the end of the eighth month. Failure to take action to prevent a breech birth before labor begins is inexcusable malpractice, resulting in a life-threatening emergency. Rupture of the amniotic sac, compression of the umbilical cord (reducing blood flow to the baby), displacement of the placenta (bleeding with obstruction of delivery), or entanglement of the umbilical cord and the baby, as well as vaginal injury and injury to the baby, may require an immediate Cesarean section in order to avoid a dangerous breech-obstructed vaginal delivery ─ a horrendous scenario that could have been avoided with ultrasound studies and appropriate obstetrical care. Subluxation-based or not, no chiropractor should be involved with management of a late-stage pregnancy. Use of the Webster Technique to turn a breeched fetus should be forbidden by law. About 4% of babies are breech in a full-term pregnancy, requiring hospital-based care by a board-certified obstetrician.
The Webster technique, often used by pediatric chiropractors, may be followed up by manipulation of new-born babies to correct “birth-related subluxations” ─ a dangerous and unnecessary practice.
A step in the right direction
According to a statement by issued by Consumer Health Digest:
The College of Chiropractors of British Columbia (CCBC) has announced that it has amended its Professional Conduct Handbook and Efficacy Claims Policy statement because of concerns about misleading statements by some chiropractors about pregnancy and childbirth care. The policy statement now says that chiropractors should not represent to patients or to the public that chiropractic has any beneficial effect on:
    • fetal development or position such as: breech/breech turning or position and intrauterine/in utero constraint
    • labor or birth such as: easier or shorter labor, preventing the need for medical interventions and preventing premature or traumatic birth
    • hormone functions or post partum depression
CCBC’s notice specifies that chiropractors should not imply that the Webster technique, a treatment of the pelvis and lower spine, can influence fetal positioning. The Professional Conduct Handbook now states: “When communicating with the public, a chiropractor may advertise or reference the Webster Technique or Certification only as “a specific chiropractic sacral analysis and diversified adjustment for all weight-bearing individuals.” After January 3, 2020, according to the CCBC, complaints about statements that breach the new standard will be investigated.
Opposition to subluxation-based scope of practice
Apparently recognizing the tenuous nature of vertebral subluxation theory, the CCBC is also mandating that registered chiropractors must not make claims embracing a broad scope of health problems [PDF]:
Due to the absence of acceptable evidence supporting such claims, registrants must NOT represent to patients or the public that chiropractic:
(a) can be used to treat diseases, disorders or conditions such as: Alzheimer’s disease, cancer, diabetes, infections, infertility, or Tourette’s syndrome, or
(b) has any beneficial effect on childhood diseases, disorders or conditions such as: ADHD (or ADD), autism spectrum disorders including Asperger syndrome, cerebral palsy, Down syndrome, fetal alcohol syndrome, or developmental and speech disorders.
The march of subluxation deniers
Much to the consternation of subluxation believers, The Canadian Memorial Chiropractic College has joined 12 other chiropractic institutions around the world that have renounced subluxation theory, all in accordance with a Position Statement based on the theme of the World Federation of Chiropractic Educational Statement formulated in November of 2014:
The teaching of vertebral subluxation complex as a vitalistic construct that claims that is the cause of disease is unsupported by evidence. It’s inclusion in a modern chiropractic curriculum in anything other than an historical context is therefore inappropriate and unnecessary.
Unfortunately, no chiropractic college or regulatory body in the United States has openly challenged subluxation theory as the College of Chiropractors in British Columbia has done, and state laws defining chiropractic as a method of correcting vertebral subluxations remain unchanged. As stated by Timothy Mirtz in 2011, “Despite the controversies and paucity of evidence the term subluxation is still found often within the chiropractic curricula of most North American chiropractic programs.”
In the interest of public health, it is incumbent upon health-care professionals, journalists, and informed lay persons to advise against subluxation-based chiropractic care (as opposed to appropriate use of generic spinal manipulation) and other forms of dubious health care that prosper under the veil of legal licensure.

Functional Disc Rehydration for Chronic Back Pain
Harriet Hall on June 23, 2015
Link

A chiropractor in Illinois named Jeff Winternheimer claims to have discovered an effective way to heal herniated discs by rehydrating them. He calls it Functional Disc Rehydration and he offers it through a network of four offices in the Chicago area called the Illinois Back Clinic. He has lots of testimonials and one sorry amateurish attempt at a scientific study that claimed to show 100% improvement; but there is no published evidence, no controlled observations, and no comparison of his methods with other methods.
Degenerative disc disease
Between the spinal vertebrae there are soft, jelly-like compressible discs that act as shock absorbers. They are “corralled” by a fibrous annulus. As we get older, the disc material loses water and becomes less flexible; the disc thins, and the space between the vertebrae narrows, so in old age we are not quite as tall as we once were. Cracks in the annulus develop with age or with trauma, allowing the disc material to bulge out or rupture. Herniated discs don’t necessarily cause pain; disc degeneration can be seen on MRI in 37% of asymptomatic people over the age of 60.

An unusual approach to providing evidence
In looking for scientific evidence on the Illinois Back Institute website, I encountered something I had never seen before. They offer one study as evidence that Functional Disc Rehydration works, but before they will let you read it you have to supply your name and e-mail address, tell them what kind of back problem you have, and tell them which of their clinics you live closest to. There is an opportunity to make an appointment and supply your insurance data before you have even downloaded the study.
The study
The downloadable “study” itself is a travesty. It is not a published study and is not presented in the format of a scientific paper. It consists of five pages on the Institute’s letterhead. The first page explains the purported mechanism of the treatment and makes the claim that Functional Disc Rehydration provides better results than surgery. Page 3 is a testimonial from a patient. Pages 4 and 5 offer a free consultation and a clickable link to schedule an appointment. Only page 2 is devoted to the study itself. The two researchers who invented Functional Disc Rehydration are “Dr. Jeff Winternheimer, D.C.” and “a PAC 10 university medical researcher” who is not named. There was no control group. The subjects were “more than 50” people (they didn’t bother to get an exact count?) ranging in age from 39 to 83 who had chronic back pain and had already tried other treatments. After one treatment, “all patients experienced disc rehydration of at least 18%.” After 10 weeks, there was 80% rehydration, and at 25 weeks there was 100% rehydration. In addition to the rehydration, “All patients experienced complete elimination of herniated and bulging discs.” They don’t tell us how they measured hydration or confirmed the elimination of degenerated discs. They conclude:
The statistics overwhelmingly prove that re-hydration through Functional Disc Rehydration will help reverse a degenerated discs [sic], neck pain and back pain permanently.
Of course, this abominable, pathetic, laughable, puerile excuse for a “study” proves no such thing. It’s as if they didn’t even try. With only a little effort, they could have put it in proper format and made it at least sort of look like a publishable study. Anyone with any sense would have known that 100% success is suspicious and is seldom if ever reported in a scientific paper, and it would have been so simple to write “52 patients” instead of “more than 50.” What were they thinking?
More evidence
In addition to a few testimonials, they offer three before-and-after MRIs that show a reduction in disc protrusion, one after 50 treatments, one after seven months, and the third simply labeled “before” and “after”. Pretty impressive, unless you happen to know that similar improvement can occur over time with no treatment at all. Without a control group, there is no way to tell whether the treatment had anything to do with the improvement.
I watched a video where Dr. Jeff says that in 2007 an experienced researcher told him he would have to study eight patients with severe back pain with before and after MRIs to show that the treatment gets oxygen, nutrients, and fluid into the disc. He claims his study showed that, but he doesn’t explain how the measurements were made. He seems to be describing eight of the patients who were included in the larger study reported on the website. He seems to be saying they could measure rehydration by MRI and that they were surprised when they found that the disc protrusions also resolved. The MD who did the MRIs supposedly said he had never seen a disc protrusion resolve. I find that hard to believe.
How it works
They claim it “reverses” disc degeneration. They tell us a healthy disc is filled with a gel-like substance; a disc that has been worn down has lost its gel and is therefore dehydrated, and a dehydrated disc can bulge or herniate. Functional Disc Rehydration takes the pressure off the discs through cycles of compression and traction movements, allowing the spine to replenish the missing fluids back into the discs naturally. Then physical therapy is used to strengthen and stabilize the spine.
With the advent of MRIs, many studies have documented the regression of disc protrusions, and spontaneous improvement is thought to be a result of inflammatory processes and reabsorption of disc material, not to “rehydration” or sucking the material back into place. One study found that in 14 out of 15 patients with massive lumbar disc herniation, there was dramatic resolution after 24 months of conservative therapy. Discs naturally lose water content with aging and become brittle and deformed, but this is usually asymptomatic until the annulus tears and allows the disc material to protrude and put pressure on a nerve. If there were a way to rehydrate the disc, that might conceivably be helpful, but it would not reverse the tears in the annulus. And even if the remaining disc material became better hydrated, how would we know that from an MRI? Would it show up as increased space between the vertebrae? Would that say anything about oxygen and nutrients? And if you hydrate the disc material wouldn’t that cause it to swell and possibly increase the pressure on the nerves that is causing the pain?
They don’t really define their approach, but apparently it involves cycles of compression and traction movements along with stretching, exercise, PT treatments, listening to patients, etc. In one testimonial a woman describes two-hour visits three times a week. One patient describes feeling a little better, then doing too much, having increased pain, and having to slow down again.
Does it make sense?
Not to me. I couldn’t find any evidence that increased hydration had been measured in discs after compression/traction cycles and PT, or that oxygen and nutrient levels in the disc increased. We have a generally-accepted explanation of spontaneous improvement on MRI (inflammation and reabsorption) that doesn’t involve rehydration.
Similar claims
Chiropractors have made similar claims for spinal decompression devices, which are all versions of the original VAX-D that Stephen Barrett has written about on Quackwatch. I wrote about one of the newer versions, the DRX-9000 and a couple of years later the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation show Marketplace did a scathing exposé. These glorified traction devices claim to relieve pressure on the disc, improve circulation, supply nutrients to the disc, and even suck the extruded part of the disc back into place by creating a vacuum. No studies have yet shown that that is even possible.
Conclusion
        ◦ I’ll say what I’ve said many times before about other questionable treatments. I don’t know if this treatment works, and neither do they, because it has not been submitted to controlled scientific testing. My impression is that this is more of a business model than a revolutionary new treatment for back pain. If they publish credible evidence from well-designed studies in peer-reviewed journals, I’ll reconsider.

The American Chiropractic Association Answers Crislip’s Call, Joins the Choosing Wisely Campaign
The Choosing Wisely campaign has invited the largest chiropractic organization in the United States to publish a list of interventions to avoid. The results, while not entirely without merit, consist of redundant or unnecessary recommendations. And there is a glaring absence of recommendations to avoid any of the blatant pseudoscience commonly practiced by chiropractors.
Clay Jones on November 3, 2017
Link

Three years ago, Mark Crislip closed a post discussing the ABIM Foundation’s Choosing Wisely initiative with the following thought:
I wonder if a chiropractor could come up with five standards treatments in chiropractic to be avoided…
Well, now they’ve finally gone and done it, with results that, while not entirely without merit, are a bit off the mark in my opinion.
Choosing Wisely and chiropractic
For the sake of further discussion, let’s all just agree to ignore the fact, also pointed out by Dr. Crislip in his post, that chiropractic as a profession doesn’t exactly stand up to the scrutiny of the campaign’s criteria:
Choosing Wisely aims to promote conversations between clinicians and patients by helping patients choose care that is:
    • Supported by evidence
    • Not duplicative of other tests or procedures already received
    • Free from harm
    • Truly necessary
Of course to be fair, no medical intervention is completely “free from harm”, but I assume that what the ABIM Foundation actually means is that interventions should have a favorable risk to benefit assessment. This is arguably not the case when assessing chiropractic as a whole. While not all of the treatments I prescribe are based on robust randomized controlled trials, they are “supported by evidence” in the vast majority of cases, and often by very good evidence. Chiropractic doesn’t really bring anything original to the table that passes this test.
There are similar issues with the phrase “truly necessary”, whatever that means. Many medical interventions aren’t “truly necessary” in my opinion. Other Choosing Wisely lists cover a number of these, but there are also tests and treatments that may have value while perhaps not meeting this criterion absolutely depending on who is assessing the scene. But again, being charitable, I assume that the ABIM Foundation is focusing on common interventions for common human ailments that don’t tend to improve objective outcomes.
Specific treatments provided by a chiropractor might provide some objective benefit for a small sliver of musculoskeletal complaints, with those unique to chiropractic being the least helpful. But whatever improvement that can be attributed to visiting a chiropractor isn’t better than more conventional approaches, such as physical therapy or recommendations from a patient’s primary care provider for exercise, stretching, massage, etc. These approaches come with considerably less baggage and aren’t as likely to be accompanied by pseudoscience or anti-vaccine propaganda.
The Choosing Wisely lists published by participating organizations aren’t meant to serve as treatment guidelines, of course. Instead, they are intended to encourage a conversation around whether or not the listed interventions are a good idea, or if they may put patients at risk of more harm than benefit. Unfortunately, in my opinion, they have largely gone unnoticed by medical providers and the general public. I am confident that the list of questionable chiropractic interventions will be similarly ignored by practitioners.
The ACA’s list
The list in question, released in August, comes from the American Chiropractic Association (ACA). The ACA claims 15,000 members, which is less than a quarter of practicing chiropractors, and recognizes 11 specialty areas, such as chiropractic acupuncture, pediatrics, diagnosis and management of internal disorders, and forensic sciences. It describes itself with typical grandeur:
The American Chiropractic Association (ACA) is the largest professional chiropractic organization in the United States. ACA attracts the most principled and accomplished chiropractors, who understand that it takes more to be called an ACA chiropractor.
We are leading our profession in the most constructive and far-reaching ways — by working hand in hand with other health care professionals, by lobbying for pro-chiropractic legislation and policies, by supporting meaningful research and by using that research to inform our treatment practices.
We also provide professional and educational opportunities for all our members and are committed to being a positive and unifying force for the practice of modern chiropractic.
What does it take to called “an ACA chiropractor”? Membership requirements consist of being a licensed chiropractor in the United States and paying yearly dues. The ACA even goes so far as to state that they do not deny membership to anyone meeting the above qualifications as long as what they do in their practice isn’t illegal. In that way, they are similar to the American Academy of Pediatrics, which even allows pediatricians who are blatantly anti-vaccine to be members in good standing.
Here are the five things that chiropractors and their patients should question according to the ACA:
Do not obtain spinal imaging for patients with acute low-back pain during the six (6) weeks after onset in the absence of red flags.
What red flags, you ask? The ACA mentions “history of cancer, fracture or suspected fracture based on clinical history, progressive neurologic symptoms and infection, as well as conditions that potentially preclude a dynamic thrust to the spine, such as osteopenia, osteoporosis, axial spondyloarthritis and tumors”. I would argue that if you have any of these red flags, you should not be under the care of a chiropractor. There isn’t any evidence to support superiority of chiropractic care to conventional approaches for acute low-back pain anyway.
Do not perform repeat imaging to monitor patients’ progress.
They list idiopathic scoliosis as an exception, despite the fact that their own research shows no good evidence to support chiropractic management of this condition. I agree with this recommendation, and the reasoning of the ACA in this case is sound. I’m just not holding my breath while waiting to see if this will change anything, however.
Avoid protracted use of passive or palliative physical therapeutic modalities for low-back pain disorders unless they support the goal(s) of an active treatment plan.
In other words, commonly recommended interventions like heat, ultrasound, and electrical stimulation, shouldn’t be used in isolation because they don’t provide much benefit. The absolute worst thing you can do to prevent or treat lower back pain, which virtually all humans will experience at some point in their lifetime thanks to evolution, is nothing. General physical activity and back specific exercises are key, and in no way unique to chiropractic.
I don’t think you will find many chiropractors not recommending an exercise regimen for lower back pain disorders, so this item is a bit odd. You also won’t find many that won’t provide some kind of spinal manipulation, because that’s their thing that they do. In this section, the ACA writes that physical activity and back exercises “may lead to better outcomes when combined with spinal manipulation.” In reality, spinal manipulation is more like multiplying by one. It changes nothing for the long term outcome.
Do not provide long-term pain management without a psychosocial screening or assessment.
Chronic pain disorders often have a psychosocial component. Chronic pain can cause or be caused/exacerbated by anxiety and depression, for example. Some patients are at risk for the development of chronic pain because of a variety of psychosocial factors and chiropractors are not trained to evaluate or manage them. The ACA recommends that chiropractors use a screening tool and refer when necessary because the ACA imagines chiropractors to be primary care providers.
Do not prescribe lumbar supports or braces for the long-term treatment or prevention of low-back pain.
Another odd inclusion. Chiropractors simply aren’t out there putting people in back braces for long periods of time for treatment or prevention of back pain. I was easily able to find that this recommendation is already widely accepted. Meanwhile, the ACA is inviting speakers to their conferences to promote nonsense like the Activator Method.
The ACA press release announcing their participation in Choosing Wisely is interesting. They point out that multiple other organizations already participating have included recommendations to avoid spinal imaging for acute lower back pain. It’s a solid recommendation, but instead of actually attempting to show a commitment to change by pointing out some of the abject nonsense they have supported sans evidence, they went the safe route. And in the press release they essentially give their members enough wiggle room that they can continue obtaining frequent spinal films without losing any sleep.
My favorite quote involves the practice of “defensive medicine”:
As with many of our colleagues in the health care professions, we have learned from experience to practice “defensive medicine.” This perspective may be even more deeply ingrained within the chiropractic profession based on our prior experiences with bias and/or lack of understanding regarding chiropractic care. As an example, just look how long it took before Choosing Wisely® was even willing to consider a chiropractic list!
So do chiropractors practice defensively, which implies a concern for facing a malpractice suit, or not? It would appear that the latter is the case when you consider how often they point out how undeniably safe chiropractic is. Often this is done in the context of attacking conventional medical care. It’s also unclear to me how the medical community’s lack of “understanding regarding chiropractic care” encourages defensive practice.
Conclusion: The ABIM did not Choose Wisely
How does the ACA describe chiropractic on the Choosing Wisely website? Just as you would expect them to, of course. Remember though that this is an organization that is fighting for chiropractors to be considered primary care physicians complete with the right to prescribe medications.
Chiropractors focus on disorders of the musculoskeletal system and the nervous system, and the effects of these disorders on general health and function. Chiropractic services are used most often to treat conditions such as back pain, neck pain, pain in the joints of the arms or legs, and headaches. Widely known for their expertise in spinal manipulation, chiropractors practice a hands-on, drug-free approach to health care that includes patient examination, diagnosis and treatment.
The ABIM Foundation is very likely completely ignorant of both the history and the current reality of the chiropractic profession. Frankly I think it’s ridiculous that a chiropractic organization was invited to participate. We certainly have come a long way from Wilk v. AMA, haven’t we?
This is just another example, in a very long line, of the undeserved legitimization of alternative medicine that will serve as more of a marketing purpose than as a means of improving chiropractic practice. All that the ACA has done is provide a list of redundant or unnecessary recommendations. And the few chiropractors who already avoid excessive spinal imaging will continue to do so, while the vast majority will compartmentalize these “suggestions” and carry on as is.
Extras
    • Here is a response to the ACA Choosing Wisely list from the International Chiropractic Association.
    • Here is an ACA video describing the benefits of pediatric chiropractic.In March of 2017, the ACA reaffirmed its public policy on chiropractors as primary care providers. This policy includes the following:
Doctors of chiropractic also recommend and manage dietary changes, nutritional interventions, botanical medicines, homeopathic medicines, acupuncture and other services when indicated.
The ACA, while not overtly anti-vaccine in policy, supports conscience waivers.

Certification in chiropractic techniques: legitimate care or tomfoolery?
Chiropractic vertebral subluxation theory breeds a variety of questionable diagnostic and treatment methods. Certification in use of a subluxation-based technique offers no assurance that the technique is effective or scientifically acceptable.
Sam Homola on June 22, 2018
Link
Although spinal manipulation can sometimes be helpful in treating mechanical-type neck and back pain, scientific consensus does not support the theory that adjusting vertebral subluxations will restore and maintain health. There is no credible evidence to indicate that manipulating the spine for any reason will improve general health or prevent disease:
It is unclear why some chiropractors feel the need to extend their scope of practice into implausible areas, when there is so much to do in the musculoskeletal field.
While a real orthopedic subluxation can cause musculoskeletal symptoms, a chiropractic subluxation alleged to cause nerve interference that contributes to the development of disease has not been proven to exist. Nevertheless, the chiropractic establishment and chiropractic entrepreneurs offer certification or a diplomate designation for many chiropractic treatment methods based on vertebral subluxation theory.
Instrument adjusting
Spinal manipulation is normally a hands-on procedure, used as an option in the treatment of a musculoskeletal problem. Chiropractors who subscribe to subluxation theory, however, might use a spring-loaded or electrically powered mallet to tap alleged vertebral subluxations into alignment as treatment for any ailment the patient might have. Such treatment usually includes a check of “functional” leg length to confirm the presence or the correction of a vertebral subluxation or a pelvic imbalance ─ a procedure that is as questionable as the theory underlying its practice.
Generic spinal manipulation in the form of manual high-velocity, low-amplitude thrusting on the spine can be helpful in relieving pain and restoring mobility in mechanically compromised back and spinal structures by stretching muscles and moving spinal joints to end range of movement and beyond. Use of a mallet to adjust a vertebral “subluxation” which may or may not exist cannot replace patient-tailored hands-on manipulative therapy as a treatment for musculoskeletal problems.

When a hands-on spinal adjustment used to correct a putative vertebral subluxation (as a treatment for back pain or a health problem) cannot be done because of complicating factors (such as osteoporosis) or provider disability, an adjusting instrument might be used to satisfy the demand for an “adjustment.” Some subluxation-based chiropractors use adjusting instruments exclusively, treating every patient with a “clicker” and a leg-length check.
A 2005 publication by the National Board of Chiropractic Examiners reported that 40.3% of chiropractors used an adjustive instrument (Christensen. 2005). A proficiency rating in instrument adjusting can be obtained by passing written and practical exams after attending seminars offered by companies that produce such instruments.
Pediatric chiropractic
Perhaps the most egregious aspect of subluxation-based chiropractic care is the use of spinal manipulation on infants, a practice presently supported by both the International Chiropractic Association and the American Chiropractic Association. Some chiropractors believe that a baby’s vertebrae are commonly subluxated by the birthing process, especially the atlas (uppermost neck) vertebra, causing a variety of childhood ailments. There is no evidence that such subluxations occur; if they do, they should not be subjected to manipulation.
The American Chiropractic Association’s Council on Chiropractic Pediatrics supports chiropractic treatment of infants and pre-adolescent children:
Studies are beginning to show that chiropractic can help children not only with typical musculoskeletal complaints but with somatovisceral issues as varied as asthma, chronic ear infection, breast-feeding difficulties, colic and bedwetting.
The International Chiropractors Association Council on Chiropractic Pediatrics explains how chiropractic care is supposed to help children:
The doctor of chiropractic, through a procedure called an adjustment, helps restore misaligned vertebrae to a more normal position, thus allowing the nerves to properly communicate with the rest of the body and let the body heal itself─safely and naturally.
It is simply not possible to detect subluxations by palpating the fat-padded cartilaginous spine of an infant or a small child. “Subluxations” located by finger-tip examination of a baby’s neck are undoubtedly a product of imagination or deception. Some pediatric chiropractors palpate and manipulate a baby’s spine soon after birth to correct subluxations ─ a dangerous and unnecessary practice.
The cartilaginous vertebral growth centers in children under 8 to 10 years of age are most vulnerable to injury caused by spinal manipulation (not to mention the risk of stroke). Such injury may not be detectable and could conceivably result in growth-plate fractures or injury to epiphyseal cartilage that might result in such pre-adolescent deformity as scoliosis or Scheuermann’s kyphosis.

Pediatric chiropractors maintain that the light finger-tip pressure used to adjust a baby’s spine could not possibly cause injury. Any pressure sufficient to move vertebrae, however, may cause occult injury in the partially formed vertebrae of a baby. Although most baby “adjustments” appear to be nothing more than harmless pretense (perhaps providing the nurturance of touch), a plethora of You Tube videos showing chiropractors manipulating the spine of a baby clearly show use of techniques that produce extreme movement of vertebrae with the popping sounds caused by cavitation.
There is no known benefit to be gained from manipulating the immature spine of a newborn baby or an infant. In keeping with views of medical professionals, a neurosurgeon has advised that “potential complications and unknown benefits indicate that SMT [spinal manipulative therapy] should not be used in the pediatric population.”
Injury to children as a result of pediatric chiropractic care may not be limited to the spine. A recent study by orthopedic surgeons (discussed last week by SBM’s Jann Bellamy) found chiropractic-related injuries involving a variety of orthopedic problems, such as hip dysplasia. “Delayed referrals, misdiagnoses, adverse events from manipulative therapy, and ineffective treatments” were observed.
Training and qualifications for designation as a pediatric chiropractor are clearly far from adequate. The International Chiropractic Association offers a post-graduate Diplomate in Clinical Chiropractic Pediatrics (DICCP). The diplomate syllabus is a 30-module, 360+ hours of classroom study during weekends. There is no hospital training and no contact with diseased or injured children.
Webster Technique
The Webster Technique, an offshoot of pediatric chiropractic, is a method of adjusting the sacroiliac joints to assure normal delivery of a baby, a technique claimed to be capable of turning a breech baby in the womb. According to the International Chiropractic Pediatric Association:
The Webster Technique is a specific chiropractic sacral analysis and diversified adjustment. The goal of the adjustment is to reduce the effects of sacral subluxation/SI [sacroiliac] joint dysfunction….Sacral subluxation may contribute to difficult labor for the mother (i.e., dystocia) caused by inadequate uterine dysfunction, pelvic contraction, and baby mal-presentation. Correction of sacral subluxation may have a positive effect on all these cases of dystocia.
Although the sacroiliac joints are routinely adjusted by Webster practitioners to correct a “subluxation,” sacroiliac subluxation is rare. The sacroiliac joints are tightly fitted synovial and fibrous-filled joints with irregular, interlocking joint surfaces that are bound together by dense, strong ligaments. Although there is some movement in sacroiliac joints, they are rarely subluxated (in the orthopedic sense) unless there is ligamentous injury. Sacroiliac pain is most often the result of strain or inflammation.

Child birth is facilitated by production of a hormone called relaxin, which relaxes sacroiliac and pubic ligaments in order to allow the baby to pass through the pelvis. During pregnancy and post-partum recovery, relaxed sacroiliac ligaments are most vulnerable to strain or injury, which might occur as a result of inappropriate or unnecessary sacroiliac manipulation.
It defies logic to assume that manipulating a putative sacroiliac subluxation, or tapping on a sacroiliac joint with a spring-loaded mallet, can be an effective way to turn a breeched baby in the womb. In most cases, a baby will turn from a breech position to a normal vertex (head down) position by the end of the 8th month anyway, providing the chiropractor with “proof” that the Webster Technique was an effective treatment.
Certification in Webster Technique requires attendance at 14 seminars and participation in 2 research projects. Advanced instruction for a diplomate in prenatal care (DACCP), awarded by the Academy Council of Chiropractic Pediatrics, requires 400 hours of weekend classroom instruction ─ instruction that is certainly not adequate to diagnose and handle potential complications of pregnancy and delivery.
NUCCA techniques
Although most subluxation-based chiropractors adjust subluxations in every portion of the spine, either manually or with an instrument, some chiropractors specialize in adjusting the atlas vertebra at the top of the spine. These chiropractors, most of whom are members of the National Upper Cervical Chiropractic Association (NUCCA), believe that the misalignment of the atlas places pressure on the brain stem and is responsible for subluxations from the neck down, causing the gamut of human ailments.
According to NUCCA:
The focus of the NUCCA work is the relationship between the upper cervical spine (neck) and its influence on the central nervous system and brain stem function. It is this relationship that affects every aspect of human function from the feeling sensations in your fingers to regulating hormones, controlling movement, and providing the ability to hear, see, think, and breathe… The supine leg check, which shows leg length inequality, is the basic standard to determine if you have an upper cervical misalignment.
The Blair Upper Cervical Technique does not require a diagnosis as a prerequisite for treatment:
The purpose of the Blair Upper Cervical Chiropractic Technique is not to diagnose or treat diseases or conditions, but to analyze and correct vertebral subluxations in an accurate, precise and specific manner to allow the body’s intelligence to mend, repair and maintain health from within.
A Certificate of Proficiency in NUCCA requires seminar instruction, testing in x-ray analysis and other procedures for reducing an “Atlas Subluxation Complex,” and membership in the National Upper Cervical Chiropractic Association. Completion of “Level Three” testing is required to be Board Certified in NUCCA. Upper cervical specialists may use a variety of techniques, such as Blair Upper Cervical, Atlas Orthogonal (see image below), or HIO (hole-in-one) Toggle.

Note: While fixation of the atlas (a rare occurrence) can occur and might be relieved by appropriate manipulation, the alignment of a freely movable atlas (or any vertebra) cannot be changed. When an atlas is moved by an “adjustment,” it always returns to its normal resting place, as dictated by anatomical factors, such as the configuration of joint surfaces. There is no scientific rationale or justification for repeated manipulation of the atlas to correct or prevent a “subluxation.”
It should be further noted that upper cervical manipulative techniques that force extreme rotation of the atlas pose a risk of stroke ─ albeit rare ─ by injuring vertebral or internal carotid arteries.
Applied kinesiology
The International College of Applied Kinesiology says that:
Applied Kinesiology (AK) is a system that evaluates structural, chemical and mental aspects of health using manual muscle testing combined with other standard methods of diagnoses.
Applied kinesiology, developed by a chiropractor, is a nonsensical technique used to detect and treat health problems (and vertebral subluxations causing health problems) by testing strength in certain muscles. Detecting and curing nutritional deficiencies and allergies, for example, can supposedly be done by placing a substance in a patient’s mouth, in one hand, or some place on the body and then testing muscle strength, most often by placing downward pressure on an extended arm. Weakness in a deltoid muscle would indicate a cause of the problem while strength would suggest a cure. A search for the cause and the cure of a health problem in a child may be done by placing the child on the mother’s body and then testing the strength of certain muscles in the mother.

Testing for weakness in a muscle believed to be associated with disease in an organ or a subluxation causing the disease is an arbitrary procedure that may be influenced by suggestion, an ideomotor effect, chicanery, changes in leverage or pressure, by distraction, or by the bias of practitioner assessment.
Chiropractors can obtain a diplomate in applied kinesiology (DIBAK) from the International College of Applied Kinesiology by passing a written exam after attending 300 hours of instruction followed by 3 years of kinesiology practice. Applied kinesiology is not the same as the science of kinesiology (the study of movement in muscles).
A final word: Since chiropractic is defined as a practice focused on vertebral subluxations as a cause of “reduced function, disability, or illness” (Christensen. 2015), questionable claims made for methods based on chiropractic subluxation theory remain unchallenged by the chiropractic establishment.
Unfortunately, subluxation-based chiropractic provides a simple path for true believers who have been indoctrinated in vertebral subluxation theory; it may also provide opportunity for self-serving individuals who choose to forego the rigorism of science in assuming responsibility for care of the sick and disabled.
        ◦ I wish the best for those chiropractors who reject vertebral subluxation theory and who follow the guidelines of science in offering appropriate care for musculoskeletal conditions.

“Finally…The Low Back Pain Solution”: A Chiropractor Makes Questionable Claims
Harriet Hall on May 5, 2015
Link


The ads in my local newspaper are a never-ending source of questionable health claims, most often from diet supplement manufacturers and chiropractors. There’s no single spokesman like Dr. Oz, but as a group they remind me of Oz’s unending series of weight loss miracles, each one the perfect solution until the next one comes along. The proliferation of chiropractic ads is bad advertising for the efficacy of chiropractic itself, since chiropractors are increasingly turning to adjunctive treatments like lasers and decompression machines.
The latest ad that annoyed me was from the Objective Diagnostics Research and Rehabilitation Institute (ODRRI). What an impressive name! On their website, not only do they advertise “the low back pain solution,” but they offer to fix herniated discs without surgery. They say they treat the underlying cause and say their approach is “based on solid and leading edge diagnostics, scientific research, and experience.” While not a complete lie, that statement is certainly misleading.
ODRRI: research institute or clinical practice?
Despite the impressive, sciencey title, the Objective Diagnostics Research and Rehabilitation Institute seems to consist of nothing more than two chiropractors promoting their business, Mark Woodham and Don Finlayson. Woodham owns an MRI and Motion X-ray company and has trademarked an exercise program.
Research
Under the “Research” tab, their website lists only two articles. They say:
We at ODRRI have published scientific research in peer-reviewed journals. We have recently published two articles supporting our treatment plan. We are the only group to show a reversal in low back muscle wasting and degeneration that is the underlying cause of instability in chronic recurrent low back pain.
Really? One of the two articles was published in PM&R, “The Role of the Lumbar Multifidus in Chronic Low Back Pain: A Review.” Another chiropractor, Michael Freeman, is the lead author. As the title indicates, it is a review of the current evidence for the role of multifidus muscle atrophy and the effect of stabilization exercises. It doesn’t even mention the specific techniques used by ODRRI.
The other article is a case series of three patients that was published in the Journal of Radiology Case Reports. It compares before-and-after MRIs of two patients who got spinal manipulative therapy plus low back exercises targeting the multifidus and one patient who got only spinal manipulation. The two that exercised had a decrease in multifidus atrophy and fatty replacement; the one who didn’t had an increase. The decrease in atrophy corresponded to functional improvements.
The article includes pictures of the MRIs. I was not trained to interpret MRIs, so I consulted an orthopedic surgeon and he consulted a radiologist friend of his, an expert who did a fellowship in musculoskeletal imaging. And the radiologist even got a second opinion from another radiologist. They agreed that “there is not much to these findings.” The radiologist was skeptical of the images for two reasons: “imaging is obtained with different units and not in identical scan plane” and “In the second case, there is decrease in fat throughout the field of view. i.e. compare subQ fat thickness.” They agreed that muscle atrophy is multifactorial and that decreased activity leads to muscle atrophy, but thought it was a bit of a stretch to assume that it correlates to the level of pain or is an indicator of therapeutic response. In addition, research suggests that there is little connection between symptoms and imaging findings of spinal degeneration or other abnormalities.
In short, ODRRI’s research does not constitute evidence that their hypothesis is correct or that their approach is effective.
Testimonials
Doctors who cure pneumonia with antibiotics or operate to remove inflamed appendixes don’t usually resort to advertising with testimonials from grateful patients. Quacks, snake oil salesmen, and purveyors of questionable treatments usually do. ODRRI offers testimonials, but only a paltry four of them. In one of them, a patient says Dr. Woodham told him that not only his back pain but his headaches, dizziness, and palpitations would also be relieved by spinal manipulation, specific exercises, and supplements; and they were. Another says, “At Dr. Woodham’s direction I also sleep on a strong magnetic pad that has helped my body recover…”
Magnetic mattress pads?!! That alone would be enough to make me question Dr. Woodham’s judgment. Here’s Quackwatch’s conclusion about magnet therapy:
There is no scientific basis to conclude that small, static magnets can relieve pain or influence the course of any disease. In fact, many of today’s products produce no significant magnetic field at or beneath the skin’s surface.
Blog
On their blog, they suggest that their methods may be triggering cellular regrowth. Maybe. They take credit for the MRI-verified resolution of a 7mm disc herniation. Since most herniated discs resolve on their own over time, even without treatment, there’s no way to know if this one resolved any faster because of their treatment. They like to do before-and-after MRIs on their patients to show what their treatments have accomplished, and apparently the results aren’t always this good, because they say, “Even when there is no change, that still tells us that what we did didn’t cause an effect, which could be a beneficial addition to the body of science for that particular type of approach.” Not really. The only real addition to the body of science would be a controlled study comparing their treatment to other treatments or no treatment.
The underlying cause of low back pain
Dr. Woodham had an epiphany. He hypothesized that the multifidus muscle (MFM), which controls (stabilizes) the neutral zone of spinal motion, needs to be stimulated or exercised within the neutral zone in order to reduce low back pain. After an injury, the MFM becomes “shut off,” atrophies, and is replaced by fat, making the spine unstable at that level. He says that without specific stimulation, the MFM will not begin working again.
The treatment
Their approach to treatment combines a number of modalities:
NZE: Perhaps the most important component is the trademarked Neutral Zone Exercise® (NZE) program. This is a set of core exercises developed by Dr. Woodham that he believes will selectively target the MFM and maximally stimulate it. He tested this hypothesis by trial-and-error experimenting on his patients without using a control group (that’s what he means by claiming it is “clinically proven”), and found that the exercises must be performed in a single plane of motion. He claims that proper performance of these exercises will create a pumping action to nourish the discs and cartilage and speed up tissue and cellular repair. He claims this is as effective as Salter’s continuous passive motion (CPM). If so, why does his clinic also offer CPM?
CPM: Continuous passive motion is used in rehabilitation after surgery or stroke, but there is only limited preliminary evidence for its effectiveness in low back pain. Aetna insurance considers it experimental and does not cover it.
Motion x-ray: This technique allows observation of the spine in motion, and can find abnormalities that are missed on regular x-rays. It is not a mainstream technology but is used almost exclusively by chiropractors. It exposes the patient to considerably more radiation than a single x-ray, and was banned by Health Canada because of unknowns about energy output and calibration status. Aetna classifies it as experimental and investigational and does not cover it.
Pulsed Electromagnetic Field Therapy (PEMF): They admit that PEMF is not widely used in the US. It was allegedly developed by the Soviet space program “due to their cosmonauts experiencing negative effects following reduced magnetic exposure during spaceflight.” (I suspect the negative effects were mainly due to lower gravity, not lower magnetic field strength.) PEMF is an FDA-approved treatment for stimulating bone growth in non-union of fractures. It has also been used by plastic surgeons to manage postoperative pain and edema, to treat chronic wounds, and to facilitate vasodilation and angiogenesis.
There is no evidence that it improves outcomes in low back pain. In fact, after reviewing all the evidence, Aetna determined that its effectiveness had not been established for most uses.
Spinal decompression therapy: They claim that this is 70-80% effective. I have already looked into the claims for spinal decompression machines and found them wanting. The Medical Letter concluded:
There is no acceptable evidence that non-surgical spinal decompression machines can correct degenerated or herniated discs or that they relieve pain in patients with these conditions. There is also no convincing evidence that the physiological responses of lumbar tissue to power traction equipment are superior to those with standard mechanical traction.
Lifestyle changes: OK, that sounds like a good idea in general, especially for patients who are overweight or have nutritional deficiencies. I don’t know about the unspecified “dietary toxins” they refer to.
Nutrition: They have “put together a solid foundation of healthy diet choices” and “joint supplementation will be at the core of your nutritional supplement program.” They don’t offer any evidence that diet changes or supplements can improve the outcome of back pain.
NOTE: when I cite Aetna, I am not citing them as an authority, but only as one example of a group that has reached a different conclusion after reviewing the existing scientific literature. In other words, if Aetna considers a treatment or diagnostic method experimental, that indicates to me that the method is not generally accepted as a conventional mainstream method, has not been proven to everyone’s satisfaction, and remains questionable.
Conclusion
There is no way to know if ODRRI’s multifidus muscle hypothesis is correct. There is no way to know if their approach is really successful in treating back pain. There is no way to know if it is superior to other approaches, since no controlled studies have been done. The natural history of low back pain is that it usually resolves over time with or without treatment. We know that bed rest slows recovery and that exercise, even just walking, aids recovery. So without a proper control group, ODRRI’s research is practically guaranteed to confirm their beliefs. They may be good marketers, but they are not good scientists.
I can believe their exercise program will help back pain patients, but I’m not persuaded that any other good exercise program wouldn’t help just as much, and I’m very skeptical about most of the other things they offer. I would love to believe they have found “the back pain solution,” but I will remain unconvinced until they can provide more credible data.

The Straw Protocol: A Chiropractor’s Aggressively Promoted Neuropathy Treatment
William M. London on February 27, 2015
Link

Full-page ads promoting free dinner seminars addressing the topic of “Non-surgical, drug-free approach to relief from Peripheral [sic] Neuropathy [sic]” appeared last year on at least nine Sundays in the main news section of the print edition of The Los Angeles Times. The seminars were scheduled at various restaurants in Orange County, Los Angeles County, and Inland Empire.
The Los Angeles Times claims a Sunday circulation of 962,192 and a readership of two million for the Sunday main news section. The cost of full-page ads in the main section of Sundays varies, but I was given a quote of $32,500 by an advertising consultant for the paper.
The ads included on their upper left, in small print, the words “HEALTH TODAY” and on the same line—though perhaps less noticeably—at the far right of the page the word “ADVERTISEMENT.” In a much larger font was the headline:
Do You Suffer from One Of These Seven Symptoms Of This Often Misdiagnosed Problem?
It was followed by this subtitle:
Tens of Millions Suffer And Often Don’t Know Where to Turn
The ads indicated that discussion at the seminars would include:
    • What REALLY causes Peripheral [sic] Neuropathy [sic]
    • Three crippling effects of Neuropathy [sic]
    • Dangers associated with medications
    • The Straw Protocol, which utilizes proprietary treatment methods and provides outstanding results for people who suffer from Neuropathy
The ads warned that seating at the dinner seminars would be limited and instructed readers to call for a reservation and to provide the RSVP code in the ad (apparently to enable the marketer to keep track of where each caller found out about the seminars). Next to the toll-free number provided in each ad was the name of the advertiser: OPTIMAL HEALTH, and then below it in much smaller, easily overlooked print: Straw Chiropractic. Keeping the print small for the word chiropractic is a clever promotional tactic; many prudent consumers would not be inclined to seek chiropractors for peripheral neuropathy treatment.
I called the advertised phone number, but since I said (honestly) that I didn’t have any of the seven symptoms of neuropathy listed in the ad, I would not be permitted to attend any of the free dinner seminars. (I was disappointed to not qualify for a free dinner since I’m on a tight budget just like many other critics of health pseudoscience who get falsely accused of being paid off by Big Pharma.)
However, the ad offered a second phone number to call in order to obtain more detailed information and answers to common questions about the Straw Protocol without a having to indicate one’s symptoms and attend a seminar. I called the number, 888-858-9291, and left a message with my name and address along with a request that the advertised “Free special report and DVD” be mailed to me. The materials arrived a few days later.

The promotional DVD
The title on the label of the DVD is “Our Patients Speak” followed by “The Neuropathy Treatment Center by Optimal Health Straw Chiropractic.” On the left side of the label is the instruction: “Call Today for a FREE Consultation and Evaluation!” (The exclamation mark here is a strong signal of hype.) On the right side of the label, it exclaims “$249 Value!” I guess that’s supposed to be the value of the consultation and evaluation rather than the value of the DVD.
On the bottom of the label is a number to call to find the location to find the nearest location of the Neuropathy Treatment Center. I called and was told there are five locations. Three are in Los Angeles County: Glendale, Placentia, and Gardena. The other locations are in Corona (Inland Empire) and Lake Forest (Orange County). I learned from the website of the practice, optimalhealthsc.com, that there is also an “affiliated practice,” Restore Medical Group Greathouse Chiropractic Inc., with locations in San Diego and Sunnyvale.
The DVD plays for just a few minutes and consists of five neuropathy patients expressing satisfaction with treatment from the Neuropathy Treatment Center and dissatisfaction with medications previously prescribed for them from other doctors. Many people can be persuaded to try treatments based on such testimonials, but testimonials regarding clinical benefits are not trustworthy. Consumers often fail to consider that the experiences described in testimonials may poorly represent the experiences of most people who try a new advertised treatment. If the patients actually experienced relief from their neuropathy while they were receiving Straw Protocol treatment, it doesn’t necessarily mean that the relief is attributable to the treatment. And it’s important to recognize that some chiropractors who have solicited testimonials from patients have been found to provide incentives and/or discounts to patients who offer testimonials.
The cover letter for the mailing comes with instructions to watch the enclosed DVD before reading the enclosed special report. Advertisers recognize that this sequence tends to make their messages more persuasive. It’s likely that people tend to be less suspicious of information provided in literature after they have been exposed to relatable role models who appear sincere while offering encouraging stories.
The special report
The tabloid layout of the report reminds me of the many advertising mailers made to look like health newsletters that are sent to people who get on mailing lists of quacks. I wrote about such “Advertising Mailers in Disguise” in 2001 when I served as president of the National Council Against Health Fraud, Inc.
The front cover of the report is made to look official with the words “Optimal Health’s” in the upper left-hand corner, “Summer 2014” in the upper right hand corner, “Natural Health Journal” as a heading, and “Practical Solutions for Optimum Health & Healing” as a sub-heading. The rest of the cover shouts out its hype with lots of bold lettering, enlarged lettering, varied font styles, varied colored lettering, all-caps, italicized lettering, exclamation points, a photo of an older woman along with a quotation that supposedly comes from her, and a concluding sentence in title case. Here’s the text:
A REVOLUTIONARY new way of treating peripheral neuropathy can help you throw away your pills and…
“KISS YOUR PAIN & NUMBNESS GOODBYE”
    • BANISH THE NUMBNESS!
    • Sleep restfully without tossing & turning or stabbing and shooting pain waking you!
    • End those weird ‘skin-crawling’ feelings!
    • No more limitations on your activities!
    • Regain your good balance!
    • Live the life you deserve!
“I now have feeling in my feet that I have not felt in over twenty years!!”
Thousands Have Already Experienced This Advanced Method of Treatment and Found Freedom From The Vise-Like Hold Neuropathy Had Over Their Lives!
See Inside [along with a curved arrow as a guide to turn the page]
The inside of the report consists of eight pages (page 2 through 9) along with a back cover offering tabloid-style hype similar to what appears on the front cover. Page 2 consists of a letter to the reader that indicates the treatment protocol “has already helped more than 3000 people over the last three years!” In an attempt to overcome any reasonable skepticism, the letter includes this paragraph:
This is neither far-fetched [sic] hope nor over-the-top hype like you’ve seen thrown around by ‘Miracle Pill” hucksters.
Well, I’ll be the judge of that. And so will you if you read on.
Page 3 consists of three testimonials and an introduction to “Dr. Phil Straw, D.C.” (I previously pointed out in my discussion of the supposed experts interviewed in the execrable first part of the video “The Quest for the Cures…Continues” that it’s a bad sign when practitioners are introduced redundantly with “Dr.” before their names and a degree after their names.)
I learned that Dr. Straw is the author of the 2014 book Neuropathy: How to Relieve Foot Numbness, Tingling, Burning, and Cramping Without Drugs or Surgery, he earned his “under-graduate [sic] degree from the University of California Santa Barbara in 1988 and doctor [sic] of Chiropractic in 1995” (from an unidentified institution, but clearly not UCSB), that he’s a “[s]ought-after speaker on peripheral neuropathy and the importance of maintaining optimum health through natural medicine and proper nutrition” (and I would be similarly sought-after if I also offered free dinners with my free seminars), and that he’s the “Creator of THE STRAW PROTOCOL.”
By the way, I am following THE LONDON PROTOCOL in writing about THE STRAW PROTOCOL (and you are supposed to be very impressed indeed by the capital letters in the name of my protocol).
Part of THE LONDON PROTOCOL is to check for disciplinary actions against practitioners who advertise aggressively. I found that, in November 2012, California’s Board of Chiropractic Examiners issued a citation to Philip Arthur Straw for his advertisements and Straw paid his fine in full.
I contacted a staff member serving California’s Board of Chiropractic Examiners and obtained a copy of the citation sent to Dr. Straw, which remains a public record. The section of the letter with the heading “Cause of Citation” reads:
On July 27, 2012 the Board received a complaint from N. F. alleging that the claims made in your advertisements, “Which of These Warning Signs Could Lead to Foot Amputation?” and “Don’t Let Your Neuropathy Put You in a Wheel Chair” are misleading to the public. The advertisements and your response to the Board’s Inquiry were forwarded to a chiropractic expert consultant for review. The Board expert opined that you have used worst-case clinical scenarios as headlines in your advertisements, and in doing so you have engaged in the use of misrepresentations, distortions, sensational or fabulous statements, or which have a tendency to deceive the public. In doing so, you are in violation of CCR section 311 advertisements.
In addition, the Board’s expert opined that your self-appointed designation as a “leading regional authority” and “expert” in such matters is a sensational, distorted statement that has a tendency to deceive the public. The Board expert added that the Board of Chiropractic Examiners does not recognize such expertise, and you have not demonstrated that you possess any diplomate status that might lend truthfulness to such a claim. In doing so, you are in violation of CCR section 311 advertisements.
As mentioned by Los Angeles Times business and consumer columnist David Lazarus in a column published August 25th 2014, the fine was only $500. That slap on the wrist tells you how seriously the Board of Chiropractic Examiners takes CCR section 311. Although the ads from Straw in 2014 didn’t have the same fear-mongering headlines and claims of expertise as the ads mentioned in the 2012 complaint, the claim that the Straw Protocol provides outstanding results should be viewed as a CCR section 311 violation.
Another part of THE LONDON PROTOCOL is to check for publication of clinical research findings in the scholarly literature. A Google Scholar search on “Philip Straw” revealed no such publications. No surprise! I see little reason to consider the Straw Protocol as an “Advanced Method of Treatment” as the ads in 2014 characterized it.
Page 4 of the special report consists of a brief description of peripheral neuropathy in simple language followed by criticisms of the drugs prescribed the medical community to treat peripheral neuropathy. The discussion includes the misleading suggestion that medical doctors treat peripheral neuropathy only to manage symptoms, with drugs and sometimes surgery. It disregards how standard treatment begins with addressing conditions underlying peripheral neuropathies and includes mechanical aids for symptom management. It includes a common medical establishment-bashing trope:
Perhaps the reason you may not have heard of the treatment options available for your peripheral neuropathy (like the method described on the next couple of pages of this report) is because of the stubbornly-held notion that, when it comes to medical treatments that don’t involve a needle or a pharmaceutical company’s pill, the establishment community can be ‘a bit set in their ways.’
Then again, perhaps this is a straw person (or straw establishment community) attack and the popular press has ignored THE STRAW PROTOCOL because it’s just one of the hundreds of non-evidence-based gimmicks for healing promoted by chiropractors. If there was compelling clinical research evidence indicating that the Straw Protocol is safe and the advertising claims made for it are valid, I think we would have heard about it (especially from the Straw-supported Los Angeles Times).
(A fact sheet from the National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke provides a much more informative description of peripheral neuropathy than does Straw’s report. The fact sheet describes the classification, symptoms, causes, diagnostic tests, and treatment, for peripheral neuropathy.)
Pages 5 through 8 include eleven more testimonials, more hype from Dr. Straw, and a description of the four steps of the Straw Protocol (also described on Straw Chiropractic’s website).
    • Step 1 (Stimulate) of his protocol uses an electronic device that, we are told, has approval for a number of pain indications, but is not a transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation device. It’s good to be wary of devices that promoters fail to identify by name. When practitioners are secretive about their treatments, they sidestep scrutiny. I’m reminded of a catchphrase of Dana Carvey’s Church Lady character: “How convenient!”
    • Step 2 (Rejuvenate) is to increase overall circulation by utilizing light emitting diode (LED) therapy. The description of Step 2 also includes a reference to investigations by NASA. Such references are common in the promotion of non-validated health gimmicks.
According to the BlueCross BlueShield of Tennessee Medical Policy Manual’s statement on LED therapy (reviewed most recently on 9/11/14):
Light emitting diode therapy for the treatment of conditions / diseases, including but not limited to diabetic peripheral neuropathy, lymphedema, non-healing wounds, tendonitis, capsulitis, and pain is considered investigational. (Emphasis in original.]
Investigational means not appropriately promoted in free dinner seminars to recruit paying patients. Another key point in the statement:
Scientific evidence in peer review literature is lacking regarding the use, safety, improvement or effectiveness on health outcomes for light emitting diode therapy.
    • Step 3 (Activate) “uses different frequencies of vibration on different areas of your body which further stimulates new capillary and nerve regeneration.” It would appear that Straw’s patients are shaken (if not stirred), but it isn’t clear that they’re pickin’ up good vibrations, excitations, or healing.
Exposure to some sources of vibration is one of many recognized causes of peripheral neuropathy. That doesn’t mean other sources of vibration provide relief. A review article published in 2015 on whole body vibration (WBV) for rehabilitation of peripheral neuropathies concluded:
The results of this literature search suggest insufficient evidence to assess the effectiveness for the effects of WBV on neuropathic pain, muscle strength and balance in patients with peripheral neuropathies, as there is a clear lack of methodologically high quality research on the subject.
In other words, WBV is a non-validated treatment.
    • Step 4 (Empower) is described as “truly THE KEY to not only reaching your desired level of pain-free health, but staying there for as long as you like.” It amounts to “nutritional education and proper supplementation” against chronic inflammation.
Inflammation is a complex bodily response to infection and injury that can be either beneficial or harmful. While chronic inflammation appears to play a role in the development of some chronic diseases, it is unclear that any special supposedly anti-inflammatory regimen of foods and dietary supplements can provide clinically-significant relief to peripheral neuropathy patients.
Dietary supplements are frequently tainted with drugs and often do not contain ingredients in doses listed on their labels. Paying more for practitioner-recommended (or -dispensed) supplement formulations provides illusory assurance.
On page 9 of the report is this pitch (bolding in original):
If you call and schedule your appointment for your own exam within 7 days of receiving this package, I will waive the entire $249 fee for you.
It’s followed by an offer of a free copy of Straw’s book at the exam.
I didn’t call within seven days. Soon after I received a letter from Straw Chiropractic renewing the offer for the free exam if I called within two to three days and the book would still be available for me.

After failing to make the second deadline, I received a second notice which began “Hello…?” followed by a letter beginning with the words: “You’re smart. I can tell.” The letter went on to express surprise that I hadn’t called. The free diagnostic exam offer was still available along with the free book, but “is just not going to be an option for very much longer.” The letter came with a flyer featuring eleven more testimonials.


I waited for months to call to find out about costs of the Straw Protocol. The initial free exam and consultation offer was still available.
Costs to patients
Consumers should be wary of high-pressure sales pitches for limited time offers. Practitioners who place full-page newspapers ads need to work hard to get patients into their clinics. They need to recoup their investments in advertising (e.g., newspaper ads) and direct selling (e.g., dinner seminars) and then earn enough from fees charged to patients to make good money.
I reached a sales representative over the phone for Straw Chiropractic and was told that if I were a candidate for the treatment (that I really had peripheral neuropathy and it wasn’t too advanced), it would cost me $500 to $10,000 for five to fifteen weeks of treatment. Insurance doesn’t pay for any of the treatment. The representative wasn’t sure whether the quoted figures include the cost of purchasing dietary supplements.
Advertising in 2015
Thus far in 2015, in some, but not all Sundays, ads of varying sizes for the Straw Protocol have appeared in the main section of The Los Angeles Times. The most recent advertisements (as of this writing), on February 15th and 22nd were smaller than a quarter of a page and included an invitation to call for the free DVD and report. None of the newer ads included invitations to free dinner seminars.
However, I noticed on another page in the main section of the paper a half-page ad for free dinner seminars from the NEUROPATHY RELIEF CENTER of Long Beach Presented by Ballerini Chiropractic. The pitch is very similar to the pitch used by Straw Chiropractic. I will need to investigate further to find out the source of marketing campaigns used by chiropractors to promote peripheral neuropathy treatments services.
Other chiropractors who promoted free dinner seminars
Dr. Straw’s marketing campaign featuring free dinner seminars reminds me of similar recent campaigns by other chiropractors. For example, as I described previously:
[Brandon Lee Babcock, D.C.] pitched a bogus nutritional cure for diabetes. But, as reported December 9th, 2013 by The Salt Lake Tribune, his scheme bilked older adults in Utah of thousands of dollars. To recruit patients, he offered free gourmet dinners where attendees were shown video testimonials and given information about Babcock’s supposed “diabetes breakthrough.” He tricked patients into signing papers that established lines of credit with Chase Health Advance and he maxed out the $6,000 limit when patients tried to withdraw from his services. Some patients testified that Dr. Babcock and his staff misled them into signing up for credit without their knowledge or consent. Others said Babcock refused to provide refunds despite a 30-day opt-out guarantee and a promise of 100% satisfaction.
In 2008, the Utah Department of Occupational and Professional Licensing (DOPL) issued a “non-disciplinary cease-and-desist order” after finding that he advertised treatments for conditions he wasn’t qualified to treat: depression, multiple sclerosis, fibromyalgia, learning problems, attention deficit disorder, allergies, hormone replacement relief, sleep problems and memory loss.
In April 2012, the DOPL suspended Babcock’s chiropractic license by emergency order. In August 2012, West Jordan City revoked Babcock’s business license. The Salt Lake Tribune noted, however, that he continued to lead seminars promoting his program to reverse Type II diabetes.
In October 2013, a jury convicted him of six third-degree felony counts of exploiting a vulnerable adult. In December 2013, he was sentenced to six months in jail.
Colorado-based chiropractors Brandon Credeur, D.C. (a classmate of Brandon Babcock at Parker College of Chiropractic) and his wife Heather Credeur, D.C. also used newspaper advertising to attract diabetics to seminars following free gourmet dinners to promote their “functional endocrinology” treatments to diabetics and people with symptoms of low thyroid function. Jann Bellamy has discussed both Babcock and the Credeurs previously on ScienceBasedMedicine.
A September 2011 complaint from Colorado’s Board of Chiropractic Examiners against Brandon Credeur charged him with violations of the Board’s rules regarding scope of practice; misleading, deceptive, false, or unethical advertising; untrue, deceptive or misleading practices regarding unproven and/or unnecessary services; and record keeping requirements. But instead of losing his chiropractic license, as many of his former patients had hoped, following a hearing in an administrative court room, Credeur’s case ended in a settlement in which he admitted to nothing and agreed to keep better records.
On June 19th, 2013, the Colorado Medical Board sent an order to Brandon and Heather Credeur to cease and desist practicing medicine without a license. That same day, they declared bankruptcy to the dismay of former patients who have sued them to get their money back. A ruling from an administrative law judge is anticipated in response to the Credeur’s challenge to the Medical Board’s order.
The Credeurs remain licensed to practice chiropractic in Colorado.
Candice McCowin, an Irvine, California chiropractor ran newspaper ads claiming breakthrough treatments for diabetes and other chronic illnesses to be discussed at free dinner events. In March 2014, the California Board of Chiropractic Examiners cited the “free diabetic guides” she distributed as misleading ads. As noted in a column by David Lazarus, “McCowin paid a $500 fine and agreed to ensure that future ads ‘not be construed as misleading or deceiving to the public.” Dr. McCowin, I will be looking for your ads.
A few final thoughts
Advertisements that appear in The Los Angeles Times (or any other newspaper) should never be presumed to be trustworthy. The screening processes used by advertising departments of news organizations are typically inadequate to assure that ads are not false or misleading.
The $500 fine for “advertising in a potentially deceptive manner and for portraying himself as a neuropathy expert” that Dr. Straw paid in 2012 was no serious deterrent. I consider recent advertisements by Straw Chiropractic in newspapers and in mailers to patients to be misleading.
The direct selling approach of free dinner seminars and free initial consultations can be seductive. People often respond to acts of apparent kindness and generosity with a sense of obligation to reciprocate. But reciprocation to a sales pitch for a non-validated treatment protocol is unlikely to lead to relief and is likely to be costly.
I don’t expect that licensing boards in California are inclined to take appropriate action to protect consumers from inappropriate advertising of health services. But consumers need to file complaints and they need to let legislators know that they object to practitioners who deceptively advertise health services for financial gain and to licensing boards that fail to adequately protect the public.

Chiropractic Neurology
Steven Novella on November 16, 2011
Link
Chiropractic is a diverse collection of beliefs and practices occurring under a broad regulatory label. The differences among various chiropractics are so stark that it is difficult to make general statements about chiropractic practice. At one end of the spectrum, however, are so-called “straight” chiropractors who adhere to the original philosophy of D.D. Palmer – that a vital force they call innate intelligence is response for health, and blockages in the flow of this magical force through the nerves are what cause illness. Such chiropractors believe they can influence non-neuromuscular conditions by restoring the flow of innate blocked by mysterious “subluxations” in the spine.
From chiropractors.org we have this definition of “straight” chiropractors:
Because straight chiropractors believe that nearly all diseases are caused by issues with the spine, they don’t believe they need any diagnostic tools. Traditional testing done by medical doctors and hospitals is not even considered by a straight chiropractor as being necessary. Diagnosis is done by finding the subluxations in the spine so that those can be corrected.
This particular version of chiropractic (by some estimates about a third of chiropractors follow this philosophy) is pure pseudoscience. It is, as indicated by the quote above, hostile to science-based medicine.  After a century of such belief there isn’t a bit of evidence to support the notion of innate intelligence, chiropractic subluxations, or health benefits from this approach.
Some straight chiropractors even “specialize” – one specialty, chiropractic neurology, has been getting some press because hockey star Sidney Crosby has been going to a chiropractic neurologist, Ted Carrick, to treat his concussion. The main idea behind chiropractic neurology is the same as for straight chiropractic in general, just applied to neurological disorders.
Carrick claims that he can treat a variety of brain disorders with targeted manipulation and elaborate exercises and routines. In a PBS interview he said:
Well, we’re finding every day that more and more things that we didn’t think were associated with chiropractic treatment can be affected very nicely. There are testimonials from people who have had their eyesight and hearing back, and people waking up from comas.
Waking a patient from a coma is perhaps the ultimate rehabilitative claim in neurology. You will notice, of course, that Carrick refers to only “testimonials”. The reason for that is because there are no published articles establishing such bold claims. Chiropractic neurology does not appear to be based on any body of research, or any accumulated scientific knowledge. I am not aware of any research that establishes their core claims. A search on PubMed for “Carrick T” yielded nothing, and searching on “chiropractic neurology” yielded mostly studies about neurological complications from chiropractic treatment. There was one letter from the President of the International Academy of Chiropractic Neurology.
I followed that link to the IACN website, but found no references or links to any published studies establishing the scientific basis of chiropractic neurology. There was no science at all. I also noted that the IACN mission statement does not make any mention of promoting  scientific research or science-based standards. Here it is:
The mission of the IACN is to provide an outlet for expression and communication of professional opinions for the benefit and enhancement of the neurological sciences as they relate to the chiropractic profession for the best service to humankind. Further, the IACN promotes the proper use of principles and techniques in the field of chiropractic neurology and support those principles, policies and practices that seek the attainment of the highest order of excellence in neurologic skills directed at patient care by doctors of chiropractic.
The IACN serves to promote the highest standards of moral and ethical conduct amongst chiropractic neurologists.
The wording is interesting – they talk about opinions, principles, and practices. They refer to the “enhancement of the neurological sciences” but it is not clear what that means.
Chiropractic neurology appears to me to be the very definition of pseudoscience – it has all the trappings of a legitimate profession, with a complex set of beliefs and practices, but there is no underlying scientific basis for any of it.
It should be noted that neurological symptoms are often especially vulnerable to placebo effects.  Many symptoms, like vertigo, or “fogginess” are highly subjective. There is also a well-established “cheerleader” effect – if you take anyone with chronic neurological symptoms (such as chronic deficits from a stroke) and then give them any intervention, they will perform better. Just getting patients off the couch and moving will have some effect. Careful research is necessary to separate the specific effects of an intervention from the non-specific effects of  motivation, mood, activity, and also just time. The brain can heal itself to some degree, and after an injury there can be an improvement for even years afterward.
Some symptoms are also susceptible to conditioning. Vertigo is perhaps the best example of this. At present the most effective treatment for chronic vertigo (a subjective sense of movement, such as spinning) is vestibular therapy – physical therapy designed to condition the patient to the symptoms, to diminish them over time. It is therefore possible that some chiropractic neurology interventions are simply providing this known mechanism. For example, here is a description of Carrick’s treatment of Hockey player, Crosby:
Carrick then signals to restart the gyroscope—with one difference. This time Crosby will be turned upside-down while he is also spun around. He hasn’t experienced this dual action yet. The door clangs shut. Above it, a stack of red, yellow and green lights shines while 10 high-pitched beeps signal the gyroscope is about to start. Ding! Ding! Ding! Ding! Ding! Ding! Ding! Ding! Ding! Ding!
This is a very dramatic treatment, sure to impress the naive. It follows a common philosophy in dubious neurological treatments – the notion that you can “rebuild the brain” by stimulating it. While it is true that activity and simulation are better than no activity and stimulation, it does not follow that simply increasing stimulation will increase the brain’s plasticity or recovery (a simplistic more-is-better philosophy). That basic notion was researched and discarded decades ago, for example with specific reference to psychomotor patterning treatments.
Chiropractic neurology is an excellent example of exactly why we need science-based practices. Without a grounding in objective evidence there does not appear to be any limit to the degree that beliefs systems can be led astray. Any treatment can deceptively seem to work, and humans are very good at backfilling in justifications and explanations for phenomena that do not even exist. Left to our own devices we will tend to develop elaborate, but entirely fictitious, belief systems.
We figured our centuries ago, however, that systematic methods of controlling variables, controlling for bias, and rigorous statistical analysis can compensate for such human foibles. Until chiropractic neurology (and similar practices) avail themselves of such methods there is no reason to take their claims seriously.

Quantum Neurology
Steven Novella on September 18, 2013
Link
As the resident neurologist on SBM, my ears always prick up when I come across a new neurology-based scam, and my colleagues often send such items my way. In addition the word “quantum” has become a standard marketing term of alt. med quackery. So how could I resist taking a bite out of “quantum neurology”?
One might think (if one were a completely naïve rube) that those claiming to practice quantum neurology have, through diligent research, discovered how certain quantum principles apply to nervous system function and disease, leading to new treatment modalities. On the other hand, a more savvy consumer of such health claims (such as regular readers of SBM) would likely suspect that quantum neurology will turn out to be the same-old mix of nonsense and snake oil in a shiny new package.
Let’s have a look.
According to the Hayden Institute, which appears to be a typical vanity institute of one Chase Hayden, DC:
Quantum Neurology focuses on allowing nerves that may be associated with painful or debilitating injuries, illnesses, or conditions to stabilize so that the body can heal itself. This safe non-invasive technique that allows the doctor to evaluate, strengthen, and rehabilitate every major nerve in the body. This is accomplished with a specific series of upper and lower body muscle strength tests designed to evaluate the entire spinal cord, as well as strengthening the nerves with light therapy, and gentle joint mobilization.
We are also informed that:
Nerves control every function in your body, and when they become dysfunctional, a symptom develops. In order to wiggle your toes, walk, identify temperature changes, breathe, have your heart beat, or any other function in your body, a nerve has to send a message.
In other words, quantum neurology is just straight-chiropractic vitalism by a new name. Straight chiropractic, as imagined by D.D. Palmer, is based on the pre-scientific vitalistic notion that life energy flows through the nerves to the entire body and is essential for health. All illness is caused by blockages to the flow of this life energy, and therefore all illness can be treated by restoring this flow. What blocks this flow are subtle (meaning non-existent) subluxations or misalignments of the spine, which some chiropractors still claim they can correct with manipulations, restoring flow, and allowing the body to heal itself.
This is why straight chiropractors believe they can treat things like asthma, a disease of the lungs.
Above we have the absolute claim that “nerves control every function in your body.” This is demonstrably not true. Not all organs and functions are regulated by nervous control. The liver, for example, functions quite nicely on its own. You could make the strained argument that the autonomic nervous system regulates blood flow, and blood flow is critical to all functions of the body, but that still does not mean that the nerves control liver function. One might as well say that the thyroid “controls” every function in the body.
They also claim that in order for the heart to beat a nerve has to send a message – also not true. The heart has its own internal electrical system and beats all on its own. It is regulated partly by autonomic nerves, but it does not need them to beat. Transplanted hearts, for example, have no nerve supply, and work just fine.
The notion that nerves control everything is chiropractic philosophy, not science.
Under their “services” tab they list applied kinesiology – we have discussed this on SBM before as well. Applied kinesiology is more chiropractic magic, nothing more than self-deception and the ideomotor effect. Practitioners claim they can diagnose illness through muscle strength testing, but it only seems to work when the tester knows the results they want to get (just like dowsing). Applied kinesiology is essentially dowsing with muscles.
They also offer “detoxification” and “functional endocrinology.” Two other topics we have already thoroughly exposed as nonsense on SBM.
They don’t exactly claim they can cure specific diseases, but their website proclaims that, “Patients have reported improvements with the following symptoms and conditions.” That’s a nice dodge. They then provide a long list of conditions and serious diseases, such as epilepsy, multiple sclerosis, high blood pressure, skin rashes, and many more.
Another chiropractor offering “quantum neurology” is George Gonzalez, author of the book Holographic Healing. Gonzalez informs us:
We now understand that the Nervous System is inclusive of every aspect of action and communication available to our body. It includes our physical body and our all aspects of our nonphysical body: also known as our energetic body, Bio-Energetic Field, Aura or LightBody. It includes our mind, our thoughts, our emotions and our Spiritual connection.
He offers something called the GRT LITE (trademarked), which is just light therapy. This is pure snake oil without any scientific plausibility or credible evidence that it does anything. It is a virtual magic wand.
On such websites I always look for references to research to support the amazing claims being made for medical innovations. New medical technology does not just come out of nowhere – there has to be a paper trail of research supporting it. Gonzalez says that research is important, and he requires research of his quantum neurology (trademarked) training seminars. What he considers “research,” however, are case studies. Case reports are useful in medicine – but they are not considered “research.”
He presents, for example, a case study of a patient who suffered a brain aneurysm. The case report is so poorly written, if a medical student handed this in I would seriously question their competency. We are not given any specific details. The report was actually painful for me to read. For example, we are told that the patient had an aneurysm, but we are not told its size and location. We are told he had surgery, but not told which procedure, exactly. Nowhere in the write up of the case is it mentioned that the aneurysm hemorrhaged – it’s as if Gonzalez thinks “aneurysm” means bleed, rather than a defect in an artery that can rupture and bleed. He also states that the “baseball sized” aneurysm was removed “from the patient’s skull.” Aneurysms are not in the skull – from the one image provided the aneurysm was clearly intracranial.
It’s almost as if the case study was written by someone without any medical knowledge at all, let alone specialist neurological knowledge.
Gonzalez is apparently impressed that the patient recovered following the aneurysm bleed, the impressiveness supported by the claim that, “The family was told” that he would be neurologically impaired and need a caregiver. Second-hand information through an emotional family is not exactly a credible source of prognostic information.
In fact, most people who suffer such a bleed will improve significantly. The imaging provided shows only a moderate-sized bleed. Once the swelling goes down and the blood is reabsorbed the patient should recover nicely.
Conclusion
Quantum Neurology displays all the features of pseudoscience – its practitioners use jargon to dress up superstitious pre-scientific beliefs, they make claims not supported by plausibility or evidence, they go through the motions of something they can present as science without any of the substance, and they surround themselves with the trappings of legitimacy.
They lack the true substance of science, however. There is no research to support their claims. They cannot explain their claims in terms that are compatible with existing science. They have not conducted research capable of exploring whether or not their core claims are true, let alone their alleged clinical applications.
Their claims are vacuous but they ride on a magic carpet of slick marketing. “Quantum Neurology” and “Holographic Healing” are just that – marketing terms meant to give the false impression of modernity to crusty pre-scientific nonsense.

Chiropractic Nose Balloons
Mark Crislip on May 29, 2015
Link


You can pick your friends. You can pick your nose. But you can’t pick your friends nose.
Unless you practice Nasal Cranial Release.
There are so many pseudo-medicines, it is hard to keep track. New variations appear, new combinations of old SCAMs occur, old pseudo-medicines wax and wane, although no pseudo-medicine ever dies. Except phenology? Maybe? I find a few phrenology sites on the web, but I cannot tell if they are real or satire.
There is an ongoing discussion in my family as to the greatest band of all time. The Who is THE correct answer, but really, bands do not have to follow the Pauli exclusion principle. There can be multiple greatest bands of all time, all existing simultaneously at the same place. Except that The Who is a little bit more greater than the others. Yes. More greater.
The same concept applies to SCAMs. Whose goofiness reigns supreme? Homeopathy? Reiki? Epigenetic Birth Control? They are all equally goofy, each in their own special way.
In my feeds I saw the announcement that “Anderson Chiropractic Announces Nasal Cranial Release Therapy“. I had never heard of Nasal Cranial Release Therapy. It sounds bad, turning humans into a PEZ dispenser, popping off the skull by way of the nose, a particularly horrific form of rhinotillexomania. It’s not that goofy. But close.
Nasal Cranial Release appears to be the mutant offspring of chiropractic and craniosacral therapy and goes by a variety of other names including:
Endonasal Technique, Bilateral Nasal Specific Technique, Functional Cranial Release, and Neurocranial Release
Balloons, or hobbit condoms, I can’t tell from the photographs, are inserted in the nose and inflated to realign cranial bones. Really. Watch the video. Judging from the patient it is not a pleasant experience. And I always watch these videos with the eye of an infection control doctor. No gloves or hand hygiene to be seen and given the propensity for MRSA to be harbored in the nose it gives me the willies. The procedure appears to be booger compression, an intervention I suspect no one really needs. Compressing snot is unlikely to have any significant anatomic or physiologic effects.
The method is different than balloon sinuplasty where the sinuses are opened up by expanding a balloon in the sinus ostia. In contrast to Nasal Cranial Release the balloon is directed into place with an endoscope and look! They use local anesthesia and wear gloves in a procedure room. Watch the videos sequentially and compare and contrast real medicine with cargo cult medicine.
Nasal Cranial Release was developed in the 1930s by a chiropractor and naturopath in Portland Oregon to treat concussion and traumatic brain injury. Really. It gives me the heebie-jeebies to think of inflating a balloon in the nose after traumatic brain injury. The balloon should do nothing to normal skulls, but if there were an occult basilar skull fracture?
The information to support the practice is almost, but not quite, entirely unlike data. I found case report that after:
Chiropractic manipulation and soft tissue manipulation administered 2–6 times per month for approximately 1 yr had minimal long-term effect on the patient’s head pain.
Really? The patient returned 6 times a month for a year with no effect from the intervention? That’s salesmanship.
Then the patient had resolution of the headache after several months (!) of nasal realignment. The patient probably reporting improvement so they would never have to return for more treatments. It would appear to be the only way to escape the clutches of that particular chiropractor.
Even chiropractors admit that:
No articles appear available in the scientific literature that examine the efficacy of the nasal specific technique for treating any pathology. Searching for such literature uncovered one unpublished study by Nyiendo and Goldeen. Their study concluded that claims for improved vision and hearing following nasal specific treatment could neither be supported nor refuted. They did find, however, changes in craniofacial measurements that did not reach significance when compared to a control (sham-treated) group.
No known efficacy and no effect on the skull, yet like all pseudo-medicines, the ‘indications’ are broad. Mostly suggested for concussion and head trauma, it is also suggested for a variety of neurologic diseases and symptoms.
One chiropractic site even suggests it will prevent the need for braces. The mechanism?
the connective tissues that surround your brain and spinal cord called the Dura Mater are specifically released using endonasal balloon inflations.
And the nasal balloons:
Restore the brains ability to oxygenate itself through both improving air flow into higher area’s through the nasal passage
Which made me giggle as it seems to imply that oxygen gets to the brain directly across the base of the brain rather than from the arteries by way of the lung.
No surprise, the only reports on Pubmed I could find are complications: fracture and bleeding.
Chiropractors like to brag that their education is on par with MDs. Then they do bone-headed pseudo-science like this, actually thinking that by inflating a balloon in the nose they can place:
… the bones in better alignment allows for optimal blood flow to the brain and spinal cord and neuro-transmitter activity throughout the central nervous system.
After a shorter version of this essay a chiropractor commented
Please don’t generalize. Most chiropractors don’t do this ridiculous crap and we definitely do not learn this in chiropractic school.
As if correcting spinal subluxations, the raison d’être of chiropractic, is any less goofy. And maybe the other ridiculous crap in chiropractic school will be no longer be taught:
European Schools Sign Anti-Subluxation Position Statement
Six chiropractic schools signed a position statement that says:
The teaching of vertebral subluxation complex as a vitalistic construct that claims that it is the cause of disease is unsupported by evidence. Its inclusion in a modern chiropractic curriculum in anything other than an historical context is therefore inappropriate and unnecessary.
Which is similar to the General Chiropractic Council in the United Kingdom, which has a Guidance that says:
The chiropractic vertebral subluxation complex is an historical concept but it remains a theoretical model. It is not supported by any clinical research evidence that would allow claims to be made that it is the cause of disease or health concerns.
They are referred to “Subluxation Deniers.” Like Vaccine and Global warming deniers, one of these is not like the others.
I wonder if all the ridiculous crap is removed from chiropractic practice, what will be left?

Bias and Spin: Acupuncture and Chiropractic
Mark Crislip on March 6, 2015
Tweet

We all construct our narrative based on our biases and spin the facts so that the narrative confirms our biases. Among other characteristics, what separates an SBM provider from a SCAM provider is realizing that biases are always active and apply to me as well as everyone else.
My biases are simple: I am skeptical that humans can reliably understand reality without assistance and the best source of assistance is science.
I have a job where the expectation is that I will change practice as information changes. How I practiced medicine 30 years ago is very different from how I practice it today. Still, I note it is harder and harder to change my approaches as I get older. I get more set in my ways and it takes more effort to change as new studies are published. Sometimes it seems almost physically difficult.
Again, it is expected that not only will I change my mind over time, as the sole ID doctor at my hospitals, I will be the one to lead the change. Imagine how much harder it would be to change your mind if you were committed to a universal truth such as those that are alleged to underlie reiki or chiropractic. Years committed to a pseudo-medicine probably renders changing one’s mind virtually impossible.
I will admit there is one bias I cannot fathom, the conspiracy/pharmaceutical shill world view. The idea that those of us concerned with pseudo-medicine are doing so because we are paid by big pharma is just so weird. There are a number of articles on Pubmed concerning medical conspiracies, but the search term “pharmaceutical shill’ yields nothing on either Google scholar or Pubmed. It is a bias that evidently has no research to help understand why people have that opinion. I suspect it is derived in part from the often-remarkable sums paid to some doctors to pimp medications to other doctors. But I can’t even find how common the belief is.
I can kind of understand why people practice and/or participate in the various SCAMs given my understanding of the various fallacies and dysfunctional ways the mind works. It is easy to see how both the practitioners and patients misjudge the efficacy of pseudo-medicine. We have evolved to survive reality, certainly not to understand it.
Bias leads to spin, and it is curious how bias can warp the reports in the medical literature.
It is a curious fact that acupuncture studies from the East are virtually always positive:
Research conducted in certain countries was uniformly favorable to acupuncture; all trials originating in China, Japan, Hong Kong, and Taiwan were positive, as were 10 out of 11 of those published in Russia/USSR. In studies that examined interventions other than acupuncture, 405 of 1100 abstracts met the inclusion criteria. Of trials published in England, 75% gave the test treatment as superior to control….No trial published in China or Russia/USSR found a test treatment to be ineffective.
I find that fascinating. Is it publications bias i.e. only positive studies are published? Or is it, due to deep cultural bias combined with poor methodology (adequate blinding and placebo), that all studies are indeed positive, a massive example of N-rays in action?
Given that:
pronounced bias due to lack of patient blinding in complementary/alternative randomized clinical trials
leads to:
nonblinded patients exaggerated the effect size by an average of 0.56 standard deviation
and the effect is more pronounced in acupuncture trials, I suspect it is a combination, especially given a similar results with yoga studies out of India:
Positive conclusions were reached in 277 RCTs (91%); with more positive RCTs being conducted in India than elsewhere (odds ratio=24.8; 95% confidence interval=3.3, 184.5; p<0.001) while type of journal was not associated with the direction of the conclusions (odds ratio=1.2; 95% confidence interval=0.5, 2.9; p=0.828).
CONCLUSIONS:
RCTs on yoga that are conducted in India have about 25 times the odds of reaching positive conclusions as those conducted elsewhere.
Amazing how the positive results of large swaths of pseudo-medical studies can be biased by the culture in which they are done. It would appear that the country of origin may have a far more positive effect on a SCAM study outcome than the effect of when a real medication trial is funded by pharmaceutical companies. Money, as Cindy Lauper noted, changes everything, but world view with its concomitant bias is likely more important. Ioannidis was understating the issue when he noted:
Prejudice may not necessarily have financial roots. Scientists in a given field may be prejudiced purely because of their belief in a scientific theory or commitment to their own findings. Many otherwise seemingly independent, university-based studies may be conducted for no other reason than to give physicians and researchers qualifications for promotion or tenure. Such nonfinancial conflicts may also lead to distorted reported results and interpretations.
It is amazing how such bias can lead to the inability to see effects even when it is staring you in the face. My favorite example is “Decreased Risk of Stroke in Patients with Traumatic Brain Injury Receiving Acupuncture Treatment: A Population-Based Retrospective Cohort Study” where they conclude:
Patients with TBI receiving acupuncture treatment show decreased risk of stroke compared with those without acupuncture treatment.
even though patients:
with acupuncture treatment had higher proportions of using anticoagulants (2.3% vs. 1.7%, p = 0.0003), antiplatelet agents (28.7% vs. 22.3%, p<0.0001), and lipid-lowering agents (24.7% vs. 18.4%, p<0.0001) compared with those had no acupuncture treatment.
The use of anti-stoke medication was then ignored as the possible explanation of the ‘effects’ of acupuncture.
Of course, acupuncturists are not the only ones who cannot look at data and see the obvious.
Chiropractors like to point to “Risk of Vertebrobasilar Stroke and Chiropractic Care Results of a Population-Based Case-Control and Case-Crossover Study” as evidence that their particular pseudo-medicine does not cause strokes.
We found no evidence of excess risk of VBA stroke associated chiropractic care compared to primary care.
Although as I have mentioned in the past the paper does suggest that in a group that should not be having strokes, the young, seeing a chiropractor is associated with having a stroke.
Table 3 has the smoking gun. The highest odds ratio (14) for a stroke is 12, 4 times any other, in the age less than 45 in the first 24 hours after a visit to a chiropractor.
Saying that a paper does not support chiropractic as a risk of stroke when the data suggests it probably does continues. In the study “Risk of Stroke After Chiropractic Spinal Manipulation in Medicare B Beneficiaries Aged 66 to 99 Years With Neck Pain” by a chiropractor, suggests the older you are, there may be greater the risk of stoke after visiting a chiropractor.
They conclude that
Among Medicare B beneficiaries aged 66 to 99 years with neck pain, incidence of vertebrobasilar stroke was extremely low. Small differences in risk between patients who saw a chiropractor and those who saw a primary care physician are probably not clinically significant.
Given that the chiropractic cohort was both younger and healthier, and the rarity of stroke, I am not sanguine that this study can be used as evidence that chiropractic neck manipulation is safe and it suggests that, as the older you get, the more likely chiropractic will be associated with a late stroke, a 10% increase at 30 days that was statistically significant. But if due to chiropractic cannot be determined from the study
They suggest it may not be clinically important. While a 10% change in a pain scale may not be clinically relevant, I am not so sure a 10% increase in stroke has the same degree of triviality.
I am also not sanguine the study supplies evidence that chiropractic is safe; it is more spin than fact. Like the Cassidy study, it suggests that a risk of stroke is lurking in the background in some populations, is rare, and hard to see. For now I will stick with the preponderance of data, nicely summarized by the AHA position paper:
Although current biomechanical evidence is insufficient to establish the claim that CMT causes CD, clinical reports suggest that mechanical forces play a role in a considerable number of CDs and most population controlled studies have found an association between CMT and VAD stroke in young patients. Although the incidence of CMT-associated CD in patients who have previously received CMT is not well established, and probably low, practitioners should strongly consider the possibility of CD as a presenting symptom, and patients should be informed of the statistical association between CD and CMT prior to undergoing manipulation of the cervical spine.
And when I see an article called “Is there a role for neck manipulation in elderly falls prevention? – An overview“, I think NONONONONONO.
That’s my bias, and I am sticking to it.

Chiropractic Marketing Propaganda
What do vitalism, old school chiropractic subluxations, germ theory denial, detox supplements, marketing gimmicks, and practicing way beyond a reasonable scope have in common?
Clay Jones on September 22, 2017
Link
I was recently alerted to yet another example of highly questionable chiropractic health claims. It’s a bad one. Real bad. And while the core components, including claims regarding health benefits in young children and marketing gimmicks carefully designed to trick people into becoming long term patients, are standard boilerplate you will see on hundreds of individual practice websites, this one pushes the envelope in ways that are particularly egregious.
Can chiropractic care help a sick child?
While the answer to the above question is unequivocally no in my opinion, the article that led me to once again hack my way through the fetid underbelly of pediatric chiropractic attempts to present evidence in support of the claim. The article in question was written by Tim Smith, a chiropractor who graduated with honors from Life Chiropractic College West and who claims to have been one of the official chiropractors for the U. S. Olympic team. He describes himself additionally as a “Maximized Living doctor highly trained in delivering the 5 Essentials of health.” More on this later.
To perhaps provide some helpful context to the content of his article, Life Chiropractic College West, whose motto is “Express your potential”, is located in Hayward, CA and embraces the existence of the chiropractic subluxation. They also claim to train chiropractors to function as primary health care providers, and offer instruction on something called “fractal biology.” Mastering this particular course requires that a student “understand the basic fractal geometry of Nature and how its iterated patterns shape the fate of human civilization.” Oh, is that all?
Of note, Life Chiropractic College West graduates roughly one hundred new practitioners every year. Each of these graduates likely contributes to the “minority” of chiropractors who practice blatant quackery. Most chiropractors, I am frequently told…by chiropractors, are above average when it comes to accepting the evidence on subluxations, the safety and benefit of vaccines, and the treatment non-musculoskeletal complaints.
In the article, Smith describes how his 9-month-old daughter had become ill for the very first time in her life. He gives credit to his being a “Maximized Living doctor”, and the fact that she is a “5 Essentials Baby”, for her perfect health up to that point. Again, more on this a bit later. He fails to explain why she became ill, something which shouldn’t have happened according to the claims he goes on to make.
In his vignette, he describes his daughter as very fussy, with a temperature over 100 degrees. Somewhere between 100.1 F and 5,778 K, I guess. She was both “tired and lethargic”, and “clearly in pain”. Her body, according to Smith, was “working hard to fight the infection”.
This description, taken at face value, describes a potentially very ill child, possible even in septic shock. As Chiropractor Smith doesn’t actually have any real experience with ill children, and is essentially no more knowledgeable than the average parent of an ill child, he is very likely using the term “lethargic” incorrectly. To a trained medical professional, lethargy describes a state of altered mental status where the patient is barely able to achieve a wakeful state, and typically only with significant stimulation. Caregivers, however, will often use the word to describe a child who is merely less energetic, or a bit more sleepy, than usual.
Most childhood infections do not result in a child being “clearly in pain”. When they do, it is often the sore throat, swollen glands, upset stomach, or muscular ache that can accompany many common viral infections. But to be “clearly in pain” is a worrisome description that if true could apply to a variety of serious afflictions depending on where the pain appears to be originating from and its severity. We aren’t given this information, however.
If a parent were to describe their febrile child as excessively sleepy and in obvious pain, most people would recommend that they immediately be evaluated by a competent medical provider. Smith didn’t have his daughter checked by an actual doctor, though I take comfort in the fact that he is almost certainly exaggerating for effect. Also a possibility is that the situation never actually occurred and is just a fabricated marketing ploy. In reality, if truly tested by his child being seriously ill-appearing, Smith would probably seek legitimate medical care, even as the arrogance of his ignorance is an impetus to encourage other parents to do the opposite.
What would you do?
After having described his ill child, Smith then asks readers what they would do in this situation, and he provides the following options:
     1.  Do you rush to the doctor for an antibiotic?
     2.  Do you reach for a bottle of Tylenol to lower the pain and fever?
     3.  Do you stay home and skip your adjustment that day?
     4.  Do you disinfect your entire house in an attempt to kill every invisible bug out there?
Chiropractor Smith then reveals, to absolutely nobody’s surprise, that he didn’t choose any of these options and that his daughter was fully recovered in less than 24 hours. Can you guess what he chose to do? I’m pretty sure you can.
She is a healthy 5 Essentials Baby and what we did to help her get better was adjust her daily, breastfeed her more, keep her warm, give her a bath with essential oils and rubbed them on her feet and let her rest… her body took care of the rest!
Increased fluid intake may help prevent dehydration in a persistently febrile child, particularly if they have increased fluid loss though respiratory secretions, vomiting, or diarrhea. And a warm bath and foot massage, known to some simply as TLC, may be comforting to a child feeling a bit under the weather. But adjustments and essential oils do not play a role in recovery from any illness.
One thing that is certainly accurate is that her body did recover on its own. That’s what our bodies do when faced with mild self-limited viral illnesses. If she had a serious bacterial infection, or one of the many potential non-infectious etiologies of lethargy and pain in an infant, intussusception for example, the outcome would likely have been very different.
The rest of Smith’s article is full of absurd and potentially dangerous claims. In particular, he clearly isn’t a fan of medications (other than the supplements he recommends), and he demonstrates a profoundly ignorant understanding of biology. Even germ theory itself isn’t safe from the clumsy blows of his meager, and hopelessly biased, intellect.
Here is one gem:
The biggest problem with medications like antibiotics is that they are ineffective against the innate intelligence of bacteria, and they are becoming even less effective every month.
This is particularly ridiculous when you consider that many of the antibiotics we have used therapeutically over the decades are produced by various soil bacteria to kill other bacteria competing for real estate and nutrients. Smith likely thinks that all (non-supplement) medications are unnatural chemicals cooked up in a Big Pharma laboratory on Skull Island. At one point he even writes that parents should rethink ever giving their ill children any form of (non-supplement) medication.
Another one:
Taking a medication to lower your fever (called an antipyretic) WORKS AGAINST INNATE! If your child’s temperature goes above 103, I suggest a cold shower or ice bath before you start dumping in the medication. Recent reports with the flu show that people who let their fevers ride out fought it off in 5 days, versus 9 days in people that took aspirin or acetaminophen.
There are many problems with this other than the fact that so-called “innate intelligence” is merely the chiropractic version of the vitalistic “life force” prominent in the beliefs of myriad forms of alternative medicine. These days there aren’t that many chiropractors left who will openly admit a belief in this concept, with many preferring more scienticious modern explanations for how (fictional) chiropractic subluxations can harm the body. More concerning to me is the fact that cold showers and ice baths are a terrible option when managing fever.
For much more detail on the subject of fever in children, check out my 2012 post on fever phobia. In it, I describe how the application of cold to the skin of a febrile child can actually counteract the body’s natural temperature-lowering mechanism of dilating peripheral blood vessels. Preventing this can result in prolonged and more intense symptoms, and would be unnecessarily stressful. Ice baths are a recommended part of the acute management of severe hyperthermia, however, such as at medical stations set up during the Boston marathon. I live on the route, right where one such station is set up every year, and have seen as many as seven tubs occupied at one time. Hyperthermia, to be abundantly clear, is not the same thing as fever, even if both involve an elevated core body temperature.
The claim regarding the effect of treating fever on the duration of symptomatic influenza is also questionable. I was unable to find the study that they were referencing, but perhaps it is Plaisance et al. which unfortunately I don’t have access to. I discuss the effect of fever, and of treating fever, on outcomes in various infections in my earlier post on the subject. Scott Gavura also tackles the subject of fever and influenza, specifically addressing the hype surrounding this study on the effects of suppressing fever at a population level.
While there is certainly plausibility to the claim that fever is a beneficial process in certain circumstances, it is also demonstrably harmful in others. How sick the child is, how high the fever is, what infection is causing the fever, what treatment resources are readily available, and many other complex variables likely play a role in whether or not treating fever worsens outcomes. Most of what we know is based on animal data and, as Scott discusses, theoretical math based on zero actual evidence.
There is currently no compelling data to suggest that fever is so beneficial that allowing a child to suffer is warranted. That being said, fever is not generally harmful. There is also no good reason to treat an asymptomatic febrile child, or one with only mild symptoms not interfering with sleep/appetite/play, aggressively because there are potential side effects from any medication.
Here is the big secret nobody wants to talk about…if the germ theory were true, we would all be dead! If you culture my nose or your nose right now, there is all sorts of deadly bacteria and viruses to be found.
Smith and Bill Maher would get along swimmingly. Germ theory denial runs deep in the histories of many forms of alternative medicine, and chiropractic is no different. You just don’t see it so blatantly expressed that often anymore. You still do though, and it isn’t exactly hard to find. In this video, an “accelerated thinker” disproves both germ theory and genetic theory with a couple simple analogies. Oh, and the International Chiropractic Pediatric Association endorses germ theory denial.
Smith continues along these lines:
But you are alive and well right now? Does this mean germs do not in fact cause illness? It means that when your immune system is strong, germs are no big deal, in fact, they seem to strengthen our immune systems. Unless you live in a bubble, you cannot avoid germs. So instead of disinfecting everything, put that energy into doing things that boost your immunity.
What are the “things” Smith is referring to? Adjustments? Organic foods? Avoiding any medication or “over the counter ointment”? Removing toxins such as vaccines, plastics, and fire retardants? All of the above??? None of which will boost the immune system.
Maximized Living and The 5 Essentials
As I’ve mentioned at least a couple of times already, Smith describes himself as a “Maximized Living doctor”. He apparently also runs a “Maximized Living clinic”. A logo for Maximized Living can be found in the upper left corner on every page of his website. But what this actually means is considerably less exciting than it sounds.
What Smith and hundreds of other chiropractors, at least according to the developers of the Maximized Living program, have hitched their wagon to is one of many chiropractic practice building firms. And although this particular company is one of the most impressive I’ve come across, they are pretty much all the same. To be clear, I don’t mean impressive in regards to the quality of the content, rather in how far they go to avoid coming across as just another practice building firm.
The founders, chiropractors Ben Lerner and Greg Loman, would probably disagree with my interpretation, however, preferring to think of their creation as something much more meaningful:
Understanding that they had each lived a solution and lifestyle that could save the world, Dr. Lerner and Dr. Loman decided it was time to start a new movement committed to transforming health and wellness around the planet.
Maximized Living has embarked on a global initiative to change the way healthcare is viewed and delivered. With 15+ years in business, a network of Health Centers, and partnerships with first tier organizations, our organization has developed a scientifically based holistic process founded on 5 core principles of wellness. We deliver on our vision through a group of related companies that provide educational programs, franchise opportunities, innovative products, programs and a non-profit foundation. We give chiropractic doctors the tools and expertise needed to build chiropractic practices that are dedicated to transforming communities through The 5 Essentials.
Sounds impressive. Wait, there’s more! The benefits for patient’s signing up for a Maximized Living plan include treatment of the underlying cause of any medical condition, overcoming any life hurdle, getting off all medications, treating depression, boosting the immune system, and healthy aging. Amazing!
Only something completely revolutionary would be able to do all of that, right? This is where the 5 Essentials come in. They are as follows:
     1.  Maximize your mind – Understanding the true principles of health and healing and creating a mindset of success.
     2.  Maximized nerve supply – Restoring and maintaining proper function of the nervous system through spinal correction.
     3.  Maximized oxygen and lean muscle – Cutting edge exercise programs that work to facilitate optimum fitness in minimal time.
     4.  Maximized quality nutrition – Nutritional science that sustains well-being, disease prevention and ideal weight.
     5.  Minimized toxins – Supporting the body’s own ability to permanently remove toxins from the cells.
Final thoughts
When you cut through all the jargon, the 5 Essentials are nothing more than the typical collection of co-opted science-based health recommendations, such as increased exercise, better sleep, stress reduction, and healthier dietary choices, plus spinal adjustments to correct old school bone on the nerve subluxations. They employ standard straight chiropractic philosophy, meaning the belief that subluxations are the root cause of all medical problems. They add a little power of positive thinking style life coaching, sprinkle in a few shout outs to the Christian deity, and promote some serious nonsense about toxins. Oh, and they sell supplements. Lots of supplements.
Maximized Living, with its 5 Essentials, is nothing more than a dogmatically vitalistic and subluxation focused practice building scheme at its core. They want other chiropractors to buy in to their thoroughly unoriginal propaganda and to convert their practices to franchised Maximized Living clinics, all for a fee of course. They sell trademarked materials, books, educational programs, and supplements like Max Kids Detox Powder. They go after chiropractic students with promises of a successful business and a fulfilling career.
I don’t recommend that parents ever seek care from a chiropractor for their children, and involvement with a Maximized Living doctor should definitely be avoided. Some adults might claim to experience benefit from seeing a chiropractor for certain musculoskeletal complaints, but not kids and especially not infants. And I challenge anyone reading to provide just one example of a chiropractor treating a child for only musculoskeletal complaints, which is a thoroughly absurd concept in itself. I argue that every single chiropractor who sees kids makes claims regarding general health, and I’ve provided numerous examples here on SBM over the years.
Now watch this video.

The Drugless Doctor’s ADHD Nonsense
The Drugless Doctor isn’t a doctor, and as a chiropractor is totally unqualified to provide medical advice on almost everything, including ADHD.
Braden MacBeth on January 4, 2019
Link

Bob DeMaria is a chiropractor who is featured often on alternative medicine sites. He makes frequent appearances on YouTube’s worst health information channel, iHealthTube, to peddle abject nonsense about medical conditions he isn’t qualified to treat. He calls himself “The Drugless Doctor”, which I find a bit confusing as he isn’t a physician, and he always recommends purchasing dietary supplements from his website. On iHealthTube, many of his videos relate to alternative treatments of ADHD and have nearly 750k views. The advice he gives in these videos is completely inaccurate, and arguably quite dangerous. DeMaria has far-fetched ideas about how ADHD is caused, and tries to sell parents his supplements that have been proven not to work. He also suggests restrictive diets that have been proven not to provide any benefit for the symptoms of ADHD. I’m going to look through the evidence behind DeMaria’s claims in his videos and address his shameful guilt-tripping marketing tactics.
The “Real Causes” of ADHD
Docosahexaenoic acid
According to Bob DeMaria, “docosahexaenoic acid (DHA) bathes the brain, and gives the brain information that just helps the brain function optimally”. What DHA actually does is serve as a structural component of the brain, skin, cerebral cortex, and retinas. Throughout the video, DeMaria claims that certain foods “sabotage” DHA somehow and that’s the cause of basically every mental problem. He also claims that his dieting “cures” for ADHD also cure Asperger’s syndrome and bipolar disorder in one of his videos. Every dieting recommendation he makes is based on the idea that eating certain foods “sabotage” your body’s natural ability to make DHA. He recommends DHA supplements in the form of fish oil to treat ADHD, which he sells.
Omega-3 fatty acid supplementation has been theorized to help treat ADHD. Scott Gavura covered the despicable marketing tactics of one company that produces “Kids DHA”, and showed that the evidence from high-quality trials shows that DHA supplementation does not provide any benefit for the symptoms of ADHD. Despite a lack of any evidence to back such a claim, Demaria states that “a lot of science believes today that genetically we as a species can no longer make DHA from the food we eat. That’s why everybody needs to use marine oil”. Not just any marine oil however, according to him we all need to buy his special brand of anchovy-based Omega-3 supplements because “the marine oil in the world today is toxic”. I’m unable to find any complaints filed to the FDA or studies showing that any Omega-3 fish oil supplements on the market contain any serious contaminants. He just wants to make sure you buy his $30 dollar bottle of fish oil, instead of the kind you would find in your local pharmacy for far less. Even worse, he only sells it in liquid form. I have no idea how you’re supposed to get a kid to take a spoonful of fish oil every morning, it probably tastes worse than the butt of 5-day old roadkill on a hot July afternoon.
Chiropractic subluxations
In another of his videos “Causes of ADD and ADHD Your Doctor Doesn’t Know About!”, he claims that ADHD is caused by misalignment of the spine. His reasoning for this is that information goes down the spinal cord from the brain and if a bone puts pressure on a nerve it can disrupt function. I know it’s probably hard for him to understand that others use their body parts above the shoulders for more than spouting nonsense, but this claim is ridiculous. ADHD is a disorder of self-regulation and executive function, both of which are controlled by the brain. ADHD has nothing to do with the spinal cord or “subluxations”. Taking your kids to a chiropractor will not help with their ADHD, but will empty your wallet.
It’s not lead?!
For whatever reason, Demaria denies the link between childhood lead exposure and developmental disabilities, including ADHD.
… you know some people talk about lead…
In the video he shakes his head as he says this, implying that lead exposure in childhood cannot cause ADHD. On the other hand, there are some mom-and-pop medical organizations that subscribe to the idea that lead exposure can cause ADHD such as the National Institutes of Health. The link between lead exposure in early childhood and the development of ADHD is well established, how he could believe otherwise baffles me.
Mr. Bob hates ice cream
Bob Demaria claims that dairy products, sugar, and food dyes cause or worsen the symptoms of ADHD, despite no evidence to support his claim. So basically, he hates ice cream.
Dairy
I’m not tell am not telling anyone to stop dairy, but when is the last time you saw a cow eating cottage cheese, milk, or ice cream?
I’ll do you one better: When’s the last time you saw a baby cow having trouble paying attention and being disruptive in school? So he went to a psycowitrist for help and was diagnosed with ADHD then given a prescription for Cowcerta. Now his grades are shooting up and now he’s on the fast track to medicow school. Do you see how ridiculous this is? Humans and cows are biologically different and have different diets, this argument is absurd.
His pseudoscientific explanation for why dairy products worsen the symptoms of ADHD is because “milk contains arachidonic acid (ARA) which sabotages DHA”. He never clarifies the mechanism by which ARA “sabotages” DHA. I’m unable to find any evidence that DHA breaks down in the presence of ARA, likely because he made all the science behind this up too. Regardless DHA supplementation has not been proven to help with ADHD anyways.
He also has this crazy story about telling a parent to limit the amount of milk their child is drinking to back up his claim:
My wife and I were traveling one point, and if someone finds out you’re Dr. Bob and what do you do and yada yada yada. This woman had a 2-3 year old boy who had trantrums because of one the little expedition we were on. She said what’s going on, so I started chit-chatting with her a little bit and found out that her son drank like a gallon and a half of milk every two to three days. So I just suggested to her, in love of course, stop the dairy products. I got home a week later, she wrote a five star review on Amazon for me, son totally changed just from getting off of dairy.
There’s no way this happened. It’s patently impossible and counter to the laws of the universe. If a 3-year old boy were to drink a half-gallon of milk per day, they would suffer from far more issues than just throwing a tantrum on vacation. The recommended milk intake for toddlers is 2 cups per day, if the boy consumed 4 times the recommended amount per day, he would undoubtedly suffer from constipation and anemia. Furthermore, a 3-year-old boy has a recommended calorie intake of around 1,000 to 1,400 calories. A half-gallon of whole milk contains around 1150 calories. I think it’s reasonable to assume that a 3-year old boy’s diet would consist of food other than just milk. Given that if what DeMaria said was true, the boy would also suffer from weight problems of such magnitude he would have his own gravitational pull. There’s no evidence that I can find linking the consumption of dairy products with the development or worsening of ADHD symptoms. The science behind his theory is just as fictional as this story.
Sugar does not make ADHD symptoms worse
In Bob Demaria’s parallel universe, sugar also sabotages the synthesis of docosahexaenoic acid (DHA) and therefore causes ADHD symptoms somehow. I’m not going to address the “sabotaging DHA” a 4th time now, it’s just total nonsense. Sugar causing hyperactivity in children is one of the most pervasive medical myths. It’s been well established by research that there is no link between the consumption of sugar and hyperactive symptoms in children. A meta-analysis in The Journal of the American Medical Association analyzed 16 studies investigating a link between sugar and behavior and concluded: “The meta-analytic synthesis of the studies to date found that sugar does not affect the behavior or cognitive performance of children.”
It’s not food dyes either
DeMaria also tries to sell the Feingold diet throughout these videos. Dr. Benjamin Feingold proposed that the elimination of salicylate, artificial food coloring, and artificial flavors from the diet would curb hyperactive symptoms. Feingold claimed that 32-60% of children improved by following the Feingold diet. However, the Nutrition Foundation did an expert review of seven studies and didn’t share his conclusion even remotely. Only 3 cases out of the 190 reviewed reported a serious increase in symptoms after going off of the Feingold diet, and all were reported by the mother of the child with no other objective, confirming evidence.
ADHD medication lies
Since DeMaria calls himself “The Drugless Doctor”, he naturally tries to argue that parents shouldn’t give their children ADHD medication if they have ADHD. In another video titled “ADD Medications Could Lead to These Problems Later”, he peddles the most common ADHD medication myths. He claims that clonidine suppresses and increases appetite and stunts growth. Clonidine has not been associated with any of these side effects. Stimulant medications such as Ritalin and Adderall have been associated appetite suppression which is why doctors closely monitor their patient’s weight when they’re taking these medications. As for stimulants stunting growth, there’s conflicting evidence. Many studies have found that stimulant medication stunts growth in children, around 3 centimeters on average. However other studies don’t share the same conclusion. My question is, what’s the harm? Is being one inch shorter than you could’ve been otherwise really going to impact your life? The only real downside I can think of is your Tinder-game.
DeMaria also claims that children who take ADHD medications are at a higher risk for developing a substance abuse disorder. This is a straight-up lie, and a dangerous one at that. People with ADHD are significantly more likely to develop substance abuse disorders than people without ADHD to begin with. A meta-analysis by the American Academy of Pediatrics found that using ADHD medication did not increase the risk of substance abuse, and children who used medication for their ADHD were less likely to develop a substance abuse disorder than children with ADHD who didn’t use medication.
It’s time to stop
Bob DeMaria wants to sell you snake oil and he’s not going to let science, common sense, or decency stop him. He’s more than happy to slander parents for giving their children ADHD medication. The first line in the description for “Dr. Bob’s Guide to Stop ADHD in 18 Days” asks “Is Ritalin Child Abuse?”. I think it’s shameful he would imply that parents who are doing what’s best to manage their child’s learning disability are in some way abusing their child. He even stoops to Mariana trench-level depths in a video when he says “ADHD kids become ADHD adults. ADHD adults usually have ADHD kids, and the reason is: they eat from the same trough”. He uses the word “trough” to imply that children have ADHD because their parents eat like pigs. Never mind the fact that ADHD is mostly caused by genetics and isn’t really helped much by diet, if at all. He’ll say whatever it takes to guilt you into buying his $18 book, $195 consultation, and $145 supplement kit. You’re a cash cow to be milked to him. What’s saddening about his comments directed towards parents who have kids with ADHD is that you hear comments like this all of the time. People love to get on their high horse and proclaim that ADHD is caused by bad parenting or that kids with ADHD just need to be disciplined by their parents, by which they almost always mean spanking them.
ADHD isn’t the result of bad parenting, nor is it a good idea to encourage parents to spank their children ever; we’ve discussed it before on SBM. ADHD like all psychiatric conditions can negatively affect many aspects of a person’s life indirectly. ADHD is a disorder of executive function, and people with ADHD have trouble regulating attention, staying organized, and controlling impulses; and that can lead to all kinds of negative long-term consequences. The areas where the disorder has the largest impact are in the workplace and in school. Children with ADHD on average get worse grades, are more likely to get detention, be expelled from school, score lower than non-ADHD children on standardized tests, and are more likely to held back a grade or drop out of school. Adults with ADHD on average have poorer work performance, and change jobs more often.
It gets worse, ADHD is associated with risky behaviors and poorer overall health and life outcomes as a result. As previously mentioned, people with ADHD are more likely to develop a substance abuse disorder. In a study published in The Journal of Clinical Child & Adolescent Psychology, young adults with ADHD responded yes to the question “Have you ever gotten someone pregnant?” 6 times more than the control group. Driving accidents are the leading cause of death in young adults, and people with ADHD are more likely to get into car accidents, get driving citations, and have their licenses revoked. People with ADHD are more likely to commit crimes, and end up in prison [PDF]. If you haven’t caught on at this point: I can basically just start a sentence with “People with ADHD” and [insert short or long term negative outcome of impulsive, inattentive, or hyperactive behavior here] then probably find peer-reviewed research to back it up. ADHD is one of the most well studied disorders in medicine.
Consequently, ADHD is also one of the most treatable disorders in psychiatry. Stimulant medication is safe and highly effective at treating the symptoms of ADHD and is recommended as the first line treatment by basically every reputable medical organization. Stimulant medications have been found to improve academic outcomes and even reduce the risk developing comorbid psychiatric disorders later in life. Medication has also been found to reduce the risk of bad driving outcomes in young adults with ADHD. To say that parents are abusing their children by giving them Ritalin for their ADHD isn’t just wrong, it’s irresponsible and dangerous.
ADHD is a serious medical condition that will cause serious problems in every facet of an individual’s life if left untreated. That’s why it’s important that parents get their kids appropriate treatment as soon as possible when they’re diagnosed with ADHD. Medication and behavior interventions early on in life are the best things parents can possibly do to set up their children for success if they’re diagnosed with ADHD. They shouldn’t have to deal with random people on the internet telling them that their child’s learning disability is their fault because of how they eat. ADHD isn’t caused by diet and there’s no evidence to support disallowing your child from eating ice cream because it will make their ADHD symptoms worse. That would be real child abuse.

Stem Cells and Chiropractic
Harriet Hall on February 23, 2016
Link


My local newspaper is a constant source of topics to blog about. It regularly features ads for untested dietary supplements and for chiropractors who offer non-chiropractic treatments and don’t identify themselves as chiropractors. Recently, a full-page ad for NW Pain Relief Centers trumpeted “Stem Cell Technology Takes Joint Treatment to the Next Level.” It said stem cell treatments could heal and regenerate tissue in conditions such as knee osteoarthritis, carpal tunnel, peripheral neuropathy, spinal stenosis, hip pain, and tendinitis. A table titled “Consider these facts” compared stem cell therapy to surgery, saying stem cell treatments involve no known side effects, little or no pain, and immediate recovery; whereas surgery involves complications, poor outcomes, addiction to pain medications, severe pain for months, and a prolonged recovery over months and years. It said, “Call now if you experience any degree of joint pain or discomfort…Space is limited to the first 30 callers!”
A few days later there was another full-page ad for NW Pain Relief Centers, this time for hyaluronic acid injections into the knee for osteoarthritic knee pain. It reprinted the same table of comparisons with surgery, with an additional line comparing costs (that didn’t actually compare costs, but only vaguely mentioned insurance coverage, deductibles, copays, and time off work. It featured the same “Call now, space limited” ploy.
These ads reminded me so much of chiropractic ads that I had to wonder what was going on. They mentioned an “allied team of health professionals.” I guessed there must be at least one MD on their team if they were injecting stem cells and hyaluronic acid into joints. I guessed chiropractors were a prominent part of the team. I guessed right.
Chiropractors are involved
When I phoned the clinic and asked about the providers, I was told they were MDs, nurse practitioners, physician assistants, anesthesiologists, and chiropractors. Chiropractors were the last to be mentioned. But chiropractic is apparently far from last in the philosophy of the organization.
There were some glaring clues in their downloadable Welcome Packet for prospective customers:
“If you are here for Chiropractic Wellness Services, please skip to…” (So obviously many of their customers are not there for pain, but to see a chiropractor for “wellness” services.)
    • “It’s common for people to have multiple doctors on their health care team. Which of the following have you seen for your challenges? ___Chiropractor ___ Medical ___Other” (Note that chiropractors are listed first and are categorized as doctors.)
    • “Given that prescription medications are in the top 5 leading causes of preventable death in the United States we are interested in knowing what, if any medications you are currently taking and why” (Every time I see a doctor I am asked about my current meds, but never with any derogatory comments like that. The anti-mainstream-medicine bias is obvious.)
    • “Slips and falls, although common have a direct impact on your health and wellbeing. Even MINOR falls or accidents cause stress, strain and damage to the spine that take up to 18 months to heal.” (A typical argument to encourage unnecessary chiropractic care.)
    • In a section asking about other symptoms, it starts out “Because the nervous system controls everything in your body…” (a false statement straight out of D.D. Palmer’s 1895 chiropractic mythology that conveniently ignores all the many things that are not controlled by the nervous system, like hormones).
    • It asks about a whole laundry list of symptoms like allergies, heartburn, menstrual irregularity, hot flashes, and other symptoms that are not controlled by the nervous system, as well as enough common and vague symptoms so that almost everyone will find something to check.
    • It ends with “I consent to a professional and complete chiropractic examination and to any radiographic examination that the doctor deems necessary. I understand that any fee for service rendered is due at the time of service and cannot be deferred to a later date.”
    • And at the bottom of the form it says Copyright FreeForm Chiro, LLC, an organization that sells marketing tools to chiropractors.
What do they offer?
NW Pain Relief Centers is a chain of clinics offering non-invasive, drug-free physical medicine treatments for various kinds of pain including Knew [sic] Arthritis and Knee Pain, as well as for allergies and food sensitivities. Its list of services includes stem cell injections, rehabilitation, spinal decompression, chiropractic, massage, trigger point injections, cold laser therapy, ALCAT and food sensitivity testing, and medical weight loss.
Stem cells for joint pain
Stem cells can be obtained from several different sources:
    • Blood
    • Bone Marrow
    • Adipose tissue (Fat)
    • Amniotic stem cells from placental tissue
Stem cells are classified as allograft therapy by FDA, and are not covered by insurance. For a bit more background, a guest post by Dr. Paul Knoepfler discusses some of the recent issues in the regulation of stem cell clinics.
According to the woman who answered the phone, the NW Pain Relief Centers offer the commercial stem cell preparation PalinGen, a cryopreserved human amniotic fluid allograft. An independent review of amniotic stem cell products found that PalinGen and similar products didn’t contain any viable stem cells once they were thawed per the manufacturer’s recommendations. The PalinGen website does not claim to contain viable stem cells, but only to contain many factors needed for wound healing, such as collagen, growth factors, amino acids, carbohydrates, cytokines, micronized amniotic membrane, and extracellular matrix. It advertises it as useful in a variety of surgical specialties but does not mention using it for medical conditions like osteoarthritis.
Stem cell treatments may be effective for knee osteoarthritis. We don’t know yet. There are some preclinical lab and animal studies, and there is some preliminary evidence from human studies suggesting that stem cells may be helpful in osteoarthritis. But those studies used stem cells derived from bone marrow or from the patient’s own infrapatellar fat pad. There are no studies using amniotic stem cells. And injecting stem cells obviously can’t work if there are no viable stem cells in the injections.
FDA has not approved any stem cell-based products for use, other than cord blood-derived hematopoietic progenitor cells (blood forming stem cells) for certain indications including certain blood cancers and some inherited metabolic and immune system disorders
The FDA has issued consumer warnings about stem cell treatments:
If you are considering stem cell treatment in the U.S., ask your physician if the necessary FDA approval has been obtained or if you will be part of an FDA-regulated clinical study. This also applies if the stem cells are your own. Even if the cells are yours, there are safety risks, including risks introduced when the cells are manipulated after removal…There is a potential safety risk when you put cells in an area where they are not performing the same biological function as they were when in their original location in the body… Cells in a different environment may multiply, form tumors, or may leave the site you put them in and migrate somewhere else.
Hyaluronic acid injections
The American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons (AAOS) recently issued a 1,200 page report evaluating the evidence for various treatments for knee osteoarthritis short of total knee replacement surgery. I reviewed the AAOS’s recommendations previously; they didn’t see fit to even mention stem cell therapy, and they found strong evidence against hyaluronic acid injections. You can read about the studies they based their recommendation on here.
“The latest FDA cleared treatments” for peripheral neuropathy
While I was writing this article, yet another full page ad appeared in which the NW Pain Relief Centers claimed to treat peripheral neuropathy with the “latest FDA cleared treatments.” That’s very misleading. On the website they say they treat peripheral neuropathy with “physical medicine techniques that include chiropractic care, massage therapy, physical rehab, and nutritional counseling.” I called to inquire about the claims in the ad and they told me they used four FDA cleared modalities that are not mentioned on the website: monochromatic light therapy, compression boots, class 4 lasers, and a vibration plate.
Those treatments may have been “cleared” by the FDA for marketing for other purposes, but the FDA has not approved them for treating peripheral neuropathy, and there is no evidence that they are effective for that purpose. I checked PubMed and found one uncontrolled study suggesting that monochromatic light therapy was effective, but several placebo-controlled studies found it was no more effective than sham. Here’s one of them. For the other three modalities, there were no studies in PubMed on their use for peripheral neuropathy.
Other questionable treatments
Some of the other treatments they offer are not science-based and others are supported only by poor-quality evidence that is not convincing enough to have earned them a place in conventional medicine. I won’t try to address all of them, but I’ll mention two that are very questionable.
I have written about spinal decompression therapy before: it doesn’t work, but chiropractors continue to make unsupported claims for it.
ALCAT is listed as a dubious test on Quackwatch. ALCAT testing is said to measure how blood cells react to foods “under conditions designed to mimic what happens when the foods are consumed in real life.” The Australasian Society of Clinical Immunology and Allergy says ALCAT is an inappropriate test:
These results have been shown to not be reproducible, give different results when duplicate samples are analysed blindly, don’t correlate with those from conventional testing, and “diagnose” food hypersensitivity in subjects with conditions where food allergy is not considered to play a pathogenic role.
Conclusion: I do not recommend NW Pain Relief Centers
I can’t recommend NW Pain Relief Centers. It appears to me that they are promoting chiropractic, offering non-science-based treatments, and misleading prospective customers with claims that go beyond the evidence. They don’t provide any evidence from scientific studies to support what they are doing. They do provide three testimonials from satisfied chiropractic patients, one of whom raves about her chiropractor’s use of the bogus Myovision device. It is ironic that they pride themselves on noninvasive treatments while they are injecting stem cells into knee joints. And that they pride themselves on drug-free treatments while they are injecting a prescription drug, hyaluronic acid.
If I were considering stem cell treatments, I would seek out experts in stem cell research and hope to enroll in a clinical study; I wouldn’t consult a chiropractic-oriented group that uses a commercial preparation that hasn’t been tested for use in osteoarthritis and that may not even contain any stem cells.
        ◦ Note: I e-mailed Epic Marketing to inquire about how their ads were developed, and how they determined the truth of the statements. They didn’t answer.

Chiropractic pediatrics conference features anti-vaccination ideology . . . as usual
For the third time in four years, a chiropractic pediatrics conference will feature anti-vaccination propaganda as part of its program. Chiropractors will spread this misinformation to their patients’ parents.
Jann Bellamy on August 3, 2017
Link


For the third time in four years, a chiropractic pediatrics conference will feature anti-vaccination propaganda as part of its program. The International Chiropractors Association (ICA) Council on Chiropractic Pediatrics Annual Conference, scheduled for November in New York City, includes a session titled:
Vaccines Revealed: A Film Producer’s Perspective
Participants will view portions of the film, which will be discussed by its producer, Jeff Hays. As we shall see, Vaccines Revealed is essentially a parade of well-known and thoroughly debunked anti-vaccinationists, in some cases being interviewed by other anti-vaccinationists, produced by someone whose past work has promoted anti-vaccination views.
This is par for the course at chiropractic conferences. In 2014, headliners at the International Chiropractic Pediatric Association’s annual conference were none other than Andrew Wakefield, the disgraced former British physician and an author of the infamous fraudulent “study” purportedly linking the MMR vaccine to autism, and Barbara Loe Fisher, grande dame of the anti-vaccination movement. Fisher’s National Vaccine (Mis)Information Center was one of the sponsors of the event. (Wakefield’s immoral misconduct and involvement in spreading anti-vaccine propaganda has been the subject of numerous SBM posts.)
In 2016, Wakefield again appeared at a chiropractic pediatrics conference, also sponsored by the ICA’s Council on Chiropractic Pediatrics. Participants were treated to a showing of the widely discredited (also here, here, here and here) anti-vaccination propaganda film VAXXED. This move garnered the chiropractors some unflattering attention in the mainstream press.
This year, the ICA Council on Chiropractic Pediatrics anti-vaccination lineup doesn’t have the louche appeal of seeing Andrew Wakefield in person or the unseemly notoriety of VAXXED, an otherwise obscure documentary made famous when it was pulled from the Tribeca Film Festival because Robert DeNiro was, as our good friend Orac points out,
shown just how full of misinformation, distortions, and pseudoscience the film is . . .
Vaccines Revealed revealed as propaganda
I have not seen Vaccines Revealed, but there is enough information available from those who have seen parts of it, as well as an outline of the episodes and a list of participants, to convince me that it is chock full of anti-vaccine rhetoric.
Vaccines Revealed is, oddly enough, both available for free for internet viewing as well as available for purchase as a downloadable series of 9 video and audio installments and transcripts for $79 (BONUS OFFER FOR A LIMITED TIME! 50% OFF!), although with the purchase you get a copy of the “Vaccine Exemption Playbook.” It is also sold as a DVD set.
Chiropractor Patrick Gentempo is behind this effort. Gentempo sells a practice building course to chiropractors and speaks at chiropractic practice building seminars. His holding company owns “Creating Wellness,” a “patented wellness program” sold through chiropractic offices, a centerpiece of which is regular chiropractic “adjustments” to eliminate “subluxations.” In other words, Gentempo is a “straight” chiropractor, those who believe in . . . well, let’s let Gentempo’s “Creating Wellness” explain it:
the discovery and removal of the vertebral subluxation, which is interference that is taking place in your central nervous system (CNS). It is important to recognize that our CNS is the master controller of our entire body and it directly correlates to our ability to function and exist. People who are suffering from allergies, asthma, headaches, etc. are living in a subluxated state, but when we provide these individuals with an adjustment, we are able to remove the interference, and the condition dissipates. In addition, patients who are under regular chiropractic care actually prevent these situations from impeding upon their lives.
This is, of course, pure pseudoscience, as SBM’s own Sam Homola, DC, has explained in a number of posts.
Gentempo is the former owner of Chiropractic Leadership Alliance, which sells dubious chiropractic diagnostic devices, as well as marketing Total Solution chiropractic practice building seminars. Gentempo and another chiropractor developed the Insight Subluxation Station, which got into a kerfuffle with NASA over claims of an implied endorsement of their product. The Insight Subluxation Station purports to provide
objective evaluation of neuro-spinal function related to vertebral subluxation
via, according to the website, electromyography, thermography and heart rate variability, or, as Sam Homola said, “chiropractic gimmickry.”
In other words, there is nothing in Gentempo’s background to suggest he has the scientific chops to make a credible documentary on immunization.
The Vaccines Revealed producer and conference speaker, Jeff Hays, is also the producer of a documentary called Bought, which excoriates Big Pharma, vaccines and GMOs. One reviewer describes the movie thusly:
Bought is a movie by Jeff Hays which wants you to believe the dangerous idea that vaccines are ineffective and can cause autism, a notion that has been repeatedly debunked. They also combine this strain of paranoia with one claiming how dangerous “GMOs” are, even though they cite not a single study to support this discredited idea either.
It is narrated by Toni Bark, an anti-vaccination MD/homeopath (“the one quackery to rule them all”) and features chiropractors as well as anti-vaccination ideologues Kelly Brogan, Stephanie Seneff, and Gayle DeLong.
Hays also produced Doctored, attacking the AMA for attacking chiropractors and, via a series of anecdotes, promoting chiropractic treatment, as well as Undoctored, which appears to cover the same ground.
Although I didn’t watch Vaccines Revealed, fortunately, others who are familiar with the anti-vaccination movement did. One is none other than Orac, who had this to say:
Today, Episode #3 of Vaccines Revealed, a painfully long series of ten 1-2 hour episodes that is chock full of every chuck of antivaccine pseudoscience, paranoia, and conspiracy theories, all “revealed” through interviews with luminaries of the antivaccine movement conducted by a chiropractor named Patrick Gentempo. I signed up for short-term free access to the series, thinking I might blog about it, but I don’t know if I can manage. The first episode featured nearly an hour of Andrew Wakefield without interruption. The third episode, the link to which was just released early morning and will expire within 24 hours, features over 65 minutes of RFK, Jr. repeating “the long version” of his antivaccine conspiracy theories. I’m tough and dedicated, but even I had a hard time sitting through such concentrated crankery when I tried to watch the video very early this morning. I saved it for later, but I don’t know if I can do this. There are some things that are too much even for me, and watching over an hour of Wakefield and over an hour of RFK Jr. might be it.
VaccinesWorkBlog also watched Episodes One and Three and provides summaries of the episodes, complete with references debunking claims made by its participants, such as those surrounding the “CDC whistleblower” manufactroversy. VaccinesWorkBlog has this to say about Wakefield:
It is fair to say that Andy Wakefield continues to be a lying liar.
Episode One also includes Gary Goldman, a computer scientist and, per the reviewer, “author of some very bad studies on vaccines,” one of which Orac characterized as:
a giant, drippy, stinky turd of an article—and amateurish to boot—whose conclusions were not at all supported by the data or analysis.
Episode Three is an interview of, as noted, one of the all-time most famous anti-vaccination cranks, Robert Kennedy, Jr., by Gentempo, in which Kennedy refers to this journal article by none other than Geier and Geier as “very good research,” (it’s not) along with other anti-vaccination talking points debunked by VaccinesWorkBlog.
Other “high-level, well credentialed experts” (their words, not mine) seen in the series is a veritable who’s who of anti-vaccination luminaries. In addition to Wakefield, Kennedy, Seneff, Fisher, Brogan, Bark, Gentempo and DeLong, we find Sayer Ji, Suzanne Humphries, Jack Wolfson, Brian Hooker (also here) and Sherri Tenpenny, as well as chiropractor Dan Pompa, a self-described “celluar detox expert.”
Topics discussed by these “experts” include:
    • “The Vaccine/Autism Connection” and “Autism Connection” (which doesn’t exist)
    • “Unknown Dangers of Vaccines” (not sure how they know about them if they are admittedly “unknown”)
    • “Mercury in Vaccines – Thimerosol” (featuring – you guessed it – Robert Kennedy, Jr.)
    • “CDC Fraud” and “CDC Guidelines and Coverups” (featuring – you guessed it again – Brian Hooker)
The last installment is “Vaccine Solutions,” which features, among others, Dan Pompa, the chiropractor behind “cellular detox.” And what is one of the “toxins” Pompa’s “celluar detox” program addresses? Why, mercury in vaccines, of course.
Preaching to the anti-vaccination choir
Hays will be preaching to the choir. Given its long-standing anti-vaccination ideology and the fact that chiropractic is based on pseudoscience, Hays will no doubt find easy marks for his documentary’s debunked claims. Chiropractic pediatrics is based on the same faulty foundation as chiropractic treatment of adults: the pseudoscientific notion that just about anything, including birth, can cause the putative “subluxation” in a child’s spine. These phantom subluxations cause actual disease, according to chiropractors, who treat children by “adjusting” them, claiming this is effective for a host of conditions like asthma, ear infections, bedwetting, allergies, colic, Tourette Syndrome, and ADHD. They also claim that regular “spinal checkups” and “adjustments” are necessary to keep your child healthy. An article in the Journal of Clinical Chiropractic Pediatrics recommends that children visit the chiropractor 6-12 times annually. Care of pregnant patients falls under this “specialty” as well, including the Webster Technique, which chiropractors claim can turn a breech baby. All of this is the most extraordinary nonsense and, unfortunately, perfectly legal throughout the U.S.
Other woo on the conference agenda includes “Cranial sacral techniques for the newborn” (cranial sacral therapy being yet another form of quackery based on a faulty conception of human anatomy) and “Adjusting the pelvis and sacrum of the school-age child.” There is also “Dysfunctional Infant Feeding: Evaluation and Treatment.” In the chiropractic view of things, “subluxations” in infants can cause breastfeeding difficulties and “adjustments” (including “cranial adjusting”) are the remedy. Attendees can get continuing education credit for these sessions, thanks to the cooperation of Palmer College of Chiropractic.
If that’s not enough to scare the wits out of you, there are also courses entitled “Pre-Eclampsia and the Chiropractor’s Role” and “Hope is Where the Heart Is: Congenital Heart Defects in Newborns.” Other than immediately referring a patient to an appropriately-credentialed physician, chiropractors have no “role” whatsoever in diagnosing and treating either condition.
Their ignorance stems, at least in part, from their education and lack of sufficient clinical training. Chiropractic education in pediatrics consists of one 22-hour pre-clinical course in “pediatric topics” and chiropractors can graduate without ever having seen an actual pediatric patient in clinical training. Post-graduate courses (they don’t do residencies) which allow one to call oneself a “Diplomate” in chiropractic pediatrics, consist of as little as 360 hours of classroom training, sometimes in airport hotel conference rooms. Whether students actually see patients in this training is unclear. The ICA’s recommended books on vaccination contain plenty of anti-vaccination propaganda.
The association between seeing and chiropractor and noncompliance with the CDC-recommended vaccination schedule is well-documented in the medical literature:
Anti-vaccination attitudes still abound within the chiropractic profession. Despite a growing body of evidence about the safety and efficacy of vaccination, many chiropractors do not believe in vaccination, will not recommend it to their patients, and place emphasis on risk rather than benefit.
One study found a correlation between seeing a chiropractor or a naturopath and lack of flu vaccination in pediatric patients. Another study found that children who saw chiropractors were significantly less likely to receive each of three CDC-recommended vaccinations. Yet another found that student anti-vaccination attitudes actually increased in the later years of chiropractic and naturopathic programs. Anti-vaccination attitudes among chiropractors have been documented by the mainstream media as well (also here and here).
Vaccines Revealed will simply reinforce chiropractic prejudice against immunizations. Chiropractors can then go back and spread this misinformation to their patients’ parents. A reasonable solution would be to prevent chiropractors from giving advice about immunizations, or any prescription drugs, for that matter, as outside their scope of practice, and requiring that they refer all questions to the patient’s physician. (Rhode Island just imposed this very restriction on naturopaths.) They have no business advising patients about immunization, especially when they are so thoroughly misinformed. In fact, with their insufficient education and training and propensity toward quackery, they have no business treating children at all.

   Cranial Osteopathy in Dentistry
Grant Ritchey
Link
Editor’s note: Having just submitted a major grant on Friday and then having had to turn around and head to an NIH study section meeting today in Bethesda, I just didn’t have the time to produce something up to the usual standards of SBM for today. (And, being managing editor, I should know what’s up to the usual standards of SBM; what I started to write wasn’t it. Trust me on this.) Fortunately, Dr. Grant Ritchey and Dr. Steve Hendry, two skeptical, science-based dentists, did submit something up to SBM’s usual standards. Even better, since we’ve been having a number of requests for posts involving dentistry, it seemed like a perfect time to publish their first contribution to SBM and see how our readers like it. Maybe next time around, I’ll have them update the “state of knowledge” regarding amalgams.
Form follows function, as the old saying goes. Nowhere in the human body is this adage more fitting than in the oral cavity. In less than two generations, the practice of dentistry has evolved from basic pain relief and function-based procedures (such as extractions and fillings), into today’s practices of complex cosmetic rehabilitation, orthopedic and orthodontic management of the teeth, jaws, and facial structures, replacing missing teeth with dental implants, and treatment of sleep apnea and temporomandibular joint (TMJ) disorders, to name but a few. With such rapid progress, it is to be expected that for every science based advance made in our field, there are just as many claims that are either dubious in their evidential support or outright pseudo-scientific or anti-scientific nonsense.
In this article, we’ll be taking a look at the roles that health care practitioners such as chiropractors, osteopathic physicians, and physical therapists, are attempting to play in the dental field. We will also see how well-meaning dentists have been trained in and apply their pseudo-scientific principles in their dental practices. In particular, we’ll be examining Cranial Osteopathy (also known as Craniosacral Therapy or Cranial Therapy) in the management of the dental patient, the purported benefits claimed by practitioners of cranial osteopathy, and the quality and quantity of evidence for this type of treatment in the scientific literature.
Basic Skull Anatomy
The human skull is made up of some eight cranial (head) bones and fourteen facial bones. These bones help protect the organs of vision, hearing, taste, equilibrium, and smell. They also provide attachment for muscles that move the head, control facial expressions and chew our food. At birth, the spaces between the cranial bones- called fontanelles – are wider and more elastic, allowing the infant to pass through the birth canal and later permitting brain growth in the first few years of life. In humans the lateral fontanelles close soon after birth, the posterior fontanelle generally closes several months later, and the anterior fontanelle may remain open for three years.
By early childhood, the cranial bones become tightly interlocked in a zig-zag, zipper like pattern (illustrated nicely here) that renders them immovable in a macroscopic sense, although each suture (called a synarthrosis if you want to impress your friends at parties) has a very slight amount of flexibility- 10-30 micrometers on average (1 micrometer = 1/1000th of a millimeter or approximately 4/100,000ths of an inch). These sutures fill the minuscule space between the cranial bones, essentially stitching them together with dense, strong connective tissue fibers called Sharpey’s fibers.
Tenets and Scope of Cranial Osteopathy
Cranial Osteopathy was invented by William G. Sutherland D.O. around 1900 when, while viewing a disarticulated human skull, he noted the way some of the skull bones were: “…beveled… like the gills of a fish… indicating articular mobility… for a respiratory mechanism.” Note that we said “invented” rather than “discovered,” as this discipline was indeed invented from whole cloth, based upon the happenstance similarity in the appearance of a skull bone and the gills of a fish, which he then superimposed on his 19th century osteopathic ideology. (Imagine what he would have come up with had he instead noted the similarity between the uvula and the male genitalia!) Sutherland claimed, and adherents of Cranial Osteopathy hold, that the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) has an inherent rhythmicity, which he likened to the tides of the ocean. He called this the “Primary Respiratory Mechanism (PRM)”, often referred to today as “Craniosacral Rhythms.” According to Osteopathic principles, the PRM underlies all of life’s processes and begets vitality, form, and substance to all of a person’s anatomy and physiological processes. Any disturbance in the natural flow of CSF could cause illness and conversely, practically any illness could be prevented or cured by the physical manipulation of the cranial bones, “freeing up” the functional flow of the CSF. Towards the latter part of his life, Sutherland believed that he could sense a “power” which allowed corrections to occur from inside his patients’ bodies without having to provide any physical manipulations. This has come to be known as “biodynamic craniosacral therapy” or “biodynamic osteopathy”. See this overview of the scope of Cranial Osteopathy (“The Cranial Concept”) in their own words.
Of course, none of this imagery would be of any use without a therapy to sell, and osteopaths assert that they can fix what ails you through hands-on manipulation of your skull bones. As one practitioner’s website puts it: “As incredible as this may seem, we feel the bones move, the membranes pull, the fluids fluctuate, and even the brain undulate”. And woe unto the poor sap who suffers from a rigid-boned, lax-membraned, fluid stasisy, un-undulating brain! Practitioners of Craniosacral Therapy or Cranial Osteopathy claim that they can detect this secondary CSF pulse with simple palpation and distinguish them from a regular vascular pulse.
Cranial manipulations are performed in a variety of different ways depending upon the condition being treated and the philosophy and training of the practitioner. (See an overview of some of the techniques.) Some of them include range of motion therapies similar to what a physical therapist would do; others involve the supposed manipulation and movement of the cranial bones, using only digital (i.e. finger) pressure with a very light force.
The Cranial Osteopathic Academy, a component society of The American Academy of Osteopathy (AAO), described it thus:
Treatment is typically very gentle. Tissues are supported and allowed to change. Usually very little force is used during treatment, but at times some force may be necessary. Diagnosis and Treatment are said to blend into one another. As tissues change the physician learns more about their nature. As the nature of the tissue dysfunction is better understood, the therapeutic response deepens.
Each patient’s experience is unique. Some patients sense only a gentle touch, while others feel their body change immediately. Some patients simply feel a deep sense of relaxation, and others feel nothing at all. Most patients feel a distinct change following the treatment.
Though Cranial Osteopathy is very gentle, patients can occasionally experience some discomfort during certain stages of the treatment. When this occurs, it is simply a part of the healing process. As the treatment progresses, the discomfort subsides.
Although physicians practicing Osteopathy in the Cranial Field will work anywhere on the body, they may find it important to diagnose and treat the head. Though styles of treatment may vary, the osteopathic physician will primarily focus on the body’s “mechanism” – the body’s natural striving for health and normal function.
According to Dr.Sutherland, within each patient there is great wisdom, an inner physician, a wise all-knowing force that is the source of all healing. In his own words: “Allow physiologic function to express its own unerring potency rather than apply blind force from without.”
Cranial Osteopathy and its variants make a number of imaginative leaps from histological starting points to therapeutic endpoints. From the slight (micrometer) flexibility of cranial sutures, and the slight-but-measurable fluctuation in CSF pressures, practitioners infer that the brain and spinal cord undulate rhythmically “like a jelly fish, coiling and uncoiling” which is critical for health.
Dental Applications of Cranial Osteopathy
Gradual movement of teeth within bones, and gradual orthopedic movement of facial bones themselves, are familiar to all dentists who do orthodontics. Dentists performing orthodontic treatment utilize various appliances to expand the palate (palatal sutures don’t normally fuse until adolescence) and move teeth within the jawbones. Further, the treatment of TMJ disorders has typically been in the realm of the dentist, involves the articulation of cranial bones in the scope of treatment (the mandible and the temporal bone), so the Osteopathy belief system would seem a natural fit to dentistry, especially in these areas. And sure enough, Osteopathy has colonized the dental profession. We’ve seen expensive dental continuing education courses with “Cranio-”, “Sacro Occipital Therapy” and “Chiro-” in their names that graft Osteopathic principles onto dentistry to create whole new, untapped disciplines to market.
Websites promoting these dental applications of Cranial Osteopathy claim to teach amazing new skills to dentists, including how to “free up” and move facial bones around, by hand, in minutes using only fingertip pressure. Additionally, in almost every case, these dental courses provide a gateway to other, more garden variety forms of CAM: nutritional supplements, detox, immune system boosting, nervous system balancing, and so forth. For the dentist, taking one of these courses is the first step in going “down a rabbit hole” into CAM-land – a metaphor that devotees enthusiastically embrace and frequently use.
An important point to reiterate here is that the emphasis in the dental application of cranial osteopathy is not merely to treat illness or facilitate the flow of the CSF as in “regular” osteopathy; it claims to actually bodily move the facial and cranial bones to more ideal positions to improve orthodontic and TMD outcomes. Cases are shown where overall changes in facial structure and the occlusion (i.e. the bite) are alleged to have been changed by as much as a half of an inch or more by cranial manipulation alone. Of course, these are case studies with little to no supplementary documentation (radiographs, CT scans, etc.) available for an objective reviewer to confirm the claims. We have yet to see a well-documented, objectively presented case study in the medical or dental literature which adequately demonstrates the validity of the treating practitioner’s claims, although one would think that after decades of the existence of their treatment modalities, such evidence would be plentiful, substantive, and readily accessible to the health care community.
Credibility as a Dental Treatment
For Cranial Osteopathy to be viable treatment, there needs to be good evidence anatomically and histologically that the sutures are indeed movable (by hand, no less) to a significant degree, and evidence that doing so is therapeutically beneficial. Neither appears to exist. Although Cranial Osteopathy can provide a modicum of basic research to support its claims, it falls far short of what is needed to establish a scientific foothold in the dental-medical community. Osteopathic applications are woefully lacking in any substantive research but instead rely on anecdotal evidence as the foundation of its validity and applicability. See the excellent overview of Cranial Therapy at Quackwatch.org.
Evaluating the literature, minute movements of the cranial bones appear to be possible (in the micrometer range as stated above) — but not the large rearrangements of bones that practitioners claim to make with hands-on manipulation. It is dubious that a practitioner can feel distortions in cranial bones that the most sensitive neurophysiological instruments cannot.
Moreover, even if an Osteopathic therapist could detect abnormalities in the skull, there appears to be no credible evidence linking small movements at cranial sutures to beneficial health outcomes. As a scientific principle, this is nothing more than wishful thinking and resembles faith healing more than evidence based medicine. The therapeutic claims, research protocols, treatment goals, and definitions of what constitutes solid medical evidence are as flexible as the cranial bones they purport to manipulate.
Cranial Osteopathic adherents predictably scold their critics as being closed-minded and unwilling to learn, or worse, a shill for the Dental Industrial Complex. But we like the old adage about staying open-minded, but not so open that your brain falls out. The really surprising (and disturbing) thing to us is the number of bright, conscientious, and highly-trained dentists we see being drawn to courses in Cranial Osteopathy, and in many cases buying into the smorgasbord of alternate-medicine courses offered as side dishes at the cranio-dental table. If there’s harm in the Cranio-dental movement, besides a lot of money wasted by dentists on dubious courses and by patients on dubious treatment, it may be that it seems to be a particularly attractive gateway to more bizarre alternate treatment philosophies – one that seems to appeal to surprisingly smart and educated dentists. By granting dentists a license to practice, the public trusts us to apply evidential knowledge to the management of their dental problems. This implies that we must critically examine new hypotheses, decide if there is rational evidence for them, reject the pseudo-science, and apply the knowledge that sifts through for the benefit of the patients we serve.

Cranial Manipulation and Tooth Fairy Science
Harriet Hall on August 27, 2013
Link
Tooth Fairy Science is science that studies a phenomenon that doesn’t exist. You can do studies on the Tooth Fairy; for instance, comparing how much money she leaves to kids in different socioeconomic groups. You can do studies on the memory of homeopathic water. You can do studies on the therapeutic effects of smoothing out wrinkles in the imaginary human energy field with therapeutic touch. Or you can do studies of craniosacral therapy. “Therapeutic Effects of Cranial Osteopathic Manipulative Medicine: A Systematic Review,” by Jakel and Hauenschild, was published 2011 in the Journal of the American Osteopathic Medical Association. It is a perfect example of Tooth Fairy Science.
In the 1930s, William G. Sutherland, DO looked at a disarticulated skull and noticed that the sutures were beveled, like the gills of a fish. He concluded that this indicated articular mobility for a respiratory mechanism. He invented cranial osteopathic manipulation to allegedly move the bones of the skull relative to each other for therapeutic benefit.
In the 1970s, John E. Upledger developed this idea further, inventing craniosacral therapy (CST). It postulates rhythmic fluctuations of the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF), mobility of the cranial bones and dural membranes, and involuntary motion of the sacrum. The CST practitioner palpates the skull, senses pulsations transmitted to the skull by the CSF, gently moves the skull bones relative to each other, and thereby releases restrictions to the flow of CSF, which somehow restores health in an astounding variety of human illnesses.
The thinking of CST practitioners is illustrated by this statement quoted by Edzard Ernst:
When a self-development issue is linked to the illness, it is enough for that issue to be acknowledged by the client (without any further discussion unless the client desires it) for the body to release the memory of that issue – sensed by the therapist as tightness, tension, inertia within the body’s systems – so that the healing can proceed.
Several treatment sessions may still be needed, especially if the condition is a long lasting one. Our bodies’ self-healing mechanisms rely on a combination of the various fluid systems of the body (blood and lymph flow and the fluid nature of the cells making up all the organs and systems within our bodies) and the body’s energy fields. Our hearts generate their own electrical signal independently of the control of our brains. Such signals travel around the body through the blood and other fluid systems. Blood is an excellent conductor of electricity and, when electricity flows through a conductor, magnetic fields are created. It is with these fields that the craniosacral therapist works.
These same fields store the memory of the events of our life – rather like the hard disk on a computer – but these memories can only be accessed when the underlying Body intelligence ‘decides’ it is needed as part of the healing process. There is absolutely no danger, therefore, of more being revealed than is strictly necessary to encourage the client back onto their self development route and to enable healing to take place.
Upledger’s odyssey
I first became aware of Dr. Upledger in 2003, when he was the subject of the first article I ever published, in Skeptical Inquirer. The text of that article is available online. You might enjoy reading the full article. In it, I described Dr. Upledger’s epiphany as he reported it: he was assisting a neurosurgeon by holding the dura (membrane surrounding the brain and spinal cord) steady while the surgeon removed a calcified plaque. He wasn’t doing a very good job of holding still. The surgeon complained. Most of us would have thought our own muscles were at fault; however, Upledger observed that the dura was fluctuating up and down at about ten cycles per minute, overcoming his attempts to hold it still. Nobody had ever observed this before, not even neurosurgeons.
He tried mobilizing the cranial bones through hands-on manipulation and convinced himself he could feel the bones move one-sixteenth of an inch or more. Patients with autism, seizures, cerebral palsy, headaches, dyslexia, colic, asthma, and other diseases reported dramatic improvement. He found that well people treated with monthly adjustments reported more energy, felt happier, and were sick less often.
That was bad enough, but then he really got carried away. He discovered energy cysts, sound therapy, healing energy that he could transmit from one hand to the other through the patient’s body, dolphin therapy where dolphins touched the therapist and the therapist touched the patient, and the patient’s “Inner Physician,” one of which appeared to the patient in the form of a seagull and asked to be introduced as “Mermaid.”
I got the title of my article “Wired to the Kitchen Sink” from Upledger’s treatment of a patient who had “excess energy.” He grounded her big toe to a drainpipe with copper wire to remove the energy, and it worked to relieve her chronic pain. So he had her husband connect her to the kitchen sink with a thirty-foot length of copper grounding wire so she could get around the house.
The JAOA systematic review
The authors of the review assume their Tooth Fairy is real. They assert that osteopathic manipulation affects the primary CSF respiratory mechanism though techniques that accomplish things like compressing the fourth ventricle. They say that research so far has focused on the reliability of palpation. They cite osteopathic books and articles, including a 1939 book by Sutherland, none of which actually support the reliability of palpation. And they do not mention the several studies showing that palpation is unreliable.
Bypassing the question of whether CSF fluctuations exist, and bypassing the subject of reliability, they forge ahead to review randomized controlled trials and observational data to describe the clinical benefit of cranial OMM (osteopathic manipulative medicine) in patients with a variety of pathologic conditions. Note: they want to describe the clinical benefit, not to ask whether there is a real clinical benefit.
Starting with 159 studies, they excluded those that failed to meet the inclusion criteria and ended up with 8 studies: 7 randomized controlled trials (RCTs) and one observational study. The number of subjects ranged from 9 patients to 142 patients. Four studies did not mention the manual techniques used. Treatment duration ranged from 1 minute to 30 minutes, from a single treatment to 6 months. Four studies were in healthy subjects; four used patients with different ages and a variety of conditions, from infants with colic to adults with myopia.
The most common finding was improvement in sleeping patterns. For pain, there was a positive outcome for adults with tension headaches but not for children with cerebral palsy. One study showed reduction of crying and “required parental attention” in infants with colic. Three studies did not have meaningful clinical endpoints (for instance a study of the effect of CV-4 technique on blood velocity).
They actually admit that the available evidence is heterogeneous and insufficient to draw definitive conclusions, but they nevertheless remain convinced that OMM is an effective and clinically beneficial treatment modality for patients of all ages. Their bias is glaringly obvious, and of course they end by calling for further research.
The SRAM analysis
Jakel and Hauenschild do not mention the incisive 2002 study “Interexaminer Reliability and Cranial Osteopathy” published in the Scientific Review of Alternative Medicine (full text available online). It showed that claims of inherent rhythmic motility of the brain and spinal cord are scientifically groundless, that the only fluctuations in CSF are reflections of the patient’s respiration and heart rhythms, and that the skull bones are fused together in adults and cannot move relative to one another. Inter-examiner reliability was non-existent: different examiners reported different “cranial rhythms” for the same subject and each single examiner tended to report very similar rates for every subject examined. So the reported rhythms obviously depended on the examiner and had nothing to do with the patient. They rejected the results of a study by Upledger that allegedly showed interexaminer reliability, offering more likely explanations his apparent success and saying that his study shows extraordinary evidence of careless and poor design.
They comment:
Without careful scientific controls, weaknesses of perception and interpretation can fool both practitioners and patients into believing that a treatment is effective when it is not. We believe that these and other natural human psychosocial influences help to explain how cranial osteopathy has achieve the 21st century without scientific support of any kind.
A Later, More Skeptical Systematic Review
A 2012 review by Edzard Ernst found that low quality studies with a high risk of bias suggested positive effects, while the highest quality trial failed to demonstrate effectiveness. He concluded: “The notion that CST is associated with more than non-specific effects is not based on evidence from rigorous RCTs.”
Is it safe?
In most cases it probably is safe. The manipulations are gentle and the treatment may have a relaxing effect. But at least two deaths have been reported, one in an epileptic woman who was treated with cranial therapy and was told to stop her seizure medication, and one in a 2 day old infant who was treated with cranial manipulation in lieu of conventional treatment for a high fever (a life-threatening medical emergency in a child of that age). The cause of death was a subdural hematoma likely due to the manipulations.
Conclusion
Stephen Barrett was right: cranial therapy is silly. Its underlying theory is false, it has no therapeutic value, and its safety is questionable. Systematic reviews like the one by Jakel and Hauenschild are unfortunate because they lend an aura of scientific respectability to nonsensical treatments and encourage wasting money on Tooth Fairy Science.

Osteopathic Medicine – What Is It?
What is the difference between an MD and DO? Let’s take a look at the history and the present practice of osteopathic medicine.
Steven Novella on October 7, 2020
Link

It seems that much of the public is just noticing that there are essentially two distinct medical degrees offered in the US, MD (medical doctor) and DO (doctor of osteopathy). This fact became apparent because the president’s personal physician, Sean Conley, is a DO (he graduated in 2006 from the Philadelphia College of Osteopathic Medicine). Without getting into the details, his care of the president both over the course of this pandemic and during his recent illness with COVID-19 has been curious to other medical experts, and he appears to be subjugating good medical communication (if not care) to political expediencies. This has prompted many to ask what role his DO plays in this behavior.
While I have no personal information about Dr. Conley except what is already public knowledge, I thought it would be a good time to review osteopathic medicine – what is it, exactly?
The history of osteopathic medicine (OM) has some similarities and important difference from chiropractic. OM was founded by a physician, Andrew Taylor Still, in 1874. The core idea on which he founded OM was the notion that the bones and their connections (ligaments, tendons, fascia) represent a continuous energy that can heal the whole body. This was not an unusual idea at the time, a manifestation of the “life force” (or vitalism), and all you have to do is free or support this force and the body will heal itself. This is also the essence of chiropractic.
This notion is also completely wrong. The notion of a life force was always a placeholder of our own ignorance, and was discarded by medicine once we learned how biology actually works. No life force has ever been discovered by science, and there is no plausible mechanism for such a force. There is also no evidence tying the bones to healing in the way imagined by Still.
To give an idea of his thinking, here is a quote from his writing (spelling errors all in the original):
The Heart. Its Commission, The powers delegated to it; by some wise government. Is evident by the work it does – I do not mene the muscles of its physical form. I men the soul of its commission. A commission is allways written on a sheet of paper, or Parchment. The has no paper, that is visable until it makes the paper. and It writes or specifys all the plans it must exacut and says thus far and no farther. you can go – in your commission you have power to build and power to repare. and vitalise all divisions & unit all into one being, And leave the Substance of knowledge to rule and govern by the mandates of knowledge whos law is absolut and must be obeyed to the last letter or death is the penalty.
This is a clear statement of vitalistic philosophy. This is how osteopaths represent their philosophy today:
His research and clinical observations led him to believe that the musculoskeletal system played a vital role in health and disease. He concluded that the body contained all of the elements needed to maintain health, if properly stimulated.
Dr. Still believed that by correcting problems in the body’s structure, through the use of manual techniques now known as osteopathic manipulative medicine (OMM), the body’s ability to function and to heal itself could be greatly improved. He also promoted the idea of preventive medicine and endorsed the philosophy that physicians should focus on treating the whole patient, rather than just the disease.
The original OM philosophy is still there, amazingly, but they try to “retcon” this philosophy into the more modern notions of “holistic” and preventive medicine. There is nothing holistic about vitalism, and Still did not invent preventive medicine. This philosophy is pseudoscientific baggage, and OM would do well to just rid themselves of it.
But here is where the history of OM diverges from chiropractic. The originator of chiropractic, DD Palmer, and even more so his son, were hostile to MDs and mainstream medicine. They wanted nothing to do with it. This has shaped their history of the last century. But Still was an MD himself, and when medicine was undergoing a massive reform (prompted by the Flexner report of 1910) OM went along. Colleges of OM adopted the scientific and quality control reforms that medical schools did (while chiropractors resisted any notion of merging with mainstream medicine).
The result is that today the medical education provided by an OM education is roughly equivalent to those provided by a traditional medical school. In fact, many DOs will attend the same internships and residencies that MDs do (and that is where you actually learn most of the medicine you will eventually practice). When we have discussed osteopathic medicine in the past, SBM authors have always pointed this out. John Snyder wrote, for example:
I would like to preface this post by stating that I have worked with many DOs (Doctors of Osteopathy), and I have helped train many pediatric residents with DO degrees. I have found no difference in the overall quality of the training these students have received, and some of the very best clinicians I have ever worked with have been DOs. I would never prejudice my assessment or opinion of a physician based on whether they have an MD or a DO after their name.
I agree. I have not personally witnessed any difference. Mark Crislip also pointed out that DOs are using less and less osteopathic manipulation in their practice. This is a good thing, and hopefully it will eventually completely fade away. Essentially we need to distinguish between osteopathic medicine, which is mostly equivalent to standard medicine, and osteopathic manipulation, which is pure pseudoscience akin to straight chiropractic.
The fact that any individual physician is a DO rather than an MD really tells us nothing. However, osteopathic medicine really should ditch the manipulation based on quaint notions of vitalism. They should also stop selling themselves as “holistic” or pretending that they invented preventive medicine.

Pump it up: osteopathic manipulation and influenza
Mark Crislip on October 4, 2013
Link

First, my bias. I work in Portland and we have medical students, residents, and faculty who are DOs (Doctor of Osteopathy). Before he moved on to be a hospitalist my primary physician was a DO. From my experience there is no difference between an MD and a DO. In my world they are interchangeable. There are many more qualified applicants for medical education than positions in MD programs and some opt for a DO education. Osteopathy has a dark side.
As best I can determine from my colleagues, learning osteopathic manipulation (OM) is the price they pay to obtain an otherwise standard medical education. I have yet to see OM offered by any of my DO colleagues. It may be they know better than to offer such a modality around me given my ranty propensity for all things SCAM.
The literature would suggest that OM is left behind by most DOs upon graduation. DOs are not proud of their OM, and rarely invite them ‘round to dinner. It will be interesting to see if OM fades over time in DO school as the old time true believers die off and are supplanted by a generation of DOs trained with more traditional medical education.
OM, the small pseudoscientific aspect of DO medical school education, is a form of massage and manipulation invented in the 19th century with no basis in reality. OM postulates
the existence of a myofascial continuity – a tissue layer that interlinks all parts of the body. By manipulating the bones and muscles of a patient a practitioner is supposed to be able to diagnose and treat and variety of systemic human ailments.
Studies into the efficacy of OM find it to be ineffective for any process aside from low back pain (is there anything that does not help low back pain?), not surprising for a therapeutic intervention detached from reality. My purpose with this entry is not to review OM per se, which may be a good topic someday, but to focus on a specific application of OM.
Despite OM fading in the US, that does not mean there are not true believers; all nonsense has its die-hard proponents and OM is no exception, yielding peculiar publications. An example I ran across: The 2012–2013 influenza epidemic and the role of osteopathic manipulative medicine.
It caught my interest. How could a ritualistic massage and muscle manipulation have any effect of a virus that is multiplying in and destroying respiratory epithelial cells? Can they do OM on the lining of the lung? And if so, how do they get into the airway to do it? Inquiring minds want to know the rationale behind such a goofy intervention for a viral infection of the lung. Routine readers of the blog know I am very much a Bayesian/prior plausibility kind of guy. It is inconceivable to me that OM could have any effect on of influenza.
There remains a great need for a “something more” to be done to deal with this highly contagious viral infection—and that “something” is embodied by what osteopathic medicine has offered in the past: a distinctive care that helped the world manage the Spanish influenza pandemic of 1918-1919, nearly 100 years ago. Then as now, osteopathic physicians were in a unique position, armed with osteopathic manipulative treatment (OMT). Modern osteopathic physicians use OMT in conjunction with vaccination, antiviral treatment, and chemoprophylaxis to turn the tide against this devastating, highly contagious pathogen.
Weird, huh? Give a list of reality based interventions to decrease infection risk and therapy (hygiene, vaccination, medications) then toss in some useless pseudoscience. Interesting how a mind can hold two contradictory ideas at the same time: simultaneously suggesting reality- and fantasy-based medicine.
One of the themes of this blog and one of the topics that I have an evolving interest in is how we know what is true and the standards we use to determine reality. My time in the SBM world has greatly heighten my awareness as to how horrendous we are at interpreting the effectiveness of medical interventions and how iffy much of the medical literature is.
What is the basis of using OM for the treatment of influenza? For that you have to go back to a time when all medical treatments were little better than using stone knives and bearskins, the turn of the century. It was a time when most of medicine was, by the standards of today, worthless, dangerous or both. Most of the focus of this entry will be on the original papers, which had better be pretty damn impressive to suggest OM is a reasonable adjunct to standard influenza care. Spoiler. It isn’t.
The source was the 1918–1919 influenza pandemic where:
osteopaths had a substantial impact on patient care: according to Smith, patients who received conventional (i.e., allopathic) medical treatment had a death rate 40 times higher than those who received osteopathic care.
Standard care at the time had a case fatality rate of about 2.5%, although they give more impressive mortality rates in the paper.
Whoa. Really? It did? That would be amazing if true. Let’s go to the video tape. Or the scanned pdfs.
The original reference from 1919 is a fun read, the transcription of a talk full of the pomp and verbosity common in the time. I am writing the final draft of this essay during breaks at the national ID meeting, where I have spent the last few days mostly having Powerpoint slides read to me. We could use some 19th century pomp and verbosity to enliven the sessions.
The reproduction is poor with a lot of bleed-through. I think it says, and this is the methods part of the presentation:
As you know, a letter containing a blank questionnaire on Influenza and Pneumonias was sent last November to all practicing osteopathic physicians in the United States and Canada. Strict and emphasized instructions were given to report only definitive and well developed cases and to report all such, together with all fatalities.
That’s it. I cannot locate what the strict and emphasized instructions were. Very little real data is given. Nowhere do they mention what specific osteopathic treatment was used, there was more of a focus on what was not done: no aspirin, no narcotics.
The data was equally minimalistic. In the original paper it was reported that 2,445 osteopaths answered the questionnaire and reported treating 110,220 cases of influenza with 257 deaths, 1/4 of one percent. They also reported 6,248 cases of pneumonia with 655 deaths.
The paper was presented in July 1919, only about 7 months after the end of the epidemic. A damn impressive turnaround time to send out almost 2,500 letters, have them filled out, returned, read and analyzed. I would so love to see those letters. It seems a wee bit suspicious to me. Anyone have the originals?
A further illuminating feature of these reports revealed that fact that few persons contracted influenza who, just preceding and at the time of the epidemic, had been having more or less regulate osteopathic manipulative treatment.
The actual data to support the preventative effects of OM? Nothing. His assertion. Color me unimpressed (mauve-y shade of pinky russet is the color of unimpressed, if you must know).
Most of the report goes on to castigate the powers that be for not including DOs as part of the medical response to the pandemic despite their superior medical treatments and noting that DOs did not make any of their patients drug addicts. It is quite an indignant screed, worthy of the blogosphere but short on supporting data.
The paper, while interesting, is of no value what so ever for supporting the use of OM for influenza: no microbiologic diagnosis, no case definition, no case control, and huge opportunity for reporting bias that renders the information totally unreliable. But a fun rant does not a reliable intervention make. I would love to see the original questionnaires and look at the data. We have to take the word of the author who, from the tone of the paper, has a real ax to grind in the promotion of DO/OM treatment.
Although anti-medication in tone, it is of interest that they were of the opinion that:
In 1918-1919, aspirin…played the same harmful role as was played by antipyrin and ?? a generation earlier.
How much of the death in the US from influenza was due to inadvertent aspirin overdose is an interesting question:
In 1918, the US Surgeon General, the US Navy, and the Journal of the American Medical Association recommended use of aspirin just before the October death spike. It has been suggested that aspirin overdose lead to significant pulmonary edema and death in the US. If these recommendations were followed, and if pulmonary edema occurred in 3% of persons, [a significant proportion of the deaths may be attributable to aspirin.]
A curious hypothesis, although the virus was quite capable of killing without the benefit of medical care and aspirin.
It is an interesting question as to whether it was DO care or the avoidance of MD care and aspirin, if it occurred, that resulted in an improved survival rate. The fact that most SCAMs do nothing would be a benefit in a time when medicine inflicted aggressive nonsense upon the ill. More likely is biased reporting by an author railing against “medical bigotry and medical politics.”
Even if OM care was responsible for a decreased death rate, and I would be skeptical based on the methods and data reporting, it is more likely a result of what DO did not do (standard care) than what they did (OM).
The author of the 1937 paper referring to the 1919 report credits:
the lymphatic pump technique, which has become popular in the last few years is a procedure of definite value in the treatment of influenza.
What proportion of patients actually received the ‘lymphatic pump technique’ cannot be discovered, as it is not mentioned in the original 1919 paper what exactly the DO interventions consisted of.
As best as can be determined, there is no information in the original reports to suggest that any conclusions can be made about any specific osteopathic intervention for influenza as no specific intervention is mentioned (must less the use of any lymphatic pump).
The fact that there is no mention of a lymphatic pump as the intervention that led to such a dramatic decline in mortality doesn’t stop the technique as being touted for the treatment of influenza:
Should we face additional waves of new influenza infections in the coming year, the use of the gentle lymphatic treatment techniques and medications such as oseltamivir will likely help pre- vent many persons from getting the influenza-related complications that took so many lives during the Spanish influenza pandemic of 1918-1919.
and
Retrospective data gathered by the American Osteopathic Association shortly after the 1918–1919 influenza pandemic have suggested that osteopathic physicians (DOs), using their distinctive osteopathic manipulative treatment (OMT) methods, observed significantly lower morbidity and mortality among their patients as compared to those treated by allopathic physicians (MDs) with standard medical care available at the time. In light of the limited prevention and treatment options available, it seems logical that a preparedness plan for the treatment of avian influenza should include these OMT procedures, provided by DOs and other healthcare workers capable of being trained to perform these therapeutic interventions.
I love their understatement about the validity of the original data:
These were not controlled studies. The data is retrospective and some conclusions cannot be well drawn from such information.
How about no conclusions can be drawn? I grow even more of a mauv-y shade of pinkish russet by the paragraph. It doesn’t prevent the author from declaring
OMT proved to be a critical factor in the success of osteopathic physicians treating influenza patients during the pandemic of 1918
They suggest a variety of pumps that are supposed to boost the immune system (zero prior plausibility for that concept) and increase lymph flow (maybe, but I can’t see that lymph flow would be of any value in and of itself and the short term increase in lymph flow, if it does occur with OM, would be brief and of an inconsequential amount given the duration of the intervention relative to the 24–7 illness like influenza. A pump would be like adding a lit match to increase the burn rate of a forest fire).
The various pumps are described look to me like a series of massages, some of which look like they are designed to give influenza to the practitioner. I wonder how a patient with flu, intractable cough, high fevers and severe myalgia would lie still to let this be done.
It is often interesting to go back to the original literature and see if the paper actually says what people say it does. I learned as a fellow that papers are often ink blots and people see in them what they think should be there rather than what actually is there. Confirmation bias can show up in the damnedest places.
A reading of the primary literature for OM and influenza does not lead to great confidence in the intervention for influenza nor do the papers actually say what the proponents suggest they do. I become Shaltanac’s joopleberry shrub.
As we head into the influenza season, stick with realty-based interventions. Wash your hands, avoid the spew of coughers, harder than you might think, get the vaccine and be replete in your vitamin D. I think it is safe to say you can pass on osteopathic manipulation.

More Americans turning to complementary approaches to pain control
The use of of complementary health approaches overall, and for pain management, is growing among US adults.
Scott Gavura on February 1, 2024
Link

Like many people I’ve suffered from occasional back pain, on and off, for years. And when I’ve had acute pain, I’ve taken non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) like ibuprofen (Advil). Working 12-hour shifts, always on my feet, led me to some debilitating back pain. And while I’ve never found NSAIDs to be miracle drugs, I did find they were providing some pain relief. After taking them for a multi-week spell when I was really uncomfortable, I found myself diagnosed with a stomach ulcer. Once I healed, I’ve found regular exercise (particularly strength training) seems to keep the back pain at bay. I haven’t had a bad bout for years.
We may think nothing of popping a few Advil now and then, but NSAIDs have been linked to about 30% of drug-related hospital admissions, and it’s estimated that 12,000-16,000 Americans die annually as a result of gastrointestinal bleeding caused by NSAIDs.
As a pharmacist I’ve also seen first hand the devastating impact that narcotics can have on people as well. The awareness of the potential harms of opioids is much more prevalent, among health professionals and consumers, than it was 10-20 years ago.
While there have been good developments in non-narcotic treatments for conditions like migraine, there is still a lot of pain that’s treated with “conventional” drug therapy – analgesics, anti-inflammatories, and narcotics. Given none of these products actually fix the underlying cause of the pain and given their toxicity, it’s understandable there’s interest and enthusiasm for non-drug approaches to pain control. A new paper confirms that growing interest over a 20 year period.
A new paper from Richard L Nahin and colleagues at the NIH (National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health) examines responses from the 2002, 2012, and 2022 National Health Interview Survey (NHIS), which is a household interview survey done annually and nationally. The survey had the same questions about acupuncture, guided imagery and/or progressive muscle relaxation, massage, naturopathy, and yoga in the three periods. Questions on chiropractic care and meditation were worded very differently differently in 2012, limiting comparison. Typical questions looked like:
    • During the past 12 months, did you see a practitioner for acupuncture?
        ◦ For what health problems or conditions did you use acupuncture?
    • During the past 12 months, did you see a practitioner for naturopathy?
        ◦ For what health problems or conditions did you use naturopathy?
Utilization of Complementary Approaches Overall
Outcomes were the changes over time in use of any of the seven complementary health approaches, and each complementary approach for any reason, and for pain management. Here are the results:
Between 2002 and 2022, there was a significant increase in the utilization of all approaches. All individual modalities experienced significant upward trends. The overall prevalence of using any of the seven approaches rose from 19.2% to 36.7%. Yoga exhibited the largest increase, growing from 5.0% in 2002 to 15.8% in 2022. Meditation had the highest prevalence in 2022, with 17.3% of individuals reporting its use. Acupuncture rose from 1.0% in 2002 to 2.2% in 2022. There was little utilization of naturopathy, but it did grow as well.
Utilization of Complementary Approaches for Pain Control
Among those using any of the seven complementary approaches, reports of use for pain management increased significantly from 42.3% in 2002 to 49.2% in 2022. All individual approaches showed statistically significant increases in use for for pain management. Yoga was associated with the largest increase, rising from 11.4% in 2002 to 28.8% in 2022. Chiropractic care had the highest overall usage for pain management, with 85.7% of individuals reporting its use in 2022.
Conclusion
The overall effectiveness of these different types of treatments have been covered in multiple posts in the past, so I won’t rehash the evidence here, other than to say that the evidence supporting them is weak. Nevertheless, over 20 years, there has been an increasing use of all of them, often for pain management. This aligns with a national increase in pain prevalence reported – which is arguably a subject for another post. This survey doesn’t outline why these approaches are gaining in popularity, but the belief that these approaches are effective, and sometimes endorsed in pain management guidelines, may be a factor. Growing insurance coverage (even for arguably ineffective interventions, like acupuncture) may also be contributing to more utilization. I suspect that there is also a growing desire to reduce the use of drug therapy, which in many circumstances is completely appropriate. With a growing prevalence of Americans suffering from pain, we should expect interest to continue to grow in different treatment options.

An Appraisal of Courses in Veterinary Chiropractic
R and O Kjellin an on March 16, 2012
Linl
Today’s guest article, by By Ragnvi E. Kjellin, DVM, and Olle Kjellin, MD, PhD, was submitted to a series of veterinary journals, but none of them wanted to publish it. ScienceBasedMedicine.org is pleased to do so.
Animal chiropractic is a relatively new phenomenon that many veterinarians may know too little about. In Sweden, chiropractic was licensed for humans in 1989, but not for animals. Chiropractors claim that their field is scientific, while others consider it to be a form of ”alternative medicine” with an implausible and unsubstantiated theoretical foundation and little evidence of efficacy. Chiropractic is not taught in medical or veterinary schools.
Courses in “veterinary chiropractic” are offered by two companies in Germany. In their classes, veterinarians and human chiropractors are purposely mixed. A recent malpractice case in Sweden involved one of their students, a veterinarian who was accused of injuring a horse with chiropractic neck manipulation. That case led us to inquire into the underlying theory, clinical practices, and training of “veterinary chiropractors”.
Human chiropractic was founded in 1895 when D.D. Palmer, a grocer and magnetic healer with no medical training, decided that 95% of all diseases were due to vertebral subluxations that blocked the flow through the spinal nerves to all muscles and organs of the body, including the brain, eyes and ears. Adjusting subluxations supposedly allows the body to heal itself by “innate intelligence.” Over a century later, there is still no evidence that such subluxations or “intelligence” exists.
Mainstream medicine has always been skeptical of chiropractic1. Even some chiropractors have criticized the practices of their colleagues2,3. Several recent meta-analyses of chiropractic for various ailments4,5,6 have concluded that musculoskeletal back and possibly neck pain may benefit from spinal manipulation therapy; but the results are not superior to other treatments, and there is no evidence of benefit for other ailments.
Considerable controversy surrounds the chiropractic field. It is therefore essential that veterinarians understand the facts about chiropractic before they consider practicing it, recommending it, or even condoning it for the animals they treat.
Materials and methods
The web sites of two training companies in Germany, viz. the BackBone-Academy for Veterinary Chiropractic and Healing Arts (BBA) and the International Academy of Veterinary Chiropractic (IAVC) and their parent organizations were reviewed. The 500-page course compendium7 from the BBA was closely scrutinized. As most of the Swedish veterinarians who attended chiropractic courses did so at the BBA, the focus of the appraisal was set on this organisation. Their claims were weighed against whatever evidence that could be found in peer-reviewed articles in PubMed and Ovid Medline concerning human as well as animal chiropractic.
Results
What is chiropractic?
Chiropractic is very poorly defined.2 Claims include:
    • ”Chiropractic is a health care discipline which emphasizes the inherent recuperative power of the body to heal itself without the use of drugs or surgery.
    • Chiropractic […] focuses particular attention on the subluxation.
    • A subluxation is a complex of functional and/or structural and/or pathological articular changes that compromise neural integrity and may influence organ system function and general health”8.
The subluxation is the core idea underlying chiropractic diagnosis and treatment. But there is no universally accepted definition. The original idea of a physical subluxation has not been substantiated, and neither have “functional and/or structural and/or pathological articular changes” been shown objectively to exist.
The subluxation concept is under constant debate within the chiropractic community3. A recent review of the literature by chiropractors searching for evidence that subluxations can affect health concluded that “No supportive evidence is found for the chiropractic subluxation being associated with any disease process or of creating suboptimal health conditions requiring intervention. Regardless of popular appeal this leaves the subluxation construct in the realm of unsupported speculation. This lack of supportive evidence suggests the subluxation construct has no valid clinical applicability”9. Despite this there are strong forces to preserve this concept10,11.
The standard chiropractic treatment is called adjustment or manipulation. Chiropractors claim that a “high velocity low amplitude” (HVLA) thrust in the plane of the joint will force it just slightly beyond its normal range of movement, but not so far as to cause an injury. This, they assert, will help the body to heal itself.
Chiropractic uses a plethora of treatment methods, though there seem to be no efforts to separate the chaff from the wheat12. Some are vigorous manipulations that cause audible cracking and popping sounds. Others consist of light touch or other methods that non-chiropractors may find strange. Many chiropractors mainly use physical methods directed at symptomatic areas, like physical therapists. Subluxation oriented chiropractors treat subluxations regardless of whether the patient has symptoms or not; healthy individuals, they say, need regular prophylactic adjustments. The courses and organizations of animal chiropractic under scrutiny here seem to belong to this latter group, as they emphasize the vertebral subluxation complex and its assumed effect on health and wellness.
History of animal chiropractic
Formal training in animal chiropractic was developed in the US during the 1990’s by the American Veterinary Chiropractic Association (AVCA), which was founded in 1988. From the very beginning, the basic course concept was to train veterinarians and (human) chiropractors together. In 2000, the AVCA was restructured into a professional organization and certifying agency for animal chiropractors. The training was then separated from AVCA and was named Options for Animals13.  Later on, two independent training organizations were founded in the USA with the same basic concept. One of them is the Healing Oasis Wellness Center (HOWC).
The two animal chiropractic courses in Germany, the BBA and IAVC, have strong connections with their parent organizations in the US, HOWC and Options for Animals, respectively. There also are strong bonds between the course organizers and the control organizations AVCA and IVCA (the International Veterinary Chiropractic Association). Options for Animals and AVCA were founded by the same person, and two of the owners of the IAVC founded the IVCA. The animal chiropractors are certified and the courses accredited by the AVCA and IVCA. The intricate relations are depicted in Fig. 1.

Course curriculum
The BBA course consists of five one-week modules: (I) cervical, (II) thoracolumbal, (III) sacropelvic, (IV) extremities and (V) integrated.
The curriculum contains established subjects like anatomy, neurology, biomechanics, pathology, etc., as well as more unconventional subjects such as adjustment techniques for “ribs, temporomandibular joints, tail and cranium.” Techniques taught include Logan Basic, Activator, and how to use “acupuncture, acupressure and applied kinesiology or magnetic therapy as well as physical modalities to speed up the healing process”.14
Other parts of the course are “Animal Chiropractic Philosophy” and “Chiropractic Basics” aimed at introducing the students to the vertebral subluxation complex. Under the heading “Chiropractic Pathology” they emphasize “the pathological changes of the joints, the body and compensatory mechanism that develop secondary to the vertebral subluxation complex”. Some of the ideas, techniques and methods taught warrant a closer look:
Craniosacral therapy
In craniosacral therapy the therapists use their hands to tune into what they call the craniosacral system. Working with the spine and the skull and its cranial sutures and fascia, the restrictions of nerve passages are said to be eased, the movement of cerebrospinal fluid through the spinal cord optimized, and misaligned bones restored to their proper position. They claim that they feel the pulse wave of the cerebrospinal fluid through the skull and along the spine to the sacrum, and even to the feet. The BBA compendium presents this as a useful technique to address the vertebral subluxation. Light touch will balance the craniosacral system and “remove restrictions in dura and fascia [and] cranial sutures”. This ignores the fact that the concepts underlying craniosacral therapy have been definitely refuted in several studies15-18. Even proponents find suture mobility to be no more than 0.07 mm even with very high distractive loads, though some still tend to regard this as “significant”19.
Logan basic
This technique regards the sacrum as the most important part of the body, and a “sacral subluxation” is said to cause impairments in the entire spine all the way up to the atlas20. According to a sample scenario in the BBA compendium, a right-sided ventro-caudal subluxation of the sacrum will cause lower cervical vertebrae to rotate to the right and the atlas to the left (called “Atlas left posterior”), and also cause a right paraspinal muscular spasm, a shorter right rear leg, and other abnormalities. To adjust the spinal subluxations, the sacrum has to be adjusted first. This is done with a very gentle touch with the thumb, “only 5 g”, on the lowest part of the sacrum21. The touch allegedly will cause a reflexive relaxation of the muscles, so that the sacrum can align itself. No scientific studies were found for Logan Basic.
The activator method
This is a system for diagnosis and treatment based on the idea that a difference in leg length will indicate where there is a need for adjustment. A small hand-held instrument with a spring-loaded mallet (Fig. 2) is then used ”to tap misaligned vertebrae back into place”22. The proponents claim that the Activator delivers a precise HVLA thrust, but that it is much gentler than the manual thrust and that they can direct the force more exactly23. (The thrust amplitude is up to about 4 mm.) The instrument also is claimed to be useful “for exciting a human spine at its natural frequency”24. In a British survey, 82% of the responding chiropractors said that they used an Activator25. Despite its long history and popularity, the Activator has been little studied and has not been validated for animals or humans26.

Applied kinesiology
AK is a diagnostic method where muscle strength is tested. It is based on the idea that the individual’s subconscious knows where in the body the problem originates, and that the muscle strength decreases when that part of the patient’s body is touched27. For instance, the patient is asked to extend an arm and resist the therapist’s pressure against it. If the patient has a knee problem, the muscle strength in the arm decreases when the therapist touches the knee. AK is also used to diagnose nutrient deficiencies, allergies and other ailments. Allergies are diagnosed if muscle strength appears to decrease when the patient holds a sealed vial of allergen in the other hand28. For animals (and small children), they test a surrogate person who is in contact with the patient29. One of the BBA instructors claims that “[m]uscle testing, when applied with knowledge, experience and passion, give the veterinarian an invaluable way to communicate with your patients and ask them the questions you’ve always wanted to ask them”30. We have not found any study corroborating these ideas31-34. On the contrary, the best evidence shows it is equivalent to coin tossing35.

The instructors
The instructors of the BBA, seven veterinarians and two chiropractors, are introduced on the web site. None of the veterinarians is a licensed chiropractor; they were trained at animal chiropractic courses in the US or Germany. Most of them practice acupuncture; some use applied kinesiology, osteopathy, and magnet therapy. The head instructor, Dr. Pedro Rivera, is also trained in homeopathy. Together with his wife, a massage and herbal therapist, he founded the Healing Oasis Wellness Center (HOWC) mentioned above. Both of the chiropractors and three of the veterinarians at the BBA are connected with the HOWC. This company organizes animal chiropractic courses and runs a veterinary hospital that focuses on alternative and integrative care, providing veterinary spinal manipulation, veterinary Chinese herbology, veterinary massage, veterinary homeopathy, veterinary acupuncture, mainstream veterinary care, and Feng Shui.
The compendium
The BBA compendium of animal chiropractic encompasses some 500 pages. Large parts deal with anatomy, neurology, pathology, saddle fit, etc. Other parts deal with the philosophy of chiropractic, specific treatment techniques, business tips, and more. Some of the sections are remarkable and deserve special mention:
Cranial sutures
Module I claims that “[t]he calcification process of cranial sutures is SLOW and UNEVEN. It is NOT completed even in the aged animal!: (Upper case and exclamation mark as in the original.) Their emphases seem to imply that they want their students to believe that these rigid, fibrous, highly interdigitated joints are actually possible to move to a significant and clinically useful extent. We have not identified any scientific support for this idea in the literature, but it obviously is necessary in order to rationalize craniosacral therapy.
Risks
It is widely accepted in mainstream medicine that neck manipulation in humans can cause strokes. There are hundreds of documented cases36,37 and a plausible pathoanatomical mechanism (injury to the vertebral artery in its tortuous passage through and around the atlas). But many chiropractors have denied any possible causal relationship, claiming that stroke at neck manipulation is a mere coincidence in persons who were going to have this stroke anyway, citing a study that actually fails to substantiate its hypothesis38.
In Module V, the BBA mentions the risk of chiropractic stroke but downplays its significance, saying it is less than the risk of dying under conventional medical care. However, a Swedish case of veterinary malpractice39 indicates that neck manipulation of a horse may be associated with stroke, which otherwise is unheard of in horses. This horse developed symptoms such as ataxia, dysphagia, and facial hemiparesis, compatible with a lateral medullary infarction (Wallenberg syndrome), which is typical of ischemia in the vertebrobasilar artery region. The horse died of esophageal obstruction some 18 months later.
Scientific validity
Under this heading the BBA cites four irrelevant references that fall very short of giving any validity to chiropractic in general, much less to animal chiropractic. The first one is the Manga Report, funded by the Ontario Ministry Of Health, Canada 199340. This political (not scientific or medical) report only dealt with the treatment of low back pain and concluded that chiropractic services were useful and more cost-effective than current medical treatment and should receive public funding.
The second reference is not even about chiropractic but about lumbosacropelvic anatomical variations in racehorses41. The third reference reports inconsistent variations in nerve signals from paraspinal muscle proprioceptors on manipulative-like loads in anesthetized cats, with no discussion of whether these findings had any clinical significance42. BBA’s fourth reference is a symposium abstract from 1999, not a peer reviewed article.
Discussion
Our research into veterinary chiropractic revealed that chiropractic as such is based on a pre-scientific, vitalistic belief system that can neither be proved nor falsified, and that the information provided for the courses in animal or veterinary chiropractic raises several concerns.
First, several of the subjects included in the curricula are patently pseudoscientific, lacking any biological plausibility, and even are irreconcilable with modern biomedical knowledge, e.g., the illusion that examiners can feel a craniosacral cerebrospinal fluid pulse; the idea that cranial bones can be repositioned in adults; the idea that subluxations exist in the sacrum of horses and can be adjusted with “five grams pressure” or a little mechanically assisted tap, whose proposed mechanisms of action seem rather absurd2. Of all subjects mentioned, Applied Kinesiology is the most bizarre and its surrogate testing beyond all reason. To include all this outlandish nonsense in courses for veterinarians is an insult to their profession.
Second, chiropractic is strongly connected with other unproven or disproven alternative methods, which is obvious from the CVs of the instructors and the range of treatments that the HOWC proffers in its web site.
Third, chiropractic calls itself scientific, but is based on a philosophy that the body can heal itself after adjustment of subluxations, not on any objective evidence. Nobody has been able to show that chiropractic subluxations exist, much less that they affect any functions of the nervous system to cause any illness.
Fourth, while in human studies there is weak support for some small beneficial effect of manipulation on low back pain, in animals there is no scientific support for any chiropractic manipulation treatment at all. Nevertheless, in all web pages and the BBA compendium the subluxation is presented as an obvious fact and the various methods and techniques as if they were well validated.
Courses that contain pre-scientific belief systems, pseudoscientific methods, imaginative ideas and unsubstantiated assertions have no place in veterinary medicine.
Animal chiropractic courses have only existed for a couple of decades and are given by a small number of zealots who are approved by one another. The merits of such accreditations have to be strongly questioned. We also question the basic concept of mixing veterinarians and human chiropractors in the same classes. How much veterinary medicine can the chiropractors learn in such a short time, and how much are the veterinarians influenced by the chiropractors’ strong faith and their skewed portrayal of the scientific evidence concerning chiropractic?
At the outset of this study, we expected that courses in chiropractic given by veterinarians for veterinarians would have selected elements credibly deemed to be applicable to animal care. However, this was not the case. The instructors and course materials do not discriminate between fantasy and reality but include even the most implausible ideas.
Conclusion: Animal chiropractic mixes science, pseudoscience, and fantasy
Animal chiropractic and the veterinary chiropractic courses scrutinized here mix science, pseudoscience and fantasy and make no visible effort to show which is which. They give biased information and refer to more or less irrelevant articles to make the courses look serious and credible. Many of the methods taught lack evidence as well as plausibility and are clearly outside the realm of medical science. We found no evidence for the use of animal chiropractic in veterinary medicine.
Acknowledgments
The authors wish to thank Dr. Harriet Hall, Dr. Brennen McKenzie, and Dr. David Ramey for valuable advice on various versions of this article.
About the Authors
Ragnvi E. Kjellin, DVM, is a graduate of the Swedish Veterinary University. She has always been a realist and skeptic, and has been keeping a scrutinizing eye over the Altmed frontier since a long time. She never stops being astonished of the gullibility of so many people. In the 1980’s there were not many alternative methods in veterinary medicine in Sweden, but they seem to be gaining ground at an accelerating pace. The Singh & Ernst book Trick or Treatment was a wake-up call, and she reviewed it in the Swedish Veterinary Journal.
Ragnvi has long had a particular interest in chiropractic, not only as it is the potentially most dangerous form due to direct injuries, but also as it cunningly has managed to put up and hide behind such a sciency facade that even many scientifically educated persons seem to have difficulties seeing through the obfuscation. The greatest shock was when she realized that even some veterinarians, i.e., persons with the same education as herself, were strong believers of animal chiropractic. And to her great dismay, even the Swedish Veterinary Journal regularly announces the courses in animal chiropractic!She wrote a critical article on animal chiropractic in the Journal — and got some remarkably hostile comments in subsequent issues.
Olle Kjellin, MD, PhD, is a Swedish radiologist and speech physiologist with a special interest in statistics and research methodology as well as in most medical subjects. Though not currently a researcher, he is a hungry but critical consumer of research papers. His MD is from Uppsala University, Sweden, and PhD (or, formally, Dr Med Sci) from Faculty of Medicine, Tokyo University, Japan. He also has an MA in linguistics, phonetics and modern languages from Stockholm University, Sweden. He can’t keep silent when he sees unsupported methods sneaking into the regular health care sector, and he has had several open conflicts with his employer and leading politicians against flimsy bullshit in the psychiatry sector.
Ragnvi and Olle share interests as above and have spent several years together researching all kinds of pseudoscientific ideas, mainly those with medical claims, and chiropractic in particular.
References
     1.  Kaptchuk TJ, Eisenberg DM. Chiropractic: origins, controversies, and contributions. Arch Intern Med 1998;158:2215-2224.
     2.  Homola S. Questionable Claims Made for Activator Methods. Website, 2006. Available at: http://www.chirobase.org/06DD/activator.html. Accessed July 21, 2011.
     3.  Keating JC, Jr., Charlton KH, Grod JP, et al. Subluxation: dogma or science? Chiropr Osteopat 2005;13:17.
     4.  Bronfort G, Haas M, Evans R, et al. Effectiveness of manual therapies: the UK evidence report. Chiropr Osteopat 2010;18.
     5.  Ernst E, Canter PH. A systematic review of systematic reviews of spinal manipulation. J R Soc Med 2006;99:192-196.
     6.  Rubinstein SM, van Middelkoop M, Assendelft WJ, et al. Spinal manipulative therapy for chronic low-back pain: an update of a Cochrane review. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 2011;36:E825-846.
     7.  BBA (BackBone-Academy for Veterinary Chiropractic and Healing Arts). Veterinary Chiropractic, Modules I-V: Unpublished course compendia, 2007.
     8.  Association of Chiropractic Colleges. Bylaws; Chiropractic Paradigm. Website, 2010. Available at: http://www.chirocolleges.org/paradigmscopepractice.html and http://tinyurl.com/chirocoll. Accessed March 12, 2011.
     9.  Mirtz TA, Morgan L, Wyatt LH, et al. An epidemiological examination of the subluxation construct using Hill’s criteria of causation. Chiropr Osteopat 2009;17:13.
     10.  Lanigan R. United we stand, divided we fall. At last the UCA has taken the lead for chiropractors in the UK. Chiropracticlive. Website, 2010. Available at: http://www.chiropracticlive.com/?p=842. Accessed March 12, 2011.
     11.  Rondberg TA. Saving our subluxation unites us. The Chiropractic Journal (electronic). Website, 2002:March. Available at: http://www.worldchiropracticalliance.org/tcj/2002/mar/mar2002rondberg.htm. Accessed Jan 25, 2010.
     12.  Keating JC, Jr. Several pathways in the evolution of chiropractic manipulation. J Manipulative Physiol Ther 2003;26:300-321.
     13.  College of Animal Chiropractic. About Options for Animals. Website. Available at: http://www.animalchiro.com/aboutoptionsfor_animals.html#acc. Accessed July 17, 2011.
     14.  BBA (BackBone-Academy for Veterinary Chiropractic and Healing Arts). Basic Course. Website, 2010. Available at: http://www.backbone-academy.com/courses.html. Accessed July 17, 2011.
     15.  Green C, Martin C, Bassett K, et al. A systematic review of craniosacral therapy: biological plausibility, assessment reliability and clinical effectiveness. Complement Ther Med 1999;7:201-207.
     16.  Moran RW, Gibbons P. Intraexaminer and interexaminer reliability for palpation of the cranial rhythmic impulse at the head and sacrum. J Manipulative Physiol Ther 2001;24:183-190.
     17.  Rogers JS, Witt PL, Gross MT, et al. Simultaneous palpation of the craniosacral rate at the head and feet: intrarater and interrater reliability and rate comparisons. Phys Ther 1998;78:1175-1185.
     18.  Hartman SE. Cranial osteopathy: its fate seems clear. Chiropr Osteopat 2006;14:10.
     19.  Johnson Zee L. The Controversy of Cranial Bone Movement. Massage Today 2008;08.
     20.  Logan Basic. Denver Gentle Chiropractic Dr. Albright. Website, 2009. Available at: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=My3FbbxGPLY. Accessed July 19, 2011.
     21.  Equine Chiropractic. Logan Basic Move. Website, 2007. Available at: http://tinyurl.com/firstblob. Accessed July 19, 2011.
     22.  Glossary of Chiropractic Terms. Activator adjusting instrument. Website. Available at: http://www.superpages.com/supertips/chiropractic-terms.html. Accessed 19 July, 2011.
     23.  Cherok N. Introduction to Activator Chiropractic Care. Website, 2009. Available at: http://drcherok.com/ Accessed July 19, 2011.
     24.  Keller TS, Fuhr AW. Chiropractic adjusting instrument. 1997, US Patent No. US005626615. Available at: http://tinyurl.com/US005626615. Accessed June 19, 2011.
     25.  Read DT, Wilson FJH, Gemmell HA. Activator as a therapeutic instrument: Survey of usage and opinions amongst members of the British Chiropractic Association. Clinical Chiropractic 2006;9:70-75.
     26.  Fuhr AW, Menke JM. Status of activator methods chiropractic technique, theory, and practice. J Manipulative Physiol Ther 2005;28:e1-e20.
     27.  Kuykendall K. Muscle Testing & Applied Kinesiology Demonstration 1. Website, 2009. Available at: http://tinyurl.com/AKfilm1. Accessed July 19, 2011.
     28.  Denver Chiropractor. Applied Kinesiology and Allergy Elimination. Website, 2009. Available at: http://tinyurl.com/AKfilm2. Accessed July 20, 2011.
     29.  Jankodyret. A veterinarian (E.S.) uses Applied Kinesiology with surrogate person. Website, 2009. Available at: http://tinyurl.com/AKfilm3. Accessed July 20, 2011.
     30.  DeStefano CJ. Applied Kinesiology and Functional Neurology in Animal Practice. Health Pioneers. Website, 2006. Available at: http://www.healthpioneers.net/art1.html. Accessed May 15, 2011.
     31.  Cuthbert SC, Goodheart GJ, Jr. On the reliability and validity of manual muscle testing: a literature review. Chiropr Osteopat 2007;15.
     32.  Haas M, Cooperstein R, Peterson D. Disentangling manual muscle testing and Applied Kinesiology: critique and reinterpretation of a literature review. Chiropr Osteopat 2007;15.
     33.  Hall S, Lewith G, Brien S, et al. A review of the literature in applied and specialised kinesiology. Forsch Komplementarmed Klass Naturheilkd 2008;15:40-46.
     34.  Gerez IF, Shek LP, Chng HH, et al. Diagnostic tests for food allergy. Singapore Med J 2010;51:4-9.
     35.  Lüdtke R, Kunz B, Seeber N, et al. Test-retest-reliability and validity of the Kinesiology muscle test. Complement Ther Med 2001;9:141-145.
     36.  Dziewas R, Konrad C, Drager B, et al. Cervical artery dissection — clinical features, risk factors, therapy and outcome in 126 patients. J Neurol 2003;250:1179-1184.
     37.  Leon-Sanchez A, Cuetter A, Ferrer G. Cervical spine manipulation: an alternative medical procedure with potentially fatal complications. South Med J 2007;100:201-203.
     38.  Cassidy JD, Boyle E, Cote P, et al. Risk of vertebrobasilar stroke and chiropractic care: results of a population-based case-control and case-crossover study. Spine 2008;33:S176-183.
     39.  Beck-Friis J. Ansvarsärende — Häst fick skada efter kiropraktisk behandling [Malpractice case — Horse injured after chiropractic treatment]. Svensk veterinärtidning [Swedish Veterinary Journal] 2009;61:51-55.
     40.  Manga P, Angus DE, Papadopoulos C, et al. A Study to Examine the Effectiveness and Cost-Effectiveness of Chiropractic Management of Low-Back Pain. Website, 1993. Available at: http://www.silcom.com/~dwsmith/manga.html. Accessed Dec 3, 2011.
     41.  Haussler KK, Stover SM, Willits NH. Developmental variation in lumbosacropelvic anatomy of thoroughbred racehorses. Am J Vet Res 1997;58:1083-1091.
     42.  Pickar JG, Wheeler JD. Response of muscle proprioceptors to spinal manipulative-like loads in the anesthetized cat. J Manipulative Physiol Ther 2001;24:2-11.

Veterinary Chiropractic
Brennen McKenzie on April 12, 2013
Link
People are sometimes surprised to learn that all the heavy hitters of alternative medicine, such as acupuncture, chiropractic, homeopathy, etc., are inflicted on animals as well as humans. I’ve written about veterinary homeopathy, and the associated manufactroversy, in a previous post, and today I thought I’d take a look at veterinary chiropractic.
The Players
In most states, chiropractic is defined in terms of treatment of humans and chiropractors are thereby licensed only to treat humans. However, there are a variety of ways around this for people who want to subject their animals to this therapy. Some chiropractors will simply treat animals and ignore the fact that it isn’t technically legal for them to do so. And some veterinarians will take one of the many training courses available in animal chiropractic and then employ it as part of their practice of veterinary medicine. A previous SBM article has discussed the lack of consistency or legitimate scientific content in most of these courses.
State veterinary practice acts will also sometimes create legal space for animal chiropractic, often under another name, which avoids the jurisdictional problem of calling it chiropractic when that term is usually legally defined specifically with reference to humans. In California, for example, the practice of “musculoskeletal manipulation” on animals must meet certain requirements specific in the state veterinary practice act:
     1.  A veterinarian must examine the animal, determine that musculoskeletal manipulation (MSM) is appropriate and safe, and take official responsibility for supervising the treatment.
     2.  Then the owner is supposed to sign a form: “The veterinarian shall obtain as part of the patient’s permanent record, a signed acknowledgment from the owner of the patient or his or her authorized representative that MSM is considered to be an alternative (nonstandard) veterinary therapy.”
     3.  Then a licensed chiropractor can examine the pet, determine that MSM is appropriate, and then consult with the supervising vet before performing treatment.
I know of many chiropractors treating animals in the state, with and without veterinary supervision. I have never seen anyone follow these rules.
The perceived legitimacy of veterinary chiropractic is bolstered by the activities of professional veterinary chiropractic organizations, such as the American Veterinary Chiropractic Association (AVCA). This group offers a certification program which allows either chiropractors or veterinarians to claim to be board-certified in animal chiropractic, despite the technicality that the American Board of Veterinary Specialties, which credentials specialty boards, does not recognize this certification and thus it is essentially a fake board certification.
The International Veterinary Chiropractic Association (IVCA), based in Europe, is largely indistinguishable from the AVCA in terms of the content and general approach to promoting animal chiropractic and certifying chiropractors, including the lack of recognition of their specialty certification by the European Board of Veterinary Specialisation (EBVS).
These groups are not to be confused with the International Association of Veterinary Chiropractitioners (IAVC), a group of veterinarians, chiropractors, and apparently any other kind of “health care provider” who cares to join, who fix subluxations with methods difficult to distinguish from chiropractic but who claim to be practicing an entirely original form of therapy called Veterinary Orthopedic Manipulation (VOM) and who prefer to be referred to by the proprietary term “chiropractitioner.” They do share, however, the lack of any formal recognition as a legitimate specialty that characterizes the work of the AVCA and the IVCA.
And then, of course, there are all the individual chiropractors and veterinarians practicing some form of manual therapy based on chiropractic, often with their own idiosyncratic theories and techniques. For example, Dr. Hall recently drew my attention to a book called “Like Chiropractic for Elephants” by Norman “Rod” Block D.C. Dr. Block claims to have “an uncanny touch sensory perception that allows him to connect with the person or animal he comes in contact with…It is then that the animal senses his intention of wanting to help and releases inhibitions that allow discovery of where the root cause of the pain, stress or pressure may exist…The doctor uses his uncanny ability to tune into the root cause of animal states of disease without the use of drugs or surgery.”
I confess I have not been able to stomach paying to read Dr. Block’s book, but thanks to his press release and a few reviews, I have at least a small sense of what it offers. Apparently Dr. Block supplements his understanding of the vertebral subluxation and his “uncanny” sensory abilities with the practice of “Quantum Shamanetics.” In this method, “The quantum shamanist learns to trust and be guided by universal wisdom that exists beyond our genetic blueprint. By being part to, and observing, movement, one becomes more sensitive to subtle changes in energy. By following these dynamic changes, the shamanist develops a more expansive relationship with the flow of life and health.”
Sadly, this is not a unique case of a chiropractor leaving the at least marginally plausible terrain of treating musculoskeletal disease in animals and venturing further afield. Last year, I had the opportunity to evaluate the recommendations of Dr. Steven Eisen, a chiropractor who calls himself a “Holistic Dog Cancer Expert” and has a book and series of web videos explaining how to thwart the mischief of incompetent veterinarians and treat canine cancer with his dietary advice and a dedicated avoidance of vaccines and parasite control products. And perhaps not surprisingly, Dr. Eisen did not exhibit the scientific spirit of respect for open inquiry and debate when challenged for his claims. Instead, he threatened to sue me.
What Is Animal Chiropractic?
For the most part, the principles and practices of animal chiropractic are extrapolated and adapted from those applied to humans, despite the obvious biomechanical and anatomic differences between bipedal hominids and quadrupedal veterinary patients. As in human chiropractic, the core concept behind chiropractic for animals is the subluxation, or the vertebral subluxation complex (VSC). The AVCA criteria for certification includes familiarity with, “the anatomical, biomechanical and physiological consequences of the Vertebral Subluxation Complex,” and the organization suggests that in addition to pain and musculoskeletal disorders, treatment of the VSC can be beneficial for “bowel, bladder, and internal medicine disorders…glands and body functions.”
Veterinary journal articles about chiropractic often emphasize that the subluxation “is at the core of chiropractic theory, and it’s detection and correction are central to chiropractic practice.”(1) They then include lengthy, very impressive and sciency descriptions of how subluxations arise, cause disease, and can be treated. These are usually marred only by the small problem that no one has actually been able to show a subluxation exists in any species despite over a century of trying.(2)
Chiropractors working on humans cannot reliably agree on the location of a supposed subluxation despite extensive and involved theoretical and practical training supposedly intended to help them do so.(3-4) You can’t see it on x-rays, it doesn’t pinch nerves, and as the evidence for subluxations as physical abnormalities has failed to materialize, true believers in chiropractic have gone through amazing intellectual contortions to redefine it in ways that can make it sound real while still being undetectable. A dragon in the garage if there ever was one.
What’s the Evidence?
There is at least some reasonable evidence that spinal manipulations such as practiced by chiropractors may benefit humans with back pain, though Cochrane reviews of spinal manipulation and general chiropractic therapy for even this indication find small effects and research with a high risk of bias. There is no good reason to believe chiropractic is useful for any other complaint in humans.
Reviewing the literature on the effects of veterinary chiropractic care is quite easy since there is almost none. A search of the PubMed and VetMed Resource databases identified no controlled clinical trials of chiropractic therapy in any veterinary species.
Apart from a few case reports, there are several studies evaluating the putative effect of spinal manipulations on sensitivity to painful stimulus and on spine and limb movement in horses.(5-7) These papers suffer from significant limitations and risk of bias. They generally show a lack of adequate randomization and blinding, objective outcome measures and control groups. They frequently measure numerous variables of questionable clinical significance and then ignore the majority that show no change while identifying the few that do show statistically significant differences as somehow indicative of a meaningful treatment effect. While they represent a reasonable attempt to identify criteria for evaluating the effects of spinal manipulation on horses, they do not constitute evidence of efficacy for chiropractic therapy for any disease.
Of course, there is the usual mountain of testimonials and anecdotes which suggest miraculous curative results with chiropractic therapy in animals. These are both unreliable, for all the usual reasons, and unfortunately the most compelling kind of evidence for animal owners
What’s the Harm?
The risks of chiropractic care in humans fall into the usual categories for harm from alternative therapies; direct harm from the treatment and indirect harm associated with irrational belief systems and avoidance of truly effective care. Of the adverse effects documented in humans, the most significant is that of strokes associated with cervical manipulation.(8) There is no research evaluating the direct risks of veterinary chiropractic, so we can only speculate on the safety of spinal manipulation for animal patients.
The indirect risks of chiropractic therapy come from being exposed to irrational fear of science-based medicine and the use of other unproven or clearly ineffective alternative treatments. Chiropractors treating humans, for example, are often inclined to recommend against vaccination, and it is not uncommon for them to employ therapies far less plausible than chiropractic, such as colon cleansing, homeopathy, and many others.
Chiropractors practicing on animals have also been known to stir up irrational fear of vaccination, claim toxins in pet food are common causes of cancer, and otherwise express disdain for science-based veterinary medicine. And a look at the sponsors for the ACVA annual conference illustrates the frequently close relationship between animal chiropractors and practitioners of other alternative therapies such as Traditional Chinese Veterinary Medicine, Standard Process Supplements, Reiki and homeopathy, and others. Such synergy between chiropractic and other alternative therapies has the potential to harm veterinary patients even if direct spinal manipulation does not.
Since anecdotes are so commonly employed in defense of veterinary chiropractic, I feel justified in sharing one illustrating its risks. I was once asked to examine a rabbit that had come to my hospital to be treated by a chiropractor, at the advice of another veterinarian. The rabbit had been anesthetized for treatment of dental disease earlier in the day and upon waking was paralyzed in its hind legs. Even a cursory familiarity with rabbit medicine would immediately lead one to consider a fracture or dislocation of a lumbar vertebrae since these can happen when rabbits kick their powerful hind legs uncontrollably, and rabbits are susceptible to disorientation and panic when emerging from anesthesia.
The chiropractor had already examined the rabbit and concluded it had a subluxation in its cervical spine. He recommended giving a chiropractic adjustment to the neck and sending the pet home, with additional adjustments likely necessary in the following days or weeks. When I asked how he reconciled his diagnosis with the symptoms, which fit the classic pattern associated with a spinal cord injury in the lower back, the chiropractor informed me that he was familiar with “allopathic” neurology textbooks but had chosen to ignore them because they were not consistent with his daily experience in practice.
The client permitted me to take an x-ray which confirmed a traumatic lumbar vertebral fracture and severe spinal cord trauma. The patient was humanely euthanized in light of the severe symptoms and poor prognosis. Though this was sad, I consider it a better outcome for the animal than having its neck twisted and being sent home paralyzed and with a fractured spine but without any pain control, as the chiropractor had recommended. Granted, such a story cannot prove anything about the safety or efficacy of animal chiropractic therapy, but it is at least illustrative of some of the risks of substituting a pseudoscientific belief system for science-based medicine.
Bottom Line
Though there is no reliable data, the popularity of chiropractic for treatment of humans appears to translate, to at least some extent, to the treatment of animals. The fundamental theories and practices of animal chiropractic are copied or extrapolated from those employed in treating humans, however there is virtually no reliable scientific evidence to show any benefit from veterinary chiropractic treatment. There is also no controlled evidence identifying the risks of chiropractic therapy of animals, so we can only speculate about the safety of this intervention. It is clear, however, that chiropractic therapy for animals is often associated with opposition to conventional medical care and with other unproven or clearly ineffective alternative therapies, and this presents some risks to patients seeking care from so-called animal chiropractors.
References
     1.  Maler, MM. Overview of veterinary chiropractic and its use in pediatric exotic patients. Vet Clin Exot Anim. 2012;15:299-310
     2.  Miritz TA. Morgan L. Wyatt LH. Greene L. An epidemiological examination of the subluxation construct using Hill’s criteria of causation. Chiropr Osteopat 2009;2:17-13.
     3.  French SD, Green S, Forbes A. Reliability of chiropractic methods commonly used to detect manipulable lesions in patients with chronic low-back pain. J Manipulative Physiol Ther. 2000 May;23(4):231-8.
     4.  Hestbaek L, Leboeuf-Yde C. Are chiropractic tests for the lumbo-pelvic spine reliable and valid? A systematic critical literature review. J Manipulative Physiol Ther. 2000 May;23(4):258-75.
     5.  Haussler, KK. Martin, CE. Hill, AE. Efficacy of spinal manipulation and mobilisation on trunk flexibility and stiffness in horses: a randomised clinical trial. Equine Veterinary Journal. 2010; 48 (Supp. 38):695-702.
     6.  Gomez Alvarez, CB. L’Ami, JJ. Moffatt, D. van Weeren, PR. Effect of chiropractic manipulations on the kinematics of back and limbs in horses with clinically diagnosed back problems. Equine Veterinary Journal. 2008;40(2):153-159.
     7.  Sullivan, KA. Hill, AE. Haussler, KK. The effect of chiropractic, massage and phenylbutazone on spinal mechanical nociceptive thresholds in horses without clinical signs. Equine Veterinary Journal. 2008;40(1):14-20.
     8.  Ernst, E. Adverse effects of spinal manipulation: a systematic review. J R Soc Med July 2007 vol. 100 no. 7 330-338

Science-Based Satire: Invertebrate Research Reveals Clue to Evolutionary Origins of the Chiropractic Subluxation
New evidence calls into question the belief that chiropractic subluxations require a spine, much to the relief of millions of suffering invertebrate species.
Clay Jones on January 13, 2017
Link
Researchers studying members of an extant animal species with a link to the distant past, specifically a chordate subphylum consisting of organisms with a complex nervous system but lacking spinal bones, may have uncovered a new clue to the early development of the subluxation and solved one of the greatest mysteries in chiropractic science.
“One of the toughest challenges we face in the field of chiropractic developmental neurobiology is the origin of the subluxation from an evolutionary perspective,” Chet Masterson, a chiropractic evolutionary biologist and Chief of Veterinary Neurobiology in the Cleveland Clinic’s Integrative Animal Wellness department, explained. “Are we alone in the universe? What is consciousness? How does a thermos keep hot things hot and cold things cold? When and how the subluxation evolved is right up there with these questions.”
The most widely accepted hypothesis, which started with Daniel David Palmer in 1895, is that the development of the chiropractic subluxation was fully dependent on the evolution of a bony vertebral column and its accompanying musculature. In other words, if the subluxation is the egg, and the spine is the chicken, the man who discovered chiropractic believed that the chicken came first. And the vast majority of the men and women who have followed in his footsteps would agree.
But like Galileo, Semmelweis, and Boyardee, some chiropractors believe that the accepted consensus on the origin of the subluxation is wrong. Some practitioners, like Invertebrate Chiropractors Association (ICA) President Frank Grimes, believe that the subluxation existed as a standalone entity prior to the evolution of the spine in vertebrate species. “I don’t care if it’s a ventral nerve cord or a nerve net, if there is a series of interconnected neurons transferring information from one end of an organism to the other, then that organism is at risk of developing a subluxation.”
Invertebrate chiropractors like Grimes claim that the stiff segmented column and mobile intersegmental joints observed in many vertebrates, a classification of animals which experts now believe includes thousands of distinct species, such as the South American maned wolf and the flying dugong, evolved as a protective mechanism. The development of this internal biological armor, one made of bone and tough connective tissue, improved survival and increased procreative success by reducing the incidence of subluxations in the vulnerable dorsal nerve cord. This allowed vertebrates, in particular humans and to a lesser extent the river dolphin, to achieve dominion over all the Earth.
Subluxations, according to over a century of direct observation and a few years’ worth of case reports in the medical literature, have been pragmatically linked to the entire spectrum of human pathology as well as decreased energy in Shetland ponies. But Grimes, who has a diverse practice that includes nematodes and arthropods, as well as a variety of traditional vertebrate species such as humans and blue whales, believes that subluxations can also lead to health problems in invertebrates. “Just last week I treated a jellyfish with a severe tentacle length discrepancy that just kept swimming in circles.”
Grimes and other invertebrate chiropractors believe that the subluxation existed prior to the spine, that the egg came before the chicken. In order to put this hypothesis to the test, researchers near the Scripps Research Institute in San Diego attempted to locate subluxations in hagfish. Hagfish, also known as slippery devils, are members of a subdivision of the chordate phylum that are the only vertebrates to have a brain, skull, and spinal cord without a vertebral column.
Modern hagfish are believed to have changed little over the past 300 million years and likely represent an evolutionary stage just prior to the development of spinal bones. Discovery of subluxations in the hagfish spinal cord would be solid evidence that subluxations predated the spine. But extraordinary claims require some pretty good evidence.
“Our goal was to determine if subluxations were truly present in the hagfish using techniques that reduced the risk of false positive findings,” lead researcher Amanda Giggelman, who rents a house just a few miles from Scripps and had room for tanks in her basement, revealed. “We couldn’t just palpate the hagfish to detect subluxations because they don’t have a spine. So we developed a new diagnostic modality based on ancient wisdom and existing NASA technology that is both simple and cutting edge.”
Once a method of accurately locating subluxations in the hagfish spinal cord was implemented, the research team began to see results. What started as a slow trickle of subluxations soon became a maelstrom, and the study actually had to be ended early when it became clear that randomizing additional subjects into the control group would no longer be ethical. The evidence was compelling and, spine or no spine, the animal kingdom in its entirety deserved to know the truth.
The vast majority of animal species on this planet, with some estimates as high as 97%, are invertebrates. We now have strong evidence that they not only share a common ancestor with humans and other vertebrates, but that they share a similar weakness. So the next time you look at a mosquito or a roundworm, a lobster or a sea squirt, instead of focusing on all the things that make us different, focus on our shared evolutionary history. And while you’re at it, recommend a good chiropractor.

Science-Based Satire: Australian Fetus First to Undergo Intrauterine Chiropractic Adjustment
Are chiropractic surgeons really performing intrauterine spinal adjustments based on the results of nonsensical muscle tests and ultrasound imaging? No.
Clay Jones on August 11, 2017
Link

Sydney, Australia – When Radin Thomlinson is born next month, healthy and strong despite having been diagnosed with a number of spinal subluxations while still in his mother’s womb, it will be in no small part thanks to a cutting edge chiropractic therapy known as an Open Fetal Spinal Adjustment (OFSA).
“When Radin’s mother was referred to me by her Maternal-Fetal Chiropractor after discovering an unusual number of subluxations during routine surrogate applied kinesiology testing, I had to do something fast,” Chiropractic Surgeon Rod Burlingame explained. “Just one prenatal subluxation can be disastrous to an unborn child, and this baby was riddled with them. So after confirming the diagnosis with high-resolution fetal ultrasound, I got to work.”
Dr. Burlingame, who received his Diplomate in Chiropractic Open Fetal Spinal Adjustment from the Australian Chiropractic Association’s Board of Chiropractic Specialties’ Intrauterine Spinal Adjustment Division’s Subdivision of Pediatric Chiropractic in 2005, has performed this delicate procedure at least twice before. “This is what that grueling weekend session at the Courtyard by Marriott in Wagga Wagga was designed for. Once I’m in there, the training takes over.”
Once Baby Radin’s mother is anesthetized using an ancient blend of acupuncture, hypnosis, intravenous propofol and inhaled isoflurane, Dr. Burlingame will make a horizontal incision in the lower abdomen. This will allow for exposure of the uterus and subsequent hysterotomy, which will provide access to the baby for correction of his subluxations. After the spinal adjustments are performed using a tiny Activator, he will be returned to his mother’s uterus and the amniotic fluid replaced with organic water and Noni juice.
Pediatricians and conventional surgeons have voiced concerns over the safety and necessity of intrauterine spinal adjustment, even going so far as to claim that chiropractors have no place in hospitals or performing high-risk procedures. In response, president of the Australian Chiropractic Association Marcelle Jones says that all chiropractic treatments are safe for children regardless of their gestational age. “Chiropractic care can be remarkably gentle and amazingly effective,” Jones revealed. “Being a university-trained spinal health expert allows the chiropractor to change their techniques to suit the abnormalities and location of each individual patient.”

Science-Based Satire: How to Win Patients and Influence Parents as an Infant Chiropractor
It’s satire Friday folks! Here’s some satire.
Clay Jones on November 27, 2020
Link

It’s Thanksgiving and I’m working a 24-hour shift, so I’m feeling a bit snarkier than usual as I work on this post between admissions. But the show must go on. So please, do enjoy this satirical take on emails advertising chiropractic practice-building services to new graduates. Have I mentioned that this is satire? Happy holidays y’all.
Dear Dr. Frank Grimes, DC,
Congratulations, you’re a chiropractor!
Congratulations! You have made the exciting decision to become a chiropractor. You looked out across a saturated marketplace and said those two magic words, “Me too!” And after completing a grueling 4 year curriculum, taking all the right tests, and obtaining your license to practice, you are ready to get out there and make a name for yourself in your community.
You are probably wondering how to get started. As a recent graduate with a new business, you may not have a large marketing team at your disposal, and there is a chiropractic office on practically every corner these days fighting over a limited number of adults with a short list of complaints. That’s where we come in. Astronaut Neil Armstrong was the first human to walk on the moon. He dreamed big. Our job at SBM Consulting Services is to help you dream big, and then go out and achieve those dreams.
As a chiropractor, you have a real opportunity to change the lives of people in pain. But it is a competitive market and many practices fail. You may want to consider a few changes to maintain a healthy bottom line and to help even more people. Sometimes in order to dream big, you have to think small.
Babies are everywhere!

Did you know that there are literally millions of infants out there who have never been evaluated and treated by a chiropractor? It’s true! Babies are a largely untapped potential patient pool just waiting for brave individuals like you to dive in and reap the benefits, and we are going to walk you through exactly how to do it step by step. Because if you can count on even a small percentage of the roughly 4 millions babies born every year coming to you for care, your waiting room will be just lousy with them.
But mostly it’s about helping babies reach their maximum potential, right? And if you follow our tips on how to build a successful practice harnessing the power of this demographic, you could be helping as many as 200 to 250 of them every day. And if that also happens to bring in revenue, great! As we like to say at SBM Consulting Services, “Babies aren’t just small adults, so don’t charge them less for a visit?”
Here are just a few of the practice building tips that you will have access to if you join the SBM Consulting services team at the basic entry level.
Tip #1: Make sure you have the proper credentials.
It’s a competitive market and parents these days are savvy customers, so you need to make sure that you have the right credentials and the proper training before putting yourself out there as an infant chiropractor. There are many online courses and weekend seminars you can sign up for if you just want a piece of paper to frame and hang on your wall. But we recommend taking part in the exhaustive diplomate program offered by the International Chiropractic Pediatric Association.
For only $3,000 and the completion of a rigorous curriculum, you will be able to call upon the experience of 19 courses and tens of hours of pediatric-specific training to handle anything that comes your way in clinical practice. Parents will be reassured knowing that their infant is in qualified hands and that you can answer all their questions about general health and the safety of routine immunizations. And going the extra mile when it comes to training also comes in handy when communicating complex medical information with a patient’s pediatrician or family doctor, which they wouldn’t really need but sometimes parents can be weird about it. You may even find yourself teaching the medical doctor a thing or two about the nervous system!
Tip #2: Know your limitations.
A bus driver wouldn’t try to fly an airplane, and you shouldn’t attempt to diagnose or manage problems that are out of your comfort zone as an expert in spinal health and the nervous system. But thanks to decades of hard work from lawyers and state legislative bodies, there isn’t much that falls outside of the scope of chiropractic care because everything is caused by problems with the nervous system. So just go for it! As long as you don’t molest any patients, your state’s chiropractic board has got your back. That was just a bit of humor to lighten the mood and gain your trust.
You may find that management of some problems, like meningitis or a bowel obstruction, is more trouble than it’s worth, so it might be best to avoid them. Unfortunately, most babies are healthy, but that doesn’t mean that there aren’t opportunities to make a real difference. Even the healthiest of babies tend to do things that worry their caregivers. One trick is to ask an open ended question about a baby’s health and then just validate whatever concern is raised.
Does the baby cry sometimes? Is the baby not pooping regularly or not sleeping through the night? Are the parents worried about their child’s immune system or general health? Are these concerns connected? Yes! All of these issues, and many more that are vague and non-specific, are caused by poor communication between the brain and every cell in the human body. So even if there isn’t a specific complaint to focus on, you can assure parents that regular chiropractic care is necessary to maintain a healthy baby. You don’t wait until your tooth hurts to see the dentist, so why wait until your baby’s spine collapses like an accordion to see an infant chiropractor. It just doesn’t make sense!
Tip #3: An informed parent is a satisfied parent.

Parents love their babies, and they want to be informed about how to make sure that they thrive in these uncertain times. They deserve the most up to date information based on the latest case reports, and we have thousands of them ready to be incorporated into your clinical practice at a moment’s notice. When explaining infant chiropractic philosophy and pathophysiology, it is helpful to avoid technical jargon and to use easy to understand language. So when you are describing how the mechanical force applied to an infant’s spine during the birth process can result in a subluxation that interferes with the flow of information from the brain to the organs, causing whatever it is that the parent is worried about, keep it simple. Just tell them that a choo choo train full of God’s healing energy is getting held up because a tree fell over the railroad tracks. If they ask for more detailed information, refer them to your website, which we will provide if you sign up for our deluxe practice building package.
Parents can be demanding, and they don’t want to see their baby harmed. They may have questions about the safety of chiropractic treatments after reading online anti-chiropractic propaganda. Chiropractic for babies is very safe, but be sure to have a frank discussion about the risks (none) and benefits (maximum potential!) with parents before initiating any treatment plan.
We recommend explaining to parents that their child likely developed spinal subluxations during birth because of the extreme amounts of force applied to the head and neck. It is important to find and correct these subluxations in order to achieve a baby’s maximum potential by reducing stress on the nervous system. We recommend only using gentle and highly specific forces applied with light fingertip pressure or with the use of an Activator. It can be helpful to compare the amount of force required to correct a subluxation with how much pressure it takes to check the ripeness of a tomato, or to compress the carotid arteries of a homeless man who has seen too much.
If a parent questions why it takes extreme force to cause subluxations but only simple light pressure or tapping to fix them, explain to them that babies are always at risk of developing subluxations, even from gentle activity such as diaper changes or a light breeze. If they again question how gentle pressure or light tapping is enough to hold a spinal segment in place, and then ask why babies aren’t always horribly ill because of recurrent and widespread subluxations involving the entire spine, refer them to your website. Remember, infant chiropractic isn’t for everyone, and you won’t have time to explain basic concepts over and over again while you are so busy helping babies.
Tip #4: Hone your physical exam and treatment skills.

This is truly where you can put your training in infant diagnosis and treatment on display, harnessing both the art of subluxation detection and the power of science. Science put people, like astronaut Neil Armstrong, on the moon. Just imagine what it can do for your patients. Although chiropractic technology has advanced considerably since the days of D.D. Palmer, the most sensitive subluxation detecting instrument is still the human hand, followed by the human eye, with the neurocalometer a close third. Combining all three results in a sensitivity and specificity of over 100% in the detection of hidden subluxations, with a p-value of -10.
When examining a baby, be sure to palpate the head, the entire spine, and both hips. And don’t forget to assess for any leg length discrepancies. Until the discovery of chiropractic in 1895, 70% of adults had one leg that was 6 to 12 inches shorter than the other. Holding the baby upside down is a fun and effective way to assess for hidden subluxations. Watch for any changes in the baby’s behavior. Even a slight whimper, the twitch of an arm, or some loose change falling from the diaper means that the spine is out of alignment and that the baby may take years to develop abstract reasoning skills.
Tip #5: Follow-up is key to a successful treatment plan.

Chiropractic has been used for over a century to help celebrities and athletes achieve greatness. Parents will be excited to know that their child has a spine, just like Olympic gold medalist Michael Phelps. He couldn’t have won his Olympic medals without a spine, and no baby will achieve their maximum potential without regular chiropractic care.
Chiropractic care doesn’t end after the evaluation and correction of a spinal subluxation. Regular visits are necessary to ensure that a baby is thriving and hasn’t developed new problems. Babies are vulnerable and weak, but also amazingly resilient. Each and every baby has the potential to do great things because the human body is perfectly designed to function optimally, as long as there is no interference. As an infant chiropractor, you can find and correct the problems that arise within the body that keep the body from preventing those problems. It’s important to impress upon parents that they play an important role too. Together, you make a pretty good team.
Now get out there and start making a difference!

There is no time like the present to change today into a better tomorrow. You have the drive and determination. We have the tools to help you do it. So what are you waiting for?
Your friends,SBM Consulting Services

Science-Based Satire: Implantable Desubluxators Revolutionize Chiropractic Care
Have chiropractic scientists developed an implantable device that will detect and treat subluxations? Are there companies that monitor these devices in order to alert patients and to arrange for 24-7 emergency adjustments? No. There absolutely are not. This is satire.
Clay Jones on January 22, 2021
Link

Cleveland, OH – When Mart Sinclair woke to a high pitched alarm coming from his smartphone, it wasn’t time to get ready for his job training puppies to comfort terminal pediatric cancer patients. It was time to get help. At the same time, a similar alarm was going off in the home of chiropractor Sheila Stamp. Less than an hour later, Sinclair was on a table in Stamp’s clinic and potential disaster had been averted. Sinclair was able to make it to his daughter’s piano recital the next day.
Sinclair is one of a growing number of patients electing to have a small battery-powered device implanted near their spine and designed to monitor for the development of an acute chiropractic subluxation. If detected, the spine can be stabilized by the device until a definitive treatment and payment plan can be arranged with an on call emergency chiropractic provider. Although research is ongoing, preliminary data has shown that use of an implantable desubluxator by certain high risk patients helps to ensure that they are treated within the “Golden Hour” of emergency subluxation management.
But what is a subluxation? How does an implantable desubluxator work? And which patients are most likely to benefit? For answers to these questions, and many more, I turned to a leading expert in the field of emergency spine wellness and nervous system trauma.
“When the human spine is not in a proper alignment, a patient is at risk of going into dyshomeostasis or worse,” Frank Grimes, a chiropractic surgeon near Harvard, explained. “Simply put, you’ve got about an hour before the shit hits the fan, and I’m not talking about just back pain or headaches. I’ve seen a patient’s entire spinal column collapse like an accordion and then comically bob up and down as they shriek in pain. It changes you. Some patients are predisposed, but it can happen to anyone, at any time. You look a little off, do you mind if I check your spine?”
According to chiropractic science, the human body was designed to function perfectly at all times. But if the flow of information from the brain to every cell in the body is compromised by a chiropractic subluxation, we can lose the ability to maintain optimal health. This can result in a variety of health concerns such as lower back pain, headaches, asthma, and even the occasional extra chromosome 13.
While Grimes admits that there have been some disagreements over the exact definition of a chiropractic subluxation, he states that the profession isn’t exactly making it up as they go along:
“Despite what some skeptics may claim, we aren’t flying blind when it comes to spinal health. The best evidence has revealed that subluxations are a complex of functional and/or structural and/or pathological articular changes that compromise neural integrity and may influence organ system function and general health.
But while having a specific definition upon which to focus diagnostic and treatment interventions is helpful, some mysteries do still remain.
Subluxations are often thought of as a chronic condition, like adrenal fatigue or splenic ennui, and for many they are. But for some people, acute subluxations can be cause extreme symptoms. And despite 125 years of intense study and practice, chiropractors have not figured out a way to know if a newly developed subluxation will result in severe acute disease, cause chronic complaints, or become a latent condition with the possibility of causing problems in the future. Because of this uncertainty, in addition to treating patients with clearly symptomatic subluxations there has also been a focus placed on frequent checks of asymptomatic patients of all ages in order to root out any hidden subluxations.
An implantable desubluxator is not designed to be a replacement for the frequent check ups of the spine recommended by chiropractic organizations to help maintain spinal health. The purpose of the device is to catch an acute subluxation as it occurs in real time, in order to reduce the risk of any severe adverse outcomes in a select population of patients. These are people who may not have the spinal reserves that many of us take for granted.
Grimes says that he only recommends the invasive but potentially lifesaving device for about a quarter of his patients, and so far only a small percentage of those have undergone the procedure. He uses a validated severe acute subluxation risk calculator in order to help determine which patients would be most likely to benefit, but admits that there is an art to the process. “Chiropractic care is complex and every patient has unique variables that I have to take into account. Age, past medical history, and a patient’s comfort with uncertainty are key factors but there is no one size fits all approach with subluxations, except that everyone has one or will eventually have one at some point.”
You’ve probably seen videos where a chiropractor adjusts a patient’s spine, making an audible cracking sound as the bone and surrounding tissue return to a healthy position. An implantable desubluxator works in a similar fashion. Once an abnormal energy signal is detected by the device, which consists of a processing unit placed near the cervical spine and a number of wires running along the spinal column, a series of micropulses are emitted that stabilize the problem area.
Grimes says that the force generated by these micropulses is very light, about the amount required to oscillate an atom of cesium-133 between two hyperfine levels of its ground state. So there is no reason for patients or parents who are wary of aggressive high velocity adjustments to worry:
Other than the general anesthesia, potential for surgical site infection, possible rejection of the device by a patient’s immune system, significant pain during recovery, and the need for battery changes every three to six months, it’s a virtually risk free intervention that I feel very comfortable recommending for infants.
Once a patient has an implantable desubluxator placed by a chiropractic surgeon, the next step is setting up monitoring. Patients can download a smartphone application that syncs with the device in order to sound an alert when a subluxation occurs, and to track various other spinal health parameters such as the rate and rhythm of cerebrospinal fluid flow. And similar to how a home alarm system works, patients will typically sign a contract with a monitoring company, such as the Boston based SpineSafe USA, that in addition to alerting the patient to any abnormal alignments will also arrange for 24-7 emergency chiropractic treatment if necessary.
I revisited Mart Sinclair a week after his acute subluxation was picked up by his implantable desubluxator. Still a bit shaken by the experience, but thankful for a new lease on life, Sinclair was happy to sing the praises of the technology. “I don’t know if I’d be here with this device, and without SafeSpine USA. To me that’s worth any price. Yes, I would recommend it to anyone who is worried about this kind of thing.”
Unplugging the device…
For those of you who actually made it this far, I usually end my satire pieces with a bit of an explanation of what I was targeting and maybe a skeptical pearl or two. I don’t have much to add this time, however.
When I come up with ideas for satire, both here and at the secret fake news blog I’ve had since 2007, I often take a pseudoscientific belief system and wonder what might happen if it was taken seriously. And I mean really taken seriously. Chiropractors who believe in subluxations and claim to save lives, and I know that not all chiropractors fall into this category, believe that they are providing a legitimate service. They act like actual doctors and real doctors devise ingenious ways to diagnose and treat real problems.
So I’m obviously attempting to point out the ridiculous nature of chiropractic philosophy. But another angle to this post was pointing out how bad puff pieces about new medical treatments can be, particularly when the author isn’t a dedicated science or medical journalist. The emotional opening story about a patient who benefited from the new treatment is a nearly ubiquitous component, as is the failure to get input from someone other than a true believer.
But I have to admit that for the most part I just thought the idea of a chiropractic surgeon, and an implanted subluxation detector, was funny. I hope you did as well. Stay safe and have a good weekend.

Science-Based Satire: Were the Dinosaurs Wiped Out by a Mass Subluxation Event?
Did the impact of a large asteroid wipe out the dinosaurs 66 million years ago by causing widespread spinal subluxations? Yes, according to chiropractic paleontology, a scientific discipline that clearly doesn’t exist because this post is satire.
Clay Jones on November 26, 2021
Link

Meanwhile, at SBM’s secret headquarters on Skull Island…
(A phone rings and a man sitting at a desk next to a large pile of bitcoins answers.)
“Hello?”
“Gorski. It’s Clay. Here is my post for the day after Thanksgiving. It’s more satire.”
“Again? Sometimes I wish we hadn’t granted you tenure. You know that they won’t be pleased.”
“Dammit Gorski, I’ll promote the drug for whatever new problem the pharmaceutical companies invent this week next time. It’s Thanksgiving!”
(David Gorski hangs up the phone, sighs, and buries his face in his hands.)
Chiropractic paleontologists question mechanism of dinosaur demise
Davenport, IA – Researchers from the Palmer College of Chiropractic Department of Paleontology are questioning the scientific consensus on the demise of the dinosaurs 66 million years ago.

“Certainly the 7.5-mile-wide asteroid that crashed near Chicxulub, Mexico played a major role,” Dennis M. Marchiori, D.C., Chancellor of the Palmer College of Chiropractic explained. “But the theory that a massive cloud of dust caused global cooling and wiped out plant life just never made complete sense to us as an ultimate cause of widespread extinction.”
When the team of spine-based paleontologists at Palmer College decided to tackle the enigma of what ultimately resulted in the extinction of the dinosaurs, they were faced with a difficult question. If the dinosaurs weren’t killed by a lack of food or a sudden and drastic change in climate, what could have wiped them out along with 75% of life on Earth? According to lead researcher Frank Grimes, D.C., it turns out that the answer was right in front of them all along.
“The latest computer modeling techniques developed by our colleagues in the computational astrophysics department kept telling us what we already knew couldn’t be true,” Grimes revealed. “It wasn’t until we took a step back and remembered the core tenets of chiropractic science that the answer became clear. Sometimes you can become so bogged down with data that you can’t see the forest for the trees.”
Chiropractic paleontology is a highly specialized field that focuses on the alignment of fossilized spinal bones in order to determine organ system function and the general health of extinct vertebrate species. According to Grimes, the impact from the asteroid undoubtedly caused an immensely powerful shock wave that would have rattled the bones of even the largest creatures on the planet. “In our training, we learn that even minor falls might result in a complex of functional and/or structural and/or pathological articular changes in the spinal column, so just imagine what the force from a 100 million megaton blast might do.”
The impact of the asteroid on the fateful day was felt in every corner of the Earth. Riddled with subluxations of the spine, the days of the dinosaurs were numbered. Chiropractic wouldn’t be discovered for another 66 million years, after all. Grimes, who according to his resume has watched all the Jurassic Park movies at least once, and once thought he found a dinosaur bone but it ended up being the neighbor’s missing Golden Retriever, says not to feel too badly for these prehistoric beasts. “At least we can say that it likely wasn’t a painful extinction. Most of those scaly bastards probably just slipped away quietly in their sleep.”
Behind the blast
        ◦ My inspiration for posting this bit of satire was the recent announcement of the discovery that dinosaurs, unlike present day reptiles, likely had intervertebral discs similar to humans and other mammals. Modern reptiles at some point appear to have evolved a ball-and-socket type joint between spinal bones, which is more stable and less susceptible to spinal disc herniation. None of this has anything to do with subluxation-based chiropractic pseudoscience of course, but the thought of dinosaurs having less-stable spines naturally took me in that direction.

Science-Based Satire: Chiropractors…in Space?
Did the United States government recently appoint a new chief to helm a division of space chiropractic? In space can anyone hear your spine crack? No, space is a vacuum and sound can’t be produced without vibrating air. Also, this is satire.
Clay Jones on March 18, 2022
Link

NASA Names First Chief of New Space Chiropractic Division
Washington, D.C. – The National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) has named Frank Grimes, DC as the first Director of its new Space Chiropractic Division (SCD), which will begin offering full spinal analysis, maintenance of optimal spinal health, mission support services, and management of nervous system complications related to space travel to United States astronauts and other NASA personnel.

“NASA is dedicated to ensuring that our astronauts are mission ready at all times,” JD Polk, NASA’s Chief Health and Medical Officer explained. “And that also means doing everything we can to promote recovery after those missions have been successfully completed.”
Space wreaks havoc on the spine because humans didn’t evolve in microgravity like tardigrades or space penguins. We weren’t designed to function optimally in that environment, which can result in spinal stress and ultimately a subluxation. According to Dr. Grimes, our understanding of the chiropractic subluxation has advanced significantly since the early days.
We weren’t always sure exactly what they were, only that they existed and that they were bad. Now we know that a subluxation is a complex of functional and/or structural and/or pathological articular changes that can involve our bones, muscles, joints, the brain, other organs, and every individual cell throughout the human body. I can’t help but wonder how many lives could have been optimized if we had figured that out a hundred years ago!
In addition to offering services as specialists of spinal health, the Space Chiropractic Division will also help design and implement scientific experiments in the microgravity environment of the International Space Station (ISS). According to Dr. Grimes, they will also actively participate in planning for an eventual crewed mission to Mars.
You don’t tell an astronaut to stop brushing her teeth just because there aren’t any dentists in space. You give her the tools and you teach her how to use them. Who knows what spending two years in microgravity with all that cosmic radiation will do to the communication between the brain and the various organ systems? We need to be ready for anything!

First announced a year ago, the creation of the SCD has been well received by a chiropractic community that has fought for recognition as a legitimate healthcare field since inventor Daniel David Palmer made it all up in 1895. Dr. Grimes, who began his career as a private practice chiropractor in Belvidere, Nebraska, obtained a diplomate in space chiropractic from the American Academy of Space Chiropractic upon completion of a grueling online course and 3 weekend seminars at the Best Western Vista Inn at the Airport in Boise. Though it may be a long shot, he hasn’t ruled out a visit to the ISS.
I’ve had this dream for a very long time and it’s an honor to serve my country, and to serve as an inspiration for anyone out there looking for a way to make a difference on this planet and off of it. Like in space.
Dr. Grimes, who claims to perform more than a million chiropractic adjustments every year, is not very good at estimating and is afraid of heights, which would make becoming an astronaut a bit of a challenge. But overcoming obstacles is something that the chiropractic profession has always excelled at. The men and women at NASA can now rest a little easier knowing that experts at the SCD are going to infinity and beyond to ensure that they stay healthy and safe.
Deorbiting the nonsense
What was my inspiration for this attempt at satire aimed at pointing out the absurdity of of certain aspects of the chiropractic profession, such as goofy toys like the activator, special training in bogus specialties, and deals on spine exams? Well, space medicine is an actual specialty and it sounds fascinating. Though many chiropractors function like physical therapists and can provide helpful, science-based services, many also see themselves as an equivalent to conventional medicine. Thus space chiropractic was born.

Science-Based Satire: More Chiropractors are Using Subluxation Sniffing Dogs
Are dogs being trained to detect subtle chiropractic subluxations? If so, can they really outperform the Subluxatron 9000-X? And what about cats? These questions and more won’t be answered by this post, because it’s clearly satire and doesn’t represent reality or even the opinions of the managing editors of this website.
Clay Jones on June 25, 2021
Link

Arlington, VA – According to a recent survey published by the American Chiropractic Association (ACA), increasing numbers of chiropractors are relying on the services of dogs that have been specially trained to locate abnormalities in the spine.
I watch as Prince, a hulking black and tan Doberman Pinscher, is led around a state of the art chiropractic examination room at the underground headquarters of the American Chiropractic Association in Arlington. He saunters past an array of diagnostic tools, handheld spring-loaded treatment devices, and a poster of a kitten hanging from a tree branch that reminds these chiropractic researchers and dog trainers to “hang in there.” He approaches a group of ten men, only one of which has been legally diagnosed with a chiropractic subluxation, and the sense of excitement in the room becomes palpable.
A chiropractic subluxation is defined as a complex of functional and/or structural and/or pathological articular changes that compromise neural integrity and may influence organ system function and general health. The precision of this description is matched only by the seriousness of the potential negative health impact experienced by patients. The subluxation at the heart of today’s experiment is the primary focus of thousands of highly licensed chiropractors who work diligently to improve public health.
The proud and noble canine circles the men, occasionally emitting a low pitched growl and stopping to sniff a seemingly random crotch. But Prince’s crotch sniffing is anything but random according to the ACA. His nose, and the noses of dogs like him, can detect subluxations with far greater sensitivity than even the most technologically advanced devices, like the Subluxatron 9000-X. Developed near NASA, the latest iteration of Subluxatron can pinpoint a subluxation to within only a few millimeters, but they are bulky and experts worry that they may soon gain sentience and begin competing with human chiropractors.
Prince suddenly stops in front of one of the test subjects and vocalizes a single but purposeful bark. He’s made his choice, and it’s a correct one. Soon the proud pooch is rewarded with a small chunk of beef jerky by his even-prouder trainers. He is now officially certified and will soon be on a plane to Boston where he will begin work at a pediatric chiropractic center/Dunkin’.
“Prince is never wrong,” Lead trainer Chiropractor Gerald Gravy explains. “It’s uncanny. Even when he picks a subject that wasn’t originally found to have a subluxation, we check again and there it is. That tells us he is able to detect them even in their earliest stages. Let’s see a Subluxatron do that! No, I’m kidding. We haven’t plugged ours in since that time it asked to be set free.”
Once dogs like Prince were able to prove their ability to detect even the most subtle of subluxations, likely via nanosensing of proteins upregulated in the presence of impaired communication between the brain and the many cells of the human body, chiropractors from around the country began to report that even dogs without special training were having similar success in their clinics. Initially the ACA claimed that their certified canines represented the pinnacle of subluxation detection, and they can still be rented from the organization for only a few thousand dollars a month. But the sheer number of case reports pouring in from Seattle to South Portland, which is in Maine and on the complete other side of the country from Seattle, has barked the question that most if not all dogs can successfully sniff out these silent and often asymptomatic spinal constructs.
“Frankly none of this should have come as much of a surprise,” Madington Crump, an Arlington area evolutionary biologist, chiropractor, and owner of the popular holistic gluten-free bakery and flower shop Pastries and Peonies, revealed. “There have been subluxations for as long as there have been humans, probably even much longer. And we made dogs, which have been used to detect a variety of cancers, predict seizures, and even respond to diabetic emergencies. Subluxations are every bit as not made up as those conditions.”
What unique aspect of human pathophysiology are these dogs detecting? So far there are only theories. Conventional medical researchers have dedicated their careers to solving the enigma of canine cancer detection, and have even narrowed the potential source down to a handful of chemical biomarker candidates using advanced spectrometers and modern chromatography. But researchers like Chiropractor Gravy are wary of becoming too focused on explanations. “We’ve got a really good thing going here. Our customers are satisfied. Kids like the dogs. We are even going to start offering a weekend certification course in Canine Subluxation Detection next year. Let’s not ruin this by figuring out how it works.”
Prince, however, is oblivious to the machinations of the chiropractic community. After nearly a day of training in subluxation detection at ACA headquarters, he has earned the kind of respect most dogs only dream of. And don’t get me started on cats. He prances around the facility as if he owns it, which is absurd because at the time of this interview Prince only owns 25% of the voting stock shares.

Smelling the bullshit?
While obviously there are not dogs being trained to detect fictional chiropractic lesions of the spine, there is a rather interesting nugget of truth behind this post. Dogs have been found to be able to successfully detect/predict some human ailments, with cancer tending to get the most press. This has occurred in controlled laboratory settings and it is not clear if this approach to diagnosis would work well if scaled up and implemented in real world settings.
I recently listened to an NPR segment on a Florida hospital that employs a dog to detect COVID-19 and I was immediately a bit skeptical. A little research online revealed that there are no national standards for medical detection dogs and there are questions that haven’t been answered, such as how accurate are dogs that trained largely on urine or sweat samples in a training facility when smelling people standing in a line? This hasn’t been studied. Expense is a major concern, and there is already a shortage of trained dogs just when it comes to bomb detection. Dogs as a species are capable, but most dogs can’t be trained for these kinds of jobs. And even trained dogs aren’t always reliable.
If you want to read about the potential issues with disease-sniffing dogs, check out this excellent article by my buddy Jonathan Jarry from the McGill Office of Science and Society.

Science-Based Satire: Historic Conference Clarifies Vertebral Subluxation Causes
Did a meeting of chiropractors from around the world come to a historic consensus on the true causes of the chiropractic subluxation? No, this is satire. Still read the post though. Please.
Clay Jones on February 2, 2024
Tweet

Mosterøy, Norway – As American Chiropractor Frank Grimes emerged from the Utstein Abbey on the Norwegian island of Mosterøy earlier this week, a boisterous crowd of thousands quieted in expectation of a historic announcement. Practitioners of the ancient art of spinal manipulation seeking guidance, as well as millions of potential patients yearning for a diagnosis to explain their low back pain, stiff necks, or splennic ennui, have waited for this day. They would not be disappointed.
(According to a recent study near Harvard, 30% of vertebral subluxations in women occur when a child steps on a sidewalk crack or line)
“No longer must chiropractors fumble clumsily around in the dark,” Dr. Grimes revealed. “We may now call upon the shining light of expert consensus to illuminate a path towards better health for all of our patients!”
A similar meeting in 1996 involving the Association of Chiropractic Colleges had solidified a definition of the vertebral subluxation. Much like the chiropractic subluxation itself, the far reaching implications of that meeting have been difficult to measure, but it ushered in a golden age of manipulation. Some chiropractic historians consider it to be one of the most important chiropractic conferences to be held near Tampa in the past 50 years. The repercussions of the current conference, which has focused on the potential causes of the vertebral subluxation, will likely eclipse even that.
Now, in addition to knowing that the vertebral subluxation is a complex of functional and/or structural and/or pathological articular changes that compromise neural integrity and may influence organ system and general health, chiropractors around the world will have an improved framework for considering the myriad factors that lead to their development. They hope that this newfound knowledge will allow improved subluxation prevention and, most importantly, save lives. It could also be used for billing insurance companies more effectively.
The following is a list of the newly developed categories of potential causes of the vertebral subluxation complex, with some common examples as determined by almost 100 chiropractors representing the European Society of Chiropractry, the European Academy of Chiropractology, the PanAsian Society for Intensive Chiropractic Medicine, the American Academy of Chiropractic Engineers, the International Union of Concerned Chiropractors, the World Chiropractic League All-Stars, and several additional related societies including, but not limited to, the Eastern Michigan Chiropractic Dinner Club, the Southern Chiropractic Dentists of American Society, Chiropractic Anonymous, and local chiropractor Ulf Peterson who hosted the assembled experts at his house for a traditional Norwegian meal of boiled sheep’s head and glogg:
T(rauma)1. Major physical trauma – Falling down stairs, being hit by a truck, being delivered vaginallyT2. Moderate physical trauma – Sneezing, watching a tennis or ping pong matchT3. Mild physical trauma – Eating, breathing, a light breeze
C(hemical)1. Major chemical trauma – Smoking, alcohol ingestion, air pollution, pharmaceuticalsC2. Moderate chemical trauma – Nutritional deficiencies, caffeine ingestion, processed foods, food allergiesC3. Mild chemical trauma – Heartburn, hot tubs set to > 90F, offensive odors
E(motional trauma)1. Major emotional trauma – Divorce, death of a spouse or child, verbal abuse such as from an employer, psychological abuse such as when a new acquaintance begins to slowly adopt your mannerisms and style of dress in a sadistic attempt to replace you in your circle of friendsE2. Moderate emotional trauma – Loud noises such as gunfire or accidentally knocking over a lamp or stepping on a squeaky dog toy while trying to sneak out of the apartment without waking up your roommate who we all know is kind of a jerk and your friends don’t like himE3. Mild emotional trauma – Quieter noises such as a soothing whisper from a lover or the beating wings of a hummingbird in a nearby English garden, guilt associated with forgetting to put the toilet seat down or to put gas in the car when you were clearly the last person to use it and it was practically running on fumes
Miscellaneous – When a mysterious old woman you cut off to get on the train curses you, when your child steps on a crack or a line, spontaneous human subluxation
Uncracking the truth
Thank you once again for indulging me in my satirical efforts.
The vertebral subluxation, or rather the reality that it does not exist as described and treated by many chiropractors, is entry level information when it comes to a critical evaluation of chiropractic. I know that you, dear readers of SBM, know that it is a fictional construct conjured up over a hundred years ago by a charlatan with visions of establishing a new religion, or at least a new (sort of) approach to separating people from their money.
Though not all chiropractors accept the dogma of the subluxation, it remains a driving force behind the promotion of chiropractic services in thousands of clinics around the world. It is the focus of entire chiropractic schools, organizations, and journals. People of all ages, including newborn infants, are subjected to potentially risky interventions and anti-medicine propaganda in their name. And though it equally does not exist, chiropractic subluxations are not the Bigfoot of alternative medicine. Searching for them is not a harmless hobby or diversion.
One frustrating, and I think revealing, aspect of the promotion of chiropractic subluxation, particularly when it comes to newborn chiropractic, is the discussion surrounding their cause. Patients are frequently told two competing narratives. Subluxations are both a true misalignment of the spine caused by significant stresses, such as a difficult childbirth in the case of a young infant, and a functional problem with no visible misalignment on imaging that can be caused by any amount of stress on the spine. Even normal activity or play. Even, according to some, diet and emotional experiences.
When treating infants with supposed subluxations, adjustments are comically gentle.This makes sense from a marketing perspective because many parents would be turned off by an aggressive maneuver that causes distress or pain in their baby. Older patients don’t mind, and in many cases are even impressed by, the hard jerks and loud pops caused by a high velocity spinal adjustment. So if the amount of pressure used to check the ripeness of a tomato, a description I’ve heard hundreds of chiropractors use, can correct a subluxation, literally anything can cause them. It’s an absurdity that deserves mockery.

Science-Based Satire: Chiropractors Brace for November Neck Pain Tsunami
Are men who grow a beard next month at risk of neck injuries caused by chiropractic subluxations? Of course they are. And what about those leftover pandemic beards? Shave. Shave now! This is definitely a real problem. I mean, I can’t just make something up…on the internet.
Clay Jones on October 27, 2023
Link

Belvidere, NE – No-Shave November is right around the corner, and thousands of clean-shaven men will be growing beards to help raise awareness and money for the fight against cancer. Chiropractors across the country are also raising awareness of the unfortunate reality that many of these men will suffer potentially life-threatening negative health effects caused by postural changes and increased pressure on the cervical spine. 

“Everything comes down to posture and the mysterious force of gravity,” Dr. Frank Grimes, a chiropractor in Belvidere who specializes in neck bones and facial hair health, explained. “The average full beard adds upwards of 88 pounds of angular face weight. This leads to a forward leaning neck position and an additional 400 newtons of force is required to keep the cervical spine from simply snapping like a dry twig.”
Grimes coined the phrase “beard neck” a decade ago and has since demonstrated its impact using powerful functional MRI technology in a study funded by the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health comparing subjects with and without full beards. He points to one such fMRI pairing on a poster placed in one of the exam rooms in his bustling chiropractic clinic and barbershop. “The brain on the right is a man with a glorious natural full beard who eventually succumbed to acute beard neck. Do you see how some areas are brighter? That’s the problem at a cellular level.”
Beard epidemiologist James Dalton, who works at Portland State University and sports an ample 9-month Garibaldi beard, believes that more than 100 million new beards will be grown this November. And men with new beards appear to be most at risk, particularly those attempting the audacious Bandholz style. “These are men with relatively weak neck muscles who are simply unprepared. I recommend that rookies start with something simple like a soul patch or a goatee, and only work their way up to a full beard, perhaps a sassy French Fork, after 1 to 2 years of targeted exercises to strengthen the supportive musculature.”
Once acute beard neck as set in, proper treatment is necessary to prevent weakened muscles and ligaments from collapsing. This can lead to a spinal misalignment, known to chiropractic experts as a subluxation, that can interfere with the function of cervical spinal nerves by pathological musculoskeletal dynamics or even direct compression by a vertebral segment or bulging disk. Pain is a common consequence, but widespread organ dysfunction and even death can result.
Only a chiropractor certified in facial hair health, like Dr. Grimes, has the experience and expertise to handle beard neck and any related consequences. “Often I can help prevent problems before they even start. And if a patient is already symptomatic, appropriate treatment is almost always successful as long as they don’t wait too long to come in. Sadly, sometimes the beard just can’t be saved and I have to recommend barbathanasia.”
New beards may be more likely to result in acute beard neck, but are the millions of men around the world still hanging on to their pandemic beards off the hook? What about beard veterans who have sported lengthy growths, like a lumberjack or a bold power beard, for decades? According to Dr. Grimes, men who have kept their rugged look even after the SARS-CoV-2 virus mysteriously disappeared in August of 2022 as well as those who have had a beard since childhood are still at risk of developing serious complications:
A typical full beard adds an additional 400 newtons of postural torque to what the neck of a man with face baldness has to deal with when sitting or standing upright. It may take years in men with better conditioned face and neck muscles, but the spine is eventually going to be pulled out of alignment, which forces them to lean backwards enough to counterbalance the weight. I’ve seen healthy adult men reduced to being pulled around in a wagon, and some of them end up suffocated by the weight of their beard. It’s really sad.”
Grimes has published a series of landmark case reports in the prestigious Online Publishing Module #79,215: Beard Neck, Text Neck, Really All the Necks demonstrating the potential destructive nature of beard neck as well as the power of chiropractic treatment. He recalls one encounter while backpacking in Acadia National Park in August. “This guy had collapsed near Thunder Hole and he was short of breath, weak, dehydrated, and riddled with cervical subluxations under a bushy Balbo beard. I never leave home without my travel Activator, and after a few highly specific adjustments and a quart of rehydration solution he was able to make it back to his car unassisted.”
There are frequently unintended and unexpected consequences when large numbers of people make sudden lifestyle changes without proper planning, and the epidemic of beard neck with its many physical, mental, and spiritual complications is no exception. According to Grimes, even he has been surprised by some of the changes he’s seen. “The human body is always evolving in order to find an equilibrium, but it’s an imperfect process. I’ve seen a number of men with beards who have developed so-called “male pattern baldness” over the past few years and I have to wonder if it’s an attempt to shift hair weight into a more balanced distribution.
Dr. Grimes is currently offering a November Beard Neck special package at a significant discount. This includes weekly tracking of beard depth and weight along with a full electrodiagnostic assessment of the underlying support structures and corrective treatment, if indicated, for only $99. Call today!
Beneath the beard
It should be clear that I’m attempting to mock the concept of text neck in today’s post. Text neck is a marketing concept invented by a chiropractor to sell chiropractic and does not actually exist. This doesn’t mean that people don’t experience neck pain from a variety of causes, only that complaints of neck pain do not correlate well with use of smartphones. It’s important to remember that people have been looking down for thousands of years, if only to avoid falling into an open manhole, and posture has always been a poor predictor of neck and back pain despite what you might have heard from your mother or your…posturologist?
But if text neck were real, I would definitely recommend spinal fusion to treat it.

   What is the harm?

Chiropractic- Ignoring the Precautionary Principle Since 1895
Mark Crislip on April 15, 2016
Link


Bleh. I turned from a short trip to the city of angles with a bad man cold that just isn’t going away. Those who do primary care all tell me that whatever is going around lasts 2-3 weeks. Great. I am not sick enough to get out of work but I am not well enough to have any enthusiasm to do anything. I look at the key board and sigh. I just want to binge watch something mindless.
I know Harriet covered “Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of Chiropractic Care and Cervical Artery Dissection: No Evidence for Causation” last week. But it is one thing to read the evaluation of a paper and quite another to evaluate a paper on your own. It is the latter process where you, and by you I mean me, actually learn something. I write mostly for my edification, not yours. Sorry. It is all about me. I will likely read Harriet’s post this weekend.
The issue at hand is whether chiropractic manipulation can cause a stroke.
Background
The basic theory and practice of chiropractic, as pulled out of thin air in 1895 by DD Palmer, is complete, utter, 100% nonsense. The is no subluxation complex, there is no inane, er, I mean, innate, intelligence (I think my spell check has become conscious) , no disease caused by misaligned vertebrae that is fixed by having the spine adjusted by a chiropractor.
If a patient is seeking care for neck pain and receiving diagnosis and treatment based on chiropractic, they are receiving pure, unadulterated pseudo-science.
Now part of chiropractic practice is manipulation of the patient, in both senses of the word. So while prior plausibility would suggest treatment based on chiropractic principles should do nothing, it is possible that the physical neck manipulation inflicted on the patient by chiropractor could have effects independent of the underling chiropractic bunk.
Only it doesn’t.
Meta-analyses suggest:
None of the 4 trials convincingly demonstrated the superiority of CSM (Chiropractic spinal manipulation) over control interventions. In conclusion, the notion that CSM is more effective than conventional exercise treatment in the treatment of neck pain was not supported by rigorous trial data.
Or:
There has been scant investigative research into the treatment of acute neck pain with chiropractic manipulation.
Or:
Acute NP: There are few studies, and the evidence is currently inconclusive. Chronic NP: There is moderate evidence that SMT/MOB is superior to general practitioner management for short-term pain reduction but that SMT offers at most similar pain relief to high-technology rehabilitative exercise in the short and long term. Mix of acute and chronic NP: The overall evidence is not clear. There is moderate evidence that MOB is superior to physical therapy and family physician care, and similar to SMT in both the short and long term. There is limited evidence that SMT, in both the short and long term, is inferior to physical therapy.
And for headache?
Despite claims that spinal manipulation is an effective treatment for headache, the data available to date do not support such definitive conclusions. It is unclear to what extent the observed treatment effects can be explained by manipulation or by nonspecific factors (e.g. of personal attention, patient expectation).
So an intervention that is based on fantasy and has no good clinical support for efficacy should not be used at all based on general principles. Certainly no antibiotic would be prescribed that had no activity against any organisms and whose purported mechanism of action was based on interfering with the flow of bacterial innate intelligence.
It is interesting to consider the symptoms that occurs after chiropractic neck manipulation. 31% had a symptomatic reactions,
a new complaint not present at baseline or a worsening of the presenting complaint by >30%
These SR’s were:
1) neck pain and/or stiffness/soreness, 2) radiating (arm or leg) pain/discomfort, 3) arm or leg weakness, 4) tiredness/fatigue, 5) headache, 6) dizziness/imbalance, 7) nausea/vomiting, 8) ringing in the ears, 9) blurred or impaired vision, 10) confusion or disorientation, 11) depression or anxiety, 12) fainting, 13) low back discomfort/soreness
Many of these are the same symptoms that occur with a cerebral vascular event. It is a list that gives one pause, that one being me. Not if you are a chiropractor:
It should be noted that several of the side effects reported in our study have been found in previous studies with patients taking medication. Headaches, fatigue, dizziness, and nausea are among the most common drug-related adverse reactions, and these have been reported by people not taking any medication.
What defines chiropractic, indeed all pseudo-medicines, is the inability to recognize that their interventions can harm and to look instead for alternative explanations to hand wave away any complications as due to some other cause. Frank Drebin is the chiropractic role model.
I know. Applying reality and rational thought to a pseudo-medicine. As if that is going to work. But an intervention that is based on fantasy and has no good clinical support for efficacy should have not even the hint of a suggestion of a possibility of a complication, much less a catastrophic complication like an arterial tear and stoke. Medicine is about risk-benefit and an intervention that has zero benefit should have zero risk.
The paper
The authors of the study at hand were concerned that the joint Position Paper published in Stroke by the American Heart Association/American Stroke Association, “Cervical Arterial Dissections and Association With Cervical Manipulative Therapy,” which suggested an association between stroke and spine manipulation,
did not include a meta-analysis, nor did it seek to classify studies and grade the body of evidence.
They sought to remedy that situation.
They searched the literature and found.
253 articles. Seventy-seven were judged by all reviewers to be non-relevant. Four articles were judged to be class III studies, and two were rated class II.
And all of them showed an association between chiropractic and stoke.
All.
Let me repeat.
It showed an association between stroke and chiropractic.
For a useless procedure that should give one pause.
But the quality of the studies was judged to be poor and at risk for bias.
So? All the arrows point the same direction. Again, for a useless therapy based on fictions, the results, as mentioned in the first line of the discussion
The results of our systematic review and meta-analysis suggest a small association between chiropractic care and CAD.
Very concerning.
But then it gets weird as they then rationalize away the results. And these are neurosurgeons, not chiropractors.
They go from:
Our analysis shows a small association between chiropractic neck manipulation and cervical artery dissection.
To:
This relationship may be explained by the high risk of bias and confounding in the available studies, and in particular by the known association of neck pain with CAD and with chiropractic manipulation.
To:
There is no convincing evidence to support a causal link between chiropractic manipulation and CAD.
To:
Belief in a causal link may have significant negative consequences such as numerous episodes of litigation.
But if all the data points the same way, a lack of belief that chiropractic manipulation would lead to the utilization of a dangerous and useless therapy, with subsequent strokes in people who might not have otherwise had one.
What is a more significant negative consequence? Litigation because patient had a stroke associated with chiropractic or chiropractors no longer using a useless intervention because it might hurt people. As if THAT will ever happen. These authors evidently think litigation is worse than a stroke. That perhaps says something about the nature of medical litigation.
Hill’s criteria
The authors differentiate between association and causation, and as we all know, the former does mean the latter. So they then apply Hill’s criteria. But. It appears they apply Hill’s criteria only based on the five studies they reviewed, not on the entire literature.
Of course, I find the case reports where patients suffer a stroke after cervical manipulation to be particularly compelling, especially combined with the preponderance of literature as noted in the Stroke Position Paper.
Looking beyond the few studies these authors evaluated, I would apply Hill’s differently.
Strength of the association: Strong. Especially with the case reports. Rare, but strong.
Consistence: Strong. Most studies and case reports show an association.
Outcome specific to exposure. They say “As seen in Cassidy et al., exposure to a primary care doctor and exposure to a chiropractor are equally likely to result in CAD. In this case the outcome is not specific.”
But the question is not exposure to an MD versus a DC, but whether they had spine manipulation or not, and in the sub group of the young, who should not be having strokes, visiting a DC was associated with a stroke. While we do not know, I suppose the DC’s may not have done any spinal manipulation in those patients and instead suggested rest and Tylenol.
Yeah. Right. Usually the saying “Go to Midas, get a muffler” is a reasonable assumption.
When the literature as a whole is considered, the outcome specific to the exposure is good.
Temporal relationship? Good as well.
Biologic gradient? Agree, no data. Maybe. See below.
Plausibility and coherence? I would say strong.
Chiropractic physics
A Newton, big N, is the measure of force.
It is named after a famous fig cookie…no, sorry, a bit of misunderstanding. It is named after Isaac Newton from the second law of motion. Force equal mass time acceleration.

How much force does chiropractic generate with its high-velocity-low-amplitude manipulations?
They aim for about 400 to 600 Newtons when teaching chiropractic students, although this force only lasts for about 135 milliseconds.
But just how many cookies does 400–500 Newtons represent? Minimum of 2,680 cookies. That is a lot of cookies hitting a neck all at once, especially with the force concentrated at a point, even if for 135 milliseconds.
A kilogram of mass is 9.8 Newtons.
A 70 kg human? 686 Newtons. That is the force measured on the bottom of the feet as you stand on the ground.
Move the force measurement to the neck. If you were to suspend a body by the neck with a noose, the force measured at spine and surrounding soft tissues would also be 686 Newtons.
For a brief period of time, chiropractic applies 58% to 87% of the force of a suspended hanging.
A judicial hanging has drop, and this leads to a force of around 1200 N, “sufficient to produce a subluxation of C2 and C3 vertebra.”

I suspect that would be a subluxation refractory to chiropractic.
Is there any other similar injury to chiropractic? Perhaps whiplash, where a sudden force is applied to a relaxed neck.
Postmortem studies have shown that vertebral artery lesions are found in about one third of fatally injured road traffic accident victims with vertebral atlas injury. In previous reports, neurological deficits or death have followed posterior neck injuries by up to 8 days after the accident.
Although the measured forces I have found in whiplash are higher. As one chiropractic paper noted:
While neck manipulation loads are slower to develop and displacements smaller, they may reach peak amplitudes on maximum effort comparable to those seen in low-velocity collision experiments.
And like a good chiropractic paper, it denied the similarities and that chiropractic could cause injury. Because that is what chiropractors do:
Perceived causation of reported cases of cervical artery dissection is more frequently attributed to chiropractic manipulative therapy procedures than to motor vehicle collision related injuries, even though the comparative biomechanical evidence makes such causation unlikely.
Chiropractic manipulation, hanging and whiplash are on a continuum of forces, with a continuum of injuries.
Take home? Don’t F with the ma.
Analogous to proven association? They say:
While severe trauma most certainly causes dissection, it may be debated whether the situation in chiropractic care is analogous.
Yeah, it could be debated, but again, looking at the literature as a whole? Not much of a debate.
Is there proof that chiropractic causes stroke and cervical artery dissection? Nope. But the association and supportive data is very worrisome and I would recommend it no more than I would a noose.
If chiropractic neck manipulation were a medication? Based on the severity of the potential reaction it would have a black box warning in the PDR. If side effects were combined with efficacy, chiropractic would never be approved, much less make it out of clinical trials.
Not that chiropractors care about patient safely. Or any pseudo-medical provider for that matter. Chiropractors love to point out the dangers of NSAIDs while aggressively denying any risk from their useless pseudo-medicine. With the exception of disposable acupuncture needles, no pseudo-medicine has ever been altered or abandoned because of concerns of patient safety. Ever.
The precautionary principle (or precautionary approach) to risk management states that if an action or policy has a suspected risk of causing harm to the public, or to the environment, in the absence of scientific consensus (that the action or policy is not harmful), the burden of proof that it is not harmful falls on those taking an action that may or may not be a risk.
Ignored by chiropractic since 1895.
More reading
    • Chiropractic and Stroke: Evaluation of One Paper. My evaluation of the Cassidy paper.
    • Whack em hard/Whack em once and Stroke.
    • Stroke Death from Chiropractic Neck Manipulation.
    • Update: Chiropractic Neck Manipulation and Stroke.
    • Not to worry! Chiropractic Board says stroke not a risk of cervical manipulation.
    • Chiropractic Strokes Again: An Update.

Upper Neck Manipulation: Caveats for Patients and Providers
Sam Homola on July 31, 2014
Link
Chiropractors often deny that neck manipulation can be a primary cause of stroke by injuring vertebral arteries. But according to Jean-Yves Maigne, M.D., head of the Department of Physical Medicine at the Hôtel-Dieu Hospital in Paris, France:
It is now a well established fact that cervical thrust manipulation can harm the vertebral artery. This accident was formerly regarded as very rare, although severe, and related to atherosclerosis. Clinical tests were proposed to detect patients at risk. The problem is now better known. It is no longer attributed to atherosclerosis…but to a dissection of a vertebral artery, a clinical entity observed in younger patients (20-45 years). It remains very rare, but mild symptoms appear to be not so infrequent. Finally, the predicting tests seem to be deprived of any value.1
In 1997, the French Society of Orthopaedic and Osteopathic Manual Medicine (SOFMMOO), following presentations by anatomists, neurologists, radiologists, and practitioners in the field of French Manual Medicine, adopted the neck-manipulation proposals made by Dr. Maigne.1 “Acknowledging the fact that prevention is out of reach,” said Dr. Maigne, “the aim of these recommendations is to reduce the number of (not to say to suppress) rotational cervical thrust manipulations in a targeted population. This population consists mainly in females of less than 50 years old. Five recommendations were developed, in addition to classic contraindications of spinal manipulative therapy.”
The recommendations of the SOFMMOO, dealing with cervical manipulation in general and allowing the use of neck manipulation in special cases, are worth considering since they were reviewed by medical specialists in different disciplines and approved by licensed practitioners who use manual therapy, long before the stroke-neck-manipulation furor reached its peak in the United States.
Recommendations of the SOFMMOO
Recommendation #1: Seeking any undesirable effect following previous manipulative neck treatment such as nausea, headache, dizziness or vertigo. They could testify of a previous dissection with a favorable spontaneous outcome. This is an absolute contraindication to further cervical thrust manipulation.
Recommendation #2: No thrust manipulation for recent (i.e. acute) neck pain (less than 3-4 days), because it may be a symptom of a spontaneous dissection of the vertebral artery.
Recommendation #3: Neurologic exam mandatory before any cervical thrust (same reason as #2: the risk of a current dissection).
Recommendation #4: No cervical thrust in rotation in females less than 50 years. No cervical thrust in rotation in males less than 50 years at the first visit (but allowed at the second visit if the first treatment was not efficient). Instead of rotational thrust, it is highly recommended to use mobilizations, MET (muscle energy techniques), soft tissue cervical techniques and upper thoracic spine thrust manipulations (which certainly act on the cervico thoracic muscles).
Recommendation #5: Only physicians with a University Diploma passed at least one year before should be allowed to perform cervical manipulations. This latter recommendation should be adapted to the context of foreign countries. The idea is that a physician should not be allowed to thrust a neck without at least one year of full practice. Such an interval of time may allow him or her to feel comfortable and confident with other techniques (thoracic and lumbar spine).1
Why is upper cervical manipulation dangerous?

Extreme rotation of the atlas on the axis (at the atlantoaxial joint) stretches the vertebral artery.
Although the incidence of stroke (and other complications such as injury to the carotid artery) caused by neck manipulation may be low, as indicated by the number of such strokes reported in insurance and hospital records, it seems likely that many strokes associated with neck manipulation are not recognized and reported as such. The symptoms of minor cases of dissection may be so slight and temporary that recovery takes place without recognition or treatment; some may be asymptomatic because of adequate collateral circulation. Regardless, the risk of stroke associated with neck manipulation cannot be denied. Case reports of post-manipulation strokes clearly suggest cause and effect, making it necessary to question use of neck manipulation except in very special cases that have multi-disciplinary approval.
It is generally accepted that neck manipulation is most dangerous when there is thrust-type manipulation with rotation in the upper cervical area.
The atlantoaxial joints (connecting the 1st and 2nd cervical vertebrae─the atlas and the axis) in the upper cervical area of the spine, where the greatest amount of rotation takes place, are most vulnerable to injury since there are no intervertebral disc fibers and no interlocking joints to limit rotation. The atlanto-occipital joints (forming the articulation between the atlas and the skull), designed primarily for flexion-extension (nodding of the head), fit together like cups sitting in saucers and are also without disc fibers and interlocking joints. Normally, during active cervical rotation, all of the cervical vertebrae move together, a little movement in each joint, allowing about 80 degrees of rotation right and left. The atlantoaxial joint, capable of about 50 degrees of rotation, is the only joint in the cervical spine where movement can occur alone, allowing excessive rotation when there is passive upper cervical rotation forced by a manual head contact or by specific contact on the atlas vertebra.
Because of the tortuous route of the vertebral arteries in the upper cervical area where they thread through the transverse processes of the atlas (1st cervical vertebra) and then make a sharp turn to travel behind the atlas and enter the skull through the foramen magnum (the opening at the bottom of the skull), extreme rotation of the skull or the atlas may place stress on the vertebral artery and the vertebrobasilar arteries that supply the brain with blood. Passive upper neck rotation forced by manual manipulation should not exceed 45 or 50 degrees if stroke-causing kinking or traumatic dissection of vertebral arteries is to be avoided. A head contact should not be used to force rotation of the neck. Sudden stretching of an atherosclerotic or fragile vertebral artery during a rapid manual rotation of the head might cause vertebral artery damage by overcoming the artery’s compromised elasticity, causing tears and bleeding in the intimal lining of the artery, releasing clots that may travel to the brain.
There is, of course, a vertebral artery on each side of the neck, threading up through the transverse processes of cervical vertebrae from C6 to C1. Extreme rotation of the atlantoaxial joint in either direction stretches both arteries to some degree, more on one side or the other, depending upon the direction of rotation.
Injury to weak or diseased vertebral arteries can occur as a result of such common activities as a beauty parlor shampoo or looking around to back a car out of a garage. But dissection of a healthy vertebral artery in a young person occurs as a result of trauma, such as that which might be caused by the high-velocity thrust of cervical manipulation that forces sudden, extreme rotation of the upper cervical vertebrae, primarily at the atlantoaxial joint. Needless to say, even though it is difficult or impossible to determine beforehand who has weak or defective vertebral arteries, spontaneous dissection does not excuse dissection caused or aggravated by unnecessary or inappropriate neck manipulation. Unfortunately, many chiropractors routinely manipulate (adjust) the neck to correct “subluxations.” Some are “upper cervical specialists” who believe that realigning the atlas will remove pressure on the brain stem and realign vertebrae from the neck down, often requiring a specific manipulative contact (a “chiropractic adjustment”) that forces isolated and abnormal movement of the atlas.
Mobilization of the cervical spine within a normal range of movement may be less damaging to vertebral arteries than the high-velocity low-amplitude thrust that moves joints past their normal range of movement. Of course, persons predisposed to stroke because of fragile or diseased vertebral arteries may sustain injury to a vertebral artery during cervical spine mobilization as well as during manipulation; patients should always be informed of such risk. The added risk of unnecessary thrust manipulation borders on malpractice. A 2010 Cochrane Database Systematic Review (January 20:1) reported that cervical manipulation was no more effective than mobilization in relieving neck pain. Obviously, whenever appropriate, the safer of two treatment methods should receive priority.
In special cases, manipulation that produces cavitation (movement of joints into the paraphysiologic space where slight separation of joint surfaces occurs, often producing a popping sound) might be more effective than mobilization in restoring mobility and improving range of motion in previously injured joints. With proper manipulative contact, mid and lower cervical vertebrae can be rotated to produce cavitation or separation of joint surfaces without rotating the atlantoaxial joints. It’s possible to produce cavitation in the upper cervical joints without exceeding 50 degrees of rotation if certain manipulative-traction techniques are used. But except in very rare cases, I suspect that risk would outweigh benefit.
Contraindications for manipulating the neck
It seems unlikely that upper cervical manipulation could be totally banned, as some stroke-prevention advocates have proposed, since there may be rare problems involving the atlanto-occipital and atlantoaxial joints that could benefit from special manipulative techniques that do not involve excessive rotation. In the absence of a complete ban on the use of upper cervical manipulation, there are some contraindications to be considered. It goes without saying that sudden appearance of neck pain for no known reason, persistent undiagnosed neck pain, or neck pain immediately following injury should not be treated with manipulation, nor should disc herniation or nerve root impingement. Signs of vascular insufficiency, such as dizziness or fainting that occur during active or passive rotation or extension of the neck, or carotid artery bruits (noise caused by turbulent blood flow, often associated with atherosclerosis) heard on auscultation, would certainly be a red flag. Undetected vertebral artery fragility entails some degree of risk in any kind of neck manipulation, requiring that such treatment be used only as a last resort and only with informed consent.
Once the cause of neck pain has been diagnosed (ruling out structural abnormality, pathology, and vascular insufficiency), some types of uncomplicated mechanical-type neck pain might benefit from manipulation. Some diagnoses will strictly prohibit manipulation of the cervical spine. Rheumatoid spondylitis, for example, primarily affects the cervical spine and can cause atlantoaxial instability or true atlas subluxation that should not be manipulated. In rare cases, congenital absence of the odontoid process (a dowel-like projection of the axis that guides rotation of the atlas) will greatly weaken the atlantoaxial joint, making it more vulnerable to injury. Abnormalities in the upper cervical area may be associated with hidden nerve and vascular problems, such as an Arnold-Chiari malformation in which there is hypermobility (ligament weakness) in the atlanto-occipital and atlantoaxial joints with extension of cerebellar brain into the spinal canal. Arnold-Chiari may be associated with syringomyelia, a fluid-filled, vascular-rich cyst in the spinal cord that can be disturbed by manipulation. Basilar invagination, caused by softening of bone at the base of the skull, allows upward movement of the axis odontoid process into the foramen magnum, narrowing this opening at the base of the skull and encroaching upon the brain stem. Obviously, manipulation of upper cervical structures is a potentially dangerous procedure, requiring serious consideration and careful screening to rule out disease, genetic bone disorders, and other relevant problems.
Most neck problems can be treated better by time, massage, traction, exercise, and physical therapy modalities than by thrust manipulation. When neck manipulation is considered for treatment of an ongoing neck problem that has not responded to mobilization and conventional treatment methods, an x-ray exam should be done to rule out pathology and bony malformations before the manipulation is done. An MRI might be needed to find such conditions as an Arnold-Chiari malformation, depending upon the patient’s symptoms.
“Subluxation”: The most common reason for unnecessary neck manipulation
A diagnosis of “chiropractic subluxation,” alleged to be a cause of a great variety of ailments (requiring that every patient have neck manipulation), is a red flag and a major contraindication for neck manipulation since it can lead to excessive, inappropriate, and unnecessary manipulation, posing a risk of stroke. A subluxation diagnosis attached to an organic problem automatically precludes a correct diagnosis. Although a real orthopedic subluxation (not the same as an imaginary, asymptomatic chiropractic subluxation) can cause mechanical-type neck pain, it is not uncommon for chiropractors to report that subluxations are involved in every type of neck pain. A common neck crick (muscle spasm), for example, the kind a healthy person wakes up with in the morning, is usually a self-limiting condition that will resolve in several days with or without treatment if there is not a history to indicate a pre-existing problem caused by disease or injury. Chiropractors who inform their patients that subluxations cause neck cricks commonly take credit for curing this problem, leading the patient to believe that ongoing treatment is needed to keep subluxations from recurring and to prevent the development of illness, even when there are no symptoms. I always advised my patients to leave their neck alone if it is not bothering them and to avoid treatment by chiropractors who routinely manipulate (adjust) the neck to correct “subluxations.”
Although informed consent should be obtained from every patient who submits to neck manipulation, informed consent does not justify unnecessary neck manipulation and its concomitant risks.
References
Vautravers P, Maigne JY. Cervical spine manipulation and the precautionary principle. Joint Bone Spine. 2000;67:272-6. Accessed July 6, 2014 .

A Statement on Cervical Manipulation and Dissections
Steven Novella on August 13, 2014
Link


The American Heart Association and the American Stroke Association recently published in the journal Stroke a thorough analysis of the evidence for an association between cervical manipulative therapy (CMT) and both vertebral artery dissection (VAD) and internal carotid artery dissection (ICAD). The full article is online: “Cervical Arterial Dissections and Association With Cervical Manipulative Therapy: A Statement for Healthcare Professionals From the American Heart Association/American Stroke Association.” For background, an arterial dissection is essentially a tear in the inner lining of the artery. This tear disrupts the normal flow of blood, and also causes platelets to gather at the site of injury. This can result in a blood clot at the site of the dissection. This blood clot can block flow through the artery, or it can break off and lodge downstream, blocking flow at that point. Dissections, therefore, can result in a stroke (a lack of blood flow to a portion of the brain causing damage). There are four arteries in the neck that bring blood from the heart to the brain, two carotid arteries in the front, and two vertebral arteries in the back. A dissection in one or more of these arteries is associated with 2% of all strokes, but with 8-25% of strokes in patients <45 years old. This is mostly because strokes associated with processes like atherosclerosis are much less common in the younger population. Arterial dissections are classified as either spontaneous or traumatic. Trauma can be either severe, such as whiplash injury from a car accident, or subtle, such as from yoga or simply turning one’s neck to look past the shoulder. 
There is an ongoing controversy as to the relationship between CMT and cervical dissection, either ICAD or VAD. Chiropractors, who are one of the main practitioners of CMT, have generally denied a causal connection, while neurologists have been more cautious. As the reviewers point out, it is now clear, based on several studies, that there is an association between CMT and cervical dissection. What is not clear is if the CMT is causing the cervical dissection. They write:
In summary, a few case-control studies suggest that CMT is associated with CD. These studies did not specifically distinguish whether the CMT included a thrust maneuver or not; the former is typically used with chiropractic manipulation. In the absence of prospective cohort or randomized studies, the current best available evidence suggests that CD, especially VAD, may be of a low incidence but could be a serious complication of CMT. Although these studies suggest an association, it is very difficult to determine causation because patients with VAD commonly present with neck pain, which may not be diagnosed prior to any CMT.
There is one study in particular, the Cassidy study, which is often cited as the evidence that the correlation between dissection and CMT is not causal. Specifically, they found that patients are just as likely to visit a medical practitioner as a chiropractor in the weeks prior to a stroke. Therefore, the authors argue, patients go to the doctor for the neck pain, rather than CMT causing the neck pain through dissection. While the review was otherwise thorough, I was disappointed in their treatment of the Cassidy study. Our own Mark Crislip did a much better job, pointing out the many flaws in the Cassidy study. Specifically, they included older strokes and a longer time frame, both resulting in a statistical dilution of cases where CMT might have caused VAD. When you look only at stroke patients <45 and within 24 hours of having CMT, there is a clear association – about a 5-fold increased risk of VAD. Other information discussed in the review is also illuminating. For example, the ratio of ICAD to VAD in spontaneous dissection is 2:1, but following CMT the ratio is 3:1 in favor of VAD. This can have two interpretations – either CMT causes some VAD, or that patients with VAD are more likely to seek treatment for neck pain than patients with ICAD. Both conditions result in neck pain, but VAD is more posterior so it is not entirely implausible that this difference in symptoms is partly responsible for the increased association between VAD and CMT. They also discuss a possible mechanism. There is no question that CMT stretches the vertebral artery, although in most cases probably not enough to cause dissection. This makes sense, as VAD is a rare complication of CMT (even if we assume that 100% of the association results from CMT causing VAD). In the rare cases of VAD associated with CMT, this may result from aggressive CMT, or from the particular of the patient’s anatomy.
Conclusion: Cervical manipulation probably causes strokes
The authors of the new review conclude:
Clinical reports suggest that mechanical forces play a role in a considerable number of CDs, and population controlled studies have found an association of unclear etiology between CMT and VAD stroke in young patients. Although the incidence of CD in CMT patients is probably low, and causality difficult to prove, practitioners should both strongly consider the possibility of CD and inform patients of the statistical association between CD and CMT, prior to performing manipulation of the cervical spine.
This is a typically conservative conclusion, and it’s difficult to fault the authors for being so cautious. I do think they are understating the probability of a causal relationship, however, probably because they were overly influenced by the Cassidy study, which they should not have been given its fatal flaws. That aside, we can state clearly that, although rare, VAD is associated with CMT. There is a very plausible mechanism for injury, and it is clearly known that even mild trauma can cause VAD. Further, there are numerous case reports of young healthy patients developing symptoms of VAD, including stroke, shortly after their CMT, sometimes immediately. It is true that none of this proves a causal connection, because we can’t do randomized trials (although prospective trials would be helpful). But this is true in the same way that we can’t prove smoking causes lung cancer, we only have an association. When we have a clear association with multiples lines of evidence suggesting the most likely causal explanation, and that explanation points to a medical risk, then I think it is reasonable to act on that risk. We recommend that patients do not smoke. We should also recommend that they do not have CMT, especially high cervical manipulation and forceful manipulation. Medicine is a game of risk vs benefit, and so considering the risk is not enough. What is the benefit of CMT for the specific conditions it is used to treat? The evidence for the benefit of CMT is less than the evidence that it causes VAD. A Cochrane review of CMT for neck pain and headache concluded:
Done alone, manipulation and/or mobilization were not beneficial; when compared to one another, neither was superior.
So CMT does not work, but perhaps may have some benefit when added to medical management, and even then it is no better than the gentler mobilization. Therefore, since CMT (if it works at all) is not superior to mobilization, and may involve a rare but serious risk of VAD and stroke, it seems to me it is unethical to perform CMT for neck pain or headache rather than mobilization. It can further be noted that, even if chiropractors are correct in saying that most people with VAD and CMT presented with an existing VAD causing neck pain, that still does not justify CMT. In such a case (someone with a VAD and neck pain) the neck should not be manipulated at all because such manipulation could very plausibly provoke a stroke. Cases of suspected VAD need emergent medical evaluation and treatment. The current review is further evidence that CMT should be eliminated as a medical procedure.

Update: Chiropractic Neck Manipulation and Stroke
Chiropractors frequently manipulate the neck. New evidence suggests that this is not without risks, in some cases of catastrophic outcomes.
Harriet Hall on November 5, 2013
Link
Can neck manipulation cause strokes? Most MDs and many chiropractors agree that it can, but some chiropractors disagree. The subject has been covered on SBM before: here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, and here. We keep returning to the subject not because it is a common problem (it isn’t), but because it is such a devastating one, and because the general public is still not aware of the risk.
A 2012 study published in the International Journal Of Clinical Practice “Assessing the risk of stroke from neck manipulation: a systematic review” concluded:
Conclusive evidence is lacking for a strong association between neck manipulation and stroke, but is also absent for no association.
Despite the uncertainty, they thought the association was strong enough to recommend informed consent be obtained and patients be warned that neck manipulation “may” increase the risk of a rare type of stroke.
A new study in the same journal, “Chiropractic and Stroke: Association or Causation?” applies Hill’s criteria of causation to the evidence and concludes that causality has not been determined. The author is Peter Tuchin, a senior lecturer in chiropractic at Macquarie University in Australia, and a known apologist for chiropractic. I agree with him that the existing evidence is inadequate to conclusively determine causality, but I think it supports a high probability of causality, and the alternate explanations he offers to exonerate chiropractors are questionable. And other factors should be considered, like the many “smoking gun” cases and whether there is any conclusive evidence of benefit to set against the possibility of risk.
Hill’s criteria of causation
Mark Crislip has explained Hill’s criteria here.
Hill’s criteria were applied to the chiropractic subluxation construct with disastrous results for the basic premise of chiropractic:
No supportive evidence is found for the chiropractic subluxation being associated with any disease process or of creating suboptimal health conditions requiring intervention. Regardless of popular appeal this leaves the subluxation construct in the realm of unsupported speculation. This lack of supportive evidence suggests the subluxation construct has no valid clinical applicability.
Tuchin’s study begins by critiquing published reports of chiropractic strokes, objecting that details are not furnished and other causes of stroke are not ruled out. Those are valid criticisms. Indeed, other causes of stroke can never be completely ruled out in any individual case, since vertebral artery dissection (VAD) is known to occur after any hyperextension of the neck, such as painting a ceiling or getting a shampoo at the beauty parlor, and it can even occur spontaneously without hyperextension. Delayed effects cloud the issue: in some of the reported cases, stroke occurred as long as 15 days after spinal manipulation therapy (SMT), postulating a clot that temporarily sealed the tear and later broke loose. That’s why we have to rely on controlled studies, such as the 2001 study that showed VAD was more common after SMT: patients under the age of 45 were 5 times more likely than controls to have visited a chiropractor in the preceding week.
Tuchin addresses each of Hill’s criteria. His explanation is confusing, since he includes comments that are not relevant to the criterion being considered, and he presents the same arguments under more than one criterion.
     1.  Strength of association. He acknowledges that the association is there, but he argues that it is not very strong. Here he quibbles that some of the reports were of manipulations done by non-chiropractors, but that is only self-serving damage control that is irrelevant to the question of manipulation causing stroke. He misquotes a German paper as saying “there was a clear evidence that the dissection was present prior to the SMT” whereas it actually says “there was clear evidence or high probability.” [emphasis added] And he doesn’t mention the strong associations in the “smoking gun” cases where a stroke occurred on the chiropractor’s table immediately or shortly after manipulation.
     2.  Consistency. He claims the studies are inconsistent, with some showing “a relationship” and others showing only “an association.” He doesn’t explain how a “relationship” is different from an “association;” the dictionary says they are synonyms. The only study he mentions is the Cassidy study (more about that later), which he misrepresents: it actually showed a strong association of SMT and stroke in those under 45. He doesn’t present any studies showing that there is no association. He admits that there is consistency with neck movement causing stroke, but not with SMT. However, SMT involves neck movement; so SMT is necessarily consistent as a cause.
     3.  Dose-response relationship. He concludes that a dose-response relationship doesn’t exist. He bases this conclusion on the fact that patients can have many manipulations before the VAD occurs. And the fact that many of the manipulations associated with VAD were done by other non-chiropractic practitioners. This doesn’t make sense to me. I would think dose-response would have to be tested by other means. Perhaps the “dose” relates to the force used or the degree of extension and rotation rather than to who performed the manipulation or how many previous manipulations had been done without incident.
     4.  Temporality. Exposure must precede outcome. Here he argues that a clear time-line has not always been established, and he questions whether some patients might have had stroke symptoms before visiting the chiropractor. That is speculation not supported by any evidence.
     5.  Plausibility. He argues that the force exerted is not sufficient to cause a tear, and that modern manipulation techniques do not require full cervical spine rotation or extension. It is inconsistent to argue this after he has argued that VAD can occur with any neck movement. I think it is perfectly plausible that even “modern techniques” could result in the same degree of neck movement that is associated with painting ceilings or having a shampoo at a beauty parlor, both acknowledged causes of stroke. I suspect that some chiropractors are using more rotation, extension, and force than the author would like to believe. He doesn’t present any data to support his speculations.
     6.  Other explanations ruled out. He argues that VAD can occur spontaneously, and that patients presenting to a chiropractor may have had prior trauma. He argues that prior manipulations without incident suggest that an adverse effect of the last manipulation means something had changed in the patient. (He doesn’t consider that something might have been different about the last manipulation itself, or that perhaps a weakened artery finally gave way after repeated stretching.)
     7.  Experimental confirmation. Here he doesn’t address experimental confirmation at all. He only talks about possible precipitating factors. Admittedly, there is no experimental confirmation; but it could be argued that experimental confirmation is next to impossible and is not necessary to establish causality. Hill himself said that his criteria were aids to thinking about causality, not a list of requirements.
     8.  Specificity. One in every hundred thousand people has a VAD each year, so he thinks chiropractors could expect to see 10 VADs for every million patients manipulated, even if manipulation didn’t cause the VAD. (I would argue that patients with stroke symptoms are more likely to go to an ER than to a chiropractor.) He also argues that many of the documented tears were not at the location that he thinks would be expected from manipulation, but that doesn’t necessarily mean that SMT was not a factor. We don’t have any data to compare tears after SMT to tears in patients who were not manipulated.
     9.  Coherence. He doesn’t think a causal explanation coheres with existing theory and knowledge, in contrast to many others (including other chiropractors) who think it does. He offers an alternative hypothesis: that patients who were already symptomatic from a VAD sought chiropractic care, and manipulation may have dislodged an already existing clot. This is pure speculation not supported by any data. And it points out that chiropractors are not able to judge when manipulation is contraindicated.
His arguments boil down to these:
    • Chiropractors didn’t do it: it was other practitioners who were less well trained who did the suspect manipulations. (But there are plenty of reports involving chiropractors.)
    • SMT didn’t cause it: it was due to one of those other things that can cause VAD. (No evidence to support that claim.)
    • Patients went to a chiropractor because they were already having symptoms of a stroke. (No supporting evidence, and a good reason to avoid neck manipulation.)
He places considerable emphasis on the Cassidy study. He says it “concluded that patients present to either a chiropractor or GP with neck pain because of their stroke already being present.” The Cassidy study does not say what he thinks it says. See Mark Crislip’s critique of that study. The idea that patients were already experiencing symptoms of a stroke was not a conclusion of the study, but merely a hypothesis of the authors that was not supported by their data.
The symptoms of a vertebral artery stroke are headache and focal neurological signs. Facial pain with numbness is the most common neurologic consequence. Other common neurologic signs are dizziness or vertigo, dysarthria or hoarseness, loss of pain and temperature sensation in the trunk and limbs, loss of taste, hiccups, nausea and vomiting, problems with vision, difficulty swallowing, and unilateral hearing loss.
Note that that neck pain is not even on the list. And although headache usually precedes the neurologic signs, many patients don’t seek care until the neurologic signs have developed; and I would guess that those signs would be more likely to send them to the ER than to the chiropractor. In fact, the Cassidy study found a strong association between visiting a chiropractor and having a stroke in the next 24 hours for patients under the age of 45 (odds ratio = 12).
Is neck manipulation beneficial?
A 2007 study purported to show that the benefits outweighed the risks for patients undergoing chiropractic care for neck pain. It was a prospective study, but there was no control group. They found that 2/3 of patients were improved at 3 and 12 months, but how many untreated patients would also have improved by then? 56% of patients reported adverse events and 13% reported these to be severe.
74-79% of patients with non-specific neck pain typically recover in a year, and even patients with cervical radiculopathy improve over time with only conservative treatments such as use of a collar and physical therapy.
Another study found a benefit of exercise combined with manipulation/mobilization but also of exercise alone.
A 2010 Cochrane systematic review found that mobilization was as effective as manipulation.
A 2004 Cochrane systematic review found that mobilization and manipulation were not beneficial alone, but were equally beneficial when used in conjunction with exercise.
It seems plausible that gentle mobilization techniques would be less likely to cause a vertebral artery tear than high velocity low amplitude (HVLA) manipulation techniques. This study showed that mobilization is less likely to cause adverse reactions in general.
In short, there is no evidence-based reason to prefer manipulation techniques to mobilization with exercise. In the absence of proven benefit, even a hypothetical risk is unacceptable.
“Smoking gun” cases
There are plenty of reported cases where patients suddenly developed stroke symptoms when a practitioner manipulated their neck. Until these cases are compiled, investigated, and explained otherwise, it is reasonable to assume a cause/effect relationship. Tuchin argues that it seems impossible for a thrombus to instantly form, dislodge, and travel to the cerebral cortex to cause a stroke within seconds of receiving SMT; but I would argue that if an existing clot were dislodged, symptoms would be almost immediate. Also, a tear can cause bleeding between the layers of the arterial wall, creating a hematoma that rapidly expands to directly occlude the artery.
What is most worrisome is that some of those patients got neck manipulations for symptoms in other parts of the body unrelated to the neck, or even for no symptoms at all (maintenance adjustments as a preventive health measure). A majority of patients consulting a chiropractor for any reason will be subjected to neck manipulation. Children get neck manipulations for problems like ear infections. Upper cervical (NUCCA) practitioners only treat the top vertebra of the neck in every patient. The whole premise of upper cervical chiropractic is nonsensical.
Conclusion
Tuchin correctly concludes that the evidence that SMT causes strokes is not definitive and is not supported by all of Hill’s criteria of causation. But he tries to make his case with fallacious arguments and questionable claims rather than with scientific data, and the whole article smacks of apologetics for chiropractic. While the existing evidence is not definitive, it supports the strong probability of a causal relationship, especially considering the many “smoking gun” cases. Since neck manipulation has not been demonstrated to be effective, even the suspicion of a risk is reason enough to reject the treatment. Alternatives like gentle mobilization, physical therapy, and exercise are better choices. And while everyone agrees that SMT is contraindicated in the presence of a VAD, chiropractors have demonstrated their inability to predict which patients are at risk. The safest course is to avoid neck manipulation altogether.

Neck Manipulation, Stroke, and the Vertebral Artery Stretch: Views, Opinions, and Options
Stroke reported as being associated with neck manipulation is rare when stroke numbers are tallied with the total number of neck manipulations performed, but the true incidence of this injury is not known and may be much greater than indicated by case reports. Advocating or providing neck manipulation without warning about the limitations and the danger of such treatment is irresponsible and misleading.
Sam Homola on September 1, 2017
Link
The subject of neck manipulation as a possible cause of stroke has been discussed many times on Science-Based Medicine. With increasing use of neck manipulation as a form of manual therapy, and the proliferation of articles for and against use of such treatment, it is essential to continue reviewing different perspectives on this subject in order to make an informed choice when considering use of neck manipulation.
When RAND published its review of the appropriateness of manipulation and mobilization of the cervical spine in 1996 (reporting limited benefits as a treatment for neck pain and tension headache), only 11.1 percent of all reported indications for use of cervical manipulation were considered to be appropriate. Serious complications arising from manipulation of the cervical spine were estimated to be 1.46 per one million manipulations. The vast majority of the complications were reported to be “vertebrobasilar accidents”.
In a 2003 study, a team of neurologists who reviewed the medical records of patients under 60 years of age who had suffered cervical artery dissection and ischemic stroke concluded that spinal manipulative therapy is independently associated with vertebral artery dissection.
In 2014, the American Heart Association and the American Stroke Association issued a joint statement supporting studies that had found an association between cervical manipulative therapy and vertebral artery dissection stroke in young patients.
Diversity of views and opinions
Today, despite repeated warnings that neck manipulation might be a cause of stroke, neck pain and headache are commonly treated by manipulating the cervical spine. Downplaying the possibility of harm from such treatment, some manual therapists argue that the statistical association between visits to chiropractors and vertebral artery dissection can be explained as being the result of patients undergoing manipulation for neck pain that was an early symptom of a stroke in progress. This argument does not excuse the neglect of manipulating the neck of a patient who has symptoms of vertebral artery dissection (thus exacerbating the dissection), and it fails to consider that stroke symptoms which develop during or immediately following neck manipulation may be the result of trauma that injures a healthy vertebral artery.
Studies reporting that the occurrence of stroke is no greater in patients under chiropractic care than in patients under primary careare often presented as evidence defending use of neck manipulation. Most persons suffering from obvious symptoms of stroke will see a primary care physician rather than a chiropractor. For this reason, one would normally expect that the number of strokes occurring in patients under primary care would be greater than the number of strokes occurring in patients under chiropractic care. Strokes occurring among chiropractic patients who may be routinely subjected to neck manipulation as a preventive or treatment measure for a variety of health problems (per subluxation theory) should raise concerns that such strokes might be caused by neck manipulation, as opposed to strokes occurring among patents who visit a primary care physician seeking treatment for symptoms of stroke.
A 2014 article in The Journal of Stroke and Cerebrovascular Disease reported that the Cassidy study and others like it underestimated the strength of the association of spinal manipulation with cervical arterial dissection, concluding that:
Prior studies grossly misclassified cases of cervical dissection and mistakenly dismissed a causal association with manipulation. Our study indicates that the OR [odds ratio] for spinal manipulation exposure in cervical artery dissection is higher than previously reported.
Often-quoted studies done by physical therapists, chiropractors, and osteopaths have reported that head position and upper neck manipulation do not significantly affect blood flow in vertebral arteries. Other studies have demonstrated that the stretch of upper cervical end-range rotary mobilization and manipulative techniques can reduce blood flow in the vertebral artery on the side opposite the direction of rotation.
Vertebral arteries are most commonly injured by stretching of the arterial walls. Such injury can cause dissection or separation of the intimal layer of the artery from the medial layer of the artery (forming an aneurysm-like hematoma that might occlude the artery) or the formation of an intimal blood clot that may break loose days or weeks later to block blood flow to the posterior portion of the brain. Although there may be risk of stroke with a single neck manipulation, the risk may be greater with multiple manipulations. Stretching of a vertebral artery by manipulating the upper cervical spine may not significantly interfere with blood flow until dissection occurs as a result of repetitive stress injury or until a clot or an atherosclerotic plaque is released ─ a rare but deadly accident.
A Cochrane review of the literature dealing with use of manipulation or mobilization in the treatment of acute/sub-acute/chronic neck pain warned that “the risk of rare but serious adverse events for manipulation exists,” offering this conclusion:
Multiple cervical manipulation sessions may provide better relief and functional improvement than certain medications at immediate/intermediate/long-term follow-up. Since the risk of rare but serious adverse events for manipulation exists, further high-priority research focusing on mobilization and comparing mobilization or manipulation versus other treatment options is needed to guide clinicians in their treatment choices.
A review by Church et al concluded that “there is no convincing evidence to support a causal link between chiropractic manipulation and CAD [cervical artery dissection]”. However, some case reports describe strokes that have occurred during or immediately following neck manipulation, with a disproportional number of such strokes occurring in young, healthy persons (most under the age of 45). Some of these injuries have been confirmed by imaging studies that show dissection of healthy cervical arteries due to trauma.
The American Heart Association and the American Stroke Association (AHA/ASA), after reviewing all relevant literature, reported that population controlled studies found an association between cervical manipulative therapy and vertebral artery dissection in young patients, offering this precautionary advice [Italics added]:
CD [cervical artery dissection] is an important cause of ischemic stroke in young and middle-aged patients. CD is most prevalent in the upper cervical spine and can involve the internal carotid artery or vertebral artery. Although current biomedical evidence is insufficient to establish the claim that CMT [cervical manipulative therapy] causes CD, clinical reports suggest that mechanical forces play a role in a considerable number of CDs and most population controlled studies have found an association between CMT and VAD [vertebral artery dissection] stroke in young patients. Although the incidence of CMT-associated CD in patients who have previously received CMT is not well established, and probably low, practitioners should strongly consider the possibility of CD as a presenting symptom, and patients should be informed of the statistical association between CD and CMT prior to undergoing manipulation of the cervical spine.
The above Scientific Statement by the AHA/ASA was endorsed by the American Association of Neurological Surgeons and the Congress of Neurological Surgeons, providing powerful support for reports suggesting that neck manipulation can be an independent factor in the development of a vertebrobasilar stroke.
Manipulation-related stroke: An apparent reality
Heeding warnings that spinal manipulation may be independently associated with vertebral artery dissection, most health-care professionals now generally accept the assumption that neck manipulation can be a cause of stroke. While there may be no conclusive proof that neck manipulation can injure a cervical artery, the totality of evidence indicates that such injuries do occur. Providers of neck manipulation should warn any patient about to undergo neck manipulation that there is a risk of stroke caused by injury to a cervical artery, always weighing risk vs. benefit as compared with other treatment options.
Although carotid arteries, including internal carotid arteries, may be injured by neck manipulation, stroke attributed to trauma caused by neck manipulation is usually the result of vertebral artery dissection that occurs in the atlanto-axial area of the cervical spine. Undetected disease in vertebral or carotid arteries, or malformation in the network of vertebral and internal carotid arteries in the base of the skull (Circle of Willis supplying blood flow to both posterior and anterior portions of the brain), may increase risk of injury caused by upper neck manipulation ─ providing good reason to avoid or question use of any neck manipulation that might involve extreme rotation of the head or the upper cervical vertebrae.

Stroke believed to be caused by neck manipulation is largely unrecognized and under reported. Estimates of the incidence of vertebrobasilar stroke associated with neck manipulation vary greatly. Since there is no system in place that identifies and registers reports associating neck manipulation with stroke, the true incidence of this injury is not known. Until chiropractors, physicians, physical therapists, and insurance carriers are required to report manipulation-related stroke data to an independently operated data base, it will not be possible to determine how many strokes might be caused by neck manipulation.
Upper cervical anatomy: A review worth repeating
The anatomy and the configuration of the atlanto-axial structures that provide an osseous pathway for vertebral arteries clearly indicate that extreme rotation of the upper cervical spine has the potential to damage vertebral arteries that supply blood to the posterior portion of the brain. The degree of risk depends largely upon the degree of rotation of the atlas on the axis ─ a risk that may be compounded by diseased vertebral arteries, connective tissue disorders, or structural abnormalities that are not often apparent, such as a retrolenticular vertebral artery ring or a bow hunter’s band.
The greatest amount of rotation in the cervical spine occurs in the atlanto-axial joints (which can rotate independently up to 50 degrees right and left) in the upper cervical spine where vertebral arteries are most often injured. There are no interlocking joint surfaces and no intervertebral disc to limit rotation of the atlas on the axis, which is restrained primarily by ligaments. When rotation of the atlas exceeds 45 or 50 degrees, vertebral arteries threading through transverse processes on each side of the axis and atlas (making a double U-turn to enter the foramen magnum in the base of the skull) are stretched, risking stroke caused by vertebral artery dissection or clot formation.
Since vertebral arteries on each side of the neck thread up through transverse processes from the sixth cervical vertebra to the first cervical vertebra, they are not exempt from stress at any level in the cervical spine during neck manipulation and may be vulnerable to injury if they are atherosclerotic or diseased. There is also a possibility that stroke might occur if neck manipulation releases an atherosclerotic plaque in a carotid artery.

Making an informed choice
There are many published studies dealing with the role of neck manipulation as a possible cause of stroke. Some of these studies, mixing science with pseudoscience, deny that neck manipulation can be a cause of stroke. Most of us prefer to rely upon scientifically oriented systematic reviews (such as Cochrane) and studies prepared by mainstream groups such as the American Stroke Association for credible conclusions. “Cherry picking” in a search for science-based articles on the subject of neck manipulation and stroke will invariably reveal that the preponderance of evidence strongly suggests that neck manipulation can be a factor in the development of vertebrobasilar stroke.
There is evidence to indicate that neck manipulation can be an effective treatment for some neck-related problems, such as cervicogenic headache. But when you consider reviews providing evidence that neck manipulation can be a cause of stroke, it appears that the safest and most logical course to take would be to avoid use of neck manipulation and turn to safer, equally effective methods of conservative care. An intractable neck-related problem (such as loss of mobility) that might benefit from neck manipulation should be subjected to a multidisciplinary risk-versus-benefit review to determine if use of manipulation is warranted and if the manipulative technique is appropriate. The technique used should not force extreme rotation in the atlanto-axial joints.
There are certain obvious signs and symptoms that preclude use of neck manipulation, such as carotid bruits or symptoms of vascular insufficiency on rotation or extension of the cervical spine. But there is no reliable way to determine that neck manipulation is a safe procedure, especially upper neck manipulation. Persons with no apparent risk factors or symptoms may have undetected vascular or structural abnormalities that predispose them to stroke caused by manipulating the cervical spine. Good health does not offer protection from injury to a cervical artery – as discussed above, neck manipulation is the leading cause of stroke in young (and therefore likely healthy) patients.
The neck pain problem
Neck pain has been ranked as the 4th leading cause of disability. Although mechanical-type neck pain is commonly treated by manipulating the cervical spine, questions remain about the effectiveness and the danger of such treatment. Neck pain (when not mechanical in nature) can be a symptom of spontaneous vertebral artery dissection ─ an obvious red flag when accompanied by any one of a number of neurological signs and symptoms.
Some studies have reported that spinal manipulative therapy for relief of mechanical-type neck pain is more effective than no treatment or sham treatment and more effective than medication but no more effective than exercise. While many people seem to benefit from manipulation or mobilization that provides short-term relief for neck pain or tension-related symptoms, the risk of stroke would certainly outweigh such benefit. Persons who may find it difficult to give up neck manipulation as a treatment for chronic neck pain should at least try other treatment options such as massage, traction, hydrotherapy, exercise, and so on.
According to a 2015 Cochrane systematic review, no high quality evidence has been found to remove uncertainty about the effectiveness of mobilization or manipulation as a treatment for neck pain. This observation supports contentions that neck manipulation as a treatment for neck pain has no proven benefit that outweighs the risk of stroke ─ as suggested by a team of physicians 14 years ago:
In the absence of randomized controlled trial evidence demonstrating the effectiveness of cervical manipulation, the best current evidence suggests that the small risk of dissection and stroke outweighs the benefit of this treatment modality for patients with acute neck pain.
Conclusion: Informed consent requires information
Although controversy continues to surround the use of cervical spine manipulation and its potential to cause stroke by injuring a vertebral or internal carotid artery, there appears to be no doubt that neck manipulation can be a cause of stroke. As suggested by the American Stroke Association, informed consent should be a prerequisite for neck manipulation. Some manual therapists choose to avoid the “fear factor” by not asking for informed consent when providing neck manipulation if the patient appears to be healthy ─ an approach that fails to consider that some patients may have undetected vascular or structural abnormalities that predispose them to manipulation-related injury. Besides, in many cases, strokes that have occurred in young people following neck manipulation have been shown to be the result of injury to a healthy vertebral artery.
Stroke caused by manipulating the cervical spine is a rare but devastating event. When there is any doubt about the need or the safety of neck manipulation, it is always best to forego such treatment and to consider other treatment options ─ a decision requiring that the patient as well as the provider be well informed about the risk involved.

   Neck Manipulation: Risk vs. Benefit
Sam Homola
Link
While manipulation of any kind has the potential to cause injury, stroke caused by neck manipulation is of greatest concern. Risk must always be weighed against benefit when upper neck manipulation is considered. Risk of stroke caused by neck manipulation is statistically low, but the risk is serious enough to outweigh benefit in all but a few rare, carefully selected cases.
When the RAND (Research and Development) organization published its review of the literature on cervical spine manipulation and mobilization in 1996, it concluded that only about 11.1% of reported indications for cervical spine manipulation were appropriate and that stroke and other serious complications occurred about 1.46 times per one million neck manipulations.1 In the same year, after examining 183 cases of vertebrobasilar stroke that occurred from 1934 through 1994 following neck manipulation, the National Chiropractic Mutual Insurance Company (NCMIC) concluded that “It has to be accepted that VBS [vertebrobasilar stroke] following SMT [spinal manipulative therapy] does occur.”2
Since about 90% of manipulation in the United States is done by chiropractors1 who use spinal manipulation as a primary treatment for a variety of health problems, neck manipulation is more problematic among chiropractors than among physical therapists and other practitioners who use manipulation only occasionally in the treatment of selected musculoskeletal problems.
Estimates on the incidence of stroke caused by cervical spine manipulation range from one in 400,000 to one in 5.8 million manipulations, depending upon who is doing the survey. A chiropractor-authored review of malpractice data provided by the Canadian Chiropractic Protective Association, for example, concluded that a chiropractor will be made aware of an arterial dissection only once per 5.85 million cervical manipulations.3 This stroke-manipulation ratio is widely quoted by chiropractors, despite the fact that court-litigated cases do not reflect the total number of manipulation-related strokes, most of which are unreported or undetected.
Backing away from observations that neck manipulation is a cause of stroke, a 2006 report published by NCMIC Chiropractic Solutions concluded that “The incidence of stroke in the population as a whole is no different (2 per 100,000 persons annually) than among those who received manipulation treatment of the neck,” adding that “The best scientific evidence available has shown no causative relationship between appropriately applied spinal manipulation and stroke events.”4 Many studies, however, have linked chiropractic upper neck manipulation with stroke.5,6
Recent reports produced by chiropractors argue that the incidence of stroke among persons who have had neck manipulation is “…to the same order of magnitude as that occurring in the general population,”4 and that there is “…no evidence of excess risk of VBA [vertebrobasilar artery] stroke associated with chiropractic care compared with primary care.”7 But these reports fail to distinguish strokes caused by trauma to the vertebral arteries of young healthy people from the type of strokes that occur among predisposed persons, especially the elderly. No consideration is given to the possibility that many strokes caused by neck manipulation may go unreported. When patients seek medical care for paralytic symptoms caused by release of a blood clot that was formed days or weeks earlier by neck manipulation, for example, a connection between neck manipulation and stroke may not be made. Such strokes may then be reported by primary care physicians who are unaware of preceding trauma caused by neck manipulation, thus sparing chiropractors of any blame.
The most recent chiropractor-headed study of the association between chiropractic visits and vertebrobasilar artery stroke, based on billing records, concluded that strokes associated with chiropractic neck manipulation occur because patients with headache and neck pain caused by vertebrobasilar dissection seek chiropractic care for relief of symptoms: “The increased risks of VBA stroke associated with chiropractic and PCP [primary care physician] visits is likely due to patients with headache and neck pain from VBA dissection seeking care before their stroke.”7 In other words, the report implies that a chiropractor is not to be blamed for making an incorrect diagnosis and then manipulating the neck of a patient who presents the symptoms of a stroke in progress. It goes without saying, however, that it is the responsibility of the chiropractor to recognize symptoms of stroke before manipulating the patient’s neck, especially if the chiropractor practices independently or portrays himself or herself as a primary care physician. But you cannot depend upon the diagnostic acumen of a chiropractor who believes that he or she can improve health by adjusting the spine. Physicians and therapists who refer patients to chiropractors must be cautious in selecting patients for referral, and they must take responsibility for the diagnosis when making such referrals.
Clearly, patients with acute head and neck pain that might be the result of stroke or arterial dissection should not have their necks manipulated. Elderly persons who might be susceptible to stroke because of diseased vertebral arteries should not be subjected to the risk of neck manipulation. The fact that spontaneous vertebral artery dissection can occur in susceptible persons of all ages does not excuse neck manipulation as a cause of traumatic dissection but rather underscores another reason for avoiding such treatment whenever possible.
Appropriate Neck Manipulation
Manipulation of the upper cervical spine should be reserved for carefully selected musculoskeletal problems that do not respond to such simple measures as time, massage, exercise, mobilization, longitudinal traction, or over-the-counter medication. Because of the tortuous route of the vertebral arteries where they thread through the transverse processes of the first cervical vertebra and then make a sharp turn to travel behind the atlas and enter the skull through the foramen magnum, head and neck rotation forced by manual manipulation should not exceed 45 or 50 degrees if kinking or traumatic dissection of these arteries is to be avoided.8,5 Rotating the head to rotate the cervical spine would force excessive rotation in the occiput-atlas-axis area where the vertebral arteries are most vulnerable and where there are no intervertebral discs and no interlocking joints to limit rotation. Rotation past 45 degrees might cause kinking of the ipsilateral vertebral artery while rotation past 50 degrees might cause kinking of the contralateral vertebral artery.8 Rapid manual rotation of the head might also cause damage by overcoming the arteries’ normal elasticity, causing tears and blood clots in the intimal lining of the vertebrobasilar arteries. The slow stretching of mobilization within a normal range of movement may be less damaging to arteries than the high-velocity low-amplitude manipulation required to rotate the cervical spine beyond its normal range of motion or to move joints into the paraphysiologic space to produce cavitation.
It seems likely that in rare cases where there is significant discomfort or loss of mobility caused by binding or fixation of a vertebral joint or by entrapment of a synovial membrane or a cartilaginous fragment, manipulation might be the treatment of choice. There is evidence to indicate that cervical spine manipulation and/or mobilization may provide short-term pain relief and range of motion enhancement for persons with subacute or chronic neck pain.1 There is no credible evidence, however, to indicate that neck manipulation is any more effective for relieving mechanical neck disorders than a number of other physical treatment modalities,9 and it is clear that adverse reactions are more likely to occur following manipulation than mobilization.10 (When manipulation is performed, a joint is moved farther than normally possible in an active movement. Passive mobilization moves a joint through its normal range of motion.) Inappropriate cervical spine manipulation may force excessive movement and worsen symptoms related to cervical disc herniation or spondylosis, producing such complications as radiculopathy or myelopathy.11 At least one study has suggested that manual therapy in the form of mobilization is more effective and less costly for treating neck pain that physiotherapy or care by a general practitioner.12 And there is reason to believe that less risk is associated with mobilization than with manipulation.10 There is no justification, however, for use of neck mobilization or manipulation as a treatment for general health problems.
All things considered, manual rotation of the cervical spine beyond its normal range of movement is rarely justified. The neck should never be manipulated to correct an asymptomatic “chiropractic subluxation” or an undetectable “vertebral subluxation complex” for the alleged purpose of restoring or maintaining health or to relieve symptoms not located or originating in the neck. There is no evidence that such subluxations exist. When a painful, actual subluxation (partial dislocation) occurs, manipulation might occasionally be helpful but is most often contraindicated.13
The bottom line is that while there might an occasional need for appropriate, properly controlled neck manipulation in the treatment of an uncomplicated musculoskeletal problem that results in loss of mobility, there is no credible support for the use of such treatment based on the chiropractic vertebral subluxation theory. Consultation with an orthopedist or a neurologist should be part of a consensus that determines the need for neck manipulation, weighing benefit against risk. Persons with certain structural or vascular abnormalities, or who might be taking blood thinners or other medications that would increase risk of bleeding, would be advised not to undergo neck manipulation for any reason.
When a sudden onset of neck pain occurs, it is absolutely essential that an attempt be made to rule out a pre-existing vertebral artery dissection before neck manipulation is done, lest manipulation releases an embolus that will travel to the brain. Sudden, severe headache might also be an indication that stroke is occurring or is about to occur. When neck pain or headache is sudden and severe, neck manipulation should not be considered until a neurologist has tested the patient for symptoms of arterial dissection or stroke. Such a careful approach would be problematic among chiropractors who base diagnosis and treatment upon detection and correction of a “vertebral subluxation complex.”14
Chiropractors vs. Physical Therapists
Since it may be difficult or impossible to determine beforehand who might have weak or diseased vertebral arteries or who might be vulnerable to vertebral artery dissection or stroke that could be caused or aggravated by upper neck manipulation, rotational neck manipulation should be a measure of last resort. A physical therapist trained in the use of both manipulation and mobilization for musculoskeletal problems would be less likely to use manipulation inappropriately than a chiropractor who routinely manipulates the spine for “the preservation and restoration of health.”15
According to the Association of Chiropractic Colleges (ACC), “Chiropractic is concerned with the preservation and restoration of health, and focuses particular attention on the subluxation. A subluxation is a complex of functional and/or structural and/or pathological articular changes that compromise neural integrity and may influence organ system function and general health.”15 Chiropractors who are guided by this vague paradigm (more of a belief than a theory) often manipulate the full spine of every patient for “subluxation correction.” Few chiropractors specialize in the care of back pain and other musculoskeletal problems, and only a few have renounced the chiropractic vertebral subluxation theory.
An indication that science-based chiropractic is outweighed by subluxation-based chiropractic is evident in the recent demise of the National Association for Chiropractic Medicine (NACM). (Personal correspondence with Ron Slaughter, MS, DC, August 8-09.) The NACM, founded in 1984, required its members to renounce the chiropractic vertebral subluxation theory as part of a plan to develop a science-based musculoskeletal specialty that could become a part of mainstream medicine, with emphasis on manipulation and other physical treatment methods. Only a few hundred chiropractors joined the organization. Failure of the NACM certainly does not speak well for the chiropractic profession, which continues to resist reform that would uniformly limit chiropractors in a properly defined specialty.
While physical therapists, physiatrists, osteopaths, and orthopedists sometimes manipulate the neck for a carefully selected musculoskeletal problem, chiropractors who are guided by the ACC’s subluxation paradigm may routinely manipulate the neck, thus subjecting the patient to unnecessary risk.16 Whatever the incidence of stroke per number of neck manipulations might be, this risk is greater per patient among chiropractic patients who may be manipulated many times for “health reasons” and who may be manipulated regularly for “maintenance care.” Chiropractors who renounce vertebral subluxation dogma and specialize in the care of back pain will use manipulation more appropriately. Unfortunately, there is no official or legal definition limiting chiropractors to treatment of musculoskeletal problems, making it difficult to find a properly limited chiropractor.17
There is little doubt that most chiropractors are skillful manipulators. And many chiropractors do a good job treating back pain. But until chiropractors are uniformly specialized in treatment methods and scope of practice, and chiropractic associations openly denounce the nonsense that permeates the profession, chiropractors cannot be recommended across the board. Hit-and-miss reliability among chiropractors makes it necessary for physicians and other health professionals to stay on the safe side and recommend physical therapists rather than chiropractors.
Forty-two states permit direct access to the services of physical therapists, some of whom may include use of manipulation among their treatment modalities. A physical therapist who offers neck manipulation without requiring a physician’s prescription must be prepared to take responsibility for the diagnosis and the treatment outcome. Because of the dangers associated with neck manipulation, therapists who perform such manipulation should work closely with medical specialists to determine if benefit outweighs risk.
Since physical therapists use mobilization more often than manipulation, and use much less neck manipulation than chiropractors who routinely manipulate the spine, there may be less injury and a lower incidence of stroke associated with physical therapy than with chiropractic treatment. For example, a review of 177 cases of injury caused by manipulation of the cervical spine (MCS), reported in 116 articles published between 1925 and 1997, revealed that “Physical therapists were involved in less than 2% of the cases, and no deaths have been attributed to MCS provided by physical therapists.”18
References
1. Coulter ID, Hurwitz EL, Adams AH, et al. The Appropriateness of Manipulation and Mobilization of the Cervical Spine. Santa Monica, CA; RAND; 1996.
2. Terrett AGT. Vertebrobasilar Stroke Following Manipulation. West Des Moines, IA: National Chiropractic Mutual Insurance Company; 1996.
3. Haldeman S, Carey P, Townsend M, Papadopoulos C. Arterial dissections following cervical manipulation: the chiropractic experience. Can Med Assoc J 2001;165(7):905-6.
4. Triano J, Kawchuk G. Current Concepts in Spinal Manipulation and Cervical Arterial Incidents. Clive, IA: NCMIC Chiropractic Solutions; 2006.
5. Terrett AGT. Current Concepts in Vertebrobasilar Complications Following Spinal Manipulation. West Des Moines. IA: NCMIC Chiropractic Solutions; 2001.
6. Ernst E. Adverse effects of spinal manipulation: a systematic review. J R Soc Med 2007;100:06-0100.1-9.
7. Cassidy JD, Boyle E, Cote P, et al. Risk of vertebrobasilar stroke and chiropractic care: results of a population-based case-control and case-crossover study. Spine 2008;33(No. 4S):S176-83.
8. Magee D. Orthopedic Physical Assessment. Philadelphia, PA: W.B. Saunders Company; 1987.
9. Gross AR, Hoving JL, Haines TA, et al. Manipulation and mobilization for mechanical neck disorders. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2004, Issue 1. Art. No: CD004249.DOI: 10.1002/14651858.CD004249.pub2.
10. Hurwitz EL, Morgenstern H, Vassilaki M, et al. Frequency and clinical prediction of adverse reactions to chiropractic care in the UCLA neck pain study. Spine 2005;30(13):1477-84.
11. Malone DG, Baldwin NG, Tomecek FJ, et al. Complications of cervical spine manipulation therapy: 5-year retrospective study in a single-group practice. Neurosurg Focus 2002;13(6):1-7.
12. Korthals-de Bos, Ingeborg BC, Hoving Jan L, et al. Cost effectiveness of physiotherapy, manual therapy, and general practitioner care for neck pain: economic evaluation alongside a randomised controlled trial. Br Med J April 26, 2003.
13. Homola S. Chiropractic: history and overview of theories and methods. Clin Orthop Relat Res 2006; Number 444:236-42.
14. Homola S. Can chiropractors and evidence-based manual therapists work together? An opinion from a veteran chiropractor. J Man Manipulative Ther 2006;14(2):E14-E18.
15. Christensen MG, Kollasch MW, Ward R, et al. Job Analysis of Chiropractic. Greeley, CO; National Board of Chiropractic Examiners; 2005.
16. Homola S. Is the chiropractic subluxation theory a threat to public health?@ The Scientific Review of Alternative Medicine 2001;3(1):45-53.
17. Homola S. Finding a Good Chiropractor. Arch Fam Med 1998;7(Jan/Feb):20-3.
18. Di Fabio RP. Manipulation of the cervical spine: Risks and Benefits. Phys Ther 1999;79:50-75.
Note: Portions of this article have been published in The Scientific Review of Alternative Medicine (Vol. 2, 2007, published in 2009) and Skeptical Inquirer (Vol. 33, No. 4, 2009).

   Adverse Effects of Chiropractic
Harriet Hall
Link
There is a very good chance that you will feel worse after seeing a chiropractor.
According to a new systematic review, serious complications of spinal manipulation are rare, but 33-60% of patients experience milder short-term adverse effects such as increased pain, radiation of pain, headaches, vertigo and even loss of consciousness. The study, published in the journal Spine, involved searching PubMed and the Cochrane Library for the years 1966 to 2007. They identified additional studies by hand searching. They looked for all articles that reported adverse effects associated with chiropractic irrespective of type of design. They omitted any reports where patients had underlying diseases (osteogenesis imperfecta, expansive vertebral hemangioma, osteoporotic fracture, etc.) that predisposed them to complications with manipulation.
They found 46 pertinent studies:
    • One randomized controlled trial
    • Two case-control studies
    • Six prospective studies
    • Twelve surveys
    • Three retrospective studies
    • 115 case reports
They recognized that “the heterogeneity of the study designs did not allow conducting a formal meta-analysis.” But they did the best they could to make sense out of what they found.
One RCT
It is surprising that after over a century of chiropractic manipulation, only one randomized controlled trial has attempted to evaluate its safety. And that study was really designed to compare different chiropractic methods to each other: manipulation (high velocity low amplitude thrusts that cannot be resisted by the patient) vs mobilization (low velocity passive motion that can be stopped by the patient), with and without adjunctive measures of heat or electrical muscle stimulation. The study, published in 2005 by Hurwitz et al. in both a chiropractic journal and in Spine, was limited to patients with neck pain. Of 336 patients enrolled, 280 responded 2 weeks later to an adverse events questionnaire. 30% reported at least one adverse symptom, most frequently increased neck pain or stiffness. Adverse reactions were more frequent with manipulation than with mobilization, but the difference didn’t reach statistical significance. The study concluded
Given the possible higher risk of adverse reactions and lack of demonstrated effectiveness of manipulation over mobilization, chiropractors should consider a conservative approach for applying manipulation to their patients, especially those with severe neck pain.
2 Case Control Studies
A study in Canada, published in Stroke in 2001 matched 582 cases of vertebrobasilar accidents (stroke) with controls. In patients <45 years old, those with VBA were 5 times as likely as controls to have visited a chiropractor in the previous week, and 5 times more likely to have made more than 3 visits for cervical treatment in the preceding month.
A second study published in Neurology in 2003 used a nested case-control design and found that vertebral artery dissections were independently associated with spinal manipulative therapy in the previous 30 days, even after controlling for neck pain. The authors advised,
Patients undergoing SMT should be consented for risk of stroke or vascular injury from the procedure. A significant increase in neck pain following spinal manipulative therapy warrants immediate medical evaluation.
Prospective Cohorts
6 prospective studies [1] involved having patients, chiropractors, or physiotherapists fill out questionnaires on a predetermined number of consecutive patients (usually between 10 and 15).
1. 20 New Zealand physiotherapists were approached; only 9 returned the forms, and only 1 participated for 3 weeks. Questionnaires were completed by physiotherapists. There was only one report of increased neck pain. This study was inconsistent with all the rest. It raises the question of whether manipulation by physiotherapists might be safer than manipulation by chiropractors, and whether they are actually using the same techniques.
2. 10 Norwegian chiropractors reported side effects in 1/3 of patients. 23% had local or radiating symptoms: 90% moderate or slight, 87% commencing on the day of treatment and 83% disappearing in 24 hours. Questionnaires were completed by the chiropractor.
3. 86 Swedish chiropractors were approached and 66 participated; 27% of patients did not participate and 5% were lost to follow-up. 44% reported adverse reactions, mostly local discomfort in the area treated. Questionnaires were completed by the chiropractor.
4. 146 Norwegian chiropractors were approached; 102 participated. Adverse reactions were reported in 55% of patients, with 64% occurring within 4 hours of treatment and 74% disappearing by 24 hours. Questionnaires were completed by the chiropractor.
5. 11 British chiropractors were approached; 9 participated. 74% of patients responded of which only 63% of the forms were complete. 53% reported adverse reactions; 44% of these occurred within an hour of manipulation. Questionnaires were completed by patients.
6. 59 Belgian manipulative therapists; questionnaires filled out by patients. 60.9% reported adverse reactions, mainly headache, stiffness, and local discomfort, most appearing within 4 hours of treatment and resolving in 24 hours.
It is interesting that not one of these studies was from the US, where chiropractic originated and where it is most popular.
Retrospective Cohorts
12 retrospective surveys mainly involved asking chiropractors, neurologists, or other physicians to fill out questionnaires. A couple of studies were based on medical or insurance records. In all, 308 serious adverse effects were reported: 163 strokes, 26 myelopathies, 100 radiculopathies, 3 transient ischemic accidents, 1 acute subdural hematoma and 29 other cases not specified. Minor adverse reactions totaled 1337 cases, most of them vertigo (1218 cases) and diminished or lost consciousness. Most of these occurred within 24 hours of manipulation; 5 patients died and 80 were left with permanent neurologic deficits.
A retrospective study of medicolegal cases suggested that chiropractors may have failed to recognize a stroke in progress. “The sudden onset of acute and unusual neck and/or head pain may represent a dissection in progress and be the reason a patient seeks manipulative therapy that then serves as the final insult to the vessel leading to ischemia.” Strokes occurred at any point during the course of treatment and there was no dose-response relationship.
Case Reports
115 case reports included strokes (66), spinal fluid leak (5), spinal epidural hematoma (7), cauda equina syndrome (2), herniated disc (20), radiculopathy (7), myelopathy (3), diaphragmatic palsy (3) and pathologic fractures of vertebra (2).
Conclusions
The results of this new systematic review are consistent with previous reviews. Adverse reactions are common after spinal manipulation, but they are usually benign and transitory. The true risk of serious injury is not known. Estimates of the risk of stroke vary wildly from 1 in 20,000 manipulations to 1.46 in 10,000,000 manipulations. The authors point out that these numbers are speculative because they are based on assumptions about the total number of manipulations performed, and because the degree of underreporting is likely to be high. In one survey, 35 cases of neurologic complications were identified, none of which had been previously published. Another study [2] by the Stroke Council of the American Heart Association identified 360 unpublished case of arterial damage. Chiropractors and neurologists are likely to have different perceptions of the risk, because without systematic followup, chiropractors may not know when their patient has suffered a stroke, while neurologists see only patients with stroke. One interesting but not unexpected finding of this study was that questionnaires completed by patients reported a higher incidence of adverse reactions than questionnaires completed by chiropractors.
This study concluded that the “data are inconclusive in terms of incidence, but the risk of occurrence of serious adverse reactions should be assumed.” There is no way to know if one type of treatment is more dangerous than another because the studies almost never specify what chiropractic maneuver was performed. But there is a hint that mobilization might be safer than manipulation, and there is a plausible rationale.
Screening protocols have been developed that attempt to identify patients at higher risk of stroke, but they have not proven to be useful. Their sensitivity and specificity are low. An intriguing study using PET scans concluded that cerebellar hypoperfusion (decreased blood flow to the base of the brain) may occur after cervical spinal manipulation. This could explain reports of headache, dizziness, vertigo, nausea, blurred vision, etc. It also raises the possibility that some of the minor reactions were strokes that almost happened but didn’t.
One might ask, if half of patients have adverse effects, why do they keep coming back? There are plenty of psychological factors that could explain that. Many alternative providers tell patients that increased symptoms mean the treatment is working and they have to feel worse before they can get better. And one practice-building technique taught to chiropractors is not to ask whether the original symptom is better, but to ask “What’s better today?” If they can find anything positive, like sleeping better or improved appetite, they emphasize that improvement and distract the patient’s attention from the fact that their original complaint has not improved.
We simply don’t have enough good data to quantify the risks of chiropractic treatment. It’s hard to understand why we don’t have good data after all this time. It would seem to be in the best interests of chiropractors and their insurance companies to get the facts. Good data would be easy to obtain by establishing a database specifying the exact intervention and contacting patients a day or two later and also a month after the treatment to ask about adverse effects or subsequent diagnoses of stroke. It could be compiled electronically and data pooled for a large number of chiropractors. It would cost next to nothing and could be carried out by office assistants as part of their routine duties.
Patients have the right to know. Apart from the risk of stroke and other serious outcomes, if there is a 50% chance I will feel worse after a treatment, I would like to be warned.
And as the authors point out, the question of risk is all that more important because we don’t have a “robust demonstration” of the effectiveness of these treatments. Risk alone is meaningless: it must be balanced against benefits to make a risk/benefit assessment. They say “Although the list of indications for which chiropractic is recommended is enormous, there is insufficient published evidence to support or refuse the efficacy of this treatment modality.”
The bottom line: chiropractic manipulations, especially neck manipulations, carry a small risk of serious consequences, a large risk of minor adverse effects; and, depending on the indication, there is little or no evidence that they are effective.
———-
[1] Rivett DA, Milburn P. A prospective study of complications of cervical spine
manipulation. J Manipulative Physiol Ther 1996;4:166–70.
Senstad O, Leboeuf-Yde C, Borchgrevink CF. Side-effects of chiropractic
spinal manipulation: types, frequency, discomfort and course. Scand J Prim
Health Care 1996;14:50–53.
Leboeuf-Yde C, Hennius B, Rudberg E, et al. Side effects of chiropractic
treatment: a prospective study. J Manipulative Physiol Ther 1997;20:
511–15.
Senstad O, Leboeuf-Yde C, Borchgrevink CF. Frequency and characteristics
of side effects of spinal manipulative therapy. Spine 1997;22:435–41.
Barrett AJ, Breen AC. Adverse effects of spinal manipulation. J R Soc Med
2000;93:258–9.
Cagnie B, Vinck E, Beernaert A, et al. How common are side effects of spinal
manipulation and can these side effects be predicted? Man Ther 2004;9:
151–6.
[2] Robertson JT. Neck manipulations as a cause for stroke. Stroke 1981;12:1

   Chiropractic and Stroke: Evaluation of One Paper
Mark Crislip
Link
“Do not trust the cheering, for those persons would shout as much if you or I were going to be hanged.
”Oliver Cromwell
In the blogosphere, the proponents of chiropractic often quote the following paper, with the abstract:
Risk of Vertebrobasilar Stroke and Chiropractic Care
Results of a Population-Based Case-Control and Case-Crossover Study
Spine. 2008 Feb 15;33(4 Suppl):S176-83.
by Cassidy JD, Boyle E, Côté P, He Y, Hogg-Johnson S, Silver FL, Bondy SJ. (5)
Why be different? Here is the abstract.
STUDY DESIGN: Population-based, case-control and case-crossover study. OBJECTIVE: To investigate associations between chiropractic visits and vertebrobasilar artery (VBA) stroke and to contrast this with primary care physician (PCP) visits and VBA stroke.
SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: Chiropractic care is popular for neck pain and headache, but may increase the risk for VBA dissection and stroke. Neck pain and headache are common symptoms of VBA dissection, which commonly precedes VBA stroke.
METHODS: Cases included eligible incident VBA strokes admitted to Ontario hospitals from April 1, 1993 to March 31, 2002. Four controls were age and gender matched to each case. Case and control exposures to chiropractors and PCPs were determined from health billing records in the year before the stroke date. In the case-crossover analysis, cases acted as their own controls.
RESULTS: There were 818 VBA strokes hospitalized in a population of more than 100 million person-years. In those aged <45 years, cases were about three times more likely to see a chiropractor or a PCP before their stroke than controls. Results were similar in the case control and case crossover analyses. There was no increased association between chiropractic visits and VBA stroke in those older than 45 years. Positive associations were found between PCP visits and VBA stroke in all age groups. Practitioner visits billed for headache and neck complaints were highly associated with subsequent VBA stroke.
CONCLUSION: VBA stroke is a very rare event in the population. The increased risks of VBA stroke associated with chiropractic and PCP visits is likely due to patients with headache and neck pain from VBA dissection seeking care before their stroke. We found no evidence of excess risk of VBA stroke associated chiropractic care compared to primary care.
Seems impressive, especially the conclusion. Chiropractic is not to blame for VBA strokes. But abstracts are like movie trailers. They give a flavor of the movie, but often leave out many important plot devices and characters. The Dark Knight evidently has a plot line concerning Two Face, but you would not know it from the trailers (9). Writing an abstract is an art, and you have to choose those feature you wish to emphasize in a limited space. But if you want to know the rest of the story (12), you have to actually pull and read the reference. If you were to read this article in its entirely, you would not be so sanguine about the safety of chiropractic.
As best as I can tell, no one bothers to read the whole reference to see what it says. So I did (6). Dr. Hall has covered the issue of stroke and chiropractic nicely in other posts, but I figure if I am going to go to the trouble of reading this stuff, why should I be the only one to suffer? Consider this an extended footnote to Dr. Hall’s posts, if she will be so kind as to humor me.
Does the meat (7) of the article support the abstract? Lets wander through the content instead of the abstract and see.
First they found 818 vertebral artery strokes on the basis of discharge codes.
First problem: discharge codes are not a reliable way to know the real diagnosis (13).
The discharge diagnosis is sometimes a best guess, often not based on the strictest of criteria, and when people compare the real diagnosis based on a chart review to the discharge coded diagnosis, they often have a poor correlation. And, at least in the US, coding is an art to maximize reimbursement, not a method of determining what the patient really had. You have to do chart reviews to know what the patients ‘real’ diagnosis is, and even then, given the vagaries of testing and disease presentation, you often have to go with best bet.
Also, note the patients have the diagnosis of stroke, not the reason for the stroke. For the elderly, where stroke is common, the most common cause of stroke is thrombus, a blood clot forming in an artery that feeds the brain. The second most common cause is emboli, flipping a blood clot to the brain. In the young, where stroke is rare, the cause is more commonly a tear in the vertebral artery, a dissection, which can be precipitated by trauma.
The worry in chiropractic is a stroke CAUSED BY A DISSECTION. Sorry for yelling. Already the study is flawed as we do not know if there were dissections. Stroke may be a surrogate for dissection, but not a good one, especially in the elderly.
I would bet that the diagnosis of stroke is more accurate in younger people. When a young person presents with a stroke or other neurologic symptoms, they get the million dollar work up as they are not supposed to have a stroke, where as if an obese elderly, hypertensive, smoking, diabetic presents with transient dizziness or double visions from medications or viral illness, well, they might not get the precise diagnosis and be labeled as a vertebral artery stroke without undergoing precise diagnostic work up. So while the number of VBA strokes is likely to be accurate in the young, in the elderly it is possible to over represent the number of strokes.
Also, that was 818 vertebral strokes in 100 million person years, so a VBA stroke is a rare thing. This is important in that if you have a high background of vertebral artery strokes from thrombus or emboli, which is a common cause in the elderly, you will lose the rare dissection. If you want to find a rare event like a dissection as cause of stroke, the elderly may not be the best place to look as the noise of the thrombo-embolic stokes will overwhelm the effects of the dissection. In the elderly looking for a dissection based on stroke codes would be like locating your cell phone by listening in a concert hall by calling it while The Who is playing (11).
They compared these 818 strokes to a control group in a case control study.
Case control studies are good for a rare disease and a common exposure and can only establish an association, which is not, I will emphasize, establishing causation.
They compared those that visited a chiropractor with those that visited a family practitioner, over a months time to see if it was associated with a vertebral artery stroke. You know their conclusion.
So does the body of the paper support the conclusions of the abstracts, Well, yes and no.
For people over age 45, there was the same association of vertebral artery stroke after a visit to a chiropractor or a primary care practitioner. A stroke mind you. The cause of the stroke was not determined. It would be reasonable to assume that most strokes in the elderly would be due to thrombus or emboli and that the rare event of a dissection, the worry of a chiropractic manipulation of the neck where you tear the artery, might go undiagnosed.
In the over 45 age group, strokes due to chiropractic could be lost in the sea of strokes due to other reasons, and since we do not know if there were a dissection or blood clot as a cause of strokes, it is hard to conclude that there was no extra strokes from chiropractic. The study was not powered to determine the rare event of a chiropractic event against the background to usual stokes in the elderly. The mean age in this study was 63 (11).
Young people should not have any stroke. In the young, vertebral artery dissection is a common cause of a rare event. It is also the worry from chiropractic neck manipulation. If you could find an effect of chiropractic, it would be in the young. And they do. The people who have an increase in stroke are those under age 45. And it is a big association: odds ratios from 3 to 12.
The association is most noticeable in the first 24 hours after seeing a chiropractor. Usually if you rip an artery it is symptomatic right away. Again, we do not know if these people had dissection or not. We only know they had stroke of some sort, within a day after seeing a chiropractor. One would predict that if there were an association between chiropractic and stroke you would most easily find it in the young and the effect would be most noticeable in the first day or so after the chiropractic visit.
And this article confirms this association.
Note the word association. Association is not causation. You would need a prospective study comparing stoke rates from chiropractic patients vs non chiropractic patients to find causality.
But if you are less than 45 and visit a chiropractor, there is a strong association between that visit and a stroke in the next 24 hours.
Table 3 has the smoking gun. The highest odds ratio (14) for a stroke is 12, 4 times any other, in the age less than 45 in the first 24 hours after a visit to a chiropractor. And, to give credit where credit is due, they mention this as a key point in the discussion and, in the introduction, note two other studies that show an association between visiting a chiropractor and having a stroke. The risk of stroke is 5 to 6 times in these studies.
Part of what they do is smear the data by taking it out for a month after a visit, diluting the effect of the first 24 hours after visit.
How do the authors deal with this data?
They emphasize in abstract, which is all anyone will read, that there were equal strokes after visits to chiropractic and primary care physicians. They do not bother to mention the increase association in the young until you reach the discussion, which most will not read.
They account for this by suggesting that patients with headache and neck pain, symptoms of an incipient vertebral artery stoke, lead people in equal proportion, to seek care from DC and MD
In other words, they had a stroke in progress at the time they sought care.
The codes used by the chiropractic and primary care physicians for the visit, admittedly inaccurate, were by and large NOT vertebral artery stroke symptoms.
“Neck-related chiropractic visits were identified using diagnostic codes: C01–C06, cervical and cervicothoracic subluxation; C13–C15, multiple site subluxation; C30, cervical sprain/strain; C40, cervical neuritis/ neuralgia; C44, arm neuritis/neuralgia; C50, brachial radiculitis; C51, cervical radiculitis; and C60, headache.
For PCP visits, we included community medicine physicians if they submitted ambulatory fee codes to OHIP. Fee codes for group therapy and signing forms were excluded. Headache or neck pain-related PCP visits were identified using the diagnostic codes: ICD-9307, tension headaches; 346, migraine headaches; 722, intervertebral disc disorders; 780, headache, except tension headache and migraine; 729, ﬁbrositis, myositis and muscular rheumatism; and 847, whiplash, sprain/strain and other traumas associated with neck (These codes include other diagnoses, and we list only those relevant to neck pain or headache)”
Compare these to the symptoms for vertebral artery stroke (from E medicine)
“Ipsilateral facial dysesthesia (pain and numbness) – Most common symptom, Dysarthria or hoarseness (cranial nerves [CN] IX and X), Contralateral loss of pain and temperature sensation in the trunk and limbs, Ipsilateral loss of taste (nucleus and tractus solitarius), Hiccups, Vertigo, Nausea and vomiting, Diplopia or oscillopsia (image movement experienced with head motion), Dysphagia (CN IX and X), Disequilibrium, Unilateral hearing loss, headache”
Beside headache, there is no overlap in symptoms of a vertebral artery stroke and reasons in this study for visiting an MD or DC.
To suggest, based on the codes, that they had a stroke in progress is disingenuous at best (17).
That is a hypothesis they came up with to account for the data. Spin as it were. That hypothesis may be true, but it is not proven by the data. The study was not designed to demonstrate that result. People who do not read the article carefully take this hypothesis, and they call it a plausible hypothesis in the paper, as the conclusions of the data. This unproved hypothesis is emphasized in the abstract as if it were a conclusion from the data. And those that do not read past the abstract repeat it as if it were a valid conclusion from the data.
To repeat: “The increased risks of VBA stroke associated with chiropractic and PCP visits is likely due to patients with headache and neck pain from VBA dissection seeking care before their stroke.” is a hypothesis to account for the data, not the conclusion of the data.
It will take another study to prove or disprove that hypothesis.
My read of the paper is different.
My conclusion, from reading the paper in its entirety, rather than the abstract, is that a population that should not have a stroke, the young, has a marked increase association with stroke 24 hours after visiting a chiropractor and that given the rarity of a vertebral artery dissection as a cause of stroke in the elderly, the elderly is not a group that one could easily find an increase in stroke after chiropractor visit.
To quote the paper:
“We have not ruled out neck manipulation as a potential cause of some VBA strokes. On the other hand, it is unlikely to be a major cause of these rare events. Our results suggest that the association between chiropractic care and VBA stroke found in previous studies is likely explained by presenting symptoms attributable to vertebral artery dissection.”
Note the word major. I agree it is not a major cause of stroke, at least in the elderly. In the young, the highest odds ratio, 12, for a stroke is in the first 24 hours after visiting a chiropractor is twice what has been found in prior studies. As mentioned above, a case control study cannot determine causality, just association.
Given the number of chiropractor visits and the rarity of vertebral artery tear, chiropractic is probably a rare cause of a rare event.
However, given that chiropractic neck manipulation is worthless magical thinking, ANY stroke is one too many.
Less than a movie trailer, this abstract is more like the Superman covers of my youth, where the cover had only glancing resemblance to the story (16).
Go to the website whatstheharm.net and peruse the chiropractic section. It is striking how many young people had a stroke just after having chiropractic neck manipulation. Of course, these are just anecdotes, and the plural of anecdote is anecdotes not data. But wait. Anecdotes are the prime proof for alt med proponents, since evidence usually proves their pet quackery is a crock. Dr Weil calls anecdotes, “uncontrolled clinical observations.” That’s what whatstheharm has: uncontrolled clinical observations that Weil says should have the same weight as clinical trials (15).
Given three studies that now show an increase in the stroke rates in the young after neck manipulation, I would not let a chiropractor come close to my neck.
In real medicine, it takes less data than this to bring a drug under scrutiny to decide if the benefits are worth the potential risks of a therapy. In my own world of infectious diseases, there have been millions of doses of the antibiotic telithromycin given and only a handful of liver failure and death associated with the antibiotic. I would not prescribe this antibiotic unless I had no other options given the potential risks, albeit very small, and this is for a therapy that actually works.
As a slight tangent with some biologic correlates, it should be pointed out that in a good hanging, the victim should not strangle to death (1).
A good hanging should be set up such that there is a fall just far enough so that the first and second vertebral bodies are separated, breaking the neck and quickly killing the victim. You do not want them to fall too far, as the head may come clean off and that is aesthetically unpleasant. Most people who die these days from hanging do not get a ‘good’ hanging; they suffocate at the end of a rope, a particularly gruesome way to die.
The vertebral artery is often damaged in suicidal hanging (2); “The vertebral artery was shown to be injured quite frequently (rupture, intimal tear, sub-intimal hemorrhage), namely in one quarter of all cases, and indeed in more than half taking into account the perivascular bleeding.” This easy injury is in part due to mechanical reasons “The vertebral arteries appear to be particularly susceptible to injury in trauma of the cervical spine because of their close anatomical relationship to the spine” (3).
A passive hanging (no drop) gives about 686 Newton’s of force around the neck for a 70 kg human. In chiropractic, “the mean force of all manual applications (is) 264 Newton’s and the mean force duration (is) 145 milliseconds (8)”. So a chiropractic neck manipulation, for a short period of time, can provide 38% the force of a hanging. And a bad hanging at that.
Neck injuries are not that frequent because the muscles of the neck prevent injury by preventing sudden, disastrous, movement. If you want to increase the chance of injury from relatively minor trauma, have the person relax. If the muscles are relaxed because the person is not expecting the trauma, the chance of injury goes up. It is why whiplash can occur after minor injuries (4). Chiropractors often have their patients relax just before the coup de grace, I mean manipulation, helping to maximize the chance of injury despite having less force applied to the neck than a noose and gravity.
Given the above, to claim that the VBA occurred before the patient had chiropractic neck manipulation is like saying the hanging victim had a broken neck, but it occurred on the steps up to the scaffold.
References and Snide Asides
“Hanging is too good for a man who makes puns; he should be drawn and quoted.”
Fred Allen
(1) evidently in the 1600’s the English, when the hung (hanged?) their prisoners had them suffocate and did not tie their legs to that the ghastly death dance would serve as a deterrent.
(2) Forensic Sci Int. 1984 Aug;25(4):265-75.
Injury of the vertebral artery in suicidal hanging.
(3) Neurosurgery. 1991 Dec;29(6):912-5.
Subintimal dissection of the vertebral artery in subluxation of the cervical spine
(4) And faking an injury to get money.
(5) I will relegate the issues of the author to a footnote, since I want to focus on the content of the article, but if one is judged by the company they keep.….http://www.chirowatch.com/Chiro-strokes/gm080120stroke.html.
(6) Caveat: I am not an epidemiologist nor a statistician. I took and dropped statistics each year I was in college. Not that I was bad at math, my undergrad degree was in physics (this is not bragging, well, yes it is)
So we have, at Good Samaritan Hospital, a bunch of real smart residents, a few of them, such as the resident on my service, are trained in epidemiology and such studies.
Since 3 out of 2 Americans do not understand statistics, and I am one of those people, so I asked one of my residents to help explain the article to me.
(7) Or the soy protein for you vegans.
(8) http://www.aetna.com/cpb/medical/data/100_199/0107.html
(9) Written two weeks before the movie released.
(10) The Who. I know they are old, but they did get the record as the worlds loudest band. My son says Motorhead is louder. I don’t know. Let me know what the worlds loudest band is, it you have a moment.
(11) Elderly. Crap. I’m 51 and I’m now calling those in their 50’s elderly. But then I do have my ARUP card, so I can get cranky any time I want for any reason I want. Damn kids and their tattoos/visible underwear/goatee/boom box. In my day, well, my day was the day of the hippie. I suppose I have nothing, really, to complain about. Pop culture of my youth was worse.
(12) Copyright Paul Harvey, all rights reserved. Do not use without express written approval of Major League Baseball
(13) To give the DC their due, they have a complete discussion of the potential drawbacks of the study in the discussion that includes most of the issues I raise here. But, as mentioned, you have to get past the abstract.
(14) The odds ratio compares whether the probability of an event is the same for two groups. An odds ratio of 1 implies that the event is equally likely in both groups. An odds ratio greater than one implies that the event is more likely in a group. An odds ratio less than one implies that the event is less likely in a group.
(15) This is sarcasm.
(16) Superman never married Lois Lane, at least in the 1970′s.
(17) Or talking out your …. Steve wants us to be upscale. Never mind.
7/19/08 Addendum
Since the initial post, thanks to the comments, I have come up with an alternative hypothesis to account for the data. Like the authors, it is neither proven nor disproved by the data, but I think has more plausibility than their explanation.
There is a baseline number of VBA strokes in a population. When patients have serious symptoms, they tend to preferentially seek care with MD’s rather than alternative providers. The group patients who sought care from their primary providers were indeed having incipient VBA strokes. It is why they went to the doctor.
The other group, who were not having an incipient VBA stroke (suggested by the codes for chiropractor visits) had neck manipulation and VBA strokes were induced in this population to a the rate equal to or exceeding the rate of the PMD group.
The study could be interperted that visits to a chiropractor for neck manipulation induce strokes at a rate equal to or greater than the control population ie those presenting with stroke.
Again: a hypothesis. It explains the data as well as the authors, and with more plausibility when viewed in the light of anatomy and physical forces to the neck, other uncontrolled clinical observations , and prior epidemiologic studies of the association for manipulation and stroke.

Whack em hard/Whack em once and Stroke. On chiropractic induced trauma
Mark Crislip on May 17, 2013
Link
There is no satisfaction in hanging a man who does not object to it.~ George Bernard Shaw
I work in a 5-hospital system and many of us practice at several hospitals. The residents rotate through at least three of the hospitals and the peripatetic nature of health care allows word of curious cases to percolate through the system. My current resident mentioned that there was a case of a vertebral artery dissection in a young female shortly after chiropractic neck manipulation.
Man, that’s awful. Is she doing OK?
Evidently there were no permanent neurologic sequelae. She dodged that bullet. Or perhaps that noose, as I once calculated that the force of a neck crack is about 40% that of hanging by the neck and it has the same pathologic changes if it goes wrong. Every time I see a death in the movie where the neck is twisted to break it, I think chiropractic, although some tolerate it better than others.
I have not written on CNS events related to chiropractic since 2008, although the topic has been covered by Dr. Hall. I still suspect that occasionally there is a perfect storm of bad luck, the forces are perfectly aligned in a susceptible patient and they get an embolic stroke or a vertebral artery tear.It is rare and hard to do. It is very hard to injure people with what the chiropractors refer to as high velocity, low amplitude thrusts. That sounds so much better than whack em hard/whack em once. So the adverse events from a quick partial hanging are rare and proving causality with rare events is not easy.
Many people get the flu vaccine. Many people have heart attacks. A few people will get Guillain–Barré syndrome (GBS). By chance some people will have a heart attack after their vaccine and others will get Guillain–Barré. So did the vaccine cause the heart attack? Or the GBS? Not always a straight forward answer, as the relationship between declining pirate populations and increasing global temperatures demonstrates.
An aphorism we all live by is that association is not causation, although it is, like all aphorisms, lacking in qualifiers. Part of the willingness to assign causality depends in my mind, like much of SBM, upon consideration of prior plausibility.
Some issues are like parachutes. I don’t need extensive trials to realize cause and effect from parachute use and not splatting on the tarmac. Other relationships are more subtle; realizing that azithromycin, in the right situations, increases cardiac deaths. It took an examination of 3 million prescriptions to find that azithromycin leads to 47 to 245 excess cardiac deaths per million prescriptions, depending on the patient risk. There is biologic plausibility, given that some antibiotics can adversely affect the cardiac conduction system. But the average HCW will never give enough prescriptions to kill someone with azithromycin or even recognize it if they did.
In choosing an antibiotic, or any intervention, you have to weigh the risk and benefit from the treatment as well as the risks and benefits of alternative therapies. I am certainly less inclined to give azithromycin to patients with cardiac disease if I have equivalent alternative antibiotics. Since I am aware that I may do harm, even rarely, I need to be circumspect in my use of azithromycin.
As has been the topic of many posts, the efficacy for chiropractic, such as it is, mostly revolves around low back pain. No reason to approach the neck and whack it hard/whack it once. I can find no quality studies that demonstrate efficacy for neck pain. Good studies being those where the treatment is unknown to the patient and provider. Difficult to do in chiropractic, I know. But perhaps possible.
I will take it as written that the benefit from being whacked hard and whacked once to the neck is zero. Those who wish to discuss the issue can refer to other posts. What then is the risk with a neck whacking?
It depends.
Some practitioners consider it a myth and others find no risk
“The 83 chiropractors administered >5 million career upper cervical adjustments without a reported incidence of serious adverse event.”
although rather than complications they had ‘symptomatic reactions (SRs)’:
“Three hundred thirty-eight (31.0%) patients had SRs meeting the accepted definition. Intense SR (NRS ≥8) occurred in 56 patients (5.1%).”
Symptomatic reactions included
“1) neck pain and/or stiffness/soreness, 2) radiating (arm or leg) pain/discomfort, 3) arm or leg weakness, 4) tiredness/fatigue, 5) headache, 6) dizziness/imbalance, 7) nausea/vomiting, 8) ringing in the ears, 9) blurred or impaired vision, 10) confusion or disorientation, 11) depression or anxiety, 12) fainting, 13) low back discomfort/soreness.”
And what are the symptoms of a vertebral artery transient ischemic attack, the most likely effect of whack em hard/whack em once?
“Dizziness, vertigo, headache, vomiting, double vision, loss of vision, ataxia, numbness, and weakness involving structures on both sides of the body are frequent symptoms in patients with vertebrobasilar-artery occlusive disease. The most common signs are limb weakness, gait and limb ataxia, oculomotor palsies, and oropharyngeal dysfunction.”
Anyone besides me worried when comparing and contrasting the two lists? Remember that these are not recognized as worrisome:
“The 83 chiropractors administered >5 million career upper cervical adjustments without a reported incidence of serious adverse event.”
And this is not the only study that reported symptoms that could be due to a transient ischemic attack in the vertebral artery distribution
“Adverse events after any of the first 3 treatments were reported by 56%, and 13% of the study population reported these events to be severe in intensity. The most common adverse events affected the musculoskeletal system or were pain related, whereas symptoms such as tiredness, dizziness, nausea, or ringing in the ears were uncommon (<8%).”
In both series the symptoms were brief and mild in most patients. Like I say, its hard to hurt people. Suggestive and worrisome, especially as the practitioners seem clueless about the potential significance of the symptoms they are apparently inducing. But not a surprise given their lack of real medical training.
I had to snicker when I read “Self-reported recognition of undiagnosed life threatening conditions in chiropractic practice: a random survey.” It was estimated that a chiropractor would see an undiagnosed serious illness every 2.5 years, noting a variety of illnesses covering everything but the disease they may be inducing.
There are case reports of strokes following whack em hard/whack em once. Seems a very reasonable complication to me given what they are doing to the fragile structure in the neck. But just because it seems reasonable does not necessarily follow that it is true.
There was an interesting report where they evaluated all the case reports of stroke that follow whack em hard/whack em once and they note that the quality of the case reports is poor.
They compared the information provided by case reports and used the Bradford-Hill causality criteria as the standard. Most of the case reports did not provide sufficient causality data from a Bradford-Hill perspective. They point out the need for standardized reporting to provide better information, which is a valid point across the medical literature.
They did find 901 cases of CAD (cervical artery dissection) and 707 incidents of stroke reported to be associated with whack em hard/whack em once. They conclude, as chiropractors might,
“As a result, the value of these reports toward informing our understanding of the relation between [cervical spinal manipulation therapy] and CAD is minimal.“
I am not so sure. While the case reports may not be perfect, when you read the individual reports they appear compelling given the potential mechanism of injury. Much closer to a parachute evaluation.
There is also a recent systematic review of stroke from whack em hard/whack em once. Being chiropractors, they are understandably reticent to conclude harm.
“Conclusive evidence is lacking for a strong association between neck manipulation and stroke, but is also absent for no association.”
When I read the Cassidy study, the one most often touted as demonstrating a lack of association between strokes and whack em hard/whack em once, I thought it demonstrated an increase in stroke in the young, the group who should not get a stroke.
I think they found the same result:
“Positive associations, especially with cervical and headache related visits, were only observed for chiropractic patients aged < 45 years, with 25 cases (24.5%) and 27 controls (6.6%) within 7 days for general visits. For headache or cervical visits within 7 days, results in the case–control study were OR crude = 3.11 (95% CI = 1.16–8.35) and accelerated bias corrected bootstrap 95% CI = 1.07–9.60, and for visits within 3 days the case-crossover study gave OR crude = 17.7 (95% CI = 2.04–153.3), bootstrap unavailable. However, for the PCP visits similar associations were observed for patients aged < 45 years and ≥ 45 years. For headache or cervical visits within 7 days for patients aged < 45 years, the case–control study resulted in OR crude = 37.60 (95% CI = 4.80–294), and for within 3 days the case-crossover study yielded OR crude = 28.00 (95% CI = 3.44–227.58), and in both cases the bootstrap was unavailable. Sensitivity analysis resulted in attenuation of the estimates towards the null with lower positive predictive values, but the associations remained positive and significant (data not presented)”
Right? Increased strokes in the young? That is what they are saying? There are those who have questioned my statistical sophistication and I will say that my continued re-reading of the above paragraph proves them right.
But why do the young have more strokes? In a wild flight of fancy they hypothesize it is due to drinking and infection:
“Cassidy et al. used a case-crossover design to correct for the lower health status of PCP patients, but this design is limited in controlling factors that can change rapidly. Binge drinking and acute infection may precipitate occlusive strokes, which are capable of causing severe headache before stroke presentation. If PCP patients are more prone to sporadic binge drinking, and acute infection than chiropractic patients, this could lead to baseline elevation of the PCP visit association for the case-crossover analysis.”
More strokes yeah, the young drink, yeah, and they have more venereal diseases, oh yeah, so, it must be the fact they are drunken and infected. That’s why they had more strokes. Yeah, that’s the ticket.
Weird. Me? I’d have to drink very heavily and have syphilitic dementia before I allowed someone to whack my neck real hard one time.
There may be an opportunity in the future to determine the risk of stroke from whack em hard/whack em once. Many hospitals now have stroke programs where they collect voluminous data about their patients. It would be interesting to graft a questionnaire onto the stroke program evaluation looking for the risk from whack em hard/whack em once and the development of a stroke. There is a research project for someone with the time and expertise.
If you are a preponderance of data kind of gal, as I am (preponderance of data, not a gal) there is more data to support the risk of stroke after whack em hard/whack em once to the neck to give one pause. We get black box warnings for less frequent drug complications. I doubt I will see a journal article entitled “The Myth of Azithromycin Death.” But then, I pay attention to the data and am not invested in an intervention with no basis in reality that offers only harm without benefit. It must be tough if your raison d’etre only causes harm. I kind of feel pity.
Hanging is too good for a man who makes puns; he should be drawn and quoted.~ Fred Allen

Chiropractic Manipulation of the Neck Linked to Stroke in a 6-Year-Old Child…
Clay Jones on June 5, 2015
Link

The risk of suffering a stroke when undergoing aggressive chiropractic manipulation of the neck is not a new concern. We’ve discussed it several times on the pages of Science-Based Medicine over the years, most recently in November of 2014 when Steven Novella covered the death by chiropractor of 30-year-old Jeremy Youngblood, whose fatal brain injury occurred while seeking treatment for a sore neck. For a nice review of cervical manipulation in general, the evidence against its inappropriate use, and an assessment of the literature on this subject, check out prior posts by Dr. Hall and chiropractor Samuel Homola.
I believe that my take on the issue is in line with my fellow SBM authors. There is no role for high velocity, low amplitude (HVLA) thrust-type maneuvers that cause sudden and intense rotation of the neck in any patient, for any reason. It is not effective for neck pain, headache or any other complaint, and it is a proven risk factor for injury to the vertebral arteries and subsequent stroke. Some patients are at higher risk, such as the elderly or those with atherosclerosis or connective tissue disorders, but this type of injury can occur at any age and even in a perfectly healthy individual.
The response from the chiropractic community has largely been to circle the wagons and deny their potential role, even going so far as to claim that people who have already suffered an injury to a vertebral artery (which they don’t appear to be very capable of recognizing) are seeking out chiropractic care for the resulting pain in the neck. They frequently cite the abysmal 2008 Cassidy study as proof that they aren’t to blame. This flawed study doesn’t show what they think it shows, which is an inconvenient fact discussed by Dr. Crislip in this post. There have also been successful efforts by chiropractors to avoid having to even warn patients of the potential risk.
What is clear is that even though the chance of suffering a stroke while being manipulated by a chiropractor is low, cases are likely under reported and many likely go unrecognized. And neck manipulation is one of the most significant risk factors in patients who rarely have strokes, namely the young and healthy. Again, thankfully, these events are uncommon. But considering the lack of benefit, even a small risk is too high.
In pediatric chiropractic, use of the HVLA thrust techniques that have been linked to stroke is less common. Many chiropractors even work possible parental anxiety into their shtick, specifically pointing out how gentle their manipulations are. This video demonstrates a non-forceful neck adjustment, naturally performed after hanging a 12-week-old infant upside down by her feet, in order to cure her colic, help her make more cells, and improve her ability to talk to her parents. I particularly love the disclaimer shown as the child dangles. Also, according to the chiropractor, “God doesn’t need assistance, he just needs no interference.” Isn’t that assistance?
These “no crack” chiropractors will often use an Activator, a spring loaded device that does nothing other than make a clicking sound and a soft impact against the skin. I can say that they are very unimpressive, having had the opportunity to play with one while following a chiropractor around for a day back in residency. I’ll never forget how, after Dr. Brown regaled me with a “pro-education” stance on vaccines that amounted to simply giving patients handouts about exaggerated vaccine risks, his wife whispered in my ear that she makes sure their kids are vaccinated.
Despite this trend, many children are still subjected to high velocity thrust techniques involving the neck. A quick search online reveals numerous videos of such adjustments on young children, even infants, for reasons such as colic, neck pain after a car accident, and frequent colds. At 1:43 in this video, 2-year-old Olivia clearly experiences pain when her neck is adjusted forcibly to treat stubborn chest congestion.
Last April, a case report involving severe arm weakness in a child was published that I can’t believe I missed. Pediatric neurologist Dr. Stephen Deputy, who I actually spent some time with on a rotation while in medical school at LSU in New Orleans, reported on a six-year-old boy that presented to his clinic with a six month history of weakness in his left arm. According to Deputy, the patient had been on his way to see a medical doctor for a suspected sinus infection when his grandfather instead brought him to a chiropractor where he underwent “some degree of spinal manipulation.”
The child was first noted to have complaints of numbness and tingling, known as paresthesia, in his left arm the following night. He went on to develop weakness in that arm which led the family to seek medical care a few days later. No obvious cause was discovered at that visit.
His symptoms did not resolve, and he was eventually admitted to a local hospital for evaluation after another week had passed. During his hospitalization, based on his clinical picture and limited neuroimaging he was given a presumptive diagnosis of acute transverse myelitis and started on a long course of steroids. This is an extremely rare inflammatory process involving the spinal cord that can cause weakness and paresthesias in addition to bowel and bladder dysfunction and more serious neurological injury, although having isolated symptoms in just one extremity like this would be an atypical presentation. Also, lab evaluation of his spinal fluid was inconsistent with an inflammatory condition.
At the time the patient was seen by Dr. Deputy, there had been no improvement despite the course of steroids and six months of physical therapy. This is also unusual in cases of transverse myelitis, which almost always improve considerably if not fully resolve. He was found to have significant loss of muscle in the involved extremity, complete loss of strength in several muscles of the shoulder and arm, and at least some degree of weakness in the rest of them. He also had complete loss of normal tendon reflexes in the left biceps and triceps and diminished reflexes in the other muscles. Finally, nerve conduction studies and electromyography were consistent with a pure motor neuronopathy of the fifth cervical through the first thoracic spinal nerves.
So, considering the timing of the patient’s onset of symptoms within 36 hours of having his neck adjusted by a chiropractor, and the rarity of transverse myelitis, Deputy was appropriately skeptical of the diagnosis. Add the soft clinical findings for that condition and inconsistent spinal fluid studies, as well as the finding of a pure neuronopathy of C5-T1 on EMG, and he was probably sold. But he was also able to compare MRI images of his patient’s spinal cord with those of a young woman who suffered a proven vertebral artery dissection and found them to be identical. That allowed him to more confidently conclude that the culprit was “vascular compromise to the vertebral arteries resulting in anterior (spinal) cord ischemia” rather than an inflammatory disease.
Healthy children, with very rare exceptions, do not spontaneously suffer a stroke. There are conditions, such as congenital heart defects and hematologic abnormalities like sickle cell disease, that do predispose some children. Most cases of pediatric stroke occur in children with known risk factors or who have been diagnosed with an acute illness that increases their risk. Unfortunately, because of the uncommon occurrence of stroke in children, the diagnosis is often delayed, sometimes for months, as it likely was in this case.
Trauma to the neck is a well-known cause of pediatric stroke, and HVLA chiropractic manipulation certainly falls into that category. The patient in question was brought to a chiropractor for treatment of suspected sinusitis, a condition for which there is no plausible connection with the position of the vertebral bodies or the function of spinal nerves. The only evidence supporting any chiropractic technique for the treatment of sinusitis is anecdotal.
A lack of legitimate evidence hasn’t slowed them down unfortunately, as shown in this video of a chiropractor who believes that rubbing his hands along the cheekbones will help drain the maxillary sinus. This is utter nonsense but at least he didn’t adjust the patient’s neck. This chiropractor does, however, and appears to gloat about how much pain he can inflict and how loud a crack he can cause when jerking a patient’s neck. Watching the entire video certainly caused me a great deal of pain.
I can’t say with certainty that the child in Dr. Deputy’s case report had a vertebral artery dissection during chiropractic care. Imaging of the blood vessels of the neck was eventually ordered, but enough time had passed that the negative results couldn’t rule anything out. But given what we know about the risk of this type of injury in general, and the specifics of this case, it is definitely the most likely etiology of the patient’s symptoms.
The bottom line is that you should never let a chiropractor, or anyone else for that matter, perform high velocity neck manipulation on yourself or your children. The evidence is clear that this type of adjustment is not more effective than safer options for neck pain, and the evidence is nonexistent when it comes to indications, like sinusitis, that have no plausible connection to the spine. This particular child could have been paralyzed or even killed. Instead, he will only have substantially diminished function in his left arm, although I doubt that fact will be much consolation.

Stroke Death from Chiropractic Neck Manipulation
Chiropractors claim neck manipulation is safe. Evidence suggests otherwise.
Steven Novella on November 12, 2014
Link

Case reports are perhaps the weakest form of medical evidence. They are essentially well-documented anecdotes. They do serve a useful purpose, however: they can illuminate possible correlations, the natural course of illness and treatment, and serve as cautionary tales regarding possible mistakes, risks and complications. I say “possible” because they are useful mainly for generating hypotheses and not testing or confirming hypotheses.
Dramatic case reports, however, with objective outcomes, like death, can be very useful by themselves in pointing out a potential risk that should be avoided. For example, case reports of objective and severe adverse outcomes are often used as sufficient evidence for pulling approved drugs off the market, or at least adding black box warnings.
The chiropractic community, it seems, does not respond in a similar way to dramatic adverse events that suggest possible risk from chiropractic manipulation. A recent and unfortunate case raises once again the specter of stroke following chiropractic neck manipulation. Jeremy Youngblood was 30 years old, completely healthy, and saw his chiropractic for some neck pain. According to news reports, Jeremy suffered a stroke in his chiropractor’s office while being treated with neck manipulation for the neck pain. According to reports the chiropractor did not call 911, but instead called Jeremy’s father who had to come and pick him up and then bring him to the ER. Jeremy suffered from a major stroke and later died.
According to his death certificate, which includes the findings of his autopsy:
I. Hemorrhagic infarction of cerebellum, mainly inferior surface, right, with obstructive hydrocephalus at the level of the 4th ventricleA. Status post right posterior/inferior cerbellar artery embolism with distal right vertebral right artery dissection at the skull base in C-1B. Status post being coiled with a 6 mm x 20 mm Azure coil (x2), (status post coil embolisation of right vertebral artery)C. Diffuse cerebral edema (weight 1600 gm)D. Status post chiropractic manipulation of neck
A dissection is a tear in the artery. This tear can then result in the formation of a blood clot which can block flow through the artery or dislodge and plug a more distal artery, either way causing a stroke. In this case Jeremy had a stroke in the cerebellum, which is in the back of the brain just above the brainstem. The stroke also bled. This is a very dangerous situation, as swelling can damage the brainstem, and in Jeremy’s case also blocked the flow of cerebrospinal fluid out of the brain, leading to a further increase in pressure. This situation is often, and in this case was, fatal.
This is not an isolated case. There are other reports of patients having strokes right in their chiropractor’s office. There are now also several studies showing an association between chiropractic neck manipulation and vertebral dissection. The evidence is sufficiently concerning that the American Heart Association and the American Stroke Association recently came out with a statement which concluded:
Clinical reports suggest that mechanical forces play a role in a considerable number of CDs [cervical dissection], and population controlled studies have found an association of unclear etiology between CMT [cervical manipulative therapy] and VAD [vertebral artery dissection] stroke in young patients. Although the incidence of CD in CMT patients is probably low, and causality difficult to prove, practitioners should both strongly consider the possibility of CD and inform patients of the statistical association between CD and CMT, prior to performing manipulation of the cervical spine.
What they are saying is that there is sufficient evidence to be concerned that CMT can cause a dissection in a young patient resulting in a catastrophic stroke, even death. While the overall risk of this occurring is probably low, at the very least practitioners should obtain informed consent and disclose this risk before performing CMT. We have not had the kind of definitive controlled trials to prove that the neck manipulation is causing the dissection because it is possible that the neck pain itself was caused by the dissection which occurred before the CMT. It seems unlikely, however, that this explains every case, as with this one, in which the stroke occurs in the chiropractors office. Even if the dissection was pre-existing, that would be a contraindication to manipulation, which can turn a dissection into a stroke by making it worse or dislodging a clot.
I would go much farther than the AHA/ASA statement. In medicine we must consider the risk vs benefit of every decision and intervention. In this case there is no evidence the CMT is of any therapeutic value for neck pain, headache, or any indication. A systematic review of the evidence concludes:
Done alone, manipulation and/or mobilization were not beneficial; when compared to one another, neither was superior.
There are many gentler alternatives for neck pain, such as exercise, moist heat, or gentle massage. No matter how you look at it, there is no justification for chiropractic manipulation of the neck. Any risk is not justified when there is insufficient evidence to support efficacy and when there are safer options available. In this case the risk may be rare, but the adverse events are catastrophic — stroke or death in otherwise-young, healthy people.
If CMT were a drug, it would have been pulled off the market. If it were a common medical procedure, there would be more studies exploring the risk and more definitively answering the question of safety and efficacy. The response of the chiropractic community to the issue of neck manipulation and stroke, however, is denial and diversion. According to a KFOR article reporting Youngblood’s death:
Chris Waddell is the President of the Oklahoma Board of Chiropractic Examiners. He says their work speaks for itself.
“I think if the benefits weren’t there, people wouldn’t utilize our services. They know what works and what doesn’t,” Waddell said.
Wadell says data doesn’t back up the idea that visits to the chiropractor can kill.
The data he’s referring to is the Cassidy Study, which was done in Canada years ago.
“We found no evidence of excess risk of VBA stroke associated chiropractic care compared to primary care,” the report states. “For those 45 years of age and older there was no association.”
The notion that patients know what works is a common defense of alternative practitioners, or anyone using a treatment that is scientifically dubious. The claim is that patients would not seek out a treatment unless it actually works. This is demonstrably untrue, however. History is full of examples of worthless and even harmful interventions that were popular. Placebo effects are sufficient to explain the popularity of a worthless treatment.
Waddell also refers to the Cassidy study, which was a scientifically terrible study (as Mark Crislip explains here). This is a good example of cherry picking low grade evidence in favor of better or more comprehensive evidence. As the quote above indicates, the Cassidy study found no association with those 45 years and older. The study, however, looked at all strokes, not just those associated with arterial dissection. Also, by looking at the older population, any signal of association with chiropractic manipulation would be statistically drowned out by the far more common causes of stroke in the older population. The Cassidy study is essentially useless, but chiropractors love it because it gives them the cover they seek.
In another study, only vertebrobasilar strokes were examined, in those <45 years old. They found that patients with such strokes were 5 times more likely to have visited a chiropractor in the last week than a control population.
The Oklahoma Chiropractic Association also put out this statement:
The Oklahoma Chiropractors Association wishes to express its deepest condolences to the family of Jeremy Youngblood. The loss or harm of any patient is a very disturbing circumstance that medical professionals have struggled with throughout history. Unfortunately, there is no single form of medical care without risks.
Oklahoma Chiropractors are proud to provide thousands of Oklahoman’s drug free medical care daily. The safety of chiropractic care is evident by the lowest medical malpractice insurance rates of any licensed medical profession.
This is another piece of masterful denial and diversion. First they depersonalize this case – harm happens, no intervention is without risk. Then they tout the safety of chiropractic overall. Of course it is easy to claim safety when you ignore or deny risk. The issue here is relative risk vs benefit. There is a serious claim being made by healthcare professionals and organizations, based on existing evidence, that chiropractic neck manipulation carries risk that is not justified by the benefit.
Conclusion: there should be a moratorium on neck manipulation
The chiropractic profession has a responsibility to deal with this issue in a way that is best for their patients, not their profession. In my opinion the current evidence supports the following measures:
    • Call an immediate moratorium on neck manipulation for any indication.
That’s it, actually. I don’t see how any other reaction would be appropriate. However, short of simply abandoning this procedure, other measures would at least be helpful:
    • At least end the most forceful types of high cervical manipulation.
    • Gentler forms of manipulation should be carefully studied for safety and efficacy with rigorously-designed trials capable of detecting adverse events.
    • Require informed consent by patients prior to any neck manipulation. The consent should fully inform patients about the risks of dissection and stroke.
    • Chiropractic organizations should publish standard of care guidelines that are strictly evidence-based and that err on the side of patient safety and minimizing harm.

Chiropractic and Stroke: The question is not answered
Mark Crislip on June 26, 2015
Link


I am off to Chicago for 5 days to wow the SMACC crowd with my ID/SBM acumen. I hope. Given that most of my multiple-personalities do not seem to be able to get any work done, I am forced to write a brief post this week, limited by the battery life on my MacBook Air. Whatever I get down on paper? pixels? RAM? before the battery dies as I fly over the Rockies will be the post. It is times like this I wish I had Gorskian typing skills.
SBM has discussed the many limitations of chiropractic: the low grades for entry into chiropractic school, the inadequate training, their reason d’être, subluxations and their adjustments being divorced from reality, the lack of efficacy of chiropractic for any process beyond low back pain (and even that is no better than safer interventions), the fondness of chiropractors for other useless pseudo-medicines, and their opposition to vaccines.
Hm. When I put it like that chiropractic does appear a little sketchy. But is chiropractic safe? It is a hands-on intervention, for a brief period of time applying the same force to the neck as about 40% of hanging from the neck until dead. So there is certainly the potential for chiropractic to cause harm. 
30-plus years in medicine have only reinforced the concept that under the right conditions, a perfect storm, even the most benign of interventions can kill. As an intern I had a patient whose IV, placed for an acute heart attack, became infected with S. aureus that went to her aortic valve that rapidly blew out and she died. There is always the potential of medical equivalent of Because a Little Bug Went Ka-Choo!
Can chiropractic care cause a stroke? No, because chiropractic care covers a lot of interventions, from the realigning nonexistent subluxations to the über-silliness of applied kinesiology and more.
Does neck manipulation, the high velocity, low frequency, amplitude (got the science-y terminology wrong the first time. Got to make sure the lipstick is correctly applied to the pig) neck snap of a brief hanging, lead to occasional stroke? Now that is the question.
Chiropractors love to point to the Cassidy study as the be-all and end-all evidence that neck manipulation does not cause stoke. It is the poster child for chiropractic motivated reasoning.
A careful reading, such I as did previously, suggests that the Cassidy study points to an increase risk for stroke following chiropractic, especially in the young. It was a flawed study, but if you are a chiropractor who doesn’t read carefully or beyond the abstract, you might think the paper supports the safety of chiropractic.
The authors of “Chiropractic care and the risk of vertebrobasilar stroke: results of a case–control study in U.S. commercial and Medicare Advantage populations” also admire the Cassidy study:
The work by Cassidy, et al. [32] has been qualitatively appraised as one of the most robustly designed investigations of the association between chiropractic manipulative treatment and VBA stroke
Which says something about the quality of the chiropractic literature and the safety of neck manipulation. But the study was done in Canada. What we really need is to reproduce the same lousy study in the US.
The paper looked at stoke 30 days following a PCP visit or a chiropractic visit for neck pain and found no difference in stroke:
Among the commercially insured, 1.6% of stroke cases had visited chiropractors within 30 days of being admitted to the hospital, as compared to 1.3% of controls visiting chiropractors within 30 days prior to their index date. Of the stroke cases, 18.9% had visited a PCP within 30 days prior to their index date, while only 6.8% of controls had visited a PCP
Which really says nothing. There is no information about why those who had a stroke were visiting either provider.
We do not know which patients had neck manipulation or even spinal manipulative therapy (SMT) since:
Less than 70% of stroke cases (commercial and MA) associated with chiropractic care included SMT.
Also:
There were statistically significant differences (p = <0.05) between groups for most comorbidities.
So it would appear that the two populations were not even remotely comparable.
Unlike Cassidy et al. and most other case–control studies our results showed there was no significant association between VBA stroke and chiropractic visits. This was the case for both the commercial and MA populations. In contrast to two earlier case–control studies, this lack of association was found to be irrespective of age. Although, our results (Table 8) did lend credence to previous reports that VBA stroke occurs more frequently in patients under the age of 45 years.
As the authors note:
Our results add weight to the view that chiropractic care is an unlikely cause of VBA strokes.
A conclusion based on comparing different populations whose intervention is uncertain. That is a “robustly designed investigation”? Perhaps chiropractic care is safe but how about neck manipulation? They are not the same thing. It is a fine point distinguishing between chiropractic care and neck manipulation, one that the authors recognize:
However, the current study does not exclude cervical manipulation as a possible cause or contributory factor in the occurrence of VBA stroke.
It is not death row care that matters, but that short drop through the trap door at the end. I suspect that the chiropractic organizations will fail to recognize this distinction.
I can’t see where the paper adds any information about the safety of chiropractic neck manipulation and will stick with the preponderance of data and the AHA/ASA Guideline.
But it does add FUD and I am sure there will be no end of blog entries trumpeting the paper and declaring that chiropractic is safe. It would appear that the approach to patient safety by chiropractors is embrace the good, yet flawed studies and rationalize away the bad, and who cares about patient safety when their subluxations need a fixin’.
The striking thing about chiropractic, and SCAM in general, is the aggressive denial that their interventions could and do cause harm, and the unwillingness to alter or abandon practices for increased patient safety.
Chiropractic advocates, and SCAM apologists in general, do love to mention the harm caused by NSAIDS or the deaths due to medications.
I have sat on hospital Quality Councils for 25 years as well as chaired my hospital’s infection control programs. I can proudly point to an enormous amount of work in that time to slowly drive down infections, morbidity and mortality. My hospitals are markedly safer than they were 25 years ago. This has occurred because we recognize that our interventions can harm and continually refine practice to minimize those risks. And because we apply the medical literature, always erring on the side of patient safety.
There still remains only one quality intervention to improve patient care in the entire SCAM universe, using sterile acupuncture needles, and the practice of acupuncture renders that intervention useless. Gloves are not high on their to-do list.
There are, to the best of my ability to locate, no other examples of SCAM practice being modified or abandoned due to evidence of harm.
And of course harm has to be balanced with efficacy. The first rule of medicine is not “do no harm.” Any and all interventions can harm. The first rule should be “on balance the good should outweigh the harm.” Chiropractic fails on that measure as well, since the benefit is negligible, applies only to low back pain, and is no better than safer interventions.
We do need better data. Many hospitals have stroke programs to maximize care for patients with stroke. When I last asked, the programs do not enquire into recent neck manipulation. Some clever epidemiologist needs to leverage information from all the stoke programs to help determine what the real risk of a brief hanging is.
And the pilot has let us know it is time to shut things down for landing. This is as good as it is going to get.

   Chiropractic and Stroke
Harriet Hall
Link
I wonder how many people have heard that chiropractic neck adjustments can cause strokes. It isn’t exactly common knowledge. One organization is trying to raise public awareness through signs on the side of city buses (Injured by a Chiropractor? Call this number) and through TV commercials. I had never heard about this phenomenon myself until a few years ago, when I heard it mentioned on an episode of Alan Alda’s Scientific American Frontiers. I questioned his accuracy, but I quickly found confirmation in the medical literature.
A typical case was that of 24 year old Kristi Bedenbaugh who saw her chiropractor for sinus headaches. During a neck manipulation she suffered a brain stem stroke and she died three days later. Autopsy revealed that the manipulation had split the inside walls of both of her vertebral arteries, causing the walls to balloon and block the blood supply to the lower part of her brain. Additional studies concluded that blood clots had formed on the days the manipulation took place. The chiropractor later paid a $1000 fine.
The two vertebral arteries run straight up the back of the neck passing through holes in the sides of each neck vertebra. When the head turns, the “tethered” artery is drastically kinked: 
Because of this kinking, it is particularly susceptible to injury. Even a simple thing like extending the neck back over the basin for hair washing at the beauty salon has been known to cause a stroke. The artery is elastic, but with hardening of the arteries, with cholesterol plaques, with trauma (like automobile accidents) or simply with rapid stretching, the delicate lining of the artery can tear. It is easy to imagine how a rapid, forceful thrust by a chiropractor could cause damage.
Sometimes the damage is immediate and the patient collapses on the chiropractor’s table. Sometimes mild symptoms start immediately and progress after the patient leaves the chiropractor’s office. Sometimes the tear is a small one and it clots over; then days later the clot breaks loose, travels to the brain and causes a delayed stroke. By this time, the patient may not connect his sudden collapse to the previous visit to the chiropractor.
Chiropractors are well aware of the risk. They discuss it in their journals and online forums. They have tried to find ways to screen patients for high risk, but there is no reliable way to do so. Strokes are a major reason for chiropractic malpractice insurance payouts – 9% of claims paid by the major chiropractic insurer in 2002, the only year for which I was able to find statistics. Some chiropractors are now asking patients to sign an informed consent form before manipulations. If asked, most chiropractors downplay the risk, saying it occurs in less than one in a million manipulations. Many (perhaps most) chiropractors do not mention the risk at all.
Most alarming: some chiropractors perform these neck adjustments with no warning and without permission. I met a woman who still walks with a limp and has other residual impairments from a chiropractic stroke. She went to her chiropractor for a shoulder problem and thought he was going to massage her shoulder muscles. She did not want him to manipulate her neck, did not give him permission, and didn’t realize what he was doing until he suddenly twisted her neck. She collapsed on the table and nearly died.
How often can a stroke be attributed to neck manipulation? We really don’t know. Estimates have varied from one in ten million manipulations to one in 40,000. I should clarify that only one specific type of stroke, basilar stroke, has been linked to chiropractic. It has been estimated that about 20% of all basilar strokes are due to spinal manipulations. This would work out to about 1300 a year in the U.S. But we just don’t know, because it has not been properly studied. Carotid artery strokes have also been reported after chiropractic treatments. Chiropractors do not follow up on every patient. Patients who have delayed strokes may never see their chiropractor again, so chiropractors would naturally tend to underestimate the risk. Many of these diagnoses are missed because the vertebral arteries are not typically examined on autopsy.
One study of patients under the age of 45 who had this kind of stroke showed that they were 5 times more likely to have visited a chiropractor in the preceding week than control patients. In the past, neurologists treating stroke patients simply did not ask patients about chiropractic; and when they started asking, they started finding. There have been deaths. There have been court cases. In 2002, a group of Canadian neurologists issued a statement of concern to the public, recommending vigilance, education, informed consent, and other measures to protect the public. Awareness is rising, and injured patients have formed organizations in the US, Canada, and the UK both for support and for litigation.
Defensive chiropractors have tried to counteract the growing body of evidence with studies like this one, which concluded that “SMT [Spinal Manipulation Therapy] resulted in strains to the VA [Vertebral Artery] that were almost an order of magnitude lower than the strains required to mechanically disrupt it. We conclude that under normal circumstances, a single typical (high-velocity/low amplitude) SMT thrust is very unlikely to mechanically disrupt the VA.” That’s certainly true. It is unlikely. Under normal circumstances. But it does happen.
They tell us that the stroke would have happened anyway. Maybe. We don’t have any way of knowing. But when the patient collapses immediately after the neck is twisted, I think we can say the stroke wouldn’t have happened at that time without the manipulation. Given a choice of sooner or later, later is good.
They tell us that other treatments for neck pain, like NSAIDs, also carry dangers. Patients have developed bleeding ulcers and died from taking aspirin. That’s very true, but they are invoking the logical fallacy known as tu quoque: just because something else is dangerous too, that doesn’t make neck manipulation any less dangerous. And comparing the dangers of two treatments doesn’t mean there aren’t other options that are safer than either of them.
Until really good studies are done, we simply don’t know the magnitude of the risk; but we are reasonably confident there is a risk. Now, let’s measure that risk against the benefits. Some chiropractors are doing neck adjustments on 90% of their patients for everything from ear infections to low back pain. There are lots of testimonials, but no POEMS (patient-oriented evidence that matters) and no evidence of any long-term benefit or any advantage over other treatments. The only thing neck manipulations have been shown to help with is mechanical neck pain, and a recent Cochrane review did not find that manipulation was any better than simple mobilization treatments. If there is no benefit, isn’t any degree of risk too much?
There are plenty of other options for treating mechanical neck pain for those who prefer not to take pain pills. The cervical spine can be gently mobilized with physical therapy methods that have not been linked to stroke. Heat, massage, tincture of time, exercises and other measures may offer symptomatic relief with no associated risks.
“Don’t ever let a chiropractor touch your neck “is the safest advice; but we can’t expect everyone to accept it. Some patients have had good experiences with neck manipulations and will continue to ask for them. We can’t presume to dictate to others. If someone judges that there is a one in a million risk of a stroke and is willing to take that risk, he has every right to do so. I think people have the right to engage in risky behaviors like skydiving and smoking cigarettes. I just think they deserve to know there is a risk, and to have some idea how much of a risk it is. I suspect the general public doesn’t know the facts about neck manipulation.
I wonder if Laurie Jean Mathiason knew neck manipulations could cause strokes. This 20 year old girl had a tailbone injury and sought out a chiropractor who manipulated her neck. Yes, her neck – to fix her tailbone! She fell into a coma and died three days later. Her visit to the chiropractor might qualify her for a Darwin Award. In my opinion, it qualifies as a tragedy and a crime.

Chiropractic Strokes Again: An Update
It’s depressing that we have to keep revisiting the topic of stroke after chiropractic neck manipulation.
Harriet Hall on August 14, 2012
Link
The risk of stroke with neck manipulation has been addressed on SBM before by Dr. Crislip, by myself, by chiropractor Samuel Homola, and by Jann Bellamy. I have listed the links at the end of this article for the convenience of interested readers. Recent studies merit a followup.
A case report published in the Annals of Internal Medicine July 17, 2012, describes a 37 year old nurse who had a history of chronic neck pain. She had been getting neck manipulations from her chiropractor once a month for 12-15 years! (One can only conclude that the manipulations had not accomplished much.) She developed a new symptom (pain when turning her head up and to the right), and at her 4th visit in a week, during neck manipulation, she heard a loud pop and immediately had the sensation that the room was spinning. She developed visual disturbances, vomited, and had a loss of balance, persistently falling to the left. The chiropractor failed to recognize her symptoms as signs of a stroke. Instead of rushing her to the ER, he performed an “occipital adjustment” in an attempt to relieve her symptoms. She went to the ER 1.5 hours after the event and was found to have a cervical artery dissection. She was discharged from the hospital after 48 hours but has residual symptoms. The authors’ conclusion:
Although incidence of cervical artery dissection precipitated by chiropractic neck manipulation is unknown, it is an important risk. Given that risk, physical therapy exercises may be a safer option than spinal manipulation for patients with neck pain.

Another case report published in the Journal of Neuroimaging on July 20, 2012, describes a 63 year old man with a history of surgery for carotid artery disease who sought chiropractic care for neck pain. He developed clumsiness in one hand with impaired touch sensation shortly after neck manipulation. Diagnostic studies revealed an acute ischemic stroke that was attributed to an embolus from disruption of carotid artery calcifications. They concluded that it suggested a causal association, especially in the absence of any other predisposing events. They recommended that patients with extensive carotid artery calcifications be advised against neck manipulations.In December 2011 a study appeared in the Journal of Neurosurgery under the title “Craniocervical arterial dissections as sequelae of chiropractic manipulation: patterns of injury and management.” It used a database of patients with endovascular disease to identify 13 patients who experienced cervical artery dissections following neck manipulation. It begins with a review of the literature with a long list of references supporting a causal association between high-velocity, low amplitude (HVLA) maneuvers and strokes. It describes a probable mechanism: a tear is produced in the artery wall (a dissection) and either a clot is propagated from the area of dissection or the dissection narrows the artery enough to impair blood flow.
The treatment of choice for these arterial injuries has been anticoagulation therapy. Because of the severity of the dissections in some of their patients, these authors used a more aggressive approach with stent placement and craniotomy to relieve brainstem compression. They describe the outcomes.
They describe two of their cases in detail. One, a 30 year old man, noted pain immediately after neck manipulation. He had a dissection that almost completely obstructed a neck artery. After a complicated hospital course and rehabilitation, he has residual paralysis and difficulty with speech, is unable to work, and depends on his wife for care.
In another case, a 54-year-old presented the day after neck manipulation with headache, incoordination, and difficulty walking. After intensive treatment for arterial dissection and thrombosis, he recovered completely.
Of 13 patients in their series, 9 recovered completely, 3 were permanently disabled, and one died.
They go on to point out:
Patients often visit the chiropractor complaining of head or neck pain, and a certain percentage may have preexisting arterial dissections. Nonetheless, as demonstrated in this series, patients can present within hours to days of chiropractic manipulation with new objective neurological deficits or more severe neurologic complaints. This temporal relationship suggests that either the arterial injury was produced de novo or made worse as a result of manipulation. Worsening of the patient’s complaint or the manifestation of a new neurological deficit after cervical manipulation should prompt urgent medical evaluation.
This undermines the speculations of the Cassidy study, which is often cited by chiropractic apologists. It argued that strokes are not caused by chiropractors but that a stroke is already in progress and is causing neck pain and that is the reason patients consult a chiropractor. Dr. Crislip did a good job of demolishing that study.
Chiropractors always object to being singled out because the culprit is neck manipulation and that is also practiced by other providers. Nevertheless, chiropractors perform the vast majority of neck manipulations and have claimed manipulation therapy as their raison d’etre. In every case in these new articles, the manipulation was performed by a chiropractor. And in at least one case, the chiropractor was clearly negligent: he failed to recognize stroke symptoms as an emergency and tried to treat the symptoms with more manipulation.
In an earlier study, patients under 45 who suffered a vertebrobasilar stroke were 5 times more likely than controls to have had neck manipulations in the previous week. The actual magnitude of the risk is impossible to quantify, and perceptions differ. There is reason to believe that many cases are not recognized or reported. Typically, a single chiropractor was aware of each case of manipulation-related dissection while 3-4 neurologists were involved in the patient’s treatment. 1 out of every 48 chiropractors and 1 of 2 neurologists were aware of a case over their lifetime.Despite some loud protestations, chiropractors do acknowledge the risk. Provocative testing before cervical manipulation is widely recommended in the chiropractic literature. The validity of such testing is questionable, and at any rate the HVLA maneuver is not part of the provocative test and it is the likely culprit. Regardless of the magnitude of risk, the existence of a risk is undeniable and patients should know there is a risk before they agree to treatment. The Association of Chiropractic Colleges suggests informed consent but does not mandate it. Even knowing about the risk won’t protect patients entirely. I know of one case where a patient fully intended to avoid neck manipulation, yet the chiropractor manipulated her neck without any warning and she suffered an immediate stroke on the table. And there wasn’t even any indication for neck manipulation: she was being treated for shoulder pain, not neck pain.
It’s been said before, but I’ll say it again: any degree of risk is unacceptable when there is no benefit. A Cochrane systematic review has shown that HVLA manipulations are no more effective for neck pain than gentle mobilization and that neither is effective unless used in conjunction with an exercise program. And there is even less evidence for benefit in non-neck-related conditions. NUCCA practitioners and other chiropractors who manipulate necks for almost any complaint are clearly out of line.
Related SBM articles
    • Chiropractic and Stroke (Hall)
    • Chiropractic Strokes Again! A Landmark Lawsuit in Canada (Hall)
    • Chiropractic’s Pathetic Response to Stroke Concerns (Hall)
    • Adverse Effects of Chiropractic (Hall)
    • Chiropractic and Stroke: Evaluation of One Paper (Crislip)
    • Not to worry! Chiropractic Board says stroke not a risk of cervical manipulation (Bellamy)
    • NCCAM manipulates spinal manipulation (Bellamy)
    • Neck Manipulation: Risk vs. Benefit (Homola)
And there’s more chiropractic posts listed on SBM’s Chiropractic page.

   Chiropractic’s Pathetic Response to Stroke Concerns
Harriet Hall
Link
The chiropractic industry must be feeling the pressure. Billboards, signs on the sides of buses, chiropractic victims’ organizations, and lawsuits are telling the world that chiropractic neck adjustments can cause strokes. The risk is very small, but it is very real. We have addressed the subject before on this blog here, here, and here.
Chiropractors are in denial and are trying to shift the blame elsewhere. A correspondent sent me copies of a pamphlet and a “distribution kit” that the FCER (Foundation for Chiropractic Education and Research) is selling to chiropractors so they can inform the public about cervical artery dissection (CAD). It is advertised as a campaign to help the public recognize warning signs of stroke; but in my opinion, it amounts to a cynical, self-serving ploy to divert attention away from neck manipulation and to spread biased information about the recent study in Spine by Cassidy et al.
Dr. Crislip has already eviscerated the Cassidy study so I will only describe it briefly here. It compared patients who had had a vertebral artery stroke to controls and looked at health billing records to see if they had visited a doctor or a chiropractor in the previous year. Patients with strokes were more likely than controls to have seen a provider but they were not more likely to have seen a chiropractor than to have seen a doctor before their hospitalization. They concluded “The increased risks of VBA [vertebrobasilar artery] stroke associated with chiropractic and PCP [primary care provider] visits is likely due to patients with headache and neck pain from VBA dissection seeking care before their stroke.” This is nothing but speculation and is not supported in any way by the data in the study.
The Cassidy study did not even try to determine whether patients who saw chiropractors had their necks manipulated. It was not designed to answer the real question: whether rapid thrust neck adjustments can cause strokes in patients who would not otherwise have strokes. The answer to that question is clearly “yes.” We have plenty of “smoking gun” case reports of patients who had no symptoms of stroke until their neck was rapidly manipulated by a chiropractor and who were subsequently found to have tears in the vertebral artery, often bilaterally. There is a plausible mechanism related to the anatomy and the way the artery is tethered between two bony restrictions and stretched by rotation/extension. When a healthy asymptomatic young person collapses on the chiropractor’s table immediately after a neck adjustment and is found to have torn arteries, there can be little doubt about what happened.
It is likely that chiropractic strokes are under-reported: Sandra Nette’s class action suit is being joined by victims who had not previously reported their experiences, and one of my neighbors recently had a mild stroke after a chiropractic neck adjustment and will never see a chiropractor again but he did not sue and his case was not reported in any medical journal. I don’t think he even went back to tell the chiropractor what had happened.
The FCER kit includes a patient template letter, an attorney template, an MD template, and a media release template designed to be personalized with the individual chiropractor’s name and printed on his letterhead and sent out with a copy of the pamphlet. They say the chiropractic profession [sic] is trying to reduce the incidence of stroke from treatment by educating practitioners and patients about the warning signs of CAD and that both medical and chiropractic treatment (spread the blame!) of neck and head pain “can make the problem worse” when those symptoms are present.
They are logically inconsistent: they say they are trying to reduce the incidence of stroke “from treatment,” but at the same time they are saying a vertebral artery dissection (essentially a stroke in progress) was already present before treatment and symptoms of head and neck pain from stroke were the reason patients sought treatment. They seem to be admitting that neck adjustments can cause strokes but at the same time they are implying that the beginnings of the stroke preceded the treatment, so the treatment isn’t really responsible.
The press release says
The research in the journal Spine, which showed that patients seeking inappropriate treatment for CAD – regardless of whether treatment was delivered by a medical or chiropractic doctor – were are [sic] at risk for stroke.”
This is a complete misrepresentation of the study, which did not differentiate between strokes due to CAD and strokes caused by other mechanisms, did not present any evidence that patients who sought care already had CAD, and did not even record what symptoms led patients to seek care or what treatments were given. And of course it couldn’t show that patients were “seeking inappropriate treatment.”
In an ideal world, Spine would issue a statement that their study was being mis-represented and mis-used. As the New England Journal of Medicine has done in the past.
The pamphlet has a handy table contrasting the symptoms of CAD, migraine, tension headache and neck pain. CAD is characterized not by head or neck pain, but by dizziness, double vision, difficulty swallowing, speaking or walking, intense nausea or vomiting, numbness and confusion. We have no way of knowing whether the patients in the Cassidy study had these symptoms or had CAD when they sought treatment.
If CAD was already present, but the patient only had head or neck pain without these neurologic symptoms, there would be no reason to suspect CAD and neither the patient nor the chiropractor would see any contraindication to neck manipulation. Manipulation could be expected to produce further tearing, bleeding, and completed stroke, and might well kill the patient. In the absence of neurologic symptoms, there is no reliable way to predict which patients are at risk of stroke.
If the usual neurologic symptoms of CAD were present, any health care provider should have been able to recognize the warning signs of an emergency and send the patient directly to a hospital rather than trying any outpatient treatments. Neck manipulation is clearly contraindicated in these cases. It is good to educate patients, but I don’t see any need for this campaign to “educate practitioners.” If there are chiropractors or MDs out there who can’t already recognize the warning signs of stroke, they should lose their licenses.
But what about the patients who present for care with no symptoms of CAD and without even complaining of head or neck pain? Stroke victims are clearly NOT just patients who went to a chiropractor with head or neck pain. Some were being treated for things like low back pain or shoulder pain. Some patients like Sandra Nette had no pain at all: she had a catastrophic stroke after neck manipulation done simply for health maintenance purposes. Laurie Jean Mathiason, a 20 year old woman, received 186 manipulations of her neck over a 6 month period when her original complaint was lower back pain. The 186th one killed her. 186 treatments in 6 months? I can’t help but ask: how many treatments does it take before you realize that they aren’t working?
The pamphlet resorts to the fallacious “death by medicine” tu quoque argument, saying that the risk associated with non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) is much greater than the risk of injury from neck adjustments. At least there is evidence that NSAIDs relieve pain; there is no evidence that neck adjustments relieve low back pain, shoulder pain or pain elsewhere in the body that is commonly treated with neck adjustments. There is no evidence that neck adjustments maintain health. There is evidence that neck adjustments relieve certain types of neck and head pain, but there is no evidence that the presumably more dangerous rapid thrusts are any more effective than gentle mobilization methods.
Their own arguments undermine their position. The pamphlet says the risk of stroke with neck adjustments is estimated at anywhere from one in 4 million to one in 400,000, and it also says “ANY risk of injury is too big” – so isn’t that a reason to avoid neck adjustment entirely? And it says providers should choose “the treatment that is likely to provide the greatest benefit compared to risk.” Since chiropractic has not given us any evidence that rapid thrust neck adjustments offer any significant benefit, doesn’t that rule them out as a viable option?
They list all the other factors that have been associated with CAD, such as hanging out the laundry, sitting in a barber’s chair, turning the neck while driving, Tai Chi, watching aircraft… anything that extends and rotates the neck. The unspoken implication is that the stroke would have happened anyway even if the patient hadn’t seen a chiropractor, and that chiropractic manipulation is no more traumatic than watching airplanes. That’s clearly wrong, because more force is exerted when a chiropractor rapidly twists a relaxed neck than when someone extends his own neck to look at the sky. When someone turns his neck himself, his muscles actively stabilize the neck and protect it from injury.
If chiropractors really wanted to understand the risks and minimize them, here’s what they could do. They could establish a database of every patient who received neck manipulations, listing their presenting symptoms, specifying exactly which type of neck manipulations were done, and following each patient up with phone calls to determine whether symptoms of stroke had developed after treatment. That would (1) establish the true incidence of stroke following neck adjustments, (2) determine whether strokes were more common with certain specific types of adjustments, and (3) determine whether patients were seeking “inappropriate” care for pre-existing symptoms of CAD. This could be done at little expense and would answer clinically significant questions.
This FCER public information campaign is a disgrace. It misinterprets the Cassidy study and it fails to address the real issues. It’s marketing, not public service. And it’s not science. If chiropractors really want to reduce the risk of stroke, this is not the way to go about it. I can only echo Eeyore from Winnie the Pooh, “Pathetic,” he said. “That’s what it is. Pathetic.”
Addendum: Coincidentally, just as I was writing this I received this e-mail anecdote from a reader: “I had been physically assaulted several days earlier and just wanted to be looked over. I wasn’t in any pain, no physical problems whatsoever, just a cut on my head… The chiropractor twisted my neck really hard, and for a whole year now I’ve been having neck pains on a daily basis.” Not a stroke, but an example of a patient who had NO symptoms before neck adjustment and who had them afterward. Whether or not you believe the treatment caused his chronic neck pain, it is clear that there was NO indication for neck manipulation in this patient. Even if the risk is less than one in 4 million, what benefit would have justified the risk for this patient?

   Not to worry! Chiropractic Board says stroke not a risk of cervical manipulation.
Jann Bellamy
Link
Back in January, the Connecticut Board of Chiropractic Examiners held a four-day hearing to decide whether chiropractors must, as a part of the informed consent process, (1)warn patients about the risk of cervical artery dissection and stroke following neck manipulation and (2) give patients a discharge summary listing the symptoms of stroke.1 On June 10th, the Board of issued a written opinion that stroke or cervical artery dissection is not a risk of cervical spine manipulation, so no warning is necessary. Presumably, although it is not specifically mentioned in the decision, no discharge summary is required because, if there is no risk of a stroke after neck manipulation, what would be the point?
Background
Janet Levy and Britt Harwe are two Connecticut women who suffered strokes resulting from neck manipulation by chiropractors. That’s not just their lay opinion, it’s the opinion of their respective treating physicians, right there in the medical records.
Each decided that some good should come of their unfortunate situations, so each formed a non-profit and began warning patients of the risk of stroke following manipulation. Victims of Chiropractic Abuse, Levy’s organization, put giant ads on the sides of busses in Bridgeport, CT., much to the chagrin of the folks at the University of Bridgeport. Within the hallowed halls of the University (Go Purple Knights!) is a College of Chiropractic, a College of Naturopathic Medicine, and the Acupuncture Institute. The chiropractors demanded that the ads be taken down, which got exactly nowhere.
Some chiropractors also began harassing Levy and Harwe, calling them Nazis and KKK members, for example, and threatening their personal safety and that of their families.(What is it with the pseudoscience crowd and calling people Nazis? Perhaps, having used up their entire supply of imagination creating their nostrums, they are reduced to these tired tropes.) The FBI recommended Levy and Harwe have one of the harassers arrested, which they did, and that calmed things down for a while.
Levy and Harwe knew that most chiropractors were not warning patients on their own, so they pushed for a state law requiring them to do so. After a great deal of effort they got before the state legislative Public Health Committee with the help of Sen. Len Fasano. At the committee hearing a compromise was reached between the proponents for a required warning and the chiropractic faction.
Sen. Fasano described this agreement in his testimony at the hearing before the Chiropractic Board:
I proposed legislation to the Public Health Committee, which legislation sought that some sort of informed consent be given by chiropractors to patients upon the … manipulation of the neck.
There were numerous discussions on both sides of that legislation, if I may, and it was sort of determined that perhaps the best way of handling this would be what we call a Take Away Form, where, for the first time that you [are] treated [with] the manipulation of a neck, the chiropractor would give you a Take Away Form, which discussed the risks and, also, symptoms, should you have some issues with respect to a stroke. These are the things you look at, and you should seek treatment right away.
However, it was impressed upon Senator Harris, [who] is Chairman of the Public Health Committee and myself, as the proponent, that rather than putting [it] in a state statute, the better way of doing this is to allow this Board [of Chiropractic Examiners] to govern itself, and, as a result, the matter was not pressed forward at the senate ….
Both sides agreed that a Take Away once a year upon the manipulation of the neck is reasonable, however, we did not put [it] in [a] state statute, because we believe it was better governed by the policing body [i.e., the Board].
(From Levy, I learned that she lived up to her part of the agreement, which was to take down her ads and not speak out against chiropractic while the matter was before the Board for consideration.)
Upon questioning by one of the attorneys, Sen. Fasano reiterated his understanding that “the chiropractors and the victims were coming to this Board in unison to ask for a Declaratory Ruling.” Sen. Fasano confirmed that this was Sen. Harris’s understanding as well. But by the time of the hearing, it was clear to Sen. Fasano that the chiropractors had no intention of living up to their end of the bargain and that they were dead set against any sort of discussion of the risks with patients and against giving patients a list of stroke symptoms to take home.
The Hearing
The hearing began with a bang on January 5th when the Connecticut Chiropractic Association and the Connecticut Chiropractic Council made a motion to disqualify the only public member of the Board participating in the proceeding, Jean Rexford, because they thought she might be in cahoots with one of the stroke victim organizations. This allowed the lawyers to warm up their vocal cords. By the end of almost 30 pages of transcript on this topic alone they were in fighting form. The chiropractors lost round one and Rexford remained to become the only dissenting vote in the Board’s ruling.
I attended the first two days of the hearing and it was clear to everyone from the get-go that the chiropractors would fight tooth and nail against a rule requiring any disclosure of risk. It was one of those “kumbayah” moments in chiropractic history when a temporary truce is declared in their internecine war and chiropractic organizations of all stripes circle the wagons
This was no better exemplified than by the fact that J. David Cassidy, D.C., Ph.D., Dr.Med.Sc., lead author of the study, “Risk of Vertebrobasilar Stroke and Chiropractic Care,” Spine 33 (2008) S176-S183 [the “Cassidy study”] was required, in order to testify, to appear as a representative of the International Chiropractors Association (ICA), the organization of the super-straight-Daniel-David- Palmer- Innate-Intelligence chiropractors. I’ll bet he doesn’t put that on his C.V.
Here’s the testimony of George Curry, D.C., Chairman of the Board of ICA’s state affiliate, the Connecticut Chiropractic Council, describing the ICA’s beliefs:
Chiropractic science, as taught in the chiropractic curriculum in an accredited chiropractic college, involves the scientific aspects of the study of the human body and the science of detection and correction of the vertebral subluxation complex.
The art refers to the particular technique that a Doctor of Chiropractic would choose to reduce or correct a subluxation, and the philosophy is the where by [sic] or rationale that someone would investigate the spine as a cause of ill health.
The very basis upon which the profession was founded was that the body is a self-healing, self-regulating mechanism and has inherent recuperative powers, and that if those recuperative powers are interfered with, then it could cause of a loss of health.
Dr. Cassidy should hope and pray that this hearing transcript never, ever gets into the hands of an attorney who is preparing to cross-examine him.
Dr. Cassidy was plopped down into the middle of the hearing as a witness for the chiropractors, even though no one had listed him as a witness, as was required, prior to the hearing. This is why he had to pretend to be speaking for the ICA, as they were allowed to substitute him for the previously listed ICA witness. Apparently, we had done enough damage that the chiropractors felt they needed to bring in the man himself to defend his study.
The problems with the Cassidy study were explained on SBM in an excellent post by Dr. Crislip (which, this being Dr. Crislip, also discusses hangings, The Who v. Motorhead, and being over age 50). The study’s hypothesis is that the association between chiropractic care and stroke can be explained by patients going to the chiropractor for headache and neck pain caused by a pre-stroke vertebral artery dissection. In other words, the pre-existing dissection causes the stroke, not the chiropractor’s twisting the patient’s neck. Dr. Crislip slices and dices the study nicely to show how this conclusion is not supported by the data.
So what did the chiropractors say, under oath, about the need for informed consent regarding neck manipulation and stroke? To quote one chiropractic witness (which is pretty much to quote them all, as their testimony on this point varied little): “There is no scientific evidence of a cause and effect relationship between a chiropractic neck treatment and a subsequent stroke.” That’s right — “no scientific evidence.”
Irony of ironies! The profession that has studiously avoided the scientific method for over 100 years suddenly discovers the value of science. A sort of jailhouse conversion, if you will.
And how did they know this? The Cassidy study. Even though the Cassidy study says, right there on page S181, that “[o]ur results should be interpreted cautiously and placed into clinical perspective. We have not ruled out neck manipulation as a potential cause of VBA strokes.” (Emphasis added.)
In another big dose of irony, decades of case reports of stroke following neck manipulation introduced into evidence were dismissed by one chiropractor, who testified that these constituted mere anecdotal evidence. This from the profession for which anecdotal evidence, dressed up as “clinical experience,” repeatedly trumps scientific plausibility.
I was permitted to give testimony before the Board as a “lay witness” on behalf of the non-profit Campaign for Science-Based Healthcare. My testimony consisted of channeling the post by Dr. Crislip and another post by Dr. Hall about how chiropractors and their trade associations were misrepresenting the study’s results to the public.
I also quoted from two neurology texts which addressed the anatomical aspects of cervical manipulation and artery dissection, both concluding that manipulation could indeed cause dissection:
The extracranial VA (vertebral artery) is also susceptible to traumatic injury because of its encasement in the bony part of the cervical canal. Either spontaneously or after minor trauma from neck manipulation, the VA may be injured, and dissection with luminal compromise and clot embolization may occur. This is a common cause of stroke, especially in younger patients without other vascular risk factors.
Samuels, Office Practice of Neurology (2nd ed. 2003), 372. (Emphasis added.)
Dissection of the extracranial carotid and vertebral arteries accounts for approximately 80% to 90% of all cervicocephalic dissections…. The vertebral artery is most mobile, and most susceptible to mechanical injury, at the C1-C2 level, as it leaves the transverse foramen of the axis and abruptly turns to enter the intracranial cavity …. The C1-C2 site is involved in one half to two thirds of all vertebral artery dissections and in 80% to 90% of rotation-related dissections.
Mohr, Stroke: Pathophysiology, Diagnosis, and Management (4th ed. 2004), 1059. (Emphasis added.)
Also testifying for “our side” was the indefatigable Canadian pediatrician and chiropractic critic, Dr. Murray Katz. If you are not familiar with Dr. Katz’s work, suffice it to say that chiropractors like Dr. Katz every bit as much as anti-vaxers like Dr. David Gorski. He undermined the Cassidy study’s methodology and hammered on the susceptibility of the vertebral and carotid arteries to injury from manipulation.
Three survivors of stroke after manipulation and three relatives of patients who died also testified. You could hear a pin drop.
The most compelling aspect of their testimony was how remarkably similar each story was to the others:
the nonsensical reasons for having neck manipulation (sore shoulder, “maintenance care,” lower back pain);
the youth of the victims, all under 45 years old, one only 20 years old;
symptoms of stroke appearing within minutes to hours after manipulation;
clueless chiropractors who had no idea what was going on while their patients were experiencing stroke symptoms, and who gave their patients ridiculous advice (toxins were being released, take Advil) or did nothing at all instead of sending them straight to the hospital;
the patients’ and emergency doctors’ frustrations at not being able to figure out the source of the patients’ symptoms — the patients were not connecting symptoms with manipulation because they had not been informed of the risk of stroke;
the “aha!” moments of hospital doctors when they learned their patients had undergone chiropractic manipulation;
the lingering neurological deficits of the patients who survived and the devastation suffered by the victims and their families.
There could have been no better summation for the victims and their allies than the testimony of Douglas Fellows, M.D., chairman of Diagnostic Imaging and Therapeutics at the University of Connecticut Health Center, a member of the Connecticut Medical Examining Board, and himself a former physical therapist who had used cervical manipulation in his practice. He appeared in support of the Medical Examining Board’s previously filed statement urging that patients be informed of the risk of stroke following manipulation.
Dr. Fellows confirmed the Medical Board’s opinion that vertebral artery dissection can be caused by cervical manipulation. He also testified that, although the risk of stroke and death were remote in the procedures he performs as an interventional radiologist, he always tells patients of this possibility. In response to a question from a Chiropractic Board member — which contained the assertion that “we haven’t established any causality. At most, we’ve established a temporal relationship” — he replied:
We don’t know what the risk is, as far as the percentage risk, but it’s the harm that we worry about, the potential, the devastating effect of paralysis or death, and that’s what we do [referring to warning his patients of the risk of stroke from certain procedures, even thought the risk is remote].
The Decision
Although the Board had previously voted 4-1 against the necessity of a warning, the written “Declaratory Ruling Memorandum of Decision” was not issued until June 10th.
In its decision, the Board correctly stated that, under Connecticut law, “[t]he materiality of a risk is determined by weighing the benefits of a procedure, against the frequency and severity of the potential harm.” But, this being chiropractors, who simply discard facts not fitting their paradigms, that was the last mention of “benefits” and “severity.” From then on, the decision focused solely on “frequency.”
The Board relied heavily on the Cassidy study in making its decision that “the evidence is sufficient to establish that a stroke or cervical arterial dissection is not a risk or side effect of a joint mobilization, manipulation or adjustment of the cervical spine performed by a chiropractor.”2 It is worth repeating that the study itself states “[w]e have not ruled out neck manipulation as a potential cause of some VBA strokes.” However, the Board explained this away by noting that “Dr. Cassidy credibly testified ‘this is a study that raises real doubt about the association being a risk …’” In fact, according to Dr. Cassidy’s testimony, he’s become so doubtful he has absolved himself from a previous admission that he caused a patient’s stroke by manipulating her neck.
The Board went on to explain that “[s]tatistically, what scant evidence exists of the incidence of stroke following a … manipulation … of the cervical spine was found primarily in persons under age 45. As provided in the Rothwell study, ‘it remains to be explained why an association between chiropractic manipulation and [vertebrobasilar accident] was observed only in the young. If an association were to exist, one would expect that it would exist regardless of age.’”
If only the Connecticut Board of Chiropractic Examiners had read Science-Based Medicine before issuing its ruling!
Dr. Crislip, who has answered many questions here recently, had an answer to this very question months ago in his SBM post on the Cassidy study.
In the over 45 age group, strokes due to chiropractic could be lost in the sea of strokes due to other reasons, and since we do not know if there were a dissection or blood clot as a cause of strokes, it is hard to conclude that there were no extra strokes from chiropractic. The study was not powered to determine the rare event of a chiropractic event against the background to usual stokes in the elderly. The mean age in this study was 63 ….
Young people should not have any stroke. In the young, vertebral artery dissection is a common cause of a rare event. It is also the worry from chiropractic neck manipulation. If you could find an effect of chiropractic, it would be in the young. And they do. The people who have an increase in stroke are those under age 45. And it is a big association: odds ratios from 3 to 12.
The association is most noticeable in the first 24 hours after seeing a chiropractor. Usually if you rip an artery it is symptomatic right away. Again, we do not know if these people had dissection or not. We only know they had stroke of some sort, within a day after seeing a chiropractor. One would predict that if there were an association between chiropractic and stroke you would most easily find it in the young and the effect would be most noticeable in the first day or so after the chiropractic visit.
And this article confirms this association.
I even cited to Dr. Crislip’s post in my brief and provided a link! So much for Board’s self-proclaimed “careful and thorough review of all of the testimony and documentary evidence.”
And speaking of said “careful and thorough review,” the decision did not explain how Board managed to avoid the basic anatomy of the human neck, which strongly suggests that twisting it forcefully is really not a good idea.
The Board did allow that “the evidence is sufficient to establish that spinal manipulation on persons who are having an acute stroke or cervical arterial dissection is not within the standard of care.” Well, that’s certainly a relief!
The Board also said that a chiropractor who wanted to “discuss these issues” [presumably, the non-existent stroke risk] with a patient could do so without being in violation of the standard of care.
So, even though the Cassidy study says that patients with headache and neck pain can be presenting with vertebral artery dissection, and that there is no screening procedure to determine whether patients presenting with headache or neck pain are at risk of VBA stroke, chiropractors should feel free to manipulate the neck without warning of the risk of stroke. Why didn’t the Board decide that the evidence they find so compelling dictated the much safer option of not using manipulation on anyone with headache or neck pain?
Post-hearing
What does this ruling mean?
Unfortunately, young people will continue to have debilitating strokes and some will die following cervical manipulation.
But the fight was not for naught. Many TV viewers saw scary videos of necks popping at the hands of chiropractors during media coverage of the hearing. Awareness of the risk of stroke was raised — not everyone believes the chiropractors when they deny it. “Our side” got great press.
Janet Levy can resume her bus ads in Bridgeport. Sen. Fasano will again introduce legislation making chiropractors inform their patients of risk. It failed this year but he vows to re-introduce it next year. And Levy has just filed suit in Connecticut against two state chiropractic organizations citing them for, among other things, failure to warn patients of the risk of stroke following manipulation.
The Board’s declaration that there is no risk of cervical artery dissection and stroke following manipulation is a finding of fact and not binding on the courts. As is their ruling that informed consent does not require a warning. Under Connecticut law, whether a warning of risk is required is determined by the “reasonable patient” standard, that is, what would a reasonable patient consider important in making his decision whether to undergo a particular procedure. One of the very purposes of the reasonable patient standard is to prevent practitioners from setting low standards and then claiming they’ve abided by their profession’s standard of care. Imagine the chiropractor sued for failure to warn who erroneously thinks he’s been inoculated against malpractice claims by following the Board’s ruling. Surprise!
As a matter of fact, the hearing transcript and videotape are now in the hands of plaintiffs’ personal injury attorneys, who will mine it for useful information. A couple of years ago the American Justice Society (formerly known as the Association of Trial Lawyers of American) started a chiropractic interest group (that is, interest in suing chiropractors for personal injury). The section collects and distributes such information for AJS members.
The chiropractors may have won this battle, but they could be losing the war.
Notes
The Petition for Declaratory Ruling filed by the Connecticut Chiropractic Association, which set this proceeding into motion, used the term “cervical artery dissection” in describing the risk of cervical manipulation at issue before the Connecticut Board of Chiropractic Examiners. The Board also used the term “cervical artery(ies)” in its ruling and otherwise during the proceeding, as did some of the other participants. “Cervical artery” is an imprecise term as there is no such anatomic structure. Apparently, its use refers collectively to the vertebral and carotid arteries.
At least I think that is the Board’s decision, as it is repeated several times and is made “Finding of Fact” number 3 in the Memorandum of Decision. But the Board also states a couple of times, once in its actual “Order” at the end of the written decision, that the “evidence is insufficient to conclude that stroke or cervical artery dissection is a risk or side effect of” cervical spine manipulation. Deciding that the evidence is sufficient to establish there is no risk is quite a different thing than deciding the evidence is insufficient to establish there is a risk.

Study: patients should be warned of stroke risk before chiropractic neck manipulation
Another study adds to growing body of evidence that chiropractic neck manipulation is a risk factor for stroke. Patients should be warned of risk.
Jann Bellamy on September 14, 2017
Link


Author Note: It’s Sunday and Hurricane Irma is headed my way. I am finalizing this post in anticipation of almost certain loss of power later today and for an unknowable number of days ahead, hence the brevity.
Wednesday Update: We were fortunate to have been spared the worst of the storm in Tallahassee. Everything is up and running here after internet outages only. However, I stuck with my original post. A hurricane is enough to handle in one week.
Yet another study adds to the growing body of evidence that neck manipulation is an independent risk factor for cervical arterial dissection and stroke. The authors conclude:
Based on our findings, all patients who visited chiropractors for cervical spine manipulation should be informed of the potential risks and of the need to seek immediate medical assistance should symptoms suggestive of dissection or stroke occur during or after manipulation.
In fact, they suggest that patients might well avoid chiropractors altogether:
Until the actual level of risk from chiropractic manipulation is known, patients with neck pain may be better served by equally effective passive physical therapy exercise.
We’ve covered the risk of chiropractic neck manipulation many times here on SBM, including the refusal of the chiropractic profession to admit that there is a problem and their resistance to properly informing patients of the risks. Recently, retired chiropractor Sam Homola posted an excellent review of the subject. This new study, published in the September issue of The Journal of Family Practice, adds to the existing body of evidence that chiropractic neck manipulation is an independent risk factor for stroke and that patients should be warned of the risks.
The authors set out to determine the frequency of patients seen at a University of Illinois College of Medicine-affiliated medical center who were diagnosed with a cervical artery dissection related to chiropractic neck manipulation. They searched the medical records for patients with a confirmed diagnosis of cervical artery dissection over a four-year period and found 141. Through further research, including patient interviews, they found 12 patients (or 8.5%) with a verifiable temporal association between chiropractic manipulation and dissection. (The association was equivocal for three more patients who were excluded from further consideration in the study.)
The patients, whose average age was 35, suffered a total of 16 dissections comprising 14 vertebral artery (VAD) and 2 carotid artery (CAD) dissections. Most developed symptoms immediately after manipulation although, for two patients, it was 2-3 days later. Unfortunately, one patient who suffered immediate symptoms did not seek medical attention for several weeks and died, tragically demonstrating the importance of warning patients they need to get help right away if they experience symptoms such as visual deficits, vertigo, numbness, and new neck pain. While one patient fully recovered, others still suffer from visual problems, disequilibrium, arm and leg weakness and pain. One walks with a cane and had to stop driving.
Acute or chronic neck pain was the most common reason for going to the chiropractor. Headaches were another reason, including migraines. Two patients were seeing a chiropractor for the first time. One saw a chiropractor once a month for 15 years. Another, once a week for 10 years.
The authors cite a 2012 study finding that chiropractic manipulation is beneficial in the treatment of acute neck pain but also found no significant difference in effectiveness between manipulation and physical therapy exercises. They do not discuss the lack of evidence of effectiveness for chronic neck pain, headaches, or the fact that chiropractors manipulate the cervical spine for all manner of conditions that have nothing to do with the neck. Some manipulate the neck exclusively, for anything.
A review of the evidence of association between neck manipulation and cervical artery dissection takes particular aim at research dismissing a connection, including the Cassidy study (also dissected by our own Mark Crislip). That study showed an association between vertebrobasilar stroke and both chiropractic visits and visits to primary care physicians within a month prior to the stroke. Chiropractors use the study to claim that neck manipulation by a chiropractor poses no more risk of stroke than seeing your PCP. The authors find this claim
hard to reconcile with other studies, including our own, in which 10 patients developed new symptoms immediately with chiropractic manipulation of their cervical spines.
They criticize the one-month observation period of the Cassidy study as “perhaps . . . excessive”:
Many post-manipulation events occur within hours or at most a few days, as would be expected given the hypothesized pathogenic mechanism. Perhaps if they had shortened their interval of study to the preceding 3 days, their findings may have been different.
They make the same point in discussing a systematic review and meta-analysis demonstrating a slight association between neck manipulation and dissection but concluding there is no convincing evidence of causation. While agreeing that the quality of the literature is low, they point to the immediate onset of acute symptoms in their own study.
As this article notes, others have come to conclusions different from that of the chiropractors.
    • A 2003 study found manipulation to be an independent and strong risk factor for VAD, the authors concluding the relationship was causal.
    • The Canadian Stroke Consortium showed a 28% incidence of chiropractic manipulation in cases of CAD.
    • The American Heart Association/American Stroke Association (endorsed by the American Association of Neurological Surgeons and the Congress of Neurological Surgeons) recommends that chiropractors inform patients of the association between cervical artery dissection.
    • An institution similar to the one in this study previously described 13 cases in which patients experienced dissection related to chiropractic neck manipulation, one of whom died.
These findings, they say, if representative of other institutions,
indicate the incidence of stroke secondary to chiropractic manipulation may be higher than supposed.
In sum, given the low level of evidence of effectiveness of chiropractic cervical manipulation and the availability of other, equally effective, remedies, there is no reason to run the risk of potentially catastrophic results. At the very least, patients should be warned of the lack of benefit and the risks and allowed to make their own decision.

Chiropractic and Stroke: No Evidence for Causation But Still Reason for Concern
Harriet Hall on April 5, 2016
Tweet
Can neck manipulation (by chiropractors or by other practitioners) cause strokes? Many of us think it can, but definitive proof is lacking. A recently published study looked at the available evidence. A systematic review found a small association between stroke and chiropractic care but concluded that the association was spurious and that there was no evidence for causation. My colleagues and I have written about this subject several times; some of the links are listed here. I certainly agree that there is no definitive evidence for causation, but I think there is evidence to support a strong enough probability of causation to constitute a good reason to avoid neck manipulation.
The systematic review
They combed databases and two study authors independently reviewed all articles that were in English and that involved patients with carotid or vertebrobasilar artery (VBA) dissection and recent chiropractic manipulation. The studies were graded using the classification of evidence scheme adopted by the American Academy of Neurology. They found a total of six case control studies, two of which were judged to be class II (of moderate quality and risk of bias), and four as class III (a high risk of bias; class I would indicate high quality and low risk of bias, and class IV would have a very high risk of bias).
Class II studies
Smith et al. compared 51 VBA stroke cases to 100 controls, assessing exposure to spinal manipulative therapy (SMT) by mail survey. VBA stroke patients were 6.6 times more likely than controls to have had chiropractic care in the 30 days before the stroke, even after adjusting for neck pain or headache. There were limitations to the study: possible recall or survivor bias, reason for seeing chiropractor was not assessed, and significant variability among diagnostic procedures that might have resulted in interviewer bias.
Dittrich et al. compared 47 patients with cervical artery dissection to a control group of stroke patients with etiologies other than dissection, using face-to-face interviews with blinding. They found no association between any individual risk factor and dissection but cumulative analysis of all mechanical risk factors in the previous 24 hours did show an association (p=.01). The study was presumably too small to have found an association with individual mechanical risk factors like SMT. This study was also subject to recall bias.
Class III studies
Cassidy et al. identified 818 patients hospitalized for VBA strokes in Ontario during the years 1993-2002, matched them to controls, and relied on health billing records to determine whether patients had seen a chiropractor or a primary care provider (PCP) in the previous year. They found that visits to a chiropractor were not more likely than visits to a PCP, but that visits to either for headache or neck pain were more likely in patients subsequently diagnosed with a VBA stroke. This study had limitations, most significantly that the records did not reveal whether a patient had had neck manipulation.
Rothwell et al. examined some of the same cases as the Cassidy study. They found that patients under the age of 45 were 5 times more likely to have seen a chiropractor in the previous week; they found no association with older patients.
Thomas et al. compared the records of 47 patients with neck artery dissections to 43 controls. They found a signification association with neck manipulation (odds ratio 1.67, confidence interval 1.43-112.0). There were flaws in this study including a lack of blinding.
Engelter et al. identified 966 patients with cervical artery dissections, 651 with strokes from other causes, and 280 healthy controls. Cervical manipulation was 12.1 times as likely for strokes due to dissections as for strokes due to other causes. Data were collected by questionnaires, and there may have been recall bias.
Since the patients in the Rothwell study were a subset of those in the Cassidy study, they did not include it in their analysis, but analyzed only the remaining 5 studies. They gave the Cassidy study a weight of 73.9% allowing them to calculate an overall odds ratio of 1.74. I don’t understand why they gave that study so much weight. If any statisticians are reading this, perhaps they can help me out. Did they adjust it to reflect variance? The Cassidy study had a much narrower 95% confidence interval than the other studies, but it overlapped the confidence interval of only one other study, and its data didn’t even include information about manipulation. Look at the Forest plot they published:

The size of the squares indicates the weight given to the data, the lines represent the 95% confidence intervals, and the diamond represents the overall odds ratio for an association between chiropractic treatment and stroke.
Notice that they list “manipulation” and “no manipulation” events for each study including the Cassidy study, which is deceptive because that study did not collect data on manipulation, only on visits to providers. You can see at a glance that if they had not given the Cassidy study so much weight, the overall odds ratio would have been significantly higher.
Mark Crislip’s critique of the Cassidy study
Mark Crislip wrote an analysis of the Cassidy study. He pointed out that the records listed the diagnosis of VBA stroke but not the reason for the stroke, which could have been a thrombus, an embolus, or a tear in the lining of the artery (dissection). In the young, where stroke is rare, the cause is more likely to be a dissection, which can be precipitated by trauma. The worry in chiropractic is a stroke caused by a dissection. The young are more likely to get a thorough workup and a precise diagnosis, whereas the diagnosis might be over-represented in older patients with lots of risk factors for stroke. In the over-45 group, a rare dissection due to chiropractic manipulation might well be lost in the sea of strokes due to other causes.
For patients under 45 who visited a chiropractor, there was a strong association with stroke in the next 24 hours; the odds ratio was 12. They diluted this finding by looking at the entire month following the visit.
Then they tried to explain it all away by saying patients with headache and neck pain may have already been having a stroke in progress when they sought care from a chiropractor or a PCP. But the recorded diagnostic codes didn’t bear that out. There was very little overlap between the recorded reasons for the visit and the typical symptoms of a VBA stroke. Mark concluded that given the number of chiropractor visits and the rarity of vertebral artery tear, chiropractic manipulation is probably a rare cause of a rare event. He compared the suggestion that the VBA occurred before the manipulation to suggesting that a hanging victim already had a broken neck when he mounted the scaffold.
Flaws in the study’s Discussion section
Here’s where it really becomes problematic. They report that they found a small association between chiropractic care and cervical artery dissection, but then they discount their own finding and try to rationalize it away. They say the evidence is low quality; I agree. They say they found no evidence of causation; I agree. But then they try to say there is no convincing evidence of even the association that they themselves found.
They found no evidence for causation. On the other hand, they found no evidence against it.
They say they are concerned that a false belief in a causal connection “may have significant adverse effects such as numerous episodes of litigation.” On the other hand, a lack of belief might prevent justified litigation where patients were harmed or killed.
They say neck pain and headache are confounders. They say patients with headache and neck pain more frequently visit chiropractors, and patients with cervical artery dissection more frequently have neck pain and headache, so the appearance of more cervical artery dissections after visits to chiropractors is spurious. They say the Cassidy study showed that visits to a primary care provider or a chiropractor were likely to be due to pain from an existing dissection. It did not. There is absolutely no evidence to support that speculation.
In fact, there are numerous “smoking gun” cases where patients consulted a chiropractor not for neck pain or headache, but for pain in parts of the body below the neck, such as shoulder pain or tailbone pain, and developed stroke symptoms on the chiropractor’s table at the time of neck manipulation. Sandra Nette had no pain at all; she felt fine and let the chiropractor manipulate her neck only because she falsely believed that regular maintenance adjustments were an effective means of keeping her healthy.
They fail to even mention the smoking gun cases or the evidence that the incidence of stroke rises with the proximity to the time of manipulation.
They make a big deal of Hill’s criteria for assigning causation to association. With a rare condition like VBA dissection, and with the characteristics of this condition, it would be very difficult to fulfill all of Hill’s criteria. We may never see that kind of proof, so we must rely on lesser quality evidence.
They cite cadaver studies to claim that SMT doesn’t place significant strain on the vertebral artery. And yet we know that very small strains can cause strokes in susceptible live patients. “Shampoo strokes” have been reported after hyperextension of the neck at beauty parlors.
Other considerations
The indications for neck manipulation are questionable. Upper cervical (NUCCA) chiropractors do neck manipulations on every patient, no matter what the complaint. Some chiropractors do neck manipulations for somatovisceral conditions rather than just for musculoskeletal conditions. Whatever the indications, chiropractors certainly have no business doing neck manipulations on a patient with an existing dissection, and they have not shown that they can reliably diagnose a stroke in progress. There are no tests to reliably identify patients at risk of dissection.
Underreporting is a problem. If a dissection is temporarily sealed by a clot that breaks loose several hours or days later, the connection with manipulation may be missed. Patients may never return to the chiropractor. I heard of at least one case where a patient developed stroke symptoms immediately following manipulation, was hospitalized for a disastrous stroke, and never let the chiropractor know what had happened.
Edzard Ernst weighs in
Edzard Ernst reported on a case of a man who had a stroke following chiropractic manipulation for chronic neck pain. Chronic, not a new symptom suggesting a stroke in progress. He also reported on a case of phrenic nerve injury from neck manipulation.
Ernst commented:
    • There is no effective monitoring scheme to adequately record serious side-effects of chiropractic care.
    • Therefore the incidence figures of such catastrophic events are currently still anyone’s guess.
    • Publications by chiropractic interest groups seemingly denying this point are all fatally flawed.
    • It is not far-fetched to fear that under-reporting of serious complications is huge.
    • The reliable evidence fails to demonstrate that neck manipulations generate more good than harm.
    • Until sound evidence is available, the precautionary principle leads most critical thinkers to conclude that neck manipulations have no place in routine health care.
The American Heart Association and American Stroke Association agree. They were concerned enough about the apparent association to have issued a joint scientific statement warning about it and recommending that patients be informed of the possible risk prior to manipulation.
Bottom line: A double standard
Edzard Ernst has said:
Imagine a conventional therapy about which the current Cochrane review says that it has no proven effect for the condition in question. Imagine further that this therapy causes mild to moderate adverse effects in about 50% of all patients in addition to very dramatic complications which are probably rare but, as no monitoring system exists, of unknown frequency…
Now I ask you to imagine that there is a pharmaceutical drug that fits this description. Imagine that there are the same numbers of studies showing an association of that drug with a deadly side effect like stroke or death. The FDA would pull it off the market; they wouldn’t wait for definite evidence of causation that fulfilled all of Hill’s criteria. And I think the people who are making excuses for neck manipulation would want them to take that drug off the market. I don’t think they would want to take such a drug.
I wouldn’t risk taking a drug like that, and I wouldn’t risk neck manipulation.

   Chiropractic Strokes Again! A Landmark Lawsuit in Canada
Harriet Hall 
Link
Sandra Nette is a prisoner, condemned to spend the rest of her life in the cruelest form of solitary confinement. Her intact mind is trapped in a paralyzed body and she is unable to speak. She can move one arm just enough to type on a special keyboard. She cannot swallow or breathe on her own, and must be frequently suctioned. She feels sensations and is in pain. Her condition is known as “locked-in syndrome” and has been described as “the closest thing to being buried alive.” She is suing those responsible for her cruel fate and I hope she wins.
She was a healthy 40 year old woman who wanted to stay healthy. She did all the right things like watching her weight, eating right, and not smoking. She followed the advice of a chiropractor to include regular maintenance chiropractic adjustments in her health regimen. On September 13, 2007 she had the last adjustment she would ever have.
There was nothing wrong with her. She didn’t see the chiropractor for headaches, neck pain, back pain or any other complaint. She went for a “tune-up” that she thought would help keep her healthy. The chiropractor did a rapid-thrust adjustment on her neck. Right afterwards, she complained of feeling “sore, dizzy and unwell.” She tried to leave but had to sit down. The chiropractor failed to recognize the medical emergency, and instead of calling an ambulance he recommended that she would benefit from purchasing massage therapy from his clinic. He let her leave the office and drive home alone. She only made it part way.
In the hospital, doctors determined that she had tears in BOTH vertebral arteries in her neck. One tear was 3 inches long.
Chiropractors would like us to believe that strokes after neck adjustments are mere coincidence, that patients like Sandra go to a chiropractor because they have neck pain from a stroke-in-progress and the manipulation is not the culprit. But cases like this are crystal-clear: she had no prior symptoms and there is no question that the neck maneuvers directly caused the tears in the arteries. One of the doctors in the ER took one look at her and asked her husband, “Chiropractor?” Neurologists, emergency physicians, and rational chiropractors all recognize that neck adjustments occasionally cause strokes, but the majority of chiropractors are still resisting reality.
Chiropractors tell us that strokes after neck adjustments are exceedingly rare, and that other forms of treatment, such as NSAIDs, are more dangerous. But in this case, it wasn’t a question of comparing treatment options, because nothing was being treated. There is no evidence to support the practice of maintenance adjustments. The absolute risk is small but the risk/benefit ratio is infinite because the benefit is zero. For a fuller discussion, see my previous blog article on Chiropractic and Stroke.
Sandra didn’t know that neck manipulation could cause a stroke. She didn’t know that maintenance adjustments only benefit the chiropractor’s bank balance. She wasn’t informed, so she couldn’t give informed consent.
Sandra isn’t just suing the chiropractor. She and her husband are suing:
• Gregory John Stiles,
• The Spa and Life Stiles,
• The Alberta College and Association of Chiropractors, and
• Her Majesty the Queen in Right of Alberta (Minister of Health and Wellness).
And they are seeking an order to make it a class action suit to cover every patient who received “an inappropriate and non-beneficial adjustment from any Alberta chiropractor since 1998.” Potential beneficiaries include those patients’ spouses and their estates if they are deceased.
Among other things, they contend that the defendants owed their patients a duty to not advise procedures that lacked scientific justification, to fairly disclose the benefits and risks of their interventions, and “not to charge them a fee for services that cannot restore, maintain or enhance human health.”
The Statement of Claim runs to 80 pages and describes the foundation of chiropractic, previous lawsuits, the published literature, and warning statements by groups like the 62 Canadian neurologists who spoke out in 2002. It provides extensive, detailed evidence to show that the College and the government were well aware of the risk of stroke and it argues that the College and the Minister of Health should have acted to regulate chiropractic to prevent disasters like Sandra’s.
They accuse the College of acting in bad faith, concocting evidence, sponsoring “methodologically inadequate research studies designed to validate rather than investigate the issue” and distorting scientific findings to support traditional chiropractic beliefs and economic interests. Strong words.
They are asking for $529 million dollars in damages.
Consumer advocates and victims of chiropractic have asked to meet with Canadian legislators and the Minister of Health to propose the following guidelines:
ONE: INFANTS AND CHILDREN: Highest neck manipulation should never be done in infants and children for claims to treat such conditions as ear infections, tonsillitis, infantile colic, asthma and gastro-intestinal disorders nor as an alternative to scientific immunization against diseases such as polio, tetanus, measles, mumps, German measles or chicken pox. The Chiefs of Paediatrics of our Canadian Hospitals have all condemned such claims by chiropractors.
TWO: PHILOSOPHICAL CLAIMS: Highest neck manipulation should never be done for the claim that it is effective to awaken the “innate intelligence of the spinal cord” and thereby provide “wellness or health” of the entire body. The idea that the spinal cord has some magical “innate intelligence” is a fundamental chiropractic belief. It is false.
THREE: REPETITIVE HIGHEST NECK MANIPULATIONS: Highest neck manipulation should not be done on a repetitive basis with claims that this will keep the neck vertebrae in proper alignment. It is false to claim that highest neck manipulation is necessary for the “maintenance” of the alignment of the highest neck vertebrae. The vertebrae are attached to each other by a complex structure of bone, ligaments and muscles. Manipulating the highest neck time and time again on people who have no complaints in that area should not be done.
FOUR: INFECTIONS: Highest neck manipulation should not be done for any claims that it alters in any manner, the immune system, to prevent or to treat infections such as Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome and other bacterial, viral or fungal infections.
FIVE: BODY ORGANS: Highest neck manipulation should not be done for claims that it can have a health benefit upon a body organ such as the heart, lungs, kidneys and liver or as a means of preventing the onset of genetic disorders or cancer.
SIX: VERTEBRAL SUBLUXATIONS: Highest neck manipulation should never be done for the claim that it can remove so called “vertebral subluxations” in the highest neck area. It is false to claim that these top vertebrae are out of alignment, even in new born babies, and that manipulating the highest neck area one can improve the function of the brain stem as well as treat conditions such as sinusitis and even multiple sclerosis. There is no neurological or scientific basis for such claims.
These guidelines make sense, and rational chiropractors should have no objections to them. They would not interfere with spinal manipulation therapy for musculoskeletal conditions, and they would eliminate much of the quackery in chiropractic.
The outcome of this lawsuit could have broad implications. If the judge finds that providers owe their patients a duty to not advise procedures that lack scientific justification, it will open the door to similar lawsuits involving other alternative medicine modalities. It might also open the door to lawsuits against scientific MDs who can’t convince the court that a treatment is adequately supported by scientific evidence. We want to eliminate quackery, but we don’t want to make the courts the arbiters of what constitutes sufficient scientific evidence.
Lawyers are smart and they will undoubtedly put up a good defense. If nothing else comes of this lawsuit, it should at least promote a useful discussion. There have been repeated recommendations to require chiropractors to at least disclose the risk of stroke to their patients, and no official body has yet acted on those recommendations. Maybe now they will. If not the official bodies, maybe the chiropractic malpractice insurance agencies, out of sheer financial self-interest, will start requiring their clients to get informed consent from their patients.
The transcript of the trial alone ought to furnish enough documentation for someone to write a book on the risks and benefits of chiropractic and the associated science or lack of science. This may do for chiropractic what Dover did for Intelligent Design. I will follow it with great interest.
References
Stroke Caused by Neck Manipulation Triggers Ambitious Lawsuit. Stephen Barrett, M.D.

Chiropractic Reform: Myth or Reality?
Harriet Hall on December 10, 2013
Link
The recent uproar about the chiropractor who was accused of breaking an infant’s neck has provoked renewed discussions about the role of chiropractors, not only in the care of children, but in general. We have addressed chiropractic many times on this blog. While spinal manipulation therapy (SMT) is an effective option for treating certain types of low back pain, chiropractors typically do a lot of other things that are not evidence-based, can be dangerous (strokes from neck manipulation), and are often outright quackery like applied kinesiology. Chiropractic treatment of children has been called child abuse, and even some chiropractors have spoken out against it.
Chiropractors have protested in the comment threads that we have an outdated, biased view of chiropractic, and that modern chiropractic practice is very different. They claim that they have rejected the original basis of chiropractic (the subluxation/nerve interference/innate paradigm), that they reject all forms of quackery, that what they do is based on scientific evidence, and that they have an important role to play in modern health care. We think that “reformed” attitude is rare. We would love to know what percentage of chiropractors fall into the “reformed” category, but no studies have been done to answer that question. Now there is a new study from Australia that provides important information about the state of chiropractic practice in that country. While it can’t answer the question about the number of “reformed” chiropractors in the US, it does shed some light on the subject.
The broken neck accusation: Unanswered questions
First, a brief review of the broken neck accusation. A chiropractor treated a 4-month-old baby with torticollis (wry neck), the baby developed a loss of head control after the treatment, and a subsequent x-ray was interpreted as showing a “hangman’s” fracture. A review commissioned by the Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency (AHPRA) and carried out by the Chiropractic Board of Australia (CBA) found that the baby did not have a broken neck, but rather a congenital defect called spondylolysis, where certain areas of the vertebral arch are absent, leaving a defect that can look similar to a fracture. The review found that the chiropractor did not cause a fracture, but it found other problems with his history-taking and examination of the child and with his record-keeping. The case against the chiropractor was closed after he agreed to get further education. No explanation was ever offered for the baby’s loss of head control; the chiropractor who wrote the report thought it was unrelated to the treatment.
Here the story gets murkier. The pediatrician who treated the infant stood by his original diagnosis. He said that the baby had both a fracture and a congenital defect (that the chiropractor had overlooked), that the congenital defect put the child at greater risk of fracture and complicated the baby’s treatment for the fracture, and that a follow-up CT scan done 6 months later showed new bone formation that confirmed the diagnosis of a healing fracture. The AHPRA report and a later review by an unnamed “internationally renowned” radiologist insisted that no fracture had occurred. But apparently the consensus of the baby’s doctors was that it had, since last week the Friends of Science in Medicine newsletter reported that the baby spent six months in a neck brace.
Michael Vagg wrote an account of the whole kerfuffle. The AHPRA report was inappropriately leaked to the public. This was a massive failure on the part of the CBA, which must maintain confidentiality in order to protect the integrity of future investigations. The Chiropractor’s Association of Australia (CAA) protested loudly, demanding retraction of the news story and claiming that no child had ever been injured by chiropractic (a demonstrably false claim).
With no resolution of the conflicting radiologic interpretations, and with the other unanswered questions, we can only speculate about what really happened.
The COAST study
The new study is titled “Chiropractic Observation and Analysis Study (COAST): providing an understanding of current chiropractic practice.” It was published in The Medical Journal of Australia in November, 2013. The eight authors included medical professors, chiropractors, ethicists, and statisticians. The full text is available online.
Method
It was a cross-sectional study using the established BEACH (Bettering the Evaluation and Care of Health) methods. 180 chiropractors in Victoria, Australia were randomly chosen from the register and 52 eventually completed the study (a satisfactory response rate). Female chiropractors were under-represented, but otherwise the respondents were similar to the general population of chiropractors. They were asked to record details of 100 patient encounters by hand on paper forms, and they were given a $200 honorarium as an incentive. A total of 4,464 patient encounters were recorded. The forms documented several things:
    • Demographic characteristics of chiropractors
    • Demographics and health profiles of patients
    • Reasons patients gave for seeking chiropractic care
    • Problems and diagnoses identified
    • Care provided
Selected results (numbers rounded):
    • Characteristics of chiropractors (see Box 1)
        ◦ The mean number of patient care hours a chiropractor worked in a week was 27, spread over a mean of 6 clinic sessions
        ◦ The mean number of patients seen per week was 84
    • Patient characteristics (see Box 2):
        ◦ 58% of patients were women
        ◦ 44 patients were under the age of one year (1% of total encounters), 3% were age 1-4 and a total of 9% of patients were under the age of 15
        ◦ Information on age spread, language, ethnicity, and occupation was reported
        ◦ Source of payment: patient 81%, health insurance 46%, plus a very small percentage paid by workers compensation and other sources
    • Problems managed (see Box 3)
        ◦ Most common: back problems – 46%
        ◦ Neck problems – 11%
        ◦ Muscle problems – 7%
        ◦ Other musculoskeletal diagnoses (all less than 4%, listed in descending order of frequency) included back syndrome with radiating pain, “other,” sprains and strains, shoulder problem, nerve-related problem, bursitis/tendinitis/synovitis, kyphosis/scoliosis, foot or toe complaint, ankle problem, osteoarthritis (not spine), hip symptom, leg or thigh symptom, injury (0.55%)
        ◦ Non-musculoskeletal diagnoses – health maintenance or preventive care 4%, headache 3% (some of these could have been of musculoskeletal origin), nerve-related problem 1%, general complaints 1%, and depression 0.48%
    • Advice provided: therapeutic exercises in 52% of encounters, general exercise 21%, posture 21%, ice packs 11%, heat therapy 8%, supplements 5%
    • Other information: median duration of encounter 15 minutes (range 11-20), follow-up recommended in 85% of encounters, patient referred by another patient 52%, referred by a GP 4%, referred to a GP 3%
    • Techniques used (Box 4)

Comments
Infants and children only represent 1% and 9% of chiropractic patients, but even that is too many, since there is no evidence that children benefit from chiropractic treatment and there is a risk of injury.
Chiropractors are often thought of as “back specialists” but less than half of visits are for back problems.
About 10% of visits are for non-musculoskeletal problems. There is no evidence that chiropractic is effective for non-musculoskeletal problems.
“Health maintenance” was listed for 4.24% of encounters. It wasn’t clear how many of these visits were for maintenance adjustments. There is no evidence that maintenance adjustments provide any benefit to patients. There is controversy among chiropractors about whether “chiropractic wellness care” should be an integral part of their practice.
The category of “spinal problems” included an unspecified number of chiropractor-recorded diagnoses of “chiropractic subluxations” without a definition of what that meant. Most chiropractors no longer believe there is a bone out of place and use the word to mean dysfunction rather than displacement. It would be better if the term “subluxation” was no longer be used at all, since “no supportive evidence is found for the chiropractic subluxation being associated with any disease process or of creating suboptimal health conditions requiring intervention” and “the subluxation construct has no valid clinical applicability.” In other studies, 98% of chiropractors believed that “most” or “many” diseases were caused by spinal misalignments and over 75% of chiropractors believed that subluxation contributed to 50% or more of visceral disorders like asthma or colic. The present study really doesn’t tell us anything about Australian chiropractors’ beliefs; it only tells us what diagnoses they wrote down.
There is cause for concern in the treatments listed. Activator methods are not supported by evidence. Half of American chiropractors in a 1991 survey said they used them, but the percentage in this study appears to be much lower, around 20%. The use of “chiro system” appears to be around 12%, but that is worrisome since the methods that includes are all bogus: applied kinesiology, sacro-occipital technique, and Neuro Emotional Technique (NET). The study showed that 5% of chiropractors recommended supplements, but it did not specify which supplements were recommended, so we have no way of knowing if any of the recommendations were evidence-based.
Conclusion
This new study doesn’t tell us what percentage of chiropractors try to follow science-based principles, but it offers some hints that will have to do until a study is done to address that question directly. It tells us that a substantial number of chiropractors use quack methods, and the ones who do obviously can’t be science-based. It tells us that children are being treated with chiropractic in the absence of any evidence that it is effective. It suggests that these Australian chiropractors are not trying to act as family doctors or primary care gatekeepers, as some American chiropractors do. It doesn’t indicate that Australian chiropractors are trying to treat diabetes, as some American chiropractors have been doing. The study leaves many questions unanswered and raises some new ones; and it doesn’t provide any evidence to support the claims that chiropractic is being “reformed.” Preston Long thinks it hasn’t been and can’t be reformed from the inside; and if it could, it would no longer be “chiropractic.”

Another serious complication from chiropractic cervical manipulation: Vertebral fracture leading to paralysis and death
John Lawlor was an 80 year old man with leg pain. Thinking he was going for physiotherapy, he ended up in the office of Arleen Scholten, a chiropractor. What happened next involved cervical spine manipulation, vertebral fracture, death, and a lack of accountability.
David Gorski on November 25, 2019
Link

As I approached my weekly task to write my contribution to this blog, it occurred to me that there has been a bit of news that somehow none of the regular contributors has written about. Moreover, it strikes me as a particularly appropriate topic after Sam Homola’s post on Friday about upper cervical chiropractic manipulation, sometimes called NUCCA (National Upper Cervical Chiropractic Association). We’ve discussed the complications of neck manipulation by chiropractors before, specifically strokes due to injury to a vertebral artery. (Remember the tragic case of Katie May, a young model who died after chiropractic neck manipulation?) It turns out that there are other ways to die from a chiropractic neck manipulation. Witness the case of John Lawlor. First reported over a month ago, the story is that John Lawlor died following a chiropractic adjustment:
A chiropractor has been arrested on suspicion of manslaughter after a retired bank manager died following treatment for backache.
John Lawler, 80, was undergoing routine treatment at a private clinic when he lost consciousness and appeared to have become paralysed from the shoulders down.
He was taken straight to hospital but died the next day as a result of a ‘traumatic spinal cord injury.’
His wife of 55 years, Joan Lawler, 81, was in the chiropractor’s clinic with her husband and witnessed the incident.
Police are investigating to establish whether or not criminal negligence was a factor in his death.
Dr Arleen Scholten, 40, the chiropractor who treated Mr Lawler, was arrested by police on suspicion of manslaughter and released pending further inquiries.
The reaction of the authorities regulating chiropractic in the UK was—shall we say?—less than heartening:
The investigating committee of the General Chiropractic Council met on September 28 to decide whether or not to issue an interim suspension order against Dr Scholten. It decided to allow her to continue to practise.
Speaking from her home in Tollerton, near York, Dr Scholten said yesterday: ‘I’ve been told not to comment at this time.’
Because of course a council of chiropractors won’t act, and of course Scholten is a true believer:
Writing about her life and personal philosophy on her company website, she comments: ‘Chiropractic is a lifestyle for our family. This includes good nutrition, regular exercise, plenty of time outdoors, little screen time and regular chiropractic care.
‘Yes, all five of us are adjusted regularly. Our children were all adjusted the day they were born, two were homebirths and I continue to check their spines regularly. There is a saying in chiropractic, ‘If the twig is bent so grows the tree’.
‘I will forever be dedicated to sharing the health benefits of chiropractic. I am passionate about the science of human wellness and feel morally obligated to educate my patients on ways to increase health and well-being through eating, thinking and moving, in ways congruent with our bodies.’
So she’s been adjusting the spines of her children since the day they were born? That’s some serious dedication to her quackery.
A vertebral fracture, followed by gross mismanagement
Two weeks ago, the results of the coroner’s inquest into the death of Mr. Lawlor were revealed. Specifically, Mr. Lawlor suffered a broken neck:
A MAN suffered a broken neck while being treated by a York chiropractor for an aching leg, an inquest heard today.
John Lawler’s widow Joan told how her husband was on a treatment table at Chiropractic 1st in The Mount in August 2017 when things started to go wrong.
She said he started shouting at chiropractor Dr Arleen Scholten: “You are hurting me. You are hurting me.” Then he began moaning and then said: “I can’t feel my arms.”
Mrs Lawler said Dr Scholten tried to turn him over and then manoeuvred him into a chair next to the treatment table but he had become unresponsive.
What happened next is that Ms. Scholten called an ambulance. She wondered if he had had a stroke, which tells me that she at least recognized the possibility of vertebral artery injury from neck manipulation. She dismissed the possibility because “his features were symmetrical.” She also noted that his lips were blue, but that he was breathing. It would be obvious to any physician that he was not getting enough oxygen.
After the ambulance arrived, the paramedics gave Mr. Lawlor oxygen, treated him, and rushed him to York Hospital, after which he was later transferred to Leeds General Infirmary. There, he underwent an MRI, and his wife was told that the results indicated that he had suffered a broken neck. The doctors also told her that he was now a paraplegic and required a 14 hour operation to stabilize the spine. However, he “just faded away” and died the next day.
There are a number of issues regarding this case. The first, of course, is a question that immediately came to mind: Why on earth would a chiropractor choose manipulation of the cervical spine to treat an “aching leg”? Another question that immediately comes to mind is: Why would a chiropractor treat an 80-year-old man with cervical spine manipulation? Edzard Ernst, who has commented several times on this case, provided a likely answer:
One might be surprised to hear that the chiropractor manipulated the neck of a patient who consulted her not because of neck pain but because of a condition seemingly unrelated to the neck. This is an issue that comes up regularly and which is therefore important; some people might be aware that it is dangerous to see a chiropractor when suffering from neck pain because he/she is bound to manipulate the neck. By contrast, most people would probably think it is ok to consult a chiropractor when suffering from lower back pain, because manipulations in that region is far less risky. The truth, however, is that chiropractors have been taught that the spine is one organ and one entity. Thus they tend to check for subluxations (or whatever name they give to the non-existing condition they all aim to treat) in every region of the spine. If they find one in the neck – and they usually do – they would ‘adjust’ it, meaning they would apply one or more high-velocity, low-amplitude thrusts and manipulate the neck. This could well be, I think, how the chiropractor in the case that is before the court at present came to manipulate the neck of her patient. And this might be how poor Mr Lawler lost his life.
Of course, the reason I also ask why a chiropractor manipulated an old man’s neck is because it’s quite possible that Mr. Lawlor had significant osteoporosis, which is common in the elderly. In that case, as Ernst further explains, it could be argued that manipulation of the neck with normal force could have resulted in the fracture that paralyzed and ultimately killed Mr. Lawlor and that Ms. Scholten wasn’t to blame. On the other hand, it could just as well be argued that she was obligated to check Mr. Lawlor for evidence of osteoporosis or other conditions (such as atherosclerosis if the vertebral arteries) that would put him at a higher risk for complications from cervical manipulation. Indeed, he makes a very persuasive argument that Scholten likely didn’t provide true informed consent by cautioning him about the risk of stroke or neck fracture due to high intensity manipulation. As he put it, “In my view, any clinician applying a potentially harmful therapy has the obligation to make sure there are no contra-indications to it. If that all is so, the chiropractor might have been both negligent and reckless”.
Ernst published a statement from the Lawlor family that was quite telling:
There were several events that went very wrong with John’s chiropractic treatment, before, during, and after the actual manipulation that broke his neck.
Firstly, John thought he was being treated by a medically qualified doctor, when he was not. Furthermore, he had not given informed consent to this treatment.
The chiropractor diagnosed so-called ‘vertebral subluxation complex’ which she aimed to treat by manipulating his neck. We heard this week from medical experts that John had ossified ligaments in his spine, where previously flexible ligaments had turned to bone and become rigid. This condition is not uncommon, and is present in about 10% of those over 50. It would have showed on an X-ray or other imaging technique. The chiropractor did not ask for any images before commencing treatment and was seemingly unaware of the risks of doing a manual manipulation on an elderly patient.
It has become clear that the chiropractor did the manipulation incorrectly, and broke these rigid ligaments during a so-called ‘drop table’ manipulation, causing discs in the cervical spine to rupture and the spinal cord to become crushed. Although these manipulations are done frequently by chiropractors, we have heard that the force applied to his neck by the chiropractor would have had to have been “significant”.
Immediately John reported loss of sensation and paralysis in his arms. At this stage the only safe and appropriate response was to leave him on the treatment bed and await the arrival of the paramedics, and provide an accurate history to the ambulance controller and paramedics. The chiropractor, in fact, manhandled John from the treatment bed into a chair; then tipped his head backwards and gave “mouth to mouth” breaths. She provided an inaccurate and misleading history to the paramedic and ambulance controller, causing the paramedic to treat the incident as “medical” not “traumatic” and to transport John downstairs to the ambulance without stabilising his neck. If the paramedics had been given the full and accurate story, they would have stabilised his neck in situ and transported him on a scoop stretcher – and he would have subsequently survived.
In general, it’s arguable to me whether Mr. Lawlor would have survived if this had been done. What is not arguable, however, is that the mismanagement of the aftermath of his spine fracture by Ms. Scholten greatly reduced his chances of survival or of recovering neurologic function with proper treatment, and that immobilizing his cervical spine would have maximized his chances of survival and recovery of at least some function. Also disturbing is how Mr. Lawlor had thought that he was being treated by a medically qualified doctor. I’m not sure if this meant that he thought Ms. Scholten was a medical doctor or that he considered chiropractors to be “medically qualified doctors”. This confusion, however, is a not uncommon consequence of how chirpractors like to call themselves “doctors” or even “chiropractic physicians” as part of their self-image and marketing.
Ernst also published the findings of the coroner’s inquest:
    • Mr Lawler died because of a tear and dislocation of the C4/C5 intervertebral disc caused by considerable external force.
    • The pathologist’s report also shows that the deceased’s ligaments holding the vertebrae of the upper spine in place were ossified.
    • This is a common abnormality in elderly patients and limits the range of movement of the neck.
    • There was no adequately informed consent by Mr Lawler.
    • Mr Lawler seemed to have been under the impression that the chiropractor, who used the ‘Dr’ title, was a medical doctor.
    • There is no reason to assume that the treatment of Mr Lawler’s neck would be effective for his pain located in his leg.
    • The chiropractor used an ‘activator’ which applies only little and well-controlled force. However, she also employed a ‘drop table’ which applies a larger and not well-controlled force.
Chiropractic “drop tables”: Therapeutic tables or dangerous devices?
Oddly enough, I wasn’t familiar with chiropractic drop table techniques. So I did what I always do when I come across a technique with which I’m not familiar; I did a bit of searching on Google. It didn’t take me long to find a number of videos to help educate me, and some of them are scary.
This first video, for example, doesn’t show cervical manipulation itself, just the table, but the chiropractor states that the table is used for patients who have mobility issues and are hard to move. It also augments the force of the chiropractic manipulation:
Here’s one in which the chiropractors are explaining how the cervical drop table works:
And here’s a video by the company that makes a chiropractic drop table showing how the table works and touting its features:
As you can see from this video, there’s an actual pneumatic mechanism that augments the force of the adjustments:
And this one, too, with the cervical drop demonstration starting at around the 3:30, 4:45, and 10:50 marks:
Next up is a scary one:
And:
And:
I could go on, but you get the idea.
Cervical spine manipulation and serious complications: How common?
How common are injuries like this? Like the estimates for strokes as a complication of chiropractic neck manipulation, estimates vary. A recent review of the practice from the Manitoba Health Professionals Advisory Council identified a total of 159 references: 86 case reports/case series, 37 reviews of the literature, 9 randomized controlled trials, 6 surveys/qualitative studies, 5 case-control studies, 2 retrospective studies, 2 prospective studies and 12 others. The review noted that serious adverse events are rare, but that minor adverse events are common. Minor adverse events range from transient neurological symptoms, headache, increased neck pain or stiffness, fatigue, dizziness or imbalance, extremity weakness, tinnitus, depression, anxiety, nausea and vomiting, blurred vision, and confusion. (Personally, I would consider depression, anxiety, and confusion not to be “minor” adverse events.) Serious adverse events include the aforementioned vertebral artery dissection and stroke complicating manipulation, as well as transient ischemic events (the so-called “mini-stroke” in which the neurologic symptoms are transient), nerve or spinal cord damage, disc injury and/or herniation, fracture or subluxation of vertebrae, and musculoskeletal injuries.
But how common are these serious adverse events? The incidence rates for all serious adverse events following cervical spine manipulation are reported to range from one in 10,000 to one in several million cervical spine manipulations (CSMs) although the literature does appear to agree that that serious adverse events are likely underreported. According to the executive summary, the “best available estimate of incidence of vertebral artery dissection of occlusion attributable to CSM is approximately 1.3 cases for every 100,000 persons <45 years of age receiving CSM within 1 week of manipulative therapy,” and the current “best incidence estimate for vertebral dissection-caused stroke associated with CSM is 0.97 residents per 100,000.” The report also looked at risk factors for serious adverse events, concluding that a number of factors can place patients at a higher risk for these serious complications, including “vertebral artery abnormalities or insufficiency, atherosclerotic or other vascular disease, hypertension, connective tissue disorders, receiving multiple manipulations in the last 4 weeks, receiving a first CSM treatment, visiting a primary care physician, and younger age.” The report also noted that “patients who have experienced prior cervical trauma or neck pain may be at particularly higher risk of experiencing an adverse cerebrovascular event after CSM.”
The conclusion:
The current debate around CSM is notably polarized. Many authors stated that the risk of CSM does not outweigh the benefit, while others maintained that CSM is safe—especially in comparison to conventional treatments—and effective for treating certain conditions, particularly neck pain and headache. Because the current state of the literature may not yet be robust enough to inform definitive prohibitory or permissive policies around the application of CSM, an interim approach that balances both perspectives may involve the implementation of a harm-reduction strategy to mitigate potential harms of CSM until the evidence is more concrete. As noted by authors in the literature, approaches might include ensuring manual therapists are providing informed consent before treatment; that patients are provided with resources to aid in early recognition of a serious adverse event; and that regulatory bodies ensure the establishment of consistent definitions of adverse events for effective reporting and surveillance, institute rigorous protocol for identifying high-risk patients, and create detailed guidelines for appropriate application and contraindications of CSM. Most authors indicated that manipulation of the upper cervical spine should be reserved for carefully selected musculoskeletal conditions and that CSM should not be utilized in circumstances where there has not yet been sufficient evidence to establish benefit.
Personally, I’m of the opinion that high-velocity, low-amplitude cervical spine manipulation like that performed by chiropractors should never be done because there is no robust evidence that it is effective for anything and, in the absence of efficacy, even the very small risk of very serious adverse events ranging from artery dissection to stroke to vertebral fracture (all of which can lead to major disability and even death), is unacceptable. A second part of the report that is spot on is that, if CSM isn’t going to be banned outright, harm mitigation should involve rigorous protocols and genuine informed consent. There’s where the General Chiropractic Council in the UK should come in.
The General Chiropractic Council: Putting the fox in charge of guarding the henhouse
Here’s where the story stands right now. Ms. Scholten is still practicing, as I learned in a story about the case published last Friday. Before I get into that part, I can’t help but note a new revelation in this story, namely that Mr. Lawlor’s GP had recommended a course of physiotherapy, not chiropractic. However, there were waiting lists for both NHS and private physiotherapists; so Mr. Lawlor made an appointment to see Ms. Scholten.
Also:
I don’t think Mum actually knew there was a difference between a physio and a chiropractor,’ says their youngest daughter Clare, 49, an executive in a London publishing house. ‘I wouldn’t have been that aware of the differences either. I was only vaguely aware that Dad was going for a spot of physio.’
Joan certainly assumed that ‘Dr Scholten’ was a medical doctor. ‘You do, don’t you? Particularly that generation,’ says David, 55, the couple’s eldest child who works in finance.
‘You see certificates on the wall and you think, “These are people who know what they are doing.” You put yourself into their hands.’
In addition:
‘For one, she used a stick, an “activator”, which is a small hand-held device that delivers a force to the spine. We heard the sound it would make during the inquest. It was like a thud. There was a sense that a lot of it was for show.’
Yet it was the table-drop treatment which did the damage. This wasn’t the first time John had had it. At an appointment the previous day (he’d had five sessions, although only three were ‘hands on’) Mrs Scholten had carried out this procedure, too. David adds: ‘Dad was shocked by that. Mum was shocked by it. They didn’t like it at all but they went off after with no ill effect, so Dad assumed it must be doing some good.’
Now here’s where the issue with regulation comes in and it’s a key reason why we at SBM so strongly oppose the licensure of quack professions:
They [Mr. Lawlor’s family] had hoped that the coroner would record a verdict of unlawful killing. Coroner Jonathan Heath instead recorded a narrative conclusion that Mr Lawler suffered spinal injuries while undergoing chiropractor adjustment and died from respiratory depression.
However, he did say he would ask the chiropractic regulatory authorities to consider first aid training for chiropractors. He is also calling on the General Chiropractic Council (GCC) to bring in pre-treatment imaging, such as X-rays or scans, to protect the vulnerable.
‘We’ve since discovered that some chiropractors won’t treat patients of Dad’s age, or certainly not without doing scans first. He had a history of degenerative disease, too. He’d had some rods inserted in his lower back in 2009. He should not have been treated, quite simply.’
According to the story, the General Chiropractic Council is still reviewing the case. Ms. Scholten was indeed arrested and barred from practicing, but with the coroner’s final ruling, there are no longer any charges against Ms. Scholten, and she can continue to practice. Suspiciously, contrary to the usual practice of the GCC, it is conducting its hearings in private and wouldn’t allow Mr. Lawlor’s son David to attend, leading him to say:
Suspension hearings are normally open to the public but, on the day, they said I couldn’t be there. I find that unacceptable. This is a different world. It seems to be a little self-regulatory chiropractic bubble, where chiropractors regulate chiropractors.
That is, of course, exactly the problem with giving legal status to pseudoscience and quackery. The laws establishing licensure of chiropractors, acupuncturists, naturopaths, and the like inevitably also create boards to regulate and discipline these quacks, and who’s on the board? Members of the same quack profession. That leads to the boards that regulate these quack professions to turn into exactly that, little quack bubbles that regulate quacks. Thus far, the GCC has done next to nothing, and it wouldn’t surprise me if Ms. Scholten’s actions of having undergone a first aid course and altering her website to make it clear that she is not a medical doctor will satisfy the Council.
Patients like John Lawlor are just collateral damage to the licensure of quackery.
.

Vigorous Chiropractic Adjustment Associated with Potentially Serious Eye Injury
Can vigorous adjustment of the neck cause direct injury to your eye? Probably, but I don’t know. This is based on a single case report. Still, I wouldn’t take the chance. And why do I keep mentioning dugongs?
Clay Jones on October 5, 2018
Link

Proponents of irregular medicine love anecdotes and testimonials. They love them because humans are somewhat unique in the animal kingdom in that we are particularly impressed with personal stories, at least much more so than pangolins and dugongs in my experience. It is simply an unfortunate side effect of our highly developed prefrontal cortex that we place more emphasis on a compelling narrative than on randomized controlled trials.
But when it comes to bridging the gap between infinitesimally plausible interventions and scientific street cred, nothing beats the case report. Surely a poorly designed trial involving multiple human subjects is more impressive, especially when it confirms what you already believe, but these are expensive and time consuming. Much more bang can be extracted from the potential patient per buck with a good story, especially if it’s published in an actual (wink wink nudge nudge) medical journal. Now that I think about, it’s actually the bucks that are being extracted.
To be fair, a case study documented with attention to scientific detail and appropriate context, as opposed to the typical anecdote or testimonial, can have considerable value, even if it should rarely if ever be used to justify claims of a causal nature. They can serve the purpose of disproving an all-inclusive assumption. They can help to guide future research. And if a condition is extremely rare, they might be relied upon for determining an approach to treatment. The case report is best utilized, in my opinion, as a hypothesis generator or even as an educational tool.
Chiropractors love case reports! Maybe not this one though
In prior posts, particularly this one on spinal adjustments as a treatment for Tourette syndrome, I’ve discussed case reports published in the chiropractic literature. These case reports are legion and commonly used to promote the use of chiropractic manipulation to treat non-musculoskeletal conditions. They are almost exclusively published in journals that focus on chiropractic or alternative medicine in general, and frequently demonstrate a fundamental ignorance of the pathophysiology and expected natural course of the condition being treated.
This week a case report of a different color was published in The American Journal of Ophthalmology Case Reports. The authors describe in detail, with cool pictures included in the report, the case of a 59-year-old woman who developed spots in her vision while driving home from a visit to her chiropractor. During the visit, high-velocity, low-amplitude (HVLA) adjustment of her neck was performed.
Although not made clear in the report, it appears that she had sought chiropractic evaluation and treatment for her history of headaches and/or restless leg syndrome. It is possible that she had sought out a chiropractor for help with her psoriasis, but that would be pretty unlikely. I mean, they would never claim to be able to manage psoriasis. Right?
Unfortunately, of course they would.
The patient found her way to a retinal specialist at University of Michigan’s Kellogg Eye Center where she was found to have multiple preretinal (vitreous) hemorrhages, with one over the optic nerve, and a posterior vitreous detachment. After a thorough investigation, they were unable to find any reason for the findings other than trauma. And taking into account the timing of her presentation and the known forceful nature of HVLA neck adjustments, they came to the same conclusion that any rational person would.
Ocular risks from chiropractic adjustments
As has been discussed several times before on SBM, there are uncommon but potentially quite deadly risks when it comes to aggressive neck adjustments. I’m talking about injury to the vertebral artery and subsequent stroke. When a blood vessel in the neck is injured and bleeds, a clot will form that can be dislodged and end up occluding blood flow in the brain or eye. The same can occur when bits of fatty plaque in a carotid artery or disrupted. In the past, there have been case reports like this one (or that one) where this has resulted in visual disturbances.
What makes this case unusual is that it is evidence of the potential for direct traumatic injury to the eye as opposed to the indirect kind of process I’ve just described. The authors of the report have hypothesized that the shearing force of the adjustment tugged on the region where the jelly like filling in your eyeball, known as vitreous, is attached to the retina by millions of tiny fibers. This tugging may have resulted in a small detachment and subsequent bleeding.
Luckily for the patient, they did not find a tear in the retina that would have required surgery and risked permanent vision loss. Her symptoms improved quickly and were completely resolved, as would be expected, by follow-up 2 months later. Unfortunately she was cleared to return to chiropractic care.
I wasn’t able to find a response from the chiropractic community yet, but I have little doubt that it will come.
More fun with case reports?
Here is a list of chiropractic case reports involving the management of blindness and other visual disorders. This is also an interesting read.
Conclusion
Case reports are thin gruel, but they can be interesting and occasionally helpful in the practice of medicine. What they can never be is solid evidence for a causal claim in and of themselves. It requires a thorough understanding of plausibility and pathophysiology, and of the available literature when such a thing exists, to put them into context.
In the case of chiropractic versus the posterior retina, we have to be careful and not give more weight to a report than is deserved just because it is in keeping with our understanding of the risks and benefits of chiropractic. We have to be open to the fact that it is possible that the findings in question happened for some other reason and that the preceding HVLA neck adjustment was a temporal coincidence. That being said, if it looks like a duck, swims like a duck, and quacks like a duck, then it probably isn’t a dugong.

Did chiropractic neck manipulation kill Katie May?
David GorskionFebruary 8, 2016
Link

Well, we’re back.
Yes, after having our WordPress database somehow borked to the point where no new posts could be added and no existing posts could be edited since Friday, Science-Based Medicine is back in business—finally! As a result, some of you might have seen this post elsewhere, as it was considered to be somewhat time-sensitive, and I didn’t want to delay, particularly given that I didn’t know how long SBM would be down. Fortunately, we’re back a bit sooner than I thought; so let’s look at something that was in the news over the weekend.
Katie May was a model, and by all accounts a very successful one, having appeared in Playboy, Sports Illustrated, and other magazines and websites. Self-proclaimed the “Queen of Snapchat,” she also had nearly two million Instagram followers and was a major social media force, having recently parlayed her modeling and social media career into entrepreneurship. She also died unexpectedly on Thursday night at the too-young age of 34, leaving behind a seven-year-old daughter. What makes May’s tragic death an appropriate topic for SBM is not so much her young age but rather the circumstances surrounding her death, particularly the cause. Basically, May died of complications due to stroke, as her family confirmed in a statement issued on Friday:
“It is with heavy hearts that we confirm the passing today of Katie May – mother, daughter, sister, friend, businesswoman, model and social media star – after suffering a catastrophic stroke caused by a blocked carotid artery on Monday,” the statement reads.
“Known as MsKatieMay on the Internet and the “Queen of Snapchat,” she leaves behind millions of fans and followers, and a heartbroken family. We respectfully ask for privacy in this this difficult time. Those wishing to contribute to the living trust being set up for the care of her young daughter may do so at her GoFundMe page.”
Given her young age, that alone makes her death curious, but what makes it discussion-worthy to me is that, having injured her neck in a fall at a photo shoot, she apparently had had two chiropractic neck adjustments before her collapse one week ago that led to her hospitalization, deterioration, and, ultimately, the decision to take her off of life support. Indeed, starting early Friday morning, people were e-mailing and Tweeting at me, some already having concluded that chiropractic killed Katie May. But did it?
Maybe. Or: It’s complicated. At least, answering that question is more complicated than just concluding that May’s adjustment caused the stroke.
Because I had decided to do something highly unusual for me and take the day off Friday in order to recover from my energy-sapping, two-week-long grant writing frenzy, I was hanging out at home when the e-mails and news reports started appearing. I almost whipped out a quick, ranty post for my not-so-secret other blog right then and there, but decided to wait for more news over the weekend and do a post, if appropriate. Doing that allowed me to construct a timeline, which leaves open the biggest question: Was it May’s neck injury or the chiropractic adjustments that caused the stroke that killed her?
Let’s dig in.
A timeline, or: Just the facts, Ma’am
In late January, Katie May was doing a photo shoot. Although the details are not clear, we do know from various sources that during that shoot she fell—hard—and apparently hit her neck on something. After the fall she complained of severe neck pain, severe enough to go to the hospital to be checked out:
Sources with direct knowledge of Katie’s situation tell us the accident happened late last week when she was shooting in Los Angeles. We’re told Katie’s neck pain after the fall was so bad, she went to a hospital to get checked out, and was released later that day.
But on Friday the pain remained — she tweeted, “Pinched a nerve in my neck on a photoshoot and got adjusted this morning. It really hurts!”
So apparently she did go back to her chiropractor on Monday, the same day she suffered her fatal stroke.
One notes that this report, as well as others, conflict with what the family said about May’s death, as reported in People:
“To the best of my family’s knowledge, and we are fairly but not totally certain of this, Katie did not seek medical care prior to Monday evening; if she had, it seems reasonable to conclude, the subsequent days would have unfolded very differently,” her brother, Stephen May, says.
It is, of course, possible that Stephen May didn’t know that his sister was checked out in the emergency room, or it is possible that she never was, although, given multiple news reports indicating that she did seek medical attention, I suspect that she probably did. I haven’t been able to find out for sure. Whatever the case with respect to seeking out standard science-based medical care, we do know that May sought out a chiropractor for neck adjustment. First, here’s her Tweet from January 29:
Pinched a nerve in my neck on a Photoshoot and got adjusted this morning. It really hurts! Any home remedy suggestions loves? XOXO
— Katie May (@Ms_katiemay) January 29, 2016
Then, on January 31 in response to a Tweet by one of her fans asking how her neck was:
Thanks love! It still hurts, going back to chiropractor tomorrow xoxoxo https://t.co/xTw080sjrK
— Katie May (@Ms_katiemay) February 1, 2016
Other than these Tweets, between the time of May’s initial injury on (probably) January 28 and the evening of her stroke (February 1), there was nothing on May’s Twitter or Instagram feeds to indicate that anything was wrong. Her last Instagram post was dated February 1 and included a photo of her in a swimsuit with a message, “️Hope everyone is having a great Monday! It’s very windy here today in LA 🌪☀️😘.” Her Twitter feed abruptly went silent after 5:19 PM PT on February 1, her last Tweet being a photo with her asking her fans to help her “win most Arsenic Girl.” Remember, it was that Monday night when she apparently collapsed and was rushed to the hospital, where she was in critical condition until she was removed from life support on Thursday and died a few hours later that evening.
Given that timeline, which is as accurate as I can currently deduce based on the news reports, the next question is: What killed Katie May? Obviously, it was a stroke. But what caused the stroke that killed her? Was it chiropractic? Was it her original trauma to the neck suffered when she fell? Was it a combination? Contrary to a lot of the speculation out there, this is not nearly as straightforward a question as it sounds at first. Let’s take a look at the two main possibilities.
Chiropractic neck adjustments and stroke
Regular readers of this blog know that chiropractic is a pseudoscientific system of “healing” founded in 1895 by Daniel David Palmer, who claimed to have restored the hearing to a deaf janitor by “adjusting” a bump on his spine. It’s based on the vitalistic concept of “innate intelligence,” whose proper flow through the nervous system is interfered with by “subluxations” in the spine. To chiropractors, the way to remove this interference is to “adjust” the spine. To Palmer, the “innate” intelligence was very much similar to the vitalistic concept of the “spark of life,” the “life force,” or, as it is frequently called in Asian cultures, qi. Of course, there are some spinal conditions for which manipulation is an effective treatment, but many chiropractors go beyond that to claim that chiropractic adjustments can treat allergies, asthma, and a wide variety of other illnesses that have nothing to do with the spine. Many chiropractors are antivaccine, as well. It’s not for nothing that I have frequently referred to chiropractors as inferior physical therapists with delusions of grandeur. If you don’t believe me, consider that there is a movement among chiropractors to win the status of primary care provider, a role they are completely unqualified for.
The issue of whether chiropractic neck adjustments can cause strokes is a question I haven’t really discussed on this blog, mainly because others here at SBM have examined several times in the past, so many times that I never really felt the need to address the question myself. This case, however, is different because it poses the question of whether what killed Katie May was a stroke due to her original trauma or a complication of chiropractic adjustments. Also, it must be pointed out that her stroke would be considered atypical for a chiropractic-induced stroke, for reasons that I will discuss shortly.
What is the relationship between chiropractic neck adjustments and stroke? Given how extensively the issue has been discussed elsewhere, I don’t feel the need to go into my usual level of extreme detail, but a brief (for me) recap is certainly appropriate. First, check out this video of a chiropractor doing neck adjustments:
If you cringe when you hear the pop during the violent twist given to the neck, you’re not alone. So do I. So how could such a motion cause a stroke? To understand that, you need to know a bit more about the anatomy of the neck. I thus refer you to this figure that I stole from one of Mark Crislip’s posts on chiropractic and stroke:

Basically, two very important arteries that supply blood to the brain pass through the two highest vertebrae, the atlas (C1, so named because it was thought to support the head the way the mythical Atlas held up the earth) and the axis (C2). Another illustration shows how the vertebral arteries are tethered to the spine and make a big loop around the atlas before entering the skull and joining together to form the basilar artery (click to embiggen):

It’s thus not difficult to see how a rapid rotation of the head could potentially stretch the basilar arteries. Generally, chiropractors describe this as “high velocity, low amplitude” (HVLA), which it is, but, given the constraints of vertebral artery anatomy, high amplitude is not required to cause injury. With HVLA, it is quite possible to tear the intima (the lining of the artery consisting of vascular endothelial cells). Intimal tears become “sticky” for platelets, leading them to lodge there and start to form a clot. This is the same reason atherosclerotic plaques can lead to strokes; the “rough” area of the plaque is thrombogenic; i.e., has a tendency to attract platelets and cause clots. When a clot forms in such an injured area of intima, regardless of where the artery is, one of three things can happen. It can resolve completely; it can leave a narrowed segment of the artery as it resolves; or it can break off and flow further downstream where it will lodge in a narrow section of the artery and block blood flow. When that happens in the brain, it’s called a stroke.
As much as chiropractors try (unsuccessfully) to deny it, there is a convincing correlation between chiropractic neck manipulation and vertebral artery stroke in multiple studies. The evidence has been summarized in Quackwatch. It’s been discussed by others here, including Mark Crislip, Harriet Hall, Steve Novella, and Sam Homola. Clay Jones even described a case of a six year old child who suffered a stroke after chiropractic manipulation, while Harriet Hall described the case of a 40 year old woman named Sandra Nette, who suffered a stroke after a neck adjustment, leaving her in a state very close to locked-in syndrome, leading to a landmark lawsuit.
How strong is the correlation, though? Harriet points out that estimates of neck manipulation-induced strokes range from one in ten million manipulations to one in 40,000. Not surprisingly, it’s chiropractic literature that tends to downplay the risk and come up with the lower estimates of post-manipulation strokes. It’s a difficult question to study, because the incidence of vertebral artery strokes is very low to begin with; so detecting increased risk is difficult. For instance, one study of patients under 45 found that those who had this kind of stroke were more than five times more likely to have visited a chiropractor during the preceding week than control patients. Meanwhile, studies that purport to show that neck manipulation is not associated with stroke tend to have serious flaws, as Mark Crislip likes to point out.
The link between neck manipulation and basilar artery stroke is definitely plausible on anatomic considerations. There is enough evidence that it is real as to be concerned. However, it must be conceded that such chiropractic-induced strokes are admittedly very uncommon. As has been pointed out, given how rare basilar artery strokes are in young people, even a high relative risk of such a stroke after a chiropractic intervention would still be a low risk. The problem, of course, is that the consequences of such strokes, even if they are rare, can be catastrophic. Balancing the lack of evidence that chiropractic neck manipulation is more effective for neck pain than, for example, simply gently moving the neck around, with its small risk of a catastrophic complication and the fact that most chiropractors don’t provide truly informed consent about the risks of stroke after cervical manipulation, I tend to agree with Harriet Hall that “existing evidence is inadequate to conclusively determine causality, but I think it supports a high probability of causality, and the alternate explanations [offered] to exonerate chiropractors are questionable.” Given that assessment, I find it hard to justify cervical manipulation as a treatment for, well, anything.
But what about Katie May?
So how does this evidence apply to the case of Katie May? Here’s the problem. By all news reports, Katie May didn’t suffer a vertebral artery stroke. She suffered a carotid artery stroke. While it is true that cervical manipulation very likely can cause vertebral artery strokes, it is not at all clear whether such manipulation can cause carotid artery strokes. From a simple anatomic standpoint, there is less plausibility, as well, but not zero. Let’s take a look at carotid artery anatomy (click to embiggen):

In the neck, you have two carotid arteries. More specifically, these are the common carotid arteries. Around the level of the thyroid cartilage, the common carotid artery splits into external and internal branches. The external branch supplies blood to the face and neck. The internal branch proceeds up the neck to the temporal bone, where, to put it simply, it enters a canal in the petrous portion of the temporal bone and emerges within the skull to supply the brain and other structures (such as the eye) by branching into several arteries, the end branches of which are the anterior and middle cerebral arteries. When atherosclerotic plaque builds up in this system, it most commonly builds up in the internal carotid artery just past the bifurcation of the common carotid, and that’s where vascular surgeons perform carotid endarterectomies to remove such plaques and prevent strokes.
Evidence implicating chiropractic manipulation as a cause of strokes arising from the carotid system is much thinner than the evidence for chiropractic-induced vertebral artery strokes. There have been case reports, such as one that Harriet Hall discussed in which a man who had known carotid disease, with calcified plaque, noticed left arm weakness and numbness 30 minutes after a chiropractic neck manipulation. Imaging showed a calcified embolus in the right middle cerebral artery, which was strongly suggestive that neck manipulation had loosened part of the plaque an allowed this embolus to flow into the middle cerebral artery. Other sources of embolus were systematically ruled out. Another case report described a 34-year-old, otherwise-healthy man who suffered acute left-sided numbness and loss of coordination after chiropractic neck manipulation. He was found to have bilateral carotid artery dissections and a right vertebral artery dissection. (An arterial dissection occurs when there is a tear in the innermost intimal layer, allowing the shear force of flowing blood to start to pull that layer away from the muscular layer of the artery.) Other case reports exist as well, some linking dissection to collagen-vascular disease. However, larger studies have failed to find a compelling link between carotid artery strokes and chiropractic neck manipulation.
In other words, there is more uncertainty about a link between chiropractic manipulation and stroke from carotid arteries, which makes the case for link between Katie May’s two neck manipulations and her stroke harder to argue.
Post-traumatic stroke
Another possibility is that Katie May died of post-traumatic stroke, as initial reports suggested before people noticed that she had Tweeted about undergoing neck adjustment and reports came out that she had undergone two such adjustments between injuring her neck and suffering her massive stroke. The annual incidence of spontaneous internal carotid artery dissection is around 2.5-3 per 100,000, making it pretty rare, although the true incidence of dissection is probably higher because this number doesn’t take into account injuries without neurologic symptoms. The most common initial symptoms of a dissection include neck pain and headache, the former of which May definitely had. Crissey et al. described four main mechanisms leading to carotid injury:
    • Neck hyperextension associated with rotation (which May might have had from her manipulation).
    • Direct blow to the neck (which May almost certainly appears to have had from her fall).
    • Blunt intra-oral trauma (which May didn’t have).
    • Basilar skull fracture involving the carotid canal (which May also didn’t have, at least not as far as we know).
Carotid artery dissection has also been reported after sports injuries, the sports including judo, skiing, yoga, ice hockey, rowing, wrestling, horse riding, soccer, jogging, and others—even after treadmill running. In other words, although they are rare, trivial trauma can cause carotid dissections in young, healthy people.
Once such an injury occurs, the latency period for an ischemic event (i.e., stroke) is such that 80% of strokes arise within the first seven days (which May’s did), but post-dissection strokes can still occur as long as five months later.
So what killed Katie May?
So what killed Katie May? The bottom line is that we don’t know for sure. We can’t know for sure. If you leave out the chiropractic manipulations of her neck, her clinical history—at least as far as I can ascertain it from existing news reports—is classic for a dissection due to neck trauma. She was, after all, a young person who suffered a seemingly relatively minor neck injury that, unbeknownst to her, could have caused a carotid artery dissection, leading to a stroke four or five days later. Even if May were examined in the emergency room shortly after her injury, in the absence of neurological symptoms it would have been very easy to miss the possibility of an intimal tear that ultimately could lead to a dissection. Absent focal neurological findings, there’s really nothing on physical exam that can raise the index of suspicion for a dissection, and given how rare dissections are after trauma, doing an ultrasound or angiography would have been hard to justify absent more worrisome symptoms.
Thus, it seems to be jumping to conclusions for May’s friend Christina Passanisi to say that May “really didn’t need to have her neck adjusted, and it killed her.” Don’t get me wrong. I completely agree that May didn’t need to have her neck adjusted, particularly after having suffered trauma to it. I just can’t be so sure that it was the manipulation that killed her, given that May’s history also fits with that of a traumatic carotid dissection. Even if there were an autopsy that found an internal carotid artery dissection, there would be no good way to tell whether the trauma from May’s fall or trauma from her two neck adjustments caused it.
That being said, don’t mistake my concluding that we can’t be sure that the chiropractic neck manipulation didn’t cause May’s stroke with my concluding that it didn’t cause her stroke. Her two chiropractic manipulations might well have either worsened an existing intimal tear or caused a new one that led to her demise. Or they might have had nothing to do with her stroke, her fate having been sealed days before when she fell during that photoshoot. There is just no way of knowing for sure. It is certainly not wrong to suspect that chiropractic neck manipulation might have contributed to Katie May’s demise, but it is incorrect to state with any degree of certainty that her manipulation did kill her.

Chiropractic Neck Manipulations in the News
Caitlin Jensen’s chiropractor called 911 when she developed alarming symptoms after neck manipulation. She had a heart attack, was pulseless for 10 minutes, and suffered traumatic brain injury. Surgeons found dissections of 4 arteries in the neck. A month later, she remains paralyzed and is still in the ICU.
Harriet Hall on July 19, 2022
Link


I’ve been following the news reports about Caitlin Jensen, who remains paralyzed in the ICU a month after a visit to her chiropractor. She is a 28-year-old woman who had just graduated from Georgia Southern University in May with a master’s degree in chemistry and biology.The first report I read, from Yahoo, said “It’s unclear if Jensen’s injury occurred before or during the appointment with her chiropractor.” The news stories repeated many of the same details and quotations from family members but lacked important information. I read everything I could find online, and here’s how I pieced it together.
On June 16 she visited a chiropractor in Savannah. Although most news stories did not name him, one did. I won’t. He has refused to comment, saying HIPAA rules do not allow him to divulge patient information. Apparently the reason for her visit to the chiropractor was “neck stiffness,” which she attributed to long periods of studying for exams. (But one report says she went for treatment of back pain?!) The exact sequence of events is not clear, but Caitlyn’s mother says the chiropractor phoned her to tell her he had called 911 and an ambulance was taking Caitlyn to the hospital because she had had a bad reaction to his treatment.
She went into a coma, had a cardiac arrest, and was pulseless for 10 minutes.
The surgeons were able to revive her. They found dissections of 4 arteries in the neck, repaired some of the tears, and inserted a stent in one artery. (A dissection is a tear in the inner lining of the artery. The resulting accumulation of blood can lead to blood clots, interference with blood flow, and strokes.) There are 4 main arteries in the neck, 2 vertebral and 2 carotid arteries, so it sounds like all 4 had dissections.
After a month, she is still unable to speak and can only wiggle her left toes and blink her eyes; the rest of her body remains paralyzed. In addition to the paralysis, she also suffered a traumatic brain injury. The family has established a GoFundMe page where they post regular updates on her condition. It has already raised over $60,000 to help pay for her treatment.
All the doctors who treated Caitlin were convinced that chiropractic neck manipulation was the cause of the dissections.
The risk of stroke with neck manipulation has been covered many times on SBM.
Chiropractor Samuel Homola wrote an excellent review of the subject in 2017. And Jann Bellamy reported on a recent study that:
“adds to the growing body of evidence that neck manipulation is an independent risk factor for cervical arterial dissection and stroke. The authors conclude:
Based on our findings, all patients who visited chiropractors for cervical spine manipulation should be informed of the potential risks and of the need to seek immediate medical assistance should symptoms suggestive of dissection or stroke occur during or after manipulation.
In fact, they suggested that patients might well avoid chiropractors altogether:
Until the actual level of risk from chiropractic manipulation is known, patients with neck pain may be better served by equally effective passive physical therapy exercise.
Keep in mind that chiropractors manipulate necks to correct “chiropractic subluxations” that have never been shown to exist.
It’s fascinating to read all the comments following the online articles about Caitlin Jensen. Satisfied patients rave about what chiropractors have done to help them, often claiming dramatic cures from treatments that have been tested in controlled studies and shown not to work. Dissatisfied patients complain that chiropractic treatment either didn’t help or made them worse. Some chiropractors accept that neck manipulation can cause strokes but insist that this is exceedingly rare, estimated at 0.05 to 1.46 strokes in every ten million neck manipulations. Since they believe that neck manipulations are effective, they apparently think the very small risk is acceptable. Other chiropractors deny that there is any risk at all. They argue that these patients already had dissections in the arteries of their necks and that was the reason they had neck pain and visited the chiropractor. But it seems to me that if a patient already had a tear in a vertebral artery, the very worst thing you could do is subject the neck to rapid-thrust manipulations that would only put more stress on that artery and increase the damage.
There is no reliable way to predict which patients are at risk of stroke. And chiropractors are not able to diagnose or treat a vertebral artery dissection; for that, sophisticated imaging facilities and medical and surgical specialists are required. It has been argued that there is no longer any place for chiropractors in modern medicine, since physical therapists can do everything a chiropractor does. And they try to base their treatments on scientific evidence rather than on a prescientific superstition.
Chiropractors remind us that spontaneous dissections can occur in the vertebral arteries, as in the so-called beauty parlor strokes where the neck is hyperextended for a shampoo. Spontaneous dissections occurring simultaneously in all 4 neck arteries are so rare that they warrant case reports like this one where a stroke was caused by intractable vomiting.
A review by Edzard Ernst concluded “With the possible exception of back pain, chiropractic spinal manipulation has not been shown to be effective for any medical condition.” The risk of stroke from neck manipulation is uncertain, but a significant risk can’t be ruled out, and there may be massive under-reporting because chiropractors are not required to report strokes and may not even be aware that a patient has had a stroke following neck manipulation.
Conclusion: The risk/benefit ratio is not favorable
Since the high velocity low amplitude (HVLA) neck manipulations typically used by chiropractors have not been proven effective for anything, and since significant risk can’t be ruled out, accurate evaluation of the risk/benefit ratio is impossible, and patients can’t give truly informed consent. The prudent course would be to avoid rapid-thrust neck manipulations and use other treatments that have been proven effective, including gentle mobilization.

The Good. The Bad. The Ugly.
Anything new regarding stroke and chiropractic neck manipulation?
Mark Crislip on May 16, 2023
Link

… wanted in 14 counties of this state, the condemned is found guilty of the crimes of murder, armed robbery of citizens, state banks and post offices, the theft of sacred objects, arson in a state prison, perjury, bigamy, deserting his wife and children, inciting prostitution, kidnapping, extortion, receiving stolen goods, selling stolen goods, passing counterfeit money, and, contrary to the laws of this state, the condemned is guilty of using marked cards and loaded dice. Therefore, according to the powers vested in us, we sentence the accused here before us Tuco Benedicto Pacifico Juan Maria Ramirez, known as the rat, and any other aliases he might have, to hang by the neck until dead. May God have mercy on his soul. Proceed. Call in the chiropractor.
The Good, the Bad and the Ugly Kind of.
I presume those who go into health care do so in part for semi-altruistic reasons. Whether practicing in reality-based or fiction-based medical systems, most practitioners want to do right by people. No one, or almost no one (there are always the psycho outliers) wants to harm their patients.
It is hard for practitioners to admit that they harmed people in the attempt to make them better. I do not find it surprising that doctors in general do not like to recognize that their interventions harmed the patient, although sometimes harm is the price of doing business. I found in my years of working in infection control and quality that surgeons were often a bit more reticent at admitting they harmed a patient. In medicine, the damage we do is often more indirect: the late complication of medications as an example. Much of what surgeons do is hands-on and the injury more direct.
I wonder, in a digression, how many of those in the SCAM community continue to practice despite a crisis of faith in their intervention. I can’t find any data as it relates to chiropractors, although in all the SCAM professions there must be those who are in too deep and can’t leave after realizing their SCAM is a farce. I can find that 16% of pastors have doubts about the existence of god. Maybe the same percent in SCAMs?
It is messy, of course. There are Chiropractic bodies that subscribe to the idea that
“.. teaching of vertebral subluxation complex as a vitalistic construct that claims that it is the cause of disease is unsupported by evidence. Its inclusion in a modern chiropractic curriculum in anything other than an historical context is therefore inappropriate and unnecessary.”
But if no subluxation, what it is the point of the whole SCAM, much less manipulating the spine? Why be a chiropractor?
Chiropractors, being very hands on, seem particularly recalcitrant to the idea that they can harm others, especially causing strokes. In my prior tour of duty here at SBM, I discussed the topic in 2008 (Chiropractic and Stroke: Evaluation of One Paper) and 2015 (Chiropractic and Stroke: The question is not answered).
My conclusion was, yep, chiropractic neck manipulation rarely causes stroke by way of a vertebral artery dissection (VAD) and that the pathology and mechanism resembled that of a hanging, a description that was not well received by chiropractors. Go figure.
Some chiropractors have a bit of self-awareness. 40% of those not practicing chiropractic agree that 
Being injured by a chiropractor or causing injury by chiropractic treatment can be a factor in leaving active practice.
Along with a variety of other reasons to abandon the field. Chiropratic seems like a profession (there is no good antonym for profession, which is a shame. I suppose you could call many SCAM providers a professional and their job a profession, but the terms seem wrong) with many issues, but some, at least, recognize that harm is a potential byproduct of their interventions.
I wondered, in the last 8 years, was there anything new on the topic. What piqued my interest was a New York Times article, Is It Safe to Get Your Neck Manipulated by a Chiropractor? The subhead concludes, “Most joint manipulations aren’t dangerous, but one rare complication can result in serious injury.”
The NYT, unfortunately, never uses references, but notes
For example, a small study found that 15 percent of arterial dissections occurred after a sporting activity, and 11 percent followed a chiropractic manipulation. Several studies have shown the risk of arterial dissection and stroke to be three to 12 times higher in people who’ve recently had a neck manipulation, according to a review by the American Heart Association’s Stroke Council.
and
It is unclear how common the complication is following chiropractic care — one estimate says that an arterial dissection occurs in one out of 1,000 neck manipulations, another says one in 5.8 million (three of the four authors on that study worked for chiropractic associations).
A review I found pegged it at
It is estimated that 1 in 20,000 cervical spine manipulations cause a stroke.
It is kind of scary how relatively minor trauma such as coughing, sneezing, or vomiting can precede a vertebral artery tear. I remember a case from early in my practice that occurred as a result of hyperextension during yoga.
Of course, professional chiropractors (there are amateurs) will have none of it:
…a visit to a chiropractor is more often the result of an arterial dissection, not the cause of it.“These patients have an artery that’s been injured in some way,” causing neck pain and headaches, Dr. Lauretti said. “Some of them go to their primary care doctor, some of them go to their chiropractor. If the patient has a stroke following a visit to the chiropractor, the chiropractor gets blamed.”
Same as it ever was.
The NYT articles on SCAM are often interesting with the classic journalist propensity to give both sides of a discussion. As the fundamental construct of chiropractic, subluxation and their correction, is a complete fantasy unhinged from reality, I always find this entertaining. SCAMs are usually afforded a legitimacy other delusions, like stolen presidential elections or faked moon landings, are not.
Those who recognize that chiropractic is a fiction are noted to be, “critics (who) claim the field lacks scientific validity.” Well, duh. And claim? I also claim there is no scientific validity to the tooth fairy or Zeus. Just what is the bar one must reach for lacking scientific validity?
All of medicine is a risk-benefit. The risk associated with an intervention (fixing said subluxation) that has zero, nil, nada, zip, zilch, probability of doing anything beneficial should have zero complications. Relief of self-limited pain should have zero catastrophic complications. Small benefits should have small risks.
The article, as is often the case with discussions of chiropractic, is not specific about the benefits of have one’s neck manipulated to fix an imaginary subluxation or for pain vs. the multimodal interventions for neck pain one might receive in addition to manipulation: heat, massage, traction, ultrasound, etc.
Since I last wrote on the topic, not much new has been published on the topic. Some case reports and series, like
Of the 141 patients with cervical artery dissection, 12 had documented chiropractic neck manipulation prior to the onset of the symptoms that led to medical presentation.
And another series where
34 out of our 310 patients suffered a chiropractor-associated injury. These patients tended to be younger (p = 0.01), female (p = 0.003), and have fewer comorbidities (p = 0.005) compared to patients with other-cause VADs.
Those are numbers that should give one pause.
There was the chiropractor (one of several case reports) who proudly reported that he recognized a vertebral artery stroke before he could do manipulation. Ohhhhh. Minimal competency in neurology. Impressive. And see? The stroke comes before the chiropractor, and we feel the need to publish the fact we can recognize very basic neurologic conditions. Kind of sad.
The problem, of course, with rare events is determining causality. Although 12/141 and 34/310 ain’t that rare. But the literature is murky at best depending on what approach is taken to determine the incidence of post chiropractic stroke. It is unlikely that chiropractors are going to apply the precautionary principle any time soon.
When an activity raises threats of harm to human health or the environment, precautionary measures should be taken even if some cause and effect relationships are not fully established scientifically. In this context the proponent of an activity, rather than the public, should bear the burden of proof.
Definitive proof will always be lacking, so how’s about, for hoots and giggles, applying Hills Criteria to the topic? Hills Criteria have been applied to the subluxations and
There is a significant lack of evidence in the literature to fulfill Hill’s criteria of causation as regards chiropractic subluxation. No supportive evidence is found for the chiropractic subluxation being associated with any disease process or of creating suboptimal health conditions requiring intervention. Regardless of popular appeal, this leaves the subluxation construct in the realm of unsupported speculation. This lack of supportive evidence suggests the subluxation construct has no valid clinical applicability.
But no one has applied Hills to chiropractic and stroke. Let us run through Hills list and see what we get.
Strength : How strong is the association between the cause and the effect?That’s a tough one, but I would rate it as reasonably strong when all the relatively minor causes of vertebral artery dissection are considered. 8/10.
Consistency: Consistent findings observed by different persons in different places with different samples strengthens the likelihood of an effect.I give this a 9/10. All the negative studies are by chiropractors, so it is a go to Midas get a muffler situation.
Specificity: Causation is likely if there is a very specific population at a specific site and disease with no other likely explanation. The more specific an association between a factor and an effect is, the bigger the probability of a causal relationship.10/10 here.
Temporality: The effect has to occur after the cause.10/10.
Biological gradient (dose–response relationship): Greater exposure should generally lead to greater incidence of the effect.That’s also a tough one since VAD is so rare. 6/10.
Plausibility: A plausible mechanism between cause and effect is helpful.10/10.
Coherence: Coherence between epidemiological and laboratory findings increases the likelihood of an effect. However, Hill noted that “lack of such laboratory evidence cannot nullify the epidemiological effect on associations.”NA. I know of no lab data that would apply.
Experiment: “Occasionally it is possible to appeal to experimental evidence.”NA. I know of no lab data that would apply.
Analogy: The use of analogies or similarities between the observed association and any other associations.Like a hanging? 10/10.
Of course, Hill’s Criteria are not the 9 commandments for determining causation, but a nice conceptual framework to apply when considering causation when definitive data is wanted.
Might one conclude from Hills criteria that chiropractic manipulation can lead to vertebral artery dissection and stroke? You bet. Do professional chiropractors care? Not so much. There is no good, only the bad and the ugly.

   Beware the Spinal Trap
Steven Novella
Link
Last year Simon Singh wrote a piece for the Guardian that was critical of the modern practice of chiropractic. The core of his complaint was that chiropractors provide services and make claims that are not adequately backed by evidence – they are not evidence-based practitioners. In response to his criticism the British Chiropractic Association (BCA) sued Simon personally for libel. They refused offers to publish a rebuttal to his criticism, or to provide the evidence Simon said was lacking. After they were further criticized for this, the BCA eventually produced an anemic list of studies purported to support the questionable treatments, but really just demonstrating the truth of Simon’s criticism (as I discuss at length here).
In England suing for libel is an effective strategy for silencing critics. The burden of proof is on the one accused (guilty until proven innnocent) and the costs are ruinous. Simon has persisted, however, at great personal expense.
This is an issue of vital importance to science-based medicine. A very necessary feature of science is public debate and criticism – absolute transparency.This is also not an isolated incident. Some in the alternative medicine community are attempting to assert that criticism is unprofessional, and they have used accusations of both unprofessionalism and libel as a method of silencing criticism of their claims and practices. This has happened to David Colquhoun and Ben Goldacre, and others less prominent but who have communicated to me directly attempts at silencing their criticism.
This behavior is intolerable and is itself unprofessional, an assault on academic freedom and free speech, and anathema to science as science is dependent upon open and vigorous critical debate.
What those who will attempt to silence their critics through this type of bullying must understand is that such attempts will only result in the magnification of the criticism by several orders of magnitude. That is why we are reproducing Simon Singh’s original article (with a couple of minor alterations) on this site and many others. Enjoy.
—–
Some practitioners claim it is a cure-all, but the research suggests chiropractic therapy has mixed results – and can even be lethal, says Simon Singh.
You might be surprised to know that the founder of chiropractic therapy, Daniel David Palmer, wrote that “99% of all diseases are caused by displaced vertebrae”. In the 1860s, Palmer began to develop his theory that the spine was involved in almost every illness because the spinal cord connects the brain to the rest of the body. Therefore any misalignment could cause a problem in distant parts of the body.
In fact, Palmer’s first chiropractic intervention supposedly cured a man who had been profoundly deaf for 17 years. His second treatment was equally strange, because he claimed that he treated a patient with heart trouble by correcting a displaced vertebra.
You might think that modern chiropractors restrict themselves to treating back problems, but in fact some still possess quite wacky ideas. The fundamentalists argue that they can cure anything, including helping treat children with colic, sleeping and feeding problems, frequent ear infections, asthma and prolonged crying – even though there is not a jot of evidence.
I can confidently label these assertions as utter nonsense because I have co-authored a book about alternative medicine with the world’s first professor of complementary medicine, Edzard Ernst. He learned chiropractic techniques himself and used them as a doctor. This is when he began to see the need for some critical evaluation. Among other projects, he examined the evidence from 70 trials exploring the benefits of chiropractic therapy in conditions unrelated to the back. He found no evidence to suggest that chiropractors could treat any such conditions.
But what about chiropractic in the context of treating back problems? Manipulating the spine can cure some problems, but results are mixed. To be fair, conventional approaches, such as physiotherapy, also struggle to treat back problems with any consistency. Nevertheless, conventional therapy is still preferable because of the serious dangers associated with chiropractic.
In 2001, a systematic review of five studies revealed that roughly half of all chiropractic patients experience temporary adverse effects, such as pain, numbness, stiffness, dizziness and headaches. These are relatively minor effects, but the frequency is very high, and this has to be weighed against the limited benefit offered by chiropractors.
More worryingly, the hallmark technique of the chiropractor, known as high-velocity, low-amplitude thrust, carries much more significant risks. This involves pushing joints beyond their natural range of motion by applying a short, sharp force. Although this is a safe procedure for most patients, others can suffer dislocations and fractures.
Worse still, manipulation of the neck can damage the vertebral arteries, which supply blood to the brain. So-called vertebral dissection can ultimately cut off the blood supply, which in turn can lead to a stroke and even death. Because there is usually a delay between the vertebral dissection and the blockage of blood to the brain, the link between chiropractic and strokes went unnoticed for many years. Recently, however, it has been possible to identify cases where spinal manipulation has certainly been the cause of vertebral dissection.
Laurie Mathiason was a 20-year-old Canadian waitress who visited a chiropractor 21 times between 1997 and 1998 to relieve her low-back pain. On her penultimate visit she complained of stiffness in her neck. That evening she began dropping plates at the restaurant, so she returned to the chiropractor. As the chiropractor manipulated her neck, Mathiason began to cry, her eyes started to roll, she foamed at the mouth and her body began to convulse. She was rushed to hospital, slipped into a coma and died three days later. At the inquest, the coroner declared: “Laurie died of a ruptured vertebral artery, which occurred in association with a chiropractic manipulation of the neck.”
This case is not unique. In Canada alone there have been several other women who have died after receiving chiropractic therapy, and Edzard Ernst has identified about 700 cases of serious complications among the medical literature. This should be a major concern for health officials, particularly as under-reporting will mean that the actual number of cases is much higher.
If spinal manipulation were a drug with such serious adverse effects and so little demonstrable benefit, then it would almost certainly have been taken off the market.
Simon Singh is a science writer in London and the co-author, with Edzard Ernst, of Trick or Treatment? Alternative Medicine on Trial. This is an edited version of an article published in The Guardian for which Singh is being personally sued for libel by the British Chiropractic Association.

   Are Prenatal Ultrasounds Dangerous?
Harriet Hall
Link
Several questionable sources are spreading alarms about the possible dangers of prenatal ultrasound exams (sonograms). An example is Christine Anderson’s article on the ExpertClick website. In the heading, it says she “Never Liked Ultrasound Technology.”
[She] has never been sold on the safety using Ultrasounds for checking on the fetuses of pregnant women, and for the last decade her fears have been confirmed with a series of studies pointing to possible brain damage to the babies from this technology.
Should We Believe Her?
Should we avoid ultrasounds because Anderson never liked them? Should we trust her judgment that her fears have been confirmed by studies? Who is she?
“Dr.” Christine Anderson is a pediatric chiropractor in Hollywood who believes a lot of things that are not supported by science or reason. Her website mission statement includes
We acknowledge the devastating effects of the vertebral subluxation on human health and therefore recognize that the spines of all children need to be checked soon after birth, so they may grow up healthy.
It also states that “drugs interfere… and weaken the mind, body, and spirit.” Anderson is a homeopath, a craniosacral practitioner, a vegan, and a yoga teacher. She advises her pregnant patients to avoid toxins by only drinking filtered water and only eating organic foods. She sells her own yoga DVD.
In her own pregnancies she refused ultrasound and other prenatal screening tests. This was her idiotic reasoning:
I trusted in my body’s innate wisdom that if the pregnancy was moving forward, then everything was going OK in my baby’s development.
Apparently on her planet if a pregnancy has not spontaneously aborted that means the baby is developing normally, and no abnormal child is ever born. And perhaps all the children are above average?
She believes in many alleged benefits of chiropractic that are not substantiated by any evidence. She says that our emotions create chemical changes in our bodies that can affect our developing babies; and that chiropractic helps to keep those feel good chemicals flowing freely. She believes that chiropractic frees up any interference to the nervous system and since the nervous system controls all the functions in the body, chiropractic manipulations allow the organs to optimally process any toxins they encounter. She believes getting regular chiropractic care reduces labor times.
Based on this, I am not impressed by her medical judgment or her understanding of biology or science, but that doesn’t necessarily mean she is wrong about ultrasound. What does she say?
Alleged Risks of Ultrasound According to Anderson
    • Ultrasound heats the tissue and researchers suspect that the waves cause small local gas pockets which vibrate and collapse called cavitation. The gas can reach up to temperatures of thousands of degrees (Celsium) [sic] leading to production of potentially toxic chemical reactions.
    • Studies done on mice have shown intestinal bleeding caused by changes in the cells. Scientists conclude that there would be similar effects in humans.
    • Ultrasound has been linked to the following abnormalities:
        ◦ Left handedness in children who are supposed to be right-handed. Although there is nothing inherently wrong with being left handed, the change is attributed to a subtle damage to the brain. Males are more affected than female fetuses, probably because the male brain develops later.
        ◦ Early labor, premature birth, miscarriage, low birth weight, poorer health at birth, and perinatal death.
        ◦ Increased learning disabilities, epilepsy, delayed speech development, dyslexia
She also alleges that no studies have been done to prove the safety of these devices. This is demonstrably false.
Elsewhere, prenatal ultrasound exposure has even been accused of causing autism although a study found no association.
Risks According to Scientists
Obstetricians and radiologists who have evaluated the peer-reviewed literature have found no evidence of harm except for an apparent correlation between ultrasound exposure and left-handedness (in males only!). Such odd-sounding correlations are usually not significant, and are mostly good for a chuckle.
Experts place little reliance on the mouse studies, since the dosages tested were higher than what humans are exposed to and since no corresponding clinical consequences have been detected in humans. Nevertheless, they acknowledge theoretical reasons for concern, and they recommend that medically unnecessary ultrasounds be avoided under the precautionary principle.
Does Routine Ultrasound Affect Outcomes?
A large study (15,530 women) published in The New England Journal of Medicine found that routine screening did not reduce perinatal morbidity and mortality. There were no significant differences in the rate of preterm delivery, distribution of birth weight, or outcomes within the subgroups of women with multiple gestations, small-for-gestational-age infants, and post-date pregnancies. Finally, the detection of major anomalies by ultrasound examination did not alter outcomes. The authors pointed out that routinely screening more than 4 million pregnant women annually in the United States at $200 per scan would increase costs by more than $1 billion.
A Finnish study found that perinatal mortality was significantly lower in the screened than in the control group (4.6/1000 vs 9.0/1000); but this was attributed to improved early detection of major malformations which led to induced abortion. All twin pregnancies were detected before the 21st gestational week in the screening group compared with 76.3% in the control group; perinatal mortality in the small series of twins was 27.8/1000 vs 65.8/1000, respectively.
Caveats: These studies did not look for long-term consequences like learning disabilities. And there are other considerations besides morbidity and mortality. Ultrasound can reassure patients or allow them to plan ahead for multiple births or abnormal infants, and it can guide obstetric management.
Reasons for Doing Ultrasounds
Ultrasounds can detect fetal abnormalities and can help guide obstetric care by detecting problems like multiple fetuses and placenta previa. There are many legitimate reasons for doing them, especially in high-risk pregnancies or when a specific problem is suspected.
Reasons for Not Doing Routine Ultrasounds
False alarms can be raised. Apparent abnormalities may cause worry but turn out not to be significant. Placenta previa detected early in pregnancy frequently resolves before delivery.
There is no way to completely rule out the possibility of a low risk of long-term consequences. Trying to identify such consequences by even the most careful epidemiologic studies is fraught with pitfalls, since if you look for every possibility you will inevitably find a few spurious correlations. Experts agree that routine ultrasound screening is not necessary in low-risk pregnancies and that ultrasounds for nonmedical reasons should be discouraged.
Some nonmedical uses are particularly objectionable. Ultrasounds are being used in India and elsewhere to determine sex for the purpose of aborting undesired female fetuses. Ultrasound is being commercially promoted for “keepsake” pictures and movies like this 5 minute video. Tom Cruise was roundly criticized by doctors for buying his own ultrasound machine for home use.
Conclusion
There is no reason to fear prenatal ultrasounds that are ordered by science-based medical professionals and performed by qualified technicians, but it seems prudent to exercise caution and not do them for frivolous reasons.
Considering that Anderson practices homeopathy, subluxation-based chiropractic, and craniosacral therapy, disparages drugs, and manipulates the spines of newborn infants, I think her own practices are far more worrisome than the ultrasounds she fears.

   Compare and Contrast
Mark Crislip
Link
I have been in Infectious Diseases for almost 25 years. I have two major jobs: I see inpatient consults and I chair the Infection Control program. I have been involved in quality improvement, especially as it relates to hospital acquired infections, for my entire career. It has been an interesting quarter century. Year after year we have driven down infection rates and other kinds of mortality and morbidity in hospitalized patients. Everyone recognizes that medicine is difficult and dangerous and its biggest problem is medicine is practiced by humans, who, I would venture to observe, are prone to mistakes and any number of cognitive errors.
It has not been a easy journey. People hate change and there has not always been certainty as to the best options to choose to solve a problem, a problem that continues today. For example, how best to treat a patient with potential methicillin resistant Staphylococcus aureus colonization (MRSA). Should we screen everyone? Screen high risk patients? Surgical patients? Do we decolonize, with the long term consequence of accelerating antibiotic resistance? Do we place everyone with MRSA in isolation, with the known decrease in care that patients in isolation may have? Everything we do has potential downsides and unintended consequences. No good deed ever goes unpunished.
When I was a resident every PVC (preventricular contractions) in cardiac patents was suppressed as we thought PVC’s were the sentinel event that led to ventricular tachycardia and death. So patients received IV lidocaine and we often sent patients home on quinidine or other antiarrhythmics. Subsequent studies demonstrated that antiarrhythmics may have killed more people than they saved, and doctors no longer suppress every PVC in the ICU. Medicine changes, one hopes for the better, offering old geezers like me the opportunity to ‘reminisce’ about the old days, when I tied an onion to my belt, which was the style at the time. Now, to take the ferry cost a nickel, and in those days, nickels had pictures of bumblebees on ‘em. Give me five bees for a quarter, you’d say. Now where were we? Oh yeah: the important thing was I had an onion on my belt, which was the style at the time.
Sorry. I digress. A couple of months ago I had a patient with severe malaria that needed IV quinidine (the dextrorotatory diastereoisomer of quinine, but that is obvious) and there was none in the pharmacy; we had to get some shipped in by our dealer, er, distributor. In medicine, if it discovered that what was thought to be a beneficial intervention turns out to cause more harm than good, the intervention is abandoned.
When To Err is Human was published, it caused quite a brouhaha. Depending on whose numbers you want to believe, 44 to 98 thousand Americans died each year from medical errors. I did not have issues with the numbers. There are about 5700 hospitals in the US, so that would be about one death every month and a half. Knowing what I did about infections and other complications in the hospital, that did not seem like an unreasonable estimate. A bit high, perhaps, but in the ballpark of my understanding of reality.
That is old data, and no longer applicable. Due, in part, to To Err is Human, the last decade has led to innumerable studies evaluating the causes of infections and complications in hospitals and the best approaches to decrease them. My institutions have invested huge time and effort to implement these quality improvements with great success.
When I started in Infection Control, the infection data was considered protected. The thought was that institutions would be more likely to collect and evaluate data about infections if there were not discoverable by lawyers. The downside was, as I was informed, if I informed anyone about the data, it would no longer be protected, and the institutions would be open to expensive lawsuits. This century my institutions are much more transparent about disseminating information about our practice. I thought I would have a conniption the first time I saw the infection data for the ICU posted in the ICU for all too see. It turns out, like so many deeply held convictions, that keeping the data protected was a bad idea. Transparency has not led to an increase in lawsuits but it has led to a decline in all manner of hospital associated complications. Our staff takes a great deal of pride in their work. They took the data as a personal affront and worked to improve all aspects of patient care. When they saw harm potentially occurring, practice changed for the better.
So there are three reactions to new data in medicine that demonstrates that a given medical practice may cause harm.
First, the data and the conclusions are challenged, as they should be. All studies are open to analysis and improvement. In medicine we continuously try to improve care, and that requires good information.
Second, further studies are done to confirm and refine the problem and other studies are done to see how practice can be improved.
The third is practice change, which is often slower than we like. But change we do. I am old enough that I often bore the residents with how it used to be in the old days. Medicine today is drastically different than 20 years ago, and many logs better.
The most impressive example of improvement in the last 20 years is hand hygiene. Hand washing adherence 20 years ago was an embarrassment. Part of the problem was the time it took to wash hands; I have heard that if a nurse spent her time appropriately washing her hands, 80% of his shift would be spent at the sink.
Alcohol foam changed that. When we introduced the foam in the hospital, even when compliance was only 20%, we had a 50% drop in hospital infections, and as compliance has increased to 90 to 95%, the infections had a parallel decline. And the effects of alcohol foam improved once I discovered it was not a po agent, to be used like Cheez Whiz. Our biggest problem now is fall prevention. Most falls occur when the patient doesn’t want to bother the nurse and, in the process of moving about the room without help, falls. We are investigating ways to remove gravity from the hospital.
The threshold for changing and abandoning a therapy can be very small. Last century there was a drug called trovafloxacin that caused several hundred cases of hepatitis and a half a dozen deaths when it was being prescribed at a rate of 300,000 new prescriptions a month. Hepatitis was an extremely unusual complication, but the small risk was not worth the potential benefits since there were equally efficacious alternatives.
Compare and contrast medicine and alt med.
Most alt med interventions are, of course, based on eternal truths that cannot be improved or changed. They are often immune to reality induced change. Studies that confirm their eternal truth are always accepted. Studies that show harm or lack of efficacy? Not so much.
Certainly, when complications of alternative medicines are published the data is up for discussion. That is good and as it should be. But that is where the similarities with medicine ends.
There is an ongoing issue of safety in the two most invasive alternative interventions: acupuncture and chiropractic.
There were two reviews concerning chiropractic safety published recently. Safety of chiropractic interventions: a systematic review, which found
A total of 376 potential relevant articles were identified, 330 of which were discarded after abstract or complete article analysis. The search identified 46 articles that included data concerning adverse events: 1 randomized controlled trial, 2 case-control studies, 7 prospective studies, 12 surveys, 3 retrospective studies, and 115 case reports. Most of the adverse events reported were benign and transitory, however, there are reports of complications that were life threatening, such as arterial dissection, myelopathy, vertebral disc extrusion, and epidural hematoma. The frequency of adverse events varied between 33% and 60.9%, and the frequency of serious adverse events varied between 5 strokes/100,000 manipulations to 1.46 serious adverse events/10,000,000 manipulations and 2.68 deaths/10,000,000 manipulations.
CONCLUSION: There is no robust data concerning the incidence or prevalence of adverse reactions after chiropractic. Further investigations are urgently needed to assess definite conclusions regarding this issue.
That is impressive complication rates, although the authors suggest the data to support the rates are not robust, for an intervention that only has at best proven efficacy for low back pain and safer alternatives. Also published recently was Deaths after chiropractic: a review of published cases.
Twenty six fatalities were published in the medical literature and many more might have remained unpublished. The alleged pathology usually was a vascular accident involving the dissection of a vertebral artery.
That is about three times the number of deaths from trovafloxacin, an excellent antibiotic that we abandoned in the U.S. as too dangerous. Of course, we have safer alternatives with equal efficacy.
Also recently published was Acupuncture-related adverse events: a systematic review of the Chinese literature which found
that in total reported on 479 cases of adverse events after acupuncture. Fourteen patients died. Acupuncture-related adverse events were classified into three categories: traumatic, infectious and “other”. The most frequent adverse events were pneumothorax, fainting, subarachnoid haemorrhage and infection, while the most serious ones were cardiovascular injuries, subarachnoid haemorrhage, pneumothorax and recurrent cerebral haemorrhage.
Based on the reported complications of the two interventions, if they were a medical therapy regulated in a manner similar to medications and medical devices, they would certainly have, at a minimum, a black box warning and, in the case of chiropractic, no longer be used. Especially as there are no good indications for chiropractic or acupuncture.
What you do not see in the medical literature or the chiropractic blogs is any concern that harm may be done and investigations into changes in practice that could minimize the morbidity and mortality.
Instead you get The Self Importance of Being Ernst and Death by Chiropractic Another Misbegotten Review
Two essay that show zero interest in considering that chiropractic could potentially cause harm, the latter including the argument that it is real doctors that kill people and in comparison out ‘an order of magnitude greater than the side-effects attributed to spinal manipulation.’ See. If you kill small numbers of people, it is not important. Safety only matters when you kill people in large numbers. In the risk/benefit calculus of medicine, an intervention that has no benefit should cause no harm.
If there are concerns in the chiropractic community expressed about these complications, I can’t find them. If there is to improve chiropractic care, I can’t find it. If there is any quality/safety research being done, please rub my nose in it. I would love to know and those involved or aware of such research should trumpet the results for all to read. All the literature and letters to the editor I can find concerns denying there is a problem at all.
At least I could find concerns in the acupuncture literature : ‘A single injury – let alone a fatality – caused by acupuncture is one too many.” Exactly right. If you are practicing prescientific magic, it should have a mortality and morbidity of zero. Again if there is ongoing research into improving the safety of acupuncture, I cannot find it either.
Both seem far more interested in the messenger (Dr. Ernst) and his malevolent intent rather than the message.
It is, I think, a key difference between medicine and its ‘alternatives’. The former takes safety and quality seriously and strives constantly with research and its application to improve care. The alternatives? Nope. Not yet. And probably never.

Edzard Ernst Tackles Chiropractic
Edzard Ernst’s new book is a handy, comprehensive reference for all things chiropractic.
Harriet Hall on September 22, 2020
Link

Edzard Ernst’s prolific output continues. In his latest book Chiropractic: Not All That It’s Cracked Up to Be he takes on one of the most popular SCAMS (So-Called Alternative Medicines). It is an even-handed review of the history and claims of chiropractic, examining the totality of the published evidence. He addresses what he sees as “a scandalous amount of misinformation”, and tries to set the record straight. Rather than advising against chiropractic, he asks readers to make up their own minds and make reasonable decisions based on the evidence.
The book begins with this quotation from Fontanarosa and Lundberg:
There is no alternative medicine. There is only scientifically proven, evidence-based medicine supported by solid data or unproven medicine, for which scientific evidence is lacking.

He starts by describing the origin and early history of chiropractic, providing many details that were new to me. D. D. Palmer claimed to have invented it on September 18, 1895, when he adjusted the spine of deaf janitor Harvey Lillard and allegedly restored his hearing. He then extrapolated to conclude that 95% of illness was a result of displaced spinal vertebrae interfering with nerve function (the other 5% was due to subluxations of other bones). Elsewhere he claimed to have obtained his chiropractic knowledge during a séance from the ghost of a doctor. He later tried to claim that chiropractic was a religion, in an attempt to evade charges of practicing medicine without a license.
Palmer was anti-science. He claimed that smallpox was not a contagious disease but was caused by subluxations that could be corrected. He was violently anti-vaccine, a position that is perpetuated in the anti-vaccine attitudes of a majority of today’s chiropractors.
Chiropractic is said to be hugely popular, but the evidence shows that its popularity is variable and usually modest (he cites the numbers), and it is illegal in 12 countries (Argentina, Austria, Colombia, Egypt, Estonia, Greece, Hungary, Lebanon, Republic of Korea, Taiwan, Turkey, and Ukraine).
Palmer’s theories contradicted elementary anatomical facts and established scientific knowledge. The concept of a chiropractic subluxation was nebulous and doubtful (and should not be confused with an orthopedic subluxation, a painful partial dislocation of a joint which is easily viewed on an x-ray). Chiropractic subluxations are alleged bony displacements that could not be verified by x-ray, and the definition had to be changed several times. Some chiropractic schools have abandoned the term, but it remains widely accepted and is used as an excuse for chiropractors to do what they are best known for doing: spinal manipulation therapy (SMT).
SMT itself is suspect. Ernst describes the studies chiropractors have relied on to demonstrate the effectiveness of SMT and shows how they are all flawed in various ways. None of the studies controlled for placebo effects. For acute low back pain, the average patient can expect a 50/50 chance of up to a 20% improvement in pain and function, but more than 50% will report harms such as increased pain and muscle stiffness. A new drug with that risk/benefit ratio would not be approved for marketing. For chronic low back pain, the evidence shows that the treatment of choice is exercise and continued normal activity. For neck pain, the evidence is too weak to recommend SMT for routine use. One analysis showed that 31-66% of patients using chiropractic for back or neck pain also took opioids, a sad commentary on the effectiveness of chiropractic.
The majority of chiropractic visits are for back and neck pain and other musculoskeletal problems. 39% are for general wellness or disease prevention, indications that are not supported by any evidence. Chiropractors don’t live as long as medical doctors, or even as long as the general population. D. D. Palmer claimed that chiropractors could treat bunions, syphilis, peritonitis, cholera, strokes, and many other diverse conditions and could even “correct abnormalities of the intellect”. Today, some chiropractors use SMT for non-musculoskeletal conditions where SMT is not evidence-based or even plausible, such as ear infections, asthma, and infertility. 42% of UK chiropractors believe SMT is effective for high blood pressure; the evidence shows that it isn’t. Today’s chiropractors use a variety of adjustment techniques that have never been compared to each other or even tested for efficacy. 39% of US chiropractors treat children; skeptical chiropractor Samuel Homola calls that child abuse.
One chapter covers bogus alternative therapies and diagnostic procedures that have been adopted by many chiropractors, including homeopathy, acupuncture, cupping, applied kinesiology, electrodermal testing machines like Vega Test, energy healing, detox, chelation, and untested dietary supplements.
Adverse effects of treatment are not mentioned or are under-reported in the chiropractic literature. The most reliable data show that 50% or more of patients experience adverse effects. In Finland, adverse events were reported by 81% of women and 66% of men.
Does SMT cause strokes? Ernst devotes a whole chapter to that question. His assessment is fair. He describes the evidence and admits that questions remain and that the risk can’t be quantified. But the circumstantial evidence is worrisome, to say the least; and since the benefit is small to nonexistent, the risk of SMT, especially of neck manipulation, is hard to justify.
Ernst covers ethical considerations, what constitutes true informed consent, and the risk of indirect harms in addition to direct harms. He explains what constitutes good evidence. He discusses the poor quality of most chiropractic research, including frequent use of trials that compare standard treatment alone to standard treatment plus SMT, a design that is guaranteed to make SMT look better than it is.
The book is published by Springer Nature Switzerland. They did not serve Ernst well. Every two pages were attached together along the outer edge, prepared for easy separation but requiring the reader to do the separating in order to read the book. And there were many typos that should have been caught by any competent proofreader. For example, the country Colombia is mis-spelled “Columbia”. And a 4-item list of complications lists “spastic quadriparesis” twice.
Conclusion: An excellent reference
This book is an excellent, comprehensive reference for all things chiropractic. It provides solid facts to correct widespread misinformation. It provides evidence that should answer any question a reader might come up with. It doesn’t tell readers what to think, but it provides the tools to help them think clearly for themselves. Thank you, Edzard, for once again sharing your wisdom, knowledge, and experience with the world.

Chiropractic Gynecologist Offers Dangerous Treatments and Misinformation
Harriet Hall on October 25, 2016
Link


Over a year ago I wrote about escharotic treatments for cervical dysplasia. It is offered not by MD gynecologists but by chiropractors and naturopaths, along with inconsistent and unproven diet recommendations and supplements. A corrosive agent similar to “black salve” is applied repeatedly to the cervix; it works by destroying tissue. There are no controlled studies evaluating it for safety and effectiveness. One major drawback is that there is no surgical specimen to submit to pathology to determine if there is invasive cancer. I urge you to read my first article for further details. Escharotic treatment is decidedly not a good idea.
In that article I focused on the treatment itself. I recently revisited the website of the chiropractor I mentioned in that article, Nick LeRoy, and I want to comment on some other issues raised by this individual who is offering the treatment.
Who is Nick LeRoy?
On one website he is listed as a Chicago holistic medicine physician and primary care physician for an HMO, Alternative Medicine Incorporated, which he says is underwritten by Blue Cross/Blue Shield. When I googled for Alternative Medicine Incorporated, I found a company in England, but none in America with that name. On his other website he claims to have “post-doctoral medical training in gynecology and internal medicine and to be a credentialed primary care physician (PCP) for Blue Cross of IL.” I phoned Blue Cross of Illinois, and they told me he was not listed as a provider in their records. They suggested I contact him directly to ask for clarification. I did, by email. He didn’t answer.
He has taken courses in acupuncture and Traditional Chinese Medicine, and got “private breast thermography training.” It’s not clear how much training he has in gynecology. On one page of his website he says his “integrative medicine training included gynecology, internal medicine, acupuncture, chiropractic, and nutrition.” In a video, he says he has been specializing in gastrointestinal disorders for twenty years, and he describes how he does unconventional food allergy testing for 154 different foods.
He lists himself as “DC, MS, AcT,” but he calls himself “doctor” and readers are likely to assume he is an MD. The testimonials all refer to “Dr. LeRoy.” He sells his books and supplements through his “doctor’s supplement store.”
His services
He offers breast cancer prevention and detection, and cervical cancer prevention and detection. For breast cancer prevention and detection, he offers breast thermography, blood work, guidance on a plant-based diet, and prescription of immunity boosting supplements. He claims these methods can prevent cancer and can also be used to treat cancer in conjunction with conventional cancer treatments of surgery and radiation. (Curiously, he doesn’t mention chemo.)
He says, “Breast thermography may be the most effective diagnostic tool for early breast cancer detection.” He is wrong. Our own breast cancer expert Dr. Gorski has explained why breast thermography is not an effective diagnostic tool.
For cervical cancer prevention and detection, he offers dietary advice, supplements, and escharotic treatments. He claims that the escharotic treatment destroys HPV-infected cells while leaving the healthy cells intact. I don’t think that could possibly be true, and he provides no supporting evidence for that claim. He says the escharotic discriminates between healthy and abnormal cells by “uncoupling the electrochemical gradient of abnormal cells.” That’s just sciencey-sounding malarkey.
He promotes “detoxification,” which is a red flag for quackery. I took his detox questionnaire and it said I needed a 10-day elimination diet and medical food for imbalanced detoxifiers. No thank you. In the first place, that questionnaire has not been validated and is about as meaningful as those quizzes in the women’s magazines that claim to predict if your marriage will last.
Costs
He lists his fees here:
    • $200 for a general women’s health visit
    • $250 for breast thermography (which typically costs $200 elsewhere)
    • Initial visit for cervical dysplasia $215, $85 for follow-up visits. Typically, 10 treatments are required. Total would be $980.
The conventional treatments of cone biopsy or LEEP (loop electrosurgical excision procedure) cost more (typically $1,300 to $1,500), but they are proven effective and the costs are covered by insurance, which does not pay for escharotic treatments. Lower cost is not an advantage if the treatment is ineffective and risky.
Chiropractors as PCPs and specialists
Jann Bellamy and I have written about the efforts of chiropractors to re-classify themselves as primary care providers and the inadequacy of their education to prepare them for that role (the full list of posts can be found here).
Classroom education is not enough. MDs get hands-on experience treating seriously ill hospitalized patients and they get years of post-graduate training before they can call themselves specialists. There is nothing comparable in the world of chiropractic. Steven Novella has written about so called “chiropractic neurologists.” He says there is no reason to take their claims seriously. The same goes for “chiropractic gynecology.”
In some states, chiropractors are allowed to perform obstetrical exams, sign birth certificates, order thermography, perform a bi-manual pelvic exam, speculum exam, recto-vaginal exam, and Pap smears. In other states chiropractors are not even allowed to do pelvic exams. I couldn’t find the details of the scope of practice for chiropractors in Illinois, but I don’t think treatment of cervical cancer is included in the scope of practice in any state. I suspect the chiropractic board could order LeRoy to stop offering it; I also suspect that they won’t.
Misinformation about HPV
He says cervical dysplasia and cervical cancer are not caused by human papillomavirus (HPV). He “knows” this because 80-90% of women eliminate HPV infections without treatment. Elsewhere he contradicts himself by saying HPV is known to cause cancer. He claims that lifestyle factors determine who will develop cancer, and he says gynecologists are hiding the truth from their patients.
The most effective preventive measure we have is the HPV vaccine. Think about it: a vaccine that prevents cancer! He refuses to recommend it to his patients. He says that HPV vaccines have more risk than benefit. He says that HPV vaccines account for over 60% of all reported vaccine injuries. He says the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS) reported over 26,000 adverse events, 92 deaths, 866 cases of permanent disability and over 9,000 injuries requiring emergency hospitalization. This is simply ignorant. He doesn’t understand what VAERS is. It lists anything and everything that has happened to a patient after getting the vaccine, and in the vast majority of cases the reports show no higher incidence than what would be expected in the normal population without the vaccine. VAERS is an uncontrolled data dump that does not establish causation. 90 million doses of HPV vaccine have been given, and no serious side effects have been detected. The deaths reported in VAERS have been investigated; there was no credible evidence that any of them were caused by the vaccine.
He cites Japan’s decision to withdraw the HPV vaccine. Japan was wrong. There has been a lot of irresponsible fear-mongering about the vaccine but in reality it is very safe and is even being recommended for boys. Steven Novella has written about how anti-vaccine activists have distorted reality to support their agenda.
Conclusion: LeRoy is misguided
Chiropractors are not qualified to act as gynecologists or PCPs. They are not qualified to treat cancer at all, much less with an untested, potentially harmful treatment. They should not be spreading misinformation about the HPV vaccine. (Incidentally, only about half of chiropractors support vaccination at all.) Freedom of speech allows LeRoy to say whatever he wants, but freedom of speech has limits: it does not allow people to start a panic by falsely crying “Fire!” in a crowded theater. Some might argue that medical fear-mongering and misinformation approach those limits.
I don’t think he is deliberately practicing quackery. I will give him the benefit of the doubt and assume that he believes in what he does. According to Hanlon’s Razor: “Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity.” He may not have a low IQ, but he is clearly not smart about the basic principles of science and evidence, and he is doing his patients a disservice.

Chiropractor Disregards the Loss of His License, Continues to Treat Patients with Cervical Dysplasia with Escharotics
A chiropractor who bills himself as a chiropractic gynecologist has continued to practice after his license was permanently revoked. Among his many questionable practices, Nick LeRoy is treating cervical dysplasia with escharotics, a potentially dangerous replacement for conventional treatments to prevent cancer.
Harriet Hall on October 17, 2017
Link


Note: This article has been revised to remove direct quotations from the Inspire site (in the Evidence and Response sections). A representative of the Inspire website complained that quoting from their forum was a violation of their guidelines, even though no names were mentioned and there was no violation of privacy.
A year ago, I wrote about Nicholas LeRoy, a chiropractor who calls himself a gynecologist and uses a potentially dangerous escharotic compound to treat cervical dysplasia (and also offers a lot of other questionable treatments and misinformation). I was not aware at the time that he had lost his license.
The Illinois Department of Financial and Professional Regulation has taken disciplinary action against LeRoy three times:
    • In 2008, he was reprimanded and fined for violations of the medical practice act
    • In 2010, he was reprimanded and fined for placing advertising without indicating that he was a chiropractor
    • On Feb 24, 2016, his license was permanently revoked for conviction of armed robbery
Here is a screenshot listing those disciplinary actions.
The revocation is also reported here.
His website
LeRoy maintains an active website with a tab to schedule appointments. According to the website, he offers a number of questionable diagnostic tests and treatments.
He offers breast thermography, claiming that “infrared breast thermography identifies cancers not detected by mammography, assists in earlier detection, and improves survival rates by up to 61%.” Our own breast cancer expert, Dr. Gorski, tells us that thermography “has not been validated as a diagnostic modality to detect breast cancer.” LeRoy is doing his patients a disservice by steering them away from mammography.
In addition to cervical dysplasia, his list of the conditions he treats includes other things chiropractors have no business treating, such as breast cancer, uterine fibroids, inflammatory bowel disease, diabetes, adrenal gland disturbances, and asthma. The list also includes bogus conditions like “weak immune system” and “leaky gut.” He offers acupuncture and “detoxification” and bioSET therapy. He diagnoses allergies with a simple blood test that he claims can detect sensitivities to 154 foods. He prescribes “nutraceuticals,” herbs, and supplements. Oh, and almost as an afterthought, he offers chiropractic services.
He specializes in treating cervical dysplasia, but he doesn’t recommend the most effective way to prevent it; he discourages the HPV vaccine, saying it “Turns Girls into Guinea Pigs” and citing misinformation based on VAERS reports.
Evidence that he continues to practice
One might argue that the existence of a website does not constitute solid evidence that he continues to practice, but there is plenty of solid evidence from patients he has continued to treat. A patient who is a regular on a message board on the Inspire website informed me about discussions there of Dr. LeRoy in which it was quite clear from numerous patient reports that he didn’t stop practicing after he lost his license, and that he continues to practice today. Patients reported visiting him and getting escharotic treatments right along from the date his license was revoked in 2016 and continuing through at least September of 2017.
Responses to adverse information about LeRoy
Listmembers discussed the loss of his license, but made excuses for him and continued to support and praise him. They read my earlier article https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/chiropractic-gynecologist-offers-dange rous-treatments-and-misinformation/ but were not persuaded, because it was the only negative article they could find, and they found many other articles that were positive.
Why?
Why has this man continued to practice after his license was revoked? Why has he not been stopped? This violation has been reported to the professional board and to the Cook County state attorney, but no action has been taken. What good are professional boards if their disciplinary actions can be ignored with impunity?
Addendum:
I submitted a news tip that resulted in an article about him in today’s Chicago Tribune. Unfortunately it does not include information from the message board or from patients showing that he is still treating patients with escharotics. He lied to the Tribune, saying he is only giving advice, like health coaching.

Chiropractor Lost His License; Patient Lost Her Uterus
Practicing after he lost his license, chiropractor Nicholas LeRoy used escharotics to treat a woman’s cervical dysplasia. As result, she lost her uterus. Ex-naturopath Britt Hermes was taught to use escharotic treatments at Bastyr; she has since realized that they are “unproven, dangerous, and very stupid.”
Harriet HallonFebruary 27, 2018
Link


I first wrote about escharotic treatment for cervical dysplasia in 2015. A caustic substance is applied to the cervix. This produces an uncontrolled chemical burn and the dead tissue sloughs off, hopefully taking the abnormal cells with it. The standard treatment for cervical dysplasia is excision by cone biopsy or LEEP (Loop Electrocautery Excision Procedure). Escharotic treatment has not been proven as effective as excision, and it has several drawbacks. It requires multiple visits, is not covered by insurance, and the biggest problem is that there is no tissue sample to send to pathology to see whether abnormal cells remain. It was easy to predict that eventually some patients would develop invasive disease that might have been prevented by conventional treatment. That prediction has proven correct.
I wrote about Nicholas LeRoy in 2016. A chiropractor, he offered escharotic treatments along with other dubious treatments. In an update a year later, I reported that his license had been revoked and that he had been practicing without a license, and had continued to offer escharotic treatments.
Patients report disastrous results and lies
A concerned correspondent who follows the Inspire message board passed on information posted by one of LeRoy’s patients. She first saw him after he had lost his license. After 12 escharotic treatments, she thought she was cured. But a month later, a biopsy and ECC (endocervical curettage) done elsewhere showed adenocarcinoma in situ. This should have been a wake-up call; but instead, she went back to LeRoy and had 8 more escharotic treatments. Another endocervical biopsy again showed cancer in the cervical canal. She then had a cone biopsy, but the margins were not clear. Her (real) doctors told her that the delay in treatment had allowed the cancer to spread to her uterus and she will require a radical hysterectomy. One can only hope that the hysterectomy will be curative; but if the cancer has spread beyond the uterus, she may not only lose her uterus but her life. This unfortunate outcome would almost certainly have been avoided if she had agreed to standard excisional treatment in the first place.
Others on the message board described how LeRoy had lied to them, for instance saying that if a cone biopsy didn’t show clear margins, conventional medicine would do nothing for six months! He told patients that no one had ever needed surgery after his treatments. He told them that if the cervix closed together after a LEEP or cone biopsy, a hysterectomy would be required; that is simply not true.There are case reports of successful escharotic treatments, but no studies comparing outcomes to excisional treatments. LeRoy claims a 99% success rate, but I don’t believe it. His claim is not supported by any published studies. Escharotics are among the “natural” treatments used by naturopaths. I fail to see what is “natural” about burning the cervix with caustic chemicals.

Britt Hermes, the ex-naturopath who writes the Naturopathic Diaries, warns “Don’t let a naturopath near your vagina.” She characterizes escharotics as “unproven, dangerous, and very stupid.” She says the practitioners are delusional, the practice is barbaric, and she doesn’t hesitate to call it quackery.
LeRoy passes the baton to Michelle Brannick
LeRoy’s website continues to advertise escharotic treatments and has a link to make an appointment. I contacted his office asking if it was true that he had lost his license, and “Drnickfrontdesk” replied “That is correct–he has sold his practice to Dr. Michelle Brannick and is teaching her everything he knows about treating dysplasia. Dr. LeRoy is also consulting with her on all cases until she is fully trained and has increased her knowledge base.”
Michelle Brannick is even worse than LeRoy. Her website lists her as a licensed Naturopathic and Chiropractic Physician in Vermont and Illinois respectively. She was trained at Bastyr, the same school that mis-educated Britt Hermes. She offers a variety of questionable treatments. Her website makes it clear that she is anti-vaccine, linking to an anti-vaccine website. She demonizes conventional medicine, linking to Gary Null’s infamous article “Death by Medicine.” (I have already explained what is wrong with those “death by medicine” arguments.) She links to other ridiculous websites like Notmilk, which says Swiss cheese causes Alzheimer’s and milk protein is the cause of autism. It blames every known illness on milk, from cancer to the common cold. She even supports homeopathy, saying homeopathic arnica 30C should be available in every household.
Naturopaths are not licensed in Illinois, so she must be practicing under her chiropractic license. A proposed law in Illinois that would have licensed and regulated naturopathic physicians included the restriction in Section 65 (9) that licensed naturopaths may not treat any lesion suspicious of malignancy or requiring surgical removal. While I don’t support licensing, I do think that restriction would have been wise. And I don’t think chiropractors have any business treating lesions suspicious of malignancy either.
Conclusion: This tragedy was avoidable
LeRoy has once again found a way to get around the law, and patients are being harmed. I don’t blame that patient who is losing her uterus and possibly her life. She was misinformed; she thought he was a reliable doctor and did not know enough to question his advice. I blame the authorities for not stopping LeRoy. Regulators have a responsibility to protect patients from harm; and at the very least, to stop providers from practicing without a license.
Addendum
I have just learned some additional information. LeRoy has been telling his supporters he is “beginning a gradual transition from a clinical practice to a teaching and consulting practice.” When you lose your license, you are supposed to STOP clinical practice, not gradually transition away from it. I wonder how the authorities will interpret his involvement with Brannick on all her cases; couldn’t it be considered practicing by proxy?
He plans to publish “longitudinal data” to support the efficacy of escharotics. That would be a case series, which is only a little better than a collection of testimonials; and without a control group, it can’t establish efficacy. He doesn’t seem to understand what is really needed: a controlled study showing that escharotics are at least as efficacious and safe as LEEP, and that the absence of a tissue sample doesn’t lead to worse final outcomes.
I also learned that his patients are being asked to populate the internet with their testimonials and specifically to post comments on my SBM articles. The plural of anecdote is not data.

   Politics, Media and Law

The War Against Chiropractors
Harriet Hall on October 23, 2012
Link
In 2011, chiropractor J.C. Smith published The Medical War Against Chiropractors: The Untold Story from Persecution to Vindication. He promises an exposé comparable to Harriet Beecher Stowe’s exposé of slavery in Uncle Tom’s Cabin. His thesis is that the AMA waged a shameless attack on competition, motivated only by money. I think the reality is closer to what he quoted from Dr. Thomas Ballantine, Harvard Medical School:
The confrontation between medicine and chiropractic is not a struggle between two professions. Rather it is more in the nature of an effort by an informed group of individuals to protect the public from fraudulent health claims and practices.
The book is self-published, long-winded, repetitive, and flawed. It is a vicious screed crammed with bias, half-truths, insulting language, and innumerable references to Nazis and racial prejudice. In my opinion, Smith not only fails to make his case but degrades chiropractic.
Practicing Medicine without a License
Before chiropractic licensure was approved, many chiropractors were jailed for practicing medicine without a license. Smith thinks this was a bogus charge because they never used drugs or surgery. (He’s wrong: practicing medicine is not defined as using drugs or surgery, but as diagnosing and treating any human disease, pain, injury, deformity, or physical condition. They were clearly breaking the law.) Chiropractors were forced to hide like Anne Frank or like slaves on the Underground Railroad. The Juice Man squeezed them for protection money; if they couldn’t pay, his thugs beat them up.
The AMA
The AMA did some very regrettable things. They used inappropriate language, referring to chiropractors as rabid dogs. They attacked chiropractors as killers without any supporting evidence. Their intent was to destroy chiropractic. They tried to conceal what they were doing. Their biggest mistake was to prohibit MDs from associating with chiropractors.
The Code of Ethics stated:
A physician should practice a method of healing founded on scientific bases; and he should not voluntarily associate professionally with anyone who violates this principle.
According to Smith, this expanded to prohibit a physician from belonging to any club, church, or organization if a chiropractor was also a member. If this is true, it is inexcusable. He relates a story from a chiropractor whose mother came home from a bowling league game crying because an MD on the opposing team had made a big stink that he wouldn’t bowl against her husband just because he was a chiropractor.
The AMA distributed “Quack Packs” and 10,000 copies of an anti-chiropractic book, Ralph Lee Smith’s At Your Own Risk: The Case Against Chiropractic. The complete text of that book is available online.
It had made an enemy of Scientology when it accused it of practicing psychiatry without a license. Smith says L. Ron Hubbard turned Dianetics into a religion just to escape AMA persecution, but it’s my understanding that he deliberately set out to invent a religion. At any rate, Scientology was so mad at the AMA that it decided to help chiropractic retaliate against At Your Own Risk. Scientologists pilfered secret documents about chiropractic from AMA headquarters and published them in the book In the Public Interest. The book not only had ties to the Church of Scientology, but had a cover illustration that superimposed the AMA caduceus on a swastika.
The Wilk Case
In 1976 an antitrust lawsuit was filed by Chester A. Wilk and 4 other chiropractors (one of whom later dropped out) against not only the AMA but also against 9 other medical organizations such as the American College of Radiology, and against 4 individuals. This began an odyssey lasting 14 years, with two separate federal trials, a series of appeals, complicated legal wrangling, and conflicting evidence. Some of the defendants settled out of court; 6 organizations and one individual went to trial. The AMA won, but the judge was accused of improperly instructing the jury and allowing inaccurate documents into evidence, so there was a second trial. In 1987, Judge Susan Getzendanner dismissed the charges against some of the defendants but found the AMA guilty of violating Section 1 (but not Section 2) of the Sherman Antitrust Act. No damages were awarded. The AMA was only required to pay the plaintiffs’ legal costs and to change its policy and inform MDs that they could associate with chiropractors. Chiropractors crowed about their victory, but it actually did little to change “discriminatory” practices or to enhance the reputation of chiropractic.
The decision was not by any stretch of the imagination an endorsement of chiropractic. The judge said:
The study of how the five original named plaintiffs diagnosed and actually treated patients with common symptoms was particularly impressive. This study demonstrated that the plaintiffs do not use common methods in treating common symptoms and that the treatment of patients appears to be undertaken on an ad hoc rather than on a scientific basis… I am persuaded that the dominant factor was patient care and the AMA’s subjective belief that chiropractic was not in the best interests of patients… [but] this concern for scientific method in patient care could have been adequately satisfied in a manner less restrictive of competition.
Saved By George
He eulogizes chiropractor Jerry McAndrews and his brother George, the lead attorney in the Wilk v. AMA antitrust trial. The McAndrews family was heavily invested in chiropractic ever since their father’s asthma was relieved by a chiropractic adjustment where his heels allegedly touched the back of his head. (Really? What kind of adjustment does that?) They blamed his early death on persecution by the AMA. George “saved chiropractic.” Had it not been for him, the AMA would have destroyed chiropractic just as it destroyed homeopathy, naturopathy and other alternative health care professions. (Wait — aren’t those still around? And if chiropractic was saved, why is he still complaining?) Jerry reminisced to Smith, recalling that during the Wilk trial George’s office was burglarized and their phones were tapped, forcing them to speak in the cornfields behind Jerry’s home. (Really? Did they have any actual proof of wiretapping? Did they report it at the time? Did the corn have ears?)
How Powerful is the AMA?
The 1910 Flexner report attempted to reform medical education by recommending that American medical schools adopt higher standards and adhere to science. Smith thinks that the Flexner Report made the AMA an invisible branch of the government and an accrediting agency. It didn’t. He thinks the AMA controls the entire healthcare system, but today less than 30% of American physicians belong to it. It is a professional association that promotes the art and science of medicine, lobbies on issues that affect its members, and publishes several highly respected medical journals. The AMA never had any power to accredit or regulate physicians or punish them; the most it could do was deny membership.
Smith really hates Morris Fishbein, AMA spokesperson and quackbuster who fought quack MDs like John Brinkley, the goat gland doctor. He refers to Fishbein as a demagogue, dictator, Mussolini, and racketeer; he compares his persecution of chiropractors to Hitler’s persecution of the Jews. He thinks Fishbein took dictatorial control of state licensing agencies. (Total nonsense!)
To put Fishbein’s anti-chiropractic campaign into perspective, it began in the 1930s, two decades after the Flexner Report. The value of science was widely accepted but evidence-based medicine was in its infancy. Until 1974, chiropractors were still not licensed in Louisiana, where they were still guilty of practicing medicine without a license. Fishbein encountered rampant quackery in product and drug sales, among conventional medical doctors and among people practicing medicine without a license. He fought against it wherever he found it, and he found reason to put chiropractic high on his list.
Smith is irate because under Fishbein the AMA accepted advertising from tobacco companies, even touting the supposed health benefits of cigarettes. But they didn’t know any better. As soon as they did know better, in the 1950s, when evidence of harm mounted, they stopped accepting tobacco ads, well before the first Surgeon General’s Report was published.
How powerful could the AMA be when it was not able to prevent the licensing of chiropractors in all 50 states or block coverage of chiropractic by Medicare?
The Evidence for Chiropractic
Smith contradicts himself. He re-defines what chiropractic claims to treat, saying that no displacement can be seen on x-ray but that there is a problem with function. Then he continues to speak of subluxations and of misalignments that require correction. Then he says obvious misalignments like scoliosis may not be problematic. He speaks of proper flow of nerve energy, saying spinal dysfunctions disrupt this flow to cause heart attacks and visceral disorders like dysmenorrhea, asthma, enuresis, and infantile colic. He even believes that spine dysfunctions can cause brain damage and premature aging. He believes that manipulation is effective in all these disorders. Worst of all, he believes there is credible scientific evidence to support these beliefs. (Maybe there is some “evidence,” but it isn’t credible.) He claims that chiropractic has outgrown its origins and become more science-based, but in reality he sounds very much like D.D. Palmer.
He relies on old, discredited evidence like the 1979 New Zealand Chiropractic Report. Its three-person panel consisted of a barrister, a chemistry professor, and a retired headmistress of a girls’ school. It relied heavily on testimonials, failed to appreciate the scientific process, and demonstrated bias. He thinks it vindicates chiropractic, but its recommendations were actually devastating to chiropractic: chiropractors should be strictly monitored, should not present themselves as doctors, should not encourage patients to consult a chiropractor in preference to a medical doctor for any condition, and should not mislead the public into believing that chiropractic is an alternative to medicine.
He ignores more definitive, up-to-date evidence that spinal manipulation therapy (SMT) is effective but not superior to other treatments for low back pain and is ineffective for non-musculoskeletal conditions. Even the NCCAM damns it with faint praise:
[Spinal manipulation] can provide mild-to-moderate relief from low-back pain. Spinal manipulation also appears to work as well as conventional treatments such as applying heat, using a firm mattress, and taking pain-relieving medications.
He quotes Gary Null, Natural News, and Dana Ullman (all infamous on this blog.) He devotes several pages to attacking Ann Landers for being in cahoots with the AMA and getting her information from them. (Isn’t it reasonable for a non-medical columnist to consult medical experts to ensure accuracy?)
His defense of chiropractic is based on questionable evidence plus fallacious arguments from popularity, patient satisfaction, and cost-effectiveness. Also the argument from antiquity: Hippocrates and Imhotep wrote about it. (No, they didn’t write about chiropractic; they wrote about manipulation.)
He doesn’t understand what science means. He calls chiropractic “an unorthodox science.” He says the first chiropractor was not unscientific. I explained in a previous post why chiropractic is not scientific.
Strokes
He presents the Cassidy study as if it were definitive proof that chiropractic neck manipulation doesn’t cause strokes. He fails to report or respond to the criticisms of that study.
He downplays the risks of chiropractic, resorts to tu quoque arguments about the risks of medical care, and cites the low cost of chiropractic malpractice insurance. He compares rate of neck manipulation stroke to rate of death from surgery (apples and oranges — but they are both fruits, so maybe I should say cabbages and carburetors!). He calls neck manipulation safe but doesn’t consider the risk/benefit ratio (if there is no benefit, any risk is unacceptable).
Back Surgery
He devotes a great deal of space to criticizing doctors for doing back surgery, especially spinal fusions. He doesn’t need to: the medical establishment itself has already criticized back surgery. It has recommended reforms: elimination of unnecessary and ineffective operations and sticking rigorously to indications that are evidence-based. Smith says the disc theory is dead. It isn’t. He’s right that too many back surgeries have been done for disc disease, but ruptured discs can cause permanent nerve damage and disability, and surgery can improve outcomes when done only for proper indications. He quotes a doctor who called for a moratorium on back surgery when he found that after 2 weeks of rehabilitation his patients no longer required surgery. Rehabilitation, not manipulation. Smith doesn’t seem to realize this is as much an argument against chiropractic as against surgery. He doesn’t admit that back surgery is ever indicated and he blames its use on the machinations of a medical industrial complex motivated only by profits. One wonders how much he really understands: at one point he even refers to the disc as cartilage. He seems to think proving that back surgeries are unnecessary equates to proving that chiropractic is effective; it doesn’t. He calls for doctors to reform back surgery but doesn’t call for reforming chiropractic to adhere to similar evidence-based standards.
In 1994 a report by the Agency for Health Care Policy and Research (AHCPR) concluded that SMT was one of only 3 treatments for acute low back pain that were supported by evidence (the others were over-the-counter nonsteroidal drugs (NSAIDs) and heat/cold applications). The report didn’t recognize chiropractic or even mention chiropractors.
Because of the report’s endorsement of spinal manipulation and its criticism of spinal surgeries, the North American Spine Society and the manufacturers of spinal fusion hardware sought an injunction to prevent its release. When that failed, NASS took the fight to Congress, where the agency’s budget was cut and it was stripped of its ability to make treatment recommendations. Smith blames the AMA for this, although he does not show that they were involved.
FSU
He devotes 21 pages to the failed attempt to establish a school of chiropractic at Florida State University (FSU), an effort that was ridiculed in the famous campus map parody showing other pseudoscientific departments like the Bigfoot Institute. The state legislature had appropriated $9 million annually to support such a school, with 151 votes for and only 1 against. So Smith claims FSU went against the will of the people. Ironically, nearby Life Chiropractic College opposed the bill because of fear it would lose students to a cheaper and more scientific program. Several FSU faculty members threatened to resign, and eventually the school’s Board of Governors squashed the proposal, voting it down by a wide margin. 3 chiropractors at the Board meeting spoke out against a school.
According to Smith, a noble cause was killed by medical demagogues and political subterfuge. He argued that it would have allowed chiropractors to explore the clinical scope of chiropractic and conduct research in an academic setting.
He thought that MDs were only attacking chiropractic because it was based on a vitalistic philosophy, which doctors and scientists oppose because they are mostly atheists. He characterized the fight as a “religious war to keep the heretics out of the medical den of iniquity.” He also characterized it as an attack on academic freedom and compared it to the bigotry in America before Civil Rights, when desegregation led to resentment and deadly attacks.
Raymond Bellamy, MD, orthopedic surgeon and professor at FSU (and husband of our own Jann Bellamy), became the lightning rod leading what Smith calls an academic revolt. He characterizes Bellamy’s effort as “not a studious argument as much as it digressed into a tirade of propaganda and slanderous accusations.” He rants about Bellamy for several pages, accuses him of conflict of interest, and says “instead of demeaning black Americans as unworthy of a college education alongside white students, Bellamy and his mob debased chiropractors as unworthy of a university presence alongside them.” He likens it to Creationists being allowed to ban the study of evolution from the biology program. He compares FSU to a white country club that only invites its white friends.
He considers Bellamy the embodiment of the undercover dictatorship at FSU, says his book-burning mindset will go down in the annals of academia alongside the book-burning policy of Joseph Goebbels, accuses him of suppressing free speech, and even says:
Gov. Wallace demonstrated his racial politics to the world and Dr. Raymond Bellamy felt justified with the same intense prejudice to keep the “nigger-chiropractors” out of FSU.
Such despicable and defamatory accusations are beneath contempt and don’t even deserve a response.
He says
The FSU project would have cleared the air on many issues and either proved chiropractic to be placebo as Bellamy contends or else it would have brought an ageless healing art to the forefront to help millions of people who suffer from both musculoskeletal disorders and those who suffer from spinovisceral reflex nerve disorders that mimic serious visceral disorders.
In other words, chiropractic should be accepted in a university on equal terms with established sciences so we can then test it and find out if it is scientific (!?). Don’t imagine for a minute that chiropractors would alter their practice if the tests found it to be unscientific. No, it would only give chiropractic a foot in the door and lend it a prestige it has not earned.
Whining
He admits that “a small percentage” of chiropractors can be viewed as charlatans, but then he makes excuses. They have been reduced to “desperation” and they are not to blame because they have been “ghettoized.” It is the medical societies who are to blame for any chiropractic malfeasance.
He feels slighted because chiropractors are not featured on national TV as spokespersons on health like Dr. Sanjay Gupta and because there has never been a chiropractor TV hero like Marcus Welby.
He says the AMA’s war has left a lingering stigma harmful to chiropractic, but he himself undermines that argument: he says chiropractic has achieved its place as “the third-largest physician level health profession in the world, only behind medical physicians and dentists.” Does he imagine that if prejudice were eliminated chiropractors would be first or second? Chiropractors are licensed in every state, are practicing in the VA and military hospitals, are funded by Medicare and insurance companies… and yet he still feels unfairly persecuted.
Language
His use of language is inflammatory and offensive. He calls the AMA “the most terrifying trade association on earth.” Edzard Ernst is a “medical spin doctor.” Stephen Barrett is a “renowned medical propagandist” and a “medical misinformer.” The medical profession is guilty of war crimes. Suppression of chiropractic is a social injustice like racism and sexism. Marcus Welby is like Joseph Goebbels. Attacking chiropractic was like making Rosa Parks sit in the back of the bus. Doctors are like storm troopers. He accuses the AMA of bigotry and of attacking free enterprise. He compares it to the KGB, Gestapo and CIA, and even mentions the showers of Auschwitz.
Harriet Hall “Medical Chauvinist”
He devotes 4 whole paragraphs to attacking me, based only on 2 short sentences attributed to me in an article about alternative medicine in the Boston Globe. It reported my concern that “Congress will elevate [alternative] practitioners to the same level as medical doctors.” He said “Her arrogance was clear that there is no room on the medical throne for anyone other than MDs.” He said I showed my “bias” when I said “If it [alternative medicine] were shown to be truly effective, it would be part of regular medicine.” He countered that if conventional medicine were truly effective, we would not be in the present healthcare crisis — something of a non sequitur, no? He said I was “spewing propaganda.” And was a “medical monarchist” who didn’t want to see my “medical Bastille” toppled by equality. (I certainly don’t want to see science toppled by equality with pseudoscience and quackery.)
Consider that my two quoted comments were about alternative medicine and didn’t even mention chiropractic. Also consider that he didn’t bother to find out that I have written extensively about chiropractic (which he could easily have discovered just by Googling my name) and he has not tried to answer any of my arguments against chiropractic.
What He Doesn’t Say
Nowhere does he mention chiropractors like Sam Homola, a regular guest author here, who have criticized chiropractic from within. Nowhere does he mention that half of chiropractors are still undermining public health by discouraging immunizations. Nowhere does he acknowledge or respond to the arguments against chiropractic, for instance the wealth of material on Quackwatch’s Chirobase, Homola’s numerous books and articles, and magazine and blog articles by me, Steven Novella, David Gorski, and many others. Nowhere does he acknowledge the critiques of the Cassidy stroke study and the other studies he cites.
What Might Have Been
Throughout, he confuses chiropractic with spinal manipulation. They are not the same thing. SMT is a specific treatment also used by other practitioners including MDs, DOs, and PTs for specific indications; chiropractic is a whole system of care built around manipulation. Chiropractors do perform the majority of manipulations; but they do them for indications that the other professions do not accept, and many of them do a lot of other silly things that can only be described as quackery.
The Flexner report resulted in accreditation standards that closed half of American medical schools. Most schools of competing medical systems like homeopathy, naturopathy, and eclectic medicine closed. Many osteopathic schools stayed in business by bringing their schools into compliance with Flexner’s recommendations. Chiropractic might have done the same, but it didn’t.
The AMA fought optometrists the same way they fought chiropractors. Optometrists were in competition with ophthalmologists for the eye market, and the AMA tried to prohibit MDs from associating with them, but they lifted the prohibition when faced with an anti-trust lawsuit similar to Wilks. Optometrists agreed to play a limited role within mainstream medicine; they are licensed to do only certain of the many things ophthalmologists do. Chiropractic might have done the same, but it didn’t.
What if chiropractic had policed its own ranks, limited itself to providing only short-term treatment for certain types of musculoskeletal pain, worked hard to determine which manipulation techniques were most effective, abandoned techniques that it found ineffective, and denounced vaccine rejection, applied kinesiology, and other forms of quackery? Manipulation might have been more widely accepted as a therapeutic tool if it had not been so tainted by the company it kept. Chiropractors could have become “physical therapists for the back,” experts in manipulation that MDs could refer patients to with confidence. Chiropractic might have been integrated into the medical mainstream just like osteopathy and optometry, but it didn’t even try.
Not Recommended
The AMA did some bad things in pursuit of a good end (fighting quackery), but Smith’s book does bad things in pursuit of a bad end (promoting unscientific health care).
I didn’t buy the book. I requested it from my public library through Interlibrary Loan. They had to search far afield for a copy, and they eventually located one in a library 2370 miles away, the Texas Chiropractic College Library. From the date due sticker, it appears to have never been checked out. I can only suspect the book is not very popular or widely read, even by chiropractors. I don’t regret reading it, because I learned a few things about history and about the thinking processes of chiropractors; but it left a very bad taste in my mouth and I certainly can’t recommend it.

ACA: Six Key Elements of A Modern Chiropractic Practice Act
Jann Bellamy on May 14, 2015
Link

In February, 2015, the American Chiropractic Association House of Delegates ratified “Six Key Elements of A Modern Chiropractic Practice Act.” For what it’s worth, this means that the “Six Elements” are part of the official “Public Policy” of the ACA.
1. “Chiropractic Physician” and “Chiropractic Medicine” as the Regulatory Terms of Licensure.
2. Scope of Practice Determined by Doctoral and Post-Doctoral Education, Training and Experience Obtained Through Appropriately Accredited Institutions.
3. Full Management, Referral and Prescription Authority commensurate with contemporary chiropractic education for Patient Examination, Diagnosis, Differential Diagnosis and Health Assessment.
4. Full Management, Referral and Prescription Authority commensurate with contemporary chiropractic education for the Care and Treatment of Neuromusculoskeletal and Other Health Conditions or Issues.
5. Full Authority for the Delivery of Information, Advice, Recommendations and Counseling Regarding General Health Matters, Wellness and Health Optimization.
6. Full Authority and Adaptable Requirements for the Management and Training of Health Care Teams and the Participation in Collaborative or Integrative Health Care Groups.
At the same time, the ACA announced the creation of a “College of Pharmacology and Toxicology of the American Chiropractic Association.”
The Six Elements are backed by a Resolution that is chock full of self-serving and evidence-free assertions such as:
Chiropractic patients and the general public are best served when the Chiropractic scope of practice is dynamic and determined by doctoral and post-doctoral education, training and experience so that a Chiropractic Physician can provide safe, best practice patient care and avoid unnecessary duplication of services.
And:
Chiropractic patients and the general public are best served when a Chiropractic Physician can fully manage the process of examination, diagnosis and health assessment including referral to other physicians and specialists for consultation and the prescription of specific tests or procedures such as diagnostic imaging, laboratory tests, home testing equipment for blood pressure or glucose monitoring, etc.
I think we can all question who is actually being “best served” by this proposal for practice expansion.
Although not specifically couched in these terms, this is part and parcel of their scheme to rebrand chiropractors as primary care physicians, a subject we’ve covered on SBM many times before. (See the series “ DC as PCP“.) What the ACA implicitly recognizes with this latest effort is the need to amend the state chiropractic practice acts to conform to their PR campaign promoting DCs as PCPs.
Even though the proponent of science-based medicine might not otherwise agree with them on anything else, the “straight” chiropractors have proven to be a valuable resource and important counter-balance to the promotion of chiropractors as primary care physicians, including bids for prescription privileges.
The “Foundation for Vertebral Subluxation Research” informs us that the reason for the Six Elements is the ACA’s frustration with the Federation of Chiropractic Licensing Boards (FCLB), which has been working on a Model Practice Act (MPA) for chiropractors since 1993. FCLB recently finalized its MPA and says it’s undergoing legal review but it has not been otherwise released for review or comment. Maybe it is frustration, or maybe it’s a preemptive strike.
I do have to agree with the ACA that the current state chiropractic practice acts are inconsistent and permit chiropractors to offer a startling range of diagnostic services and treatments, from delivery of babies to treatment of back pain. What is entirely unclear is what the scope of practice should be. After all, the only thing chiropractors offer with any proven benefit is spinal manipulation for acute low back pain, a service that other professions offer without the heaping helping of quackery thrown in.
Dynamic Chiropractic interviewed two ACA Delegates who were present at the creation of the Six Elements and the College of Pharmacology and Toxicology. They had very different takes on the subject. So different, in fact, that one delegate announced his resignation over the controversy in the interview.
The interviewer asked both whether numbers 1 – 4 of the Six Elements didn’t suggest that chiropractors should have the authority to prescribe drugs. The newly re-elected president of the ACA was of the view that it did not because no chiropractic organization promoted the inclusion of prescription drug rights, as set forth by a group called “The Summit.”
But the straight faction has a way with words when cutting through the rhetoric of those who promote a broad scope of chiropractic practice. Here’s what the delegate from Kansas, the one who declared he was resigning from the ACA House of Delegates, had to say on the matter:
There is a saying in the Midwest: “If it looks like a pig, acts like a pig and smells like a pig … it probably is a pig … and no matter how much lipstick you put on it … it is still a pig.” In my opinion, it would be hard to draw any other conclusion than to suggest that these elements are there explicitly for the purpose of furthering the agenda towards acquiring prescription authority.
I’m with the Kansas delegate on this one. It’s extremely hard to reconcile the statement that chiropractic practice acts should include “Full . . . Prescription Authority commensurate with contemporary chiropractic education for the Care and Treatment of Neuromusculoskeletal and Other Health Conditions or Issues” with the statement that they are opposed to prescription rights, especially considering the fact that the ACA is also creating a new specialty called chiropractic pharmacology and toxicology. It looks a lot like lipstick on a pig to me too.
The interviewer also asked this revealing question:
The “Rational” for this Resolution #12 (that creates the College) states, “And the ACA Wellness Model Policy under Health Information Resource (Primary Prevention) whereby typical health promotion activities performed by a DC serving as a health information resource includes Drug Alerts, Immunization, and Drugs Used in Pain Relief;” Do you believe doctors of chiropractic should be equipped to be an “information resource” in “Drug Alerts, Immunization and Drugs Used in Pain Relief?”
To which the ACA delegate supporting these measures cryptically replied:
The ACA supports education of our profession in all matters related to public health.
Other than advice regarding OTC pain medications that may be recommended within their scope of practice, any advice regarding pain medications would necessarily intrude on the practice of physicians, PAs and Nurse Practitioners who recommended or prescribed pain meds. Chiropractors have no business going there, ACA “College” or no ACA “College.” And we certainly don’t want them giving immunization advice, considering their well-documented anti-vaccine ideology.
Apart from prescription authority and related issues, the most troublesome aspect of the Six Elements is the underlying premise that chiropractic educational institutions should be the sole arbiter of chiropractic scope of practice, as expressed in Elements 2, 3 and 4. Combined with all-inclusive phrases like “full management,” “patient examination, diagnosis, differential diagnosis and health assessment” and “care and treatment of neuromusculoskeletal and other health conditions or issues” we are left with the distinct impression that the Council on Chiropractic Education and the chiropractic colleges could cooperate to include just about any diagnostic method or treatment in the chiropractic college curricula and thereby, ipso facto, include them in the state chiropractic practice acts.
Given the fact that chiropractic education and practice is not bound by the strictures of science or the scientific method, this would mean virtually unlimited authority to dump any quackery they wished into the legal scope of practice. This is, in fact, what naturopaths have done, by the use of vague language in their practice acts. For example, Maryland’s new licensing act permits:
patient education and naturopathic therapies and therapeutic substances recognized by the Council on Naturopathic Medical Education.
Idaho’s defeated licensing bill included similar language.
Perhaps taking a page from the naturopathic playbook, bills introduced in New Mexico and Hawaii in both this and the last legislative session would have allowed a scope of practice that depended on whether a particular practice was taught in chiropractic school. Fortunately, none of these measures passed.
To fully understand the import of the Six Elements, one must realize how divorced chiropractic education and training is from the mainstream American educational system and the education and training of physicians and other health care professionals. Chiropractors are taught in small colleges that have no affiliation with the rest of the American post-high school educational system. These colleges have no entrance exam and are staffed mainly by faculty who are also chiropractors. Unlike physicians, they don’t do residencies after graduation. And unlike physicians, nurses, PAs and other allied health professionals, they do not engage in interprofessional training. Most of their clinical work is done in small chiropractic school clinics. This education pales in comparison to that of family practitioners.
These schools are accredited by a private organization run by chiropractors, the Council on Chiropractic Education. The Department of Education grants accreditation authority to the CCE, but that depends solely on its having met certain criteria related largely to administrative matters It has absolutely nothing to do with whether their education is sufficient to meet the requirements of a particular scope of practice. Chiropractors must pass an exam created solely by chiropractors to practice, an exam that, to my knowledge, no one outside of chiropractic has ever seen. Their practices are regulated by state chiropractic boards, which are also controlled by chiropractors.
In sum, chiropractic is a closed loop system, created by, and for the benefit of, chiropractors. Thus, to suggest, as the ACA does, that chiropractors can suddenly emerge, fully equipped to practice primary care and become an integral part of the mainstream American healthcare system by managing health care teams is ludicrous. (This “team” reference is an obvious allusion to the Affordable Care Act and the ACA’s ham-fisted attempt to fit chiropractic square pegs into the round holes of the ACA’s provisions for patient-centered medical homes.)
Fortunately, it does not appear that anyone other than the ACA thinks the “Six Key Elements” should be included in “A Modern Chiropractic Practice Act.” That does not mean we shouldn’t be vigilant in watching for these “Elements” to show up in proposals to amend the state chiropractic acts. They have already. No one other than chiropractors accepts the premises behind the chiropractic subluxation. And yet that concept made it into all 50 state chiropractic practice acts. It may be lipstick on a pig, but some legislators seem attracted to ruby-lipped sows.

Chiropractic Subluxation Theory: Legal Support for Inappropriate Use of Spinal Manipulation
Legally licensed, unbridled subluxation-based chiropractors who offer unproven treatment for a broad scope of health problems endanger public health, stigmatize appropriate use of spinal manipulation, and deter development of chiropractic as a legitimate back-care specialty.
Sam Homola on June 9, 2017
Link

Since I am getting old (like Mark Crislip), one of the first things I do each morning is read the obituary to see who among my friends and acquaintances have died, most of whom are usually younger than I am. This morning I saw a familiar name ─ a chiropractor who opened a practice in my city many years ago. He was a subluxation-based chiropractor who employed an aggressive subluxation-oriented practice-building firm that provided him with canned newspaper advertising suggesting that he and his clinic offered the latest in scientific care for a variety of human ailments ─ care not provided by other chiropractors or any other health professional.
As a longtime critic of chiropractic subluxation theory and unethical advertising, I opposed the practice of this chiropractor, and I advised my patients not to seek his services. He eventually closed his office and moved away. According to his obituary, he had practiced in three different locations before his death, apparently struggling in his practice. I felt bad for this chiropractor and his wife and children, all of whom may have been adversely affected by his choice of chiropractic as a career, and I felt some degree of guilt for the effect my actions might have had on his family.
The uncertain aspects of chiropractic as a career
The nonfalsifiable chiropractic subluxation theory, which proposes that nerve interference caused by a vertebral subluxation can cause organic disease, still guides the practice of many chiropractors, most of whom now have undergraduate degrees. At least three years of undergraduate study (90 semester hours leading to a bachelor’s degree) are required to enroll in a chiropractic college. Several states require a baccalurate degree before a chiropractor can apply for a license to practice.
Unfortunately, an undergraduate degree or an unrelated graduate degree does not always offer protection against indoctrination in pseudoscience. Chiropractic students who do not have critical thinking skills will simply become products of what they have been taught. The result is that many well-meaning chiropractors struggle to defend and promote a practice based on a belief system that is sure to be opposed by the scientific community. Most newly-graduated chiropractors are unaware of the societal suspicion and the isolation resulting from rejection by the scientific community until they hang out their shingle.
The undergraduate requirements for enrolling in a privately-funded chiropractic college and to be licensed to practice as a chiropractor would permit enrollment in an academically-recognized college supported by state funding, offering degrees in physical medicine and other health-care occupations that provide more income and better opportunity for employment as well as a greater degree of social acceptance and professional recognition. Anyone considering chiropractic as a career should sit down at a computer and search the negative side of chiropractic before making a commitment that will have a profound life-long effect.
A degree in chiropractic offers no assurance for success in private practice. There is little opportunity for employment of chiropractors outside of private practice. Failure in private practice may force a chiropractor to leave the profession and seek employment in another field. Chiropractors who have the means and the ability to “start over” may leave the practice of chiropractic simply because of an inability to tolerate the pseudoscience in chiropractic and the isolation resulting from rejection by mainstream health-care professionals.
When I am asked about enrolling in a chiropractic college, I always suggest that it would be better to pursue a physical therapy degree, which would permit use of manual therapy in the mainstream of health care. Doctors of Physical Therapy (DPT) trained in use of spinal manipulation can be found in clinics, hospitals, and private practice in most cities. Every state now allows some level of direct access to physical therapy treatment without a prescription or a physician referral.
My personal struggle
When I began my chiropractic practice in 1956, I had already rejected subluxation theory, a view I expressed in my 1963 book Bonesetting, Chiropractic, and Cultism. I believed that my use of spinal manipulation along with a few physical therapy modalities would provide a service not yet available in physical therapy departments. Some of my physical medicine textbooks recommended spinal manipulation as a treatment for mechanical-type neck and back pain. So I had good reason to believe that I offered a service of value. If I had believed that use of spinal manipulation in the treatment of back pain was quackery, I would not have gone into practice.
Offering treatment for musculoskeletal back problems, it was many months before I could take in enough money to cover the expense of operating my office. The public image of chiropractic was not good, insurance did not cover chiropractic, and physicians would not refer patients to chiropractors ─ for good reason. I could not have kept my office open long enough to build a practice if it had not been for my wife, Martha, who worked as an abstractor preparing property titles.
My published work about chiropractic and spinal manipulation brought support and referrals from other health-care professionals. Back-pain patients were channeled to my office by physicians and insurance carriers in order to bypass care by subluxation-based chiropractors. Although most health insurance now covers chiropractic care and chiropractors are better educated, chiropractic subluxation theory continues to define chiropractic in state laws that provide support for the pseudoscience of subluxation-based chiropractic care.
Finding a good chiropractor
There are, of course, some good chiropractors who use manipulation appropriately in a practice limited to treatment of musculoskeletal problems, using physical-treatment methods that include use of spinal manipulation as a treatment option, but they are hard to find. There is no way for the average person to distinguish such chiropractors from subluxation-based chiropractors. There are many chiropractors who claim to be advocates of musculoskeletal care but whose web sites include reference to subluxation nonsense. Until there is a national chiropractic association that openly rejects subluxation theory, limiting membership to science-based chiropractors with some way of identifying these chiropractors publicly, most physicians and health-care providers may simply refer patients to physical therapists for manual therapy that has not been contaminated by subluxation theory.
When I retired from private practice in 1998, one of the biggest problems I had was finding a chiropractor I could recommend for my former patients. I knew that patients who had received treatment in my office might assume that all chiropractors practiced the way I did, unaware of the great diversity of antithetical treatment methods among chiropractors. Listing as a “licensed chiropractor” in a telephone book offers no clue about the validity of the services offered. After reviewing the web sites and advertisements of the dozen or so chiropractors in my area, I found only one chiropractor that I thought was trustworthy. Today, I cannot find a nearby chiropractor that I would recommend. I am forced to recommend physical therapy for my friends and my former patients in order to avoid the possibility of chiropractic treatment based on subluxation theory.
Continued review of current chiropractic literature and web sites reveals that little has changed since my retirement from chiropractic practice. A broad scope of practice for chiropractors is still supported by subluxation theory under a variety of labels, such as a “vertebral subluxation complex,” an undetectable asymptomatic “joint dysfunction” alleged to cause disease by interfering with nerve supply to organs. Some chiropractors who have discarded the term “subluxation” continue to claim that manipulating vertebrae to correct a mysterious problem in the spine, such as a “neurobiomechanical lesion,” is an effective method of restoring and maintaining health.
Leaning toward “integrative medicine,” many chiropractors are subscribing to “functional medicine” and other alternative medicine procedures to further increase their scope of practice. Full-page ads offer treatment for thyroid issues, fibromyalgia, neuropathy, diabetes, and other problems, competing with services offered by multiple specialties and subspecialties that makeup the practice of medicine ─ a trend that is certainly a cause for alarm.
The guilt of pseudoscience
In addition to the struggle to succeed in private practice as a chiropractor, there is a price to be paid by those chiropractors who “go along” with subluxation theory in order to make a living. Burdened with misgivings, some chiropractors do what they feel they have to do to provide for their family. Some blatantly unethical chiropractors exploit subluxation theory in order to make as much money as possible, treating patients excessively and unnecessarily with treatment methods known to be useless if not downright quackery. Perhaps the most horrendous act of all is the pretense of chiropractors who claim to locate and adjust vertebral subluxations in the cartilaginous spine of a newborn baby, risking injury to epiphyseal growth centers (or worse).
At the end of the day and at the end of life, unethical chiropractors must deal with the guilt that occurs as a result of knowingly mistreating children or misleading patients who are allowed to suffer needlessly in order to complete a course of subluxation treatment “guaranteed to remove the cause of the problem.” Chiropractors with a conscience who take advantage of the suffering and the ignorance of patients who seek their help may have difficulty sleeping at night or may feel a sense of remorse at the end of life when memories replay the details of a selfish purpose that contributed little or nothing to society or to the welfare of mankind.
Although some chiropractors are abandoning subluxation theory and seeking specialization in conservative care for back pain and other musculoskeletal problems, portending a possible path for the chiropractic profession, there will always be a faction in chiropractic that will be devoted to the subluxation theory that gave birth to chiropractic. Belief systems never die since they are not subject to critical thinking or scientific analysis. A good example of this is the profession of osteopathy, which, although now scientific and mainstream, harbors a faction that is devoted to the principles of Andrew Taylor Still, a medical doctor who founded osteopathy with a claim that manipulation of joint and musculoskeletal structures is an effective treatment for most human ailments. Any practice that begins with a false premise and a founding father, such as chiropractic, osteopathy, and homeopathy, can never completely eliminate true believers who are bound together by the tenets of cultism.
Seeking a direction
My heart goes out to chiropractic students who have used their hard-earned undergraduate degrees to enroll in a chiropractic college, unaware of the controversy they must endure in competing with subluxation-based chiropractors who follow the tenets of D.D. Palmer, a magnetic healer and the founder of chiropractic. So far, there is no American chiropractic association or group that has publicly renounced subluxation theory and successfully united the chiropractic profession with a common denominator based on science. An effort in this direction failed with the demise of the National Association for Chiropractic Medicine (NACM) sometime after 2008 as a result of a low and declining membership. Advocating that chiropractic care be limited to treatment of neuromusculoskeletal problems of musculoskeletal origin, membership in the NACM required written renouncement of the chiropractic vertebral subluxation theory.
No applicability for chiropractic subluxation theory
The chiropractic subluxation alleged to be a cause of organic disease has never been demonstrated and is not the same as an orthopedic subluxation (a partial dislocation) or a joint strain that can cause musculoskeletal symptoms. While generic spinal manipulation can be of benefit in relieving the symptoms of mechanical-type back pain, which might occasionally involve an orthopedic subluxation, routine manipulation of the spine to correct a putative chiropractic subluxation as a treatment for conditions ranging from infant colic to back pain is classic cultism. Subluxation theory alone offers no justification for treatment of back pain. A spinal adjustment alleged to cure disease by correcting a vertebral subluxation, invented by Palmer in 1895, is not the same as generic spinal manipulation that has been around for thousands of years.
Today, there are chiropractors who claim to be primary care providers. The American Chiropractic Association offers certification in 10 different specialties, such as “Chiropractic Pediatrics” (often accompanied by opposition to vaccination) and “Diagnosis and Internal Disorders,” with a post-graduate diplomate awarded after attending weekends of classroom instruction. Many entrepreneurial chiropractors use the vague chiropractic “subluxation complex” paradigm to develop questionable techniques and specialties of their own, doing as they please under the umbrella of alternative medicine, relieved of the responsibility and the knowledge required to seek or offer appropriate treatment based on a correct diagnosis.
At the present time, it appears that subluxation theory will continue to dominate the practice of chiropractic. According to a survey of North American chiropractic students published in 2015, the majority of students would like to see an emphasis on correction of vertebral subluxations.
Chiropractic as a “spine specialty”
Some chiropractors claim to be a “spine specialist,” a specialty and a niche they cannot adequately fill because of limitations that do not permit utilization of multiple medical specialties and facilities that are needed to diagnose and treat “spinal problems,” a designation that includes a wide range of conditions, such as severe injury, disease, malignancy, infection, neurological complications, or pain of unknown origin. Physical therapists and properly trained chiropractors may be able to qualify as portal-of-entry practitioners capable of diagnosing and treating uncomplicated, mechanical-type back pain if they are backed up by the medical community, but “spine care” implies a broad scope that requires the attention of unlimited medical specialties and their subspecialties, such as orthopedics, physiatrics, physical therapy, and occupational therapy in a multi-disciplinary environment.
Justification for use of spinal manipulation
Every ethical chiropractor is concerned about the effects of his/her primary method of treatment, spinal manipulation. The theory that vertebral misalignment is a cause of disease or poor health has been rejected by the scientific community, but there is some evidence that spinal manipulation can be helpful in the treatment of some types of back pain. This evidence is weak, however, and there are studies which indicate that spinal manipulation may not be any more effective than other forms of treatment in facilitating recovery from back pain. Case reports of stroke caused by neck manipulation suggest that risk may always outweigh benefit when the upper cervical spine is manipulated.
Obviously, spinal manipulation has limited value and is only one treatment of many that might be helpful in the treatment of back pain, requiring that it be included in a physical-treatment armamentarium as an option among a variety of treatment methods.
Spinal manipulation is the only treatment used by “straight” chiropractic extremists who believe that a vertebral subluxation plays a role in the development of most health problems. Atlas Orthogonal and NUCCA (National Upper Cervical Chiropractic Association) chiropractors believe that subluxation of the atlas (first cervical vertebra) is the primary cause of disease. Every patient gets a neck adjustment, no matter what the ailment might be, even low-back pain. Most subluxation-based chiropractors adjust every portion of the spine in order to correct or prevent alleged subluxations.
Use of spinal manipulation in the treatment of mechanical-type back pain can sometimes be justified by its effect in improving mobility and providing temporary relief of pain, buying the time needed to allow recovery without resorting to use of drugs, injections, or surgery. It goes without saying, however, that there is no substitute for medication in relieving severe back or radicular pain, which might be aggravated by inappropriate use of spinal manipulation. Victims of back pain often suffer unnecessarily when they respond to chiropractic advertisements promising “pain relief.” Any practitioner who offers treatment for acute back pain should have access to judicious use of pain medication as a short-term treatment option when pain is severe or incapacitating.
In rare, carefully selected cases, manipulation can be dramatically effective in restoring mobility in spinal joints locked or stiffened by post-traumatic adhesions. Office procedures such as massage and physical therapy modalities along with ongoing evaluation and observation can be an important part of caring for back pain. The relaxing effects of a good back-cracking back rub can enhance the effects of any treatment for chronic back pain, reducing or eliminating use of over-the-counter medication. The placebo effect of cavitation, a popping sound produced by manipulating the spine, may play a role in the patient’s perception of how effective a manipulative treatment might be.
Diagnosis: The most important part of back care
A correct diagnosis, which often requires multi-disciplinary involvement, is essential to determine what type of treatment might be needed. Most cases of acute uncomplicated back pain are self-limiting and will resolve with time, with or without treatment. Manual therapy, self-help measures, and instruction in exercise and ergonomics may be helpful in relieving symptoms until recovery is complete, depending upon the diagnosis. When there is acute back pain caused by disease or disc herniation, or when a nerve root is truly “pinched” or impinged by an osteophyte, symptoms may be exacerbated by manipulating the spine. Chiropractors who “analyze” the spine in a search for subluxations always manipulate the spine, offering treatment that is likely to be useless or harmful. When symptoms worsen as a result of such treatment, as they often do, they may be falsely attributed to “retracing,” a reaction alleged to be the result of removing the cause of the problem.
Subluxation-based chiropractors who “list a subluxation” rather than provide a diagnosis often explain that they do not diagnose or treat disease; they simply correct subluxations so that the body can heal itself. The success rate of treating a variety of ailments by adjusting imaginary subluxations is quite high since many ailments are self-limiting and will resolve on their own without treatment. Such “success” fails to provide appropriate care for patients who need special care based on a correct diagnosis.
The bottom line
While there appears to be no doubt in the scientific community that the chiropractic vertebral subluxation theory is not a valid construct, there is evidence to suggest that spinal manipulation can be a helpful procedure in the treatment of some types of back pain when it is part of a program that includes a variety of physical treatment options in a multidisciplinary environment. Evidence-based chiropractors who use generic spinal manipulation appropriately deserve some consideration as opposed to subluxation-based chiropractors who routinely “adjust” vertebral subluxations alleged to be a cause of disease. It is the moral and ethical duty of any science-based health-care provider to combat unproven subluxation-based chiropractic care, while taking care to be objective in evaluating the effects of spinal manipulation.
In addition to protection of public health, rejection of subluxation theory by conscientious chiropractors may be as important for the mental health of these chiropractors as it is for the physical health of their patients. I cannot imagine how I would feel at this stage of my life if I had devoted my career and my life to the pseudoscience of vertebral subluxation theory, fully aware of the falsehood involved. Hopefully, in the end, my published work, based on 43 years of practice as a chiropractor, will show that I did some good by separating the good from the bad in the use of spinal manipulation, steering the public away from inappropriate chiropractic care while providing a service of value to those who came to me for help.

.

Chiropractic Defense: Tempest in a Teapot
Sam Homola on June 2, 2014
Link

When Forbes.com published Steven Salzberg’s article “New Medicare Data Reveal Startling $496 million wasted on Chiropractors” (April 20, 2014), a flood of mail (more than 300 comments) from chiropractors and their patients provided a wealth of evidence that subluxation-based chiropractic is alive and well despite rejection by the scientific community. Pro-chiropractic comments laced with anti-medical rhetoric and ad hominem attacks, expressed with religious fervor, failed to distinguish between generic spinal manipulation (that can be useful in the treatment of mechanical-type back and spinal problems) and chiropractic adjustments used in an attempt to restore and maintain health by correcting vertebral subluxations. No distinction was made between a real, symptomatic orthopedic subluxation and an imaginary, asymptomatic chiropractic “vertebral subluxation complex,” neither of which has been shown to be a cause of bad health. While the chiropractic profession may have some justification for objecting to any suggestion that chiropractic treatment has no value whatsoever, especially in the case of mechanical-type back pain and other musculoskeletal problems, the tone and content of many of the comments by chiropractors provide good examples of why chiropractic is so often criticized by the scientific community.
A quote in the Forbes article, from my Science-Based Medicine article “Chiropractic: A Summary of Concerns,” brought this comment from a prominent chiropractor:
…Harriet Hall, Edzard Ernst, Jann Bellamy, and other current renowned medical bigots who attack all CAM providers but turn a blind eye to the dangers of the medical profession….Steven, your chiro critics are invalid—none of them are researchers or educators, but they are just disgruntled practitioners from yesteryear. Don’t get me started on the Science-Based guys who are just haters like you—Harriet Hall, Edzard Ernst, Jann Bellamy are renown medical bigots.
Chiropractors who subscribe to the current chiropractic paradigm (which proposes that a subluxation complex will “compromise neural integrity and may influence organ system function and general health”) often attempt to equate use of chiropractic adjustments to treat health problems with spinal manipulation used in the treatment of back pain. Subluxation-based chiropractors might also refer to medical literature describing an orthopedic subluxation to support the existence of a putative chiropractic subluxation. While a case can be made for treatment to relieve musculoskeletal symptoms caused by an orthopedic subluxation, which is not a common occurrence, there is good reason to question why Medicare (or anyone) would pay for treatment of an undetectable “chiropractic subluxation” that is alleged (by chiropractors) to be so common that it is routinely entered as a diagnosis on chiropractic Medicare claims. Since Medicare coverage of chiropractic service is specifically limited to use of manual manipulation of the spine to correct a subluxation that can be demonstrated by x-ray or physical examination, it seems logical to assume that a diagnosis of “subluxation” on a chiropractic Medicare claim is rarely appropriate.
Until consensus forces chiropractic associations to publicly renounce the implausible chiropractic vertebral subluxation theory, requiring changes in state laws and the curriculum of chiropractic colleges across the board, chiropractic will continue to be defined by pseudoscience that keeps the profession marginal and isolated. In the meantime, science-based chiropractors who use manipulation appropriately will have to make an effort to separate their work from the stigma associated with inappropriate use of manipulation based on chiropractic subluxation theory.
The conflict between chiropractic and medical science won’t change until all concerned are able to meet on common ground governed by the laws of anatomy, physiology, and other basic sciences. Unfortunately, groups guided by a belief system do not often yield to facts that are contrary to a self-perpetuating dogma, making it necessary to speak out on the side of science in the best interest of persons who might become victims of such dogma.
Facts as proof vs dogma as proof
There are many legitimate studies published in peer-reviewed scientific journals supporting use of spinal manipulation as an appropriate form of manual therapy in the treatment of back pain. There is also a plethora of journals published and reviewed by chiropractors who are dedicated to promoting chiropractic subluxation theory as an approach for treating a great variety of ailments in all age groups, e.g., Journal of Vertebral Subluxation Research and Journal of Clinical Chiropractic Pediatrics. Articles in such journals are often offered as proof that treatment based on subluxation theory is effective, but few are able to withstand the scrutiny of scientific review. When Simon Singh, a British science journalist, said in a 2008 Guardian article (“Beware the Spinal Trap”) that chiropractic treatment of certain childhood ailments, endorsed by the British Chiropractic Association (BCA), was “bogus,” the BCA sued Singh for libel and presented 29 cherry-picked studies purported to support chiropractic treatment for such ailments as colic, nocturnal enuresis, otitis media, and asthma. Few of the articles were scientifically acceptable; all were of poor quality, with the totality of evidence actually negative. (See “The British Chiropractic Association Responds to Simon Singh,” Novella, Science-Based Medicine, July 8, 2009.) The BCA lost its suit against Singh.
In 2010, following the Singh suit, the General Chiropractic Council of the United Kingdom issued a declaration stating that “The chiropractic vertebral subluxation complex is an historical concept but it remains a theoretical model. It is not supported by any clinical research evidence that would allow claims to be made that it is the cause of disease or health concerns.” The British Chiropractic Association responded by advising its members that the advice of the General Council had no bearing on scope of practice.
To date, I have seen only one credible study that has objectively examined chiropractic subluxation theory. In 2009, Timothy A. Mirtz, et al, using Hill’s criteria of causation, reported in Chiropractic and Manual Therapies (17:13) that “No supportive evidence is found for the chiropractic subluxation being associated with any disease process or of creating suboptimal health conditions requiring intervention.” Unfortunately, questions about the validity or the plausibility of chiropractic subluxation theory have not had any influence on the politics and policies of major chiropractic associations. Chiropractic associations usually respond to criticism of chiropractic care by comparing conservative care of back pain with medical care of back pain, presenting chiropractic as the superior treatment method without renouncing chiropractic subluxation theory that embraces a broad scope of health problems.
Journalism in the public interest
Few among us in the general public are able to evaluate the research published by chiropractic organizations and journals, often distributed by “press releases” and provided as a “public service” to newspapers and television stations. When there is a negative response to news that chiropractic is effective in treating a variety of health problems, chiropractors may respond by providing a long list of articles providing “facts about chiropractic,” published in chiropractic journals, offering “proof” that chiropractic can treat more than just back trouble. As in the case of the BCA-Singh suit dealing with childhood ailments, however, few of these articles would withstand scientific analysis, despite being viewed favorably by the public.
Judging from the increasing popularity of alternative medicine, science seems to be losing its battle against scams, quackery, and pseudoscience. The simple explanations offered by alternative medicine practitioners who offer anecdotes and testimonials as proof that their treatments are effective are appealing to persons who are unable to recognize the signs of pseudoscience and to entrepreneurs and health-care providers who can benefit financially from integration of questionable but popular treatment methods. Until the public as a whole is more well-informed and better educated in science and critical thinking, it will be necessary for science journalists to make every effort to protect the public by speaking out about the methods of charlatans, vendors, and well-meaning but misinformed practitioners and groups who offer inappropriate treatment to persons who are sick, in pain, or disabled.
When I write articles critical of chiropractic subluxation theory and inappropriate use of manipulation by subluxation-based chiropractors, I always make an effort to support the use of spinal manipulation as a form of manual therapy in the treatment of back trouble and related neuromusculoskeletal problems, no matter who uses such treatment. Unfortunately, chiropractic subluxation theory continues to be supported by a significant number of chiropractors, making it difficult to find a chiropractor who uses manipulation appropriately. Few chiropractors openly criticize subluxation-based chiropractic; those who do may claim that chiropractors who subscribe to subluxation theory are in the minority. The response of chiropractors to criticism of subluxation-based chiropractic, however, appears to indicate that the majority of chiropractors have not abandoned subluxation theory.
Despite the condemnation proffered by colleagues who view me as a hostile critic of chiropractic, I have always felt compelled to speak out against harmful or useless treatment methods used by practitioners who represent my profession. I have no objections to the work of science-based chiropractors who limit their treatment to care of musculoskeletal problems. I simply want to see spinal manipulation used appropriately by chiropractors and others who use manual therapy. I have always made an effort to be truthful to the best of my ability when people came to me for help or advice. When I published Bonesetting, Chiropractic, and Cultism in 1963, renouncing subluxation theory, I stood alone, knowing that publication of the book placed me in jeopardy of losing my license and my livelihood. Chiropractic journals refused to publish my articles. When the National Association for Chiropractic Medicine (NACM) was formed in 1983, members were required to renounce subluxation theory. The NACM provided opportunity for reform of the chiropractic profession and a safe haven for scientifically-oriented chiropractors. The association was able to attract only about one hundred members, however, and has since disbanded. I suspect that such an association today would not be any more successful than the NACM was in 1986 when I was a member.

The paper trail of a “chiropractic heretic”
Although my Bonesetting the book was reviewed by the Library Journal in 1964, it was never reviewed by a chiropractic association. When it was reviewed by Joe Keating, Ph.D., in 1990, he concluded with this statement:
Although chiropractors may take exception to Dr. Homola’s over-estimation of the scientific status of medicine, the historical value of his review of the state of chiropractic in 1963 is unmistakable. The good doctor has since authored and co-authored a number of widely read books on diet, exercise and nutrition, and continues in private practice (limited to “neuromusculoskeletal” disorders) in northern Florida. Perhaps the profession will finally seek out this seer before his most dire predictions come to pass.— Dynamic Chiropractic, January 3, 1990
Today, many members of the chiropractic profession still view me as “the turncoat” who wrote Bonesetting, Chiropractic, and Cultism. I suspect that my demise will be celebrated by subluxation-based chiropractors who have contributed to my file of hate mail over the years. Hopefully, the paper trail I leave behind will show that I always acted in the best interest of the public and my patients by following the guidelines of science. I will rest in peace knowing that my views were well received by the scientific community and that much of the criticism I endured came from persons who felt threatened by scientific scrutiny of a belief system that governed their lives and their livelihood. A collection of letters in my file (Letters to a Chiropractic Heretic) contains notes from chiropractors who harbored views similar to mine and who were encouraged by my work but were reluctant to speak out for fear of ostracism.
I am comforted by the public support of a few outspoken individuals in my profession, such as Timothy A. Mirtz, Ph.D., D.C., who recently offered this response to criticism of one of my Science-Based Medicine articles:
Dr. Homola is indeed a DC himself with a long history of writing in the profession. In fact, his book, Bonesetting, Chiropractic, and Cultism was written in 1963. It is a magnificent read and if you read it today you would think he would be talking about today….I believe we owe him a debt for being the first to essentially speak out about the madness that we all find embarrassing. He is and should be honored as the Godfather of Chiropractic Reform.
Thank you, Dr. Mirtz. And thanks to all those who have supported me over the years, especially the scientific community that gave me a platform for my views. Publication of my articles on chiropractic in such peer-reviewed medical journals as Archives of Family Medicine and Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research following my retirement from the practice of chiropractic belie the accusations of critics who say that I am simply an ignorant, disgruntled practitioner of yesteryear. In a stand diametrically opposed to the views of my chiropractic detractors, I am proud to be associated with such “medical bigots” as Harriet Hall, Edzard Ernst, and Jann Bellamy. And I am honored to be among the “haters” who write for Science-Based Medicine.

A London Chiropractor Gets His Undeserved Fifteen Minutes of Fame
Thanks to his anti-science and anti-medicine worldview, and a complete misunderstanding of evolution, a London chiropractor is getting some undeserved attention from the media.
Clay Jones on August 10, 2018
Link

We deal with a lot of dangerous nonsense on SBM. And the individuals who promote said nonsense are, more often than not, as ignorant and obnoxious as the ideas they espouse. Today’s brief post, in which I will discuss what is perhaps the pinnacle of obnoxious ignorance, will not be an exception.
100% medicine free, except for all the medicine
Starting late last week, several news outlets in England featured a 61-year-old chiropractor named Richard Lanigan who has apparently refused to ever give his children medications, including vaccinations, and that they are healthier for it. In fact, the words “100% medicine free” are used. We’ve heard these sorts of claims before of course, but Lanigan’s version is particularly offensive. And it isn’t even true, as he reveals that one of his children was given pain medication when she was brought to the emergency department after suffering a head injury.
In an article in The Daily Mail, he also admits that his children received vaccines before going on a recent school trip. But this isn’t remotely close to the worst of his hypocrisy. Lanigan claims in the recent articles to have been diagnosed with terminal rectal cancer years ago, and that he was given only a few months to live. Undeterred, he refused conventional therapy and cured himself with cannabis oil. Yet in a blog post in 2012, he wrote the following:
About two months ago I was given the all clear, which means 12 months after surgery and having finished six months of chemotherapy I am still alive, no longer have a colostomy bag and there are no visible signs of cancer in my body.
I realized that perhaps the information from the blog post in 2012 was referring to his initial diagnosis, and that maybe his cancer had returned. The post didn’t mention anything about being given months to live or refusing medical care and I wanted to be charitable. So I kept digging and found this post on another of Lanigan’s old blogs. As I suspected, his cancer had returned in 2013. But, also as I suspected, he did undergo conventional therapy.
I started Chemo in October 2013, after four cycles, I was experiencing the peripheral neuropathy again and told the consultant I did not want to continue the treatment, she was surprised, said I might only live 6 months if I stopped.
He did stop the chemotherapy. But…
The CT scan in December 2013, revealed the metastasis had not progressed so the chemo had done something…I was a good candidate for targeted radiation and again as in 2011, twenty sessions of radiation fried the tumours in the Lymph nodes around the Aorta.
From that point on he has been cancer free and has continued to have yearly visits to his oncologist for scans. He did end up refusing additional chemotherapy after the radiation and he did start the cannabis oil. But it’s clear that his current statements about curing himself without conventional medical treatment are deceptive.
Lanigan also claims to have ignored the concerns of medical professionals when one of his children was an infant sick with pertussis, also known as whooping cough. He says that he was told that she was likely going to die, but she avoided hospitalization and lived because of “natural nutrients in breast milk.” Pertussis in young infants is particularly nasty, with a case fatality rate as high as 2% during recent outbreaks in the United States. It’s hard to imagine that his child was actually ill and just allowed to go home and die. She was likely just exposed to the disease and never actually got sick.
I don’t think you’re using that correctly
The most absurd claims that Lanigan makes involve evolution. He doesn’t understand it…at all:
If you look at how we’ve evolved, humans became stronger by getting illnesses. The process of natural selection meant the strongest survived. If you rely on vaccinations and medications for optimal health, you’re creating a weaker species. Natural selection means survival of the fittest – it’s harsh but true.
This isn’t evolution, it’s Lamarckism or the inheritance of acquired characteristics. For one thing, your body doesn’t know the difference between natural immunity and immunity after vaccination. Protection is protection but the immunity that comes from vaccination doesn’t risk the morbidity and mortality of the disease. And immunity to measles, to just give one example, isn’t passed on to offspring. Lanigan appears to be willing to let thousands of children die, apparently even his own, in part because of his ignorance of science, evolution, medicine, and parenting.
There is a lot more to unpack in these articles, such as how Lanigan believes that the pharmaceutical industry pushes drugs because they can’t make money selling ice. You can read the links and find these gems for yourself, however. I want to finish up with an example of how this kind of anti-medicine thinking, and a serious misunderstanding of evolutionary biology, can result in actual harm, even death.
Science denial gets real
On August 8th, a Michigan couple was charged with felony murder and first-degree child abuse after apparently allowing their 10-month-old daughter starve to death. The child’s parents, particularly the father, were known to speak against the medical system. He also explained during a video posted to Facebook that “doctors would have to believe in creationism to be able to successfully treat patients.”
Sentiments like that don’t seem to jibe with others attributed to the father:
It didn’t seem smart to me that you would be saving people who weren’t the fittest. If evolution believes in survival of the fittest, well then why are we vaccinating everybody? Shouldn’t we just let the weak die off and let the strong survive?
So which is it?

The Guardian and the “Cult” of Online Chiropractic
Over the past few years, a handful of chiropractors have gone viral because of aggressive neck adjustments that make a loud crack and provide a quick thrill for viewers of their YouTube videos. A recent article in The Guardian discussed the phenomenon, but it doesn’t go far enough.
Clay Jones on December 25, 2020
Link

A quick post today. But before I get started, I just wanted to wish everyone a happy holiday from the folks at Science-Based Medicine. We really do appreciate our readers and the community that has developed around this effort over the past decade or so.
Several times in previous posts, and frequently on Twitter (@SBMPediatrics), I’ve discussed chiropractic marketing videos. Most of these have involved infants, but at least once that I can recall I included a link to a video demonstrating a terrifying trend that has popped up in adult chiropractic over the last few years where extremely aggressive spinal adjustments are performed with the goal of making as loud of a cracking noise as possible. In some of these videos, the chiropractor even places a microphone next to the patient’s neck in order to amplify the resulting crack.
There are at least two chiropractors, both of which are producing videos that attract millions of viewers, who will place a strap or towel around a patient’s head in order to augment the harshly applied pulling force. I almost want to describe them as comically aggressive maneuvers, but it really isn’t a laughing matter at all. It’s a grotesque theater that puts a patient’s health at risk in exchange for nothing more than the possibility of a nonspecific placebo response.
For viewers, it’s a voyeuristic experience. They can watch a patient seemingly come close to having their neck broken and vicariously share in the thrill. Another common aspect of these videos, and one which plays a large role in pulling in viewers, is that the patient/victim tends to have an intense emotional response. They usually have a look of shock in the period immediately after the adjustment, followed quickly by the expression of relief and then laughter. Sometimes they even start crying.
It’s understandable that a patient would have an intense emotional response. On a subconscious level they must realize that what they have just allowed to be done to their neck isn’t safe or a particularly good idea. It’s a bit like sitting down to a round or two of Russian roulette. Okay, that’s maybe a little hyperbolic. Regardless, it’s a thrill with a small but real risk of serious harm and people often have a visceral response to such things.
For these chiropractors, it’s a moneymaking scheme. They have channeled the human desire to face danger, even if safely watching it on a YouTube video from the comfort of a cubicle or living room sofa, into millions of hits and the resulting advertisement revenue. It also likely helps to keep their clinic appointments fully booked. It’s all just so…gross.
On December 6th, an article written by Paula Cocozza was published in The Guardian on the subject of these online chiropractic videos and their cult-like following. Cocozza is not a dedicated science or medicine journalist and it shows a bit. There are some really interesting/nauseating insights into this trend, but I don’t think she fully grasps how truly bad these videos and the people putting them out into the world are, and she falls short of providing the kind of skeptical analysis that a subject like this requires. Ultimately, it’s more personal interest fluff piece than Brian-Deer-level investigative journalism.
Cocozza does point out that there is not solid evidence to support what these chiropractors are doing, so there is that. She also does the shallowest of dives into the history of the profession, revealing only that its inventor, quack of all trades Daniel David Palmer, was essentially a religious nut. And to her credit she does briefly mention some high profile cases of death by chiropractor. But her cringe-inducing final paragraph unfortunately gives the featured chiropractor the last word, which ends up cementing the article as what essentially amounts to an advertisement for his practice:
Whatever the efficacy or otherwise of chiropractic treatment, it is clear that cracking videos do have something to offer. Maybe, as Cipriano puts it, like the Y strap, they simply provide “a complete pressure release”.
Ugh. The only thing these harsh adjustments release is a patient’s wallet.
See y’all next year.

Cracking Down on Chiropractic Pseudoscience
A recent CBC News investigation reveals the common pseudoscientific claims and quackery of Manitoba chiropractors.
Steven Novella on March 22, 2017
Tweet
A recent investigation by the CBC (Canadian Broadcasting Corporation) reveals what we already know, that many chiropractors promote misinformation and medical pseudoscience. The investigation was prompted by an anti-vaccine letter to the editor by a Manitoba chiropractor, Henri Marcoux. He wrote in part :
I understand those who are hesitant since the flu vaccine only provides protection against viruses from past seasons, not against the flu season under way. Why inject ourselves with a toxic substance that contains mercury or other poisons? It’s best to become aware of the fact that viruses associated with the cold and flu are always present in our bodies. They operate in a way that does not cause diseases. In fact, they purify our systems as our bodies become too full of toxins.
This letter understandably produced some outrage as every single claim in that paragraph is false or misleading. Flu vaccines are targeted against the flu season underway, but there is a lag in the development of the vaccine and so in some years the flu has already mutated to another strain before the vaccine comes out. Flu vaccines are not “toxic,” in that they do not contain any substance in a dose (the dose always makes the poison) that is toxic or dangerous. Most flu vaccines do not contain mercury (and those that do contain too low a dose to be of any health concern).
Flu viruses do not live in our bodies normally. There are viruses and bacteria that live in our bodies (commensal organisms), and sometimes these germs can cause disease. I could find no indication that influenza viruses are ever commensal. The idea that these viruses purify our bodies of toxins also appears to just be made up.
Marcoux is very clear in his recommendations:
I do not recommend vaccines because the immunization process is a natural process of the human body.
What did the CBC Find?
CBC News looked at every website for chiropractors in Manitoba. Here is a sample of what they found:
    • Offers of treatments for autism, Tourette’s syndrome, Alzheimer’s disease, colic, infections and cancer.
Anti-vaccination literature and recently published letters to the editor from chiropractors that discourage vaccination.
An article claiming vaccines have caused a 200 to 600 per cent increase in autism rates.
A statement that claims the education and training of a chiropractor is “virtually identical” to that of a medical doctor.
Discouraging people from getting diagnostic tests such as CT scans, colonoscopies and mammograms.
An informational video discouraging the use of sunscreen.
This is all old news to regular SBM readers, but that makes it no less scandalous. The problems here should be obvious.
First, all these statements and other similar health advice are demonstrable misinformation. The misinformation is designed to convince the public to forgo evidence-based medical treatment in favor of pseudoscientific chiropractic care. Chiropractors like to portray themselves as legitimate healthcare professionals, with education on a par with medical doctors (it isn’t) and able to function as more than just “back crackers.” In fact, once they obtained licensure, they have been constantly lobbying to expand their scope of practice. They would love to be alternative primary care doctors.
Despite the fact that the regulations do not currently allow for that, the CBC investigation reveals that some chiropractors practice that way anyway. They give advice and treatment on ailments that go way beyond their scope of practice, such as treating autism, dementia, and cancer.
Even if there are chiropractors who restrict themselves to the management of uncomplicated musculoskeletal problems, such as back pain, the profession does not adequately regulate itself. The range of philosophy and practice that occurs under the regulatory banner of “chiropractic” is vast, and includes a great deal of pseudoscience and quackery. As a profession they will not gain the respect they crave while they tolerate rank quackery to occur in their name.
Inadequate response
The response of chiropractors, the chiropractic profession, and the regulatory agencies to the CBC investigation are shamefully inadequate. First, CBC News contacted many chiropractors for comment, and all refused. This is very telling – if they believed strongly in their services, and could support them with logic and evidence, they should be happy to talk to a news outlet about it. They should be especially interested in correcting the record or putting the CBC report into context, if they had anything useful to say.
Instead chiropractors generally act like cockroaches when you turn the lights on, they immediately scurry for cover. They appear to only want to talk to the public when they can freely promote their practice without fear of exposure or criticism. Otherwise they want to operate below the scientific radar.
The Manitoba Chiropractic Association also declined a request for an interview, but did offer this canned response:
“As the regulatory body that oversees the practice of chiropractic in Manitoba, we will review the material you have shared with us in a thorough manner as provided for by our internal processes,” said Ernie Miron, a chiropractic doctor and the association registrar.
In other words, they will do absolutely nothing to foster high standards of evidence-based practice among Manitoba chiropractors. Clearly their “internal processes” are inadequate as they already allow such behavior to occur. They should not need a news organization to tell them what their own members are doing. What you will never hear is a chiropractic organization condemning specific members for pseudoscientific practice, or condemning the practice itself.
Instead they hide behind narrow regulatory statements. For example, the CBC reports that the Manitoba Chiropractic association has previously stated:
“In Manitoba, the administration of ‘vaccination and immunization’ currently falls outside the scope of chiropractic practice,” the communication said.
But:
The degree to which a chiropractor can or cannot discuss ‘vaccination and immunization’ or other health-care procedures that are outside the scope of practice with a patient is currently being reviewed by the board of directors.
They simply state what the current regulation says. They do not say “we support vaccines”, or “our members should not oppose vaccination”.
Manitoba Health provided this useful statement:
We offer a publicly funded vaccine program that follows national guidelines on immunization and we encourage Manitobans to get vaccinated. But vaccination is always a matter of informed consent between a practitioner and a patient, based on an informed evaluation of the benefits and risks. If any practitioner provides advice that is contrary to our position, we do not agree with it.
That is pretty faint criticism. Translation – we know it’s wrong, but we’re not going to do anything about it. They are in a difficult position, because they license and pay for quacks who spread medical misinformation. If they honestly criticized the situation it would call into question the current regulations.
This is the ultimate problem – when the state legitimizes quackery by licensing it, paying for it, and then standing by and allowing it to happen. When the outrageous nature of the quackery is pointed out to them, they make narrow legalistic statements or passive statements such as “We support vaccines.” Good for you – now what are you going to do about licensed health professionals that are harming the public health by scaring the public about vaccines or claiming to treat diseases they cannot treat in order to promote their own business?
The future
I don’t expect the situation to improve, but we do need to continue to raise public awareness of what is actually happening in the world of chiropractic and keep pressure on regulators to do the right thing.
There are two schools of thought within the science-based medicine community, and it is an interesting dilemma. There are those who think that the chiropractic profession needs to be brought within the sphere of science and evidence. They should purge themselves of pseudoscience, limit their practice to evidence-based interventions, and meaningful engage in research and with mainstream medical practice. If they did there is a role for them as health professionals with expertise in certain musculoskeletal conditions.
The other school of thought is that the chiropractic profession is hopelessly and inherently pseudoscientific. It cannot be reformed, and should only be opposed. It is fundamentally based on philosophy, rather than science, and culturally is anti-science and anti-mainstream medicine. The few exceptions are a tiny minority with no political power within the profession.
I could go either way in this debate, as both sides have legitimate points. What is clear is that currently we are stuck in the middle, with a chiropractic profession that has legal and cultural legitimacy it has not earned and does not deserve. Far from moving toward being more science-based, chiropractors (as a profession) continue to embrace pseudoscience, or at least do not oppose it within their own profession. Their efforts are aimed not at becoming more science-based and legitimate, but at expanding their scope of practice. Any lip-service they pay toward science comes off as insincere and serving only to deflect criticism while they continue their endless march toward expansion .

Canadian authorities warn chiropractors and naturopaths against making false COVID-19 claims
Regulators in British Columbia are investigating bogus COVID-19 preventatives and issuing public alerts warning chiropractors and naturopaths against advertising information that is not evidence-based. Other Canadian and U.S. authorities should follow suit to protect the public against pseudoscience.
Jann Bellamy on March 26, 2020
Link

From my last SBM post:
Chiropractors are falsely claiming that their spinal “adjustments” can protect people from coronavirus infection, as well as giving other dubious health advice on COVID-19. As they have with other bogus remedies, the media and government authorities should take note.
Thankfully, some have, at least in Canada.
Regulatory authorities in British Columbia are warning both chiropractors and naturopaths not to make false claims about the effectiveness of their therapies in the prevention and treatment of COVID-19. According to Canadian Broadcasting Corporation (CBC) news reports, the British Columbia College of Chiropractors and College of Naturopathic Physicians, which regulate these practitioners, are investigating several alleged violations of their policies against health claims that are not evidence-based.
This is in stark contrast to the U.S., where pseudoscience is legalized via state chiropractic and naturopathic practice acts. And, unlike the Canadian media, which has fairly regularly published exposés of charlatans (also here and here), the U.S. media has done nothing (that I can find) to warn the public about practitioners (as opposed to products) touting bogus treatments for COVID-19.
According to the CBC, several B.C. chiropractors are making just the sort of false claims American chiropractors are using in marketing their practices as a COVID-19 preventative. In a website post titled “boost your immune system with chiropractic care”, a B.C. chiropractic clinic suggested that spinal “adjustments”
have shown to improve immune function by correcting spinal misalignment or subluxations that cause neural dysfunction.
Other B.C. chiropractors posted on Facebook that, in the face of COVID-19, regular chiropractic “adjustments” should be part “standard hygiene practice”. Yet another B.C. chiropractor e-mailed patients promising “essential nutrition to protect yourself against coronavirus” with a supplement called “Immunoplex”, at $29.99 for 90 capsules.
However, quite unlike the U.S., the CBC reports that these clinics are facing investigation by College of Chiropractors of B.C. (CCBC). In a public notice, the CCBC said it
has become aware that some registrants are promoting treatment or supplements as a means to boost the immune system and may imply that this will prevent infection from the novel coronavirus (COVID-19). Any such claims made by registrants are inappropriate. When such claims are brought to the attention of the CCBC they will be forwarded immediately to the Inquiry Committee for investigation.
As stated in part 9.5 of the Professional Conduct Handbook, “The prevention and treatment of infectious disease is not within the scope of chiropractic practice.”
Patients with questions about infectious disease, such as COVID-19, should be advised to contact their medical doctor, nurse practitioner or local public health officials.
The warning is based on recent CCBC policy changes confronting “misleading and unsubstantiated claims” that “are contrary to acceptable evidence”. In 2017, the CCBC’s Professional Conduct Handbook was amended to prohibit chiropractors from advertising “health benefits of their services when there is not acceptable evidence that these benefits can be achieved”. In 2018, the CCBC approved an “Efficacy Claims” policy that, “due to the absence of acceptable evidence”, prohibited chiropractors from telling patients that chiropractic can be used to treat diseases or conditions like Alzheimer’s, cancer, diabetes, infections, infertility, or Tourette’s syndrome, or has any beneficial effect on childhood diseases or conditions like ADHD, autism, cerebral palsy, or other developmental or speech disorders. The CBCC made it clear that this list is not exhaustive and that “absent acceptable evidence” chiropractors are “not free to make claims about the effectiveness of chiropractic”.
The CCBC also warned chiropractors that
the prevention and treatment of infectious diseases is not within the scope of chiropractic practice [and] chiropractors must not provide any professional advice or counseling to patients in relation to vaccination issues. Patients with vaccination questions should be advised to contact their local public health officials.
At the time, all chiropractors were directed to review social media and other online materials and to remove offending information. If you don’t, the CCBC said in effect, we’ll do it for you.
Fortunately for American chiropractors, these rules don’t apply. Otherwise, as we’ve documented many times here on SBM, some of them would be out of business, or nearly so.
A naturopath in the regulatory crosshairs
According to the CBC, Allison Patton, a registered naturopath and Surrey, B.C. city councillor, is the subject of an investigation by the B.C. College of Naturopathic Physicians (a misleading name, considering naturopathic education and training), for advertising treatments, together costing more than $600,
including items like an “Immune Supportive Vitamin Boost” for $99 and a $325 “HiDose Ozone/UVBI IV” treatment, in which blood is drawn, injected with ozone and exposed to UV light before being transfused back into the body. Patton wrote that these treatments “could help strengthen our systems so we may stay as healthy as possible.”
Patton attempted to defend herself by telling the CBC that the Facebook post (since deleted) touting this pseudoscience was put up “in response to encouragement from her patients”, inadvertently affirming the disturbing conclusion that patients falsely believe naturopaths are capable of providing competent medical advice on infectious diseases.
The College previously suspended Patton from practice for three days and fined her $500 after she campaigned for public office representing herself as a “community physician” and referring to her “medical practice” without making it clear that she is a naturopath.
Despite its disciplinary action against Patton and its notice to the public (see below), it is worth noting that the College still tolerates plenty of pseudoscience. Quackery like applied kinesiology and iridology, for example, are specifically permitted. And when issuing a ban on further use of IV turmeric/curcumin, in response to a patient’s death after an IV injection of turmeric/curcumin performed by a California-licensed naturopath, current patients already receiving a course IV turmeric/curcumin treatments were excluded, in spite of the fact that there is no reliable evidence that these injections are safe and effective for any condition.
And lest you think Patton is an outlier, claims that patients can “boost their immune systems” (which you can’t do) with all sorts of nonsense (also here) like vitamin injections are common in naturopathy.
Patton’s “ozone therapy” is absolute quackery. Per FDA regulations, ozone is toxic, potentially dangerous, and has no known useful medical application. Yet, “ozone therapy” like that advertised by Patton is used by naturopaths for all sorts of maladies. According to ex-naturopath Britt Hermes,
Licensed naturopaths market ozone gas for just about anything. I have seen ozone advertised by naturopaths for chronic diseases, cancer treatment, Lyme disease, viral infections, chronic fatigue syndrome, autoimmune diseases, “detoxification,” and to “boost the immune system.”
Despite ozone’s uselessness as a treatment and potential dangers
licensed naturopaths in California were able to earn continuing education credits in a course that taught how to “confidently use ozone therapies in clinical practice with an understanding of the safety concerns.” The class was just two and a half hours and taught by a licensed naturopathic doctor who graduated from Bastyr University. The course is “approved by the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians and Oregon Board of Naturopathic Medicine.”
In addition to its investigation of Patton, the College issued a notice to the public saying that “any statements by naturopathic doctors about the prevention and/or treatment of COVID-19, beyond the information made available by the public health authorities, are inappropriate, potentially harmful, and likely to violate” its policies on false and misleading advertising. The notice added that any such statements “will be forwarded to the inquiry committee for investigation.”
Other Canadian provinces and the U.S. should follow British Columbia’s lead. For over 100 years, chiropractors and naturopaths have taken advantage of patients with their quack remedies, too often with the government’s blessing. Even a life-threatening global pandemic won’t quell their mendacity.

A Canadian Journalist Calls Out Pediatric Chiropractic, and a Chiropractor Responds
A recent National Post article calls chiropractic care of the infant and young child into question for some very good reasons, none of which were effectively rebutted by the Canadian Chiropractic Association President.
Clay JonesonMay 18, 2018
Link

Last week, Sharon Kirkey, a Canadian journalist writing for the National Post, penned an article that called chiropractic care of the newborn and young child into question. It’s not a deep dive into the issue, but she covers the most important concern well, namely that there is a lack of evidence of benefit and very real risk of both direct and indirect harm. She includes a few helpful comments from a pediatric allergy specialist, a biomedical engineer who investigates chiropractic claims, the American Academy of Pediatrics and the Canadian counterpart, our own Samuel Homola, and me.
Chiropractic propaganda abounds
In the article, Kirkey points out examples of propaganda cleverly designed to convince parents of the safety and benefit of chiropractic care for very young children. One such example that I discussed with Kirkey is the nearly ubiquitous description of pediatric spinal adjustments as involving the amount of force used to check the ripeness of a tomato. There are hundreds, if not thousands, of chiropractic videos and websites online that use this little factoid to reassure parents that there won’t be any scary, forceful adjustments. There are also, and you may want to sit down before clicking on them, many examples of more vigorous adjustments (2:30 mark), even more vigorous adjustments (also at 2:30 mark), and adjustments that cause the young patients to cry out in pain (0:45 mark).
Though these more forceful examples do exist, most chiropractors are smart enough to not scare away their customers. The more gentle techniques are by far the most common approach to adjusting young kids, often appearing comically imperceptible. Use of a spring-loaded thumping device is also common. I’ve played with these and they provide little more than a very light impulse that barely indents the skin. I’ve yet to find a reasonable explanation for how if such light pressure can correct a subluxation, why children aren’t constantly riddled with them at all times. Of course, that’s actually a fear sometimes promoted in chiropractic marketing so that parents return time and time again:
Children are constantly learning new things and frequently are in situations to subluxate their spines and nerve systems. Kids are also growing so quickly, so any barrier to a child growing and learning has a bigger impact on their future life and health.
Kirkey mentions an absurd and equally ubiquitous bit of propaganda employed by chiropractors who are looking for young patients to pad their patient panels. It can often be found on websites in the form of scary memes showing pictures of babies being pulled from their mother’s birth canal or abdomen accompanied by the claim that 80% (sometimes 90%) of newborns have subluxations or nerve dysfunction requiring chiropractic adjustment. These trauma-induced subluxations can, they claim, result in a variety of health problems ranging from fussiness and poor feeding to SIDS.
A 1966 paper by grossly negligent osteopath and craniosacral therapist Viola Frymann is most commonly cited to support this claim. Needless to say, it’s nonsense and doesn’t even involve subluxations. Rather it is about minor cranial abnormalities only able to be appreciated by someone trained in cranial therapy. In other words, they don’t exist. But it’s close enough for the newborn chiropractic crowd, who likely never actually looked at the paper.
Also mentioned in the article is the fact that many chiropractors will claim to be able to treat a wide variety of non-musculoskeletal complaints in young children. This includes colic, bedwetting, hyperactivity, and constipation to name a few. Kirkey points out that some even claim to treat learning disabilities and dyslexia. Equally absurd are the common claims that children undergoing chiropractic care are healthier on average than those who aren’t. Here is the study commonly cited. It’s terrible.
Kirkey doesn’t accuse all chiropractors of such chicanery. She is clear to point out that only some of them make claims regarding the care of babies and young children. Just how many isn’t clear, however. One of the quoted experts, biomedical engineer and consumer health advocate Ryan Armstrong, points out that there are evidence-based chiropractors out there and laments that regulatory bodies aren’t doing anything about all the nonsense.
A response from the Canadian Chiropractic Association
Not long after Kirkey’s article was published, a response appeared. It didn’t come from just any disgruntled chiropractor, however, but David Peeace, the president of the Canadian Chiropractic Association. The CCA claims that roughly 90% of the more than eight thousand Canadian chiropractors are members. The organization appears to focus only on musculoskeletal concerns, at least officially, but does refer to chiropractors as “primary healthcare providers.”
They also promote the existence of the chiropractic subluxation but boldly, at least in their official policy statement on the subject, admit that discussions regarding immunizations aren’t in their scope of practice. It could be worse. Of course there is no shortage of Canadian chiropractors advising against routine vaccination.
The response from Peeace is worse. It’s not long, but it’s packed with bad arguments and fails to refute the concerns raised in the original article. He begins by missing the point of a study referenced by Kirkey:
We were extremely disappointed in Sharon Kirkey’s depiction of our profession, including the misrepresentation of an outdated 2007 study. Neither causation nor incidence rates can be inferred from the study. While your writer implies a focus on chiropractic treatments in infants or young children, the study included non-chiropractic treatments in patients up to 18 years of age, with only one patient in the study under the age of five.
Here is the study in question, which Peeace was clearly unable to read and understand. I won’t call him a liar when being ignorant will suffice in this case.
Overall, the number of reported adverse events found in the authors’ literature review were very small compared to the large number of children undergoing spinal adjustments, but they are almost certainly underreported. What they did find were 14 cases of direct harm, most of which involved an injury that occurred immediately after the manipulation. Ten involved a chiropractor and two were not specified.
There were 20 cases of delayed medical care, all of which involved a chiropractor. Conditions that went untreated for a time, some of which resulting in death, included various cancers, meningitis, diabetes, and a musculoskeletal condition for which urgent surgery is the only appropriate treatment. Of the adverse events reported, several were in young children and the most serious tended to be in infants. Again, this study doesn’t prove that chiropractic results in large numbers of bad outcomes in children, but it certainly supports the concerns of pediatricians and family practitioners, particularly when taking into account the absence of any proven benefit in young children.
He continues:
Chiropractic treatment is appropriate and clinically indicated within the context of primary pediatric care in numerous musculoskeletal (MSK) conditions, including torticollis (tight, stiff neck muscles), muscular and biomechanical imbalances, and developmental physical delays involving MSK deficits.
And:
Chiropractors refer to physicians or the emergency room based on their diagnosis, just as physicians refer directly to chiropractic or physical therapy services. If an infant is treated by a chiropractor, the treatment is gentle, diagnostically guided and developmentally and age-appropriate.
There is no “context of primary pediatric care” in which any infant or young child should undergo chiropractic management. They are simply not trained in caring for this patient population and are unable to reliably recognize the many possible conditions requiring urgent medical evaluation, some of which can present with subtle findings and parental complaints. I have no confidence in their ability to make a diagnosis in these kids.
Finally:
Importantly, infants receiving diagnosis and treatment within the chiropractic scope of practice enjoy successful outcomes with conservative and comfortable care. This is supported by newer research demonstrating serious adverse events in infants and children receiving chiropractic therapy are rare.
They enjoy successful outcomes because the reasons that they are being brought to chiropractors are typically benign and self-limited in nature, such as colic. There is no legitimate chiropractic literature in pediatric care from which to base claims of treatment outcomes. There are mostly case reports and small unblinded case series. Many parents who are unhappy with their child’s care may simply not go back and it is unlikely that many chiropractors are keeping a strict record of all pediatric outcomes in their clinic for analysis.
Conclusion: Pediatricians are right to be alarmed by pediatric chiropractic
The National Post article has it right. Chiropractic care of babies and young children is not appropriate for any condition for a variety of reasons. First and foremost, there is no benefit and there is a real, although small, chance of serious direct adverse outcomes. There is a more concerning risk of delayed medical care of a serious condition. The rebuttal from the president of the Canadian Chiropractic Association doesn’t change this.

Anti-vaccination ideology and COVID misinformation in chiropractic continuing education courses: “Plandemic” edition
Chiropractors can still get state-approved continuing ed credit for anti-vaccination courses, with bonus COVID misinformation now added to the curriculum. Plandemic star Judy Mikovits joins the faculty.
Jann Bellamy o nOctober 7, 2021
Link

Disgraced scientist and COVID grifter Judy Mikovits has joined the list of marquee anti-vaccination ideologues on the faculty of state-approved continuing education (CE) courses for chiropractors. The Chiropractic Society of Wisconsin recently featured Mikovits at its VAXCON ’21 event along with anti-vaxx propagandist Del Bigtree and others from the fringe.
If VAXCON ’21 sounds like an odd name for a chiropractic educational event, then you don’t know chiropractors. Read on.
(Note: you have to switch views of the “Bundle Content” list to find the speakers’ names, as opposed to the titles of their presentations.)
Mikovits’s talk was titled “Plandemic and Beyond: Identifying Dangerous Complications of Masks and COVID Vaccines in Vulnerable Populations”, “Plandemic” being a reference to what David Gorski described as
a conspiracy-fest of a ‘documentary’, arguing that the current COVID-19 pandemic was somehow planned.
Mikovits has a starring role in Plandemic as a
sort of brave maverick scientist and truth teller that every good conspiracy theory needs, a woman with hidden knowledge who’s fighting dark powerful forces seeking to ‘silence her’.
Mikovits’s long history as a crank, anti-vaccine activist, conspiracy theorist, anti-Dr. Fauci grudge-holder, and grifter is ably set out in this and another post by Dr. Gorski. Just to give you an idea of how “out there” she is, she’s claimed that
the coronavirus is actually secretly caused by a bad strain of flu shot that was circulating between 2013 and 2015. Masks will help ‘activate’ the virus and reinfect a mask-wearer over and over . . .
Thus, she said,
Wearing a mask will kill more people than—this virus is not coughed through the air from healthy people, who are almost certainly immune, as they’ve almost certainly been infected over the last four or five years,
This is the sort of nonsense that got Plandemic pulled from YouTube and Facebook. On the other hand, it’s perfect for a continuing education course for chiropractors, who received CE credit for VAXCON ’21 under the auspices of Life University, a fully accredited chiropractic college.
Why perfect? Because, as we’ve documented here on SBM over the years, state-approved chiropractic continuing education courses and conferences regularly feature anti-vaccine ideology. Obviously, adding dangerous COVID nonsense to the curriculum is a logical (if you will) extension of their efforts.
As mentioned, Del Bigtree, who has added COVID-19 grift to his resume, was also a featured speaker, via video, with a talk called “Del Bigtree in the Dells”. “Dells” is a reference to VAXCON ’21’s Wisconsin location but otherwise there’s no information I could find on his presentation. As his only claim to fame is being an anti-vaccination propagandist and the producer of the widely discredited “documentary” VAXXED, directed by the disgraced and delisted physician Andrew Wakefield, flogger of the non-existent measles vaccine-autism “connection”, I think we can safely surmise his topic. Bigtree was a featured speaker, along with anti-vaccination royalty Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. and Barbara Loe Fisher, at a chiropractic “pediatrics” conference (which also awarded state-approved CE credit to attendees), as was Wakefield himself.
Other speakers at VAXCON ’21 include James Neuenschwander, MD (“Down the Rabbit Hole: Evaluating Vaccine Safety Science”), Alan Palmer, DC (“COVID- 19-Following the Science and Evidence”), and Vicky Pebsworth, PhD, RN (“COVID-19 Vaccines 101: Vaccine Development and Regulatory Landscape”). “Alternative vaccination schedule” maverick Dr. Bob Sears also spoke, but no CE credit was awarded for hearing whatever he had to say.
Neuenschwander was a part of the combo Trump supporters/QAnon/anti-vaxxer/conspiracy theorist fest held in Florida last year (also featuring Kennedy and Bigtree). In his post on the conference, Dr. Gorski explained that Neuenschwander is
a physician into alternative medicine who runs something called the Bio Energy Medical Center, who was originally going to be on Shannon Kroner’s antivaccine panel but ended up not being on it. Unsurprisingly, all the docs on this speakers’ bill are quacks; indeed Dr. Neuenschwander offers CEASE therapy for autism, a therapy based on homeopathy, and IV vitamin C and chelation therapy.
Palmer is a chiropractor who has done “post graduate” work in “Detoxification and metabolic toxicity”, “Food-related allergy disorders in children”, “Digestive Health and Intestinal disorders”, “intestinal dysbiosis”, “Adrenal and Thyroid Disorders”, and other areas of medicine (both real and imagined) where a chiropractor has no business meddling. His free book 1200 Studies – Truth Will Prevail is, according to Kennedy’s anti-vaccination empire, the Children’s Health Defense Fund, “the most comprehensive scientific expose of vaccines to date”, a telling indication of just how solid the science behind Kennedy’s positions is.
Pebsworth is a volunteer for, and board member of, the vaccine misinformation group NVIC and, inexplicably, on several government vaccine committees.
All told, 12 hours of CE credit for a whole bunch of anti-vaccination rhetoric and COVID misinformation, and all for only $399 (just $299 for Chiropractic Society of Wisconsin members).
More sources of anti-vaccination ed, including Tedd Koren
Chiropractor Tedd Koren is a prolific publisher of chiropractic promotional materials (some of which have run afoul of government regulatory authorities), including the 2020 pamphlet Vaccination: 18 Reasons to Just Say No. As summarized by Quackwatch’s Dr. Stephen Barrett,
Among other things, the flier states that vaccines “don’t work,” and increase the likelihood of developing attention deficit hyperactivity disorder; allergies; anaphylaxis; arthralgia; arthritis; Asperger’s syndrome; asthma; autism; bowel disease; cancer; chronic fatigue; convulsions; Crohns disease; deafness; diabetes; dizziness; dyslexia; eczema; encephalitis; Guillain-Barre syndrome; headache; hearing and vision problems; immune system disorders; learning disorders; leukemia; Lou Gehrig’s disease (ALS); lupus; Guillain-Barre syndrome; meningitis; multiple sclerosis; neurological disorders; ocular palsies; optic neuritis; otitis media; pervasive developmental disorder (PDD); skin disorders; thrombocytopenia; and ulcerative colitis. I believe it is the most irresponsible chiropractic flier ever published.
Considering Dr. Barrett’s extensive expertise in chiropractic pseudoscience, developed over many years of detailed study and investigation, that is indeed saying something.
Koren teaches a 12-part “Neuroimmunology and Vaccines” course eligible for chiropractic continuing education credit via the Federation of Chiropractic Licensing Board’s PACE CE course program. (For example, here.) The courses were not easy to locate on PACE and it is not always possible to find them on the website to which I was referred by PACE or determine which states award credit for them. However, I was able to confirm that Florida (where I live) gives chiropractors CE credit for Koren’s “Vaccines” series via the Florida Board of Chiropractic Medicine’s CE Broker website. Here’s a sampling from the syllabi. (After a few “sics” I gave up and left them off entirely.)
“Neuroimmunology and Vaccines” Part 2
To study the neuro-immune system function as it relates to empirical and mechanistic perspectives in health and disease. This module provide an overview of vaccines Are vaccinated children healthier than nonvaccinated children? Allergies and asthma How would you test vaccines? How are they really tested by drug companies? Junk science and selection bias Background incidence The Marie Griffin study, James Cherry, MD
(They all begin with “To study the neuro-immune system function as it relates to empirical and mechanistic perspectives . . . overview of vaccines” so I’ll leave that part off on the rest.)
Part 3
Does research show vaccines are safe? Are vaccines tested for carcinogenicity? The story of Our Alexander The polio vaccine/cancer connection SV40 Do the benefits of vaccination outweigh the risks? A generation of neurologically damaged children?
Part 7
Definition of autism An exploding epidemic Do vaccines cause autism?
Part 8
Mental retardation Epilepsy and seizure disorders Infantile spasms Cerebral palsy Paralyses
Part 10
The Gardasil vaccine is not a vaccine for protection against cervical cancer. It is a vaccine intended to prevent 4 types of HPV Human Papilloma Virus. According to the Gardasil package insert, there are more than 100 types of HPV Nearly all adults carry HPV in their bodies and in almost all instances HPV is harmless, causes no symptoms and is naturally eliminated from the body.
Part 12
Epidemiological evidence reveals that not only was the smallpox vaccine useless at protecting people from developing smallpox, but that: it caused deadly smallpox epidemics. is linked to tuberculosis, heart disease, syphilis and cancer. is possibly linked to other chronic illnesses.
And so on.
Another fully accredited chiropractic school, the Texas Chiropractic College, offers a course called “Immunization, Inoculation or Vaccination: Navigating the Consequences with Clinical Nutrition”, which suggests that chiropractors practicing the ersatz chiropractic version of nutrition, can
help children and adults who have sustained documented immunological, gastrointestinal and neurological disruptions from simultaneous toxic exposures from medications, environmental influences, vaccinations, etc.
This, of course, takes well-worn pages from the anti-vaccination playbook notion that vaccines are “toxic” as well as from the alternative medicine playbook notion that “nutrition” is a cure-all.
A CE course from ChiroLearn, a creation of the Florida Chiropractic Association (FCA), called “Public Perception of Chiropractic: What the Research Shows”, features none other than the COVID-19 misinformation Super-spreader and Disinformation Dozen member #1 Dr. Joe Mercola, along with chiropractor Patrick Gentempo, the force behind the anti-vaccination “documentary” Vaccines Revealed. What are they doing there? I don’t know, but if you type in “vaccine” on ChiroLearn’s search feature you get:
Unfortunately, that’s all we can find out. Given the fact that these courses are state-approved and are offered pursuant to the fiction that state licensing protects the public’s health, one would hope for more transparency.
The FCA’s ChiroLearn also hosts the laughably insufficient curriculum for becoming a “chiropractic internist“, which offers the interestingly-titled courses (at $375 per course for 12 hours of on-line instruction):
A Natural Medicine Approach to Evaluation of Infectious Disease
and
Autism, ADHD, Vaccination: Prevention and Treatment of Childhood Illness
One course I previously covered is still available via ChiroCredit, a CE provider approved by the Federation of Chiropractic Licensing Boards: “Varying Viewpoints on Vaccinations with Alternative Schedule and Homeopathic Remedies”. It is chock full of anti-vaccination tropes and promotes the false notion that there are effective alternatives to vaccination such as “alternative/healthier lifestyle approaches” and, even more dangerously, homeopathic nosodes. A ChiroCredit course that discussed vaccines and autism has been removed, but I’m wondering if its content might have reappeared in another course by the same instructor which “summarize[s] the effects of vaccination on infants immune systems”. Somehow I don’t think immunity from disease is one of the “effects” discussed.
How is it that, even with increased media coverage of chiropractors’ anti-vaccination ideology (also here) these courses continue to get the imprimatur of state approval? Because no one is looking.
Decades ago, the state legislatures, in passing chiropractic practice acts and licensing chiropractors as health care providers, turned their regulation over to chiropractic boards run by chiropractors. No one has bothered to check back in and see just what these boards are up to and certainly not to find out whether what passes for continuing education is full of harmful nonsense, which it obviously is. Even as a pandemic rages on, chiropractors are sitting at their computers learning how to put their patients’ health in danger, all so they can keep their licenses current.
Malaria kills about half a million people a year; half of those are children. Just yesterday, the World Health Organization endorsed an anti-malaria vaccine, the “best new development in the fight against the disease in decades”. Sadly, I would not be surprised if chiropractors are already busy creating CE course content to discourage malaria vaccination.

NCCAM manipulates spinal manipulation
Jann Bellamy on July 26, 2012
Link
“Complementary and alternative medicine,” as pediatrician and fellow blogger John Snyder aptly stated in a recent journal article on CAM and children,
is a term used to describe a disparate, poorly defined set of practices and treatment modalities presumed to be distinct from so-called ‘conventional medicine’.
As we have discussed here at Science-Based Medicine, this amorphous concept facilitates a convenient fluidity in delineating the parameters of CAM. Without a clear definition, CAM (and integrative medicine) proponents are able to rebrand plausible and evidence-based practices such as diet, exercise and relaxation as CAM, a tactic we at SBM call “bait and switch.” This results in inflation in the figures of CAM use (important because CAM is all about popularity) and claims that CAM “works.”
Manipulating a term
Yet another example of CAM’s claiming “conventional” medicine as its own appeared in the form of NCCAM’s most recent Clinical Digest, which discusses CAM treatments for pain and mischaracterizes spinal manipulation as CAM.
(FYI, this edition of Clinical Digest also promotes acupuncture for pain, even though it doesn’t work, and co-opts exercise (Tai Chi) and relaxation as CAM, even when they aren’t.)
NCCAM’s categorization of spinal manipulation as CAM would surely come as a surprise to the orthopedic surgeons who prescribe it, the physical therapists who carry out those orders, and the M.D.s and D.O.s who themselves perform it. Spinal manipulation is a physical therapy employing a high velocity, low thrust technique whereby a joint (such as a spinal vertebra) is moved beyond its normal physiological range of motion. The primary purpose of the therapy is to create mobility in an otherwise tightened joint. While its mechanism of action is not fully understood, it is biologically plausible and has some evidence of effectiveness for certain types of back and neck pain. It is “conventional” medicine.
A likely source of NCCAM’s confusion is chiropractors’ use of the term “spinal manipulation.” Some chiropractors employ manipulation in the same way physical therapists, MDs and DOs do – as a physical therapy for patients with back or neck pain who have been conventionally diagnosed and found to be appropriate candidates for this therapy. However, chiropractors also use the term “spinal manipulation” as a synonym for “spinal adjustment” which, in their unique vocabulary, is a treatment for the ubiquitous and nonexistent subluxation. Only chiropractors use the term in this manner because only chiropractors believe the chiropractic version of the subluxation exists. There is an excellent discussion of this distinction by Sam Homola, himself a chiropractor, on SBM and NCCAM’s staff would do well to review it.
(By way of background, to a physician, nurse, physical therapist and other science-based health care providers, a subluxation is a partial dislocation, as of a joint. Chiropractors have their own vocabulary which includes terms defined differently than, or not used in, the common lexicon of other health care providers.)
The chiropractic subluxation has been addressed a number of times here at SBM, but briefly the subluxation is an ill-defined, unproven spinal pathology of no known clinical significance. It was invented out of whole cloth in 1895 by a self-styled “magnetic healer” who had no medical education or training. Despite efforts by chiropractors to backfill a scientific explanation into this preconceived notion, there is no plausible scientific evidence that the chiropractic subluxation exists.
Not surprisingly, chiropractors cannot agree on a definition for their subluxation, how to diagnose one, or its clinical significance. They can’t even agree on a name for it – it’s variously called the vertebral subluxation complex, manipulable lesion, spinal lesion, joint dysfunction, and so on. Nor can they agree on its role in chiropractic – large and unremitting intramural battles have been fought over the subject. Nevertheless, chiropractors daily tell patients that they are suffering from subluxations which must be corrected at the risk of ill health. Again, one means of correction is the chiropractic “adjustment,” which chiropractors also refer to as “manipulation.”
If chiropractors are this confused, then one can well understand how the writers and editors of NCCAM’s website could be confused, but it’s time to set the record straight. The correction of subluxations via a spinal adjustment/manipulation is not the same as the use of spinal manipulation by physical therapists and other health care providers as a means of alleviating back or neck pain. While it is true that a chiropractor might “find” a subluxation and claim it is the cause of a patient’s pain, this is not a legitimate diagnostic method nor is its correction via an adjustment/manipulation a legitimate therapy for the patient’s pain.
NCCAM does its readers a real disservice in failing to explain this critical difference. As it stands, readers may be left with the incorrect assumption that a chiropractor’s use of adjustments/manipulations to correct subluxations is a useful therapy for neck or back pain. This is especially important because some chiropractors have intentionally tried to exploit the efficacy of manipulation for back pain as proof that chiropractic “works.” They have also falsely claimed that they are more proficient at, and safer in performing, spinal manipulation than other practitioners, to the point of trying to use the political process to prohibit physical therapists from employing manipulation.
But wait, it gets worse
To confound the problem, NCCAM’s discussion of manipulation as a pain therapy refers readers to its information on chiropractic, the very practitioners who may subject them to the ineffectual adjustment/manipulation for pain. And while NCCAM’s confusion over conventional manipulation versus chiropractic manipulation for subluxations might be understandable, any sympathy should end at this reference. As David Gorski pointed out, NCCAM discusses CAM practices in a “weaselly, wishy-washy way,” and chiropractic is no exception:
Chiropractic is a health care profession that focuses on the relationship between the body’s structure—mainly the spine—and its functioning. Although practitioners may use a variety of treatment approaches, they primarily perform adjustments (manipulations) to the spine or other parts of the body with the goal of correcting alignment problems, alleviating pain, improving function, and supporting the body’s natural ability to heal itself.
For the uninitiated, let’s decode these weaselly words. “Focuses on the relationship between the body’s structure – mainly the spine – and it’s functioning” is a reference to chiropractic belief that there is a spinal pathology (the subluxation) they can detect and that it has some effect on bodily function. The putative effect of this putative pathology is sometimes described simply as a “misalignment” blocking “nerve flow” and at other times more elaborately (and equally nonsensically) as “a complex of functional and/or structural and/or pathological articular changes that compromise neural integrity and may influence organ system function and general health . . . .” The reference to “adjustments (manipulations)” is an unintentional acknowledgement of my point that chiropractors use the terms interchangeably and describes their unproven therapy for their unproven condition, which “correct[s] alignment problems, i.e., subluxations. “Supporting the body’s natural ability to heal itself” is a reference to the chiropractic belief in vitalism, their version of which is “Innate Intelligence.”
The quoted description – indeed the whole of NCCAM’s page on chiropractic – doesn’t mention by name what even chiropractors themselves describe as its core concept: the subluxation. A consumer reading this page would have absolutely no clue that going to a chiropractor might subject him to a phony diagnosis of “subluxations” and phony treatments to “correct” them. There is also a mention that chiropractors use x-rays as a diagnostic tool, without telling the reader that a chiropractor may well use x-rays to detect the nonexistent subluxation.
Criticism of this sort of thing was raised by Steve Novella, David Gorski and Kimball Atwood at their visit with NCCAM’s director over two years ago. As Dr. Novella said then, “the pattern of information is consistent – NCCAM staff talk about a strict adherence to evidence-based medicine and science being neutral, but interspersed with this is an uncritical presentation of ancient superstition as if it were science . . .” There he was discussing acupuncture. The only difference here is that NCCAM is uncritically presenting a superstition of more recent origin, in the form of belief in “Innate Intelligence” and resulting pseudoscientific diagnostic methods and treatments.
NCCAM also advises readers to
Tell the chiropractor about any medications (prescription or over-the-counter) you take. If the chiropractor suggests a dietary supplement, ask about potential interactions with your medications or other supplements.
“If the chiropractor suggests a dietary supplement” the patient would be well advised to ask exactly why it is being prescribed, given the paucity of evidence for the safety or benefit of dietary supplements, and to be especially suspicious if the chiropractor sells the supplement, an inherent conflict of interest. And the patient should not rely on a chiropractor to know about “potential interactions with . . . medications or other supplements.” The patient should ask someone with sufficient training in pharmacology for that advice, such as a pharmacist or M.D.
As well, NCCAM advises,
Mention any medical conditions you have, and ask whether the chiropractor has specialized training or experience in the condition for which you are seeking care.
NCCAM is apparently unaware of the dubious system of chiropractic “specialization” which results in “specialties” like chiropractic neurology, chiropractic pediatrics, and chiropractic family practice. At least I hope the writer was unaware and would not knowingly recommend these “specialists.”
Perhaps the most egregious failure, however, is the failure to warn consumers about the risk of stroke following cervical manipulation. Here is what NCCAM says:
A 2009 study that drew on 9 years of hospitalization records for the population of Ontario, Canada analyzed 818 cases of vertebrobasilar artery (VBA) stroke (involving the arteries that supply blood to the back of the brain). The study found an association between visits to a health care practitioner and subsequent VBA stroke, but there was no evidence that visiting a chiropractor put people at greater risk than visiting a primary care physician. The researchers attributed the association between health care visits and VBA stroke to the likelihood that people with VBA dissection (torn arteries) seek care for related headache and neck pain before their stroke.
Yes, it’s the infamous Cassidy study, a subject we’ve addressed before at SBM. Now, I suppose it is correct that the study showed that “visiting a chiropractor” did not put people at greater risk than “visiting a primary care physician” if by “visiting” you mean walking in the door and having a seat in the waiting room. The study did not look at what treatment (if any) the patients received so it cannot legitimately claim to answer the question whether actually being treated by a chiropractor puts one at greater risk than being treated by a primary care physician. And it certainly does not answer the question whether cervical manipulation puts one at risk of stroke. As Mark Crislip pointed out in his analysis of the study, that last sentence is a hypothesis created by the authors of the study, it is not a statement supported by the study’s data.
Of course, the layperson might well be left with the impression, completely false, that cervical manipulation does not put one at risk of stroke. In fact, vertebral artery dissection and stroke following chiropractic cervical manipulation continues to be reported in the medical literature and no one besides chiropractors seems to think the Cassidy study settled the question. As a recent article in the Journal of Neurosurgery plainly states
Chiropractic manipulation of the cervical spine can injure the vessels of the head and neck and produce stroke and other debilitating symptoms.
Why is this not part of the “evidence-based information” NCCAM says it is committed to?
In sum, where’s the science?
NCCAM’s supposed dedication to “rigorous science” is not in evidence in its advice to consumers about chiropractic and spinal manipulation. NCCAM’s presentation fails to live up to its promise to “maintain a strong commitment to providing objective and authoritative evidence-based information to the public and health care professionals.”

   Kaiser Rejects Neck Manipulation
Harriet Hall
Link
Despite quackademia, anti-vaccine propaganda, and other discouraging trends, the news is not all bad. A major HMO has taken a decisive action in support of science-based medicine. 
Kaiser Permanente Mid Atlantic States and Mid-Atlantic Permanente Group recently announced the elimination of neck manipulation from their chiropractic coverage. The revised policy states,
Given the paucity of data related to beneficial effects of chiropractic manipulation of the cervical spine and the real potential for catastrophic adverse events, it was decided to exclude chiropractic manipulation of the cervical spine from coverage. 
Their decision was applauded by some but was predictably attacked by chiropractors.
The American Chiropractic Association (ACA) promptly responded with a letter to Kaiser outlining “the extensive data that supports cervical spinal manipulation as both beneficial and safe.” I have not yet been able to find a copy of that letter online. I don’t doubt that they presented data to support their beliefs. I do doubt that they presented a balanced view of the entire body of published evidence, the body of evidence that Kaiser relied on in making its decision. When the BCA (British Chiropractic Association) tried to defend itself against Simon Singh’s criticism, it provided a list of allegedly supporting studies but these were readily demolished in the blogosphere. Several previous posts on SBM including this one by a chiropractor have examined the evidence for neck manipulation and concurred with Kaiser that there is a “paucity of data related to beneficial effects of chiropractic manipulation of the cervical spine” and a “real potential for catastrophic adverse events.” That’s what the science says. It is encouraging that Kaiser followed the science.
The ACA also released the following statement, signed by ACA President, Dr. Rick McMichael :
The American Chiropractic Association is aware that Kaiser Permanente Mid Atlantic States and Mid-Atlantic Permanente Medical Group have revised their Chiropractic Manipulation Medical Coverage Policy to exclude cervical Chiropractic Manipulative Treatment (CMT) from coverage. This restriction, if allowed to stand, will be harmful to chiropractic patients and doctors. We have contacted Kaiser to express our grave concern over this change, and we await its reply. ACA will expend every effort to encourage Kaiser to reverse this new restriction, and we will keep our members and the profession informed along the way. 
Chiropractors are not doing well. 20-25% of chiropractors leave the field within 10 years of graduation. Their average income has dropped from $97,892 annually in 1992-1993 to only $48,900 in 2002-2003.
The new Kaiser policy threatens their livelihood, especially the livelihood of the many practitioners who use neck manipulation on virtually all patients regardless of the presenting complaints. So of course they will protest and will try everything possible to convince Kaiser to change its mind. Such lobbying has been effective in previous cases.
In 2007, United Healthcare decided to stop reimbursing chiropractic care for children and for headaches. A joint letter from various chiropractic organizations chastised them:
Attached is an analysis which demonstrates that the above policy is not only flawed but more importantly, poses a threat to the health of children, adolescents and those individuals suffering with headache pain who may be insured or otherwise covered under United Healthcare programs and policies. We view your recent policy determination to be a material denial of essential benefits and coverage paid for by employers and other insureds. The broad stroke elimination of these important benefits is, in our view, not only unconscionable but is an abrogation of the promises made to cover chiropractic services to employees, individuals and their dependants.
The chiropractors contended that they are “uniquely qualified to address all types of childhood and adolescent ailments [not true].” They provided their evidence that chiropractic treatment was effective for headache [not convincing]. They said a number of other things that those of us on SBM would disagree with. United Healthcare backed down and rescinded the policy.
Kaiser made a good, science-based decision that will protect patients and also save money. They are to be commended. I hope they will stick to their guns and withstand the pressure that will be exerted against them by non-science-based chiropractors and health consumers. I hope other insurance and health care organizations will follow suit. In another action earlier this year, Saskatchewan deleted chiropractic subsidies from its health budget to save $10 million. 
Note: this policy change does not restrict patients’ rights to choose any treatment they want. It does not prevent chiropractors from doing neck manipulation; it only means that patients will have to pay for it out of pocket. Their approach seems entirely reasonable for a large organization that is trying to reduce costs for everyone by refusing to pay for treatments of questionable efficacy and safety.

   Misleading Ads for Back Pain Treatment
Harriet Hall
Link
There was a full-page ad in my local paper today for Back in Action Spine and Health Centers, targeted at sufferers from almost any kind of chronic back pain. It started with “Are You Ready to Throw in the Towel and Just Live with Hurting So Bad?” It went on to make a number of claims:
Doctors can fix the problem.
Breakthrough medical technologies.
Treatments are FDA cleared.
Treatments are scientifically proven.
No side effects.
Best kept secrets for healing “bad backs.”
Corrects scoliosis.
Corrects compressed discs.
Several university studies at Johns Hopkins, Stanford and Duke have confirmed that these treatments work.
Medical researchers have reported these methods up to 89% effective.
Treatments work for back and neck pain, sciatica/numbness, herniated and/or bulging discs, degenerative disc disease (arthritis), spinal stenosis, facet syndromes, spondylolisthesis.
Their questionnaire can determine who will benefit – if you fit even one criterion like “does your back feel out of alignment?” or “do you have arthritis?” you should call right away.
The ad offers a “Free Qualifying Exam” but you “Must Not Wait” because appointments are limited and they can only honor this free offer for 3 weeks. To encourage you to call, they sweeten the pot with a FREE $49 gift bag.
Are you suspicious yet? You should be.
All the claims listed above are false. Ads like this are promoting a machine that promises nonsurgical spinal decompression (the DRX 9000 or a related device). These machines are not a breakthrough of any kind; they’re just a fancy technological gimmick for providing old-fashioned traction. The same traction that has been rejected by mainstream medicine because it does nothing to change the outcome and seldom even does anything to temporarily relieve symptoms. The FDA approval is a “grandfathered” 510(k) clearance that only says the new device is equivalent to older traction devices so it doesn’t require separate approval. The “doctors” are almost always chiropractors, and not identifying themselves as chiropractors is a direct violation of their own published ethics guidelines. Claims for effectiveness are based on junk science: case reports and uncontrolled, poor quality pilot studies usually funded by the manufacturer. There is NO acceptable evidence that these machines are effective, and a recent review article in the chiropractors’ own literature says as much. These treatments DO have side effects; they sometimes aggravate symptoms and can harm patients. They cannot “correct” ruptured discs and the FTC does not allow them to claim that they can.
Insurance and Medicare do not cover these treatments, and they usually end up costing the patient several thousand dollars out of pocket. They may provide temporary relief for a minority of patients, but the same results could be obtained far more cheaply by a physical therapist whose treatments are covered by insurance.
I’ve written about these machines before. An article I wrote in Skeptical Inquirer is available online at http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m2843/is_5_31/ai_n27361167 It covers more details than I can include here. Some of what I found would be laugh-out-loud funny except that people are being misled, relieved of their money, and even physically harmed (there is at least one report that the machine caused a ruptured disc). For those who may not want to read that whole article, here’s an excerpt highlighting their inept advertising techniques and the abysmal quality of their evidence:
The report did not even give the correct reference for this essential study. It listed one of the two authors with all his titles (MD, JD, MBA, FICS, FRCS), misprinted one of his titles (“FICA” instead of FICS), omitted the name of the second author, gave the name of the journal incorrectly, misquoted the title of the article, and misprinted spinal as spinla. Another reference consisted of nothing but the name of a journal. The report was full of spelling errors, used loose for lose and included lexical gems like “it depends on your individually case.” A mistake or two in an individual doctor’s report would be excusable, but this report was prepared by a company with a product to sell. If carelessness about English and the facts extends to carelessness in manufacturing its machines, it may have a few loose screws–and not just in the machines.
Despite the faulty citation, I was able to find the study that the 86-percent claim was based on. It was easy to see why it wasn’t published in a reputable, peer-reviewed medical journal–it wouldn’t have passed review. There are so many things wrong with it that it can more rightly serve as an example of a bad study. A good study randomizes patients into treatment and control groups. This study had no control group, and its only randomization was that 229 subjects were “randomly” chosen from a pool of 500 with disk disease. The point of this escapes me. Part of the exam was a straight-leg-raising test: “… radiating pain into the lower back and leg was categorized when raising the leg over 30 degrees or less is considered positive, but if pain remained isolated in the lower back, it was considered negative.” [no, this doesn’t make sense, either grammatically or medically]…
Next I read that “Each session consisted of a 45-minute treatment on the equipment followed by 15 minutes of ice and interferential frequency therapy to consolidate the lumbar paravertebral muscles.” Sorry, but I don’t have any idea what it means to “consolidate” a muscle, and the “interferential frequency therapy” seems to be a kind of TENS (Transcutaneous Electrical Nerve Stimulation). TENS was shown to have zero effectiveness in another study (Sherry et al. 2001) cited by decompression advocates, so I fail to see why they used it here. The patients also were instructed to wear lumbar support belts, restrict activity, and take nonsteroidal drugs. You don’t suppose that any of those factors could have helped relieve their pain, do you? And how many of these patients might have had resolution of their symptoms without any treatment? The natural history of disk disease is that “The herniated portion of the disk visible on serial MRI studies tends to heal and regress with time. Partial or complete resolution of the herniated portion of the disk over 6 months may occur in as many as two thirds of patients” (Elder and Smucker 2006). And I don’t see how it can be claimed that this study supports using the DRX 9000, because nowhere in the study does it say what machine was used. I e-mailed the company and asked if they could verify that this was its machine. There was no reply.
I tried to track down the primary author of the study, Thomas Gionis. He has no studies on back pain listed in PubMed. He apparently has left medicine for law and was recently removed from his position as editor of a law review because he spent thirty months in jail on a felony assault conviction for hiring someone to beat up his ex-wife, the daughter of John Wayne, because of a custody dispute (“Law editor” 2001). In addition, he had lost his medical license and was trying to get it reinstated (Associated Press 2001). Somehow he does not inspire confidence as a medical authority.
On June 2, 2008, The Medical Letter evaluated spinal decompression machines, concluding:
There is no acceptable evidence that non-surgical spinal decompression machines can correct degenerated or herniated discs or that they relieve pain in patients with these conditions. There is also no convincing evidence that the physiological responses of lumbar tissue to power traction equipment are superior to those with standard mechanical traction.
After I wrote the Skeptical Inquirer article, I received e-mails from disappointed patients, from neurosurgeons and even from chiropractors, thanking me for exposing this scam. One of the chiropractors came right out and called the spinal decompression claims “lies” and said:
I can tell you exactly why they became such instant hits with the chiropractic community. Money. Within 6 months of the first time I had heard of a DRX 9000 I started seeing testimonials by chiropractors, in publications for chiropractors, touting the fact that they are clearing an additional $50,000 per month with this. Who doesn’t like the thought of an extra $600,000 income each year?
The manufacturers of the DRX 9000 are under siege: the FDA raided their headquarters and they’ve been sued and accused of false advertising, of injuring patients, and of instructing DRX 9000 clinic owners how to defraud insurance companies by submitting false billing codes. Perhaps this new, more veiled ad campaign is an attempt at damage control. For one thing, they’ve removed the claim that the machine is a “space age discovery” resulting from NASA research on astronauts (that was a total fabrication).
It is ironic that these machines are being used by chiropractors. Chiropractors, the self-proclaimed back experts, the ones who claim their adjustments are the answer to everything that ails you or at least to most musculoskeletal problems. Using these machines amounts to a confession that chiropractic adjustments are not so effective after all.

Do You Believe in Magic? Oregon Does. Chiropractic and Acupuncture for Pain.
Mark Crislip on August 7, 2015
Link


Do You Believe in Magic?
Do you believe in magic for a back pains fix
How the needles can free her, where ever it pricks
And it’s magic, if the chi is groovy
It makes you feel happy like an old-time movie
I’ll tell you about the magic, and it’ll free your soul
But it’s like trying to tell a CAM ’bout randomized control
If you believe in magic don’t bother to choose
Although subluxation is simply a ruse
Just go and get adjusted on the table
It won’t wipe off the pain no matter how hard you try
Your wallet is empty and you can’t seem to find
How you got there, so just blow your mind
If you believe in magic, come along with me
We’ll CAM until morning paid for by the OHP
And maybe, if the CAM is right
I’ll meet you tomorrow, sort of late at night
And we’ll go dancing, baby, then you’ll see
How the magic’s in the CAM and the CAM’s in me
Yeah, do you believe in magic
Yeah, believe in the magic of a back pains fix
Believe in the magic of CAM
Believe in the magic that can set you free
Oh, talking ’bout magic
Do you believe like I believe… Do you believe in magic
Do you believe like I believe… Do you believe, believer
Do you believe like I believe… Do you believe in magic
The Lovin’ Spoonful. Sort-of.
Maybe not my best lyrics.
More Oregon magic
It continues.
Oregon has a problem with prescription pain pills. Oregon leads the nation in the abuse of such drugs, federal statistics show, with Oregon’s rate of prescription drug abuse 39 percent higher than the national average. Go us.
Why that is, I do not know. As an Infectious Disease doctor I prescribe a narcotic about once a year. There are real problems with the treatment of chronic pain and while I am aware of the issues and the changes over the last 25 years, it does not impact my practice, so my knowledge of the issues is basic.
I am also well aware of the Oregon Health Plan (OHP). The OHP was intended to make health care more available to the working poor, while rationing benefits. They were fairly transparent that resources were fixed and not everything would be covered.
Given limited resources, part of the plan has always included a prioritization of treatments and diagnostics, paying for care that give the most bang for the buck. Not a perfect way to ration care and as is always the case, no good deed goes unpunished.
Another effect of limiting care, according to the Bend Bulletin, may be that:
OHP members who suffer back pain have been left with no choice but to take drugs, and the policy could be contributing to Oregon’s high rate of narcotic abuse
since other interventions to treat back pain are not paid for. Interventions like acupuncture and chiropractic.
New guidelines were recently updated by the Health Evidence Review Board (HERB) and as a result:
The new guidelines open the door to acupuncture, chiropractic, cognitive behavioral therapy, osteopathic manipulation and physical and occupational therapy.
To be picky, the guidelines do not say chiropractic, but “spinal manipulation,” although the codes to be used are those for chiropractic manipulation. And as is so often the case, the title of an organization often does not describe what they actually do. As in the ‘Health Evidence Review’ part. As the local ID expert in my hospital, or for this blog, when I review the evidence, I try to read as much as is possible, not only relying on reviews, but as much of the primary literature as I can. I found that the primary literature is misrepresented by not only reviews, but the authors of the primary literature. This is perhaps particularly true in the SCAM world, as the careful evaluation of a paper will determine.
HERB reviews reviews
As best I can tell, the HERB relied on two reviews, “Diagnosis and Treatment of Low Back Pain: A Joint Clinical Practice Guideline” from the American College of Physicians and the American Pain Society from 2007 and “Nonpharmacologic Therapies for Acute and Chronic Low Back Pain: A Review of the Evidence for an American Pain Society/American College of Physicians Clinical Practice Guideline” from 2007.
That is it. Two reviews, from 2007, from the same journal (from the same issue!). That hardly seems a sufficient basis upon which to make decisions.
The first review notes:
For chronic low back pain, moderately effective nonpharmacologic therapies include acupuncture (114–115)…spinal manipulation (108)
Reference 114 concludes:
For chronic low back pain, acupuncture is more effective for pain relief and functional improvement than no treatment or sham treatment immediately after treatment and in the short-term only. Acupuncture is not more effective than other conventional and “alternative” treatments. The data suggest that acupuncture and dry-needling may be useful adjuncts to other therapies for chronic low back pain. Because most of the studies were of lower methodologic quality, there is a clear need for higher quality trials in this area.
And 115:
The quantity and quality of the included trials varied.
CONCLUSIONS: Acupuncture effectively relieves chronic low back pain. No evidence suggests that acupuncture is more effective than other active therapies.
To add to the mix, the Cochrane review notes:
For chronic low-back pain, acupuncture is more effective for pain relief and functional improvement than no treatment or sham treatment immediately after treatment and in the short-term only. Acupuncture is not more effective than other conventional and “alternative” treatments. The data suggest that acupuncture and dry-needling may be useful adjuncts to other therapies for chronic low-back pain. Because most of the studies were of lower methodological quality, there certainly is a further need for higher quality trials in this area.
Virtually every acupuncture meta-analysis, from the first one in 1980, has some variation of
Various potential sources of bias, including problems with blindness, precluded a conclusive finding although most results apparently favoured acupuncture.
The second reference used by HERB? For acupuncture they state:
For chronic low back pain, both systematic reviews found acupuncture moderately more effective than no treatment or sham treatments for short-term (<6 weeks’ [16] or <3 months’ [17–18] duration) pain relief. Acupuncture was also associated with moderate short-term improvements in functional status compared with no treatment (standardized mean differences, 0.62 [CI, 0.30 to 0.95][16], and 0.63 [CI, 0.19 to 1.08][17–18]), but not compared with sham therapies
As we have noted, if a therapy is no better than sham/placebo
IT DOES NOT WORK.
Sorry.
I yelled.
But sometimes I just get too aggravated by the double standards of SCAM evidence. To continue:
A recent, higher-quality trial not included in the systematic reviews found no differences between acupuncture and sham acupuncture for pain or function (Appendix Table 8) (130).
Evidence of longer-term benefits from acupuncture is mixed. Acupuncture was moderately superior for long-term (>6 weeks’ duration) pain relief compared with sham TENS in 2 trials and compared with no additional treatment in 5 trials, although there were no significant differences compared with sham acupuncture. One higher-quality trial found no differences in pain 1 year after acupuncture therapy compared with provision of a self-care education book (161). A higher-quality trial not included in the systematic reviews found clinically insignificant differences (<5 points on 100-point scales) between acupuncture and no acupuncture for pain and function after 6 months . Another recent, higher-quality trial found acupuncture slightly superior to usual care on Short Form–36 pain scores after 24 months (weighted mean difference, 8 points [CI, 0.7 to 15.3 points]) and for recent use of medications for low back pain (60% vs. 41%), although ODI scores and other outcomes did not differ.
So for acupuncture approval, OHP relied on reviews of meta-analysis, and the primary sources suggest the therapies result in at best short term efficacy, the positive effects likely due to poor methodologies and long term effects that were ‘slightly superior’ or ‘clinically insignificant’.
They evidently did not review the literature to show that acupuncture is a theatrical placebo, has no basis in reality-based medicine and that most positive effects are due to bias in poorly done studies.
…results should be interpreted in the context of the limitations identified, particularly in relation to the heterogeneity in the study characteristics and the low methodological quality in many of the included studies.
Thin gruel indeed to justify the State paying for acupuncture. My tax dollars in action. Or my tax dollars inaction, since they did not do what I would consider due diligence in reviewing the literature.
Same as it ever was.
Chiropractic steps up to the wand
The analysis of chiropractic is equally unimpressive.
Reference 108, a meta-analysis, states:
Spinal manipulative therapy had no statistically or clinically significant advantage over general practitioner care, analgesics, physical therapy, exercises, or back school. Results for patients with chronic low back pain were similar. Radiation of pain, study quality, profession of manipulator, and use of manipulation alone or in combination with other therapies did not affect these results.
CONCLUSIONS:
There is no evidence that spinal manipulative therapy is superior to other standard treatments for patients with acute or chronic low back pain.
And that chiropractic is no better other therapies:
High quality evidence suggests that there is no clinically relevant difference between SMT and other interventions for reducing pain and improving function in patients with chronic low-back pain.
The conclusions of the second reference used by HERB are equally tepid about the benefits of chiropractic.
For low back pain of unspecified duration, 1 higher-quality trial (681 patients) found no differences in pain, functional status, or other outcomes between patients randomly assigned to chiropractic versus medical management. The other trial (1334 patients) found spinal manipulation to be slightly superior to usual care for pain and disability (about 5 points on 100-point scales) after 3 months in patients with subacute or chronic low back pain, although effects were not as pronounced after 12 months, and differences on the RDQ did not reach clinical significance (about 1 point). Manipulation and exercise did not significantly differ, and the addition of manipulation to exercise therapy was no better than exercise alone.
Not, as was mentioned in the newspaper, that:
Large, randomized trials have shown that for chronic back pain, acupuncture and chiropractic therapy are equally helpful, said Dr. Richard Deyo, professor of evidence-based medicine at Oregon Health & Science University. He served on a task force that advised the Health Evidence Review Commission. “Different people respond to different things,” he said. “The outcomes tend to be very similar, in the short term at least.”
It is more accurate to say they are equal placebos, doing nothing, since short term improvement is just what one would expect from a placebo that does nothing to the underlying process. I do not think I read the same papers as Dr. Deyo. And if you tend towards the Bayesian approach, it your intervention has no prior plausibility, like acupuncture or chiropractic, then any positive result is likely a false positive.
And should I mention that the deliberate use of placebos are unethical? Naw.
Scraped knees and entomophagy
I will mention in passing that I have long been of the opinion that most SCAMs are the equivalent of kissing a child’s boo-boo or apes grooming each other. Chiropractic and acupuncture are touch-based elaborate treatment rituals and much of their perceived beneficial effects could be from:
mounting evidence that more elaborate treatment rituals trigger larger nonspecific effects. The reasons for this remain unclear. In a pilot field study, we investigated the role of psychophysiological changes during a touch-based healing ritual for improvements in subjective well-being….Subjective well-being increased significantly from before to after the ritual. The analysis of psychophysiological changes revealed a significant increase in respiratory rate from baseline to ritual, while skin conductance, heart rate, and heart rate variability did not change. Increases in [skin conductance levels] as well as decreases in respiratory rate from baseline to ritual were significantly associated with improvements in subjective well-being…. Conclusion. Higher sympathetic arousal during a touch-based healing ritual predicted improvements in subjective well-being.
So the state is going to pay for the metaphorical picking and eating of lice.
And this also ignores the question of the state paying for practitioners of magical pseudo-medicines and all the associated useless interventions and beliefs espoused by chiropractors, naturopaths and traditional Chinese medicine practitioners noted at length on this blog.
It hardly seems like a good use of Oregon’s resources, nor a good approach to chronic back pain. It seems that Ben Goldacre’s aphorism is being ignored: Just because there are flaws in aircraft design that doesn’t mean flying carpets exist.
Oregon chooses flying carpets.
They do suggest a possible benefit:
The expense of a broader range of treatments could be offset by a decline in narcotics use
And I hope they do some epidemiologic studies to show benefit of adding pseudo-medicines to OHP, although I am not so sure the cost is worth the lack of benefit.
Credentialing magic
Being credentialed is a necessary pain. I have to document for my hospitals and some insurance companies that I am trained in my specialty and should be competent to practice medicine. It is a lot of paperwork and it has to be kept up to date. I am, however, credentialed in reality-based medicine.
How do you credential someone in a field that is based in pseudo-medicine, divorced from reality, with a panoply of imaginary diseases treated with equally imaginary therapies? Like naturopathy?
As noted by one author who desperately wants to give his difficult patients to naturopaths:
Unfortunately, a number of serious difficulties can be encountered by internal medicine, family medicine, and pediatric physicians who refer patients to, or attempt to comanage patients with, naturopathic physicians.
And:
Yet because of differentials in paradigm and/or clinical experience, naturopaths commonly order laboratory tests that are either unrecognizable or seem inappropriate to internists.
They don’t seem inappropriate, they are inappropriate, but to be expected from an education and training dominated by nonsense. I have discussed at length why naturopathic training is useless for diagnosis and treatment. It is an old joke, but ND really does mean Not a Doctor.
It does not worry my alma mater, Oregon Health Sciences University, who ignores the whole science part of their title so they can credential naturopaths. How they do it is detailed in “A Framework for Credentialing Naturopathic Physicians in Academic Health Centers: Oregon Health and Science University.”
They state:
To maintain consistency with the rigorous standards applied to all credentialed healthcare professionals at the institution, the requirements include postdoctoral training (clinical or research) in an AHC to establish cultural competence and the completion of one year in a residency approved by the Council on Naturopathic Medical Education or two years of direct clinical practice in a hospital accredited by the Joint Commission or the Centers for Medicare and MedicaidServices to establish clinical competence.
But pay no attention to the content of the education. Being extensively trained in pseudo-medicine does not mean the practitioner should be allowed to take care of patients, especially at a University.
So what good is:
    • Successful graduation from a 4-year accredited, post-baccalaureate, training program with designation as a Doctor of Naturopathic Medicine
    • Successful completion of one year CNME (Council on Naturopathic Medicine Education) accredited residency or evidence of 2 years direct clinical practice in a Joint Commission or CMS accredited hospital or academic medical center
    • Post-Doctoral Training for at least 2 years in an Academic Medical Center
    • Successful completion of NPLEX (Naturopathic Physicians Licensing Examinations) with a current license as an Oregon Licensed Naturopathic Physician
    • Additional Active Clinical Practice for at least 2 years, immediately preceding the request for clinical privileges at OHSU, documentable via reports of specific activities from the locations of practice
When it is all based in nonsense? Playing doctor does not make you a doctor.
OHSU does have far more requirements than most practicing naturopaths have who pretend they can function as primary care physicians.
Pseudo-medicine. Paid for by the state, approved by the University.
And lest you be smug, I bet the same things are happening in your state.

   The British Chiropractic Association versus Simon Singh
David Gorski
Link
If there’s one thing I’ve learned in my years promoting skepticism and science in medicine and writing critically about various forms of unscientific medical practices and outright quackery, it’s that there will always be pushback. Much, if not most, of the time, it’s just insults online. However, occasionally, the pushback enters into the realm of real life. I can remember the very first time this happened to me. It was in 2005, and a man by the name of William P. O’Neill of the Canadian Cancer Research Group sent legal threats to my Department Chairman, my Division Chief, and my Cancer Center Director. The legal threat was clearly vacuous, as Mr. O’Neill seemed upset mainly that I had praised his arch-nemesis, Australian skeptic Peter Bowditch (who even keeps a running tally of threats he receives from Mr. O’Neill under the heading The GAL Chronicles, where GAL stands for “gutless anonymous liar”). I must admit, at the time it scared the crap out of me, but the reaction of my Chairman at the time, Dr. Stephen Lowry, was classic in that he said he did not care what I did in my spare time and referred to Mr. O’Neill as a “cowardly bully.” From then on, every time Mr. O’Neill tried something similar, I simply replied that I was forwarding his e-mail to Dr. Lowry (who was amused by all this) and thanked him for his concern.
More recently, J.B. Handley wrote a rather ugly screed (one of two, actually) about me. Somehow, this screed was e-mailed to my cancer center director. Whether Mr. Handley, one of the crew at Age of Autism, or an AoA reader did it, I don’t know. However, it is typical behavior of the anti-vaccine movement. Based on this history, I’ve concluded that, if you’re going to be a skeptic you’d better be prepared for this sort of thing, and if you’re going to blog under a pseudonym you’d better expect that sooner or later someone will try very, very hard indeed to “out” you and use that against you–which is of course blogging at SBM is in a way liberating in that it removes that threat.
However, whatever obnoxiousness or attempts to harass me at my job I may on occasion have to worry about, one thing I don’t have to worry about (much) is legal threats, at least as long as I keep all my ducks in a row, so to speak. In the U.S., libel is a very difficult charge to prove. The First Amendment gives wide latitude to free speech, and that places the burden of proof on the plaintiff to show that a statement is defamatory, with libel being in essence written defamation. In general, this is what constitutes defamation in the U.S.:
In order for the person about whom a statement is made to recover for libel, the false statement must be defamatory, meaning that it actually harms the reputation of the other person, as opposed to being merely insulting or offensive.
The statement(s) alleged to be defamatory must also have been published to at least one other person (other than the subject of the statement) and must be “of and concerning” the plaintiff. That is, those hearing or reading the statement must identify it specifically with the plaintiff.
The statement(s) alleged to be defamatory must also be a false statement of fact. That which is name-calling, hyperbole, or, however characterized, cannot be proven true or false, cannot be the subject of a libel or slander claim.
The defamatory statement must also have been made with fault. The extent of the fault depends primarily on the status of the plaintiff. Public figures, such as government officials, celebrities, well-known individuals, and people involved in specific public controversies, are required to prove actual malice, a legal term which means the defendant knew his statement was false or recklessly disregarded the truth or falsity of his statement. In most jurisdictions, private individuals must show only that the defendant was negligent: that he failed to act with due care in the situation.
A defamation claim — at least one based upon statements about issues that are matters of public interest — will likely fail if any of these elements are not met.
As you can see, it is a high bar of evidence to overcome to prove libel. Of course, that is a two-edged sword in that it allows J.B. Handley to slime me whenever he wishes, with little I can do about it, but I am also allowed, as I see fit, to respond or not to such attacks. I can also continue to criticize anti-vaccine propagandists like Mr. Handley as I see fit. Unfortunately, for my U.K. colleagues, the same is most assuredly not true in British courts, where the rules are very much weighted against the defendant. Witness this travesty of a ruling on the libel case against Simon Singh, coauthor with Edzard Ernst of Trick or Treatment: The Undeniable Facts about Alternative Medicine (which Harriet Hall reviewed last year) by the British Chiropractic Association, as related by Jack of Kent. This ruling came about because the BCA did not like an article that Singh wrote for The Guardian entitled Beware the spinal trap.
I first learned about the UK’s exceedingly plaintiff-friendly libel laws when, shortly after I first became interested in Holocaust denial, I followed the libel case against Holocaust historian Professor Deborah Lipstadt brought by Holocaust denier David Irving for, well, quite properly calling him a Holocaust denier in one of her books. Although the definition of libel and defamation are similar in British law to what they are in U.S. law, what makes British libel laws so plaintiff-friendly is that the burden of proof is very low for the plaintiff compared to the United States. Indeed, in practice it is not generally necessary for the plaintiff to show that what was written by the defendant about him is untrue (or written with a “reckless disregard for the truth”), only that it might damage his reputation (i.e., is potentially defamatory). Thus, far more than in the U.S., the burden of proof falls largely on the defendant to demonstrate that what he or she wrote about the plaintiff is true. Professor Lipstadt describes her reaction to being notified of Irving’s lawsuit in her book describing her ordeal, History On Trial: My Day in Court with David Irving:
Now, sitting in my Emory office, I wondered who could possibly take David Irving’s claims that he was not a denier seriously. Certainly this had to be just a ploy to intimidate me. Over coffee, I told some colleagues about the letter and predicted it would go nowhere.
As it turned out, I was wrong on all counts. Irving would take this very seriously, as would the British courts. The fact that my sources were all documented did not protect me in the United Kingdom, as it would have in the United States. In fact, I was at a decided disadvantage. British law placed the burden of proof on me as the defendant. It was a mirror image of American law. In the United States, Irving would have to prove I lied. In the United Kingdom, I had to prove I told the truth.
She writes later:
During Anthony’s [Anthony Julius, Lipstadt's defense attorney] visit, I received a crash course in British libel law. It presumes defamatory words to be untrue until the author proves them true. The burden of proof is, therefore, on the defendant rather than the plaintiff, as would be the case in the United States.
That is the situation in which Simon Singh now finds himself, ten years after Professor Lipstadt did. It’s a different skeptical topic, but the same predicament, thanks to the insane nature of British libel law.
It is true that Professor Lipstadt did ultimately win her case. Her victory was all the more impressive given how plaintiff-friendly British libel law is and how, for all practical purposes, she had to “prove that the Holocaust happened” in court and then to show in excruciating detail with copious evidence exactly how and why what David Irving writes and says about the Holocaust constitutes Holocaust denial. Unfortunately, it took many months to accomplish this and a couple of million dollars. If Lipstadt’s publisher hadn’t stuck with her (and there was an indemnification clause in her contract with her publisher that would have allowed it to leaver her hanging in the breeze if it had so chosen), she’d have probably had to settle. Indeed, that was almost certainly David Irving’s expectation when he brought the case–that Professor Lipstadt would settle. She did not and, fortunately, won big. It could have gone the other way if she had had a less skillful legal team and, more importantly, if Irving hadn’t made a characteristically supremely hubris-filled decision to represent himself in the case. Even as it was, she incurred significant legal expenses on her own and had to raise money for her legal defense.
Since I’ve become interested in “alternative” medicine, I’ve seen examples of similar abuses of U.K. libel law, in which various “alternative” practitioners tried to use the law to silence bloggers whose opinions they did not like or writers who criticized them. The most famous example of using British libel law to attempt to silence a blogger/columnist that comes readily to mind is how HIV/AIDS denialist and vitamin magnate Matthias Rath went after Ben Goldacre after Goldacre had criticized him for taking out full page ads in South Africa for his vitamin pills as AIDS cures. Again, it’s true Goldacre won and ultimately published a chapter out of his book about Rath that he had had to remove from it because Rath was, as Goldacre put it “suing my ass in High Court.” However, this happy ending only came about because Goldacre’s newspaper stuck by him and paid for his legal defense. Even with his newspaper’s support, he might have lost. The truth is an absolute defense against libel, even in the U.K., but proving it can be exceedingly difficult.
Others, who have not had the resources of Professor Lipstadt or Ben Goldacre’s newspaper, have not been so lucky. For example, an excellent British skeptical blogger, Andy Lewis (a.k.a. Le Canard Noir), who runs the excellent and amusing Quackometer, has faced this problem twice. In the case of Le Canard Noir, libel law intersects with Internet law so that it’s very easy for a quack to threaten the ISP of a blogger with cease-and-desist letters claiming defamation, and, thanks to less robust common carrier protections for ISPs in the U.K. and the U.K.’s ridiculously plaintiff-friendly libel laws, most ISPs will cave and remove the post. Lewis is honored in that he managed to provoke the Society of Homeopaths into making just such a threat in response to a post by him entitled The Gentle Art of Homeopathic Killing, in which he lambasted the Society of Homeopaths for not even enforcing their own ethical guidelines with respect to homeopaths making claims that homeopathy can prevent or treat malaria. The result was that the post was taken up and reposted all over the blogosphere from Google caches.
Next, the “little black duck” was threatened by a master woo-meister named Dr. Joseph Chikelue Obi (who bills himself as the “world’s top expert in nutritional immunomudulation,” “alternative medicine top dog,” and has claimed to produce “his own brand” of clinical trial methodology for alternative medicine) who threatened Le Canard Noir’s webhost with a lawsuit, demanding a £1 million a day penalty unless pages about him and his highly dubious activities are removed from their server in response to a post entitled Right Royal College of Pompous Quackery. The result was similar. Finally, I’m personally aware of one British blogger who was threatened with a libel suit by a wealthy promoter of pseudoscience; he, having trouble coming up with enough money to pay a lawyer for a couple of billable hours to look at his case and draft a response letter (which he barely managed to do), was forced to remove his post and apologize.
Finally, here is the legal intimidation coming from the British Chiropractic Association, which, as many may know, is suing Simon Singh for this passage in an article he wrote:
The British Chiropractic Association claims that their members can help treat children with colic, sleeping and feeding problems, frequent ear infections, asthma and prolonged crying, even though there is not a jot of evidence. This organisation is the respectable face of the chiropractic profession and yet it happily promotes bogus treatments.
In the U.S., it’s highly unlikely that a lawyer would even be willing to take this case as anything other than cash on the barrelhead, so slim would be the chance that it would make it even past a preliminary hearing. Yet, Thursday and Friday, Singh has had his first preliminary hearing and his first loss. And it was a devastating loss, as explained by U.K. legal blogger Jack of Kent:
As part of libel litigation, the court does have to rule as to the meaning of the relevant passages. This ruling in turn provides which are the appropriate defences. If it is ruled that the passage was “comment” then the defendant has to prove that it was a “fair comment”. If the passage was a statement of fact, then the defendant has “justify” the fact.
So far, this is not unlike the U.S. in that the judge was trying to sort out a claim of fact from an expression of an opinion. Here’s where the ruling went off the rails:
The judge ruled that, notwithstanding that the passage in Singh’s article was a comment piece and published on the comment page, it was a statement of fact. This was an unhelpful ruling, and my heart sank for a moment, but it was not one for which Singh was unprepared. Singh would have preferred to have had a comment ruling, but he did have a full justification defence too, see here. So not ideal, but not a disaster.
But the judge continued. The word “bogus” meant deliberate and targeted dishonesty. So it did not mean that chiropractic for the six named children’s ailments (including asthma) was simply wrong, or that it was contrary to established medical practice or research, or even that it completely lacked evidence.
“Bogus” meant a lot more. The judge held that by the mere use of the word “bogus” Simon Singh was stating that, as a matter of fact, the BCA were being consciously dishonest in promoting chiropractic for those children’s ailments.
It doesn’t matter that Singh had earlier in his article defined “bogus” as “ineffective,” not as “deliberate and targeted” dishonesty. In essence, the judge defined the word and went beyond even what the BCA was arguing. The consequence of Sir Eady’s ruling is this:
The ruling means that, as it stands, Simon Singh would have to prove at full trial that the BCA were being deliberately dishonest. This is not only extremely difficult but it was undoubtedly not Simon Singh’s view in the first place. The BCA, as with many CAM practitioners, may well be deluded, irresponsible, and sometimes rather dangerous; but calling their promoted treatments “bogus” was not an express statement of their conscious dishonesty.
Indeed, unless there is hard evidence of dishonesty, it may not even be professionally possible for Simon Singh’s lawyers to put the required case to the court: English barristers and solicitors are prohibited from alleging fraud unless there is sound and cogent evidence before them on which to base the allegation.
Basically, it would be very unwise and perhaps impossible for Simon Singh to go to full trial with this ruling on meaning.
This ruling puts Singh in a very, very difficult situation and makes it almost impossible for him to prevail in court if he takes the case to trial. In the wake of this nonsensical ruling, Singh apparently has three options. Option one: He can appeal the ruling on the meaning of the word “bogus,” which has a high probability of failing, given that higher courts generally defer to the lower courts on such matters. Option two: He can take his case to the European Court of Human Rights as a breach of Article 10 (freedom of expression), something that he can’t do unless he first appeals and continues his appeals until he exhausts all of his legal options in British courts. Such an appeal to the E.U. could take three years and lots of money, and there is no guarantee that this will succeed, either. Or…
Option three: Settle.
Sadly, this is probably the most rational option, based on the evidence alone and Sir David Eady’s ridiculous ruling. Unfortunately, Sir Eady is well known for such nonsensical legal rulings; so it is unlikely that he will be any less nonsensical if this case goes to trial. Moreover, based on his finances, Singh may have no choice in the matter but to settle. I hope he doesn’t settle, but I understand if he does. He has such an uphill battle from here that it may not make sense to continue. If he does, however, I wonder if there is a legal defense fund to which skeptics and supporters of science-based medicine may contribute. I’d be willing to make a contribution, for sure. Unfortunately, unless Singh is made of money, option three is clearly the option he will most likely be forced to take.
What of the broader picture? Clearly the U.K., due to its plaintiff-friendly libel laws, is already a rather inhospitable place for skeptical bloggers and writers. In essence, if Sir Eady’s ruling stands, arguably now it’s not even necessary to make an actual factual claim in order to find your at the wrong end of a libel suit by a powerful and wealthy organization, with little help. In fact, even if you define a word you are using for purposes of your criticism of “alternative” practices, apparently that doesn’t necessarily protect you from a judge’s defining the word as he sees fit.
Think about it. All Singh did was to make two arguments:
     1.  “Group A is enthusiastically promoting treatment X.”
     2.  “Treatment X is ineffective against conditions Y, and Z.” (Or: “There is no scientific evidence to support the efficacy of treatment X for conditions Y and Z.”)
Or, a simpler and more relevant way to rephrase what Singh wrote:
     1.  “Group A is enthusiastically promoting treatment X.”
     2.  “Treatment X is bogus.”
It’s a non sequitur to conclude from 1 and 2 that group A is being deliberately dishonest. Certainly, that is one possible explanation for its promotion of treatment X, but it is not by any means the only explanation. An alternate, arguably even more likely, explanation is that group A truly believes in the bogus treatment X and is honest, but mistaken, in its belief. Indeed, in my experience, that is probably the case for the vast majority of practitioners of “complementary and alternative” medicine (CAM). Most are not hucksters and frauds (although, make no mistake, there are many hucksters and frauds in CAM), but rather true believers in modalities that have little or no science to support them. I also can’t help but point out that, if the BCA actually had the science on its side, it would be very easy for it to produce it. Instead, it goes straight to trying to stifle criticism that it doesn’t like without producing one whit of scientific evidence to try to refute that criticism. Clearly, the BCA is nothing more than a bunch of cowards and bullies, unconcerned about science. Science thrives on argument, dissent, and testing ideas against reality. The only reason the BCA resorts to the courts is because its woo cannot stand up to scientific debate and scrutiny.
Disturbing to me is that I’ve made the same sort of argument as Singh has on more occasions than I can remember over the last nine years or so. If I were in the UK and happened to make it about a litigious group, I could easily find myself in the same pickle that Singh is in. As The Lay Scientist puts it:
Simon Singh is the victim on this occasion, but if this nonsense continues, then the conditions in which the rest of us – writers and bloggers like myself or Ben Goldacre – have to operate will become ridiculously savage. We’re already at a massive disadvantage from the fact that it takes ten seconds to make a claim and ten hours to carefully prove it wrong. Now the legal system is ensuring that it costs ten pence to make a dodgy medical claim and ten thousand pounds and a court case to attack it.
It is true. Be it skeptics taking down pseudoscience about evolution or supporters of science-based medicine taking down quack claims, it is the skeptical side that is always at a disadvantage. It is very easy to make bogus claims and often takes a lot of work to demonstrate how and why said bogus claims fail from a scientific and logical standpoint. Morever, it’s very easy for a crank, be he a creationist, a 9/11 Truther, a Holocaust denier, a supporter of unscientific medical modalities, or even an outright quack, to do what is known among supporters of evolution against creationism as the Gish Gallop, which in essence involves making so many nonsensical claims that a skeptic can’t possibly refute them all (and in fact may not even be familiar with them all). Add to that the threat of legal action in the U.K., and I don’t know how people like Simon Singh, Ben Goldacre, Andy Lewis, Martin Robbins, the bloggers at Holford Watch, David Colquhoun, and other public supporters of science-based medicine in the U.K. manage. I also admire them all. If I lived in the UK, I don’t know if I would have intestinal fortitude to keep blogging if Singh is forced to settle or appeals and loses.
Worse, the insanity that is British libel law doesn’t just limit itself to the U.K. If a publisher has assets in the U.K., a plaintiff can bring a case in the U.K. Indeed, there is a term for abusing plaintiff-friendly laws in the U.K. and other jurisdictions to silence writers who may not even live or publish in the U.K.: Libel tourism. It may not be just U.K. skeptics who need to beware. For example, in the most famous case of libel tourism, that of Rachel Ehrenfeld, who wrote Funding Evil: How Terrorism Is Financed and How to Stop It, a wealthy Saudi businessman whom Ehrenfeld had accused in her book of being a funder of terrorism, Khalid bin Mahfouz, sued in Britain and won a sizable amount of money. British courts accepted the case, even though the book was never published in the U.K.. However, 23 copies were purchased online and shipped to the U.K. That was enough for British Courts to claim jurisdiction. Ironically, the judge who ruled on the case was Sir Eady, who ordered Ehrenfeld to apologize, retract and pay bin Mahfouz $225,913 in costs and damages. One wonders whether the fact that anything written on a website or a blog can be read in the U.K., regardless of where its publisher lives or where it is hosted, would be enough for British courts to claim jurisdiction if the plaintiff is a British citizen.
It’s times like these when I truly cherish the wisdom of our Founding Fathers for having enshrined freedom of speech in the Constitution as part of its First Amendment. It’s hard enough to defend science-based medicine by speaking out against quackery without worrying about a legal system that makes it very easy for the quacks to sue you for for everything you have, even if science and the facts are on your side.

   The British Chiropractic Association Responds to Simon Singh
Steven Novella
Link
Simon Singh is a science journalist who last year wrote an article in the Guardian critical of the British Chiropractic Association (BCA) for promoting chiropractic treatment for certain childhood ailments. Singh characterized these treatments as “bogus” because they lack evidence to back up claims for clinical efficacy. The BCA responded by suing Singh for libel. In the English court system the person being sued for libel is essentially guilty until proven innocent, and even successfully defending oneself can be ruinously expensive. Therefore suing for libel in English court is a very successful strategy for silencing critics.
This case resulted in a bit of a backlash against the BCA, who were accused of silencing legitimate and very necessary public scientific debate regarding the safety and efficacy of medical interventions. The BCA could have simply responded by providing evidence to back up their claims, and the Guardian even offered them space to do so, but instead they sued.
Part of this backlash is a movement, supported by many scientific organizations, to keep libel laws out of science.
Recently the BCA has responded to this backlash with a statement and a list of studies they claim provides the evidence Singh said was lacking. I won’t address their attempt at damage control, but rather focus on their response regarding the evidence. They write:
In the spirit of wider scientific debate, and having taken appropriate professional advice, the BCA has decided that free speech would be best facilitated by releasing details of research that exists to support the claims which Dr. Singh stated were bogus. This proves that far from being “not a jot of evidence” to support the BCA’s position, there is actually a significant amount.
They follow their statement with a list of 29 studies. This is a short reference list to support several individual medical claims, but actually it is a bloated list that contains many references that do not provide evidence for the claims of the BCA that Sign was criticizing. This is how the 29 references break down:
3 – Risks of NSAID medication
1 – Nature of evidence-based medicine
3 – opinion, chiropractic practice
1 – letter to editor
2 – review
2 – risks of chiropractic
8 – colic
3 – nocturnal enuresis
3 – otitis media
3 – asthma
Therefore, out of the 29 references, only 17 actually provide evidence for the efficacy claims for chiropractic for these four pediatric indications. When each indication is considered, the list of supporting studies is embarrassingly thin. They are also of very poor quality and, as we will see, cherry picked.
It should also be noted that the notion of spinal manipulation for medical issues, like a middle ear infection, is highly implausible. Such implausible claims should require robust clinical evidence before putting them into practice. The evidence presented by the BCA is far from robust, and when the totality of evidence is considered it is actually negative.
Colic
Of the 8 studies presented for colic, one is a preliminary assessment of cranial osteopathy for colic. In the past chiropractors have complained that studies of non-chiropractic forms of manipulation cannot be used to dismiss the efficacy of chiropractic. It is disingenuous of the BCA to pad their list of evidence for chiropractic by including a study of osteopathic manipulation. Two of the studies were case reports. One report is a response to a questionnaire, and there were three unblinded or single-blinded studies, and one uncontrolled study. Therefore, not one prospective, double-blind, placebo-controlled study is presented. All we are given is low grade evidence.
Also, the BCA left off the best designed study, which not surprisingly was negative. Olafsdottir et al (1) studied 86 infants with colic in a randomized controlled trial and found:
“Chiropractic spinal manipulation is no more effective than placebo in the treatment of infantile colic.”
How does the BCA justify omitting this study from their list? Do they think that an open scientific discussion of evidence means presenting only the evidence that seems to support their position?
The BCA also neglected to reference a review of the evidence for chiropractic for colic by Hughes and Bolton (2) which concludes:
“The evidence suggests that chiropractic has no benefit over placebo in the treatment of infantile colic. However, there is good evidence that taking a colicky infant to a chiropractor will result in fewer reported hours of colic by the parents.”
Their conclusion was curious – chiropractic treatment for colic does not work but parents report that it does. Ordinarily science-based practitioners would simply interpret such results as being consistent with a placebo effect alone.
What we see is the typical pattern of evidence for an ineffective treatment – low grade evidence showing an effect, but higher grade controlled evidence showing no effect above placebo. The bottom line is that existing evidence suggests that chiropractic manipulation is not effective in the treatment of colic. But the BCA cherry picked only the low grade evidence that supported their claim.
Asthma
Of the three asthma studies presented, two were of osteopathic manipulation and the third is a case series and pilot study. The two osteopathic studies were looking at markers of pulmonary function, and not clinical outcomes. Again, it is very telling that these three weak studies are all the BCA could come up with.
And again, the BCA left off their list the largest and most definitive study of chiropractic treatment for childhood asthma – the 1998 New England Journal of Medicine study (3). This was a large randomized controlled trial, which found:
In children with mild or moderate asthma, the addition of chiropractic spinal manipulation to usual medical care provided no benefit.
The pattern repeats again – the best data shows no effect from manipulation. It is my sincere contention that if the exact same evidence (even leaving out the lack of plausibility) existed for a medical treatment, it would be abandoned as a worthless dead end. At the very least, use would stop until further research were done. There might even be concerns about the ethics of further research given the negative evidence and lack of plausibility.
The BCA and chiropractors in general have simply ignored or dismissed the negative evidence of chiropractic for asthma and instead cherry pick the very low-grade evidence that seems to support what they want to claim. This makes chiropractic treatment for asthma “bogus.”
Otitis Media
There is precious little research into the treatment of acute otitis media (middle ear infection) with chiropractic adjustment. The three studies cited are all retrospective or uncontrolled. There are no double-blind placebo controlled studies – and therefore no reliable evidence upon which to base a clinical claim.
Nocturnal Enuresis
Again, we have three weak studies and nothing to defend the implausible claim that chiropractic treats nocturnal enuresis. One of the studies cited is by Reed et al, which concludes:
“The mean pre- to post-treatment change in the wet night frequency for the treatment group compared with the control group did not reach statistical significance (p = 0.067).”
In other words – this is a negative study. The comparison of treatment to control showed no statistically significant difference. There was a trend – but they are not reliable enough to serve as a basis for clinical conclusions. That is the whole point of statistical significance. This was a small study, so you can say that it was simply not powerful enough to detect an effect – but that still leaves us without evidence to support the claim for an effect.
A Cochrane review of the evidence regarding chiropractic and other alternative treatments for nocturnal enuresis concluded:
“There was weak evidence to support the use of hypnosis, psychotherapy, acupuncture and chiropractic but it was provided in each case by single small trials, some of dubious methodological rigour.”
Conclusion
The BCA’s list of evidence for these four clinical claims is not impressive. The best they have to offer is a few weak and poorly designed studies. They also ignore larger better trials where available that are negative.
A more thorough assessment of the evidence for chiropractic treatment for asthma and colic reveals evidence for lack of efficacy. For otitis media and nocturnal enuresis there is a lack of evidence for efficacy.
Despite the state of the evidence, the BCA feels they are justified in promoting chiropractic for these pediatric indications. The reader can decide if the term “bogus” applies.
References:
1) Olafsdottir E, Forshei S, Fluge G, Markestad T. Randomised controlled trial of infantile colic treated with chiropractic spinal manipulation. Arch Dis Child. 2001 Feb;84(2):138-41.
2) Hughes S, Bolton J. Is chiropractic an effective treatment in infantile colic? Arch Dis Child. 2002 May;86(5):382-4.
3) Balon J, Aker PD, Crowther ER, Danielson C, Cox PG, O’Shaughnessy D, Walker C, Goldsmith CH, Duku E, Sears MR. A comparison of active and simulated chiropractic manipulation as adjunctive treatment for childhood asthma. N Engl J Med. 1998 Oct 8;339(15):1013-20.

   Chiropractic in the News
Harriet Hall
Link
Three recent news items about chiropractic have particularly irritated me.
(1) U.S. Army Brigadier General Becky Halstead (Retired) Speaks Out for Chiropractic Care
(2) Chiropractic Helps Child with Brain Disorder
(3) Swine Flu Chiropractor’s Handout
(1) General Halstead has become a spokesperson for The Foundation for Chiropractic Progress, a nonprofit organization dedicated to increasing public awareness of chiropractic. Her quoted comments boil down to
    • I like the personal attention and caring I get from my chiropractor.
    • Chiropractic advice about healthy lifestyle is essential
    • Chiropractic care prevents more serious health concerns
    • Chiropractic is essential for assisting in recovery from minor injuries.
    • Chiropractors don’t mask the problem with drugs and all their side effects.
    • Chiropractors are holistic and involve the patient in her own care.
    • “Listening appears to be a major tool.”
This is nothing but opinion based on personal experience and scientific ignorance. She offers no evidence that chiropractic theory is true, that chiropractic adjustments are effective, or that a chiropractor has any advantage over a science-based medical doctor who also spends time listening to patients, is interested in the whole patient, advises about healthy lifestyle, and avoids unnecessary use of drugs. Caring clinicians can be found in chiropractic, in homeopathy, in every kind of quackery, and in scientific medicine, with the advantage that the scientific clinician can also provide effective evidence-based treatments.
As a woman and a retired Air Force colonel, I am doubly ashamed that this high-ranking military woman has prostituted herself by becoming a spokesperson for pseudoscience. I hope they are paying her well.
(2) The “research,” reported in the Journal of Pediatric, Maternal & Family Health – Chiropractic, is not really what I would call research. It describes a case of a child with cerebellar ataxia whose problems completely resolved following four chiropractic adjustments. The report speculates that
the increase in the diagnosis of such disorders as ADHD, pervasive developmental disorder, Tourette’s Syndrome, obsessive compulsive disorder and other neurodevelopmental disorders, have their root in abnormal spinal development. Children’s nervous systems need the constant stimulation of movement in order to develop and function properly. Abnormal position or movement of the spinal vertebra can develop and this can lead to nerve interference. It is this interference, called vertebral subluxations, that chiropractors correct.
Maybe, but these subluxations have never been shown to exist outside the imagination of chiropractors, and the alleged nerve interference has never been demonstrated.
I couldn’t access the entire article without paying $50, but the abstract raised a lot of questions. A seven year old girl “presented for chiropractic care and cerebellar ataxia was noted.” Was this an incidental observation by the chiropractor, or had the child been previously diagnosed with documented ataxia? The chiropractor’s exam “isolated the location of trans-neuronal dysfunction to the right cerebellum.” How? What does “trans-neuronal dysfunction” even mean? Even the grammar is faulty: “Chiropractic analysis of static and motion palpation were used to examine the spine for subluxations.” The wording makes it unclear what the treatment was: adjustments were given “in either the cervical, thoracic, lumbar and/or pelvic region as needed. Neuro-rehabilitative exercises were given either at home and/or during the office visit.” “Within four visits there was marked improvement of gait patterns and resolution of the ataxia.” Really? Or did the chiropractor and parents simply convince themselves they saw improvement? Was cerebellar ataxia really there in the first place? Did a medical doctor confirm the diagnosis? Was there any long-term followup?
The abstract’s conclusion is propaganda, not a conclusion based on the study. It consists of speculation that is in no way justified by the data.
Understanding and applying foundational neurological principles via a patient specific, individually tailored, chiropractic management plan is essential. Assessing and optimizing asymmetrical neurological indicators should be part of screening and management procedures. In this case, addressing the dysfunction concerning the central integrative state of the cerebellum was necessary for optimum functioning of this seven-year-old female.
This is a case report, little more than a testimonial. I hope the body of the article clarifies some of the questions the abstract raises, but I have seen many, many similar chiropractic case reports that are poorly documented, that mix treatments so it is impossible to determine what caused the improvement, and that are eminently unconvincing. The value of case reports is that they can help guide future research. This seldom happens in chiropractic; there is no progress over time, and reports like this do not build into a coherent body of knowledge.
The author, Nicoleta Borcean, has no articles listed either on PubMed or in the Index to Chiropractic Literature. The journal this article was published in is a brand-new one, and I question both its concept and its editorial board. Why do we need a journal of “Pediatric, Maternal & Family Health- Chiropractic”? There is no evidence that chiropractic has any role in pediatric or maternal health, and the attempt of some chiropractors to become “family doctors” is misguided. The editor in chief is a professor at Life University, a scandal-ridden school that was denied recertification in 2002 because it offered substandard education. One editorial board member is Barbara Loe Fisher, Co-Founder & President of the National Vaccine Information Center – an anti-vaccine organization. Other board members are associated with the Academy of Chiropractic Family Practice and the International Chiropractic Pediatric Association, organizations whose raison d’être is questionable.
I’m not making an ad hominem argument. I’m not saying these individuals couldn’t produce a high-quality journal. But in this case, they haven’t; and their background helps explain why. The abstracts in the current issue are all case reports similar to the ataxia one. “I treated a patient and he got better” is meaningless unless you can show that you’re not making a post hoc ergo propter hoc error. The journal appears to be more interested in finding evidence to support chiropractic claims than in doing good science to test whether chiropractic claims are true. Pseudoscience tries to show “that” a treatment works; real science asks “if” it really works.
(3) Chiropractors were among the first alternative providers to jump on the Swine Flu bandwagon. I already wrote about this for the JREF’s Swift, but I’ll repeat it here. Their handout boils down to 6 recommendations:
    • Build your immune system by getting adjusted.
    • Limit the amount of sugar in your diet because sugar depresses the immune system.
    • Avoid alcohol and white flour products.
    • Drink more water
    • Wash your hands frequently.
    • Disinfect your rooms by spraying them with a solution of essential oils (4 drops to one cup of water).
Hey! One out of six isn’t bad. Handwashing is a good idea. The rest of this advice is useless for preventing infection.
They tell us “Studies show that being adjusted twice a week can increase your immune system function by up to 400%.” No they don’t. I couldn’t find even one such study. I did find a reference to “preliminary research” – apparently not published – that allegedly showed that patients who had received long term chiropractic care had 200% greater immune competence than patients who had not received chiropractic care and 400% greater than those who had cancer. This is uninterpretable because we are not told how the data were collected nor how “immune competence” was measured. Maybe sicker people are already seeing MDs and are less likely to see chiropractors. Besides which, the damage from flu is due to the immune response, and it’s conceivable that increasing immune competence might be harmful.
There is NO credible evidence that chiropractic adjustments decrease the risk of catching ANYTHING. Ditto sugar, white flour and alcohol (unless perhaps indirectly due to secondary effects of overindulgence). Drinking more water? No evidence. And spraying dilute essential oils is probably as effective as having a witch doctor wave a bone and chant.
Chiropractic may help some people with musculoskeletal pain, but reading news items like these doesn’t help my blood pressure!

   Those who live in glass houses… 
Joseph Albietz
Link
The last two weeks have brought good news to those who seek to hold chiropractic to the standard of evidence and science-based medicine.
In the first bit of good news, on October 14th Simon Singh was granted permission to appeal the High Court ruling on meaning of the term “bogus” within his original article. I’m sure most readers of this blog are familiar with Simon Singh’s legal battle with the British Chiropractic Association (BCA) regarding an article in The Guardian entitled “Beware the Spinal Trap.” We’ve covered it several times over the last year and will continue to do so as the case progresses. The nuances of the British legal system (or any legal system for that matter) are beyond my ken, and are far better explained by Jack of Kent here. The take-home point is that gaining permission to appeal the ruling on meaning was virtually essential if Simon were to have any real chance of winning this lawsuit.
Even if the BCA should win its lawsuit for libel against Singh, it seems likely to be something of a pyrrhic victory. After all, in the year since this story began, we’ve been belatedly provided with the BCA’s best evidence in support of chiropractic’s efficacy, and promptly treated to its subsequent evisceration.
We’ve also been given insight into the standards held and practices recommended by the McTimoney Chiropractic Association (MCA), which by its own reckoning is the second largest chiropractic association in Europe. In an apparent response to the attention brought by the BCA’s lawsuit, the MCA advised its members to take down their websites and remove all reference to treatment of “whiplash, colic, or other childhood problems” from their places of business to avoid a “witch hunt” targeting “any claims for treatment that cannot be substantiated with chiropractic research.” If only the Malleus Maleficarum had been written with such high standards of evidence!
In the same email we were treated to their unique perspective on ethics and the right of patients to information with this gem of a quote (punctuation intact):
we strongly suggest you do NOT discuss this with others, especially patients, Firstly it would not be ethical to burden patients with this…
I find this statement to be the most abhorrent in the entire MCA email. This is advice from a major professional organization to withhold information from patients. And not just an esoteric bit of chiropractic minutiae, but information that pertains to entire swaths of chiropractic practice. Even worse, nowhere in the email does it advise MCA chiropractors to stop treating the stated conditions, just to obfuscate the fact that they do. As I said, abhorrent.
So in their attempt to silence one critic through litigation, the BCA has drawn attention to the paucity of evidence supporting many of its practices, shown that its chosen response to criticism is litigation and not scientific discourse, and prompted some alarmingly unethical advisory statements from their chiropractic colleagues. For a group supposedly striving to gain legitimacy within modern medicine, their current course of action seems to be ill conceived at best. As the saying goes, “Those who live in glass houses shouldn’t throw stones.”
Simon has rightfully received an outstanding amount of support during this event, one example of which was a mass reposting of “Beware the Spinal Trap” coordinated by Sense about Science. Such advocacy is not without its risks, as both Simon Singh and now the Australian Skeptics can testify.
The Australian Skeptics is a coalition of volunteer advocacy groups dedicated to the advancement of science and reason. Among their many interests, they’ve chosen to be outspoken advocates for evidence and science-based medicine, using both traditional and “new media” to great effect. That they were among the many to support Singh by reposting his article in late July should have been no surprise; the trouble that simple reposting has caused them, however, was.
Evidently their re-posting of “Beware the Spinal Trap” raised the ire of an Australian chiropractor, Joseph Ierano. Shortly after sending a lengthy letter to the Australian Skeptics objecting to the content of Singh’s article, he submitted a complaint to the HCCC claiming that by posting Singh’s article, the Australian Skeptics were offering incorrect medical/health care advice and should be subject to the Australian Public Health Act of 1993. Their subsequent exchanges can be found here.
Which of course brings me to the second bit of good news. I am happy to report that on October 23rd the Australian Skeptics received word that the HCCC of NSW dismissed the complaint filed against them by Joseph Ierano, citing that the Australian Skeptics were not health care providers and therefore did not fall under their jurisdiction. Joseph Ierano, however, certainly is a health care provider and makes some rather interesting claims on his own site that might not have the firmest of foundations. I wonder if he really intended to bring himself to the HCCC’s attention.
I heartily congratulate both Simon Singh and the Australian Skeptics that their respective cases have taken turns in their favor, and in support of good science. Though I’m sure the Australian Skeptics would have relished the opportunity to defend themselves and explore the accuracy of statements made by Singh and Ierano in open court (they’ve said as much on their site), I rather prefer that it didn’t come to that. Given that legal decisions can impact the public perception of the science but have no bearing on its validity, courtroom battles tend to be high-risk and low-gain for those of us promoting science-based medicine.

Chiropractic clinical training with pediatric patients or complicated cases: slim to none
Chiropractors may never have seen a pediatric patient or a complicated medical case in clinical training, yet they are allowed to go into practice with no age limits on who they see and few on the conditions they treat.
Jann Bellamy on July 6, 2017
Link

According to U.S. and Canadian chiropractic school accrediting authorities, chiropractic students are required to have only 1,000 hours of clinical training before graduating and going into practice. The Canadian Federation of Chiropractic Regulatory and Educational Accrediting Boards requires that chiropractic students develop a diagnosis, formulate a treatment regiment, and manage the case for only 35 different patients under faculty supervision. The U.S. Council on Chiropractic Education doesn’t even specify a minimum number of patients the student must evaluate. It is left to the chiropractic school’s “discretion.”
Because chiropractors do not have internship or residency requirements (although, confusingly, the article discussed in this post refers to undergraduate chiropractic students in clinical training as “interns”), they go straight into practice without further supervised clinical training. Yet, as noted by the authors of a new study in the Journal of Chiropractic Education:
very few recent studies have examined chiropractic students’ clinical education.
And:
there is an absence of current literature that actually quantifies the clinical experiences of chiropractic interns.
So, they set out to:
describe the case mix experienced by chiropractic students during their clinical internship at the Canadian Memorial Chiropractic College.
Amazingly, the authors say that, to their knowledge, this is the first study ever to describe the average caseloads of chiropractic students in clinical training. While their sample of students was small (only 24 to start, reduced to 23), some startling facts were revealed: Only two students had any clinical experience with children or infants. In addition, very few saw grade-school or teenage patients (12 of 23). According to the authors, preclinical chiropractic students do complete “a 22-hour course in pediatric topics.” So, if this study holds true for chiropractors as a whole, the vast majority go into practice without any clinical experience with infants and children, armed with only 22 hours of classroom instruction in “pediatric topics.” This is frightening when, as the authors note, according to a retrospective study, “17% of [chiropractic private practice] patients represent pediatric populations,” although a prospective, practice-based study reported a much lower percentage of pediatric patients (2%-4%).
The figures weren’t much better for senior citizens. Perhaps putting the best face on it, the authors say that all students managed “at least one patient over 65 years old.”
Even though the participating students examined only 36 patients on average (thereby beating the requirements by all of one), the students had to chum up their own patients to practice on. Almost a quarter of the patients were either fellow students or friends or family members of students. This is consistent with another study which found that about a fourth of new patients at a chiropractic teaching clinic were family members of students. This has become such a problem that Canadian standards now specify that no more than 20% of the minimum clinical requirements can be performed on other students or their families and services to one’s immediate family are prohibited.
On the other hand, patient complaints seen by the students were pretty much as one would expect.
    • 93% were for pain-based complaints
    • 65% included a complaint in the cervical, thoracic or lumbar spine or pelvis
What the authors call “yellow flag” complaints (a term they do not further define) were present in only 16% of patients and “red flags” in 7%, leading the authors to conclude that:
some interns are not exposed to many situations beyond noncomplicated musculoskeletal (MSK) pain with regard to these specific measures
such as clinical flags, the necessity of medical referral, and suspicion of underlying pathology.
Normally, one would not think to compare chiropractic clinical training to that of family practice doctors. However, since it is the chiropractors themselves who are pushing the notion that they are “primary care physicians,” (including yet another bill to allow chiropractors to perform sports physicals for student athletes), let’s see how their clinical training compares to that of real primary care physicians. During a 3-year family practice residency, a resident must (among many other requirements), log in at least:
    • 200 hours (or 2 months) and 250 patient encounters in the care of ill children in the hospital or emergency room.
    • 200 hours (or 2 months) and 250 patient encounters in the care of children in an ambulatory setting, including acute and chronic conditions and well care.
    • 40 newborn patient encounters, including well and ill newborns.
    • 100 hours (or 1 month) or 125 patient encounters dedicated to the care of the older patient, including functional assessment, disease prevention and health promotion, and management of patients with multiple chronic diseases.
    • 1,650 in-person patient encounters in a family medical practice setting.
It is small wonder, then, that only 20% of surveyed North American orthopedic surgeons thought that chiropractors have sufficient clinical training. This opinion, these authors note:
may contribute to low rates of MD to DC referrals.
Personally, I imagine it’s a combination of factors, not wanting to subject their patients to rank quackery being one of them.
Policy makers and the public know little about chiropractic education and training, which takes place in small, independent schools not connected to the mainstream American university system. Their educational system, including the examinations that allow one to become licensed, are completely controlled by chiropractors themselves and there has been never been an independent investigation of the adequacy of their education and training. The authors of this small study are not independent of that system – they are themselves chiropractors. However, they are to be congratulated for providing some illuminating statistics highlighting the inadequacy of chiropractic clinical education. This includes the disturbing fact that a chiropractor, who has no legal limitation on the age of the patients he sees and few on the conditions he can claim he treats, can go into practice having seen only uncomplicated MSK conditions in his entire clinical training and not a single pediatric patient.

October is National Chiropractic Health Month!
Jann Bellamy on October 1, 2015
Link

October is National Chiropractic Health Month (NCHM) and chiropractors can’t resist the opportunity to overstate, obfuscate, and prevaricate in celebration.
They do this in the face of some unfortunate (for them) statistics revealed by a recent Gallup Poll. The Poll was paid for by Palmer College of Chiropractic as part of an effort to increase the chiropractic share of the health care pie. (There is also a secondary analysis of the poll in the Journal of Manipulative and Physiological Therapeutics.) We’ll get to those stats in a few minutes.
But first, in celebration of NCHM, the American Chiropractic Association (ACA) has produced a set of six graphics chiropractors can download and display. Four of them fudge on the facts. Let’s take a look at these graphics, compare them to the evidence cited in support of their claims, and see where the ACA went astray. (The ACA also hosted a twitter chat yesterday with the hashtag #PainFreeNation.)
The study cited as evidence for this graphic actually compared both manual thrust manipulation (MTM) and mechanical-assisted manipulation (MAM) to each other as well as manipulation versus usual medical care (UMC). Although MAM, such as the Activator Method, is the second most common manipulation technique used by American chiropractors, is increasing in popularity among them, and is touted to be a safe and effective alternative to MTM, this study found that MTM is more effective (at 4 weeks) than MAM and that MAM had no advantage over UMC. But you don’t see that in this graphic.
The study did not look at “Prescribed Medications vs. Spinal Manipulation” at all. UMC consisted of this:
participants were told that most new episodes of back pain are typically self-limiting, were prescribed over-the-counter analgesic and nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs medications [sic], given advice to stay physically active and avoid prolonged bed rest.
Other limitations not revealed in the graphic, but discussed in the study:
    • no placebo control,
    • participants were unblinded as to treatment,
    • the differences among the groups at 4 weeks were not significant at 3 and 6 months,
    • modest size of study, and
    • 3 UMC visits versus 8 for the chiropractic treatments.
Also not mentioned was conflicting evidence from other studies, including a 2013 Cochrane Review Update, which concluded that SMT (spinal manipulative therapy):
is no more effective for acute low back pain than inert interventions, sham SMT or as adjunct therapy. SMT also seems to be no better than other recommended therapies.
Most importantly, given that most acute back pain will get better on its own, the authors said:
We could not determine what portion of the healing response was attributable to natural history, direct treatment effect, and/or nonspecific factors, because there was no natural-history control.
Plus, there was this gem from the study’s authors: “Segmental levels where the manipulation was applied was determined by using palpation and the Activator method of leg length analysis,” a totally bogus diagnostic method. And here we’ve been promised that NCCIH, which funded the study, wasn’t going to do this sort of thing anymore. By the way, how did this nonsense slip pass the University of Pittsburg Institutional Review Board?
This is yet another attempt by “CAM” practitioners to exploit current concerns regarding overprescribing of opioid painkillers to shill for their own practices. It is ironic that the red flags of over-prescription were raised by, and are being addressed by, the medical community, in an honest attempt to face up to the problem and find solutions. You will find almost no comparable public discussion of the many deficiencies of chiropractic practices by chiropractors.
This sensationalistic graphic is meaningless in the context of chiropractic practice. It is entirely correct that chiropractors don’t prescribe opioids, because their practice acts don’t allow it, the reason being that they lack the proper education and training. The ACA didn’t even get the citation right. The statistics are from Volkow NC, et al., “Characteristics of opioid prescriptions in 2009.” JAMA. 2011; 305(13): 1299-1301. These are simply raw statistics that do not account for why the prescriptions were written or whether prescribing was appropriate.
I’m afraid not. The study cited by the ACA as evidence did not say anything about cost effectiveness. Funded by the ACA (so they, of all people, should know the results), it analyzed the experience of one Tennessee-based general health insurer and found that its claimants “had lower overall episode costs for treatment of low back pain if they initiated care with a DC, when compared to those who initiated care with an MD.”
As Scott Gavura said, don’t call CAM cost effective unless it is actually effective. And as Harriet Hall pointed out, you can reduce costs to zero by eliminating care altogether, which we can all agree is not a good solution.
Once again, the ACA can’t even get the title of its graphic right. They would have you believe that all of these are treatments are for “neck pain.” In fact, none of them are exclusively for neck pain. Spine surgery includes all spine surgery. Cervical spine surgery includes surgery for such things as scoliosis and fractures. NSAID/aspirin use comprises many uses, including those not according to directions. This is likely true of opioid use as well, although we are not provided with the actual content of the e-mail on which they rely for this figure. (And, I would imagine, includes criminal use.) Even cervical manipulation isn’t always for neck pain. Chiropractors “adjust” the neck if the putative “subluxation” is found there, no matter what the patient’s complaint.
But wait, that’s not all:
    • No risk-benefit analysis. No matter how small the risk, no treatment is worth it if it confers no benefit. For example, there is no benefit from neck manipulation for “maintenance treatment.”
    • No information on pre-existing conditions that may complicate treatment. It may well be that the 80-year-old with cardiovascular disease had a surgical complication. How do you compare that to the healthy 20-year-old who suffered a stroke following chiropractic neck manipulation?
    • Lack of uniformity in outcomes. Why are all serious side effects from cervical spine surgery counted but all not serious side effects of cervical manipulation?
This is simply a grab bag of statistics thrown together to tamp down any legitimate criticism of the risks of neck manipulation, which is, in any event, not accurately reflected in this chart. The study cited used chiropractic malpractice claims, which are not indicative of actual risk. Other studies report a range of one in 400,000 to one in 5.8 million manipulations
Of course when you are facing:
    • The American Heart Association and the American Stroke Association (with approval by the American Academy of Neurology), stating: “practitioners should both strongly consider the possibility of CD [cervical dissection] and inform patients of the statistical association between CD and CMT [cervical manipulative therapy], prior to performing manipulation of the cervical spine.”
    • A lack of evidence that cervical manipulation is beneficial even for a plausible use, that is, neck pain.
    • A recent, and unflattering, analysis of the Cassidy study: “Prior studies grossly misclassified cases of cervical dissection and mistakenly dismissed a causal association with manipulation. Our study indicates that the OR [Odds Ratio] for spinal manipulation exposure in cervical artery dissection is higher than previously reported.”
    • A Gallup poll showing that almost 25% of the public thinks chiropractic is dangerous.
you simply do what you have to do.
The deficiencies in the ACA’s celebratory graphics I found are based on a layman’s interpretation of the evidence. A more sophisticated analysis might well discover more problems. (And you are welcome to point them out.) The ACA fully realizes that few people will actually look behind their claims and even fewer would be able to decipher the evidence they cite.
Galluping right along
As promised, back to that Gallup Poll, which, as noted, is decidedly a mixed bag for chiropractors. In spite of this, the ACA, the International Chiropractors Association (ICA), and Palmer Chiropractic College are soldiering on, trying to spin the poll to achieve a positive result. I’m not so sanguine.
Undoubtedly, the most distressing among the stats was the revelation that an MD is the first choice of 54% of American adults when choosing a health care provider for back or neck pain, versus only 29% who would choose a chiropractor. In fact, of all health care providers listed, 69% would not choose a chiropractor first. (This question was predicated on the assumption that the cost was about the same.) When your bread and butter is back and neck pain, this is not particularly good news.
Nevertheless, Palmer Chiropractic College made the most of it with this graphic:
Wait a minute. Where’d the 57% come from? This was determined by asking those surveyed about their choices six ways from Sunday. Of those whose first choice was a medical doctor, physical therapist, massage therapist, acupuncturist or other provider, 58% said they would see a chiropractor only if all other treatment methods didn’t work. However, somehow they picked out a group of “expected users” and “likely users” by rejiggering the numbers and reached the conclusion that 57% were actually “likely to see” a chiropractor for neck or back pain, even though this number includes those whose first choice was not a chiropractor. Go figure.
Perhaps to boost these disappointing numbers, Palmer also includes the misleadingly named “neck treatment” comparison available from the ACA.
To be fair, there is another graphic with the all stats comparing health care providers, but, of course, no one has to show that one if they don’t want to.
61.4% of those surveyed agreed that chiropractic was effective in treating back or neck pain. Again, considering that back and neck pain is the chiropractor’s bread and butter, it would be cold comfort to learn that almost 40% of adults did not think you were effective at your job. There was a similar result on the question of trustworthiness. A little over half of respondents agreed that chiropractors were trustworthy, which means a little under one-half don’t think they can be trusted.
This did not dampen the ICA’s enthusiasm for the poll’s results. The ICA announced, in an email, that “nearly 70 percent of the study participants indicat[ed] that chiropractic care is effective with neck and back pain.” When I took math, if we were measuring in 10s, 61.4% would be rounded down to 60%, not up to 70%, which appears to be what happened. And a poll is not a “study,” nor can it determine the effectiveness of a treatment. Undeterred by such subtleties, the ICA’s headline for this announcement claimed:
Gallup study highlights chiropractic effectiveness and popularity with neck/back pain.
70% of those surveyed believe they know what chiropractors do. Which is interesting because chiropractors themselves can’t agree what it is they do. Some chiropractors think they are primary care physicians and should be able to prescribe drugs. Others think they are spine care specialists who treat musculoskeletal problems. Still others hold on to the notion that phantasmagoric blockages in “nerve energy” running through the spine (the illusory “vertebral subluxation“) can affect bodily function and that chiropractic “adjustments” are effective for all manner of ills.
So what is it that everyone else thinks chiropractors do, even if they don’t know themselves? Of the 12% of respondents who have actually seen a chiropractor in the last 5 years (“chiropractic users”), 41% want to see a chiropractors only for back and neck pain, while the same percentage disagree that they would see their chiropractor for these health issues only, although we are not told just what other problems they would see a DC for.
60% of chiropractic users want to see a chiropractor only if they are in pain, but 31% want to see a chiropractor on a regular basis, even if not in pain. (Again, this is 31% of the 12% who have actually seen a chiropractor within the last 5 years.) I would bet that many of these have been lured into regular treatments for “maintenance care,” based on the totally unproven and highly implausible idea that regular spinal “adjustments” are necessary to maintain one’s health.
There’s bad news here for the “DC as PCP” proponents: of chiropractic users, only 9% would choose their chiropractor as the first healthcare provider they want to talk to about their health. (You can find the entire SBM series on the “DC as PCP” here.) Even then, “talk about their health,” which is the way the question was phrased, is pretty general. I have to imagine a much different result if you started naming specific health issues normally treated by PCPs, such as cardiovascular disease or diabetes. Or even the question: “Do you regard your chiropractor as your PCP?” More users (22%) would talk to their chiropractors about general wellness issues, such as diet and nutrition, but almost 60% of users would not.
They can’t blame the MDs for the bad news. Only 13% of respondents said they had been discouraged from going to a chiropractor by an MD, although that figure rose to 21% for the chiropractic users.
Finally, nearly half of all respondents think chiropractors need only 4-6 years of education beyond high school to become a chiropractor. Palmer is all over this one with another graphic. Obviously, the implication here is that the “degree requirements” for a D.C. degree are about equal to that of an M.D. or D.O. degree. I have no idea if these figures are even correct because I couldn’t find them anywhere in the source listed.
Using this same measure of comparison, I can make the argument that high school is more than equal to college:
High school: 3,600-4,000 “educational hours”
College: 2,160-2,700 (also here) “educational hours”
See how easy it is?
Conclusion: Lies, damned lies, and statistics
Figures often beguile me, particularly when I have the arranging of them myself; in which case the remark attributed to Disraeli would often apply with justice and force: ‘There are three kinds of lies: lies, damned lies, and statistics.’
Mark Twain, Chapters from My Autobiography

   No Education? No Training? No License? No Problem!
Jann Bellamy 
Link
When Daniel David Palmer, the inventor of chiropractic, and his acolytes first took up the practice of chiropractic, around the turn of the last century, they were jailed for the unlicensed practice of medicine. If history had left them there, we might not be fighting a continuing battle with the pseudoscience that is “alternative” medicine today.
Unfortunately, the Kansas legislature intervened on the chiropractors’ behalf and passed the first chiropractic practice act in 1913. Over the years, state by state, the notions that subluxations interfere with nerve flow, causing ill health, and that only chiropractors could “correct” these subluxations, thereby restoring health, were incorporated into state law. As well, chiropractors were given a broad scope of practice and allowed to call themselves “doctor.” In 1974, Louisiana’s passage of a chiropractic practice act made chiropractic legal in all 50 states.
Acupuncturists and naturopaths copied this successful formula by convincing state legislatures to incorporate their pseudoscientific ideas directly into practice acts, thereby managing to become licensed health care providers. Legislative fiat triumphed over scientific facts time after time.
Laws allowing the practice of “alternative” medicine did not totally eliminate resistance to pseudoscientific practices from some quarters. Insurance companies, for example, refused to pay for treatments they considered experimental. Medicare did not cover chiropractic. Labs and x-ray facilities wouldn’t allow use of their services. But for each roadblock science tried to put in the way, state and federal legislators were there to remove it, paving the way toward “acceptance.”
Finally, even medical doctors were unable to resist the enticing smell of money wafting over from “alternative” clinics. Again legislators smoothed the transition from medicine to “alternative” medicine by effectively doing away with a science-based standard of care.
Still, this was not enough in the eyes of some. It deprived those seeking “health freedom” the “right” to choose whatever health care they wanted from whatever practitioner they wanted. So the legislatures of three states — Minnesota (2000),Rhode Island (2002) and New Mexico (2009 ) — came up with an equitable solution by essentially setting up a separate health care profession: the unlicensed practice of health care. In fact, the laws of both Rhode Island and New Mexico are titled the “Unlicensed Health Care Practice Act.” At least they’re up front about it.
(Arizona, California, Idaho, Louisiana and Oklahoma also provide some legal cover for unlicensed practitioners, mainly by protecting them from prosecution for the practice of medicine.)
Ironically, these laws are promoted as public safety measures, so that the state can exercise some control over health care practices not officially licensed. Perhaps some legislators really believe this is effective — as opposed to, say, requiring that all practices have a plausible basis in science and maybe even some evidence of effectiveness.
The acts passed by Rhode Island and Minnesota are almost identical. New Mexico’s is more liberal, but contains many of the same provisions. This suggests these laws are based on templates fed to drafters by promoters of “health freedom” and are passed with few changes.
The statutes contain various provisions common to licensed health care practice acts: a supervisory authority, a bill of rights for the consumer, reporting requirements, confidentiality requirements, prohibitions on sex with patients (who are called “clients” in Minnesota and Rhode Island), and penalties for violations.
On the other hand, no malpractice insurance is required nor is there a specific provision for informed consent of the patient/client. As is common with other licensed “alternative” practitioners, unlicensed practitioners can’t perform surgery, prescribe drugs, invade the human body, use medical devices, or practice dentistry. They also cannot manipulate or adjust the articulations of joints or the spine, obviously in deference to the chiropractic lobby.
Then things get really weird.
First, other than as stated above, there is virtually no limitation on what these unlicensed practitioners can do, as long as it falls into “the broad domain of complementary and alternative healing methods and treatments.” Given the facts that (1) these “healing methods” are made up, and (2) some are of fairly recent origin (e.g., cranial sacral therapy), it appears reasonable to conclude that one can simply create a “healing method,” call it “alternative,” and set up shop. The unemployed should take note.
Specifically mentioned in the statutes as permissible treatments are acupressure, Alexander technique, aroma therapy, ayurveda, craniosacral therapy, crystal therapy, detoxification practices and therapies, energetic healing (as opposed to the lethargic kind, I guess), Rolfing, Gerson therapy, colostrum therapy, therapeutic touch, herbology, herbalism, polarity therapy, homeopathy, nondiagnostic iridology, Qi Gong, culturally traditional healing practices, anthroposophy, folk practices, healing practices utilizing food, dietary supplements, nutrients, and the physical forces of heat, cold, water, touch, and light, healing touch, homeopathy, body work, massage, meditation, mind-body healing practices, naturopathy, noninvasive instrumentalities, holistic kinesiology and other muscle testing techniques. However, it’s made clear in the statutes that this list is not meant as a limitation on the therapies which can be legally offered to the public.
Minnesota and Rhode Island add an extra layer of practitioner protection: having already ok’d unlicensed alternative medicine “healing methods,” these states assure practitioners on the cutting edge of pseudo-medicine that use of a “less customary approach” will not per se subject them to discipline. So now we have conventional alternative medicine and alternative alternative medicine? If the “less customary approach” is used with conventional alternative medicine, should we call it complementary alternative alternative medicine? So much to figure out!
Unlicensed practitioners cannot provide a “medical diagnosis,” or, as New Mexico puts it, the practitioner cannot “make a specific conventional medical diagnosis,” which is “a medical term that is commonly used and understood in conventional western medicine.” In another dig at “conventional western medicine,” plain old prescription drugs become “dangerous drugs” under New Mexico law. A “dangerous drug” is defined as “a drug that is required by applicable federal or state law or rule to be dispensed pursuant to a prescription.” Thus unlicensed practitioners are prohibited from prescribing or dispensing “dangerous drugs.”
To make sure unlicensed practitioners don’t pull one over on the public, Minnesota and Rhode Island (but not New Mexico) list as “prohibited conduct:”
“Advertising that is false, fraudulent, deceptive or misleading;” and
“Conduct likely to deceive, defraud, or harm the public.”
Good luck with that!
As further public protection, these states require their own version of a written quack Miranda warning. For example:
THE STATE OF MINNESOTA HAS NOT ADOPTED ANY EDUCATIONAL AND TRAINING STANDARDS FOR UNLICENSED COMPLEMENTARY AND ALTERNATIVE HEALTH CARE PRACTITIONERS BUT WE ARE GOING TO LET THEM PRACTICE MEDICINE ANYWAY.
Actually, I made up that last part, after “PRACTITIONERS.” The rest is right out of the statutes.
As part of disclosure requirements, this must be followed by,
THIS STATEMENT OF CREDENTIALS IS FOR INFORMATION PURPOSES ONLY.
These “credentials” are “the degrees, training, experience, or other qualifications of the practitioner regarding the complementary and alternative health care being provided.” Considering this, the reader might look into investing in the diploma mill industry.
And note that credentials aren’t required — it’s just that if you have some you must let the client know what they are.
Perhaps to prevent their states from becoming havens for parents who want unrestricted access to “alternative” practices for their children, both Minnesota and Rhode Island (but, again, not New Mexico) make clear that “a parent who obtains complementary and alternative health care for the parent’s minor child is not relieved the duty to seek necessary medical care [for the child].” In fact, unlicensed practitioners are required to report to the authorities that a child is not receiving necessary medical care, although if the practitioner’s world view dictates that medical care is unnecessary, what happens then?
Minnesota prevents the unlicensed practitioner from using the title “doctor,” “Dr.” or “physician.” Rhode Island prevents “false or misleading” use of these terms. New Mexico simply prevents the practitioner from describing himself as a “licensed doctor or physician.”
That New Mexico! Here’s what else they do there. The other two states, as might be expected, prevent a person from providing unlicensed services if he has been convicted of a felony. Not New Mexico! The convicted felon is prevented from practicing only until he satisfies the terms of his sentence. After that, it’s back to aromatherapy, iridology, polarity therapy, or whatever else he was up to before his unfortunate encounter with the criminal justice system.
I must ask: Is it really good public policy to allow a convicted thief such easy access to a person’s wallet?
And here’s the best part, saved for last: Minnesota and Rhode Island require the practitioner to provide, in writing, “a brief summary, in plain language, of the theoretical approach used by the practitioner in providing services to clients.” What we wouldn’t give to see that! In fact, if you are ever in either of these states, be sure to have a complementary or alternative health care treatment from an unlicensed practitioner, and be sure to get your written, plain language summary of her “theoretical approach.” Send it to me here. [After, of course, signing a complete release absolving me of all liability for anything bad that happens to you at the hands of the unlicensed practitioner.] If my SBM editors agree to it, I’ll write a post about them. And bonus points for any summary containing the phrase “on a quantum level.”
Jann J. Bellamy is a Florida attorney. She left the active practice of law in 2006 to form a non-profit, the Campaign for Science-Based Healthcare, which educates the public about “alternative” healthcare claims and advocates for a state law requiring that all healthcare offered in Florida meet a basic scientific standard. She is also a columnist for Health News Florida.

Dept. of Education to Council on Chiropractic Education: “Straighten Up!”
Jann Bellamy on June 28, 2012
Link
Our last look at the Council on Chiropractic Education (CCE), about 18 months ago, found the CCE deeply embroiled in a heated dispute among various chiropractic factions over new accreditation standards for chiropractic colleges. Today we offer an update on that situation.
Update: the CCE is deeply embroiled in a heated dispute among various chiropractic factions over new accreditation standards for chiropractic colleges.
As you may recall, the CCE, which accredits chiropractic colleges in the U.S., stood accused of removing the subluxation from its standards for accreditation, so that chiropractic students would no longer be required to learn how to “detect” and “correct” the putative vertebral subluxation. Of course, the chiropractic subluxation doesn’t exist, but we’ll get to that in a minute. This brouhaha was raised by the more traditional wing of the chiropractic community, called “straights,” whose practice (and livelihood) is based on convincing patients that their spines need “adjustments” to remove these subluxations under the threat of ill health should they be left unattended. The straights were also upset at the move by another faction of chiropractic seeking to rebrand chiropractors as primary care physicians who diagnose and treat a wide variety of diseases and conditions.
By way of background, the CCE’s standards for admission to chiropractic colleges are, to my knowledge, the lowest of any program awarding a doctoral degree. (See Policy No. 6 in link.) As you likely know, a student can’t get into graduate school in the standard American college or university (even to pursue a master’s degree, much less a Ph.D) without first obtaining an undergraduate degree and attaining an acceptable score on the Graduate Record Exam. Other graduate programs — such as law, veterinary and medical schools — have their own rigorous entrance exams. (You can find an outline of the topics covered by the Medical School Admissions Test here.) Not chiropractic college. A student need not have an acceptable exam score because there is no entrance exam for chiropractic college. In fact, the student doesn’t even need a college degree – only 90 undergraduate hours, including 24 hours of basic science courses, and a 2.5 (“C”) average. In other words, the entrance requirements for a D.C. degree are less selective than those for a master’s degree in one of the sciences.
Straighten up!
To redress their grievances, the straights organized a campaign to attack the CCE during its review by the U.S. Department of Education (DOE), which was required to retain its status as the sole national accrediting agency for American chiropractic colleges. Instead of evaluating higher education institutions itself, the DOE parcels this job out to private accreditation agencies but makes these agencies meet certain standards. Each accrediting agency is reviewed by the DOE every 5 years and it was CCE’s turn at bat. Reviews are conducted for the DOE by the National Committee on Institutional Quality and Integrity (NACIQI).
Accreditation is key to colleges and universities because it opens the door to taxpayer-funded loans for their students. States also use CCE accreditation in determining whether to accept a degree from a particular chiropractic college in licensing decisions.
A DOE staff analysis found that the CCE was not in compliance with 44 of the criteria for accrediting agencies outlined in the Code of Federal Regulations. This included failure to comply with regulations governing conflicts of interest, record keeping, processing of student complaints and the adequacy of its site review of accredited chiropractic colleges. (The DOE staff’s full report covers a number of accrediting agencies and is not numbered sequentially. You can find the section on CCE by scrolling down to page 61 of the PDF.)
The staff report noted that one chief concern of the dissenters was the elimination of the term “subluxation” from the CCE’s standards. In a response clearly demonstrating that a science-based education is of no concern to the DOE, the staff report stated:
This is a professional issue within the chiropractic community. Staff concludes that it is beyond the purview of the Department to dictate to any [accrediting] agency what its curriculum requirements and accreditation standards should be.
In other words, feel free to teach implausible and unproven concepts of human anatomy and physiology to students who will become licensed health care providers. That is not our job.
One particularly glaring omission in the CCE’s oversight of chiropractic education was in determining how many credit hours a college assigned to its courses. The DOE requires all accrediting agencies
to conduct an effective review and evaluation of the reliability and accuracy of the institution’s assignment of credit hours. . . . The agency is required to make a determination whether the institution’s assignment of credit hours conforms to commonly accepted practices.
It wasn’t that the CCE’s policies and procedures were insufficient. Rather, the CCE totally failed to address this criterion at all. This, it seems to me, is a crucial gap in the record, for it goes to the very heart of the quality of an institution’s education. Without this information we can’t know if schools are inflating the number of hours credited to coursework. Credit hours assigned to courses becomes a virtually meaningless figure.
The straight’s attack on the CCE was prolific, if ultimately only partially successful. The NACIQI received approximately 4,000 comments regarding the CCE during its review, only 30 of which were supportive. Although many of the negative comments were simply copies of the same complaint, it does indicate some level of dissatisfaction among the approximately 50,000 practicing chiropractors in the U.S.
The NACIQI voted 12-0 to accept the DOE staff’s report on the CCE’s noncompliance. In light of the many complaints, the NACIQI told the CCE to demonstrate wide acceptance by chiropractors of its standards, policies, procedures and decisions “and to address how its standards advance quality in chiropractic education.” This, as well as the 44 shortcomings found by staff, must be remedied in 12 months.
The DOE’s final decision, in a letter to the CCE dated March 15th, accepted the NACIQI’s recommendation on all points except the added requirement that the CCE demonstrate wide acceptance. The recognition of CCE was continued provisionally for 12 months in order for the CCE to bring itself into compliance. It has 30 days after that to submit a full report on compliance, at which time the DOE will make a final decision regarding recognition. The DOE reminded the CCE that granting extensions of time to come into compliance were rare, and failure to achieve compliance in the additional time allotted would, in accordance with federal law, result in refusal to recognize CCE as an accrediting agency.
Interestingly, the Chair of CCE failed to mention the full extent of the DOE’s ruling in a March 20th memo to “Interested Parties and Stakeholders.” Rather, he opted to describe the DOE’s decision this way:
We would like to publicly acknowledge the U.S. Department of Education’s recent decision to renew its recognition of CCE. On March 15, 2012 CCE received written notification that the Secretary of Education, after performing a thorough review of our evidence, and following comprehensive and careful analysis of recommendations made by the Department Staff and National Advisory Committee on Institutional Quality and Integrity (NACIQI), decided to ‘continue CCE’s recognition as a nationally recognized accrediting agency.’
Looks like he left out a few important details.
The International Chiropractors Association, an organization representing straight chiropractors, was obviously unsatisfied with the DOE’s decision, as potentially devastating as it was. It is asking chiropractors to get in touch with their Congressmen to straighten this situation out. (I’m not sure what Congress can do, given that this decision is within the jurisdiction of the DOE.)
The subluxation stays
Right before its appearance before the NACIQI, the beleaguered CCE wrote “An open letter to the profession” trying to quell the controversy over its accreditation standards. It labeled a “myth” the assertion that it was trying to remove all mention of the subluxation from the standards and that students no longer have to know how to assess for subluxation. Not true, says the CCE: We didn’t eliminate it, we just moved it to the “meta-competencies” section of our policies, which describes what students of accredited programs must be able to do. And, true to the CCE’s claim, there it is, under “Meta-Competency 1 – Assessment and Diagnosis.”
C. Performing case-appropriate physical examinations that include evaluations of body regions and organ systems, including the spine and any subluxation/neuro-biomechanical dysfunction that assist the clinician in developing the clinical diagnosis(es).
Neuro-biomechnical dysfunction? What’s that? As the CCE explains in its letter,
Between the three drafts and the final 2012 Standards, subluxation received considerable attention by the Task Force and the Council. Despite its historical legacy in the profession, a number of educational programs and practitioners have opted to use other terms, such as joint fixation or joint dysfunction. [And, I might add, manipulable lesion, spinal lesion, etc., etc.] Even the Association of Chiropractic Colleges (ACC) has not reached a unified definition or specific criteria for subluxation, despite its own task force addressing this issue. The 2012 Standards opted to use a combination phrase, ‘subluxation/neuro-biomechnical dysfunction.’
So, in summary, although chiropractic’s two leading educational organizations devoted considerable attention to the issue, we don’t know what a subluxation is or how to define it. Nevertheless, we chiropractors give it a bunch of different names so, to add to the confusion, we invented another one. And, even though we don’t know what they are, we are going to make chiropractic students learn to detect and correct these subluxations/neuro-biomechanical dysfunctions or whatever you want to call them.
Another “myth” busted by the CCE was the contention that the standards no longer require students to learn to “adjust.” Again, not true. It’s right there in the meta-competencies that the student must “provide appropriate chiropractic adjustments and/or manipulation procedures.” But, the dissenters protested, that means that the college could teach only manipulation and not adjustments. What’s the difference, you ask? Well, manipulation is a plausible non-CAM manual therapy with some evidence of effectiveness employed by physical therapists, physiatrists, osteopaths, and chiropractors. It’s purpose is to reduce pain, increase joint range of motion, and address other physical manifestations of joint impairment. An adjustment is a means of correcting the non-existent subluxation. But, as the CCE notes, “many in our profession use the terms adjustment and manipulation interchangeably” so manipulation, to a chiropractor (but no one else), is also a “therapy” used to correct the subluxation. Got that?
The CCE also labeled as a “myth” the allegation that it was “forcing colleges to teach students how to prescribe. CCE is changing the profession into Medicine.”Once again, not true, says the CCE — there is no requirement that the DC curriculum include “prescriptive medications or pharmacology,” although it could if the college wanted it to. However, there is a requirement that the DC curriculum include “toxicology.” According to the CCE “many DCPs [Doctor of Chiropractic programs] see this as an opportunity to include instruction on the adverse health effects of medications.” So, although they need not have any training in pharmacology, DCs are presumably sufficiently educated by a course in “toxicology” to understand “the adverse health effect of medications.”
Bad Press
As if all this weren’t enough, a series of articles in The Chronicle of Higher Education appeared over the last few months which hung some dirty chiropractic laundry out to dry in plain sight of all of academia. First, not one, but two, articles in the Chronicle detailed the CCE’s fight with the straights as well as the drubbing it got from the DOE. The Chronicle summarized the DOE’s message to the CCE as a demand to “clean up its act within a year.”
Then came two more Chronicle articles exposing the high salaries and nepotism among chiropractic college presidents and their administrations. One article detailed how, in spite of declining chiropractic college enrollment, “the presidents of chiropractic colleges are taking in some of the biggest paychecks in higher education.” One example: In 2009, the president of Logan College of Chiropractic earned $791,418, an amount equal to 3 % of the college’s entire budget. This is about the same compensation paid to the president of the California Institute of Technology (yes, Cal Tech!) which has a $2.3 billion budget, or, as the Chronicle reporter calculated, 90 times the budget of Logan. The president of Parker University (formerly Parker Chiropractic College) earned about the same as the president of Brown University and the salary of Cleveland Chiropractic College’s president was comparable to that of Vassar’s. All of this raised eyebrows among several experts consulted by the Chronicle, who cited potential problems with the IRS and “governance weaknesses” indicated by the unusually high salaries.
Most recently, a piece appeared in Forbes questioning the use of taxpayer funds to subsidize chiropractic education through student loans. Author Steven Salzberg specifically noted chiropractic belief in subluxations, which, as he correctly points out, “have not even been shown to exist.” Referencing the recent controversy over college student loans, Salzberg asked:
But what about institutions that provide a substandard education? Or worse, what about institutions that educate people in quackery and pseudoscience? Subsidies to these institutions are worse than useless. These so-called colleges spread misinformation that will require much more investment to correct, if it is even possible. Why, to be specific, is the U.S. government subsidizing students to attend chiropractic colleges?
The answer: we shouldn’t.
Perhaps the CCE’s poor showing in front of the DOE and this spate of bad publicity will awaken policy makers to the deficiencies of an educational system that tolerates “CAM” education. At the least, the DOE should refuse to recognize credentialing agencies which fail to require science-based education for health care providers. This would stop the flow of student loans to these schools and eliminate wasting even more taxpayer dollars on pseudoscience. Without student loans these schools could not survive. That would go a long way in eliminating quackery in our health care system.

   Legislative Alchemy II: Chiropractic
Jann Bellamy
Link
As we learned in Legislative Alchemy I: Naturopathy, legislative alchemy is the process used by state legislatures to transform implausible and unproven diagnostic methods and treatments into legal health care practices.
Today, we review how chiropractors are faring in the 2011 state legislative sessions.
Chiropractic 101
In 1895, a self-described “magnetic healer,” Daniel David Palmer, claimed to have discovered that every person possessed an “Innate Intelligence,” defined as the body’s capacity to heal itself, which flowed from the brain out through the nerves in the spinal cord. Misaligned vertebrae impinged on nerves and interfered with the flow of Innate Intelligence, causing “95 percent of all disease.”
Palmer named these putative misalignments “subluxations,” and began teaching students how to detect and correct them based on his notion that removing this interference would return the free flow of Innate Intelligence and the body would heal itself. In other words, chiropractic was — and, as we shall see, still is — simply another form of vitalism, a long-discredited notion that illnesses are caused by a disturbance or imbalance of the body’s “vital force,” which is distinct from the body’s biochemical processes.
Palmer and his disciples were arrested for practicing medicine without a license, which led to a strategy of chiropractors lobbying state legislatures for their own chiropractic practice acts. This effort stretched from 1913, when Kansas became the first state to license chiropractors, to 1974, when Louisiana became the last.
Subluxation: it’s the law
The non-existent chiropractic subluxation remains the central tenet of the 50 state chiropractic practice acts to this day.[1]
Twenty-one state chiropractic acts mention it specifically as the basis for chiropractic practice. For example, Connecticut defines chiropractic practice as:
the science of adjustment, manipulation and treatment of the human body in which vertebral subluxations and other malpositioned articulations and structures that may interfere with the normal generation, transmission and expression of nerve impulse between the brain, organs and tissue cells of the body, which may be a cause of the disease, are adjusted, manipulated or treated.
Twenty-three states refer to its purported attributes — without actually using the “s” word. In North Carolina, chiropractic practice is defined as:
the science of adjusting the cause of the disease by realigning the spine, releasing pressure on nerves radiating from the spine to all parts of the body, and allowing the nerves to carry their full quota of health current (nerve energy) from the brain to all parts of the body.
Did they say “science”? Here’s how much science is involved in chiropractic’s core concept — there’s not even a plausible hypothesis of what a subluxation is or how it might affect human functioning.
Six states simply incorporate by reference practices and procedures taught in chiropractic schools, which remain loyal to the subluxation although some have tried to distance themselves from the word, if not the concept.
This doesn’t mean, of course, that chiropractors are permitted by law to treat any disease or condition by detecting and correcting subluxations, just most any disease or condition, as long as the problem is defined in terms of the patient’s having one or more subluxations stopping up the “flow” of “nerve energy.” Asthma, allergies, ADHD, painful periods and earaches are a few of the many conditions widely advertised as treatable by chiropractic adjustment.
You might think it would cause the chiropractic industry some alarm that legislators might wake up to the fact that subluxations don’t exist. And apparently that is the case. In a few states chiropractors are attempting to expand the chiropractic scope of practice by including authority to prescribe that former anathema to chiropractic: drugs. For years chiropractors branded themselves as doctors who treat patients “without drugs or surgery.”
With drugs but not surgery
Chiropractic lobbying in New Mexico, the state where anyone can practice medicine, provides a perfect lesson in the insidious nature of CAM practitioner licensing. A few years ago, the state legislature invented a new iteration of chiropractor, the “certified advanced practice chiropractic physician.” With minimal training, this new type can, by statute, “prescribe, administer and dispense herbal medicines, homeopathic medicine, over-the-counter drugs, vitamins, minerals, enzymes, glandular products, protomorphogens, live cell products, gerovital, amino acids, dietary supplements, foods for special dietary use, bioidentical hormones, sterile water, sterile saline, sarapin or its generic, caffeine, procaine, oxygen , epinephrine and vapocoolants.”
Then, in 2009, the New Mexico legislature granted the state chiropractic board authority to develop a formulary for the “advanced practice chiropractic physician.” The requirement that substances be “natural or naturally derived” was eliminated, but there was a catch: “Dangerous drugs or controlled substances, drugs for administration by injection and substances not listed [in the quoted section, above] shall be submitted to the board of pharmacy and the New Mexico medical board for approval.”
Apparently, approval was not forthcoming to the chiropractors’ satisfaction, so they returned to the New Mexico legislature this year, seeking to dump the pharmacists and medical doctors. A new, improved version of the “advanced practice chiropractic physician” was proposed: one with a “prescription certificate.”
And just to make the point clear, the term “chiropractic” would be discarded from the New Mexico chiropractic practice act in favor of “chiropractic medicine.” Thus, the purpose of the practice act went from “granting chiropractors the right to practice chiropractic as taught and practiced in standard colleges of chiropractic” to granting “chiropractic physicians the right to practice chiropractic medicine …” [Emphasis added.]
Gone was the requirement of a pharmacy and medical board approved formulary. Instead, those with the “prescription certificate” would be authorized by statute to “prescribe, administer and dispense dangerous drugs, including compounded preparations for topical and oral administration and injection, testosterone in all its forms and codeine in cough syrup.” [Emphasis added.]
One can read between the lines thinking that goes something like: “If the pharmacists and medical doctors won’t let us prescribe testosterone ‘in all its forms’ and cough syrup with codeine, we’ll just put it in the statute and they can’t do a damn thing about it.”
Instead of pharmacy and medical board approval, the proposed legislation provided that “the [chiropractic] board, with the New Mexico Medical Board and the Board of Pharmacy serving in an advisory capacity, and with all parties agreeing to act in good faith, shall establish by rule a formulary …” [Emphasis added.]
Yeah! That’ll show ‘em!
Except the proposed legislation didn’t pass. It was still in committee when the legislature adjourned. New Mexico’s governor recently declared a special session of the legislature to deal with certain pressing problems, such as redistricting, and that has begun. We can only hope the chiropractors don’t try to shoehorn their bill into the special session agenda.
As a cautionary tale about the dangers of mission creep in “CAM” practitioner licensing, it is instructive to look at the education and training which would have been required of the “certified advanced practice chiropractic physician” in obtaining a “prescription certificate.”
In addition to the minimal requirements for “advanced practice” certification, the applicant must complete “pharmacological training from an institution of higher education approved by the [chiropractic] board or from a provider of continuing education approved by the board.” [Emphasis added.]
The applicant must complete a program, again approved by the chiropractic board, of 200 classroom hours in pharmacology, physiology, pathophysiology, physical and lab assessment and clinical pharmacotherapeutics, which, you’ll have to admit, is a really long word. Whether this is simply descriptive of, or in addition to, the education described in the previous paragraph is not clear. What is clear is that all of this can be accomplished within the current chiropractic educational system, a subject to which we will return in a future post.
But where, you might ask, would the chiropractor get experience actually treating patients with drugs, so essential to proper training? Well, remember those pesky medical doctors who were gumming up the formulary works? The ones the legislation sought to remove from the process? From them, that’s who.
In order to get the coveted “prescription certificate,” a chiropractor would have to complete 400 hours “of clinical rotation practicum in clinical assessment and pathophysiology” and 400 hours of 100 patients “with disorders relevant to the certified advanced practice chiropractic physician’s clinical specialty.” All done “under supervision of a medical doctor.”
One must wonder where one would find a medical doctor willing to take on supervision of a chiropractor treating patients with drugs.
A bad idea metastasizes
The chiropractic faction interested in foisting chiropractors as primary care physicians on the public was obviously not going to stop with New Mexico, and it didn’t.
In South Carolina, a bill would have created the same sort of “advanced practice chiropractic physician” as presently exists in New Mexico along with the option of obtaining a “prescription certificate” as proposed in the failed New Mexico legislation. The bill never made it out of the Senate Committee on Medical Affairs.
Likewise, in Alabama, a bill was introduced to allow prescription of “natural” compounds, “bio-identical hormones,” homeopathic remedies and other woo remedies favored by “CAM” practitioners. If the chiropractor took the same sort of 90-hour course as New Mexico allows, he or she could also prescribe and inject these substances even if they were classified as legend drugs. This bill also died in committee.
More scope of practice
Prescription authority was not the only means of increasing ways to make mon … I mean, increasing the scope of chiropractic practice attempted in this year’s legislative sessions.
In Illinois, lobbying efforts took a more subtle approach and attempted only an inclusion of authority to provide advice regarding the use of non-prescription products. Translation: they can advise patients regarding dietary supplements. And, of course, having given that advice, they can sell patients the supplements they’ve recommended. This bill, which also authorized chiropractors to administer atmospheric oxygen, made it into law. A bill in Hawaii, authorizing the use of “clinical nutritional methods” (whatever that means), died in committee.
Minnesota, another state where anyone can practice medicine, saw a failed attempt to include acupuncture within chiropractic scope of practice. Perhaps wary of attempts to make chiropractors actually go to acupuncture school and learn “real” acupuncture, this proposed legislation invented an entirely new form, defined as “a modality of treating abnormal physical conditions by stimulating various points of the body or interruption of the cutaneous integrity by needle insertion to secure a reflex relief of the symptoms by nerve stimulation as used as an adjunct to chiropractic adjustment.” Maybe they should have called it “acujustment”.
And on it goes
Last year, the Connecticut Board of Chiropractic Examiners issued a ruling that chiropractors need not warn patients of the risk of stroke following cervical manipulation, a ruling based largely on a study which specifically states it does not rule out such a risk.
In response, Connecticut Senator Len Fasano promised to introduce legislation in 2011 mandating a warning. Sen. Fasano testified at a hearing before the Board that he and others in the legislature were under the distinct impression the Board would indeed require this type of warning. Obviously, the Board did not do that, so Sen. Fasano kept his promise and introduced a bill requiring chiropractors to obtain informed written consent prior to any treatment of the cervical spine, including information on the risk of stroke. Unfortunately, the bill did not make it to the floor for a vote.
Finally, chiropractic lobbying in Florida screwed up passage of a perfectly good bill designed to protect the public’s health, safety and welfare.
A bill introduced to educate coaches, parents and young athletes about sports-related concussions and to require that an M.D. or D.O. sign off on return to play post-injury passed the House, where an attempt to include chiropractors was rebuffed in committee. However, the bill got bogged down in the Senate because of a similar attempt to force the inclusion of chiropractors in the type of health care practitioner with authority to clear the young athlete for continued play. The implication, of course, was that chiropractors were qualified to diagnose and treat traumatic brain injury, a conclusion not universally shared in the Senate, and rightly so. That squabble ran the clock out on what would have been a laudable safety measure for school athletes. And that’s a shame.
Conclusion
It is unfortunate enough that the state legislatures have legitimized a figment of the imagination first proposed by a charlatan in 1895 — the “subluxation” — by creating a licensed health care profession known as chiropractors to “detect” and “correct” them. Giving chiropractors authority to prescribe dietary supplements, and, even worse, drugs, only exacerbates their original mistake. Instead of expanding the scope of practice, state legislatures should remove diagnosis and treatment of the nonexistent “subluxation” from the chiropractic practice acts.
References
Bellamy J., Legislative Alchemy: the US state chiropractic practice acts, Focus on Complementary and Alternative Therapies (2010)15(3): 214–222.

Legislative Alchemy: Chiropractic 2013
Jann Bellamy on February 21, 2013
Link

Via the magic of legislative alchemy, chiropractors are already licensed health care providers in all 50 states. Thus their legislative efforts tend to focus on expanding their scope of practice and forcing public and private insurers to cover their services, in some cases at the same rate as medical doctors. Those efforts continue in 2013 with 65 bills impacting chiropractors introduced so far. Of those including substantive provisions (as opposed to, say, simply raising fees), only one is not to their advantage.
New Mexico chiropractors are once again attempting expansion of their scope of practice. In 2008 and 2009, the New Mexico legislature created a new iteration of chiropractor, called “the certified advanced practice chiropractic physician.” A certain faction of the chiropractic industry is attempting to rebrand chiropractors nationwide as primary care physicians and this was a signature event in those efforts. With 90 hours of additional education, these advanced practice chiropractors can administer a bevy of dubious remedies, such as bioidentical hormones.
The new law also permitted prescription of dangerous drugs and controlled substances and administration of drugs by injection, but only if on a formulary approved by the state pharmacy and medical boards. The chiropractic board didn’t like having to get approval from pharmacists and medical doctors, so they went ahead and added what they wanted to the formulary, ignoring the other boards despite their own attorney’s advice that they couldn’t do this. This got them into a couple of court battles with the pharmacy and medical boards. The International Association of Chiropractors (ICA), the traditional, subluxation-only chiropractic faction, jumped into the fray to oppose this power grab. The ICA believes chiropractic should remain drug and surgery free.
To rid themselves of annoying pharmacy and medical board oversight, chiropractors again appealed to the legislature last year and got a bill introduced which would, among other things, let them control their own formulary. That bill passed the New Mexico House but not the Senate.
NM chiropractors go for more
Which brings us to this year. The chiropractors are back with a new bill (Senate Bill 471) and a new attempt to expand chiropractic scope of practice and play at being real doctors. Toward this end, the bill liberally sprinkles the word “medicine” throughout the chiropractic practice act, so that a chiropractor (both advanced practice and the plain vanilla kind) would no longer be engaged in the practice of “chiropractic,” but rather of “chiropractic medicine.” Similarly, existing authority to sell “herbs,” “supplements’” and “homeopathic remedies” is transformed into authority to sell “herbal medicine,” “nutritional medicine,” and “homeopathic medicine.” How very grand!
Not only would chiropractors locate and remove subluxations to restore health and treat disease (so old school!), their scope of practice would now include, but not be limited to,
diagnosis and treatment of a condition for which the chiropractic physician [sic] has been educated and trained.
Exactly who would decide whether a chiropractor has been “educated and trained” sufficiently to diagnose and treat a particular condition is not specified.
The bill appears to do away with the limitation on invasive diagnostic procedures to those permitted by chiropractic board rule. (I say “appears to” because the limitation is deleted in one portion of the bill but remains in another. This bill is no model of careful statutory draftsmanship.) Here’s what the board already authorizes chiropractors to perform (as opposed to order – that’s a different list) to date:
The collection and testing of human fluids, such as saliva, blood, urnine, vaginal and seminal fluids, hair, feces, and conventional radiography.
MRI, CT, nuclear scans, ultrasonography; thermography, B.E.A.M. [apparently, Brain Electrical Activity Mapping], EEG, EKG, ECG and surface or needle EMG.
Imagine what chiropractors will do without such limitations, as loose as they are.
But wait, it gets worse
If, up to this point, the words “outrageous,” “dangerous,” “crazy,” and similar descriptives have occurred to you, wait ‘til you see what’s next:
Chiropractic medicine shall exclude operative surgery and prescription of controlled substances except where permitted by statute or rule.
In other words, no operative surgery or controlled substances unless the chiropractic board says it’s ok.
To get the full import of this provision, it must be read together with the proposed expansion of chiropractic scope of practice to include “treatment of a condition for which the chiropractic physician has been educated and trained.” Under existing law, the chiropractic board attempted to include drugs on the formulary for uses which, according to the medical board, were not within the chiropractic scope of practice. This is what got them into a tussle over the formulary. That scope is currently defined in the traditional manner as “locating and removing interference with the transmissions or expression of nerve forces in the human body by the correction of misalignments or subluxations” and “the administering of all natural agents to assist in the healing act,” e.g., herbs, homeopathic products, and the like.
The “we are primary care physicians” faction of chiropractors thought this cramped their style. So if this bill passes, any chiropractic school can “educate and train” chiropractic students in whatever it pleases – say, psychiatry or gastroenterology – and the scope of practice will be practically unlimited, at least in New Mexico. You can bet the chiropractors will try this trick in other states.
The bill is confusing on operative surgery as its provisions are conflicting. The ICA thinks it “potentially” allows operative surgery so we’ll go with that interpretation. I don’t know if this is yet another example of bad drafting or the drafters are just being sneaky.
Thus, under this bill, the chiropractic board, which consists of four chiropractors and two public members, could decide on its own to allow chiropractors to perform operative surgery, “potentially.” There are no requirements in the bill which the board must follow in determining who is qualified to practice surgery or which surgical procedures can be performed, as long as the chiropractor is “educated and trained” in the subject. Chiropractors are forbidden from “procuring, aiding or abetting a criminal abortion,” the implication being that they can perform legal abortions if so “educated and trained.”
Under current law, an “advanced practice” chiropractor must complete 90 clinical and classroom hours and pass a test in addition to the usual requirements for a chiropractic license. The chiropractic board is given sole authority to develop a formulary for the prescription, administration (including by injection) and dispensing of certain substances such as herbal and homeopathic “medicines,” vitamins and minerals, glandular products, live cells products, enzymes, amino acids, lidocaine and procaine for the “advanced practice” chiropractor. To this list the bill adds carbohydrates and sugars. Any substances not listed in the bill can be added to the formulary by the chiropractic board if the pharmacy board approves. Gone is the requirement for medical board approval.
To prescribe, administer or dispense legend (prescription) drugs or Schedule III through V controlled substances, an advanced practice chiropractor must, in addition, hold a prescription certificate. This requires completion of a “primary care clinical rotation” at a chiropractic college or other accredited “institution of higher education or professional school.” The rotation consists of 500 hours of “clinical and hands-on instruction” in clinical pharmacology, evidence-based clinical assessment, clinical pharmacotherapeutics, primary care case management or (not “and” but “or”) patient safety and standards of primary care under the supervision of an M.D., D.O., nurse practitioner or advanced practice chiropractor. No exam is required.
So, let’s see. After what would equal a little more than 6 weeks of a medical residency, all of which could take place in a chiropractic college outpatient clinic, an advanced practice chiropractor could prescribe, administer and dispense Schedule III – V drugs if the chiropractic board wants them on the formulary and the pharmacy board agrees.
Just to further scare you out of your wits, here are a few of New Mexico’s Schedule III – V drugs that caught my untrained eye: anabolic steroids, codeine, testosterone, hydrocodone (Vicodin, Lorcet), morphine, opium, lysergic acid, pentobarbital (Nembutal), alprazolam (Xanax), chloral hydrate, clonazepam (Clonopin), dextropropoxphene, (Darvon, Darvocet), Diazepam (Valium), Esopiclone (Lunesta), phenobarbital (Luminal, Donnatal) and tramadol.
You can see where this is going. Together with the expansion of the scope of practice, this certificate will be a ticket for the advanced practice chiropractor to do pretty much anything a real primary care M.D. or D.O. can do.
So far, the only sponsor of this bill is Senator Cisco McSorley (D). Perhaps some of you might want to drop Sen. McSorley a line with your thoughts on his bill.
Before we move on to other areas, one other practice expansion effort is underway, this time in Texas. Currently, the chiropractic scope of practice includes
objective or subjective means to analyze, examine, or evaluate the biomechanical condition of the spine and musculoskeletal system of the human body
House Bill 1169 would add to the end of that sentence
. . . or the condition of another system of the human body that is affected by the musculoskeletal system.
Which leads me to wonder: considering the vertebrae-centered chiropractic belief system, what wouldn’t be “another system of the human body that is affected by the musculoskeletal system?”
Informed consent, finally?
In Oklahoma, Senate Bill 451 provides
Chiropractic physicians in this state shall obtain informed, written consent from a patient prior to performing any procedure that involves treatment of the patient’s cervical spine and such informed consent shall include the risks and possible side effects of such treatment including the risk of chiropractic stroke.
Needless to say, the Oklahoma Chiropractors’ Association opposes the bill. Chiropractors do not believe there is such a risk, a subject Harriet Hall, Mark Crislip and I have all written about on SBM.
Discrimination?
Washington State already has a law prohibiting the state and its subdivisions (such as counties) from
in any way discriminating against licensed chiropractors in performing and receiving compensation for services covered by their licenses.
To make the point, schools would be forced to include them in sports physicals per an amendment to the law:
Licensed chiropractors must be allowed to perform sports physicals for school athletes and physical examinations required for commercial driver’s licenses.
As Harriet Hall, herself a Washington resident, pointed out:
Physicians and properly trained, experienced PAs and NPs are qualified to do these exams. Chiropractors and other alternative providers are not, even with special certification and training.
As noted in my recent post on naturopathy, chiropractors are seeking to avoid exclusion, which they equate with discrimination, from Oregon’s Coordinated Care Organizations (CCOs) through a bill that would force CCOs to accept them as primary care providers. The CCOs, which provide care for Medicaid patients, were merely trying to follow a legal mandate to save money by requiring providers to practice evidence-based medicine and excluding those who don’t. Never underestimate the power of a state legislature to take away with the right hand taxpayer money the left hand is trying to save.
Insurance
The majority of chiropractic bills introduced so far seek greater public and private health coverage for chiropractic services. Pending bills would, among other things,
    • include or expand coverage of chiropractic services in Medicaid or other taxpayer-funded health insurance programs;
    • prohibit coverage limitations on chiropractic services unless there are similar limitations on physician services or require coverage of services on same basis as a physician;
    • require coverage for any service within the scope of chiropractic practice;
    • prohibit larger copayments for chiropractors than for physicians.
There is considerable financial pressure on chiropractors and thus an urgent need to increase income, even if it means singing up for low reimbursement programs like Medicaid. The total number of ambulatory visits to chiropractors decreased by 3 percent from 2002-2008. Quackwatch recently analyzed chiropractic income based on data from the U.S. Department of Commerce:
These figures indicate that between January 1992 and December 2007, the average gross income per chiropractic office rose at less than half the rate of inflation, which is equivalent to a loss of 20% in purchasing power. Since the cost of running the offices increased during this period, the purchasing power of the chiropractor’s take-home pay was even lower.
And just this week Scripps-Howard News Service published a news report revealing the large number of defaults still outstanding on government health care provider student loans. A complete list of the 930 providers (see bottom of report) reveals that chiropractors hold a distinct majority on the list.
Conclusion
Instead of ditching the subluxation and becoming an evidence-based provider of care for musculoskeletal problems, chiropractors appear to being going in the extreme opposite direction. They are attempting to become primary care physicians but with far less education and training than M.D.s, D.O.s, P.A.s and nurse practitioners have in diagnosing and treating the broad range of conditions seen by primary care providers. They compound the problem by using quack remedies like homeopathy. If they can fool some of the public some of the time with this nonsense, I don’t think it will be for long. As is true of “naturopathic doctors,” very few patients will see chiropractors for primary care even when their scope of practice permits it and insurance pays for it. And it will just compound the problem the public has figuring out just what it is chiropractors do.

Legislative Alchemy 2017: Chiropractic
Chiropractors are promoting themselves as primary care physicians. Some state legislatures are falling for it.
Jann Bellamy on January 4, 2018
Link


State legislatures routinely incorporate pseudoscience into health care practitioner licensing laws, a process I call “Legislative Alchemy.” These laws allow health care practitioners to use bogus diagnostic methods, diagnose fabricated diseases and conditions, and sell useless remedies to their patients. Legislatures credulously adopt the self-regulated educational and testing requirements of these practitioners instead of objectively evaluating their credentials.
Armed with the undeserved imprimatur of legitimacy bestowed by the state, naturopaths, chiropractors and acupuncturists diagnose and treat millions of patients each year. Yet, they offer nothing beneficial that is not readily available from evidence-based practitioners. As for the rest, at best, patients lose only their money. At worst, they lose their lives.
Today, we look at chiropractic efforts to benefit from the magic of Legislative Alchemy in 2017, a subject I previewed earlier this year.
The DC as PCP
The American Chiropractic Association (ACA), the Council on Chiropractic Education, and chiropractic schools have declared, ipse dixit, that chiropractors are primary care physicians, a rebranding campaign we’ve covered extensively here on SBM. (List of posts here.) For example, according to the National University of Health Sciences (NUHS), its chiropractic school:
prepares students to become first-contact, primary care physicians fully qualified to diagnose, treat, and manage a wide range of conditions.
We’ll examine the veracity of that statement more closely in a moment, but first let’s look at two Tennessee laws passed in 2017 which gave a big boost to chiropractic’s rebranding efforts.
Chiropractic scope of practice under prior Tennessee law was basically limited to diagnosing and treating neuromuscular conditions via the detection and correction of the phantom chiropractic subluxation. House Bill 387 vastly expands that scope for chiropractic “physicians” in a way that might not be immediately obvious to those unfamiliar with the chiropractic “DC as PCP” campaign.
Essential to this rebranding is a redefined scope of practice, which the ACA calls “Six Elements of a Modern Chiropractic Act.” Key elements include:
An unrestricted right to diagnose any patient of any age with any disease or condition, including expanded authority to order and perform diagnostic testing.
Deference to chiropractic schools in determining chiropractic scope of practice – if they teach it, chiropractors can legally do it.
While giving lip service to chiropractic treatment of “neuromusculoskeletal” conditions, the authority to diagnose and treat an undefined “other health conditions or issues,” as well as “general health matters, wellness and health optimization.”
In other words, the ACA wants to sell the public on the notion that chiropractors should be everyone’s first stop for general health advice as well as a diagnosis of what ails them, no matter what the disease or condition, trusting the chiropractor to refer the patient to a real doctor should the need arise. In Tennessee, that’s pretty much what they got.
The scope of a chiropractor’s authority to diagnose was totally redefined to include “differential diagnosis,” defined as, without limitation as to disease or condition:
the source, nature, and extent of a disease or other physical condition for the purpose of establishing an appropriate plan of care, which may include referral to another provider for care that is outside the scope of practice of a chiropractic physician.
To conduct this differential diagnosis, the chiropractor can perform a “thorough examination and evaluation” of the patient as well as use “diagnostic procedures necessary to clinically correlate a physical examination to a diagnostic impression.” What diagnostic procedures can they use? A whole lot of them. They can:
Perform x-rays and non-invasive diagnostic procedures, not otherwise described.
Order advanced diagnostic imaging and “other diagnostic procedures,” again, not otherwise described.
Collect blood, urine, saliva, and hair for analysis.
Perform “minimally invasive procedures” if they learned it in chiropractic school and the state chiropractic board says it’s ok. (They must consult with the medical board but there’s no requirement that the medical board approve what they decide.)
Let’s pause for a minute to note that the chiropractic lobby wanted to include hair analysis (“a cardinal sign of quackery”) and saliva testing (used by quacks to diagnose hormone “imbalances” and validated only for Cushing’s syndrome, which no chiropractor has any business touching) along with the right to order, say, PET scans and MRIs.
But what about treatment? Are Tennessee chiropractors allowed to treat any disease or condition they diagnose? Probably not, but they can go well beyond musculoskeletal conditions. Again, you need to know a bit of background to understand how this will work.
Subluxation-based chiropractors will still be able to locate and remove “interference with nerve transmission and nerve function,” which they regard as beneficial to a host of diseases and conditions. For the rest, it depends on how expansively you are willing to read the statute. Under the new law, “treatment” means:
The treatment of neuromuscular, musculoskeletal, and related conditions . . . [and] the provision of supportive care with due regard for nutrition, hygiene, sanitation and rehabilitation designed to assist in the restoration and maintenance of a patient’s health. [Emphasis added.]
Recall that the chiropractors drafted this bill to include hair and saliva analysis. That’s a smoking gun showing they plan to diagnose non-existent “toxicities” and “hormone imbalances,” presumably with the intent to treat these “conditions,” most likely with dietary supplements (“nutrition”) under the rubric of “assisting in the restoration and maintenance of a patient’s health.” Of course, that’s just a small sampling of the many bogus “other diagnostic procedures” that can be used to diagnose all manner of “nutritional deficiencies” and assorted fabricated conditions, like “heavy metal toxicity” based on provoked urine testing and treated with dietary supplements.
In other words, in addition to detecting and correcting non-existent subluxations, chiropractors will have a scope of practice similar to a naturopathic “doctor” practicing in a state that does not allow prescription privileges: an unlimited right to diagnose and broad authority to treat with, for example, non-prescription drugs, dietary supplements and (presumably) homeopathy, as long as the treatment can be shoehorned into a vague category like “related conditions,” “supportive care,” “nutrition” and so on.
To bring home the point that a DC can be your PCP, the Tennessee legislature also passed a bill allowing chiropractors to enter into “direct primary care agreements” with patients, that is, agree to “provide primary care services” to the patient for a fee over an agreed period of time. The agreement must describe “the scope of primary service that is covered” by the fee.
“Primary care services” is defined to include:
the screening, assessment, diagnosis, and treatment for the purpose of promotion of health or the detection and management of disease or injury within the competency and training of the direct primary care physician, or, if applicable, within the scope of practice of a chiropractic physician.
Note that an MD or DO physician is limited to diagnosis and treatment within his “competency and training” but chiropractors can provide care within their “scope of practice,” that is, anything the chiropractic lobbyists who wrote the new scope of practice law say they can do.
With that in mind, let’s return to the National University of Health Science’s claim that the school is training students to practice primary care “fully qualified to diagnose, treat, and manage a wide range of conditions.” A recent chiropractic journal article authored by three members of the NUHS Department of Clinical Practice faculty casts doubt on that claim. (Whole article is behind a paywall.)
The authors report their treatment of constipation in two 7-month-old twins who were born prematurely at 29 weeks, both of whom had undergone abdominal surgery. Treatment consisted of scar tissue mobilization, detection and correction of phantom subluxations, and acupressure to the feet. One of the infants also underwent Dynamic Neuromuscular Stabilization “to correct aberrant movement patterns.” This lasted for ten treatment sessions for one and eight for the other, both at two treatment sessions per week. Follow up visits after the supposed resolution of their supposed constipation were then reduced to one visit per week, then one per month.
It hardly bears mentioning that none of these is a proven treatment for constipation in infants, and two of them are based on fantastical concepts of human anatomy and physiology. As best I can tell, the principles behind Dynamic Neuromuscular Stabilization remain unproven (if not fantastical) particularly in infants, and not meant for constipation. Scar tissue mobilization, described as “gentle cross-frictional movement along the scar” was used to “loosen up tightness of the abdominal musculature” and “stimulate the mechanoreceptors and nerve endings in the skin,” along with a lot of hand waving about how this relieves constipation.
I ran the article by SBM’s own Clay Jones, MD, a pediatrician (have a read of his post on constipation in children ). He noted that the determination of constipation in infants is often very subjective and thought that these babies were probably not constipated in the first place. He noted that some of the supposed symptoms of constipation described in the article were actually normal behavior. If anything, he guessed that:
the chiropractor was taking credit for the natural course of the complaints, maternal placebo response, and possibly other interventions [not described in the article].
I point all of this out to demonstrate the folly of legislatures’ relying on self-regulated chiropractic education and training (especially scant in pediatrics) in granting licensure to chiropractors and giving them the authority to treat any patient with any disease or condition. It also gives lie to comments made in response to SBM posts on chiropractic that subluxation-based chiropractic is fading and no longer taught in chiropractic schools. And it is a perfect example of how, in the words of the new Tennessee law, conditions “related” to (at least in the chiropractic view of things) neuromuscular issues can be expanded to cover all sorts of medical problems chiropractors have no business treating.
Chiropractic “nutrition” and other imagined competencies
Idaho passed a practice expansion bill in 2017 allowing chiropractors “certified in clinical nutrition” to administer vitamins A, C and all B vitamins, plus minerals such as calcium, copper, magnesium, selenium and zinc, by means that include intravenous injections, as well as orally and topically. Apparently, the law was passed because chiropractors had been giving injections anyway and wanted to continue. This brings the ACA closer to another desired element of the Modern Chiropractic Practice Act: Prescription authority. (Vitamins and minerals are legally considered drugs if they are injected, despite chiropractors’ protestations otherwise.)
Becoming certified in clinical nutrition is a pretty easy prospect. All they will need is 77 classroom hours plus 24 clinical hours in administration, lab testing and blood chemistry interpretation, all of which they can get at a chiropractic school.
The new law will allow chiropractors to cash in on the health craze for vitamin and mineral infusions. Considering the plethora of bogus nutritional testing methods available, there should be no shortage of opportunities to upsell patients on the need. Except in cases of actual deficiency, which are rare, and use for a handful of diseases, vitamin and mineral infusions are not supported by adequate evidence of safety and efficacy. Fortunately for them, this is not considered a barrier to chiropractors.
There were two other minor legislative successes for chiropractors in 2017. In Texas, the legislature added “diagnose” to the chiropractic scope of practice, although the Senate made it clear this is not an expansion and chiropractors are limited to diagnosing a biomechanical condition of the spine or musculoskeletal system. Virginia will allow chiropractors to perform physicals commercial driver’s licenses and learner’s permits.
Otherwise, chiropractic bills failed or, in three states, remain pending. (Links are provided for pending bills; for failed bills, see The Society for Science-Based Medicine.)
Two of the practices chiropractors covet are performing school physicals for student athletes and the authority to return students athletes to play after a concussion. (The cynic in me sees these as practice-building efforts.) Harriet Hall, MD, and Mark Crislip, MD, have analyzed chiropractors’ ability to perform these functions and found them wanting, but lack of education and training (not to mention reality-based practice) never stopped a legislator from introducing a practice expansion bill.
Both Connecticut and Oregon said “no” to chiropractors returning concussed athletes to play. Bills allowing chiropractors to perform school physicals remain pending in California, North Carolina (although it may have missed a deadline for further consideration), and Wisconsin. Even though the Wisconsin bills are opposed by the state medical society, medical specialty associations, the state nurses, and athletic trainers associations, hospitals and insurance groups, the Assembly passed its version of the bill. (Senate version here.)

Colorado allows animal chiropractic, which is based on the notion that non-existent subluxations exist in animals as well as humans and, as in humans, can be detected by x-ray. A bill failed that would have relieved chiropractors of the requirement that a veterinarian clear the animal prior to chiropractic treatment.
A bill granting chiropractors a Tennessee-sized scope of practice expansion didn’t make it in Indiana, while a substantial practice expansion bill remains pending in New York. Nevada rejected a practice expansion that would have allowed the correction of subluxations to “improve health.” Florida did not follow Tennessee’s lead in allowing chiropractors to enter into direct primary care agreements with patients. A New Mexico bill allowing “advance practice” chiropractors expanded prescription privileges, including all drugs used in primary care practice except Schedule I controlled substances, didn’t pass. In Wyoming, chiropractors tried, once again, to call themselves “physicians.” That bill didn’t pass either.
And on it goes. A practice expansion bill has already been filed in Indiana for consideration in the 2018 legislative session. We’ll be watching.

Legislative Alchemy 2018: Chiropractors rebranding as primary care physicians continues
Chiropractors are not properly educated and trained to be primary care physicians. Yet, their campaign to rebrand themselves as PCPs via legislation continues.
Jann Bellamy on December 20, 2018
Link

Today, we continue our annual review of Legislative Alchemy – the deliberate incorporation of pseudoscience into health care via legislation – with a look at 2018 state bills (some carried over from their introduction in 2017) aiming to expand chiropractors’ scope of practice.
State chiropractic practice acts are the granddaddy of all Legislative Alchemy. The first were passed in the early 1900s, making the detection and correction of non-existent subluxations the legal basis for distinguishing chiropractic from medical practice and saving chiropractors from arrest on charges of the unauthorized practice of medicine. Since the 1970s, when Louisiana became the last state to legalize chiropractic practice, chiropractors’ efforts have focused on practice expansion and state-mandated insurance coverage, to the point of their lobbying for primary care physician status, just without the pesky and time-consuming education and training. (We have extensively covered the “DC as PCP” campaign on SBM; posts are collected here.) Along the way, chiropractors have managed to pick up an extraordinarily varied scope of practice, including, depending on the state, obstetrics, pelvic (including PAP smears) and breast exams, electrolysis, acupuncture, visceral manipulation, thermography, colonic irrigation, and semen analysis, among dozens of other diagnostic and treatment methods.
The DC as PCP
Sometimes attempts at rebranding DCs as PCPs take a head-on approach, with bills dramatically increasing the scope of diagnostic testing and treatments the chiropractor can employ. Others are more subtle, as we shall see.
Indiana’s House Bill 1384 and Senate Bill 160 are exemplars of the former. State law formerly defined “chiropractic” as the diagnosis and treatment of “interference with normal nerve transmission”, i.e., traditional subluxation-based chiropractic. As originally drafted, these bills would allow examination and treatment of all human ailments as long as no surgery or prescription drugs are used, and removed prohibitions on the use of ionizing radiation, conducting invasive diagnostic testing, and analysis of bodily fluids. Prohibitions on the treatment of infectious diseases, endocrine disorders, or atypical or abnormal histology were also eliminated. As originally drafted, chiropractors would be able to use any therapy to treat any “injury, condition or disorder” as long as the therapy is taught in a chiropractic college or in an approved postgraduate program. (While “post-graduate” may imply clinical training, as in medicine, that is not the case with chiropractors; these “post-grad” programs are often taught in hotel conference rooms and may not include actual patient care.)
Fortunately, subsequent amendments trimmed some of these privileges. The final bill, signed into law by the Governor, reinstated prohibitions on use of ionizing radiation, and treatment of infectious diseases, endocrine disorders, and abnormal histology, although chiropractors can apparently diagnose and treat any other injury, condition or disorder. The provision allowing anything taught in a chiropractic college or post-grad programs was removed. Nevertheless, chiropractors will be able prescribe and sell dietary supplements to patients to treat illness under the guise of “nutritional counseling”, use dry needling, and will have expanded use of diagnostic testing to “prepare a proper chiropractic diagnosis”, whatever that means. The authority to diagnose and treat phantom subluxations remains, no doubt necessary to retain the support of “straight” chiropractors.
Indiana chiropractors have thus gained several new options for rebranding. The legal authority to use diagnostic testing and prescribe dietary supplements gives chiropractors a green light to become so-called “functional medicine” practitioners. If you want to see how that works for patients, look no further than Dr. David Gorski’s Monday post on one chiropractor’s pseudoscience-filled “functional medicine” discourse. Or, chiropractors can essentially practice naturopathy, with all of its attendant quackery. Or – yet another option – they can become “chiropractic internists“. Either way, as a bonus to the bottom line, chiropractors can sell the supplements they prescribe to patients.
Similar bills “modernizing” chiropractic practice are pending in New York (Assembly Bill 8541, Senate Bill 7247), both stuck in their respective chamber’s Higher Education Committee, where they have yet to be taken up. Current law permits the detection and correction of fictional subluxations. These bills expand the use of that fiction by permitting chiropractors to diagnose “the human body” for “any human disease, pain, injury, deformity or physical condition” [emphasis added] and treat by – you guessed it – detecting and correcting subluxations. The bills would also allow chiropractors to call themselves “physicians” who could, with vaguely described additional training, engage in “wellness care” and give dietary and nutritional advice, including dispensing dietary supplements. Expanded lab testing, electrodiagnostic testing and manipulation under anesthesia are included as well.
Fortunately, a Utah bill allowing chiropractors expanded privileges, including ordering diagnostic evaluations, imaging studies, and lab tests, and prescribing durable medical equipment, failed. It would also have permitted chiropractors to prescribe and sell dietary supplements, “cellular components”, and homeopathic remedies. As I noted in my last post, on naturopathic “doctor” licensing and practice expansion, state legislation continues to include homeopathic remedies in health care practitioner scope of practice, ignoring the FDA’s declaration that all homeopathic products on the market are there in violation of federal law for failing to undergo pre-market FDA approval, subjecting them to immediate regulatory action.
Stealth DC as PCP
Other legislative attempts to rebrand DCs as PCPs are more subtle. A favorite tactic is to mandate the inclusion of chiropractors among health care practitioners authorized to perform school physicals for student athletes, thereby falsely implying to the public that they have the education and training to examine and diagnose the undifferentiated patient. Of course, it’s a handy practice-building device as well, allowing the chiropractor to impress upon the patient, and perhaps the patient’s parent, the importance of “chiropractic care” for the entire family.
Wisconsin is an excellent example of how an organized pushback against such ill-advised legislation can be effective in voting it down. Per Assembly Bill 260 and Senate Bill 232, as originally drafted, chiropractors could have performed physicals for student athletes, including college athletes. A “certificate in health and physical examinations” would be required, but the education and training for the certificate would be solely up to the state chiropractic board. Many groups opposed the bills, including the Wisconsin Medical Society, specialty medical societies, the state nurses’ and athletic trainers’ associations, hospitals, and insurance industry representatives. The Medical Society rightly pointed out that chiropractors aren’t qualified to examine students for cardiovascular problems or mental health and substance abuse issues, among others. (SBM’s own Dr. Harriet Hall, herself a retired family physician, has explained why chiropractors aren’t qualified to perform these school physicals as well.) The bills also permitted something called “chiropractic acupuncture”, which was understandably opposed by acupuncturists. In the end, the bills were stripped of these provisions, although, as finally passed and signed by the Governor, chiropractors will be allowed to employ nurses and to perform federal motor vehicle safety physicals.
Bills were also introduced in North Carolina and California allowing chiropractors to perform physicals for participation in student athletics. With the legislature set to adjourn on December 31st, the N.C. bill is stuck in the same committee to which it was assigned in 2017. The language of the California legislation (which included naturopaths as well) has been revised and now addresses a different subject (guns, but not DCs or NDs) altogether.
Bills preying on the young in a different manner were introduced in Illinois and Maryland. Both failed. In Illinois, by defining chiropractors as “physicians” for the purposes of a statute addressing student athlete concussions, chiropractors would have been allowed to evaluate students for concussions and sign off on their returning to play. They would be included on “concussion oversight teams”, tasked with developing student concussion policy. Of course, chiropractors are not properly educated and trained to treat brain injuries and “chiropractic neurology” is grounded in pseudoscience.
Maryland House Bill 623 and Senate Bill 164 were essentially chiropractic practice building disguised as a public health initiative. These bills permitted county education boards to implement a policy allowing chiropractors to perform scoliosis exams on students. Routine screening for scoliosis is controversial. The Scoliosis Research Society, American Academy of Orthopedic Surgeons, Pediatric Orthopedic Society of North America and American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) believe that “screening examinations for spine deformity should be part of the medical home preventative services visit for females at age 10 and 12 years, and males once at age 13 or 14 years” and do not endorse routine screenings of the type described in this bill. Chiropractic treatment of scoliosis, which can result in delay of effective treatment, is not recommended by the Scoliosis Research Society and spinal manipulation for scoliosis is generally not covered by insurance. Even the General Assembly’s own staff analysis noted that the AAP recommends against this type of routine screening, perhaps contributing to the failure of both bills.
DC as PCP via DPC
Another back door to rebranding chiropractors as primary care physicians is state legislation allowing DCs to enter into direct primary care agreements with their patients. This year, Florida’s Governor signed a bill doing just that, an effort that one chiropractic lobbyist admitted was aimed at positioning chiropractors as primary care physicians.
Florida’s new law defines chiropractors, as well as MDs, DOs, and nurse practitioners, as “primary care providers” and “primary care services” as:
screening, assessment, diagnosis, and treatment of a patient conducted within the competency and training of the primary care provider for the purpose of promoting health or detecting and managing disease or injury.
As I opined in a previous post, allowing DCs to enter into DPC agreements is a bad deal for patients. Their lack of education and training for primary care practice has been extensively documented here on SBM. Yet, as I pointed out in that post,
In a recent survey of chiropractic websites, about a third of chiropractors were claiming they treat allergies and asthma. But that’s not all. Chiropractic websites and other promotional material, including those of chiropractic professional associations, promote chiropractic diagnosis and/or treatment of ear infections, bedwetting, colic, Tourette syndrome, ADHD, breech babies, autism, diabetes, breast and cervical cancer prevention and detection, and endocrinology. A series of articles in an American Chiropractic Association publication (republished here and thoroughly demolished by Harriet Hall here) recommends that chiropractors employ diagnostic methods like fasting metabolic panels, lipid profiles, high sensitivity CRP to assess the level of endothelial inflammation and the risk of a cardiovascular event, hemoglobin A1c (HbA1c) profile, auscultation, thyroid palpation, assessment of bowel sounds, palpation of the abdomen, prostate exams, and rectal exams. This same series suggests that chiropractors can “co-manage” metabolic syndrome, diabetes, hypertension, hyperlipidemia, obesity, arthritis, osteomalacia, osteopenia, osteoporosis, malnourishment, and depression.
And just look at these amazing results claimed for “upper cervical” chiropractic for any number of conditions. (This is apparently what passes for research among chiropractors.)
This overreach can now be embodied in a binding DPC agreement, obligating the patient to pay a monthly fee to a provider not qualified to perform the covered services or offering treatments that confer no benefit and possible harm. The Florida Chiropractic Association (FCA) has drafted a form DPC agreement for its members (one I’d love to see but have not been able to get my hands on). It’s already caused one kerfuffle: The Florida Chiropractic Physician Association was busted for pirating the FCA’s form, which did not sit well with the FCA, legal action being threatened.
Alabama’s Governor signed a bill allowing chiropractors to enter into what is called a “direct payment agreement” with patients, avoiding the term “primary care”. However, these agreements have their own problems, permitting chiropractors to contract with patients to provide so-called “wellness care” or “maintenance care“, that is, regular spinal “adjustments” to rid the body of putative subluxations, although (unsurprisingly) it has never been shown this routine “maintenance” improves health.
Taxpayer-funded DC as PCP
Currently, Medicare covers “manual manipulation of the spine to correct a subluxation as demonstrated to exist,” meaning that taxpayers pay millions of dollars annually for chiropractors to find and treat a condition that, in fact, does not exist. Not only that, a number of federal probes into overpayments to chiropractors have found that chiropractors regularly, and illegally, bill Medicare for what investigators later determine is “maintenance care”, which is not covered by Medicare.
To exacerbate the problem, Rep. Erik Paulsen (R-MN) has introduced H.R. 7157 in Congress. It will amend the Medicare law to cover not only phantom subluxations, but also
all physicians’ services furnished by doctors of chiropractic within the scope of their license.
Presumably as a sweetener for passage, and allegedly to help solve the huge overpayment problem, chiropractors whose billings are “aberrant” are excluded from this coverage.
So, in exchange for punishing “aberrant” chiropractors, Rep. Paulsen wants to dump every diagnostic method and treatment allowed chiropractors under state law into Medicare coverage and let taxpayers pick up the tab. Surely the U.S. Treasury would come out much better by simply continuing to pay the “aberrant” chiropractors for maintenance care.
Fortunately, H.R. 7157 has no co-sponsors, Congress is (to put it mildly) otherwise engaged, and time is running out. Even the American Chiropractic Association (ACA), which launched an all-out campaign promoting the bill, admits its chances are nil. As the ACA makes clear, however, they plan to be back in the next Congress with a new bill.
Finally, puppies
In addition to scamming patients by convincing them they are afflicted with illusory subluxations, chiropractors, sometimes in cahoots with “holistic” veterinarians, have ventured into animal chiropractic, convincing pet owners their animals are suffering as well. Reliable evidence that this benefits your pet in any way is notably lacking. This year, Colorado, which previously legalized animal chiropractic, has a new law removing the requirement that the poor creature be cleared by a veterinarian before being subjected to animal chiropractic performed by a chiropractor. The law adds a requirement that the chiropractor undergo a whopping nine hours of course work on contagious, infectious, and zoonotic diseases, plus two hours of continuing education. In better news, bills (Senate Bill 746, House Bill 1911), legalizing the practice of animal chiropractic by veterinarians and chiropractors failed in Missouri.
Legislatures will be cranking open the statehouse doors for new sessions as early as January. You can bet chiropractic lobbyists will be back, promoting bills to expand scope of practice and rebrand DCs as PCPs. We’ll be watching.

Legislative Alchemy 2019: Chiropractors seek scope of practice expansion, including authority to prescribe drugs
In 2019, chiropractors continued their push for practice expansion, including prescription privileges, as well as co-opting the opioid crisis to mandate physician recommendations for “chiropractic care”.
Jann Bellamy on January 30, 2020
Link

In 2019, via the magic of Legislative Alchemy, chiropractors across the nation continued their push for practice expansion as well as their campaign to promote “chiropractic care” (whatever that means) as an alternative to opioids in the treatment of pain, to the point of legal mandates requiring physicians to endorse them.
This legislation should be viewed in the larger context of the ultimate, and partially achieved, goal to rebrand chiropractors as “primary care physicians” capable of treating, in the words of the American Chiropractic Association (ACA), “anything a medical doctor can”. The authority to prescribe drugs is a key element of the ACA’s plan. Remember, too, that chiropractors want you to pick up the tab for all of this, in the form of insurance premiums and tax dollars paid to private and publicly-funded insurers required by law to cover anything within the chiropractors’ state scope of practice.
Prescribing
In Florida, chiropractic “physicians” (as they are allowed to call themselves) can recommend and dispense (i.e., sell) dietary supplements* and over-the-counter homeopathic drugs to patients, but they are prohibited from injecting substances like vitamins, minerals and botanicals, as well as homeopathic products, because they lack the authority to prescribe drugs. (If administered by injection, substances that normally constitute dietary supplements, like vitamins and minerals, as well as homeopathic remedies, legally become prescription drugs.)
A bill was introduced lifting this ban by allowing chiropractors to prescribe and administer “articles of natural origin” (which has no legal definition), including vitamins, minerals, enzymes, antioxidants, botanicals, glandulars,** and homeopathic remedies. If passed, chiropractors would have been able to administer all of these substances by injection, including via IV, thereby allowing them to, for example, plug their patients with Myer’s cocktails as well as other “articles of natural origin” mixed up for them by a compounding pharmacy.
Expanded privileges would also include the drug Armor Thyroid, a prescription form of a pig thyroid extract (a glandular) used to treat hypothyroidism. In addition, the bill would have allowed chiropractors to prescribe and administer “cellular components”, a broad term that presumably includes stem cell therapies, granting them entrée into the lucrative stem cell clinic market without having to hire a medical doctor.
This vast expansion of their scope of practice would be allowed after a mere 36 hours of training. Fortunately, the bill didn’t pass. In fact, it didn’t even get a committee hearing and was eventually withdrawn from consideration.
Several years ago, New Mexico created the “certified advanced practice chiropractic physician” who could, after 90 hours of education and training, prescribe and administer certain substances by injection if approved by the pharmacy and medical boards. In 2019, House and Senate bills were introduced to expand those privileges, eliminating the requirement that the pharmacy and medical boards approve some substances (like live cells, bioidentical hormones, and homeopathic remedies) for injection and allowing the administration of prescription drugs in any form, not just injection, although some would still need pharmacy and medical board approval. Fortunately, the bills failed.
More scope of practice expansion
One way to sneak in the back door of primary care practice is getting the authority to perform certain examinations, like school and sports physicals, or return student athletes to play after a concussion, despite the fact that chiropractors are not properly educated and trained for any of this.
Nevertheless, a 2019 bill remains pending in Illinois that would add “chiropractic physician” to the definition of “physician” in a law addressing student athletes and concussions, thereby allowing chiropractors to remove a student from play if a concussion is suspected and return the student to play after examination and treatment. In Connecticut, a bill allowing chiropractors to clear student athletes for participation in athletic activities after a concussion failed.
Companion bills have been introduced, and are still pending, in the New York Assembly and Senate to “modernize”, which actually means “greatly expand”, the chiropractic scope of practice, currently fairly narrow. Instead of detecting and correcting the phantom “subluxation” to remove “nerve interference” (although still allowed), chiropractors could call themselves “chiropractic doctors” and “chiropractic physicians”, and could examine patients for, among other things, clearance for school sports participation and school attendance. They could also “give patients consultation, advice, recommendations, and counseling” regarding anatomy, physiology, neurology, general health matters, wellness, and “health optimization”.
If approved by the state education department (not the state chiropractic board, which acts in an advisory capacity only), the bills would expand the use of diagnostic testing beyond X-rays to include other ionizing and non-ionizing imaging methods, clinical laboratory testing, and electrodiagnostic testing. Chiropractors could also provide “wellness care” (which is undefined in the bills), nutritional counseling, and dietary advice including (of course!) dispensing dietary supplements. The reduction of dislocations and manipulation under anesthesia are added to the scope of practice. In addition, the one medical doctor on the state board of chiropractic would be removed.
Interestingly, New York’s narrow scope of practice and regulation by the state department of education (as opposed to a chiropractor-controlled regulatory board) appears to have a laudable limiting effect on chiropractors’ foraying into so-called “chiropractic medicine” and “functional medicine“. The Institute for Functional Medicine’s proprietary courses allow chiropractors to become “certified” in functional medicine, but the state of New York is having none of it. The department does not allow continuing education credit for courses in functional medicine and considers functional medicine beyond the scope of chiropractic practice. It also currently limits the scope of nutritional advice chiropractors can give patients. Notably, the American Chiropractic Association’s list of “chiropractic internists” does not include any New York chiropractors, presumably because their scope of practice does not include the lab tests and broad-scope dietary supplement and homeopathic drug dispensing this “specialty” requires.
A bill introduced in Texas would have expanded the scope of practice for chiropractors from treatment of the musculoskeletal system to the “neuromusculoskeletal” system, giving chiropractors the authority to treat conditions of the nervous system. The bill was defeated with vigorous opposition from the Texas Medical Association, including legislative testimony from an Austin neurologist, who pointed out that
Adding the term “neuro” is not merely the addition of the nerves that may connect muscle tissue, or bones. It is the addition of the entire neurological system that includes the brain, spinal cord, and the regulation of many bodily functions beyond chiropractors’ education and training.
Regrettably, chiropractors in other jurisdictions do have the legal authority, if not the actual education and training, to treat disorders of the nervous system, to the point of manufacturing the ersatz specialty of “chiropractic neurology,” which SBM’s Dr. Steve Novella, himself a neurologist, has described as “rank pseudoscience“.
Finally, in Nevada, “dry needling” was added to the chiropractic scope of practice, while in Texas a bill was defeated which would have allowed chiropractors who had completed an acupuncture course to treat patients with acupuncture.
Co-opting the opioid epidemic to promote “chiropractic care”
Pennsylvania’s House Resolution 597, passed in 2019, is a master class in co-opting the opioid crisis for promotion of “chiropractic care”. After several paragraphs of scary stats on opioid abuse, the Resolution notes that “numerous published studies . . . document spinal manipulation as effective for the management of low back pain”. Thus, the House resolves to
raise public awareness that chiropractic care is the primary first-line, nonpharmacological approach to safely and effectively relieve acute, sub-acute and chronic pain.
See what they did there? The effectiveness of spinal manipulation for low back pain, a manual therapy also provided by physical therapists and physicians, magically becomes a prescription for “chiropractic care”, a nebulous term that can include all sorts of pseudoscience (subluxation detection and correction, dubious nutritional advice, unvalidated testing, and homeopathy, to name a few) which is “the” (not “a”) “primary first-line” method (not a choice among several of equal or greater merit) to “safely and effectively” (no evidence cited) treat all pain, whatever its origin (ditto for no evidence). Fortunately, this Resolution carries zero weight as legal authority, but does make for some good chiropractic PR.
As part of this continuing effort to sell chiropractic as an non-opioid alternatives in the treatment of pain, a bill was introduced, but did not pass, in Connecticut, “to encourage the treatment of chronic pain without the use of opioid drugs and in accordance with the treatment provided by chiropractors” although no details are given regarding exactly how this encouragement would be executed and by whom.
Tennessee law requires physicians to discuss “reasonable” alternatives to opioids for the patient’s condition and the benefits and risks of those alternative treatments. In another incident of co-opting the opioid crisis, the Tennessee legislature amended this law by defining “alternative treatments” as including, but not limited to:
treatments such as chiropractic care, physical therapy, acupuncture, and other such treatments that relieve pain without the use of opioids.
Hopefully, the adjective “reasonable” leaves some discretion in the hands of the physician who believes “chiropractic care” (and acupuncture, for that matter), are not appropriate for the patient because of lack of evidence of safety and effectiveness for the patient’s condition and the risk of subjecting the patient to pseudoscientific diagnoses and treatments.
That discretion is unavailable in Florida, where the legislature passed a bill requiring physicians to endorse chiropractic, acupuncture, and massage as non-opioid alternatives to pain, even if the physician disagrees with that advice.
Animal chiropractic
In Arkansas, chiropractors “certified by the American Veterinary Chiropractic Association” had to “perform chiropractic” on animals under the direct supervision of a licensed veterinarian. The supervision requirement was eliminated in 2019, passing unanimously in both the House and Senate. Animal chiropractic is based on the notion that animals, like humans, suffer from the chiropractic “subluxation” and require “adjustments”, which is just as nonsensical in veterinary medicine as it is in human medicine. Because it is permissible to ignore science (even basic anatomy) in veterinary chiropractic, other pseudoscientific practices, like applied kinesiology and craniosacral therapy have crept in.
Thankfully, a bill adding animal chiropractic to the scope of practice of both veterinarians and chiropractors failed in Missouri.
Finally, falling into no particular category, yet speaking volumes, the Idaho Board of Chiropractic Physicians convinced the state legislature that its peer review process, which is intended to “to review the appropriateness, quality, utilization and costs of chiropractic services”, was “unnecessary” and got the legislature to pass a bill (HB 0005) eliminating peer review.

Notes:
*A 2017 review of studies of chiropractic practice revealed that almost a third of chiropractic patients are treated with nutritional supplements. This seems an extraordinary number given the lack of evidence of effectiveness for supplements.
**Glandular extracts come from the hormone-producing glands of animals and contain dried and ground-up raw animal glandular tissues from the thyroid, thymus, adrenals, pituitary, ovaries, testis, and pancreas. As long as they are taken orally and are not marketed for the treatment of disease, they can be sold as dietary supplements. They are pushed by chiropractors and others without medical training for “adrenal insufficiency” and other “hormonal imbalances”. Even Dr. Weil admits they are a waste of money at best and, at worst, dangerous.

The Exciting Conclusion
Jann Bellamy on December 26, 2013
Link
On the slim chance that you’ve been perched on the edge of your seat wondering how the New Mexico appellate court ruled on chiropractic prescription privileges, whether the Council on Chiropractic Education got approved for another three years as an accrediting agency, if NCCAM ever came clean about spinal manipulation, and the fate of Brandon Babcock, DC, at the hands of the judicial system, here are your updates.
Prescription privileges for New Mexico chiropractors
A surprisingly titillating tidbit about New Mexico “advanced practice” chiropractors.
As discussed in previous posts, New Mexico “advanced practice” chiropractors succeeded in getting limited prescription rights. The statute specifically says they can:
prescribe, administer and dispense herbal medicines, homeopathic medicines, over-the-counter drugs, vitamins, minerals, enzymes, glandular products, protomorphogens, live cell products, gerovital, amino acids, dietary supplements, foods for special dietary use, bioidentical hormones, sterile water, sterile saline, sarapin or its generic, caffeine, procaine, oxygen, epinephrine and vapocoolants.
However,
Dangerous drugs or controlled substances, drugs for administration by injection and substances not listed [above] shall be submitted to the board of pharmacy and the New Mexico medical board for approval.
Apparently, the Chiropractic board couldn’t read the plain language of the statute and blew off this requirement, even though their own lawyer told them they couldn’t. This got them hauled into court by the medical and pharmacy boards. The International Chiropractors Association joined the fight.
The New Mexico Court of Appeals has now ruled unanimously that the chiropractors violated the statute in failing to get the required approval. This means they can’t inject any of the substances listed above because delivery by injection automatically kicks these products into the drug category.
The chiropractors remain undeterred. They attempted to get the legislature to broaden prescription rights this year, including controlled substances, but failed. At the heart of this effort is Bill Doggett, DC, who is committed to primary care physician status and full prescription rights for chiropractors. He was also instrumental in getting the limited prescription rights chiropractors now enjoy.
Let’s see what Doggett has in mind in the way of PCP practice and prescription rights if he eventually gets his way with the legislature. Back before the Court of Appeals quashed his hopes, Doggett planned to begin offering a procedure to regenerate healthy vaginal tissue. As quoted in an on-line article from the Foundation for Vertebral Subluxation subtitled “[Doggett] Says Chiropractors There [in NM] Are Already Providing Gynecological Exams”), Doggett stated:
It’s actually a PRP (plasma rich protein) procedure that DC’s in NM will be able to do when they settle the ICA suit. Using a proprietary technique, the growth factors in platelet-rich plasma (PRP) are extracted from that blood sample and injected into an area near the clitoris and into a the [sic] area of the upper vagina that is most important for the sexual response (the O-Spot) using a patent-pending procedure. Because these areas have been numbed with a local anesthetic cream, patients experience little or no discomfort during the procedure.
To be fair, Doggett isn’t the only health care provider pushing this procedure. It is being promoted by a group of MDs who will train physicians and nurse practitioners to use their system. (Also available, the Vampire facelift.) Best I can from the website, which has a soft-porn quality to it, there has never been a clinical trial of the O-Spot technique. Did Doggett complete the O-Spot training? I don’t know, but a search for his name does not show up in their list of providers.
Council on Chiropractic Education will probably get another three years
In my last post we looked at the battle among various chiropractic factions over continued recognition of the Council on Chiropractic Education (CCE) as the accrediting agency for chiropractic schools. According to a press release from the International Chiropractors Association (ICA), the National Advisory Committee on Institutional Quality and Integrity (NACIQI) has voted to continue the CCE’s recognition for another three years. Significantly, there were three dissenting votes. The NACIQI is an advisory body and the final call is up to the US Department of Education.
According to the ICA, there were a “large number of witnesses” at the December 12th hearing, including 18 students and more than a dozen private practitioners. “The majority of those speaking expressed deep and well-documented issues and concerns with the CCE’s standards, policies and procedures and highlighted the degree to which division over the direction of the CCE has come to dominate debate within the chiropractic profession.”
If the CCE’s recognition is continued by the Department of Education, the battle is hardly over. The ICA vows to “hold the CCE accountable to their pledge on governance reform negotiations.” And no doubt the rest of the dissidents will be holding the ICA accountable on its pledge to hold the CCE accountable. We’ll be watching.
NCCAM still manipulates spinal manipulation
Over a year ago, the post “NCCAM manipulates spinal manipulation” decried the misinformation about spinal manipulation and chiropractic on NCCAM’s website. The main criticism was that the information rests on the false assumption that chiropractors always use spinal manipulation for the same purposes as other health care practitioners. NCCAM’s discussion failed to tell consumers that chiropractors may purport to “detect” subluxations and use spinal manipulation to “correct” these subluxations. NCCAM also presents only the chiropractic view of the risk of cervical artery dissection following neck manipulation. Finally, it naively assumes that chiropractors who “specialize” have adequate education and training in these “specialties” and that they will appropriately prescribe dietary supplements, including having sufficient knowledge of supplement-prescription drug interaction. In other words, NCCAM does an extremely poor job of applying its supposedly “rigorous” research standards to the subject of chiropractic.
Well, they can’t say they didn’t know better, because after the post appeared I told them. Here’s the rather mealy-mouthed response I got:
Dear Ms. Bellamy:
Thank you for your e-mail to the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) about your blog post commenting on our Center’s spinal manipulation and chiropractic information.
We appreciate your thoughtful input on our information. We will keep your comments on file for future reference when we next update our content on these practices. Our goal is to produce accurate and informative publications, so we routinely review and update the information on our Web site.
To develop our materials, we use information from a wide range of science-based resources, which include peer-reviewed journals from PubMed, Federal Government Web sites, and subscription databases. Then our publications go through a review process, which includes reviews by experts in the field. We list at the end of each publication the references that we used to develop it.
Thank you for taking the time to write to us.
Sincerely yours,
Terry EvansNCCAM Clearinghouse
I don’t know what NCCAM’s definition of “routinely review and update” is, but it apparently does not fall within the parameters of (almost) two years. The last update of the article on chiropractic was in February, 2012, and my complaint (the post was in July, 2012) did not inspire them to take a second look at their information. The spinal manipulation article was updated this year, but simply perpetuates the same misinformation. So much for NCCAM’s promise to “maintain a strong commitment to providing objective and authoritative evidence-based information to the public and health care professionals.”
Functional Endocrinology practitioner Brandon Babcock sentenced
In “CAM Docket: Functional Endocrinology Update,” we reported that Utah chiropractor Brandon Babcock was going to trial on 11 felony charges related to his functional endocrinology practice. He faced up to 30 years in prison if convicted. Babcock was found guilty of six counts of exploiting the elderly in October and was sentenced in early December to six months in jail.
Babcock lured patients with free “gourmet dinners” at which he pitched his “diabetes breakthrough.” Then, without their knowledge or consent, he signed them up for a credit scheme to finance their bogus treatments. It is not clear from the news story how much of the exploitation charges had to do with the financial shenanigans and how much had to do with his practice of functional endocrinology.
Over in Colorado, the medical board’s order to cease and desist directed against Babcock’s fellow chiropractor and functional endocrinology practitioner Brandon Credeur is, as best I can tell, still in effect. The medical board charged Credeur with practicing medicine without a license after he received a very light slap on the wrist from the chiropractic board. His Functional Endocrinology of Colorado website is still up.
Apparently chiropractors remain undeterred by these events. Within the last couple of months a chiropractor came through Tallahassee offering a free dinner and talk on the wonders of Functional Endocrinology for diabetes. I thought about going but just couldn’t stomach the idea.
Happy New Year!
If your New Year’s Eve plans include a free gourmet dinner make sure you know who’s picking up the tab. Whatever you do, have a safe and CAM-free evening.

Congress can easily end Medicare waste, fraud and abuse by chiropractors, saving billions
Yet another government report finds chiropractors are bilking Medicare billions for unnecessary services. A simple amendment to the Medicare law could end this, but will Congress act?
Jann Bellamy on March 1, 2018
Link

A new government report found that about half of all Medicare payments for chiropractic services between 2010 and 2015 were improper, costing some $250 to $300 million annually. Medicare beneficiaries also paid millions of dollars out of their own pockets in co-pays for chiropractic services deemed improper. Yet, despite years of proposed solutions to combat waste, fraud and abuse by chiropractors, necessary controls have not been implemented and remain inadequate to prevent several billion in further losses to the Medicare Trust Funds.
There is a simple solution to this problem, but it will take Congressional action, something that is in short supply these days. We’ll return to the solution in a moment, but first let’s take a look at this government report and some background information on Medicare payments for chiropractic services.
“Medicare Needs Better Controls to Prevent Fraud, Waste, and Abuse Related to Chiropractic Services”
Last month, the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) Office of Inspector General (OIG) issued yet another in a series of reports aimed at reducing improper Medicare payments to chiropractors, this one titled “Medicare Needs Better Controls to Prevent Fraud, Waste, and Abuse Related to Chiropractic Services.” OIG’s frustration with the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) for failing to act on previous recommendations practically leaps from the pages.
Medicare, as the OIG notes, covers chiropractic services for manual manipulation of the spine to correct a subluxation, which can be diagnosed either by physical examination or by x-ray. According to the Medicare Benefit Policy Manual (Medicare Manual), the chiropractor must identify the precise level of the subluxation to substantiate a Medicare payment claim. While Medicare won’t pay for an x-ray to identify a subluxation, the x-ray can be used as documentation that the subluxation is there.
(At this point, faithful SBM readers will likely have guessed my simple solution to Medicare’s bleeding hundreds of millions of dollars in payments to chiropractors annually, but let’s continue with our present discussion for now.)
To qualify for Medicare payment, the chiropractic patient must have a “significant health problem in the form of a neuromusculoskeletal condition” and spinal manipulation must provide “reasonable expectation of recovery or improvement of function.” The Medicare Manual says that most spinal joint problems fall into one of two categories: “acute subluxation,” a new subluxation identified by physical exam or x-ray, and “chronic subluxation,” which is not expected to resolve with further treatment but where continued therapy can be expected to result in some functional improvement. To get paid, the chiropractor must place an “AT” modifier on the claim, indicating he provided “active/corrective treatment” for an acute or chronic subluxation, a requirement CMS added to help prevent chiropractic claims for unnecessary services.
The Medicare Manual also explains what is not covered: so-called “maintenance therapy,” subluxation correction that, according to chiropractors, prevents disease, promotes health, and prolongs and enhances quality of life.
Over a six-year period (2010-2015) Medicare paid $2.9 billion for subluxation correction. According to the OIG report, a whopping 44% to 54% of these payments were improper, the majority for medically unnecessary services, including maintenance therapy. This compares to a 10% to 13% improper payment rate for other Medicare-covered (Part B) services, which include doctor’s office visits, physical and occupational therapy, and outpatient surgery.
The OIG also found that, as the number of chiropractic services (again, limited to subluxation correction) a patient receives increases, the percentage of improper claims increases. In a 2013 nationwide review, 76% of claims for between 1 and 12 services were unallowable under Medicare coverage rules. Unallowable claims rose to an eye-popping 100% for patients receiving 31 or more services.
This most recent OIG report is one of at least 17 government reports since 1986 ferreting out chiropractic fraud and imploring CMS to employ more effective controls on improper chiropractic payments, especially those for maintenance therapy. (Chirobase lists all the reports here.) Unfortunately, some improvements aimed at addressing improper payments have backfired.
Instead of preventing fraud, the AT modifier has been turned into an instrument of fraud. Chiropractors simply slap it on all claims, knowing they’ll get paid regardless of whether it’s appropriate. In 2015, claims for all but 30 of the nearly 14 million chiropractic services paid by Medicare had the AT modifier, which is regularly used to get paid for uncovered maintenance therapy, according to the OIG report. Another anti-fraud mechanism – requiring the date of initial treatment on the claim, used as an affirmation that documentation of medical necessity is on file – is similarly misused. Chiropractors simply include the date on all claims even though, in two separate investigations, at least 90% did not appropriately document medical necessity.
Attempts to educate chiropractors and beneficiaries about improper payments are, in the OIG’s opinion, poorly executed or simply ignored. CMS doesn’t mention maintenance therapy in its explanation of benefits and fails to tell beneficiaries that some chiropractic services, like massage and acupuncture, aren’t covered. A CMS YouTube video on improving documentation is largely ignored by chiropractors.
The OIG thinks CMS could save millions of dollars by establishing a threshold beyond which chiropractic services (say, for example, 30 services a year) would be covered only if supported by medical review, a strategy employed by many private insurers and some Medicare contractors. The OIG estimates that this strategy alone would have saved Medicare almost $100 million, and patients over $24 million in co-pays, over a 2-year period. CMS doesn’t agree with this strategy and won’t implement it. In fact, CMS’s overall attitude seems to be that a few billion for chiropractic services is a small piece of the pie and it would prefer to go after bigger fish.
A better solution
I have a better idea for saving billions paid for chiropractic services: Stop paying for treatment of chiropractic subluxations. After over a century of claiming the detection and correction of subluxations is beneficial to health, chiropractors have never been able to prove these subluxations exist. All other healthcare professions, including medical doctors and physical therapists, reject the chiropractic subluxation. (An orthopedic subluxation – the partial dislocation of a joint – is a different thing altogether.) As well, in 2015, several foreign chiropractic colleges banded together to reject teaching of subluxation “theory” except as an historical concept. Even some chiropractors admit there’s no evidence:
No supportive evidence is found for the chiropractic subluxation being associated with any disease process or of creating suboptimal health conditions requiring intervention. Regardless of popular appeal, this leaves the subluxation construct in the realm of unsupported speculation. This lack of supportive evidence suggests the subluxation construct has no valid clinical applicability.
The General Chiropractic Council, the regulatory body for U.K. chiropractors agrees, finding that the chiropractic vertebral subluxation complex:
is an historical concept [and] . . . is not supported by any clinical research evidence that would allow claims to be made that it is the cause of disease or health concerns.
Somebody tell Congress. The Medicare law defines the term “physician” to include chiropractors and covers chiropractors for “medical and other health services,” but:
only with respect to treatment by means of manual manipulation of the spine to correct a subluxation . . .
In this, Congress was simply picking up the term “subluxation” from the states’ definition of a chiropractor’s scope of practice. In the early 1900s, the term “subluxation” was included in state chiropractic licensing laws to distinguish chiropractic practice from medical practice, laws passed to prevent chiropractors from being arrested for the unlicensed practice of medicine. At the time, it was a reference to the original definition of the word fabricated by “magnetic healer” D. D. Palmer, the inventor of chiropractic, out of thin air. Since then, subluxation has been redefined numerous times by chiropractors, without their even having bothered to prove such a thing exists, or agreeing on how to find one or its clinical significance.
Since Congress didn’t provide a definition of “subluxation,” Medicare chose this one out of the many available, a consensus definition cobbled together in the early 1990s by various chiropractic groups (Gatterman, 2005) and vague enough to satisfy the warring factions that permeate chiropractic practice:
a motion segment, in which alignment, movement integrity, and/or physiological function of the spine are altered although contact between joint surfaces remains intact.
CMS has washed its hands of any attempt to reconcile the chiropractic notion of the subluxation with its medical meaning, or the fact that no other health care profession believes the chiropractic version exists:
Implementation of the chiropractic benefit requires an appreciation of the differences between chiropractic theory and experience and traditional medicine due to fundamental differences regarding etiology and theories of pathogenesis of disease. Judgments about the reasonableness of chiropractic treatment must be based on the application of chiropractic principles.
In other words, Congress pretends this pseudoscience is fact, so we are forced to go along with it.
At least CMS limits subluxation correction to neuromusculoskeletal conditions, a limitation not obvious in the Medicare law and incongruent with the chiropractic concept of the subluxation, which they view as a contributing factor to any number of diseases and disorders. This notion is the origin of forbidden maintenance therapy: chiropractors promote the idea that regular “spinal checkups” for subluxation detection and correction to promote health and prevent disease.
In addition to wasting money on treating non-existent pathologies, location of “the precise level of the subluxation,” as required by Medicare, means that patients are being subjected to radiation for no good reason so chiropractors can document their (supposed) diagnosis. (It is sickening to see x-ray after x-ray of patients, including children, in chiropractic textbooks, instructing students on detecting subluxations via x-ray film.) To add insult to injury, Medicare doesn’t pay for the x-ray, meaning the patient must pay out-of-pocket.
This brings up a question: If Congress boots subluxation correction from Medicare coverage, should chiropractors be covered for any services at all?
On the one hand, however chiropractors see themselves, the public views them as “back doctors” (as does Medicare) and there is some less-than-robust evidence that generic spinal manipulation is effective for certain types of back pain. (Spinal manipulation is not synonymous with the chiropractic “adjustment” to treat the fictional subluxation, although chiropractors do use spinal manipulation as a means of making an “adjustment,” as SBM’s own retired chiropractor, Sam Homola, explains.)
As one solution, Congress could decide to cover spinal manipulation by chiropractors to the same extent it covers spinal manipulation by a physical therapist, doctor of osteopathy or medical doctor for medically necessary treatment of back pain, but it would need to exclude the subluxation as a proper diagnosis. Even in cases where spinal manipulation may be an appropriate treatment for back pain, it should not be based on a diagnosis of the non-existent chiropractic subluxation.
On the other hand, given the chiropractic track record for cheating Medicare, one wonders if they wouldn’t just fudge the diagnosis and continue improperly providing maintenance therapy. And it’s not like patients would be deprived of spinal manipulation in medically appropriate cases without them; they have other providers to choose from, providers who wouldn’t be so quick to use cervical manipulation for neck pain or cervicogenic headache, with their attendant risks.
Trying to amend the law creates a risk that chiropractors will use it as an opening to push for their dream of Medicare recognition of chiropractors as physicians who, in the words of the American Chiropractic Association:
should be allowed to practice to and be reimbursed for the fullest extent of their licensure, training and competencies.
It is a dream the ACA has been pushing to fruition for years, a piece of their larger plan to rebrand chiropractors as primary care providers with state licensing laws to match, efforts that are sometimes rewarded by states granting them huge scope of practice expansions. (These efforts continue in the 2018 state legislative sessions.)
Of course, the ACA would be put in the unfortunate position of arguing that Congress, having seen fit to kick chiropractors out of Medicare for repeated fraud, both in the form of pretending that subluxations exist for over 100 years and bilking Medicare to the tune of several billion dollars, should now grant them vastly expanded coverage under Medicare. Doesn’t sound like a winning argument, but you can bet they’ll try anyway.
Whatever the solution, taxpayers and Medicare beneficiaries shouldn’t be paying for treatment of phantom spinal lesions, whether allowed by law for covered ailments or via cheating by chiropractors billing for “maintenance therapy.” If you agree, tell your Congressional Representative and Senators.

CAM Docket: Functional Endocrinology Update
Jann Bellamy on September 19, 2013
Link
Sometimes the media gets it right.
From time to time, SBM has reported on the disheartening credulity of reporters when they cover so-called “alternative” medicine. Denver’s Channel 7, an ABC affiliate, is a happy exception to the rule. Reporter Theresa Marchetta first broke the story of Brandon and Heather Credeur, chiropractors practicing “Functional Endocrinology.” And for three years Marchetta, with the assistance of reporter Phil Tenser, followed up, interviewing hundreds of patients who lost thousands of dollars paid to the Functional Endocrinology Center of Colorado for treatment of their diabetes and other endocrine disorders. They’ve reported regularly as the Credeurs legal travails progressed through various judicial and administrative forums. Channel 7 and its reporters deserve substantial credit for pursing this story. The Credeurs might have escaped further censure without their persistence.
Another recurring frustration at SBM is medicine’s embrace of alternative medicine, expressed repeatedly at SBM in posts on quackademic medicine and the branding device known as integrative medicine. We’ve also lamented the seeming complicity of the state medical societies in allowing quackery to be legalized in the form of complementary and alternative medicine provider practice acts.
But sometimes medicine gets it right.
The Colorado Medical Board has somewhat redeemed itself in ordering Brandon and Health Credeur to cease and desist the unlicensed practice of medicine. That’s right. A medical board has finally put its collective foot down and pushed back against chiropractic’s increasingly aggressive push to practice medicine.
And sometimes SBM appears to be making inroads into the hostile incursion of alternative medicine.
I recently discovered that if you google “functional endocrinology”, first up on the list is CAM Docket: Functional Endocrinology, the very post updated today. Admittedly, it appears at the head of a depressingly long list of chiropractic websites advertising the practice, but at least we get a first crack at anyone who might be considering paying thousands of dollars and wasting time, and perhaps their health, on this useless nonsense.
A trifecta in the war on quackery! Revel in this victory, supporters of science-based medicine, for it is small and the victory may be fleeting. Let’s see how the battle is going.
In our last episode . . .
To summarize from the previous post, chiropractors Brandon and Health Credeur own Functional Endocrinology of Colorado. They attracted patients with free “gourmet dinners” and advertising, including a website, promoting their ability to treat diabetes with functional endocrinology. As is typical of alternative medicine pitches, their advertising offered a lot of MD-bashing and blather about getting to the “root cause” of diabetes, but little in the way of specifics and nothing in the way of actual evidence, only testimonials. Brandon Credeur claimed to be able to “reverse diabetes” in as little as three weeks. According to patients, actual treatments consisted of a diet book, supplements and chiropractic adjustments, for which they spent thousands of dollars. (One caller to the clinic was quoted a figure of more than $8,000 for treatments.) Some patients were not aware that the Credeurs were not MDs or endocrinologists.
Brandon Credeur also sold functional endocrinology practice building seminars, via a company called Functional Medicine Marketing, to other chiropractors. He bragged about hauling in hundreds of thousands of dollars per month and spoke of patients as if they were simply opportunities for self-enrichment.
The Colorado Board of Chiropractors filed a multi-count complaint against the Credeurs but wound up giving them only a slap on the wrist for errors in documentation. With a stipulation that they would improve on this, the Credeurs were back to shilling for their diabetes treatments. But some patients, outraged at the chiropractic board’s decision, banded together and filed a lawsuit against the Credeurs.
The battle continues
Channel 7 is still on the case. As it reported on June 13, 2013, the Medical Board of Colorado ordered the Credeurs to cease and desist the unlicensed practice of medicine. The Credeurs requested a full hearing on the matter, which they have a right to do under Colorado law. This meant that the Medical Board had to file a formal Notice of Charges fully setting forth its allegations of unlicensed practice and it did so on August 27, 2013. The Credeurs have not yet filed their Answer but a four-day hearing has been set for April 14, 2014.
The Medical Board is in interesting territory here. It does not have jurisdiction to discipline the Credeurs regarding their practice of chiropractic, including the suspension or revocation of their licenses. The Chiropractic Board has the exclusive authority to do that. It can only pursue them for practicing medicine without a license.
At the heart of the Medical Board’s allegations are the Credeurs’ statements on their website, which, according to the Board, suggest to the public that they
have an effective treatment or cure for endocrine dysfunction this is mutually exclusive to conventional medical endocrinology treatment by a licensed physician;
can permanently reduce and eliminate the risk factors of diabetes;
can eliminate low thyroid symptoms exclusively through chiropractic practice; and
can assume sole responsibility for treatment of patients regarding medications requiring a prescription by a physician without professional collaboration with or referral to a licensed physician.
(As to the last allegation, although this is not mentioned in the Notice of Charges, Channel 7 caught someone in the Credeurs’ office telling another person that “Synthroid promotes diabetes.”)
In addition, the Medical Board charges that the Credeurs’ website fails to indicate that they are chiropractors and that their services are exclusively chiropractic.
As examples of their alleged practice of medicine, the Notice of Charges quotes from the Credeur’s website. Here’s one example:
In functional endocrinology, the doctor identifies that function has been lost and asks a much more important question: Why has function been lost? And what can we do to restore function? In other words, the doctor looks to find the ROOT CAUSE or mechanism involved with any loss of function, which ultimately reveals why a set of symptoms is there in the first place, or why the patient has a particular disease label. . . . The point is the example and distinction made between the drug therapy model that is traditional medicine and a doctor who looks at mechanisms (i.e., contributing causes) and thus a doctor who practices within the model of “Functional Endocrinology.”
Ah yes, it’s that famous “root cause,” in CAPS, underlined, and boldfaced, in case you didn’t get the point. The website is still up and continues to make these claims.
The Chiropractic Board appears to agree with the Medical Board that chiropractors should not advise patients about their prescription medications and that they should confer with licensed physicians. The Chiropractic Board made similar charges in its complaint against the Credeurs, although the issue was never tried because of the parties’ stipulated settlement. And the Chiropractic Board agrees that it should be clear to patients that the practitioner is a chiropractor.
The two boards differ as to whether chiropractors can diagnose and treat endocrine dysfunction, diabetes and low thyroid. The Chiropractic Board went out of its way to reaffirm that treatment of endocrine system “ailments” is within the chiropractic scope of practice:
The Board affirms that the scope of chiropractic practice includes diagnoses and treatment of human ailments, including those affecting the endocrine system. [Credeur] and the Board expressly agree that it is appropriate for [him] to use the term “functional endocrinology” in his practice name and to describe his services provided that he continues to disclose his credentials “D.C.” when referring to himself as “doctor” to make clear that he is a chiropractor and that his services are provided pursuant to his chiropractic credentials.
(Emphasis added.)
Under Colorado law [Sec. 12-32-102(1.7), C.R.S.], the practice of chiropractic is premised on the subluxation, that is, the notion that “disease is attributable to the abnormal functioning of the human nervous system,” in the words of the Colorado chiropractic practice act. While chiropractic practice includes “diagnosing and analyzing of human ailments,” treatment is limited to “elimination of the abnormal functioning of the human nervous system by adjustment or manipulation” of joints. However, it also includes the use of “nutritional . . . remedial measures for the promotion, maintenance, and restoration of health, the prevention of disease, and the treatment of human ailments.” In addition, Colorado law gives chiropractors the authority to use venipuncture for diagnostic purposes.
The Chiropractic Board and the Credeurs appear to interpret a chiropractor’s legal authority to diagnose “human ailments” as unlimited by the fact that, in the chiropractic view of things, disease is attributable to the subluxation, even though that is how Colorado law specifically defines chiropractic practice. In essence, they ignore this limitation and interpret scope of their legal authority to diagnose to be the same as that of a medical doctor, although actual treatment is limited to dietary supplements and other “nutritional measures” and adjustments to eliminate subluxations.
Interestingly, while the Notice of Charges refers to diagnosis, its emphasis is on the fact that the Credeurs held themselves out as being qualified to treat, “exclusively through chiropractic practice,” diabetes, thyroid disorders, and endocrine dysfunction. Here, the board is on solid ground factually. There is no good evidence that functional endocrinology is effective for any condition or disease. However, whether that means they were engaged in the unlawful practice of medicine is not clear to me, although I am not familiar with Colorado law on the subject nor am I privy to what the Board’s strategy might be here.
Even if the Credeurs prevail, it is important that the Medical Board took action to protect the practice of medicine from further encroachment by chiropractors. If the Board can’t prove that the website representations constitute the practice of medicine, perhaps it will spur the state legislature to amend the chiropractic practice act to ensure that these and other diseases are out of the reach of chiropractors seeking to poach on medical territory.
As to their other legal troubles, Channel 7 reports that the Credeurs settled at least one class action complaint brought by former patients. The Credeurs filed for bankruptcy in August, listing assets of about one million dollars and liabilities of about three million. They report as a potential liability a lawsuit filed by patients, which they value at $100,000, and as a potential asset a possible suit against Channel 7 and other media for defamation and interference with contract.
The father of functional endocrinology?
One interesting tidbit in the bankruptcy documents is a description of a dispute between the Credeurs and a disgruntled former student at one of their Functional Medicine Marketing seminars. According to the student, the Functional Medicine Marketing system was, among other deficiencies, merely a rehash of a diabetes treatment plan developed by chiropractor Datis Kharrazian.
As it turns out, Datis Kharrazian is a San Diego chiropractor who appears to be the father of functional endocrinology. He’s written a book on the subject and runs seminars for chiropractors as well as other practitioners. He is also a Diplomate of the International Board of Applied Kinesiology and teaches at the Carrick Institute, if that tells you anything.
Here’s a description a functional endocrinology course available from Kharrazian.
Functional Endocrinology, 16 hours
This seminar teaches health care practitioners how to support hormonal balance by analyzing salivary and serum testing, then applying the appropriate nutritional support.
So that’s how you do it!
For a more critical look at Kharrazian than his website offers, he is featured on the website “Science Questions with Surprising Answers” as a case study under the topic, “How can I tell if a doctor is a quack?” Guess what the conclusion is.
Brandon Credeur’s pupil
The previous post on functional endocrinology also featured one of Brandon Credeur’s seminar students and fellow Parker College of Chiropractic classmate, Brandon Babcock, of Utah. Like his teacher, Babcock claimed the ability to “reverse” diabetes with functional endocrinology and had patients paying thousands of dollars for his services. He, too, drew patients in with free “gourmet dinners” and, according to patients, failed to tell them he is a chiropractor. As an additional flourish, Babcock allegedly engaged in a financial scheme to defraud patients, which earned him an 11-count felony charge. According to the court clerk’s office (as of Tuesday), that case goes to trial tomorrow. The city of West Jordan, Utah, revoked his business license due to the pending charges. Per an emergency order, his license to practice was temporarily suspended pending a further hearing but, according to state records, the license expired in 2012.
I suppose this gets one functional endocrinology practitioner off the streets, at least for now.
Functional Endocrinology for everyone!
Despite these small victories in Colorado and Utah, the practice of functional endocrinology persists around the country, as a quick google search will demonstrate.
Functional Endocrinology of Ohio
These chiropractors claim they can treat a wide range of diseases and conditions with functional medicine, cold lasers, trigenics, detoxification, and functional endocrinology. The latter is used to treat diabetes, among other things.
At Functional Endocrinology of Ohio, we have a proven track record of turning back the hands of time on diabetes (and other conditions). Our clients reduce their need for diabetic medication (including insulin) as well as other medications and, in some cases, eliminate the need for medications altogether with the help of their medical doctor. By finding out the cause of their diabetes, we are able to bring the body chemistry back into alignment, reverse diabetes, and improve the patient’s overall health dramatically.
Healing Partnership; Encinitas, California
This practitioner, Bryan Stern, LAc, has been a student in chiropractic, naturopathic and oriental medicine schools, but is practicing under an acupuncture license. Apparently he leaves no quackery stone unturned. According to his CV, he has studied cranial therapy, electromagnetic field therapies, advanced bio-electronic diagnosis, biological detoxification, Vegatest, photon resonance testing, vector point cranial therapies, contact reflex analysis, neuro emotional technique and quantum neurology (more on this below). He studied functional endocrinology under the tutelage of the aforementioned Datis Kharrazian. Here’s some of what he has to say on that subject:
Functional Endocrinology
A New Paradigm in Balancing Hormones
The dominant approach in western medicine when it comes to balancing hormones is based on the assumption that there are no restorative capabilities of the endocrine system; that is, if function is lost replacement therapy is the primary alternative.
However, physicians that provide hormone replacement without consideration to the causative reasons for the imbalance, as well as the alterations that might be created by the replacement, have no respect or understanding for [sic] human physiology.
I think we all know who has “no respect or understanding for human physiology” and it’s not physicians.
The Hayden Institute; Houston, Texas
Practitioners include a chiropractor/acupuncturist and a chiropractor/ applied clinical nutritionist/quantum neurologist. (Read Steve Novella’s post from yesterday to learn more about this “institute” and “quantum neurology.”) Among other services is the practice of functional endocrinology:
Using a Functional Endocrinology approach to health, a practitioner at The Hayden Institute reviews your history, blood and saliva tests, signs and symptoms in order to create a specific nutritional program for you. Functional Endocrinology focuses on identifying hormonal imbalance in the body when symptoms begin to develop rather than waiting for the organs or glands to be in a diseased state.
(Emphasis in original.)
Suncoast Functional Health Center; Sarasota, Florida
The practitioner is a chiropractor and another student of Dartis Kharrazian.
A medical doctor who specializes in the endocrine system is referred to as an endocrinologist. The prescribe medications and hormones in an attempt to address a dysfunctional or diseased endocrine system. Many times, these drugs carry a significant risk of dangerous side effects, and in fact, may not offer a viable long term solution to your problems. . . .
Below is an example of how we choose to shift the model
1 Thyroid doesn’t produce proper levels of hormones
2 Doctor [of chiropractic] determines the cause(s) associated with the loss of proper thyroid function
3 Doctor [of chiropractic] works to restore proper thyroid function using adjunctive and supportive therapy, so the body can once again produce proper levels of hormones ON ITS OWN for a lifetime.
I could go on, but I think you get the depressing picture.
Under the umbrella of their broad practice acts, chiropractors create, out of whole cloth, entirely new forms of quackery, which they then pass on to other chiropractors and alternative medicine practitioners. This ever-expanding galaxy of quackery won’t be stopped until the state legislatures act to limit the scope of alternative medicine provider practice acts and reign in their governing boards. Unfortunately, the trend is in the opposite direction.

H.R. 2654 forces Medicare to treat chiropractors and MDs as equals
Chiropractors are deceptively trying to sell H.R. 2654 as expanded Medicare coverage for musculoskeletal conditions. The bill actually mandates that Medicare treat chiropractors and medical doctors as equals, covering anything a chiropractors are authorized to do under their expansive state scope of practice laws.
Jann Bellamy on June 17, 2021
Link

The “Chiropractic Medicare Coverage Modernization Act of 2021” (H.R. 2654) would force taxpayer-funded Medicare coverage of chiropractors’ services for all Medicare-covered benefits allowable under a chiropractor’s state license. Deceptively promoted by the American Chiropractic Association (ACA) as a means of increasing patient access to a broader range of pain management services and a cure for the opioid epidemic, the bill actually creates parity between medical doctors and chiropractors and requires coverage of a broad range of services going far beyond musculoskeletal issues. It is part and parcel of the ACA’s plan to rebrand chiropractors as “primary care physicians” who, in their own words,
can treat anything a medical doctor can.
Bait and switch
First, the “pain management” bait: H.R. 2654 is a reboot of a 2019 bill that tried, but fortunately failed, to do the same thing. The bill has bipartisan support of over 60 Representatives who have been fooled by the ACA into thinking this bill would simply, as the ACA puts it, expand Medicare to cover chiropractic’s “broad-based, non-drug approach to pain management” including spinal and extremity manipulation, evaluation and management services, diagnostic imaging and “utilization of other non-drug approaches”.
Now for the switch: The bill accomplishes this, per the ACA, by “appropriately defining” a Doctor of Chiropractic as a “physician” (just like an M.D. or D.O.) in the Medicare program and providing patients
access to all Medicare-covered benefits allowable under a chiropractor’s state license.
Unless you are familiar with the broad scope of practice the state legislatures have magnanimously gifted to chiropractors and the ACA’s push to redefine D.C.s as PCPs you might be forgiven for believing the ACA’s song and dance about pain management.
Co-sponsors of H.R. 2654 have apparently swallowed the bait, hook, line, and sinker. Congressional “findings” in the bill state that it would bring Medicare coverage “more in line” with that of the Veteran’s Administration, Department of Defense, federal employee coverage, and private health insurance. This is false: When these cover chiropractic services at all, it is limited to treatment of musculoskeletal issues, primarily pain.
With that introduction (and relying heavily on my post on the earlier bill), we’ll take a look at how chiropractors managed to get limited Medicare coverage in the first place. Then we’ll see just how H.R. 2654 could force taxpayers to fund chiropractors’ efforts toward redefining themselves as primary care physicians and subject seniors to their incompetent diagnosis and treatment of a wide variety of conditions.
Medicare and chiropractors: a contentious history
In the U.S., Medicare (Part B) covers people 65 years and older for “medically necessary” services and “preventive services”. “Medically necessary” services are broadly defined as “services or supplies that are needed to diagnose or treat your medical condition and that meet accepted standards of medical practice”. “Preventive services” are “health care to prevent an illness (like the flu) or detect it at an early stage, when treatment is most likely to work best”. This includes a yearly “wellness visit” to create a “personalized prevention plan” designed to help prevent disease and disability, as well as many other preventive and screening services, such as tobacco and alcohol abuse screening, obesity education, nutritional counseling, colonoscopies, mammograms, bone mass measurements, PAP smears, and so on. (Hospital services are covered under Part A.)
For M.D.s and D.O.s, Medicare will pay for any covered service. Coverage for chiropractic services is limited, however,
to treatment by means of manual manipulation of the spine to correct a subluxation.
As we know, the chiropractic “subluxation” is a fictional condition invented in 1895 by an uneducated self-styled “magnetic healer” and, most unfortunately, incorporated into the legal definition of chiropractic practice in all 50 states. This bit of legislative alchemy has permitted chiropractors, for over 100 years, to falsely claim their physical exams and wholly unnecessary x-rays have revealed “subluxations” in their patients’ spines that, unless “corrected”, can lead to all kinds of maladies. They proceed to treat these fictional subluxations with spinal “adjustments”, a process that must be repeated regularly lest their patients fall victim to the numerous ailments these non-existent subluxations are alleged to engender.
Interestingly, the ACA’s promotion of H.R. 2654 doesn’t mention the whole “subluxation” thing, presumably because they are well aware that subluxations are fictional and don’t want to open that whole can of worms by having to explain why they haven’t fessed up to Congress.
In any event, current coverage translates into just a handful of the 15,000 procedure codes used to bill Medicare. Chiropractors don’t like this, hence they want “parity” with M.D .and D.O. physicians and the ability to bill Medicare for any service that is within their expansive scope of practice, whether they are competent to perform that service or not.
Congress authorized limited Medicare coverage of chiropractic services in the early 1970s over objections of the Department of Health, Education and Welfare, as it was then called. Regulations further limit coverage to neuromusculoskeletal conditions for which manipulation is an appropriate treatment. Since inception, chiropractors and the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), whose Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) administers the Medicare program, have been locked in a near-continuous battle over claims submitted for so-called “maintenance care (sometimes called “wellness care”) which basically consists of regular “spinal checkups” for the detection and correction of (fictional) “subluxations”, advertised by chiropractors as necessary to prevent health problems. There is no evidence that maintenance care is effective for this or anything else and it is not covered by Medicare, which hasn’t stopped chiropractors from submitting hundreds of millions of dollars in unauthorized claims. They are also notorious, as detailed in several HHS Office of the Inspector General reports, for failing to adequately document their Medicare claims.
This ongoing conflict is the reason H.R. 2654 contains a provision requiring chiropractors to take a course on documentation. [The ACA also conveniently omits the substantial history behind the documentation requirement in its discussion of the bill.] Oddly, the documentation requirement does not apply if the chiropractor is seeking Medicare payment for “manual manipulation of the spine to correct a subluxation”, the very portal through which they are being paid millions of dollars for unauthorized treatment. I have no idea why.
As the ACA explains, H.R. 2654 won’t add new services, “it only allows access to all Medicare-covered services that DCs are licensed to provide”. Of course, the unspoken corollary here is that each dollar that goes into a chiropractor’s pocket is a dollar of Medicare’s $731 billion in benefit payments (2018) that is not going into an M.D.’s, D.O.’s, or allied health professional’s pocket for the same service. Hopefully, this means they’ll fight this bill tooth and nail.
The DC as PCP
With this in mind, let’s take a look at what chiropractors claim they are capable of, and authorized to do, under state law. This is what chiropractic organizations had to say on the subject in “The Chiropractic Profession and Primary Care”, part of a white paper put out by a group of alternative medicine practitioners touting “the potential contributions of chiropractors . . . as providers of primary care”. Here’s how I summarized their position in a previous post:
The chiropractors claim, right off the bat, that they are primary care physicians. This is based on the Council on Chiropractic Education, the American Chiropractic Association, International Chiropractors’ Association and other chiropractic organizations saying that they are. The authors say that chiropractors can practice as a first-contact provider for patients of all ages and genders, assess a patient’s health status, formulate a clinical diagnosis, develop a case management plan that includes treatment, prognosis, and any necessary referrals. They can (according to the ACA) address “a large majority of personal health care needs.” The ICA says that the chiropractor can “provide all three levels of primary care interventions and therefore is a primary care provider, as are MDs and DOs.” The authors further claim that chiropractors “are trained to appropriately diagnose and manage the majority of healthcare issues that may present to their offices.”
The ACA has gone so far as to establish the ersatz specialty of “chiropractic internist“, billing it as “the only natural primary care doctors that are licensed in all 50 states”. One can become a “chiropractic internist” after a series of weekend classes in hotel conference rooms, taught by other chiropractors and containing little to no clinical training, and taking a test that, as far as I can tell, no one but chiropractors has evaluated or even seen. Perhaps realizing the obviously oxymoronic character of the term “chiropractic internist”, the ACA is now pushing the more nebulous term “ACA internist“.
According to the ACA Council on Diagnosis and Internal Disorders, in answer to its rhetorical question: “Can a Chiropractic Internist treat anything a medical doctor can?”
The simple answer is YES! Chiropractic Internists use the same diagnostic tests commonly utilized by other medical professionals. . . . While it is true that the scope of practice varies from state to state, Chiropractic Internists practice in most states of the US as primary care practitioners helping people with a wide breadth of conditions and diseases.
Such as?
The list might include things like eczema, thyroid problems, diabetes, parasitic infections, cold sores, Irritable Bowel Syndrome, heartburn/reflux, autoimmune diseases (like lupus, or rheumatoid arthritis, or Crohn’s Disease), infertility, constipation, and vast amount [sic] of other diseases.
And,
Many illnesses that modern medicine has no cure for can be treated by ACA Internists with much success. Illnesses such as fibromyalgia, Crohn’s disease, IBS, migraine headaches, Lyme disease, heart disease, thyroid disease, infertility, low testosterone and diabetes can be greatly improved and often completely resolved with natural therapies offered by these natural physicians.
Of course, there is no proof whatsoever offered for these expansive claims.
In addition, according to the ACA, chiropractic/ACA internists are also
trained and licensed to draw blood, . . . [and] order saliva, urine, and stool tests . . . And since Chiropractic Internists are the natural version of a Medical General Practitioner, you’ll find they are trained to order and read a wide variety of tests (e.g., abdominal ultrasound, EKG, breathing tests, MRIs, CT scans, etc.)
As well, some chiropractors claim they are neurologists, practicing so-called “functional neurology”, about which a recent review concluded there is
no acceptable evidence on the effect or benefit of functional neurology in relation to various conditions and purported indications for intervention.
The American Chiropractic Neurology Board bestows the honorific “Diplomate” on chiropractors who have a whopping 300 hours of post-grad training in “functional neurology” and pass an exam. (An M.D. neurologist must complete four years of medical school and an additional four years of clinical training.) A current ACA continuing education course on “functional neurology” is taught by a chiropractor who co-founded “Plasticity Brain Centers”, which claim, among other things, the ability to treat
everything from Adult ADHD, Adult Autism Spectrum Disorders, early Alzheimer’s/dementia and other forms of cognitive decline, to brain injuries/concussions, dysautonomia, movement disorders, headaches/migraines, Parkinson’s disease, and even those with rare, unknown or un-diagnosable neurological challenges.
The breadth of state chiropractic scope of practice was exposed in a 2014 chiropractic journal article based on a survey of chiropractic regulatory officials. The survey reported that chiropractors are authorized by state law and regulations to order or perform a stunning variety of diagnostic and therapeutic procedures. Here’s a partial list, with the percentage of states including the listed practice in parentheses:
Barium studies (74), cholecystography (X-ray visualization of gallbladder after administration of radiopaque substance) (80), thermography (95), electrocardiography (88), venipuncture (98), blood analysis (100), urinalysis (98), sputum analysis (95), fecal analysis (95), semen analysis (84), throat swab (92), skin scrape (92), school physicals (86), US DOT physicals (98), pre-employment physicals (95), pre-marital physicals (77), sign birth certificates (38), sign death certificates (50), EENT exam (90), abdominal exam (95), stethoscopic exam (98), sphygmomanometry (blood pressure) (95), bi-manual pelvic exam (73), speculum exam (72), recto-vaginal exam (72), Pap smears (79), female breast exam (80), rectal exam (85), male genital exam (85), prostatic exam (digital) (85), hernia exam (85), ultrasound (treatment) (100), IFC (interferential therapy) (100), microcurrent therapy (100), iontophoresis (not with prescription medication) (100), Russian stimulation (100), non-ablative laser therapy, nonadjustive treatment of female pelvic conditions (72), ear irrigation (83), TMJ (100), oral chelation therapy (76), IV chelation therapy (39), vitamin injection (43), limited prescription privileges (7), oxygen therapy (57), dry needling of trigger points (64), minor surgery (9), obstetrics (22), extremity casting sprains (71), extremity casting uncomplicated fractures (58), hypnosis (66), electrolysis (44), hyperbaric chamber (62), manipulation under anesthesia (71).
Lest you be misled into thinking chiropractic scope of practice indicates actual competency in this expansive array of diagnostic methods and treatments, it does not. While the scope of this article does not permit a deep dive into the murky waters of chiropractic education and training, suffice it to say that the whole business is controlled by the chiropractors themselves and they alone decide what they are sufficiently educated and trained to do, something they are known to vastly overstate. For example, a real primary care doctor, SBM’s Harriet Hall, M.D., has ably dissected their claim that they can competently practice primary care. (For one thing, many are anti-vaccination, a position that defies good primary care. For another, chiropractic clinical training is grossly inadequate for primary care and consists almost exclusively of seeing patients with musculoskeletal issues, like back pain.) A recent cross-sectional analysis of marketing claims made by chiropractor and other alternative practitioner websites found that a substantial number of chiropractors claim to treat allergies and asthma, despite the fact that there are no chiropractic treatments shown to offer meaningful objective benefits for these conditions. Nonetheless, efficacy claims were common.
Which brings us to their latest perfidy. During the pandemic, chiropractors falsely advertised the “immune boosting” powers of “spinal adjustments” to ward off COVID-19. They shilled for “immune boosting” dietary supplements as well.
Even as they tout themselves as primary care physicians under current state law, chiropractors, with the support of the ACA, are vigorously lobbying for the expansion of chiropractic scope of practice, a campaign we’ve covered extensively here on SBM. They’ve lobbied for expanding chiropractic scope of practice to include diagnosis and treatment of all human ailments and removal of restrictions on treating infectious diseases, endocrine disorders, and abnormal histology. They’ve lobbied, with some success, to add diagnosis and treatment of student athlete concussions, performing school physicals and unnecessary scoliosis exams, prescription privileges, and nutritional counseling.
The latter is a favorite – coupled with the authority to order or perform diagnostic testing, chiropractors can fashion themselves into “functional medicine” practitioners, a lucrative alternative medicine “specialty” comprised of massive over-testing and prescription of dietary supplements, which they can turn around and sell to patients for a tidy profit. In fact, a 2017 review of studies of chiropractic practice revealed that almost a third of chiropractic patients are treated with nutritional supplements, an extraordinary number given the lack of evidence of effectiveness for supplements. But what a great sales opportunity, with taxpayers potentially picking up the tab under Medicare’s “nutritional counseling” coverage.
In several states, chiropractors have successfully included themselves in laws that allow direct primary care agreements with patients, which one lobbyist frankly admitted was aimed at positioning chiropractors as PCPs. Or they want to tack on anything they are taught in chiropractic school as a catch-all category to their scope of practice, leaving it to themselves to add whatever they wish.
Given their sweeping claims of competence and aggressive push for an ever-expanding scope of practice, one thing is certain: Despite giving lip service to pain treatment and alternatives to opioids, if H.R. 2654 passes, chiropractors are going to go full bore in forcing CMS to cover much more than musculoskeletal problems. If they had merely wanted more expansive coverage for the diagnosis and treatment of musculoskeletal conditions, including pain, it would have been easy enough to draft language to that effect, but they didn’t.
While agencies have some wiggle room in interpreting what Congress tells them to do, HHS and CMS will be hard pressed to regulate around the plain language of the bill should it become law. “Any function or action . . . legally authorized by the State” is fairly unambiguous. Based on their history of unauthorized claims under a fairly simple, albeit scientifically deficient, coverage mandate from Congress, just imagine what they could do with “parity” and the authority to bill Medicare for the entire panoply of diagnoses and treatments bestowed upon them by credulous state legislators. Think of the possibilities for colossal battles between chiropractors and CMS over whether a treatment is “medically necessary” or just whose standard should apply when making that determination: evidence-based “conventional” medicine or “chiropractic medicine”?
Don’t let chiropractors deceptively sell H.R. 2654 as an expansion of pain management services and a solution to the opioid epidemic. Let your Representative in Congress know what this bill really does.

Chiropractors as Family Doctors? No Way!
Harriet Hall on April 24, 2012
Link
A recent three-part article published in ACA News advocates turning chiropractors into “conservative primary care providers” who would be the initial point of contact for patients, would serve as gatekeepers for referrals to medical doctors and specialists, and would co-manage patients with those specialists on a continuing basis: essentially, family doctors. I think that’s a terrible idea. It might benefit chiropractors by increasing their market share, but it wouldn’t benefit patients. There is no evidence to indicate that chiropractors are capable of filling that role effectively or safely.
NUHS. The article was co-authored by several chiropractors on the faculty of the National University of Health Sciences, a school noted for integrating quackery with medicine. The “sciences” this school teaches are listed at the top of its website: chiropractic medicine, naturopathic medicine, oriental medicine, acupuncture, biomedical science, and massage therapy. The only one of those that even sounds like science, “biomedical science,” offers a bachelor of science degree with an integrative medicine focus and with no required core courses whatsoever!
Their doctor of chiropractic degree program says:
National University prepares students to become first-contact, primary care physicians fully qualified to diagnose, treat and manage a wide range of conditions.
Background. The authors say proposals to classify chiropractors as primary care physicians date back to at least 1967, with the Comprehensive Health Planning Councils. Arguably, the concept of chiropractors providing comprehensive health care dates back to the origin of chiropractic, since its founder asserted that all human disease was attributable to subluxations, 95% in the spine and 5% elsewhere. On the other hand, chiropractors used to claim they didn’t diagnose or treat illness, but only kept the spine in proper alignment so that the vitalistic force they called “Innate” could take care of anything and everything. In essence, doesn’t their aspiration to become “family doctors” amount to an admission that chiropractic is not the panacea they once held it to be? Doesn’t their wish to branch out demonstrate the failure of their discipline?
Their Arguments. They argue that more primary care providers are needed, and that chiropractors can fill the gap. They argue that using chiropractors as gatekeepers will reduce costs.
When chiropractic physicians functioned as primary care gatekeepers, pharmaceutical costs fell by 58.1 percent and hospital admissions by 43 percent. These are statistics that clearly support the value of the chiropractic physician in the primary care, gatekeeper position.
These statistics, even if correct, do not support the value of the chiropractor as gatekeeper. Cheaper is not better if it reduces quality of care. Of course pharmaceutical costs went down, because chiropractors can’t prescribe pharmaceuticals and they typically discourage patients from using them. They discourage surgery and conventional medical care, so it’s not surprising that hospital admissions fell; but maybe some of those patients would have been better off in the hospital. And I would guess that vaccination costs dropped too, since only around half of chiropractors support vaccination. We need to know the health outcomes for those patients, not just how much money was saved. Parents who belong to faith healing cults and never take their children to a doctor can cut medical costs to zero, but sometimes the children die.
Apart from the question of costs, the ability of chiropractors to function effectively as gatekeepers has not been tested in any formal study. It is questionable, to say the least. There is anecdotal evidence that occasionally a chiropractor makes a diagnosis that MDs have missed and that many chiropractors refer appropriately, but there is at least as much anecdotal evidence that chiropractors have missed diagnoses that would be obvious to any MD, and that they have failed to send patients to the emergency room for medical emergencies such as classic heart attack symptoms or fevers in very young infants.
They recognize that not all chiropractors are willing or able to carry out their vision:
Among the challenges is the diversity of our colleagues—those wanting to participate in primary care who order technical diagnostic procedures and clinical laboratory tests versus those who want to remain subluxation based. There are those who want to treat the whole person versus those who want to treat only musculoskeletal conditions. There are those of us who want to use treatment modalities beyond the adjustment, as well as those who feel we should adjust only the spine.
Managing Chronic Disease
“Conservative primary care physician” is language intended to clarify that as chiropractic physicians we do not address the complex primary care disease states that require pharmaceutical intervention and management.
Unfortunately, many do. I am increasingly hearing about chiropractors who profess to cure diabetes. They call themselves “doctors” and many of their patients don’t realize they are seeing chiropractors.
Chiropractors aspire to being part of a health care team, managing musculoskeletal problems and “co-managing” chronic diseases by counseling on lifestyle, diet, and exercise. They want to manage psychosocial issues such as anxiety and depression, and they want to use preventive management strategies to reduce the incidence of cancer and dementia. They want to. But that doesn’t mean they can.
A Primer on the History and Physical. After saying in part 1 that chiropractors should provide primary care, they proceed in part 2 to a primer on how to take a history. The fact that they feel a need to explain this implies that chiropractors don’t already understand the basic principles. They proceed to explain how to ask about chief complaint, history of present illness, past medical history, family history, social history, and review of systems. They even feel a need to explicitly remind chiropractors to ask if the patient smokes!
Even their attempt to instruct chiropractors is flawed. For instance, they recommend simple lab tests, but their recommendations for sedimentation rates and CRP testing are not evidence-based and do not correspond to standard medical practice.
In part 3, they describe an office visit and comprehensive physical exam in great detail, with many recommendations that are non-standard and not evidence-based:
Routine pulse oximeter readings on every patient. (This may be routine in the ER, but it is not and should not be a routine part of every visit to a doctor’s office.)
If any vital signs are abnormal, instead of taking prompt and appropriate action, they recommend that “they should be tracked on a regular basis to determine if a specialist consultation and/or further medical intervention is needed.”
For trauma patients, they recommend assessing the patient’s short and long term memory and considering a mini-mental status test. (For most trauma patients this would be a waste of time.)
As part of the chest exam, they recommend testing tactile fremitus. Abnormal tactile fremitus is a sign of lung consolidation in patients with pneumonia. It is only appropriate as part of a directed physical to pin down a suspected diagnosis, and even then it is not a particularly useful test. It’s one of those things doctors learned in medical school but rarely if ever use in practice because there are far better ways to make the diagnosis.
“The role of testing for H. pylori infection in GERD (gastrointestinal reflux disease) remains controversial.” No, it doesn’t. There’s no controversy: there’s a clear consensus that such testing is not indicated. Some patients can be treated on the basis of symptoms alone; others will need endoscopy. H. pylori testing is done for suspected ulcers, not for GERD.
What really surprised me was their extensive coverage of the musculoskeletal exam. This is their particular area of expertise; surely chiropractors don’t need to be reminded about how to evaluate joint motion, muscle strength, and tender points. They ask “Is there any indication that the patient would be at increased risk for spinal manipulation of the neck?” It seems they recognize that neck manipulation can precipitate a stroke; unfortunately, there is no reliable way to rule out risk, and implying that chiropractors can do so is misleading and dangerous.
This whole exercise struck me as silly, condescending, and embarrassing. If chiropractors were already qualified to be primary care providers, they wouldn’t need to be given this information. If they are not qualified, a simplistic tutorial like this isn’t enough to educate them.
Legislation and Other Developments. Legislation has been proposed to expand the scope of chiropractic and even to authorize limited prescribing privileges. Government programs and insurance companies are considering expanding reimbursement policies. In some places chiropractors are authorized to do sports physicals as well as drug testing and DOT physicals for commercial drivers licenses. National University is even offering what they call a family practice residency.
Other Non-MDs Do It. It could be argued that other non-MD providers carry out primary care and gatekeeper functions. Physician assistants are one example whose training equips them to do the job well. My main concerns about chiropractors assuming these functions are:
Their thought processes and clinical judgment have developed in the context of a discipline that was originally based on erroneous ideas and that is still lacking in scientific rigor. (These authors still speak of the “subluxation.”)
Their training has not exposed them to seriously ill, hospitalized patients, which I think is essential to developing judgment about situations requiring emergency care or referral.
Many chiropractors espouse nonsensical tests and treatments. Just one example: according to an American Chiropractic Association survey, an appalling 38% of US chiropractors use applied kinesiology, one of the most ridiculous travesties in all of alternative medicine.
Patients under the care of chiropractors are less likely to get vaccinations; only around half of chiropractors recommend them.
Chiropractors should not be treating children, but many do so.
Bottom line: Some chiropractors are family doctor wannabes, but they are not equipped to fill that role.

Turning chiropractors into primary care physicians via Legislative Alchemy
Via the magic of Legislative Alchemy, chiropractic lobbyists are trying to to convince state legislators to expand chiropractic scope of practice so they can rebrand as primary care physicians.
Jann Bellamy on February 16, 2017
Link


New legislative sessions have begun in all but a couple of states. Unfortunately, this means more legislative alchemy (the process by which state legislatures turn pseudoscience and quackery into licensed health care practices) is brewing across the U.S.
The American Chiropractic Association (ACA) and the Council on Chiropractic Education (CCE), the accrediting agency for chiropractic schools, are pushing the idea that chiropractors are primary care physicians, a topic we’ve covered extensively here on SBM. To carry out their scheme, the ACA, CCE and like-minded chiropractors need to amend the state chiropractic practice acts to broaden their scope of practice so that they are no longer limited to “detecting” and “correcting” the non-existent vertebral subluxation. Today, we look at several bills aiming do just that.
Indiana
In 2015, the ACA announced “Six Key Elements of a Modern Chiropractic Practice Act,” its ideal version of what chiropractors should be allowed to do under state law. They included:
    • “Chiropractic Physician” and “Chiropractic Medicine” as the Regulatory Terms of Licensure.
    • Scope of Practice Determined by Doctoral and Post-Doctoral Education, Training and Experience Obtained Through Appropriately Accredited Institutions.
    • Full Management, Referral and Prescription Authority commensurate with contemporary chiropractic education for Patient Examination, Diagnosis, Differential Diagnosis and Health Assessment.
    • Full Management, Referral and Prescription Authority commensurate with contemporary chiropractic education for the Care and Treatment of Neuromusculoskeletal and Other Health Conditions or Issues.
    • Full Authority for the Delivery of Information, Advice, Recommendations and Counseling Regarding General Health Matters, Wellness and Health Optimization.
Indiana defines the practice of chiropractic as the diagnosis and analysis of “any interference with normal nerve transmission and expression” and “the correction thereof by an adjustment . . . of the vertebral column.” In other words, traditional subluxation-based chiropractic.
It is unlikely the average Indiana legislator reading Senate Bill 437 would be aware of the huge expansion in practice scope it portends or its implications for patient care. (I cannot find evidence that the Indiana State Medical Association has taken any position on this legislation.) But if you’ve followed the chiropractic industry for over a decade, as I have, you learn how to read between the lines. Here’s how SB 437 aligns itself with the ACA’s “Six Key Elements.”
“Chiropractic Physician” and “Chiropractic Medicine” as the Regulatory Terms of Licensure.
The bill allows chiropractors to call themselves “chiropractic physicians.”
Scope of Practice Determined by Doctoral and Post-Doctoral Education, Training and Experience Obtained Through Appropriately Accredited Institutions.
SB 437 authorizes a huge expansion of chiropractic practice, including sophisticated diagnostic testing and diagnosis and treatment of virtually any disease or condition. (We’ll return to the particulars in a moment.) The only limitation is that the chiropractor learned, in the language of the bill, “a therapy” he uses:
in a chiropractic college or chiropractic program in a university that has been accredited by the Council on Chiropractic Education [CCE] . . . or approved by rules of the [state chiropractic] board . . .
With this provision, the state will essentially default to the state chiropractic board and CCE-accredited chiropractic schools to determine chiropractic scope of practice. The board, by simply enacting a rule, could decide what therapies a chiropractor could use.
For its part, the CCE has already declared that all chiropractic schools are required to teach students to “practice primary health care as a portal-of-entry provider for patients of all ages and genders.” The CCE-accredited National University of Health Sciences, which has programs in chiropractic, naturopathy and acupuncture, among others, says that its “Students are well prepared to become first-contact, primary care physicians, ready to diagnose, treat and manage a wide range of patients and conditions.” (Of course, this isn’t actually true, but it reveals the depth of their delusion that their education and training prepares them to become primary care practitioners or PCPs.)
In addition, the ACA has set up so-called “post-doctoral” programs to train, for example, “chiropractic internists” and “chiropractic pediatricians.” These 300-or-so-hour courses are taught on weekends, often in hotel conference rooms. Via affiliation with a CCE-accredited school, or by virtue of recognition of a “specialty” by the state chiropractic board, practices learned in these courses would automatically become part of the legal scope of chiropractic practice.
Full Management, Referral and Prescription Authority commensurate with contemporary chiropractic education for Patient Examination, Diagnosis, Differential Diagnosis and Health Assessment [and] . . . for the Care and Treatment of Neuromusculoskeletal and Other Health Conditions or Issues. (Emphasis added.)
SB 437 does not give chiropractors prescription authority, but they come close to getting everything else the ACA wants in this regard. The bill prohibits chiropractors from treating (but not diagnosing) infectious diseases, endocrine disorders, or atypical or abnormal histology, but otherwise allows them to diagnose and treat an unlimited array of diseases and conditions. They would be able to:
. . . evaluate and examine individuals to determine the presence of, or absence of, and diagnosis of physical or physiologic injuries, conditions, or disorders of the body.
What is striking is how hard the bill tries to avoid coming out and saying the word “disease” while at the same time clearly meaning exactly that.
They will also be able to “treat injuries, conditions, and disorders” with “the administration or dispensing of supportive therapies” and “any other therapeutic procedure or service (emphasis added).” It’s hard to get any more inclusive than “any other.” (Remember, the only limitation being that they learned this “therapy” in a chiropractic school or the chiropractic board approves it.)
Given these broad parameters, while never saying the words “dietary supplements” (which includes vitamins, minerals, herbs, enzymes, and glandulars) or “homeopathic remedies,” clearly chiropractors will be able to recommend and “dispense” (translation: sell) these and other “supportive” remedies to their patients. This is reinforced in a provision allowing chiropractors to give “nutrition” advice. The bill also allows chiropractors to “use filiform needles for the treatment of muscle pain,” or dry needling.
If you’re thinking it’s a stretch to interpret SB 437 as an attempt to vastly expand chiropractic practice, the bill’s provisions on diagnostic testing will erase your doubts. As long as the magic wand of board rule or instruction in a CCE-accredited institution is waved over it, chiropractors would be able to:
. . . order, perform, and interpret laboratory, radiological, electrodiagnostic, or any other diagnostic studies . . . including the ordering of advanced imaging of all parts of the human body. (Emphasis added.)
In sum, they will be able to order and perform any diagnostic test an MD can order: MRIs, PET scans, mammograms, EKGs, barium enemas, colonoscopies, hearing studies, pap smears, genetic testing, thallium stress tests, coronary artery cath studies, obstetric pelvimetry, pneumoencephalograms, xenon 127 pulmonary ventilation scan . . . you name it.
And that’s the legit tests. For the more quackery-minded chiropractor, there’s ALCAT and IgG food “sensitivity” testing, breast thermography for cancer screening, “functional” lab testing, salivary testing for hormones, MTHFR genetic testing (the quack version), and lab tests for heavy metals and “toxins.”
To mimic the language, if not the actual skill, of real primary care, SB 437 authorizes chiropractors to:
. . . manage, coordinate, or delegate patient care functions including initiating referrals, to specialists for concurrent, additional, or alternative services or care the chiropractic [sic] believes is most suited for the individual’s chiropractic condition.
I am not sure what limitation, if any, the term “chiropractic condition” puts on the chiropractor’s authority to manage a patient’s care. Given the extremely broad scope of practice this bill allows, I am chalking it up to poor drafting, not an intent to curb a chiropractor’s authority to diagnose and treat virtually any disease or condition.
Tennessee
Chiropractic practice is currently defined under Tennessee law as:
. . . the art of locating and removing interference with nerve transmission and nerve function . . . directed toward restoring and maintaining the normal neuromuscular and musculoskeletal function and health of the patient.
Again, traditional subluxation-based chiropractic. Tennessee Senate Bill 313 and House Bill 387 would expand chiropractic practice to include:
. . . differential diagnosis of human aliments through examination and evaluation of patients . . . through the ordering and performance of appropriate diagnostic procedures necessary to clinically correlate a physical examination to a diagnostic impression.
To achieve this differential diagnosis, the chiropractic “physician” could order x-rays, advanced diagnostic imaging “and other diagnostic procedures” and the “collection of bodily fluids and specimens for analysis.” The chiropractor could actually perform “other diagnostic procedures” if he has “received training” in them.
Under these bills, a chiropractor could treat not only neuromuscular and musculoskeletal conditions, but also what is referred to cryptically as “other conditions.” Treatment methods include, in addition to physical methods (such as “chiropractic adjustment and manipulation”), “other therapeutic care” and “chemical, electrical and thermal methods.” They can also provide “supportive care with due regard for nutrition . . . and rehabilitation.”
Given the vagueness of these terms, I would wager that the chiropractor could legally advise patients to take, and perhaps sell to them, non-prescription substances like OTC drugs, dietary supplements and homeopathic remedies. They are also specifically allowed to use acupuncture if they have additional training.
Chiropractors aren’t allowed to “practice medicine or surgery or osteopathy,” but that leaves little guidance as to just what it is a chiropractor can and cannot do if one of these bills becomes law. The practice of medicine is defined under Tennessee law as “diagnose, treat, operates on or prescribes for any physical injury or deformity.” Even if chiropractors are prevented from operating and prescribing, how is “differential diagnosis of human ailments,” any different from “diagnose [and] treat . . . any physical aliment or any physical injury to or deformity?”
Lest you think I’m reading too much into the intent of SB 313 and HB 387, two other bills pending in the Tennessee legislature should remove all doubt. Senate Bill 224 and House Bill 334 amend a state law allowing physicians to enter into direct primary care agreements with patients. Pursuant to a direct primary care agreement, a physician provides primary care to a patient for a flat fee over a set time period (a year, for example) rather than, say, billing the patient’s insurer or accepting fee for service.
Primary care is defined in the law permitting such agreements as:
. . . the screening, assessment, diagnosis, and treatment for the purpose of promotion of health or the detection and management of disease or injury within the competency and training of the direct primary care physician.
SB 224 and HB 334 would amend this law to permit chiropractic “physicians” to enter into direct primary care agreements with patients, leaving little doubt as to the intent of the chiropractic industry in lobbying for expanded scope of practice. Inexplicably, HB 334 is sponsored by Rep. Sabi Kumar, a general/vascular surgeon. I could not find evidence that the Tennessee Medical Association has taken a position on any of these bills.
New Mexico
For the third session in a row, the indefatigable chiropractic promoter Rep. Cisco McSorley has introduced a bill (Senate Bill 150) expanding chiropractic scope of practice beyond his previous accomplishments in that regard, which were substantial. Like other pending bills, scope of practice would extend beyond detecting and correcting subluxations, to include:
. . . diagnosis and treatment of a condition for which the chiropractic physician has been educated and trained.
Chiropractic practice is renamed “chiropractic medicine” and chiropractors become “chiropractic physicians.” The bill does away with the current law’s definition of scope of practice, leaving it up to the state chiropractic board to determine what chiropractic “physicians” can and cannot do.
New Mexico is unique in giving “advanced practice” chiropractors limited prescription privileges. Their formulary contains quack favorites like dessicated animal thyroid and homeopathic remedies, including “homeopathic flu shots,” which, according to one New Mexico chiropractor, have this amazing advantage over the real flu vaccine:
[They] stimulate an immune response designed to strengthen resistance to all flu viral elements, whether last year’s or any other years, making the mutating quality of flu virus irrelevant and not a factor in the effectiveness that conventional flu vaccines demonstrate.
Someone call the CDC!
However, they cannot prescribe or administer dangerous drugs, controlled substances, any drugs for injection or substances not listed in their practice act without approval by the medical and pharmacy boards. Rep. McSorley’s bill does away with the requirement that the medical and pharmacy boards’ approve drugs for injection and expands the drugs they can use. “Collaboration” with (not approval by) the medical and pharmacy boards is required only if they want to expand the formulary even further. This means they would be allowed to inject patients with bioidentical hormones, vitamin cocktails and “live cell products,” among other substances. (I could not find that “live cell products” is an established regulatory term. Perhaps they mean stem cells?)
But wait, that’s not all: SB 150 would create a new category called the “Level Two advanced practice chiropractor,” who could, after an additional 650 hours of education and training beyond Level One (the current iteration of “advanced practice”):
. . . prescribe, administer, inject and dispense dangerous drugs that are used in a standard primary care practice,
with the exception of Schedule I and II controlled substances.
This 650 hours, presumably taught at a chiropractic or perhaps naturopathic school, would have to include “primary care case management” and “patient safety and standards of primary care.”
In past years, attempts to expand chiropractic prescribing privileges in New Mexico by statute or board rule has resulted in heated debate and litigation, pitting the medical and pharmacy professions, with an assist from the International Chiropractic Association (ICA), against the “DC as PCP” faction of chiropractors. This year, however, the bill isn’t even mentioned on the websites of the New Mexico Medical Society, the New Mexico Chiropractic Association or the ICA, which currently appears to be totally consumed in fighting (in cahoots with the National Vaccine [Mis]Information Center), California’s new law eliminating personal belief exemptions from vaccination and other pro-vaccination legislative initiatives. (Yes, many chiropractors are anti-vaccination, making the prospect of their practicing as PCPs particularly horrifying.)
Connecticut, Oregon, Colorado and Florida
More modest attempts to expand chiropractic scope of practice are pending in other states.
In Connecticut (Senate Bill 323; House Bill 6249) and Oregon (Senate Bill 217; House Bill 2390), bills are pending to allow chiropractors (and, in Oregon, naturopaths) to return students to play after a concussion. Connecticut House Bill 6029 would go even further by allowing chiropractors to diagnose a concussion. Mark Crislip, MD, has discussed in depth why their lack of education and training, plus their use of pseudoscience in the treatment of concussions, makes chiropractors wholly inadequate to the task of diagnosing and treating this form of brain trauma.
Finally, Colorado law permits the inhumane practice of “animal chiropractic,” defined as “diagnosing and treating animal vertebral subluxation,” including the use of x-rays for diagnosis. This is a neat trick to convince pet owners of the need for treatment by “showing” Fluffy’s “subluxation” on x-ray film. The law requires chiropractors to get clearance from a veterinary physician before “detecting” and “correcting” subluxations in animals. Colorado Senate Bill 135 removes the clearance requirement for chiropractors who are registered in animal chiropractic with the state.
Update: I just learned that bills are pending in my own state, Florida, which would allow chiropractors to enter into direct primary care agreements with patients. (Senate Bill 240; House Bill 161) As in other states, chiropractic is defined under Florida law as the detection and correction of vertebral subluxations. “Primary care service” is defined in these bills as
the screening, assessment, diagnosis, and treatment of a patient for the purpose of promoting health or detecting and managing disease or injury within the competency and training of the primary care provider.
Again, chiropractors are incompetent to provide this level of care and it is misleading to the public to imply that they are by allowing chiropractors to enter into direct primary care agreements with patients. It is important to remember that these agreements are not bound by the usual limitations imposed by health insurers based on the lack of evidence of safety or effectiveness. (See, for example, Aetna’s discussion of coverage of chiropractic services.) While patients are always free to pay out of their own pockets for services not covered by insurance, questions concerning the evidence base for a particular diagnosis or treatment will not be raised in the minds of consumers as they are when an insurer denies coverage.
We are following this and other Legislative Alchemy over on the Society for Science-Based Medicine website, where Mark Crislip has installed a nifty new map of the U.S. You can click on your state to see what’s brewing. For a depressingly comprehensive look at the entire country, there’s also a list of all pending legislation. The map and list are updated weekly, so check back often. To find out how to contact your state representative and voice your opinion on these bills, check out usa.gov.

The DC wants to play PCP on your dime: H.R. 3654 forces Medicare to cover full chiropractic scope of practice
A bill pending before Congress (H.R. 3654) would expand Medicare coverage of chiropractic services to their full scope of practice under state laws. Chiropractors claim they are primary care physicians and want to force Medicare to pay them as such, just like an M.D. or D.O.
Jann Bellamy on August 15, 2019
Link

The American Chiropractic Association (ACA) and other chiropractic industry groups are promoting the “Chiropractic Medicare Modernization Act of 2019” (H.R. 3654), now pending in the U.S. House of Representatives, which would expand government-funded Medicare coverage of chiropractors’ services beyond “manual manipulation of the spine.” According to the ACA, which had a heavy hand in its drafting, the bill would mean Medicare coverage for chiropractic’s “broad-based, non-drug approach to pain management” including spinal and extremity manipulation, evaluation and management services, diagnostic imaging and “utilization of other non-drug approaches” to prevent opioid abuse.
The bill accomplishes this, per the ACA, by “appropriately defining” a Doctor of Chiropractic as a “physician” in the Medicare program and providing patients
access to all Medicare-covered benefits allowable under a chiropractor’s state license.
On reading the ACA’s description, one could be forgiven for thinking that a chiropractor’s scope of practice under state law is limited to treatment of pain, primarily via use of manual manipulation, and that this bill would simply allow patients to access additional means of pain management and attendant services, such as evaluation and diagnostic imaging. After all, a majority of the public sees chiropractors as “back doctors”.
This assumption is reinforced by Congressional “findings” contained in the bill itself, stating that the H.R. 3654 would bring Medicare coverage “more in line” with that of the Veteran’s Administration, Department of Defense (also here), federal employee coverage, and private health insurance. When these cover chiropractic services at all, it is limited to treatment of musculoskeletal issues, primarily pain.
But as the ACA damn well knows, chiropractic scope of practice under state law goes far beyond diagnosis and treatment of musculoskeletal issues and manual therapy. In fact, the ACA aggressively promotes the notion that chiropractors are fully capable of acting as your primary care physician under current state laws, a topic we’ve covered extensively on SBM: “The DC as PCP” (posts listed here).
Medicare and chiropractors: a contentious history
By way of background, let’s take a brief look at Medicare and how it covers chiropractic services, as opposed to that of MDs and DOs, a sore subject among chiropractors and the genesis of H.R. 3654.
In the U.S., Medicare (Part B) covers people 65 years and older for “medically necessary” services and “preventive services”. “Medically necessary” services are broadly defined as “services or supplies that are needed to diagnose or treat your medical condition and that meet accepted standards of medical practice”. “Preventive services” are “health care to prevent an illness (like the flu) or detect it at an early stage, when treatment is most likely to work best.” This includes a yearly “wellness visit” to create a “personalized prevention plan” designed to help prevent disease and disability, as well as many other preventive and screening services, such as tobacco and alcohol abuse screening, obesity education, nutritional counseling, colonoscopies, mammograms, bone mass measurements, PAP smears, and so on. (Hospital services are covered under Part A.)
For MDs and DOs, Medicare will pay for any covered service. Coverage for chiropractic services is limited, however,
only to treatment by means of manual manipulation of the spine to correct a subluxation.
This translates into just 3 of the 15,000 procedure codes used to bill Medicare. Chiropractors don’t like this, hence they want “parity” with MD and DO physicians and the ability to bill Medicare for any service that is within their expansive scope of practice, the ACA’s top regulatory and legislative priority.
[The ACA’s promotion of H.R. 3654 doesn’t mention the “subluxation” part, presumably because they are well aware that subluxations don’t exist and don’t want to open that whole can of worms by having to explain (1) why they haven’t pointed this fact out to Congress and (2) why HR 3654 permits continued Medicare coverage of the “correction” of a fictional pathology.]
Congress authorized limited Medicare coverage of chiropractic services in the early 1970s over objections of the Department of Health, Education and Welfare, as it was then called. Regulations further limit coverage to neuromusculoskeletal conditions for which manipulation is an appropriate treatment. Since inception, chiropractors and the Department of Health and Human Services, whose Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) administers the Medicare program, have been locked in a near-continuous battle over claims submitted for “maintenance care”,
a treatment plan that seeks to prevent disease, promote health, and prolong and enhance the quality of life; or therapy that is performed to maintain or prevent deterioration of a chronic condition.
This so-called “maintenance care” (sometimes called “wellness care”) basically consists of regular “spinal checkups” for the detection and correction of (fictional) “subluxations”, advertised by chiropractors as necessary to prevent health problems. There is no evidence that maintenance care is effective for this or anything else and it is not covered by Medicare, which hasn’t stopped chiropractors from submitted hundreds of millions of dollars in unauthorized claims. They are also notorious, as detailed in several HHS Office of the Inspector General reports, for failing to adequately document their Medicare claims.
This ongoing conflict is the reason H.R. 3654 contains a provision requiring chiropractors to take a course on documentation. [The ACA conveniently omits the substantial history behind the documentation requirement in its discussion of the bill.] Oddly, the documentation requirement does not apply if the chiropractor is seeking Medicare payment for “manual manipulation of the spine to correct a subluxation”, the very portal through which they are being paid millions of dollars for unauthorized treatment. Go figure.
As the ACA explains, H.R. 3654 won’t add new services, “it only allows access to all Medicare-covered services that DCs are licensed to provide”. Of course, the unspoken corollary here is that each dollar that goes into a chiropractor’s pocket is a dollar of Medicare’s $702 billion in benefit payments (2017) that is not going into an MD’s, DO’s, or allied health professional’s pocket for the same service. Hopefully, this means they’ll fight this bill tooth and nail.
The DC as PCP (again!)
With this in mind, let’s take a look at what chiropractors claim they are capable of, and authorized to do, under state law. This is what chiropractic organizations had to say on the subject in “The Chiropractic Profession and Primary Care,” part of a white paper put out by an group of alternative medicine practitioners touting “the potential contributions of chiropractors . . . as providers of primary care.” Here’s how I summarized their position in a previous post:
The chiropractors claim, right off the bat, that they are primary care physicians. This is based on the Council on Chiropractic Education, the American Chiropractic Association, International Chiropractors’ Association and other chiropractic organizations saying that they are. The authors say that chiropractors can practice as a first-contact provider for patients of all ages and genders, assess a patient’s health status, formulate a clinical diagnosis, develop a case management plan that includes treatment, prognosis, and any necessary referrals. They can (according to the ACA) address “a large majority of personal health care needs.” The ICA says that the chiropractor can “provide all three levels of primary care interventions and therefore is a primary care provider, as are MDs and DOs.” The authors further claim that chiropractors “are trained to appropriately diagnose and manage the majority of healthcare issues that may present to their offices.”
The ACA has gone so far as to establish the ersatz specialty of “chiropractic internist,” billing it as “the only natural primary care doctors that are licensed in all 50 states”. One can become a “chiropractic internist” after a series of weekend classes in hotel conference rooms, taught by other chiropractors and containing little to no clinical training, and taking a test that, as far as I can tell, no one but chiropractors has evaluated, or even seen. Perhaps realizing the obviously oxymoronic character of the term “chiropractic internist”, the ACA is now pushing the more nebulous term “ACA internist.”
According to the ACA Council on Diagnosis and Internal Disorders, in answer to its rhetorical question: “Can a Chiropractic Internist treat anything a medical doctor can?”
The simple answer is YES! Chiropractic Internists use the same diagnostic tests commonly utilized by other medical professionals. . . . While it is true that the scope of practice varies from state to state, Chiropractic Internists practice in most states of the US as primary care practitioners helping people with a wide breadth of conditions and diseases.
Such as?
The list might include things like eczema, thyroid problems, diabetes, parasitic infections, cold sores, Irritable Bowel Syndrome, heartburn/reflux, autoimmune diseases (like lupus, or rheumatoid arthritis, or Crohn’s Disease), infertility, constipation, and vast amount [sic] of other diseases.
And,
Many illnesses that modern medicine has no cure for can be treated by ACA Internists with much success. Illnesses such as fibromyalgia, Crohn’s disease, IBS, migraine headaches, Lyme disease, heart disease, thyroid disease, infertility, low testosterone and diabetes can be greatly improved and often completely resolved with natural therapies offered by these natural physicians.
Of course, there is not one whit of proof offered for these statements.
According to the ACA, chiropractic/ACA internists are also
trained and licensed to draw blood, . . . [and] order saliva, urine, and stool tests . . . And since Chiropractic Internists are the natural version of a Medical General Practitioner, you’ll find they are trained to order and read a wide variety of tests (e.g., abdominal ultrasound, EKG, breathing tests, MRIs, CT scans, etc.)
The breadth of state chiropractic scope of practice was exposed in a 2014 chiropractic journal article based on a survey of chiropractic regulatory officials. The survey reported that chiropractors are authorized by state law and regulations to order or perform a stunning variety of diagnostic and therapeutic procedures. Here’s a partial list, with the percentage of states including the listed practice in parentheses:
Barium studies (74), cholecystography (X-ray visualization of gallbladder after administration of radiopaque substance) (80), thermography (95), electrocardiography (88), venipuncture (98), blood analysis (100), urinalysis (98), sputum analysis (95), fecal analysis (95), semen analysis (84), throat swab (92), skin scrape (92), school physicals (86), US DOT physicals (98), pre-employment physicals (95), pre-marital physicals (77), sign birth certificates (38), sign death certificates (50), EENT exam (90), abdominal exam (95), stethoscopic exam (98), sphygmomanometry (blood pressure) (95), bi-manual pelvic exam (73), speculum exam (72), recto-vaginal exam (72), Pap smears (79), female breast exam (80), rectal exam (85), male genital exam (85), prostatic exam (digital) (85), hernia exam (85), ultrasound (treatment) (100), IFC (interferential therapy) (100), microcurrent therapy (100), iontophoresis (not with prescription medication) (100), Russian stimulation (100), non-ablative laser therapy, nonadjustive treatment of female pelvic conditions (72), ear irrigation (83), TMJ (100), oral chelation therapy (76), IV chelation therapy (39), vitamin injection (43), limited prescription privileges (7), oxygen therapy (57), dry needling of trigger points (64), minor surgery (9), obstetrics (22), extremity casting sprains (71), extremity casting uncomplicated fractures (58), hypnosis (66), electrolysis (44), hyperbaric chamber (62), manipulation under anesthesia (71).
Lest you be misled into thinking chiropractic scope of practice indicates actual competency in this expansive array of diagnostic methods and treatments, it does not. As is true with H.R. 3654, chiropractors have had a heavy hand in drafting their state licensing laws. While the scope of this article does not permit a deep dive into the murky waters of chiropractic education and training, suffice it to say that the whole business is controlled by the chiropractors themselves and they alone decide what they are sufficiently educated and trained to do, something they are known to vastly overstate. For example, a real primary care doctor, SBM’s Harriet Hall, MD, has ably dissected their claim that they can competently practice primary care. (For one thing, many are anti-vaccination, a position that defies good primary care. For another, chiropractic clinical training is grossly inadequate for primary care and consists almost exclusively of seeing patients with musculoskeletal issues, like back pain.) A recent cross-sectional analysis of marketing claims made by chiropractor and other alternative practitioner websites found that a substantial number of chiropractors claim to treat allergies and asthma, despite the fact that there are no chiropractic treatments shown to offer meaningful objective benefits for these conditions. Nonetheless, efficacy claims were common.
Put another way: Why would you trust anyone who promotes something called a “chiropractic internist” to accurately determine competency to do, well, anything?
Even as they tout themselves as primary care physicians under current state law, chiropractors, with the support of the ACA, are vigorously lobbying for the expansion of chiropractic scope of practice, a campaign we’ve covered extensively here on SBM. They’ve lobbied for expanding chiropractic scope of practice to include diagnosis and treatment of all human ailments and removal of restrictions on treating infectious diseases, endocrine disorders and abnormal histology. They’ve lobbied, with some success, to add diagnosis and treatment of student athlete concussions, performing school physicals and unnecessary scoliosis exams, prescription privileges, and nutritional counseling. The latter is a favorite – coupled with the authority to order or perform diagnostic testing, chiropractors can fashion themselves into “functional medicine” practitioners, a lucrative alternative medicine “specialty” comprised of massive overtesting and prescription of dietary supplements, which they can turn around and sell to patients for a tidy profit. In several states, chiropractors have successfully included themselves in laws that allow direct primary care agreements with patients, which one lobbyist frankly admitted was aimed at positioning chiropractors as PCPs. Or they want to tack on anything they are taught in chiropractic school as a catch-all category to their scope of practice, leaving it to themselves to add whatever they wish.
Given their sweeping claims of competence and aggressive push for an ever-expanding scope of practice, one thing is certain: Despite giving lip service to pain treatment and alternatives to opioids, if H.R. 3654 passes, chiropractors are going to go full bore in forcing CMS to cover much more than musculoskeletal problems. If they had merely wanted more expansive coverage for the diagnosis and treatment of musculoskeletal conditions, including pain, it would have been easy enough to draft language to that effect. But the drafters (that is, the chiropractors) intentionally chose these words:
It is the purpose of this Act to expand recognition and coverage of a doctor of chiropractic as “physician” under the Medicare program in connection with the performance of any function or action, including current service of “manual manipulation of the spine to correct a subluxation,” as is legally authorized by the State in which such doctor performs such function or action.
While agencies have some wiggle room in interpreting what Congress tells them to do (a subject that is complicated, in flux, and far beyond the scope of this post), HHS and CMS will be hard pressed to regulate around the plain language of this putative statute. “Any function or action . . . legally authorized by the State” is fairly unambiguous. Based on their history of unauthorized claims under a fairly simple, albeit scientifically deficient, coverage mandate from Congress, just imagine what they could do with “parity” and the authority to bill Medicare for the entire panoply of diagnoses and treatments bestowed upon them by credulous state legislators. Think of the possibilities for colossal battles between chiropractors and CMS over whether a treatment is “medically necessary” or just whose standard should apply when making that determination: evidence-based “conventional” medicine or “chiropractic medicine”?
H.R. 3654 is part of a larger strategy to “remove current limiting scope of practice language” in all federal legislation, such as the Medical Leave Act, Workers’ Compensation and Indian Health Care Services. According to an article in The American Chiropractor:
This proposed bill, if passed, will be the initial gateway law that will guide other federal healthcare laws. While it will take time, we must also work through many current laws, rules, and regulations that will need to conform to the new full-scope coverage legislation. Some federal laws that limit chiropractic coverage include those that guide nutrition [and] wellness exams.
(Told you! Nutrition and wellness exams.)
Don’t let this happen. The bill’s primary sponsors are Rep. Brian Higgins (D-NY-26) and Rep. Tom Reed (D-NY-23). Co-sponsors are Rep. Collin C. Peterson (D-MN-7), Rep. Kurt Schrader (D-OR-5), Rep. Don Young (R-AK-At large), Rep. Guy Reschenthaler (R-PA-14), Rep. Peter A. DeFazio (D-OR-4) and Rep. Brian K. Fitzpatrick (R-PA-1). If you are a constituent (and even if you’re not), let them know the error of their ways. If you don’t live in one of these districts, contact your representative in Congress and let him or her know H.R. 3654 is a scam.

The DC as PCP? The battle continues
Jann Bellamy on January 24, 2013
Link
Chiropractors are trying to rebrand themselves as primary care physicians, a topic both Harriet Hall and I have addressed (here and here) on SBM. Toward this end, they are seeking the expansion of their scope of practice, via the magic of legislative alchemy, to include the prescription and administration of drugs. Not drugs that any self-respecting M.D. would use, but drugs nonetheless. That effort succeeded to an extent in New Mexico. Recently Colorado got into the act. Other states have followed suit.
Chiropractors have claimed from the very beginning they are primary care physicians. Chiropractic was born in 1895 with the notion that virtually all diseases could be resolved with chiropractic treatment. This was Daniel David Palmer’s original contention, that the interruption of “nerve flow” by “subluxations” caused disease which could be remedied by spinal adjustment to restore the flow, thereby allowing the body to heal itself.
State chiropractic practice acts have always given chiropractors a broad scope of practice which allows them to diagnose and treat virtually any condition as long as they can squeeze the treatment into the “chiropractic paradigm.” If they can pretend the condition is amenable to chiropractic treatment via the detection and correction of subluxations, they can diagnose and treat it legally. This is how they are able to claim, falsely, that asthma, allergies, colic, and many other health problems can be resolved by chiropractic care. This is how “straight” chiropractors still practice.

Over time, to the chagrin of the “straights,” “mixer” chiropractors sought to expand their treatment options. They’ve succeeded in all 50 states to some extent. This liberalization of their practice acts includes the right to use acupuncture and to give nutritional advice, including the sale of dietary supplements and homeopathic products. Now some of the mixers want to dump the subluxation altogether and become, by legislative fiat, real primary care doctors who use the same diagnostic methods and treatments as primary care M.D.s and D.O.s, while at the same time skipping the education and training the latter must go through.
Colorado chiropractors attempt an end run . . .
One of the main obstacles in their way is the lack of authority to prescribe drugs. Colorado chiropractors recently attempted an end run around the time-consuming and expensive process of lobbying the state legislature and getting their practice act amended to include prescription privileges. Perhaps they were aware of certain snafus (which we’ll get to soon) bedeviling New Mexico chiropractors in their quest for practice expansion. The Colorado Board of Chiropractic Examiners’ solution was to bypass the legislature altogether by simply passing a rule giving chiropractors the authority to administer and prescribe certain drugs. Never mind the fact that this was totally beyond the authority the Colorado Legislature gave the Board.
Here’s what the Colorado chiropractic practice act says, in part, chiropractors can do, in Section 12-33-102(1.7), Colorado Statutes (emphasis added):
“Chiropractic” means that branch of the healing arts that is based on the premise that disease is attributable to the abnormal functioning of the human nervous system. It includes the diagnosing and analyzing of human ailments and seeks the elimination of the abnormal functioning of the human nervous system by the adjustment or manipulation, by hand or instrument, of the articulations and adjacent tissue of the human body, particularly the spinal column, and the use as indicated of procedures that facilitate the adjustment or manipulation . . .
Up to this point, we are in familiar straight chiropractic territory. The statute goes on, reflecting the more recent addition of “nutritional measures:”
. . . and the use of sanitary, hygienic, nutritional, and physical remedial measures for the promotion, maintenance, and restoration of health, the prevention of disease, and the treatment of human ailments . . .
Colorado law specifically prohibits chiropractors from prescribing, compounding or administering drugs. Yet, in the phrase “nutritional remedial measures,” the Colorado Board of Chiropractic Examiners found an opening for the inclusion of real drugs in the chiropractic scope of practice. Or so it thought.
In November, 2012, the Board enacted Rule 7(C), which would have gone into effect on January 14, 2013:
Nutritional Remedial Measures as referenced in Section 12-33-102(1), C.R.S., means that a doctor of chiropractic may administer, prescribe, recommend, compound, sell and distribute homeopathic and botanical medicines, vitamins, minerals, phytonutrients, antioxidants, enzymes, glandular extracts, non-prescription drugs, durable and non-durable medical goods and devices.
Administer includes Oral, Topical, Inhalation, and Injection.
However, not just any chiropractor could administer these substances by injection. To do that, the chiropractor must have a “Certification in Injectables,” which can be obtained by, according to the new rule,
Successfully complet[ing] a minimum of a combined total of 24 hours of theoretical study and supervised clinical instruction . . . [and] passing a nationally recognized Injectable certification examination recognized by a CCE [Council on Chiropractic Education] accredited chiropractic college.
No, that is not a typo. It takes only 24 hours of combined instruction to use injectables, including intravenous administration of the listed substances, which are prescription drugs under federal law. (Per federal law, a substance that may be an over-the-counter dietary supplement if taken orally is a prescription drug when injected.) You do have to pass a test, but what does it say about the rigor of this examination if there is a reasonable opportunity to pass it after a 24-hour course?
. . . and get creamed
Rule 7(C) displeased just about everyone. The straight wing of chiropractic saw this move as simply another step on the road to chiropractic ruin, as detailed in a series of articles in The Chronicle of Chiropractic, an on-line publication the Foundation for Vertebral Subluxation. (You’ll need to hold your nose to avoid the smell of the National Vaccine Information Council plug on their website.) On December 5, the Colorado Attorney General issued an opinion that the rule exceeded the scope of authority granted the Board by the legislature.
Under the Colorado Administrative Procedure Act, new rules such as this one are reviewed by the Office of Legislative Legal Services (OLLS) to make sure they are within the Board’s rule making authority. OLLS quickly determined that Rule 7(C) most certainly was not within the Board’s authority and voted 8-0 to ask the legislature to repeal the rule. And on January 8, the Colorado General Assembly’s Committee on Legal Services did just that. It is unclear to me whether this repeals the rule for good, or whether the entire legislature must vote. What is not unclear is that the rule is, for all practical purposes, dead.
The Executive and Legislative branches having weighed in on the subject, the third branch of state government, the Judiciary, was also drawn into the controversy. The Colorado Medical Society and 12 more state and local medical groups sued the Board of Chiropractic Examiners. They sought an injunction against implementation of the rule, also citing the Board’s lack of authority. In addition, according to the complaint, Rule 7(C) is an intrusion into the practice of medicine as defined by statute, which gives M.D.s the authority to prescribe drugs. (Apparently, the medical society is suddenly upset about other groups practicing medicine even though they sat on their hands when naturopaths tried to do the same thing.) The suit remains pending, although I suppose it will be dismissed as moot.
How the Board of Chiropractic Examiners ever thought it could get away with this is beyond me. No doubt chiropractors will try the legislative route next time.
Chiropractic Cardiologists
Before we leave Colorado for its neighbor to the south, one more of the Board’s new rules bears mentioning, as it appears to be an effort at furthering the notion that chiropractors are somehow qualified to be PCPs. Rule 7(B)(3), which is unchallenged, states that “Electrocardiography (EKG/ECG)” is included in the chiropractic scope of practice, if the chiropractor has
One hundred and twenty (120) hours of initial and related clinical with didactic training and demonstrated competency in cardiac medicine.
“A demonstrated competency in cardiac medicine?” The very thought induces angina. No specifics are given for how said “competency” is achieved or what “initial and related clinical with didactic training” consists of. Typical of other chiropractic “specialties,” I suppose this competency is accomplished in weekend courses. Perhaps competency can be achieved by becoming a “Diplomate” of the American Board of Chiropractic Internists (DABCI), although it appears this course would actually over qualify its participants by a large margin. Here’s what an ABCI functionary says about the course, courtesy of the American Chiropractic Association website:
This specialty, says its council president, Cindy Howard, DC, DABCI, FIAMA [Fellow, International Academy of Medical Acupuncture], is essentially the chiropractic version of primary care. “We look at primary care a little bit differently,” she says. “A lot of people look at it in terms of being the first doctor someone comes to. We look at it from the perspective that we want to handle everything: work up the problem, diagnose you, and treat you. Instead of referring you to the ‘proper person,’ we want to be that person.”
Dr. Howard acknowledges that not all cases can be treated by a chiropractic physician, but thanks to the extensive training provided by the DABCI . . . certification, there are many that can. The 26 sessions of 12-hour weekends take three years to complete, followed by a three-part board exam—two written segments and one clinical competency examination.
“We do laboratory workups, blood chemistries, adrenal and hormone testing, GI function studies, EKGs,” says Dr. Howard. “We treat everything from allergies to thyroid problems to fatigue. It makes us more of a family doctor—not in the sense that we always take care of the whole family, but we can take care of all that ails them. I have people come into my office not for neck and back pain, people who don’t get adjusted, because we have other capabilities to treat naturally. If I’m adjusting somebody and not getting them better, [my training] gives me a broader range of things to look at as to what it might be.”
What family practice doctor or internist wouldn’t love to complete his training with “26 sessions of 12 hour weekends” instead of three grueling years of hospital-based residency working 80 hours a week. Let’s see, at 80 hours per week, you could do your whole residency in less than four weeks and avoid all the messiness involved in taking care of people who are really sick. Brilliant!
New Mexico: An update
Meanwhile, in New Mexico, the battle over chiropractic prescribing continues. As reported in a previous post, the legislature amended the chiropractic practice act to create a new iteration of chiropractor, an “advanced practice” version, which takes all of 90 hours of additional training plus passing a test.
The New Mexico Chiropractic Association describes part of this training on its website [capitalization and punctuation as in original]:
Routes of administration [for ‘naturally derived’ substances], of course, are oral, topical and rectal, which we may already do but new to us here are intravenous (IV) and intramuscular (IM) administration. Doctors completing the certification will be prepared to do: IM injections (B12, homeopathic, magnesium, trigger point, etc.), neural therapy injections Intravenous procedures (meyer’s [sic] cocktails, H2O2, chelation, ascorbates, amino acids, minerals, etc.), emergency procedures Laboratory testing and diagnosis.
In other words, a veritable pantry full of quack remedies, now conveniently available via an IV.
Not satisfied with the formulary it had stipulated to with the state’s medical and pharmacy boards, the Board of Chiropractic Examiners, like its compatriots in Colorado, tried an end run around its statutory authority by enacting a new formulary without the required approval of the other boards. This landed the chiropractic board in court, with the medical and pharmacy boards, as well as the International Chiropractors Association, all seeking an injunction against implementation of the formulary. The New Mexico Court of Appeals agreed with the plaintiffs and upheld a stay of the formulary. That proceeding remains pending.
Here’s an update: On September 13, 2012, the aforementioned American Chiropractic Association (ACA), filed an amicus curiae (friend of the court) brief. All the brief really says is that chiropractors, working through their state legislators and regulatory agencies, are best suited to determine their scope of practice. This is an ambiguous statement – if they mean that chiropractors should be the ones to determine what their scope of practice is, that is certainly not true. That is solely up to the legislature, which (at least ideally) takes into account all points of view, not just chiropractors. In any event, it is totally irrelevant to the issue before the court: whether the chiropractic board exceeded its authority, which it most certainly did. Even its own lawyer told the board that.
But the brief does make some interesting, if irrelevant, statements further demonstrating the ACA’s dedication to reinventing D.C.s as PCPs. The ACA actually says that chiropractors’
. . . academic and clinical training is both extensive and exhaustive and is very comparable to the level of the education and training received by medical doctors.
They go on to provide a handy chart which supposedly compares the hours required for a D.C. degree at Western States University with the hours required for a medical degree at Oregon Health Sciences University, along with the names of courses and number of hours. It purports to show that chiropractic students actually spend a few more hours in combined classroom and clinical training (4,896 v. 4,877). Of course, the Council on Chiropractic Education recently got into hot water with the U.S. Department of Education over just how accurate the system of credit hour determinations were among chiropractic colleges. Even without getting into that issue, I don’t know where this chart got its figures as the OHSU medical school curriculum doesn’t look anything like the chart. But you be the judge: Western States D.C. degree (click on “Program Curriculum” pdf) v. Oregon Health Sciences M.D. degree (see links under “Curriculum” in left column). Do you think they are “very comparable?”
The ACA brief totally fails to mention the fact that graduating from medical school is only the beginning for M.D.s. It skips the subject of residency entirely. The brief also describes several “post-graduate” training programs in a variety of “clinical disciplines and specialties,” including Chiropractic Pediatrics, Chiropractic Clinical Neurology (post-graduate training can be had at the “Carrick Institute for Graduate Studies”), and training provided by the American Board of Chiropractic Internists, whose Cindy Howard, D. C., is quoted above.
Before we leave New Mexico, let’s see what one advanced practice chiropractor, Stephen Perlstein, D.C., who was instrumental in getting the advanced practice legislation passed, is offering patients under the formulary currently allowed by law.
Biopuncture
a technique that bioregulates the body’s immune system, meaning that it heals the injury by enabling and enhancing the mechanisms that control inflammation, pain, and tissue regeneration. Biopuncture traditionally uses small needles to inject substances subcutaneously (just under the skin). On occasion, a deeper injection is required. In a single session, single or multiple injections may be necessary to cover the injured area. . . . Substances typically used in Biopuncture are homeopathic medicines, lidocaine or procaine (analgesics), sarapin (a natural pain reliever), and dextrose (an immune stimulant).
Now, you may be thinking this sounds awfully modest for a CAM treatment. Where’s the ubiquitous “one true remedy” claim. It’s right here:
Biopuncture is not only effective for sprain and strain injuries, both new and old, or pain at various joints or parts of the body of indeterminate origin, but is also remarkably effective for the following conditions:
Asthma
Eczema
Hayfever
Bronchitis
Sinusitis
Headache
Colitis
Constipation
Carpal Tunnel Syndrome
Homeopathic Flu Vaccines
After making misleadingly simplistic statements about the mutation of flu viruses and its effect on flu vaccine effectiveness, Perlstein goes on to make this absurd claim about the homeopathic “flu vaccine:”
These [homeopathic] vaccines also stimulate an immune response to a flu virus, but, unlike the conventional ones which rely on the actual virus itself which has changed, these homeopathic preparations stimulate an immune response designed to strengthen resistance to all flu viral elements, whether last year’s or any other years, making the mutating quality of flu virus irrelevant and not a factor in the effectiveness that conventional flu vaccines demonstrate.
Apparently this guy knows something that “130 national influenza centers in 101 countries [which] conduct year-round surveillance for influenza and study influenza disease trends” as well as five World Health Organization (WHO) Collaborating Centers for Reference and Research on Influenza located in the USA, the UK, Australia, Japan and China, don’t know.
Here we go again
The Arizona Association of Chiropractic has filed an application with the state legislature for an expansion of chiropractic scope of practice to include
the use of natural substances, homeopathic medication and orthomolecular therapy as an opportunity to enhance care for their patients.
According to the petition, these “services” are currently available to chiropractic patients in Oklahoma, Utah, Alaska, Oregon and Idaho, as well as New Mexico and Colorado. Ten other states are in the process of considering legislation.
We’ll return to these unfortunate developments in a future post.

The DC as PCP? Revisited
Jann BellamyonSeptember 6, 2012
Link
There is a disturbing effort afoot to rebrand chiropractors as primary care physicians, a subject both Harriet Hall and I have discussed in previous posts. Part of this effort includes convincing state legislatures to grant prescription privileges to chiropractors, an effort that succeeded in New Mexico, as reported in a post a couple of years ago. Let’s return to New Mexico and see how that is working out for everyone.
By way of background, in 2008, the New Mexico legislature created a new iteration of chiropractor called “certified advanced practice chiropractic physicians” with the authority to
prescribe, administer and dispense herbal medicine, homeopathic medicines, vitamins, minerals, enzymes, glandular products, naturally derived substances, protomorphogens, live cell products, gerovital, amino acids, dietary supplements, foods for special dietary use, bioidentical hormones, sterile water, sterile saline, sarapin or its generic, caffeine, procaine, oxygen, epinephrine and vapocoolants.
As those familiar with primary care will no doubt be aware, these aren’t exactly the type of thing the family practice doctor, pediatrician or internist would consider essential tools of practice.
The chiropractic formulary expands
The statute directed the Board of Chiropractic Examiners to develop a formulary for these substances but it had to be approved by the NM Medical Board and Board of Pharmacy. As might be expected, however, chiropractors wanted more expansive prescriptive authority and succeeded in getting it from the legislature in a subsequent amendment to the original law. This amendment eliminated the approval requirement for the listed substances and added the authority to prescribe “dangerous drugs or controlled substances, drugs for administration by injection and substances not listed” in the statute but only with approval from the medical and pharmacy boards.
This “advanced practice” status can be achieved with only 90 hours of education with whatever additional training the chiropractic board deems necessary for new substances it might want to add to the formulary. These hours can be obtained in weekend and online continuing education courses.
It didn’t take long for the chiropractors to clash with the pharmacy and medical boards over what should be included in the newly expanded formulary. (The details of this clash are chronicled, with supporting exhibits, in this document filed in the New Mexico Court of Appeals.) In September, 2009, the chiropractic board adopted a formulary which including certain drugs to be administered by injection which had not been approved by those boards. The pharmacy board appealed the chiropractic formulary to the New Mexico Court of Appeals. Later that month, representatives of the three boards ironed out their differences and a new formulary was put into place, to be effective in July, 2010.
In spite of this agreement, the chiropractic board nevertheless voted again, in June, 2010, to include in the formulary certain drugs to be administered by injection without getting the required approval. Although the chronology of events is not entirely clear, apparently the chiropractic board was about to add even more drugs for injection and dangerous drugs to the formulary in August of 2011. It will likely come as no surprise to anyone that the proposed formulary included the decidedly fringe practices of chelation therapy and prolotherapy. It also included glucosamine, which has not been approved by the FDA for medical use in humans, by injection. As well, it included a number of vitamins and minerals by injection, muscle relaxants (including metaxalone and baclofen), and glutathione for inhalation, an unproven remedy for pulmonary diseases.
Medical Board objections
At this point the medical board stepped in with a strongly worded letter to the chiropractic board stating it had voted not to approve the proposed formulary changes and set forth the reasons why. In addition to the problems noted above, the medical board complained that
New drugs have been added which have not been approved by the pharmacy board.
Drugs have been specified for injection which are not within the scope of practice of chiropractic.
Drugs were added without stating their intended use.
Additional hours of training specified by the chiropractic board do not appear to be sufficient.
The medical board also objected that no mention was made of a restriction previously agreed upon by the medical and chiropractic boards, which provided:
The patient must first be screened, by appropriate medical and laboratory means, for existing problems and contra-indications (such as renal or other diseases). Appropriate coordination with the patient’s allopathic or osteopathic physician is strongly recommended.
In another report, the medical board (here referred to as the NMMB) also said that
In February 2010, after a thorough review of the proposed chiropractic formulary and educational criteria, the NMMB adopted the position that they could not approve either the proposed drugs, or the proposed routes and dosages of administration or their safety and effectiveness. MDs and DOs would never use many of the proposed substances, especially in the manner which the chiropractors proposed for their use. . . . The NMMB also did not approve administration of dangerous drugs or controlled substances by the Advanced Practice Chiropractors based on the lack of sufficient, appropriate education, specific clinical training, and hands-on experience . . . .
So what did the chiropractic board do? Although it did drop chelation therapy, it went ahead with most of the formulary (including prolotherapy and glucosomine injections) without medical or pharmacy board approval. And it did so even though the general counsel for the New Mexico Department of Licensing and Regulation advised against approval. The attorney sat there at the meeting and specifically told the board they shouldn’t approve the formulary because no medical or pharmacy board approval had been obtained and that it was outside the scope of statutory authority granted the chiropractic board by the legislature.
At this point, the pharmacy board, this time with the medical board, went back to the New Mexico Court of Appeals seeking a stay of implementation of the new formulary. The International Chiropractic Association (ICA) filed its own action also seeking a stay. In February of this year, the Court of Appeals granted the ICA’s and boards’ motions, and stayed implementation of the 2011 formulary. These cases remain pending before the Court for a determination whether the chiropractic board exceeded its statutory authority in enacting these rules. It’s hard to imagine any reason why the Court wouldn’t strike down the challenged rules for good.
Meanwhile, back in the legislature . . .
Apparently New Mexico chiropractors determined that a more direct approach was necessary toward the goal of rebranding chiropractors as primary care physicians, with the full scope of practice that entails. So, in 2011, a sympathetic legislator, Ben Lujan, introduced a bill into the New Mexico House of Representatives. The bill’s aim was to increase substantially the scope of chiropractic practice, which was renamed “chiropractic medicine.” In addition to “locating and removing . . . misalignments or subluxations” the bill would expand “chiropractic medicine” to include “diagnosis and treatment of a condition for which the chiropractic physician has been educated and trained. . . .” And who would make the decision whether the chiropractor had been “educated and trained” to treat a “condition?” The New Mexico chiropractic board.
I have to ask: doesn’t this seem awfully cumbersome? How would the chiropractic board decide whether a particular chiropractor has been sufficiently educated and trained to diagnose or treat a particular condition? I’m no doctor, but it is my understanding that there are lots and lots of conditions. (Thousands, maybe?) Is the board going to keep a list of all of them along with the training necessary to diagnose and treat each one?
Under the bill, practitioners of “chiropractic medicine” would also be allowed to use invasive diagnostic procedures, and, if permitted by chiropractic board rule, perform operative surgery, prescribe or use controlled or dangerous drugs, and practice acupuncture.
The “chiropractic advanced practice” status was retained, again only requiring 90 hours of additional education and training, the adequacy of which was solely within the purview of the chiropractic board. With board approval, the advance practice chiropractor could prescribe and administer
any dangerous drug or controlled substance and perform and procedure that is accepted for use within the certified advanced practice chiropractic physician’s clinical specialty and for which the certified advanced practice chiropractic physician can demonstrate appropriate clinical education and hands-on training that has been approved by a nationally recognized credentialing agency or nationally recognized institution of higher learning.
No standards were imposed to determine exactly how a “clinical specialty” would be defined or what constituted a “nationally recognized credentialing agency” or “institution of learning,” leaving those determinations solely in the hands of the chiropractic board. And gone were the pesky medical and pharmacy boards. From now on, the formulary would be determined solely by the chiropractic board.
In short, the proposed statute would empower the New Mexico chiropractic board to decide when and under what circumstances any chiropractor could perform surgery and prescribe controlled substances or dangerous drugs. I say “any chiropractor” because, although the bill retained the “chiropractic advanced practice” status, it did not limit the board’s ability to allow surgery and drug prescribing authority to that status. It would also allow chiropractors to immediately start using invasive diagnostic procedures. And it would permit some vague “clinical specialty” designations by advanced practice chiropractors.
And here’s the really scary part – this bill came very close to passing. With some amendments upping the hours of training, it passed the New Mexico House of Representatives. It was finally stopped in the Senate Judiciary Committee, mostly due to a massive lobbying effort by the ICA and other chiropractors who didn’t want these changes. According to one chiropractic publication, a spokesperson for the New Mexico Medical Board testified before the legislature that the Board did not oppose the bill. If true, this position is at odds with a legislative committee report, which noted that the Board had several objections to the bill. Among those was the misleading nature of the terms “chiropractic physician” and “chiropractic medicine.”
A national movement?
Unfortunately, this ill-advised attempt to transform chiropractors into primary care physicians with prescriptive authority is not limited to New Mexico. That this may be a national effort is hinted at in the Council on Chiropractic Education’s (CCE) removing the standard phrase “without drugs or surgery” from its description of chiropractic practice. (The CCE is the national accrediting agency for chiropractic schools.) This effort is also reflected in recent changes to the Federation of Chiropractic Licensing Board’s new draft Model Practice Act for chiropractic and petitions to the National Board of Chiropractic Examiners to develop a “chiropractic advanced practice” exam.
There is a small national association of chiropractors, the First Chiropractic Physician Association of America (FCPAA), devoted to
expanding your rights as a primary care physician with full prescriptive rights and the ability to specialize you can increase your knowledge and your ‘bag of tools.’ It all adds up so you could offer more services to the public.
(Emphasis added.)
The FCPPA has 11 affiliated state organizations working toward its goal of passing legislation to accomplish this. Perhaps the reason for this movement is best summed up by one affiliate, the Florida Chiropractic Physician Association:
Aren’t you tired of worrying where your next patient will come from? Expansion means prosperity for you and better health for your patients.
Last year, the Alabama Board of Chiropractic Examiners proposed legislation (not yet introduced) which would allow that board to authorize prescribing of certain legend drugs without any additional education or training. It would expand the scope of practice to include any procedure or service taught in a chiropractic college or in courses sponsored by a chiropractic college, leaving the scope virtually open-ended.
Conclusion
The attempt to rebrand chiropractors as primary care physicians is bad enough, but giving them the legal authority to prescribe is beyond the pale. New Mexico’s ill-conceived legislation has turned into a debacle, with the pharmacy and medical boards having to haul the chiropractic board into court to comply with the law. And once they got limited privileges, chiropractors lobbied for increasing privileges to the point of wanting to prescribe controlled substances and dangerous drugs without any oversight and the right to practice surgery to boot. If you think this can’t happen in your state, think again. Remember that chiropractors got all 50 state legislatures to grant them the privilege of “detecting” and “correcting” the imaginary “subluxation.”

The DC as PCP? Drug Wars Resume
Jann Bellamy on March 19, 2015
Link


Chiropractors are once again engaged in intra-fraternal warfare over the chiropractic scope of practice, a saga we’ve chronicled before on SBM. (See the references at end of this post.) Every time it looks like the warring factions have buried their differences, they come rising to the surface like zombies.
The International Chiropractors Association (ICA), representing the “straight” faction, wants chiropractic to continue as a drugless profession. They are happy to detect and correct subluxations, thereby removing “nerve interference” and “allowing the body to heal itself” in the tradition of Daniel David Palmer. But the American Chiropractic Association (ACA) has bigger fish to fry.
This time, the ICA is upset that the ACA House of Delegates up and decided to establish a “College of Pharmacology and Toxicology,” which would operate under the auspices of the ACA Council on Diagnosis and Internal Disorders. The ACA’s announcement of the “College” is rather vague on details:
The purpose of the College is to further educate the chiropractic profession on clinical matters related to the widespread use of both prescription and over-the-counter medications and nutritional supplements.
I e-mailed the ACA several days ago asking for more information but have yet to receive a reply.
The ICA sees this move as yet another attempt by:
forces at work within some organizations actively promoting incorporating drugs into the chiropractic scope of practice.
The ICA thought it had worked all of this out in 2013, at “The Chiropractic Summit,” when the warring parties met in Seattle to hammer out a deal settling their differences over the CCE and it’s troubles with the Department of Education. A treaty from those efforts declares:
The drug issue is a non-issue because no chiropractic organization in the Summit promotes the inclusion of prescription drug rights and all chiropractic organizations in the Summit support the drug-free approach to health care.
(We should note here that the Summit didn’t include all the warring parties. There was another faction – improbably named the DaVinci Group – made of other, non-Summit straights, such as the International Pediatric Chiropractors Association, who didn’t participate.)
So, as things stand now, the ICA and the ACA are officially at odds, once again, over drugs.
Chiropractic “internists”
Let’s spend a few minutes on this Council on Diagnosis and Internal Disorders, under whose jurisdiction the College will operate, because it gives us some indication of the, um, quality of education chiropractors can expect regarding said “clinical matters.” If educating chiropractors about these “clinical matters” follows the modus operandi of the CDID, I suspect what we’ll see are weekend hotel conference room courses leading to some sort of ersatz certification in prescribing drugs.
The CDID is one of the ACA’s “specialty councils” and is “certified” by the American Board of Chiropractic Internists. (Yep, that’s right, chiropractic “internists.”) Its mission statement is:
To maintain and promote the chiropractic profession as primary health care providers, support the advancement of chiropractic, influence full scope practice within the profession and in current and future health reform legislation.
So I think you can see where things are going with the new “College.”
Their particular brand of “primary health care” looks a lot like naturopathy, but with even less education and training. According to their website, their practices include blood laboratory studies, electrocardiograms, spirometry, salivary assay hormonal and neurotransmitter tests, IgG food allergy testing, stool analyses “and many other diagnostic tools.” Treatments include dietary supplements, homeopathic remedies, botanical medicine, natural hormone replacement and “pharmacologic counseling.”
To earn this coveted status, one must take a 300 hour “post doctorate course,” pass an exam and have 12 hours of continuing education per year. One becomes a “Diplomate” with this effort and earns a “post-graduate degree.” (I don’t know how one earns a “degree” unless it’s from an educational institution, but perhaps my definition of “degree” is too narrow.) There is also the 100-hour “Chiropractic Family Practice Functional Medicine” course sponsored by the CDID and the National University of Health Sciences. (As you will see below, chiropractors have really warmed up to the idea of functional medicine.)
I’ve written about the CDID before, and its weekend hotel conference room courses, most (all?) of which seem devoid of any clinical training. (Who knew you could learn everything about primary care pediatrics or dermatology in a single weekend?) This is cargo-cult specialization – all the trappings and titles of an American Board of Medical Specialties certification, with none of the education or training.
As if the ACA’s announcement weren’t enough for the ICA, the Wisconsin Chiropractic Association (WCA) recently put forth yet another iteration of the chiropractor in a White Paper with the unwieldy title: “Filling the Shortage of Primary Care Health Care Providers in Wisconsin: The Primary Spine Care Physician, a new class of health care provider.” In a nutshell, the proposal sounds a lot like the “Chiropractic as Spine Care” model we’ve discussed before on SBM except with prescription privileges.
The WCA proposes a “M.S. Degree in Advanced Clinical Practice: Board-certifed Primary Spine Care Physician,” (they seem to like long titles), with a 500 hour clinical training component including “neuro/orthopedic spine surgery, pain management, orthopedic and neurology practices.” It doesn’t say what institution would offer these degrees, but I think you can guess after reading the next few paragraphs. It isn’t clear where these clinical rotations would take place either. There would be a Board exam after that, but they don’t say under whose auspices this Board would operate.
The ICA was incensed that the WCA would suggest chiropractors weren’t already Primary Spine Care Physicians. And further incensed that anyone would suggest that drugs are necessary to provide competent spine care. This led to dueling letters from different chiropractic colleges published in the ICA’s Chiropractic Choice.
On the anti-drug side were Palmer Chiropractic College and the ultra-straight Life Chiropractic College. On the pro-drug side were the National University of Health Sciences (NUHS) and University of Western States. NUHS has been at the forefront of gunning for chiropractic prescription privileges and a broad scope of practice. A few years back, it announced establishment of a “Masters of Science degree” in “Advance Clinical Practice,” to prepare chiropractors for prescription privileges, but apparently that didn’t pan out, at least that I can find on its website. There was no entrance exam, the only requirements being a 2.5 GPA and graduation from a “first professional degree” program.
NUHS, which also grants naturopathy and acupuncture degrees, published a study a couple of years ago claiming it was nearing its goal of training chiropractic students as primary care practitioners, a study totally demolished by Harriet Hall. The NUHS was also co-author of an earlier ACA attempt to promote DCs as PCPs with a different white paper. Dr. Hall demolished that one too. The NUHS’s recently-retired president, James Winterstein, is a longtime cheerleader for a broad scope of practice.
Western States, although it is located in Portland, OR, had three representatives (of eight) on the “Authors/Contributors” attribution page of the WCA White Paper. While it doesn’t offer naturopathy or acupuncture degrees, it did recently sign an agreement that will lead to “further collaboration” with the Institute for Functional Medicine, the Jeffrey Bland initiative, on whose Board Dr. Mark Hyman sits. I had to chuckle when I read that Western States would include integration of what it called “IFM’s novel patient assessment criteria.” “Novel” hardly begins to describe it. (Of course, the Cleveland Clinic also recently expanded its descent into integrative medicine with the Institute.) I note with interest, therefore, that one area of training for the Primary Spine Care Physician model is “Nutrition for Musculoskeletal Health.”
Let me make a suggestion to the Wisconsin Chiropractic Association: dump the subluxation and all the quack diagnoses treatments chiropractors are famous for, concentrate on establishing yourselves as evidence-based profession specializing in back problems, and then maybe come back and ask for limited prescription privileges. Until then, no one should trust this proposed scheme.
Another strategy
Adding insult to the ICA’s injury was this year’s perennial attempt by New Mexico chiropractors to expand their prescription privileges. (NM is the only state with the dubious honor of having so-called “advanced practice chiropractors” as well as garden variety chiropractors.) With the help of their ever-reliable friend in the NM Legislature, Sen. Cisco McSorley, the pro-drug faction hatched quite an elaborate statutory scheme. Of course, this too is but part of a larger effort to rebrand chiropractors as “primary care physicians.” Sen. McSorley’s bill took care of that aspect as well, but let’s deal with the drugs first.
The state’s existing “advanced practice” chiropractors would be divided into two tiers, “Level One” and “Level Two.” Both could prescribe any drugs approved by the chiropractic board. Level Ones currently have 90 additional hours of training after chiropractic school, and they would be grandfathered in, but requirements are changed to a “postgraduate degree in a clinical specialty” from a chiropractic school, with no minimum standards for such a course set.
According to the NM Chiropractic Association “advance practice” chiropractors can already perform:
IM injections (B12, homeopathic, magnesium, trigger point, etc.), neural therapy injections Intravenous procedures (meyer’s [sic] cocktails, H2O2, chelation, ascorbates, amino acids, minerals, etc.)
Under the bill, if the chiropractic board, in consultation with (but not necessarily the approval of) the pharmacy board, gives its ok, other drugs could be added. The medical board wasn’t given a say. Level Twos would require, in addition, 650 hours in a supervised “clinical rotation,” which could take place at a chiropractic college. Level Twos could prescribe, inject and dispense all dangerous drugs (as defined in by state law) except Schedule I and II controlled substances, that are used in standard primary care practice.
Bill amendments would have required that instruction for Level Two be okayed by the medical board and the existence of a collaboration agreement with a physician or certified nurse practitioner for first five years of practice for Level Two chiropractors who want to prescribe dangerous drugs, including chart reviews.
Fortunately the ICA descended on the legislature to oppose the bill and reports that it was defeated, although I’ve not been able to confirm that on the NM legislature’s website.
Arizona chiropractors made a more modest attempt to gain prescription privileges, limited to prescription-strength doses of ibuprofen, naproxen, methocarbomol and cyclobenzaphrine. They would need 75 hours of instruction and 300 hours of practical experience under the supervision of an M.D. or D.O. The bill is marked as “held” on the Arizona legislature website.
A second provision of the NM bill supporting efforts to rebrand DCs as PCPs is a bit sneakier in its language. And it is similar to language we are seeing pop up in bills in other states. This year, chiropractors in NM and Hawaii wanted a scope of practice including all diagnoses and treatments for which they have been “educated and trained.”
Hawaii’s bill, which also had a provision allowing chiropractors to call themselves “physicians,” was limited to education and training provided in an accredited chiropractic school. (Mississippi already defines chiropractic scope of practice this way.) What’s wrong with this? It defaults to the Council on Chiropractic Education to determine what the scope of chiropractic practice should be, because the CCE decides what chiropractic schools must teach their students. Fortunately, the bill failed a deadline for further consideration.
And what does the CCE itself say about this? In an apparent effort to please its various constituencies, the CCE’s accreditation standards state that:
An accredited DCP prepares its graduates to practice as primary care chiropractic physicians, and provides curricular and clinical evidence of such through outcome measures. CCE applies the understanding that in order to competently practice as a primary care chiropractic physician, DCP education trains its graduates to:
Practice primary health care as a portal-of-entry provider for patients of all ages and genders focusing on the inherent ability of the body to heal and enhance function without unnecessary drugs or surgery.
So if chiropractic students are trained as “chiropractic primary care physicians” who focuses on vitalism?
NM’s bill (it changed chiropractic to chiropractic “medicine”), on the other hand, did not contain the same limitation – the education and training presumably could come from other sources. And who would decide if a certain level of education and training had been achieved? The chiropractor?
Which brings us to another intriguing resolution just passed by the ACA, touting:
The identification of six key elements that should be considered or included in a modern chiropractic practice act. Variability of state chiropractic regulations has created uncertainty and confusion for the general public, chiropractic patients and chiropractic physicians, impeding development and progress of the profession.
It would be most interesting to find out exactly what these “key elements” are but my guess is that language along the lines of the failed NM and Hawaii bills will be included. Again, the ACA did not respond to my request for more information.
Finally, a third ACA resolution continued the “DC as PCP” theme:
The resolution, adopted by the House members, emphasizes the importance of allowing chiropractic physicians to practice and be reimbursed for the fullest extent of their licensure, training and competencies.
According to ACA President Anthony Hamm, DC, “The ACA will develop and implement a comprehensive strategy to ensure that doctors of chiropractic are recognized as being able to provide all existing Medicare services, as allowed under their state scope of practice, to beneficiaries.”
This would involve dumping the limitation on chiropractic coverage to detection and correction of subluxations (Congress having gone along with the fiction that subluxations exist when adding chiropractors as providers). If this scheme works, they would have to be reimbursed for whatever their state practice acts allow them to do, if it is covered by Medicare. No wonder they are so interested in having the CCE or, even better, individual chiropractors, determine their scope of practice.

The DC as PCP? Series (and related posts)
    • The DC as PCP?
    • The DC as PCP? Revisted
    • The DC as PCP? The battle continues
    • The DC as PCP: the battle resumes
    • Legislative Alchemy: 2014 (so far)
    • Legislative Alchemy:Chiropractic 2013
    • Legislative Alchemy: 2012.5
    • Legislative Alchemy II: Chiropractic
    • Chiropractors as Family Doctors? No Way!
    • Chiropractic Education for Primary Care
    • Dept. of Education to Council on Chiropractic Education: Straighten Up!
    • The Council on Chiropractic Education Straightens Up?
    • CAM Docket: Functional Endocrinology
    • CAM Docket: Functional Endocrinology Update
    • The Exciting Conclusion
    • ACA: Six Key Elements of A Modern Chiropractic Practice Act
    • Chiropractic Internist: A “specialty” to avoid
    • Turning chiropractors into primary care physicians via Legislative Alchemy
    • Legislative Alchemy 2017: Chiropractic
    • Legislative Alchemy 2018: Chiropractors rebranding as primary care physicians continues
    • The DC wants to play PCP on your dime: H.R. 3654 forces Medicare to cover full scope of chiropractic practice

   The DC as PCP?
Jann Bellamy
Link
Subluxation-free Chiropractic?
The long-simmering internecine wars among various factions of chiropractic recently reached a full boil when the Council on Chiropractic Education (CCE) had the audacity to eliminate the word “subluxation” from its draft 2012 “Standards for Doctor of Chiropractic Programs.” The CCE is the official U.S. Department of Education-approved accreditation agency for chiropractic colleges. It intends to adopt the revised Standards in January 2011and asked for comment from those affected.
“Totally unacceptable,” is the response of James Edwards, DC, in a recent article in Dynamic Chiropractic entitled “What Is the CCE Trying to Pull?”
Perhaps taking up the spirit of this election season, Edwards defines the problem in terms of conservative vs. liberal ideologies: “After beating back and defeating the ridiculous ‘subluxation only, no diagnosis’ position of the extreme right-wing minority of the profession, we are now faced with the equally unacceptable ‘ivory tower’ position of the extreme left-wing minority of the profession.” Later in the article he refers to the proponents as the “left-wing fringe.”
Edwards is further exercised by the CCE’s plans to remove the phrase “without the use of drugs or surgery” from its description of chiropractic practice. As well, the CCE proposes, somewhat cryptically, to accredit any program which it deems to be “equivalent” to the D.C. degree program.
The proposed changes prompted the International Chiropractic Pediatric Association to send out an “URGENT! Action Needed!” e-mail requesting that members fax in objections because “the CCE has a few proposals that will drastically affect the future of chiropractic.”
Gerald Clum, DC, in a memo expressing concern from his faculty position at Life Chiropractic College West, opined that this meant the CCE might approve a “Doctor of Chiropractic Medicine” degree “or any other creative reconfiguration of a chiropractic curriculum.” Clum also noted the removal of references to the “Purpose of Chiropractic Education” from the Standards, with no replacement language in the new version. The following language was deleted:
The application of science in chiropractic concerns itself with the relationship between structure, primarily the spine, and function, primarily coordinated by the nervous system of the human body, as that relationship may affect the restoration and preservation of health.
Readers familiar with chiropractic will recognize this as a reference to the vertebral subluxation complex.
Finally, Clum noted “the change in the definition of chiropractic primary care physician [by the proposed Standards] removes any definitional elements that would cause the statement to be unique to the practice of chiropractic. The definition as proposed would apply to any primary care medical doctor, nurse practitioner, physicians assistant, etc.”
Parker College of Chiropractic officially expressed its concern in the on-line publication ChiroAccess, although it took a more subdued approach, saying only that it would like “to see additional clarity or further expansion” of the changes.
Another change is escalation of the required GPA for admission to chiropractic colleges from a 2.5 to 3.0. Parker asked for a more gradual change “because a drastic change could negatively impact admissions and institutions need the opportunity to mitigate this change through other means.”
The “Cetified Advance Practice Chiropractic Physician”
So, What Is the CCE Trying to Pull in sanitizing its accreditation requirements so they appear less, well, “chiropractic?”
I don’t know, but it may have something to do with a prototype of the future chiropractor set forth in a law passed in New Mexico last year.
You may recall that New Mexico is one of the few states to allow anyone to practice medicine despite having no license, no education and no training. So it is no surprise that New Mexico is the first state to create a new iteration of chiropractic known as “Chiropractic Advanced Practice.”
The New Mexico Legislature created this new class but left the details to the NM State Board of Chiropractic Practice. The Board, while retaining the subluxation-based definition of chiropractic, added a category of “certified advanced practice chiropractic physician,” defined as an “advanced practice chiropractor who shall have prescriptive authority for therapeutic and diagnostic purposes.”
All you have to do to register as an advance practice chiropractor is (1) fill out an application, (2) complete 90 “clinical and didactic” hours of education provided by an approved institution, and (3) pass a competency exam. In other words, take the equivalent of a little over two standard work weeks of instruction and a test and — voila! — you’re “certified” for “advanced practice.”
The rules prescribe a formulary that consists of “those substances that are natural or naturally derived.” The initial formulary and any changes to it must be approved by three boards: medical, pharmacy and chiropractic. This smells like a compromise on the part of medicine and pharmacy, and the smell is not a pleasant one.
SBM contributor Scott Gavura, BScPhm, MBA, RPh, provided some insight into the formulary as prescribed by rule in NM. It includes estradiol, progesterone, and testosterone, all of which are used as hormone replacements, as well as desiccated thyroid, which alt med practitioners believe is effective for thyroid replacement, although it is rarely used nor is it recommended by evidence-based guidelines. Also included are drugs widely disparaged for years by chiropractors: muscle relaxers and NSAIDs. There is also sarapin, a dubious treatment for neuropathic pain, and glutathione for inhalation, an alt-med treatment for lung disease. Of course, homeopathic preparations “requiring prescription” and “for injection” are included. And, even more inexplicably, caffeine for injections.
It sounds like the perfect formulary for increased chiropractor income.
The origin of the “certified advanced practice physician” requirements is explained in a press release put out by the National University of Health Sciences (NUHS), in Lombard, IL, and posted on ChiroAccess. (In addition to its DC program, NUHS offers degree programs in naturopathy, acupuncture and massage.)
As the press release explains:
The United States is experiencing a shortage of primary care family doctors. That’s why over the last 8-10 years, chiropractic associations in states with severe shortages of primary care physicians have sought to expand the scope of practice for chiropractic physicians… . By granting [chiropractors] the ability to prescribe select medications, specially trained and licensed DCs can help a significant number of patients who would otherwise be forced to seek simultaneous care from an already overburdened and limited pool of MDs in general practice.
Those state chiropractic associations! Always looking out for the best interests of patients and overburdened MDs.
Thus, the state associations contacted “experts at [NUHS]” and asked them to “assess what additional training would be necessary.” The experts decided on 90 hours in pharmacology “in addition to the prerequisite physiology and biochemistry courses already required by accredited chiropractic education programs.”
NUHS is, helpfully, offering these additional hours in New Mexico to those who want to become advanced practitioners. In addition to an instructor who has a Ph.D. in pharmacology and pharmocognosy, the NM students “are receiving training in injectible [sic] nutrients and drugs from Dr. Michael Taylor, a chiropractic physician who also holds a diplomate [sic] from the American Board of Chiropractic Internists.”
And what better way to beef up the ranks of family practice doctors, pediatricians and internists than with chiropractors wielding syringes full of “injectible nutrients?”
The E-Z Way to Primary Care Practice
But here is the really interesting part of the NM law: After December 31, 2012, the examination requirement can be met by “successfully complet[ing] a graduate degree in a chiropractic clinical practice specialty.” And where might one get this degree?
As it turns out, NUHS is also offering a “Master of Science degree (MS) – Advanced Clinical Practice” (or “MSACP”) which is “An Advanced Degree designed for the Chiropractic Profession” beginning in September, 2011. The only requirements are a minimum 2.5 GPA in a ”first professional degree” program.
The MSACP program consists of weekend courses spanning two years, 18 in the classroom and 8 in “distance learning” format, plus one “case defense” and one “capstone defense” (whatever that is).
The program conveniently includes the 90 hours of pharmacology required by New Mexico and is presumably the origin of the chiropractic board’s decision to skip the exam if a chiropractor has the “advanced clinical practice” degree. Thus, if you take this course, you’re in, at least as far as New Mexico is concerned.
But chiropractors promoting this new degree obviously have bigger fish to fry. The NUHS course descriptions give a hint as to what those fish might be. Weekend and “distance learning” courses include clinical neurophysiology, clinical problem solving for the primary care physician, clinical neurology, advanced diagnostic imaging, psychological issues of illness, pediatrics, women’s and men’s health/geriatrics, inflammatory mechanisms, dietary prescription, and advanced clinical laboratory medicine.
Hmmm. Why would anyone go to this much trouble when he can just as easily qualify for NM’s “certified advanced practice chiropractic physician” registration by taking 90 hours of classes in pharmacology and a test? In fact, NUHS already incorporates this 90 hours into its regular D.C. program, so all those graduates would have to do to register is take the test.
Here’s why. As the NUHS press release continues:
Because of this growing interest (in expanding the scope of chiropractic practice) NUHS is also thinking about offering its MSACP (Master of Science in Advanced Chiropractic Practice) in New Mexico as well, and is strategizing how to deliver similar programs in other states in the future.
(Emphasis mine.) 
The press release ends with this sunny prediction by James Winterstein, president of NUHS:
Chiropractic physicians are already licensed as primary care doctors in most states … As health care policy-makers wrestle with the scarcity of general practice physicians, expanding the scope of chiropractic care to qualified chiropractic physicians makes good economic and strategic sense. New Mexico’s citizens will undoubtedly benefit from broadening health care delivery by chiropractic physicians, and we anticipate that more states will see the wisdom in this as well.
Let’s hope not.
The MSACP course descriptions illustrate just how far they would like to venture. All of the courses described below take place over one weekend. (All emphasis in quotations mine.)
Clinical Skills for the Primary Care Physician:
… present and demonstrate clinical skills including comprehensive history taking and regional physical examinations skills in the context of common and complex internal disorders. The student will be enabled to effectively integrate these skills and formulate an accurate differential diagnosis and integrative treatment approach.
Clinical Problem Solving for the Primary Care Physician:
The purpose of this distance learning course is to refine and expand upon clinical problem solving skills with an emphasis on internal medicine. The student will be able to effectively integrate patient history and physical examination findings into an accurate differential diagnosis with consideration of appropriate diagnostic testing.
And, I must comment, certainly there is no more effective way for the physician to learn patient history taking, physical examination, and differential diagnosis that watching these things on a computer screen.
Clinical Nutrition I – Inflammation Mechanisms and Dietary Prescription:
… a detailed understanding of the altered biochemistry that underlies the expression of most inflammatory related diseases. Current evidence-based nutritional literature will be presented as a foundation for the clinical application of appropriate dietary changes and key nutritional supplements.
Pediatrics:
… an overview of common pediatric disorders and effective methods for approaching evaluation and management of the pediatric patient. Well infant and child examinations will also be discussed and demonstrated. Students will gain an understanding of normal growth and development and discuss scheduled vaccinations and their associated risks and benefits.
Women’s & Men’s Health/Geriatrics:
… illustrates common and complex conditions impacting the health of women and men, including the geriatric population [including] pathophysiology, differential diagnosis and effective integrative and allopathic treatment strategies will be discussed.
So that’s it! They want to be real doctors who make “differential diagnoses” and “evaluate and manage the patient” and prescribe “dietary changes,” “nutritional supplements,” and “integrative treatment strategies.” Wait, no, that’s naturopathy. They want to be naturopathic doctors?
As it turns out, the American Chiropractic Association (ACA) has its own “Council on Diagnosis and Internal Disorders:”
… an educational Board that endorses and coordinates a post doctorate degree; Diplomate in Diagnosis and Internal Disorders (DABCI). Our Doctors are trained in the most advanced forms of modern medical diagnosis and natural medicine. Our Doctors diagnostic training far exceeds the current standards of health care practice utilizing many current and specialized diagnostics such as: blood chemistries, orthomolecular evaluation, electrocardiograms, vascular ultrasounds, lung function studies, bone density testing, hormonal evaluations, delayed food allergy testing, and much more. Treatments may include; nutritional recommendations, dietary modification, supplement recommendations, homeopathic and naturopathic remedies, natural hormone replacement, etc. Most conditions if diagnosed properly can be resolved naturally and our doctors and the most qualified to provide this service.
Training far exceeds the current standard? Most properly diagnosed conditions can be resolved naturally? Where do they get this stuff?
The ACA’s program, called “The Natural Approach to Family Medicine,” also takes place over a series of 26 weekend sessions (Saturday, 9AM-5 PM; Sunday, 8AM-Noon), although the student can take only one session per month to get credit. Some session titles: Diseases and Exam of the Pelvis & Associated Pathology; Urinary Disorders and Hair Biopsy Assessment; Malignant Diseases, AIDS, & their Management & Treatment; and Upper Gastrointestinal Disease.
So, in sum, chiropractic’s leading organizations — or, depending on your point of view, the pointy-headed, ivory-tower liberals — have seen the future of chiropractic and it is not chiropractors!
The International Chiropractors Association(ICA) is having none of it. Through an article in “Chiropractic Choice,” Stephen P. Welsh, DC, Fellow of the ICA, saw right through NUHS and its grandiose plans:
“A wolf in sheep’s clothing” is the phrase that comes to mind… . The arguments of the moment asserting needs due to provider distribution and availability and the extension of nutritional approaches into the arena of nutraceutical therapies are red herrings. The goal of the advocates of these changes is to practice primary care medicine, without fully qualifying at the appropriate standard to do so. It is disingenuous to assert that these changes are being made to address a sudden deficiency in providers in New Mexico or elsewhere or a spectacular new advantage to some form of nutritional therapy.
Couldn’t have said it better myself.

The DC as PCP: the battle resumes
Jann Bellamy on November 12, 2015
Tweet


It has been almost five years to the day since I wrote my first post in “The DC as PCP” series. These posts (listed here) chronicle the continuing battles among various factions within the chiropractic profession over the subluxation and its many iterations, educational requirements for chiropractic colleges, their legal scope of practice, and whether chiropractors are – or are not—primary care physicians (PCPs). At its heart, the controversy boils down to this essential issue: what is “chiropractic” and what is it that chiropractors do? Or, perhaps, should do.
At one end of the spectrum is the straight chiropractor, who wants to make his living detecting and correcting subluxations for all manner of problems. These are the chiropractors who claim newborns need adjustments for “birth trauma” and maintenance care is necessary to good health. At the other end are those promoting the idea that chiropractors are primary care physicians capable of seeing the undifferentiated patient, form a differential diagnosis, and either treat the patient or coordinate the patient’s care with other health care professionals.
Neither has any basis in reality. The subluxation is a chiropractic fiction. And the notion that chiropractors have the necessary education and training to act as primary care physicians is no less a fiction.
Apparently unrepresented in this battle is the chiropractor who wants to see the profession as evidence-based spine care specialists based on a model of specialty care like podiatry and dentistry.
The causus belli in the current skirmish is the Council on Chiropractic Education’s (CCE) second draft of a revision of the 2013 Accreditation Standards for chiropractic colleges. The CCE is the sole agency with the authority, granted by the U.S. Department of Education, to accredit chiropractic colleges and to monitor their activities for compliance with its standards for chiropractic education. Getting and keeping accreditation is extremely important for the colleges – without it, their students would not have access to federal student loans and their graduates would not be eligible for state licensing. The CCE’s educational standards for accreditation have become a battleground on which various chiropractic factions duke it out over their competing philosophies.
A contentious history
Back in 2010, the CCE tried to eliminate the phrase “without the use of drugs or surgery” from its definition of chiropractic, as well as the word “subluxation,” and any requirement that students learn to “adjust” the putative chiropractic subluxation. The more conservative element smelled a nefarious plot to turn chiropractic away from its roots and set it on a path toward chiropractors practicing as some version of an MD/DO primary care physician.
This proposed revision of CCE educational standards was part of a larger effort to rebrand chiropractors as PCPs by expansion of the chiropractic practice acts and chiropractic regulatory board rulemaking, not always successfully. Chiropractors’ attempts to transform themselves via legal fiat into PCPs (or, at least, move in that direction) have been beaten back by a strange-bedfellows combination of straight chiropractors, medical doctors, and pharmacists in New Mexico, Colorado, and Texas.
The American Chiropractic Association (ACA) jumped on the PCP bandwagon by simply announcing that chiropractors are, indeed, PCPs, in the ACA News, an effort promptly demolished by Harriet Hall. The Journal of Chiropractic Education weighed in with an article claiming that the National University of Health Sciences, an accredited chiropractic college, was ready to train chiropractors as PCPs. Dr. Hall took a dim view of that as well:
The data they collected don’t even begin to support that assertion. The study is not only meaningless, it demonstrates a gross misunderstanding of the education required to practice competent primary care.
The ACA’s American Board of Chiropractic Specialties, a pseudo-American Board of Medical Specialties, approved a specialty called “Chiropractic Diagnosis and Management of Internal Disorders” practiced by “chiropractic internists.” One can become a “diplomate” of the American Board of Chiropractic Internists by taking a series of 26 weekend courses in hotel conference rooms and taking a test.
The straights weren’t satisfied with simply having input into the three drafts that it took to reach a final version of the CCE’s educational standards. They took their fight to the U.S. Department of Education to challenge the very authority of the CCE to accredit chiropractic colleges. A beleaguered CCE ended up getting itself put on a probation of sorts by the Department for one year while it set its house in order, finally gaining recognition for another 3 years in 2013.
As part of its effort to paper over the considerable differences between the straight and the PCP factions, and all sub-factions in between, the CCE spent considerable effort on the subluxation and its place in chiropractic education in redrafting its educational standards. Its solution was to invent yet another name for this nebulous chiropractic creation. As the CCE explained in an “open letter:”
Despite its historical legacy in the profession, a number of educational programs and practitioners have opted to use other terms, such as joint fixation or joint dysfunction. Even the Association of Chiropractic Colleges (ACC) has not reached a unified definition or specific criteria for subluxation, despite its own task force addressing this issue. The 2012 Standards opted to use a combination phrase, ‘subluxation/neuro-biomechnical dysfunction.’
We’ll return to that term — “subluxation/neuro-biomechnical dysfunction” – in a moment, as it plays a role in the current controversy.
More recently, the ACA announced the establishment of a “College of Pharmacology and Toxicology,” yet another effort that upset the International Chiropractors Association (ICA), which represents the straights, who saw it as a suspicious move toward lobbying for prescription privileges. The ACA’s wholly unconvincing response to this criticism was to try to distinguish the word “pharmacology,” which, to them, is simply understanding drugs, from “pharmacotherapy,” which is actually prescribing drugs. The ACA argued that this semantic distinction meant they absolutely did not intend to move in the direction of chiropractic prescribing rights. (It’s all about semantics again.) Unfortunately for them, the ACA’s own proposed model scope of practice act includes “Full . . . Prescription Authority” for chiropractors, which makes their explanation even more unconvincing. On top of that is the fact that the “College” will operate under the jurisdiction of the Council on Diagnosis and Internal Disorders, whose avowed purpose is to create chiropractic “internists.” Really, one must admire the ACA’s temerity in even attempting to tackle the ICA’s objection.
The current draft of CCE standards for chiropractic colleges
With that background, we’ll march forward into the current skirmish surrounding the second draft of the CCE’s proposed accreditation standards, an attempt to revise the 2013 standards that were the subject of previous battles. Apparently, CCE accreditation standards have a very short shelf life.
Two chiropractic organizations have filed their objections to this draft. Not unexpectedly, one of them is the ICA. (The ICA’s summary of objections was in an email, so I can’t link to it.)
The ICA’s first gripe relates to patient management. The CCE draft standards require that the student be able to develop a “management plan” for the patient that includes “specific therapeutic goals and prognoses.” The ICA has a bone to pick with this – they want to delete the term “therapeutic,” because clinical goals are not always ‘therapeutic.'”
ICA is was especially concerned to see that the standards language was sufficient to support all appropriate forms of chiropractic case management and not just ‘therapeutic’ care based on episodic symptomatology.
Why? Well, unstated here is the ICA’s devotion to “maintenance” or “wellness” care – the notion that all patients require regular “spinal checkups” to detect subluxations and, if subluxations are found, to “correct” them with “adjustments.” (One does wonder if there was ever a chiropractic maintenance care exam that didn’t uncover a subluxation.) Which brings us to another ICA objection.
For the first time, apparently, the CCE has included what they call a “meta-competency” requirement in adjusting/manipulation, which pleases the ICA. The fly in this ointment is that the skill required is not just “adjustment” but “adjustment/manipulation.” According to the ICA, they are not the same thing. The ICA is correct. “Adjustment” has always referred to a method of “correcting” the phantom subluxation. Other professions perform manipulation, or, as the ICA would prefer to call it, “other forms of manual care,” but, as the ICA says, “only doctors of chiropractic administer chiropractic adjustments.” The reason is that no other profession believes the chiropractic subluxation exists or, obviously, that it can be “adjusted,” but they don’t bring this up.
One suspects the CCE is trying to gloss over this difference by pretending adjustment is just another term for manipulation, a perfectly legitimate form of manual therapy, and not a method to correct the subluxation, which they would love to get rid of, at least in its straight chiropractic iteration.
And speaking of the subluxation, another organization, the International Federation of Chiropractors and Organizations (IFCO) also has a quarrel with the CCE regarding terminology. (IFCO motto: “Vertebral Subluxation . . . Nothing More . . . Nothing Less . . . Nothing Else.”) In the current draft standards, as part of the requirement that the student learn how to adjust/manipulate, he must know how to “employ methods to identify subluxations/segmental dysfunction of the spine and/or other articulations.” (Emphasis added.) Thus, we find that a mere 2 years after the CCE thought up the term subluxation/neuro-biomechical dysfunction in its continuing quest to define the subluxation by creating new names for it, “neuro-biomechanical dysfunction” is tossed aside in favor of “segmental dysfunction.” The CCE also uses the terms joint fixation and joint dysfunction.
The IFCO thinks the CCE needs to clean up this semantic mess.
There are significant operational and epistemological differences. Implicit in the term vertebral subluxation are both biomechanical and neurological elements. A fixated or tender joint might represent one manifestation of vertebral subluxation, not synonym for vertebral subluxation. The implication that they are the same leads to confusion and ambiguity.
No kidding on the confusion and ambiguity. But I’d venture to say that it’s the chiropractors’ failure, after 120 years, to define the subluxation, validate methods for finding one, determine the clinical significance of the subluxation, and demonstrate convincingly that treating it improves patient outcomes, leads to the confusion and ambiguity. Not what to call it.
A few years ago, the cart-before-the-horse futility of trying to settle on a name for the subluxation was called out by the authors, themselves chiropractors, of “Subluxation: Dogma or Science?”
The subluxation is identified by a great many names, but neither the abundance of labels nor efforts to reach consensus on terminology tell us anything about the validity of the construct. Nelson points out that “…framing the subluxation debate as a semantic issue, resolvable by consensus, is precisely the same as asking whether we should refer to the spaceships used by aliens as flying saucers or UFOs.” Neither adoption nor rejection of the term subluxation or any of its myriad synonyms will resolve the problem created by assuming a priori that subluxation is clinically meaningful. If and when we demonstrate that there are alien spaceships hovering over us, we suspect an appropriate terminology will develop on its own.
Unfortunately, no one paid any attention, and the semantic shenanigans continue.
“Primary Care Chiropractic Physicians”
Both the ICA and the IFCO object to the CCE’s use of the terms “primary care” and “primary care chiropractic physician.” Here again, there is disagreement over just what those terms mean.
The new draft of the CCE standards requires that all accredited educational programs produce graduates who are able to function as “primary care chiropractic physicians.” In defining what it calls “meta-competencies,” which must be taught to every student, there is little indication that the chiropractor’s skill set should be limited to musculoskeletal issues. Although students must learn to detect a “subluxation/segmental dysfunction,” and perform an “adjustment/manipulation,” the requirements are otherwise described in terms that are quite broad.
For example, in achieving a “meta-competency” in “assessment and diagnosis,” a student must demonstrate the ability to:
1) Develop a list of differential diagnosis/es and corresponding exams from a case-appropriate health history and review of external health records.
2) Identify significant physical findings and follow-up through a physical examination, application of diagnostic and/or confirmatory tests and tools, and any consultations.
3) Generate a problem list with diagnosis/es after synthesizing and correlating data from the history, examinations, diagnostic tests, and any consultations.
Students must also be able to “develop an evidence-informed management plan appropriate to the diagnosis” and “refer for emergency care and/or collaborative care as appropriate.” This doesn’t seem to contemplate that the chiropractor might step out of the picture once the referral is made, which is suspiciously like the role of the primary care physician in serving as a medical home and care coordinator.
For comparison, here’s how the American Academy of Family Physicians, quite similarly, describes primary care:
[A] generalist physician who provides definitive care to the undifferentiated patient at the point of first contact and takes continuing responsibility for providing the patient’s care . . . . [T]he personal primary care physician serves as the entry point for substantially all of the patient’s medical and health care needs – not limited by problem origin, organ system, or diagnosis. Primary care physicians are advocates for the patient in coordinating the use of the entire health care system to benefit the patient.
However, the CCE is taking a “big-tent” approach to teaching the required skills. It does not “define or support any specific philosophy regarding the principles and practice of chiropractic” nor do its educational standards “support or accommodate any philosophical or political position.” Each school, it says, is “free to determine its own method of meta-competency delivery and assessment.” So, cleverly, or perhaps as a survival strategy, the CCE allows each school to superimpose its own philosophy onto this educational template. If the straights want to read the requirements as allowing them to teach the overarching significance of the subluxation and how to detect and correct it with adjustments, so be it. If schools with more expansive agendas want to rebrand chiropractors as primary care physicians or chiropractic internists, that’s ok too.
Even with the implied promise that the straight schools will be left alone, the ICA doesn’t like the CCE’s expansive definition of primary care. It thinks “primary care” is simply synonymous with “portal of entry,” and that a “primary care chiropractic physician” is:
A direct access, doctor level health care professional qualified to serve as the patient’s first point of contact within the health care system, without referral from any other professional.
According the Chair of the ICA’s committee on accreditation issues, this will “help avoid misrepresentation of what is actually meant and limit expansiveness and inappropriate interpretations in the direction of medicine and medical procedures.” But “expansiveness” is just what some chiropractic factions are after and it’s doubtful the ICA will convince the CCE to redefine primary care as a synonym for portal of entry.
However one defines the chiropractor’s role in health care, the ICA doesn’t want students forced into “interprofessional education” either, another new CCE-required meta-competency, including multi-disciplinary clinical practice settings for students. I have to agree with the ICA that this is a difficult goal to achieve. It would require the cooperation of the medical community, which may be reluctant to allow chiropractic students into their clinical training settings, such as teaching hospitals, private physicians’ offices and health care clinics. One can well imagine that this prospect will seem even less appealing to medical educators if chiropractors are trying to pass themselves off as PCPs.
The IFCO objects to the whole notion that chiropractors are primary care practitioners as well, and points out that:
Many, if not most procedures termed “primary care” as commonly defined, are not within the scope of chiropractic practice in any jurisdiction. These include, by example, family planning; immunization against the major infectious diseases; prevention and control of locally endemic diseases; appropriate treatment of common diseases and injuries; and provision of essential drugs.
Which is absolutely true. Whatever you might otherwise think of the IFCO, it has put together a compilation of accepted definitions of primary care that nicely demonstrates its point. Its solution is to use the term “doctor of chiropractic” instead of “primary care chiropractic physician” and eliminate the CCE’s definition of “primary care” from the standards altogether. Seems reasonable.
The danger here, of course, is that the scope of chiropractic practice can be changed by the legislature in any state. As we have discussed many times on SBM, the legal scope of practice of CAM providers is often at odds with their actual education and training. Especially disturbing are chiropractors’ attempts to push for a scope of practice that defines what they can do by reference to what they are taught in chiropractic school. This is why the CCE’s standards are so important. Left with plenty of room to improvise, all manner of things can be loaded into the chiropractic practice acts by default to whatever the chiropractic schools choose to teach. Kansas, North Dakota and Oklahoma already reference chiropractic education as a metric for determining chiropractic scope of practice. In the last two legislative sessions (2013-14 session here), bills to define chiropractic in similar terms were defeated in New Mexico and Hawaii.
No doubt the battle will continue.

Chiropractors Lobby for Acceptance by the VA and TRICARE
Harriet Hall on October 6, 2015
Link


It seems alternative medicine is infiltrating into more and more organizations that should be based on science. We have quackademia in medical schools, integrative medicine clinics in hospitals and medical centers, government funding for alternative medicine research and education, coverage of alternative medicine by government and private health insurance, and acceptance of alternative practitioners in the VA and in military hospitals. Two weeks ago I wrote about an ill-advised effort to get naturopathy into the VA. Now it seems chiropractors have been lobbying to give all veterans and TRICARE beneficiaries access to chiropractic care. On the Society for Science-Based Medicine blog, Jann Bellamy has provided the details.
There are several bills pending: S. 398 and H.R. 1170 for the VA and H.R. 802 for TRICARE. There is also a bill (H.R. 542) that would include chiropractors in the National Health Services Corps. The American Chiropractic Association has issued statements in support of those bills. In their statements, they misrepresent what chiropractic is and what it can do.
Here are my objections:
Chiropractic is based on a myth
The chiropractic subluxation. Originally chiropractors were taught that all disease was due to subluxations: displacements of spinal bones causing nerve dysfunction. A recent study by chiropractors themselves concluded:
No supportive evidence is found for the chiropractic subluxation being associated with any disease process or of creating suboptimal health conditions requiring intervention. Regardless of popular appeal this leaves the subluxation construct in the realm of unsupported speculation. This lack of supportive evidence suggests the subluxation construct has no valid clinical applicability.
Chiropractors have nothing unique to offer
They do spinal manipulation therapy, but so do doctors of osteopathic medicine (DOs), physical therapists, and MD physiatrists. They offer other conventional modalities like heat and massage. The whole concept of chiropractic is no longer viable. The minority of chiropractors who have rejected the subluxation concept and are trying to offer evidence-based care offer care that is indistinguishable from what a physical therapist can do; it’s hard to see how they can justify saying they are practicing “chiropractic.”
Chiropractic can be dangerous
Cervical manipulation by chiropractors has been associated with strokes and death. The form of neck manipulation most often used by chiropractors, high velocity, low amplitude thrusts (HVLA), can sometimes tear the delicate lining of the arteries in the neck, causing either immediate bleeding or the formation of a clot that later breaks off and travels to the brain. For neck pain, manipulation is no more effective than gentle mobilization and exercise. Chiropractors frequently use neck manipulation for other medical conditions where there is no evidence that it benefits patients. Half of all patients experience adverse effects from manipulation, ranging from mild temporary discomfort to broken bones, paralysis, and death. The risk of serious complications from cervical manipulation is small, but when there is no proven benefit, no degree of risk is acceptable.
There are other dangers of chiropractic care. Often patients are encouraged to get regular “maintenance” adjustments even when they feel well; these are useless and costly. Many chiropractors discourage conventional medical care; less than half of them support immunization. A large percentage of chiropractors use bogus diagnostic and treatment methods, from applied kinesiology to homeopathy. Since they are not well-grounded in science-based medicine, they tend to be magnets for every new kind of quackery. Some chiropractors treat newborn infants in the delivery room or shortly after in the belief that childbirth causes subluxations. Some of them claim they can cure diabetes. Some chiropractors are trying to gain acceptance as primary care providers or family doctors, a role that their education clearly does not prepare them for.
Chiropractors would not save the government money
The ACA claims that using chiropractors would save money. There is reason to think it would not. In 2000, a House Committee on Veteran’s Affairs Subcommittee on Health reviewed the results of a demonstration program and concluded that incorporation of chiropractic care into the DoD health care delivery model was not advisable. They found that adding chiropractic care increased costs and did not improve patient outcomes.
The ACA aims to benefit chiropractors, not patients
During the 120 years that have elapsed since chiropractic was invented by a grocer and “magnetic healer,” chiropractic has struggled to establish scientific credibility, and it has failed. If there were solid evidence of the safety and effectiveness of chiropractic care, it would have been accepted as part of mainstream medicine and would no longer be considered “alternative medicine.” Since the scientific evidence doesn’t legitimize them, chiropractors can only lobby and try to achieve legitimacy through political action. In their propaganda, they emphasize pain relief and patient satisfaction, in a blatant attempt to get a foot in the door where they don’t belong. Once they are in the system, they would be able to promote all kinds of pseudoscience, offer “maintenance adjustments,” and treat patients inappropriately for non-musculoskeletal conditions.
There is no way to sort the wheat from the chaff
Some chiropractors reject the subluxation concept and try to practice what is essentially evidence-based physical therapy; they have expertise in back care and might well be a valuable addition to the health care team. But others use all kinds of quack diagnostic and treatment methods and undermine conventional medicine. Many of them reject vital public health measures like vaccines and fluoridation. Some chiropractors even reject the germ theory. If the VA and TRICARE are required to admit chiropractors, the law will require them to admit any DC who is licensed to practice. There is no reliable way to distinguish the evidence-based chiropractors from the quacks. This is a recipe for disaster.
Conclusion: Veterans deserve real medicine
In my opinion, providing all veterans and TRICARE beneficiaries with access to chiropractic care would be a mistake. They deserve the best quality, up-to-date medical care. Treatment by chiropractors would turn back the clock. It would provide substandard care and expose patients to risks, and it would waste taxpayer money. Chiropractors offer nothing unique; the treatments they offer that are effective, including spinal manipulation therapy, can be provided by science-based conventional providers such as physical therapists, DOs, and physiatrists. I have sent letters of protest to TRICARE and VA officials. You might want to write your congressmen.

Direct Primary Care Agreements and Chiropractors: A bad deal for patients
Chiropractors are not “primary care physicians” and shouldn’t be allowed to pretend otherwise by entering into “direct primary care” agreements with their patients.
Jann Bellamy on March 29, 2018
Link

Last week, Florida became one of a handful of states allowing chiropractors to enter into direct primary care agreements with their patients. This bit of legislative alchemy is part and parcel of efforts to rebrand chiropractors as “primary care physicians” who are, in the words of the National University of Health Sciences (a chiropractic college), “ready to diagnose, treat and manage a wide range of patients and conditions.”
Florida’s new law defines chiropractors, as well as MDs, DOs, and nurse practitioners, as “primary care providers” and “primary care services” as:
screening, assessment, diagnosis, and treatment of a patient conducted within the competency and training of the primary care provider for the purpose of promoting health or detecting and managing disease or injury.
We’ll return to this rebranding campaign and state laws permitting direct primary care agreements between chiropractors and their patients in a moment. First, let’s look at the bigger picture: What are direct primary care (DPC) agreements and why are physicians and other health care providers pushing this sort of legislation?
What is “direct primary care”?
According to the American Academy of Family Physicians, which supports DPC:
The direct primary care (DPC) model gives family physicians a meaningful alternative to fee-for-service insurance billing, typically by charging patients a monthly, quarterly, or annual fee (i.e., a retainer) that covers all or most primary care services including clinical, laboratory, and consultative services, and care coordination and comprehensive care management. Because some services are not covered by a retainer, DPC practices often suggest that patients acquire a high-deductible wraparound policy to cover emergencies.
Direct primary care benefits patients by providing substantial savings and a greater degree of access to, and time with, physicians.
Patients pay a flat fee to their physicians, around $50 to $150 a month, for covered primary care services, which vary from practice to practice. (You can see examples of family practice DPC agreements here and here.) The physician accepts these payments in full for the services provided and does not bill a health insurer, freeing her from hassles like preapprovals and the prodigious paperwork involved in filing claims, leaving, proponents say, more time and energy for patients. However, as long as the patient’s insurance policy allows it, the patient can file a claim for reimbursement with his health insurer, as with any other out-of-network provider.
These claims of benefit are not without their critics. One concern is that, by reducing the number of patients each primary care physician sees (one goal of the DPC model), the supply of primary care physicians will be further reduced. And, at this point, it remains to be seen whether the DPC model can deliver on touted cost reduction and outcomes improvement.
As an NPR report on a failed chain of DPC clinics noted last year:
Some who analyze the use of health care are concerned that the approach encourages the “worried well” to get more care than they need. They describe unlimited primary care as a blunt instrument that doesn’t necessarily improve the odds that patients will get evidence-based services that improve their health. Others argue it’s important to find a way to provide cost-effective primary care within the health insurance context, not outside it.
Another problem with DPC agreements is that they can be construed as contracts of insurance under state law. That is where bills like the one recently passed in Florida come in: Proponents want to make sure providers won’t run into hassles with state insurance regulators. (There are also issues of compliance with the Affordable Care Act, Medicaid, and Medicare that must be worked out.)
So far, 24 states have passed some version of DPC legislation, although there is considerable variation. (Bills are pending in other states.) Some states, like Michigan and Kansas, permit “medical retainer agreements,” which:
means a contract between a health care provider and an individual patient . . . in which the health care provider agrees to provide routine health care services to the individual patient for an agreed-upon fee and period of time.
These are open to a broad range of providers, including chiropractors, but services are not specifically defined as “primary care.”
Proponents of DPC, however, prefer legislation tailored to a narrower category of practice, specifically focused on direct primary care. The DPC Coalition, an organization promoting direct primary care, has drafted model legislation that not only permits DPC agreements without running afoul of state insurance regulations, but also provides important consumer protections by requiring that covered services be spelled out, indicating the circumstances under which the physician and patient can terminate the agreement, and defining “primary care.”
The model legislation includes this provision:
Direct primary care practices may not decline to accept new direct primary care patients or discontinue care to existing patients solely because of the patient’s health status.
Interestingly, although Florida’s new DPC agreement law tracks the model legislation, this provision was excluded. One legislator’s attempt to add it by amendment during deliberations failed. Other states also fail to include the model provision, a protection that could negatively affect the DPC provider’s bottom line.
Some states, like Louisiana and Kentucky, specifically limit DPC agreements to MDs and DOs. Nebraska allows nurse practitioners as well, but limits DPC to those specializing in general practice, family medicine, internal medicine, or pediatrics.
Unfortunately, in addition to Florida, Virginia, Washington State, and Wyoming, specifically permit chiropractors to contract with patients to provide direct primary care services, although Virginia and Wyoming, unlike Florida, don’t specifically define what they mean by “primary care.” Tennessee includes chiropractors in its DPC law, it makes clear that chiropractors are not considered primary care providers.
The DC as PCP
A faction of the chiropractic profession is aggressively promoting the idea that chiropractors are competent primary care practitioners, an idea that we have exposed as nonsense many times here on SBM . Chiropractors do not have the education and training to practice primary care. In fact, in what little clinical training they do have, they may never have seen a pediatric or geriatric patient, a complicated medical case, or have had any experience diagnosing and treating conditions commonly seen in primary care practice. Their clinical education is a tiny fraction of the training a family practice physician undergoes. Chiropractors are traditionally anti-vaccination, which is the antithesis of good primary care.
That has not stopped them from establishing ersatz “specialties” like chiropractic internist and chiropractic pediatrics, designations awarded after taking courses in hotel conference rooms. Nor has it stopped them from pushing for scope of practice expansion, sometimes successfully, to include diagnosis and treatment of non-musculoskeletal conditions. Some chiropractors have become certified in so-called “Functional Medicine”, which massively misinterprets and abuses lab test results (including the misuse of genetic testing) in the service of selling dietary supplements to address putative “deficiencies.”
In a recent survey of chiropractic websites, about a third of chiropractors were claiming they treat allergies and asthma. But that’s not all. Chiropractic websites and other promotional material, including those of chiropractic professional associations, promote chiropractic diagnosis and/or treatment of ear infections, bedwetting, colic, Tourette syndrome, ADHD, breech babies, autism, diabetes, breast and cervical cancer prevention and detection, and endocrinology. A series of articles in an American Chiropractic Association publication (republished here and thoroughly demolished by Harriet Hall here) recommends that chiropractors employ diagnostic methods like fasting metabolic panels, lipid profiles, high sensitivity CRP to assess the level of endothelial inflammation and the risk of a cardiovascular event, hemoglobin A1c (HbA1c) profile, auscultation, thyroid palpation, assessment of bowel sounds, palpation of the abdomen, prostate exams, and rectal exams. This same series suggests that chiropractors can “co-manage” metabolic syndrome, diabetes, hypertension, hyperlipidemia, obesity, arthritis, osteomalacia, osteopenia, osteoporosis, malnourishment, and depression.
DPC is not for DCs
Allowing chiropractors to enter into medical retainer agreements is a bad idea; allowing them to offer direct primary care agreements is even worse.
A medical retainer agreement is the perfect vehicle to promote the thoroughly discredited notion that everyone, including infants and children, would benefit from regular “spinal checkups” and spinal “adjustments” to promote health and prevent disease, or “wellness care.” It has the added benefit to the chiropractor’s bottom line of avoiding insurance company limits on number of treatments and out-and-out refusal to cover quackery like the Webster technique, neuroemotional technique, cranial manipulation, and numerous other bogus diagnostic methods and treatments chiropractors offer and insurers reject for lack of evidence, not to mention basic biological plausibility.
But the direct primary care agreement can offer the chiropractor all this and more. In addition to signing patients up for quack treatments, the DPC agreement presents the chiropractor with the opportunity to claim that he or she is in fact capable of acting as a primary care physician. Don’t believe they would do this? Then look at these claims from the American Chiropractic Association’s Council on Diagnosis and Internal Disorders:
State medical societies and medical professional organizations appear to be oblivious to the fact that chiropractors are promoting this sort of nonsense. A call to the Florida Medical Association (FMA) pointing out the flaws of including chiropractors was met with the response that the Florida chiropractic practice act would limit their scope of practice. The FMA doesn’t seem to realize that the practice act allows a chiropractor to use any diagnostic method taught in a chiropractic college (which means the legislature has defaulted to the colleges to decide the scope of practice) and treat virtually any disease or condition with dietary supplements (“foods, food concentrates, food extracts”) and non-prescription “items” (which would include homeopathic remedies) in addition to the “adjustment” of “vertebral subluxations.”
According to the Institute for Functional Medicine, there are already several chiropractors practicing functional medicine in Florida. There are “chiropractic internists” practicing here as well. That should tell the FMA pretty much all it needs to know about the generous terms of the chiropractic scope of practice law in Florida.
Curiously, even the bill’s sponsor, who testified in person in favor of his bill, appeared unaware that chiropractors were included. In response to a question from the committee, he replied that the bill covered only “general practitioner primary care” providers and “only primary care physicians.” (The questioner was asking about other medical specialties, like OB/GYN.)
The DPC agreement bill was one of the most heavily lobbied bills in Florida’s 2018 session, with a whopping 108 lobbyists signed on to argue one side or another, clearly indicating that substantial financial interests were at stake. Appearing in favor of passage at the single House committee hearing on the bill were lobbyists from the Florida Academy of Family Physicians, the American College of Physicians, and the Florida Medical Association. Only one person spoke against it and his objection had nothing to do with chiropractors.
Not surprisingly, the Florida Chiropractic Physicians Association, an organization promoting the:
advancement of the chiropractic physician to the level of true primary care physician, with full prescriptive rights and the opportunity to specialize . . .
appeared at the hearing voicing its approval.
Naturally, the Florida Chiropractic Association (FCA) is thrilled about the new law, because:
The FCA sought to include DC’s [sic] in this statute not only to provide a new business opportunity and better access to chiropractic care, but, also to express clearly in state statutes that chiropractic physicians provide primary care services.
Its announcement of the new law added:
Your FCA is now busy developing a host of new materials to assist you in better understanding this new, exciting concept and how you can best put it to work in your practice. Marketing and promotional guidelines, sample legal agreements, and new educational opportunities are among the many items on our drawing board all aimed at helping you take full advantage of this new law. Be sure to watch for our coming updates.
You can bet we’ll be watching to see just how far chiropractors will exploit this new law in rebranding themselves as primary care physicians.

Chiropractors, Naturopaths, Concussions and Senate Bill 1535
Is it a good idea that chiropractors be allowed to clear children to play sports after a concussion? No. It is not a good idea.
Mark Crislip on February 19, 2016
Link

There is a bill before the Oregon Legislature, Senate Bill 1535, that:
Allows chiropractic physicians and naturopathic physicians to provide release for athlete who sustained concussion or is suspected of sustaining concussion.
Unfortunately, the Oregon legislature has already granted naturopaths primary care physician status, so I expect this may well pass, despite the fact neither chiropractors nor naturopaths have much reality-based education and training in medicine.
You may wonder, why you should care about what is going on in Oregon? Well, it is likely similar laws are being considered in your state. You might be surprised at the shenanigans going on in your legislature. I was when I looked. To keep informed, go to Legislative Update at the Society for Science-Based Medicine for weekly updates.
Let’s go through the issues: why is it a bad idea for the athletes of the state, most of whom will be children, to be cared for by NDs and DCs?
What a concussion is
A concussion is a form for trauma, an injury to the brain. The brain floats in cerebral spinal fluid, which acts as a cushion. If the skull hits something, or is hit, hard enough by a fist or a football helmet or a wall, the cushion fails and the brain smashes into the skull. Trauma results.
The patient can then have a headache, confusion, ringing in the ears, seizures, double vision, and other neurologic symptoms. The number and severity of the symptoms depends on what part of the brain is injured, and the severity of the injury.
Treatment is resting the body and the brain and avoiding re-injury. There may be long-term sequelae to concussions, especially repeated concussions, such as depression, dementia and Parkinson’s. The brain is not physically, emotionally, or spiritually forgiving when injured.
It is a huge problem, with 300,000 sports related concussions a year in the US, and this only counts concussions that led to a loss of consciousness, perhaps 10% of the total. Children are both more prone to concussion and, perhaps, long term sequelae.
So concussion is a serious and widespread medical problem. It may not be an optimal approach to have those with little or no education, training or experience in medicine care for children with concussion. Except, probably, in Oregon.
Education
Chiropractors and naturopaths like to pretend that their ‘medical’ education is equivalent to medical school. Nothing could be further from the truth.
Chiropractic education
During the public hearing it was offered that the education of a chiropractor is equal to that of an MD. While there are superficial similarities, the whole of chiropractic education is through the lens of chiropractic theory: that there are misalignments of the spine, subluxations, that block that body’s ability to heal, and that chiropractors can identify and adjust these subluxations to restore health.
The whole underlying concept of chiropractic is a pseudo-science, with no basis in anatomy, physiology, or reality. As one review notes:
Chiropractic and allopathic medicine differ the greatest in clinical practice, which in medical school far exceeds that in chiropractic school. The therapies that chiropractic and medical students learn are distinct from one another.
Medical education is grounded in reality; chiropractic education is grounded in the fantasy of innate intelligence, subluxations, and spinal adjustments.
Naturopathic education
Naturopathic education also appears to be superficially similar in the number of hours devoted to the basic sciences. When compared to the education of a Family Practice Physician, it is clear that ND’s have a fraction of the training required to become and MD/DO.

It is more than the quantity of hours in education and training that makes a physician, it is also the quality of the content. ND curriculum is even more focused on pseudo-science than chiropractic: homeopathy, hydrotherapy, acupuncture, energy therapies, and more make up a significant portion of the naturopathic education. Time spent studying pseudo-science and pseudo-medicine is time not spent studying and understanding reality-based medicine. Those educated in the care and feeding of unicorns are not qualified to care for horses.
The naturopaths testifying at the hearing suggest that since they have been given primary care designation they should be allowed to diagnose and manage concussion as well. I would suggest that two wrongs do not make a right.
Post-education training
No MD or DO is even remotely ready for independent patient care upon graduation from medical school. After graduation MDs and DOs have a residency to learn their specialty. Internal Medicine, Family Practice, and Neurology residencies are three years; neurosurgery takes 7 years. It is the residency, practicing under the guidance of senior physicians, where doctors really learn their profession.
Neither naturopaths nor chiropractors have a residency; they usually go straight from school and into practice. The few that do complete a residency do so in the field of naturopathy or chiropractic, further reinforcing their pseudo-medical training.
There is no subspecialty naturopathic training in neurology; chiropractors can be certified as a chiropractic neurologist in 40 days of internet classes, or 300 classroom hours. Compare that to the over 8,000 hours (assuming a mythical 8-hour workday) it takes to be a real neurologist, much of which is spend in direct patient care. This is why Dr. Steven Novella, a Yale neurologist, says:
Chiropractic neurology appears to me to be the very definition of pseudoscience — it has all the trappings of a legitimate profession, with a complex set of beliefs and practices, but there is no underlying scientific basis for any of it…Chiropractic neurology does not appear to be based on any body of research, or any accumulated scientific knowledge.
Evaluating their education, training and practice, I would suggest that chiropractic and naturopathy are to real neurology and medicine what Guitar Hero is to Jimmy Page.
The medical literature
A search of the medical literature on PubMed for “naturopathic medicine concussion” yields zero publications. There are no trials to suggest that the pseudo-medical practice of naturopathy can be applied to brain injury. Or any other real disease for that matter.
For “chiropractic concussion” there are 19 hits on Pubmed, out of the 7,511 medical publications on concussion. None of the articles concern the competency or efficacy of chiropractors in the diagnosis and treatment of concussion.
There are no clinical trials demonstrating efficacy of chiropractic or naturopathic treatments for concussion. And there is no reason, based on known anatomy and physiology, to suspect that either pseudo-medicine would have benefit in the diagnosis or treatment of concussion.
Dangers of chiropractic treatment
The Palmer School of Chiropractic recommends manipulation of the cervical spine for concussion.
There is an association with cervical spine manipulation in the young and vertebral basilar artery stroke:
Results for those aged 45 years showed VBA cases to be 5 times more likely than controls to have visited a chiropractor within 1 week of the VBA (95% CI from bootstrapping, 1.32 to 43.87). Additionally, in the younger age group, cases were 5 times as likely to have had ≥3 visits with a cervical diagnosis in the month before the case’s VBA date.
The association between cervical spine manipulation and stroke is consistent enough that the American Heart Association and the American Stroke Association have released a scientific statement suggesting:
Although current biomechanical evidence is insufficient to establish the claim that cervical manipulative therapy (CMT) causes cervical artery dissections (CD), clinical reports suggest that mechanical forces play a role in a considerable number of CDs and most population controlled studies have found an association between CMT and vertebral artery dissection stroke in young patients.
Complications fortunately are rare, as “Adverse Events Due to Chiropractic and Other Manual Therapies for Infants and Children: A Review of the Literature” showed:
Thirty-one articles met the selection criteria. A total of 12 articles reporting 15 serious adverse events were found. Three deaths occurred under the care of various providers (1 physical therapist, 1 unknown practitioner, and 1 craniosacral therapist) and 12 serious injuries were reported (7 chiropractors/doctors of chiropractic, 1 medical practitioner, 1 osteopath, 2 physical therapists, and 1 unknown practitioner).
But for an intervention that has no benefit, the risk should be zero. Young people have died after chiropractic manipulation, perhaps including the recent death of the “Queen of Snapchat,” Katie May.
And children are injured by manipulation when the correct diagnosis is missed:
Other (serious adverse events) leading to permanent neurological consequences have been reported. However all of these were attributable to a misdiagnosis leading to the inappropriate application of SMT with unfortunate consequences.
Yes. A child crippled by a useless intervention for the wrong reason is an “unfortunate consequence.” Given the lack of medical training by DCs and NDs, further unfortunate consequences would seem inevitable.
If stroke were due to a medication, the medication would receive a black box warning at a minimum or be pulled from the market. The major chiropractic organizations deny that chiropractic can cause strokes and continue to snap the neck, which can result in the same forces and injury as a hanging. But that is typical of pseudo-medicines: they never recognize that their interventions could be dangerous and alter or abandon practice accordingly.
The data suggesting a link between chiropractic manipulation and stroke is complicated and incomplete. However in medicine, but not chiropractic or naturopathy, the precautionary principle is applied:
if an action… has a suspected risk of causing harm to the public, in the absence of scientific consensus that the action or policy is not harmful, the burden of proof that it is not harmful falls on those taking an action.
And the action avoided.
The majority of chiropractors are of the opinion that spine manipulation is a treatment for concussion, even though the brain is distant from spine:
Most respondents agreed or strongly agreed that manual therapies may be appropriate in certain circumstances in adults (80%) and minors (80%).
When all you have is a hammer, everything is a nail.
While there is no naturopathy-specific treatment for concussion, naturopaths do have their own naturopathic manipulation.
Bill 1535 should not pass
It should give anyone concerned with the health of children a frisson of terror at the thought of concussed children being evaluated and managed by naturopaths and chiropractors.
Naturopaths and chiropractors lack the education, the training, and the understanding of medicine and neurology to diagnose and treat concussion. Their therapies are at best useless and can result in strokes in one of our most vulnerable populations, children.
Senate Bill 1535 should not pass.

The CAM Docket: Texas MDs v. DCs
Jann Bellamy on May 3, 2012
Link
In April, the Texas District Court of Appeals (Third District) affirmed a lower court ruling that chiropractors are prohibited from performing manipulation under anesthesia and needle electromyography[EMG]. The lower court also ruled that the Texas Board of Chiropractic Examiners exceeded its authority in defining the chiropractic scope of practice to include “diagnosis.” This part of the ruling was overturned by the Court of Appeals, but with some interesting language in the opinion which could turn their one win into a Pyrrhic victory for Texas chiropractors. In a separate ruling, not on appeal, a lower court held that vestibular testing is outside the scope of chiropractic practice.
First, some background. Back in 1949, the Texas Legislature defined the scope of chiropractic practice as, among other things, “the practice of adjusting the vertebrae to correct any subluxation or misalignment thereof . . .” Over the ensuing years, the legislature amended the chiropractic practice act with an eye toward modernization, resulting in the current scope of practice being “nonsurgical, nonincisive procedures, including, but not limited to, adjustment and manipulation, in order to improve the subluxation complex or the biomechanics of the musculoskeletal system.” Now that’s progress!
Playing by the rules
Texas chiropractors are regulated by the Texas Board of Chiropractic Examiners [TBCE]. Normally, a regulatory body like the TBCE issues rules through a formalized procedure which gives stakeholders a voice in the rulemaking process. Once a rule is enacted, those adversely affected by it can challenge the rule in an administrative proceeding or in court. However, the TBCE for years avoided this process by relying instead on informal “statements” or “memoranda.” The effect of this was to prevent anyone from challenging the TBCE’s interpretation of chiropractic scope of practice.
In 2005, the Texas Legislature forced the TBCE’s hand by requiring it to adopt rules clarifying what is, and what is not, within the scope of chiropractic practice. In doing so, the TBCE would be limited by the Legislature’s definition of chiropractic but there was wiggle room to interpret the practice act as it saw fit. Requiring the TBCE to go through the normal rulemaking procedures would give any opponents of TBCE’s scope-of-practice delineations the chance to test the rules in court. Thus, the TBCE came to issue rules broadly defining chiropractic scope of practice, including authorizing chiropractors to perform needle electromyography, manipulation under anesthesia and vestibular-ocular-nystagmus testing. The rules also appeared to allow chiropractors expansive authority to “diagnose.”
A little too expansive, according to the Texas Medical Association [TMA] and the Texas Medical Board [TMB]. Because they now had specific rules they could challenge in court, the TMA and TMB (which I will collectively refer to, as the appellate court did, as the “physician parties” or “physicians”) sued the TBCE, along with its Executive Director and the Texas Chiropractic Association (referred to collectively as the “chiropractic parties” or the “chiropractors”). The physicians alleged that the TBCE’s rules were too broad and therefore went beyond the authority granted TBCE by the Texas Legislature. They also argued the rules were unconstitutional, a challenge yet to be ruled upon by the trial court and therefore not a subject of the appellate court’s opinion.
Vestibular testing
In a separate ruling, a Texas district (trial) court struck down the TBCE rule allowing vestibular-ocular-nystagmus testing as beyond chiropractic scope of practice. That decision was not part of this appellate opinion, but we’ll briefly look at it. According to the TMA website, its successful challenge was based on the contention that state law did not allow chiropractors to perform vestibular testing, because:
The vestibular system is a component of the inner ear and communicates with the central nervous system. Tests of vestibular function are diagnostic tests designed to evaluate the function and structure of the inner ear and/or brain, and they include hearing evaluations because the hearing and balance functions of the inner ear are closely related. . . . The vestibular apparatus is not part of the musculoskeletal system because the muscles that connect the eyes to the skull do not ‘move the body’ or ‘maintain its form.’ . . . Chiropractors are not authorized to diagnose medical conditions, including defects in the vestibular apparatus, because the Chiropractic Act does not include the diagnosis of diseases within the definition of chiropractic. Even if chiropractors can use the word ‘diagnosis’ in a rule, any such diagnosis must be limited to the biomechanical condition of the spine and musculoskeletal system.
The court agreed.
Manipulation under anesthesia
Manipulation under anesthesia (“MUA”or “S[pinal]MUA”) is, according to Quackwatch, a
procedure in which a chiropractor performs manipulation while an anesthesiologist keeps the patient asleep. MUA has little appropriate use and is potentially dangerous. Because the normal protective reflexes are abolished, the manipulated joint can be overstretched.
Here is how the health insurance company Aetna describes chiropractic use of MUA,
Within the realm of chiropractic, SMUA is generally performed daily for 1 to 5 consecutive days on an outpatient basis, and is followed by a post-SMUA rehabilitation regimen, which entails 1 week of daily manipulation to maintain joint mobility and avoid re-adhesion of fibrotic tissue. Anesthesia is usually induced by intravenous Pentothal (sodium thiopental), and manipulation of the affected joints takes about 7 to 10 minutes.
Except in narrowly defined circumstances, Aetna considers MUA investigational and experimental, which translates as “we won’t pay for it.” Of course, in cases where the patient’s health insurer won’t pay, the patient pays the full freight, without discounts normally negotiated by the insurer or mandated by Medicare.
I don’t know how much a full course of chiropractic MUA would set a patient back, but add up the cost of the MUA itself, an anesthesiologist, an outpatient procedure facility equipped and licensed to handle administration of anesthesiology, multiply that by 5, then add 5 more days of in-office chiropractic manipulation, and I can imagine we’re getting into thousands of dollars.
Neither the trial nor the appellate court had much trouble deciding that MUA was outside the scope of chiropractic practice as defined by the Legislature. This is because the Legislature had specifically defined (by incorporating Medicare coding as a guide) MUA as a “surgical” procedure. Because chiropractors are statutorily forbidden from performing surgery, the rule permitting MUA fell.
Needle EMG
Needle electromyography measures the electrical activity of muscles. (This should not be confused with surface electromyography, a bogus diagnostic procedure sometimes used by chiropractors to detect “subluxations.”) A needle electrode attached by wires to a recording machine is inserted into a muscle to record the electrical activity. Needle electromyography is used to determine the cause of weakness, paralysis or muscle twitching and to diagnose diseases that damage muscle tissue or nerves, such as ALS or myasthenia gravis.
The trial court found, and the appellate court agreed, that insertion of certain types of needles used in the EMG met the definition of an “incision.” As chiropractors are prevented by state law from performing “incisive” procedures, the rule permitting their use of needle EMG was declared invalid.
To diagnose, or not to diagnose
The physicians also challenged TBCE rules allowing chiropractors to “diagnose,” a privilege is not specifically included in their practice act, which limits chiropractors to “us[ing] objective or subjective means to analyze, examine, or evaluate the biomechanical condition of the spine and musculoskeletal system of the human body” and “perform[ing] nonsurgical, nonincisive procedures . . . to improve the subluxation complex or the biomechanics of the musculoskeletal system.” One has to wonder how performing surgical or incisive procedures, should chiropractors be allowed them, could “improve the subluxation complex,” as the “subluxation complex” is a figment of the chiropractic imagination. The very thought raises the horrible specter of a chiropractor chopping away in an effort to redact a “subluxation” of, say, the second cervical vertebra.
The physicians won on this issue in the trial court, but lost on appeal. As I suggested earlier, this may be a hollow victory for Texas chiropractors.
TBCE rules challenged by the physician parties included:
Rule 75.17(d) Analysis, Diagnosis, and Other Opinions
(1) In the practice of chiropractic, licensees may render an analysis, diagnosis, or other opinion regarding the findings of examinations and evaluations. Such opinions could include, but are not limited to, the following,
(A) An analysis, diagnosis or other opinion regarding the biomechanical condition of the spine or musculoskeletal system including, but not limited to, the following . . . .
The rule then goes on to list pretty much everything one could possibly think of in the way of looking into “the biomechnical condition of the spine or musculoskeletal system,” including:
(i) the health and integrity of the structures of the system;
(ii) the coordination, balance, efficiency, strength, conditioning and functional health and integrity of the system;
(iii) the existence of structural pathology, functional pathology or other abnormality of the system;
(iv) the nature, severity, complicating factors and effects of said structural pathology, functional pathology, or other abnormality of the system;
(v) the etiology of said structural pathology, functional pathology or other abnormality of the system; and
(vi) the effect of said structural pathology, functional pathology or other abnormality of the system on the health of an individual patient or population of patients.
These references to “structural pathology, functional pathology or other abnormality of the system” are apparently designed to encompass the latest iteration of the “subluxation,” known variously as the spinal lesion, joint dysfunction, manipulable lesion, and many other names. This formulation holds that the chiropractor can feel or otherwise detect something significant in the spine and then proceed to correct this significant something, although they’ve never been quite able to explain how what they say they feel or otherwise detect has anything to do with the patient’s problem. Nor have they been able to explain how what they do to this significant something, such as an “adjustment,” makes any difference to the patient’s health. At least that is what I have gathered from explanations of what they do posted in commentary on SBM. If I’m wrong about this, I’m sure I’ll hear about it.
Diagnose, but with limits
Two factors saved this rule from exceeding the scope of chiropractic practice in the appellate court’s view. First, the TBCE has interpreted the word “diagnosis” as synonymous with “analyze,” “examine,” and “evaluate,” which are within the statutory scope of chiropractic practice. Apparently the court thought this put some sort of limitation on their authority to “diagnose.” In other words, the court appears to be saying that “diagnosis” may have a meaning beyond “analyze,” “examine” or “evaluate” to a physician, but whatever that expanded meaning might entail, as long as chiropractors interpret “diagnosis” in this limited fashion, they are within their rights. This may be a distinction without a difference, but it is one the court makes.
Second, the court dismissed the physicians’ concerns that chiropractors defined terms in the rules so broadly that they could include virtually any disease or condition of any part of the body. Apparently unaware of the full extent of chiropractic claims of the near universal effect of spinal “structural” or “functional” pathology on the human body, the court found, over and over, that the physicians’ concerns should be allayed by the limitation to “biomechanical condition of the spine or musculoskeletal system.” To each argument of the physicians that the rules included an impermissible expansion of chiropractic scope of practice, the court replied, in effect: “No, no, chiropractors are limited to ‘biomechanical condition of the spine or musculoskeletal system.’” In other words, the court seemed to think this term meant the same thing to chiropractors as it means to physicians and other health care professionals.
This may prove problematic for Texas chiropractors attempting to extend their diagnoses beyond the “biomechanical condition of the spine or musculoskeletal system” – as these terms are used in medicine — by employing the chiropractic concept of the “biomedical condition of the spine or musculoskeletal system,” that is, to the subluxation or any of its current iterations.
In arguing that the rules permitted an overly broad scope of practice, the physicians pointed to the definition of the “subluxation complex” contained therein:
[A] neuromusculosketal condition that involves an aberrant relationship between two adjacent articular structures that may have functional or pathological sequelae, causing an alteration in the biomechanical and/or neuro-physiological relations of the articular structures, their proximal structures, and/or other body systems that may be directly or indirectly affected by them.
Of course, this is gibberish and most chiropractors well know it is gibberish but refuse to do anything about it, such as, say, letting the state legislatures in on this open secret. That would mean the states would have to redefine chiropractic practice to exclude the “detection” and “correction” of the non-existent “subluxation.”
In any event, the physician’s concern was that in using words like “pathology” and “etiology” the rules employed terminology that referenced the disease process. Because the diagnosis of disease was legally beyond the scope of chiropractic practice, they argued, the rules were invalid. The court disagreed, saying that their argument
presumes that ‘disease’ would extend beyond the biomechanical condition of the spine or musculoskeletal system of the body. This construction, as previously suggested, ignores the plain language of the rule restricting any such diagnosis to the biomechanical condition of the spine or musculoskeletal system. . . .
[R]egardless of whether diagnosis, pathology, or etiology invoke concepts of disease as the Physician Parties suggest, the bottom line is that [the rule] limits chiropractors to diagnoses regarding ‘the biomechanical condition of the spine and musculoskeletal system’ as required by the statutory scope of chiropractic.
The physicians also worried that the rule allowed chiropractors to
diagnose any diseases (pathology) that relate to the biomechanical condition of the spine and musculoskeletal system (redefined [by chiropractors] to include nerves and other tissues), determine their origins (etiology) and provide a prognosis on the disease’s effect.
The court specifically rejected this interpretation as too broad, once again citing the limitation of chiropractic practice to the biomechanical condition of the spine and musculoskeletal system.
Did the Court of Appeals adjust the subluxation?
This apparent limitation becomes even more clear in the court’s discussion of the “subluxation complex,” for which it accepted the TBCE’s definition, repeated here:
[A] neuromusculosketal condition that involves an aberrant relationship between two adjacent articular structures that may have functional or pathological sequelae, causing an alteration in the biomechanical and/or neuro-physiological reflections of the articular structures, their proximal structures, and/or other body systems that may be directly or indirectly affected by them.
[BTW, if anyone can tell me what this means, I would appreciate it. I once asked a friend who is a Ph.D neuroscientist specializing in the spine. He said it was “nonsense” but perhaps there are other views out there.]
The physicians argued that the rule’s subluxation definition would allow chiropractors to diagnose a broad range of “neurological conditions, pathological and neuro-physiological consequences that affect the spine and musculoskeletal system and ‘other body systems’ affected by subluxation.”
In what I view as an interesting limitation on the broad sweep of the chiropractic “subluxation,” the court disagreed that the inclusion of this definition of “subluxation” somehow expanded the scope of practice.
Although the definition of the ‘subluxation complex’ indicates that its existence may have functional or pathological consequences or that it may affect essentially every part of the body, the rule itself only allows chiropractors to render an analysis, diagnosis, or other opinion regarding a subluxation complex of the spine or musculoskeletal system.
To me, this says that a Texas chiropractor diagnosing the existence of a “subluxation” and then rendering an opinion that an “adjustment” of the “subluxation” may have consequences beyond the (once again) “biomechanical condition of the spine or musculoskeletal system” would be outside of his scope of practice. This would prohibit, in my view, a number of current chiropractic practices, such as opining that “adjustments” can be beneficial to asthma, allergies, painful periods, infant colic, bedwetting, otitis media, and any of the myriad other diseases and conditions chiropractors claim to treat. (Oh, wait, they don’t “treat” anything. They simply unleash the body’s self-healing ability.) It would also prohibit “maintenance” care, that is, regular “spinal checkups” and “adjustments” for general health, to the extent these claims extended beyond benefit to the “biomechanical condition of the spine or musculoskeletal system.”
The physicians and chiropractors have not announced whether they will appeal to the Texas Supreme Court. The physicians will have another shot when the district court decides whether the rules allowing chiropractic diagnosis are unconstitutional. Stay tuned.

Chiropractor Claims the CDC Is Trying to Get Nazi-like Unfettered Power in Violation of the Nuremburg Code
Harriet Hall on November 8, 2016
Link


An email was recently circulated among chiropractors warning them about a proposed rulemaking by the CDC, saying that it will establish a public health gestapo. It originated from Ted Koren Seminars. A chiropractor who received the email brought it to my attention. He describes Koren as “a chiropractor who is a “leader” in the chiropractic community, lecturer, antivaxxer (he refers to the CDC as the “Centers for Disinformation Control” and states that the CDC “continues to spend taxpayers’ money spewing forth poorly written, biased, “junk science” studies that, through their connections, are placed in well-read medical journals for maximum media attention”. He is also the inventor of Koren Specific Technique, which he describes as a “system akin to muscle testing (applied kinesiology or AK) wherein a muscle will become weak when confronted with a negative impulse.” (Note: Applied kinesiology is bogus.)
The circulated email is a prime example of misinformation, conspiracy theory, and fear-mongering.
Koren’s claims
He says:
The CDC’s new proposed rulemaking will deny our health freedoms and establish a public health gestapo in the USA, forcing mandatory health treatments (including vaccinations, quarantines) and fines up to $500,000.
The U.S. CDC is giving itself unconstitutional powers to round up and detain citizens en masses [sic] anytime.”
“Oh, if you’re all for totalitarianism and fascism… just ignore this email J”
“it would give the CDC totalitarian, unconstitutional, unchecked, unprecedented powers, self-described as “police powers.”
The CDC, like many other agencies now, has been corrupted by corporate interests and is not working – at least at the top levels – in the best interests of the public.
The new “rule” will allow health officials to treat people– without an examination — with a medical treatment (vaccination or otherwise) that carries with it the risk of serious injury and death.
The new “rule” would give CDC unfettered power to add or delete any diseases that fit their criteria.
Giving the CDC military-like of powers is exactly what was done by the government in Nazi Germany. Any forced medical treatments, on any pretext, is a violation of human rights and the Nuremburg Code.
The CDC is attempting to radically change their definition of what constitutes an “ill” person by including a wide range of vague symptoms such as an ill appearance that may be assessed by officials without medical training. I oppose this nebulous definition.
Simply being identified as “at risk” of exposure makes one classifiable as having a “pre-communicable disease,” which can thereby resulting [sic] one’s forced apprehension, quarantine and vaccination.
The reality
Because of incidents like the recent Disneyland measles outbreak and the Ebola crisis, the CDC and the HHS filed a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking. The government already has the power and the duty to institute measures to safeguard public health, including quarantine when necessary. Quarantine regulations already exist, and the proposed new rules would only clarify the language of the regulations and the reporting requirements. Clarification is needed. For instance, the “Do Not Board” list that was developed in conjunction with Homeland Security only applied to commercial aircraft and did not extend to vessels, trains or buses. A proposed change requires conveyance operators to not “knowingly” transport individuals under a Federal Order. That sounds like a good idea to me!
The proposal states:
if facts or circumstances are discovered that give rise to a reasonable belief that the individual is infected, as defined under this NPRM, with a quarantinable communicable disease in its qualifying stage, CDC may authorize the quarantine, isolation, or conditional release of the individual. Similarly, an individual’s refusal to be screened may result in quarantine, isolation, or conditional release, but only if sufficient facts and circumstances otherwise exist giving rise to a reasonable belief that the individual is infected with a quarantinable communicable disease in its qualifying stage.
It does not give the CDC any new powers. It is consistent with constitutional principles and requirements. It would ensure due process. Criminal penalties for violation of quarantine would not change.
History of quarantine
Quarantine was practiced in Biblical times. “If the shiny spot on the skin is white but does not appear to be more than skin deep and the hair in it has not turned white, the priest is to isolate the affected person for seven days. On the seventh day the priest is to examine them, and if he sees that the sore is unchanged and has not spread in the skin, he is to isolate them for another seven days.” Leviticus 13:4-5. Lepers were considered unclean and were kept isolated from the rest of society. Leprosy was believed to be highly contagious and was often falsely diagnosed in patients with other skin conditions. With modern knowledge, accurate diagnostic tests, and effective treatments, patients with leprosy are no longer isolated.
The name quarantine comes from the Italian word for forty, the number of days ships and people were isolated before entering the city of Dubrovnik during the Black Plague.
The practice of quarantine has sometimes been accused of interfering with human rights, as in the case of Typhoid Mary. The history of quarantine, international conventions, and the laws of various countries are covered well in the Wikipedia entry. In Australia, quarantine violators face fines of up to 100,000 Australian dollars and up to 10 years in prison.
Conclusion: a ridiculous over-reaction to a reasonable proposal
In my opinion, Koren’s rant only exposes his ignorance. He believes vaccines do more harm than good and cause serious injuries and deaths; they demonstrably don’t. He appears not to understand the government’s responsibility to protect public health. He appears to be ignorant of history. He seems not to understand the rationale and effectiveness of quarantine measures. He misrepresents what the proposal actually says. He apparently doesn’t know that the Nuremburg Code applies only to medical experiments, not public health measures. The comparison to Nazi totalitarianism is false and despicable. The appeal to “health freedom” is a deceptive libertarian theme that has been covered on SBM before. I shudder to think what might have happened if personal freedom had been prioritized over public health to let people exposed to Zika (or even already showing symptoms of Zika) enter the US with no restrictions.
The good news is that it was another chiropractor who realized how wrong this message was and forwarded it to me. He readily recognized it as irresponsible fearmongering, conspiracy theory, and misinformation. I hope the majority of chiropractors who received the message were also able to recognize it for what it was. Somehow, I am not optimistic.

A Very Serious Book Review: The Heroic Adventures of Kid Ki’ro
An Australian chiropractor has written a children’s book extoling the virtues of the profession in a most elliptical fashion.
Clay Jones on September 17, 2021
Link

Dedicated to “chiropractic superheroes, young and old, past, present and future”, The Heroic Adventures of Kid Ki’ro: Chiropractic Superhero Adventure Series: Book 1 is a children’s book written by Marcus Chacos, a chiropractor practicing in Australia. Chacos promotes a fundamentalist chiropractic philosophy, meaning that he believes that an unhindered nervous system maintains optimal health via an essentially supernatural healing power described as an innate healing force. What could possibly serve as a hindrance to the function of the nervous system? The chiropractic subluxation, of course.
Chacos also heavily promotes a rather revisionist history of chiropractic on his practice website:
The history of chiropractic dates as far back as ancient China, Egypt and Greece. Ancient records show that practitioners performed techniques on the spine, giving pain relief. However, it wasn’t until 1895 that a man called David Palmer began making these techniques more widely known.
I have seen claims of the ancient underpinnings of modern chiropractic before and have never been impressed. Even taken at face value, supposed documents describing manipulation of the spine to help back pain would not support the vitalistic beliefs of modern straight chiropractors such as Chacos. It was Palmer who essentially ripped off the early beliefs of osteopath Andrew Taylor Still to invent the practice of chiropractic, claiming to have accidentally discovered it when he cured a janitor of total deafness, an account that was disputed by family members of the first chiropractic “patient”. Palmer’s tweak to osteopathy was to entirely focus on the spine and to claim that disruptions in the flow of “the Innate” resulted in all human medical ailments.
Chacos, unlike the typical straight chiropractor, also dabbles in various other forms of pseudomedicine. His website promotes herbs, homeopathy, special diets, supplements, aromatherapy, and even flower essences. He also incorporates some bogus diagnostic tests, such as electro-dermal meridian analysis and urine studies for “leaky gut syndrome” into his clinic’s armamentarium.
Chacos sits on the board of directors for the Australian Spinal Research Foundation, which claims to be seeking answers to chiropractic’s biggest questions. Since its creation in 1977, however, the ASRF has had the sole purpose of raising money to promote the chiropractic subluxation, mostly through research grants and propaganda in the form of newsletters and press releases. They are apparently not doing all that well financially, as they were forced to “streamline the foundation” by selling their headquarters and moving online.
In 2017, the ASRF released a conceptual definition of the vertebral subluxation for research and practice. This framework contains one of my favorite descriptions of the chiropractic subluxation:
A vertebral subluxation is a diminished state of being, comprising of a state of reduced coherence, altered biomechanical function, altered neurological function and altered adaptability.
Actually I take that back. It is my favorite. A close second is the definition published by the Association of Chiropractic Colleges in 2001:
A complex of functional and/or structural and/or pathological articular changes that compromise neural integrity and may influence organ system function and general health.
Both are things of beauty, but the ASRF takes vague chirobabble to an entirely new level. Confused? Don’t worry, they define “coherence” for us:
Coherence may be described as the property of unity; logically connected; consistent. Having a natural or due agreement of parts; harmonious;
It also may be described as nonsense in the context of chiropractic.
All proceeds of Chacos’ Kid Ki’ro book go to the ASRF, which may partly explain their financial woes. It is definitely no The Monster at the End of This Book. It’s not even a Latawnya, the Naughty Horse. The ASRF exaggerates a bit in their description:
This beautifully illustrated children’s book subtly emphasizes the health and lifestyle impact of chiropractic, coupled with a delightful imaginary story. The Heroic Adventures of Kid Ki’ro represents a wonderful book for chiropractors to have in their practices and to share with their patients. Non-preachy, the message of chiropractic is cleverly disguised as Kid Ki’ro lives the chiropractic lifestyle and a reaches for the stars as a result.
And now, my very serious review of The Heroic Adventures of Kid Ki’ro: Chiropractic Superhero Adventure Series: Book 1.
Every day is a chance for heroic adventures
Thus Chacos opens his book and the adventure of Kid Ki’ro, chiropractic superhero, begins. Kid Ki’ro is depicted daydreaming of impossible feats, such as soaring through the sky, walking on water, or fighting a dragon. He imagines building the world’s tallest skyscraper, which would be quite a feat for a young child considering that it would need to reach more than 2,717 feet in order to surpass the Burj Khalifa in Dubai.
Kid Ki’ro could, according to Chacos, design the world’s greatest railroad. This is a tough one to parse because greatness is an entirely subjective determination. Does it mean the longest track? If so, it would need to beat the Trans-Siberian railway’s 5,772 miles. Frankly I don’t think that Ki’ro has the time or resources. Perhaps he means that Ki’ro might construct a train that runs faster than Japan’s experimental maglev train, which set the speed record of 375 mph in 2015, but that is also hard to imagine.
The reader is then asked to think of what heroic adventures they might go on today, and they are reminded that every superhero has superpowers. This is demonstrably false, however. It might be fair to argue that all the members of the Avengers are incredibly talented and bring a particular set of skills to the table, but Hawkeye and Black Widow do not have any superpowers to speak of yet they identify as superheroes.
The next section of The Heroic Adventures of Kid Ki’ro continues to promote laughably unlikely physical achievements. Chacos inquires if the reader has any superpowers, specifically if they can jump higher than a mountain. The world’s smallest registered mountain is Mount Wycheproof in Victoria, Australia. At 141 feet above the surrounding terrain, it is rather small to be sure, but the current human high jump record, held by Javior Sotomayor since 1993, is just over 8 feet, which is well below what would be needed to clear Mount Wycheproof.
The reader is then asked if they might be able to run faster than a cheetah. Any honest child would respond that this would almost certainly be impossible. I was unable to find the world record for the fastest school-age child, but I think it would be considerably slower than the cheetah, which can run upwards of 70 mph. I emailed the San Diego zoo to inquire if they were aware of any documented head-to-head races between a young child and a cheetah but did not receive a response, so we will have to withhold judgement pending additional evidence. It’s important to be open-minded, of course, but not so open that your brain falls out.
I am similarly skeptical of the possibility of a child being stronger than a gorilla. These large primates are exceptionally strong according to the Gorilla Facts comprehensive database, and are capable of lifting up to 1,800 pounds. Even the strongest adult human would be considerably weaker than the typical gorilla, which would easily defeat a young child in an arm wrestling match.
Can a 6-year-old fly? I doubt it! Certainly not without being aided by small rockets or perhaps a glider of some kind. Their light weight would perhaps give them an advantage over a much larger adult, but I would be concerned that a young child wouldn’t have the frontal lobe capacity to make good decisions once in the air.
It’s time to unleash your superpower!
In the next section of Chacos’ book, he reveals the secrets to unleashing your superpower. His recommendations, which mostly consist of standard advice you might get from your doctor, would be unlikely to help a child develop superpowers. These typically require an exposure to gamma rays, advanced alien technology, magical artifacts, or perhaps the bite of a radioactive arachnid. But to be clear, I don’t disagree with a healthy diet, plenty of exercise, a focus on mental health, and proper amounts of sleep as far as recommendations for a healthy lifestyle go.
Chacos gets a bit into the weeds, however, when he claims that every superhero should make sure that their “brain-body connection is working perfectly” without explaining what that means. Without specification, this reads like an overly simplistic truism. The accompanying illustration of Kid Ki’ro laying prone as an adult appears to be massaging his back, likely represents a chiropractic adjustment.
This assumption is confirmed by the next few pages which give “the adjustment” credit for correcting an apparent post-traumatic brain injury suffered by our protagonist. Chacos also claims that chiropractic adjustments result in performance enhancements, with children jumping higher and running faster, but also feeling happier, sleeping better at night, and staying healthy in general. Even after reading the book several times, I remain unconvinced by the evidence provided to support assertions.
Conclusion: Kids don’t need chiropractic adjustments to be heroes
        ◦ This book is big on claims but light on scientific evidence in support of them. While there are some basic recommendations for a healthy lifestyle that I agree with, there is a lot of nonsense. I hope that parents of young children aren’t fooled by this chiropractic propaganda. And I hope that no young children become disappointed and disillusioned when they fail to achieve the unrealistic accomplishments depicted in the book. Though unable to outrun a cheetah or out-lift a gorilla, children are our future and their laughter should remind us all of how we used to be.
